new kane county 2012-2016 community health improvement plan · 2019. 4. 23. · clinical care all...
TRANSCRIPT
Kane County 2012-2016 Community HealtH improvement plan
years of service
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
A Community Health Improvement Plan is a long-term, systematic effort to address health problems in a community based on results from a community health assessment. The plan recommends priorities for action and is used by health and other governmental, education, and social service agencies and organizations to implement policies and programs that promote health. The 2012-2016 Kane County Community Health Improvement Plan reflects the understanding that the quality of the communities where we live, work, and play is as important to achieving good health as going to the doctor for regular checkups, proper nutrition, and adequate physical activity. There are many factors, or determinants, that affect health and have a tremendous influence on health outcomes. The physical environment, social and economic factors, and clinical care all play a part in an individual’s health and are all incorporated into the plan.
Kane County is recognized nationally as leader in integrating health, land use and transportation planning. In 2010, acknowledging the importance of this integration, the Kane County Board became the first county in Illinois to formally provide policy direction to link health, land use, and transportation planning into a comprehensive master plan. As part of the formal integration and for the first time, there will be a stand-alone chapter on community health in the Kane County 2040 Plan. In 2011, we initiated a comprehensive community health assessment, aligning planning efforts with the five hospitals in Kane County, two United Way agencies, and the INC Board, who all provided direction and leadership to the process as well as resources and expertise.The Community Health Improvement Plan guides policy and program decisions that optimize health and well-being. Analysis of health, social and economic data as well as direct input from the community led to the identification of the top six threats to community health – obesity, chronic disease, infant mortality, childhood lead poisoning, communicable disease, and poor social & emotional wellness – and the selection of four priorities that will address these threats. The plan recommends 16 strategies to improve health and well-being across the lifespan for all Kane County residents. This is truly the community’s plan, designed to be implemented by community agencies, partners, and residents across the county. Working together we can ensure Healthy People, Healthy Living, Healthy Communities in Kane County and reach our vision of having the healthiest residents in Illinois.
1
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Executive Summary ........................................................................................................................ i
Part 1 Introduction
Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 2
Community Health Improvement Plan Partnership ..................................................................... 10
Update on Past Priorities .............................................................................................................. 11
Part 2 Community Health Assessment
Methodology and Community Participation ................................................................................ 24
Assets ........................................................................................................................................... 28
Health Status of Kane County...................................................................................................... 31
Top Community Health Assessment Findings ............................................................................ 45
Part 3 Community Health Improvement Plan
Community Health Improvement Plan ........................................................................................ 62
Priorities and Strategies ............................................................................................................... 64
Strategy Selection ........................................................................................................................ 68
Implementation ............................................................................................................................ 90
Appendix A - Progress Report on Strategy Implementation 2007-2011 ........ See Comprehensive Version
Appendix B – Comprehensive Kane County Community Health Assessment Databook ........ See Comprehensive Version
Appendix C – Acknowledgements ............................................................................................. 92
2
Introduction
Located 40 miles west of Chicago, Kane County is home to 515,269 people who reside in 30
municipalities. Kane is ranked as fifth largest by population of 102 Illinois counties and 51st
largest by area (522 sq miles). By 2040, the population is expected to reach 800,000 persons with
corresponding growth projected for households and jobs (53% and 64% respectively).1
2000 Census 2010 Census 2040 Estimate 404,119 515,269 (27.5% increase) 800,000 (55% increase)
The demographic profile has changed dramatically in the past two decades. The 2010 U.S.
Census reports the Hispanic population has tripled since 1990 and now stands at 158,390, or
31% of the total population, the highest proportion of Hispanic residents of all Illinois counties.
Kane County is notable for its age distribution. The median age in Kane is 35.4 years (national
median age of 36.7 years) and the fastest growing segment of the population is 55-69 year olds.
Children less than 18 years make up 34% (174,763) of the population. As it has throughout the
nation, the economic downturn is also affecting our residents in many ways that ultimately affect
our greatest resource: the health of our communities. Now, more than ever, we must address the
most pressing issues affecting our health to ensure that current and future Kane County residents
lead healthy, happy, and prosperous lives. Through periodic community health assessments, we
can examine these changes and focus our efforts based on the results.
Together, community health assessment and planning are important tools to use in determining
the overall health of a community and identifying the key health issues facing a community.
The quality of the community where we live, work, and play is as important to achieving good
health as going to the doctor for regular checkups, proper nutrition, and adequate physical
activity. There are many factors, or determinants, that affect health and have a tremendous
influence on health outcomes. The physical environment, social and economic factors, and
clinical care all play a part in an individual’s health. Instead of looking at health as purely the
absence of illness, the Kane County Health Department uses a different model where we see
1 “Population Forecast” Chicago Metropolitan Agency for Planning, http://www.cmap.illinois.gov/population-forecast
3
many factors relating to health: the economic & social opportunities and resources, living and
working conditions in homes and communities, medical care, and personal behavior. Figure 1
illustrates how these determinants work together to create a foundation of health and well-being.
These factors are not separate and can be influenced by each other. For example, personal
behaviors are shaped as much by social context as they are by individual risk factors.
Socioeconomic conditions, peer influences, marketing tactics, and policies and practices all
affect individual choices.
Figure 1: Influences on Health, Robert Wood Johnson Foundation
Another model the county is using to examine population health is the County Health Rankings.
In 2009, the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation collaborated with the University of Wisconsin
Population Health Institute to create health reports for all counties in all 50 states, called the
County Health Rankings. These reports allow counties to be compared, or ranked, relative to
other counties within each state. The University of Wisconsin Population Health Institute
developed a model for measuring health that includes several determinants of health including:
Physical Environment
Social and Economic Factors
Policies to promote healthier
homes, neighborhoods,
schools and workplaces
Policies to promote
economic development and reduce poverty
Policies to promote child and youth
development and education, infancy
through college
4
Clinical Care
Health Behaviors
Figure 2 shows how the various determinants of health, combined with programs and policies,
lead to certain health outcomes, measured by mortality (how long people live) and morbidity
(how healthy people feel while alive).
Figure 2 County Health Rankings Model
5
With this model, a full 50% of health outcomes come from social and economic factors and the
physical environment, two areas that were not traditionally considered when assessing overall
health. Looking at Figure 2, health behaviors like tobacco use, alcohol consumption, and diet
and exercise can be directly related to the physical environment through the use of land use
policies and zoning. For example, if there is limited access to fresh produce in a neighborhood,
increasing the number of outlets that offer fresh fruits and vegetables makes the healthy choice
the easier choice. People living in food deserts cannot easily find healthy food options and often
choose the unhealthy, accessible fast food prevalent in their community. With tobacco and
alcohol use, the density of outlets that offer tobacco and alcohol can be limited, making it more
difficult to access these products which are known to have a detrimental effect on health.
Housing infrastructure plays a key role in the health of residents as well. Providing affordable
housing for all residents allows many people to live in healthier communities and lower their risk
for health problems caused by the environment. Residents who live in substandard housing have
an increased risk of being exposed to pollution, which can lead to health problems like asthma.
In addition, homes built before 1970 may have lead paint, exposing families to lead. Lead
exposure has negative impacts on the growth and development of young children and can be
prevented by a combined effort of the health department, medical community, parents, landlords,
contractors, and local decision makers.
Land use and transportation planners can plan walkable neighborhoods which provide residents
with the necessary amenities (sidewalks, access to trails, complete streets) to incorporate exercise
into a daily routine which leads to better health outcomes. Access to parks and recreational
facilities also makes physical activity more convenient. These factors are influenced by land use
and transportation planning policies and ordinances.
One key determinant that falls under both models is socioeconomic status. Low socioeconomic
status is associated with an increased risk for many diseases, including cardiovascular disease,
arthritis, diabetes, chronic respiratory diseases, and cervical cancer as well as frequent mental
distress.2 For example, in Kane County, the highest rates of adults who have been told by a
2 Brennan Ramirez LK, Baker EA, Metzler M. “Promoting Health Equity: A Resource to Help Communities Address Social Determinants of Health.” Atlanta: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention; 2008. http://www.cdc.gov/nccdphp/dach/chhep/pdf/SDOHworkbook.pdf
6
doctor that they have angina/coronary heart disease are those with the lowest income levels.
Figure 3 below demonstrates this difference:
Figure 3: Kane County Community Health Survey 2011
The department is able to analyze the information collected during a health assessment and
compare it by factors like age, income, race/ethnicity, and educational attainment. These factors
present other disparities in the community and allow the entire health system to focus on where
help is needed most.
In 2010, the Kane County Board became the only county government in Illinois to provide
policy direction to formally integrate health, land use, and transportation into a comprehensive
master plan. The Kane County 2040 Plan will have a stand-alone chapter dedicated to public
health entitled “Community Health” and includes an introductory chapter which describes how
health is the overarching theme for the plan. In 2011, this formal collaboration between the
planning disciplines was titled “Quality of Kane” to capture its mission to maintain and enhance
an exceptional Kane County with Healthy People, Healthy Living and Healthy Communities.
The three groups had previously worked together to create the Fit Kids 2020 Plan, but this is a
0.0%
1.0%
2.0%
3.0%
4.0%
5.0%
6.0%
7.0%
8.0%
9.0%
Percent of Adult Population
Income
Percent of Kane County adults who report having been told they have angina or coronary heart
disease & Income
7
formal recognition of the collaboration. Figure 4 demonstrates how the three areas work
together to align planning efforts.
Figure 4: Quality of Kane Model
To kick off the campaign, the three departments held a series of public open houses in April and
May of 2011, inviting the community to learn about planning in Kane County and how the three
disciplines are working together on current and future plans. The six open houses were held
throughout the county in urban and rural areas. Attendees learned about the past, present, and
future of Kane County planning and were invited to discuss plans with staff members present at
the events. Approximately 150 attended the events over the six nights.
Soon after, work started on the individual chapters for the 2040 Plan which included land use,
transportation and health planning staff. The planners shared resources and worked together on
outlines for the chapters. In addition to the Community Health chapter, the 2040 Plan has a
chapter on Mobility and Connectivity which was written by the transportation planners. Staff
presented draft versions of the chapters to the Kane County Regional Planning Commission,
where they received feedback and guidance and continued editing them throughout the fall.
A second series of Public Open Houses took place in November, with two locations in urban
areas of the county. The public was invited to share their comments with the health, land use and
transportation planning staff present. Sixty people attended these sessions and gave the planners
constructive feedback on the plans presented. The health department received comments that
Community Health
Transportation Land Use
2040 Transportation Plan
Bicycle Pedestrian Plan
Bus Rapid Transit Study
2012-2016 Community Health Improvement Plan
KCHD Strategic Plan
Fit Kids 2020 Plan
2040 Plan
2040 Energy Plan
Farmland Preservation
8
were focused around services for senior citizens, including more affordable housing, more
healthy meal options, and better public transportation options.
The next step for the Quality of Kane campaign is the launch of the Kane County Planning
Cooperative. The main mission of the Cooperative will be to encourage education and
information sharing related to planning and to assist with local planning decisions. The
Cooperative will be staffed primarily with County planners from three departments –
Development and Community Services, Health and Division of Transportation (KDOT) – in
addition to support from the Chicago Metropolitan Agency for Planning (CMAP). The
Cooperative will fill the gap that currently exists due to the reduction or elimination of planning
staff among municipal and other partners and will be open to municipal staff, elected and
appointed officials, and other decision-makers. See Figure 5 for the Cooperative model.
Municipalities, park districts, school districts, hospitals and local taxing bodies with a critical
stake in local land use decisions may be understaffed but faced with a need to address new issues
Figure 5
9
not previously seen at the magnitudes they are today. The
Kane County Planning Cooperative will establish a county-
wide partnership that provides direct technical assistance
and information for municipalities and local units of
government to make Kane County and its partners more
competitive for public and private grant funds. Participants
can benefit from a streamlined grant application preparation
process that meets current collaboration requirements from
funders and enhances opportunities for success.
A key objective for the health department is to integrate
Health Impact Assessment as part of projects, plans, and
policies at the county and municipal level. Health Impact
Assessment (HIA) helps policy makers analyze potential
health impacts by bringing together scientific data, health
expertise and public input to identify the potential—and
often overlooked—health effects of proposed new laws,
regulations, projects and programs. It offers practical
recommendations for ways to minimize risks and capitalize
on opportunities to improve health. HIA is a new tool that
is gaining favor with planning professionals nationwide
because it emphasizes the connection between the built
environment and health. Although the assessments are
focused on health, they can be most effective in the non-
health field: building a new transit system, developing an
agricultural plan, planning a city’s growth or deciding where
to locate a new school.
The 2011 Community Health Assessment plays an
important role in local health department voluntary
accreditation through the Public Health Accreditation Board
(PHAB). According to PHAB, “The goal of the national
Health Impact Assessment (HIA) Examples
The Kane County Health Department and Development and Community Services Department jointly applied for and were awarded a grant in 2011 to undergo training and conduct an HIA. The HIA team is examining an amendment to the county’s Farmland Protection Program. In 2012-2013, the Kane County Farmland Protection Commission and the Kane County Board will consider an amendment to Ordinance 01-67, the Farmland Protection Program. The proposed amendment, an implementation strategy of the master land use plan, will expand eligibility criteria to include small food producing farms, and ensure that acreage remains available for local food production. At present, 100% of participants in the farm protection program are conventional row crop and livestock producers situated in rural Kane. This policy balances investment in permanent farmland protection in all planning regions (food and farms, critical growth, and sustainable urban corridors) and encourages local food production for the benefit of population health.
Another example of an HIA is from Denver, Colorado where the master plan for a redevelopment project was considered. The South Lincoln Homes community is located in downtown Denver and is managed by the Denver Housing Authority. The HIA studied the potential health impacts of the redevelopment and included recommendations that were incorporated into the master plan. Through focus groups, interviews, food and walkability studies, and other data analysis, the HIA team encouraged that space for community gardens and a farmer’s market be included in the plan, as well as noise barriers, a stormwater management system, bike lanes, and pedestrian-friendly sidewalks.
10
public health accreditation program is to promote and protect the health of the public by
advancing the quality and performance of all health departments in the United States through
national public health department accreditation.”3 This is the first time that public health
departments can demonstrate their performance against a set of national criteria. Accreditation
will benefit residents because it will ensure the health department is meeting these standards
which were created to protect and improve their health. Three main pre-requisites for
accreditation are a community health assessment, a community health improvement plan, and
department strategic plan, all of which are addressed in 2011-2012.
