newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
1/127
1
Summer traing reportWays to Increase the Idea Cellular Ltd.
Submitted By :
Nuzahat Afrose
Submitted To :
C.Lal IMS (Shepa)
In partial fullfillment of the requirement of mba
degree of u.p. Technical university, lucknow
Session : 2009-10
Enrolment o Roll No 0918470034
INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT SCIENCES
SHEPA
(Nibia, Bachchaon, VRM Bypass, Varanasi-210011)
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
2/127
2
PREFACE
I am highly obliged to the learners and the guider whose kind blessings energies
me to complete my report. I would specially like to thanks and great regards to
my guide Mr.Saurabh Jaisawal whose kind guidance, motivation made me to
complete this report on time.
The project is carried out to translate the theoretical knowledge of subject into
practical field work. This project is carried out in partial fulfillment of MBA 2nd
Semester course from ISMT, Varanasi
Nuzahat Afrose
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
3/127
3
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
This report bears the imprint of many people. Right from the experienced staff ofIdea Cellular Ltd, to the staff of Atal Bihari Vajpayee Indian Institute of
Information Technologyand Management without whose support and guidance I
would have not got the unique opportunity to successfully complete my internship
in this esteemed organization.
I would like to thank Mr. Amaljeet Singh,who allow me to do this project in Idea
Cellular Ltdsuccessfully.
I take this opportunity to express my deep gratitude to all the employees of, Idea,
Gwalior. Also I am indebted for the rich guidance, knowledge and suggestions
provided by my guide, Mr. Yugal Kishorewho took sincere efforts and illustrated
the Marketing Concept and channel development in Idea Cellular Ltd, with their
vast knowledge in the field, which helped me in carrying out my internship.
Last but not least, I also thank all those people whom I met in the industry during
my internship and helped me to accomplish my assignments in the most efficient
and effective manner.
Date: Nuzahat Afrose
Place:
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
4/127
4
Contents
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
5/127
5
INTRODUCTION
As India's leading GSM Mobile Services operator, IDEA Cellular has licenses to
operate in 11 circles. With a customer base of over 17 million, IDEA Cellular has
operations in Delhi, Maharashtra, Goa, Gujarat, Andhra Pradesh, Madhya
Pradesh, Chattisgarh, Uttaranchal, Haryana, UP-West, Himachal Pradesh and
Kerala. IDEA Cellular's footprint currently covers approximately 45% of India's
population and over 50% of the potential telecom-market.
As a leader in Value Added Services, Innovation is central to IDEA's VAS Factory. It
is the first cellular company to launch music messaging with 'Cellular Jockey',
'Background Tones', 'Group Talk', a voice portal with 'Say IDEA' and a complete
suite of Mobile Email Services.
Idea Cellular is a wireless telephony company operating in various states in India.
It initially started in 1995 as a join venture between the Tatas, Aditya Birla Group
and AT&T by merging Tata Cellular and Birla AT&T Communications.
Initially having a very limited footprint in the GSM arena, the acquisition of
Escotel in 2004 gave Idea a truly pan-India presence covering Maharashtra
(excluding Mumbai), Goa, Gujarat, Andhra Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, Chattisgarh,
Uttar Pradesh (East and West), Haryana, Kerala, Rajasthan and Delhi (inclusive of
NCR).
The company has its retail outlets under the "Idea n' U" banner. The company has
also been the first to offer flexible tariff plans for prepaid customers. It also offers
GPRS services in urban areas.
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
6/127
6
IDEA Cellular is a publicly listed company, having listed on the
Bombay Stock Exchange (BSE) and the National Stock Exchange (NSE) in
March2007.
IIDEA Cellular is a leading GSM mobile service operator with pan India licenses.
With a customer base of over 44 million in 17 service areas, operations are soon
expected to start in Chennai Metro; Kolkata & West Bengal, North East & Assam,
and J&K.
A frontrunner in introducing revolutionary tariff plans, IDEA Cellular has the
distinction of offering the most customer friendly and competitive Pre Paid
offerings, for the first time in India, in an increasingly segmented market. From
basic voice & Short Message Service (SMS) services to high-end value added
services such as Mobile TV, Games etc - IDEA is seen as an innovative,
customerfocusedbrand.
IDEA 'Women's Card' caters to the special needs of women on
the move, and 'Youth Card' covers the emerging youth segment. IDEA 'My Gang' -
the widely popular community user group product recently bagged the
prestigious 'Golden Peacock Award 2008' under the Most Innovative Product
category at the "19th World Congress on Total Quality".
A brand known for many firsts, IDEA was the first to launch
GPRS and EDGE in India. IDEA has partnered with Research in Motion (RIM) to
offer Blackberry services on its network. IDEA 'Net Setter'- Plug & Play, EDGE
enabled USB Data Card offers affordable data connectivity with faster speed and
consistency.
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
7/127
7
IDEA offers seamless coverage to roaming customers traveling to any part of
the country, as well as to international traveling customers across over 200
countries. IDEA Cellular has partnership with over 400 operators worldwide to
ensure that customers are always connected while on the move, across the globe.
IDEA has received several national and international recognitions for its path-
breaking innovations in mobile telephony products & services. It won the GSM
Association Award for "Best Billing and Customer Care Solution" for 2 consecutive
years. It was awarded "Mobile Operator of the Year Award - India" for 2007 and
2008 at the Annual Asian Mobile News Awards.
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
8/127
8
Brief hisroty of the organization
The chronology of key events ofthe Company from incorporationis set out below:
Calendar year Events
2009
Subscriber base as onDecember 31, 2009:57,611,872
Idea becomes a pan-India
operator
Emerging Company of theYear - fastest growing mobileoperator in the worlds fastestgrowing telecom market
2008
Subscriber base as on December
31, 2008: 40,016,153Idea acquired 9 licences forPunjab, Karnataka, Tamil Nadu& Chennai, West Bengal,Orissa, Kolkata, Assam, NorthEast and Jammu & Kashmir
Acquired SpiceCommunications with the
operating circles of Punjab andKarnataka
Launched services in Mumbaimetro in the largest single
Becomes pan-India
operator in 2009
Acquired Escotel,
incumbent cellular service
provider in Haryana,
UP(W) & Kerala and new
licensee in HP
Brand IDEA launched
Delhi operations
commence (Nov)
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
9/127
9
metro city launch, ever
Launched services in Bihar
2007
Subscriber base as on December31, 2007: 21,054,027
Won an award for the "CARE"service in the "Best Billing orCustomer Care Solution" at theGSM Association Awards inBarcelona, Spain
Initial Public Offering
aggregating to Rs. 28,187million and Listing of EquityShares on the Bombay StockExchange and the NationalStock Exchange
Merger of seven subsidiarieswith Idea Cellular Limited
Reached the twenty million
subscriber mark
2006
Subscriber base as on December31, 2006: 12,442,450
Became part of the Aditya Birla
Acquired RPG Cellcom,
service provider in
Madhya Pradesh (Feb)
Awarded
MoU for merger between
Birla AT&T and Tata
Cellular Limited Andhra
Pradesh signed (Jan)
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
10/127
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
11/127
11
subscriber mark
Turned Profit Positive
Won an Award for the "Bill
Flash" service at GSMAssociation Awards inBarcelona, Spain
Sponsored the InternationalIndian Film Academy Awards
2004
Completed debt restructuringfor the then existing debt
facilities and additional fundingfor the Delhi Circle.
Acquired Escotel MobileCommunications Limited(subsequently renamed asIdea Mobile CommunicationsLimited)
Reached the four million
subscriber mark
First operator in India tocommercially launch EDGEservices 2005
2003
Reached the two millionsubscriber mark
2002
Changed name to Idea CellularLimited and launched "Idea"brand name
Commenced commercial
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
12/127
12
operations in Delhi Circle
Reached the one millionsubscriber mark
2001
Acquired RPG Cellular Limitedand consequently the licensefor the Madhya Pradesh(including Chattisgarh) Circle
Changed name to Birla TataAT&T Limited
Obtained license for providing
GSM-based services in theDelhi Circle following the fourthoperator GSM license biddingprocess
2000
Merged with Tata CellularLimited, thereby acquiringoriginal license for the AndhraPradesh Circle
1999
Migrated to revenues sharelicense fee regime under NewTelecommunications Policy("NTP")
1997
Commenced operations in theGujarat and MaharashtraCircles
1996
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
13/127
13
Changed name to Birla AT&TCommunications Limitedfollowing joint venture betweenGrasim Industries and AT&T
Corporation
1995
Incorporated as BirlaCommunications Limited
Obtained licenses for providingGSM-based services in theGujarat and Maharashtra
Circles following the originalGSM license bidding process.
Vision
It goes without saying that the brand vision of idea mirrors the companys vision.
The brand mission statement is...... To be the most customer-focused mobile
service brand, continuously innovating to help liberate our customers from the
shackles of time & space.
Mission
The India footprint IdeaAnywhere connectivity - bringing India closer.
The Technology Advantage IdeaTomorrow's technology to enrich today.
The Customer Focus IdeaMake a single interaction a lasting relationship.
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
14/127
14
The Employee Focus IdeaNurture the roots that nurture our ideas.
