neurologicandneuroimaging findingsinpatients with covid-19 · enhancement (17%), and encephalitis...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Neurologicandneuroimaging findingsinpatients with COVID-19 · enhancement (17%), and encephalitis (13%) were the most frequent neuroimaging findings. Confusion (53%) was the most](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060813/6091b284d4b0681e5152b42b/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
ARTICLE
Neurologic and neuroimagingfindings in patientswith COVID-19A retrospective multicenter study
Stephane Kremer MD PhD Franccedilois Lersy MD Mathieu Anheim MD PhD Hamid Merdji MD
Maleka Schenck MD Helene Oesterle MD Federico Bolognini MD Julien Messie MD Antoine Khalil MD
Augustin Gaudemer MD Sophie Carre MD Manel Alleg MD Claire Lecocq MD Emmanuelle Schmitt MD
Rene Anxionnat MD PhD Franccedilois Zhu MD Lavinia Jager MD Patrick Nesser MD Yannick Talla Mba MD
Ghazi Hmeydia MD Joseph Benzakoun MD Catherine Oppenheim MD PhD
Jean-Christophe Ferre MD PhD Adel Maamar MD Beatrice Carsin-Nicol MD Pierre-Olivier Comby MD
Frederic Ricolfi MD PhD Pierre Thouant MD Claire Boutet MD PhD Xavier Fabre MD
Geraud Forestier MD Isaure de Beaurepaire MD Gregoire Bornet MD Hubert Desal MD PhD
Gregoire Boulouis MD Jerome Berge MD Apolline Kazemi MD Nadya Pyatigorskaya MD PhD
Augustin Lecler MD PhD Suzana Saleme MD Myriam Edjlali-Goujon MD PhD Basile Kerleroux MD
Jean-Marc Constans MD PhD Pierre-Emmanuel Zorn PhD Muriel Mathieu PhD Seyyid Baloglu MD
Franccedilois-Daniel ArdellierMD ThibaultWillaumeMD Jean-ChristopheBrisset PhD Sophie CaillardMD PhD
Olivier Collange MD PhD Paul Michel Mertes MD PhD Francis Schneider MD PhD
Samira Fafi-Kremer PharmD PhD Mickael Ohana MD PhD Ferhat Meziani MD PhD
Nicolas Meyer MD PhD Julie Helms MD PhD and Franccedilois Cotton MD PhD
Neurologyreg 202095e1868-e1882 doi101212WNL0000000000010112
Correspondence
Dr Kremer
stephanekremer
chru-strasbourgfr
AbstractObjectiveTo describe neuroimaging findings and to report the epidemiologic and clinical charac-teristics of patients with coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) with neurologicmanifestations
MethodsIn this retrospective multicenter study (11 hospitals) we included 64 patients with confirmedCOVID-19 with neurologic manifestations who underwent a brain MRI
ResultsThe cohort included 43 men (67) and 21 women (33) their median age was 66 (range20ndash92) years Thirty-six (56) brain MRIs were considered abnormal possibly relatedto severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus Ischemic strokes (27) leptomeningeal
MORE ONLINE
COVID-19 ResourcesFor the latest articlesinvited commentaries andblogs from physiciansaround the world
NPuborgCOVID19
CME CourseNPuborgcmelist
These authors contributed equally to this work
From the Hopitaux Universitaires de Strasbourg (SK FL SB F-DA TW) Service drsquoimagerie 2 Hopital de Hautepierre Engineering Science Computer Science and ImagingLaboratory (SK NM) UMR 7357 University of StrasbourgndashCNRS Service de Neurologie (M Anheim) Hopitaux Universitaires de Strasbourg Institut de Genetique et de BiologieMoleculaire et Cellulaire (M Anheim) INSERM-U964CNRS-UMR7104Universite de Strasbourg Illkirch Federation de Medecine Translationnelle de Strasbourg (M Anheim) Uni-versite de Strasbourg Hopitaux universitaires de Strasbourg (HM FM JH) Service de Medecine Intensive Reanimation Nouvel Hopital Civil INSERM (French National Institute ofHealth and Medical Research) (HM FM) UMR 1260 Regenerative Nanomedicine Federation de Medecine Translationnelle de Strasbourg Medecine Intensive-Reanimation (MSFS) Hopital de Hautepierre Hopitaux Universitaires de Strasbourg Service deNeuroradiologie (HO FB JM) Hopitaux Civils de Colmar Service drsquoImagerie (A Khalil AG) Unite deNeuroradiologie Assistance Publique-Hopitaux de Paris Hopital Bichat Claude Bernard Universite Paris Diderot (A Khalil) Paris Service de Neurologie (S Carre CL) CentreHospitalier de Haguenau Service de Radiologie (M Alleg) Centre Hospitalier de Haguenau Service de Neuroradiologie (ES RA FZ) Hopital Central CHU de Nancy CHIC Unisante(LJ PN YTM) Hopital Marie Madeleine Forbach Neuroimaging Department (GH J Benzakoun CO G Boulouis ME-G BK) GHU Paris Psychiatrie et Neurosciences HopitalSainte-Anne Universite de Paris INSERMU1266 F-75014 CHU Rennes (J-CF BC-N) Department of Neuroradiology CHU Rennes (AM) Medical Intensive Care Unit Department ofNeuroradiology (P-OC FR PT) University Hospital of Dijon Hopital Franccedilois Mitterrand Service de Radiologie (CB) CHU de Saint-Etienne Service de Reanimation (XF) CH deRoanne Service de Neuroradiologie (GF SS) CHU de Limoges Radiology Department (IdB G Bornet) Hopital Prive drsquoAntony Department of Diagnostic and InterventionalNeuroradiology (HD) University Hospital Nantes Neuroradiology Department (J Berge) CHUdeBordeaux Service deNeuroradiologie (A Kazemi) CHUde Lille Assistance PubliqueHopitaux de Paris (NP) Service de Neuroradiologie Hopital Pitie-Salpetriere Sorbonne Universite (NP) Univ Paris 06 UMR S 1127 CNRS UMR 7225 ICM F-75013 Service deNeuroradiologie Diagnostique (AL) Foundation A Rothschild Hospital Paris EA CHIMERE 7516 (J-MC) Universite de Picardie Jules Verne Service de NeuroRadiologie pole ImagerieMedicale Centre Hospitalo-Universitaire drsquoAmiens Hopitaux Universitaires de Strasbourg (P-EZ MM) UCIEC Pole drsquoImagerie Strasbourg Observatoire Franccedilais de la Sclerose enPlaques (J-CB) Lyon Nephrology and Transplantation Department (S Caillard) Hopitaux Universitaires de Strasbourg Inserm UMR S1109 (S Caillard) LabEx TransplantexFederation de Medecine Translationnelle de Strasbourg Universite de Strasbourg Hopitaux Universitaires de Strasbourg (OC PMM) Service drsquoAnesthesie-Reanimation NouvelHopital Civil HopitauxUniversitaires de Strasbourg (SF-K) Laboratoire de VirologieMedicale Radiology Department (MO) Nouvel Hopital Civil StrasbourgUniversity Hospital CHUde Strasbourg (NM) Service de Sante Publique GMRC F-67091 Strasbourg Immuno-Rhumatologie Moleculaire (SF-K JH) INSERM UMR_S1109 LabEx TRANSPLANTEX Centre deRecherche drsquoImmunologie et drsquoHematologie Faculte de Medecine Federation Hospitalo-Universitaire OMICARE Federation de Medecine Translationnelle de Strasbourg Universitede Strasbourg MRI Center (FC) Centre Hospitalier Lyon Sud Hospices Civils de Lyon and Universite Lyon 1 (FC) CREATIS-LRMN CNRSUMR5220-INSERM U630 VilleurbanneFrance
Go to NeurologyorgN for full disclosures Funding information and disclosures deemed relevant by the authors if any are provided at the end of the article
e1868 Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
enhancement (17) and encephalitis (13) were the most frequent neuroimaging findings Confusion (53) was the mostcommon neurologic manifestation followed by impaired consciousness (39) presence of clinical signs of corticospinal tractinvolvement (31) agitation (31) and headache (16) The profile of patients experiencing ischemic stroke was differentfrom that of other patients with abnormal brain imaging the former less frequently had acute respiratory distress syndrome(p = 0006) and more frequently had corticospinal tract signs (p = 002) Patients with encephalitis were younger (p = 0007)whereas agitation was more frequent for patients with leptomeningeal enhancement (p = 0009)
ConclusionsPatients with COVID-19 may develop a wide range of neurologic symptoms which can be associated with severe and fatalcomplications such as ischemic stroke or encephalitis In terms of meningoencephalitis involvement even if a direct effect of thevirus cannot be excluded the pathophysiology seems to involve an immune or inflammatory process given the presence of signsof inflammation in both CSF and neuroimaging but the lack of virus in CSF
ClinicalTrialsgov identifierNCT04368390
In December 2019 many unexplained pneumonia cases oc-curred in China12 In January 2020 the causative agent wasidentified as a novel coronavirus which has been called severeacute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) givingthe disease the name coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19)Coronaviruses have neuroinvasive capacities because they areisolated in both brains and CSF of infected animals andhumans3ndash8 However few neurologic complications with humancoronaviruses (hCoVs) were documented in the past 2 decades
Concerning COVID-19 5 recent publications have presentedneuroimaging presentations of patients with neurologiccomplications9ndash13
The first studies that focused on clinical features of patientswith COVID-191211 showed neurologic manifestations such asheadache dizziness confusion hypogeusia hyposmia and moresevere neurologic disorders especially for patients hospitalized inintensive care units (ICUs) In a recent cohort of 214 patients11
248 of them presented CNS manifestations and 6 cases ofstrokes were diagnosed The neurologic symptoms were morecommon in cases of severe respiratory infection11 It has recentlybeen reported12 that patients referred to ICU frequently experi-enced encephalopathywith agitation confusion and corticospinaltract signs Brain MRI revealed in some patients leptomeningealenhancement (LME) and cerebral blood flow abnormalities
Despite these findings the potential brain injuries related toCOVID-19 have not been well described with neuroimagingin a large cohort Thus our aims were to describe the neu-roimaging findings in a population of COVID-19 with neu-rologic manifestations who underwent brain MRI to assessthe frequency of these abnormalities and to correlate thesefindings with clinical features
MethodsThis retrospective national multicenter study was initiated bythe French Neuroradiology Society
Patient cohortPatients with COVID-19 from 11 French centers including 6university hospitals and 5 general hospitals were includedfromMarch 16 2020 until April 9 2020 The number of casesincluded from each center was as follows 29 in Strasbourg 11in Colmar 7 in Paris (Bichat) 5 in Haguenau 4 in Nancy 4again in Paris (Sainte-Anne) 3 in Rennes 2 in Dijon 1 inSaint-Etienne 1 in Forbach and 1 in Antony
The diagnosis of COVID-19 was based on the following cri-teria possible exposure history symptoms clinically com-patible with COVID-19 and detection of SARS-CoV-2 byreverse transcriptase-PCR (RT-PCR) assays on the naso-pharyngeal throat or lower respiratory tract swabs Inclusioncriteria were diagnosis of COVID-19 with neurologic mani-festation and a brain MRI assessment Exclusion criteria weremissing data or noncontributory (lack of sequences numer-ous artifacts) data regarding brain MRI
The diagnosis of acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS)was based on Berlin criteria14
Clinical and laboratory data were extracted from the patientsrsquoelectronic medical records in the hospital information system
Virologic assessmentQuantitative real-time RT-PCR tests for SARS-CoV-2 nucleicacid were performed on upper or lower respiratory tract swabsand CSF Primer and probe sequences were targeting 2regions on the RdRp gene which are specific to SARS-CoV-2Assay sensitivity was asymp10 copies per reaction
Brain MRI protocolsImaging studies were conducted on 15T or 3T MRI Themulticenter nature of the study and the various clinical pre-sentations did not allow standardization of sequences
The most frequently sequences performed were 3DT1-weighted spin-echo with and without contrast-enhancedimaging diffusion-weighted imaging gradient echo T2 or
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1869
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
susceptibility-weighted imaging 2D or 3D fluid-attenuatedinversion recovery (FLAIR) postcontrast and 3D time-of-flight magnetic resonance angiography of the circle of Willis
Brain MRI readingAfter anonymization images were presented to readers withour GE Picture Archiving and Communication System(General Electric Milwaukee WI) Two neuroradiologists(SK and FL with 20 and 9 years of experience in neuro-radiology respectively) who were blinded to all patient dataindependently reviewed all brain MRIs The final diagnosiswas determined by consensus and if consensus could not bereached a third neuroradiologist (SB with 9 years of expe-rience in neuroradiology) was questioned
Neuroimaging abnormalities were divided into 3 groupsischemic stroke encephalitis and LME Ischemic strokeswere classified into large artery infarctions watershed cere-bral infarctions lacunar infarctions and hypoxic-ischemicinjuries Encephalitis was ranked as limbic encephalitis cy-totoxic lesion of the corpus callosum (CLOCC) radiologicacute disseminated encephalomyelitis (ADEM) radiologicacute hemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy and mis-cellaneous encephalitis
Encephalitis was defined as brain parenchymal abnormalFLAIR hyperintensity involving gray matter (GM) whitematter or basal ganglia with variable enhancement localizedmainly in medial temporal and inferior frontal lobes in case oflimbic encephalitis The term CLOCC has been proposed re-cently to describe a clinicoradiologic syndrome characterizedby a transient mild encephalopathy and a reversible lesion ofthe corpus callosum localized mainly to the central part of thesplenium onMRI CLOCCs are the consequence of numerousetiologies the 2 most frequent being antiepileptic drug with-drawal and infections They are related to a cytokine increaseinducing glutamate elevation in the extracellular space leadingto a dysfunction of callosal neurons and microglia with in-tracellular water influx resulting in cytotoxic edema15
ADEM is an autoimmune-mediated disease occurring afterviral infections and vaccinations Multifocal demyelinatinglesions involving white matter but also GM (basal ganglia) areseen with variable enhancement Acute hemorrhagic necro-tizing encephalopathy is a fulminant inflammatory de-myelinating disease which is considered the most severe formof ADEM associated with hemorrhagic lesions
A brain MRI without acute significative abnormalities orshowing lesions unrelated to SARS-CoV-2 was considerednormal
Statistical analysisData were described with frequency and proportion (numberpercent) for categorical variables and mean median andrange for quantitative data Categorical data were comparedwith the Fisher exact test Quantitative data were compared
with analysis of variance Multiple correspondence analysis(MCA) was used to give a simultaneous multivariate de-scription of clinical and radiologic characteristics of all di-agnostic groups MCA plots display results either for thesubjects or for their characteristics Those plots are to beinterpreted on the basis of the proximity of the data points 2subjects who are close on a plot share a common pattern ofsymptoms and 2 clinical symptoms that are close on a plotdescribe similar types of subjects Ellipses are drawn aroundthe mean position of each characteristic such that non-overlapping ellipses can be considered to show a contrastbetween the subjects who share 1 or the other characteristic
Computations were made with 353 through R-Studio withthe readxl and FactoMineR packages (R Foundation forStatistical Computing Vienna Austria) A value of p lt 005was considered significant
Standard protocol approvals registrationsand patient consentsThe study was approved by the ethics standards committeeon human experimentation of Strasbourg University Hos-pital (CE-2020-37) and was in accordance with the 1964Declaration of Helsinki and its later amendments Due to theemergency in the context of COVID-19 pandemic responsiblefor acute respiratory and neurologic manifestations pandemicthe requirement for patientsrsquo written informed consent waswaived
The study has been registered in ClinicalTrialsgov(NCT04368390)
Data availabilityWe state that the data published are available and anonymizedand will be shared on request by email to the correspondingauthor from any qualified investigator for purposes of repli-cating procedures and results
ResultsA total of 68 patients with COVID-19 were included in thismulticenter study Among them 4 were excluded becausetheir brain MRIs were considered noncontributory
Clinical characteristicsThe demographic and clinical characteristics of the 64patients and their neurologic manifestations are summarizedin tables 1 through 3 The most frequent neurologic mani-festations were confusionagitationalteration of conscious-ness corticospinal tract signs and headache
Complementary data concerning patients with COVID-19with acute ischemic stroke are given in table 2 including riskfactors clinical presentation echocardiography and ECGresults neuroimaging description and D-dimer serum levelFurther information related to patients with COVID-19 withmeningoencephalitis is given in table 3
e1870 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
Neuroimaging findingsAmong the 64MRIs included 41 (64) were performed withgadolinium-based contrast agent administration Thirty-onehad a postcontrast FLAIR and 18 had a delayed postcontrastFLAIR The latter was achieved asymp10 minutes after the in-jection after the realization of conventional postcontrastFLAIR and enhanced T1-weighted imaging Thirty-six (56)brain MRIs were considered abnormal possibly related toSARS-CoV-2
Ischemic strokes (27) (figure e-1 available from Dryaddoiorg105061dryadw9ghx3fm7) LME (17) (figure 1)and encephalitis (13) (figures 2 and 3 and figure e-2 availablefrom Dryad) were the most frequent neuroimaging findingsLME was seen on both postcontrast T1-weighted and FLAIRsequences and was even better visualized when delayed post-contrast FLAIR was performed These signal abnormalitieswere not present on precontrast T1 or FLAIR images
Among the 8 encephalitis 2 cases of limbic encephalitis2 cases of radiologic acute hemorrhagic necrotizing encepha-lopathy 2 cases of miscellaneous encephalitis 1 case of radio-logic ADEM and 1 case of CLOCC were described
CSF analysisTwenty-five (39) patients underwent a lumbar puncture 7in the encephalitis group 8 in the LME group 2 in the is-chemic stroke group and 8 in the normal brain MRI group
CSF glucose was normal in all cases
In the encephalitis group (table 3) 6 patients showedmarkersof inflammation 4 had pleocytosis 5 had high levels of pro-tein 2 had elevated immunoglobulin G and another hadoligoclonal bands that were identical in CSF and serum In theLME group (table 3) 6 patients showed markers of in-flammation 2 had pleocytosis 3 had high levels of protein 2
Table 1 History neurologic manifestations and clinical characteristics of the cohort
All patients(n = 64)
Ischemic stroke(n = 17)
Encephalitis(n = 8)
LME(n = 11) p Value
Sex n () 028
Men 43 (67) 11 (65) 7 (88) 5 (46)
Women 21 (33) 6 (35) 1 (12) 6 (54)
Age y 0007
Mean 65 75 61 66
Median 66 75 59 64
Range 20ndash92 59ndash92 55ndash71 51ndash81
History of stroke n () 7 (11) 4 (24) 0 1 (9) 036
History of seizures n () 3 (5) 1 (6) 0 0 1
Another neurologic history n () 9 (14) 2 (12) 0 0 017
History of autoimmune diseases n () 7 (11) 3 (18) 0 1 (9) 083
History of hematologic malignancies n () 4 (6) 1 (6) 0 1 (9) 1
Headaches n () 10 (16) 3 (18) 2 (25) 1 (9) 085
Seizures n () 1 (2) 0 0 0 1
Anosmia n () 2 (3) 1 (6) 0 1 (9) 031
Ageusia n () 4 (6) 0 1 (13) 1 (9) 045
Clinical signs of corticospinal tract involvement n () 20 (31) 10 (59) 1 (13) 4 (36) 002
Disturbance of consciousness n () 25 (39) 3 (18) 4 (50) 6 (55) 015
Confusion n () 34 (53) 7 (41) 3 (38) 6 (55) 034
Agitation n () 20 (31) 1 (6) 3 (38) 7 (64) 0009
Oxygen therapy n () 53 (83) 13 (76) 8 (100) 10 (91) 052
ARDS n () 33 (52) 3 (18) 6 (75) 8 (73) 0006
Death n () 7 (11) 2 (12) 2 (25) 0 038
Abbreviations ARDS = acute respiratory distress syndrome LME = leptomeningeal enhancement
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1871
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
Table 2 Characteristics of patients with COVID-19 with acute ischemic stroke
Sex Age y Risk factors Clinical presentation
Days from COVID-19respiratory symptomonset to ischemicstroke symptom onset
Treatment up tothis time point
Arrhythmias (ECGor echocardiography)
BrainMRI
Large vesselocclusion
D-dimers(reference range lt400) μgL
M 86 HypertensionDyslipidemia
Left hemiplegiaimpairedconsciousness
1 Supportive No LAI Distal M1 occlusionwith thrombus
NR
M 71 HypertensionDiabetesmellitus
Left hemiplegia 16 Antibiotics Yes (previouslyunknown)
LAI Distal M1 occlusionwith thrombus
2860
F 74 mdash Bilateral pyramidal tract signs 8 AntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
No WCI mdash gt20000
M 63 Smoking Left-sided weaknessleft-sidedsensory inattention
14 Antibiotics Yes (previouslyunknown)
LAI mdash 1000
M 65 HypertensionDiabetesmellitusDyslipidemiaHOS
Impaired consciousness 22 Antibiotics No WCI mdash 1570
F 78 Hypertension Dysarthria 3 Supportive No WCI mdash 720
F 75 HypertensionDyslipidemiaAtrial Fibrillation
Aphasiaright hemiplegiaimpaired consciousnessagitation
6 Supportive NR LAI ICA occlusion NR
M 79 HypertensionDyslipidemiaHOS
Headachesimpairedconsciousnessconfusion
5 Supportive No WCI mdash NR
F 71 HypertensionSmokingAtrial fibrillation
Left hemiplegia 3 Supportive Yes LAI Proximal M2occlusion
gt20000
M 59 HypertensionSmoking
Left hemiplegialeft facial droop 1 Supportive No LAI Proximal M1occlusion withthrombus
2868
M 66 HypertensionDyslipidemiaDiabetesmellitus
Left pyramidal tract signsleftfacial droopaphasia
4 Supportive No LAI ICA dissection 5227
M 72 DyslipidemiaAtrial fibrillation
Impaired consciousness 15 Antibiotics Yes LAI mdash 993
M 78 Hypertension Dysarthriaright-sidedweaknessright facial droop
16 Supportive No LAI mdash NR
Continued
e1872Neu
rology
|Vo
lume95N
umber
13|
Septem
ber
292020NeurologyorgN
Copyright
copy2020
American
Academ
yof
Neurology
Unauthorized
reproductionof
thisarticle
isprohibited
had elevated immunoglobulin G and 4 had oligoclonal bandsthat were identical in CSF and serum In the ischemic strokegroup 1 patient had a high level of protein
The RT-PCR SARS-CoV-2 analysis was negative in the 20patients who were investigated The analysis was not realizedfor 5 patients 1 with a normal brain MRI 2 with an ischemicstroke 1 with encephalitis and 1 with LME Cultures for otherviruses or bacteria were always negative when performed
Correlation analysisThere were statistically significant differences between thevarious groups concerning age (p = 0007) the presence ofpyramidal tract signs (p = 002) agitation (p = 0009) andrespiratory status (ARDS) (p = 0006) (table 1)
The MCA showed that the ischemic stroke group could bedistinguished from the 3 others which largely overlap (figure 4)Most patients with ischemic stroke (numbers and dots in redon the plot) are located on the same lower-right half of thegraph indicating a commonality of symptoms Those patientscan be overall described as older with no ARDS no oxygenrequirement no confusion no disturbances of consciousnessand a lower death rate The converse is true for the 3 otherdiagnoses that cannot be distinguished Considering eachclinical manifestation separately (figure e-3 available fromDryad doiorg105061dryadw9ghx3fm7) subjects can bedistinguishedmainly on the basis of a global pattern dependingon their oxygen requirement seizure sex headaches history ofautoimmune disease history of seizure age anosmia confu-sion and disturbances of consciousness
DiscussionThis is the first large nationwide cohort of MRIs performed inpatients with COVID-19 with neurologic manifestations
The majority of patients had MRI abnormalities with seriousand various findings beyond the severe respiratory disease(half of the patients had ARDS and 11 died) cerebrovas-cular disease (especially ischemic stroke large artery infarc-tions more frequently than watershed cerebral infarctions)encephalitis (including limbic encephalitis radiologic ADEMCLOCC and radiologic acute hemorrhagic necrotizing en-cephalopathy) and focal or even diffuse LME The hetero-geneity of the imaging abnormalities was underpinned byheterogeneous clinical manifestations ranging from anosmiaageusia or headache to more severe findings such as confu-sion with agitation loss of consciousness and corticospinaltract signs Some correlations were found between clinical andimaging findings allowing the identification of clinicoradio-logic profiles of patients with COVID-19 displaying neuro-logic manifestations
Ischemic stroke was 1 kind of clinicoradiologic phenotype itwas an acute event arising in older patients who more fre-quently had corticospinal tract signs but was less frequentlyTa
ble
2Charac
teristicsofpatients
withCOVID-19withac
ute
isch
emicstroke
(con
tinue
d)
Sex
Age
yRiskfactors
Clinicalpre
senta
tion
Days
from
COVID
-19
resp
irato
rysy
mpto
monse
tto
isch
emic
stro
kesy
mpto
monse
tTr
eatm
entupto
this
timepoint
Arrhythmias(ECG
orech
oca
rdiogr
aphy)
Bra
inMRI
Larg
eve
ssel
occ
lusion
D-dim
ers
(refere
nce
range
lt400
)μgL
M76
mdashConfusion
24Su
pportive
No
WCI
mdash397
7
F92
mdashConfusion
10Su
pportive
No
WCI
mdash98
7
F77
Hyp
ertension
HOS
Lefthem
iplegialeft
homonym
oushem
ianopia
hea
dac
hes
minus2(stroke
prece
ded
resp
iratory
symptoms
by2d)
mdashYe
s(previously
unkn
own)
LAI
P2occlusion
NR
M88
Hyp
ertension
Dyslip
idem
iaDiabetes
mellitus
Atrialfibrilla
tion
HOS
Righthem
iplegiaim
paired
consciousn
ess
minus2(stroke
prece
ded
resp
iratory
symptoms
by2d)
mdashYe
sLA
IProximal
M2
occlusion
NR
Abbreviations
COVID-19=co
ronav
irusdisea
se20
19H
OS=history
ofstroke
IC=intern
alca
rotidarteryL
AI=
largeartery
infarctionN
R=Notrealized
WCI=
watersh
edce
rebralinfarction
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1873
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
Table 3 Characteristics of patients with COVID-19 with meningoencephalitis
Sex Age y Clinical symptoms
Days from COVID-19respiratory symptomonset to brain MRI Treatment up to this time point CSF analysis Imaging findings
F 71 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
22 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
0 celluarr Total protein 057 gL
Miscellaneous encephalitisdiffusionand T2FLAIR hyperintensitiesinvolving supratentorial WM
M 64 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
17 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
40 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 11 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 56 mgL
Miscellaneous encephalitisFLAIRhyperintensity involving both middlecerebellar peduncles
M 56 Impaired consciousnesspathologic wakefulness whensedation was stopped
23 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
1 cellmm3
uarr Total protein 2 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 169 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Radiologic acute hemorrhagicnecrotizing encephalopathy
M 66 Impaired consciousnesspathologic wakefulness whensedation was stopped
34 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
NR Radiologic acute hemorrhagicnecrotizing encephalopathy
M 55 Headachesdizzinessimpairedconsciousness
3 mdash 7 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 056 gLCLOCC
M 56 Headaches 20 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
3 cellsmm3
Total protein 024 gLLeft limbic encephalitis
M 58 Ataxia 21 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
4 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 077 gLLeft limbic encephalitis
M 60 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
13 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
0 cellTotal protein 03 gL
Radiologic ADEM
F 51 Movement disordersagitation 16 mdash 5 cellsuarr Total protein 066 gL
Focal LME
F 59 Headachesdizziness 18 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
NR Focal LME
M 62 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
19 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
0 cellTotal protein 023 gLImmunoglobulin G 33 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Diffuse LME
Continued
e1874Neu
rology
|Vo
lume95N
umber
13|
Septem
ber
292020NeurologyorgN
Copyright
copy2020
American
Academ
yof
Neurology
Unauthorized
reproductionof
thisarticle
isprohibited
Table 3 Characteristics of patients with COVID-19 with meningoencephalitis (continued)
Sex Age y Clinical symptoms
Days from COVID-19respiratory symptomonset to brain MRI Treatment up to this time point CSF analysis Imaging findings
M 78 Agitation 15 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
NR Focal LME
M 72 Impaired consciousnessbilateralpyramidal tract signs
20 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavirHydroxychloroquine
0 cellTotal protein 023 gLImmunoglobulin G 17 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Focal LME
M 61 Impaired consciousnessbilateralpyramidal tract signsconfusionagitation
14 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
1 cellmm3
Total protein 023 gLImmunoglobulin G 17 mgL
Focal LME
M 66 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
22 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
NR Focal LME
F 53 Confusionimpairedconsciousness
29 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
0 cellTotal protein 029 gLImmunoglobulin G 21 mgL
Focal LME
F 64 Bilateral pyramidal tract signs 11 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
2 cellsmm3
Total protein 030 gLImmunoglobulin G 15 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Focal LME
F 77 Bilateral pyramidal syndromeconfusionagitation
30 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavirHydroxychloroquine
1 cellmm3
uarr Total protein 080 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 58 mgL
Diffuse LME
F 81 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
20 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
80 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 062 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 38 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Focal LME
Abbreviations ADEM = Acute disseminated encephalomyelitis CLOCC = cytotoxic lesion of the corpus callosum COVID-19 = coronavirus disease 2019 FLAIR = fluid-attenuated inversion recovery ICU = intensive care unitLME = leptomeningeal enhancement NR = not realized WM = white matter
Neurolo
gyorgN
Neurology
|Volum
e95N
umber
13|
Septem
ber292020
e1875
Copyright
copy2020
American
Academ
yof
Neurology
Unauthorized
reproductionof
thisarticle
isprohibited
requiring oxygen or presenting an ARDS This profile couldbe distinguished from the 2 others LME and encephalitisThe encephalitis profile affected younger patients and seemedto be particularly severe because it was associated with theneed for oxygen ARDS and death
Stroke patients less frequently had ARDS and this result is inagreement with the 6 patients with stroke previously reportedin that only 2 patients were admitted to ICUs16 One mayhypothesize that strokes in patients with COVID-19 could bedue to procoagulant events leading to thrombosis17 ratherthan to the systemic inflammatory process that accompaniesARDS which is also directed against the CNS However thisneeds to be assessed by further studies dedicated to stroke andthrombosis in patients with COVID-19
In our study 17 (27) patients had an acute ischemic strokeas was previously reported with SARS-CoV18 Middle Eastrespiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERS-CoV)19 andSARS-CoV-2111617 and among them 11 had large arteryinfarctions (including 6 proximal artery occlusions 2 cases ofinternal carotid artery dissection or occlusion) and 6 hadwatershed cerebral infarctions For 15 of 17 patients with anischemic stroke the respiratory symptoms related to COVID-19 had begun before this acute event while stroke precededrespiratory symptoms by 2 days for 2 patients
Several mechanisms are likely to be associated It is nowknown that SARS-CoV-2 could directly lead to myocardialinjury promoting cardiac arrhythmias associated with em-bolic events20 Six of our patients had arrhythmias which werepreviously unknown for 3 of them In the same way a severeacute myocardial injury may be associated with a decrease inbrain perfusion and therefore with watershed cerebralinfarctions As previously mentioned it is acknowledged thatviruses particularly SARS-CoV-221 are associated with anincrease of prothrombotic events such as ischemic stroke2223
Thereby viral infections may elevate procoagulant markersleading to thrombosis disseminated intravascular coagulationand hemorrhagic events23 As Beyrouti et al16 recently men-tioned all our patients tested showed elevated D-dimersmarkedly elevated (gt1000 μgL) for 10 of the 11 patientstested
Varicella zoster virus is also associated with direct vascularinvolvement and eventually arteritis promoting ischemicstroke events22 Furthermore the more severe critically illpatients hospitalized in ICUs have probably had hypoxemiaand hypotension leading to brain injuries18
Of the 36 abnormal MRIs 8 diagnoses of encephalitis weremade and LME was described especially on postcontrast T1-weighted and FLAIR in 11 patients either focal (single focus
Figure 1 Leptomeningeal enhancement
Axial T1 (A) before and (B) 5 minutes after contrast axial FLAIR (C) before and (D) immediately after contrast and (E and F) delayed (10 minutes) postcontrastaxial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) weighted MRIs Woman 77 years of age diffuse leptomeningeal linear FLAIR and T1 contrast enhancement(arrows) not visible on precontrast T1 and FLAIR (arrows) but seen better on delayed postcontrast FLAIR weighted MRIs (E and F)
e1876 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
vs multiple foci) or diffuse and preferentially located in theposterior supratentorial regions of the brain
Two main pathophysiologic hypotheses can be advanced toexplain the neuroimaging findings in the inflammatory profilegroup First SARS-CoV-2 may have a neuroinvasive potentialsimilar to other hCoVs because this family of viruses is relatedto each other genetically It is not clear if the virus can infiltratethe CNS with active replication and direct damage to braincells (viral encephalitis) as observed with other viruses suchas herpes simplex virus Likewise viral meningitis due to di-rect infiltration of the virus into the CSF may also be con-sidered because it was previously reported with SARS-CoV-1Indeed SARS-CoV-1 RNA was detected in the CSF of 2patients with seizures2425 A recent case report10 has de-scribed for the first time a case of seizures with the detection ofSARS-CoV-2 RNA in the CSF Similarly leptomeningealinflammation may be present adjacent to subpial corticallesions in the case of viral meningoencephalitis In the case ofviral encephalitis CSF analysis usually demonstrates lym-phocytic pleocytosis26 In addition the CSF protein level istypically elevated in viral encephalitis CSF viral RT-PCR isusually positive but can be negative if done too early This wasnot the case in our series and our results are in accordance
with recently published data that demonstrated an absence ofCSF pleocytosis and negative SARS-CoV-2 RT-PCR (5 of 5patients) but elevated protein level (4 of 5 patients) inpatients presenting cerebral MRI cortical abnormalities13
