nrcan/cgsb certification of ndt personnel: program … · ndt c.b. – yearly statistics 3...
TRANSCRIPT
NRCan/CGSB Certification of NDT Personnel:
Program Updates
Presentation for 2013 CINDE Conference – Oct 10, 2013
P.K. Yuen
Manager
National Non-Destructive Testing Certification Body /
Organisme national de certification en Essais-Non-Destructif
CanmetMATERIALS
Natural Resources Canada
Government of Canada / Gouvernement du Canada
2
Presentation Outline
Program Updates
Certification Statistics
Administration & Client Service
Scheme and Technical Committees
ISO 9712:2012 – CGSB Adoption CAN/CGSB 48.9712:2013
Preview and Highlights of Updated Requirements and Rules of
Implementation
Recertification
Training and Examination
Summary
3 NDT C.B. – Yearly Statistics
Certificates Issued
PERSONNEL CERTIFIED EACH YEAR – 2012, 2011, 2010.
JANUARY 1, 2012 - December 31, 2012
Method Level
XRF RT UT MT PT ET Total
3 2 7 3 7 0 19
2 73 38 65 234 166 17 593
1 156 5 104 22 287
Total certified NDT clients: 572
Total certified NDT+XRF clients: 801
Certified Level 3 Clients: 19 Certified Level 2 Clients: 520
Certified Level 1 Clients: 131
Total NDT certificates issued: 670
Total NDT+XRF certificates issued: 899 Total 229 45 176 237 173 39 899
JANUARY 1, 2011 - DECEMBER 31, 2011
Method Level
XRF RT UT MT PT ET Total
3 4 4 4 3 1 16
2 108 51 90 195 149 18 611
1 114 22 100 14 250
Total certified NDT clients: 562
Total certified NDT+XRF clients: 784
Certified Level 3 Clients: 16 Certified Level 2 Clients:395
Certified Level 1 Clients: 136
Total NDT certificates issued: 655
Total NDT+XRF certificates issued: 877 Total 222 77 194 199 152 33 877
JANUARY 1, 2010 - DECEMBER 31, 2010
Method Level
XRF RT UT MT PT ET Total
3 3 3 3 9 2 20
2 69 40 88 216 156 13 582
1 87 14 102 19 222
Total certified NDT clients: 571
Total certified NDT+XRF clients: 733
Certified Level 3 Clients: 20 Certified Level 2 Clients: 513
Certified Level 1 Clients: 135
Total NDT certificates issued: 668
Total NDT+XRF certificates issued: 824 Total 156 57 193 219 165 34 824
4 NDT C.B. – Statistics:
Certificate Renewals
2012 NDT RENEWAL WIND UP A total of 1974 individuals with the family name starting with the letters G-M were to renew
their NDT certifications by December 31, 2012. Renewal notices went out mid September 2012.
As of May 3, 2013, 1763 individuals renewed at least one of their certificates. Thus 211
individuals failed to renew at least one of their certificates. This is an attrition rate of
10.6%. Note: We continue to receive renewal information daily and this rate may
continue to decrease.
Note: The attrition rate for the year before (2012) was 10.1%, and the rates in the previous years
were 10.9 for 2011, 11.7% for 2010, 11.7% for 2009, 15.0% for 2008, 14.5% for 2007, 15.8%
for 2006, and 13.5% for 2005.