The five hospitals in Kane County are required to complete a health needs assessment as one
provision of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act of 2010 (ACA). It states that non-
profit hospitals will “conduct a community health needs assessment” and “adopt an
implementation strategy” once every three years. The ACA also specifies that hospital
assessments must “take into account input” from those who “represent the broad interests of the
community (including) those with special knowledge of or expertise in public health.”4 The
department worked with the hospitals to meet their requirement and demonstrate the importance
of conducting community health assessments every 3-5 years.
The focus on population-level health and the social determinants of health led the department to
approach the upcoming assessment with a different focus: looking to the community for
opportunities to collaborate with local organizations in conducting a robust community
assessment and create a true community plan that could be used throughout the county.
Community Health Improvement Plan Partnership
Community health assessment is an important tool in setting priorities, guiding health, land use
and transportation planning, program development, coordination of community resources, and
creation of new partnerships to improve the health of the population. The results are used to
define improvement areas and guide a community toward implementing and sustaining policy,
systems, and environmental conditions that improve community health. The results also assist
the community in prioritizing needs which lead to the appropriate allocation of available
3 “About PHAB”. Public Health Accreditation Board http://www.phaboard.org/about-phab/ 4 http://www.recovery.gov/About/Pages/The_Act.aspx
11
resources. The health assessment provides an evidence-
based core foundation for improving the health of a
community.
In 2011, the department conducted a community health
assessment in collaboration with several partners (see
Figure 6) to guide future health planning and meet the
state’s requirement for local health departments to update
their community health action plans every five years.
This assessment was used to update the 2006 Community
Health Action Plan and provided up to date data and
information that reflected the changes in social,
economic, and environmental factors over the past five
years.
Update on Past Priorities
To begin, we looked back at our priorities from the last health action plan and examined whether
health outcomes improved for the five priorities and what partnerships, policies, or system
changes were implemented. An evaluation of the past plan is an important step in the assessment
process because it helps us determine if what we did actually had a positive outcome and
people’s lives have improved. The five priorities were:
Improve access to health care for those without insurance
Eliminate the disparity in African American infant mortality
Reduce the level of chronic disease
Improve availability of community mental health services
Maintenance of core public health protection services
In addition, we measured progress on the priorities as part of the Progress Report on Strategy
Implementation 2007-2011 and presented the findings to various stakeholders. Below are
selected goals and measures for each priority. The full report is available in Appendix A of the
Comprehensive Version.
Community Health Assessment Partners
Delnor Hospital
Fox Valley United Way
INC Board
Provena Mercy Medical Center
Provena Saint Joseph Hospital
Rush-Copley Medical Center
Sherman Hospital
United Way of Elgin
Figure 6
12
For Improve Access to Health Care, one goal was to have 98% of Kane County residents with
access to healthcare by 2030. This is important because a lack of health insurance may cause
people to skip routine, preventative care which can help people live longer, healthier lives. It
could also cause people to use hospital emergency departments for care which leads to higher
health care costs for all. Figure 7 shows that the percentage of residents in Kane County with
health insurance coverage has decreased to 89.1% in 2011.
For Eliminate the Disparity in African American Infant Mortality, two goals and measures show
progress:
Improve 1st trimester entry into prenatal care to 80% for African Americans by 2010
Zero disparity among racial groups in infant mortality by 2030
Figures 8 and 9 indicate that we have not reached our goals for either measure, but the disparity
is less, which demonstrates improvement.
75
80
85
90
95
100
1997 2002 2006 2008 2011
Percent of Adults
Kane County Health Insurance Coverage
Kane
Collar
IL*
2030 Goal
*IL 2011 rate was actually for 2010
Figure 7
Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System Survey
13
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Percent of Live Births
Kane County First Trimester Entry Into Prenatal Care
All Kane County
All African American
2010 Goal
Source: Illinois Dept of Public Health
Figure 8
0.0
2.0
4.0
6.0
8.0
10.0
12.0
14.0
16.0
18.0
20.0
99‐03
00 ‐04
01 ‐05
02 ‐06
03 ‐07
Rate per 1,000 Live Births
Infant Mortality Rates for Kane County By Race/Ethnicity, 5‐Year Averages, 1999 to 2007
AFRICAN AMERICAN
WHITE
HISPANIC
KANE COUNTY
Source: IL Dept of Public Health
Figure 9
14
As a result of the 2006 plan, two groups were formed to address infant mortality in the county,
the Elgin and Aurora Circles of Wise Women. Their mission is: Improve infant wellness and
survival through education and prevention by increasing health awareness within the African
American community; create a circle of change by promoting healthy behavior and increase the
circle of life by surrounding parents and infants with strong, loving community bonds. These
groups continue meeting monthly and support pregnant and new mothers by holding events,
participating in fairs, and providing information to a population that continues to see higher rates
of infant mortality than other racial/ethnic groups.
For Reduce the level of chronic disease, two following factors contributed to the level of chronic
disease found in the county. In Figure 10, the rate of adult smoking has decreased since 2006
and currently stands at 12% which is below the 2015 goal.
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
1997 2002 2006 2008 2011
Percent of Adult Population
Adult Smoking, 1997 to 2011
Kane
IL
US
2015 Goal
*IL 2011 rate was actually for
2010
Figure 10
15
As seen in Figure 11, the adult overweight and obese population increased to 63.9% in 2011,
well above the 2015 goal of 50%, and higher than years past.
The next priority was Improve availability of community mental health services and was
measured by adults reporting feeling sad or depressed in the past 30 days and by high school
students reporting feeling sad or hopeless. Figure 12 shows the Kane County percentage
increased to 40.6 in 2008 from below 35 in 2006. Figure 13 indicates a slight increase for
Illinois and Chicago, but a decrease for the U.S.
Figure 11
16
051015202530354045
1997 2002 2006 2008
Per
cen
t o
f A
du
lt P
op
ula
tio
n
Adults Reporting Feeling Sad or Depressed in Past 30 Days
1997 ‐ 2008
Kane
IL
2015 Goal
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
IL US Chicago
Per
cen
t o
f S
tud
ents
High School Students Who Reported Feeling Sad or Hopeless
2007
2009
2015 Goal
Source: Youth Risk Behavior Survey
Figure 12
Figure 13
17
The Kane County Mental Health Council was formed as a result of the 2006 Community Health
Action Plan to address access to mental health services. Kane County has a wide array of private
and public mental health services but in many cases they are not well coordinated, unevenly
distributed, under-funded, and often not accessible to those without insurance. Awareness of
mental health needs and available resources is also relatively low. A Community Awareness
Committee meets monthly to develop awareness campaigns. It has established a Web site,
conducted news conferences, sponsored educational
programs for educators, developed presentation material
and is branching out into social media. The latest
program is the “We Support Mental Health” badge which
is an electronic campaign to raise awareness of mental
health needs in the community. Council members are
asked to display or embed a badge on their websites to show support for mental health. The next
step is to invite other community organizations to view their website, display the badge, and
learn more about mental health.
More information on the We Support Mental Health initiative can be found on the
following website: http://wesupportmentalhealth.org/
18
The final priority from 2006 is Maintain core public health protection services. The measure in
Figure 14 demonstrates that Kane County is above the U.S. percentage for childhood
immunizations, but is below the goal of 90%. Figure 15 shows continued progress in lowering
the percentage of children with elevated blood lead levels, but we have not reached our goal of
0%.
60
65
70
75
80
85
90
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
Percent of Child
ren
Goal/ MetaUSILKane
Childhood ImmunizationsPercent of Children age 19‐35 months
Source: IL Dept of Public Health
Figure 14
19
Other partnerships, coalitions, and initiatives were created as a result of past community health
assessments and improvement plans. These were designed to address problems identified during
the planning process and continue their work today. The following graphic illustrates the path of
the last Community Health Assessment and the programs that came together as a result of it. A
few are described in more detail following Figure 16.
0.0%
1.0%
2.0%
3.0%
4.0%
5.0%
6.0%
7.0%
8.0%
9.0%
10.0%
'00 '01 '02 '03 '04 '05 '06 '07 '08 '09 '10
Percent of Child
ren
Percentage of Children with Elevated Blood Lead Level
Source: IL Dept of Public Health
Kane County Percentage of ChildrenGoal
Figure 15
20
Coalition for Health and Wellness
The Kane County Coalition for Health and Wellness is a volunteer collaborative organization
focusing on improving the health of Kane County residents and providing the community with
health screening/referral services, assessments, educational outreach programs, and policy
advocacies. By bringing people together from across sectors, the coalition can better target the
health and wellness issues and concerns of county residents. The coalition was created as a
result of the last community health action plan. Some accomplishments include:
Created and maintains the Coalition Speakers Bureau Advocated for a Smoke-Free Illinois in the state legislature
g
Figure 16: 2006 Community Health Assessment
21
Awarded a grant to enhance women’s health education Produced health messages for posting in PACE buses Enhanced awareness of physical education programs within Kane County schools Produced a Wellness Campaign Booklet (an action-based guide for groups, organizations
and companies) Offers a free Wellness Assessment tool for employees, along with free data compilation Creates and maintains the Stall Street Journal collection of flyers on timely public health
education topics Offers a free prop lending library for educational purposes
Fit Kids 2020 Plan
One of the most significant projects the health department coordinates is
the Fit Kids 2020 Plan. The purpose of the plan is to provide a strategic
framework that will guide the work of the community so that we will
reverse the toll of childhood obesity in our children by the year 2020.
The plan is a result of the county’s Making Kane County Fit for Kids
campaign, which was launched in 2008 with a Leadership Summit
attended by more than 100 executive leaders from Kane County
municipalities, school districts, park districts, businesses, the faith community, health care
providers, health and social service agencies, as well as local and state elected officials. Out of
this summit, the group created four strategic action principles that reach to the core of the obesity
problem in the county:
1. Providing parents and children with reliable, up-to-date information in multiple settings
regarding healthy physical activity and eating habits;
2. Supporting a culture of wellness and health promotion in our workplaces, schools, and
other institutions;
3. Develop land use, planning, and other public policies that foster and support physical
activity for all in our community;
4. Assure that fresh fruits and vegetables are affordable and accessible to all families in our
community.
In February 2010, the county held a Fit Kids 2020 Leadership Summit, where over 100 leaders
came together for a day and one-half and focused on what has led to the obesity problem, the
present state of the problem, and future actions that will reverse this trend. From this summit,
22
work began on the Fit Kids 2020 Plan. Over 80 community
stakeholders worked together in sector-specific workgroups
(see Figure 17 for a listing) for more than six months to
create strategies and action steps for each sector. The plan
was adopted by the county board in April 2011.
There are some common themes that came out of the
workgroups and are reflected in the plan. They include:
Community Gardens
Healthy Food Policy
Walk to School Initiatives
Workplace Wellness
Land-Use Policy
Support of Breastfeeding
Transportation Policy
The action items identified by the groups have moved into the implementation stage, where
people are working together on ways to make them come to life. The Fit for Kids Funders’
Consortium, a public-private partnership of Kane agencies, was formed to coordinate and raise
funds to support the initiative’s work across sectors to reverse childhood obesity. Fit for Kids,
selected in 2009 as one of 50 Healthy Kids, Healthy Communities sites across the nation by the
Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, is now a highly visible, respected collaborative effort to
prevent childhood obesity in Kane County through the implementation of systems, policy and
environmental change. The Consortium offers a mini-grant program that is designed to give
organizations the funding necessary to carry out the work outlined in the plan. To date, more
than $330,000 has been awarded to the community to support the plan. Past grantee projects
include providing equipment necessary for several farmers’ markets to accept Link cards,
increasing access to fresh produce for lower-income residents; funding to a food bank
consortium to purchase refrigeration units, allowing them to offer fresh produce to clients; and
new playground equipment at a neighborhood’s soccer fields, providing a place for siblings to
play during the matches.
Sector Specific Workgroups
Built and Natural Environment
Economic Strength
Faith Community
Family, Culture, and Community
Food Policy
Healthcare and Medicine
Mobility
Recreation and Lifestyle
Schools and Education
Figure 17
23
Part 2 Community Health Assessment
Figure 18 demonstrates how the 2011 Community Health Assessment data is used to update the
Community Health Improvement Plan and inform other county plans.
Figure 18
24
Methodology and Community Participation
Kane County approached the 2011 Community Health Assessment differently than in years past.
In late 2010, we engaged the five hospitals in the county and the INC Board in a formal
Community Health Assessment Committee to fund and lead the assessment effort. In early 2011,
the Fox Valley United Way and the United Way of Elgin both formally agreed to fund and
support the assessment process as well. See Figure 6 for a listing of the partners. This
partnership allowed all agencies to meet their community assessment requirements and provided
an efficient use of assessment and planning resources from all involved agencies. The assessment
included the collection and analysis of the most up-to-date health, social, economic, housing and
other data as well as qualitative input directly from residents gathered through focus groups,
Community Cafés, Community Meetings and Quality of Kane Open Houses.
The assessment partnership funded a comprehensive
telephone survey of Kane County residents to collect
health status information for over 1,500 adults and the
caregivers of over 400 children. The survey questions
were created based on the Behavioral Risk Factor
Surveillance System survey, allowing the results to be
compared with state and national figures. Established
by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the
BRFSS is the world’s largest, on-going telephone health
survey system, tracking health conditions and risk
behaviors in the United States yearly since 1984. This
is the first time amount of information is available about
the health of Kane County residents and the first time a
child survey was included. The Northern Illinois University Public Opinion Laboratory was
contracted to conduct the phone survey between March and July of 2011. Additional data was
collected from a number of sources to help us better understand the social and economic
environment in Kane County. See Figure 19 for a partial list of sources.
In addition to quantitative data, the department gathered qualitative information from residents
about the health of the community through the Quality of Kane Public Meetings, Focus Groups,
Secondary Data Sources
2010 U.S. Census
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
Illinois Department of Public Health
Illinois Department of Employment Security
Kane County Health Department
Youth Risk Behavior Survey
Other Kane County Offices & Departments
Figure 19
25
Community Cafés and Community Meetings. These events provided an opportunity to hear
directly from residents about the factors most influencing health in their communities. This
information was used to help planners understand the health data collected. Over 200 residents
participated in at least one of these events.
The Quality of Kane Public Meetings were held in April, May, and November 2011. These
meetings provided community members an opportunity to hear about and provide their input on
planning initiatives in Kane County from three different planning disciplines: health, land use,
and transportation. These meetings were an opportunity to engage residents throughout Kane
County in the assessment process. There were six meetings total, two from each of the three
planning areas in the county. The planning areas are defined by the county and are used by all
departments. Figure 20 shows the boundaries for each area and a list of municipalities included
in each.
