north minneapolis, south minneapolis: a tale of two cities

15
ECONOMIC & TERRITORIAL DEVELOPMENT | SCIENCES PO MPA North Minneapolis, South Minneapolis: A Tale of Two Cities Jeremy Dennison 2012-12-20

Upload: jdennison81

Post on 25-Nov-2015

46 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Over the course of the past two decades, half of Minneapolis has prospered. While the South Side flourishes and continues on its path to becoming one of “America’s Most Livable Cities,” the North Side flounders. Indeed, “The North Side” has become synonymous with urban blight, deprivation, and crime. If this trend were to continue, the city would be greatly at risk of institutionalizing a permanent underclass. This paper takes a look at the current problems facing the North Side of Minneapolis. It will analyze the causes of deprivation and how the city government should address North Minneapolis’ segregation from the rest of the city and its resultant inequality.

TRANSCRIPT

  • ECONOMIC & TERRITORIAL DEVELOPMENT | SCIENCES PO MPA

    North Minneapolis, South Minneapolis:

    A Tale of Two Cities

    Jeremy Dennison

    2012-12-20

  • Jeremy Dennison Economic & Territorial Development Minneapolis North Side

    December 20, 2012

    Page 1 of 14

    I. Introduction

    Over the course of the past two decades, half of Minneapolis has prospered. During the 1990s

    Minneapolis had earned the undesirable nickname of Murderapolis. Crime was rife, and

    authorities seemed at a loss of how to handle it. (Johnson, 1996) Today, the successful halflocated

    on the south side of townis inhabited by a relatively urbane population. Its transport

    infrastructure is growing, parks are abundant and heavily trafficked, and it has been rated among

    the most bike friendly cities for commuters and hobbyists. However, the city is not without its issues.

    It is again a city divided. While the South Side flourishes and continues on its path to becoming one

    of Americas Most Livable Cities, (Minnesota Department of Employment and Economic

    Development, 2012) the North Side flounders. Indeed, The North Side has become synonymous

    with urban blight, deprivation, and crime. If this trend were to continue, the city would be greatly at

    risk of institutionalizing a permanent underclass.

    This paper takes a look at the current problems facing the North Side of Minneapolis. It will analyze

    the causes of deprivation and how the city government should address North Minneapolis

    segregation from the rest of the city and its resultant inequality. While the areas high crime rate

    might be the most visible sign of trouble and obviously important to the discussion, it is but a

    reflection of the conditions. The most pressing factors to be addressed are the areas geographic

    isolation, the lack of native capital, problems with housing and foreclosures, and poor educational

    opportunities. Additionally, the paper will contrast the progressive nature of Minneapolis urban

    renewal policies, mostly centered on the South Side of the city and the seemingly perpetuate decline

    of the North Side.

    Improving Minneapolis North Side requires a long term strategy, comprised of many components to

    address the areas underlying troubles. Over the past decade-and-a-half, the citys planners have

    embraced a more progressive approach to urban development, better integrating the citys natural

    endowments into the urban infrastructure. The South Side has witnessed over recent years the

    development of more robust transportation networks, urban housing, the growing support for

    businesses and local produce and has evolved in tandem with a trend toward repopulation of the

    urban center (Downtown Minneapolis population has grown by nearly one-quarter in the past ten

    years). (Rybak, 2012)

    The North Side has seen a flight of the white population and the devolution of its native economic

    structure. It is encircled by major roadways and poorly served by public transport. Thus, the thrust of

    this paper will contrast the two areas of town and look at what can be done to improve the standard

    of living on the citys North Side. A case study of Lake Streets renewal will be used to illustrate one

    path a formerly deprived area used to successfully reintegrate itself into the urban fabric. The Lake

    Street rehabilitation showed that simply putting more police on the street and drawing a cordon

    around the North Side is a temporary patch that has proven time and again to be ineffective.

    Instead, the areas residents struggle on as the neighborhoods around them continue to deteriorate.

    This paper will recommend policy prescriptions that can be implemented on the North Side to foster

    positive change and include the North Side in Minneapolis growth and increasing quality of life.

