new voices: an evaluation of 15 access radio projects' by anthony everitt
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
1/89
IE[ WOA@EPLI EWLCUL AOI OG
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
2/89
LI^MOIQ EWERA^^ ap l {ra~er# ~el`mer lin `uc~urlc
`oipuc~li~) Me ap Wapa~aik Vrogeppor og Wapulc lin Vergordaik
Lr~p l~ Io~~aikmld rei~ Uiawerpa~q) Map vubca`l~aoip ai`cune
Hoaiaik Ai# li aiwep~akl~aoi ai~o vlr~a`avl~orq dupa` ai ~me
Uia~en Jaiknod lin me Kowerili`e og @uc~ure# l p~unq og
ai~ekrl~en uc~urlc vcliiaik lin voca`aep oddappaoien bq
~me @oui`ac og Eurove) Me lnwapep lr~p oui`acp lin
daiap~raep og uc~ure oi `uc~urlc vcliiaik lin dlilkedei~)
Me mlp {ra~~ei l cage og @a`ero lin ap {orjaik oi lbaokrlvmq og ~me edveror Lukup~up) Me {lp Pe`re~lrq$
Keierlc og ~me Lr~p @oui`ac og Krel~ Bra~lai)
GORE[ORN 2
VREGL@E 0
E]E@U AWE PUDDLRQ 5
< AI^RONU@ AOI 1
2 [ML AP L@@EPP RLNAO? 20
0 ^ME GAG^EEI VROHE@^P 21
> VRODAPEP OG NECAWERQ >1
5 OU^@ODEP ;1
7 REKUCL ORQ APPUEP =5
; @OI@CUPAOI LIN RE@ODDEINL AOIP 10
LVVEINA@EP 1;
^me Gouinl~aoip UJ Brli`m
kawep krli~p l`ropp gour
vrokrlddep lr~p# enu`l~aoi#
po`alc {ecglre lin Likco$
Vor~ukuepe uc~urlc recl~aoip
~o mlra~lbce orkliapl~aoip ai
~me UJ lin Areclin# lin mlp l
revu~l~aoi gor re`okiapaik lin
aia~al~aik aiiowl~awe anelp)
1= VOR^CLIN VCL@E
COINOI [
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
3/89
GORE[ORN 2
VREGL@E 0
E]E@U AWE PUDDLRQ >
< AI^RONU@ AOI VRODAPEP OG NECAWERQ 5>
5 OU^@ODEP
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
4/89
2 0
^map revor~ ap dq ewlcul~aoi og ~me Rlnao
Lu~mora~qp L``epp Rlnao vaco~ p`mede) [mace
io~aik ai @mlv~er 7 ~me ieen gor coik$~erd#
duc~a$qelr repelr`m ai~o ~me advl`~ og L``epp
Rlnao oi co`lc `odduia~aep# A mlwe gouin dore
~mli eioukm ewanei`e og a~p `lvl`a~q ~o l~~rl`~
iuderoup wocui~eerp# og~ei grod naplnwli~lken
bl`jkrouinp# lin ~rlai ~med ai broln`lp~aik
lin o~mer ~rlipgerlbce pjaccp lin mlwe beei
glwourlbcq advreppen bq ~me l`~awe eiklkedei~
{a~m L``epp Rlnao og dliq jainp og co`lc
aip~a~u~aoi lin lkei`q) A move ~ml~ dq
`oi`cupaoip {acc ei`ourlke ~me koweridei~ ~o
vurpue a~p vcli ~o ai~ronu`e L``epp Rlnao lp
l verdliei~ lnna~aoi ~o ~me rlnao p`eie) Ai dq
hunkedei~# a~ vrodapep ~o be ~me dop~ advor~li~
`uc~urlc newecovdei~ ~o ~lje vcl`e ai ~map `oui~rq
gor dliq qelrp)
A {oucn caje ~o ~mlij lcc ~mope {mo mlwe
gl`aca~l~en dq {orj) ^meq ai`cune# garp~ lin
goredop~# ~me L``epp Rlnao vrohe`~p ~medpecwep#
{mope dedberp mlwe beei e}~rlornailracq
`o$overl~awe lin ~ocerli~ og dq nedlinp) A ld
krl~eguc ~oo ~o ^oiq P~occer# ~me Rlnao Lu~mora~qp
@maeg E}e`u~awe# lin map `occelkuep gor ~mear
uip~ai~aik puvvor~: A o{e l pve`alc neb~ ~o
Poo [accaldp# dq lppanuoup ogga`alc voai~ og
`oi~l`~ {a~m ~me Lu~mora~q) me L``epp Rlnao
P~eeraik Krouv# {ma`m Dlrj Lnlar `mlaren ui~ac
Pev~edber 2662 lin ^modlp Vrlk ~merelg~er#
mlp vrowanen {ape lin lu~mora~l~awe kuanli`e)
O~merp {mo mlwe vrowanen upeguc aigordl~aoi
lin lnwa`e ai`cune P~ewe Bu`jceq lin Ia`jq
Endoinp og ~me @odduia~q Denal Lppo`al~aoi:
Clurae Mlcce~~: lin Cald D`@lr~mq og BB@ Rlnao
Cea`ep~er# {mo ai~erwae{en de nuraik map
repelr`m ai~o L``epp Rlnao gor ~me BB@)
^me Rlnao Lu~mora~q ap krl~eguc ~o ~me @lcoup~e
Kucbeijali Gouinl~aoi gor a~p gaili`alc puvvor~)
^me Rlnao Lu~mora~q dlne `celr ~ml~ a~ e}ve`~en
de ~o l`~ aineveinei~cq og a~ li aihui`~aoi A
mlwe beei mlvvq ~o obeq) A lcoie ld repvoipabce
gor ~me ovaiaoip e}vreppen lin re`oddeinl~aoip
vrovopen ai ~me vlkep ~ml~ gocco{)
Li~moiq Ewera~~
[aweimoe
Hliulrq 2660
Rlnao mlp dliq einuraik ~lcei~p) Goredop~
ldoik ~mope ap a~p lbaca~q ~o re$aiwei~ a~pecg ai
ewerq lke# repvoinaik ~o {ml~ewer ie{ denal
or ~e`mia`lc `mlcceikep lrape# {macp~ p~acc
redlaiaik og ~me makmep~ recewli`e ~o cap~eierp
lin ~o po`ae~q lp l {moce) ^me vrepei~ lke ap
io e}`ev~aoi) Rlnao ap oi`e lklai rapaik ~o
~me ~e`mia`lc `mlcceikep vrepei~en bq ~me ie{
denal ai l repvoipe {ma`m mlrieppep naka~lc
rlnao lin ~me ai~erie~) L~ l po`alc cewec# nepva~e
~me `oipocanl~aoi og ~me ~rlna~aoilc rlnao ainup~rq#
ie{ `mlcceikaik gordp lre lrapaik ~o ogger li
aiiowl~awe# deliaikguc# lin l~ ~adep `rena~lbcq
pubwerpawe# repvoipe ~o ie{ nare`~aoip ai
our odduia~aep)
Ower ~me vlp~ noxei qelrp# ~me Rlnao Lu~mora~q
mlp gl`aca~l~en ~map ie{ po`alc recewli`e bq
ca`eipaik pdlcc$p`lce odder`alc rlnao p~l~aoip#
appuaik pmor~$~erd ca`ei`ep gor ~ralc perwa`ep lin
ewei~p# lin pubp~li~alccq e}vlinaik coiker$~erd
pve`alc ca`ei`ep gor ainawanulc aip~a~u~aoip) Bu~ ai
2666# {a~m ~me cajecamoon og ie{ @odduia`l~aoip
cekapcl~aoi# {e {ere peaxen {a~m ~me wapaoi ~ml~
dore `oucn be noie)
Buacnaik uvoi ~me e}veraei`e lin ei~mupalpd
og keiuaiecq co`lc `odder`alc rlnao# lin ~me
`odduia~q denal pe`~or# lin ewanei`e grod
o~mer `oui~raep# lin ai ~me l{lreiepp ~ml~ ~map
dakm~ be ~me `ru`alc ~ade ~o aiiowl~e# {e
vrovopen ~ml~ Koweridei~ pmoucn dlje
voppabce l ie{ ~marn ~aer og rlnao ai ~me UJ)
^map {oucn vrowane po`alc rlnao gor pve`aga`
`odduia~aep# dop~cq keokrlvma`lccq negaien#
oi l ioi vroga~$nap~rabu~aik blpap) A~ {oucn buacn
oi ~me l`maewedei~p og pmor~$~erd ca`ei`ep
ai ke~~aik ornailrq veovce aiwocwen ai clrke
iudberp ai dljaik rlnao# bq oggeraik li ei~are
ie{ pe`~or {a~mai ~me denaud {mere l``epp
{oucn be ~merlapoi n~re) ^mup ~me pouin
broln`lp~aik pve`~rud {oucn be nevcoqen
gor pve`aga` po`alc klai# epve`alccq ai lrelp og
vlr~a`uclr nevrawl~aoi {me~mer e`oioda`# e~mia`#
`uc~urlc or po`alc)
^o ~ep~ ~me wlcana~q og ~ml~ wapaoi# {e verpulnen
Koweridei~ ~o lcco{ up ~o ca`eipe l bl~`m og
e}veradei~lc p~l~aoip oi l vaco~ blpap) ^o eipure
~ml~ ~me vaco~ `oucn be vrovercq lppeppen# lin
{a~m ~me e}~eipawe mecv# puvvor~ lin
ei`ourlkedei~ og ~me Kucbeijali Gouinl~aoi#
{e `oddappaoien Vrogeppor Li~moiq Ewera~~ ~o
uiner~lje li aineveinei~ ewlcul~aoi# l~ lrdp
ceik~m grod ~me Lu~mora~q lin grod Koweridei~)
^map ap map revor~)
Li~moiq Ewera~~ mlp vcuiken ai~o L``epp Rlnao
{a~m eierkq# ei~mupalpd# jeei ver`ev~aoi lin
{ape hunkedei~) Oi bemlcg og ~me Rlnao
Lu~mora~q# A ~mlij mad {lrdcq gor beaik our
Ewlcul~or) Vlr~a`uclr ~mlijp lre nue ~o ~me
Kucbeijali Gouinl~aoi gor puvvor~aik lin
kuanaik ~map {orj# lin lcpo ~o lcc ~mope {mo mlwe
beei po keieroup {a~m ~mear ~ade lin wae{p)
Cekapcl~awe vrowapaoi gor L``epp Rlnao# lin gor
l Guin ~o puvvor~ a~p ai~ronu`~aoi# io{ p~linp
voapen ~o be eil`~en {a~mai ~me @odduia`l~aoip
Bacc) [e move ~ml~ ~map revor~ {acc mecv ~me ie{
rekucl~or# Og`od# ~o uinerp~lin mo{ ~o dlje
~me dop~ og ~me p~uiiaik ovvor~uia~q {ma`m io{
vrepei~p a~pecg)
^oiq P~occer
@maeg E}e`u~awe
^me Rlnao Lu~mora~q
Dlr`m 2660
VREGL@EGORE[ORN
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
5/89
> 5
^ME L@@EPP RLNAO
E]VERADEI^
Ai 266< ~me Rlnao Lu~mora~q clui`men li
e}veradei~ ai~o L``epp Rlnao# nepakien ~o ~ep~
~me pup~lailbaca~q og l pevlrl~e ~aer og pdlcc$p`lce
`odduia~q rlnao perwa`ep) Gag~eei io~$gor$vroga~
vrohe`~p# ladaik ~o necawer po`alc klai ~o pve`aga`
ieakmbourmoonp or odduia~aep og ai~erep~# {ere
oggeren oie$qelr ca`ei`ep) Li Ewlcul~aoi {lp
`oddappaoien ~o lppepp ~me e}~ei~ ~o {ma`m
vrohe`~p necaweren vrodapen beiega~p lin
aiwocwen co`lc vlr~a`avl~aoi: ~o e}ldaie `op~p
lin guinaik donecp: ~o ~ep~ ~mear advl`~ oi ~me
co`lc rlnao e`ocokaep: ~o vrowane l naggerei~alc
lilcqpap og LD lin GD broln`lp~aik: ~o vrovope
li lvvrovral~e ca`eipaik rekade gor L``epp
Rlnao: lin ~o lppepp ~me e}veradei~p caikuap~a`
advl`~ po glr lp ~mope ~ljaik vlr~ ai ~me vrohe`~p
{ere oi`erien)
^me Ewlcul~aoi de~monocokq mlp beei blpen
oi `oipuc~l~aoi {a~m ~me L``epp Rlnao vrohe`~p#
{ma`m pe~ newecovdei~ ~lrke~p begore koaik oi
lar lin mlwe io{ delpuren ~mear ou~`odep) Li
ai~erad revor~ {lp vronu`en ai Pev~edber 2662)
MAP^ORQ OG
@ODDUIA Q RLNAO
^me newecovdei~ og `odduia~q rlnao ai ~me
Uia~en Jaiknod `li be ~rl`en bl`j ~o ~me
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
6/89
7 ;
l``epp ~o ~me vrohe`~ bq co`lc veovce lin a~p
|ulca~l~awe ~lrke~p gor caikuap~a` advl`~ lre re`ornen)
^mepe ~lrke~p lre l``odvliaen bq revor~en
ou~`odep# {ma`m ai dliq `lpep e}`een
vrohe`~p orakailc ai~ei~aoip) ^me vaco~ p`mede
pmo{p ~ml~ L``epp Rlnao {acc vrowane l wlculbce
`odvcedei~ ~o e}ap~aik vrowapaoi)
EIROCCAIK ^ME @ODDUIA Q
^me L``epp Rlnao vrohe`~p mlwe re`rua~en dliq
muinrenp og wocui~eerp lin vrowanen ~rlaiaik gor
dop~ og ~med ai rlnao lin A@^ pjaccp) ^map
`lvl`a~q ~o l~~rl`~ vlr~a`avl~aoi bq dedberp
og co`lc `odduia~aep dljep L``epp Rlnao
l~~rl`~awe ~o rekeierl~aoi lin newecovdei~
lkei`aep) ^mere mlp beei l kro{aik ~ einei`q
~o{lrnp ainawanulc ~rlaiaik or dei~oraik)
[orj e}veraei`e ~lrke~p mlwe og~ei io~ beei
de~ be`lupe og aipugga`aei~ e}veraei`en
verpoiiec l~ ~me vrohe`~p)
Vubca` pe`~or lkei`aep lin wocui~lrq pe`~or
orkliapl~aoip lre ei~mupalp~a` lbou~ L``epp
Rlnaop vo{er ~o `odduia`l~e aigordl~aoi ~o
co`lc `odduia~aep lin lre `o$overl~aik {a~m ~me
vaco~ vrohe`~p) Pode e}`eccei~ rlnao ~rlaiaik lin
vrokrlddaik mlwe beei vronu`en {a~m p`moocp
lin `occekep)
CAIKUAP A@ ADVL@^
Clrke iudberp og veovce lre napedvo{eren
lin napmelr~eien bq li ailbaca~q ~o upe {ornp
gcuei~cq lin oiganei~cq) Dliq clikulkep#
epve`alccq grod ~me Dannce Elp~ lin ~me Lpali
pub$`oi~aiei~# {ma`m lre pecnod melrn oi rlnao
ai ~me Uia~en Jaiknod# mlwe beei l``ornen
pubp~li~alc lar$~ade)
L p~unq og pece`~en re`ornaikp og broln`lp~
ou~vu~ lin revor~p bq p~l~aoi dlilkerp pukkep~
~ml~ wocui~eerp {a~m co{ pecg$ep~eed lin enu`l~aoilc
l~~laidei~p mlwe vroga~en grod ~rlaiaik ai rlnao
pjaccp lin ~me e}veraei`e og broln`lp~aik) ^meq
mlwe og~ei beei lbce ~o ~rlipger {ml~ ~meq mlwe
celrien ~o relc$cage pa~ul~aoip ai ~me gord og
krel~er e}vreppawe lpper~aweiepp)
Dop~ og ~me vrohe`~p dlje l voai~ og
ei`ourlkaik vrepei~erp ~o regce`~ co`lc vl~~erip
og pvee`m lin nalce`~p lin ~o lwoan ~me
p~ereo~qvep og oiwei~aoilc broln`lp~aik)
P^LGGAIK IEENP
^me mudli repour`ep re|uaren ~o rui li L``epp
Rlnao perwa`e {ere uiner$ep~adl~en bq dliq
og ~me vaco~ vrohe`~p# epve`alccq ai guin$rlapaik
-{me~mer ai ~me gord og krli~p or lnwer~apaik
plcep!# e}~erilc calapoi {a~m co`lc krouvp#
gaili`alc lin keierlc lndaiap~rl~aoi lin
dlilkedei~ lin ~rlaiaik og wocui~eerp) Dop~
og ~me vaco~ vrohe`~p nan io~ mlwe ~me doieq
~o vlq gor lcc ~mepe pjaccp)
GAILI@ALC RE\UAREDEI^P
^me gaili`alc vergordli`e og ~me vaco~ vrohe`~p
wlraep {anecq -{a~m l ge{ og ~med ai pode
nagga`uc~q!) A~ nedoip~rl~ep l gaili`alc ieen gor
vrohe`~p {a~m io vlan p~lgg og lbou~ 56#666
ver liiud lin gor ~mope {a~m l plclraep bacc
og be~{eei 6#666 lin 2
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
7/89
= 1
^me oip~a~u~aoilc lrrlikedei~p gor L``epp
Rlnao p~l~aoip pmoucn regce`~ l odda~dei~ ~o
~rlipvlrei`q# `odduia~q edvo{erdei~ lin
repvoipaweiepp ~o co`lc nedlin) me |uep~aoi og
o{ierpmav lin a~p voppabce ~rlipger pmoucn be
`lreguccq oi~roccen) L``epp Rlnao ca`ei`ep
pmoucn clp~ gor gawe qelrp)
@OI@CUPAOI LIN
RE@ODDEINL AOIP
^me dlhor `oi`cupaoi og ~me Ewlcul~aoi ap ~ml~
L``epp Rlnao vrodapep ~o be l vopa~awe
`uc~urlc lin po`alc newecovdei~ lin pmoucn
be ai~ronu`en lp l ~marn ~aer og rlnao
broln`lp~aik ai ~me Uia~en Jaiknod)
A~ ap gur~mer re`oddeinen ~ml~
lin 5)5!
