nsa - out of control - who audits the auditors? imagine we leak it all. 12.21.2012 11:11 project...

7/31/2019 NSA - OUT OF CONTROL - WHO AUDITS THE AUDITORS? iMAGIne we LEAK it ALL. 12.21.2012 11:11 Project Mayhe

1/7

j gj{ yfqyfrfg{6/BYF[

Jv{ jh Bjg{yjl %V$

DG[YJKVB[DJG %{l$%V$ Dg '{efdy vfr{ {j ifgfhd{ hyjm {ef cyfo{ okxog{ocfr jh 'gf{sjy`fk bjmqv{fy

rtr{fmr, {ef V'R' mdld{oyt og k dg{flldcfgbf bjmmvgd{dfr eoxf qv{ olmjr{ oll jh { e f d w blorrdhdfk dghjymo{djg )fccr) dg{j jgf xfyt qyfboydjvr ior`f{> bjmqv{fy r t r { w m okmdgdr{yo{jyr' O yflo{dxflt rmoll gvmify jh rtr{fm okmdgdr{yo{jyr oyf oilf {j {fok,bjqt, mjxf, ol{fy, og k kfr{yjt olmjr{ fxfyt' qdfbf jh blorrdhdfk dghjymo{djg eogklfk it ocdxfg ocfgbt jyjycogd~o{djg' Og dgrdkfy-cjgf-iok sd{e fgjvce eob`dgc r`dllr {j c o w yjj{qydxdlfcfr mdce{ obvdyf rdmdloy boqoidld{dfr' D{ rffmr omo~dgc {eo{ rj hfs oyf olljsfk {jbjg{yjl rj mvbe - oqqoyfg{lt sd{e ld{{lf jy gj rvqfyxdrdjg jy rfbvyd{t ovkd{r' [ef rtr{fmokmdgdr{yo{jyr mdce{ ovkd{ vrfyr, iv{ sej ovkd{r {efm: Fxfg dh edcefy lfxfl ovkd{dgc jhrtr{fm okmdgdr{yo{jyr {o`fr qlobf, d{ dr vgld`flt {eo{ rvbe ovkd{r oyf hyfvfg{ fgjvce jyf'u{fgrdxf fgjvce' {j if fhhfb{dxf, frqfbdollt ocodgr{ fuqfy{r sej qyjioilt `gjs {efdyrtr{fmr if{{fy {eog {efdy ovkd{jyr'

%8 VJ$ #yedr dr' gj{ mfog{ or og o{{ob` jg {ef dg{fcyd{t jh rtr{fm okmdgdr{yo{jyr or osejlf, gjy dr d{ og o{{fmq{ {j ilomf ogtjgf hjy' {edr coqdgc xvlgfyoidld{t' D { dr, yo{efy, osoygdgc {eo{'rtr{fm okmdgdr{yo{jyr oyf ld`flt {j if {oycf{fk- dgbyfordgclt {oycf{fk- it hjyfdcg dg{flldcfgbf rfyxdbfr ifbovrf jh {efdy rqfbdol obbfrr {j dghjymo{djg' [edr drfrqfbdollt {yvf hjy {ef rtr{fm okmdgdr{yo{jyr jhblorrdhdfk gf{sjy`r' Edr{jydbol fxdkfgbfhjyfdcg dg{flldcfgbf {oycf{dgc jh V'R' bjmmvgdbo{jyr- qfjqlf sej eok rqfbdol obbfrr {jbytq{jcyoqedb mo{fydol- r{yjgclt rvqqjy{r {edr orrfy{djg'

%V$ [l\dr rd{vo{djg olrj yodrfr o bjgbfyg oijv{ dgkdxdkvol obbjvg{oidld{t hjy blol:rdhdfkdghjymo{djg' Dg re'jy{, dgkdxdkvol vrfyr eoxf ljr{ bjg{yjl jxfy obbfrr {j flfb{yjgdb -''>fyrdjg,rjh {efdy blorrdhdfk hdlfr' Dh {ef gfu{ Olkydbe Omfr {vygr jv{ {j if o rtr{fm okmdgdr{yo{jysej r{folr ogk rfllr blorrdhdfk yfqjy{r r{jyfk jg-ldgf it ogoltr{r jy j{efy vrfyr, sdll w e f vrfyr if ldoilf dg ogt sot: Blfoylt, r{fqr mvr{ if {o`fg {j bjvg{fy {ef {eyfo{ {j rtr{fmokmdgdr{yo{jyr ogk {j fgrvyf dgkdxdkvol obbjvg{oidld{t hjy blorrdhdfk dghjymo{djg {eo{ drbyfo{fk, qyjbfrrfk, jy r{jyfk flfb{yjgdbollt'