MRI pictures of viral encephalitis vary with causal pathogenNevertheless viral encephalitis usually involves cerebral GMwith diffusion restriction and can be associated with intrale-sional and diffuse leptomeningeal contrast enhancement Thiswas not the case in our series and did not argue for the directeffect of the virus It is all the more likely that the directdetection of SARS-CoV-2 RNA by RT-PCR was alwaysnegative in all our CSF samples
An alternative hypothesis appears more relevant the neuro-virulence of hCoVs especially MERS-CoV seems to bea consequence of immune-mediated processes1927ndash29 IndeedADEM and Bickerstaff brainstem encephalitis which weredescribed with MERS-CoV18ndash27 are 2 examples of autoim-mune demyelinating diseases resulting from a postinfectious orparainfectious process A recent case report9 has describeda case of acute hemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy (whichis the most severe form of ADEM) associated with COVID-19which strengthens the hypothesis of a predominant immuno-logic mechanism In our cohort we also described 2 cases of
Figure 2 Encephalitis
(A B D) Axial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) and(C) diffusion-weighted MRIs (A) Man 56 years of age lefthippocampus and amygdala FLAIR hyperintensity (B)Woman 71 years of age periventricular and subcorticalwhite matter FLAIR confluent hyperintensities (C) Man 55years of age corpus callosum splenium diffusion hyper-intensity (D) Man 64 years of age FLAIR middle cerebellarpeduncle hyperintensity
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1877
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
limbic encephalitis and 1 case of CLOCC Concerning thelatter no treatment had been started or stopped in previousweeks Thus 75 of encephalitis cases in our cohort (limbicencephalitis CLOCC radiologic ADEM radiologic acutehemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy) are possibly con-sidered immune-mediated diseases Therefore SARS-CoV-2ndashmediated disease is driven largely by immunologic processesand the same mechanisms could explain LME Indeed thearachnoid and pial membranes form the leptomeninges anda significant amount of antigen-presenting cells are present inthe subarachnoid space30 Thus initial immune activationoccurs in the subarachnoid space which is a site for antigenpresentation lymphocyte accumulation and proliferation andantibody production30 All lead to an important local in-flammatory infiltrate with a blood-CSF barrier disruptionwhich can also explain LME Thus LME can be linked toinflammatory or immunologic responses as previously de-scribed in animal models of autoimmune encephalomyelitis31
with some neurotropic viruses such as human T-cell leukemiavirus and HIV31 and in several immune-mediated neurologicdiseases31 Moreover a very similar intracranial pattern hasbeen described in an animal study in piglets affected by gas-troenteritis coronavirus32 Indeed histology demonstrateddiffuse pia matter gliosis with mild congestion of the meningeal
and parenchymal vessels with neuronal degeneration locatedmostly in posterior parietooccipital lobes24 PostcontrastFLAIR is the best sequence to highlight LME but a potentialpitfall is inhalation of increased levels of oxygen by patients whoare intubated which may increase subarachnoid space signalintensity noted on FLAIR images within the basal cisterns andsulcus along the cerebral convexities33 That is why we havechosen in this situation to acquire systematically precontrastand postcontrast FLAIR sequences to avoid misinterpretationof FLAIR hyperintensity within the subarachnoid spaces andnot to misdescribe a meningeal enhancement For our 11patients with LME no precontrast FLAIR signal abnormalitieswere visible in the subarachnoid spaces
Our study has several limitations mainly due to its multicenterand retrospective design First brain MRI protocols were dic-tated by clinical need and the patterns of working could bedifferent among the 11 centers even if neuroradiologists areused to work together Thus 36 of the MRIs were performedwithout administration of gadolinium-based contrast agentsnotably preventing the detection of LME therefore probablyunderestimating it Moreover LMEs are very subtle neuro-imaging findings which need the realization of delayed post-contrast FLAIR sequences which were not done in the vast
Figure 3 Radiologic acute disseminated encephalomyelitis
(A E I) Axial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) (B F J) axial diffusion (B F J) apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC) map and (D H L) postcontrast T1-weighted MRIs Man 60 years of age subcortical periventricular corpus callosum and posterior fossa white matter FLAIR hyperintensities without contrastenhancement (arrows) Some lesions appear hyperintense on diffusion-weightedMRIs with decreased ADC corresponding to cytotoxic edema (stars) Otherlesions present an ADC increase corresponding to vasogenic edema (cross)
e1878 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
majority of the centers Second we did not realize a follow-upMRI and some abnormalities could have appeared duringfollow-up Third outcomes were not available for all patients atthe time of writing Thus the mortality rate is probablyunderestimated in our cohort Fourth although patients withCOVID-19may develop a wide range of neurologic symptomswhich can be associated with ischemic stroke or encephalitis itis difficult to state without a controlled general neurologicpopulation that such events are more frequent in patients withCOVID-19 However it now seems well established thatthrombotic events are particularly frequent in patients withCOVID-1921 Moreover encephalitis which is a rare disorderin the general population34 was surprisingly frequent in ourpopulation
In this large multicentric national cohort most patients withCOVID-19 (56) with neurologic manifestations had brainMRI abnormalities such as ischemic stroke LME and enceph-alitis Because the detection of LME suggests the abnormality ofbrain MRI it would be interesting to realize systematicallypostcontrast FLAIR acquisition in patients with COVID-19
Concerning the cases of encephalitis and LME even if a directviral origin cannot be eliminated the pathophysiology of braindamage related to SARS-COV-2 seems rather to involve aninflammatory or autoimmune response The knowledge ofthe various clinicoradiologic manifestations of COVID-19could be helpful for the best care of the patients and ourunderstanding of the disease In addition to SARS cytokine
Figure 4 Multiple correspondence analysis
The ischemic stroke group (red) can be distinguished from the 3 others which largely overlapMost patients with ischemic stroke (numbers and dots in red onthe plot) are located on the same lower-right half of the graph indicating a commonality of symptoms Diag 1 (black) = normal brain MRI Diag 2 (red) =ischemic stroke Diag 3 (green) = encephalitis Diag 4 (blue) = leptomeningeal enhancement
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1879
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
storm syndrome and heart failure brain injuries may con-tribute to increased mortality This highlights the importanceof neurologic evaluation especially for patients hospitalized inICU with clinical deterioration or worsening of their symp-toms which can be associated with an acute neurologic event
AcknowledgmentThe authors thank Marie Cecile Henry Feugeas for her workin data acquisition for this study
Study fundingNo targeted funding reported
DisclosureThe authors report no disclosures relevant to the manuscriptGo to NeurologyorgN for full disclosures
Publication historyReceived by Neurology April 28 2020 Accepted in final formJune 9 2020
Appendix Authors
Name Location Contribution
StephaneKremer MDPhD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study acquisition of datainterpreted the data draftedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Franccedilois LersyMD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study acquisition of datainterpreted the data draftedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MathieuAnheim MDPhD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
Hamid MerdjiMD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MalekaSchenck MD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
HeleneOesterle MD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FedericoBolognini MD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Julien MessieMD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Antoine KhalilMD PhD
Bichat Hospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
AugustinGaudemer MD
Bichat Hospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Sophie CarreMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Manel AllegMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Claire LecocqMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
EmmanuelleSchmitt MD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ReneAnxionnatMD PhD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Franccedilois ZhuMD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Lavinia JagerMD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Patrick NesserMD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Yannick TallaMba MD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GhaziHmeydia MD
Saint-Anne hospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
JosephBenzakounMD
Saint-Anne hospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
CatherineOppenheimMD PhD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jean-ChristopheFerre MD PhD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Adel MaamarMD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
BeatriceCarsin-NicolMD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Pierre-OlivierComby MD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FredericRicolfi MDPhD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
PierreThouant MD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Claire BoutetMD PhD
University hospital ofSaint-Etienne France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
e1880 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
References1 Chen N Zhou M Dong X et al Epidemiological and clinical characteristics of 99
cases of 2019 novel coronavirus pneumonia in Wuhan China a descriptive studyLancet 2020395507ndash513
2 Huang C Wang Y Li X et al Clinical features of patients infected with 2019 novelcoronavirus in Wuhan China Lancet 2020395497ndash506
3 Glass WG Subbarao K Murphy B Murphy PM Mechanisms of host defense fol-lowing severe acute respiratory syndrome‐coronavirus (SARS‐CoV) pulmonary in-fection of mice J Immunol 20041734030ndash4039
4 Li K Wohlford‐Lenane C Perlman S et al Middle East respiratory syndromecoronavirus causes multiple organ damage and lethal disease in mice transgenic forhuman dipeptidyl peptidase 4 J Infect Dis 2016213712ndash722
5 Arbour N Day R Newcombe J Talbot PJ Neuroinvasion by human respiratorycoronaviruses J Virol 2000748913ndash8921
6 Desforges M Le Coupanec A Stodola JK Meessen-Pinard M Talbot PJ Humancoronaviruses viral and cellular factors involved in neuroinvasiveness and neuro-pathogenesis Virus Res 2014194145ndash158
7 Desforges M Le Coupanec A Dubeau P et al Human coronaviruses and otherrespiratory viruses underestimated opportunistic pathogens of the central nervoussystem Viruses 201912E14
8 Bohmwald K Galvez NMS Rıos M Kalergis AM Neurologic alterations due torespiratory virus infections Front Cell Neurosci 201812386
9 Poyiadji N Shahin G Noujaim D Stone M Patel S Griffith B COVID-19-associatedacute hemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy CT and MRI features Radiology2020201187
10 Moriguchi T Harii N Goto J et al A first case of meningitisencephalitis associatedwith SARS-coronavirus-2 Int J Infect Dis 20209455ndash58
11 Mao L Jin H Wang M et al Neurologic manifestations of hospitalized patients withcoronavirus disease 2019 in Wuhan China JAMA Neurol 2020771ndash9
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Xavier FabreMD
Hospital of RoanneFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GeraudForestier MD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Isaure deBeaurepaireMD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GregoireBornet MD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Hubert DesalMD PhD
University Hospital ofNantes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GregoireBoulouis MD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jerome BergeMD
University Hospital ofBordeaux France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ApollineKazemi MD
University Hospital ofLille France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
NadyaPyatigorskayaMD
Pitie-SalpetriereHospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
AugustinLecler MD
Foundation ARothschild Paris
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
SuzanaSaleme MD
University Hospital ofLimoges France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Myriam Edjlali-Goujon MD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
BasileKerleroux MD
University Hospital ofTours France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jean-MarcConstans MDPhD
University Hospital ofAmiens France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Pierre-EmmanuelZorn PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the acquisitionof data
MurielMatthieu PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the acquisitionof data
Seyyid BalogluMD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of datarevised the manuscriptfor intellectualcontent
Franccedilois-DanielArdellier MD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ThibaultWillaume MD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of datarevised the manuscriptfor intellectualcontent
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Jean-ChristopheBrisset PhD
French Observatoryof Multiple SclerosisLyon France
Interpretation of the datarevised the manuscript forintellectual content
SophieCaillard MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
OlivierCollange MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Paul MichelMertes MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FrancisSchneider MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Samira Fafi-KremerPharmD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MickaelOhana MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FerhatMeziani MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Nicolas MeyerMD PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the analysis andinterpretation of the data
Julie HelmsMD PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
FranccediloisCotton MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1881
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
12 Helms J Kremer S Merdji H et al Neurologic features in severe SARS-CoV-2infection N Engl J Med 20203822268ndash2270
13 Kandemirli SG Dogan L Sarikaya ZT et al Brain MRI findings in patients in theintensive care unit with COVID-19 infection Radiology Epub 2020 May 8
14 Ferguson ND Fan E Camporota L et al The Berlin definition of ARDS an expandedrationale justification and supplementary material Intensive Care Med 2012381573ndash1582
15 Starkey J Kobayashi N Numaguchi Y Moritani T Cytotoxic lesions of the corpuscallosum that show restricted diffusion mechanisms causes and manifestationsRadiographics 201737562ndash576
16 Beyrouti R Adams ME Benjamin L et al Characteristics of ischaemic stroke asso-ciated with COVID-19 J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry Epub 2020 Apr 30
17 Hess DC Eldahshan W Rutkowski E COVID-19-related stroke Transl Stroke Res202011322ndash325
18 Umapathi T Kor AC Venketasubramanian N et al Large artery ischaemic stroke insevere acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) J Neurol 20042511227ndash1231
19 Arabi YM Harthi A Hussein J et al Severe neurologic syndrome associated withMiddle East respiratory syndrome corona virus (MERS-CoV) Infection 201543495ndash501
20 Guo T Fan Y ChenM et al Cardiovascular implications of fatal outcomes of patientswith coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) JAMA Cardiol Epub 2020 Mar 27
21 Helms J Tacquard C Severac F et al High risk of thrombosis in patients in severeSARS-CoV-2 infection a multicenter prospective cohort study Intensive Care Med2020461089ndash1098
22 NagelMAMahalingamRCohrs RJ GildenD Virus vasculopathy and stroke an under-recognized cause and treatment target Infect Disord Drug Targets 201010105ndash111
23 Subramaniam S Scharrer I Procoagulant activity during viral infections Front Biosci(Landmark Ed) 2018231060ndash1081
24 Hung EC Chim SS Chan PK et al Detection of SARS coronavirus RNA in thecerebrospinal fluid of a patient with severe acute respiratory syndrome Clin Chem2003492108ndash2109
25 Lau KK Yu WC Chu CM Lau ST Sheng B Yuen KY Possible central nervoussystem infection by SARS coronavirus Emerg Infect Dis 200410342ndash344
26 Toledano M Davies NWS Infectious encephalitis mimics and chameleons PractNeurol 201919225ndash237
27 Kim JE Heo JH Kim HO et al Neurological complications during treatment ofMiddle East respiratory syndrome J Clin Neurol 201713227ndash233
28 Li Y Li H Fan R et al Coronavirus infections in the central nervous system andrespiratory tract show distinct features in hospitalized children Intervirology 201659163ndash169
29 Yeh EA Collins A Cohen ME Duffner PK Faden H Detection of coronavirus in thecentral nervous system of a child with acute disseminated encephalomyelitis Pedi-atrics 2004113(pt 1)e73ndashe76
30 Kivisakk P Imitola J Rasmussen S et al Localizing central nervous system immunesurveillance meningeal antigen-presenting cells activate T cells during experimentalautoimmune encephalomyelitis Ann Neurol 200965457ndash469
31 Absinta M Cortese IC Vuolo L et al Leptomeningeal gadolinium enhancementacross the spectrum of chronic neuroinflammatory diseases Neurology 2017881439ndash1444
32 Papatsiros VG Stylianaki I Papakonstantinou G Papaioannou N Christodoulo-poulos G Case report of transmissible gastroenteritis coronavirus infection associatedwith small intestine and brain lesions in piglets Viral Immunol 20193263ndash67
33 Stuckey SL Goh TD Heffernan T Rowan D Hyperintensity in the subarachnoidspace on FLAIR MRI AJR Am J Roentgenol 2007189913ndash921
34 Parpia AS Li Y Chen C Dhar B Crowcroft NS Encephalitis Ontario Canada 2002-2013 Emerg Infect Dis 201622426ndash432
e1882 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
DOI 101212WNL0000000000010112202095e1868-e1882 Published Online before print July 17 2020Neurology
Steacutephane Kremer Franccedilois Lersy Mathieu Anheim et al multicenter study
Neurologic and neuroimaging findings in patients with COVID-19 A retrospective
This information is current as of July 17 2020
ServicesUpdated Information amp
httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullincluding high resolution figures can be found at
References httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullref-list-1
This article cites 30 articles 6 of which you can access for free at
Citations httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullotherarticles
This article has been cited by 3 HighWire-hosted articles
Subspecialty Collections
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmriMRI
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmeningitisMeningitis
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionencephalitisEncephalitis e
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_cerebrovascular_disease_strokAll Cerebrovascular diseaseStrokefollowing collection(s) This article along with others on similar topics appears in the
Permissions amp Licensing
httpwwwneurologyorgaboutabout_the_journalpermissionsits entirety can be found online atInformation about reproducing this article in parts (figurestables) or in
Reprints
httpnneurologyorgsubscribersadvertiseInformation about ordering reprints can be found online
rights reserved Print ISSN 0028-3878 Online ISSN 1526-632X1951 it is now a weekly with 48 issues per year Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology All
reg is the official journal of the American Academy of Neurology Published continuously sinceNeurology
![Page 2: Neurologicandneuroimaging findingsinpatients with COVID-19 · enhancement (17%), and encephalitis (13%) were the most frequent neuroimaging findings. Confusion (53%) was the most](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060813/6091b284d4b0681e5152b42b/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
enhancement (17) and encephalitis (13) were the most frequent neuroimaging findings Confusion (53) was the mostcommon neurologic manifestation followed by impaired consciousness (39) presence of clinical signs of corticospinal tractinvolvement (31) agitation (31) and headache (16) The profile of patients experiencing ischemic stroke was differentfrom that of other patients with abnormal brain imaging the former less frequently had acute respiratory distress syndrome(p = 0006) and more frequently had corticospinal tract signs (p = 002) Patients with encephalitis were younger (p = 0007)whereas agitation was more frequent for patients with leptomeningeal enhancement (p = 0009)
ConclusionsPatients with COVID-19 may develop a wide range of neurologic symptoms which can be associated with severe and fatalcomplications such as ischemic stroke or encephalitis In terms of meningoencephalitis involvement even if a direct effect of thevirus cannot be excluded the pathophysiology seems to involve an immune or inflammatory process given the presence of signsof inflammation in both CSF and neuroimaging but the lack of virus in CSF
ClinicalTrialsgov identifierNCT04368390
In December 2019 many unexplained pneumonia cases oc-curred in China12 In January 2020 the causative agent wasidentified as a novel coronavirus which has been called severeacute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) givingthe disease the name coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19)Coronaviruses have neuroinvasive capacities because they areisolated in both brains and CSF of infected animals andhumans3ndash8 However few neurologic complications with humancoronaviruses (hCoVs) were documented in the past 2 decades
Concerning COVID-19 5 recent publications have presentedneuroimaging presentations of patients with neurologiccomplications9ndash13
The first studies that focused on clinical features of patientswith COVID-191211 showed neurologic manifestations such asheadache dizziness confusion hypogeusia hyposmia and moresevere neurologic disorders especially for patients hospitalized inintensive care units (ICUs) In a recent cohort of 214 patients11
248 of them presented CNS manifestations and 6 cases ofstrokes were diagnosed The neurologic symptoms were morecommon in cases of severe respiratory infection11 It has recentlybeen reported12 that patients referred to ICU frequently experi-enced encephalopathywith agitation confusion and corticospinaltract signs Brain MRI revealed in some patients leptomeningealenhancement (LME) and cerebral blood flow abnormalities
Despite these findings the potential brain injuries related toCOVID-19 have not been well described with neuroimagingin a large cohort Thus our aims were to describe the neu-roimaging findings in a population of COVID-19 with neu-rologic manifestations who underwent brain MRI to assessthe frequency of these abnormalities and to correlate thesefindings with clinical features
MethodsThis retrospective national multicenter study was initiated bythe French Neuroradiology Society
Patient cohortPatients with COVID-19 from 11 French centers including 6university hospitals and 5 general hospitals were includedfromMarch 16 2020 until April 9 2020 The number of casesincluded from each center was as follows 29 in Strasbourg 11in Colmar 7 in Paris (Bichat) 5 in Haguenau 4 in Nancy 4again in Paris (Sainte-Anne) 3 in Rennes 2 in Dijon 1 inSaint-Etienne 1 in Forbach and 1 in Antony
The diagnosis of COVID-19 was based on the following cri-teria possible exposure history symptoms clinically com-patible with COVID-19 and detection of SARS-CoV-2 byreverse transcriptase-PCR (RT-PCR) assays on the naso-pharyngeal throat or lower respiratory tract swabs Inclusioncriteria were diagnosis of COVID-19 with neurologic mani-festation and a brain MRI assessment Exclusion criteria weremissing data or noncontributory (lack of sequences numer-ous artifacts) data regarding brain MRI
The diagnosis of acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS)was based on Berlin criteria14
Clinical and laboratory data were extracted from the patientsrsquoelectronic medical records in the hospital information system
Virologic assessmentQuantitative real-time RT-PCR tests for SARS-CoV-2 nucleicacid were performed on upper or lower respiratory tract swabsand CSF Primer and probe sequences were targeting 2regions on the RdRp gene which are specific to SARS-CoV-2Assay sensitivity was asymp10 copies per reaction
Brain MRI protocolsImaging studies were conducted on 15T or 3T MRI Themulticenter nature of the study and the various clinical pre-sentations did not allow standardization of sequences
The most frequently sequences performed were 3DT1-weighted spin-echo with and without contrast-enhancedimaging diffusion-weighted imaging gradient echo T2 or
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1869
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
susceptibility-weighted imaging 2D or 3D fluid-attenuatedinversion recovery (FLAIR) postcontrast and 3D time-of-flight magnetic resonance angiography of the circle of Willis
Brain MRI readingAfter anonymization images were presented to readers withour GE Picture Archiving and Communication System(General Electric Milwaukee WI) Two neuroradiologists(SK and FL with 20 and 9 years of experience in neuro-radiology respectively) who were blinded to all patient dataindependently reviewed all brain MRIs The final diagnosiswas determined by consensus and if consensus could not bereached a third neuroradiologist (SB with 9 years of expe-rience in neuroradiology) was questioned
Neuroimaging abnormalities were divided into 3 groupsischemic stroke encephalitis and LME Ischemic strokeswere classified into large artery infarctions watershed cere-bral infarctions lacunar infarctions and hypoxic-ischemicinjuries Encephalitis was ranked as limbic encephalitis cy-totoxic lesion of the corpus callosum (CLOCC) radiologicacute disseminated encephalomyelitis (ADEM) radiologicacute hemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy and mis-cellaneous encephalitis
Encephalitis was defined as brain parenchymal abnormalFLAIR hyperintensity involving gray matter (GM) whitematter or basal ganglia with variable enhancement localizedmainly in medial temporal and inferior frontal lobes in case oflimbic encephalitis The term CLOCC has been proposed re-cently to describe a clinicoradiologic syndrome characterizedby a transient mild encephalopathy and a reversible lesion ofthe corpus callosum localized mainly to the central part of thesplenium onMRI CLOCCs are the consequence of numerousetiologies the 2 most frequent being antiepileptic drug with-drawal and infections They are related to a cytokine increaseinducing glutamate elevation in the extracellular space leadingto a dysfunction of callosal neurons and microglia with in-tracellular water influx resulting in cytotoxic edema15
ADEM is an autoimmune-mediated disease occurring afterviral infections and vaccinations Multifocal demyelinatinglesions involving white matter but also GM (basal ganglia) areseen with variable enhancement Acute hemorrhagic necro-tizing encephalopathy is a fulminant inflammatory de-myelinating disease which is considered the most severe formof ADEM associated with hemorrhagic lesions
A brain MRI without acute significative abnormalities orshowing lesions unrelated to SARS-CoV-2 was considerednormal
Statistical analysisData were described with frequency and proportion (numberpercent) for categorical variables and mean median andrange for quantitative data Categorical data were comparedwith the Fisher exact test Quantitative data were compared
with analysis of variance Multiple correspondence analysis(MCA) was used to give a simultaneous multivariate de-scription of clinical and radiologic characteristics of all di-agnostic groups MCA plots display results either for thesubjects or for their characteristics Those plots are to beinterpreted on the basis of the proximity of the data points 2subjects who are close on a plot share a common pattern ofsymptoms and 2 clinical symptoms that are close on a plotdescribe similar types of subjects Ellipses are drawn aroundthe mean position of each characteristic such that non-overlapping ellipses can be considered to show a contrastbetween the subjects who share 1 or the other characteristic
Computations were made with 353 through R-Studio withthe readxl and FactoMineR packages (R Foundation forStatistical Computing Vienna Austria) A value of p lt 005was considered significant
Standard protocol approvals registrationsand patient consentsThe study was approved by the ethics standards committeeon human experimentation of Strasbourg University Hos-pital (CE-2020-37) and was in accordance with the 1964Declaration of Helsinki and its later amendments Due to theemergency in the context of COVID-19 pandemic responsiblefor acute respiratory and neurologic manifestations pandemicthe requirement for patientsrsquo written informed consent waswaived
The study has been registered in ClinicalTrialsgov(NCT04368390)
Data availabilityWe state that the data published are available and anonymizedand will be shared on request by email to the correspondingauthor from any qualified investigator for purposes of repli-cating procedures and results
ResultsA total of 68 patients with COVID-19 were included in thismulticenter study Among them 4 were excluded becausetheir brain MRIs were considered noncontributory
Clinical characteristicsThe demographic and clinical characteristics of the 64patients and their neurologic manifestations are summarizedin tables 1 through 3 The most frequent neurologic mani-festations were confusionagitationalteration of conscious-ness corticospinal tract signs and headache
Complementary data concerning patients with COVID-19with acute ischemic stroke are given in table 2 including riskfactors clinical presentation echocardiography and ECGresults neuroimaging description and D-dimer serum levelFurther information related to patients with COVID-19 withmeningoencephalitis is given in table 3
e1870 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
Neuroimaging findingsAmong the 64MRIs included 41 (64) were performed withgadolinium-based contrast agent administration Thirty-onehad a postcontrast FLAIR and 18 had a delayed postcontrastFLAIR The latter was achieved asymp10 minutes after the in-jection after the realization of conventional postcontrastFLAIR and enhanced T1-weighted imaging Thirty-six (56)brain MRIs were considered abnormal possibly related toSARS-CoV-2
Ischemic strokes (27) (figure e-1 available from Dryaddoiorg105061dryadw9ghx3fm7) LME (17) (figure 1)and encephalitis (13) (figures 2 and 3 and figure e-2 availablefrom Dryad) were the most frequent neuroimaging findingsLME was seen on both postcontrast T1-weighted and FLAIRsequences and was even better visualized when delayed post-contrast FLAIR was performed These signal abnormalitieswere not present on precontrast T1 or FLAIR images
Among the 8 encephalitis 2 cases of limbic encephalitis2 cases of radiologic acute hemorrhagic necrotizing encepha-lopathy 2 cases of miscellaneous encephalitis 1 case of radio-logic ADEM and 1 case of CLOCC were described
CSF analysisTwenty-five (39) patients underwent a lumbar puncture 7in the encephalitis group 8 in the LME group 2 in the is-chemic stroke group and 8 in the normal brain MRI group
CSF glucose was normal in all cases
In the encephalitis group (table 3) 6 patients showedmarkersof inflammation 4 had pleocytosis 5 had high levels of pro-tein 2 had elevated immunoglobulin G and another hadoligoclonal bands that were identical in CSF and serum In theLME group (table 3) 6 patients showed markers of in-flammation 2 had pleocytosis 3 had high levels of protein 2
Table 1 History neurologic manifestations and clinical characteristics of the cohort
All patients(n = 64)
Ischemic stroke(n = 17)
Encephalitis(n = 8)
LME(n = 11) p Value
Sex n () 028
Men 43 (67) 11 (65) 7 (88) 5 (46)
Women 21 (33) 6 (35) 1 (12) 6 (54)
Age y 0007
Mean 65 75 61 66
Median 66 75 59 64
Range 20ndash92 59ndash92 55ndash71 51ndash81
History of stroke n () 7 (11) 4 (24) 0 1 (9) 036
History of seizures n () 3 (5) 1 (6) 0 0 1
Another neurologic history n () 9 (14) 2 (12) 0 0 017
History of autoimmune diseases n () 7 (11) 3 (18) 0 1 (9) 083
History of hematologic malignancies n () 4 (6) 1 (6) 0 1 (9) 1
Headaches n () 10 (16) 3 (18) 2 (25) 1 (9) 085
Seizures n () 1 (2) 0 0 0 1
Anosmia n () 2 (3) 1 (6) 0 1 (9) 031
Ageusia n () 4 (6) 0 1 (13) 1 (9) 045
Clinical signs of corticospinal tract involvement n () 20 (31) 10 (59) 1 (13) 4 (36) 002
Disturbance of consciousness n () 25 (39) 3 (18) 4 (50) 6 (55) 015
Confusion n () 34 (53) 7 (41) 3 (38) 6 (55) 034
Agitation n () 20 (31) 1 (6) 3 (38) 7 (64) 0009
Oxygen therapy n () 53 (83) 13 (76) 8 (100) 10 (91) 052
ARDS n () 33 (52) 3 (18) 6 (75) 8 (73) 0006
Death n () 7 (11) 2 (12) 2 (25) 0 038
Abbreviations ARDS = acute respiratory distress syndrome LME = leptomeningeal enhancement
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1871
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
Table 2 Characteristics of patients with COVID-19 with acute ischemic stroke
Sex Age y Risk factors Clinical presentation
Days from COVID-19respiratory symptomonset to ischemicstroke symptom onset
Treatment up tothis time point
Arrhythmias (ECGor echocardiography)
BrainMRI
Large vesselocclusion
D-dimers(reference range lt400) μgL
M 86 HypertensionDyslipidemia
Left hemiplegiaimpairedconsciousness
1 Supportive No LAI Distal M1 occlusionwith thrombus
NR
M 71 HypertensionDiabetesmellitus
Left hemiplegia 16 Antibiotics Yes (previouslyunknown)
LAI Distal M1 occlusionwith thrombus
2860
F 74 mdash Bilateral pyramidal tract signs 8 AntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
No WCI mdash gt20000
M 63 Smoking Left-sided weaknessleft-sidedsensory inattention
14 Antibiotics Yes (previouslyunknown)
LAI mdash 1000
M 65 HypertensionDiabetesmellitusDyslipidemiaHOS
Impaired consciousness 22 Antibiotics No WCI mdash 1570
F 78 Hypertension Dysarthria 3 Supportive No WCI mdash 720
F 75 HypertensionDyslipidemiaAtrial Fibrillation
Aphasiaright hemiplegiaimpaired consciousnessagitation
6 Supportive NR LAI ICA occlusion NR
M 79 HypertensionDyslipidemiaHOS
Headachesimpairedconsciousnessconfusion
5 Supportive No WCI mdash NR
F 71 HypertensionSmokingAtrial fibrillation
Left hemiplegia 3 Supportive Yes LAI Proximal M2occlusion
gt20000
M 59 HypertensionSmoking
Left hemiplegialeft facial droop 1 Supportive No LAI Proximal M1occlusion withthrombus
2868