  • Jeremy Dennison Economic & Territorial Development Minneapolis North Side

    December 20, 2012

    Page 2 of 14

    Situating ones self in Minneapolis

    It is difficult to divide the affairs of the Twin Cities of Minneapolis and Saint Paul, Minnesota. The

    border between the two is often fuzzy, and their suburbs tend to bleed into one another. When one

    sneezes, the other catches cold. For the purposes of this piece, Minneapolis means Minneapolis

    proper, with its own mayor and city council and its own municipal regulations and will exclude the

    metropolitan area unless otherwise noted.

    The map below is presented to help

    the reader situate him/herself in

    Minneapolis. The colored sections

    represent the areas of town which

    will be discussed in this paper.

    Though it should be fairly obvious,

    North and South Minneapolis are

    indicated as well. The black lines

    indicate the territorial borders of the

    City of Minneapolis; the green box

    represents North Minneapolis, the

    primary area under consideration in

    this paper. Additionally, Downtown

    Minneapolis has been marked with

    by the yellow circle. The final two

    lines correspond to important

    thoroughfares noted in the paper.

    The red line is Lake Street, which will

    be discussed in reference to its

    former deprivation and gradual

    renewal. The purple line is Hiawatha

    Avenue, the citys newest transit

    corridor and the home of its first

    light rail line.

    Much of the recent upscale development in the city has taken place at the intersection of Downtown

    Minneapolis along the Mississippi River, which cuts through the center of town. Also to be noted in

    the map is that the southern border of the city extends ten blocks further south than indicated on

    the map. The city of Saint Paul lies directly to the east of the represented area; suburbs ring its other

    sides. Finally, the city runs six miles across along Lake Street and roughly twelve miles north-south

    from the eastern edge of the green box to the southern border of the city.

    Understanding North Minneapolis in the context of the city

    Minneapolis began its life as an industrial city. Located along the banks of the Mississippi River, the

    city played a role as an important transportation hub in the Upper Midwest. The citys development

    centered on the river and developed outward.

  • Jeremy Dennison Economic & Territorial Development Minneapolis North Side

    December 20, 2012

    Page 3 of 14

    Up through the first half of the 20th century, the North Side was the nicer side of town and the

    destination for the citys immigrant arrivals, as well as home to the working class and upper-middle

    class merchants. Many businesses were started along West Broadway and Washington Avenues at

    the turn of the century and large and ornate brick and clapboard homes were built for these

    successful merchants in what is now called Old Highland; an area just north of Plymouth Avenue and

    west of Lyndale. (Northminneapolis.net, 2012) North High and Patrick Henry were the best high

    schools in town, and even before World War II, the neighborhood was integrated with large African-

    American and Jewish populations. (Goldberg, 2007) This integration broke down in the period after

    the war, and in 1967frustrations ignited into a riot on Plymouth Avenue. Minneapolis joined the

    list of cities, including Los Angeles, Detroit and Newark, in which the civil rights movement sparked a

    rebellion. (Goldberg, 2007)

    The riot accelerated the speed of white flight from the area, and over the course of the following

    decades, many of the locally owned business pulled up stakes and either closed or moved from the

    area. People sold their homes, and rental properties became the norm; poverty became embedded.

    Today, North Minneapolis embodies the racial inequality found across Minnesota. MinnPost lays out

    a disturbing list of statistics: Poverty rate, 36 percent among blacks. Among whites, 7.4 percent.

    Home ownership among blacks, 32 percent. Among whites, 74 percent. (Grow, 2011) Although

    Patrick Henry High is still well-regarded and offers the successful International Baccalaureate

    program, and North High has a version of the open enrollment program that South High offers,

    South High and Southwest High are now regarded as some of best schools in the state and the

    preference of local families. In fact, Southwest High is considered on par with, or better than, a lot of

    the private schools in the city, reflecting the flight of many of Norths residents to the South Side and

    adjacent suburbs.

    Concurrently, the industry along the Mississippi began to dry up. Minneapolis has long served as a

    hub of industry in the Upper Midwest, and its location along the river stimulated the citys growth.