Objectives
The summer internship done with Idea Cellular Objective was to find the ways of increasing the ARPU
(Average Revenue Per User) for the company.
The objective of the summer project was to understand the customer preferences while choosing a
telecom service provider.
Other main objective of the project was to study the trends in the International Telecom market.
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
15/127
15
STRATETEGY FOR IDEA CELLULAR
The Idea Cellular Limited falls in the question mark quadrant of BCG matrix and
in the High attractive and Strong Competitive strength category as per the GE
Matrix. Thus they need to formulate some strategies to try capturing some market
share, growing and building their brand image as well as brand value.
Market penetration
The company enters where the products and the market already exists. IDEA being
a question mark that means it is competing in a high growth market but with a
relatively low share compare to its competitors. Market penetration can be done by
attracting competitors customers that implies increase in market share. The
strategy that IDEA can adapt under market penetration is to attract non-users and
convince to use their product more often. They are different market penetration
strategies like cutting price, increase in promotion, and creating innovative
distribution tactics. The target should be in such a way that IDEA sales volume
relative to its competitors should be high as expressed in percentage. IDEAs
present market share is about 12%, and competitors like airtel, Vodafone, and bsnl
have a market share of about 31, 23, and 19 percent respectively. Though telecom
industry is growing rapidly every year, there is always a little increment in the
percentage of sales for IDEA. To overcome this problem and to occupy the
competitors position we recommend following strategies.
Increasing the mobile circles which are at present are only 11, so there is
always a need to expand its services.
Target the rural segment in India which is expected to grow by 15% every
year
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
16/127
16
Launch different types of packages as per the requirements for different
segments of the customers
Provide more high end services like GPRS, mobile internet services
Collaboration with different service providers on global basis to provide
better facility to customers on roaming.
Tracing out the search patterns which are left untapped by the competitors to
reveal new markets.
Backward Integration In July 2008Swedish equipment supplier entered into a
contract to provide technology Ericsson Mobile organizer to Idea cellular
enabling its subscribers to serve email facility on its cell phones.
Forward IntegrationCompany operate approximately 589 Idea n U and other
showrooms which supplement the distribution channels and provide customer
service.
Horizontal Integration:Idea acquired the Modi familys stake of 40.8% in sp ice
which ultimately in a way increased the market share of Idea. This can be seen ashorizontal integration
Strategic Alliance
1) Product alliance
Idea should form product alliance with a company that has a strong brand
image and carry a promotion for one another. E.g. Acer in collaboration with
Ferrari launched Acer Ferrari laptops which are catering to high end niche
segment having high specifications and high price.
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
17/127
17
2) Promotional Alliance:
Idea should form promotional alliances in collaboration with big movie
houses or big retail brands to promote their products. Recently SONY Viao
had a promotional alliance with James Bond latest movie Casino
Royale.
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
18/127
18
Organization structure & management
Board of Directors -
Mr. Kumar Mangalam Birla (Chairman)Smt. Rajashree BirlaMr. Sanjeev Aga (Managing Director)Mr. Arun ThiagarajanMs. Tarjani VakilMr. Mohan GyaniMr. Gian Prakash GuptaMr. R.C. BhargavaMr. P. Murari
Mr. Biswajit A. SubramanianDr. Rakesh JainMr. Juan Villalonga NavarroDr. Hansa Wijayasuriya (Alternate to Mr. Juan Villalonga Navarro)
Management Team -
Corporate Leadership Team
Mr. Sanjeev Aga, Managing DirectorMr. Akshaya Moondra, Chief Financial OfficerMr. Anil K. Tandan, Chief Technology OfficerMr. Prakash K. Paranjape, Chief Information OfficerMr. Pradeep Shrivastava, Chief Marketing OfficerMr. Navanit Narayan, Chief Service Delivery OfficerMr. Vinay K. Razdan, Chief Human Resource OfficerMr. Rajat K. Mukarji, Chief Corporate Affairs OfficerMr. Rajesh K. Srivastava, Chief Materials & Procurement OfficerMr. Ambrish Jain, Director - OperationsMr. Himanshu Kapania, Director - Operations
Circle Heads
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
19/127
19
Mr. Iyer Subbaraman S., Chief Operating Officer, Andhra PradeshMr. Rajendra Chourasia, Chief Operating Officer, MadhyaPradesh & ChattisgarhMr. Virad Kaul, Chief Operating Officer, Uttar Pradesh (West),
Delhi & HaryanaMr. T. G. B. Ramakrishna, Chief Operating Officer, KeralaMr. Sashi Shankar, Chief Operating Officer, MumbaiMr. P.Lakshminarayana, Chief Operating Officer, Maharashtra &GoaMr. Naozer Firoze Aibara, Chief Operating Officer, Uttar Pradesh(East)Mr. Sunil Kataria, Senior Vice President - Operations, RajasthanMr. Arul Bright, Senior Vice President - Operations, Gujarat
Mr. M. D. Prasad, Senior Vice President - Operations, BiharMr. M. Srinivas, Senior Vice President - Operations, Tamil Nadu &ChennaiMr. Siva Ganapathi, Chief Operating Officer, KarnatakaMr. Anish Roy, Chief Operating Officer, Punjab, J&K andHimachal PradeshMr. Aloke Malik, Chief Operating Officer, East (Kolkata, Rest ofBengal, Orissa & NESA)
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
20/127
20
Idea Cellular Limited
An Aditya Birla Group Company
Quarterly Report
Fourth Quarter ended March 31, 2009
A D I T Y A B I R L A G R O U P
istered Office: Suman Tower, Plot No. 18, Sector 11, Gandhinagar 382011, India
the Corporate Office: 5 Floor, Windsor, Off C.S.T. Road, Near Vidya Nagari,
Kalina Santacruz (East), Mumbai 400 098, India
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
21/127
21
Supplemental Disclosures
Unless stated otherwise, the financial data in this report is derived from our
unaudited / audited consolidated financial statements prepared in accordance with
Indian GAAP. Our financial year ends on March 31 of each year, so all references
to a particular financial year are to the twelve months ending March 31 of that
year. In this report, any discrepancies in any table between the total and the sums
of the amounts listed are due to rounding-off. There are significant differences
between Indian GAAP, IFRS, and U.S. GAAP; accordingly, the degree to which
the Indian GAAP financial statements will provide meaningful information is
dependent on the readers level of familiarity with Indian accounting practices.
Any reliance by persons not familiar with Indian accounting practices on the
financial information presented in this report should accordingly be limited. We
have not attempted to explain those differences or quantify their impact on the
financial data included herein.
Unless stated otherwise, industry data used throughout this report has been
obtained from industry publications. Industry publications generally state that the
information contained in those publications has been obtained from sources
believed to be reliable but that their accuracy and completeness are not guaranteed
and their reliability cannot be assured. Although we believe that industry data used
in this report is reliable, it has not been independently verified. Actual results may
differ materially from those suggested by the forward-looking statements due to
risks or uncertainties associated with our expectations with respect to, but notlimited to, our ability to successfully implement our strategy, our growth and
expansion, technological changes, our exposure to market risks, general economic
and political conditions in India which have an impact on our business activities or
investments, the monetary and interest policies of India, inflation, deflation,
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
22/127
22
unanticipated turbulence in interest rates, foreign exchange rates, equity prices or
other rates or prices, the performance of the financial markets in India and
globally, changes in domestic and foreign laws, regulations and taxes and changes
in competition in the industry
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
23/127
23
2. Company Overview
Idea Cellular Limited (Idea) is a leading mobile services operator in India, with ~
39 mn subscribers as on March09. Idea has a subscriber market share of 19.5% in
its 8 established service areas, and 14.5% in its 13 operating service areas. After
inclusion of Spice Communications, Brand !dea has 43.02 mn subscribers,
corresponding to a 11.0% national market share.
A. Promoter Group
Idea is part of the Aditya Birla Group, India's first truly multinational group. The
Group has businesses in sectors ranging from metals, garments, cement, fertilisers,life insurance and financial services among others. Over 50% of the Groups
revenues are derived from overseas operations. The group operates in 25 countries,
and is anchored by an extraordinary force of over 125,000 employees belonging to
25 nationalities. The current Group holding of 49.13% in Idea is made up of;
Aditya Birla Nuvo Ltd. 27.02%
Birla TMT Holdings Pvt. Ltd. 9.15%
Hindalco Industries Ltd. 7.37%
Grasim Industries Ltd. 5.52%
IGH Holdings Pvt. Ltd. 0.08%
Total 49.13%
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
24/127
24
B. Key Shareholders
AXIATA Group Berhad, previously TM International Berhad, through its
affiliates has 14.99% shareholding in Idea Cellular, and a 49.0% holding in Spice
Communications. With the proposed merger of Spice Communications into Idea
Cellular, the Axiata Group holding in Idea Cellular would increase to around 20%.
