nonradial oscillations. the science case: stellar ages - directly for individual stars age...

26
Nonradial Oscillations

Post on 15-Jan-2016

216 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Nonradial Oscillations. The Science Case:  Stellar Ages - directly for individual stars  Age determination is direct and reliable  Ages to stars which

Nonradial Oscillations

Page 2: Nonradial Oscillations. The Science Case:  Stellar Ages - directly for individual stars  Age determination is direct and reliable  Ages to stars which

The Science Case: Stellar Ages - directly for individual stars

Age determination is direct and reliable Ages to stars which are not accessible with cluster

method

1. Convection in Stars - direct probe of global & local parameters of envelope convection zones

Beyond MLT: constraining 3-D models

2. Other Fundamental Stellar Parameters: M, R, & Y

1. Y = He abundance and the dY/dZ relation2. Abundance patterns with depth, e.g. stellar pollution

Asteroseismology Today

Page 3: Nonradial Oscillations. The Science Case:  Stellar Ages - directly for individual stars  Age determination is direct and reliable  Ages to stars which

The topology & dynamics of our Sun’sconvection zone:

Asteroseismology Today

B. Freytag & M. Steffen (2001)R. Stein & A. Nordlund (2003)

2-D model >

Strong up/down asymmetry

QuickTimeª and aYUV420 codec decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

Page 4: Nonradial Oscillations. The Science Case:  Stellar Ages - directly for individual stars  Age determination is direct and reliable  Ages to stars which

Probing Interiors:

Asteroseismology Today

Pressure waves of different n & l : * large & small separations

Pressure waves of different l :

The Sun

Page 5: Nonradial Oscillations. The Science Case:  Stellar Ages - directly for individual stars  Age determination is direct and reliable  Ages to stars which

Low order p-modes

QuickTimeª and aGIF decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

QuickTimeª and aGIF decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

QuickTimeª and aGIF decompressor

are needed to see this picture.l=3, m=3

l=3, m=1l=3, m=2

Page 6: Nonradial Oscillations. The Science Case:  Stellar Ages - directly for individual stars  Age determination is direct and reliable  Ages to stars which

1040 microHz

Page 7: Nonradial Oscillations. The Science Case:  Stellar Ages - directly for individual stars  Age determination is direct and reliable  Ages to stars which

2020 microHz

Page 8: Nonradial Oscillations. The Science Case:  Stellar Ages - directly for individual stars  Age determination is direct and reliable  Ages to stars which

83 microHz (200 min)

Page 9: Nonradial Oscillations. The Science Case:  Stellar Ages - directly for individual stars  Age determination is direct and reliable  Ages to stars which

TheorySun

Angular order

Frequency

(in

creasi

ng r

adia

l ord

er)

Page 10: Nonradial Oscillations. The Science Case:  Stellar Ages - directly for individual stars  Age determination is direct and reliable  Ages to stars which
Page 11: Nonradial Oscillations. The Science Case:  Stellar Ages - directly for individual stars  Age determination is direct and reliable  Ages to stars which

Probing Interiors:

Asteroseismology Today

Pressure waves of different n & l :

* large separations:Proportional to inverse tdyn , hence to (GM / R3) 1/2.

* small separations:Proportional to r -1 and grad c2 , hence to stellar core and to molecular weight there: stellar age !

Bedding & Kjeldsen 2003

Sun’s p-modes:

Page 12: Nonradial Oscillations. The Science Case:  Stellar Ages - directly for individual stars  Age determination is direct and reliable  Ages to stars which

Hydrogen abundance inside the present Sun:

Asteroseismology Today

JCD (2002)

Convection zonebottom visible >

Page 13: Nonradial Oscillations. The Science Case:  Stellar Ages - directly for individual stars  Age determination is direct and reliable  Ages to stars which

First steps have been taken recently: Detections of individual p-modes in radial

velocity1. Alpha Cen A: a G-dwarf (Butler et al. 2004)2. Alpha Cen B: a K-dwarf (Bouchy & Carrier

2004)3. Eta Boo: a G subgiant maybe ? 4. Procyon: an F subgiant maybe ??5. Mu Arae: a G-dwarf (Bouchy et al 2006) (Neptune

planet was easier to discover !)

