o s 1t 2 eck - supreme court of florida · 2018. 7. 18. · lks reichs cer s on rh4h s1% nb w en c6...
TRANSCRIPT
IN 68u teco è t Iphp
L
CASE tvo , A Diol- 30 75CA5& lVO . 2013-346
VEf8¼s. LTxy oL-cs-os
s o flee4pA °E SO
esFonor ' oc1 o 2912|NMATES S
G±dioN&(ts T o N (C
o e e om oA f6Al Seconro e
s o
o s
1t 2 eckonoA n o
TÁl>le oÊ0cN+rfrhf ris,
TAhe ' ns, , , . 3--56 CMfr * , , 5 ,
SJ¼ß 3 Nkl JCoM SloN. .
hRqunc 9
Thf DE C 3 oN o e SEcoND DiSff C 0s CASE S CoN
sù)N s w6f í 3 1
35 50 Lo k 5 0 0 N6 0 N f%Â AP 4,030 V
un . , 4-10.nense oms se o o e e
s CAS6 33 CcNS &S Roù o6 S 0(C fe Co A
pet N + s owel fr5 Soa77 o o V, 7 i D S oMA9 ¼$)p' (L
Aí¼urv6NÌ' 3. Ji,
6 D604 LoN e 6 Setolvt> otsW4Ayrd ¼Ês case Ano pi cosfsc4s
e oF«dækes,
w N his CeßÊWV Doh5 N / íME93 SO , hp ÑN ¼{6f V, o 6
45 cìBd¢S j id NsN IS @GS¼%D LN ff
01 b>0 on st*tes choice hT tà N h FSR-C#h .3 Š31, o y l%t %†bV
w&iN 7 t0 50. 21¶ CftA ool ,
iteÊ'_1 _ . ,_ , , 12 -14/,
L The peeA3cos eß¾e se no ob39¿im Ñ6 ChS& ¼D Di
w 6 0 C4SloN o S50. 474 b,4f1 + s Nn
6S o þN f%,R o ,S%hf Ma,ol2 7/ ,
C& Gk FAges,
Tho(tNkbl v A%h 33Ao as,17 ho ¿c4 U 13,fuNo½t6R , Cvh/ ett 15 f CUC.
/4f5 930 3 ILShWo V D eR 4 JA S Llid b .14f1). 13.
i& V,6 43h 30, ib RA>4 7 ,J13 73 ff JM i 151440 L ci4J-%l),13.
Tkble CM*h'o N3 ,ones. (kas.
DØ tWiÖ 3'13SS.T¾E3 3A¼q LoÜÁDÅ&LS/ / 1%È , . . . J 4.
2kl n V, foW6( Tf5 S0. 277(f1A100V, Ikl>iN 37 Jot J4iLf , ,st*ts ']49 S5 4 t| Lf i S
ochsoN V. StNe3 ty39 30 33 t AG ,3% 4cy 30 13 5 o At
Ao ni.åtM3bo30 33o3(BA a ,v StMe$od so,3 Cf
. S¼te 5% So 4td , T5%tr sg so. 13+k7)
wes V 3¾ 315 Jo, log3 o J473) . l.w¼4 V, † %â coo 10,
5 AS,130 f53 5 A5 0L L. Loy B , , 10.
JMsoN t V 3 S 30A %f l1499åknisgV.y say p Los EvocMr
5%t&Mekk o 30 3AÚllf .5%i .SW6 VA%ns ¼hro a4 h7tM4CfS'f"lo
Disässeo %f50 inh 4 ,#Ewùi&hip 349, 358 o Loh10 bg 40 25
t 3
t%3ce@N60% Aw accH&s -C 6 estA.gc nnp.1140 C 3Atl%$3M0 3
a 9 15 ,
se næus Awwon« s.Nps
om . 3240030 )03
ftAAa.oia )f¼.at*h noyfo.na m.13 Ci¼eO)(2)Lwá)ftA s% Da.o .al att. 1n592[ S.5-C. 3 ?%9 ,Aßhc¼isl ¶ lonr* . ,M¾c¾Q is fm. ceust .