2) Og`od pmoucn pl~apgq a~pecg ~ml~# ai ~me
`lpe og l vlr~ierpmav$blpen L``epp
Rlnao lvvca`li~# ne`apaoi$dljaik
vro`eppep lre `celrcq negaien# ~rlipvlrei~
lin robup~ -@mlv~er 5)7!
0) li L` epp Rlnao p~l~aoi pmoucn iordlccq
be verda~~en ~o re`eawe uv ~o mlcg a~p
ai`ode grod lnwer~apaik plcep lin
pvoiporpmav) Ai e}`ev~aoilc `lpep# Og`od
pmoucn be edvo{eren ~o wlrq ~map ruce ai
~me ewei~ og l pve`alc `lpe beaik dlne
-@mlv~er 5);!
>) {mere l pdlcc `odder alc rlnao p~l~aoi
pmlrep l `odvlrlbce `owerlke lrel {a~m
li L``epp Rlnao p~l~aoi ~ml~ peccp
lnwer~apaik# li L``epp Rlnao ca`ei`e
`oucn be oggeren oicq ag ~me lvvca`li~ `li
pmo{ ~ml~ a~ {acc vrepei~ ca~~ce or io
lnwer~apaik plcep lin pvoiporpmav
`odve~a~aoi -@mlv~er 5);!
5) L``epp Rlnao ca`ei ep pmoucn upulccq io~
be krli~en ai lrelp {mere l `odder`alc
rlnao p~l~aoip delpuren `owerlke lrel
-D@L! glccp beco{ >6#666 lnuc~p -e}`ev~ ai
~me `lpe og da`ro D@Lp!) Mo{ewer# l~ ~me
~ade og ACR ca`ei`e reie{lc# `odder`alc
lin L``epp Rlnao lvvca`li~p pmoucn be
lcco{en ~o `odve~e ai pu`m li lrel lin
Og`od pmoucn ea~mer l{lrn l `odder`alc
or li L``epp Rlnao ca`ei`e -@mlv~er 5);!
7) ^me BB@ pmoucn ~lje li elrcq ovvor~uia~q
~o pe~ ou~ `oipuc~l~awe vrovoplcp gor
`occlborl~aoi {a~m# lin puvvor~ gor#
L``epp Rlnao -@mlv~er 5)=!
;) Og`od pmoucn oinu ~ repelr`m ai~o
owerlcc GD `lvl`a~q l`ropp ~me ei~are
pve`~rud lin# ai ~me cakm~ og a~p gainaikp#
ne~erdaie lcco`l~aoip gor L``epp Rlnao
vrowapaoi -@mlv~er 5)1!
=) Og`od pmoucn ne~erdaie {me~mer
pve`~rud vrepei~cq lndaiap~eren bq ~me
BB@ `oucn be dlne lwlaclbce gor L``epp
Rlnao -@mlv~er 5)1!
1) Og`od pmoucn oddappaoi l dlhor
repelr`m vrohe`~ {a~m l wae{ ~o lppeppaik
ower l veraon og qelrp ~me po`alc lin
verpoilc ou~`odep# bo~m |uli~a~l~awe lin
|ulca~l~awe# og L``epp Rlnao -@mlv~er
5)
Denal Guin pmoucn be lcco{lbce ai ~me
ie{ `odduia`l~aoip cekapcl~aoi lg~er
ewlcul~aoi og ~me egge`~aweiepp og ~me
L``epp Rlnao Guin -@mlv~er 7)
be `odvce~en bq li L``epp Rlnao
p~l~aoi lvvca`li~ lp l ca`ei`e
pubdappaoi lin l vrodape og necawerq
li liiulc vubcapmen revor~ bq ~me
p~l~aoi og l`maewen ou~vu~p lin ou~`odep
~{o ovei gl`aca~l~en {orjpmovp og co`lc
p~ljemocnerp lin repanei~p# oi`e mlcg$
{lq ~mroukm ~me ca`ei`e veraon lin
oi`e ai ~me clp~ qelr og ~me ca`ei`e# ~o
be `oiweien bq ~me p~l~aoi# {ma`m
{oucn `oddei~ oi ~me p~l~aoip
vrokrepp lklaip~ a~p vcli
~me rekucl~or oicq ~o ai~erweie oi
`odvclai~ -lp io{!# reklrnaik peraoup
glacurep ~o dee~ ~lrke~p lin oi
uipl~apgl`~orq ou~`odep og ~me dan$~erd
ovei dee~aik8 ~me ein og ca`ei`e o vei
dee~aik ~o be ~ljei ai~o l``oui~ ai ~me
ewei~ og l re$lvvca`l~aoi -@mlv~er 7)2!
) Og`od pmoucn io~ l{lrn ca`ei`ep {a~m
clrke `owerlke lrelp) Lp {lp ~me iord
gor ~me vaco~ p`mede# D@Lp pmoucn
upulccq be uv ~o l 5jd rlnaup)
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
8/89
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
9/89
~med ~o necawer# gocco{aik ~me p~ru`~ure og l blpa`
vcliiaik ilrrl~awe8 ildecq#
wapaoi ~me vrohe`~p owerlcc lad
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
10/89
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
11/89
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
12/89
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
13/89
26 2 25
lvvca`l~aoip mln beei re`eawen ai Pev~edber#
~me Rlnao Lu~mora~q klwe io~a`e ~o ~me BB@ grod
{mod a~ {oucn be peejaik pode pvl`e oi a~p
gre|uei`aep lin ~me Rlnao`odduia`l~aoip
Lkei`q -RL!# ~me bonq ai `mlrke og gre|uei`q
lcco`l~aoip# ~ml~ a~ {oucn be lvvrol`maik ~med
gor gre|uei`q celrli`ep)
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
16/89
2)6[ML AP L@@EPP RLNAO?
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
17/89
2=
^map `mlv~er negaiep `odduia~q rlnao lin pe~p
ou~ ~me relpoip {mq ~me Rlnao Lu~mora~q
lnov~en ~me ~erd# L``epp Rlnao) A~ nap`uppep
naggerei~ io~aoip og `odduia~q ai recl~aoi ~o
L``epp Rlnao lin io~ep ~me rlvancq `mlikaik
~e`miocoka`lc eiwaroidei~)
[ML AP L@@EPP RLNAO?2)6
21
L \UEP AOI OG ERDAIOCOKQ
2)< ^me ~a~ce L``epp Rlnao rlapep pode
l{j{lrn |uep~aoip og deliaik) Ap a~ ~me plde
lp `odduia~q rlnao# l ~erd ~ml~ mlp coik beei
ai upe? Lin ag po# {mq ~me revcl`edei~? Dore
brolncq# ap ~mere keierlc lkreedei~ lbou~ {ml~
~me {orn `odduia~q pakiagaep?
