next steps in ecological impact assessment
DESCRIPTION
Next Steps in Ecological Impact Assessment. IEMA QMark Series. Dawn Phythian CEnv MCIEEM Ecology Team North October 2014. Todays topics. Dawn Phythian Guidance Scoping – opportunity often missed Natural England – Discretionary advice service Scale – proportionate impacts - PowerPoint PPT PresentationTRANSCRIPT
www.watermangroup.com
1
Next Steps in Ecological Impact Assessment
IEMA QMark Series
Dawn Phythian CEnv MCIEEMEcology Team NorthOctober 2014
www.watermangroup.com
2
Dawn Phythian • Guidance• Scoping – opportunity often missed• Natural England – Discretionary advice service• Scale – proportionate impacts
Steve Jackson-Mathews
• Overview of current approach
• Reflecting emerging good practice
• Common issues
• Future challenges for EcIA
• Update on developing CIEEM EcIA guidance
Todays topics
www.watermangroup.com
3
• Chartered Institute of Ecology and Environmental Management (CIEEM)‘Guidelines for Ecological Impact in the United Kingdom (2006)’
• 2014 legislative change
The point of EcIA is:
To provide clear information regarding significant impacts
Guidance - CIEEM
www.watermangroup.com
4
• Scoping report after PEA and desk study• Tool to identify and consult with stakeholders• Used as a basis for consultation into what assessment is required• The scope of the project refines the project through consultation
Opportunities to:• Get agreement on methodologies• Scope out surveys
Scoping – missed opportunities
www.watermangroup.com
5
Preliminary Ecological Assessment• Any time of year has limitations.
Within the PEA the Desk study should include:• Appropriate distance search for sites• Appropriate distance search for species• Rule out/In HRA
Appropriate Consultees• Avoiding groups only puts it off• LPA may rely on outside consultees due to no Ecologist
What needed to effective Scoping
www.watermangroup.com
6
• What methodologies will be used, in detail
• Timescale for assessment
• What will not be involved – scope out the insignificant impacts
What scoping needs to include
www.watermangroup.com
7
Natural England advice service
Initial Free Advice:• “identify any significant potential impacts that need to be considered within the
application• advise on how these concerns may be addressed”
standard advice
DAS chargeable service is for:
“….More complex requests, such as the review of a draft Environmental Statement, will be charged on a per-hour basis, based on an estimate.”
Discretionary advice service (DAS)
www.watermangroup.com
8
Should be:• Proportionate to the scale of habitat• Relevant to a species • In scale to the impact
Not:• Related to the legal protection afforded to the site/species
Valuing a Significant Impact
www.watermangroup.com
9
Appropriate to:• Range • Feeding requirements• Resting requirements• Life span
Species scale
www.watermangroup.com
10
• Context within the site• Size• Context within local area• Actual ecological value it might have
Habitats Scale
www.watermangroup.com
11
Includes:
• Take scale into account• Lighting• Noise• Cumulative effects
Appropriate Impact