NDT Certificates not renewed by May 3, 2013
Method Level
XRF RT UT MT PT ET Total
3 7 3 5 6 1 22
2 36 35 45 133 108 12 369
1 71 20 55 2 2 8 158
Total NDT non renewed clients:
211
22
: 333
87
Total NDT + XRF certificate drop: 549 Total 107
62
103 140 116 21 549
NDT Certificates not renewed by April 30, 2012
Method Level
XRF RT UT MT PT ET Total
3 4 2 5 4 0 15
2 41 26 96 91 9 263
1 1 17 48 10 76
Total NDT non renewed clients:
160
15
: 263
75
Total NDT + XRF certificate drop: 354 Total 1 62 76 101 95 19 354
5
Administration & Client Service:
Update
Program priority
Providing expedient and high quality client-service nationally
Updating and improving program delivery and policies
Full website restructure (http://ndt.nrcan.gc.ca)
Enhanced usability and accessibility
Improved organization of information / documents, structured by
specific program
NRCan / CGSB 48.9712 NDT Personnel Certification
NRCan / Health Canada Portable XRF Operator Certification
CNSC CEDO Written Examination
6
Program Updates
Refreshing and Rebuilding the fundamentals
Establishing resources (after relocation from Ottawa to
Hamilton)
Stakeholders & Industry Engagement
Improved relevancy and transparency in decision-making
and program interpretations
Establishment of Scheme and Technical Committee(s)
For the ongoing maintenance and further development of the national
program, stakeholder consultation and industry participation will be
the key fundamental philosophies for the program - Inputs from
Industry and Experts
First inaugural meeting to be held during Oct 22-23, 2013 at Trois-
Rivieres (in conjunction with the CGSB 48/2 Committee meeting)
Updated and Improved XRF Version 4 will be launched
very soon
7
Structure - Committees
CanmentMATERIALS (CMAT)
NDT CA Advisory and Scheme Committee
CMAT NDT CA Advisory Members:Recommendations provided directly to CANMET-MTL Directorate
NDT CA Scheme Committee Members:Immediate Agenda Topics:
Recertification Implementation
Further Structure Development
Sectoring Review: Broad Sectors vs. Specific, Additional methods for AS?
NRCan National NDT Certification Agency
Technical Committee
/ Taskgroup:
PT
Special Committee::
Official
Languages
Supports
Supports
Technical Committee
/ Taskgroup:
MT
Technical Committee
/ Taskgroup:
VT(Proposed – for review)
Technical Committee
/ Taskgroup:
UT
(+ Advanced)(UT-PA SubTaskgroup)
Technical Committee
/ Taskgroup:
ET
Technical Committee
/ Taskgroup:
RT(Digital RT ?)
CanmentMATERIALS (CMAT)
NDT CA Advisory and Scheme Committee
CMAT NDT CA Advisory Members:Recommendations provided directly to CANMET-MTL Directorate
NDT CA Scheme Committee Members:Immediate Agenda Topics:
Recertification Implementation
Further Structure Development
Sectoring Review: Broad Sectors vs. Specific, Additional methods for AS?
NRCan National NDT Certification Agency
Technical Committee
/ Taskgroup:
PT
Special Committee::
Official
Languages
Supports
Supports
Technical Committee
/ Taskgroup:
MT
Technical Committee
/ Taskgroup:
VT(Proposed – for review)
Technical Committee
/ Taskgroup:
UT
(+ Advanced)(UT-PA SubTaskgroup)
Technical Committee
/ Taskgroup:
ET
Technical Committee
/ Taskgroup:
RT(Digital RT ?)
8
ISO 9712:2012 – CGSB Adoption
Updated Rules of Implementation
Clarifications for Recertification
CAN/CGSB 48.9712:2013 & Updated Rules of Implementation –
Preview and Some Highlights of Proposed Requirements
For RT-only: Radiation Safety Training
The candidate shall complete a minimum amount of radiation safety training provided by an
Accepted Training Organization.
Rationale: in section 7.2.4, reference Table 2, “Note: For RT, training hours do not include radiation
safety training.” This leaves a significant gap in the training requirements for a critical subject
matter, and should be addressed with an appropriate minimum requirement.
CAN/CGSB 48.9712:2013 & Updated Rules of Implementation –
Preview and Some Highlights of Proposed Requirements
CAN/CGSB 48.9712:2013 & Updated Rules of Implementation –
Preview and Some Highlights of Proposed Requirements
8. Minimum Period of Experience Prior to Examination
NRCan to define meaningful % experience prior to Practical & Written Examinations
For Written Examinations:
a) Level 1: TBD (0%?)
b) Level 2: TBD (0%?)
c) Level 3: TBD (25%?)
For Practical Examinations:
a) Level 1: TBD (25-50%?)
b) Level 2: TBD (25-50%?)
c) Level 3: TBD (25-50%?)