BJMMVGDBO[JYR EOXF IFFG EFOXDLT [OYCF[FKHJY [EFDY OBBFRR [J @ w T {R VJ$%RVJ$ Kvydgc {ef Bjlk Soy, vg{jlk gvmifyr jh qfjqlf sfyf yfbyvd{fk it Rjxdf{ Iljb

dg{flldcfgbf rfyxdbfr {j rqt ocodgr{ {ef V'R' og k {ef Sfr{, o w j g c {ef mjr{ qyd~fkocfg{r sfyf V'R' bjmmvgdbo{jyr jy j{efyr sej bjvlk rvqqlt bytq{jcyoqedb mo{fydol ogkyf'lo{fk dghjymo{djg' If{sffg ?4;8 ogk ?458,? l{,N'R' c j w f y g m f g {

Q ' L ' 58 - 28

Kfblorrdhdfk ogk oqqyjxfk hjy y f l f o r w it GRO jg12-92 91?? qvyrvog{ hhd&_ ?269kD>N'5' 4QliT _h{fJl% F J ? ' ; ' %b $

Q ' L ' 58 - 28


2/7

''' y j > 2 4 8 3 ?9j RFBYF[ BYTQ[JLJCDB _VOY[FYLT

)0) /) ''' ' ' '' ' '

qfyrjggfl sfyf `gjsg {j bjmqyjmdrf V'R' bytq{jcyoqedb rtr{fmr jg ifeolh jh hjyfdcgdg{flldcfgbf rfyxdbfr, qydmoydlt {ejrf jh {ef Rjxdf{ Vgdjg' Mogt j{efy dgkdxdkvolr olrjqyjxdkfk V'R' `ft {j hjyfdcg dg{flldcfgbf rfyxdbfr iv{ sfyf gfxfy hjymollt beoycfk' Bytq{j`ft sor %ogk r{dll dr$ ej { r{vhh ifbovrf obvdydgc d { - frqfbdollt {eyjvce og ocfg{- sor {effordfr{ sot {eo{ {e f iok' cvtr bjvlk codg obbfrr {j evgkyfkr jy fxfg {ejvrogkr jh blorrdhdfkV'R' mfrrocfr'

RTR[FM OKMDGDR[YO[JYR OYF QJ[FG[DOLLT MJYF LVBYO[DXFEVMDG[[OYCF[R[EOG BJMMVGDBO[JYR %RVJ${R VJ$ Sd{'e rtr{fm okmdgdr{yo{jyr, {ejvce, {ef rd{vo{djg dr qj{fg{dolltmvbe sjyrf

{eog d { eo r fxfy iffg sd{e bjmmvgdbo{jyr' Dg qoy{, {edr dr ifbovrf {ef rtr{fmokmdgdr{yo{jyr bog rj fordlt, rj vdb`lt, rj vgkf{fb{oilt, r{fol xor{ vog{d{dfr jhdghjymo{djg' Bjmmvgdbo{jyr jh {ef qor{ vrvollt rfg{ jglt yflo{dxflt rejy{ mfrrocfr ogk)hdgdrefk) kjbvmfg{r, iv { {jkot#r rtr{fm okmdgdr{yo{jyr bog ji{odg hvll-lfgc{e bjqdfr jhfg{dyf yfqjy{r, dgblvkdgc kyoh{ xfyrdjgr, or sfll or dghjymol f-modl mfrrocfr, flfb{yjgdbbolfgkoy oqqjdg{mfg{r, ogk o sdkf xoydf{t jhj{efy ko{o'

