novo performance review 20100122

23
Novo Asset Management LLC Performance Review As of January 22, 2010 NOS VOBISCUM

Upload: davidloeffel

Post on 18-Nov-2014

867 views

Category:

Economy & Finance


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Performance review for investors as of 01/22/2010.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Novo Performance Review 20100122

Novo Asset Management LLC

Performance ReviewAs of January 22, 2010

NOS VOBISCUM

Page 2: Novo Performance Review 20100122

2

Legal Disclaimer

“This information has been prepared as a summary to describe certain trading strategies developed by Novo Asset Management LLC. This summary does not constitute an offering of limited partnership interest in any fund managed by Novo Asset Management LLC. An offering may only be made by means of a private placement memorandum for the applicable fund. Investors are urged to read the private placement memorandum in its entirety before making an investment decision.”

NOS VOBISCUM

Page 3: Novo Performance Review 20100122

3

Roadmap for Performance Presentation

1) Investing strategy2) Performance analysis3) Performance explanation4) Outlook for our value investment strategy5) Review6) Contact information7) Appendix

NOS VOBISCUM

Page 4: Novo Performance Review 20100122

4

Investing Strategy

– Fundamentals of Success (The 3 I’s)• Investments with a margin of safety• Investors with a long term value orientation• Incentives aligned to focus on risks first, rewards second

– Investment Discipline• Bottom Up strategy• Focusing on discounts to value

– Concentrating on Discount to Net Asset Value while looking at DCF skeptically

– Divestment Discipline• Double down on research, evaluate, take appropriate action• Going up - 100% return in 2 to 4 years

– Sell at full value, do not get greedy• Going down – 10% down

– If Cheaper – Buy more– If a value trap – Divest

NOS VOBISCUM

Page 5: Novo Performance Review 20100122

Investing Fundamentals

Quantitative Analysis

Strong Operating Results

- Long-Term Earnings Growth-Above Average ROE-Significant FCF-Above Average Dividend Yield

Attractive Price

-Significant Pricing Anomaly-Low Pricing Multiples (e.g., P/E, P/B, P/FCF) Relative to Industry

Conservative Balance Sheet

-Low Debt -Above Average Current Ratio -Share Repurchases

Qualitative Analysis

IndustryPositioning

-Threats to Industry Relevance-Regulatory Concerns- Capital Intensity

Durable Competitive Advantage

-Does the company control a key resource?-Does the company effectively execute a sustainable strategy?-Does the company have a strong brand?

Sustainability

- How will these questions be answered in 5 years? 10 years?

NOS VOBISCUM 5

Page 6: Novo Performance Review 20100122

6

Executing our Strategy: Tactical Overview

Dig– Week 1 Publicly Traded Companies

Discover – Week 220 companies

Digest – Week 310 companies

Decide – Week 40-3 companies

Investment Process Sample Screen

I. All public companiesII. Countries of choiceIII. Industries in which to focus or

eliminateIV. All companies with positive earningsV. All companies with positive book valueVI. Bottom 10% book value

NOS VOBISCUM

Page 7: Novo Performance Review 20100122

7

Performance Overview - Top Holdings as of 01/22/10

Rank Symbol Company Market Value

% of Portfolio

Unrealized G/L

Industry

1 CONN Conn's Inc. 1,016,000$ 9.0% 6.54% Consumer Services2 CASH Cash 851,013 7.6% 0.00% N/A3 CBR Ciber Inc. 837,720 7.5% 11.86% IT Services4 NE Noble Corp. 770,740 6.9% 2.51% Energy5 SNV Synovous Fin Corp. 708,000 6.3% 56.08% Financial Services6 PTRY Pantry 698,775 6.2% -6.27% Consumer Services7 AMED Amedisys Inc. 695,640 6.2% 55.08% Healthcare Services8 SUSQ Susquehanna 622,890 5.5% 37.08% Financial Services9 CAB Cabela's Inc. 612,720 5.5% 35.18% Consumer Services10 NLS Nautilus Inc. 611,240 5.4% 31.78% Consumer Goods

NOS VOBISCUM

Page 8: Novo Performance Review 20100122

8

Portfolio Construction Relative to the S&P 500

Portfolio(% of stocks) S&P (%)