    However, as was the case in many second-tier cities in the regionCleveland, Milwaukee, Cincinnati,

    Kansas City, Indianapolis, Detroitindustry moved out and the cities had to deal with the often

    uncomfortable transition to a service economy. The decline of Minneapolis North Side can be

    understood as a consequence of the citys deindustrialization through the latter half of the twentieth

    century. Although Minneapolis has weathered the transition better than many of its peers, the shift

    has not led to renewed inequalities with the citys demographic makeup.

    While several areas of Minneapolis remained underdeveloped (one, along Lake Street will be

    discussed in this paper), the deprivation remains most apparent today on the North Side. In the end,

    the city was left with the North Minneapolis we know today. It should be noted here that North

    Minneapolis is not a hole of ceaseless deprivation; it is home to hardworking, honest men and

    women who raise families and live normal lives. However, it is a part of the city facing more serious

    problems that most other areas. The North Side has a higher home foreclosure rate than the rest of

    Minneapolis, a higher crime rate, and in the first decade of the 21st century, the area lost more than

    10% of its population. (Rybak, 2012)

  • Jeremy Dennison Economic & Territorial Development Minneapolis North Side

    December 20, 2012

    Page 4 of 14

    II. The issues affecting Minneapolis now and looking forward

    The problems of urban poverty, increasing social exclusion, and inequality are far from unique to

    Minneapolis. Increasingly, the poorer areas of American cities lack outlets for adequate education,

    business, and even nutrition. The effects are wide-ranging. The Economist notes in a recent article

    that, Social mobility in America, contrary to conventional wisdom, is lower than in most European

    countries. The gap in test scores between rich and poor American children is roughly 30-40% wider

    than it was 25 years ago. (The Economist, 2012) These findings threaten the establishment of a

    permanent underclass, where crime, deprivation and inequality become institutionalized.

    Minneapolis North Side is just one area where this trend plays out.

    While Minneapolis as a whole has dealt well with social and economic changes, the North Side faces

    a multitude of problems, mostly stemming from the flight of capital in the last several decades. The

    area has fallen deeply behind on quality of life indices. In this section, we will take a look more

    specifically at the primary areas in which the North Side is lagging. While again there are no short-

    term solutions, directing policy to these areas will serve to fix many of the problems; it will set the

    groundwork to build a community that can thrive. The processes that undid the city must be

    countered and it will take long-term commitment from policymakers

    Breakdown of the problems and their relevance to the equation

    The problems of North Minneapolis can be broken down into five different categories, as detailed

    below. Crime is the common theme that runs through this, but this paper wont take it on directly;

    instead we will look at the underlying factors that lead to crime. In a depressed community, crime is

    a symptom of depression more so than a cause.

    Deindustrialization and geographic isolation: The North Side is surrounded by major highways. The

    configuration of these roadways encircles the area and doesnt lead into the neighborhoods. This

    isolation discourages business that might otherwise pass through the area and stymies the North

    Sides economic development. Similarly, North Minneapolis is comparatively more poorly served by

    public transportation. (Rybak, 2012)

    The process of deindustrialization brought the closure of the areas factories and local businesses.

    Driving through the North Side, one is greeted by a swarm of disused factories and vacant buildings.

    When the factories closed, local business left the area, as did the areas capital. What was left

    behind is what the area must contend with today.

    Lack of native capital: Related to the last point is North Minneapolis lack of native capital. During its

    heyday, the area was home to many businesses owned and operated by the local residents. (Grow,

    2011) The money generated by the people in the area is from jobs that are located outside of North

    Minneapolis, and because of the lack of local options, is spent outside of North Minneapolis.

  • Jeremy Dennison Economic & Territorial Development Minneapolis North Side

    December 20, 2012

    Page 5 of 14

    Home foreclosures: The lack of native capital has compounding effects. For example, the citys rate

    of home foreclosures is highest on the North Side. Minnesota Public Radio reports that, On some

    streets in North Minneapolis, vacant homes almost outnumber occupied ones. (Mador, 2009) Out

    of the 14,000 homes that have

    been foreclosed on since

    2006, 6,000 of them are on

    the citys North Side. (Rybak,

    2012)

    The map to the left shows the

    locations of loan assistance

    provided by Minneapolis

    Advantage, a program

    designed to boost home

    ownership and stop

    foreclosures. The area of most

    intense implementation, that

    is the area most at risk for

    foreclosures, corresponds

    almost directly to the

    boundaries of the citys North

    Side used in this paper.