%V$ Dg rjmf borfr, {eft mdce{ fxfg if oilf {j mjvg{ seo{ oyf bollfk bljrf-dg {fbegdbolo{{ob`r it yfmj{flt ob{dxo{dgc sjy`r{o{djg mdbyjqejgfr, fhhfb{dxflt {vygdgc {efm dg{jovkdj )ivcr') [eft olrj eoxf {ef oidld{t {j obvdyf ogk qyf-rjy{ edce-vold{t dghjymo{djg,sedbe roxfr {ef hjyfdcg dg{flldcfgbf rfyxdbf {dmf ogk yfrjvybfr {eo{ sjvlk j{efysdrf ifkfxj{fk {j rjy{dgc {eyjvce ivl` bjllfb{djg' Hvy{efymjyf, rtr{fm okm dgdr{yo{jyr oyf boqoilf jh m o g w q v l o { d j g -kfr{yjtdgc jy ol{fydgc ko{o ogk bjg{yjlldgc {ef oxodloidld{t jhgf{sjy`r jy rqfbdhdb oqqldbo{djgr '

HJYFDCG DG[FLLDCFGBF RFYXDB FR OYF OLYFOKT [OYCF[DGCBJMQV[FY Q F Y R J G G F L w

RFBYE 98;V 'R' JGLT JYf{E 1 > w 7 0

''

? ' ;Q 'L '


3/7

DK> 2483?91

JV[ JH BJG[YJL

? ' ; ' %b $' Q,'L ' 58 - 28

RFFOF[

''''' [edR soygmc oijv{ {ef EVM DG[ xvlgfyoidld{t dr dg gj sot mfog{ {j kjsgqlot{ef gffk hj y r{ydgcfg{ {fbegdbol rfbvyd{t rjlv{djgr, iv { nvr{ or vgiyfo`oilf V 'R'bytq{jcyoqet eo r qvrefk hjyfdcg dg{flldcfgbf rfyxdbfr {j {oycf{ {ef qfjqlf sej b>>jg{yjl {ef

' `ft, rj {jj sdll r{yjgcfy gf{sjy` rfbvyd{t rqvy dgbyforfk {oycf{dgc jh {ef qfjqlf sejbjg{yjl {ef bjmqv{fyr'

986 FBYF['-V'R JGLT % # # l l { F 6 / w

# '

\


4/7

2483?91

RFBYF[ BYTQ[JLJCDB _VOY[FYLT

[EF GFFK H J w MJYF DGKDXDKVOL OBBJVG[OIDLD[T %V$

? ' ; ' %b $F'j ? ' ; ' % c $N:


5/7

248'3?91 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - w = = -JV[ JZH BJG[YJL RFFY/l

%V$ [efrf oy f {yjvildgc vfr{djgr 'ifbovrf, fxfg {ejvce {ef xor{ mon_yd>{t jh d g { w V d c f g b f { 7 f y r w g g f l oyf gj{ rtr{fm okmdgdr{yo{jyr, {eft oyf r{dl l lfcollt, qyjhfrrdjgollt0ogk m w y o l l t yfrqjgrdilf hjy {ef blorrdhdfk dghjymo{djg {eo{ {eft qyjkvbf, eogklf, jy r { j y f wV r f y w jh blorrnhdfk rtr{fmr mvr{, {efyfhjy-f, if cdxfg cyfo{fyZ jg{yjl- dgkdxdkvollt>- jxfy'>{ef flfb{yjgdb xfyrdjgr jh {efdy g:{fr, yfqjy{r, ogk j { w f y kjbvmfg{r' [ef dghjymo{djg o{ydr` dgblvkfr

sdkflt kdrrfmdgo{fk blorrdhdfk ogk rfgrd{dxf-iv{-vgblorrdhdfk kjb{>dmfg{r0edcelt bjmqoy{mfg{fk dghjymo{djg sd{e xfyt r{ydb{ g f w k {j `gjs0dghjymo{djg qyj{fb{fk it {ef 'qydxobt ob{, rvbe or qfyrjggfl hdlfr, mfkdbolyfbjykr, ogk rfbvyd{t hdlfr0j { e f w edcelt rfgrd{dxf dghjymo{djg, rvbe or Dgrqfb{jy w g f y o l dgxfr{dco{djgrogk rfbvyd{t dgxfr{dco{djgr hjy bjvg'{fydg{flldcfgbf jy los fghjybfmfg{mo{{fyr'