The Group, is one of the largest Asian telecommunication companies, focused in
high growth low penetration emerging markets. AXIATA has a controlling
interest in Malaysia, Indonesia, Sri Lanka, Bangladesh and Cambodia with
significant strategic stakes in India and Singapore. India and Indonesia are some of
the fastest growing markets in the world. In addition, the Malaysian grown holding
company has assets in telecommunication operations in Thailand, Pakistan and
Iran. As of December 2008, the Group, including its subsidiaries and associates,
has close to 90 million mobile subscribers in Asia. The Group provides
employment to over 25,000 people across Asia. Upon its de-merger from Telekom
Malaysia in April 2008, AXIATA became an independent entity and
simultaneously listed on the Malaysian stock exchange.
Providence Equity Partners, through its affiliates has a 10.6% shareholding in Idea,
and has also invested Rs. 20982 mn in ABTL through Compulsorily Convertible
Preference Shares.
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
25/127
25
C. Corporate Structure
Idea Cellular Limited (Idea)
100% -- Idea Cellular Infrastructure Services Limited (ICISL) 100% --
Idea Cellular Services Limited (ICSL) 100% -- Swinder Singh Satara & Co
Limited (SSSL) 41.1% -- Spice Communications Limited (Spice)
100% -- Aditya Birla Telecom Limited (ABTL)
100% -- Idea Cellular Tower Infrastructure Limited (ICTIL) 16% --
Indus Towers Limited (Indus)
IICCIISSLL tower company owning towers in Bihar and Orissa service area.
IICCSSLL provides manpower services to operating entities i.e. Idea & ABTL.
SSSSSSLL holds MSC real estate in the Delhi service area.
SSppiiccee provides GSM based mobile services in Punjab and Karnataka
service areas. AABBTTLL provides GSM based mobile services in Bihar service
area, and has 16% shareholding in Indus. IICCTTIILL holds towers de-merged
from Idea, which will subsequently merge in Indus. IInndduuss a joint venture
between Bharti Infratel, Vodafone Essar and Idea (through ABTL), to provide
passive infrastructure services in 15 service areas.
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
26/127
26
Operating Service Areas (as on April 2009))
Brand !dea covers 16 telecom service areas, viz, Maharashtra & Goa, Gujarat,
Andhra Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh & Chhattisgarh, Delhi, Kerala, Haryana, Uttar
Pradesh West & Uttaranchal, Rajasthan, Uttar Pradesh East, Himachal Pradesh,
Mumbai, Bihar & Jharkhand, Orissa, Punjab and Karnataka, covering ~ 80% of
the all India subscriber base. Of these, the 3 service areas of Rajasthan, UP East
and Himachal Pradesh, were rolled out during Sep-Nov06, while the 2 service
areas of Mumbai and Bihar became operational during Aug-Oct08. The service
areas of Punjab and Karnataka were added through Spice w.e.f October 16,
2008.
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
27/127
27
3. Reporting Guidelines:
To facilitate an analytical perspective, the results have been formatted and grouped
as under: a) Standalone Idea, and its 100% subsidiaries, grouped together on a
standalone basis. Effectively, this encompasses all mobile operations in India,
excluding Spice and Indus.
b) Consolidated Idea and its 100% subsidiaries, and JVs, grouped together. This
covers Idea operating service areas and the ABTL operating service area of Bihar,
the proportionate consolidation of Indus (16%), and the proportionate
consolidation of Spice (41.09% w.e.f. October 16, 2008).
JV financials have been consolidated as jointly controlled entities as per AS 27 -
Financial reporting of Interests in Joint Ventures . It may be noted that the
consolidation of financials of two or more entities requires elimination of inter
entity transactions. Illustratively, rentals paid by Idea to Indus, become expenses
for Idea and revenues for Indus, on a standalone basis. However, upon
consolidation, the proportionate revenue of Indus gets reduced to the extent
contributed by Idea. The rental expenses of Idea also stand correspondingly
reduced in the consolidated financials.
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
28/127
28
4. Financial Highlights
A. Standalone Profit & Loss Account
B. Consolidated Profit & Loss Account
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
29/127
29
C. Revenue & Profitability Break-up
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
30/127
30
D. Summarized Balance Sheet
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
31/127
31
5. Key Performance Indicators
A. Financial Indicators Idea Standalone
B. Operational IndicatorsIdea Standalone
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
32/127
32
C. Operational IndicatorsSpice
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
33/127
33
6. Management Discussion & Analysis
Fastest Growing Major TelcoBack to Back Years of Strong Market Gains
Standalone revenues for the quarter at Rs. 28,626 mn, grew 9.2% on a QoQ basis.In a period marked by economic downturn and increased competitive and price
pressure, Idea was able to maintain its strong growth momentum. Annual revenues
of 99,622 mn show a growth of 47.9%
compared to the last year. This revenue growth
of 47.9%, on the back of the FY08 revenue
growth of 53.6%, places Idea as the fastest
growing major operator in one of the largest, fastest growing, and most
competitive telecom markets in the world. Idea on a standalone basis, added 4.7
mn subscribers in the
quarter, its highest ever. For the entire year FY09, subscriber base has grown
by 79.2 %. In its 8 established service areas, Idea strengthened its market position
by gaining 1% market share, and consolidating its position close to the market
leader. In the 3 gestating service areas, Idea also increased its market share to
6.3%, from 5.8% a due to change in subscribers recognition criteria year ago.
In the newly launched service areas of Mumbai and Bihar, Idea has
acquired a 4.0 % share of the combined market, with a net adds market share of
16.6%, during last 6 months.
Total Minutes on the Network at 44,224 mn grew by 9.9% on a QoQ basis.
The Average Realised Rate per Minute, which had moved up from 62p to 64p in
the previous quarter, settled at 63p.
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
34/127
34
Indus IRU Impact
Idea (standalone) rent-paying cell sites jumped from 21,459 at Dec08 quarter end
to 36,573 at Mar09 quarter end. This increase of 15,294 cell sites includes 11,094
cell sites on Idea towers, transferred to Indus, through the IRU effective January 1,
2009. As of March09, out of the 36,573 rent paying cell sites, 25,150 cell sites are
on Indus Towers. The accounting treatment of the IRU arrangement increased the
network operating cost for the March09 quarter. Rental income that Idea was
deriving from guest sites also ceased w.e.f. January 1, 2009, as these would accrue
to Indus. The combined impact of these 2 factors was the equivalent of ~ 3.4 %
EBITDA contraction for the quarter ended March09. Until the merger into Indus
is consummated, Idea will account for depreciation for the IRU towers. However,
Idea will receive an IRU income for the transferred towers until the merger, which
for the quarter ended March09 was the equivalent of ~1.2% of the EBITDA.
Therefore, the net negative EBITDA impact for the quarter was ~2.2 %. The above
treatment does not include Ideas pro-rata share of Indus profit/loss. The
financials do not also capture the notional capex cost saving derived because ofIndus, and the speed to market benefit.
Upon consolidation, Ideas share of 16% of Indus revenues is Rs. 1,870 mn.
However, with consolidation eliminations, no revenue has been consolidated. An
equal amount has been eliminated from the Indus rentals accounted by Idea.
Further Idea has consolidated Rs. 1,196 mn as 16% share of Indus operating
expenses, after elimination of IRU income received from Indus.
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
35/127
35
Network Capacity
Cell sites
Idea rolled out 4,941 cell sites during the March09 quarter, taking the FY094423050000tally to 19,437, and the EoP cell sites to 44,230. In the preceding year
FY08, 40000Idea had added 14,679 cell sites. Thus, in the last 2 fiscal years, Idea
has enhanced its cell site capacity 4.4 times, representing a massive
2479330000enhancement of capacity to build competitive strength.
2000010114The capacity already built, together with improved spectrum
availability and 47631000018433049enhanced technology features will result in
greater capex efficiency in FY10, 0and reduced capex intensity.
FY04FY05FY06FY 07FY08FY09Total capex for FY09 was Rs. 54.5 bn. For
FY10, including for new service area launches, the capex will indicatively be in the
region of Rs. 60.0 bn. This estimate does not factor the unknown impact of a
possible 3G auction. Financial Performance
At the EBITDA level the net negative impact of Indus IRU is 2.2% for the quarter.
However, EBITDA margin for Q4 at 25.9% is almost similar to the Q3 margin,
indicative of other operational efficiencies which have absorbed the negative Indus
IRU impact.
Depreciation & Amortization for FY09 at Rs.13,212 mn increased by 50.7% on a
YoY basis. Net interest and finance cost for FY09 at Rs.4,070 mn increased by
46.6% on a YoY basis.
PAT for the quarter at Rs.3,032 mn was higher by 18.3% on a QoQ basis. After
absorbing the losses of the new launches of Mumbai and Bihar, Profit after Tax for
FY09 was Rs.9,754 mn.
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
36/127
36
New Launches
thBrand Idea has expanded its wings to its 16 service area, with the commercial
launch of Orissa in April 2009. With this, Idea now covers ~ 80% of the national
subscriber base. Preparatory work for other roll outs is on track, with Tamil Nadu
planned for the Jun09 quarter. Within the calendar year 2009, Idea plans to have
pan India operations. Tailored Approach for Different Service Areas
Idea holds 900 MHz GSM spectrum in 9 service areas, which make up ~50% of
the national market. This frequency band confers capex and opex benefits. It is also
accompanied by early mover advantage. Idea is the mobility revenue market
leader in 3 of these service areas, and is overall in the second spot. The twin
advantages of spectrum and scale underpin Ideas enduring competitive edge.