    The lack of housing security

    has a negative influence on

    the development of stable,

    nurturing communities. Even

    more so, it has an effect on

    revenue that can be generated

    through property taxes, which

    in turn affects economic

    development and the funding

    of local schools.

    Education: The lack of money from property taxes is only part of the problem facing education on

    the North Side. Another part of the decline in education can be attributed to the advent and

    popularity of charter schools in Minneapolis. With their open enrollment policies, they have been

    drawing students away from public schools. (Post, 2012)

    Secondly, the Bush-era No Child Left Behind is responsible for the restructuring of several North Side

    schools and the closure of one. (Mitchell, 2011) Many children are now bused out to the

    surrounding suburbs, further inhibiting the development of community and leaving officials with

    even less to invest in.

  • Jeremy Dennison Economic & Territorial Development Minneapolis North Side

    December 20, 2012

    Page 6 of 14

    Food desert: Lastly, the lack of native capital and the absence of strong community ties affect the

    health of the community. The departure of local business has led to a scarcity of healthy food

    options. This dearth of options is common in economically depressed areas. North Minneapolis is

    overrun with convenience stores, fast food restaurants, and liquor stores, but there are few grocers.

    Poor health raises health care costs in an already poverty-stricken area, and negatively affects well-

    being. Though the food desert might seem like a minor point compared to what has been described

    above, the next section will show that tackling this problem can have far reaching effects that can be

    combined to ameliorate the other factors.

    In the end, the above factorsisolation, absence of community and security, poverty and the lack of

    capital, and poor educationdo increase the level of crime in North Minneapolis. For example, a

    recent study shows the connection between home foreclosures and the local crime rate. The

    Atlantic cites the studys findings, Crime did increase about one percent following a

    foreclosurebut only after three or more foreclosure notices were issued to a particular block. In

    other words, home closures may lead to crime, but not until a block passes a threshold of housing

    stress. They also found that the effects of this closure-crime relationship were greater in

    neighborhoods with higher levels of crime in general. (Jaffe, 2012) The statistics do indeed indicate

    that the North Side has a higher crime rate than the Minneapolis average. (City of Minneapolis,

    2012) The area is responsible for half of the citys murders. (Williams, 2010)

    The instability has also led to growing social inequality. Any policy must address the five factors

    described above. The goal is to better integrate those who are at a high risk of being left behind and

    denied the fruits of progress in Minneapolis. Policy must be used to bring them into the fold and

    empower them with skills and a sense of belonging, and above all, sources of income to mitigate

    what could be an increasing divide between different communities. Minneapolis is a patchwork

    community and proud of this fact. Setting policy to integrate all Minneapolitans will strengthen and

    enrich the city and its denizens.

    III. How do we address the problems to make Minneapolis and more

    equitable, safer, and livable city?

    The solutions to North Minneapolis problems require long-term consideration. Policy must also be

    comprehensive, taking into account the factors outlined in the last section. The key is to apply policy

    smartly, rather than broadly. It is not necessary to regulate everything: some improvements will

    trigger other improvements, a multiplier effect of sorts. However, the city does need an integrated

    strategy of many overlapping components over the course of a decade or morenot a simple list of

    short-term solutions. Naturally, policy must be implemented to alleviate the blight as quickly as

    possible, and there should be some measures that have an effect in the short-term. However, these

    should not be mistaken as end goals. And a lack of quick improvement must not be viewed as a sign

    of failed policy.

    Policy prescriptions will attempt to take a holistic view in addressing the most pressing issues

    described in the last section. Policies currently in place will also be noted. Essentially,

    recommendations will need to answer two questions:

  • Jeremy Dennison Economic & Territorial Development Minneapolis North Side

    December 20, 2012

    Page 7 of 14

    How can the city mitigate the dearth of business on the North Side?

    How can the North Side become less isolated and have a healthier environment?