Rationale: This is needed to satisfy the requirements under 7.3.1. The minimum period required should be meaningful and provides the basis for valid on-the-job type industrial experience. Some CGSB committee members suggested that even at 100%, the certification process has worked well in the past.
CAN/CGSB 48.9712:2013 & Updated Rules of Implementation –
Preview and Some Highlights of Proposed Requirements
7. Validated Attestations of Experience
a) Employer: On the updated application form, each level of reported experience (trainee, Level 1 and Level 2) will be attested to in writing by the candidate’s Employer.
b) Supervisor: On the updated application form, each level of reported experience (trainee, Level 1 and Level 2) will be attested to in writing by the employee’s Supervisor.
c) Sponsor: To protect the attestation from Supervisors/Employers ‘who will sign anything’, a Sponsor (CGSB certified Level 2 or 3) must co-sign the attestation of the various levels of experience.
In special situations, (for example: self-employed work status, or other misc situations, etc.), special accommodations may be granted on a case-by-case basis by NRCan, provided that supporting written attestations are available.
25% Verification: As a general process guideline, NRCan will verify the claimed experience of 25% of applicants.
Questionable experience: If the experience claimed is questionable, NRCan will perform a detailed assessment and investigation, and may also further verify the experience.
Rationale: To protect the integrity of the certification scheme and properly validate the attestation of experience from unscrupulous Supervisors, a Sponsor (CGSB certified Level 2 or 3) must co-sign the attestation of the various levels of experience.
Should the claimed experience be revealed as false, NRCan can take disciplinary action against those certified individuals who falsely attested. E.g. That’s why a sponsor is required; as other non-certified individuals are not signatories to the NRCan Code-of-Conduct.
CAN/CGSB 48.9712:2013 & Updated Rules of Implementation –
Preview and Some Highlights of Proposed Requirements
CAN/CGSB 48.9712:2013 & Updated Rules of Implementation –
Preview and Some Highlights of Proposed Requirements
14. Accommodation Process for Foreign candidates
a. Training: A foreign candidate, claiming previous training, will be directed to an accepted training organization of his choice, where he must pass the training organization's tests for:
i) Basic Math
ii) Materials & processes, and
iii) NDT method(s).
NRCan will accept as proof of adequate prior training, a certificate issued by the accepted training organization stating that the candidate had passed these tests (i, ii, iii).
Note: The candidate does not have to take the training courses - just the tests. The candidate gets two tries at the tests. In the event that the candidate cannot pass the tests, the candidate must take the necessary training course(s) appropriate to pass each of the tests.
NRCan will treat both national and foreign candidates the same way. All must produce a certificate from an NRCan accepted training organization stating the candidate has passed the training organizations test for basic math, the test for materials and processes and all tests pertaining the NDT methods/levels in which he/she seeks certification.
b. Experience: A foreign candidate, claiming previous experience, will be required to meet the same requirements as national candidates. In cases where the experience is questionable and/or difficult to verify (previous supervisors reside in a foreign country, NRCan-certified sponsor not available), NRCan will further assess the submitted claims of experience.
c. Certification: NRCan will assess the submitted claims of certification of a foreign candidate. His certifications may be acceptable proof of prior training and experience and NRCan may allow him to proceed to full or partial examination. On the other hand, the foreign candidate may be required to demonstrate training and experience as per item 14 a.) and b.).
CAN/CGSB 48.9712:2013 & Updated Rules of Implementation –
Preview and Some Highlights of Proposed Requirements
Recertification – Strategic Approach
CGSB 48/2 NDT and NRCan Scheme Committee: NRCan to proceed forward in providing an implementation that complies with the requirements in the 9712 standard
Considering the associated financial and logistical challenges, NRCan is taking a very careful approach in finalizing the details of recertification. Various elements are being adjusted and optimized for our national needs.
E.g. the selection and refining of applicable test specimens, the coordinated scheduling and availability of examinations, a gradual transition through phase-in of expiry dates, etc.