In some of the remaining service areas, Idea pursues a strategy of optimisation
as opposed to maximisation. It plans to achieve a pan India footprint and
leverage synergies of scale and wider presence, and calibrated capex spend
through infrastructure sharing. The focus is on operational and financial goals,
and not on league tables.
The service area tailored strategy is designed to enhance Ideas long term
competitiveness.
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
37/127
37
Update on Spice Communications
The accounts of Spice continue to be consolidated in proportion of the
shareholding of 41.09%, until its eventual merger into Idea. Finalisation of the
merger scheme is in an advanced stage and will be effective after the court order.
Update on Indus Towers
As the 3 shareholders, Bharti Infratel, Vodafone Essar Ltd and ABTL (100%
subsidiary of Idea) signed the IRU with Indus effective January 01, 2009, Indus
has started invoicing respective entities for the sites covered by the IRU. Idea has
filed the scheme for demerger of towers to ICTIL. This will be followed by thefiling of the merger scheme of ICTIL with Indus.
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
38/127
38
7. Stock Market Highlights
Idea Cellular Daily Stock price (NSE) & Volume (Combined of BSE & NSE)
Movement
Volume (no. of Shares) Closing Price
20,000,0005516,000,0005012,000,000458,000,000404,000,000350309999999999
9999999999-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-00-00-00-
0anananananananebebebebebebarar-arar-arar-ar-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-F-F-F-F-F-F-M-M-
M-M-M-M-M0106121520232936169525270500011120011223BSE & NSE
Combined VolumeNSE Cl Price8. Shareholding Pattern as on March 31, 2009:
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
39/127
39
9. Glossary
Definitions/Abbreviation Description/Full Form Annualized EBITDA Annualised
figure of quarterly EBITDA ARPU (Average Revenue Per User) Is calculated by
dividing services revenue (exclusive of activation charges and infrastructure
revenues) for the relevant period by the average number of subscribers during the
period. The result obtained is divided by the number of months in that period to
arrive at the ARPU per month figure
AS Accounting Standards as issued by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of
India
ARR (Average Realised rate) ARR is calculated as ARPU divided by MoUs Churn
Churn relates to subscribers who are removed from the EoP base for discontinuing
to use the service of the company.
Circle/ Service Area Unless otherwise specifically mentioned, means telecom
circles in India (including metropolitan circles) as defined by the DoT. Circles are
classified as metropolitan circles and as category A, B or C Circles. The
Circles are classified on the basis of the revenue generation capacity of each circle
with category A being considered the most revenue generating
EBIT Earnings Before Interest and Tax EBITDA (Earnings before interest, This is
the amount after deducting operating expenditure from total tax, depreciation and
amortisation) income. Total income is comprised of service revenue, sales of
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
40/127
40
trading goods and other income. Operating expenditure is comprised of cost of
trading goods, personnel expenditure, network operating expenditure, license and
WPC charges, roaming and access charges, subscriber acquisition and servicing
expenditure, advertisement and business promotion expenditure and administration
and other expenses EoP End of period
FY /Fiscal Financial year ending March 31 GSM Global System for Mobile
communications, the most popular standard for mobile phones in the world
Indian GAAP Indian Generally Accepted Accounting Principles IRU Indefeasible
right of use MoUs/Sub (Average Minutes of We calculate the MoUs/Sub as , total
Minutes of Use in our network Usages per Subs) during the period divided by
average of subscribers during the period Net Adds Refers to net customer additions
which is calculated as the difference between the closing and the opening
customers for the period Net Debt Total loan funds reduced by cash and cash
equivalents Calculated as summation of Share Capital and Reserves & Surplus Net
Worth
reduced by debit balance of profit & loss account
PBT Profit before tax
PAT Profit after tax
ROCE ROCE is calculated as a) for the year : PAT plus gross int. & fin. cost
divided by average capital employed for the year, b) for the quarter : PAT plus
gross int. & fin. cost for the quarter is annualised and divided by capital employed
for the quarter. Capital employed is taken as average of opening and closing of
Shareholders funds and Loan Funds reduced by debit balance of P&L account, for
the respective period Subscribers Mobile telephone service customers TRAI
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
41/127
41
Telecommunications Regulatory Authority of India, constituted under the
Telecommunications Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
42/127
42
SWOT ANALYSIS ORGANIZATION
Attractive existing footprintThe subscriber base under brand Idea, increased from
24 million as of end March 2008 to 43.02 million as of end March 2009, a growth
of around 79%, taking its national market share to 11%.
Original licensee in seven of the Established Circles, providing incumbency
advantages-The established service areas are Delhi, Andhra Pradesh, Gujarat,
Maharashtra, Haryana, Kerala, Madhya Pradesh and Uttar Pradesh (West). The
New Service Areas are Uttar Pradesh (East), Rajasthan, Himachal Pradesh, Bihar,
Mumbai, Karnataka, Punjab, Orissa, Chennai & Tamil Nadu, Jammu & Kashmir,
Kolkata & West Bengal, and Assam & North East. leader in two of, and
established positions in the remainder of, the Established Circles.
Strong distribution channels.
High quality network structure.
Innovation always comes out with new products.IDEA is the winner of The
Emerging Company of the Year Award' at The Economic Times Corporate
Excellence Awards 2008-09. The company has received several other national and
international recognitions for its path-breaking innovations inmobile telephony
products & services. It won the GSM Association Award for Best Billing and
Customer Care Solution for 2 consecutive years. It was awarded Mobile
Operator of the Year Award -India for 2007 and 2008 at the Annual Asian Mobile
News Awards.
A national brand -The Company through its participative work
environment, skill development activities, and by championing the values of
commitment, integrity, passion, seamlessness and speed, promotes strong bonding
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
43/127
43
with its employees. During the year, it has again undertaken sharing of value
creation by granting another tranche of employee stock options to the eligible
employees. The findings of OrganizationHealth Study (OHS) have been analyzed,
which are very encouraging, and concern areas are being suitably addressed. The
employee strength onrolls stood at 6,481 as on March 31, 2009.
Attractive growth From 11.8 million subscribers in 2006 to 24 millionin 2008
,then to 43 million by end of March 2009 and to 51 by end of 2009 is really a great
performance from Idea.
Part of the Aditya Birla Group-IDEA Cellular is an Aditya Birla Group Company,
India's first truly multinational corporation. The group operates in 25 countries, and
is anchored by over 1, 30,000employees belonging to 30 nationalities. The Group
has been adjudged the 6th Top Company for Leaders in Asia Pacific Region' in
2009, in a survey conducted by Hewitt Associates, in partnership with The RBL
Group, and Fortune. The Group has also been rated The Best Employer in India
and among the Top 20 in Asia' by the Hewitt-Economic Times and Wall Street
Journal Study 2007.Their promoters-1. Aditya Birla Nuvo Limited2. Grasim
Industries Limited
3. Hindalco Industries Limited
4. Birla TMT HoldingsPrivate LimitedWeaknesses -Equity Ratio: The
Company's Debt-Equity ratio is high as compared to its peers. Moreover, the
Company needs the approval of the lenders under its financing arrangements
before undertaking certain significant corporate actions. The
Company revenues are derived solely from providing mobile services and it is
dependent on four of the Established Circles for a significant proportion of its
revenues.
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
44/127
44
The Company had accumulated losses amounting to Rs. 19.23 billion and Rs.
17.23 billion for financial years 2005 and 2006 respectively. The Company may
not be in a position to pay dividends until it clears its accumulated losses.
Opportunities Indian telecommunication industry is expected to continue to
enjoygrowth due to its low teledensity and increasing affordability of mobile
telephone and services. The strong growth in the sector continues, mainly due to
expansion of telecom networks to rural India, the reduced cost of entry and the
reduced cost of handsets. Low penetration, more particularly in rural India,
provides opportunity for further growth, and your company, an
incumbent GSM player with 900 MHz spectrum in about half of India, is well
positioned to tap this opportunity.
The contribution of service sector to the GDP has improved significantly from
29% in 1950 to 54% in 2005. This is primarily due to growth of information-
technology and information technology enables services. This will further
stimulate the demand for mobile telecommunication services.
The regulatory environment is improving and there is greater clarity in existing
rules and procedures. This would enable operators in improving network quality.
Also raising of funds will become easier due to greater predictability of operational
environment. from new technologies is an inherent threat. While the
planned 2100 MHz spectrum auction for 3G services will lead to additional cash
outflow, it will also open new revenue streams. The Company
s strong balancesheet and market standing, positions it to participate effectively in such auction.
Threats There is intense competitionin the Indian telecommunication industry. Idea
Cellular faces significant competition from private companies that have a pan-
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
45/127
45
India footprint such as Bharti Airtel, Tata Teleservices and Reliance
Communication Ventures. Also it faces competition from government owned
companies such as BSNL and MTNL. technology is evolving very
rapidly in the telecommunications industry. For instance, Wi-Fiand Wi-
Maxwhich allows for voice data transfer have been tested and handsets with
such technology maysoon be available in the Indian market. Moreover, satellite
communication voice data transport medium like Skypemay become a serious
competitor in the long distance voice data transfer business.Porters five forces -
Analysis the external environment1.Competitive rivalry within the
Industrya.Principal competitors- industry
leader Bharti Airtel. Bharti Airtelhas 24.3% customer market share and 33.8%
revenue market share. India has 18.8% customer market share and
20.7% revenue market share.