    Though difficult, the city has succeeded before in turning a destitute area around and seen it

    flourish. The city of Minneapolis has turned around the area along Lake Street, a major east-west

    corridor south of Downtown. Lake Street still has many problems, several of them are the same as

    those on the North Side, but it is also unmistakably on a better path than it was 10-15 years ago.

    Addressing North Minneapolis

    In some ways, things are already looking better in North Minneapolis, though it has a long way to go.

    In a speech in June 2012, Minneapolis mayor RT Rybak pointed to dramatic improvement,

    including the implementation of housing programs and a reduction in crime. (Rybak, 2012) However,

    the area has a long way to go. If followed, the policy recommendations in this section would

    stimulate development and inclusion on the North Side.

    The following dimensions were laid out in the previous section. Here we will discuss policies that can

    be used to address specific problems.

    Development and inclusion: There are a great number of social services and work centers for the

    underclass, but few of them located on the North Side. Theyre located along Franklin Ave and Lake

    Street. Their location has helped to stimulate development around those two corridors, and opening

    offices or establishing outreach to the North Side would go a long way in bolstering that areas

    economic development.

    One of the organizations that work with economically depressed areas is the Department of

    Employment and Economic Development (DEED). DEED has connections to groups like

    WomenVenture that give out grants to small businesses trying to open in areas not typically

    considered business-friendly. One such program is called the Urban Loan Initiative Program. Through

    the program, DEED support[s] the growth of minority owned and operated businesses and to

    create jobs in economically distressed areas of the Twin Cities. DEED provides grant funds to a

    network of nonprofit lenders which use these funds for loans to start-up and expanding businesses.

    (Minnesota Department of Employment and Economic Development, 2012) While this is exactly the

    sort of program needed, it remains relatively unknown.

    The city government should work more closely with DEED, a state agency, to promote and provide

    training to potential entrepreneurs and connect them with organizations helping advance local small

    business growth in areas that have been identified as needing development, such as on the North

    Side. It could help open field offices in that part of town and channel owners to programs like the

    Urban Loan Initiative.

    Proximity to a public transport corridor: The second part of the equation involves accessibility.

    Mayor Rybak, in a recent speech, stressed the importance of connecting the North Side to the rest of

    Minneapolis, We can have a safe neighborhood with good places to live, good jobs and good

    employers, but North Minneapolis can't grow like it should or like the rest of Minneapolis needs it

    to grow until it has better physical connections to the rest of the city and the rest of the

    regionNorth Minneapolis is surrounded by three important physical assets the Mississippi River,

  • Jeremy Dennison Economic & Territorial Development Minneapolis North Side

    December 20, 2012

    Page 8 of 14

    Wirth Park and Downtown Minneapolis but when you are here you could not feel further away

    from all three.

    Again, promoting the use of public transportation and even the implementation of bus lines better

    connecting the North Side are fundamental. The city government might also want to look at

    subsidizing the cost of bus passes for residents below a certain income threshold or for small

    business owners in the area.

    The economic implications of access are clear. A research report produced by the Cooperation for

    Urban Mobility in the Developing World (CODATU) notes that, There is a strong link between

    mobility and income. The creation of wealth requires that earners be able to move about quickly and

    easily. The relationship between the number of trips made per day and per capita income is very

    significant. (CODATU, 2009) The group also found that subsidizing transport can pay for itself by

    increasing business for local shops and services, and increasing productivity whilst reducing costs

    for consumers, business activities and public administrations. Moreover, land near the transport

    corridors is put to better use, with increased land value giving rise to new urban developments, or

    new ways to use the land. (CODATU, 2009)

    Food Deserts: Addressing food deserts has surprisingly far-reaching effects on urban development:

    they help inclusion, local business, and transportation links, as well as the general health of the area.

    As noted, North Minneapolis is overrun with convenience stores, fast food restaurants, and liquor

    stores but has few quality outlets for healthy food.

    Sasha Hulsey, a policy analyst with the think tank Minnesota 2020, notes that [i]ncreased urban

    farming opportunities may have notable benefits to community health and economic development,

    and that policymakers have identified North and Northeast Minneapolis as areas that could benefit

    the most from urban farming. (Hulsey, 2012) The practice has already gained a foothold in areas of

    the North Side. The organizers have turned disused factories and parking lots into community

    gardens and farming areas to help generate income and reverse the effect of the food desert.