NORTH
Algonquin Barrington Hills Bartlett Burlington Carpentersville East Dundee Elgin Gilberts Hampshire Huntley Pingree Grove Sleepy Hollow South Elgin West Dundee
CENTRAL
Campton Hills Elburn Geneva La Fox Lily Lake Maple Park St. Charles Virgil Wayne
SOUTH
Aurora Batavia Big Rock Kaneville Montgomery North Aurora Sugar Grove
26
Finally, we conducted focus groups and Community Cafés with residents and Community
Meetings with stakeholders from various organizations throughout the county. Focus groups are
a key component in a community health assessment as they provide additional information in a
less structured setting. Instead of answering questions from a list of responses, participants are
asked open-ended questions that spark discussion among the group members. Holding multiple
sessions in different areas during different times ensured that enough information was gathered
to identify common themes in all the responses. Holding focus groups also helps the department
reach more people to inform them about the assessment and health improvement plan. Twelve
of the groups consisted of residents recruited by Northern Illinois University Public Opinion
Laboratory and were held in the three planning areas of the county with four meetings in each
area.
Figure 20: Kane County Planning Areas
27
Two Community Cafés were held in conjunction with the Strengthening Families organization
and used their “Parent Café” model. The model has specially trained parent coordinators who
host and facilitate the discussion. Three questions are presented at each session, one per table,
and participants move from one table to the next, building upon what was discussed by the prior
group. Responses are recorded by the table hosts on large pieces of paper and they are trained on
how to engage participants and keep the conversations flowing. Dinner and child care are
provided for attendees to encourage people to attend. The Strengthening Families Parent Cafés
are a valuable part of the community, bringing parents together to discuss topics that help keep
families strong and children safe by looking at the social-emotional side of health.
The Kane County Health Department used the trained parent hosts and facilitators to conduct the
Community Cafés but used questions relating to education, income/employment, and health
instead of the standard Parent Café questions. The questions were designed to generate a
discussion and allow participants to share personal stories and learn from each other. One
session was conducted in English and the other in Spanish.
For the Community Meetings, the department targeted existing groups to ask another series of
questions relating to health, education, and income/employment. This method was effective
because it did not require special recruitment of participants; meetings were held during existing
meeting times to increase participation. Table 1 summarizes the qualitative data collection
methods.
Type of Meeting Number of Meetings Number of Participants
Quality of Kane 8 210
Community Café 2 10 in Spanish-Speaking Session, 9 in English-Speaking Session
NIU Focus Groups 12 88
Community Meetings 6 52
369 Total Participants
Table 1: Methods of Qualitative Data Collection
28
The results of the survey, focus groups, Community Cafés, and Community Meetings were
analyzed along with the secondary data collected to identify potential threats to community
health. See Figure 19 for a partial list of sources used in the assessment.
For the first time, the results of the Kane County Community Health Assessment were made
available online in a webinar format in October and November 2011. The webinar provided
new, updated information on the overall health of our community, a progress report on our last
community health improvement plan and nine recommended key opportunities for community
health improvement over the next five years. Two versions were created, a 15 minute executive
summary and a 90 minute comprehensive review, both narrated by the Executive Director of the
Health Department. The webinars were available on-demand which allowed people to view them
at their own convenience and pace and permitted pausing/restarting at the click of a button. 169
individuals from many different agencies and communities viewed the webinar over a three
week period.
After viewing the webinar, an online survey asked residents, stakeholders, and other interested
parties to prioritize the nine recommended key opportunities for community health improvement,
provide input on who should be involved in addressing the issues, and comment on what
resources are currently available in the community. In addition, members of the Kane County
Board of Health and Health Advisory Committee participated in a retreat to review the data and
discuss the results.
Assets
As part of the assessment, the department examined the assets in the community: hospitals,
physicians, agencies, and partnerships which all help us achieve our vision of having the
healthiest residents in Illinois by 2030. There are five hospitals in Kane County, (two in Elgin,
one in Geneva, and two in Aurora) all of whom work closely with the department on the
assessment and many other projects including health access, wellness programs, and the Fit Kids
2020 Plan initiative. Five Federally Qualified Health Centers (FQHC) serve Kane County and
together they provided essential health services for 68,943 patients, dental services for 18,976
patients, and mental health services for 6,038 patients in 2010. These centers are crucial in
helping our vulnerable populations get access to the services they need.
29
Looking at physicians, there are 46.3 primary care physicians (including pediatricians) per
100,000 population, as compared to the national median of 54.6 per 100,000 population. Kane
has 9 pediatricians per 100,000 population as compared to the national median of 4 per 100,000.
This is beneficial to the county because of its large population of children under 18. The number
of specialists in the county is higher than the national median as well, with 85.8 per 100,000
compared to 31.7. Finally, the number of dentists in the county per 100,000 population is 53.7,
higher than the national median of 33. The county does not have a community mental health
center; however, there are 20 agencies coordinating the provision of services through the Kane
County Mental Health Council.5
There are currently numerous partnerships and coalitions active in the community which are
addressing community health issues. Kane County Health Department staff lead or participate in
many. These groups bring diverse perspectives and experiences to the table and because the
county is reaching out to as many leaders in the community as possible, it assures that all aspects
of community health and wellness are examined. With this important sharing of knowledge and
resources, the department’s reach is extended beyond the constraints of financial and human
capital. A partial listing of partnerships and coalitions excluding those already described, is
found below in Figure 21
5 “Area Resource File.” U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Health Resources and Service Administration, 2008
30
Activate Elgin An initiative to engage all sectors of the community to work in harmony providing all residents with opportunities to improve their health, well-being, and overall quality of life
Perinatal Committee Includes representatives from hospitals, community health centers, early intervention agencies, and home visitation programs focusing on collaboration and coordination about health messages, referral and linkage systems, and infant death review studies
Kane Community Health Access Integrated Network (KCHAIN)
The Network focuses on increasing access to specialty care for the uninsured and under-insured and decreasing inappropriate use of emergency departments by increasing coordination between providers and increasing community awareness
Kane County Continuum of Care The Continuum has brought together more than two dozen faith-based and community organizations that serve the homeless in Kane County, in order to assure coordination of services and exchange best practices
Kane County Breastfeeding Coalition Founded to promote the health benefits of breastfeeding
Compañeros en Salud Provides the Hispanic community and other diverse groups with the means to access resources and services for their health and well-being
All Our Kids Early Childhood Network (AOK) A coalition of 200 child service agencies that acts strategically to address gaps in child services
Kane County Healthy Places Coalition A new initiative led by KCHD will build capacity to address environmental issues in child-occupied settings and improve child health by establishing a child environmental health network to focus on three communities in the county with demographics that indicate that they bear a disproportionate environmental risk burden: Aurora in southern Kane, Elgin in northern Kane, and Carpentersville in the far northern region of Kane County.
Home Visitation Collaborative The Collaborative supports implementation of evidence-based home visitation programs serving low income families in Kane County
Figure 21 Community Partnerships and Coalitions
31
The Health Status of Kane County6
Demographic and Socio-Economic Characteristics
Kane County is the fifth largest county in Illinois, with a 2010 population of 515,269. It has
grown by about 30% since 2000 and by 60% since 1990. It is located 40 miles west of Chicago,
within the Chicago Metropolitan Area. Its land area is about 520 square miles, with a population
density of about 776.5 people per square mile. It has a small rural area (2.3% of total
population), mostly in the western half of the County. Most of its urban population is clustered
around the Fox River. The largest community in Kane County is Aurora on the southern end
with a population of 197,899. Aurora straddles four counties: DuPage, Kane, Kendall and Will.
Kane County is the 7th youngest county in Illinois, with a median age of 34.5 years. The largest
age group in Kane County is the 5 – 14 year olds, about 16% of the total population. This age
group has increased by about 25%, consistent with the County. However, the fastest growing
6 The complete 2011 Community Health Assessment Databook can be found in the Comprehensive Version available online www.kanehealth.com
0
100,000
200,000
300,000
400,000
500,000
600,000
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Count
Year
Kane County Population Trend
Source: US Census Bureau
Figure 22
32
age group in Kane is the age group 55 to 69 year which increased by more than 70%. In fact, the
60 to 64 year age group doubled in the last ten years.
The racial distribution has changed from 2000 to 2010. Non-Hispanic whites constitute 59% of
total population, a drop from 68% in 2000, while Hispanics now comprise 31% of the total
population, an increase from 24% in 2000. When compared to Illinois, the proportion of
Hispanics is double in Kane County and it has the largest proportion of Hispanics in the state.
Additionally, the Asian population at 17,505 has increased by 145% from its 2000 population.
39,870
84,605
67,909 68,90476,116 74,246
53,929
28,10821,582
0
10,000
20,000
30,000
40,000
50,000
60,000
70,000
80,000
90,000
Under 5 years
5 ‐ 14 15 ‐ 24 25 ‐ 34 35 ‐ 44 45 ‐ 54 55 ‐ 64 65 ‐ 74 75 +
Age Distribution of Kane County, 2010
Source: US Census Bureau
Figure 23
33
Demographics of Kane County Planning Areas7
Northern Kane County Planning Area (NPA)
Northern Kane County (NPA) makes up about 37% of the total Kane County population, with a
2010 population of 189,284. It comprises 15 communities located in the northern third of Kane
County by land mass. The largest communities in NPA are Elgin, 44% of NPA population, and
Carpentersville, 20% of the population. These two communities are in the youngest 10% of
cities in Illinois respectively. NPA is quite diverse, with 55% white, 33% Hispanic, 6% Asian,
5% African American, as well as other races and combinations.
The age distribution shows that 30% of NPA population is aged less than 18 years, 9% under 5
years. However, 32% is aged 45 years and older. Although 14% of the population is 60 years or
older, this age group is the fastest growing age group in NPA as well as Kane County as a whole.
7 See Figure 20 for a list of municipalities in each Planning Area
304,051
27,819591
17,505130 522 6,261
158,390
0
50,000
100,000
150,000
200,000
250,000
300,000
350,000
White*
Black or
African
American*
American
Indian and
Alaska Native*
Asian
*
Native
Haw
aiian/O
the
r Pacific Isl.*
Some other
race*
Two or more
races*
Hispan
ic any
Race
Po
pu
lati
on
Co
un
tRacial and Ethnic Distribution in Kane County
2000
2010
* Not of Hispanic orgin
Source: US Census Bureau
Figure 24
34
Southern Kane Planning Area (SPA)
Southern Kane makes up about 37 % of the Kane County population, with a 2010 population of
192,259. It comprises seven communities located in the southern third of Kane County by land
mass. The largest communities in SPA are Aurora, comprising 68% of SPA as a whole, and
Batavia, 14% of SPA. Aurora is home to the largest Hispanic community in Illinois outside
Chicago. It is quite racial/ethnically diverse, with 46% of the population white, 42% Hispanic,
9% African American and 2% Asian.
The age distribution showed that SPA is also a younger community, with a third of the
population aged less than 18 years and 9% under 5 years old. On the other hand, 31% is aged 45
and older, while 13% of the population is aged 60 years and older. Although the latter is a
smaller proportion than the population of children in SPA, this is by far the fastest growing age
group in the planning area.
Central Kane Planning Area (CPA)
The Central Kane Planning Area is located midpoint between the North and South of the County.
Its population of 73,514 is about 14% of Kane County’s 2010 population. It comprises eight
communities. The largest community in the CPA is St Charles, with a 2010 population estimate
of about 32,000. The demographics of CPA, according to the 2010 U.S. Census, showed a
homogenous community in terms of race and ethnicity. White non-Hispanics made up 88% of
the population. Although the population grew, the proportion of the races did not change
appreciably from 2000 to 2010. African Americans and Asian races contributed 1% and 3%
respectively. Hispanics made up about 7% of the 2010 population.
The CPA is a relatively older community than the other planning areas. The age distribution
showed 27% of the population less than 18 years old, with only 5% under age 5, while about
17% of the population was aged 60 and older. About 42% of its population is aged 45 and older,
compared to NPA and SPA at 32% and 31% respectively.
Socio-Economic Characteristics
The unemployment rate, at 10.3% in 2010, has increased significantly in the past few years,
doubling from 1990 to 2010. This rate was similar to the overall Illinois rate but higher than the
35
U.S. rate of 9.6%. Most municipalities in the county also experienced increased unemployment
rates. The Kane County parts of Aurora and Elgin, as well as Carpentersville, had higher
unemployment rates than Kane County overall.
Similarly, poverty rates have increased by two thirds to 11.1% in Kane County. When viewed
by race/ethnicity, one third of African Americans living in Kane County are below the poverty
level compared to one in five Hispanics and one in twenty whites. Seventeen percent of children
less than 18 years old lived below the poverty level, while 24% of female-headed households
were below the poverty level.
There were 10,194 cases of violent crime reported in Kane County in 2009. At a crime index rate
of 2,008.4 per 100,000, it was lower than Illinois rate of 3,298.8 per 100,000 but slightly higher
than the collar county average of 1,998.2 per 100,000. The Kane 2010 rate was a reduction of
40% from 2000. The top three crimes were burglary (328.8), aggravated assault/battery (164.7)
and theft (1,346.6).
General Health and Access to Care Kane County residents are living longer, like many other counties around the U.S. The life
expectancy for Kane County in 2007 was 81 years for women and 77.4 for men, having
increased from 79.7 for women and 75.3 for men in 2000. Similarly, life expectancy for Illinois
and the U.S. increased as well. Life expectancy was lower for African Americans (75.4 for
females and 70.1 for males) than whites (79.9 for females and 75.5 for males).
The age adjusted mortality rate for Kane County decreased by 16% from 2000 to 2007. Similar
declines were evident in all races and ethnicities. In 2007, the African American age adjusted
death rate was 1,019.8 per 100,000, more than double those of Asian or Pacific Islanders and
Hispanics, as well as 40% higher than the rate for whites. Years of Potential Life Lost (YPLL) at
age 75 for Kane County in 2007 was 482,355 person years or 4,800.4 per 100,000.
In the 2011 Community Health Assessment (CHA) phone survey of Kane County adult residents
conducted by the Health Department in partnership with area hospitals, the INC Board and the
major United Ways in the county, 89% of Kane adult residents reported that they had health
insurance coverage compared to 87.8% in 2002. In Illinois, 87% of adults reported having health
36
care coverage, compared to 85% in the U.S. Additionally, 67% had a routine health check up
within the past year compared to 73.5% in 2002. The U.S. 2010 Census reported that 86.8% of
the total population had health insurance, compared to 86.2% for Illinois, and lower than the
Healthy People 2020 goal of 100%. There is a disparity in health insurance coverage for
residents in the county: 73% of Hispanics had health insurance and 83% of African Americans,
compared to 94% for non-Hispanic whites.