Idea Cellular has 11.2% subscribers market share and 12.1% revenue market share
BSNL has subscriber share of 12.7% and mere 10.2% of revenue share Reliance
Communications is the worst performerwith 18.9% customer market share and
pathetic 11.5% revenue market share.
(Data mentioned are by end of August 2009)b.Salient strengths -
full advantage of its wide network and fixed line subscriber base, and has
established itself as the provider with maximum coverage over the country.
Bharti Airtel has dominated the scene with wide reach, innovativepackages, catchy ads, and has emerged the leader of the pack. Reliance
Communications also has the wide network to its advantage. Tata tele-services
banks on the Tata-trust factor to gain foothold in the market. Vodafone is hitting
the Indian market in a huge way. They have large cash reserves at their disposal to
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
46/127
46
wipe out the competition in future. Weaknesses- BSNL lines are mostly marred by
congestion,bottlenecks and they have failed to capture the attention of the
customers with attractive offers. Unstable range and poor customer support are
Airtel s minuses. Ambiguous schemes have reduced Reliance s
popularity. Indicom has not really been able to fully capitalize its goodwill
factor. c.Their basis for competition-Vodafone and Idea are comparatively new
entrants into the market and hence the rest of the competition has anadvantage over
them. Also both these brands have undergone rebranding more than once, and
subsequently have had hiccups with people not realizing the transformation. Giants
like BSNL, Airtel and Reliance have wide networks in the nooks and crannies ofthecountry, while Idea is still to open account in several states.
2.Bargaining Power of CustomersThe bargaining power of customers determines
how much customers can impose pressure on margins and volumes. Customers
bargaining power is likely to be high because
Customersuse multiple mobile services these days and hence have a good
knowledge of the pros and cons of each service provider.
Telecommunication industry comprises a number of operators
is not related to h shave low margins and are price
sensitive
product.3.Bargaining power of suppliersIn this industry there is less number of
suppliers compared to other industries such as the manufacturing or textile
industry.
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
47/127
47
I.Mobile handset suppliers although there are many handset suppliers in the
country, some service providers have their own handset manufacturing units
operating inthe country like the Reliance Classic and Tata Indicom (backward
integration). Some of the telecom companies also have some collaboration with
major handset manufacturers like Samsung, L.G, and the Blackberry for their
CDMA services.II.Some other suppliers include optical fibre suppliers and
aluminium (for the construction of towers) suppliers. Here the suppliers have a
limited bargaining power.III.Another important one is the software assistance
where the suppliers have some edge. Major solution providers include TCS,
Infosys, Wipro, etc. While Reliance and Tata have their own software services
other players like Vodafone and Idea depend on the above mentioned software
service providers.
4.Threat ofnew entrantsIndian telecom sector provides unprecedented
opportunities for foreign companies in various areas such as 3G, virtual private
network, international long distance calls, value added services etc.
The market is witnessing M&A activities that are leading to consolidations in the
industry. This trend has assisted companies in expanding their reach in the Indian
telecom market to offer better services to the customers. The Indian telecom
industry has always attracted foreign investors. In fact, the cumulative FDI inflow,
from August 1991 to March 2007, in this sector amounted to $3,892.19 million.
This makes telecom the third largest sector to attract FDI since the liberalization.
Although the entry barriers are in place like license and high fixed costs, still we
observe many new players emerging from the state-level to national-level. This
includes Aircel, Virgin, Spice and Unitech.
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
48/127
48
5.Threat from substitutesTelecom sector offers a wide range of services in India
such as wireline, CDMA, GSM, internet, VoIP, IP etc.
Internet telephone is emerging as a best substitute for the mobile telephony
because it is cheaper and video can also be added. The increasing use and
penetration of internet in the country also augments this. Other facilities on the
internet such as Google talk, Yahoo Messenger, Rediff Bol are used at an
unprecedented level by the youngsters of this country. These are the major
substitutes for the mobile telephony. Maybe this is on of the reasons why the major
service providers also have their presence in internet service. Ideas strategyIdea
is not the market leader in India. They were operating in a few circles earlier and
were considered a regional player. Recently Idea started operations in many states
as part of their national roll out plan and they have operations in 2200 towns in
India. Idea has been focusing on value added services (VAS) from its inception
which is reflected in its products. They have always taken extra care in providing
customer friendly and competitive Pre Paid offerings. Differentiation and
innovation can be associated with Idea right from its beginning. It
s clear from
the following:
Power', 2 Minutes Outgoing Free, Lifelong offer, Women'sCard,
'Lifetime Idea'etc are some of the offerings of IDEA.
first cellular company to launch music messaging with 'Cellular
Jockey','Background Tones', 'Group Talk',a voice portal with 'Say IDEA'and a
complete suite of Mobile EmailServices.
are also providing GPRS and EDGE services for transferring data.
new product introduced by IDEA is the EDGE enabled USB Data Card which is
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
49/127
49
named as 'NetSetter'. Initially NetSetterwas offered to post paid customers
only. Now it is available to prepaid customers in selected circles.
partnership with IIFA for 10th Anniversary Awards, its association with
Mumbai Indians in IPL and major sought after programs in television like MTV
Roadies and Idea Star singerclearly shows its marketing strategies. They always
seek something different and is always in touch with the youth of the country as
they easily switch to other services.
ad campaign showing AbhishekBachanin different settings but all clearly
showing their corporate social responsibility is great. Their approach is different
from others. was the first to provide one rupee STD calls in the country.
Now when every one else gives per second billing and also 50 paisaper minute,
Idea offers at 49 paisaper minute.
As far as Idea is concerned it should not start a price war with Vodafone and other
large players in the industry. This is because Vodafone has a lot ofmoney with
them to suffer the losses and eventually emerge as the winner and it is almostdoing that. Idea can only afford to come out with some differentiated tariff plan
that does not result in a war with the leaders like Airtel and Vodafone. Indian
telecom is already in trouble with the lowest tariff in the world. Differentiation and
innovation is the way forward for Idea in this already bleeding industry, otherwise
it will be a severe bloodshed.
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
50/127
50
Growth in Installed Capacity
Performance Highlights
- Sequential drop in Top-line due to subdued rural demand:Idea Cellular recorded a 0.1%
qoq drop in its consolidated top-line, on account of the subdued rural demand due to the delayed
monsoon (rural areas contribute ~40% to the companys top-line). However, on a yoy basis, the
top-line grew by 29.1%. Ideas standalone subscribers moved up from 42.8mn to 46.8mn qoq in
2QFY2010 (30.4mn in 2QFY2009), while the total subscriber base, including Spice, has moved
up from 47.1mn to 51.5mn qoq in 2QFY2010 (34mn in 2QFY2009). However, the ARPU (Idea
standalone), was down by 20.5% yoy and 9.9% qoq to Rs209. Segment-wise, the top-line
growth, (including Spice) was backed by National Long Distance (NLD) services, which grew
by 25% qoq (87% yoy growth) to Rs269cr. The revenues from Passive Infrastructure services,
which had a miniscule revenue contribution of Rs9cr in 2QFY2009, were up by 2.1% qoq in
2QFY2010 to Rs225cr. The only laggard in the growth during 2QFY2010 was a 2.8% qoq de-
growth (27.5% yoy growth) in the Mobility services segment to Rs2,926cr. Minutes of Usage
(MoUs) declined by 11% yoy and 6% qoq to 375 minutes for Idea Standalone, while MoUs in
Spice stood at 429, down by 1.1% yoy and 5.5% qoq. In 2QFY2010, Idea Standalone recorded
Rs182.2cr of Revenues from its newer circles, Mumbai, Bihar, Orissa and Tamil Nadu (incl.
newly launched services in Chennai), witnessing a growth of 27.6% qoq.
- EBITDA losses in newer service areas contracts EBITDA margins:Idea standalone
continued to witness EBITDA losses in its new service areas, while the existing 11 areas
witnessed a 40bp qoq drop in margins. On a consolidated basis in 2QFY2010, Idea recorded a
167bp qoq contraction in its EBITDA Margins. This was mainly due to a 73bp increase in
personnel expenditure, and an 80bp rise in subscriber acquisition and business promotion
expenses. The margins in the Indus business witnessed a 110bp qoq increase on account of pass-
through costs and benefits from vendors on recurring expenses. On a yoy basis, the margins were
up by 89bp, mainly on account of a 447bp reduction in Roaming and Access Charges, and a
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
51/127
51
224bp drop in subscriber acquisition and business promotion expenses, vis--vis an increase of
600bp in Network Operating Expenditure.
- Higher Interest costs and effective tax rate suppress the Bottom-line: Owing to a 21.6%
qoq increase in interest costs and an increase in the effective tax rate from 6.4% to 14% in
2QFY2010, the Bottom-line declined by 25.9% qoq. On a yoy basis, the Bottom-line spurted by
52.8%, mainly on account of strong operational efficiency.