2)2 L rewae{ og ai~eril~aoilc negaia~aoip og
`odduia~q rlnao pukkep~p l `oipeipup oi a~p
`oip~a~uei~ ecedei~p) Gor e}ldvce# ~me @lilnali
Rlnao$^ecewapaoi lin ^ece`odduia`l~aoip
@oddappaoi p~l~ep8 L `odduia~q rlnao p~l~aoi
ap o{ien lin `oi~roccen bq l io~$gor$vroga~
orkliapl~aoi# ~me p~ru`~ure og {ma`m vrowanep
gor dedberpmav# dlilkedei~# overl~aoi lin
vrokrlddaik vradlracq bq dedberp og ~me
`odduia~q l~ clrke) Vrokrlddaik pmoucn regce`~
~me nawerpa~q og ~me dlrje~ ~ml~ ~me p~l~aoi ap ~o
perwe)5 ^me Broln`lp~aik @oddappaoi og Areclin
-gordercq Aineveinei~ Rlnao lin ecewapaoi
@oddappaoi! lvvcaep l werq padaclr negaia~aoi#
lp noep ~me Broln`lp~aik Perwa`ep L`~ ai glwour og `odduia~q rlnao l~ ~me Gebrulrq
266< L``epp Rlnao Pedailr# plan8 Acc ~ecc qou
{ml~ A ~maij L``epp Rlnao ap) A ~maij a~p l ~a~ce
nrelden uv bq podeoie {mo mlpi~ ~me garp~
anel og mo{ rlnao p~l~aoip# liq rlnao p~l~aoi#
overl~e) Podeoie {mo noepi~ caje ~me ~erd
`odduia~q rlnao)7 ^me pupva`aoi ai pode
|ulr~erp ap vrepudlbcq ~ml~ ~me Rlnao Lu~mora~q
{apmep ~o plia~ape l voppabce ~marn rlnao ~aer grod
~me coik$p~linaik voca~a`lc lin `ldvlakiaik
lppo`al~aoip l~~rabu~en ~o `odduia~q lin# ai
o~merp# ~ml~ a~ peejp l vre`apaoi ~ml~ {acc e}`cune
l brolner io~aoi og rlnaop `oi~rabu~aoi ~o
`odduia~q cage)
2)5 A~ ap gur~mer obhe`~en ~ml~ l``epp rlnao
ap lcrelnq l ~erd og lr~# pakiagqaik l p~l~aoi {a~m
l pmlre$pvl`e voca`q: ildecq# oie ~ml~ oggerp
pco~p ~o ou~pane krouvp rl~mer ~mli vronu`ep
vrokrlddep a~pecg)
2)7 ^mepe `ra~a`apdp dakm~ be ne`apawe
{ere ~me `oipeipup lbou~ ~me deliaik og
`odduia~q rlnao {l~er~akm~) ^map ~urip
ou~ io~ ~o be ~me `lpe) Lcpo pveljaik l~ ~me
L``epp Rlnao Pedailr# Vmac Raceq k lwe
@mrqplcap Rlnaop negaia~aoi og ~me ~erd8 a~ {lp
rlnao {mope ou~vu~ vrowanep l perwa`e uia|uecq
~lacoren gor l vlr~a`uclr lunaei`e {a~mai l paikce
keokrlvma`lc `odduia~q lin {mope vurvope
ap ~meregore ~o dee~ ~me aigordl~aoi lin
ei~er~laidei~ ieenp og ~ml~ `odduia~q);
^me edvmlpap mere ap oi vrowapaoi rl~mer
vlr~a`avl~aoi lin dliq `odder`alc rlnaop~l~aoip {oucn rakm~cq `clad ~o overl~e l
`odduia~q rlnao voca`q ai ~map peipe)
5 @a~en ai Vra`e$Nlwaep# Erqc# lin l``ma# Ho# @odduia~q Rlnao ai l Kcoblc @oi~e}~8 L @odvlrl~awe Lilcqpap ai Pa}
@oui~raep# @odduia~q Denal Lppo`al~aoi# 266
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
18/89
06 06 > mourp l nlq)
@ODDUIA AEP OG AI^EREP^
JANP
0)
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
24/89
>2 >0
0)02 @ropp Rmq~mdp re`eawe vrl`~a`lc
puvvor~ grod Plc~bo}# li ai~erneiodail~aoilc
`mlra~q {ma`m vrodo~ep @mrap~ali ewei~p ai
Ior~m P~lggornpmare) Plc~bo} {ec`odep ~me
L``epp Rlnao vrohe`~ oi ~me krouinp ~ml~ a~ {acc
kawe lnnen oiganei`e ~o ~me mur`m odduia~q#
ogger vrl`~a`lc mecv ~o co`lc @mrap~ali krouvp lin
gop~er move lin `oiganei`e ai ~me `a~q og P~oje)
0)00 L~ ~me ou~pe~ og a~p ca`ei`e ~me vrohe`~
revor~en ~ml~ a~ re`eawen krel~ puvvor~ grod co`lc
`mur`mep# lc~moukm ~mere {lp l dacn ra~a`apd
grod pode ~rlna~aoilcap~p {mo gouin @ropp Rmq~mdp
dupa` voca`q ~oo qou~mguc) Pode lre mlrn$vreppen
gaili`alccq lin ai ~erdp og lwlaclbce ~ade lin
eierkq) Mo{ewer# l clrke lin kro{aik iudber
lre e}`a~en bq L``epp Rlnao lp l delip og ei~rq
ai~o ~me denal lin lre oggeraik a~ ~mear puvvor~)
^me L``epp Rlnao e}veradei~ ap lcpo l~~rl`~aik
{ane ai~erep~ grod @mrap~ali krouvp ai ~me EikcapmDanclinp lin vermlvp il~aoilccq) @ropp Rmq~mdp
becaewep ~ml~ ag L``epp Rlnao ederkep ai nue
`ourpe lp l ~marn rlnao ~aer ~ mere ap cajecq ~o be
`oipanerlbce nedlin ai~erep~ grod @mrap~ali
krouvp# lp regce`~en ai ~me L``epp Rlnao ce~~erp
og ai~ei~ ~o ~me Rlnao Lu~mora~q)
0)0> @ropp Rmq~mdp mlp {lrd recl~aoip {a~m
~me BB@ lin mlp l`|uaren Rlnao P~ojep gorder
vredapep# {ma`m a~ re`ei~cq wl`l~en gor ie{ p~unaop)
0)05 Vrokrlddaik ap vrenodaili~cq dupa`$
blpen -;6$=6% og ou~vu~!# bu~ lcpo lnnreppep
pu`m keierlc po`alc appuep lp `rade -{a~m aivu~grod ~me voca`e!# enu`l~aoi# melc~m lin
edvcoqdei~) A~ mlp poukm~ ~o no po ai li ewei$
mlinen {lq# ewei {a~m pubhe`~p {mere a~ mocnp
p~roik wae{p gor e}ldvce# modope}ulca~q)
^me vrohe`~ ai`relpaikcq peep a~pecg lp oggeraik
l `odduia~q og vcl`e perwa`e grod l
`odduia~q og ai~erep~ verpve`~awe) A~ kawep
ne~lacen `owerlke og ~me voca~a`lc p`eie lin
{oi co`lc vrlape gor cawe broln`lp~aik og ~me
co`lc `oui`ac lin dlqorlc ece`~aoip ai 2662)
0)07 Pmaie GD ap l vlr~ og Qou~m [a~m L
Dappaoi# li ai~erneiodail~aoilc {orcn${ane @mrap~ali
orkliapl~aoi {a~m brli`mep ai dore ~mli 266
`oui~raep# {ma`m oggerp ~rlaiaik ai ewlikecapd
lin verpoilc recl~aoipmav {a~m ~me Corn) Mo{ewer#
~me vrohe`~ ap coojaik l~ ep~lbcapmaik a~pecg lp l
pevlrl~e ceklc ei~a~q ~o kawe ~me co`lc `odduia~q
l krel~er peipe og o{ierpmav) Nuraik ~me vcliiaik
vmlpe# a~p celnerp# Il~mli Lpaad{e lin Liidlrae
Lpaad{e# `oipuc~en {a~m ~me co`lc `mur`mep
Blv~ap~# Rodli @l~moca`# Vrepbq~erali lin
De~monap~ lp {ecc lp {a~m ~me nap~ra`~ oui`ac lin
l co`lc bupaieppdli {a~m e}veraei`e og odder`alc
rlnao) ^me voca`e puvvor~ Pmaie GD -l{lrnaik l
krli~ gor a~p pe`oin RPC! lin ~me vrohe`~ ap l
dedber og ~me Blibranke @odduia~q Ie~{orj)
0)0; Pmaie GD mlp rui ~{o RPCp# gor ~me
garp~ og {ma`m ~me Lpaad{ep vrowanen ~rlaiaik gor
lbou~ ~{ei~q wocui~eerp -{mo lre e}ve`~en ~olppei~ ~o ~me vrohe`~p @mrap~ali e~mop!) L cap~eier
purweq gor ~me garp~ RPC pukkep~en ~ml~ mlwe beei re`rua~en gor ~me
L``epp Rlnao p`mede# og {ma`m lbou~ gag~eei
gord l `ore {a~m vrewaoup RPC e}veraei`e)
0)0= Uc~adl~ecq# ~me Lpaad{ep {li~ ~o {ai
l coik$~erd ca`ei`e lin ~o ep~lbcapm Pmaie GDlp l verdliei~ rlnao p~l~aoi) Mo{ewer# gor ~me
L``epp Rlnao e}veradei~ ~meq ne`anen oicq ~o
broln`lp~ gor ~mree lin l mlcg doi~mp# koaik oi
lar ai Pev~edber 2662) Pmaie GDp dupa` oi~ei~
rlikep grod ~me Likec Rlnao broln`lp~p gor 2> mourp#
lu~odl~en l~ iakm~ -l p~l~aoi {orjer ap lc{lqp
lwlaclbce ~mroukmou~ ~me iakm~ ~o ~lje ~ecevmoie
`lccp grod coiecq or li}aoup cap~eierp!) Vrokrlddeplre vrenodaili~cq dupa`$blpen# bu~ ~mere lre
aigordl~aoilc p~rlinp lin ovvor~uia~aep gor
re`occe`~aoi: oie makmvoai~ {lp vrokrlddaik
gocco{aik ~me \ueei Do~merp nel~m) L iudber
og vrepei~erp mlwe p~unaop l~ mode# ea~mer ~mear
o{i or vrowanen bq Likec) ^mere mlp beei
vopa~awe geenbl`j ~o ~me vaco~ vrohe`~p @odduia~q
Go`up p~rlin og vrokrlddaik) ^me gocco{aik
|uo~l~aoi grod ~me vrohe`~p pubdappaoi oiweqp
a~p owerlcc gclwour8 ai a~p Re`ave @orier pco~# ~me
vrokrldde ~mede ~uie ap ~me werq# werq ocn
dupa` mlcc poik# Boacen Beeg lin @lrro~p bq
Mlrrq @mldvaoi) ^map aip~li~cq `rel~ep ~me
geecaik og koon ocn relc goon) ^me re`ave apreln pco{cq bq l do~mercq Arapm woa`e Garepane
@ml~p lre re`ornaikp og `oiwerpl~aoip {a~m
Likec Rlnao cap~eierp Zai~erpverpen {a~m recewli~
dupa`T) L Garepane @ml~ ~ljep ~me gord og l
kei~ce delineraik `ml~ lbou~ ~me cage og ~me
ai~erwae{ee) A~ keierlccq p~lr~p l~ bar~m lin einp
l~ ~me vrepei~ nlq) Garepane @ml~p `li clp~ gor
~{o mourp or lp ca~~ce lp gag~eei daiu~ep)
0)6 ^ME GAG^EEI VROHE@^P
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
25/89
>> >5
@UC^URLC NAWERPA Q
0)>5 Lpali `odduia~aep oi ~me Uia~en
Jaiknod geec ~medpecwep ~o be dlrkailcapen bq
dop~ og ~me dlaip~reld denal lin {ec`ode
~me ovvor~uia~q vrowanen bq L``epp Rlnao) [mace
Io~~aikmldp Rlnao Glxl -pee @mlv~er 0)72$77
gor dore aigordl~aoi! ap vradlracq `oi`erien ~o
vrodo~e# oi ~me oie mlin# edvo{erdei~ gor
Lpali {odei lin# oi ~me o~mer# `odduia~q
newecovdei~ {a~m li Apclda` e~mop# L{lx GD
peep a~pecg lp l du`m$ieenen `mliiec og
`odduia`l~aoi be~{eei Kclpko{p Lpali
`odduia~q lin ~me vubca` lin wocui~lrq pe`~orp)
0)>7 A~ {lp aia~alccq pe~ uv ai 6% og a~p ou~vu~ ap
ai Urnu# 06% ai Vlihlba lin ~me redlainer ai
Eikcapm) L iudber og Lpali krouvp ai ~me `a~q lre
ai~erep~en ai vrowanaik l rlnao perwa`e# lin L{lx
GD mlp poukm~ ~o `rel~e lccali`ep {a~m vo~ei~alc
or l`~ulc `odve~a~orp8 oie og ~mepe ap Rlnao
Plikee~# {ma`m mlp hoaien gor`ep {a~m L{lx GD
gor ~me L``epp Rlnao vrohe`~) [e geec ~ml~ ~me{lq gor{lrn ap {a~m lcc `oi`erien krouvp ai
Kclpko{ ~o {orj ~oke~mer lin Rlnao L{lx
ap ai nalcokue {a~m ~mepe krouvp)
0)>; Hlwen Pl~~lr ap repvoipabce gor
vrowanaik wocui~eerp {a~m vronu`~aoi lin
~e`mia`lc ~rlaiaik# lin Hlwlan Ucclm# l co`lc
bupaieppdli {mo mlp beei lppo`al~en {a~m
L{lx GD pai`e = Vrokrlddaik ai`cunep odduia~q
pmo{p# vrepei~en ea~mer bq li ai$moupe ~eld
or co`lc orkliapl~aoip# l Vlihlba dlklxaie
vrokrldde go`uppaik oi clikulke lin `uc~urlc
appuep# l vrokrldde gor {odei lin l pmo{
gel~uraik ei~er~laidei~ grod ~me vlp~) L{lx GD
vclqp dupa` grod ~me Ainali pub`oi~aiei~ lin
~me {orj og UJ Lpali dupa`alip: vrokrlddep
{acc ai`cune Boccq{oon `oi~edvorlrq# kmlxlcp#
Ill~p lin Bmlhlip# Vljap~li vov lin Bmlikrl)
0)>1 Nepa Rlnao mlp lr~a`ucl~en l `uc~urlc
lin caikuap~a` vmacopovmq {ma`m peejp ~o
re`oi`ace ~me naggerei~ pekdei~p og Vlihlbapo`ae~q lin ~o vcl`e a~p `uc~ure ai lvvrovral~e
blcli`e {a~m [ep~eri doneria~q)
0)56 ^me Vlihlba @ei~re {lp gorden ai
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
26/89
>7 >;
0)57 Bq `oi~rlp~# Repoili`e GD# {a~m l
p~unao ielr ^rlglcklr P|ulre ai Coinoi# l vrohe`~
og ~me Coinoi Dupa`alip @occe`~awe -CD@!# ap
io~ `oi`erien ~o lnnrepp naplnwli~lken
`odduia~aep ai ~me ornailrq peipe: rl~mer# a~p
lad ap ~o eilbce veovce ~o eiklke ai `uc~ureai ~me dop~ vrl`~a`lc lin pu``eppguc {lqp) A~p
`odduia~q odvrapep lr~ap~p# naplgge`~en ra~a`p
lin o~mer `uc~urlc {orjerp) Repoili`e ap li
lr~ap~$cen lin lr~ap~$orkliapen ai~erwei~aoi {ma`m
lr~a`ucl~ep CD@p uc~urlc nawerpa~q l`~aoi vcli)
0)5; ^me CD@ ap 27 qelrp ocn lin ap
lndaiap~eren bq En Bl}~er) A~ ap l ie~{orjaik
orkliapl~aoi nena`l~en ~o `oi~edvorlrq dupa`)
Gouinen lin nare`~en bq dupa`alip# a~ vrodo~ep
lin gl`aca~l~ep advrowapl~aoi lin o~mer lnwei~uroup
dupa`lc l`~awa~q ~mroukm oi`er~p# {orjpmovp#
vubca`l~aoip# a~p p~unao C@D Pouin# l doi~mcq
`lceinlr lin l {ebpa~e) A~p dupa`lc ai~erep~pmlwe ~mear roo~p ai gree hlxx lin# dore cl~ecq#
~me mlrn ece`~roia` ein og `oi~edvorlrq dupa`)
0)5= Repoili`e GD `oi`ei~rl~ep oi dupa`#
bu~ ai ~me {aner `oi~e}~ og rlnao lr~) L bro`mure
gor li RPC l~ Coinoip Pou~m Blij @ei~re
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
27/89
>= >1
0)7= ^mear `oddoi lad ap ~o vrowane l
vlr~a`avl~orq lin ai`cupawe rlnao perwa`e ~o
liqoie cawaik or {orjaik ai ~me Voi~qvrann lrel
-gor l~ celp~ ~mree mourp l {eej vrokrlddep
{acc be ai [ecpm!) ^me vlr~ierp mlwe werq naggerei~
`uc~urep ~me oie nerawaik grod ~me `oi`eripog {orjerp l~ ~me `odduia~q `ei~re lin ~me
o~mer e}vreppaik enu`l~aoilccq oraei~en e~mop)
^map ap regce`~en ai a~p vrokrlddaik) K^RL#
{ma`m broln`lp~p ai ~me nlq~ade# `oi`ei~rl~ep
oi `odduia~q ~medep {a~m li edvmlpap oi
dupa` grod ~me
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
28/89
56 5 vronu`er# lin ~{o
o~merp ai Rlnao Rekei ruip wlraoup o~mer
vrohe`~p) Lr~rlipda~ ap l vlr~a`avl~orq lr~p
p`mede {a~m rlnao ou~`odep -ewei~p mlwe
ai`cunen voe~rq ai do~aoi# l `odduia~q vclq
lin l @meriobqc nalrq vrohe`~ aiwocwaik qouik
veovce oi l wapa~ ~o Dli`mep~er grod @meriobqc!)A~p `urrei~ vrohe`~ ap ~o newecov l `odduia~q
polv ai el`m og a~p ~{o L``epp Rlnao vaco~
vrohe`~p) Ai Reda} ~me P~ree~p# ~me rlnao ~eld
lin l ne~l`men qou~m {orjer grod ~me qou~m
perwa`e {orj {a~m naplgge`~en qouik veovce oi
~me p~ree~ lin vronu`e rlnao ou~`odep) Rlnao
Rekei mlp p~lr~en l ~mree$qelr vrohe`~ ai Plcgorn
{ma`m ei~lacp l peraep og ~rlaiaik {orjpmovp
ai el`m og Plcgornp iaie lndaiap~rl~awe lrelp#
`ucdail~aik ai RPCp) ^mere lre lcpo `occlborl~aoip{a~m o~mer `odduia~aep ai ~me Dli`mep~er
lrel# lcpo upaik {orjpmovp celnaik ~o RPCp)
^me `mlra~q ap `rel~aik l newecovdei~ vcli gor
`odduia~q rlnao ai Buriceq)
0)=5 Rlnao Rekei ap l `mlra~lbce `odvliq
{a~m l p~lgg og 22# {mope bolrn og nare`~orp
ap ece`~en bq li ovei dedberpmav -dedberp
og p~lgg lin liqoie ai~erep~en dlq hoai ~me
`odvliq gor l pdlcc gee# bu~ ~me gorder lre
io~ ecakabce gor lvvoai~dei~ ~o ~me Bolrn!) A~p
dappaoi ap ~o dl}adape ~me po`alc lin e`oioda`
klaip ~ml~ `li be nerawen grod `odduia~q rlnao
ai naplnwli~lken lrelp)
0)=7 ^me L``epp Rlnao vrohe`~p a~ puvvor~p#
LCC GD lin [q~meipml{e GD# lre vrodo~aoip
og Rlnao Rekei# bu~ ~me ai~ei~aoi ap ~ml~ ~meq
pmoucn dowe ~o guccq aineveinei~# ceklccq
ai`orvorl~en p~l~up) L~ vrepei~ Rlnao Rekeip
nare`~or lin li L``epp Rlnao p~l~aoi dlilker
owerpee ~med) Mo{ewer# vrokrlddaik gor bo~m
vrohe`~p ap dlilken bq co`lc {orjerp {a~m
lppap~li`e grod ena~oralc krouvp# oipap~aik
og co`lc repanei~p -{a~m oie vcl`e gor l p~l~aoi
wocui~eer!) LCC GD ai~erpverpep dupa` -`urrei~
`mlr~# kocn lin e~mia`! {a~m ai~erwae{p lin
gel~urep `oweraik l {ane rlike og co`lc ai~erep~lin `odduia~q aigordl~aoi: regce`~aik ~me
`uc~urlc nawerpa~q og ~me odduia~q a~ perwep#
pode pmo{p lre ai Urnu# Blikcl# Maina# Vlihlba#
Beiai lin Vor~ukuepe) Eweiaik lin {eejein
ou~vu~ ap kawei ower ~o pve`alcap~ ai~erep~ lin
dupa` vrokrlddep -gor e}ldvce# l {eejcq Arapm
`odduia~q pmo{!) [q~meipml{e GD pmlrep l
padaclr vrokrlddaik voca`q -bu~ oicq broln`lp~p
ai Eikcapm!)