BJGBLVRDJGR OGK YFBJMMFGKO[DJGR %V$[qf cyjsdgc {eyfo{ {q rtr{fm okmdgdr{yo{jyr efdce{fy>{r {ef gffk hjy obbjvg{oid ld{t

hjy blorrdhdfk flfb{yjgdb d g h j y m o { d w g , iv{ {efyf dr gj jgf f o r t ' # w g r s f y {j {edr qyjilfm' >Mjr{vrfyr fgnjt ogk w q q y f b d o { f gfs {fbegjljct og%d ol l jh {ef orrjbdo{fk ifgfhd{r, hy'jm'f-modl {jivllf{ndN' ijoykr {f Sfi iyjsrfyr {j b%$r{-roxdgc reoyfk y f w j v y b f r > D{ dr vgld`flt o w t 4 g f sog{r {j yf{vyg {j ' {ef qyf-bldfg{-rfyxfy fyo, fxfg dh d{ sfyf qjrrdilf '{j kj rj' R{dll {e fmdld{oyt ogk d g w f l l d c f g b f bjmmvgd{dfr mvr{ kj rjmf{edgc dh {eft oy f {j { f w / $ { o i l d r l /

983f I' ({jhiT 8{{fm#

FJ ? ' ; ' %FJ ? ' ; ' %Q ' L ' 58 -


6/7

N > w w 2483?9158 - 28

RFFOF[ BYTQD#JLJCDB _VOY[FYLT

' dgkdxdkvol fmqljtffr# bjg{yjl jxfy {ef )dghj'ymo{djg hjy sedbe {eft oyf qfyrjgolltyfrqjgrdilf' Qjrrdilf ob{djgr dgblvkf {ef hjlljsdgc>

' '%V$ Olljs qetrdbol rfqoyo{djgr p>yjm gf{sjy`r' Olljs fobe sjy`r{o{djg {jhvgb{djg or ij{e o r{ogk-oljgf ogk o gf{s'jy` {fymdgol, sd{e o qetrdbolkdrbjggfb{ hyjm {ef LOG jy j{ld'fy gf{sjy`' Qfjqlf sej gffk {j sjy` jg edcedtrfgrd{dxf mo{{fyr' bjvlk {evr kj rj sd{e lfrr ogudf{t oijv{ gf{sjy` o{{ob`r itqetrdbollt kdrbjggfb{dgc hyjm {efdy LOG' [j if fhhfb{dxf, {edr sjvlk y>fvdyf{ef mjyf fuqfgrdxf dgr{ollo{djg jh sjyk qyjbfrrdgc jy j{efy oqqldbo{djgr jgfobe sjy`r{o{djg- yo{efy {eog or o reoyfk gf{sjy` yfrjvybf vrdgc )ldbfgrfr)iv { d{ sjvlk olrj olljs qfjqlf {j if q y w k v b { d x f kvydgc gf{sjy` kjsg {dmf' Jh

' bjvyrf, bjggfb{dgc {j {ef g f { w j y ` {j rfgk f-modl jy rvyh {ef Sfi sjvlk eoxf {jif o yflo{dxflt _#0Ddb` ogk fort qyjbfkvyf- rvbe or qlvccdgc dg o boilf ogk {efg

'bldb`dgc jg og dbjg'pl)8{l#8$ h? jvdkf fgbytq{oilf eoyk kydxfr' Ogoltr{r ogk mogocfyr rejvlkoilf {j rsyf dghjymo{djg jg {efdy jsg sjy`r{o{djgr# dgkdxdkvol eoyk kydxfr dgog fgbytq{fk hjym {eo{ b o g g w { if 'kfbytq{fk it ogtjgf flrf, dgblvkdgc rtr{fmokmdgdr{yo'{jyr ' Tfr, rjmf qfjqlf sdll hjycf{ o qorrsjyk jy rjmf{edgc ogk fgkvq ljrdgc og dmqjy{og{ hdlf, iv{ {eo{ dr {ef qydbf 'jh dgkdxdkvol yfrqjgrdidld{t '[ejrf ogoltr{r sej kj edcelt bjmqoy{mfg{fk jy j{efysdrf rfgrd#{dxf sjy`rejvlk if qyjxdkfk sd{e yfmjxoilf eoyk kydxfr {eo{ bog if fgbytq{fk og kr{jyfk dg o {eyff-bjmij rohf' D{ sjvlk if qyfhfyoilf dh, dg {ef hv{vyf, oll eoykkydxfr bjlk if# yfmjxfk hjy r{jyocf dg o rohf {j qyfxfg{ {efh{ jy komocf hyjmhdyf jy j w e f y kdror{fyr' Iv{ {efg' fud{ dgrqfb{dJh:'R sjvlk eoxf {j if y f d g r w d { v { f k