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
52/127
52
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
53/127
53
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
54/127
54
Outlook and Valuation
In addition to the five newer service areas, Idea has recently expanded to the service areas ofJammu & Kashmir, Kolkata & West Bengal, and North East & Assam. It now covers a total of
18 service areas, which will contribute to revenues from 3QFY2010 onwards. This move is in
line with the companys expansion plan to garner a pan-India presence, for seizing upcoming
opportunities, like the demand in Broadband services, Value Added Services and the
forthcoming 3G auction, once the regulatory and pricing environment in the Indian Telecom
Sector stabilises. Hence, the companys operational expense is expected to be on the higher side
in the coming quarters, as it focuses on brand-building and high-end technology to match up with
the growing demand, and for increasing its coverage in rural areas. For these initiatives, Idea has
planned a capex of Rs45bn in FY2010.
Going forward, we expect Idea Cellular to record a CAGR of 23% in its consolidated Top-line
over FY2009-11E, while the Bottom-line is expected to record a CAGR de-growth of 1.5% over
the same period. We estimate the companys mobile subscriber base (excluding Spice) to post a
CAGR of 32% over FY2009-11E and to touch 67.9mn, while including Spice, the subscriberbase is estimated to post a CAGR of 31.4% to touch 74.3mn. We estimate blended ARPUs (ex-
Spice) to post a CAGR decline of 15% to Rs190.4 by FY2011E. At the CMP, the stock is trading
at a P/E of 20.2x FY2011E EPS and an EV/EBITDA of 6.1x FY2011E EBITDA.
On account of the significant headwinds being faced by the Indian Telecom Sector in general,
and little scope of an improvement in the near-term profitability of Idea in particular (with an
increase in the opex and capex), we believe that the company is currently trading at expensive
valuations. Hence, we maintain a Reduce on the stock, with a Target Price of Rs49. We have
valued Ideas core business at Rs27 and have valued the Tower business (16% stake in Indus) at
Rs22 per share, based on our DCF estimates.
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
55/127
55
ACCUMULATE
Performance Highlights Price Rs43 Top-line soars on strong subscriber adds, Spice consolidation: Idea Cellular
recorded a strong 59.6% yoy and 18.5% qoq growth in consolidated Target Price Rs48 Top-line in 3QFY2009 driven by
an increase in its mobile subscriber base, which grew by an impressive 62.4% yoy and 12.6% qoq. At the end ofInvestment Period 12 months
3QFY2009, Idea had a mobile subscriber base of 34.2mn, recording net adds of 3.8mn over the quarter. Including
Spice, the companys subscriber Stock Info
base stands at 38mn. Gross mobile average revenues per user (ARPUs, ex-Spice) rose 1.6% qoq (fall of 5.7% yoy)
to Rs271 (Rs266 in 2QFY2009, Sector Telecom
Rs287 in 3QFY2008). The sequential rise in ARPUs was due to higher Market Cap (Rs cr) 13,299 in-roaming Revenues.
Spice ARPUs rose 8% qoq to Rs279 (Rs259 in 2QFY2009). Part of the Revenue growth was due to consolidation of
Spice Beta 1.0
with effect from October 16, 2008 (proportionate basis, with 41.09% stake) and proportionate Revenues from Indus
Towers.
52 WK High / Low 129 / 34
Minutes of Usage (MoUs) declined 1.7% qoq to 410 minutes per user per Avg Daily Volume 1948137
month. On a yoy basis, however, this metric grew by a decent 8.8%. Thus, Face Value (Rs) 10 the MoU fall
sequentially led to rise in realisations, with Revenues per Minute (RPMs) increasing 3.2% qoq, even as they fell by
over 13% on a yoy basis. BSE Sensex 8,674 In 3QFY2009, the company launched operations in the Bihar circle and full
impact of the Mumbai launch was also absorbed. These circles recorded Nifty 2,679
Rs48.3cr of Revenues. Top-line for the 13 service areas of the company (ex-Spice) grew by a robust 53.2% yoy and
13.9% qoq. BSE Code 532822
NSE Code IDEA Margins fall on expansion, higher rental sites and Access Charges: In 3QFY2009, Idea recorded a
significant 777bp yoy and 81bp qoq contraction Reuters Code IDEA.BO in EBITDA Margins. Network Expansion costs
rose, as a percentage of Sales, by 513bp yoy and by 270bp qoq. This quarter, the number of Bloomberg Code IDEA@IN
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
56/127
56
rent-paying sites for Idea rose by 146% yoy to 21,459 (8,721 in 3QFY2008). Shareholding Pattern (%) This led to the
significant rise in Network Expenses. Roaming & Access Charges also rose by 148bp yoy, as a percentage of Sales
(7bp qoq). Promoters EBITDA losses of 158.4% (Rs76.5cr) in the Mumbai and Bihar circles also 49.1
adversely impacted the companys Margin profile.
MF/Banks/Indian FIs
6.7 Lower Margins, higher Depreciation reduce Bottom-line: Owing to FII/ NRIs/ OCBs Margin contraction and
higher Depreciation (up 72.9% yoy), Ideas 40.1
Bottom-line for the quarter declined 7.3% yoy. However, on a qoq basis, Indian Public/Others 4.1 strong growth of
52.3% was recorded due to lower Net Interest Costs (down 42% qoq) due to Rs179.4cr of Interest Income recorded.
Abs. 3m 1yr 3yr*
Key Financials (Consolidated)
Sensex (%) (11.2) (50.7) (32.7) Y/E March (Rs cr) FY2007 FY2008 FY2009E FY2010E Net Sales 4,366 6,720 10,094
14,451 Idea Cellular (%) (3.5) (61.3) (49.9)
% chg 47.2 53.9 50.2 43.2 * Since listing on March 9, 2007
Net Profit 502 1,042 804 909
% chg 148.2 107.6 (22.8) 13.0 Harit Shah
EBITDA Margin (%) 33.6 33.5 26.7 25.1
FDEPS (Rs) 1.6 3.2 2.5 2.8 Tel: 022 4040 3800 Ext: 345
P/E (x) 27.6 13.3 17.2 15.3 e-mail: [email protected]
EV/EBITDA (x) 10.7 8.6 5.3 4.3 RoE (%) 30.3 36.4 10.5 7.4
RoCE (%) 18.4 19.8 12.2 17.1 Sales/GFA (x) 0.6 0.6 0.6 0.7
Mobile ARPUs (Rs/user/month)340 295 257 247
Source: Company, Angel Research
January 23, 2009 1
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
57/127
57
Idea Cellular
Telecom
Subscriber growth drives Top-line; first quarter of Spice consolidation
In 3QFY2009, Idea Cellular recorded a strong 59.6% yoy and an impressive 18.5% qoq
growth in consolidated Top-line primarily driven by growth in the companys mobile subscriber base, which grew
62.4% yoy and 12.6% qoq to 34.2mn. Over the year, Idea added 13.1mn mobile subscribers, while over the quarter
it added 3.8mn subscribers, implying monthly net adds of 1.3mn. Gross mobile ARPUs fell by 5.7% yoy but rose
1.6%
qoq to Rs271 (Rs287 in 3QFY2008 and Rs266 in 2QFY2009).
This was the first quarter of consolidation of Spice with the company. The consolidation is with effect from October
16, 2008. At the end of the quarter, Idea held 41.09% stake in Spice Communications, with the balance holding
distributed amongst Telecom Malaysia International (TMI) and Green Acre, an affiliate. Proportionate consolidation
of Indus
Towers was also done, with proportionate Revenues from joint ventures at Rs127.3cr. This
boosted Top-line. Excluding this, Revenues from its 13 service areas (including Mumbai
and Bihar) grew 53.2% yoy and 13.9% qoq. Mumbai and Bihar recorded Rs48.3cr in Top-line and ended the
quarter with 3.3 lakh and 2.7 lakh subscribers, respectively. At the end of 3QFY2009, Ideas marketshare in its
circles of operations stood at 17.6% v/s 17.2% at the end of 2QFY2009 and 17.3% at the end of 3QFY2008.
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
58/127
58
Exhibit 1: Total MoUs on Ideas network
(Mn minutes)
41,000
CQGR 17.4%34,000
27,000
20,000
13,000
6,000
1QFY072QFY073QFY074QFY071QFY082QFY083QFY084QFY081QFY092QFY093QFY09 Source: Company, Angel Research
Ideas MoUs witnessed a fall of 1.7% qoq, even as yoy growth in this metric was decent at
8.8%. MoUs per month stood at 410 as against 417 in 2QFY2009 and 377 in 3QFY2008.
On account of this fall, realisations (RPMs) rose by 3.2% qoq to 64 paise, while on a yoy
basis, a fall of 13.5% was witnessed. The total MoUs on Ideas network grew by an impressive 79.2% yoy and by
10.8% qoq, crossing 40bn minutes (40.25bn).
