new the role of resonancesastronomy.nmsu.edu/danielcv/resonances.pdf · 2005. 3. 29. · realistic...

24
THE ROLE OF RESONANCES IN N-BODY MODELS OF BARRED GALAXIES Daniel Ceverino & Anatoly Klypin (New Mexico State University) 

Upload: others

Post on 16-Oct-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: New THE ROLE OF RESONANCESastronomy.nmsu.edu/danielcv/resonances.pdf · 2005. 3. 29. · Realistic orbits and resonances Natural frequencies of a general orbit: Ω , Κ , υ Pattern

THE ROLE OF RESONANCES

IN N­BODY MODELS OF BARRED GALAXIES

Daniel Ceverino & Anatoly Klypin(New Mexico State University)

Page 2: New THE ROLE OF RESONANCESastronomy.nmsu.edu/danielcv/resonances.pdf · 2005. 3. 29. · Realistic orbits and resonances Natural frequencies of a general orbit: Ω , Κ , υ Pattern

Realistic orbits and resonances

Natural frequencies of a general orbit:

Ω , Κ , υ

Pattern frequency: ΩP

l Κ + m1 Ω + n υ = m2 ΩP l , m i , n are integers.

RESONANCE!

Linear regime: A resonance produces a dramatic change in the evolution of the orbit.

This is not always the case.

Page 3: New THE ROLE OF RESONANCESastronomy.nmsu.edu/danielcv/resonances.pdf · 2005. 3. 29. · Realistic orbits and resonances Natural frequencies of a general orbit: Ω , Κ , υ Pattern

Resonances in the solar system: Trojan asteroids.

Libration around Lagrangian points L4 and L5 of the system Sun­Jupiter.

Example of a trapping resonance. 1:1 .

L4

L5

Page 4: New THE ROLE OF RESONANCESastronomy.nmsu.edu/danielcv/resonances.pdf · 2005. 3. 29. · Realistic orbits and resonances Natural frequencies of a general orbit: Ω , Κ , υ Pattern

Gaps.

Gaps

Trapping resonances

Page 5: New THE ROLE OF RESONANCESastronomy.nmsu.edu/danielcv/resonances.pdf · 2005. 3. 29. · Realistic orbits and resonances Natural frequencies of a general orbit: Ω , Κ , υ Pattern

Searching resonances in N­body simulations.

• Athanassoula 2003:

– Frozen potential.

– Ratio:(Ω – ΩP ) / Κ = ­l / m , where l and m are integers

(­1:2)

(1:2)

(­1:6)

(1:1)

Page 6: New THE ROLE OF RESONANCESastronomy.nmsu.edu/danielcv/resonances.pdf · 2005. 3. 29. · Realistic orbits and resonances Natural frequencies of a general orbit: Ω , Κ , υ Pattern

Radial frequency (K) measurements

• For every particle, we measure the frequencies during a given period of time (1-2 Gyrs) in which the pattern speed is almost constant.

– Κ: Fourier Analysis of the radial evolution.

Page 7: New THE ROLE OF RESONANCESastronomy.nmsu.edu/danielcv/resonances.pdf · 2005. 3. 29. · Realistic orbits and resonances Natural frequencies of a general orbit: Ω , Κ , υ Pattern

Angular frequency (Ω)

Ω: Averaged time of one angular revolution.

Time

Ang

le

Slope: Ω

Page 8: New THE ROLE OF RESONANCESastronomy.nmsu.edu/danielcv/resonances.pdf · 2005. 3. 29. · Realistic orbits and resonances Natural frequencies of a general orbit: Ω , Κ , υ Pattern

Face-on views of the Models using contours of equal density.

Page 9: New THE ROLE OF RESONANCESastronomy.nmsu.edu/danielcv/resonances.pdf · 2005. 3. 29. · Realistic orbits and resonances Natural frequencies of a general orbit: Ω , Κ , υ Pattern

weak bar (Pseudobulge) strong bar

Corotation radius.

Page 10: New THE ROLE OF RESONANCESastronomy.nmsu.edu/danielcv/resonances.pdf · 2005. 3. 29. · Realistic orbits and resonances Natural frequencies of a general orbit: Ω , Κ , υ Pattern

The frequency space: K vs Ω.

Commonly used in plasma physics and planetary

science. (Laskar 1990 )

Each point represents the orbit of a particle.

Straight lines with certain slopes define the main

resonances.