    However, none of the projects are directly funded by the city; these projects instead tend to be

    community funded.

    The City of Minneapolis has only recently legalized urban farming, though with many restrictions.

    (Hulsey, 2012) The government could further show its support by better promoting these gardens as

    a tool of economic development and community empowerment. Urban farms help repurpose vacant

    areas and blot out the blight of the deindustrialized landscape.

    Urban farms and the resulting farmers markets bring people who wouldnt ordinarily go to the area

    as well, lessening exclusion, and drawing a typically young, urbane crowd who want to spend money

    locally. The farms generate native capital and make space greener and more livable while providing

    local nutritional outlets. Milwaukee, a city comparable in many ways to Minneapolis, has had some

    success with its own urban farming programs.

    Home foreclosures: To combat home vacancy, since 2008, the city of Minneapolis has been running

    a program called Minneapolis Advantage, wherein the city government assists homebuyers in

    neighborhoods with high foreclosure rates. The map on page five shows where the program has

    given out favorable loans to buyers. (City of Minneapolis, 2012) The housing market in the area is a

  • Jeremy Dennison Economic & Territorial Development Minneapolis North Side

    December 20, 2012

    Page 9 of 14

    victim of the national downturn, but suffers doubly from the economic weakness and isolation of the

    area. Minneapolis Advantage is a good start to incentivizing people and making it feasible for

    residents to buy homes in North Minneapolis. Further economic development will speed up this

    process. When people have a reason to take up a stake in the community, they will do so.

    Education: Education can play a role in integrating students. But instead of merely busing North Side

    children out of the area, the establishment of after-school programs in key areas would better

    incorporate children from various parts of the city. These programs would let immigrant children mix

    with native-born students and draw South Side kids to the North Side. Here a robust transportation

    network would also be needed. For high school aged and older students, the following steps could

    be taken to improve their education and give them skills to help employment:

    Reintroduce technical programs back to the citys public high schools

    Develop centralized afterschool tutor and sports programs to integrate immigrant/North

    Side children and teens, especially those deemed at risk, to provide academic

    enrichment and safe activities as well as mix children from different socioeconomic

    demographics

    Liaise with the main technical college and university to foster training programs,

    scholarships, and internships for high-performing students

    What Lake Street did and what can be generalized from that approach

    As noted, the area of Minneapolis

    along Lake Street recently faced many

    of the same problems the North Side

    now deals with. A big part of

    improving Lake Streets rehabilitation

    was bringing it closer to the rest of

    Minneapolis. Drawing people from

    other areas of town onto Lake Street

    increased exchange, and

    transportation development made it

    easier for people living along Lake

    Street to move around the city. To some degree, this was easier due to Lake Streets relatively

    central position. However, the placement of the light rail station at a key point on Lake and the

    construction of a transit station as part of the Midtown Exchange project made a difference. The

    growth of local businesses was vital to building an inclusive, vibrant business and residential district.

    The area also benefited from the establishment of social

    services and work centers for the underclass around Franklin

    and Lake. These organizations were able to engage local

    entrepreneurs and connect them with investment that

    brought native capital into the area.

    Lake Streets development employed a powerful symbol to

    spur development and attract funding. For over a decade,

    local leaders rallied around the long-vacant Sears building at

  • Jeremy Dennison Economic & Territorial Development Minneapolis North Side

    December 20, 2012

    Page 10 of 14

    the corner of Lake Street and Chicago Avenue and pushed for the buildings renovation and

    transformation into commercial and residential space. (Midtown Community Works, n.d.) The

    building served as a visible, tangible symbol of the areas renewal. North Minneapolis has many

    buildings that could serve as a similar symbol. Getting the private sector involved would be crucial,

    and its involvement would defer some of the cost. The city must first build the foundation and the

    infrastructure for renewal and then court organizations interested in investing in the area.

    How will the city pay for these polices?

    Money is of course always the issue. There are some different avenues to explore to make the

    necessary renewal of North Minneapolis more affordable.