C Mhc¼¾ } A 4 cm .Afttic¾ Vi 3 alb) aÙ4ro BA sh
3 7 L3 L3
,73
so, 10
7
5% ktv*o ¥.s. com¾¼¾os . LW keno v.skumb¼s ,
hrso %. C»NShk¾o/L a
1. a cowbo o e oNitrxt A wo to 3L onnen M%r tr te3gonootsi n is:osm n rheN
ShR ovmc4 ††rm41Mk 6 0R ks ao sus t
K h tu o Lv ¾e
a ce tr%p
HMenent al-¼6 cAse Ann fècá,
ON hehAlfof-fksecu¼¢¼l niscow»e&%eHour4 in ¾e % ve s brr te is ne
A Ca s oGne6 SG rD i3W
Aue LkK6 tRo ' A, ThG eA1eo W lvoN-evloenS¼¼ An14 ÂþÑ6 Con S t'o N6¼#& UTushces DAis LA se Ano
ouz c ucus at> Ah«hß(No Disc.o to k hiNkAr NE
Ev ce R6 c\¿co 50 % fn NAf¥A%VB
36 C6SS AND Ñ8V00dfrD AN of%f
D frAS ru:rHoÑ 3 len6N4 600+] 'yy Su† o ¼†&Sf $6
kNb Ñ\E cAko E'VloBac6 ON kNEss CBä& ks we as6(toSS . UN 0Üco66 ÍN fAIS 6 T
CB , Ñfth6%in WM D6Nkn o aniß sfr N0; 3D -3075 Â1to P6f(Ca
6%ßoN6ßS C6NV K6 Di3c4fr¼ JhßÁ3bicÅtoN S
ro l6 Cou&†'ith&¼& [6o oNi 0Ñ ÑIooS r ITsoh6R AS o%i2 CASG : clo¼-3075 kN10C & Alt: ADM 3¥0V ,
IN %CAsee †%6 Dis¼c4 cc SNk6%%&h .ïs IVo†-EN +o A y oRw@Acil o N%6 ftrA5aN w †he Be
w 3 (c¾nselteNc6 fed ¾ef u+ h
&¼¼ teki« oR 6S to choN kNo Sfn i4
en ¢eMom w c ArConv\ kmo e sc+r N 6
o oNs R&to sAmo L63 LoNCM3' I onsEN h Bro fte¼rrepoR ete%vhu kH5
n6« ked a is R2 ao bn V okct¥ Judteo 3%%3 Comh no
5 Wh nrw¼us errssW Å wit'çØ15N {ÈfrMoN W 6 C4 NAno senten s Fe¢ce n neo
o s Ce sMvho
60 s% con n ,
Donctus
Th6 3 ce#Showtv (tevr*tse ,o 26*¼1An A [er as o ved] h KE evivinCG
C t,o - 3¼†&1 teshne WDAsseS3%ev ole iersc6"i« R dHYl.
15
7¼S oltbomepLltaïfin
The -Furtn*h o e frosioA suf¢ene cA3 Disc4e soiekio 2dew A
Decùio De efdss Anb o co cAs wi% Dec s A& Ce kNo S
. . o)) . . 4,030
0 Th o&C n ehhe se no o sweane&k in s CAss s ANb Dk e i con e s
The oía te eth oe r e<ne s
og (Ac½ee
6N Geso 6v à k t> oIs su63 ¢esrø ws# Nr> D&S88V& &
Co A J to ßcce in Ae AR6Afavowleo e
C kNo ïAT scxno a bon
TkeRG i s IN ilt N S o
c(tsx>u k 6 C4%ne 5C6N
I oO CE Co 6( 0
R 3C 1 Atwb5 No 50 o fsD
S no
C1d D s oo EÄofnC& N½-000rt 0 5di o S+ktE kN68 +d%A1
W S30 Ao45 1 8 4759 So ßV • o
O S0 1303
W £ I vo e r o(LTrvhtmkhon w ho one e & o no è 6ssenhMe ts
es4ne u«nra w
a a oThe a a
o s D S
T .