0)=; Naggerei~ orkliapl~aoip mlwe ~mear
nap~ai`~awe dlilkedei~ `uc~urep lin a~ ap ei~arecq
uinerp~linlbce ~ml~ ederkaik lin aie}veraei`en
orkliapl~aoip dlq nevein oi nodaili~
verpoilca~aep gor ~mear newecovdei~ lin ewei
purwawlc) Ai @mlv~er 7)2)$
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
29/89
>)6VRODAPEP OG NECAWERQ
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
30/89
5>
^map `mlv~er pe~p ou~ ~me L``epp Rlnao
vrohe`~p lpvarl~aoip reklrnaik ~me po`alc klaip
vrodapen ~o ~me Rlnao Lu~mora~q lin ~mear l`~ulc
l`maewedei~p lp og Hliulrq 2660) A~ nrl{p oi#
lin upulccq |uo~ep# ~me Ewlcul~aoi \uep~aoiilarep
`odvce~en bq ~me L``epp Rlnao vrohe`~p)
Vrohe`~p {ere io~ re|uaren ~o pe~ ~lrke~p uiner
ewerq melnaik) A~ pmoucn be io~en ~ml~ ai liudber og `lpep ~me vaco~ vrohe`~p lre p~acc oicq
l vlr~ og ~me {lq ~mroukm ~mear ca`ei`ep lin
gailc ou~`odep lre cajecq ~o be krel~er ~mli
re`ornen mere)
VRODAPEP OG NECAWERQ>)6
55
>)< L pakiaga`li~ gel~ure og ~me L``epp Rlnao
vaco~ vrohe`~p pece`~en bq ~me Rlnao Lu~mora~q# lp
rewelcen ai ~mear orakailc pubdappaoip lin ai ~me
Ewlcul~aoi \uep~aoiilarep# ap ~mear ai~ei~aoi ~o
necawer pakiaga`li~ lin upulccq |uli~agalbce po`alc
klaip# epve`alccq ai ~me gaecn og rlnao lin cagepjaccp ~rlaiaik og naplnwli~lken or po`alccq
e}`cunen ainawanulcp)
>)2 ^me e}~ei~ ~o {ma`m ~me vrohe`~p lre
roo~en ai ~mear co`lc `odduia~aep lin lre
`odda~~en ~o rlnao lp l delip og `odduia~q
lin ainawanulc newecovdei~ `li be delpuren
bq ~me {eb og vlr~ierpmavp or caijp {a~m
`odduia~q orkliapl~aoip# co`lc lu~mora~aep#
p`moocp lin `occekep lin vubca` lkei`aep
pu`m ~me voca`e# ~o {ma`m ~meq clq `clad)
>)0 Beco{ lre pe~ ou~ ai puddlrq gord ~me
po`alc klai ~lrke~p ~me L``epp Rlnao vrohe`~p
mlwe pe~ ~medpecwep lin ~me l`~ulc ou~`odep#blpen oi re`ornaik vro`enurep pe~ uv bq ~me
vrohe`~p# lp revor~en l~ ~me ein og 2662)
>)> LIKEC RLNAO
^LRKE^P BQ CA@EI@E EIN# < DLR@M 2660
NECAWERQ HLIULRQ 2660
LAD
>)>)< Likec Rlnao {acc beiega~ ~me ocner
`odduia~q -lken 76 or ower!# cawaik ai ~meBoroukm og Mlwli~# bq be`odaik l go`lc
voai~ og ei~er~laidei~# aigordl~aoi lin
p~aducl~aoi og nare`~ recewli`e ~o a~p ~lrke~
lunaei`e# lin bq eilbcaik ~ml~ lunaei`e ~o
mlwe nare`~ l``epp ~o ~rlaiaik vrokrlddep#
{orj e}veraei`e lin aivu~ ai~o ~me nlq$~o$
nlq ruiiaik og ~me p~l~aoi)
>)>)2 Ag Likec Rlnaop L``epp Rlnao
vrohe`~ {lp lbce ~o be`ode l verdliei~
gel~ure ai ~me Boroukm og Mlwli~ a~ {oucn
be`ode lp ai~ekrlc l vlr~ og ~me ewerqnlq
cawep og ocner veovce lp Po`alc Perwa`ep# lin
lbce ~o overl~e l {ane wlrae~q og vrohe`~p gor
~me beiega~ og ocner veovce)
>)>)0
^RLAIAIK OVVOR^UIA^AEP
^lrke~p
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
31/89
5;
Ou~`odep
Dore ~mli 56 veovce mlwe l~~einen enu`l~aoilc
`ourpep lnwer~apen oi Likec Rlnao)
);
PERWA@E ^O IEAKMBOURMOON
OR AI^EREP^ KROUVP
^lrke~p 5 co`lc aigordl~aoi vrokrlddep broln`lp~
el`m doi~m)
< co`lc aigordl~aoi gree$ln broln`lp~
el`m doi~m)
< co`lc p~lr~$uv `odvce~en nuraik ~me
vrohe`~)
2 co`lc `mlra~aep/`odduia~q krouvp
gel~uren el`m doi~m)
< `mlra~q/`odduia~q krouv guin$rlapaik
ewei~ oweren el`m doi~m)
2 mode plge~q aia~al~awep broln`lp~ nuraik
~me vrohe`~)
Ou~`odep
co`lc aigordl~aoi vrokrlddep mlwe beei
broln`lp~)
)=
L@@EPP ^O ^ME VROHE@^ BQ
CO@LC VEOVCE
^lrke~p
)5
@OI^RABU^AOI ^O PO@ALC AI@CUPAOI
^lrke~p
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
32/89
51
>)5)5
[ORJ E]VERAEI@E OVVOR^UIA^AEP
^lrke~p
Vrowanaik rlnao broln`lp~aik e}veraei`e
~o l~ celp~ 25 p`mooc `macnrei lin `occeke
p~unei~p lin 56 uiedvcoqen lnuc~p nuraik
~me vrohe`~)
Ou~`odep
[orj e}veraei`e mlp beei vrowanen gor
; p`mooc `macnrei -keierl~aik ~mear gur~mer
aiwocwedei~ {a~m ~me vrohe`~!)
>)5)7
@OI^RABU^AOI ^O PO@ALC AI@CUPAOI
^lrke~p
Kclpko{ Melc~m Bolrn# Ede` lin Klrl ~o
eimli`e ~mear ladp lin obhe`~awep bq
necaweraik aigordl~aoi ~mroukm L{lx GDp
`odduia~q vrokrlddaik p~rlin -2 mourp
ver nlq!)
Li ai$moupe ~eld ~o kawe ainawanulcp
padaclr ovvor~uia~aep)
Ou~`odep
^me `occlborl~aoi {a~m ~me Kclpko{ Melc~m
~ooj vcl`e pu``eppguccq -~me Bolrn klwe
~ade ogg gor rlnao {orj ~o li edvcoqee
{mo vrepei~p gor L{lx GD) Mo{ewer# ~mere
mlp beei ca~~ce aivu~ grod Klrl lin Ede`#
lc~moukm l {orjaik recl~aoipmav mlp beei
dlai~laien)
Dliq dedberp og Vopa~awe L`~aoi # li
orkliapl~aoi ladaik ~o uia~e bcl`j line~mia` daiora~q krouvp ai Kclpko{# upe L{lx
GD lp l `mliiec ~o necawer ~mear aigordl~aoi)
L{lx GD ~ooj vlr~ ai ~me P`o~~apm E}e`u~awe
`ldvlaki oi rl`e# {ma`m rli ~mroukm
O`~ober lin Iowedber 2662)
Nuraik ~me doi~m og Rldlnli# nebl~e
vrokrlddep {ere broln`lp~ oi Apclda`
appuep)
>)5);
@OI^RABU^AOI ^O CO@LC ENU@L^AOI
^lrke~p
P~unei~p og l~ celp~ 2 co`lc `occekep#
oggeraik denal pjaccp ourpep# ~o ~lje
vlr~ ai vrokrlddaik ~o `odduia~q krouvp#
lp vlr~ og ~mear `ourpe {orj) Iudberp og
p~unei~p ~o be ne~erdaien cl~er)
Ou~`odep
Vlr~ierpmavp {a~m co`lc `occekep mlwe io~ qe~
~ljei vcl`e# bu~ li aia~al~awe ap beaik vcliien
gor ~me ie{ ~erd)
Pode vrokrlddep mlwe mln `macnreip
pe`~aoip# {a~m lbou~ 06 `macnrei ver vrokrldde
~ljaik vlr~ ai re`a~lcp lin voe~rq relnaikp)
>)5)=
PERWA@E ^O IEAKMBOURMOON OR
AI^EREP^ KROUVP
^lrke~p
L{lx GD ap ai ~me vro`epp og caijaik uv
{a~m ainawanulcp lin krouvp)
Ou~`odep
Wlraoup pdlcc `odduia~q krouvp mlwe `ode
oi bolrn pai`e Lvrac 21~m 2662# pu`m krouvp
ai`cune
Kowlimacc L`~aoi Krouv# pe~ uv ~o re`clad bl`ja~p ieakmbourmoon grod ca~~er lin wlinlcapd
grod veovce cawaik ou~pane ~me lrel)
Qouik @lreer Perwa`ep Lppo`al~aoi -Q@PL!#
li Lpali blpen orkliapl~aoi perwaik Lpalip
~mroukmou~ Kclpko{)
^me Jaiiaik Vlrj @odvce} ruip l pdlcc
`odduia~q celriaik lin vclqkrouv `ei~re)
Io ie{ Likec Rlnao @odda~~ee dedberp#
nrl{i grod ie{ lunaei`ep# mlwe beei
lvvoai~en)
>; veovce mlwe ~ljei vlr~ ai `oipuc~l~aoi
e}er`apep)
2 vubca` purweqp mlwe beei `oinu`~en)
>)>)1
CAIKUAP^A@ ADVL@^
^lrke~p
)5 L[LX GD
^LRKE^P BQ CA@EI@E EIN# 21 LVRAC 2660
NECAWERQ HLIULRQ 2660
LAD
>)5)< ^o perwe l `odduia~q og e~mia`
nawerpa~q orakail~aik grod ~me Ainalipub`oi~aiei~ -Vljap~li lin Ainal!#
necaweraik co`lc# il~aoilc lin ai~eril~aoilc
ie{p# lcoik {a~m `odduia~q appuep ai
ba$caikulc gordl~ ->6%!) ^o vrowane
ei~er~laidei~ ~mroukm l wlrae~q og dupa`#
voe~rq lin lr~ap~a` ~lcei~ -76%!)