Source: US Census Bureau
Additionally, 27% of residents who were at 200% of the federal poverty level or lower were
uninsured compared to 7% for those above 200% of the federal poverty level.
0%5%10%15%20%25%30%
All Races White Black or African American
Asian White not Hispanic
Hispanic of any race
Percent of Population
Population With No Health Insurance By Race/Ethnicity
Kane
Illinois
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
Total: < 18 yrs: 18 ‐ 64 yrs: >=65 yrsPercent of Population
Population With No Health Insurance By Age
Kane
Illinois
Figure 25
37
Maternal and Child Health Indicators
The total births in Kane County decreased by 5% from 2000 to 2008, similar to Illinois’ 4.5%
decrease. The largest proportion of births was among Hispanics (45%) and white non-Hispanics
(44%). African American and Asian births were 6.5% and 4.4% respectively. The teen birth
rate for Kane County in 2008 was 42.4 per 1,000 females aged 15 to 19. This was a 22%
decrease from the teen birth rate in 2000. The Kane teen birth rate was higher than Illinois (38.1)
and the U.S. (41.5) for the same year.
Adequacy of prenatal care has been shown to improve birth outcomes. In Kane County, only
72% of mothers received adequate prenatal care as measured by Kessner Index, compared to the
Illinois average of 73% and HP 2020 goal of 77.6%. African Americans and Hispanics had the
lowest rate at 55% and 63% respectively. Asians and non-Hispanic whites had rates higher than
Illinois at 83% and 76% respectively. Adequate prenatal care rate for whites met the HP 2020
objective.
In 2008, 568 or about 6% of Kane County babies were born with a birthweight below 2,500
grams (5.5 lbs). Of these, 101 had a birthweight less than 1,500 grams (3.3 lbs). Kane County
has consistently met the HP 2020 objective of below 7.8%. Similarly, about 10% of Kane
County babies were born before 37 weeks of pregnancy. This rate was same as Illinois, lower
than the U.S. rate, and met the HP 2020 objective of 11.4% or below.
4.4%6.5%
44.0%
0.1%0.0%
0.0%
45.0%
Kane County Births By Race/Ethnicity, 2008
Asian not Hispanic
Black not Hispanic
White not Hispanic
American Indian & Alaska Native not HispanicNative Hawaiian other Pacific Islander not HispanicSome Other Race/Unknown
Hispanic of any Race
Source: IL Dept of Public Health
Figure 26
38
Infant mortality rates for all races/ethnicities in Kane County are declining. The decline is
greatest among African American infants, yet, twice as many African American babies died
before their first birthday compared to all other races/ethnicities in Kane County. The Kane
County infant mortality rate for 2008 was 6.6 per 1,000 live births, lower than the Illinois rate of
7.2. The 5-year Kane infant mortality rate average for 2004 to 2008 was 5.6. Comparing infant
mortality for the different races and ethnicities, the white infant mortality at 4.9 was lower than
the HP 2020 objective of 6.0. The African American rate at 10.8 was more than double the
white rate. The Hispanic infant mortality rate was 5.9 per 1,000, also lower than the HP 2020
objective.
Indicated child abuse/neglect increased by about 12% from 2000 (9.1 per 1,000 children) to 2010
(8.0 per 1,000 children). This was about the same as the Illinois rate.
Chronic Disease Indicators
Chronic diseases are among the most common, costly, and preventable of all health problems in
the U.S. In 2007, a total of 2,687 residents died in Kane County. With an age adjusted rate of
714.5 per 100,000, the death rate was lower than Illinois and U.S., both at 760 per 100,000.
Non‐Communicable
Diseases(Chronic Diseases)
81%
Accidents 6%
Influenza and Pneumonia
4%
Kidney Disease 4%
Alzheimer's Disease3%
Septicemia2%
Mortality Distribution, Kane County 2007
Figure 27
39
This was a 16% reduction from the 2000 rate of 847.9. The three leading causes of death in
Kane County were: cancer, heart disease and stroke, all of which are chronic diseases.
Non-communicable diseases (NCDs) accounted for 81% of all deaths in Kane County in 2007.
These non-communicable diseases include: cancer, heart disease, stroke, chronic lower
respiratory disease (CLRD) and diabetes mellitus. Several behavioral risk factors are responsible
for many of these NCDs. The 2011 Community Health Assessment survey in Kane County
revealed that only 54% of adults meet recommended levels of physical activity, 14% eat
recommended five servings of fruits and vegetables, and 39% of adults were told they had high
cholesterol. Although the overall Kane County smoking rates decreased to 12%, meeting the HP
2020 objective for the first time this year, there is economic disparity in smoking rates in Kane
County as seen in the graph below:
Heart disease is the leading cause of death in Kane County, with an age adjusted rate of 171.8
per 100,000. Although it has declined 15% the last five years and is lower than the Illinois and
U.S. rates of approximately 190, it singly accounts for 23% of total deaths. Coronary heart
disease is the major sub-type of heart disease, causing 411 deaths, an age adjusted rate of 116.3
per 100,000. Kane County has yet to achieve the HP 2020 goal of 100.8 per 100,000.
Figure 28
40
Cancer was the major cause of death in 24% of deaths in Kane County in 2007, an age adjusted
rate of 164.5 per 100,000. Although the Kane rate was lower than Illinois and U.S. rates, it is
still higher than the HP 2020 goal of reducing it to 160.6 per 100,000. The most common cancer
was bronchus and lung cancer, with a total of 174 deaths or 27% of all cancer deaths, and an age
adjusted rate of 44.9 per 100,000. There is racial/ethnic disparity in cancer mortality. African
American age adjusted cancer death rate was 200.4, compared with Hispanic death rate of 90.2
and white rate of 173.2 per 100,000.
Cerebrovascular disease or stroke mortality rate was 41.9 per 100,000 in 2007. This rate has
decreased 19% in the last five years but has still not reduced the HP 2020 objective of 33.8.
Diabetes mellitus is the 5th leading cause of death in Kane County, with an age adjusted death
rate of 24.9 per 100,000. The Kane rate was slightly higher than Illinois and U.S. rates. Unlike
other causes of death mentioned so far, diabetes deaths increased 20% from 2003 to 2006. It is
highest among Hispanics.
There were 9,340 new cases of cancer for 2003 to 2007 combined. This translates to about 1,868
cases per year. The most common cancers in Kane County were lung/bronchus, breast, prostate
and colorectal cancers. There is great gender and racial disparities in many of the cancers. The
age adjusted cancer incidence rates for African American males were at least twice higher in
stomach, kidney, multiple myeloma, bronchus and lung compared to white males. African
American prostate cancer rate was almost twice that of whites as well. African American female
incidence rate for multiple myeloma was more than five times the white female rate. Although
Kane rates were similar to Illinois rates for all races, Kane County was higher than Illinois
among African Americans for lung/bronchus, multiple myeloma, kidney among males, and
leukemia among females. For whites, Kane County rates were slightly higher for invasive breast
cancer.
41
Source: IL Dept of Public Health 2007
Hospitalizations are often used as a surrogate for prevalence of diseases. There were a total of
39,506 hospitalizations for Kane County residents (excluding hospitalizations for newborn and
delivery) in 2009, a rate of 77.4 per 1,000 residents. The top five causes of hospitalization were
heart disease, mental disorders, pneumonia, injury and cancer.
The 2011 Community Health Assessment survey showed that 63.9% of Kane adults were obese
or overweight. Obesity is a key risk factor for chronic diseases and it increased by 9% from 2002
to 2011. Among children in Kane County, 36% were obese or overweight. Similarly, 18.2% of
adults reported binge drinking, increasing 4.6% from 2002. Diabetes prevalence among adults
increased 135% from 3.7% in 2002 to 8.7% in 2011. The map below shows diabetes
hospitalizations of Kane County residents in 2010.
4,053, 23%
3,760, 21%
1,723, 10%
1,679, 10%
1,670, 10%
1,170, 7%
974, 6%
920, 5%
793, 4%711, 4%
Leading Causes of Hospitalization
Heart Disease
Mental Disorders
Pneumonia/Influenza
Injury
Cancer
Stroke
Urinary Dis. ‐ Other
Dorsopathies
Rehabilitation
Infection ‐ Septicemia
Figure 29
42
Figure 30
43
About 9% of Kane County adults reported that their mental health was not good 14 or more days
in the past 30 days, compared to 9.7% and 10.6% for Illinois and U.S., respectively.
Additionally, 13% have diagnosed depressive disorder.
Infectious Disease Indicators There were 537 cases of reportable infectious diseases in Kane County in 2011. The leading
reportable diseases were Hepatitis C virus infection (chronic or resolved), salmonellosis,
pertussis, varicella (Chicken Pox), and Hepatitis B (chronic). Among vaccine preventable
diseases, there were 51 cases of pertussis, two cases of mumps, and 40 cases of chickenpox. The
2010 immunization rate for Kane County among children 19 to 35 months was 72.8%. The
Illinois rate is the same as the Kane rate and the U.S. rate was 69.9%. The HP 2020 objective is
to increase the immunization rate for children 19 to 35 months to 80%.
Tuberculosis cases in Kane County increased 22% from 4.9 per 100,000 in 2000 to 6 per
100,000 in 2010. The Kane County rate was double the Illinois rate and was the highest rate of
tuberculosis in Illinois. The Illinois rate for 2010 was 2.9 per 100,000. The HP 2020 objective is
1.0 per 100,000.
In 2010, reportable sexually transmitted diseases have decreased over the last five years.
Chlamydia decreased by 19% to 214.5 per 100,000, while gonorrhea decreased by 57% to 31.6
per 100,000. Both rates are lower than Illinois rates for both categories. As of December 2010,
a total of 104 HIV cases had been diagnosed since 2005, at a rate of 3.4 per 100,000. This rate is
lower than that of Illinois but higher than the collar counties. Similarly, 137 cumulative cases of
AIDS (a rate of 4.5 per 100,000) have been diagnosed in Kane County since 2005. The rate of
4.5 per 100,000 was lower than Illinois but higher than the collar counties.
Environmental/Occupational/Injury Control Indicators There was insufficient data on environmental indicators. The chemical scorecard, a website
maintained by Environmental Defense Fund, showed that Kane County ranked at the top 20% of
all counties in the U.S. for non-cancer hazards, air releases of suspected cardiovascular or blood
toxicants, air releases of suspected kidney toxicants, total production-related waste and total off-
site transfers.
44
Accidents are the 6th leading cause of death in Kane County. In 2007, the age adjusted rate for
Kane County was 24.6 per 100,000. This rate is much lower than the Illinois and the U.S. rates
of 33.4 and 40 per 100,000 respectively. Kane County has met the HP 2020 goal of reducing
accidents to no more than 53.3 per 100,000. Homicide is no longer a leading cause of death in
Kane County. There were 17 deaths due to homicide in 2007, a rate of 3.4 per 100,000. The
suicide death rate in 2007 was 8.4 per 100,000, about the same as the rate five years ago. Kane
County has met HP 2020 objective of less than 10.2 per 100,000 for suicide.
The 2011 Community Health Assessment survey revealed that 2.5% of Kane County adults have
driven drunk at least once in the past 30 days.
Blood lead levels in children decreased 33% from 2007 to 2009. Kane County’s lead poisoning
rate was higher than Illinois and the U.S.
The criminal sexual assault rate for Kane County in 2009 was 39.2 per 100,000. This rate was
61% higher than the average for collar counties. Aggravated assault at a rate of 164.7 per
100,000 was 53% higher than the collar counties average. Kane County crime rates were higher
than collar county average rates in all categories except theft and murder.
Sentinel Events
In looking at specific indicators that serve as sentinel events for lack of access to care,
uncontrolled hypertension, which is usually among the adult population, decreased about 16%
from 2005 to 44.1 per 100,000 in 2009. Tuberculosis in Kane County increased to 6.0 per
100,000 in 2010, double the Illinois rate for the same year. Uncontrolled hypertension and
tuberculosis are indicators for inadequate access to care for adults.
Hospitalizations for dehydration, rheumatic fever and asthma are sentinel indicators for children.
Asthma hospitalization in 2008 showed that Kane County rates for the age groups 5 to 9 years
and 10 to 14 years were significantly higher than Illinois when Cook County was excluded from
Illinois. In the age group 10 to 14 years, Kane County was almost 10 times higher than Illinois
excluding Cook County. The rate for the 5 to 9 age group was 1.5 times Illinois excluding Cook
County.
45
In looking at in-situ breast cancer, a sentinel event for lack of access to primary care for cancer,
the incidence rate was 30.4 per 100,000. There was no racial disparity as the white and African
American rates were 30.3 and 30.1 respectively.
Top Community Health Assessment Findings
Analysis of the 2011 Community Health Survey data, secondary data, online survey results, and
qualitative data, the Kane County Health Assessment results point to six major threats to
community health and well-being:
Obesity
Chronic Disease
Infant Mortality
Childhood Lead Poisoning
Communicable Disease
Poor Social and Emotional Wellness
These issues contribute to a lower quality of life for many Kane County residents, as well as
increased spending on health care costs. To improve the overall quality of life in Kane County,
the Community Health Improvement Plan recommends four cross-cutting priorities to address
these threats. Each priority can be addressed through implementation of one or more evidence-
based strategies that are described in the next section.
Six Top Threats to Community Health in Kane County
OBESITY
For adults, obesity is defined as having a Body Mass Index (BMI) equal to or greater than 30.
The calculation for BMI uses a person’s height and weight. For children and teens, the
calculation is more precise, using height, weight, age, and gender.
46
37% 33% 33% 35% 35% 36%
28%
18%
37% 29% 29% 28%
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
North Central South Kane Illinois US
Adult Overweight/Obesity 2011
Kane County Community Health Survey 2011
Why is it important for us to focus on obesity? The problem of obesity in the United States
has reached epidemic levels and Kane County is experiencing equally high rates for adults and
children.
13.5%
14.0%
14.5%
15.0%
15.5%
16.0%
16.5%
17.0%
Overweight Obese
Percent of WIC Population
Overweight/Obesity for WIC Children 2 to 5 Years Old
Kane
IL
US
Source: CDC Pediatric Nutrition Surveillance
The current percentage of adults in Kane County who are overweight (BMI between 25 and
29.9) is 34.5%. Those who are obese make up 29.4% which means, together, 63.9% of Kane
County adults are considered overweight and obese. According to the Centers for Disease
Figure 31
Overweight Obese
Figure 32
47
Control and Prevention, being overweight or obese can increase the risk for health problems
including heart disease, type 2 diabetes, high blood pressure, cancer, stroke, and osteoarthritis.