M 66 HypertensionDyslipidemiaDiabetesmellitus
Left pyramidal tract signsleftfacial droopaphasia
4 Supportive No LAI ICA dissection 5227
M 72 DyslipidemiaAtrial fibrillation
Impaired consciousness 15 Antibiotics Yes LAI mdash 993
M 78 Hypertension Dysarthriaright-sidedweaknessright facial droop
16 Supportive No LAI mdash NR
Continued
e1872Neu
rology
|Vo
lume95N
umber
13|
Septem
ber
292020NeurologyorgN
Copyright
copy2020
American
Academ
yof
Neurology
Unauthorized
reproductionof
thisarticle
isprohibited
had elevated immunoglobulin G and 4 had oligoclonal bandsthat were identical in CSF and serum In the ischemic strokegroup 1 patient had a high level of protein
The RT-PCR SARS-CoV-2 analysis was negative in the 20patients who were investigated The analysis was not realizedfor 5 patients 1 with a normal brain MRI 2 with an ischemicstroke 1 with encephalitis and 1 with LME Cultures for otherviruses or bacteria were always negative when performed
Correlation analysisThere were statistically significant differences between thevarious groups concerning age (p = 0007) the presence ofpyramidal tract signs (p = 002) agitation (p = 0009) andrespiratory status (ARDS) (p = 0006) (table 1)
The MCA showed that the ischemic stroke group could bedistinguished from the 3 others which largely overlap (figure 4)Most patients with ischemic stroke (numbers and dots in redon the plot) are located on the same lower-right half of thegraph indicating a commonality of symptoms Those patientscan be overall described as older with no ARDS no oxygenrequirement no confusion no disturbances of consciousnessand a lower death rate The converse is true for the 3 otherdiagnoses that cannot be distinguished Considering eachclinical manifestation separately (figure e-3 available fromDryad doiorg105061dryadw9ghx3fm7) subjects can bedistinguishedmainly on the basis of a global pattern dependingon their oxygen requirement seizure sex headaches history ofautoimmune disease history of seizure age anosmia confu-sion and disturbances of consciousness
DiscussionThis is the first large nationwide cohort of MRIs performed inpatients with COVID-19 with neurologic manifestations
The majority of patients had MRI abnormalities with seriousand various findings beyond the severe respiratory disease(half of the patients had ARDS and 11 died) cerebrovas-cular disease (especially ischemic stroke large artery infarc-tions more frequently than watershed cerebral infarctions)encephalitis (including limbic encephalitis radiologic ADEMCLOCC and radiologic acute hemorrhagic necrotizing en-cephalopathy) and focal or even diffuse LME The hetero-geneity of the imaging abnormalities was underpinned byheterogeneous clinical manifestations ranging from anosmiaageusia or headache to more severe findings such as confu-sion with agitation loss of consciousness and corticospinaltract signs Some correlations were found between clinical andimaging findings allowing the identification of clinicoradio-logic profiles of patients with COVID-19 displaying neuro-logic manifestations
Ischemic stroke was 1 kind of clinicoradiologic phenotype itwas an acute event arising in older patients who more fre-quently had corticospinal tract signs but was less frequentlyTa
ble
2Charac
teristicsofpatients
withCOVID-19withac
ute
isch
emicstroke
(con
tinue
d)
Sex
Age
yRiskfactors
Clinicalpre
senta
tion
Days
from
COVID
-19
resp
irato
rysy
mpto
monse
tto
isch
emic
stro
kesy
mpto
monse
tTr
eatm
entupto
this
timepoint
Arrhythmias(ECG
orech
oca
rdiogr
aphy)
Bra
inMRI
Larg
eve
ssel
occ
lusion
D-dim
ers
(refere
nce
range
lt400
)μgL
M76
mdashConfusion
24Su
pportive
No
WCI
mdash397
7
F92
mdashConfusion
10Su
pportive
No
WCI
mdash98
7
F77
Hyp
ertension
HOS
Lefthem
iplegialeft
homonym
oushem
ianopia
hea
dac
hes
minus2(stroke
prece
ded
resp
iratory
symptoms
by2d)
mdashYe
s(previously
unkn
own)
LAI
P2occlusion
NR
M88
Hyp
ertension
Dyslip
idem
iaDiabetes
mellitus
Atrialfibrilla
tion
HOS
Righthem
iplegiaim
paired
consciousn
ess
minus2(stroke
prece
ded
resp
iratory
symptoms
by2d)
mdashYe
sLA
IProximal
M2
occlusion
NR
Abbreviations
COVID-19=co
ronav
irusdisea
se20
19H
OS=history
ofstroke
IC=intern
alca
rotidarteryL
AI=
largeartery
infarctionN
R=Notrealized
WCI=
watersh
edce
rebralinfarction
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1873
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
Table 3 Characteristics of patients with COVID-19 with meningoencephalitis
Sex Age y Clinical symptoms
Days from COVID-19respiratory symptomonset to brain MRI Treatment up to this time point CSF analysis Imaging findings
F 71 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
22 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
0 celluarr Total protein 057 gL
Miscellaneous encephalitisdiffusionand T2FLAIR hyperintensitiesinvolving supratentorial WM
M 64 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
17 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
40 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 11 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 56 mgL
Miscellaneous encephalitisFLAIRhyperintensity involving both middlecerebellar peduncles
M 56 Impaired consciousnesspathologic wakefulness whensedation was stopped
23 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
1 cellmm3
uarr Total protein 2 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 169 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Radiologic acute hemorrhagicnecrotizing encephalopathy
M 66 Impaired consciousnesspathologic wakefulness whensedation was stopped
34 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
NR Radiologic acute hemorrhagicnecrotizing encephalopathy
M 55 Headachesdizzinessimpairedconsciousness
3 mdash 7 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 056 gLCLOCC
M 56 Headaches 20 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
3 cellsmm3
Total protein 024 gLLeft limbic encephalitis
M 58 Ataxia 21 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
4 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 077 gLLeft limbic encephalitis
M 60 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
13 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
0 cellTotal protein 03 gL
Radiologic ADEM
F 51 Movement disordersagitation 16 mdash 5 cellsuarr Total protein 066 gL
Focal LME
F 59 Headachesdizziness 18 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
NR Focal LME
M 62 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
19 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
0 cellTotal protein 023 gLImmunoglobulin G 33 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Diffuse LME
Continued
e1874Neu
rology
|Vo
lume95N
umber
13|
Septem
ber
292020NeurologyorgN
Copyright
copy2020
American
Academ
yof
Neurology
Unauthorized
reproductionof
thisarticle
isprohibited
Table 3 Characteristics of patients with COVID-19 with meningoencephalitis (continued)
Sex Age y Clinical symptoms
Days from COVID-19respiratory symptomonset to brain MRI Treatment up to this time point CSF analysis Imaging findings
M 78 Agitation 15 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
NR Focal LME
M 72 Impaired consciousnessbilateralpyramidal tract signs
20 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavirHydroxychloroquine
0 cellTotal protein 023 gLImmunoglobulin G 17 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Focal LME
M 61 Impaired consciousnessbilateralpyramidal tract signsconfusionagitation
14 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
1 cellmm3
Total protein 023 gLImmunoglobulin G 17 mgL
Focal LME
M 66 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
22 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
NR Focal LME
F 53 Confusionimpairedconsciousness
29 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
0 cellTotal protein 029 gLImmunoglobulin G 21 mgL
Focal LME
F 64 Bilateral pyramidal tract signs 11 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
2 cellsmm3
Total protein 030 gLImmunoglobulin G 15 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Focal LME
F 77 Bilateral pyramidal syndromeconfusionagitation
30 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavirHydroxychloroquine
1 cellmm3
uarr Total protein 080 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 58 mgL
Diffuse LME
F 81 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
20 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
80 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 062 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 38 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Focal LME
Abbreviations ADEM = Acute disseminated encephalomyelitis CLOCC = cytotoxic lesion of the corpus callosum COVID-19 = coronavirus disease 2019 FLAIR = fluid-attenuated inversion recovery ICU = intensive care unitLME = leptomeningeal enhancement NR = not realized WM = white matter
Neurolo
gyorgN
Neurology
|Volum
e95N
umber
13|
Septem
ber292020
e1875
Copyright
copy2020
American
Academ
yof
Neurology
Unauthorized
reproductionof
thisarticle
isprohibited
requiring oxygen or presenting an ARDS This profile couldbe distinguished from the 2 others LME and encephalitisThe encephalitis profile affected younger patients and seemedto be particularly severe because it was associated with theneed for oxygen ARDS and death
Stroke patients less frequently had ARDS and this result is inagreement with the 6 patients with stroke previously reportedin that only 2 patients were admitted to ICUs16 One mayhypothesize that strokes in patients with COVID-19 could bedue to procoagulant events leading to thrombosis17 ratherthan to the systemic inflammatory process that accompaniesARDS which is also directed against the CNS However thisneeds to be assessed by further studies dedicated to stroke andthrombosis in patients with COVID-19
In our study 17 (27) patients had an acute ischemic strokeas was previously reported with SARS-CoV18 Middle Eastrespiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERS-CoV)19 andSARS-CoV-2111617 and among them 11 had large arteryinfarctions (including 6 proximal artery occlusions 2 cases ofinternal carotid artery dissection or occlusion) and 6 hadwatershed cerebral infarctions For 15 of 17 patients with anischemic stroke the respiratory symptoms related to COVID-19 had begun before this acute event while stroke precededrespiratory symptoms by 2 days for 2 patients
Several mechanisms are likely to be associated It is nowknown that SARS-CoV-2 could directly lead to myocardialinjury promoting cardiac arrhythmias associated with em-bolic events20 Six of our patients had arrhythmias which werepreviously unknown for 3 of them In the same way a severeacute myocardial injury may be associated with a decrease inbrain perfusion and therefore with watershed cerebralinfarctions As previously mentioned it is acknowledged thatviruses particularly SARS-CoV-221 are associated with anincrease of prothrombotic events such as ischemic stroke2223
Thereby viral infections may elevate procoagulant markersleading to thrombosis disseminated intravascular coagulationand hemorrhagic events23 As Beyrouti et al16 recently men-tioned all our patients tested showed elevated D-dimersmarkedly elevated (gt1000 μgL) for 10 of the 11 patientstested
Varicella zoster virus is also associated with direct vascularinvolvement and eventually arteritis promoting ischemicstroke events22 Furthermore the more severe critically illpatients hospitalized in ICUs have probably had hypoxemiaand hypotension leading to brain injuries18
Of the 36 abnormal MRIs 8 diagnoses of encephalitis weremade and LME was described especially on postcontrast T1-weighted and FLAIR in 11 patients either focal (single focus
Figure 1 Leptomeningeal enhancement
Axial T1 (A) before and (B) 5 minutes after contrast axial FLAIR (C) before and (D) immediately after contrast and (E and F) delayed (10 minutes) postcontrastaxial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) weighted MRIs Woman 77 years of age diffuse leptomeningeal linear FLAIR and T1 contrast enhancement(arrows) not visible on precontrast T1 and FLAIR (arrows) but seen better on delayed postcontrast FLAIR weighted MRIs (E and F)
e1876 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
vs multiple foci) or diffuse and preferentially located in theposterior supratentorial regions of the brain
Two main pathophysiologic hypotheses can be advanced toexplain the neuroimaging findings in the inflammatory profilegroup First SARS-CoV-2 may have a neuroinvasive potentialsimilar to other hCoVs because this family of viruses is relatedto each other genetically It is not clear if the virus can infiltratethe CNS with active replication and direct damage to braincells (viral encephalitis) as observed with other viruses suchas herpes simplex virus Likewise viral meningitis due to di-rect infiltration of the virus into the CSF may also be con-sidered because it was previously reported with SARS-CoV-1Indeed SARS-CoV-1 RNA was detected in the CSF of 2patients with seizures2425 A recent case report10 has de-scribed for the first time a case of seizures with the detection ofSARS-CoV-2 RNA in the CSF Similarly leptomeningealinflammation may be present adjacent to subpial corticallesions in the case of viral meningoencephalitis In the case ofviral encephalitis CSF analysis usually demonstrates lym-phocytic pleocytosis26 In addition the CSF protein level istypically elevated in viral encephalitis CSF viral RT-PCR isusually positive but can be negative if done too early This wasnot the case in our series and our results are in accordance
with recently published data that demonstrated an absence ofCSF pleocytosis and negative SARS-CoV-2 RT-PCR (5 of 5patients) but elevated protein level (4 of 5 patients) inpatients presenting cerebral MRI cortical abnormalities13
MRI pictures of viral encephalitis vary with causal pathogenNevertheless viral encephalitis usually involves cerebral GMwith diffusion restriction and can be associated with intrale-sional and diffuse leptomeningeal contrast enhancement Thiswas not the case in our series and did not argue for the directeffect of the virus It is all the more likely that the directdetection of SARS-CoV-2 RNA by RT-PCR was alwaysnegative in all our CSF samples
An alternative hypothesis appears more relevant the neuro-virulence of hCoVs especially MERS-CoV seems to bea consequence of immune-mediated processes1927ndash29 IndeedADEM and Bickerstaff brainstem encephalitis which weredescribed with MERS-CoV18ndash27 are 2 examples of autoim-mune demyelinating diseases resulting from a postinfectious orparainfectious process A recent case report9 has describeda case of acute hemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy (whichis the most severe form of ADEM) associated with COVID-19which strengthens the hypothesis of a predominant immuno-logic mechanism In our cohort we also described 2 cases of
Figure 2 Encephalitis
(A B D) Axial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) and(C) diffusion-weighted MRIs (A) Man 56 years of age lefthippocampus and amygdala FLAIR hyperintensity (B)Woman 71 years of age periventricular and subcorticalwhite matter FLAIR confluent hyperintensities (C) Man 55years of age corpus callosum splenium diffusion hyper-intensity (D) Man 64 years of age FLAIR middle cerebellarpeduncle hyperintensity
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1877
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
limbic encephalitis and 1 case of CLOCC Concerning thelatter no treatment had been started or stopped in previousweeks Thus 75 of encephalitis cases in our cohort (limbicencephalitis CLOCC radiologic ADEM radiologic acutehemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy) are possibly con-sidered immune-mediated diseases Therefore SARS-CoV-2ndashmediated disease is driven largely by immunologic processesand the same mechanisms could explain LME Indeed thearachnoid and pial membranes form the leptomeninges anda significant amount of antigen-presenting cells are present inthe subarachnoid space30 Thus initial immune activationoccurs in the subarachnoid space which is a site for antigenpresentation lymphocyte accumulation and proliferation andantibody production30 All lead to an important local in-flammatory infiltrate with a blood-CSF barrier disruptionwhich can also explain LME Thus LME can be linked toinflammatory or immunologic responses as previously de-scribed in animal models of autoimmune encephalomyelitis31
with some neurotropic viruses such as human T-cell leukemiavirus and HIV31 and in several immune-mediated neurologicdiseases31 Moreover a very similar intracranial pattern hasbeen described in an animal study in piglets affected by gas-troenteritis coronavirus32 Indeed histology demonstrateddiffuse pia matter gliosis with mild congestion of the meningeal
and parenchymal vessels with neuronal degeneration locatedmostly in posterior parietooccipital lobes24 PostcontrastFLAIR is the best sequence to highlight LME but a potentialpitfall is inhalation of increased levels of oxygen by patients whoare intubated which may increase subarachnoid space signalintensity noted on FLAIR images within the basal cisterns andsulcus along the cerebral convexities33 That is why we havechosen in this situation to acquire systematically precontrastand postcontrast FLAIR sequences to avoid misinterpretationof FLAIR hyperintensity within the subarachnoid spaces andnot to misdescribe a meningeal enhancement For our 11patients with LME no precontrast FLAIR signal abnormalitieswere visible in the subarachnoid spaces
Our study has several limitations mainly due to its multicenterand retrospective design First brain MRI protocols were dic-tated by clinical need and the patterns of working could bedifferent among the 11 centers even if neuroradiologists areused to work together Thus 36 of the MRIs were performedwithout administration of gadolinium-based contrast agentsnotably preventing the detection of LME therefore probablyunderestimating it Moreover LMEs are very subtle neuro-imaging findings which need the realization of delayed post-contrast FLAIR sequences which were not done in the vast
Figure 3 Radiologic acute disseminated encephalomyelitis
(A E I) Axial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) (B F J) axial diffusion (B F J) apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC) map and (D H L) postcontrast T1-weighted MRIs Man 60 years of age subcortical periventricular corpus callosum and posterior fossa white matter FLAIR hyperintensities without contrastenhancement (arrows) Some lesions appear hyperintense on diffusion-weightedMRIs with decreased ADC corresponding to cytotoxic edema (stars) Otherlesions present an ADC increase corresponding to vasogenic edema (cross)
e1878 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
majority of the centers Second we did not realize a follow-upMRI and some abnormalities could have appeared duringfollow-up Third outcomes were not available for all patients atthe time of writing Thus the mortality rate is probablyunderestimated in our cohort Fourth although patients withCOVID-19may develop a wide range of neurologic symptomswhich can be associated with ischemic stroke or encephalitis itis difficult to state without a controlled general neurologicpopulation that such events are more frequent in patients withCOVID-19 However it now seems well established thatthrombotic events are particularly frequent in patients withCOVID-1921 Moreover encephalitis which is a rare disorderin the general population34 was surprisingly frequent in ourpopulation
In this large multicentric national cohort most patients withCOVID-19 (56) with neurologic manifestations had brainMRI abnormalities such as ischemic stroke LME and enceph-alitis Because the detection of LME suggests the abnormality ofbrain MRI it would be interesting to realize systematicallypostcontrast FLAIR acquisition in patients with COVID-19
Concerning the cases of encephalitis and LME even if a directviral origin cannot be eliminated the pathophysiology of braindamage related to SARS-COV-2 seems rather to involve aninflammatory or autoimmune response The knowledge ofthe various clinicoradiologic manifestations of COVID-19could be helpful for the best care of the patients and ourunderstanding of the disease In addition to SARS cytokine
Figure 4 Multiple correspondence analysis
The ischemic stroke group (red) can be distinguished from the 3 others which largely overlapMost patients with ischemic stroke (numbers and dots in red onthe plot) are located on the same lower-right half of the graph indicating a commonality of symptoms Diag 1 (black) = normal brain MRI Diag 2 (red) =ischemic stroke Diag 3 (green) = encephalitis Diag 4 (blue) = leptomeningeal enhancement
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1879
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
storm syndrome and heart failure brain injuries may con-tribute to increased mortality This highlights the importanceof neurologic evaluation especially for patients hospitalized inICU with clinical deterioration or worsening of their symp-toms which can be associated with an acute neurologic event
AcknowledgmentThe authors thank Marie Cecile Henry Feugeas for her workin data acquisition for this study
Study fundingNo targeted funding reported
DisclosureThe authors report no disclosures relevant to the manuscriptGo to NeurologyorgN for full disclosures
Publication historyReceived by Neurology April 28 2020 Accepted in final formJune 9 2020
Appendix Authors
Name Location Contribution
StephaneKremer MDPhD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study acquisition of datainterpreted the data draftedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Franccedilois LersyMD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study acquisition of datainterpreted the data draftedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MathieuAnheim MDPhD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
Hamid MerdjiMD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MalekaSchenck MD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
HeleneOesterle MD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FedericoBolognini MD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Julien MessieMD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Antoine KhalilMD PhD
Bichat Hospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
AugustinGaudemer MD
Bichat Hospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Sophie CarreMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Manel AllegMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Claire LecocqMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
EmmanuelleSchmitt MD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ReneAnxionnatMD PhD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Franccedilois ZhuMD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Lavinia JagerMD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Patrick NesserMD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Yannick TallaMba MD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GhaziHmeydia MD
Saint-Anne hospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
JosephBenzakounMD
Saint-Anne hospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
CatherineOppenheimMD PhD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jean-ChristopheFerre MD PhD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Adel MaamarMD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
BeatriceCarsin-NicolMD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Pierre-OlivierComby MD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FredericRicolfi MDPhD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
PierreThouant MD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Claire BoutetMD PhD
University hospital ofSaint-Etienne France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
e1880 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
References1 Chen N Zhou M Dong X et al Epidemiological and clinical characteristics of 99
cases of 2019 novel coronavirus pneumonia in Wuhan China a descriptive studyLancet 2020395507ndash513
2 Huang C Wang Y Li X et al Clinical features of patients infected with 2019 novelcoronavirus in Wuhan China Lancet 2020395497ndash506
3 Glass WG Subbarao K Murphy B Murphy PM Mechanisms of host defense fol-lowing severe acute respiratory syndrome‐coronavirus (SARS‐CoV) pulmonary in-fection of mice J Immunol 20041734030ndash4039
4 Li K Wohlford‐Lenane C Perlman S et al Middle East respiratory syndromecoronavirus causes multiple organ damage and lethal disease in mice transgenic forhuman dipeptidyl peptidase 4 J Infect Dis 2016213712ndash722
5 Arbour N Day R Newcombe J Talbot PJ Neuroinvasion by human respiratorycoronaviruses J Virol 2000748913ndash8921
6 Desforges M Le Coupanec A Stodola JK Meessen-Pinard M Talbot PJ Humancoronaviruses viral and cellular factors involved in neuroinvasiveness and neuro-pathogenesis Virus Res 2014194145ndash158
7 Desforges M Le Coupanec A Dubeau P et al Human coronaviruses and otherrespiratory viruses underestimated opportunistic pathogens of the central nervoussystem Viruses 201912E14
8 Bohmwald K Galvez NMS Rıos M Kalergis AM Neurologic alterations due torespiratory virus infections Front Cell Neurosci 201812386
9 Poyiadji N Shahin G Noujaim D Stone M Patel S Griffith B COVID-19-associatedacute hemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy CT and MRI features Radiology2020201187
10 Moriguchi T Harii N Goto J et al A first case of meningitisencephalitis associatedwith SARS-coronavirus-2 Int J Infect Dis 20209455ndash58
11 Mao L Jin H Wang M et al Neurologic manifestations of hospitalized patients withcoronavirus disease 2019 in Wuhan China JAMA Neurol 2020771ndash9
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Xavier FabreMD
Hospital of RoanneFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GeraudForestier MD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Isaure deBeaurepaireMD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GregoireBornet MD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Hubert DesalMD PhD
University Hospital ofNantes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GregoireBoulouis MD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jerome BergeMD
University Hospital ofBordeaux France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ApollineKazemi MD
University Hospital ofLille France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
NadyaPyatigorskayaMD
Pitie-SalpetriereHospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
AugustinLecler MD
Foundation ARothschild Paris
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
SuzanaSaleme MD
University Hospital ofLimoges France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Myriam Edjlali-Goujon MD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
BasileKerleroux MD
University Hospital ofTours France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jean-MarcConstans MDPhD
University Hospital ofAmiens France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Pierre-EmmanuelZorn PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the acquisitionof data
MurielMatthieu PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the acquisitionof data
Seyyid BalogluMD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of datarevised the manuscriptfor intellectualcontent
Franccedilois-DanielArdellier MD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ThibaultWillaume MD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of datarevised the manuscriptfor intellectualcontent
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Jean-ChristopheBrisset PhD
French Observatoryof Multiple SclerosisLyon France
Interpretation of the datarevised the manuscript forintellectual content
SophieCaillard MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
OlivierCollange MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Paul MichelMertes MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FrancisSchneider MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Samira Fafi-KremerPharmD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MickaelOhana MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FerhatMeziani MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Nicolas MeyerMD PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the analysis andinterpretation of the data
Julie HelmsMD PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
FranccediloisCotton MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1881
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
12 Helms J Kremer S Merdji H et al Neurologic features in severe SARS-CoV-2infection N Engl J Med 20203822268ndash2270
13 Kandemirli SG Dogan L Sarikaya ZT et al Brain MRI findings in patients in theintensive care unit with COVID-19 infection Radiology Epub 2020 May 8
14 Ferguson ND Fan E Camporota L et al The Berlin definition of ARDS an expandedrationale justification and supplementary material Intensive Care Med 2012381573ndash1582
15 Starkey J Kobayashi N Numaguchi Y Moritani T Cytotoxic lesions of the corpuscallosum that show restricted diffusion mechanisms causes and manifestationsRadiographics 201737562ndash576
16 Beyrouti R Adams ME Benjamin L et al Characteristics of ischaemic stroke asso-ciated with COVID-19 J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry Epub 2020 Apr 30
17 Hess DC Eldahshan W Rutkowski E COVID-19-related stroke Transl Stroke Res202011322ndash325
18 Umapathi T Kor AC Venketasubramanian N et al Large artery ischaemic stroke insevere acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) J Neurol 20042511227ndash1231
19 Arabi YM Harthi A Hussein J et al Severe neurologic syndrome associated withMiddle East respiratory syndrome corona virus (MERS-CoV) Infection 201543495ndash501
20 Guo T Fan Y ChenM et al Cardiovascular implications of fatal outcomes of patientswith coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) JAMA Cardiol Epub 2020 Mar 27
21 Helms J Tacquard C Severac F et al High risk of thrombosis in patients in severeSARS-CoV-2 infection a multicenter prospective cohort study Intensive Care Med2020461089ndash1098
22 NagelMAMahalingamRCohrs RJ GildenD Virus vasculopathy and stroke an under-recognized cause and treatment target Infect Disord Drug Targets 201010105ndash111
23 Subramaniam S Scharrer I Procoagulant activity during viral infections Front Biosci(Landmark Ed) 2018231060ndash1081
24 Hung EC Chim SS Chan PK et al Detection of SARS coronavirus RNA in thecerebrospinal fluid of a patient with severe acute respiratory syndrome Clin Chem2003492108ndash2109
25 Lau KK Yu WC Chu CM Lau ST Sheng B Yuen KY Possible central nervoussystem infection by SARS coronavirus Emerg Infect Dis 200410342ndash344
26 Toledano M Davies NWS Infectious encephalitis mimics and chameleons PractNeurol 201919225ndash237
27 Kim JE Heo JH Kim HO et al Neurological complications during treatment ofMiddle East respiratory syndrome J Clin Neurol 201713227ndash233
28 Li Y Li H Fan R et al Coronavirus infections in the central nervous system andrespiratory tract show distinct features in hospitalized children Intervirology 201659163ndash169
29 Yeh EA Collins A Cohen ME Duffner PK Faden H Detection of coronavirus in thecentral nervous system of a child with acute disseminated encephalomyelitis Pedi-atrics 2004113(pt 1)e73ndashe76
30 Kivisakk P Imitola J Rasmussen S et al Localizing central nervous system immunesurveillance meningeal antigen-presenting cells activate T cells during experimentalautoimmune encephalomyelitis Ann Neurol 200965457ndash469
31 Absinta M Cortese IC Vuolo L et al Leptomeningeal gadolinium enhancementacross the spectrum of chronic neuroinflammatory diseases Neurology 2017881439ndash1444
32 Papatsiros VG Stylianaki I Papakonstantinou G Papaioannou N Christodoulo-poulos G Case report of transmissible gastroenteritis coronavirus infection associatedwith small intestine and brain lesions in piglets Viral Immunol 20193263ndash67
33 Stuckey SL Goh TD Heffernan T Rowan D Hyperintensity in the subarachnoidspace on FLAIR MRI AJR Am J Roentgenol 2007189913ndash921
34 Parpia AS Li Y Chen C Dhar B Crowcroft NS Encephalitis Ontario Canada 2002-2013 Emerg Infect Dis 201622426ndash432
e1882 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
DOI 101212WNL0000000000010112202095e1868-e1882 Published Online before print July 17 2020Neurology
Steacutephane Kremer Franccedilois Lersy Mathieu Anheim et al multicenter study
Neurologic and neuroimaging findings in patients with COVID-19 A retrospective
This information is current as of July 17 2020
ServicesUpdated Information amp
httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullincluding high resolution figures can be found at
References httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullref-list-1
This article cites 30 articles 6 of which you can access for free at
Citations httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullotherarticles
This article has been cited by 3 HighWire-hosted articles
Subspecialty Collections
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmriMRI
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmeningitisMeningitis
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionencephalitisEncephalitis e
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_cerebrovascular_disease_strokAll Cerebrovascular diseaseStrokefollowing collection(s) This article along with others on similar topics appears in the
Permissions amp Licensing
httpwwwneurologyorgaboutabout_the_journalpermissionsits entirety can be found online atInformation about reproducing this article in parts (figurestables) or in
Reprints
httpnneurologyorgsubscribersadvertiseInformation about ordering reprints can be found online
rights reserved Print ISSN 0028-3878 Online ISSN 1526-632X1951 it is now a weekly with 48 issues per year Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology All
reg is the official journal of the American Academy of Neurology Published continuously sinceNeurology
![Page 3: Neurologicandneuroimaging findingsinpatients with COVID-19 · enhancement (17%), and encephalitis (13%) were the most frequent neuroimaging findings. Confusion (53%) was the most](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060813/6091b284d4b0681e5152b42b/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
susceptibility-weighted imaging 2D or 3D fluid-attenuatedinversion recovery (FLAIR) postcontrast and 3D time-of-flight magnetic resonance angiography of the circle of Willis
Brain MRI readingAfter anonymization images were presented to readers withour GE Picture Archiving and Communication System(General Electric Milwaukee WI) Two neuroradiologists(SK and FL with 20 and 9 years of experience in neuro-radiology respectively) who were blinded to all patient dataindependently reviewed all brain MRIs The final diagnosiswas determined by consensus and if consensus could not bereached a third neuroradiologist (SB with 9 years of expe-rience in neuroradiology) was questioned