Exhibit 2: Mobility Business - Operating metrics (excluding Spice)
Particulars 3QFY08 2QFY09 3QFY09 % chg yoy % chg qoq
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
59/127
59
Revenues (Rs cr) 1,710 2,301 2,621 53.2 13.9
Mobile subscriber base (Mn) 21.1 30.4 34.2 62.4 12.6
Gross mobile ARPUs (Rs/month) 287 266 271 (5.7) 1.6 Total minutes of usage (Mn) 22,457 36,315 40,254 79.2 10.8
Revenues per minute (Rs) 0.74 0.62 0.64 (13.5) 3.2 Minutes of use per user/month 377 417 410 8.8 (1.7) EBITDA (Rs cr) 569
608 680 19.4 11.9
EBITDA Margins (%) 33.3 26.4 25.9 (7.3) (0.5)
EBITDA/minute (Rs) 0.25 0.17 0.17 (33.4) 0.9 Source: Company, Angel Research; Note: These metrics are for the 13 service areas that Spice
currently operates in and do not include Spice Communications.
Margins fall on expansion, higher rental sites and Access Charges In 3QFY2009, Idea recorded a significant 777bp
yoy and 81bp qoq contraction in EBITDA Margins. Network Operating Expenditure rose, as a percentage of Sales,
by 513bp yoy and by 270bp qoq. This quarter, the number of rent-paying sites for Idea rose by 146% yoy to 21,459
(8,721 in 3QFY2008). This led to the significant rise in Network Expenses. Roaming
& Access Charges also rose by 148bp yoy, as a percentage of Sales (7bp qoq). EBITDA January 23, 2009 2
Idea Cellular
Telecom
losses of 158.4% in the Mumbai and Bihar circles (Rs76.5cr) also adversely impacted the
companys Margin profile.
Exhibit 3: Consolidated Revenue break-up (Rs cr) 3QFY08 2QFY09 3QFY09 % chg yoy % chg qoq Revenues
Established circles 1,710 2,295 2,572 50.4 12.1 Newer circles - 5 48 - 828.8 Sub-total - 13 service areas 1,710 2,300 2,620 53.2
13.9
Proportionate revenue from JVs - 7 127 - 1,858.5
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
60/127
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
61/127
61
Issues 1.925mn Compulsorily Convertible Preference Shares to Providence affiliate Idea Cellular on December 5,
2008 received Rs2,100cr from an affiliate of Providence Equity Partners by way of subscription to 1.925mn
Compulsorily Convertible Preference Shares, which will be converted into 16.14% of the equity capital of Aditya
Birla Telecom
(ABTL) post conversion.
Signs IRU with Indus Towers to transfer 11,100 towers; to impact Margins by 4-5% Idea Cellular has signed an
Indefeasible Right to Use (IRU) agreement with Indus Towers, the tower joint venture (JV) between itself, Bharti
and Vodafone involving the transfer of 11,100 of its towers to Indus, each of which will have one cell site for Idea.
Thus, out of the
balance of 17,830 towers that were until now non-rent paying, 11,100 will become
rent-paying on the books of Indus. The approximate book value of these towers is
Rs1,450cr.
This will lead to a significantly higher component of rent-paying towers for Idea and capex will get converted into
opex. There will be a 4-5% impact on EBITDA Margins in FY2010 on
account of this. However, lower Depreciation and Interest costs will offset the impact to an
extent on the Bottom-line. Moreover, with consolidation of 16% of Indus, the impact is likely
to be limited to around 2-2.5% at the Net Profit level.
January 23, 2009 3
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
62/127
62
Idea Cellular
Telecom
Outlook and Valuation
Going forward, we expect Idea Cellular to record a CAGR of 46.3% in Top-line over FY2008-10E, while Bottom-
line is expected to record a CAGR fall of 7.5% over the period
on account of significant Margin pressures. We estimate the companys mobile subscriber
base (including Spice) to post a CAGR of 52.9% over FY2008-10E to 56.1mn, while ARPUs
would post a decline in CAGR of 8.4% over the period to Rs247.
At the CMP, the stock is trading at a P/E of 15.3x FY2010E EPS, EV/EBITDA of 4.3x FY2010E EBITDA and at
an EV/subscriber of US $67.5 on our FY2010E subscriber base.
We believe the company is well-positioned in terms of spectrum holdings across the
country. Strong fund infusion from recent initiatives like the stake sale in ABTL and the
Spice deal with TMI will result in a well-funded Balance Sheet and Net Debt-Equity ratio of just 0.19x. However,
the environment going forward is likely to become more difficult given intensifying competition, falling ARPUs,
cost pressures owing to rapid expansion of coverage area, leading to Margin pressures, which are likely to get
further exacerbated due
to roll outs in newer circles (higher initial EBITDA losses), which would in turn exert
significant pressure on Profitability, and regulatory risks. With RCOMs GSM roll-out and the
upcoming GSM launches of Tata Teleservices, apart from circle expansion by Aircel (GSM) and Shyam-Sistema
(CDMA) as well as newer operator roll-outs, the competitive environment is expected to further intensify.
We downgrade our 12-month Target Price to Rs48 (Rs66), which includes Rs22 as the
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
63/127
63
value of the core business after downgrading the P/E multiple to 8x (10x), and Rs26 as the
value of its 16% stake in Indus Towers. We recommend an Accumulate on the stock and believe that while the
companys recent initiatives will enable it to build a strong business in the longer-term, the increasingly difficult
environment is likely to exert significant strain on its key operating and financial parameters, thereby limiting
major upsides in the stock price.
January 23, 2009 4
Idea Cellular
Telecom
Exhibit 4: 3QFY2009 Consolidated Financial Performance
Y/E March (Rs cr) FY2009 FY2008 % chg FY2009 % chg 9MFY2009 9MFY2008 % chg 3Q 3Q (yoy) 2Q (qoq) Net
revenues 2,731 1,710 59.6 2,303 18.5 7,212 4,752 51.8 Operating expenditure 2,034 1,141 78.2 1,697 19.8 5,188
3,156 64.4 Operating profit (EBITDA) 697 569 22.4 607 14.9 2,024 1,596 26.8 Other income 1 - 0 1 -
Interest charges (Net) 87 78 11.8 150 (41.6) 390 157 148.1 Depreciation & Amortisation 394 228 72.9 303
29.9 972 617 57.5 Income before income taxes 216 264 (17.9) 154 40.5 663 822 (19.3) Tax (3) 27 (111.6) 10 (131.3) 36 56
(34.9) Net income 219 237 (7.3) 144 52.3 627 766 (18.2) Diluted EPS (Rs) 0.7 0.9 (21.1) 0.5 42.0 2.2 2.9
(25.1) EBITDA margin (%) 25.5 33.3 26.3 28.1 33.6 Net profit margin (%) 8.0 13.8 6.3 8.7 16.1 Mobile
ARPUs (Rs/user/month) 271 287 (5.7) 266 1.6 271 301 (10.0) Source: Company, Angel Research
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
64/127
64
Growth in sales:
Aditya Birla Group
A US $28 billion corporation, the Aditya Birla Group is in the league of Fortune 500. It is a
multinational corporation based in Mumbai, India with operations in 25 countries. The group is a
major player in all the industry sectors it operates in. The Group has been adjudged the best
employer in India and among the top 20 in Asia by the Hewitt-Economic Times and Wall Street
Journal Study 2007. The origins of the group lie in the conglomerate once held by one of India's
foremost industrialists Mr. Ghanshyam Das Birla. He bequeathed most of these companies to his
grandson, Mr. Aditya Vikram Birlathe father of the current Chairman of the group, Mr. Kumar
Mangalam Birla. Mr. Kumar Mangalam Birla is the grandson of Mr. Basant Kumar Birla, who
heads his own independent business conglomerate. Several other members of the Birla Family
own and run their independent business groups.
Aditya Birla is organized into various subsidiaries that operate across different sectors. Among
these are viscose staple fibre, non-ferrous metals, cement, viscose filament yarn, branded
apparel, carbon black, chemicals, Modern retail (under the 'More' brand of supermarkets, and
also under the Trinethra, and Fabmall brands until recently),fertilizers,sponge iron, insulators,
financial services, telecom,BPO and IT services. The Group consists of four main companies,
which operate in various industry sectors through subsidiaries, joint ventures, etc. These are
Hindalco, Grasim,Aditya Birla Nuvo,and UltraTech Cement.
We have focused on the Idea Cellular SBU of Aditya Birla Group. It is One of India's leading
GSM mobile service operators; IDEA Cellular is headquartered in Mumbai and has over 30
million subscribers. Innovation is central to IDEA's Value Added Service products. It was the
first to offer 'Global SMS' in over 540 networks across all technology platforms. It has also
acquired Modi familys Spice. But then it even faces tough competition from various major
players. The leading Mobile Networks today in India are Airtel, Vodafone (sold by Hutchinson
Essar to Vodafone), BSNL, MTNL, Orange, Aircel, Tata Indicom, Idea, BPL etc. Each of these
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viscosehttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-ferroushttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cementhttp://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Filament_yarn&action=edit&redlink=1http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chemicalshttp://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Modern_retail&action=edit&redlink=1http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fertilizershttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sponge_ironhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insulatorshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_serviceshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telecomhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BPOhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Information_technologyhttp://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Aditya_Birla_Nuvo&action=edit&redlink=1http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Aditya_Birla_Nuvo&action=edit&redlink=1http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Information_technologyhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BPOhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telecomhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_serviceshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Insulatorshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sponge_ironhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fertilizershttp://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Modern_retail&action=edit&redlink=1http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chemicalshttp://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Filament_yarn&action=edit&redlink=1http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cementhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-ferroushttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viscose -
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
65/127
65
companies has a tough competition with one another. BSNL & MTNL being government sectors
have more advantages than other Private sector Companies.Strategic Business Unit Idea Cellular Limited
Idea Cellular Limited has a share of 12% in the total GSM telecom market in India (as on
Mar08). The Entire Telecom Industry is growing at a rate of 25% as compared to the base year
2006-07. This can be termed as a moderately growing Industry and it is expected to grow in the
coming years. We are thus putting the middle line of the vertical axis in our BCG matrix as 15%
as a division between low and high growth.