0Aapncd1
The os eist n ok¼e acow m3+ncß is s cAse 570 ftess Do es aN
e 3 ocfèp shh¼081 z vï po aso 29 40 }ßRM A lev n 3E3 S 1 '3
Thu 3 Reâ+Mro1 oso espenorøkw a
coveneo En B ¼> s 3 onpn Bo
C n dee esGe#o 6peo
1 AGS - norNi¼ ARe un s 5%%scorÅ°omrtt e o
e 454; % 4ll r1EVio6NCB to cAts 6Dóeß 3 5wh6H in 6 (tened ro i& ne
omrAn viceo shes †o€%f& Shte 3
e (teponoenh oeldrxt neoe f*tse
e & As Ash rr onne wvt te Ites nAY6 e
C 4 kno Boasooonce( e r es no tu
C8olstef en r$3 Ant>
e whr«Krdt wks Nevcdt R&E rrwihvass †he
6p C£ínG. teko o Rev W †ke N*n&o 6 R&lech CM{rdlwig:sq
L Sthte c4Ameo 3 ogn egs newelks Reichs cer
S ON Rh4h S1% nBW EN c6 sh%s Kuo ue
8 srano ois5 o AS RfíS †60 ¡A oN o .
o S 5S.C 39
o r 5 405¼SJSo 65 S S3A #/ 4 2) wil Á4rtS 9
6 36 000
GRc vs f ( Reb e 3 -H Ce s il
6 L V, w, '391 , ¼1 VAchtFO
a 110 AS .
The o&ch o¼e secono os i 3 CAS& D 0 Co C
e o a o s
e?a%hAseo on ¾e SWres
6 †oL I1uSoM k¼dto %A . C¢m , Ce? ¾A, 8%t kl.o
L l¼no ¼%v, w L 7ro so M21GF¼. o sacci j A¢¾4e A J A)poSGCubod ÜR A C4€Ín6
2 AccogpW to l%Ce 3, tin ( )' HA i R%6 eR Seca¾oN o IN nh¼N
ecs 3 wck,e swom treso n tik%R4Ai wdt/6SS636e to twthho i s ¼SH nomi 3AN bÑ%3†vN01 c- O(T
3 v.(kk¼ àY) so 153+A% v4%s o % b A o skot3rq3sep, %15 13
1 Ay Lies¼st rös 4wvo neNHd G#od Whe
C u o s¼css C
0A<te«arøM
The o e sica of+he 3rr o céw4
A kc e 3 o cee
N
05 NL ( R 33&sspoNA1vo hra Mo o e M stotcin (to se
3.ThG G to RoV6 nM%FV ] o ee oced&&c out 6r
ft o oc
0ns (5He oE¾e e 4s neveR piso
wh RcesonMeoW1 s. ¼9 ao R so'ra
23 x a unkvvgmA9 s30/31g 16 # V b 0\LŠ
7
Tisrfo wyors cS C
Co yon ON &D iSDEn650
s one · 3 t a n § akou¼(à
C f1k H+k wt
hmAM se e s Ivon e on3t%fCf 0 n ilt C&t%f NeSS
A oc6 & Cowtt- Ã&Assanfr3A res to htre e ¼ oenen
e s eas Ann deO S 0 D 5 Th
e A Res ons
á R ndr OBoß o s c M N
ces sS - C N L
[Vio(AhoMh6 . GC4MA¾en o(%6C-oN5%¼ho 6 Stue A b#
f%enceo w ¾& oeH rd¾%o oN noø$s, The oec¿3tpg Triceno oi3
s was LCo to oR invoWkN VNR6ks k N &5ktc ish6cfens¢At LAw A$v (3dyed 3rateNc6 wks AND A (C4cw% Wo l%#¿i'Doush lik ts.Af6¼cle 1 Roß. C<>MS oR CoN
S Á edv lheføs 5M o JHtes Colch¼ on ,
C I fB .. rio
Mcansoßka.
C e o (c6
I 6 A †¢a& Ano Oc
eo / A s : CAerte NL ThoriAS 0 WM¼ Too
3 A e kryFloruoA .325g Josoo c o 6 RN Too . sie
A33&oQ3So'JF:r
33ack 13'10
1
D.C-
Cir4K Supten& t<upbo 4'tok¿oABAÅskS D500 5 DwVNÍ Jtfl6;lA A55 Er& 3 flof A .315%,A030 -
0$ce o M&te Miotoo G KäyNeo bodayTh†â flogé . 33b03,
ON& 0 h6 htfo/W SfM6f@ÍtÝDb kN A KLA H{ %ncouR3r3507 &. f¢o r G u fe*olooTb A o&voA 33kol 1013,
e se s osIkAve rtJWò s olchonA1 Ano Er St oisÚ hitfr 6 o Co
DA%v A3 s
o(10 nLoiÓ