Information 7.9% 23.4%Software 7.9% 4.5%Hardware 0.0% 11.0%Media 0.0% 2.5%Telecom. 0.0% 5.4%

Services 54.0% 39.5%Health Care 6.7% 12.4%Consumer 25.3% 8.6%Business 9.3% 3.3%Financial 12.7% 15.2%

Manufacturing 38.1% 37.1%Consumer Goods 20.4% 10.9%Industrial 4.6% 10.8%Energy 7.3% 11.8%Utilities 5.9% 3.7%

Not Classified 0.0% 0.0%

NOS VOBISCUM

Portfolio Relative to S&P

Price/Prospective Earnings 10.55 0.72Price/Book Ratio 0.62 0.29

Projected EPS Growth - 5yr % 10.75 1.14

Yield% 0.37 0.18

Average Market Cap 605.76 0.01

Page 9: Novo Performance Review 20100122

9

Risk Adjusted Return as of 01/22/10 Compared to Other Teams

Thena

rdier

Clusterfu

nd

Short

TCM

Sonict

hehe

dgefu

nd

Test123

Lossoros

Triumvira

te

Chiefsca

pital

Stone

hedg

e

BetaChi

dwan

g27 (5.00)

(4.00)

(3.00)

(2.00)

(1.00)

-

1.00

2.00

3.00

-25.00%

-20.00%

-15.00%

-10.00%

-5.00%

0.00%

5.00%

10.00%

15.00%

Sharpe Ratio% Return

NOS VOBISCUM

NOVO

Page 10: Novo Performance Review 20100122

10

Performance as of 01/22/10

Beginning Balance: $10,000,000Ending Balance: $10,986,654ROI: 9.87%

NOS VOBISCUM

Page 11: Novo Performance Review 20100122

11

Performance Explanation

ROI9,347,070.59

851,286.56 10,198,357.15 1.98%

10,135,367.00 851,286.56

10,986,653.56 9.87%

7.88%

Asset Class ValueCash Value

Total Portfolio Value

Actual Portfolio ValueCash Value

Total Portfolio Value

Returns Attributable to Asset Allocation

Total Returns

Returns Attributable to Stock Selection

Returns exceed what could be attributed to either Beta or asset class selection.

Alpha 4.08% Per Periodn 3 Monthsb 1.321 Portfolio Betax -1.79% Return of S&P 500y 9.87% Return of Fund

NOS VOBISCUM

Page 12: Novo Performance Review 20100122

12

Executing our Strategy: Specific Examples

– Largest percentage gains• Amedysis (AMED: Original Price Target = $63.00)

– Undervalued, misunderstood– Great demographics, strong and steady growth– Trading with significant margin of safety based on book value

and growth prospects – Steady increase of earnings for last 10 years (trading at P/E of

8x while comps were 14-17x)• Synovus (SNV: Original Price Target = $2.46)

– The inside story (Total Systems to Synovus)– Personal familiarity with the bank and their strategy to

aggressively write off loans

NOS VOBISCUM

Page 13: Novo Performance Review 20100122

13

Executing our Strategy: Specific Examples

– Largest percentage losses• Pantry (PTRY: Current Price Target = $36.00)

– Enhancing their equity» Market Cap = $290MM» Investing in 2009 = $166MM» Paydown of Debt = $52MM

– Strategy of growing business through acquisition of mom & pop convenience stores

• Borders (BGP: Original Price Target = $2.50)– Repositioning to a higher margin strategy– Ratcheting down on expenses– Discussion with management– Ultimately sold > CEO left co. & potential credit concerns

NOS VOBISCUM

Page 14: Novo Performance Review 20100122

14

Outlook for Our Value Investment Strategy

– Near Term• Considerable uncertainty in the market, stock selection

is even more important• Risk premiums appear to have decreased, as such, it

may be difficult to find bargains but we’ll keep looking– Long Term (there will always be irrationality)• Distressed situations, with a specific company, industry

or geography, security type• Chaotic situations• Insider +/- actions

NOS VOBISCUM

Page 15: Novo Performance Review 20100122

15

Review

• Novo Asset Management is a value-focused investment company. Our goals include: – Develop long-term, mutually beneficial relationships with investors

by maintaining trust and generating sustained excess returns.– Position the managers and investors as team members by:

• Aligning the compensation structure• Investing along-side LPs

– Incentive structure:• Management Fee = 1.5%• On the Upside = earn a % of all returns over +10YT• On the Downside = pay a % of all returns under -10YT

Our Guiding Strategy: Nos Vobiscum. We position ourselves on the same side of the table as our investors, and get paid for taking risks, not for chasing the S&P.

