new exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.secollisions19@lund, 2019/02/28 csörgő, t. a...

40
Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. Applications of a new family of solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T . Csörgő 1,2 , G. Kasza 2 , M. Csanád 3 and Z. Jiang 4,5 1 Wigner Research Center for Physics, Budapest, Hungary 2 EKE GYKRC, Gyöngyös, Hungary 3 Eötvös University, Budapest, Hungary 4 Key Laboratory of Quark and Lepton Physics , Wuhan , China 5 IoPP, CCNU, Wuhan , China Introduction and motivation A New Family of Exact Solutions of Relativistic Hydro Rapidity and pseudorapidity distributions Initial energy density R long HBT radius Non - monotonic s - behaviour Outlook Conclusions , s ummary Partially supported by NKTIH FK 123842 and FK123959

Upload: others

Post on 02-Feb-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

Applications of a new family of solutionsof relativistic hydrodynamics

T. Csörgő1,2 , G. Kasza2, M. Csanád3 and Z. Jiang4,5

1Wigner Research Center for Physics, Budapest, Hungary2EKE GYKRC, Gyöngyös, Hungary

3Eötvös University, Budapest, Hungary4Key Laboratory of Quark and Lepton Physics, Wuhan, China

5IoPP, CCNU, Wuhan, China

Introduction and motivation

A New Family of Exact Solutions of Relativistic Hydro

Rapidity and pseudorapidity distributions

Initial energy density

Rlong HBT radius

Non-monotonic s-behaviour

Outlook

Conclusions, summary

Partially supported by NKTIH FK 123842 and FK123959

Page 2: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

A new family of exact solutionsof relativistic hydrodynamics

T. Csörgő1,2 , G. Kasza2, M. Csanád3 and Z. Jiang4,5

Introduction and motivation

A New Family of Exact Solutions of Relativistic Hydro

Rapidity and pseudorapidity distributions

Rlong HBT radius

Outlook to other presentations

Conclusions, summary

Partially supported by NKTIH FK 123842 and FK123959

and EFOP 3.6.1-16-2016-00001

arXiv.org:1805.01427 +

Page 3: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

Context

Renowned exact solutions, reviewed in arXiv:1805.01427

Landau-Khalatnikov solution: dn/dy ~ Gaussian

Hwa solution (1974) – Bjorken: same solution + e0 (1983)

Chiu, Sudarshan and Wang: plateaux, Wong: Landau revisited

Revival of interest: Zimányi, Bondorf, Garpman (1978)

Buda-Lund model + exact solutions (1994-96)

Biró, Karpenko, Sinyukov, Pratt (2007)

Bialas, Janik, Peschanski, Borsch+Zhdanov (2007)

CsT, Csanád, Nagy (2007-2008)

CsT, Csernai, Grassi, Hama, Kodama (2004)

Gubser (2010-11)

Hatta, Noronha, Xiao (2014-16)

New simple solutions Evaluation of dn/dh arXiv:1806.06794

Rapidity distribution Advanced initial e0 arXiv:1806.11309

HBT radii Advanced life-time tf arXiv:1810.00154

Energy scan Non-monotonic e0(s) :arXiv:1811.0999

Page 4: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

Goal

Need for solutions that are:

explicit

simple

accelerating

relativistic

realistic / compatible with the data:

lattice QCD EoS

ellipsoidal symmetry (spectra, v2, v4, HBT)

finite dn/dy

Generelization of a class that satisfies each of these criteria

but not simultaneously

T. Cs, M. I. Nagy, M. Csanád, arXiv:nucl-th/0605070, PLB (2008)

M.I. Nagy, T. Cs., M. Csanád, arXiv:0709.3677 , PRC77:024908 (2008)

M. Csanád, M. I. Nagy, T. Cs, arXiv:0710.0327 [nucl-th] EPJ A (2008)

New family of exact solutions:

CsT, Kasza, Csanád, Jiang, arXiv.org:1805.01427

Page 5: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

Perfect fluid hydrodynamics

Energy-momentum

tensor:

Relativistic

Euler equation:

Energy conservation:

Charge conservation:

Consequence is entropy conservation:

Page 6: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

Self-similar, ellipsoidal solutions

Publication (for example):

T. Cs, L.P.Csernai, Y. Hama, T. Kodama, Heavy Ion Phys. A 21 (2004) 73

3D spherically symmetric HUBBLE flow:

No acceleration:

Define a scaling variable for self-similarly expanding ellipsoids:

EoS: (massive)

ideal gas

Scaling function n(s) can be chosen freely.