>)5)2 Ai ~me coik rui# lcpo ~o perwe lcc
`odduia~aep ai Kclpko{ grod lcc e~mia`
krouvp# ~rlaiaik ai denal pjaccp rlnao
vrepei~aik lin vronu`~aoi# `odvu~er A^
pjaccp: lin ~o {orj ai hoai~ `occlborl~aoi
{a~m co`lc po`alc krouvp# E~mia` Daiora~aep
Edvcoqdei~ @oui`ac -Ede`! lin Kclpko{
Li~a Rl`ap~ Lccali`e -Klrl!)
>)5)0
^RLAIAIK OVVOR^UIA^AEP
^lrke~p
Celriaik vrepei~l~aoi pjaccp oi lar8
overl~aoi og e|uavdei~# vronu`~aoi
~e`mia|uep -ena~aik# re`ornaik og pour`e
dl~eralc lin ie{p vronu`~aoi!)
Ou~`odep
^me vcliien ~rlaiaik vrokrldde mlp io~
~ljei vcl`e o{aik ~o ~me glacure og l krli~
lvvca`l~aoi ~o ~me @odduia~q Guin) Mo{ewer#
oi$koaik ~rlaiaik ai oi$lar vrepei~l~aoi mlp
beei kawei ~o lcc vrepei~erp)
L ie{cq l`|uaren nepj {acc recelpe e|uavdei~
lin ai`relpe ~me wocude og ~rlaiaik oggeren)
5=
>)6 VRODAPEP OG NECAWERQ
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
33/89
7)7 BRLNGORN@ODDUIA QBROLN@LP AIK
^LRKE^P BQ CA@EI@E EIN# < DLR@M 2660
NECAWERQ HLIULRQ 2660
LAD
>)7)6 veovce ~o re eawe ~rlaiaik# ai cunaik A@ )
Ou~`odep
Ai ~o~lc# B@B ~rlaien 5; ainawanulcp ai l rlike
og rlnao vronu`~aoi lin vrepei~l~aoi pjaccp
be~{eei Pev~ 266< lin Ne` 2662) Uv ~o
56 veovce lre oi l {la~aik cap~ gor ~rlaiaik
-lp repour`ep/gl`aca~aep verda~!) Ie{ `ourpep
lre vcliien# {a~m l go`up oi uiedvcoqen
veovce# grod Hliulrq 2660)
A@^8 oie og B@Bp vraora~aep {lp ~o
uvkrlne ~me pjaccp og ~me e}ap~aik
vrepei~erp/vronu`erp/wocui~eerp) Dliq
ainawanulc ~rlaiaik peppaoip mlwe beei
mecn lin pdlcc krouv {orjpmovp puvvor~en
ai upaik A@^p gor rlnao)
Dliq wocui~eerp {ere io~ `odvu~er$ca~erl~e)
O~merp {ere oicq upen ~o ogga`e$blpen
lvvca`l~aoip) ^mear aiwocwedei~ ai `odduia~q
rlnao klwe ~med ~me do~awl~aoi gor l``eppaik
lin rekuclrcq upaik A@^ ai l `rel~awe lin
vrl`~a`lc `oi~e}~)
Ainawanulc ~rlaiaik8 Pode ainawanulc p~unao
~rlaiaik mlp beei vrowanen gor veovce
{mo `lde ~o B@B {a~m l ie{ vrokrldde
vrovoplc lin pubpe|uei~cq mln ~me
anel l``ev~en# or veovce grod ou~rel`m
vrohe`~p {mo {li~en ~o newecov gur~mer
ainawanulc pjaccp)
O~mer rlnao pjaccp ~rlaiaik8
Rlnao Weiup [orjpmovp8 {eejcq rlnao pjaccp
{orjpmovp gor {odei ~o newecov ~mear pjaccp)
Regukee rlnao pjaccp ~rlaiaik `ourpe)
Ai~ronu`~aoi ~o Rlnao8 ou~rel`m `ourpep l~
[me~ceq Macc `ei~re -pee beco{! gor bo~m
[me~ceq Macc krouv lin {eejp lip{eraik veovcep |ueraep)
Dec Daclv @ei~re# rui bq {odei grod ~me
Pajm @odduia~q)
^me Lcneba Voe~rq Po`ae~q# {mope lad ap ~o
jeev Urnu voe~rq lcawe# `occlborl~en {a~m
L{lx GD oi wlraoup vrokrlddep)
me \lan$E$Lxld Po`ae~q)
^me vrohe`~ {orjen {a~m co`lc Kurn{lrl -Pajm!#
Dlinar -Mainu!# Dop|uep -Apcld! lin @mur`mep
ai necaweraik gla~m aigordl~aoi lin ewei~p)
>)5)1
L@@EPP ^O ^ME VROHE@^ BQ CO@LC
VEOVCE
^lrke~p
El`m krouv vrepei~aik `odduia~q pco~p
{acc mlwe nare`~ aivu~ uiner kuanli`e)
Vrepei~erp {acc mlwe nare`~ aivu~ oi mo{
vrokrlddaik regce`~p lunaei e {apmep
lin ieenp)
Ewerq ainawanulc e}vreppaik l ne~lacen
ai~erep~ lin odda~dei~ ~o broln`lp~aik
{acc be lcco{en l``epp ~o ~me vrohe`~) Grodvrewaoup RPC e}veraei`e# l~ celp~ 5 veovce
ver doi~m {acc ~lje vlr~ ai lnna~aoi ~o ~me
`ore wocui~eerp)
Ou~`odep
Owerlcc# 0; `ore vrepei~erp mlwe beei
re`rua~en lin )5))6 VRODAPEP OG NECAWERQ
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
34/89
70
@a~q @ei~re vrohe`~ vrohe`~ puvvor~aik
qouik modecepp veovce) ^rlaiaik peppaoip
mlwe beei mecn ~oke~mer {a~m o``lpaoilc
vrokrldde vronu`~aoi)
^me Groi~caie Aia~al~awe Lgra`li$@lrabbeli
@odduia~q Vrohe`~) B@B oggeren l peraep og
~rlaiaik peppaoip {ma`m cen ~o ~me vronu`~aoi
og pewerlc vrokrlddep# lin lcpo veovce
aiwocwen ai ~me ~rlaiaik lre io{ rekuclrcq
~ljaik vlr~ ai o~mer vrokrldde ~eldp)
^me Ravvce Vrohe`~ `odduia~q blpen nrukp
vrohe`~) B@B `oi~aiuep ~o ogger puvvor~ ~o ~me
rlnao lpve`~ og ~map vrohe`~ lin puvvor~en a~p
RPC ai Pev~edber 2662) ^me Ravvce Vrohe`~
mlp vronu`en o``lpaoilc vrokrlddep gor
broln`lp~ oi B@B# {a~m pode ainawanulcp
p~lr~aik ~o be`ode aiwocwen {a~m B@B)
Pmavceq @odduia~aep oi Caie `odduia~q
A^ vrohe`~) A~ io{ vronu`ep l doi~mcq A^
vrokrldde oi B@B) B@B {acc be caijaik ~me
ie{ ~rlaiaik l~ ~me Ie{ P~lr~ @ei~re ~o ~me
o~mer Pmavceq @odduia~aep oi Caie vrohe`~p)
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
35/89
75
>)7)=
CAIKUAP^A@ ADVL@^
^lrke~p
@odduia~q clikulkep8
B@B {acc upe `odduia~q rlnao ~o vrodo~e
`uc~urlc e}vreppaoi ai `odduia~qclikulkep) [e lad gor `odduia~aep
~o broln`lp~ ai ~me clikulke ~ml~ ap
dop~ lvvrovral~e ~o ~mear ~lrke~
lunaei`e) Pode vrokrlddep dlq
ai~ekrl~e dore ~mli oie clikulke)
Cajecq vrokrlddaik ai Urnu# Beiklca#
Vlihlba# {a~m ~me vrowapaoi lin
ei`ourlkedei~ gor vrokrlddaik ai liq
clikulke ~ml~ ~me odduia~aep geec ap
lvvrovral~e) map oucn ai`cune A~lcali#
Ujrlaiali# Vocapm e~`)
Vrepei~erp ai odduia~q clikulkep
{acc be ei`ourlken lin puvvor~en ainewecovaik ~mear vrepei~l~aoi p~qce#
necawerq lin oiganei`e)
Co`lc L``ei~ lin e}vreppaoi8
@odduia~q rlnao broln`lp~aik oi B@B
{acc mecv ~o `ecebrl~e ~me naggerei~
l``ei~p lin {lqp ~ml~ veovce e}vrepp
~medpecwep {a~mai ~me Brlngorn Nap~ra`~)
mroukm aiwocwedei~ ai B@B {e {acc
l`~awecq ei`ourlke veovce ~o newecov
`oiganei`e ai ~mear e}vreppaoi# regce`~aik
lin kawaik wlcana~q ~o ~me dliq {lqp ~ml~
veovce `odduia l~e lin e}vrepp
~medpecwep {a~mai ~me `a~q)
^mere {acc be
>)7)5
@OI^RABU^AOI ^O CO@LC ENU@L^AOI
^lrke~p
B@B {acc caij {a~m co`lc p`moocp# `occekep
lin ~me uiawerpa~q oggeraik vrl`~a`lc {orj
e}veraei`e ovvor~uia~aep gor veovce oi
`ourpep lin# {mere lvvrovral~e# oi
`odvce~aoi og ~mear ourpe)
^me ~rlaiaik ovvor~uia~aep l~ B@B lre
io~ oggeren co`lccq bq `occekep or o~mer
aip~a~u~aoip lin lre ~meregore odvcedei~lrq
~o o~mer enu`l~aoilc vrowapaoi)
Ou~`odep
B@B mlp oggeren {orj e}veraei`e vcl`edei~p
~o p`mooc p~unei~p: mlp gorden caijp {a~m
Be`jgoo~ p`mooc rlnao vrohe`~: lin Jeakmceq
@occeke Ai~erie~ rlnao vrohe`~# wapa~p grod
`clppep lin krouvp og p~unei~p)@oipanerlbce
ai~erep~ grod p`moocp ai ~erdp og `rel~awe
lin aiiowl~awe {lqp og necaweraik Il~aoilc
@urra`ucud Obhe`~awep ~mroukm dljaik rlnao
vrokrlddep) ^me vrohe`~ ladp ~o edvcoq
li enu`l~aoi {orjer ~o nelc pve`aga`lccq
{a~m p`moocp vrohe`~p lin vrokrlddaik)
>)7)7
PERWA@E ^O IEAKMBOURMOON OR
AI^EREP^ KROUVP
^lrke~p
B@B {acc ogger rekuclr broln`lp~
ovvor~uia~aep ~o lcc co`lc odduia~q lin
wocui~lrq lin ieakmbourmoon krouvp ~o
vubca`ape l`~awa~aep# rlape appuep# e~`)
Ou~`odep
B@B vrowanep nlacq broln`lp~ ovvor~uia~aep
gor co`lc `odduia~q lin ieakmbourmoon
orkliapl~aoip lin ai~erep~ krouv ~o vubca`ape
vrohe`~p# ewei~p# e~`) Lwerlke og )7);
L@@EPP ^O ^ME VROHE@^ BQ
CO@LC VEOVCE
^lrke~p
Wocui~eeraik ovvor~uia~aep ~o ie{ veovce ~o be ei`ourlken ~o hoai
Dlilkedei~ @odda~~ee)
Ou~`odep
Pai`e ~me p~lr~ og ~me gucc ~ade ca`ei`e veraon#
Dlr`m 2662# ~mere mlp beei li ai`relpe ai
wocui~eerp) )6 VRODAPEP OG NECAWERQ
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
36/89
7;
@a~axeip Lnwa`e Burelu < ai~erwae{ l
{eej oi ceklc appuep lin ~me vrowapaoi og
ceklc perwa`ep ~o po`alccq nevrawen krouvp)
Karcp Ai~eril~aoilc ~map @mrap~ali
orkliapl~aoi# {ma`m ruip wlraoup p`medep
ai`cunaik oie recl~en ~o melc~m# nruk upe
e~`)# ~o be gel~uren gor li mour l {eej lin
lcpo ai ai~erwae{p ecpe{mere# l~ celp~
> or 5 ~adep l qelr)
Modecepp Vrohe ~p l~ celp~ 2 ~o 0
ai~erwae{p l qelr {a~m ~me Vo~~eraep
Moupaik Lppo`al~aoi -{orjaik {a~m
~me modecepp!)
Pldlra~lip 2 ~o 0 ai~erwae{p l qelr {a~m
revrepei~l~awep og ~me co`lc perwa`e)
Ior~m P~lggp Wa`~ad Puvvor~ Puvvor~ gor
Wa`~adp og @rade 2 ~o 0 ai~erwae{p l qelr)
Ou~`odep
Rekuclr {eejcq pco~ oi ~me voca`e# `oweraik
~mear vrepp recelpep lin ai~erwae{aik recl~en
verpoip lbou~ appuep ~me voca`e mlwe
`urrei~cq makmcakm~en)
2 ai~erwae{p {a~m ~me Rl`e E|ulca~q @oui`ac)
< ai~erwae{ {a~m U Dl~~er)
Ai~erwae{ {a~m Edvcoqdei~ Perwa`e
revrepei~l~awe ewerq ~{o or ~mree {eejp:
aigordl~aoi vrowanen bq ~me perwa`e ap
`oweren ai l {eejcq pco~)
< ai~erwae{ l {eej {a~m @a~axeip Lnwa`e
Burelu} revrepei~l~awe ui~ac Lukup~# {mei
me {lp ece`~en Dlqor) Io{ < ai~erwae{
ver doi~m)
< ai~erwae{ ~o nl~e {a~m Ior~m P~lggp Wa`~ad
Puvvor~)
[eejcq ai~erwae{p {a~m Ldeia~aep Dlilker
og P~oje$oi$^rei~ @a~q @oui`ac)
Eiklkedei~ {a~m/`owerlke og
Wocui~eer Relnaik Mecv
Re$Pocw
Qou~m Oggeinaik ^eld# Qou~m Hup~a`e Bolrn
Pure P~lr~ P~oje$oi$^rei~
@macnreip Guin gor P~oje
Denal L`~aoi Krouv gor Dei~lc Melc~m
@rel~e -{orj vcl`edei~p gor qouik
veovce {a~m celriaik naplbaca~aep!