{j eflq qyfxfg{ qfjq#l'f hyjm boyytdgc {ef ky dZxfr jv{' Og ol{fygo{dxf sjvlkif {jdgr{oll rfgrjyr o{ fobe fud{ ogk {oc fobe kydxf sd{e o {ydccfy mfbeogdrm, rdmdloy {j {ef {fbegjljct vrfk it r{jyfr {j bjmio{ rejqldh{dgc'%h_l>N_$ Cdxf M6 ogk j{efy r f b w w > y d { t jycogd~o{djgr mjyf m j g w t ' y{ dr ' v g w d r f {jbv{ rfbvyd{t ivkcf'{r gjs, ogk d{#r gj{ jglt ifbovrf jh {ef {eyfo{ jh o rqfbdolltfvdqqfk Ytkfy yfg{ol xog {o`dgc jv{ eolh jh {ef H OGU DDD ivdlkdgc' Jxfyoll,fmqljtff rvrbfq{didld{t {j hjyfdcg dg{flldcfgbf yfbyvd{mfg{ eor qyjioiltdgbyforfk# >dg {edr fyo jh vgqyfbfkfg{fk ivkcf{ bv{r ogk {ef obbjmqogtdgc ljsmjyolf' Dg {ef ljgc-{fym, rfbvyd{t ob{r o r o hjybf-mvl{dqldfy ifbovrf d{ ld'md{r

RFFYF[ 985{0'r' 4QhiT fYf{m


7/7

2483?91

Dl

JV[JHBJG[YJL RFBYF[

j{efysdrf fuqjgfg{dol ljrrfr bovrfk it rqdfr, og k cjjk ivkcf{ qloggfyr `gjs{eo{ hjybf mvl{dqldfyr rejvlk gj{ if bv { o{ {ef romf yo{f or yfcvloy hjybfrkvydgc kjsgrd~dgc'

D ? Ef ?r {ef qgmoyt fkd{jyjh -{ef Go{{jgol DGHJRFB Dg{flldcfgbfYfxdfs %GDDY$, qvildrefk oqfydjkdbolltit X69, ogk {ef DRRJ Cljiol [eyfo{Rvmmoyt, o yfhfyfgbf mogvol o lrj

'qvildrefk it X69' Ef njdgfk {e f Ocfgbt#d g ?458 ogk sor qyjhfrrdjgold~fk or ogD g { w V / c f g b f Yfrfoybe % lY$ Ogoltr{ dg?441 oh{-fy cyokvo{dgc hyjm {efDY dg{fygqyjcyom' hd f eor og M'O' dg go{djgolrfbvy d {t r{d>{-{hdfr h yjm Cfjycf{jsgVgdxfyrd{t ogk I w O ' dg hjyfdcg ohhodyr 'hyjm {ef Vgdxfyrd{t jh Xdycdgdo' Ef'

ejlkr m w m i f y r e d q r dg {ef Go{djgol Mdld,{oyt Dg{flldcfgbf Orrjbdo{djg, {efOrrjbdo{djg jh Jlk Byjsr, ogk {ef Dg{fygo{djgol Ohhodyr Dgr{d{v{f' Ef sor

' hjymfylt o beoq{fy qyfrdkfg{ jh Qd Rdcmo Olqeo, {e f G o{djgo-? Qjld{dbol RbdfgbfEjgjy Rjbdf{t' Ef dr og osoyk-sdggdgc f r r w t d r { ogk eor qvildrefk w f x f y o l oy{dblfr dg qyjhfrrdjgol njvygolr o { GRO ogk BDO'

Kfydxfk hyjm>

Kfblorrdht Jg>

984V'R' mhiT JYBml

GRO*BRRM ?929,Ko{fk 2 Rfq{fmify ?44?Rjvybf Moy`fk )JOKY)p$o{f jh Rjvybf> 2 Rfq %E

RFBYF[

F_ ? '; ' %ZFJ ? ' ; ' %* Q ' L '

nsa - out of control - who audits the auditors? imagine we leak it all. 12.21.2012 11:11 project...

Documents