With a large young population, it is critical that this issue be addressed now to prevent future
health problems which affect residents’ quality of life and worker productivity. The following
root cause analysis worksheet provides details on contributing factors to obesity.
48
Health Problem Root Cause Analysis Indirect Contributing FactorDirect Contributing Factor
Indirect Contributing Factor
Risk Factor Direct Contributing Factor
Indirect Contributing Factor
Direct Contributing Factor
Health Problem
Indirect Contributing Factor
Direct Contributing Factor
Indirect Contributing Factor
Risk Factor Direct Contributing Factor
Indirect Contributing Factor
Direct Contributing FactorSocial norms and cultural values Overw eight & obestiy view ed positively
Perceived lack of time
Dominance of motorized transport
Walkability of community & environment
Limited or no healthy options available
Limited restaurant nutritional information
Not breastfeeding
Healthy options cost more
Overweight & Obesity
Limited active transport
Limited acces to fresh fruits & vegetables
Poor food literacy
Sedentary lifestyle
Low levels of physical activityPhysical Inactivity
Unhealthy Diet
Learned patterns of unhealthy behaviors from family and/or friends
Abundance of unhealthy options (i.e. fast food)
Advertising
Nutrition education is low priority
Perceived dangers and safety concerns
Decrease in physical activity
Limited or no PA at w ork
Lack of know ledge or education about importance of PA
Increase in screen time
Parental modeling
Health Problem
A situation or condition of people which is considered undesirable, is likely to exist
in the future, and is measured as death, disease
or disability
Risk Factor
Scientifically established factors that are related directly to the level of a
health problem.
Direct Contributing Factor
Scientifically established factors that directly affect the
risk factor
Indirect Contributing Factor
Community specific factors that directly affect the direct
contributing factor
49
CHRONIC DISEASE
Chronic disease refers to those illnesses that are not spread from person to person and instead are
caused by a person’s behavior or genetics. Examples of chronic diseases include stroke, heart
disease, cancer, diabetes, and arthritis. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention identifies
four modifiable risk behaviors -- lack of physical activity, poor nutrition, tobacco use, and
excessive alcohol consumption—which are responsible for much of the illness, suffering, and
early death related to chronic diseases.8
020406080
100120140160180200
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
Rat
e p
er 1
00,
000
Po
pu
lati
on
Trends in Diabetes Hospitalization, 2002 to 2009
Kane
IL
Why is it important for us to focus on chronic disease? Chronic diseases – such as heart
disease, stroke, cancer, diabetes, and arthritis – are among the most common, costly, and
preventable of all health problems in the U.S. These diseases also cause major limitations in
daily living for many residents.9 Chronic disease is costly to health care providers and insurance
companies and puts an undue strain on the entire health system. The cost of heart disease and
stroke in the United States is estimated to be $444 billion for 2010. As seen in Figure 34, these
diseases account for 80% of all deaths in Kane County. With the rapidly growing older
population in the county, these diseases will become more prevalent unless preventative action 8 “Chronic Diseases and Health Promotion.” Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. http://www.cdc.gov/chronicdisease/overview/index.htm 9 “Chronic Diseases and Health Promotion” Centers for Disease Control and Prevention http://www.cdc.gov/chronicdisease/overview/index.htm
Figure 33
50
is taken. Without proper insurance, people are unable to keep their conditions under control and
will end up in hospital emergency rooms for issues that could be more effectively managed by
regular visits to a physician.
Non
Communicable (Chronic) Diseases81%
Accidents 6%
Influenza and Pneumonia
4%
Nephritis, etc. 4%
Alzheimer's Disease3%
Septicemia2%
Mortality Distribution, Kane County 2007
Source: Illinois Dept. of Public Health
Figure 34
51
Health Problem Root Cause Analysis Indirect Contributing FactorDirect Contributing Factor
Indirect Contributing Factor
Risk Factor Direct Contributing Factor
Indirect Contributing Factor
Direct Contributing Factor
Indirect Contributing Factor
Direct Contributing Factor
Indirect Contributing Factor
Risk Factor Direct Contributing Factor
Indirect Contributing Factor
Direct Contributing Factor
Indirect Contributing Factor
Direct Contributing Factor
Indirect Contributing Factor
Risk Factor Direct Contributing Factor
Indirect Contributing Factor
Direct Contributing Factor
Indirect Contributing Factor
Direct Contributing Factor
Risk Factor
Indirect Contributing Factor
Direct Contributing Factor
No health insurance
Lack of access to quality preventive care services
Education
Lack of medical home
Unemployment
No health insurance
Low SES
Uncontrolled Hypertension
No regular ongoing source of care Lack of medical home
Unemployment
EducationLow SES
Healthy options cost more
Decrease in physical activity
Sedentary lifestyle Limited or no physical activity at w ork
Lack of know ledge or education about importance of physical activity
Increase in screen time
Limited restaurant nutritional information
Not breastfeeding
Social norms and cultural values Overw eight & obestiy view ed positively
Learned patterns of unhealthy behaviors from family and/or friends
Social and cultural factors Easy access to alcohol
Chronic Disease
Perceived lack of time
Dominance of motorized transport
Limited active transport Walkability of community & environment
Perceived dangers and safety concerns
Limited access to fruits and vegetables Limited or no healthy options available
Abundance of unhealthy options (i.e. fast food)
Advertising
Unhealthy Diet Poor food literacy Nutrition education is low priority
Health Problem
Environment that encourages excessive drinking
Alcohol Consumption Easy access to alcohol
Physical Inactivity Low levels of physical activity Parental modeling
Beginning drinking at an early age
Family history
Parents w ho are alcoholic
No alcohol restriction in the family for under-aged family members
Peer pressure
Steady drinking over time
Environment that encourages excessive drinking
52
INFANT MORTALITY
Infant mortality has long been known to be the best single measure of the health of a population,
group or community. This is measured as the rate of babies who die before their first birthday
per 1,000 births. Women who have access to and begin prenatal care in their first trimester of
pregnancy can improve their chances for having a healthy baby. With prenatal care, potential
pregnancy and delivery problems are found early and treated as soon as possible.
0
5
10
15
20
25
1997
-20
01
1998
-20
02
1999
-20
03
2000
-20
04
2001
-20
05
2002
-20
06
2003
-20
07
Rat
e pe
r 1,
000
Live
Bir
ths
5‐Year Infant Mortality Rates for Kane County By Race/Ethnicity
KANE COUNTY
WHITE
AFRICAN AMERICAN
HISPANIC
Infant mortality rates for all races/ethnicities in Kane County are declining. The decline is greatest among African American infants, yet, twice as many African American babies died
before their first birthday compared to all other races/ethnicities in Kane County
Source: IL Dept of Public Health
Why is it important for us to focus on infant mortality? In Kane County, there is a disparity
in the infant mortality rate when compared by race/ethnicity; the rate is two times higher for
African-Americans than for Hispanic and white residents. Looking at the current trend, which is
improving, it will still take another two generations to close the gap in rates. However, by
implementing various strategies, like increasing the number of African-American women who
enter prenatal care in the first trimester, that gap can be closed by 2030.
Figure 35
53
Health Problem Analysis Worksheet Indirect Contributing FactorDirect Contributing Factor
Indirect Contributing Factor
Risk Factor Direct Contributing Factor
Indirect Contributing Factor
Direct Contributing Factor
Health Problem
Indirect Contributing Factor
Direct Contributing Factor
Indirect Contributing Factor
Risk Factor Direct Contributing Factor
Indirect Contributing Factor
Direct Contributing FactorTeen pregnancy Low perceived risk of drug or alcohol use
Lack of commitment to school
Tobacco use Mental health status
Access to tobacco products
No daycare
Limited education about importance
Poor health status
Low Birth Weight Lack of prenatal care Lack of transportation
Low self esteem
Truancy
Teen pregnancy Inadequate after school programs
Sexual promiscuity
Infant Mortality
Low SES
Lack of family support
Stress Poverty
Stress
Prematurity Smoking Easy access to cigarettes
54
CHILDHOOD LEAD
Lead is highly toxic, especially to young children. Lead exposure can result in lasting
impairment of a child’s development and behavior such as decreased IQ and attention span and
increased risk for delinquent behavior.
0.0%
1.0%
2.0%
3.0%
4.0%
5.0%
6.0%
7.0%
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
Percent of Children tested
Elevated Blood Lead Levels in Children
Kane
Illinois
US
Why is it important for us to focus on childhood lead exposure? Lead poisoning is entirely
preventable. The key is stopping children from coming into contact with lead and treating
children who have been poisoned by lead. Unfortunately, Illinois leads the nation in the
percentage of lead poisoned children. Outside of Cook County, Kane County has the highest
rate of childhood lead poisoning in the state. Nearly 1,500 children in Kane are documented to
have elevated blood lead levels and need to have their homes evaluated for lead hazards and
have the lead hazards reduced or eliminated.
Figure 36
55
Health Problem Root Cause Analysis Indirect Contributing FactorDirect Contributing Factor
Risk Factor
Indirect Contributing Factor
Direct Contributing Factor
Health Problem
Indirect Contributing Factor
Direct Contributing Factor
Risk Factor
Indirect Contributing Factor
Direct Contributing Factor
Low SES
Lead Poisoning
Lack of culturally appropriate messaging
Exposure to lead-based paint
Lack of access to electronic messaging
EducationPoverty
Language barriers
Use of lead cooking pots
Lack of culturally appropriate messaging
Cultural factors
Lack of access to abatement resourcesHouses built prior to 1978
Cultural practice Lack of access to electronic media
Language access
Communication Lack of access to electronic media
Language access
56
COMMUNICABLE DISEASE
A communicable disease such as a cold is a disease that spreads from person-to-person.
Communicable diseases are diseases that you can “catch” from someone or something else.
Why is it important for us to focus on communicable diseases? People in the United States
continue to get diseases that are vaccine preventable. Viral hepatitis, influenza, and tuberculosis
(TB) remain among the leading causes of illness and death in the United States and account for
substantial spending on the related consequences of infection. Because the U.S. health care
system focuses on treatment of illnesses, rather than health promotion, patients do not always
receive adequate information about prevention and healthy lifestyles.
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
Rate per 100,000
Tuberculosis Trends, 2000 to 2010
Kane Illinois IL Excl ChicagoSource: IL Dept of Public Health
Vaccines are among the most cost-effective clinical preventive services and are a core
component of any preventive services package. Childhood immunization programs provide a
very high return on investment. For example, for each birth cohort vaccinated with the routine
immunization schedule society:
Figure 37
57
✿ Saves 33,000 lives ✿ Prevents 14 million cases of disease ✿ Reduces direct health care costs by $9.9 billion ✿ Saves $33.4 billion in indirect costs10
Unfortunately, only 56% of 2 year olds in Kane County received the recommended vaccinations
in 2010. Outbreaks of communicable disease lead to increased absenteeism in workplaces and
schools and increased healthcare costs. A robust healthcare system in Kane County working to
prevent, identify early, and treat communicable diseases is critical to reducing the burden of
communicable disease.
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
2005 2006 2007 2008 2010
Percent of Records Assessed
Adequate Immunization for 24 ‐ 35 Month Olds (4:3:3:1:3)
Kane
Illinois
DTP/DTap 4, POLIO 3+, MMR 1, Hib 3+, & Hep B 3
Source: Illinois Dept of Public Health
10 “Immunization and Infectious Diseases” HealthyPeople2020.gov http://www.healthypeople.gov/2020/topicsobjectives2020/overview.aspx?topicid=23
Figure 38
58
Health Problem Root Cause Analysis Indirect Contributing FactorDirect Contributing Factor
Risk FactorDirect Contributing Factor
Direct Contributing Factor
Health Problem
Direct Contributing Factor
Risk Factor
Direct Contributing Factor
Communicable Disease
Restaurant staff not trained on proper food handling
Perception of vaccine safety
Lack of know ledge of available immunization resources
Media coverage on linking autism to vaccination
Multiple sexual partners
Immunization coverage
Injection drug use
Low socio-economic status
Unsasfe food handling at restaurants Lack of funding resources to remedy food violations
Sale of homemade foods at restaurants
Unemployment
Access to healthcare High health insurance deductible
Low socio-economic status
Foodborne contamination
Increased incidence of vaccine-preventable diseases
High risk behavior
Lack of know ledge of proper foodhandling
Unsafe food handling at home Cultural norms
59
POOR SOCIAL AND EMOTIONAL WELLNESS
Mental health is a state of successful performance of mental function, resulting in productive
activities, fulfilling relationships with other people, and the ability to adapt to change and to
cope with challenges. Mental health is essential to personal well-being, family and interpersonal
relationships, and the ability to contribute to community or society.
Why is it important for us to focus on poor social and emotional wellness? Mental disorders
are among the most common causes of disability. The resulting disease burden of mental illness
is among the highest of all diseases.
0.0%
2.0%
4.0%
6.0%
8.0%
10.0%
12.0%
14.0%
North Central South Kane
Percent of Adult Population
Kane Adults Reporting Their Mental Health Was Not Good 14 or More Days in Last 30 Days
Kane County Community Health Survey 2011
Mental health and physical health are closely connected. Mental health plays a major role in
people’s ability to maintain good physical health. Mental illnesses, such as depression and
anxiety, affect people’s ability to participate in health-promoting behaviors. In turn, problems
with physical health, such as chronic diseases, can have a serious impact on mental health and
decrease a person’s ability to participate in treatment and recovery.
Figure 39
60
81%
82%
82%
83%
83%
84%
84%
85%
85%
86%
North Central South Kane
Percent of Adult Population
Kane Adults Reporting Usually/Always Getting Social/Emotional Support
Kane County Community Health Survey 2011
Figure 40
61
Health Problem Root Cause Analysis Indirect Contributing FactorDirect Contributing Factor
Risk Factor
Health Problem
Direct Contributing Factor
Risk Factor
Low education
Low SES Unemployment
Under-employment
Lack of access to quality early developmental resources
Lack of culturally appropriate messaging
Communication Lack of access to electronic media
Language access
Financial constraints of agencies
Capacity of early childhood programs Language access
Shortage of qualif ied staff
Social and Emotional Wellness
Low education
Stress
Stress Unemployment
Under-employment
Depression
Sudden change in SES due to layoffs
Alcohol Family history
Lack of physical activity
Self Image Poor nutrition
Lack of tailored relevant health messaging
62
Part 3 Community Health Improvement Plan
Community Health Improvement Plan
The collaborative effort on the 2011 Community Health Assessment continues with the update to
the Community Health Improvement Plan. The Kane County Community Health Improvement
Plan (CHIP) is a comprehensive set of policy and program recommendations for our community
based on the most up-to-date information. It identifies areas where we can have the largest
impact on improving the quality of life for all Kane residents – particularly the most vulnerable
residents of our community – by reducing preventable sickness and death. Each priority area is
equally important in improving our health and well-being. All priorities have goals and measures
for improvement over the next five years. These will be tracked and reported each year.