    A recent paper by economists Lawrence Summers and Brad DeLong look at the role of stimulus

    spending in depressed economies. Their findings show that stimulus money will trigger the multiplier

    effect and that, combined with currently low interest rates, these programs can begin to pay for

    themselves. (DeLong & Summers, 2012) Economic growth will also generate more money through

    the increased value of property, though greater employment, and from additional business.

    Another option deals with state money through the Local Government Assistance program (LGA).

    The previous Republican governor had slashed LGA funding to communities, (Perry, 2009) but

    Minnesota still has excess bonding capacity to work with. LGA money could be used to support

    educational and afterschool programs. Additionally, Minnesotas borrowing rates are at historic

    lows, (Dennison, 2012) so again, the borrowing has the potential to pay for itself.

    Finally, one last avenue to explore to generate revenue is betterment taxation. Betterment is

    generally defined as the increase in value of land which results from actions other than those of the

    land owner i.e. the increase in land which is created by the community and which can be positive.

    (Plimmer & McGill, 2003) Originating in the UK, it is a tax on the value added to the land rather than

    the land itself, which incentivizes the community to put it toward a more beneficial use. While

    deriving the exact added value, as well as its source, can be a difficult process, the city would do well

    from trying to leverage this form of taxation.

    Naturally there would be opposition from the implementation of such measures. Conservatives

    complain about any government spending, and many Minneapolitans would object to their money

    being spent on the other side of town. However, as this paper has outlined, the money in the North

    Side would generate a great deal of local revenue and bring prosperity and security to many in the

    city. Expenses can be offset in the long-term through the revenue generated by this growth,

    progressive taxation, and drawing revenue from betterment. The business community, if it were to

    look at the long-term, should have no reasonable objection to building an inclusive and vibrant

    North Minneapolis.

  • Jeremy Dennison Economic & Territorial Development Minneapolis North Side

    December 20, 2012

    Page 11 of 14

    IV. Closing: Summary / A look to the future

    Sadly, much of the current discourse revolves around stronger law enforcement. As a community,

    Minneapolis must overcome the desire to shift its underclass into an effective ghetto, which can

    then be roped off by a strong police line. More policing presents a great cost to the community with

    no hope of payback. Strong, progressive policy and moves toward inclusive growth on the North Side

    go hand in hand with development and reduction in crime.

    Several non-profit and community organizations work with the North Side to bring about positive

    change to the community. The city government must now take a stronger role in tackling the areas

    exclusion and deprivation. Following the policy prescriptions laid out in this paper will present an

    important first step in addressing the underlying issues on the North Side. Minneapolis, like any

    other city, will never rid itself of poverty. However, a long-term view of the causes of the poverty

    and deprivation currently afflicting the citys North Side will go far in stopping the development of a

    permanent underclass before it becomes institutionalized.

  • Jeremy Dennison Economic & Territorial Development Minneapolis North Side

    December 20, 2012

    Page 12 of 14

    Works Cited City of Minneapolis, 2012. Crime Statistics: January-October 2012. [Online]

    Available at:

    http://www.ci.minneapolis.mn.us/www/groups/public/@mpd/documents/webcontent/wcms1p-

    100564.pdf

    [Accessed 15 December 2012].

    City of Minneapolis, 2012. Minneapolis Advantage Program--Mortgage Assistance. [Online]

    Available at:

    http://www.minneapolismn.gov/cped/housing/cped_minneapolis_advantage_nsp_mortgage_assist

    ance

    [Accessed 30 November 2012].

    CODATU, 2009. Handbook of good pratices: Who pays what for urban transport ?, Cahors: CODATU.

    DeLong, B. J. & Summers, L. H., 2012. Fiscal Policy in a Depressed , s.l.: Brookings Institute.

    Dennison, J., 2012. An Overlooked Budget Forecast Number. [Online]

    Available at: http://www.mn2020hindsight.org/view/an-overlooked-budget-forecast-number

    [Accessed 13 December 2012].

    Goldberg, S., 2007. North Minneapolis: Past and Present. [Online]

    Available at: http://www.kare11.com/news/news_article.aspx?storyid=259164

    [Accessed 12 December 2012].