The first BCG matrix will be plotted for Idea Cellular Limited, our chosen SBU, with respect to
the market leader, Bharti Airtel. Taking the market share of Bharti as 1X, the relative market
share of Idea comes as 0.39X. The BCG matrix thus, would look like as under.
BCG Matrix of Idea Cellular Limited with respect to Airtel
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
66/127
66
Analysis of BCG matrix:
In the above matrix, Idea Cellular Limited falls in the first quadrant of QUESTION MARKS.
The circle size represents the absolute market share (i.e. 12%) of our SBU in the telecom sector.
We will formulate the strategies which Idea should follow in the later part of this project.
MarketGrowthRate(in%)
0
LO
15
HIGH
30
10X 1X 0.39X 0.1X
Relative Market Share
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
67/127
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
68/127
68
1X, the relative market share of Vodafone comes as 0.74X. The BCG matrix of Airtel
will look as under:
BCG Matrix of Vodafone with respect to Airtel
Analysis of BCG matrix:
In the above matrix, Vodafone falls in the quadrant of QUESTION MARK with respect to the
market LEADER. The circle size represents the absolute market share (i.e. 23%) of Vodafone in
the telecom sector.
3. BSNL: BSNL is another competitor ahead of IDEA in the telecom sector with a market
share of 19%. The market leader in this industry is Airtel and so we plot the BCG matrix
of BSNL with respect to Airtel. Taking the market share of Airtel (i.e. 31%) as 1X, the
relative market share of BSNL comes as 0.61X. The BCG matrix of Airtel will look as
under:
BCG Matrix of Idea Cellular Limited with respect to Airtel
M
arketGrowthRate(in%
)
0
LO
15
HIGH
30
10X 1X 0.74X 0.1X
Relative Market Share
Ma
rketGrowthRate(in%)
0
LO
15
HIGH
30
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
69/127
69
Analysis of BCG matrix:
In the above matrix, BSNL falls in the quadrant of QUESTION MARK with respect to the
market LEADER. The circle size represents the absolute market share (i.e. 19%) of BSNL in the
telecom sector.
10X 1X 0.6X 0.1X
Relative Market Share
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
70/127
70
GE Matrix
The GE matrixfor Idea Cellular will be made keeping the following two major dimensions:
1. Market Attractiveness
2. Business Strength
Market Attractiveness: This dimension forms the Vertical axis of the GE matrix. The factors
which we have considered which may affect the industry attractiveness for our SBU are:
1. Overall Market Size: IDEA operates in an industry which has overall revenue of Rs.
125 Billion and has a subscriber base of 261.07 million customers. Thus it has a huge
target audience and we need to give substantial weightage to this factor. We have given it
0.20 out of 1.0.
2. Market Growth Rate: The telecom industry is growing at 25%. As previously stated,
this can be considered as a moderately growing and having high growth opportunities
with the growth of Indian economy. But in the current recession scenario, we decided to
give it a little less weightage of 0.15 out of 1.0.
Market Attractiveness Weightage Rating(1-5) Weighted Score
Overall Market Size 0.20 4 0.8
Market Growth Rate 0.15 4 0.6
Profitability 0.10 3 0.3
Technological
Development 0.15 4 0.6
Global Opportunities0.05 5 0.25
Market Rivalry0.20 5 1.0
Pricing 0.15 3 0.6
Total 1.00 4.05
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
71/127
71
3. Profitability: Telecom industry net profits just increased from 12% to 14% from the last
fiscal year. Due to no such significant increase in profitability as compared to sales, we
have given it a weightage of 0.10 out of 1.0.
4. Technological Development: With new technologies like 3G knocking at the doors of
Indian telecom sectors, technological development will be an important factor to be
considered in the business policies towards our chosen SBU. Hence a weight of 0.15.
5. Global Opportunities: Bharti has started making forays into global markets. With the
expected entry of many foreign players in the near future, this can open the door for
global opportunities for Indian players. Hence the weightage of 0.10.
6. Market Rivalry: Indian telecom sector is an Oligopoly where 80% of the market share is
picked by only 4 players. Also the future guarantees the entrance of several big global
names in this sector. Hence clearly market rivalry weighs above others at 0.20 out of 1.0.
7. Pricing: Being an Oligopoly, pricing strategies are a key for any player to make profits in
such a competitive sector. Thus we have given it equal weightage as technology and
more than even factors like profitability and growth rate.
Factors considered for Market Attractiveness
The rating is done on a scale of 1-5 where the industry attractiveness is rated associated with the
industry as a whole. Here 1 represents very unattractive and 5 represents very attractive. We can
see the difference in weightage and type of rating varying in the different factors. The market
growth rate can have a low weightage as compared to market size but has the same rating
because growth rate is attractive for the players in the market. Also pricing may have much more
weightage as compared to global opportunities but the ratings are the other way round. This is
for the reason that pricing strategies are not that attractive to the company because of strong
competition and regulations whereas global opportunities are more attractive for the industry.
Based on the above assumptions substantiated by the industry facts and growth avenues, the
weighted total score for market attractiveness in case of Idea Cellular comes to be 4.05.
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
72/127
72
Business Strength:
1. Market Share: The market share of Idea Cellular is 12%. Well it just acquired Spice
Communications and is among the top 4 players in GSM sector. But being a market
follower its primary motive is profitability. Thus we gave less weight to market share.
2. Market Growth Rate: Idea being a small player has ample of scope to grow but its
growth rate puts little effect to market rate as compared to other players. So it has again
been given weightage of 0.10.
3. Profit margin relative to competitors: This is the most important aspect of Ideas
competitiveness. IDEAs profit margin increased about 4 percent from 2006-07(11%) to
current profit margin (15%) that is 2007-08. This is an area where it would like to have a
competitive edge.
4. Technological Innovation: Idea was the first telecom operator to launch GPRS and
EDGE technology. We have given high weightage to support its innovational outlook.
Recently it formed a alliance with high tech computers(HTC). It also launched and
secured a position of leader in value added services like cellular jockey, background
tones, and group talk.
5. Brand Reputation: IDEA already has a backbone Aditya Birla group which has
already established as a global and truthful image. Being a part of Aditya Birla Group, it
has to carry a brand name. But now its strategy would be more of brand building than
brand reputation. So we have given a low weight.
6. Sales Distribution Effectiveness: The breadth of the distribution network has grown by
over 30% in the past year. In addition to this the company is operating additional 589
Idea n U and showrooms which supplement the distribution channels and provide
customer service.
7. Advertising and Promotional Effectiveness:Idea went for aggressive promotional
techniques such as having Abhishek Bachhan as the Brand Ambassador. The tag line
What An Idea was very successful proving the effectiveness of the advertising and
promotional activities carried by Idea.
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
73/127
73
8. Pricing strategies and Customer Loyalty:By adopting different pricing strategy it
discriminates among its customers. For example it has different pricing strategies for
postpaid subscribers and prepaid subscribers.
Key Competitive
FactorsWeight Rating(1-5) Weighted Score
Market Share 0.10 4 0.4
Market Growth Rate 0.10 4 0.4
Profit Margin relative
to competitors0.15 5 0.75
Technological
Innovation0.15 4 0.6
Brand Reputation0.10 4 0.4
Sales Distribution
Effectiveness 0.10 3 0.3
Advertising and
Promotional
Effectiveness0.15 4 0.6
Pricing strategies0.05 4 0.2
Customer Loyalty 0.10 3 0.3
Total= 3.95
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
74/127
74
LOW
MEDIUM
5
3.66
2.33
1
5 3.66 2.33 1
19%
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
75/127
75
he factor for Industry attractiveness will remain same for market leader as well. Bur the
competitive strength will differ and so the weights and ratings. It is evident from our above
assumptions about Airtel that they will lesser rating to profit margins and more towards
advertising and promotional effectiveness and brand reputation. The GE matrix of Airtel will
look like as under:-
5
3.66
2.33
15 3.66 2.33 1
31%
-
8/13/2019 newmicrosoftofficeworddocument6-101108042419-phpapp01
76/127
76
The GE matrix for Airtel indicates that it lies in the 1stquadrant corresponding to high market
attractiveness and strong competitive strength.
GE Matrix for Vodafone
The market challenger Vodafone will again have the same Market Attractiveness dimension as
the other players but will have an entirely different competitive strength dimension. Assuming
Vodafones company objectives to be more focused on building a customer loyalty, we assign it
a weight of 0.15. Also its sales and distribution effectiveness is much lesser than Airtel or Idea,
so give a weight of 0