Shear and bulk viscous corrections in NR limit: known analytically.

Page 7: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

Auxiliary variables: hx, t, W , hp, y

Consider a 1+1 dimensional, finite, expanding fireballAssume: W=W(hx)

Notation T. Cs., G. Kasza, M. Csanád, Z. Jiang, arXiv.org:1805.01427

Page 8: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

Hydro in Rindler coordinates, new sol

Assumptions of TCs, Kasza, Csanád and Jiang, arXiv.org:1805.01427 :

From energy-momentum conservation, theEuler and temperature equations are obtained:

For the entropy density, the continuity equation is solved.

Page 9: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

A New Family of Exact Solutions of Hydro

Page 10: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

A New Family of Exact Solutions of Hydro

New: not discovered before,as far as we know …

Family:For each positive scaling

function t(s), a different

solution, with same T0, s0, k, l

Not self-similar: Coordinate dependenc NOT on

scaling variable s ONLY, butadditional dependence on

H = H(hx) too.

Explicit and Exact:Fluid rapidity, temperature,

entropy density explicitly givenby formulas

New feature:Solution is given

as parametric curves of H in hx :

(hx(H),W(H,t))

Simlification, for now: limit the solution in hx

where parametric curvescorrespond to functions

Page 11: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

Limited in space-time rapidity hx

Page 12: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

Illustration: results for T

Page 13: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

Limited in space-time rapidity hx

Page 14: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

Illustration: results for fluid rapidity W

Page 15: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

Limited in space-time rapidity hx

arXiv.org:1805.01427 : W l h x

Page 16: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

Approximations near midrapidity

Page 17: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

Observables: rapidity distribution

dn/dy evaluatedanalytically,

in a saddle-pointapproximation

Page 18: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

Pseudorapidity distribution

dn/dh evaluatedanalytically,

in an advanced saddle-pointapproximation

An important by-product:pT = pT (y) is rapiditydependent, a Lorentzian

just as in Buda-Lund model

Page 19: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

dn/dh for p+p, 7-8 TeV, CMS data

arXiv.org:1805.01427

Page 20: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

dn/dh for Pb+Pb, 5 TeV, ALICE data

arXiv.org:1806.06794

Page 21: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

dn/dh for Xe+Xe, 5.44 TeV, CMS data

NEW (preliminary, too good)

Page 22: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

dn/dh for Au+Au, 200 GeV, PHOBOS

arXiv.org:1806.11309

Page 23: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

dn/dh fits, √sNN = 200 GeV

23

Allowed fit region(depends on λ)

Page 24: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

dn/dh fits, √sNN = 130 GeV

24

Allowed fit region(depends on λ)

Page 25: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

dn/dh fits, √sNN = 62.4 GeV

25

Allowed fit region (dependson λ)

Page 26: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

dn/dh fits, √sNN = 19.6 GeV

26

Page 27: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

Rlong fits, √sNN = 62-200 GeV

27

Page 28: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

Correction factors, √sNN = 62-200 GeV

28

Page 29: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

Init energy densities, √sNN = 62-200 GeV

29

Page 30: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

Conclusions

Explicit solutions of a very difficult problem

New estimates of initial energy density

New exact solution

for arbitrary EOS with const e/p

after 10 years, finally

Non-monotonic initial energy density(s)

A lot to do …

more general EoS

less symmetry, ellipsoidal solutions

rotating viscous solutions

New solutions with shear/bulk viscosity …

Page 31: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

Thank you for your attention

Questions and Comments ?

Page 32: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

Backup slides

Page 33: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

Rlong systematics

Page 34: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

Teff systematics

Page 35: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

dn/dh systematics

Page 36: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

Rlong systematics

Page 37: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

e0 systematics

Page 38: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

e0 systematics

Page 39: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

e0 systematics

Page 40: New exact solutions of rel hydro - indico.lucas.lu.seCollisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T. A new family of exact solutions of relativistic hydrodynamics T. Csörgő1,2, G. Kasza2,

Collisions19@Lund, 2019/02/28 Csörgő, T.

Time evolution systematics