The plan can be used by health, government, education, community, social service, faith-based
and other agencies to identify where resources are best directed to improve the quality of life in
Kane County. Individuals and agencies are encouraged to identify the areas they are best
positioned to support and use the recommended strategies to help make their community
healthier.
The plan includes four overarching priorities which address each of the six top health threats and
complement the goals of the Kane County 2040 Plan. The priorities were developed by
considering the root causes contributing to the health issues we face. In order to successfully
address the health threats, we must focus our efforts not only on better access to medical care or
personal behaviors but also on assuring that our social, economic and built environments
contribute to good health. The priorities recognize the interconnectedness of our personal
behaviors with the systems and environments we live in. To be successful in improving
population health, we believe we have to address issues in each of these areas. Each priority is
color-coded and the strategies, measures, and goals are easily tied back to the priorities.
Priority 1: Support Health Behaviors that Promote Well-Being and Prevent Disease
Priority 2: Increase Access to High Quality, Holistic Preventive and Treatment Services Across the Health Care System
Priority 3: Support and Create Health Promoting Neighborhoods, Towns and Cities
Priority 4: Promote Social, Economic, and Educational Environments that Optimize Health
63
The four priorities align with the State Health Improvement Plan (SHIP) for Illinois. In 2010,
the state identified five “Public Health System Priorities” which came out of their review of
existing state and local plans and other data.11
Improve Access to Health Services
Enhance Data and Health Information Technology
Address Social Determinants of Health and Health Disparities
Measure, Manage, Improve and Sustain the Public Health System
Assure a Sufficient Workforce and Human Resources
Aligning our efforts with those of the state helps reinforce the importance of working together to
make the most out of limited resources. If local health departments are all working toward
similar goals, there is a greater chance for positive change at the local level and statewide.
The priorities were also created to
coordinate with the National
Prevention Strategy, which is a
federal-level public health plan to
move the nation’s focus away from
sickness and disease to prevention
and wellness.12 The Strategy
identifies four Strategic Directions
and includes seven priorities with
evidence-based recommendations
for action utilizing federal resources
as well as state and local level
partnerships with public health
professionals and public and private
organizations (see Figure 41)
11 Illinois Department of Public Health. Illinois State Health Improvement Plan 2010. http://www.idph.state.il.us/ship/09-10_Plan/SHIP_Final_2010.pdf 12 National Prevention Council, National Prevention Strategy, Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of the Surgeon General, 2011 http://www.healthcare.gov/prevention/nphpphc/strategy/report.pdf
Figure 41
64
The four Strategic Directions are:
Healthy and Safe Community Environments
Clinical and Community Preventive Services
Empowered People
Elimination of Health Disparities
Like the SHIP, the National Prevention Strategy is based on the idea that all sectors must work
together to address the most pressing health issues in the United States.
Priorities and Strategies
Within each priority, several strategies are identified to address major contributing factors to
premature illness and death. The recommended strategies are supported by evidence of success
or “evidence-based practice.” The “Community Guide”13 published by the Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention, includes more information about each of these strategies and the careful
study and research that supports these strategies as being effective. Each strategy includes a
measure as well as baseline data and the goal for the next five years. These measures and goals
were determined and reviewed by stakeholders including the Community Assessment Partners,
Kane County Health Advisory Committee, Kane County Board of Health, and Kane County staff
members. Each measure will be tracked and reported on each year to provide an update on the
progress made towards the 2016 goals. The detailed description of the strategies along with
specific measures and explanations of each are found at the end of this section. The following is
a listing of the strategies, how they align with the top six threats to community health, and a
summary of each one with evidence supporting the selection of each.
13 “The Community Guide” Community Preventive Services Taskforce http://www.thecommunityguide.org/index.html
65
Community Health Improvement Plan Priorities and Strategies
Priority 1 – Support Health Behaviors that Promote Well-Being and Prevent DiseaseReduce tobacco use and exposure to environmental tobacco smoke.
Increase access to, and consumption, of fresh fruits and
vegetables.
Coordinate the effective communication of tailored,
accurate and actionable health information to Kane County residents across the lifespan.
Create environments that prevent excessive consumption of
alcohol.
Priority 2 – Increase Access to High Quality, Holistic Preventive and Treatment Services Across the Health Care System
Increase the proportion of residents of all ages that have regular, ongoing sources of medical and
dental care.
Increase the proportion of residents of all ages who
receive appropriate, evidence-based clinical
preventive services.
Focus culturally appropriate outreach and
engagement efforts to eliminate racial disparities
in health outcomes, especially in infant
mortality.
Enhance systems to support the prevention, early identification and
treatment of communicable diseases in
the community.
Enhance systems to support the prevention, early identification and
evidence-based treatment of mental health
conditions.
Priority 3 –Support & Create Health Promoting Neighborhoods, Towns & Cities
Increase the availability and variety of high quality, safe and affordable housing and compact,
mixed use developments.
Institute “complete streets” types of policies to ensure that
roadways are designed and operated with all users in mind -
including bicyclists, public transportation vehicles and riders,
and pedestrians of all ages and abilities.
Assure access to safe playgrounds, parks, trails and
open space.
Assure access to safe food and clean and safe water and air.
Priority 4 – Promote Social, Economic and Educational Environments that Optimize Health Increase the proportion of children who have
high-quality early developmental support, especially in child care and education.
Increase the proportion of Kane County young people that complete high school education.
Increase the job skills and readiness of Kane County residents that are unemployed.
66
Priorities and Strategies Aligned with 6 Top Threats to Community Health
Priority 1 – Support Health Behaviors that Promote
Well-Being and Prevent Disease
Priority 2 – Increase Access to High Quality, Holistic Preventive and Treatment Services Across the Health
Care System
Reduce tobacco use
and exposure to
environmental tobacco smoke.
Increase access to, and consumption, of fresh fruits
and vegetables.
Coordinate the effective
communication of tailored,
accurate and actionable
health information to Kane County
residents across the lifespan.
Create environments that prevent
excessive consumption
of alcohol.
Increase the
proportion of
residents of all ages that have regular, ongoing
sources of medical
and dental care.
Increase the proportion of residents of all ages
who receive appropriate,
evidence-based
clinical preventive services.
Focus culturally
appropriate outreach and engagement
efforts to eliminate
racial disparities in
health outcomes,
especially in infant
mortality.
Enhance systems to support the prevention,
early identification and treatment
of communicable diseases in the
community.
Enhance systems to support the prevention,
early identificatio
n and evidence-
based treatment of mental
health conditions.
Obesity
X X X X X X
Chronic Disease
X X X X X X X X
Infant Mortality
X X X X X X X X
Childhood Lead
Poisoning X X X X
Communicable
Disease X X X X X X
Poor Social &
Emotional Wellness
X X X X X X
67
Priority 3 – Support & Create Health Promoting Neighborhoods, Towns & Cities
Priority 4 – Promote Social, Economic and Educational Environments that
Optimize Health
Increase the availability and variety of high quality, safe
and affordable housing and
compact, mixed use
developments.
Institute “complete
streets” types of policies to ensure that
roadways are designed and operated with
all users in mind -
including bicyclists,
public transportation vehicles and riders, and
pedestrians of all ages and
abilities.
Assure access to safe
playgrounds, parks, trails and open
space.
Assure access to safe
food and clean
and safe water
and air.
Increase the proportion of children who
have high-quality early
developmental support,
especially in child care and
education.
Increase the
proportion of Kane County young
people that complete
high school
education.
Increase the job skills and readiness of Kane County residents that
are unemployed.
Obesity X X X X X X
Chronic Disease X X X X X X
Infant Mortality X X X X
Childhood Lead Poisoning X X X X
Communicable Disease X X X
Poor Social & Emotional Wellness
X X X X X X
68
Strategy Selection
SUPPORT HEALTH BEHAVIORS THAT PROMOTE WELL-BEING
AND PREVENT DISEASE
1. Reduce tobacco use and exposure to environmental tobacco smoke.
3. Coordinate the effective communication of tailored, accurate and actionable health information to Kane County residents across their lifespan.
2. Increase access to and consumption of, fresh fruits and vegetables.
4. Create environments that prevent excessive consumption of alcohol.
The County Health Rankings model (see Figure 2 ) indicates that health behaviors account for
30% of health outcomes and the National Prevention Strategy recommends empowering people
to make healthy choices as a method of improving community health.14 The information
gathered as part of the assessment, along with the evidence from the two models, emphasizes
that personal health choices and behaviors are an important component in overall health and
should be a key priority for the Community Health Improvement Plan.
The first strategy of reducing use of tobacco and exposure to environmental tobacco smoke has a
direct affect on chronic disease. According to the CDC, smoking causes certain types of cancer,
bronchitis, emphysema, heart disease, and stroke, all chronic diseases.15 Many people who do
not use tobacco products are exposed to hazardous environmental tobacco smoke and therefore
need to be protected through policies that prohibit smoking in public and private places.
14 National Prevention Council, National Prevention Strategy, Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of the Surgeon General, 2011 http://www.healthcare.gov/prevention/nphpphc/strategy/report.pdf 15 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. “Smoking-Attributable Mortality, Years of Potential Life Lost, and Productivity Losses—United States, 2000–2004,” Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 2008;57(45):1226–8. http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm5745a3.htm
PRIORITY 1
69
The next strategy calls for an increase in access to and consumption of fresh fruits and
vegetables. This strategy will help reduce obesity rates by providing residents with healthy
options, particularly those residents in lower-income areas who do not have healthy options
available in their neighborhoods. There is evidence that shows that access to supermarkets in
underserved areas leads to an increased consumption of fruits and vegetables by adults.16
The third strategy focuses on the coordination of effective communication, which has an impact
on all six top threats to community health. Health care and public health professionals are
turning to the Internet and other technology-dependent methods of sharing information to reach
as many people as possible. However, not everyone has access to or is comfortable with these
types of communications. We must take into account all residents across the lifespan and ensure
we are not leaving out any groups. Research has shown that those who do not receive messages
are more prone to lower usage rates of preventive services, less knowledge of chronic disease
management, higher rates of hospitalization, and poorer reported health status.17
The final strategy for Priority 1 addresses excessive consumption of alcohol.18 By creating
environments that prevent the excessive consumption of alcohol, we can influence rates of
obesity, chronic disease, infant mortality, and communicable disease for the better and have a
positive effect on social and emotional wellness. According to the County Health Rankings,
there is a strong correlation between excessive drinking and motor vehicle crashes due to
alcohol-impaired driving. In addition, excessive drinking puts residents at a higher risk for
alcohol poisoning, hypertension, fetal alcohol syndrome, sudden infant death syndrome, sexually
transmitted infections, and suicide.19 Preventing consumption of alcohol is a proactive method
for helping residents live healthier lives.
16 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. “Recommended Community Strategies and Measurements to Prevent Obesity in the United States,” Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report. 2009;58(7): 8. http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/rr5807a1.htm 17 “Health Communication and Health Information Technology” U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Healthy People.gov. http://www.healthypeople.gov/2020/topicsobjectives2020/overview.aspx?topicId=18 18 Excessive consumption refers to consuming 4 drinks in a session for women, 5 drinks in a session for men 19 Naimi TS, Brewer RD, Molded A, Denny C, Ferula MK, Marks JS. “Binge drinking among US adults,” Journal of the American Medical Association 2003;289:70—5 http://jama.ama-assn.org/content/289/1/70.full
70
Bright Spot: Elgin Community Garden Network
You could say the Elgin Community Garden Network is a “growing” affair. A passionate group of volunteers committed to teaching sustainable gardening skills and helping to feed the hungry in the Elgin area, the ECGN has worked with the Elgin Firefighters to raise money to support their efforts. The Fire Fighters also contributed time and labor to help build and install the gardens. The ECGN has created a partnership with the City of Elgin to raise funds and to use city land for gardens. In addition, the Network has received two $10,000 Fit Kids grants from the Making Kane County Fit for Kids Funders Consortium for its programs. The EGCN has participated with the City adding gardening to summer pre-school and youth programs. School District U-46 is also an active participant.
The gardening effort in Elgin has continued to expand and “grow,” supporting health behaviors that promote well-being and prevent disease. The gardens increase access to and consumption of fresh fruits and vegetables as a way to help battle chronic disease. A focus of the gardening effort is children. The children participate in “planting days,” and plenty of fun and educational opportunities are scheduled for them. Here, they get a hands-on education. The original goal was to provide 200 pounds of produce to local soup kitchens and food pantries. This past season they donated almost 700 pounds of fresh produce. And, their reach extends beyond growing and giving produce away. In addition to planting giving gardens, the ECGN team has located gardens at low income housing complexes and local schools. In the past year, more gardens have been added and include schools, The Centre, East Side Recreation Center and low income communities. There are now 17 garden sites and plans are already underway for the 2012 season. The ECGN has continued to add partnerships to work together to expand the reach of the gardens. For a complete list of all the gardening events and opportunities, check out the Elgin Community Garden Network, Facebook page at http://www.facebook.com/ElginCommunityGardens.
71
INCREASE ACCESS TO HIGH QUALITY, HOLISTIC PREVENTIVE
AND TREATMENT SERVICES ACROSS THE HEALTH CARE
SYSTEM
Increase the proportion of residents of all ages that have regular, ongoing sources of medical and dental care.
Enhance systems to support the prevention, early identification and treatment of communicable diseases in the community.
Increase the proportion of residents of all ages who receive appropriate, evidence-based clinical preventive services.
Enhance systems to support the prevention, early identification and evidence-based treatment of mental health conditions.
Focus culturally appropriate outreach and engagement efforts to eliminate racial disparities in health outcomes, especially in infant mortality.