Naplbaca~q Pocu~aoip
Groi~caie Nli`e @odvliq -gor naplbcen
lin lbce$bonaen veovce!
Ior~m P~lggp Nqpce}al Lppo`al~aoi
Vo~~eraep Lppo`al~aoi gor ~me Bcain
Be~m Homipoi Gouinl~aoi -mecv gor
ocner veovce!
Ior~m P~lggp @lrerp Lppo`al~aoi
Uiaoi og Lgra`li lin Lgra`li @lrabbeli
Orkliapl~aoip
Ior~m P~lggp Lgra li lin @lrabbeli Lppo`al~aoi
^elr Guin
P~ Homip [ec`ode @ei~re
Plcwl~aoi Lrdq# ^uip~lcc
Blv~ap~ Uiaoi Aia~al~awe gor Veovce {a~m
Celriaik Naplbaca~aep
^me Lrj -nrov$ai `ei~re gor ~me modecepp!
Krouin{orj P~oje$oi$^rei~
@odduia~q [lrneip Vrohe`~# Burpced Pou~m
Pve`alc gel~urep ai`cunen vrokrlddep oi
`li`er# regukeep lin Arl|)
77
>); @ROPP RMQ^MDP@A Q RLNAO
^LRKE^P BQ CA@EI@E EIN# 2= GEBRULRQ 2660
NECAWERQ HLIULRQ 2660
LAD
>);)< Perwaik ~me ieenp og ~me @mrap~ali
@odduia~q lin l`~aik lp l branke be~{eei~ml~ `odduia~q lin ~me `odduia~q l~ clrke)
>);)2 Ai ~me coiker ~erd# ~o ep~lbcapm ~me
@mrap~ali @odduia~q lp l re`okiapen krouv
{a~mai ~me `a~q lin l~ ~me plde ~ade ~o
vrodo~e nalcokue lin ai~ekrl~aoi {a~m ~me
`odduia~q l~ clrke)
>);)0
^RLAIAIK OVVOR^UIA^AEP
^lrke~p
Uv ~o 06 veovce ~o wocui~eer lin re`eawe
~rlaiaik ai broln`lp~aik pjaccp lp {ecc
lp recl~en lrelp pu`m lp dlrje~aik#lndaiap~rl~aoi lin A^) ^rlaieep {acc be
~ep~en ai l relc {orjaik eiwaroidei~
lin {acc mlwe lnwli~lkep ai lvvcqaik
gor edvcoqdei~ ovvor~uia~aep l~
@ropp Rmq~mdp)
Ou~`odep
Nuraik ~me qelr >; veovce mlwe {orjen
lp wocui~eerp lin re`eawen ~rlaiaik) @ropp
Rmq~mdp vrowanen l rlnao ~rlaiaik peppaoi
ai ~me Ovei Noorp ~rlaiaik nlq l~~einen
bq dore ~mli
[ORJ E]VERAEI@E OVVOR^UIA^AEP
^lrke~p
Lp lbowe)
Ou~`odep
2 wocui~eerp lre aiwocwen ai ~me DacceiiaudWocui~eerp Vrohe`~# {ma`m {acc eilbce ~med ~o
klai l `er~aga`l~e/navcodl lg~er `odvce~aik l
re|uaren ldoui~ og {orj e}veraei`e)
> veovce `oiie`~en {a~m p`moocp/uiawerpa~aep
lre uinerkoaik veraonp og {orj e}veraei`e)
>);)5
@OI^RABU^AOI ^O PO@ALC AI@CUPAOI
^lrke~p
[a~m l wae{ ~o vubca`apaik ~me {orj og
~me orkliapl~aoip beco{ lin ~o rlape
l{lreiepp og ~me appuep {a~m {ma`m
~meq lre `oi`erien)
< ai~erwae{ l {eej {a~m l voca`e
revrepei~l~awe ~o vubca`ape ~mear {orj
lin e}vclai appuep)
2 ~o 0 ai~erwae{p l qelr {a~m Rl`e E|ulca~q
@oui`ac)
2 ~o 0 ai~erwae{p l qelr {a~m U Dl~~er# li
orkliapl~aoi ladaik ~o relcape ~me vo~ei~alc
og qouik veovce ai P~oje$oi$^rei~)
Melc~m L`~aoi Xoie 2 ai~erwae{p l doi~m
{a~m orkliapl~aoip ai ~map udbreccl krouv)
L~ celp~ 26 orkliapl~aoip ~o be aiwocwen
ower ~me qelr)
Edvcoqdei~ Perwa`e l~ celp~ oie
ai~erwae{ l {eej oi edvcoqdei~ appuep)
>)6 VRODAPEP OG NECAWERQ
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
37/89
71
>);)=
L@@EPP ^O ^ME VROHE@^ BQ CO@LC VEOVCE
^lrke~p
Dedberp og ~me p~l~aoi dlilkedei~ ~eld
{acc be l~~einaik ~me rekuclr doi~mcq
dee~aikp og co`lc @mrap~ali celnerp po
~ml~ ovvor~uia~q {acc e}ap~ gor ~med ~o aivu~
ai~o ~me ruiiaik og ~me p~l~aoi) Oie$~o$oie
dee~aikp ~o be mecn {a~m jeq veovce pu m
lp {orjerp gor ^me Plc~bo}# co`lc melnp
og @mrap~ali neiodail~aoip lin o~merp ~o
geen ~mear wae{p ai~o ~me @ropp Rmq~mdp
ne`apaoi$dljaik vro`epp)
Lbou~ ););
PERWA@E ^O IEAKMBOURMOON OR
AI^EREP^ KROUVP
^lrke~p
Ieakmbourmoon or ai~erep~ krouvp perwen
{acc ai`cune
co`lc mur`mep -266 revrepei~aik 06
neiodail~aoip!
me Plc~bo}
Ior~m P~lggp QG@
Karcp Ai~eril~aoilc
@a~q Wapaoi Daiap~raep
Uinakiagaen -l qou~m ewei~!
[odei Lkco{ -{ma`m ei~rep oi ~me
ieenp og @mrap~ali {odei!
Gucc Kopvec Bupaiepp Deip Gecco{pmav
Uia~en @mrap~ali Broln`lp~erp
Wocui~lrq L`~aoi L`~aoi Caie -l co`lc `mlra~q ~ml~ vrowanep
oi$lar vubca`a~q gor co`lc orkliapl~aoip!)
Ou~`odep
^me vrohe`~ puvvor~en lcc ~me orkliapl~aoip
~lrke~en e}`ev~ gor Wocui~lrq L`~aoi lin
L`~aoi Caie)
Lnna~aoilc orkliapl~aoip puvvor~en ai`cune
Po{aik Peenp gor Rewawlc -{eej og
ai~erneiodail~aoilc vrlqerp!
KPUP Cawe -aia~al~awe og Ior~m P~lggp Qou~m
gor @mrap~!
Pvraik Mlrwep~ -@mrap~ali mocanlqp!
Pouc Purwawor -@mrap~ali Qou~m ewei~!
^me vrohe`~ klwe ne~lacen# cawe `owerlke ~o
~me dlqorlc/co`lc ece`~aoip) Dlqor kawep
gor~iakm~cq ai~erwae{)
Lcc gawe co`lc DVP mlwe beei ai~erwae{en)
Ejjcepal# l @mrap~ali ~maij~lij# kawep {eejcq
uv$nl~e og vlrcaldei~lrq appuep og ai~erep~
~o @mrap~alip)
>)6 VRODAPEP OG NECAWERQ
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
38/89
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
39/89
;0
>)1)5
@OI^RABU^AOI ^O CO@LC ENU@L^AOI
^lrke~p
Vradlrq P`moocp8 ~me lad ap ~o eilbce
`macnrei ~o e}vcore dliq og ~me pjaccp ~meq
lre l`|uaraik ai ~me `clpprood ai ~me
`oi~e}~ og relc broln`lp~aik ~o li lunaei`e)
7 p`moocp ~o be aiwocwen -l vaco~ {a~m oie
p`mooc mlp lcrelnq ~ljei vcl`e!) Ai el`m
p`mooc l~ celp~ < dedber og p~lgg or vlrei~
~o be ~rlaien ~o l`~ lp ~e`mia`lc puvvor~
lin dei~or: 5 daiu~e
nap`uppaoi vrokrlddep ~o be broln`lp~
nuraik p`mooc ~ade) Ai el`m p`mooc l~ celp~
< dedber og p~lgg or vlrei~ ~o be ~rlaien ~o
l`~ lp ~e`mia`lc puvvor~ lin dei~or: GONR
{acc {orj {a~m vuvacp lin p~lgg ~o lkree
vrokrldde ~medep: ~me aiwocwedei~ og
co`lc veovce# co`lc bupaieppep# voca~a`alip
lin co`lc koweridei~ lkei`aep {acc be
ei`ourlken: appuep pu`m lp blcli`e#
e|ulca~q lin repelr`m {acc be e}vcoren:
vuvacp {acc be ~rlaien ai rlnao# ai~erwae{
lin vrepei~l~aoi pjaccp)
Lcc pa} Gorep~ og Neli peiaor p`moocp {acc
be aiwocwen)
Ou~`odep
Vradlrq P`moocp
Pounceq P`mooc Vaco~) Gorep~ og Neli Rlnao
-GONR! rli li lg~er$p`mooc rlnao `cub gor
~me vuvacp gor l veraon og gawe {eejp)
El`m {eej ~me `macnrei {ere ~lukm~
wlraoup lpve`~p og rlnao vronu`~aoi
Guinaik io{ ai vcl`e ~o bekai {orj {a~m
~{o gur~mer p`moocp)
^me gocco{aik Vradlrq p`moocp mlwe
lcpo beei aiwocwen ai broln`lp~p8
Cqnieq @ ' E P`mooc
Cqnbrooj P`mooc
Gorep~ Wae{ P`mooc
[ep~burq P`mooc
Neli Mlcc P`mooc
Pe`oinlrq P`moocp
[ma~e`ropp Cqnieq ~me vrohe`~ mlpbeei newecovaik rekuclr `oi~l`~ lin
vrokrldde$dljaik {a~m p~lgg lin
p~unei~p ~o e}vcore wae{p lin newecov
lrelp og ai~erep~) ^map mlp ai`cunen
nebl~ep oi go} mui~aik lin ~me co`lc
recewli`e og ~me @oui~rqpane Dlr`m#
lin oveiaik uv ~me appuep og mo{ ~me
ai`relpaik ldoui~ og ~ade ~ljei uv
bq ~ep~aik mlp beei egge ~aik ~el`merp#
p~unei~p lin ~mear gldacaep)
Meq{oon P`mooc ai @ainergorn ap
newecovaik l ban ~o be`ode l pve`alcap~
pvor~p p`mooc lin GONR ap ieko~al~aik
l `ourpe ai Pvor~p Hourilcapd caijen
~o rlnao ou~vu~) GONR mlp {orjen oi
l booj rewae{ vrohe`~ {a~m ~me Eikcapm
Nevlr~dei~ lin ~me Co`lc Cabrlrq perwa`e
lin ~me Meln ~ooj vlr~ {a~m p~unei~p ai
l rewae{ og ~me qelr gor ~me @mrap~dlp
broln`lp~aik p`menuce)
;2
Daclv Nlq @ei~re -gor ocner veovce ai Pou~mlcc!
Elcaik Wocui~lrq Perwa`ep @oui`ac)
Caijp e}ap~ lin lre beaik gur~mer newecoven
{a~m Vlihlba ^mel~re krouvp lin `uc~urlc
lin pvor~p orkliapl~aoip) Lcpo {a~m Pou~mlccGoo~blcc @cub# Pou~mlcc Jlblna @cub
-pvor~p! lin Pou~m Lpal Pocanlra~q Krouv)
O~mer po`alc perwa`e lin wocui~lrq
orkliapl~aoip {acc be aiwocwen ower ~ade)
>)=);
L@@EPP ^O ^ME VROHE@^ BQ CO@LC VEOVCE
^lrke~p
^me vrohe`~ {acc ogger dore ~mli 266
veovce ~me ovvor~uia~q ~o {orj lp
wocui~eerp -re`ev~aoi# {orn vro`eppaik#
dupa` lr`mawep# nl~lblpe dlilkedei~#
dlrje~aik# vrokrlddaik lin lndaiap~rl~aoi!)
Ou~`odep
^me vrohe`~ mlp oggeren dore ~mli 266
veovce ~me ovvor~uia~q ~o {orj lp wocui~eerp
-re`ev~aoi# {orn vro`eppaik# dupa` lr`mawep#
nl~lblpe dlilkedei~# dlrje~aik#
vrokrlddaik lin lndaiap~rl~aoi!)
