new nlrb decision: independent contractor...
TRANSCRIPT
New NLRB Decision:
Independent Contractor ClassificationEntrepreneurial Activity, Common Law Factors, Interaction With Federal, State and Local Laws
Today’s faculty features:
1pm Eastern | 12pm Central | 11am Mountain | 10am Pacific
The audio portion of the conference may be accessed via the telephone or by using your computer's
speakers. Please refer to the instructions emailed to registrants for additional information. If you
have any questions, please contact Customer Service at 1-800-926-7926 ext. 1.
WEDNESDAY, APRIL 10, 2019
Presenting a live 90-minute webinar with interactive Q&A
Alan I. Model, Shareholder, Littler Mendelson, Newark, N.J.
Teresa R. Tracy, Partner, Freeman Freeman & Smiley, Los Angeles
Tips for Optimal Quality
Sound Quality
If you are listening via your computer speakers, please note that the quality
of your sound will vary depending on the speed and quality of your internet
connection.
If the sound quality is not satisfactory, you may listen via the phone: dial
1-866-258-2056 and enter your PIN when prompted. Otherwise, please
send us a chat or e-mail [email protected] immediately so we can address
the problem.
If you dialed in and have any difficulties during the call, press *0 for assistance.
Viewing Quality
To maximize your screen, press the F11 key on your keyboard. To exit full screen,
press the F11 key again.
FOR LIVE EVENT ONLY
Continuing Education Credits
In order for us to process your continuing education credit, you must confirm your
participation in this webinar by completing and submitting the Attendance
Affirmation/Evaluation after the webinar.
A link to the Attendance Affirmation/Evaluation will be in the thank you email
that you will receive immediately following the program.
For additional information about continuing education, call us at 1-800-926-7926
ext. 2.
FOR LIVE EVENT ONLY
Program Materials
If you have not printed the conference materials for this program, please
complete the following steps:
• Click on the ^ symbol next to “Conference Materials” in the middle of the left-
hand column on your screen.
• Click on the tab labeled “Handouts” that appears, and there you will see a
PDF of the slides for today's program.
• Double click on the PDF and a separate page will open.
• Print the slides by clicking on the printer icon.
FOR LIVE EVENT ONLY
Proprietary and Confidential
Presented by
ALAN I. MODEL
Shareholder, Littler, Newark
Cell 973.477.4002
Direct 973.848.4740
TERESA R. TRACY
Partner, Freeman Freeman & Smiley
Direct 310.255.6176
Fax 310.255.6276
Proprietary and Confidential
Agenda
• Employer –Employee Relationship
• Independent Contractor Classification
• Discuss Recent Developments
• Identify “red flags” that may suggest independent contractor misclassification
• Steps to Minimize Risk
6
Proprietary and ConfidentialProprietary and Confidential
Today’s Workplace:Employees, Independent Contractors and
Joint Employers/ Employees
7
Proprietary and Confidential
• Worker is the full-time employee of the Company
• Worker is an employee of both the Company and a Third Party Client Company (joint employee/ joint employer) (PEO in agreed-to instances)
• Worker is an employee of the Company and a nonemployee or independent contractor of a Third Party Client Company (Franchisee / Franchisor)
• Worker is a nonemployee (or independent contractor) of the Company and an employee of the Third Party Client Company (temp agency, staff leasing co., etc.)
• Worker is a non employee (or independent contractor)of both the Company and a Third Party Client Company
Possible Arrangements in the Workplace Between Worker and Company
8
Proprietary and Confidential
Employer- Employee Relationship
9
Proprietary and Confidential
Most Workers Are Employees
• FLSA defines “employ” as “to suffer or permitto work”
• “Broadest definition of employment under the law because it covers work that the employer directs or allows to take place”
10
Proprietary and Confidential
Contrast with Independent Contractor Relationship
• Independent Contractors are economically independent,
– Self-employed
– Often business owners
– Freedom to come and go, perform job in any manner that accomplishes the desired result
• Frequently over-used classification
– Job titles not determinative; “economic realities” control
– Contracts designating people as independent contractors generally not effective
– Much litigation stems from classification of people who are really employees as independent contractors
• Largely considered as an abused and misused classification
11
Proprietary and Confidential
The “Shared Economy” or “Gig Economy”:
New Addition to the IC Picture
• Loosely defined as an economic model in which technology platforms allow individuals to borrow, rent, or use assets owned by someone else…
• A significant portion of the Gig Economy work as Independent Contractors
12
Proprietary and Confidential
Employees’ Rights, Generally
• Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA)– Minimum Wage ($7.25 per hour worked) – Overtime Wages (1.5 times the “regular rate” for all hours
worked over 40, unless exempt)
• National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) – Right to Engage in “Concerted Activity”– Right to organize and collectively bargain over terms and
conditions of employment
• Discrimination Laws– Title VII (sex, gender, religion, race, national origin)– Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)– Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA)– Equal Pay Act (EPA)
• Worker Safety (OSHA, state worker’s compensation)• Security and Benefits (ACA, ERISA, state
unemployment insurance)
13
Proprietary and ConfidentialProprietary and Confidential
The Allure and Risks of Treating Workers as Independent Contractors
14
Proprietary and Confidential
To 1099 or W-2?Independent Contractors vs. Employees
GENERAL DEFINITIONS
• EMPLOYEE = A person hired to perform services for another who has the right to control the performance by the worker.