Neuroimaging abnormalities were divided into 3 groupsischemic stroke encephalitis and LME Ischemic strokeswere classified into large artery infarctions watershed cere-bral infarctions lacunar infarctions and hypoxic-ischemicinjuries Encephalitis was ranked as limbic encephalitis cy-totoxic lesion of the corpus callosum (CLOCC) radiologicacute disseminated encephalomyelitis (ADEM) radiologicacute hemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy and mis-cellaneous encephalitis
Encephalitis was defined as brain parenchymal abnormalFLAIR hyperintensity involving gray matter (GM) whitematter or basal ganglia with variable enhancement localizedmainly in medial temporal and inferior frontal lobes in case oflimbic encephalitis The term CLOCC has been proposed re-cently to describe a clinicoradiologic syndrome characterizedby a transient mild encephalopathy and a reversible lesion ofthe corpus callosum localized mainly to the central part of thesplenium onMRI CLOCCs are the consequence of numerousetiologies the 2 most frequent being antiepileptic drug with-drawal and infections They are related to a cytokine increaseinducing glutamate elevation in the extracellular space leadingto a dysfunction of callosal neurons and microglia with in-tracellular water influx resulting in cytotoxic edema15
ADEM is an autoimmune-mediated disease occurring afterviral infections and vaccinations Multifocal demyelinatinglesions involving white matter but also GM (basal ganglia) areseen with variable enhancement Acute hemorrhagic necro-tizing encephalopathy is a fulminant inflammatory de-myelinating disease which is considered the most severe formof ADEM associated with hemorrhagic lesions
A brain MRI without acute significative abnormalities orshowing lesions unrelated to SARS-CoV-2 was considerednormal
Statistical analysisData were described with frequency and proportion (numberpercent) for categorical variables and mean median andrange for quantitative data Categorical data were comparedwith the Fisher exact test Quantitative data were compared
with analysis of variance Multiple correspondence analysis(MCA) was used to give a simultaneous multivariate de-scription of clinical and radiologic characteristics of all di-agnostic groups MCA plots display results either for thesubjects or for their characteristics Those plots are to beinterpreted on the basis of the proximity of the data points 2subjects who are close on a plot share a common pattern ofsymptoms and 2 clinical symptoms that are close on a plotdescribe similar types of subjects Ellipses are drawn aroundthe mean position of each characteristic such that non-overlapping ellipses can be considered to show a contrastbetween the subjects who share 1 or the other characteristic
Computations were made with 353 through R-Studio withthe readxl and FactoMineR packages (R Foundation forStatistical Computing Vienna Austria) A value of p lt 005was considered significant
Standard protocol approvals registrationsand patient consentsThe study was approved by the ethics standards committeeon human experimentation of Strasbourg University Hos-pital (CE-2020-37) and was in accordance with the 1964Declaration of Helsinki and its later amendments Due to theemergency in the context of COVID-19 pandemic responsiblefor acute respiratory and neurologic manifestations pandemicthe requirement for patientsrsquo written informed consent waswaived
The study has been registered in ClinicalTrialsgov(NCT04368390)
Data availabilityWe state that the data published are available and anonymizedand will be shared on request by email to the correspondingauthor from any qualified investigator for purposes of repli-cating procedures and results
ResultsA total of 68 patients with COVID-19 were included in thismulticenter study Among them 4 were excluded becausetheir brain MRIs were considered noncontributory
Clinical characteristicsThe demographic and clinical characteristics of the 64patients and their neurologic manifestations are summarizedin tables 1 through 3 The most frequent neurologic mani-festations were confusionagitationalteration of conscious-ness corticospinal tract signs and headache
Complementary data concerning patients with COVID-19with acute ischemic stroke are given in table 2 including riskfactors clinical presentation echocardiography and ECGresults neuroimaging description and D-dimer serum levelFurther information related to patients with COVID-19 withmeningoencephalitis is given in table 3
e1870 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
Neuroimaging findingsAmong the 64MRIs included 41 (64) were performed withgadolinium-based contrast agent administration Thirty-onehad a postcontrast FLAIR and 18 had a delayed postcontrastFLAIR The latter was achieved asymp10 minutes after the in-jection after the realization of conventional postcontrastFLAIR and enhanced T1-weighted imaging Thirty-six (56)brain MRIs were considered abnormal possibly related toSARS-CoV-2
Ischemic strokes (27) (figure e-1 available from Dryaddoiorg105061dryadw9ghx3fm7) LME (17) (figure 1)and encephalitis (13) (figures 2 and 3 and figure e-2 availablefrom Dryad) were the most frequent neuroimaging findingsLME was seen on both postcontrast T1-weighted and FLAIRsequences and was even better visualized when delayed post-contrast FLAIR was performed These signal abnormalitieswere not present on precontrast T1 or FLAIR images
Among the 8 encephalitis 2 cases of limbic encephalitis2 cases of radiologic acute hemorrhagic necrotizing encepha-lopathy 2 cases of miscellaneous encephalitis 1 case of radio-logic ADEM and 1 case of CLOCC were described
CSF analysisTwenty-five (39) patients underwent a lumbar puncture 7in the encephalitis group 8 in the LME group 2 in the is-chemic stroke group and 8 in the normal brain MRI group
CSF glucose was normal in all cases
In the encephalitis group (table 3) 6 patients showedmarkersof inflammation 4 had pleocytosis 5 had high levels of pro-tein 2 had elevated immunoglobulin G and another hadoligoclonal bands that were identical in CSF and serum In theLME group (table 3) 6 patients showed markers of in-flammation 2 had pleocytosis 3 had high levels of protein 2
Table 1 History neurologic manifestations and clinical characteristics of the cohort
All patients(n = 64)
Ischemic stroke(n = 17)
Encephalitis(n = 8)
LME(n = 11) p Value
Sex n () 028
Men 43 (67) 11 (65) 7 (88) 5 (46)
Women 21 (33) 6 (35) 1 (12) 6 (54)
Age y 0007
Mean 65 75 61 66
Median 66 75 59 64
Range 20ndash92 59ndash92 55ndash71 51ndash81
History of stroke n () 7 (11) 4 (24) 0 1 (9) 036
History of seizures n () 3 (5) 1 (6) 0 0 1
Another neurologic history n () 9 (14) 2 (12) 0 0 017
History of autoimmune diseases n () 7 (11) 3 (18) 0 1 (9) 083
History of hematologic malignancies n () 4 (6) 1 (6) 0 1 (9) 1
Headaches n () 10 (16) 3 (18) 2 (25) 1 (9) 085
Seizures n () 1 (2) 0 0 0 1
Anosmia n () 2 (3) 1 (6) 0 1 (9) 031
Ageusia n () 4 (6) 0 1 (13) 1 (9) 045
Clinical signs of corticospinal tract involvement n () 20 (31) 10 (59) 1 (13) 4 (36) 002
Disturbance of consciousness n () 25 (39) 3 (18) 4 (50) 6 (55) 015
Confusion n () 34 (53) 7 (41) 3 (38) 6 (55) 034
Agitation n () 20 (31) 1 (6) 3 (38) 7 (64) 0009
Oxygen therapy n () 53 (83) 13 (76) 8 (100) 10 (91) 052
ARDS n () 33 (52) 3 (18) 6 (75) 8 (73) 0006
Death n () 7 (11) 2 (12) 2 (25) 0 038
Abbreviations ARDS = acute respiratory distress syndrome LME = leptomeningeal enhancement
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1871
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
Table 2 Characteristics of patients with COVID-19 with acute ischemic stroke
Sex Age y Risk factors Clinical presentation
Days from COVID-19respiratory symptomonset to ischemicstroke symptom onset
Treatment up tothis time point
Arrhythmias (ECGor echocardiography)
BrainMRI
Large vesselocclusion
D-dimers(reference range lt400) μgL
M 86 HypertensionDyslipidemia
Left hemiplegiaimpairedconsciousness
1 Supportive No LAI Distal M1 occlusionwith thrombus
NR
M 71 HypertensionDiabetesmellitus
Left hemiplegia 16 Antibiotics Yes (previouslyunknown)
LAI Distal M1 occlusionwith thrombus
2860
F 74 mdash Bilateral pyramidal tract signs 8 AntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
No WCI mdash gt20000
M 63 Smoking Left-sided weaknessleft-sidedsensory inattention
14 Antibiotics Yes (previouslyunknown)
LAI mdash 1000
M 65 HypertensionDiabetesmellitusDyslipidemiaHOS
Impaired consciousness 22 Antibiotics No WCI mdash 1570
F 78 Hypertension Dysarthria 3 Supportive No WCI mdash 720
F 75 HypertensionDyslipidemiaAtrial Fibrillation
Aphasiaright hemiplegiaimpaired consciousnessagitation
6 Supportive NR LAI ICA occlusion NR
M 79 HypertensionDyslipidemiaHOS
Headachesimpairedconsciousnessconfusion
5 Supportive No WCI mdash NR
F 71 HypertensionSmokingAtrial fibrillation
Left hemiplegia 3 Supportive Yes LAI Proximal M2occlusion
gt20000
M 59 HypertensionSmoking
Left hemiplegialeft facial droop 1 Supportive No LAI Proximal M1occlusion withthrombus
2868
M 66 HypertensionDyslipidemiaDiabetesmellitus
Left pyramidal tract signsleftfacial droopaphasia
4 Supportive No LAI ICA dissection 5227
M 72 DyslipidemiaAtrial fibrillation
Impaired consciousness 15 Antibiotics Yes LAI mdash 993
M 78 Hypertension Dysarthriaright-sidedweaknessright facial droop
16 Supportive No LAI mdash NR
Continued
e1872Neu
rology
|Vo
lume95N
umber
13|
Septem
ber
292020NeurologyorgN
Copyright
copy2020
American
Academ
yof
Neurology
Unauthorized
reproductionof
thisarticle
isprohibited
had elevated immunoglobulin G and 4 had oligoclonal bandsthat were identical in CSF and serum In the ischemic strokegroup 1 patient had a high level of protein
The RT-PCR SARS-CoV-2 analysis was negative in the 20patients who were investigated The analysis was not realizedfor 5 patients 1 with a normal brain MRI 2 with an ischemicstroke 1 with encephalitis and 1 with LME Cultures for otherviruses or bacteria were always negative when performed
Correlation analysisThere were statistically significant differences between thevarious groups concerning age (p = 0007) the presence ofpyramidal tract signs (p = 002) agitation (p = 0009) andrespiratory status (ARDS) (p = 0006) (table 1)
The MCA showed that the ischemic stroke group could bedistinguished from the 3 others which largely overlap (figure 4)Most patients with ischemic stroke (numbers and dots in redon the plot) are located on the same lower-right half of thegraph indicating a commonality of symptoms Those patientscan be overall described as older with no ARDS no oxygenrequirement no confusion no disturbances of consciousnessand a lower death rate The converse is true for the 3 otherdiagnoses that cannot be distinguished Considering eachclinical manifestation separately (figure e-3 available fromDryad doiorg105061dryadw9ghx3fm7) subjects can bedistinguishedmainly on the basis of a global pattern dependingon their oxygen requirement seizure sex headaches history ofautoimmune disease history of seizure age anosmia confu-sion and disturbances of consciousness
DiscussionThis is the first large nationwide cohort of MRIs performed inpatients with COVID-19 with neurologic manifestations
The majority of patients had MRI abnormalities with seriousand various findings beyond the severe respiratory disease(half of the patients had ARDS and 11 died) cerebrovas-cular disease (especially ischemic stroke large artery infarc-tions more frequently than watershed cerebral infarctions)encephalitis (including limbic encephalitis radiologic ADEMCLOCC and radiologic acute hemorrhagic necrotizing en-cephalopathy) and focal or even diffuse LME The hetero-geneity of the imaging abnormalities was underpinned byheterogeneous clinical manifestations ranging from anosmiaageusia or headache to more severe findings such as confu-sion with agitation loss of consciousness and corticospinaltract signs Some correlations were found between clinical andimaging findings allowing the identification of clinicoradio-logic profiles of patients with COVID-19 displaying neuro-logic manifestations
Ischemic stroke was 1 kind of clinicoradiologic phenotype itwas an acute event arising in older patients who more fre-quently had corticospinal tract signs but was less frequentlyTa
ble
2Charac
teristicsofpatients
withCOVID-19withac
ute
isch
emicstroke
(con
tinue
d)
Sex
Age
yRiskfactors
Clinicalpre
senta
tion
Days
from
COVID
-19
resp
irato
rysy
mpto
monse
tto
isch
emic
stro
kesy
mpto
monse
tTr
eatm
entupto
this
timepoint
Arrhythmias(ECG
orech
oca
rdiogr
aphy)
Bra
inMRI
Larg
eve
ssel
occ
lusion
D-dim
ers
(refere
nce
range
lt400
)μgL
M76
mdashConfusion
24Su
pportive
No
WCI
mdash397
7
F92
mdashConfusion
10Su
pportive
No
WCI
mdash98
7
F77
Hyp
ertension
HOS
Lefthem
iplegialeft
homonym
oushem
ianopia
hea
dac
hes
minus2(stroke
prece
ded
resp
iratory
symptoms
by2d)
mdashYe
s(previously
unkn
own)
LAI
P2occlusion
NR
M88
Hyp
ertension
Dyslip
idem
iaDiabetes
mellitus
Atrialfibrilla
tion
HOS
Righthem
iplegiaim
paired
consciousn
ess
minus2(stroke
prece
ded
resp
iratory
symptoms
by2d)
mdashYe
sLA
IProximal
M2
occlusion
NR
Abbreviations
COVID-19=co
ronav
irusdisea
se20
19H
OS=history
ofstroke
IC=intern
alca
rotidarteryL
AI=
largeartery
infarctionN
R=Notrealized
WCI=
watersh
edce
rebralinfarction
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1873
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
Table 3 Characteristics of patients with COVID-19 with meningoencephalitis
Sex Age y Clinical symptoms
Days from COVID-19respiratory symptomonset to brain MRI Treatment up to this time point CSF analysis Imaging findings
F 71 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
22 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
0 celluarr Total protein 057 gL
Miscellaneous encephalitisdiffusionand T2FLAIR hyperintensitiesinvolving supratentorial WM
M 64 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
17 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
40 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 11 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 56 mgL
Miscellaneous encephalitisFLAIRhyperintensity involving both middlecerebellar peduncles
M 56 Impaired consciousnesspathologic wakefulness whensedation was stopped
23 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
1 cellmm3
uarr Total protein 2 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 169 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Radiologic acute hemorrhagicnecrotizing encephalopathy
M 66 Impaired consciousnesspathologic wakefulness whensedation was stopped
34 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
NR Radiologic acute hemorrhagicnecrotizing encephalopathy
M 55 Headachesdizzinessimpairedconsciousness
3 mdash 7 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 056 gLCLOCC
M 56 Headaches 20 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
3 cellsmm3
Total protein 024 gLLeft limbic encephalitis
M 58 Ataxia 21 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
4 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 077 gLLeft limbic encephalitis
M 60 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
13 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
0 cellTotal protein 03 gL
Radiologic ADEM
F 51 Movement disordersagitation 16 mdash 5 cellsuarr Total protein 066 gL
Focal LME
F 59 Headachesdizziness 18 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
NR Focal LME
M 62 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
19 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
0 cellTotal protein 023 gLImmunoglobulin G 33 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Diffuse LME
Continued
e1874Neu
rology
|Vo
lume95N
umber
13|
Septem
ber
292020NeurologyorgN
Copyright
copy2020
American
Academ
yof
Neurology
Unauthorized
reproductionof
thisarticle
isprohibited
Table 3 Characteristics of patients with COVID-19 with meningoencephalitis (continued)
Sex Age y Clinical symptoms
Days from COVID-19respiratory symptomonset to brain MRI Treatment up to this time point CSF analysis Imaging findings
M 78 Agitation 15 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
NR Focal LME
M 72 Impaired consciousnessbilateralpyramidal tract signs
20 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavirHydroxychloroquine
0 cellTotal protein 023 gLImmunoglobulin G 17 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Focal LME
M 61 Impaired consciousnessbilateralpyramidal tract signsconfusionagitation
14 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
1 cellmm3
Total protein 023 gLImmunoglobulin G 17 mgL
Focal LME
M 66 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
22 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
NR Focal LME
F 53 Confusionimpairedconsciousness
29 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
0 cellTotal protein 029 gLImmunoglobulin G 21 mgL
Focal LME
F 64 Bilateral pyramidal tract signs 11 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
2 cellsmm3
Total protein 030 gLImmunoglobulin G 15 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Focal LME
F 77 Bilateral pyramidal syndromeconfusionagitation
30 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavirHydroxychloroquine
1 cellmm3
uarr Total protein 080 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 58 mgL
Diffuse LME
F 81 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
20 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
80 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 062 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 38 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Focal LME
Abbreviations ADEM = Acute disseminated encephalomyelitis CLOCC = cytotoxic lesion of the corpus callosum COVID-19 = coronavirus disease 2019 FLAIR = fluid-attenuated inversion recovery ICU = intensive care unitLME = leptomeningeal enhancement NR = not realized WM = white matter
Neurolo
gyorgN
Neurology
|Volum
e95N
umber
13|
Septem
ber292020
e1875
Copyright
copy2020
American
Academ
yof
Neurology
Unauthorized
reproductionof
thisarticle
isprohibited
requiring oxygen or presenting an ARDS This profile couldbe distinguished from the 2 others LME and encephalitisThe encephalitis profile affected younger patients and seemedto be particularly severe because it was associated with theneed for oxygen ARDS and death
Stroke patients less frequently had ARDS and this result is inagreement with the 6 patients with stroke previously reportedin that only 2 patients were admitted to ICUs16 One mayhypothesize that strokes in patients with COVID-19 could bedue to procoagulant events leading to thrombosis17 ratherthan to the systemic inflammatory process that accompaniesARDS which is also directed against the CNS However thisneeds to be assessed by further studies dedicated to stroke andthrombosis in patients with COVID-19
In our study 17 (27) patients had an acute ischemic strokeas was previously reported with SARS-CoV18 Middle Eastrespiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERS-CoV)19 andSARS-CoV-2111617 and among them 11 had large arteryinfarctions (including 6 proximal artery occlusions 2 cases ofinternal carotid artery dissection or occlusion) and 6 hadwatershed cerebral infarctions For 15 of 17 patients with anischemic stroke the respiratory symptoms related to COVID-19 had begun before this acute event while stroke precededrespiratory symptoms by 2 days for 2 patients
Several mechanisms are likely to be associated It is nowknown that SARS-CoV-2 could directly lead to myocardialinjury promoting cardiac arrhythmias associated with em-bolic events20 Six of our patients had arrhythmias which werepreviously unknown for 3 of them In the same way a severeacute myocardial injury may be associated with a decrease inbrain perfusion and therefore with watershed cerebralinfarctions As previously mentioned it is acknowledged thatviruses particularly SARS-CoV-221 are associated with anincrease of prothrombotic events such as ischemic stroke2223
Thereby viral infections may elevate procoagulant markersleading to thrombosis disseminated intravascular coagulationand hemorrhagic events23 As Beyrouti et al16 recently men-tioned all our patients tested showed elevated D-dimersmarkedly elevated (gt1000 μgL) for 10 of the 11 patientstested
Varicella zoster virus is also associated with direct vascularinvolvement and eventually arteritis promoting ischemicstroke events22 Furthermore the more severe critically illpatients hospitalized in ICUs have probably had hypoxemiaand hypotension leading to brain injuries18
Of the 36 abnormal MRIs 8 diagnoses of encephalitis weremade and LME was described especially on postcontrast T1-weighted and FLAIR in 11 patients either focal (single focus
Figure 1 Leptomeningeal enhancement
Axial T1 (A) before and (B) 5 minutes after contrast axial FLAIR (C) before and (D) immediately after contrast and (E and F) delayed (10 minutes) postcontrastaxial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) weighted MRIs Woman 77 years of age diffuse leptomeningeal linear FLAIR and T1 contrast enhancement(arrows) not visible on precontrast T1 and FLAIR (arrows) but seen better on delayed postcontrast FLAIR weighted MRIs (E and F)
e1876 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
vs multiple foci) or diffuse and preferentially located in theposterior supratentorial regions of the brain
Two main pathophysiologic hypotheses can be advanced toexplain the neuroimaging findings in the inflammatory profilegroup First SARS-CoV-2 may have a neuroinvasive potentialsimilar to other hCoVs because this family of viruses is relatedto each other genetically It is not clear if the virus can infiltratethe CNS with active replication and direct damage to braincells (viral encephalitis) as observed with other viruses suchas herpes simplex virus Likewise viral meningitis due to di-rect infiltration of the virus into the CSF may also be con-sidered because it was previously reported with SARS-CoV-1Indeed SARS-CoV-1 RNA was detected in the CSF of 2patients with seizures2425 A recent case report10 has de-scribed for the first time a case of seizures with the detection ofSARS-CoV-2 RNA in the CSF Similarly leptomeningealinflammation may be present adjacent to subpial corticallesions in the case of viral meningoencephalitis In the case ofviral encephalitis CSF analysis usually demonstrates lym-phocytic pleocytosis26 In addition the CSF protein level istypically elevated in viral encephalitis CSF viral RT-PCR isusually positive but can be negative if done too early This wasnot the case in our series and our results are in accordance
with recently published data that demonstrated an absence ofCSF pleocytosis and negative SARS-CoV-2 RT-PCR (5 of 5patients) but elevated protein level (4 of 5 patients) inpatients presenting cerebral MRI cortical abnormalities13
MRI pictures of viral encephalitis vary with causal pathogenNevertheless viral encephalitis usually involves cerebral GMwith diffusion restriction and can be associated with intrale-sional and diffuse leptomeningeal contrast enhancement Thiswas not the case in our series and did not argue for the directeffect of the virus It is all the more likely that the directdetection of SARS-CoV-2 RNA by RT-PCR was alwaysnegative in all our CSF samples
An alternative hypothesis appears more relevant the neuro-virulence of hCoVs especially MERS-CoV seems to bea consequence of immune-mediated processes1927ndash29 IndeedADEM and Bickerstaff brainstem encephalitis which weredescribed with MERS-CoV18ndash27 are 2 examples of autoim-mune demyelinating diseases resulting from a postinfectious orparainfectious process A recent case report9 has describeda case of acute hemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy (whichis the most severe form of ADEM) associated with COVID-19which strengthens the hypothesis of a predominant immuno-logic mechanism In our cohort we also described 2 cases of
Figure 2 Encephalitis
(A B D) Axial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) and(C) diffusion-weighted MRIs (A) Man 56 years of age lefthippocampus and amygdala FLAIR hyperintensity (B)Woman 71 years of age periventricular and subcorticalwhite matter FLAIR confluent hyperintensities (C) Man 55years of age corpus callosum splenium diffusion hyper-intensity (D) Man 64 years of age FLAIR middle cerebellarpeduncle hyperintensity
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1877
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
limbic encephalitis and 1 case of CLOCC Concerning thelatter no treatment had been started or stopped in previousweeks Thus 75 of encephalitis cases in our cohort (limbicencephalitis CLOCC radiologic ADEM radiologic acutehemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy) are possibly con-sidered immune-mediated diseases Therefore SARS-CoV-2ndashmediated disease is driven largely by immunologic processesand the same mechanisms could explain LME Indeed thearachnoid and pial membranes form the leptomeninges anda significant amount of antigen-presenting cells are present inthe subarachnoid space30 Thus initial immune activationoccurs in the subarachnoid space which is a site for antigenpresentation lymphocyte accumulation and proliferation andantibody production30 All lead to an important local in-flammatory infiltrate with a blood-CSF barrier disruptionwhich can also explain LME Thus LME can be linked toinflammatory or immunologic responses as previously de-scribed in animal models of autoimmune encephalomyelitis31
with some neurotropic viruses such as human T-cell leukemiavirus and HIV31 and in several immune-mediated neurologicdiseases31 Moreover a very similar intracranial pattern hasbeen described in an animal study in piglets affected by gas-troenteritis coronavirus32 Indeed histology demonstrateddiffuse pia matter gliosis with mild congestion of the meningeal
and parenchymal vessels with neuronal degeneration locatedmostly in posterior parietooccipital lobes24 PostcontrastFLAIR is the best sequence to highlight LME but a potentialpitfall is inhalation of increased levels of oxygen by patients whoare intubated which may increase subarachnoid space signalintensity noted on FLAIR images within the basal cisterns andsulcus along the cerebral convexities33 That is why we havechosen in this situation to acquire systematically precontrastand postcontrast FLAIR sequences to avoid misinterpretationof FLAIR hyperintensity within the subarachnoid spaces andnot to misdescribe a meningeal enhancement For our 11patients with LME no precontrast FLAIR signal abnormalitieswere visible in the subarachnoid spaces
Our study has several limitations mainly due to its multicenterand retrospective design First brain MRI protocols were dic-tated by clinical need and the patterns of working could bedifferent among the 11 centers even if neuroradiologists areused to work together Thus 36 of the MRIs were performedwithout administration of gadolinium-based contrast agentsnotably preventing the detection of LME therefore probablyunderestimating it Moreover LMEs are very subtle neuro-imaging findings which need the realization of delayed post-contrast FLAIR sequences which were not done in the vast
Figure 3 Radiologic acute disseminated encephalomyelitis
(A E I) Axial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) (B F J) axial diffusion (B F J) apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC) map and (D H L) postcontrast T1-weighted MRIs Man 60 years of age subcortical periventricular corpus callosum and posterior fossa white matter FLAIR hyperintensities without contrastenhancement (arrows) Some lesions appear hyperintense on diffusion-weightedMRIs with decreased ADC corresponding to cytotoxic edema (stars) Otherlesions present an ADC increase corresponding to vasogenic edema (cross)
e1878 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
majority of the centers Second we did not realize a follow-upMRI and some abnormalities could have appeared duringfollow-up Third outcomes were not available for all patients atthe time of writing Thus the mortality rate is probablyunderestimated in our cohort Fourth although patients withCOVID-19may develop a wide range of neurologic symptomswhich can be associated with ischemic stroke or encephalitis itis difficult to state without a controlled general neurologicpopulation that such events are more frequent in patients withCOVID-19 However it now seems well established thatthrombotic events are particularly frequent in patients withCOVID-1921 Moreover encephalitis which is a rare disorderin the general population34 was surprisingly frequent in ourpopulation
In this large multicentric national cohort most patients withCOVID-19 (56) with neurologic manifestations had brainMRI abnormalities such as ischemic stroke LME and enceph-alitis Because the detection of LME suggests the abnormality ofbrain MRI it would be interesting to realize systematicallypostcontrast FLAIR acquisition in patients with COVID-19
Concerning the cases of encephalitis and LME even if a directviral origin cannot be eliminated the pathophysiology of braindamage related to SARS-COV-2 seems rather to involve aninflammatory or autoimmune response The knowledge ofthe various clinicoradiologic manifestations of COVID-19could be helpful for the best care of the patients and ourunderstanding of the disease In addition to SARS cytokine
Figure 4 Multiple correspondence analysis
The ischemic stroke group (red) can be distinguished from the 3 others which largely overlapMost patients with ischemic stroke (numbers and dots in red onthe plot) are located on the same lower-right half of the graph indicating a commonality of symptoms Diag 1 (black) = normal brain MRI Diag 2 (red) =ischemic stroke Diag 3 (green) = encephalitis Diag 4 (blue) = leptomeningeal enhancement
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1879
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
storm syndrome and heart failure brain injuries may con-tribute to increased mortality This highlights the importanceof neurologic evaluation especially for patients hospitalized inICU with clinical deterioration or worsening of their symp-toms which can be associated with an acute neurologic event
AcknowledgmentThe authors thank Marie Cecile Henry Feugeas for her workin data acquisition for this study
Study fundingNo targeted funding reported
DisclosureThe authors report no disclosures relevant to the manuscriptGo to NeurologyorgN for full disclosures
Publication historyReceived by Neurology April 28 2020 Accepted in final formJune 9 2020
Appendix Authors
Name Location Contribution
StephaneKremer MDPhD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study acquisition of datainterpreted the data draftedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Franccedilois LersyMD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study acquisition of datainterpreted the data draftedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MathieuAnheim MDPhD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
Hamid MerdjiMD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MalekaSchenck MD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
HeleneOesterle MD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FedericoBolognini MD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Julien MessieMD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Antoine KhalilMD PhD
Bichat Hospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
AugustinGaudemer MD
Bichat Hospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Sophie CarreMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Manel AllegMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Claire LecocqMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
EmmanuelleSchmitt MD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ReneAnxionnatMD PhD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Franccedilois ZhuMD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Lavinia JagerMD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Patrick NesserMD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Yannick TallaMba MD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GhaziHmeydia MD
Saint-Anne hospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
JosephBenzakounMD
Saint-Anne hospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
CatherineOppenheimMD PhD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jean-ChristopheFerre MD PhD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Adel MaamarMD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
BeatriceCarsin-NicolMD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Pierre-OlivierComby MD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FredericRicolfi MDPhD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
PierreThouant MD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Claire BoutetMD PhD
University hospital ofSaint-Etienne France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
e1880 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
References1 Chen N Zhou M Dong X et al Epidemiological and clinical characteristics of 99
cases of 2019 novel coronavirus pneumonia in Wuhan China a descriptive studyLancet 2020395507ndash513
2 Huang C Wang Y Li X et al Clinical features of patients infected with 2019 novelcoronavirus in Wuhan China Lancet 2020395497ndash506
3 Glass WG Subbarao K Murphy B Murphy PM Mechanisms of host defense fol-lowing severe acute respiratory syndrome‐coronavirus (SARS‐CoV) pulmonary in-fection of mice J Immunol 20041734030ndash4039
4 Li K Wohlford‐Lenane C Perlman S et al Middle East respiratory syndromecoronavirus causes multiple organ damage and lethal disease in mice transgenic forhuman dipeptidyl peptidase 4 J Infect Dis 2016213712ndash722
5 Arbour N Day R Newcombe J Talbot PJ Neuroinvasion by human respiratorycoronaviruses J Virol 2000748913ndash8921
6 Desforges M Le Coupanec A Stodola JK Meessen-Pinard M Talbot PJ Humancoronaviruses viral and cellular factors involved in neuroinvasiveness and neuro-pathogenesis Virus Res 2014194145ndash158
7 Desforges M Le Coupanec A Dubeau P et al Human coronaviruses and otherrespiratory viruses underestimated opportunistic pathogens of the central nervoussystem Viruses 201912E14
8 Bohmwald K Galvez NMS Rıos M Kalergis AM Neurologic alterations due torespiratory virus infections Front Cell Neurosci 201812386
9 Poyiadji N Shahin G Noujaim D Stone M Patel S Griffith B COVID-19-associatedacute hemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy CT and MRI features Radiology2020201187
10 Moriguchi T Harii N Goto J et al A first case of meningitisencephalitis associatedwith SARS-coronavirus-2 Int J Infect Dis 20209455ndash58
11 Mao L Jin H Wang M et al Neurologic manifestations of hospitalized patients withcoronavirus disease 2019 in Wuhan China JAMA Neurol 2020771ndash9
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Xavier FabreMD
Hospital of RoanneFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GeraudForestier MD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Isaure deBeaurepaireMD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GregoireBornet MD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Hubert DesalMD PhD