Preventive care is a key method of maintaining proper health and goes beyond trips to the
doctor’s office. The entire community plays a role in preventive care, from policies and
programs that encourage people to get the care they need to sharing information with other
agencies to identify potential outbreaks of diseases and communicating services available to
residents. The quality of services and access to treatment is also an important component of
health. Quality care is tailored to the patient, timely, and appropriate for the problem. Treatment
for mental health conditions will help people achieve psychological, social, and emotional well-
being which can lead to better overall health.20 This priority was chosen because it is a proactive
way of improving health, rather than a reactive view of addressing the symptom instead of the
root cause.
The first strategy in this priority is to increase the proportion of residents that have regular,
ongoing sources of medical and dental care. Having a primary care provider increases patient
trust in the provider, helps maintain provider-patient communication, and leads to a greater 20 “Mental Health Basics” Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. http://www.cdc.gov/mentalhealth/basics.htm
PRIORITY 2
72
likelihood that patients will receive the care they need.21 Studies have shown that having a usual
and ongoing source of care will lead to better health outcomes and fewer disparities, which in
turn will reduce rates of obesity, chronic disease, and other threats to community health
identified in the health assessment.22
The next strategy will increase the proportion of residents who receive appropriate, evidence-
based clinical preventive services. This strategy affects all of the top threats because of the
evidence that early intervention leads to better health outcomes by detecting early warning signs
or symptoms (proactive) or by early detection of a problem allowing for early treatment.23 In
addition, clinical preventive services include childhood immunizations which prevent disease,
which is measured as part of this strategy.
The third strategy is to focus culturally appropriate outreach and engagement efforts to eliminate
racial disparities in health outcomes, especially in infant mortality. According to the Robert
Wood Johnson report, “Overcoming Obstacles to Health”, there is a disparity in health by
race/ethnicity at every income level, with African-Americans and Hispanics reporting poor/fair
health.24 In Kane County, there is a great disparity in infant mortality, with African-American
babies having a higher rate than Hispanics and whites. Infant mortality is recognized as the best
single measure of the health of a population, group, or community and ties in with the six top
threats to community health.25
Strategy Four is focused on enhancing systems to support the prevention, early identification and
treatment of communicable diseases in the community. This strategy is relevant to the top threat
of communicable disease, as the county is responding to a large outbreak of tuberculosis in a
community. The surveillance of communicable diseases leads to early intervention and is an
21 “Access to Health Services” U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Healthy People.gov http://www.healthypeople.gov/2020/topicsobjectives2020/overview.aspx?topicid=1 22 http://www.healthypeople.gov/2020/topicsobjectives2020/overview.aspx?topicid=1 23 http://www.healthypeople.gov/2020/topicsobjectives2020/overview.aspx?topicid=1 24 Braverman, Paula and Egeter, Susan. Report from the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation to the Commission to Build a Healthier America: Overcoming Obstacles to Health. Princeton, NJ: Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, 2008. http://www.rwjf.org/files/research/obstaclestohealth.pdf 25 Reidpath DD, Allotey P. Infant mortality rate as an indicator of population health. Journal of Epidemiology& Community Health.2003;57:344–6
73
important tool for public health professionals, reducing illness, hospitalization, and death from
vaccine-preventable diseases and other infectious diseases.26
The final strategy for Priority 2 is enhancing systems to support the prevention, early
identification and evidence-based treatment of mental health conditions. Mental health is closely
related to physical health, affecting people’s ability to maintain good physical health and
participate in health promoting behaviors.27 The CDC’s “Healthy Days” questions allow us to
track mental health status using an internationally recognized standard for measuring population
health.28
26 “Immunization and Infectious Diseases” U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Healthy People.gov. http://www.healthypeople.gov/2020/topicsobjectives2020/overview.aspx?topicId=23 27 “Mental Health and Mental Disorders” U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Healthy People.gov http://www.healthypeople.gov/2020/topicsobjectives2020/overview.aspx?topicid=28 28 “Surveillance Overview” Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. http://www.cdc.gov/hrqol/overview.htm
74
SUPPORT & CREATE HEALTH-PROMOTING NEIGHBORHOODS, TOWNS, & CITIES
Increase the availability and variety of high quality, safe and affordable housing and compact, mixed-use development.
Assure access to safe playgrounds, parks, trails and open space.
Institute “complete streets” types of policies to ensure that roadways are designed and operated with all users in mind – including bicyclists, public transportation vehicles and riders, and pedestrians of all ages and abilities.
Assure access to safe food and clean and safe water and air.
The environment, both the built where we live, learn, work, and play and the natural, plays a
critical role in our health and well-being. Living in safe housing gives us a chance to be
physically active and protects us from environmental hazards like lead and allergens.29 Increased
use of public transportation decreases air pollution, leading to better health outcomes for
residents. This priority focuses on the environmental factors that affect our health and what can
be done to improve community health.
The first strategy is to increase the availability and variety of high quality, safe and affordable
housing and compact, mixed use developments. This strategy will have an effect on obesity,
chronic disease, childhood lead poisoning, and social/emotional wellness. The percent of
children in Kane County with elevated blood lead levels is higher than Illinois overall. Children
with high levels of lead in their blood are at risk for damage to the brain and nervous system,
29 National Prevention Council, National Prevention Strategy, Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Office of the Surgeon General, 2011 http://www.healthcare.gov/prevention/nphpphc/strategy/report.pdf
PRIORITY 3
75
behavior and learning problems, slowed growth, and hearing problems, making this one of the
top threats to community health in Kane County.30
The next strategy is to institute “complete streets” types of policies to ensure that roadways are
designed and operated with all users in mind - including bicyclists, public transportation vehicles
and riders, and pedestrians of all ages and abilities. These policies increase opportunities for
residents to incorporate physical activity into their daily routine, leading to lower rates of obesity
and chronic disease, as well as improving social and emotional wellness. Residents will have
greater success in losing weight and maintaining a healthy weight if they are engaged in regular
physical activity.31
The next strategy is to assure access to safe playgrounds, parks, trails and open space. Looking
at children in particular, they need a safe environment where they are able to utilize parks, trails,
and open spaces to get the physical activity they need to be healthy. The problem of childhood
obesity in Kane County is alarming, with 14.7% of children considered overweight and another
21.8% of children considered obese.32 As with the prior strategy, maintaining a healthy weight is
easier when people are engaged in regular physical activity.
The final strategy for this priority is to assure access to safe food and clean and safe water and air
which contribute to the top threats of chronic disease and communicable disease. The measure
for this strategy focuses on foodborne outbreaks in Kane County. The CDC estimates that each
year roughly 48 million people get sick, 128,000 are hospitalized, and 3,000 die of foodborne
diseases in the U.S.33 By keeping the food system safe for all residents through preventive
methods like food safety, education, surveillance and restaurant inspections, we can help control
and prevent foodborne outbreaks.
30 “Lead in Paint, Dust, and Soil”, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency http://www.epa.gov/lead/pubs/leadinfo.htm#health 31 “Physical Activity for a Healthy Weight”, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention http://www.cdc.gov/healthyweight/physical_activity/index.html 32 Kane County Community Health Survey, 2011 33 “2011 Estimates of Foodborne Illness” Centers for Disease Control and Prevention http://www.cdc.gov/foodborneburden/2011-foodborne-estimates.html
76
Bright Spots: Aurora Township
As we battle the epidemic of childhood obesity, we see the importance of physical activity as a way to help combat the chronic diseases that are so often associated with it. We know that physical activity is an important part of regular family life, and children are more likely to remain active throughout their lives if they learn those lifestyle behaviors at an early age.
In urban areas, one of the biggest barriers for children increasing physical activity is providing access to safe playgrounds, parks, trails and open space. That’s where Aurora Township comes in. With the help of business donations, local volunteers and Fit Kids grants from the Making Kane County Fit for Kids Funders Consortium, new playground equipment was installed Nov. 11th and 12th , 2011.
At the site of a previous eyesore, the new playground is at the corner of Jackson Street and Montgomery Road. Up until about 10 years ago, the property was a virtual dump. Only after a significant clean-up nine years ago was the property turned into a soccer field, and then an additional field was added. Now, the equipment has been added. The equipment was installed to give siblings a place to be physically active while they watch soccer. Prior to this, parents bribed the younger kids into behaving with food. Now they can be physically active.
The equipment was chosen with the help of children and is geared toward ages 3 to 12. As many as 52 kids can be active at the same time and swings will be added in the near future. Community donations of cement were given by Ace Hardware and Farm and Fleet. Muscle was provided by local Labor Union 149 who helped install the playground as volunteers on Veterans Day. Also, 15 soccer parents lent their muscles, and one entire family, including a 4-year-old, helped. This was truly a community project.
77
PROMOTE SOCIAL, ECONOMIC AND EDUCATIONAL
ENVIRONMENTS THAT OPTIMIZE HEALTH
Increase the proportion of children who have high-quality early developmental support, especially in child care and education.
Increase the job skills and readiness of Kane County residents that are unemployed.
Increase the proportion of Kane County young people that complete high school education
The fourth priority focuses on education and employment, recognizing the important link
between these factors and health. People with higher educational attainment are better equipped
to make decisions about their health behaviors and those of their family. Those who are
employed have access to employer-sponsored health insurance, including employee wellness
programs, and the income provides enough money to afford to live in a safe neighborhood, with
quality schools and access to healthy food.
The first strategy is to increase the proportion of children who have high-quality early
developmental support, especially in child care and education. Children’s health is shaped by
community influences such as safety, school quality, presence of favorable role models and
availability of healthful foods and recreational opportunities.34 Helping children get the early
childhood support they need, through school or family-based programs will help them live
healthier lives.
The next strategy is increase the proportion of Kane young people that complete high school
education. The relationship between higher education and improved health outcomes is well
known, with higher education leading to increased job opportunities which generally provide
34 Egerter, S., Braveman, P., Pamuk, E., Cubbin, C., Dekker, M., Pedregon, V., Sadegh-Nobari, T. Robert Wood Johnson Foundation Commission to Build a Healthier America, America’s Health Starts with Healthy Children: How do States Compare? http://www.commissiononhealth.org/Documents/ChildrensHealth_Chartbook.pdf
PRIORITY 4
78
access to health care.35 Not only does one’s education level affect his or her health; education
can have multigenerational implications that make it an important measure for the health of
future generations. The following graphic illustrates how a parent’s educational attainment is
important in a child’s environment and the effect on health.36
35 Cutler D, Lleras-Muney A. Education and Health: Evaluating Theories and Evidence. Cambridge, MA: National Bureau of Economic Research;2006. Working Paper Series, no. 12352 http://www.nber.org/papers/w12352.pdf 36 Egerter, S., Braveman, P., Pamuk, E., Cubbin, C., Dekker, M., Pedregon, V., Sadegh-Nobari, T. Robert Wood Johnson Foundation Commission to Build a Healthier America, America’s Health Starts with Healthy Children: How do States Compare? 2008. http://www.commissiononhealth.org/Documents/ChildrensHealth_Chartbook.pdf
Higher levels of parents' education
Better jobs and increased family
income
Affordability of good housing, a
safe neighborhood with access to recreational
opportunities and nutritious diet
Higher levels of parents' education
Healthier behaviors by
parents
Good role models for children and lower exposure to
unhealthy conditions such as secondhand
smoke
Increased family income
Resources to cope with
stressors (e.g., child care,
transportation, health
insurance)
Decreased levels of
chronic stress experienced by children
Positive effects on neuroendocrine systems that can lead to lesser
risks for developing
chronic diseases such as heart disease and diabetes
79
The final strategy in Priority 4 is to increase the job skills and readiness of Kane County
residents that are unemployed. There is a strong correlation between employment and health,
particularly in access to care and mental health. Unemployment in particular has been shown to
lead to an increase in unhealthy behaviors related to alcohol and tobacco consumption, diet,
exercise, and other health-related behaviors, which in turn can lead to increased risk for disease
or mortality.37 Studies have also shown that people who lose a job through no fault of their own
were twice as likely to develop a new health problem, such as high blood pressure, diabetes, or
heart disease over the next year and a half compared with those who were continuously
employed.38 Through coordinating job training programs and increasing job skills, we can
address all of the six top threats to community health in Kane County.
37 “Employment” County Health Rankings http://www.countyhealthrankings.org/health-factors/employment 38 Strully, Kate W., “Job Loss and Health in the U.S. Labor Market” Demography 46 no. 2, (2009): 221-246. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2831278/
80
Detailed Priorities and Strategies Strategy Measure Data Source Evidence
Priority 1 –
Support Health
Behaviors that Promote Well-Being and Prevent
Disease
Reduce tobacco use and exposure to environmental tobacco smoke.
Measure: Percentage of Kane County adults (over age 18) who report being current smokers. Current smoking was defined as having smoked at least 100 cigarettes in a lifetime and still smoking some days or every day. 2011 Baseline: 12% of Kane County adults report smoking cigarettes currently 2016 Goal: Decrease percent of adults who currently smoke to 9%
Kane County Community Health Survey (CHS).
The percentage of the adult population who are current smokers represents the extent of health risk in a community related to tobacco use. Measuring the prevalence of tobacco use in the population can alert communities to potential adverse health outcomes in the future and can be valuable for assessing the need for cessation programs or the effectiveness of existing programs. http://www.countyhealthrankings.org/health-factors/tobacco-use
Increase access to, and consumption, of fresh fruits and vegetables.
Measure: Percentage of Kane County adults who report eating at least five servings of fruits and vegetables per day. 2011 Baseline: 14.4% of adults 25.5% of children 2016 Goal:
17.3% for adults 30.6% for children
Kane County Community Health Survey or Illinois BRFSS
Access to and availability of healthier foods can help people follow healthful diets. For example, better access to retail venues that sell healthier options may have a positive impact on a person’s diet; these venues may be less available in low-income or rural neighborhoods. HP2020: http://www.healthypeople.go
81
v/2020/topicsobjectives2020/overview.aspx?topicId=29#nine
Coordinate the effective communication of tailored, accurate and actionable health information to Kane County residents across the lifespan.
Measure: The percent of the adult population that is satisfied with health communication from the KCHD. 2011 Baseline: 89% satisfied (2009 H1N1 campaign) 2016 Goal:
60% very satisfied 30% satisfied
Kane County H1N1 Communications Survey
Effective use of communication and technology by health care and public health professionals can bring about an age of patient- and public-centered health information and services. By strategically combining health IT tools and effective health communication processes, there is the potential to:
Improve health care quality and safety.
Increase the efficiency of health care and public health service delivery.
Improve the public health information infrastructure.
Support care in the community and at home.
Facilitate clinical and consumer decision-making.
Build health skills and knowledge.
HP2020:
82
http://www.healthypeople.gov/2020/topicsobjectives2020/overview.aspx?topicid=18
Create environments that prevent excessive consumption of alcohol.