    Grow, D., 2011. Dayton wows North Minneapolis economic summit with a simple promise. [Online]

    Available at: http://www.minnpost.com/politics-policy/2011/03/dayton-wows-north-minneapolis-

    economic-summit-simple-promise

    [Accessed 7 December 2012].

    Hulsey, S., 2012. Urban Farming: Or, Old MacRybak had a Farm. [Online]

    Available at: http://www.mn2020.org/issues-that-matter/economic-development/Urban-Farming-

    Or-Old-MacRybak-had-a-Farm

    [Accessed 30 November 2012].

    Jaffe, E., 2012. Do Foreclosures Increase Crime After All?. [Online]

    Available at: http://www.theatlanticcities.com/housing/2012/11/do-foreclosures-increase-crime-

    after-all/3828/

    [Accessed 30 November 2012].

    Johnson, D., 1996. Nice City's Nasty Distinction: Murders Soar in Minneapolis. [Online]

    Available at: http://www.nytimes.com/1996/06/30/us/nice-city-s-nasty-distinction-murders-soar-in-

    minneapolis.html

    [Accessed 4 December 2012].

    Mador, J., 2009. Saving foreclosed homes in north Minneapolis. [Online]

    Available at: http://minnesota.publicradio.org/display/web/2009/12/07/reclaiming-foreclosed-

  • Jeremy Dennison Economic & Territorial Development Minneapolis North Side

    December 20, 2012

    Page 13 of 14

    homes-in-north-minneapolis/

    [Accessed 18 November 2012].

    Midtown Community Works, n.d. Midtown Exchange News. [Online]

    Available at: http://www.midtowncommunityworks.org/exchange/

    [Accessed 12 December 2012].

    Minnesota Department of Employment and Economic Development, 2012. Living and Working.

    [Online]

    Available at:

    http://www.positivelyminnesota.com/Business/Locating_in_Minnesota/Why_Minnesota/Living_Wo

    rking.aspx

    [Accessed 7 December 2012].

    Minnesota Department of Employment and Economic Development, 2012. Urban Initiative Loan

    Program. [Online]

    Available at:

    http://www.positivelyminnesota.com/Business/Financing_a_Business/DEED_Business_Finance_Prog

    rams/Urban_Initiative_Loan_Program.aspx

    [Accessed 12 December 2012].

    Mitchell, C., 2011. Minneapolis schools struggle under No Child Left Behind. [Online]

    Available at: http://www.startribune.com/local/blogs/130914078.html

    [Accessed 9 December 2012].

    Northminneapolis.net, 2012. North Mpls History. [Online]

    Available at: http://northminneapolis.net/north-mpls-history/

    [Accessed 9 December 2012].

    Perry, S., 2009. The Pawlenty budget: Proposed local government aid cuts, city by city. [Online]

    Available at: http://politicsinminnesota.com/2009/01/pawlenty-budget-proposed-local-

    government-aid-cuts-city-city/

    [Accessed 15 December 2012].

    Plimmer, F. & McGill, G., 2003. Land Value Taxation: Betterment Taxation in England and the

    Potential for Change , Paris: FIG Working Week.

    Post, T., 2012. State's trend of growing charter school enrollment reflected across country. [Online]

    Available at: http://minnesota.publicradio.org/display/web/2012/11/14/charter-school-enrollment-

    grows-across-the-country-in-minnesota/

    [Accessed 18 November 2012].

    Rybak, R., 2012. One Minneapolis, Growing North. [Online]

    Available at: http://www.minneapolismn.gov/mayor/news/speeches/WCMS1P-091007

    [Accessed 30 November 2012].

  • Jeremy Dennison Economic & Territorial Development Minneapolis North Side

    December 20, 2012

    Page 14 of 14

    The Economist, 2012. True Progressivism. [Online]

    Available at: http://www.economist.com/node/21564556?frsc=dg%7Ca

    [Accessed 4 November 2012].

    Williams, B., 2010. For teens in north Minneapolis, safety is an everyday concern. [Online]

    Available at: http://minnesota.publicradio.org/display/web/2010/09/24/youth-safety-minneapolis/

    [Accessed 30 November 2012].