University Hospital ofNantes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GregoireBoulouis MD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jerome BergeMD
University Hospital ofBordeaux France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ApollineKazemi MD
University Hospital ofLille France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
NadyaPyatigorskayaMD
Pitie-SalpetriereHospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
AugustinLecler MD
Foundation ARothschild Paris
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
SuzanaSaleme MD
University Hospital ofLimoges France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Myriam Edjlali-Goujon MD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
BasileKerleroux MD
University Hospital ofTours France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jean-MarcConstans MDPhD
University Hospital ofAmiens France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Pierre-EmmanuelZorn PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the acquisitionof data
MurielMatthieu PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the acquisitionof data
Seyyid BalogluMD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of datarevised the manuscriptfor intellectualcontent
Franccedilois-DanielArdellier MD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ThibaultWillaume MD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of datarevised the manuscriptfor intellectualcontent
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Jean-ChristopheBrisset PhD
French Observatoryof Multiple SclerosisLyon France
Interpretation of the datarevised the manuscript forintellectual content
SophieCaillard MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
OlivierCollange MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Paul MichelMertes MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FrancisSchneider MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Samira Fafi-KremerPharmD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MickaelOhana MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FerhatMeziani MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Nicolas MeyerMD PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the analysis andinterpretation of the data
Julie HelmsMD PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
FranccediloisCotton MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1881
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
12 Helms J Kremer S Merdji H et al Neurologic features in severe SARS-CoV-2infection N Engl J Med 20203822268ndash2270
13 Kandemirli SG Dogan L Sarikaya ZT et al Brain MRI findings in patients in theintensive care unit with COVID-19 infection Radiology Epub 2020 May 8
14 Ferguson ND Fan E Camporota L et al The Berlin definition of ARDS an expandedrationale justification and supplementary material Intensive Care Med 2012381573ndash1582
15 Starkey J Kobayashi N Numaguchi Y Moritani T Cytotoxic lesions of the corpuscallosum that show restricted diffusion mechanisms causes and manifestationsRadiographics 201737562ndash576
16 Beyrouti R Adams ME Benjamin L et al Characteristics of ischaemic stroke asso-ciated with COVID-19 J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry Epub 2020 Apr 30
17 Hess DC Eldahshan W Rutkowski E COVID-19-related stroke Transl Stroke Res202011322ndash325
18 Umapathi T Kor AC Venketasubramanian N et al Large artery ischaemic stroke insevere acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) J Neurol 20042511227ndash1231
19 Arabi YM Harthi A Hussein J et al Severe neurologic syndrome associated withMiddle East respiratory syndrome corona virus (MERS-CoV) Infection 201543495ndash501
20 Guo T Fan Y ChenM et al Cardiovascular implications of fatal outcomes of patientswith coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) JAMA Cardiol Epub 2020 Mar 27
21 Helms J Tacquard C Severac F et al High risk of thrombosis in patients in severeSARS-CoV-2 infection a multicenter prospective cohort study Intensive Care Med2020461089ndash1098
22 NagelMAMahalingamRCohrs RJ GildenD Virus vasculopathy and stroke an under-recognized cause and treatment target Infect Disord Drug Targets 201010105ndash111
23 Subramaniam S Scharrer I Procoagulant activity during viral infections Front Biosci(Landmark Ed) 2018231060ndash1081
24 Hung EC Chim SS Chan PK et al Detection of SARS coronavirus RNA in thecerebrospinal fluid of a patient with severe acute respiratory syndrome Clin Chem2003492108ndash2109
25 Lau KK Yu WC Chu CM Lau ST Sheng B Yuen KY Possible central nervoussystem infection by SARS coronavirus Emerg Infect Dis 200410342ndash344
26 Toledano M Davies NWS Infectious encephalitis mimics and chameleons PractNeurol 201919225ndash237
27 Kim JE Heo JH Kim HO et al Neurological complications during treatment ofMiddle East respiratory syndrome J Clin Neurol 201713227ndash233
28 Li Y Li H Fan R et al Coronavirus infections in the central nervous system andrespiratory tract show distinct features in hospitalized children Intervirology 201659163ndash169
29 Yeh EA Collins A Cohen ME Duffner PK Faden H Detection of coronavirus in thecentral nervous system of a child with acute disseminated encephalomyelitis Pedi-atrics 2004113(pt 1)e73ndashe76
30 Kivisakk P Imitola J Rasmussen S et al Localizing central nervous system immunesurveillance meningeal antigen-presenting cells activate T cells during experimentalautoimmune encephalomyelitis Ann Neurol 200965457ndash469
31 Absinta M Cortese IC Vuolo L et al Leptomeningeal gadolinium enhancementacross the spectrum of chronic neuroinflammatory diseases Neurology 2017881439ndash1444
32 Papatsiros VG Stylianaki I Papakonstantinou G Papaioannou N Christodoulo-poulos G Case report of transmissible gastroenteritis coronavirus infection associatedwith small intestine and brain lesions in piglets Viral Immunol 20193263ndash67
33 Stuckey SL Goh TD Heffernan T Rowan D Hyperintensity in the subarachnoidspace on FLAIR MRI AJR Am J Roentgenol 2007189913ndash921
34 Parpia AS Li Y Chen C Dhar B Crowcroft NS Encephalitis Ontario Canada 2002-2013 Emerg Infect Dis 201622426ndash432
e1882 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
DOI 101212WNL0000000000010112202095e1868-e1882 Published Online before print July 17 2020Neurology
Steacutephane Kremer Franccedilois Lersy Mathieu Anheim et al multicenter study
Neurologic and neuroimaging findings in patients with COVID-19 A retrospective
This information is current as of July 17 2020
ServicesUpdated Information amp
httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullincluding high resolution figures can be found at
References httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullref-list-1
This article cites 30 articles 6 of which you can access for free at
Citations httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullotherarticles
This article has been cited by 3 HighWire-hosted articles
Subspecialty Collections
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmriMRI
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmeningitisMeningitis
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionencephalitisEncephalitis e
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_cerebrovascular_disease_strokAll Cerebrovascular diseaseStrokefollowing collection(s) This article along with others on similar topics appears in the
Permissions amp Licensing
httpwwwneurologyorgaboutabout_the_journalpermissionsits entirety can be found online atInformation about reproducing this article in parts (figurestables) or in
Reprints
httpnneurologyorgsubscribersadvertiseInformation about ordering reprints can be found online
rights reserved Print ISSN 0028-3878 Online ISSN 1526-632X1951 it is now a weekly with 48 issues per year Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology All
reg is the official journal of the American Academy of Neurology Published continuously sinceNeurology
![Page 4: Neurologicandneuroimaging findingsinpatients with COVID-19 · enhancement (17%), and encephalitis (13%) were the most frequent neuroimaging findings. Confusion (53%) was the most](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060813/6091b284d4b0681e5152b42b/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Neuroimaging findingsAmong the 64MRIs included 41 (64) were performed withgadolinium-based contrast agent administration Thirty-onehad a postcontrast FLAIR and 18 had a delayed postcontrastFLAIR The latter was achieved asymp10 minutes after the in-jection after the realization of conventional postcontrastFLAIR and enhanced T1-weighted imaging Thirty-six (56)brain MRIs were considered abnormal possibly related toSARS-CoV-2
Ischemic strokes (27) (figure e-1 available from Dryaddoiorg105061dryadw9ghx3fm7) LME (17) (figure 1)and encephalitis (13) (figures 2 and 3 and figure e-2 availablefrom Dryad) were the most frequent neuroimaging findingsLME was seen on both postcontrast T1-weighted and FLAIRsequences and was even better visualized when delayed post-contrast FLAIR was performed These signal abnormalitieswere not present on precontrast T1 or FLAIR images
Among the 8 encephalitis 2 cases of limbic encephalitis2 cases of radiologic acute hemorrhagic necrotizing encepha-lopathy 2 cases of miscellaneous encephalitis 1 case of radio-logic ADEM and 1 case of CLOCC were described
CSF analysisTwenty-five (39) patients underwent a lumbar puncture 7in the encephalitis group 8 in the LME group 2 in the is-chemic stroke group and 8 in the normal brain MRI group
CSF glucose was normal in all cases
In the encephalitis group (table 3) 6 patients showedmarkersof inflammation 4 had pleocytosis 5 had high levels of pro-tein 2 had elevated immunoglobulin G and another hadoligoclonal bands that were identical in CSF and serum In theLME group (table 3) 6 patients showed markers of in-flammation 2 had pleocytosis 3 had high levels of protein 2
Table 1 History neurologic manifestations and clinical characteristics of the cohort
All patients(n = 64)
Ischemic stroke(n = 17)
Encephalitis(n = 8)
LME(n = 11) p Value
Sex n () 028
Men 43 (67) 11 (65) 7 (88) 5 (46)
Women 21 (33) 6 (35) 1 (12) 6 (54)
Age y 0007
Mean 65 75 61 66
Median 66 75 59 64
Range 20ndash92 59ndash92 55ndash71 51ndash81
History of stroke n () 7 (11) 4 (24) 0 1 (9) 036
History of seizures n () 3 (5) 1 (6) 0 0 1
Another neurologic history n () 9 (14) 2 (12) 0 0 017
History of autoimmune diseases n () 7 (11) 3 (18) 0 1 (9) 083
History of hematologic malignancies n () 4 (6) 1 (6) 0 1 (9) 1
Headaches n () 10 (16) 3 (18) 2 (25) 1 (9) 085
Seizures n () 1 (2) 0 0 0 1
Anosmia n () 2 (3) 1 (6) 0 1 (9) 031
Ageusia n () 4 (6) 0 1 (13) 1 (9) 045
Clinical signs of corticospinal tract involvement n () 20 (31) 10 (59) 1 (13) 4 (36) 002
Disturbance of consciousness n () 25 (39) 3 (18) 4 (50) 6 (55) 015
Confusion n () 34 (53) 7 (41) 3 (38) 6 (55) 034
Agitation n () 20 (31) 1 (6) 3 (38) 7 (64) 0009
Oxygen therapy n () 53 (83) 13 (76) 8 (100) 10 (91) 052
ARDS n () 33 (52) 3 (18) 6 (75) 8 (73) 0006
Death n () 7 (11) 2 (12) 2 (25) 0 038
Abbreviations ARDS = acute respiratory distress syndrome LME = leptomeningeal enhancement
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1871
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
Table 2 Characteristics of patients with COVID-19 with acute ischemic stroke
Sex Age y Risk factors Clinical presentation
Days from COVID-19respiratory symptomonset to ischemicstroke symptom onset
Treatment up tothis time point
Arrhythmias (ECGor echocardiography)
BrainMRI
Large vesselocclusion
D-dimers(reference range lt400) μgL
M 86 HypertensionDyslipidemia
Left hemiplegiaimpairedconsciousness
1 Supportive No LAI Distal M1 occlusionwith thrombus
NR
M 71 HypertensionDiabetesmellitus
Left hemiplegia 16 Antibiotics Yes (previouslyunknown)
LAI Distal M1 occlusionwith thrombus
2860
F 74 mdash Bilateral pyramidal tract signs 8 AntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
No WCI mdash gt20000
M 63 Smoking Left-sided weaknessleft-sidedsensory inattention
14 Antibiotics Yes (previouslyunknown)
LAI mdash 1000
M 65 HypertensionDiabetesmellitusDyslipidemiaHOS
Impaired consciousness 22 Antibiotics No WCI mdash 1570
F 78 Hypertension Dysarthria 3 Supportive No WCI mdash 720
F 75 HypertensionDyslipidemiaAtrial Fibrillation
Aphasiaright hemiplegiaimpaired consciousnessagitation
6 Supportive NR LAI ICA occlusion NR
M 79 HypertensionDyslipidemiaHOS
Headachesimpairedconsciousnessconfusion
5 Supportive No WCI mdash NR
F 71 HypertensionSmokingAtrial fibrillation
Left hemiplegia 3 Supportive Yes LAI Proximal M2occlusion
gt20000
M 59 HypertensionSmoking
Left hemiplegialeft facial droop 1 Supportive No LAI Proximal M1occlusion withthrombus
2868
M 66 HypertensionDyslipidemiaDiabetesmellitus
Left pyramidal tract signsleftfacial droopaphasia
4 Supportive No LAI ICA dissection 5227
M 72 DyslipidemiaAtrial fibrillation
Impaired consciousness 15 Antibiotics Yes LAI mdash 993
M 78 Hypertension Dysarthriaright-sidedweaknessright facial droop
16 Supportive No LAI mdash NR
Continued
e1872Neu
rology
|Vo
lume95N
umber
13|
Septem
ber
292020NeurologyorgN
Copyright
copy2020
American
Academ
yof
Neurology
Unauthorized
reproductionof
thisarticle
isprohibited
had elevated immunoglobulin G and 4 had oligoclonal bandsthat were identical in CSF and serum In the ischemic strokegroup 1 patient had a high level of protein
The RT-PCR SARS-CoV-2 analysis was negative in the 20patients who were investigated The analysis was not realizedfor 5 patients 1 with a normal brain MRI 2 with an ischemicstroke 1 with encephalitis and 1 with LME Cultures for otherviruses or bacteria were always negative when performed
Correlation analysisThere were statistically significant differences between thevarious groups concerning age (p = 0007) the presence ofpyramidal tract signs (p = 002) agitation (p = 0009) andrespiratory status (ARDS) (p = 0006) (table 1)
The MCA showed that the ischemic stroke group could bedistinguished from the 3 others which largely overlap (figure 4)Most patients with ischemic stroke (numbers and dots in redon the plot) are located on the same lower-right half of thegraph indicating a commonality of symptoms Those patientscan be overall described as older with no ARDS no oxygenrequirement no confusion no disturbances of consciousnessand a lower death rate The converse is true for the 3 otherdiagnoses that cannot be distinguished Considering eachclinical manifestation separately (figure e-3 available fromDryad doiorg105061dryadw9ghx3fm7) subjects can bedistinguishedmainly on the basis of a global pattern dependingon their oxygen requirement seizure sex headaches history ofautoimmune disease history of seizure age anosmia confu-sion and disturbances of consciousness
DiscussionThis is the first large nationwide cohort of MRIs performed inpatients with COVID-19 with neurologic manifestations
The majority of patients had MRI abnormalities with seriousand various findings beyond the severe respiratory disease(half of the patients had ARDS and 11 died) cerebrovas-cular disease (especially ischemic stroke large artery infarc-tions more frequently than watershed cerebral infarctions)encephalitis (including limbic encephalitis radiologic ADEMCLOCC and radiologic acute hemorrhagic necrotizing en-cephalopathy) and focal or even diffuse LME The hetero-geneity of the imaging abnormalities was underpinned byheterogeneous clinical manifestations ranging from anosmiaageusia or headache to more severe findings such as confu-sion with agitation loss of consciousness and corticospinaltract signs Some correlations were found between clinical andimaging findings allowing the identification of clinicoradio-logic profiles of patients with COVID-19 displaying neuro-logic manifestations
Ischemic stroke was 1 kind of clinicoradiologic phenotype itwas an acute event arising in older patients who more fre-quently had corticospinal tract signs but was less frequentlyTa
ble
2Charac
teristicsofpatients
withCOVID-19withac
ute
isch
emicstroke
(con
tinue
d)
Sex
Age
yRiskfactors
Clinicalpre
senta
tion
Days
from
COVID
-19
resp
irato
rysy
mpto
monse
tto
isch
emic
stro
kesy
mpto
monse
tTr
eatm
entupto
this
timepoint
Arrhythmias(ECG
orech
oca
rdiogr
aphy)
Bra
inMRI
Larg
eve
ssel
occ
lusion
D-dim
ers
(refere
nce
range
lt400
)μgL
M76
mdashConfusion
24Su
pportive
No
WCI
mdash397
7
F92
mdashConfusion
10Su
pportive
No
WCI
mdash98
7
F77
Hyp
ertension
HOS
Lefthem
iplegialeft
homonym
oushem
ianopia
hea
dac
hes
minus2(stroke
prece
ded
resp
iratory
symptoms
by2d)
mdashYe
s(previously
unkn
own)
LAI
P2occlusion
NR
M88
Hyp
ertension
Dyslip
idem
iaDiabetes
mellitus
Atrialfibrilla
tion
HOS
Righthem
iplegiaim
paired
consciousn
ess
minus2(stroke
prece
ded
resp
iratory
symptoms
by2d)
mdashYe
sLA
IProximal
M2
occlusion
NR
Abbreviations
COVID-19=co
ronav
irusdisea
se20
19H
OS=history
ofstroke
IC=intern
alca
rotidarteryL
AI=
largeartery
infarctionN
R=Notrealized
WCI=
watersh
edce
rebralinfarction
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1873
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
Table 3 Characteristics of patients with COVID-19 with meningoencephalitis
Sex Age y Clinical symptoms
Days from COVID-19respiratory symptomonset to brain MRI Treatment up to this time point CSF analysis Imaging findings
F 71 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
22 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
0 celluarr Total protein 057 gL
Miscellaneous encephalitisdiffusionand T2FLAIR hyperintensitiesinvolving supratentorial WM
M 64 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
17 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
40 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 11 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 56 mgL
Miscellaneous encephalitisFLAIRhyperintensity involving both middlecerebellar peduncles
M 56 Impaired consciousnesspathologic wakefulness whensedation was stopped
23 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
1 cellmm3
uarr Total protein 2 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 169 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Radiologic acute hemorrhagicnecrotizing encephalopathy
M 66 Impaired consciousnesspathologic wakefulness whensedation was stopped
34 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
NR Radiologic acute hemorrhagicnecrotizing encephalopathy
M 55 Headachesdizzinessimpairedconsciousness
3 mdash 7 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 056 gLCLOCC
M 56 Headaches 20 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
3 cellsmm3
Total protein 024 gLLeft limbic encephalitis
M 58 Ataxia 21 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
4 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 077 gLLeft limbic encephalitis
M 60 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
13 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
0 cellTotal protein 03 gL
Radiologic ADEM
F 51 Movement disordersagitation 16 mdash 5 cellsuarr Total protein 066 gL
Focal LME
F 59 Headachesdizziness 18 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
NR Focal LME
M 62 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
19 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
0 cellTotal protein 023 gLImmunoglobulin G 33 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Diffuse LME
Continued
e1874Neu
rology
|Vo
lume95N
umber
13|
Septem
ber
292020NeurologyorgN
Copyright
copy2020
American
Academ
yof
Neurology
Unauthorized
reproductionof
thisarticle
isprohibited
Table 3 Characteristics of patients with COVID-19 with meningoencephalitis (continued)
Sex Age y Clinical symptoms
Days from COVID-19respiratory symptomonset to brain MRI Treatment up to this time point CSF analysis Imaging findings
M 78 Agitation 15 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
NR Focal LME
M 72 Impaired consciousnessbilateralpyramidal tract signs
20 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavirHydroxychloroquine
0 cellTotal protein 023 gLImmunoglobulin G 17 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Focal LME
M 61 Impaired consciousnessbilateralpyramidal tract signsconfusionagitation
14 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
1 cellmm3
Total protein 023 gLImmunoglobulin G 17 mgL
Focal LME
M 66 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
22 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
NR Focal LME
F 53 Confusionimpairedconsciousness
29 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
0 cellTotal protein 029 gLImmunoglobulin G 21 mgL
Focal LME
F 64 Bilateral pyramidal tract signs 11 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
2 cellsmm3
Total protein 030 gLImmunoglobulin G 15 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Focal LME
F 77 Bilateral pyramidal syndromeconfusionagitation
30 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavirHydroxychloroquine
1 cellmm3
uarr Total protein 080 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 58 mgL
Diffuse LME
F 81 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
20 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
80 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 062 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 38 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Focal LME
Abbreviations ADEM = Acute disseminated encephalomyelitis CLOCC = cytotoxic lesion of the corpus callosum COVID-19 = coronavirus disease 2019 FLAIR = fluid-attenuated inversion recovery ICU = intensive care unitLME = leptomeningeal enhancement NR = not realized WM = white matter
Neurolo
gyorgN
Neurology
|Volum
e95N
umber
13|
Septem
ber292020
e1875
Copyright
copy2020
American
Academ
yof
Neurology
Unauthorized
reproductionof
thisarticle
isprohibited
requiring oxygen or presenting an ARDS This profile couldbe distinguished from the 2 others LME and encephalitisThe encephalitis profile affected younger patients and seemedto be particularly severe because it was associated with theneed for oxygen ARDS and death
Stroke patients less frequently had ARDS and this result is inagreement with the 6 patients with stroke previously reportedin that only 2 patients were admitted to ICUs16 One mayhypothesize that strokes in patients with COVID-19 could bedue to procoagulant events leading to thrombosis17 ratherthan to the systemic inflammatory process that accompaniesARDS which is also directed against the CNS However thisneeds to be assessed by further studies dedicated to stroke andthrombosis in patients with COVID-19
In our study 17 (27) patients had an acute ischemic strokeas was previously reported with SARS-CoV18 Middle Eastrespiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERS-CoV)19 andSARS-CoV-2111617 and among them 11 had large arteryinfarctions (including 6 proximal artery occlusions 2 cases ofinternal carotid artery dissection or occlusion) and 6 hadwatershed cerebral infarctions For 15 of 17 patients with anischemic stroke the respiratory symptoms related to COVID-19 had begun before this acute event while stroke precededrespiratory symptoms by 2 days for 2 patients
Several mechanisms are likely to be associated It is nowknown that SARS-CoV-2 could directly lead to myocardialinjury promoting cardiac arrhythmias associated with em-bolic events20 Six of our patients had arrhythmias which werepreviously unknown for 3 of them In the same way a severeacute myocardial injury may be associated with a decrease inbrain perfusion and therefore with watershed cerebralinfarctions As previously mentioned it is acknowledged thatviruses particularly SARS-CoV-221 are associated with anincrease of prothrombotic events such as ischemic stroke2223
Thereby viral infections may elevate procoagulant markersleading to thrombosis disseminated intravascular coagulationand hemorrhagic events23 As Beyrouti et al16 recently men-tioned all our patients tested showed elevated D-dimersmarkedly elevated (gt1000 μgL) for 10 of the 11 patientstested
Varicella zoster virus is also associated with direct vascularinvolvement and eventually arteritis promoting ischemicstroke events22 Furthermore the more severe critically illpatients hospitalized in ICUs have probably had hypoxemiaand hypotension leading to brain injuries18
Of the 36 abnormal MRIs 8 diagnoses of encephalitis weremade and LME was described especially on postcontrast T1-weighted and FLAIR in 11 patients either focal (single focus
Figure 1 Leptomeningeal enhancement
Axial T1 (A) before and (B) 5 minutes after contrast axial FLAIR (C) before and (D) immediately after contrast and (E and F) delayed (10 minutes) postcontrastaxial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) weighted MRIs Woman 77 years of age diffuse leptomeningeal linear FLAIR and T1 contrast enhancement(arrows) not visible on precontrast T1 and FLAIR (arrows) but seen better on delayed postcontrast FLAIR weighted MRIs (E and F)
e1876 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
vs multiple foci) or diffuse and preferentially located in theposterior supratentorial regions of the brain
Two main pathophysiologic hypotheses can be advanced toexplain the neuroimaging findings in the inflammatory profilegroup First SARS-CoV-2 may have a neuroinvasive potentialsimilar to other hCoVs because this family of viruses is relatedto each other genetically It is not clear if the virus can infiltratethe CNS with active replication and direct damage to braincells (viral encephalitis) as observed with other viruses suchas herpes simplex virus Likewise viral meningitis due to di-rect infiltration of the virus into the CSF may also be con-sidered because it was previously reported with SARS-CoV-1Indeed SARS-CoV-1 RNA was detected in the CSF of 2patients with seizures2425 A recent case report10 has de-scribed for the first time a case of seizures with the detection ofSARS-CoV-2 RNA in the CSF Similarly leptomeningealinflammation may be present adjacent to subpial corticallesions in the case of viral meningoencephalitis In the case ofviral encephalitis CSF analysis usually demonstrates lym-phocytic pleocytosis26 In addition the CSF protein level istypically elevated in viral encephalitis CSF viral RT-PCR isusually positive but can be negative if done too early This wasnot the case in our series and our results are in accordance
with recently published data that demonstrated an absence ofCSF pleocytosis and negative SARS-CoV-2 RT-PCR (5 of 5patients) but elevated protein level (4 of 5 patients) inpatients presenting cerebral MRI cortical abnormalities13
MRI pictures of viral encephalitis vary with causal pathogenNevertheless viral encephalitis usually involves cerebral GMwith diffusion restriction and can be associated with intrale-sional and diffuse leptomeningeal contrast enhancement Thiswas not the case in our series and did not argue for the directeffect of the virus It is all the more likely that the directdetection of SARS-CoV-2 RNA by RT-PCR was alwaysnegative in all our CSF samples
An alternative hypothesis appears more relevant the neuro-virulence of hCoVs especially MERS-CoV seems to bea consequence of immune-mediated processes1927ndash29 IndeedADEM and Bickerstaff brainstem encephalitis which weredescribed with MERS-CoV18ndash27 are 2 examples of autoim-mune demyelinating diseases resulting from a postinfectious orparainfectious process A recent case report9 has describeda case of acute hemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy (whichis the most severe form of ADEM) associated with COVID-19which strengthens the hypothesis of a predominant immuno-logic mechanism In our cohort we also described 2 cases of
Figure 2 Encephalitis
(A B D) Axial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) and(C) diffusion-weighted MRIs (A) Man 56 years of age lefthippocampus and amygdala FLAIR hyperintensity (B)Woman 71 years of age periventricular and subcorticalwhite matter FLAIR confluent hyperintensities (C) Man 55years of age corpus callosum splenium diffusion hyper-intensity (D) Man 64 years of age FLAIR middle cerebellarpeduncle hyperintensity
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1877
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
limbic encephalitis and 1 case of CLOCC Concerning thelatter no treatment had been started or stopped in previousweeks Thus 75 of encephalitis cases in our cohort (limbicencephalitis CLOCC radiologic ADEM radiologic acutehemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy) are possibly con-sidered immune-mediated diseases Therefore SARS-CoV-2ndashmediated disease is driven largely by immunologic processesand the same mechanisms could explain LME Indeed thearachnoid and pial membranes form the leptomeninges anda significant amount of antigen-presenting cells are present inthe subarachnoid space30 Thus initial immune activationoccurs in the subarachnoid space which is a site for antigenpresentation lymphocyte accumulation and proliferation andantibody production30 All lead to an important local in-flammatory infiltrate with a blood-CSF barrier disruptionwhich can also explain LME Thus LME can be linked toinflammatory or immunologic responses as previously de-scribed in animal models of autoimmune encephalomyelitis31
with some neurotropic viruses such as human T-cell leukemiavirus and HIV31 and in several immune-mediated neurologicdiseases31 Moreover a very similar intracranial pattern hasbeen described in an animal study in piglets affected by gas-troenteritis coronavirus32 Indeed histology demonstrateddiffuse pia matter gliosis with mild congestion of the meningeal
and parenchymal vessels with neuronal degeneration locatedmostly in posterior parietooccipital lobes24 PostcontrastFLAIR is the best sequence to highlight LME but a potentialpitfall is inhalation of increased levels of oxygen by patients whoare intubated which may increase subarachnoid space signalintensity noted on FLAIR images within the basal cisterns andsulcus along the cerebral convexities33 That is why we havechosen in this situation to acquire systematically precontrastand postcontrast FLAIR sequences to avoid misinterpretationof FLAIR hyperintensity within the subarachnoid spaces andnot to misdescribe a meningeal enhancement For our 11patients with LME no precontrast FLAIR signal abnormalitieswere visible in the subarachnoid spaces
Our study has several limitations mainly due to its multicenterand retrospective design First brain MRI protocols were dic-tated by clinical need and the patterns of working could bedifferent among the 11 centers even if neuroradiologists areused to work together Thus 36 of the MRIs were performedwithout administration of gadolinium-based contrast agentsnotably preventing the detection of LME therefore probablyunderestimating it Moreover LMEs are very subtle neuro-imaging findings which need the realization of delayed post-contrast FLAIR sequences which were not done in the vast
Figure 3 Radiologic acute disseminated encephalomyelitis
(A E I) Axial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) (B F J) axial diffusion (B F J) apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC) map and (D H L) postcontrast T1-weighted MRIs Man 60 years of age subcortical periventricular corpus callosum and posterior fossa white matter FLAIR hyperintensities without contrastenhancement (arrows) Some lesions appear hyperintense on diffusion-weightedMRIs with decreased ADC corresponding to cytotoxic edema (stars) Otherlesions present an ADC increase corresponding to vasogenic edema (cross)
e1878 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
majority of the centers Second we did not realize a follow-upMRI and some abnormalities could have appeared duringfollow-up Third outcomes were not available for all patients atthe time of writing Thus the mortality rate is probablyunderestimated in our cohort Fourth although patients withCOVID-19may develop a wide range of neurologic symptomswhich can be associated with ischemic stroke or encephalitis itis difficult to state without a controlled general neurologicpopulation that such events are more frequent in patients withCOVID-19 However it now seems well established thatthrombotic events are particularly frequent in patients withCOVID-1921 Moreover encephalitis which is a rare disorderin the general population34 was surprisingly frequent in ourpopulation
In this large multicentric national cohort most patients withCOVID-19 (56) with neurologic manifestations had brainMRI abnormalities such as ischemic stroke LME and enceph-alitis Because the detection of LME suggests the abnormality ofbrain MRI it would be interesting to realize systematicallypostcontrast FLAIR acquisition in patients with COVID-19
Concerning the cases of encephalitis and LME even if a directviral origin cannot be eliminated the pathophysiology of braindamage related to SARS-COV-2 seems rather to involve aninflammatory or autoimmune response The knowledge ofthe various clinicoradiologic manifestations of COVID-19could be helpful for the best care of the patients and ourunderstanding of the disease In addition to SARS cytokine
Figure 4 Multiple correspondence analysis
The ischemic stroke group (red) can be distinguished from the 3 others which largely overlapMost patients with ischemic stroke (numbers and dots in red onthe plot) are located on the same lower-right half of the graph indicating a commonality of symptoms Diag 1 (black) = normal brain MRI Diag 2 (red) =ischemic stroke Diag 3 (green) = encephalitis Diag 4 (blue) = leptomeningeal enhancement
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1879
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
storm syndrome and heart failure brain injuries may con-tribute to increased mortality This highlights the importanceof neurologic evaluation especially for patients hospitalized inICU with clinical deterioration or worsening of their symp-toms which can be associated with an acute neurologic event
AcknowledgmentThe authors thank Marie Cecile Henry Feugeas for her workin data acquisition for this study
Study fundingNo targeted funding reported
DisclosureThe authors report no disclosures relevant to the manuscriptGo to NeurologyorgN for full disclosures
Publication historyReceived by Neurology April 28 2020 Accepted in final formJune 9 2020
Appendix Authors
Name Location Contribution
StephaneKremer MDPhD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study acquisition of datainterpreted the data draftedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Franccedilois LersyMD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study acquisition of datainterpreted the data draftedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MathieuAnheim MDPhD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
Hamid MerdjiMD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MalekaSchenck MD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
HeleneOesterle MD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FedericoBolognini MD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Julien MessieMD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Antoine KhalilMD PhD
Bichat Hospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