• INDEPENDENT CONTRACTOR = A person who performs services for another who is interested only in the outcome, not the details of how the work gets done.
15
Proprietary and Confidential
What are the Benefits of Hiring ICs?
• Why do employers use ICs over employees?
• No matching payroll (FICA) taxes
• No unemployment taxes or state disability taxes
• No workers compensation insurance
• No extensive record keeping
• No benefits (insurance, vacation, sick, etc.)
• No FMLA or OSHA protection
• Increased flexibility in matching “head count” to work flow
• Termination limited only by terms of contract
• No union organizing
• Easier
• Only downside is lack of control… OR IS IT???
16
Proprietary and Confidential
Risks for Misclassifying Workers as ICs: Pressure From All Sides
• Federal agencies, state agencies, labor unions, and other advocates focused on stopping “wage theft” resulting from IC misclassification
• Studies estimate federal govt. loses between $2.7 and $4.3 billion annually
A Perfect Storm
IRS
DOLStates
Agencies
Unions
17
Proprietary and Confidential
Risks for Misclassifying Workers as ICs:Liability Goes Far Beyond Unpaid Overtime
Workers’ Comp
Taxes
Stock Options
Unemployment
Title VII/ADA/ADEA
Retirement
Affordable Care Act
18
Proprietary and Confidential
Risks for Misclassifying Workers as ICs:Agreements with State Agencies
• U.S. DOL has entered into Memoranda of Understanding with the IRS & 40 states (and the District of Columbia) concerning IC misclassification
• These partnerships provide for data sharing, referrals, and coordinated enforcement efforts between the DOL and these states
(https://www.dol.gov/whd/state/statecoordination.htm)
19
Proprietary and ConfidentialProprietary and Confidential
The Varying Legal Frameworks for Evaluating IC Treatment &
Recent Developments
20
Proprietary and ConfidentialProprietary and Confidential
Few problems in the law have given greater variety of application and conflict in results than the cases arising in the borderland between what is clearly an employer-employee relationship and what is clearly one of independent entrepreneurial dealing
NLRB v. Hearst Publications, Inc., 322 U.S. 111 (1944)
21
Proprietary and Confidential
• Key Term is “Independent”
• Contract language or the IC’s preference do not control the determination; the court will look at the actual relationship of the parties.
• The more control exerted by the principle, the more likely the worker is an employee.
• The default status is an employment relationship.
Refresher: Who Is An Independent Contractor?
22
Proprietary and Confidential
• Federal law alone has multiple different tests for determining IC status
• Layered on top of these, states may have up to six different tests under different laws
Over 100 Different Legal Tests in the US
IRS 20-Factor
Test
FLSA Economic Reality
Test
Common Law Test
Over 100 State Law
Tests
NLRBTest
23
Proprietary and Confidential
The IC Tests Under Federal Law
24
Proprietary and Confidential
NLRB Test
By reverting to the common-law test, the NLRB in
SuperShuttle DFW, Inc., 367 NLRB No. 75 (2019) noted:
entrepreneurial opportunity is not an independent common-law factor, let alone a “superfactor” . . . . Nor is it an
“overriding consideration,” a “shorthand formula,” or a “trump card” in the independent-contractor analysis. Rather .
. . entrepreneurial opportunity, like employer control, is a principle by which to evaluate the overall effect of the
common-law factors on a putative contractor’s independence to pursue economic gain. Indeed, employer control and
entrepreneurial opportunity are opposite sides of the same coin: in general, the more control, the less scope for
entrepreneurial initiative, and vice versa.
25
Proprietary and Confidential
The NLRB Weighs in . . . Again!