NOS VOBISCUM

Page 16: Novo Performance Review 20100122

16

Contact Information

Dave Loeffel – [email protected] Moss – [email protected]

NOS VOBISCUM

Page 17: Novo Performance Review 20100122

17

Appendix

NOS VOBISCUM

Page 18: Novo Performance Review 20100122

18

AMED Valuation

Present Value of FCFF in high growth phase = $629.35 2009 EPS EstimatesPresent Value of Terminal Value of Firm = $1,778.89Value of the firm = $2,408.23 Reuters $4.84

Firstcall $4.87Cash and Marketable Securities = $45.20

Average $4.86Market Value of outstanding debt = $444.80

Market Value of Equity = $2,008.63 Current AMED P/Earnings Est. 11.12Value of Equity options issued by the company = $185.00Market Value of Equity (Less options) $1,823.63 Current Comps P/Earnings Est.* 12.47

No. of Shares Outstanding 27.96 Implied Share Price at Comps Multiple $60.54

Market Value of Equity/share = $65.22

Target Stock Price = $62.88

*Note: Peers are comprised of 3 companies including Gentiva Health Sciences, LHC Group and Almost Family

DCF Valuation Price/Earnings Valuation

NOS VOBISCUM

Page 19: Novo Performance Review 20100122

19

SNV ValuationPrice to Book Value Calculation

Macquarie - Jan. 29, 2010Peer Analysis* 2009A 2010E 2011E

2009A 2010E 2011EP/BV 0.5 0.6 0.5 Peer Price/Book 0.69 0.69 0.69

Book Value Per Share 3.96 2.94 3.97 Avg. Book Value Per Share $4.00 $3.09 $3.78Tangible Book Value Per Share 3.88 2.87 3.91

Implied Price - P/BV $2.76 $2.13 $2.60Implied Price-P/BV $1.98 $1.76 $1.99

FIG Partners - Jan. 29, 2010

Book Value Per Share 4.04 3.23 3.58

Implied Price-P/BV (using Macquarie P/BV) $2.02 $1.94 $1.79

Average Implied Price - P/BV $2.00 $1.85 $1.89

Weighting Analyst Estimates 40% Peer Population Estimates 60%

Thenardier Price Expectation $2.46

*Note: Peers are comprised of 304 institutions within the same SIC code, operate in the same region as SNV, and have a similar amount of assets.

NOS VOBISCUM

Page 20: Novo Performance Review 20100122

20

PTRY Valuation

Normalized EBIT (1- tax rate) = $94.94 - (Capital Spending - Depreciation) $0.00 - Change in Working Capital $7.00Free Cashflow to Firm = $87.94

Cost of Equity = 10.30%Cost of Debt = 5.38%Cost of Capital = 6.84%

Expected Growth rate = 2.00%

Value of Firm $1,852.63Value of Cash & Equivalents $179.50

Value Per Share $36.16

1 Stage Growth Valuation

NOS VOBISCUM

Page 21: Novo Performance Review 20100122

21NOS VOBISCUM

Page 22: Novo Performance Review 20100122

22

BGP Valuation

EBIT (1- tax rate) = $46.50 - (Capital Spending - Depreciation) $0.00 - Change in Working Capital $6.00Free Cashflow to Firm = $40.50

Cost of Equity = 14.85%Cost of Debt = 7.44%Cost of Capital = 9.65%

Expected Growth rate = 2.00%

Value of Firm $540.29Value of Cash & Equivalents $45.00

Value Per Share $4.96

1 Stage Growth Valuation

NOS VOBISCUM

Page 23: Novo Performance Review 20100122

23NOS VOBISCUM