AugustinGaudemer MD
Bichat Hospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Sophie CarreMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Manel AllegMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Claire LecocqMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
EmmanuelleSchmitt MD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ReneAnxionnatMD PhD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Franccedilois ZhuMD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Lavinia JagerMD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Patrick NesserMD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Yannick TallaMba MD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GhaziHmeydia MD
Saint-Anne hospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
JosephBenzakounMD
Saint-Anne hospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
CatherineOppenheimMD PhD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jean-ChristopheFerre MD PhD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Adel MaamarMD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
BeatriceCarsin-NicolMD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Pierre-OlivierComby MD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FredericRicolfi MDPhD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
PierreThouant MD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Claire BoutetMD PhD
University hospital ofSaint-Etienne France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
e1880 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
References1 Chen N Zhou M Dong X et al Epidemiological and clinical characteristics of 99
cases of 2019 novel coronavirus pneumonia in Wuhan China a descriptive studyLancet 2020395507ndash513
2 Huang C Wang Y Li X et al Clinical features of patients infected with 2019 novelcoronavirus in Wuhan China Lancet 2020395497ndash506
3 Glass WG Subbarao K Murphy B Murphy PM Mechanisms of host defense fol-lowing severe acute respiratory syndrome‐coronavirus (SARS‐CoV) pulmonary in-fection of mice J Immunol 20041734030ndash4039
4 Li K Wohlford‐Lenane C Perlman S et al Middle East respiratory syndromecoronavirus causes multiple organ damage and lethal disease in mice transgenic forhuman dipeptidyl peptidase 4 J Infect Dis 2016213712ndash722
5 Arbour N Day R Newcombe J Talbot PJ Neuroinvasion by human respiratorycoronaviruses J Virol 2000748913ndash8921
6 Desforges M Le Coupanec A Stodola JK Meessen-Pinard M Talbot PJ Humancoronaviruses viral and cellular factors involved in neuroinvasiveness and neuro-pathogenesis Virus Res 2014194145ndash158
7 Desforges M Le Coupanec A Dubeau P et al Human coronaviruses and otherrespiratory viruses underestimated opportunistic pathogens of the central nervoussystem Viruses 201912E14
8 Bohmwald K Galvez NMS Rıos M Kalergis AM Neurologic alterations due torespiratory virus infections Front Cell Neurosci 201812386
9 Poyiadji N Shahin G Noujaim D Stone M Patel S Griffith B COVID-19-associatedacute hemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy CT and MRI features Radiology2020201187
10 Moriguchi T Harii N Goto J et al A first case of meningitisencephalitis associatedwith SARS-coronavirus-2 Int J Infect Dis 20209455ndash58
11 Mao L Jin H Wang M et al Neurologic manifestations of hospitalized patients withcoronavirus disease 2019 in Wuhan China JAMA Neurol 2020771ndash9
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Xavier FabreMD
Hospital of RoanneFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GeraudForestier MD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Isaure deBeaurepaireMD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GregoireBornet MD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Hubert DesalMD PhD
University Hospital ofNantes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GregoireBoulouis MD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jerome BergeMD
University Hospital ofBordeaux France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ApollineKazemi MD
University Hospital ofLille France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
NadyaPyatigorskayaMD
Pitie-SalpetriereHospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
AugustinLecler MD
Foundation ARothschild Paris
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
SuzanaSaleme MD
University Hospital ofLimoges France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Myriam Edjlali-Goujon MD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
BasileKerleroux MD
University Hospital ofTours France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jean-MarcConstans MDPhD
University Hospital ofAmiens France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Pierre-EmmanuelZorn PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the acquisitionof data
MurielMatthieu PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the acquisitionof data
Seyyid BalogluMD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of datarevised the manuscriptfor intellectualcontent
Franccedilois-DanielArdellier MD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ThibaultWillaume MD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of datarevised the manuscriptfor intellectualcontent
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Jean-ChristopheBrisset PhD
French Observatoryof Multiple SclerosisLyon France
Interpretation of the datarevised the manuscript forintellectual content
SophieCaillard MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
OlivierCollange MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Paul MichelMertes MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FrancisSchneider MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Samira Fafi-KremerPharmD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MickaelOhana MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FerhatMeziani MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Nicolas MeyerMD PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the analysis andinterpretation of the data
Julie HelmsMD PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
FranccediloisCotton MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1881
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
12 Helms J Kremer S Merdji H et al Neurologic features in severe SARS-CoV-2infection N Engl J Med 20203822268ndash2270
13 Kandemirli SG Dogan L Sarikaya ZT et al Brain MRI findings in patients in theintensive care unit with COVID-19 infection Radiology Epub 2020 May 8
14 Ferguson ND Fan E Camporota L et al The Berlin definition of ARDS an expandedrationale justification and supplementary material Intensive Care Med 2012381573ndash1582
15 Starkey J Kobayashi N Numaguchi Y Moritani T Cytotoxic lesions of the corpuscallosum that show restricted diffusion mechanisms causes and manifestationsRadiographics 201737562ndash576
16 Beyrouti R Adams ME Benjamin L et al Characteristics of ischaemic stroke asso-ciated with COVID-19 J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry Epub 2020 Apr 30
17 Hess DC Eldahshan W Rutkowski E COVID-19-related stroke Transl Stroke Res202011322ndash325
18 Umapathi T Kor AC Venketasubramanian N et al Large artery ischaemic stroke insevere acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) J Neurol 20042511227ndash1231
19 Arabi YM Harthi A Hussein J et al Severe neurologic syndrome associated withMiddle East respiratory syndrome corona virus (MERS-CoV) Infection 201543495ndash501
20 Guo T Fan Y ChenM et al Cardiovascular implications of fatal outcomes of patientswith coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) JAMA Cardiol Epub 2020 Mar 27
21 Helms J Tacquard C Severac F et al High risk of thrombosis in patients in severeSARS-CoV-2 infection a multicenter prospective cohort study Intensive Care Med2020461089ndash1098
22 NagelMAMahalingamRCohrs RJ GildenD Virus vasculopathy and stroke an under-recognized cause and treatment target Infect Disord Drug Targets 201010105ndash111
23 Subramaniam S Scharrer I Procoagulant activity during viral infections Front Biosci(Landmark Ed) 2018231060ndash1081
24 Hung EC Chim SS Chan PK et al Detection of SARS coronavirus RNA in thecerebrospinal fluid of a patient with severe acute respiratory syndrome Clin Chem2003492108ndash2109
25 Lau KK Yu WC Chu CM Lau ST Sheng B Yuen KY Possible central nervoussystem infection by SARS coronavirus Emerg Infect Dis 200410342ndash344
26 Toledano M Davies NWS Infectious encephalitis mimics and chameleons PractNeurol 201919225ndash237
27 Kim JE Heo JH Kim HO et al Neurological complications during treatment ofMiddle East respiratory syndrome J Clin Neurol 201713227ndash233
28 Li Y Li H Fan R et al Coronavirus infections in the central nervous system andrespiratory tract show distinct features in hospitalized children Intervirology 201659163ndash169
29 Yeh EA Collins A Cohen ME Duffner PK Faden H Detection of coronavirus in thecentral nervous system of a child with acute disseminated encephalomyelitis Pedi-atrics 2004113(pt 1)e73ndashe76
30 Kivisakk P Imitola J Rasmussen S et al Localizing central nervous system immunesurveillance meningeal antigen-presenting cells activate T cells during experimentalautoimmune encephalomyelitis Ann Neurol 200965457ndash469
31 Absinta M Cortese IC Vuolo L et al Leptomeningeal gadolinium enhancementacross the spectrum of chronic neuroinflammatory diseases Neurology 2017881439ndash1444
32 Papatsiros VG Stylianaki I Papakonstantinou G Papaioannou N Christodoulo-poulos G Case report of transmissible gastroenteritis coronavirus infection associatedwith small intestine and brain lesions in piglets Viral Immunol 20193263ndash67
33 Stuckey SL Goh TD Heffernan T Rowan D Hyperintensity in the subarachnoidspace on FLAIR MRI AJR Am J Roentgenol 2007189913ndash921
34 Parpia AS Li Y Chen C Dhar B Crowcroft NS Encephalitis Ontario Canada 2002-2013 Emerg Infect Dis 201622426ndash432
e1882 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
DOI 101212WNL0000000000010112202095e1868-e1882 Published Online before print July 17 2020Neurology
Steacutephane Kremer Franccedilois Lersy Mathieu Anheim et al multicenter study
Neurologic and neuroimaging findings in patients with COVID-19 A retrospective
This information is current as of July 17 2020
ServicesUpdated Information amp
httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullincluding high resolution figures can be found at
References httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullref-list-1
This article cites 30 articles 6 of which you can access for free at
Citations httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullotherarticles
This article has been cited by 3 HighWire-hosted articles
Subspecialty Collections
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmriMRI
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmeningitisMeningitis
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionencephalitisEncephalitis e
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_cerebrovascular_disease_strokAll Cerebrovascular diseaseStrokefollowing collection(s) This article along with others on similar topics appears in the
Permissions amp Licensing
httpwwwneurologyorgaboutabout_the_journalpermissionsits entirety can be found online atInformation about reproducing this article in parts (figurestables) or in
Reprints
httpnneurologyorgsubscribersadvertiseInformation about ordering reprints can be found online
rights reserved Print ISSN 0028-3878 Online ISSN 1526-632X1951 it is now a weekly with 48 issues per year Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology All
reg is the official journal of the American Academy of Neurology Published continuously sinceNeurology
![Page 5: Neurologicandneuroimaging findingsinpatients with COVID-19 · enhancement (17%), and encephalitis (13%) were the most frequent neuroimaging findings. Confusion (53%) was the most](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060813/6091b284d4b0681e5152b42b/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Table 2 Characteristics of patients with COVID-19 with acute ischemic stroke
Sex Age y Risk factors Clinical presentation
Days from COVID-19respiratory symptomonset to ischemicstroke symptom onset
Treatment up tothis time point
Arrhythmias (ECGor echocardiography)
BrainMRI
Large vesselocclusion
D-dimers(reference range lt400) μgL
M 86 HypertensionDyslipidemia
Left hemiplegiaimpairedconsciousness
1 Supportive No LAI Distal M1 occlusionwith thrombus
NR
M 71 HypertensionDiabetesmellitus
Left hemiplegia 16 Antibiotics Yes (previouslyunknown)
LAI Distal M1 occlusionwith thrombus
2860
F 74 mdash Bilateral pyramidal tract signs 8 AntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
No WCI mdash gt20000
M 63 Smoking Left-sided weaknessleft-sidedsensory inattention
14 Antibiotics Yes (previouslyunknown)
LAI mdash 1000
M 65 HypertensionDiabetesmellitusDyslipidemiaHOS
Impaired consciousness 22 Antibiotics No WCI mdash 1570
F 78 Hypertension Dysarthria 3 Supportive No WCI mdash 720
F 75 HypertensionDyslipidemiaAtrial Fibrillation
Aphasiaright hemiplegiaimpaired consciousnessagitation
6 Supportive NR LAI ICA occlusion NR
M 79 HypertensionDyslipidemiaHOS
Headachesimpairedconsciousnessconfusion
5 Supportive No WCI mdash NR
F 71 HypertensionSmokingAtrial fibrillation
Left hemiplegia 3 Supportive Yes LAI Proximal M2occlusion
gt20000
M 59 HypertensionSmoking
Left hemiplegialeft facial droop 1 Supportive No LAI Proximal M1occlusion withthrombus
2868
M 66 HypertensionDyslipidemiaDiabetesmellitus
Left pyramidal tract signsleftfacial droopaphasia
4 Supportive No LAI ICA dissection 5227
M 72 DyslipidemiaAtrial fibrillation
Impaired consciousness 15 Antibiotics Yes LAI mdash 993
M 78 Hypertension Dysarthriaright-sidedweaknessright facial droop
16 Supportive No LAI mdash NR
Continued
e1872Neu
rology
|Vo
lume95N
umber
13|
Septem
ber
292020NeurologyorgN
Copyright
copy2020
American
Academ
yof
Neurology
Unauthorized
reproductionof
thisarticle
isprohibited
had elevated immunoglobulin G and 4 had oligoclonal bandsthat were identical in CSF and serum In the ischemic strokegroup 1 patient had a high level of protein
The RT-PCR SARS-CoV-2 analysis was negative in the 20patients who were investigated The analysis was not realizedfor 5 patients 1 with a normal brain MRI 2 with an ischemicstroke 1 with encephalitis and 1 with LME Cultures for otherviruses or bacteria were always negative when performed
Correlation analysisThere were statistically significant differences between thevarious groups concerning age (p = 0007) the presence ofpyramidal tract signs (p = 002) agitation (p = 0009) andrespiratory status (ARDS) (p = 0006) (table 1)
The MCA showed that the ischemic stroke group could bedistinguished from the 3 others which largely overlap (figure 4)Most patients with ischemic stroke (numbers and dots in redon the plot) are located on the same lower-right half of thegraph indicating a commonality of symptoms Those patientscan be overall described as older with no ARDS no oxygenrequirement no confusion no disturbances of consciousnessand a lower death rate The converse is true for the 3 otherdiagnoses that cannot be distinguished Considering eachclinical manifestation separately (figure e-3 available fromDryad doiorg105061dryadw9ghx3fm7) subjects can bedistinguishedmainly on the basis of a global pattern dependingon their oxygen requirement seizure sex headaches history ofautoimmune disease history of seizure age anosmia confu-sion and disturbances of consciousness
DiscussionThis is the first large nationwide cohort of MRIs performed inpatients with COVID-19 with neurologic manifestations
The majority of patients had MRI abnormalities with seriousand various findings beyond the severe respiratory disease(half of the patients had ARDS and 11 died) cerebrovas-cular disease (especially ischemic stroke large artery infarc-tions more frequently than watershed cerebral infarctions)encephalitis (including limbic encephalitis radiologic ADEMCLOCC and radiologic acute hemorrhagic necrotizing en-cephalopathy) and focal or even diffuse LME The hetero-geneity of the imaging abnormalities was underpinned byheterogeneous clinical manifestations ranging from anosmiaageusia or headache to more severe findings such as confu-sion with agitation loss of consciousness and corticospinaltract signs Some correlations were found between clinical andimaging findings allowing the identification of clinicoradio-logic profiles of patients with COVID-19 displaying neuro-logic manifestations
Ischemic stroke was 1 kind of clinicoradiologic phenotype itwas an acute event arising in older patients who more fre-quently had corticospinal tract signs but was less frequentlyTa
ble
2Charac
teristicsofpatients
withCOVID-19withac
ute
isch
emicstroke
(con
tinue
d)
Sex
Age
yRiskfactors
Clinicalpre
senta
tion
Days
from
COVID
-19
resp
irato
rysy
mpto
monse
tto
isch
emic
stro
kesy
mpto
monse
tTr
eatm
entupto
this
timepoint
Arrhythmias(ECG
orech
oca
rdiogr
aphy)
Bra
inMRI
Larg
eve
ssel
occ
lusion
D-dim
ers
(refere
nce
range
lt400
)μgL
M76
mdashConfusion
24Su
pportive
No
WCI
mdash397
7
F92
mdashConfusion
10Su
pportive
No
WCI
mdash98
7
F77
Hyp
ertension
HOS
Lefthem
iplegialeft
homonym
oushem
ianopia
hea
dac
hes
minus2(stroke
prece
ded
resp
iratory
symptoms
by2d)
mdashYe
s(previously
unkn
own)
LAI
P2occlusion
NR
M88
Hyp
ertension
Dyslip
idem
iaDiabetes
mellitus
Atrialfibrilla
tion
HOS
Righthem
iplegiaim
paired
consciousn
ess
minus2(stroke
prece
ded
resp
iratory
symptoms
by2d)
mdashYe
sLA
IProximal
M2
occlusion
NR
Abbreviations
COVID-19=co
ronav
irusdisea
se20
19H
OS=history
ofstroke
IC=intern
alca
rotidarteryL
AI=
largeartery
infarctionN
R=Notrealized
WCI=
watersh
edce
rebralinfarction
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1873
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
Table 3 Characteristics of patients with COVID-19 with meningoencephalitis
Sex Age y Clinical symptoms
Days from COVID-19respiratory symptomonset to brain MRI Treatment up to this time point CSF analysis Imaging findings
F 71 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
22 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
0 celluarr Total protein 057 gL
Miscellaneous encephalitisdiffusionand T2FLAIR hyperintensitiesinvolving supratentorial WM
M 64 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
17 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
40 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 11 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 56 mgL
Miscellaneous encephalitisFLAIRhyperintensity involving both middlecerebellar peduncles
M 56 Impaired consciousnesspathologic wakefulness whensedation was stopped
23 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
1 cellmm3
uarr Total protein 2 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 169 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Radiologic acute hemorrhagicnecrotizing encephalopathy
M 66 Impaired consciousnesspathologic wakefulness whensedation was stopped
34 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
NR Radiologic acute hemorrhagicnecrotizing encephalopathy
M 55 Headachesdizzinessimpairedconsciousness
3 mdash 7 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 056 gLCLOCC
M 56 Headaches 20 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
3 cellsmm3
Total protein 024 gLLeft limbic encephalitis
M 58 Ataxia 21 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
4 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 077 gLLeft limbic encephalitis
M 60 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
13 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
0 cellTotal protein 03 gL
Radiologic ADEM
F 51 Movement disordersagitation 16 mdash 5 cellsuarr Total protein 066 gL
Focal LME
F 59 Headachesdizziness 18 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
NR Focal LME
M 62 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
19 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
0 cellTotal protein 023 gLImmunoglobulin G 33 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Diffuse LME
Continued
e1874Neu
rology
|Vo
lume95N
umber
13|
Septem
ber
292020NeurologyorgN
Copyright
copy2020
American
Academ
yof
Neurology
Unauthorized
reproductionof
thisarticle
isprohibited
Table 3 Characteristics of patients with COVID-19 with meningoencephalitis (continued)
Sex Age y Clinical symptoms
Days from COVID-19respiratory symptomonset to brain MRI Treatment up to this time point CSF analysis Imaging findings
M 78 Agitation 15 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
NR Focal LME
M 72 Impaired consciousnessbilateralpyramidal tract signs
20 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavirHydroxychloroquine
0 cellTotal protein 023 gLImmunoglobulin G 17 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Focal LME
M 61 Impaired consciousnessbilateralpyramidal tract signsconfusionagitation
14 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
1 cellmm3
Total protein 023 gLImmunoglobulin G 17 mgL
Focal LME
M 66 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
22 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
NR Focal LME
F 53 Confusionimpairedconsciousness
29 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
0 cellTotal protein 029 gLImmunoglobulin G 21 mgL
Focal LME
F 64 Bilateral pyramidal tract signs 11 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
2 cellsmm3
Total protein 030 gLImmunoglobulin G 15 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Focal LME
F 77 Bilateral pyramidal syndromeconfusionagitation
30 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavirHydroxychloroquine
1 cellmm3
uarr Total protein 080 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 58 mgL
Diffuse LME
F 81 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
20 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
80 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 062 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 38 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Focal LME
Abbreviations ADEM = Acute disseminated encephalomyelitis CLOCC = cytotoxic lesion of the corpus callosum COVID-19 = coronavirus disease 2019 FLAIR = fluid-attenuated inversion recovery ICU = intensive care unitLME = leptomeningeal enhancement NR = not realized WM = white matter
Neurolo
gyorgN
Neurology
|Volum
e95N
umber
13|
Septem
ber292020
e1875
Copyright
copy2020
American
Academ
yof
Neurology
Unauthorized
reproductionof
thisarticle
isprohibited
requiring oxygen or presenting an ARDS This profile couldbe distinguished from the 2 others LME and encephalitisThe encephalitis profile affected younger patients and seemedto be particularly severe because it was associated with theneed for oxygen ARDS and death
Stroke patients less frequently had ARDS and this result is inagreement with the 6 patients with stroke previously reportedin that only 2 patients were admitted to ICUs16 One mayhypothesize that strokes in patients with COVID-19 could bedue to procoagulant events leading to thrombosis17 ratherthan to the systemic inflammatory process that accompaniesARDS which is also directed against the CNS However thisneeds to be assessed by further studies dedicated to stroke andthrombosis in patients with COVID-19
In our study 17 (27) patients had an acute ischemic strokeas was previously reported with SARS-CoV18 Middle Eastrespiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERS-CoV)19 andSARS-CoV-2111617 and among them 11 had large arteryinfarctions (including 6 proximal artery occlusions 2 cases ofinternal carotid artery dissection or occlusion) and 6 hadwatershed cerebral infarctions For 15 of 17 patients with anischemic stroke the respiratory symptoms related to COVID-19 had begun before this acute event while stroke precededrespiratory symptoms by 2 days for 2 patients
Several mechanisms are likely to be associated It is nowknown that SARS-CoV-2 could directly lead to myocardialinjury promoting cardiac arrhythmias associated with em-bolic events20 Six of our patients had arrhythmias which werepreviously unknown for 3 of them In the same way a severeacute myocardial injury may be associated with a decrease inbrain perfusion and therefore with watershed cerebralinfarctions As previously mentioned it is acknowledged thatviruses particularly SARS-CoV-221 are associated with anincrease of prothrombotic events such as ischemic stroke2223
Thereby viral infections may elevate procoagulant markersleading to thrombosis disseminated intravascular coagulationand hemorrhagic events23 As Beyrouti et al16 recently men-tioned all our patients tested showed elevated D-dimersmarkedly elevated (gt1000 μgL) for 10 of the 11 patientstested
Varicella zoster virus is also associated with direct vascularinvolvement and eventually arteritis promoting ischemicstroke events22 Furthermore the more severe critically illpatients hospitalized in ICUs have probably had hypoxemiaand hypotension leading to brain injuries18
Of the 36 abnormal MRIs 8 diagnoses of encephalitis weremade and LME was described especially on postcontrast T1-weighted and FLAIR in 11 patients either focal (single focus
Figure 1 Leptomeningeal enhancement
Axial T1 (A) before and (B) 5 minutes after contrast axial FLAIR (C) before and (D) immediately after contrast and (E and F) delayed (10 minutes) postcontrastaxial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) weighted MRIs Woman 77 years of age diffuse leptomeningeal linear FLAIR and T1 contrast enhancement(arrows) not visible on precontrast T1 and FLAIR (arrows) but seen better on delayed postcontrast FLAIR weighted MRIs (E and F)
e1876 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
vs multiple foci) or diffuse and preferentially located in theposterior supratentorial regions of the brain
Two main pathophysiologic hypotheses can be advanced toexplain the neuroimaging findings in the inflammatory profilegroup First SARS-CoV-2 may have a neuroinvasive potentialsimilar to other hCoVs because this family of viruses is relatedto each other genetically It is not clear if the virus can infiltratethe CNS with active replication and direct damage to braincells (viral encephalitis) as observed with other viruses suchas herpes simplex virus Likewise viral meningitis due to di-rect infiltration of the virus into the CSF may also be con-sidered because it was previously reported with SARS-CoV-1Indeed SARS-CoV-1 RNA was detected in the CSF of 2patients with seizures2425 A recent case report10 has de-scribed for the first time a case of seizures with the detection ofSARS-CoV-2 RNA in the CSF Similarly leptomeningealinflammation may be present adjacent to subpial corticallesions in the case of viral meningoencephalitis In the case ofviral encephalitis CSF analysis usually demonstrates lym-phocytic pleocytosis26 In addition the CSF protein level istypically elevated in viral encephalitis CSF viral RT-PCR isusually positive but can be negative if done too early This wasnot the case in our series and our results are in accordance
with recently published data that demonstrated an absence ofCSF pleocytosis and negative SARS-CoV-2 RT-PCR (5 of 5patients) but elevated protein level (4 of 5 patients) inpatients presenting cerebral MRI cortical abnormalities13
MRI pictures of viral encephalitis vary with causal pathogenNevertheless viral encephalitis usually involves cerebral GMwith diffusion restriction and can be associated with intrale-sional and diffuse leptomeningeal contrast enhancement Thiswas not the case in our series and did not argue for the directeffect of the virus It is all the more likely that the directdetection of SARS-CoV-2 RNA by RT-PCR was alwaysnegative in all our CSF samples
An alternative hypothesis appears more relevant the neuro-virulence of hCoVs especially MERS-CoV seems to bea consequence of immune-mediated processes1927ndash29 IndeedADEM and Bickerstaff brainstem encephalitis which weredescribed with MERS-CoV18ndash27 are 2 examples of autoim-mune demyelinating diseases resulting from a postinfectious orparainfectious process A recent case report9 has describeda case of acute hemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy (whichis the most severe form of ADEM) associated with COVID-19which strengthens the hypothesis of a predominant immuno-logic mechanism In our cohort we also described 2 cases of
Figure 2 Encephalitis
(A B D) Axial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) and(C) diffusion-weighted MRIs (A) Man 56 years of age lefthippocampus and amygdala FLAIR hyperintensity (B)Woman 71 years of age periventricular and subcorticalwhite matter FLAIR confluent hyperintensities (C) Man 55years of age corpus callosum splenium diffusion hyper-intensity (D) Man 64 years of age FLAIR middle cerebellarpeduncle hyperintensity
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1877
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
limbic encephalitis and 1 case of CLOCC Concerning thelatter no treatment had been started or stopped in previousweeks Thus 75 of encephalitis cases in our cohort (limbicencephalitis CLOCC radiologic ADEM radiologic acutehemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy) are possibly con-sidered immune-mediated diseases Therefore SARS-CoV-2ndashmediated disease is driven largely by immunologic processesand the same mechanisms could explain LME Indeed thearachnoid and pial membranes form the leptomeninges anda significant amount of antigen-presenting cells are present inthe subarachnoid space30 Thus initial immune activationoccurs in the subarachnoid space which is a site for antigenpresentation lymphocyte accumulation and proliferation andantibody production30 All lead to an important local in-flammatory infiltrate with a blood-CSF barrier disruptionwhich can also explain LME Thus LME can be linked toinflammatory or immunologic responses as previously de-scribed in animal models of autoimmune encephalomyelitis31
with some neurotropic viruses such as human T-cell leukemiavirus and HIV31 and in several immune-mediated neurologicdiseases31 Moreover a very similar intracranial pattern hasbeen described in an animal study in piglets affected by gas-troenteritis coronavirus32 Indeed histology demonstrateddiffuse pia matter gliosis with mild congestion of the meningeal
and parenchymal vessels with neuronal degeneration locatedmostly in posterior parietooccipital lobes24 PostcontrastFLAIR is the best sequence to highlight LME but a potentialpitfall is inhalation of increased levels of oxygen by patients whoare intubated which may increase subarachnoid space signalintensity noted on FLAIR images within the basal cisterns andsulcus along the cerebral convexities33 That is why we havechosen in this situation to acquire systematically precontrastand postcontrast FLAIR sequences to avoid misinterpretationof FLAIR hyperintensity within the subarachnoid spaces andnot to misdescribe a meningeal enhancement For our 11patients with LME no precontrast FLAIR signal abnormalitieswere visible in the subarachnoid spaces
Our study has several limitations mainly due to its multicenterand retrospective design First brain MRI protocols were dic-tated by clinical need and the patterns of working could bedifferent among the 11 centers even if neuroradiologists areused to work together Thus 36 of the MRIs were performedwithout administration of gadolinium-based contrast agentsnotably preventing the detection of LME therefore probablyunderestimating it Moreover LMEs are very subtle neuro-imaging findings which need the realization of delayed post-contrast FLAIR sequences which were not done in the vast
Figure 3 Radiologic acute disseminated encephalomyelitis
(A E I) Axial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) (B F J) axial diffusion (B F J) apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC) map and (D H L) postcontrast T1-weighted MRIs Man 60 years of age subcortical periventricular corpus callosum and posterior fossa white matter FLAIR hyperintensities without contrastenhancement (arrows) Some lesions appear hyperintense on diffusion-weightedMRIs with decreased ADC corresponding to cytotoxic edema (stars) Otherlesions present an ADC increase corresponding to vasogenic edema (cross)
e1878 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
majority of the centers Second we did not realize a follow-upMRI and some abnormalities could have appeared duringfollow-up Third outcomes were not available for all patients atthe time of writing Thus the mortality rate is probablyunderestimated in our cohort Fourth although patients withCOVID-19may develop a wide range of neurologic symptomswhich can be associated with ischemic stroke or encephalitis itis difficult to state without a controlled general neurologicpopulation that such events are more frequent in patients withCOVID-19 However it now seems well established thatthrombotic events are particularly frequent in patients withCOVID-1921 Moreover encephalitis which is a rare disorderin the general population34 was surprisingly frequent in ourpopulation
In this large multicentric national cohort most patients withCOVID-19 (56) with neurologic manifestations had brainMRI abnormalities such as ischemic stroke LME and enceph-alitis Because the detection of LME suggests the abnormality ofbrain MRI it would be interesting to realize systematicallypostcontrast FLAIR acquisition in patients with COVID-19
Concerning the cases of encephalitis and LME even if a directviral origin cannot be eliminated the pathophysiology of braindamage related to SARS-COV-2 seems rather to involve aninflammatory or autoimmune response The knowledge ofthe various clinicoradiologic manifestations of COVID-19could be helpful for the best care of the patients and ourunderstanding of the disease In addition to SARS cytokine
Figure 4 Multiple correspondence analysis
The ischemic stroke group (red) can be distinguished from the 3 others which largely overlapMost patients with ischemic stroke (numbers and dots in red onthe plot) are located on the same lower-right half of the graph indicating a commonality of symptoms Diag 1 (black) = normal brain MRI Diag 2 (red) =ischemic stroke Diag 3 (green) = encephalitis Diag 4 (blue) = leptomeningeal enhancement
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1879
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
storm syndrome and heart failure brain injuries may con-tribute to increased mortality This highlights the importanceof neurologic evaluation especially for patients hospitalized inICU with clinical deterioration or worsening of their symp-toms which can be associated with an acute neurologic event
AcknowledgmentThe authors thank Marie Cecile Henry Feugeas for her workin data acquisition for this study
Study fundingNo targeted funding reported
DisclosureThe authors report no disclosures relevant to the manuscriptGo to NeurologyorgN for full disclosures
Publication historyReceived by Neurology April 28 2020 Accepted in final formJune 9 2020
Appendix Authors
Name Location Contribution