The desired goal is a mandatory recertification process that is consistent, unbiased, credible, and places the least amount of undue stress on the industry, the users, and the certified personnel.
Note: a voluntary recertification program via practical examination has been available for those seeking full compliance with respect to the recertification element in the ISO / CGSB 9712 standards. Some individuals who are certified under the current NRCan / CGSB scheme have
already been successfully recertified under this provision.
Going forward: an Effective and
Achievable Implementation Plan
Flexible options to achieve efficient and effective recertification compliance is being considered - Mechanisms to minimize cost and disruptions:
Practical examination specimens for recertification
Number of specimens: 1 to 3 test pieces depending on Method/Level/Sector
Optimized selection and grading criteria for recertification exams
Not treated or graded as initial certification exam
Options for examination locations
Current network of Authorized Examination Centres (AECs)
Special Examination Centres for Recert (i.e. On-Site locations)
To allow registering of on-job-site locations as special examination centers (i.e. ref section 5.4.2)
Procedures and control mechanisms will be incorporated to deal with potential conflicts of interest
May be eligible to piggy-back onto other task-qualification or performance-demonstration
“Recertification examination kits” to be made available for Special Examination Centres or other viable examination proctoring locations
Combine mandatory recertification roll-out with extended renewal cycle (changeover from 3 to 5 years)
Transitional phase-in of 5-10 years from start of mandatory program – grace period
15
Training and Examination
National Forum for NDT Certification Training and Examination was held on May 2nd, 2012 at Hamilton by NRCan Participation from Accepted Training Organizations (ATOs), Authorized
Examination Centres (AECs), and other interested parties (scheduled in conjunction with CGSB Standard Committee)
Technical Workshops/Seminars were provided by NRCan Staff & Examiners + with Open Discussion Sessions with All Participants
Plan for next one in 2014
Priority: Improve communication, support and requirements to Training Organizations and Authorized Examination Centres Quality, Consistency, Effectiveness
Fully updated requirements and guidelines for ATO’s and AEC’s is being developed and implemented
Will be addressed and finalized via NRCan Scheme Committee
16
Upcoming Scheme Topics
Evaluate and provide recommendations on key
processes and documentation/requirements in
support of maintaining and further developing our
quality management system
Priority topics / Items:
Recertification
Accepted Training Organization (ATO) Requirements
Authorized Examination Center (AEC) Requirements
Minimum Experience Requirement Before Examination
Confirming Sector Definition
Certification process: improvements for the
administrative scheme and client-service aspects
17
Summary
Properly implementing the updated CGSB/ISO standard is critical
NRCan will be very cautious in implementing updated requirements,
and where possible, provide effective alternative options to support
the industry and certification candidates.
Clarifications for the transition to the updated standard will be
available on our website when details are locked-in.
We’re entering a new chapter for how the certification scheme will
be maintained and improved going forward
Many opportunities for inputs from stakeholders and the industry.
Your ongoing support is essential and much appreciated.
The Canadian CGSB / NRCan system is here to serve you.
18
Thank you! NRCan NDT website for program info & updates
http://ndt.nrcan.gc.ca (English)
http://end.rncan.gc.ca (Français)
Seize this opportunity to better shape and tailor our
Canadian program to best satisfy the needs of our
industry. Working together, renew and refresh our
Canadian system to be best-in-world & best-in-class!
19
QUESTIONS?
DISCUSSION
FEEDBACK
20
ADDITIONAL / BACKUP SLIDES
NDT Personnel Certification
22 ISO – CGSB Adoption:
Considerations
Credibility
National
International
Long-term (Impact: 6-8 year cycles)
System Integrity
Part of a world-wide evolving and continually improving system
Foundation for Growth in Recognition
Confidence
23
Technical Areas of Interest
Advanced Ultrasonics - Phased-Array Ultrasonic Inspection (UT-PA) Program UT-PA: confirmed need for national certification
NRCan will implement a program for UT-PA within the next 9-12 months
Program details to be further developed through Technical Committee structure
Ongoing Evaluations to Support Additional Technologies Digital Radiography – Updated body of knowledge
Visual Inspection (VT)
Etc.
23