Page 11: New THE ROLE OF RESONANCESastronomy.nmsu.edu/danielcv/resonances.pdf · 2005. 3. 29. · Realistic orbits and resonances Natural frequencies of a general orbit: Ω , Κ , υ Pattern
Page 12: New THE ROLE OF RESONANCESastronomy.nmsu.edu/danielcv/resonances.pdf · 2005. 3. 29. · Realistic orbits and resonances Natural frequencies of a general orbit: Ω , Κ , υ Pattern

)4()( 22

2

2

2

2 Ω+Ω=∂Φ∂

=ΚdR

dR

RE ff

weak bar

ILCR

Higherorder

UH

IL

CROL

strong bar

Page 13: New THE ROLE OF RESONANCESastronomy.nmsu.edu/danielcv/resonances.pdf · 2005. 3. 29. · Realistic orbits and resonances Natural frequencies of a general orbit: Ω , Κ , υ Pattern

• (Ω – ΩP)/Κ = ­n /m

• Fraction of particles per unit bin.

• Low-order resonances (±1:m)

• Trapping resonances.

• No indications of gaps of low-order.

• 1σ statistical error.

Main resonances ( weak bar)

495m:

2

n=1 n=­1

Page 14: New THE ROLE OF RESONANCESastronomy.nmsu.edu/danielcv/resonances.pdf · 2005. 3. 29. · Realistic orbits and resonances Natural frequencies of a general orbit: Ω , Κ , υ Pattern

Main resonances ( strong bar)

Page 15: New THE ROLE OF RESONANCESastronomy.nmsu.edu/danielcv/resonances.pdf · 2005. 3. 29. · Realistic orbits and resonances Natural frequencies of a general orbit: Ω , Κ , υ Pattern

A portrait of resonances for a weak bar.

Page 16: New THE ROLE OF RESONANCESastronomy.nmsu.edu/danielcv/resonances.pdf · 2005. 3. 29. · Realistic orbits and resonances Natural frequencies of a general orbit: Ω , Κ , υ Pattern

OL

IL ­1:4

­1:9

1:5 CR

Page 17: New THE ROLE OF RESONANCESastronomy.nmsu.edu/danielcv/resonances.pdf · 2005. 3. 29. · Realistic orbits and resonances Natural frequencies of a general orbit: Ω , Κ , υ Pattern

Inner Lindblad

IL is not

localized at a

given radius

Page 18: New THE ROLE OF RESONANCESastronomy.nmsu.edu/danielcv/resonances.pdf · 2005. 3. 29. · Realistic orbits and resonances Natural frequencies of a general orbit: Ω , Κ , υ Pattern

Third model: Corotation. Selected particles in corotation at 3.5 Gyr

COROTATION

Particles are trapped at corotation.

0.1 Gyr

3.5 Gyr

4.4 Gyr

Page 19: New THE ROLE OF RESONANCESastronomy.nmsu.edu/danielcv/resonances.pdf · 2005. 3. 29. · Realistic orbits and resonances Natural frequencies of a general orbit: Ω , Κ , υ Pattern

Instantaneous change of angular momentum.

• Torque field.

• Areas in which the angular momentum of the particles increases (positive torque) or decreases (negative torque).

Positive

Negative

Page 20: New THE ROLE OF RESONANCESastronomy.nmsu.edu/danielcv/resonances.pdf · 2005. 3. 29. · Realistic orbits and resonances Natural frequencies of a general orbit: Ω , Κ , υ Pattern

AM change over a longer interval• Maximum increment and

decrement in angular momentum.

• The maximum (positive) and minimum (negative) areas of AM change lie at corotation radius.

+

­

Page 21: New THE ROLE OF RESONANCESastronomy.nmsu.edu/danielcv/resonances.pdf · 2005. 3. 29. · Realistic orbits and resonances Natural frequencies of a general orbit: Ω , Κ , υ Pattern

A example of a orbit that circulates along corotation.

The particle is trapped at corotation radius at 1.6 Gyr.

Selected particle to be near corotation at 3.5 Gyr.

reference frame rotating with the bar.

Page 22: New THE ROLE OF RESONANCESastronomy.nmsu.edu/danielcv/resonances.pdf · 2005. 3. 29. · Realistic orbits and resonances Natural frequencies of a general orbit: Ω , Κ , υ Pattern

A slow orbit: Libration around a lagrangian point at corotation .

++

­­

No net change of angular momentum+­

Page 23: New THE ROLE OF RESONANCESastronomy.nmsu.edu/danielcv/resonances.pdf · 2005. 3. 29. · Realistic orbits and resonances Natural frequencies of a general orbit: Ω , Κ , υ Pattern

A last result: Resonances in the halo

• Similar pattern of resonances.

• We select halo particles which are close to the disk so the interaction with the bar is stronger.

Page 24: New THE ROLE OF RESONANCESastronomy.nmsu.edu/danielcv/resonances.pdf · 2005. 3. 29. · Realistic orbits and resonances Natural frequencies of a general orbit: Ω , Κ , υ Pattern

CONCLUSIONS

First time that resonances are detected in a N­body simulation with a evolving disk in a living halo using only their trajectories.

Trapping resonances. No gaps are found.

There are no evolution after particles get trapped.

Corotation captures particles in a ring outside the bar.

Inner Lindblad is not localized at a given radius.

The halo also exhibits trapping resonances.