StephaneKremer MDPhD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study acquisition of datainterpreted the data draftedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Franccedilois LersyMD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study acquisition of datainterpreted the data draftedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MathieuAnheim MDPhD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
Hamid MerdjiMD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MalekaSchenck MD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
HeleneOesterle MD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FedericoBolognini MD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Julien MessieMD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Antoine KhalilMD PhD
Bichat Hospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
AugustinGaudemer MD
Bichat Hospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Sophie CarreMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Manel AllegMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Claire LecocqMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
EmmanuelleSchmitt MD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ReneAnxionnatMD PhD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Franccedilois ZhuMD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Lavinia JagerMD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Patrick NesserMD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Yannick TallaMba MD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GhaziHmeydia MD
Saint-Anne hospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
JosephBenzakounMD
Saint-Anne hospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
CatherineOppenheimMD PhD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jean-ChristopheFerre MD PhD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Adel MaamarMD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
BeatriceCarsin-NicolMD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Pierre-OlivierComby MD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FredericRicolfi MDPhD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
PierreThouant MD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Claire BoutetMD PhD
University hospital ofSaint-Etienne France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
e1880 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
References1 Chen N Zhou M Dong X et al Epidemiological and clinical characteristics of 99
cases of 2019 novel coronavirus pneumonia in Wuhan China a descriptive studyLancet 2020395507ndash513
2 Huang C Wang Y Li X et al Clinical features of patients infected with 2019 novelcoronavirus in Wuhan China Lancet 2020395497ndash506
3 Glass WG Subbarao K Murphy B Murphy PM Mechanisms of host defense fol-lowing severe acute respiratory syndrome‐coronavirus (SARS‐CoV) pulmonary in-fection of mice J Immunol 20041734030ndash4039
4 Li K Wohlford‐Lenane C Perlman S et al Middle East respiratory syndromecoronavirus causes multiple organ damage and lethal disease in mice transgenic forhuman dipeptidyl peptidase 4 J Infect Dis 2016213712ndash722
5 Arbour N Day R Newcombe J Talbot PJ Neuroinvasion by human respiratorycoronaviruses J Virol 2000748913ndash8921
6 Desforges M Le Coupanec A Stodola JK Meessen-Pinard M Talbot PJ Humancoronaviruses viral and cellular factors involved in neuroinvasiveness and neuro-pathogenesis Virus Res 2014194145ndash158
7 Desforges M Le Coupanec A Dubeau P et al Human coronaviruses and otherrespiratory viruses underestimated opportunistic pathogens of the central nervoussystem Viruses 201912E14
8 Bohmwald K Galvez NMS Rıos M Kalergis AM Neurologic alterations due torespiratory virus infections Front Cell Neurosci 201812386
9 Poyiadji N Shahin G Noujaim D Stone M Patel S Griffith B COVID-19-associatedacute hemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy CT and MRI features Radiology2020201187
10 Moriguchi T Harii N Goto J et al A first case of meningitisencephalitis associatedwith SARS-coronavirus-2 Int J Infect Dis 20209455ndash58
11 Mao L Jin H Wang M et al Neurologic manifestations of hospitalized patients withcoronavirus disease 2019 in Wuhan China JAMA Neurol 2020771ndash9
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Xavier FabreMD
Hospital of RoanneFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GeraudForestier MD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Isaure deBeaurepaireMD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GregoireBornet MD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Hubert DesalMD PhD
University Hospital ofNantes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GregoireBoulouis MD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jerome BergeMD
University Hospital ofBordeaux France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ApollineKazemi MD
University Hospital ofLille France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
NadyaPyatigorskayaMD
Pitie-SalpetriereHospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
AugustinLecler MD
Foundation ARothschild Paris
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
SuzanaSaleme MD
University Hospital ofLimoges France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Myriam Edjlali-Goujon MD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
BasileKerleroux MD
University Hospital ofTours France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jean-MarcConstans MDPhD
University Hospital ofAmiens France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Pierre-EmmanuelZorn PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the acquisitionof data
MurielMatthieu PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the acquisitionof data
Seyyid BalogluMD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of datarevised the manuscriptfor intellectualcontent
Franccedilois-DanielArdellier MD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ThibaultWillaume MD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of datarevised the manuscriptfor intellectualcontent
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Jean-ChristopheBrisset PhD
French Observatoryof Multiple SclerosisLyon France
Interpretation of the datarevised the manuscript forintellectual content
SophieCaillard MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
OlivierCollange MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Paul MichelMertes MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FrancisSchneider MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Samira Fafi-KremerPharmD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MickaelOhana MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FerhatMeziani MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Nicolas MeyerMD PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the analysis andinterpretation of the data
Julie HelmsMD PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
FranccediloisCotton MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1881
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
12 Helms J Kremer S Merdji H et al Neurologic features in severe SARS-CoV-2infection N Engl J Med 20203822268ndash2270
13 Kandemirli SG Dogan L Sarikaya ZT et al Brain MRI findings in patients in theintensive care unit with COVID-19 infection Radiology Epub 2020 May 8
14 Ferguson ND Fan E Camporota L et al The Berlin definition of ARDS an expandedrationale justification and supplementary material Intensive Care Med 2012381573ndash1582
15 Starkey J Kobayashi N Numaguchi Y Moritani T Cytotoxic lesions of the corpuscallosum that show restricted diffusion mechanisms causes and manifestationsRadiographics 201737562ndash576
16 Beyrouti R Adams ME Benjamin L et al Characteristics of ischaemic stroke asso-ciated with COVID-19 J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry Epub 2020 Apr 30
17 Hess DC Eldahshan W Rutkowski E COVID-19-related stroke Transl Stroke Res202011322ndash325
18 Umapathi T Kor AC Venketasubramanian N et al Large artery ischaemic stroke insevere acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) J Neurol 20042511227ndash1231
19 Arabi YM Harthi A Hussein J et al Severe neurologic syndrome associated withMiddle East respiratory syndrome corona virus (MERS-CoV) Infection 201543495ndash501
20 Guo T Fan Y ChenM et al Cardiovascular implications of fatal outcomes of patientswith coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) JAMA Cardiol Epub 2020 Mar 27
21 Helms J Tacquard C Severac F et al High risk of thrombosis in patients in severeSARS-CoV-2 infection a multicenter prospective cohort study Intensive Care Med2020461089ndash1098
22 NagelMAMahalingamRCohrs RJ GildenD Virus vasculopathy and stroke an under-recognized cause and treatment target Infect Disord Drug Targets 201010105ndash111
23 Subramaniam S Scharrer I Procoagulant activity during viral infections Front Biosci(Landmark Ed) 2018231060ndash1081
24 Hung EC Chim SS Chan PK et al Detection of SARS coronavirus RNA in thecerebrospinal fluid of a patient with severe acute respiratory syndrome Clin Chem2003492108ndash2109
25 Lau KK Yu WC Chu CM Lau ST Sheng B Yuen KY Possible central nervoussystem infection by SARS coronavirus Emerg Infect Dis 200410342ndash344
26 Toledano M Davies NWS Infectious encephalitis mimics and chameleons PractNeurol 201919225ndash237
27 Kim JE Heo JH Kim HO et al Neurological complications during treatment ofMiddle East respiratory syndrome J Clin Neurol 201713227ndash233
28 Li Y Li H Fan R et al Coronavirus infections in the central nervous system andrespiratory tract show distinct features in hospitalized children Intervirology 201659163ndash169
29 Yeh EA Collins A Cohen ME Duffner PK Faden H Detection of coronavirus in thecentral nervous system of a child with acute disseminated encephalomyelitis Pedi-atrics 2004113(pt 1)e73ndashe76
30 Kivisakk P Imitola J Rasmussen S et al Localizing central nervous system immunesurveillance meningeal antigen-presenting cells activate T cells during experimentalautoimmune encephalomyelitis Ann Neurol 200965457ndash469
31 Absinta M Cortese IC Vuolo L et al Leptomeningeal gadolinium enhancementacross the spectrum of chronic neuroinflammatory diseases Neurology 2017881439ndash1444
32 Papatsiros VG Stylianaki I Papakonstantinou G Papaioannou N Christodoulo-poulos G Case report of transmissible gastroenteritis coronavirus infection associatedwith small intestine and brain lesions in piglets Viral Immunol 20193263ndash67
33 Stuckey SL Goh TD Heffernan T Rowan D Hyperintensity in the subarachnoidspace on FLAIR MRI AJR Am J Roentgenol 2007189913ndash921
34 Parpia AS Li Y Chen C Dhar B Crowcroft NS Encephalitis Ontario Canada 2002-2013 Emerg Infect Dis 201622426ndash432
e1882 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
DOI 101212WNL0000000000010112202095e1868-e1882 Published Online before print July 17 2020Neurology
Steacutephane Kremer Franccedilois Lersy Mathieu Anheim et al multicenter study
Neurologic and neuroimaging findings in patients with COVID-19 A retrospective
This information is current as of July 17 2020
ServicesUpdated Information amp
httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullincluding high resolution figures can be found at
References httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullref-list-1
This article cites 30 articles 6 of which you can access for free at
Citations httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullotherarticles
This article has been cited by 3 HighWire-hosted articles
Subspecialty Collections
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmriMRI
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmeningitisMeningitis
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionencephalitisEncephalitis e
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_cerebrovascular_disease_strokAll Cerebrovascular diseaseStrokefollowing collection(s) This article along with others on similar topics appears in the
Permissions amp Licensing
httpwwwneurologyorgaboutabout_the_journalpermissionsits entirety can be found online atInformation about reproducing this article in parts (figurestables) or in
Reprints
httpnneurologyorgsubscribersadvertiseInformation about ordering reprints can be found online
rights reserved Print ISSN 0028-3878 Online ISSN 1526-632X1951 it is now a weekly with 48 issues per year Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology All
reg is the official journal of the American Academy of Neurology Published continuously sinceNeurology
![Page 6: Neurologicandneuroimaging findingsinpatients with COVID-19 · enhancement (17%), and encephalitis (13%) were the most frequent neuroimaging findings. Confusion (53%) was the most](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060813/6091b284d4b0681e5152b42b/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
had elevated immunoglobulin G and 4 had oligoclonal bandsthat were identical in CSF and serum In the ischemic strokegroup 1 patient had a high level of protein
The RT-PCR SARS-CoV-2 analysis was negative in the 20patients who were investigated The analysis was not realizedfor 5 patients 1 with a normal brain MRI 2 with an ischemicstroke 1 with encephalitis and 1 with LME Cultures for otherviruses or bacteria were always negative when performed
Correlation analysisThere were statistically significant differences between thevarious groups concerning age (p = 0007) the presence ofpyramidal tract signs (p = 002) agitation (p = 0009) andrespiratory status (ARDS) (p = 0006) (table 1)
The MCA showed that the ischemic stroke group could bedistinguished from the 3 others which largely overlap (figure 4)Most patients with ischemic stroke (numbers and dots in redon the plot) are located on the same lower-right half of thegraph indicating a commonality of symptoms Those patientscan be overall described as older with no ARDS no oxygenrequirement no confusion no disturbances of consciousnessand a lower death rate The converse is true for the 3 otherdiagnoses that cannot be distinguished Considering eachclinical manifestation separately (figure e-3 available fromDryad doiorg105061dryadw9ghx3fm7) subjects can bedistinguishedmainly on the basis of a global pattern dependingon their oxygen requirement seizure sex headaches history ofautoimmune disease history of seizure age anosmia confu-sion and disturbances of consciousness
DiscussionThis is the first large nationwide cohort of MRIs performed inpatients with COVID-19 with neurologic manifestations
The majority of patients had MRI abnormalities with seriousand various findings beyond the severe respiratory disease(half of the patients had ARDS and 11 died) cerebrovas-cular disease (especially ischemic stroke large artery infarc-tions more frequently than watershed cerebral infarctions)encephalitis (including limbic encephalitis radiologic ADEMCLOCC and radiologic acute hemorrhagic necrotizing en-cephalopathy) and focal or even diffuse LME The hetero-geneity of the imaging abnormalities was underpinned byheterogeneous clinical manifestations ranging from anosmiaageusia or headache to more severe findings such as confu-sion with agitation loss of consciousness and corticospinaltract signs Some correlations were found between clinical andimaging findings allowing the identification of clinicoradio-logic profiles of patients with COVID-19 displaying neuro-logic manifestations
Ischemic stroke was 1 kind of clinicoradiologic phenotype itwas an acute event arising in older patients who more fre-quently had corticospinal tract signs but was less frequentlyTa
ble
2Charac
teristicsofpatients
withCOVID-19withac
ute
isch
emicstroke
(con
tinue
d)
Sex
Age
yRiskfactors
Clinicalpre
senta
tion
Days
from
COVID
-19
resp
irato
rysy
mpto
monse
tto
isch
emic
stro
kesy
mpto
monse
tTr
eatm
entupto
this
timepoint
Arrhythmias(ECG
orech
oca
rdiogr
aphy)
Bra
inMRI
Larg
eve
ssel
occ
lusion
D-dim
ers
(refere
nce
range
lt400
)μgL
M76
mdashConfusion
24Su
pportive
No
WCI
mdash397
7
F92
mdashConfusion
10Su
pportive
No
WCI
mdash98
7
F77
Hyp
ertension
HOS
Lefthem
iplegialeft
homonym
oushem
ianopia
hea
dac
hes
minus2(stroke
prece
ded
resp
iratory
symptoms
by2d)
mdashYe
s(previously
unkn
own)
LAI
P2occlusion
NR
M88
Hyp
ertension
Dyslip
idem
iaDiabetes
mellitus
Atrialfibrilla
tion
HOS
Righthem
iplegiaim
paired
consciousn
ess
minus2(stroke
prece
ded
resp
iratory
symptoms
by2d)
mdashYe
sLA
IProximal
M2
occlusion
NR
Abbreviations
COVID-19=co
ronav
irusdisea
se20
19H
OS=history
ofstroke
IC=intern
alca
rotidarteryL
AI=
largeartery
infarctionN
R=Notrealized
WCI=
watersh
edce
rebralinfarction
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1873
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
Table 3 Characteristics of patients with COVID-19 with meningoencephalitis
Sex Age y Clinical symptoms
Days from COVID-19respiratory symptomonset to brain MRI Treatment up to this time point CSF analysis Imaging findings
F 71 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
22 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
0 celluarr Total protein 057 gL
Miscellaneous encephalitisdiffusionand T2FLAIR hyperintensitiesinvolving supratentorial WM
M 64 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
17 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
40 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 11 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 56 mgL
Miscellaneous encephalitisFLAIRhyperintensity involving both middlecerebellar peduncles
M 56 Impaired consciousnesspathologic wakefulness whensedation was stopped
23 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
1 cellmm3
uarr Total protein 2 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 169 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Radiologic acute hemorrhagicnecrotizing encephalopathy
M 66 Impaired consciousnesspathologic wakefulness whensedation was stopped
34 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
NR Radiologic acute hemorrhagicnecrotizing encephalopathy
M 55 Headachesdizzinessimpairedconsciousness
3 mdash 7 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 056 gLCLOCC
M 56 Headaches 20 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
3 cellsmm3
Total protein 024 gLLeft limbic encephalitis
M 58 Ataxia 21 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
4 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 077 gLLeft limbic encephalitis
M 60 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
13 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
0 cellTotal protein 03 gL
Radiologic ADEM
F 51 Movement disordersagitation 16 mdash 5 cellsuarr Total protein 066 gL
Focal LME
F 59 Headachesdizziness 18 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
NR Focal LME
M 62 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
19 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
0 cellTotal protein 023 gLImmunoglobulin G 33 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Diffuse LME
Continued
e1874Neu
rology
|Vo
lume95N
umber
13|
Septem
ber
292020NeurologyorgN
Copyright
copy2020
American
Academ
yof
Neurology
Unauthorized
reproductionof
thisarticle
isprohibited
Table 3 Characteristics of patients with COVID-19 with meningoencephalitis (continued)
Sex Age y Clinical symptoms
Days from COVID-19respiratory symptomonset to brain MRI Treatment up to this time point CSF analysis Imaging findings
M 78 Agitation 15 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
NR Focal LME
M 72 Impaired consciousnessbilateralpyramidal tract signs
20 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavirHydroxychloroquine
0 cellTotal protein 023 gLImmunoglobulin G 17 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Focal LME
M 61 Impaired consciousnessbilateralpyramidal tract signsconfusionagitation
14 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
1 cellmm3
Total protein 023 gLImmunoglobulin G 17 mgL
Focal LME
M 66 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
22 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
NR Focal LME
F 53 Confusionimpairedconsciousness
29 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
0 cellTotal protein 029 gLImmunoglobulin G 21 mgL
Focal LME
F 64 Bilateral pyramidal tract signs 11 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
2 cellsmm3
Total protein 030 gLImmunoglobulin G 15 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Focal LME
F 77 Bilateral pyramidal syndromeconfusionagitation
30 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavirHydroxychloroquine
1 cellmm3
uarr Total protein 080 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 58 mgL
Diffuse LME
F 81 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
20 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
80 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 062 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 38 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Focal LME
Abbreviations ADEM = Acute disseminated encephalomyelitis CLOCC = cytotoxic lesion of the corpus callosum COVID-19 = coronavirus disease 2019 FLAIR = fluid-attenuated inversion recovery ICU = intensive care unitLME = leptomeningeal enhancement NR = not realized WM = white matter
Neurolo
gyorgN
Neurology
|Volum
e95N
umber
13|
Septem
ber292020
e1875
Copyright
copy2020
American
Academ
yof
Neurology
Unauthorized
reproductionof
thisarticle
isprohibited
requiring oxygen or presenting an ARDS This profile couldbe distinguished from the 2 others LME and encephalitisThe encephalitis profile affected younger patients and seemedto be particularly severe because it was associated with theneed for oxygen ARDS and death
Stroke patients less frequently had ARDS and this result is inagreement with the 6 patients with stroke previously reportedin that only 2 patients were admitted to ICUs16 One mayhypothesize that strokes in patients with COVID-19 could bedue to procoagulant events leading to thrombosis17 ratherthan to the systemic inflammatory process that accompaniesARDS which is also directed against the CNS However thisneeds to be assessed by further studies dedicated to stroke andthrombosis in patients with COVID-19
In our study 17 (27) patients had an acute ischemic strokeas was previously reported with SARS-CoV18 Middle Eastrespiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERS-CoV)19 andSARS-CoV-2111617 and among them 11 had large arteryinfarctions (including 6 proximal artery occlusions 2 cases ofinternal carotid artery dissection or occlusion) and 6 hadwatershed cerebral infarctions For 15 of 17 patients with anischemic stroke the respiratory symptoms related to COVID-19 had begun before this acute event while stroke precededrespiratory symptoms by 2 days for 2 patients
Several mechanisms are likely to be associated It is nowknown that SARS-CoV-2 could directly lead to myocardialinjury promoting cardiac arrhythmias associated with em-bolic events20 Six of our patients had arrhythmias which werepreviously unknown for 3 of them In the same way a severeacute myocardial injury may be associated with a decrease inbrain perfusion and therefore with watershed cerebralinfarctions As previously mentioned it is acknowledged thatviruses particularly SARS-CoV-221 are associated with anincrease of prothrombotic events such as ischemic stroke2223
Thereby viral infections may elevate procoagulant markersleading to thrombosis disseminated intravascular coagulationand hemorrhagic events23 As Beyrouti et al16 recently men-tioned all our patients tested showed elevated D-dimersmarkedly elevated (gt1000 μgL) for 10 of the 11 patientstested
Varicella zoster virus is also associated with direct vascularinvolvement and eventually arteritis promoting ischemicstroke events22 Furthermore the more severe critically illpatients hospitalized in ICUs have probably had hypoxemiaand hypotension leading to brain injuries18
Of the 36 abnormal MRIs 8 diagnoses of encephalitis weremade and LME was described especially on postcontrast T1-weighted and FLAIR in 11 patients either focal (single focus
Figure 1 Leptomeningeal enhancement
Axial T1 (A) before and (B) 5 minutes after contrast axial FLAIR (C) before and (D) immediately after contrast and (E and F) delayed (10 minutes) postcontrastaxial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) weighted MRIs Woman 77 years of age diffuse leptomeningeal linear FLAIR and T1 contrast enhancement(arrows) not visible on precontrast T1 and FLAIR (arrows) but seen better on delayed postcontrast FLAIR weighted MRIs (E and F)
e1876 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
vs multiple foci) or diffuse and preferentially located in theposterior supratentorial regions of the brain
Two main pathophysiologic hypotheses can be advanced toexplain the neuroimaging findings in the inflammatory profilegroup First SARS-CoV-2 may have a neuroinvasive potentialsimilar to other hCoVs because this family of viruses is relatedto each other genetically It is not clear if the virus can infiltratethe CNS with active replication and direct damage to braincells (viral encephalitis) as observed with other viruses suchas herpes simplex virus Likewise viral meningitis due to di-rect infiltration of the virus into the CSF may also be con-sidered because it was previously reported with SARS-CoV-1Indeed SARS-CoV-1 RNA was detected in the CSF of 2patients with seizures2425 A recent case report10 has de-scribed for the first time a case of seizures with the detection ofSARS-CoV-2 RNA in the CSF Similarly leptomeningealinflammation may be present adjacent to subpial corticallesions in the case of viral meningoencephalitis In the case ofviral encephalitis CSF analysis usually demonstrates lym-phocytic pleocytosis26 In addition the CSF protein level istypically elevated in viral encephalitis CSF viral RT-PCR isusually positive but can be negative if done too early This wasnot the case in our series and our results are in accordance
with recently published data that demonstrated an absence ofCSF pleocytosis and negative SARS-CoV-2 RT-PCR (5 of 5patients) but elevated protein level (4 of 5 patients) inpatients presenting cerebral MRI cortical abnormalities13
MRI pictures of viral encephalitis vary with causal pathogenNevertheless viral encephalitis usually involves cerebral GMwith diffusion restriction and can be associated with intrale-sional and diffuse leptomeningeal contrast enhancement Thiswas not the case in our series and did not argue for the directeffect of the virus It is all the more likely that the directdetection of SARS-CoV-2 RNA by RT-PCR was alwaysnegative in all our CSF samples
An alternative hypothesis appears more relevant the neuro-virulence of hCoVs especially MERS-CoV seems to bea consequence of immune-mediated processes1927ndash29 IndeedADEM and Bickerstaff brainstem encephalitis which weredescribed with MERS-CoV18ndash27 are 2 examples of autoim-mune demyelinating diseases resulting from a postinfectious orparainfectious process A recent case report9 has describeda case of acute hemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy (whichis the most severe form of ADEM) associated with COVID-19which strengthens the hypothesis of a predominant immuno-logic mechanism In our cohort we also described 2 cases of
Figure 2 Encephalitis
(A B D) Axial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) and(C) diffusion-weighted MRIs (A) Man 56 years of age lefthippocampus and amygdala FLAIR hyperintensity (B)Woman 71 years of age periventricular and subcorticalwhite matter FLAIR confluent hyperintensities (C) Man 55years of age corpus callosum splenium diffusion hyper-intensity (D) Man 64 years of age FLAIR middle cerebellarpeduncle hyperintensity
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1877
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
limbic encephalitis and 1 case of CLOCC Concerning thelatter no treatment had been started or stopped in previousweeks Thus 75 of encephalitis cases in our cohort (limbicencephalitis CLOCC radiologic ADEM radiologic acutehemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy) are possibly con-sidered immune-mediated diseases Therefore SARS-CoV-2ndashmediated disease is driven largely by immunologic processesand the same mechanisms could explain LME Indeed thearachnoid and pial membranes form the leptomeninges anda significant amount of antigen-presenting cells are present inthe subarachnoid space30 Thus initial immune activationoccurs in the subarachnoid space which is a site for antigenpresentation lymphocyte accumulation and proliferation andantibody production30 All lead to an important local in-flammatory infiltrate with a blood-CSF barrier disruptionwhich can also explain LME Thus LME can be linked toinflammatory or immunologic responses as previously de-scribed in animal models of autoimmune encephalomyelitis31
with some neurotropic viruses such as human T-cell leukemiavirus and HIV31 and in several immune-mediated neurologicdiseases31 Moreover a very similar intracranial pattern hasbeen described in an animal study in piglets affected by gas-troenteritis coronavirus32 Indeed histology demonstrateddiffuse pia matter gliosis with mild congestion of the meningeal
and parenchymal vessels with neuronal degeneration locatedmostly in posterior parietooccipital lobes24 PostcontrastFLAIR is the best sequence to highlight LME but a potentialpitfall is inhalation of increased levels of oxygen by patients whoare intubated which may increase subarachnoid space signalintensity noted on FLAIR images within the basal cisterns andsulcus along the cerebral convexities33 That is why we havechosen in this situation to acquire systematically precontrastand postcontrast FLAIR sequences to avoid misinterpretationof FLAIR hyperintensity within the subarachnoid spaces andnot to misdescribe a meningeal enhancement For our 11patients with LME no precontrast FLAIR signal abnormalitieswere visible in the subarachnoid spaces
Our study has several limitations mainly due to its multicenterand retrospective design First brain MRI protocols were dic-tated by clinical need and the patterns of working could bedifferent among the 11 centers even if neuroradiologists areused to work together Thus 36 of the MRIs were performedwithout administration of gadolinium-based contrast agentsnotably preventing the detection of LME therefore probablyunderestimating it Moreover LMEs are very subtle neuro-imaging findings which need the realization of delayed post-contrast FLAIR sequences which were not done in the vast
Figure 3 Radiologic acute disseminated encephalomyelitis
(A E I) Axial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) (B F J) axial diffusion (B F J) apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC) map and (D H L) postcontrast T1-weighted MRIs Man 60 years of age subcortical periventricular corpus callosum and posterior fossa white matter FLAIR hyperintensities without contrastenhancement (arrows) Some lesions appear hyperintense on diffusion-weightedMRIs with decreased ADC corresponding to cytotoxic edema (stars) Otherlesions present an ADC increase corresponding to vasogenic edema (cross)
e1878 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
majority of the centers Second we did not realize a follow-upMRI and some abnormalities could have appeared duringfollow-up Third outcomes were not available for all patients atthe time of writing Thus the mortality rate is probablyunderestimated in our cohort Fourth although patients withCOVID-19may develop a wide range of neurologic symptomswhich can be associated with ischemic stroke or encephalitis itis difficult to state without a controlled general neurologicpopulation that such events are more frequent in patients withCOVID-19 However it now seems well established thatthrombotic events are particularly frequent in patients withCOVID-1921 Moreover encephalitis which is a rare disorderin the general population34 was surprisingly frequent in ourpopulation
In this large multicentric national cohort most patients withCOVID-19 (56) with neurologic manifestations had brainMRI abnormalities such as ischemic stroke LME and enceph-alitis Because the detection of LME suggests the abnormality ofbrain MRI it would be interesting to realize systematicallypostcontrast FLAIR acquisition in patients with COVID-19
Concerning the cases of encephalitis and LME even if a directviral origin cannot be eliminated the pathophysiology of braindamage related to SARS-COV-2 seems rather to involve aninflammatory or autoimmune response The knowledge ofthe various clinicoradiologic manifestations of COVID-19could be helpful for the best care of the patients and ourunderstanding of the disease In addition to SARS cytokine
Figure 4 Multiple correspondence analysis
The ischemic stroke group (red) can be distinguished from the 3 others which largely overlapMost patients with ischemic stroke (numbers and dots in red onthe plot) are located on the same lower-right half of the graph indicating a commonality of symptoms Diag 1 (black) = normal brain MRI Diag 2 (red) =ischemic stroke Diag 3 (green) = encephalitis Diag 4 (blue) = leptomeningeal enhancement
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1879
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
storm syndrome and heart failure brain injuries may con-tribute to increased mortality This highlights the importanceof neurologic evaluation especially for patients hospitalized inICU with clinical deterioration or worsening of their symp-toms which can be associated with an acute neurologic event
AcknowledgmentThe authors thank Marie Cecile Henry Feugeas for her workin data acquisition for this study
Study fundingNo targeted funding reported
DisclosureThe authors report no disclosures relevant to the manuscriptGo to NeurologyorgN for full disclosures
Publication historyReceived by Neurology April 28 2020 Accepted in final formJune 9 2020
Appendix Authors
Name Location Contribution
StephaneKremer MDPhD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study acquisition of datainterpreted the data draftedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Franccedilois LersyMD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study acquisition of datainterpreted the data draftedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MathieuAnheim MDPhD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
Hamid MerdjiMD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MalekaSchenck MD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
HeleneOesterle MD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FedericoBolognini MD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Julien MessieMD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Antoine KhalilMD PhD
Bichat Hospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
AugustinGaudemer MD
Bichat Hospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Sophie CarreMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Manel AllegMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Claire LecocqMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