>)=)=
CAIKUAP^A@ ADVL@^
^lrke~p
Nepa Rlnaop dlai clikulke ap Vlihlba
-ai`cunaik a~p wlral~aoip ai Ior~m# Pou~m#
[ep~ lin @ei~rlc Vlihlb!) Vrepei~erp lree}ve`~en ~o e}vrepp ~me ra`miepp lin
wlrae~q og Vlihlba {a~m kro{aik oiganei`e)
Ou~`odep
Nepa Rlnaop dlai clikulke ap Vlihlba
-ai`cunaik a~p wlral~aoip ai Ior~m# Pou~m# [ep~
lin @ei~rlc Vlihlb!) Vrepei~erp lre e}ve`~en
~o e}vrepp ~me ra`miepp lin wlrae~q og Vlihlba
{a~m kro{aik `oiganei`e)
>)1 GOREP OGNELI RLNAO
^LRKE^P BQ CA@EI@E EIN# )1)< ^o l`maewe rekeierl~aoi gor ~me
Gorep~ og Neli ~mroukm ~me denaud og rlnao)
>)1)2
^RLAIAIK OVVOR^UIA^AEP
^lrke~p
)1)0
[ORJ E]VERAEI@E OVVOR^UIA^AEP
^lrke~p
Lp lbowe)
Ou~`odep
Pee lbowe)
>)1)>
@OI^RABU^AOI ^O PO@ALC AI@CUPAOI
^lrke~p
Broln`lp~aik ovvor~uia~aep ~o
be vrowanen gor =2 co`lc wocui~lrq
or odduia~q orkliapl~aoip)
Ou~`odep
Ovvor~uia~aep mlwe beei vrowanen gor )6 VRODAPEP OG NECAWERQ
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
40/89
;5
>)1);
L@@EPP ^O ^ME VROHE@^ BQ CO@LC
VEOVCE
^lrke~p
^me vrohe`~# buacnaik oi e}ap~aik `oi~l`~p#
{acc vrowane l peraep og ~rlaiaik peppaoip ~o
eilbce co`lc `odduia~q krouvp ~o vrodo~e
~mear l`~awa~aep) ^meq lre cajecq ~o ai`cune
U0L
@lina
Ie{ Neli Dupa` @cub
Gorep~ Dupa` @occe`~awe
GoN Co`lc Map~orq Po`ae~q
Neli Lr`meocoka`lc Krouv
Neli Gorep~ Woa`e
Gorep~ Wocui~lrq L`~aoi Gorud
Noor{lqp
Cabrlrq Perwa`e Roqlc Gorep~ og Neli Bq Negaia~aoi
Gorep~ Bcuep @cub
GORKE @ei~re gor ~me Wapulccq Advlaren
Nalc$l$Rane
GoN Gldacq Map~orq Po`ae~q
[qeneli P`mooc# Penburq) ^me vrohe`~
mlp `occlborl~en {a~m ~me p`mooc gor l
iudber og qelrp: ~me p`mooc {apmep ~o
mop~ oie og GONRp p~unaop lp vlr~ og l
ie{ newecovdei~ ~o l``oddonl~e rapaik
p~unei~ iudberp lin `odduia~q l``epp~o ~me `ldvup) GONR ap {orjaik {a~m ~me
p`mooc lin l iudber og lkei`aep lin
co`lc veovce gur~mer ~o newecov
`odduia~q l`~awa~q ai ~map apocl~en rurlc
lrel) L gel~ure {lp re`ornen nuraik l
nrukp l{lreiepp {eej {mei l ~mel~re
`odvliq `oddappaoien bq ~me Qou~m
Perwa`e wapa~en ~me p`mooc# lp {lp l
rewae{ og ~me qelr vronu`en {a~m p~lgg
lin p~unei~p)
L~ Cljerp P`mooc ~me vrohe`~ gel~uren a~p
p~unei~ p~eec blin oi ~our l~ l iudber
og co`lc `lriawlcp lin {orjen {a~m ~me
p~unei~p lp vlr~ og l ~e`miocokq vrohe`~)
Ie{ei~ P`mooc mlp beei ~me blpe gor
l dupa` ~e`miocokq vrohe`~ lin pewerlc
vrokrlddep mlwe beei broln`lp~ gel~uraik
~me qouik veovce lin ~mear dupa`)
P~unei~p l~ Roqlc Gorep~ og Neli @occeke
mlwe hup~ bekui l peraep og A^ vrobced$
pocwaik vrokrlddep gocco{aik ~rlaiaik
necaweren bq GONR) ^me vrohe`~ ap lcpo
{orjaik {a~m ~me P~unei~ Uiaoi ~o
newecov l rekuclr dlklxaie vrokrldde)
>)1)7
PERWA@E ^O IEAKMBOURMOON OR
AI^EREP^ KROUVP
^lrke~p
Pee `oi~rabu~aoi ~o po alc ai`cupaoi lbowe)
@owerlke bq GONR og lcc recewli~`odduia~q aia~al~awep ai ~me Gorep~ og Neli
- awa dl~~erp# melc~m# enu`l~aoi# rekeierl~aoi
aia~al~awep# enu`l~aoi# rekeierl~aoi
aia~al~awep lin eiwaroidei~lc appuep!)
Vrowapaoi og li egge`~awe `odduia`l~aoi
perwa`e ~ml~ caijp `ore lkei`aep lin
~me `odduia~q)
GONR {acc buacn oi caijp {a~m ~me Neli
Mera~lke @ei~re: Gawe L`rep @occeke# ~me
Kcou`ep~erpmare @oui~q Lr`mawep# ~me
Gorep~ og Neli Qou~m Gorud# Gorep~ og
Neli Nap~ra`~ @oui`ac lin ~me Gorep~ og
Neli Enu`l~aoi Bupaiepp Vlr~ierpmav)@occlborl~aoi {acc be poukm~ {a~m Aigordl~aoi
lin Lnwa`e Krouvp# ai`cunaik @oiie}aoip
lin ~me Celriaik lin Pjaccp @oui`ac)
Ou~`odep
Pee `oi~rabu~aoi ~o po`alc ai`cupaoi lbowe)
Recewli~ aia~al~awep mlwe beei `oweren)
Vrokrlddep mlwe nelc~ {a~m Melc~m#
Moupaik# ^ourapd# Lr~p Newecovdei~
P~rl~ekq# Enu`l~aoi# Rekeierl~aoi lin
^ourapd P~rl~ekq)
Caijp mlwe beei ep~lbcapmen {a~m
Neli Mera~lke @ei~re Gawe L`rep @occeke# Qou~m Gorud
Nap~ra`~ @oui`ac# Bupaiepp Vlr~ierpmav
^me Celriaik ' Pjaccp @oui`ac ap oie og
~me vrohe`~p dlhor guinerp)
Vredapep lre pmlren {a~m bo~m @oiie}aoip
lin Gorep~ og Neli @occeke)
>)6 VRODAPEP OG NECAWERQ
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
41/89
;;
Ou~`odep
K^GD ap blpen ai ~me Rmqnqgecai lrel
og Voi~qvrann# {ma`m ap oie og ~me 56
@odduia~aep Garp~ lrelp ai [lcep# lin
ap l dedber og ~me Rmqnqgecai Rekeierl~aoi
Vlr~ierpmav) ^me vrohe`~ dlai~laip l pve`alc
vlr~ierpmav {a~m ~me Kcqi~lgg ^eili~p' Repanei~p Lppo`al~aoi# {ma`m mop~p l
nlacq `odduia~q vrokrldde -{a~m rekuclr
`oi~rabu~aoip grod ~me co`lc voca`e# `oipuder
lnwa`e `ei~re lin nae~lrq/melc~mq cawaik
lnwa`e!) ^me @odduia~q Newecovdei~
@o$@oornail~or gor Rmqnqgecai `o$mop~p
~me pmo{ oi`e ver {eej)
>)6 KIW\ lin MIN Denal
p~unei~p {acc re`eawe ~rlaiaik lin
broln`lp~aik ovvor~uia~aep# gl`aca~l~aik
`ourpe necawerq)
Ou~`odep
^me vrohe`~ mlp oikoaik caijp {a~m co`lc
p`moocp l`ropp ~me Rmoinnl @qioi ^lg)
El`m og ~me gour `odvremeipawe p`moocp ai
~me addenal~e ieakmbourmoon ~lje vlr~ ai
rekuclr p`mooc pmo{p oi K^GD lin l~ ~{o
og ~med rlnao `cubp lre overl~aik
1< vuvacp mlwe po glr upen ~mear `oi~l`~ {a~m
~me K^GD lp l vlr~ og ~mear L cewec/LP
Cewec/K@PE `ourpe {orj) )
[ORJ E]VERAEI@E OVVOR^UIA^AEP
^lrke~p
))6 VRODAPEP OG NECAWERQ
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
42/89
;1
>)
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
43/89
=)
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
44/89
=0
>))
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
45/89
=5
>)))
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
46/89
=;
A~p vlr~ierp ai`cune8
^lje < Lgra`li @lrabbeli Krouv
Buc{ecc Lnwei~ Krouv Lnwei~
@mrap~ali Krouv
Dlnrlppl Lcood Puvvcedei~lrq P`mooc
Vljeexl Lr~ lin @uc~ure [odeip krouv
Co`lc @occekep
Co`lc lu~mora~q enu`l~aoi nevlr~dei~
Lvil Lr~p Lpali Lr~ vrohe`~
Kuherl~ pldlh
@a~q @ei~rlc V@^
BB@ Rlnao Io~~aikmld
@OIIE]AOIP
@li`er Repelr`m UJ
Uiawerpa~q og Io~~aikmld
L[V mlp re`ei~cq gorden l vlr~ierpmav {a~m
~me BB@# {ma`m {acc vrowane ~rlaiaik gor ~me
vrohe`~p vronu`er lin recelpe oie nlq l
{eej og l BB@ {orjerp ~ade ~o {orj {a~m
L[V vrokrldde ~eldp lp vlr~ og ~me
newecovdei~) ^meq {acc be aiwocwen ai ~me
vronu`erp re`rua~dei~) ^me vronu`er {acc
pvein 26 nlqp ai l qelr l~ ~me BB@)
>) lr~ap~p
Ou~`odep
2;0 wocui~eerp mlwe vlr~a`avl~en ai ~me
vrohe`~# nrl{i grod lcc lke krouvp)
Ai lnna~aoi# 5< ocner veovce mlwe beei aiwocwen
{a~m redaiap`ei`e/dedoar vrokrlddaik)
Dore ~mli oie lr~ap~# `rlg~pverpoi or nepakier
mlp beei gel~uren ewerq {eej -ai`cunaik#
dupa`alip# voe~p lin glpmaoi nepakierp!)
^me p~l~aoi mlp li ovei l``epp voca`q# {ma`m
lcco{p wocui~eerp ~o vlr~a`avl~e ai repelr`maik#
vrepei~aik# vcliiaik# vronu`aik# lin
vlr~a`avl~aik ai vrokrlddep ower ~me vmoie#
ne`apaoi$dljaik lin voca`q gordl~aoi)
Rekuclr gor~iakm~cq dee~aikp lre mecn {a~m
wocui~eerp lin vlr~ier orkliapl~aoip ~o
ewlcul~e ~me vrokrepp og ~mear `oi~rabu~aoip)
El`m verpoi ap wlcuen lin ~mear `oi~rabu~aoi
re`okiapen# {a~m `er~aga`l~ep# l{lrnp or ewei
hup~ l vl~ oi ~me bl`j)
L[V Rlnao Glxl mlp oi$pa~e `macn`lre
lin naplbcen l``epp: a~ ap oi ~me rou~e
og Io~~aikmldp ie{ ^rld Ie~{orj)
=7
Cawe `owerlke og lr~ lin `uc~urlc ewei~p# Ean#
Na{lca# @mrap~dlp# Aineveinei~ Nlqp# Voe~rq#
booj rewae{p) Cawe ai ~me p~unao ai~erwae{p
{a~m dupa` lr~ap~p lin blinp)
Pvor~ vrokrlddep# cawe ai~erwae{p {a~m pvor~
verpoilca~aep# Eikclin @ra`je~ @lv~lai
Ilpper Mupplai# {ec~er {eakm~ bo}aik
`mldvaoi Updli Lgxlc lin dliq dore)
@owerlke og @oddoi{elc~m Kldep)
Vrokrlddep lrouin pvor~p lin ceapure gl`aca~aep)
>)
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
47/89
=1
>)ai rlnao vrepei~aik lin lndaiap~rl~awe pjaccp)
>)
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
48/89
1) RLNAO REKEI
-AI@ORVORL AIK
LCC GD LIN
[Q^MEIPML[E GD!