Other multi-mode pulsating stars1. Gamma Dor variables: g-modes2. Beta Cep & Delta Scuti variables3. white dwarfs

Asteroseismology Today

Page 14: Nonradial Oscillations. The Science Case:  Stellar Ages - directly for individual stars  Age determination is direct and reliable  Ages to stars which

The First Comparison:

Asteroseismology Today

Kjeldsen et al (2005)

G2 V

G2 V

K1 V

1.10 Ms

1.00 Ms

0.93 Ms

1.23 Rs

1.00 Rs

0.87 Rs

n =

Page 15: Nonradial Oscillations. The Science Case:  Stellar Ages - directly for individual stars  Age determination is direct and reliable  Ages to stars which

2.0

1.5

1.0

0.5

0.0

-0.5

-1.0

log L/L

¤

4.0 3.9 3.8 3.7

log Teff

Z=0.01

-8

-6

-4

-2

0

log M

cz/M¤

Page 16: Nonradial Oscillations. The Science Case:  Stellar Ages - directly for individual stars  Age determination is direct and reliable  Ages to stars which
Page 17: Nonradial Oscillations. The Science Case:  Stellar Ages - directly for individual stars  Age determination is direct and reliable  Ages to stars which
Page 18: Nonradial Oscillations. The Science Case:  Stellar Ages - directly for individual stars  Age determination is direct and reliable  Ages to stars which
Page 19: Nonradial Oscillations. The Science Case:  Stellar Ages - directly for individual stars  Age determination is direct and reliable  Ages to stars which
Page 20: Nonradial Oscillations. The Science Case:  Stellar Ages - directly for individual stars  Age determination is direct and reliable  Ages to stars which

The 3-D topology of a moderately deepconvection zone:

So, what is going on ?

B. Freytag & M. Steffen (2001)R. Stein & A. Nordlund (2003)

2-D model >

Strong up/down asymmetry

QuickTimeª and aYUV420 codec decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

Page 21: Nonradial Oscillations. The Science Case:  Stellar Ages - directly for individual stars  Age determination is direct and reliable  Ages to stars which

The 3-D topology of a shallowconvection zone:

So, what is going on ?

Freytag & Steffen (2001)P. Demarque et al (2004)

2-D model >

Stronger vorticity& coherence,more vigorous

QuickTimeª and aYUV420 codec decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

Page 22: Nonradial Oscillations. The Science Case:  Stellar Ages - directly for individual stars  Age determination is direct and reliable  Ages to stars which

The excitation & damping of p-modesin a convection zone:

So, what could we learn ?

Robinson, Demarque et al (2003)

3-D models of 1.5 Sun-mass star >

Super-ad. overshoot

Page 23: Nonradial Oscillations. The Science Case:  Stellar Ages - directly for individual stars  Age determination is direct and reliable  Ages to stars which

The 3-D topology of a shallowconvection zone can lead to:

So, what could we learn ?

QuickTimeª and aYUV420 codec decompressorare needed to see this picture.

Surface >

• non-gaussian eddy time-correlation > mode excitation R. Samadi et al. (2003)

• extended super-adiabatic layers > surface reflection P. Demarque et al. (2004)

• enhanced granulation R. Stein & A. Nordlund (2003)

Page 24: Nonradial Oscillations. The Science Case:  Stellar Ages - directly for individual stars  Age determination is direct and reliable  Ages to stars which
Page 25: Nonradial Oscillations. The Science Case:  Stellar Ages - directly for individual stars  Age determination is direct and reliable  Ages to stars which

 

© Thomas Kallinger

NGC 2264NGC 2264N

GC

22

64

NG

C 2

26

4

Scie

nce T

eam

Meeti

ng

10-1

2 D

ec 2

00

5S

cie

nce T

eam

Meeti

ng

10-1

2 D

ec 2

00

5

MOST 2004MOST 2004

15 Mon

V589 MonV588 Mon

MOST Field of View

Fabry target 15Mon (O-star)

Secondary targets V588Mon, V589Mon and 7 others

133166 frames 48.13 daysduty cycle ≈95%

Page 26: Nonradial Oscillations. The Science Case:  Stellar Ages - directly for individual stars  Age determination is direct and reliable  Ages to stars which

 

© Thomas Kallinger

NGC 2264NGC 2264N

GC

22

64

NG

C 2

26

4

Scie

nce T

eam

Meeti

ng

10-1

2 D

ec 2

00

5S

cie

nce T

eam

Meeti

ng

10-1

2 D

ec 2

00

5

pre

-MS

post

-MS

instability region

~3x10 5yr

~4x106yr

2 solar mass

Stellar evolutionStellar evolution

R » »

P

Q P