• Trump NLRB clarifies its position on the independent contractor issue in SuperShuttle DFW, Inc. - January 2019
Concerned SuperShuttle franchisees, who drive customers to and from Dallas-area airports
⎻ Board returned to the common-law independent contractor test in effect prior to 2014
1. The extent of control, which by agreement, the master may exercise over the details of the work
2. Whether or not the one employed is engaged in a distinct occupation or business
3. The kind of occupation, referencing whether the work is usually done under the direction of the employer or by a specialist without supervision
4. The skill required
5. Whether the employer or the worker supplies the tools and place of work for the person doing the work
6. The length of time the worker is employed
7. The method of payment, whether by time or by job
8. Whether or not the work is part of the regular business of the employer
9. Whether or not the parties believe they are creating a master-servant relationship
10. Whether the principal is or is not in business
Criticized the prior Board for merging the common-law test into an economic realities test that diminished the entrepreneurial opportunity analysis and overemphasized the right to control test
26
Proprietary and Confidential
Impact of SuperShuttle on Other Laws
• NLRB is a federal agency of limited jurisdiction
• Whole groups of businesses are excluded
• Scope of power limited to employees’ rights to organize and
bargain collectively
• Admittedly swayed by political appointees and their agendas
27
Proprietary and Confidential
Impact of SuperShuttle on Other Laws
• SuperShuttle does not change the standard or analysis of independent contractor/employee status under other federal, state, and local laws
• Employers face confusing, overlapping and differing standards in a wide variety of areas
28
Proprietary and Confidential
Impact of SuperShuttle on Other Laws
• Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA)
• not directly impacted by SuperShuttle
• uses “economic realities” test which has multiple factors
• the guidance on even this test changes from time to time
• unclear whether arguments based on SuperShuttle will be
successful
29
Proprietary and Confidential
Impact of SuperShuttle on Other Laws
• Title VII
• not directly impacted by SuperShuttle
• uses what can be described as hybrid economic realities/common
law test which has multiple factors
• unclear whether arguments based on SuperShuttle will be
successful
30
Proprietary and Confidential
Impact of SuperShuttle on Other Laws
• FMLA
• uses same definition of “employee” as FLSA
• split in Circuit Court approaches
• unclear whether arguments based on SuperShuttle will be
successful
31
Proprietary and Confidential
Impact of SuperShuttle on Other Laws
• ADA and ADEA
• not directly impacted by SuperShuttle
• uses common law test with many different factors
• mix of economic realities/common law control test
• unclear whether arguments based on SuperShuttle will be
successful
32
Proprietary and Confidential
IRS “20 Factors” Test
11. No required reports
12. Payment for the result
13. Business expenses
14. Own tools
15. Significant investment
16. Possible profit or loss
17. Working for multiple firms
18. Services available to the
general public
19. Limited right to discharge
20. Liability for non-completion
1. No instructions
2. No training
3. No integration
4. Services do not have to
be rendered personally
5. Control over assistants
6. No continuing relationship
7. Work hours
8. Time to pursue other work
9. Job location
10. No requirements on the
order or sequence of work
33
Proprietary and Confidential
Impact of SuperShuttle on Other Laws
• State and Local Laws
• State and local laws have fewer “ties” to federal laws
• Even individual states have internally overlapping and differing
tests for “employee” status
• Limited federal preemption
34
Proprietary and Confidential
Impact of SuperShuttle on Other Laws
• State and Local Laws – California
• Labor Code (minimum wage, overtime, breaks, expenses, etc.)
• Wage Orders (cover many but not all aspects of Labor Code)
• Workers’ Compensation
• Unemployment Insurance Benefits
35
Proprietary and Confidential
Impact of SuperShuttle on Other Laws
• State and Local Laws – California
Dynamex decision in 2018
• Wage Orders have three alternative tests:
a) to exercise control over the wages, hours or working conditions, or
b) to suffer or permit to work, or
c) to engage, thereby creating a common law employment relationship.
36
Proprietary and Confidential
Impact of SuperShuttle on Other Laws
• State and Local Laws – California
Dynamex decision in 2018
• Under the second (suffer or permit to work) test, the hiring entity must prove that an independent contractor:
a) is free from the control and direction of the hirer in connection with the performance of the work, both under the contract for the performance of such work and in fact;
b) performs work that is outside the usual course of the hiring entity’s business; and
c) is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, or business of the same nature as the work performed for the hiring entity.
37
Proprietary and Confidential
Impact of SuperShuttle on Other Laws
• State and Local Laws – Indiana
• Unemployment benefits – ABC test with different factors than
Dynamex
• Workers’ compensation – IRS rules
38
Proprietary and Confidential
Impact of SuperShuttle on Other Laws
• State and Local Laws – New Jersey
• Wage Laws require hiring entity to prove that independent contractor:
a) has been and will continue to be free from control or direction over the performance of such services, both contractually and factually;
b) provides services either outside the usual course of the hiring entity’s business for which services are provided, or performs services outside of all the places of business of the hiring entity; and
c) is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, profession or business.