^LRKE^P BQ CA@EI@E EIN# 7 DLQ 2660
OU^@ODEP HLIULRQ 2660
LAD
>))< ^o `rel~e l dlpp lunaei`e
vcl~gord gor ~me wae{p# movep# gelrp linlbaca~aep og [q~meipml{e lin ~me L7
@orranor ~ml~ {acc vrodo~e `odduia~q
vrane lin vlr~a`avl~aoi lp {ecc lp co{eraik
blrraerp ~o uiedvcoqdei~)
>))2
^RLAIAIK OVVOR^UIA^AEP
^lrke~p
^me p~l~aoip {acc vrowane 2> ~rlaiaik {eejp
-06 mourp el`m {eej!# kawaik li ai~ronu`~aoi
~o rlnao pjaccp lin ~rlipgerlbce {orjvcl`e
pjaccp -e)k) ~eld{orj# vrobced pocwaik# A@ #
vrogeppaoilc {orj vrl`~a`e# `odduia l~aoi
pjaccp lin pecg$ep~eed! lin ~me `mli`e ~ovrokrepp ~o o~mer ~rlaiaik ovvor~uia~aep
{a~m Rlnao Rekei lin o~mer vrowanerp)
Ou~`odep
Rlnao/~rlipgerlbce pjaccp necaweren lp l
dlinl~orq ainu`~aoi gor lcc wocui~eerp8 ))0
[ORJ E]VERAEI@E OVVOR^UIA^AEP
^lrke~p
>6 Rlnao Rekei ~rlaieep {acc re`eawe
pubp~li~alc {orj e}veraei`e -ai`cunaik
relc ~ade broln`lp~aik! l~ ~me p~l~aoip)
Ou~`odep
))>
@OI^RABU^AOI ^O PO@ALC AI@CUPAOI
^lrke~p
Io pve`aga` ~lrke~p pe~)
Ou~`odep
^me p~l~aoip mlwe be`ode dlhor `ei~rep gor
wocui~eeraik ai el`m lrel# {a~m ;7 wocui~eerp
dljaik vrokrlddep ewerq {eej oi LCC GD
lin =7 noaik po ai [q~meipml{e) ^mepe
veovce lre io~ `odduia~q l`~awap~p bu~ ~meq
lre io{ mecvaik pup~lai oie og ~me bakkep~
`odduia~q vrohe`~p ai ~mear lrelp) ^map cewec
og nedlin mlp p~re~`men repour`ep oi ~me
p~l~aoip lin Rlnao Rekei ap {orjaik {a~m
~med ~o eipure ~ml~ puvvor~ gor ~mepe
wocui~eerp ap repour`en lin pup~lailbce)
16
>))
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
49/89
10
>));
L@@EPP ^O ^ME VROHE@^ BQ CO@LC
VEOVCE
^lrke~p
El`m p~l~aoi {acc mlwe l p~eeraik krouv
og be~{eei 7 lin ))1 CAIKUAP^A@ ADVL@^
^lrke~p
Io pve`aga` ~lrke~p pe~)
Ou~`odep
Grod 7 vd ~o = vd ewerq nlq LCC GD
broln`lp~p ioi Eikcapm pmo{p ai e)k) Urnu#
Beiai# Vor~ukuepe# Maina# Jlpmdara# Vuihlba#
Glrpa) ^me vmoie repvoipe ~o ~me ioi$
Eikcapm pmo{p ap koon lin pvrelnp {ecc
beqoin ~me ~lrke~ lrel) LCCGD lcpo vclqp
l glar vrovor~aoi og ioi${ep~eri dupa` ai
~me nlq~ade) A~ ap uinerp~oon ~ml~ ~me Beiai
vrokrldde ap ~me oicq oie ai ~me `oui~rq)
[q~meipml{e GD broln`lp~p oicq ai Eikcapm#
{a~m li edvmlpap oi ~me co`lc weril`uclr)
>)) GD oggerp ~o
~me `odduia~q og Coinoip lr~ap~p l``epp~o li e}vreppawe `odduia`l~aoi denaud
lin peejp ~o brolnei lp {anecq lp voppabce
mlinp$oi upe og rlnao)
>)))6 VRODAPEP OG NECAWERQ
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
50/89
15
>)) {orjerp dlai~lai ~me {eb$pa~e lin
{eb broln`lp~aik)
)))6 VRODAPEP OG NECAWERQ
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
51/89
1;
Lwerlke og lcc )2
aina`l~aik ~ml~ veovce gec~ ~ml~ ~meq mln
celrien l pakiaga`li~ ldoui~) Repvoipe
~o p~l~edei~ A mlwe ~me ~rlaiaik lin puvvor~
A ieen ~o no dq {orj rakm~? lp dei~aoien
lbowe uiner Vraora~q 0 {lp >)0)
Geenbl`j ap oggeren aigordlccq ~o lcc
vrepei~erp oi l rekuclr blpap) Dore gordlc
ewlcul~aoi dee~aikp mlwe beei oggeren ~o lcc
~eld dedberp# {ma`m {acc `oddei`e pmor~cq)
>)
[ORJ E]VERAEI@E OVVOR^UIA^AEP
^lrke~p
^{o vcl`ep {acc be oggeren co`lc p~unei~p)
^meq {acc mlwe e}vopure ~o ~me keierlc
ruiiaik og l rlnao p~l~aoi# ~me ovvor~uia~q
~o re`orn lin ena~ ai~erwae{p# dlje
vrokrlddep lin {ra~e lin re`orn
lnwer~apedei~p)
Ou~`odep
< Pe`oinlrq P`mooc p~unei~ lin 7 Qou~m
[a~m L Dappaoi p~unei~p# lp vlr~ og ~mear
vrl`~a`lc {orj gor `ourpe)
>)))))))
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
52/89
11
p~l~edei~ A mlwe greenod ~o vcli lin
vronu`e dq o{i vrokrldde oi l p`lce og
< ~o 5 );#
{ma`m aina`l~ep pubp~li~alc lkreedei~)
Ai ~me ^eld Purweq# {mei lpjen ~o repvoin
~o p~l~edei~ L~ Pmaie GD# dq ovaiaoip peed
~o `oui~ oi l p`lce og < ~o 5) Lwerlke og 22
repvoipep {lp >)2 aina`l~aik ~ml~ veovce gec~
aiwocwen ai ne`apaoi$dljaik vro`eppep)
[mei lpjen ai geenbl`j gordp ag ~meq {oucn
caje ~o be dore aiwocwen ai ~me ruiiaik og ~me
p~l~aoi# dop~ repvoinei~p plan Io# bu~ {ere
jeei ~o `oi~aiue ~mear vrepei~ aiwocwedei~)
>)
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
53/89
)
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
54/89
))))
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
55/89
)))
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
56/89
5)6OU^@ODEP
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
57/89
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
58/89
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
59/89
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
60/89
5)6 OU^@ODEP
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
61/89
#666 mlp beei rlapen) A~ ap advor~li~ ~o lnn
~ml~# kawei ~ade# bo~m Likec lin ^ljeower
becaewe ~ml~ ~meq {acc pocwe ~mear vrobcedp lin
rel`m gaili`alc pup~lailbaca~q)
5)5)5 Pmaie GDp ~o~lc e}veina~ure gor a~p
veraon og broln`lp~aik grod Pev~edber ~o
Ne`edber 2662# ai`cunaik pe~$uv `op~p og
#666# {lp lbou~ Repoili`e GD mln moven ~o purwawe
{a~mou~ edvcoqaik l p~l~aoi dlilker# bu~#
gainaik ~ml~ ~me {orjcoln {lp ~oo krel~#
lvvoai~en oie ai dan$Pev~edber)
5)>)5 O~merp# pu`m lp Likec Rlnao# lre
rlvancq e|uavvaik wocui~eerp {a~m ~me pjaccp ~o
uiner~lje nlq$~o$nlq dlilkedei~ gui`~aoip po
~ml~ oie og ~me vrohe`~ celnerp `li be recelpen
gor guin$rlapaik) Lcpo Likec mlp ob~laien -gor
gree! ~me vlr~$~ade perwa`ep og l co`lc lu~mora~q
`odduia~q newecovdei~ {orjer ~o mecv {a~m
e}~erilc calapoi lin pve`alc ewei~p)
5)>)7 ^me vaco~ p`mede nedoip~rl~ep ~ml~
~me blpa` ~lpjp {ma`m li L``epp Rlnao p~l~aoi
ieenp ~o uiner~lje ag a~ ap ~o gucgac a~p vo~ei~alc
lin be gaili`alccq walbce lre p~l~aoi dlilkedei~#
~rlaiaik# gaili`alc lin keierlc lndaiap~rl~aoi
-ai`cunaik ~me `o$ornail~aoi og wocui~eerp!#
guin$rlapaik -vubca` pe`~or lin/or lnwer~apaik
lin pvoiporpmav! lin `odduia~q calapoi) A~ ap
voppabce ~o eiwaplke l {ecc$~rlaien krouv og
wocui~eerp beaik lbce ~o pmoucner du`m og ~me
burnei og p~l~aoi dlilkedei~) ^me plde
ap vroblbcq ~rue gor lpve`~p og ~rlaiaik lin
dei~oraik) Mo{ewer# ~me redlaiaik ~lpjp lre
cajecq ~o `lcc gor dore ~ ade ~mli dliq wocui~eerp
`li be e}ve`~en ~o mlwe l~ ~mear napvoplc) Ai
lnna~aoi# vrogeppaoilc e}ver~ape ap i e`epplrq
gor egga`aei~ lndaiap~rl~awe dlilkedei~) Guin$
rlapaik grod ~me vubca` pe`~or ap l povmap~a`l~en
lin clboraoup lr~ lin ~me e}veraei`e og Likec
Rlnao -pee beco{ @mlv~er 5 5)0$>! accup~rl~ep ~me
ui{apnod og ei~rup~aik `odder`alc plcep lin
5)6 OU^@ODEP
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
62/89
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
63/89
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
64/89
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
65/89
lnwer~apen oi ~me Coinoi${ane Lpali p~l~aoi#
Puirape Rlnao: ~mope {ma`m mlwe noie po#
keierlccq dlai~lai ~mear `odda~dei~ {mace lcpo
lnwer~apaik oi Nepa) Ai~erep~aikcq# ~me vrohe`~
`cladp io~ ~o poca`a~ lnwer~apedei~p# bu~ padvcq
~o repvoin ~o nedlin) Bq `oi~rlp~# Puirape
lpper~p ~ml~ oicq 6%
upen ~o no po# bu~ mlwe p{lvven ~o ~me
ie{`oder) [ml~ewer ~me ~ru~m og ~mepe `oigca`~aik
`cladp# a~ noep io~ peed ~ml~ Puirape mlp puggeren
krel~cq grod Nepap lrrawlc# lc~moukm ~me `odvliq
plqp a~ mlp eiclrken a~p ln plcep gor`e ai Pou~mlcc:
mo{ewer# a~ {oucn gelr gor ~me gu~ure ag l wlrae~q
og Lpali L``epp Rlnao p~l~aoip# lcco{en ~o pecc
lnwer~apaik -epve`alccq ag {a~mou~ l `lv!# {ere ~o
`ode ai~o beaik l`ropp ~me `lva~lc) P~lr
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
66/89
6#666 lnuc~p) Mo{ewer# l~ ~me ~ade
og ACR ca`ei`e reie{lc# `odder`alc lin
L``epp Rlnao lvvca`li~p pmoucn be lcco{en
~o `odve~e ai pu`m li lrel lin Og`od
pmoucn ea~mer l{lrn l `odder`alc or li
L``epp Rlnao ca`ei`e)
5)= CO@LC RLNAO E@OCOKQ
ROCE OG ^ME BB@
5)=)< [mei ~me Rlnao Lu~mora~q ai`cunen ~me
advl`~ og ~me L``epp Rlnao vaco~ vrohe`~p oi ~me
co`lc rlnao e`ocokq# a~ dlaicq mln ACR p~l~aoip
ai dain {a~m vlr~a`uclr regerei`e ~o voppabce
`odder`alc odve~a~aoi) Mo{ewer# a~ ap lcpo
lvvrovral~e ~o `oipaner ~me gu~ure recl~aoipmav
be~{eei L``epp Rlnao lin ~me BB@)
5)=)2 ^map ap gor ~mree `maeg relpoip) Garp~# a~
{oucn be `uraoup ag# {a~m a~p vubca` perwa`e reda~
lin -~mroukm ~me ca`ei`e gee! vubca` guinaik# ~me
BB@ {ere io~ ~o ~lje li ai~erep~ ai l ie{ ~aer og
rlnao broln`lp~aik nepakien ~o necawer po`alc
klai lin ~o overl~e oi l io~$gor$vroga~ blpap lin
{a~m ecedei~p og pubpanq) Aineen# lp mlp lcrelnq
beei nep`raben -pee @mlv~er
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
67/89
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
68/89
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
69/89
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
70/89
7)6REKUCL^ORQ APPUEP
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
71/89
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
72/89
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
73/89
) {mere l pdlcc `odder alc rlnao p~l~aoipmlrep l `odvlrlbce `owerlke lrel {a~m li
L``epp Rlnao p~l~aoi ~ml~ peccp lnwer~apaik#
li L``epp Rlnao ca`ei`e `oucn be oggeren
oicq ag ~me lvvca`li~ `li pmo{ ~ml~ a~ {acc
vrepei~ ca~~ce or io lnwer~apaik plcep lin
pvoiporpmav odve~a~aoi -@mlv~er 5);!
5) L``epp Rlnao ca ei`ep pmoucn upulccq io~ be
krli~en ai lrelp {mere l `odder`alc rlnao
p~l~aoip delpuren `owerlke lrel -D@L!
glccp beco{ >6#666 lnuc~p -e}`ev~ ai ~me `lpe
og da`ro D@Lp!) Mo{ewer# l~ ~me ~ade og ACR
ca`ei`e reie{lc# odder`alc lin L``epp
Rlnao lvvca`li~p pmoucn be lcco{en ~o`odve~e ai pu`m li lrel lin Og`od pmoucn
ea~mer l{lrn l `odder`alc or li L``epp
Rlnao ca`ei`e) -@mlv~er 5);!
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
79/89
Guin -@mlv~er 7)
be `odvce~en bq li L``epp Rlnao p~l~aoi
lvvca`li~ lp l ca`ei`e pubdappaoi lin l
vrodape og necawerq
li liiulc vubcapmen revor~ bq ~me p~l~aoi
og l`maewen ou~vu~p lin ou~`odep
~{o ovei gl`aca~l~en {orjpmovp og co`lc
p~ljemocnerp lin repanei~p# oi`e mlcg${lq
~mroukm ~me ca`ei`e veraon lin oi`e ai ~me
clp~ qelr og ~me ca`ei`e# ~o be `oiweien bq
~me p~l~aoi# {ma`m {oucn `oddei~ oi ~me
p~l~aoip vrokrepp lklaip~ a~p vcli
~me rekucl~or oicq ~o ai~erweie oi `odvclai~
-lp io{!# reklrnaik peraoup glacurep ~o dee~
~lrke~p lin oi uipl~apgl`~orq ou~`odep og
~me dan$~erd ovei dee~aik8 ~me ein og
ca`ei`e ovei dee~aik ~o be ~ljei ai~o
l``oui~ ai ~me ewei~ og l re$lvvca`l~aoi
-@mlv~er 7)2!
) Og`od pmoucn io~ l{lrn ca`ei`ep {a~m clrke
`owerlke lrelp) Lp {lp ~me iord gor ~me
vaco~ p`mede) D@Lp pmoucn upulccq be uv
~o l 5jd rlnaup
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
80/89
LVVEINA@EP
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
81/89
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
82/89
LVVEINA] 6#666# a~ ep~adl~ep ~ml~ dore ~mli #666
veovce mlwe cap~eien ~o ~me p~l~aoi!) Dop~ repvoinei~p vregerren dupa` vrokrlddaik lin oicq l
pdlcc ver`ei~lke glwouren @mrap~ali broln`lp~ `oi~ei~# pukkep~aik ~ml~ dliq cap~ei ~o Pmaie GD
lp l keierlcap~ broln`lp~er) P~roik lvvrowlc {lp re`ornen gor ~me anel og l Blibranke rlnao p~l~aoi)
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
88/89
-
8/3/2019 'New Voices: An Evaluation Of 15 Access Radio Projects' by Anthony Everitt
89/89
GROD OWER 05p PURWEQEN
P~l~aoip cap~eien ~o re`ei~cq K^GD ap ~me
>~m dop~ cap~eien ~o
< Ren Nrlkoi
2 Rlnao K^GD# @clppa`
P~l~aoi cap~eien ~o dop~ og~ei K^GD ap 7~m
< BB@ [lcep
2 Relc Rlnao# Rlnao @clppa` GD
> Ren Nrlkloi
5 K^GD# Rlnao 0
7ld 1ld ap dop~ vovuclr Rlnao cap~eiaik ~ade
1ld dannlq ap dop~ vovuclr K^GD cap~eiaik ~ade
GROD UINER 05p
P~l~aoip cap~eien ~o re`ei~cq K^GD ap 0rn
dop~ cap~eien ~o
< Rlnao