Measure: The percent of the adult population that reports consuming more than 4 (women) or 5 (men) alcoholic beverages on a single occasion in the past 30 days. 2011 Baseline: 27.6% of adults 2016 Goal: 22% of adults
Kane County CHS or Illinois BRFSS
Excessive drinking is a risk factor for a number of adverse health outcomes such as alcohol poisoning, hypertension, acute myocardial infarction, sexually transmitted infections, unintended pregnancy, fetal alcohol syndrome, sudden infant death syndrome, suicide, interpersonal violence, and motor vehicle crashes. County Health Rankings: http://www.countyhealthrankings.org/health-factors/alcohol-use
Priority 2 – Increase Access to
High Quality, Holistic
Preventive and
Treatment Services
Across the Health
Increase the proportion of residents of all ages that have regular, ongoing sources of medical and dental care.
Measure: The percent of adult population that reports having a personal doctor or health care provider. 2011 Baseline: 83.6% of adults 2016 Goal: 88% of adults
Kane County CHS or Illinois BRFSS
Improving health care services depends in part on ensuring that people have a usual and ongoing source of care. People with a usual source of care have better health outcomes and fewer disparities and costs. HP2020: http://www.healthypeople.gov/2020/topicsobjectives2020/overview.aspx?topicId=1
83
Care System
Increase the proportion of residents of all ages who receive appropriate, evidence-based clinical preventive services.
Measures: Hospitalization rate for diabetes
per 100,000 residents The percent of two-year olds
who receive age-appropriate immunizations.
2011 Baseline:
138 hospitalizations for diabetes per 100,000 residents (2009)
56% of two-year olds received age-appropriate immunizations (2010).
2016 Goal:
100 hospitalizations for diabetes per 100,000 residents
75% of two-year olds receive age-appropriate immunizations
Illinois Department of Public Health
Hospitalization for diagnoses amenable to outpatient services suggests that the quality of care provided in the outpatient setting was less than ideal. The measure may also represent the population’s tendency to overuse the hospital as a main source of care. CHR: http://www.countyhealthrankings.org/illinois/kane/5 Vaccines are among the most cost-effective clinical preventive services and are a core component of any preventive services package. Childhood immunization programs provide a very high return on investment. For example, for each birth cohort vaccinated with the routine immunization schedule (this includes DTap, Td, Hib, Polio, MMR, Hep B, and varicella vaccines), society:
Saves 33,000 lives. Prevents 14 million
cases of disease. Reduces direct health
84
care costs by $9.9 billion.
Saves $33.4 billion in indirect costs.
HP2020: http://www.healthypeople.gov/2020/topicsobjectives2020/overview.aspx?topicId=23
Focus culturally appropriate outreach and engagement efforts to eliminate racial disparities in health outcomes, especially in infant mortality.
Measure: African American infant mortality rate per 1,000 live births (5-year average) 2011 Baseline: 12.2 deaths per 1,000 live births (2003-2007) 2016 Goal: 9.8 deaths per 1,000 live births
Illinois Department of Public Health
Infant mortality rates are an important indicator of the health of a nation because they are associated with maternal health, quality of and access to medical care, socioeconomic conditions, and public health practices. CDC: http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/su6001a9.htm
Enhance systems to support the prevention, early identification and treatment of communicable diseases in the community.
Measure: The number of new cases (Incidence) of Tuberculosis in Kane County per 100,000 residents. 2011 Baseline: 6 confirmed cases per 100,000 residents 2016 Goal: 2 confirmed cases per 100,000 residents
Kane County Health Department, Disease Prevention Division
The infectious disease public health infrastructure, which carries out disease surveillance at the federal, state, and local levels, is an essential tool in the fight against newly emerging and re-emerging infectious diseases. HP2020:
85
http://www.healthypeople.gov/2020/topicsobjectives2020/overview.aspx?topicId=23
Enhance systems to support the prevention, early identification and evidence-based treatment of mental health conditions.
Measure: Percentage of Adults Reporting Poor Mental Health. Data represent adults who reported their mental health was not good on 14 or more days during the past 30 days. 2011 Baseline: 9% of adults 2016 Goal: 7% of adults
Kane County Community Health Survey or Illinois BRFSS
The CDC Healthy Days measures are an acknowledged standard for population health surveillance by national and international groups. The four core Healthy Days questions have been asked of all participants in the Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System (BRFSS) from 1993 through 2009 (except in 2002 when only 20 states asked these questions). Since 2000, the Healthy Days measures have also been administered to respondents aged 12 years or older in the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES). These measures are now accepted as standards in the United States and have been used in other countries including Canada, Sweden, and Italy. http://www.cdc.gov/hrqol/overview.htm
Priority 3 – Support & Create
Increase the availability and variety of high quality, safe and
Measure: Percent of children under six years old with elevated blood lead levels
Kane County Health Department, Disease Prevention
Lead exposure can result in lasting impairment of a child’s development and
86
Health Promoting Neighborhoods, Towns & Cities
affordable housing and compact, mixed use developments.
2011 Baseline: 1.0% of children less than 6 years old tested have elevated lead levels in their blood. 2016 Goal: 0.65% of children less than 6 years old tested will have elevated lead levels in their blood.
Division behavior such as decreased IQ and attention span and increased risk for delinquent behavior (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention 2005d).
Institute “complete streets” types of policies to ensure that roadways are designed and operated with all users in mind - including bicyclists, public transportation vehicles and riders, and pedestrians of all ages and abilities.
Measure: The percent of Kane County adults who meet the recommended level of physical activity. The percent of Kane County adults who are considered obese as measured by their Body Mass Index (BMI). 2011 Baseline:
53.5% of adults meet physical activity recommendations.
29.4% of adults are considered obese.
2016 Goal:
64% of adults meet physical activity recommendations
26% of adults are considered obese
Kane County CHS Most weight loss occurs because of decreased caloric intake. However, evidence shows the only way to maintain weight loss is to be engaged in regular physical activity. Most importantly physical activity reduces risks of cardiovascular disease and diabetes beyond that produced by weight reduction alone. CDC: http://www.cdc.gov/healthyweight/physical_activity/index.html
Assure access to safe playgrounds, parks, trails and open space.
Measure: The percentage of Kane County children who are considered obese as measured by their BMI. 2011 Baseline: 21.8% of children under 18 are considered obese
Kane County CHS Physical activity is an important part of regular family life. Studies have shown that lifestyles learned as children are much more likely to stay with a person into adulthood. If
87
2016 Goal: 18.5% of children under 18 are considered obese
sports and physical activities are a family priority, they will provide children and parents with a strong foundation for a lifetime of health. American Academy of Pediatrics: http://www.aap.org/healthtopics/physact.cfm
Assure access to safe food and clean and safe water and air.
Measure: The number of foodborne outbreaks identified in Kane County. 2011 Baseline: 3 confirmed foodborne outbreaks in 2011 2016 Goal: 0 confirmed foodborne outbreaks
Kane County Health Department
Foodborne diseases affect tens of millions of people and kill thousands in the United States each year. They also cause billions of dollars in healthcare-related and industry costs annually. CDC: http://www.cdc.gov/WinnableBattles/FoodSafety/index.html
Priority 4 – Promoting Social, Economic and Educational environments that optimize
Increase the proportion of children who have high-quality early developmental support, especially in child care and education.
Measure: This measure is not finalized and is under development. The intended measure will be based on the kindergarten readiness assessment currently being developed in Illinois. The Illinois State Board of Education is establishing a Kindergarten Individual Development Survey (KIDS) Advisory Committee comprised of early childhood experts who will guide the state department of education as it
TBD Evidence shows that experiences in the 1st years of life are extremely important for a child’s healthy development and lifelong learning. How a child develops during this time affects future cognitive, social, emotional, and physical development, which influences school readiness
88
health moves forward with recommendations for developing a comprehensive kindergarten readiness assessment process. It is expected that the readiness assessment will be piloted this fall during the 2012-2013 school year. More information is available from the Illinois State Board of Education39
and later success in life. Research on a number of adult health and medical conditions points to predisease pathways that have their beginnings in early and middle childhood. (HP2020)
Increase the proportion of Kane County young people that complete high school education.
Measure: High school graduation rate, reported as the percent of the county’s ninth-grade cohort in public schools that graduates from high school in four years. 2011 Baseline: 87.1% (2011) Range: 68.7%-96% 2016 Goal: 90%
Illinois State Board of Education
The relationship between more education and improved health outcomes is well known, with years of formal education correlating strongly with improved work and economic opportunities, reduced psychosocial stress, and healthier lifestyles. CHR: http://www.countyhealthrankings.org/illinois/kane/21
Increase the job skills and readiness of Kane County residents that are unemployed.
Measure: The percent of the civilian labor force, age 16 and older, in Kane County that is unemployed but seeking work. Data is the most recent calendar-year annual estimate for unemployment. 2011 Baseline: 10.3% (2010 annual estimate) 2016 Goal: 5.4%
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), Local Area Unemployment Statistics (LAUS). The most recent calendar-year annual estimate for unemployment.
While employment has been associated with health improvements, unemployment has been linked with declines in health status. Unemployment may lead to physical health responses ranging from self-reported physical illness to mortality, especially suicide.
39 Kindergarten Readiness Stakeholder Committee Report to the Illinois Board of Education. “A New Beginning: The Illinois Kindergarten Individual Development Survey” April 2011. http://www.isbe.net/assessment/pdfs/agendas/KIDS/KIDS_report.pdf)
89
(National benchmark set at 90th percentile for all counties: 2012 County Health Rankings. Other important measures of success for this strategy include the percentage of workers who completed job skills enhancement programs who subsequently entered employment and retained employment three quarters after program completion.
Kane County Department of Employment & Education
It has also been shown to lead to an increase in unhealthy behaviors related to alcohol and tobacco consumption, diet, exercise, and other health-related behaviors, which in turn can lead to increased risk for disease or mortality. CHR: http://www.countyhealthrankings.org/health-factors/employment
90
Implementation
The Kane County Community Health Improvement Plan (CHIP) is designed to be implemented
by organizations and groups throughout the community. Through the Community Health
Assessment process, we identified six top threats to the health of our communities. We know that
these six threats: Obesity, Communicable Disease, Chronic Disease, Infant Mortality, Childhood
Lead Poisoning, and Poor Social & Emotional Wellness are responsible for much of the
premature illness and death in Kane County. These threats affect our quality of life every day.
The CHIP identifies four high priority areas for work over the next four years in order to address
the six top health threats. The priority areas consider that where we live, learn, work and play can
have a greater impact on how long and well we live than medical care alone. And, a person’s
health and chances of becoming sick and dying early are greatly influenced by powerful social
factors such as education, income, housing and neighborhoods. Fortunately, as individuals and as
a community, there are many actions we can take to make our communities healthier.
The CHIP recommends proven, evidence-based strategies for each of the four priority areas.
There are sixteen recommended strategies to address the top health threats. The strategies were
selected because there is existing evidence that shows these strategies can positively impact the
top health threats identified through the community health assessment. In an era of declining
resources for all agencies, it is more important than ever to focus our efforts and limited
resources on strategies that have been proven to work.
Clearly, not every organization can address all 16 strategies. Some strategies focus on changing
individual behavior and creating environments that make the healthy choice the easy choice.
Others focus on enhancing connections across the healthcare system, while others focus on
changing our neighborhoods to be more health promoting. The final set of strategies recognizes
the critical importance of education to a person’s health. The CHIP provides a framework of
recommended policies and programs to be implemented. Organizations throughout the county
can identify the strategies on which they can focus their efforts and resources and have the most
impact.
Hospitals may choose to focus their Community Benefit Plans on strategies to increase access to
high-quality, holistic preventive and treatment services. School districts might focus on
91
increasing students’ access to fresh fruits and vegetables through enhancements to their school
lunch programs. Faith communities might choose to promote walking to services as an
opportunity to increase physical activity. Municipalities can institute “complete streets” policies
to ensure that roadways are designed with all users in mind – including bicyclists, public
transportation vehicles and riders, and pedestrians of all ages and abilities. Community colleges
might enhance programs to train job seekers on the skills they need to qualify for new jobs. Over
the next six months, community leaders will be identified for each strategy and action plans will
be developed.
The CHIP is also part of a larger Kane County plan to shape our environments in ways that
promote and optimize health for all. For the first time, the Kane County 2040 Plan integrates
planning for community health with land use and transportation issues. The overarching theme
for the 2040 Plan is Healthy People, Healthy Living, Healthy Communities. This theme
recognizes and emphasizes the connection between the most important resource in Kane County
– its people – with the opportunities and barriers for healthy living created by the built and
natural environment, and how together they shape the overall health of communities.
Ultimately, the health of Kane County depends on the health of all residents. The Community
Health Improvement Plan calls on individuals, organizations, employers and communities to take
action using the recommended strategies to improve the health of Kane County residents. How
will you take action?
92
APPENDIX C
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The Kane County Health Department would like to thank our partners for their dedication of time and resources in completing the 2011 Kane County Community Health Assessment and 2012-2016 Community Health Improvement Plan. Without their expertise, input, and financial support, this plan would not have been possible.
Lynne Bosley, President, United Way of Elgin Edward Hunter, Vice President, Mission Services, Provena Mercy Medical Center and
Provena Saint Joseph Hospital Tina Link, Director, Community Outreach, Sherman Hospital Michael Meyer, President, Fox Valley United Way Jerry Murphy, Executive Director, INC Board Karin Podolski, Director, Community Health and Outreach, Cadence Health Terese Raabe, Director, Planning and Business Development, Rush-Copley Medical
Center The department would also like to thank the members of the Kane County Health Advisory Committee for their input and support throughout the assessment and planning process.
Lourdes Blacksmith, Director of Federal and Cultural Relations, Waubonsee Community College
Richard Chroust, DDS Diane Homan, MD, Vice President, Quality Patient Safety Officer, Rush-Copley Medical
Center Jeanette Mihalec, Chairman, Kane County Public Health Committee Carmella Moran, PhD, RN, Director and Associate Professor, Aurora University School
of Nursing Karin Podolski, RN, MPH, Director, Community Health and Outreach, Cadence Health David Stone, PhD, Director, Office of Sponsored Projects, Northern Illinois University Robert Tanner, LCSW, ACSW, President, CEO Greater Elgin Family Care Center
Linnea Windel, RN, MSN, President, CEO VNA Health Care
93
Community Health Improvement Plan Record of Change
Date of Change Changes Made Person Responsible
August 13, 2012 Corrected typographical errors
Jackie Forbes
Release Date: April 9th, 2012