39
Proprietary and Confidential
Best Practices
1. Avoid language commonly used in employment relationship
2. Avoid contractual terms and factual evidence of relationships common to employment relationship
3. Identify highest risk jurisdiction and law and comply with it
4. Maximize compliance
5. Update and maintain comprehensive and realistic agreements
6. Strong and enforceable arbitration provision
40
Proprietary and Confidential
• Employ/Employee/Employment
• Full time
• Part time
•Wages
• Payroll
• Supervise
•Direct
•Discipline
•Apply/Interview
Terms that Don’t Apply to Independent Contractors
41
Proprietary and Confidential
• Independent Contractors Can:• Work when they want
• Accept the jobs they want
• Wear what they want
• Take the route they want
• Employ others to perform the work
• Use the equipment they want
• Contract with competitors
• Contract with customers
• Promote their own business
Signs of Independent Contractor Status
42
Proprietary and Confidential
BUT: Watch for IC Red Flags
There is a problem if:
• IC performs same work as employees
• IC is paid by the hour, not by the project
• Company provides training to IC
• Company controls hours worked by IC
• Company provides tools or equipment to IC
• IC cannot refuse or negotiate work
• Work is performed by IC on a “full-time” basis and relationships are long-term and continuous
• IC Agreement includes a restrictive covenant
43
Proprietary and Confidential
Risky Practices• Utilizing Employees and ICs for the same
job
• Having ICs “report” to local supervisors
• Providing guidance on “how to” do the work
• Allowing long, protracted relationships.
Best Practices
Best Practices
• Work with ICs who are incorporated and serve other businesses (even competitors)
• Present projects as outcome-oriented.
• Limit duration of engagement.
• Allow for negotiation of contract terms and prices, when possible.
44
Proprietary and Confidential
$$$ Misclassification Liability $$$
• Failure to recognize coverage and benefits for not only misclassified individual but other acknowledged employees where there is “employee numerosity” threshold
• Failure to provide mandatory compensation and benefits
• Failure to comply with mandatory requirements (e.g., minimum wage, overtime)
• Penalties (e.g., liquidated damages under FLSA, break and last paycheck penalties in California)
• Attorneys’ fees
45
Proprietary and Confidential
Misclassification Issues With Benefit Plans
• Failure to offer coverage for medical plans
• Failure to follow terms of retirement plans
• Multiple employer welfare arrangements
• Employer reporting for ACA
• Record retention for hours of service for benefit plans
• Liabilities (penalties and past due taxes of FICA/FUTA, Medicare, and state and local income taxes)
These issues apply equally to liability for IC Misclassification
and Joint Employment.
GOAL: Make sure workers receive proper pay and benefits46
Proprietary and Confidential
Taxes
• Employer is the party “in control of the payment of wages”
⎻ That may be the common law employer, or it may be an entity that would be a joint or co-employer under employment laws
• Deciding the correct employer can have significant tax implications because of the withholding, reporting, and remitting obligations
KEY: Someone needs to pay the taxes (social security and unemployment taxes, etc.)
47
Proprietary and ConfidentialProprietary and Confidential
How Can Company Be Sure They Get This Right?
48
Proprietary and Confidential
Evaluate
• Determine whether the benefits of arrangement (use of staffing firm, leasing, outsourcing of entire functions, etc.) are worth potential risks
• Recognize that agreements and approaches must be tailored to the particular arrangement and context
• Trust but Verify…audit practices
49
Proprietary and Confidential
Understanding Key Risk Areas: More Important Than Ever
• Lack of due diligence with respect to potential business partners
• Lack of training and auditing of “on the ground” practices and supervision
• Nature of work performed and interaction with “regular” employees
• Management overlap/shared services/procedures
• Written agreements that reserve more control than necessary with respect toterms and conditions of employment
50
Proprietary and Confidential
Due Diligence
• Essential to contract with a reputable company with good service, financial wherewithal and record of positive employee relations
• Investigate (independently)
• Obtain reps and warranties regarding legal compliance
51
Proprietary and Confidential
Check Your Agreements
• Explicitly provide that staffing agency is solely responsible for hiring, firing, promoting, disciplining, and compensating employees
• Improve indemnification clause to explicitly cover employment-related claims
• Strengthen independent contractor provision by explicitly acknowledging that employer utilizing contingent workers employed by staffing agency is not a joint employer
• Consider mandating employment practices liability insurance
52
Proprietary and Confidential
Sample Indemnification ClauseYou agree to indemnify us against any claims related to your noncompliance or alleged noncompliance with any law, ordinance, rule or regulation, including any allegation that we are a joint employer or otherwise responsible for your acts or omissions relating to your employees
Check Your Agreements
53
Proprietary and Confidential
Other Language That Can Help…
• Distinguish between requirements and recommendations
• Focus on results rather than process
• Make sure documentation distinguishes between employees and contingent workers
• Explicitly include IC and/or joint employment-related disclaimers
54