EmmanuelleSchmitt MD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ReneAnxionnatMD PhD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Franccedilois ZhuMD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Lavinia JagerMD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Patrick NesserMD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Yannick TallaMba MD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GhaziHmeydia MD
Saint-Anne hospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
JosephBenzakounMD
Saint-Anne hospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
CatherineOppenheimMD PhD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jean-ChristopheFerre MD PhD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Adel MaamarMD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
BeatriceCarsin-NicolMD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Pierre-OlivierComby MD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FredericRicolfi MDPhD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
PierreThouant MD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Claire BoutetMD PhD
University hospital ofSaint-Etienne France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
e1880 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
References1 Chen N Zhou M Dong X et al Epidemiological and clinical characteristics of 99
cases of 2019 novel coronavirus pneumonia in Wuhan China a descriptive studyLancet 2020395507ndash513
2 Huang C Wang Y Li X et al Clinical features of patients infected with 2019 novelcoronavirus in Wuhan China Lancet 2020395497ndash506
3 Glass WG Subbarao K Murphy B Murphy PM Mechanisms of host defense fol-lowing severe acute respiratory syndrome‐coronavirus (SARS‐CoV) pulmonary in-fection of mice J Immunol 20041734030ndash4039
4 Li K Wohlford‐Lenane C Perlman S et al Middle East respiratory syndromecoronavirus causes multiple organ damage and lethal disease in mice transgenic forhuman dipeptidyl peptidase 4 J Infect Dis 2016213712ndash722
5 Arbour N Day R Newcombe J Talbot PJ Neuroinvasion by human respiratorycoronaviruses J Virol 2000748913ndash8921
6 Desforges M Le Coupanec A Stodola JK Meessen-Pinard M Talbot PJ Humancoronaviruses viral and cellular factors involved in neuroinvasiveness and neuro-pathogenesis Virus Res 2014194145ndash158
7 Desforges M Le Coupanec A Dubeau P et al Human coronaviruses and otherrespiratory viruses underestimated opportunistic pathogens of the central nervoussystem Viruses 201912E14
8 Bohmwald K Galvez NMS Rıos M Kalergis AM Neurologic alterations due torespiratory virus infections Front Cell Neurosci 201812386
9 Poyiadji N Shahin G Noujaim D Stone M Patel S Griffith B COVID-19-associatedacute hemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy CT and MRI features Radiology2020201187
10 Moriguchi T Harii N Goto J et al A first case of meningitisencephalitis associatedwith SARS-coronavirus-2 Int J Infect Dis 20209455ndash58
11 Mao L Jin H Wang M et al Neurologic manifestations of hospitalized patients withcoronavirus disease 2019 in Wuhan China JAMA Neurol 2020771ndash9
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Xavier FabreMD
Hospital of RoanneFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GeraudForestier MD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Isaure deBeaurepaireMD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GregoireBornet MD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Hubert DesalMD PhD
University Hospital ofNantes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GregoireBoulouis MD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jerome BergeMD
University Hospital ofBordeaux France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ApollineKazemi MD
University Hospital ofLille France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
NadyaPyatigorskayaMD
Pitie-SalpetriereHospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
AugustinLecler MD
Foundation ARothschild Paris
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
SuzanaSaleme MD
University Hospital ofLimoges France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Myriam Edjlali-Goujon MD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
BasileKerleroux MD
University Hospital ofTours France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jean-MarcConstans MDPhD
University Hospital ofAmiens France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Pierre-EmmanuelZorn PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the acquisitionof data
MurielMatthieu PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the acquisitionof data
Seyyid BalogluMD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of datarevised the manuscriptfor intellectualcontent
Franccedilois-DanielArdellier MD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ThibaultWillaume MD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of datarevised the manuscriptfor intellectualcontent
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Jean-ChristopheBrisset PhD
French Observatoryof Multiple SclerosisLyon France
Interpretation of the datarevised the manuscript forintellectual content
SophieCaillard MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
OlivierCollange MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Paul MichelMertes MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FrancisSchneider MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Samira Fafi-KremerPharmD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MickaelOhana MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FerhatMeziani MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Nicolas MeyerMD PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the analysis andinterpretation of the data
Julie HelmsMD PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
FranccediloisCotton MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1881
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
12 Helms J Kremer S Merdji H et al Neurologic features in severe SARS-CoV-2infection N Engl J Med 20203822268ndash2270
13 Kandemirli SG Dogan L Sarikaya ZT et al Brain MRI findings in patients in theintensive care unit with COVID-19 infection Radiology Epub 2020 May 8
14 Ferguson ND Fan E Camporota L et al The Berlin definition of ARDS an expandedrationale justification and supplementary material Intensive Care Med 2012381573ndash1582
15 Starkey J Kobayashi N Numaguchi Y Moritani T Cytotoxic lesions of the corpuscallosum that show restricted diffusion mechanisms causes and manifestationsRadiographics 201737562ndash576
16 Beyrouti R Adams ME Benjamin L et al Characteristics of ischaemic stroke asso-ciated with COVID-19 J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry Epub 2020 Apr 30
17 Hess DC Eldahshan W Rutkowski E COVID-19-related stroke Transl Stroke Res202011322ndash325
18 Umapathi T Kor AC Venketasubramanian N et al Large artery ischaemic stroke insevere acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) J Neurol 20042511227ndash1231
19 Arabi YM Harthi A Hussein J et al Severe neurologic syndrome associated withMiddle East respiratory syndrome corona virus (MERS-CoV) Infection 201543495ndash501
20 Guo T Fan Y ChenM et al Cardiovascular implications of fatal outcomes of patientswith coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) JAMA Cardiol Epub 2020 Mar 27
21 Helms J Tacquard C Severac F et al High risk of thrombosis in patients in severeSARS-CoV-2 infection a multicenter prospective cohort study Intensive Care Med2020461089ndash1098
22 NagelMAMahalingamRCohrs RJ GildenD Virus vasculopathy and stroke an under-recognized cause and treatment target Infect Disord Drug Targets 201010105ndash111
23 Subramaniam S Scharrer I Procoagulant activity during viral infections Front Biosci(Landmark Ed) 2018231060ndash1081
24 Hung EC Chim SS Chan PK et al Detection of SARS coronavirus RNA in thecerebrospinal fluid of a patient with severe acute respiratory syndrome Clin Chem2003492108ndash2109
25 Lau KK Yu WC Chu CM Lau ST Sheng B Yuen KY Possible central nervoussystem infection by SARS coronavirus Emerg Infect Dis 200410342ndash344
26 Toledano M Davies NWS Infectious encephalitis mimics and chameleons PractNeurol 201919225ndash237
27 Kim JE Heo JH Kim HO et al Neurological complications during treatment ofMiddle East respiratory syndrome J Clin Neurol 201713227ndash233
28 Li Y Li H Fan R et al Coronavirus infections in the central nervous system andrespiratory tract show distinct features in hospitalized children Intervirology 201659163ndash169
29 Yeh EA Collins A Cohen ME Duffner PK Faden H Detection of coronavirus in thecentral nervous system of a child with acute disseminated encephalomyelitis Pedi-atrics 2004113(pt 1)e73ndashe76
30 Kivisakk P Imitola J Rasmussen S et al Localizing central nervous system immunesurveillance meningeal antigen-presenting cells activate T cells during experimentalautoimmune encephalomyelitis Ann Neurol 200965457ndash469
31 Absinta M Cortese IC Vuolo L et al Leptomeningeal gadolinium enhancementacross the spectrum of chronic neuroinflammatory diseases Neurology 2017881439ndash1444
32 Papatsiros VG Stylianaki I Papakonstantinou G Papaioannou N Christodoulo-poulos G Case report of transmissible gastroenteritis coronavirus infection associatedwith small intestine and brain lesions in piglets Viral Immunol 20193263ndash67
33 Stuckey SL Goh TD Heffernan T Rowan D Hyperintensity in the subarachnoidspace on FLAIR MRI AJR Am J Roentgenol 2007189913ndash921
34 Parpia AS Li Y Chen C Dhar B Crowcroft NS Encephalitis Ontario Canada 2002-2013 Emerg Infect Dis 201622426ndash432
e1882 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
DOI 101212WNL0000000000010112202095e1868-e1882 Published Online before print July 17 2020Neurology
Steacutephane Kremer Franccedilois Lersy Mathieu Anheim et al multicenter study
Neurologic and neuroimaging findings in patients with COVID-19 A retrospective
This information is current as of July 17 2020
ServicesUpdated Information amp
httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullincluding high resolution figures can be found at
References httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullref-list-1
This article cites 30 articles 6 of which you can access for free at
Citations httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullotherarticles
This article has been cited by 3 HighWire-hosted articles
Subspecialty Collections
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmriMRI
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmeningitisMeningitis
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionencephalitisEncephalitis e
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_cerebrovascular_disease_strokAll Cerebrovascular diseaseStrokefollowing collection(s) This article along with others on similar topics appears in the
Permissions amp Licensing
httpwwwneurologyorgaboutabout_the_journalpermissionsits entirety can be found online atInformation about reproducing this article in parts (figurestables) or in
Reprints
httpnneurologyorgsubscribersadvertiseInformation about ordering reprints can be found online
rights reserved Print ISSN 0028-3878 Online ISSN 1526-632X1951 it is now a weekly with 48 issues per year Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology All
reg is the official journal of the American Academy of Neurology Published continuously sinceNeurology
![Page 7: Neurologicandneuroimaging findingsinpatients with COVID-19 · enhancement (17%), and encephalitis (13%) were the most frequent neuroimaging findings. Confusion (53%) was the most](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060813/6091b284d4b0681e5152b42b/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Table 3 Characteristics of patients with COVID-19 with meningoencephalitis
Sex Age y Clinical symptoms
Days from COVID-19respiratory symptomonset to brain MRI Treatment up to this time point CSF analysis Imaging findings
F 71 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
22 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
0 celluarr Total protein 057 gL
Miscellaneous encephalitisdiffusionand T2FLAIR hyperintensitiesinvolving supratentorial WM
M 64 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
17 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
40 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 11 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 56 mgL
Miscellaneous encephalitisFLAIRhyperintensity involving both middlecerebellar peduncles
M 56 Impaired consciousnesspathologic wakefulness whensedation was stopped
23 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
1 cellmm3
uarr Total protein 2 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 169 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Radiologic acute hemorrhagicnecrotizing encephalopathy
M 66 Impaired consciousnesspathologic wakefulness whensedation was stopped
34 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
NR Radiologic acute hemorrhagicnecrotizing encephalopathy
M 55 Headachesdizzinessimpairedconsciousness
3 mdash 7 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 056 gLCLOCC
M 56 Headaches 20 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
3 cellsmm3
Total protein 024 gLLeft limbic encephalitis
M 58 Ataxia 21 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
4 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 077 gLLeft limbic encephalitis
M 60 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
13 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
0 cellTotal protein 03 gL
Radiologic ADEM
F 51 Movement disordersagitation 16 mdash 5 cellsuarr Total protein 066 gL
Focal LME
F 59 Headachesdizziness 18 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
NR Focal LME
M 62 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
19 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
0 cellTotal protein 023 gLImmunoglobulin G 33 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Diffuse LME
Continued
e1874Neu
rology
|Vo
lume95N
umber
13|
Septem
ber
292020NeurologyorgN
Copyright
copy2020
American
Academ
yof
Neurology
Unauthorized
reproductionof
thisarticle
isprohibited
Table 3 Characteristics of patients with COVID-19 with meningoencephalitis (continued)
Sex Age y Clinical symptoms
Days from COVID-19respiratory symptomonset to brain MRI Treatment up to this time point CSF analysis Imaging findings
M 78 Agitation 15 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
NR Focal LME
M 72 Impaired consciousnessbilateralpyramidal tract signs
20 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavirHydroxychloroquine
0 cellTotal protein 023 gLImmunoglobulin G 17 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Focal LME
M 61 Impaired consciousnessbilateralpyramidal tract signsconfusionagitation
14 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
1 cellmm3
Total protein 023 gLImmunoglobulin G 17 mgL
Focal LME
M 66 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
22 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
NR Focal LME
F 53 Confusionimpairedconsciousness
29 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
0 cellTotal protein 029 gLImmunoglobulin G 21 mgL
Focal LME
F 64 Bilateral pyramidal tract signs 11 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
2 cellsmm3
Total protein 030 gLImmunoglobulin G 15 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Focal LME
F 77 Bilateral pyramidal syndromeconfusionagitation
30 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavirHydroxychloroquine
1 cellmm3
uarr Total protein 080 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 58 mgL
Diffuse LME
F 81 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
20 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
80 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 062 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 38 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Focal LME
Abbreviations ADEM = Acute disseminated encephalomyelitis CLOCC = cytotoxic lesion of the corpus callosum COVID-19 = coronavirus disease 2019 FLAIR = fluid-attenuated inversion recovery ICU = intensive care unitLME = leptomeningeal enhancement NR = not realized WM = white matter
Neurolo
gyorgN
Neurology
|Volum
e95N
umber
13|
Septem
ber292020
e1875
Copyright
copy2020
American
Academ
yof
Neurology
Unauthorized
reproductionof
thisarticle
isprohibited
requiring oxygen or presenting an ARDS This profile couldbe distinguished from the 2 others LME and encephalitisThe encephalitis profile affected younger patients and seemedto be particularly severe because it was associated with theneed for oxygen ARDS and death
Stroke patients less frequently had ARDS and this result is inagreement with the 6 patients with stroke previously reportedin that only 2 patients were admitted to ICUs16 One mayhypothesize that strokes in patients with COVID-19 could bedue to procoagulant events leading to thrombosis17 ratherthan to the systemic inflammatory process that accompaniesARDS which is also directed against the CNS However thisneeds to be assessed by further studies dedicated to stroke andthrombosis in patients with COVID-19
In our study 17 (27) patients had an acute ischemic strokeas was previously reported with SARS-CoV18 Middle Eastrespiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERS-CoV)19 andSARS-CoV-2111617 and among them 11 had large arteryinfarctions (including 6 proximal artery occlusions 2 cases ofinternal carotid artery dissection or occlusion) and 6 hadwatershed cerebral infarctions For 15 of 17 patients with anischemic stroke the respiratory symptoms related to COVID-19 had begun before this acute event while stroke precededrespiratory symptoms by 2 days for 2 patients
Several mechanisms are likely to be associated It is nowknown that SARS-CoV-2 could directly lead to myocardialinjury promoting cardiac arrhythmias associated with em-bolic events20 Six of our patients had arrhythmias which werepreviously unknown for 3 of them In the same way a severeacute myocardial injury may be associated with a decrease inbrain perfusion and therefore with watershed cerebralinfarctions As previously mentioned it is acknowledged thatviruses particularly SARS-CoV-221 are associated with anincrease of prothrombotic events such as ischemic stroke2223
Thereby viral infections may elevate procoagulant markersleading to thrombosis disseminated intravascular coagulationand hemorrhagic events23 As Beyrouti et al16 recently men-tioned all our patients tested showed elevated D-dimersmarkedly elevated (gt1000 μgL) for 10 of the 11 patientstested
Varicella zoster virus is also associated with direct vascularinvolvement and eventually arteritis promoting ischemicstroke events22 Furthermore the more severe critically illpatients hospitalized in ICUs have probably had hypoxemiaand hypotension leading to brain injuries18
Of the 36 abnormal MRIs 8 diagnoses of encephalitis weremade and LME was described especially on postcontrast T1-weighted and FLAIR in 11 patients either focal (single focus
Figure 1 Leptomeningeal enhancement
Axial T1 (A) before and (B) 5 minutes after contrast axial FLAIR (C) before and (D) immediately after contrast and (E and F) delayed (10 minutes) postcontrastaxial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) weighted MRIs Woman 77 years of age diffuse leptomeningeal linear FLAIR and T1 contrast enhancement(arrows) not visible on precontrast T1 and FLAIR (arrows) but seen better on delayed postcontrast FLAIR weighted MRIs (E and F)
e1876 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
vs multiple foci) or diffuse and preferentially located in theposterior supratentorial regions of the brain
Two main pathophysiologic hypotheses can be advanced toexplain the neuroimaging findings in the inflammatory profilegroup First SARS-CoV-2 may have a neuroinvasive potentialsimilar to other hCoVs because this family of viruses is relatedto each other genetically It is not clear if the virus can infiltratethe CNS with active replication and direct damage to braincells (viral encephalitis) as observed with other viruses suchas herpes simplex virus Likewise viral meningitis due to di-rect infiltration of the virus into the CSF may also be con-sidered because it was previously reported with SARS-CoV-1Indeed SARS-CoV-1 RNA was detected in the CSF of 2patients with seizures2425 A recent case report10 has de-scribed for the first time a case of seizures with the detection ofSARS-CoV-2 RNA in the CSF Similarly leptomeningealinflammation may be present adjacent to subpial corticallesions in the case of viral meningoencephalitis In the case ofviral encephalitis CSF analysis usually demonstrates lym-phocytic pleocytosis26 In addition the CSF protein level istypically elevated in viral encephalitis CSF viral RT-PCR isusually positive but can be negative if done too early This wasnot the case in our series and our results are in accordance
with recently published data that demonstrated an absence ofCSF pleocytosis and negative SARS-CoV-2 RT-PCR (5 of 5patients) but elevated protein level (4 of 5 patients) inpatients presenting cerebral MRI cortical abnormalities13
MRI pictures of viral encephalitis vary with causal pathogenNevertheless viral encephalitis usually involves cerebral GMwith diffusion restriction and can be associated with intrale-sional and diffuse leptomeningeal contrast enhancement Thiswas not the case in our series and did not argue for the directeffect of the virus It is all the more likely that the directdetection of SARS-CoV-2 RNA by RT-PCR was alwaysnegative in all our CSF samples
An alternative hypothesis appears more relevant the neuro-virulence of hCoVs especially MERS-CoV seems to bea consequence of immune-mediated processes1927ndash29 IndeedADEM and Bickerstaff brainstem encephalitis which weredescribed with MERS-CoV18ndash27 are 2 examples of autoim-mune demyelinating diseases resulting from a postinfectious orparainfectious process A recent case report9 has describeda case of acute hemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy (whichis the most severe form of ADEM) associated with COVID-19which strengthens the hypothesis of a predominant immuno-logic mechanism In our cohort we also described 2 cases of
Figure 2 Encephalitis
(A B D) Axial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) and(C) diffusion-weighted MRIs (A) Man 56 years of age lefthippocampus and amygdala FLAIR hyperintensity (B)Woman 71 years of age periventricular and subcorticalwhite matter FLAIR confluent hyperintensities (C) Man 55years of age corpus callosum splenium diffusion hyper-intensity (D) Man 64 years of age FLAIR middle cerebellarpeduncle hyperintensity
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1877
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
limbic encephalitis and 1 case of CLOCC Concerning thelatter no treatment had been started or stopped in previousweeks Thus 75 of encephalitis cases in our cohort (limbicencephalitis CLOCC radiologic ADEM radiologic acutehemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy) are possibly con-sidered immune-mediated diseases Therefore SARS-CoV-2ndashmediated disease is driven largely by immunologic processesand the same mechanisms could explain LME Indeed thearachnoid and pial membranes form the leptomeninges anda significant amount of antigen-presenting cells are present inthe subarachnoid space30 Thus initial immune activationoccurs in the subarachnoid space which is a site for antigenpresentation lymphocyte accumulation and proliferation andantibody production30 All lead to an important local in-flammatory infiltrate with a blood-CSF barrier disruptionwhich can also explain LME Thus LME can be linked toinflammatory or immunologic responses as previously de-scribed in animal models of autoimmune encephalomyelitis31
with some neurotropic viruses such as human T-cell leukemiavirus and HIV31 and in several immune-mediated neurologicdiseases31 Moreover a very similar intracranial pattern hasbeen described in an animal study in piglets affected by gas-troenteritis coronavirus32 Indeed histology demonstrateddiffuse pia matter gliosis with mild congestion of the meningeal
and parenchymal vessels with neuronal degeneration locatedmostly in posterior parietooccipital lobes24 PostcontrastFLAIR is the best sequence to highlight LME but a potentialpitfall is inhalation of increased levels of oxygen by patients whoare intubated which may increase subarachnoid space signalintensity noted on FLAIR images within the basal cisterns andsulcus along the cerebral convexities33 That is why we havechosen in this situation to acquire systematically precontrastand postcontrast FLAIR sequences to avoid misinterpretationof FLAIR hyperintensity within the subarachnoid spaces andnot to misdescribe a meningeal enhancement For our 11patients with LME no precontrast FLAIR signal abnormalitieswere visible in the subarachnoid spaces
Our study has several limitations mainly due to its multicenterand retrospective design First brain MRI protocols were dic-tated by clinical need and the patterns of working could bedifferent among the 11 centers even if neuroradiologists areused to work together Thus 36 of the MRIs were performedwithout administration of gadolinium-based contrast agentsnotably preventing the detection of LME therefore probablyunderestimating it Moreover LMEs are very subtle neuro-imaging findings which need the realization of delayed post-contrast FLAIR sequences which were not done in the vast
Figure 3 Radiologic acute disseminated encephalomyelitis
(A E I) Axial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) (B F J) axial diffusion (B F J) apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC) map and (D H L) postcontrast T1-weighted MRIs Man 60 years of age subcortical periventricular corpus callosum and posterior fossa white matter FLAIR hyperintensities without contrastenhancement (arrows) Some lesions appear hyperintense on diffusion-weightedMRIs with decreased ADC corresponding to cytotoxic edema (stars) Otherlesions present an ADC increase corresponding to vasogenic edema (cross)
e1878 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
majority of the centers Second we did not realize a follow-upMRI and some abnormalities could have appeared duringfollow-up Third outcomes were not available for all patients atthe time of writing Thus the mortality rate is probablyunderestimated in our cohort Fourth although patients withCOVID-19may develop a wide range of neurologic symptomswhich can be associated with ischemic stroke or encephalitis itis difficult to state without a controlled general neurologicpopulation that such events are more frequent in patients withCOVID-19 However it now seems well established thatthrombotic events are particularly frequent in patients withCOVID-1921 Moreover encephalitis which is a rare disorderin the general population34 was surprisingly frequent in ourpopulation
In this large multicentric national cohort most patients withCOVID-19 (56) with neurologic manifestations had brainMRI abnormalities such as ischemic stroke LME and enceph-alitis Because the detection of LME suggests the abnormality ofbrain MRI it would be interesting to realize systematicallypostcontrast FLAIR acquisition in patients with COVID-19
Concerning the cases of encephalitis and LME even if a directviral origin cannot be eliminated the pathophysiology of braindamage related to SARS-COV-2 seems rather to involve aninflammatory or autoimmune response The knowledge ofthe various clinicoradiologic manifestations of COVID-19could be helpful for the best care of the patients and ourunderstanding of the disease In addition to SARS cytokine
Figure 4 Multiple correspondence analysis
The ischemic stroke group (red) can be distinguished from the 3 others which largely overlapMost patients with ischemic stroke (numbers and dots in red onthe plot) are located on the same lower-right half of the graph indicating a commonality of symptoms Diag 1 (black) = normal brain MRI Diag 2 (red) =ischemic stroke Diag 3 (green) = encephalitis Diag 4 (blue) = leptomeningeal enhancement
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1879
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
storm syndrome and heart failure brain injuries may con-tribute to increased mortality This highlights the importanceof neurologic evaluation especially for patients hospitalized inICU with clinical deterioration or worsening of their symp-toms which can be associated with an acute neurologic event
AcknowledgmentThe authors thank Marie Cecile Henry Feugeas for her workin data acquisition for this study
Study fundingNo targeted funding reported
DisclosureThe authors report no disclosures relevant to the manuscriptGo to NeurologyorgN for full disclosures
Publication historyReceived by Neurology April 28 2020 Accepted in final formJune 9 2020
Appendix Authors
Name Location Contribution
StephaneKremer MDPhD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study acquisition of datainterpreted the data draftedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Franccedilois LersyMD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study acquisition of datainterpreted the data draftedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MathieuAnheim MDPhD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
Hamid MerdjiMD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MalekaSchenck MD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
HeleneOesterle MD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FedericoBolognini MD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Julien MessieMD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Antoine KhalilMD PhD
Bichat Hospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
AugustinGaudemer MD
Bichat Hospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Sophie CarreMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Manel AllegMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Claire LecocqMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
EmmanuelleSchmitt MD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ReneAnxionnatMD PhD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Franccedilois ZhuMD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Lavinia JagerMD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Patrick NesserMD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Yannick TallaMba MD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GhaziHmeydia MD
Saint-Anne hospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
JosephBenzakounMD
Saint-Anne hospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
CatherineOppenheimMD PhD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jean-ChristopheFerre MD PhD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Adel MaamarMD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
BeatriceCarsin-NicolMD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Pierre-OlivierComby MD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FredericRicolfi MDPhD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
PierreThouant MD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Claire BoutetMD PhD
University hospital ofSaint-Etienne France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
e1880 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
References1 Chen N Zhou M Dong X et al Epidemiological and clinical characteristics of 99
cases of 2019 novel coronavirus pneumonia in Wuhan China a descriptive studyLancet 2020395507ndash513
2 Huang C Wang Y Li X et al Clinical features of patients infected with 2019 novelcoronavirus in Wuhan China Lancet 2020395497ndash506
3 Glass WG Subbarao K Murphy B Murphy PM Mechanisms of host defense fol-lowing severe acute respiratory syndrome‐coronavirus (SARS‐CoV) pulmonary in-fection of mice J Immunol 20041734030ndash4039
4 Li K Wohlford‐Lenane C Perlman S et al Middle East respiratory syndromecoronavirus causes multiple organ damage and lethal disease in mice transgenic forhuman dipeptidyl peptidase 4 J Infect Dis 2016213712ndash722
5 Arbour N Day R Newcombe J Talbot PJ Neuroinvasion by human respiratorycoronaviruses J Virol 2000748913ndash8921
6 Desforges M Le Coupanec A Stodola JK Meessen-Pinard M Talbot PJ Humancoronaviruses viral and cellular factors involved in neuroinvasiveness and neuro-pathogenesis Virus Res 2014194145ndash158
7 Desforges M Le Coupanec A Dubeau P et al Human coronaviruses and otherrespiratory viruses underestimated opportunistic pathogens of the central nervoussystem Viruses 201912E14
8 Bohmwald K Galvez NMS Rıos M Kalergis AM Neurologic alterations due torespiratory virus infections Front Cell Neurosci 201812386
9 Poyiadji N Shahin G Noujaim D Stone M Patel S Griffith B COVID-19-associatedacute hemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy CT and MRI features Radiology2020201187
10 Moriguchi T Harii N Goto J et al A first case of meningitisencephalitis associatedwith SARS-coronavirus-2 Int J Infect Dis 20209455ndash58
11 Mao L Jin H Wang M et al Neurologic manifestations of hospitalized patients withcoronavirus disease 2019 in Wuhan China JAMA Neurol 2020771ndash9
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Xavier FabreMD
Hospital of RoanneFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GeraudForestier MD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Isaure deBeaurepaireMD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GregoireBornet MD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Hubert DesalMD PhD
University Hospital ofNantes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GregoireBoulouis MD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jerome BergeMD
University Hospital ofBordeaux France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ApollineKazemi MD
University Hospital ofLille France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
NadyaPyatigorskayaMD
Pitie-SalpetriereHospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
AugustinLecler MD
Foundation ARothschild Paris
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
SuzanaSaleme MD
University Hospital ofLimoges France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Myriam Edjlali-Goujon MD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
BasileKerleroux MD
University Hospital ofTours France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jean-MarcConstans MDPhD
University Hospital ofAmiens France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Pierre-EmmanuelZorn PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the acquisitionof data
MurielMatthieu PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the acquisitionof data
Seyyid BalogluMD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of datarevised the manuscriptfor intellectualcontent
Franccedilois-DanielArdellier MD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ThibaultWillaume MD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of datarevised the manuscriptfor intellectualcontent
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Jean-ChristopheBrisset PhD
French Observatoryof Multiple SclerosisLyon France
Interpretation of the datarevised the manuscript forintellectual content
SophieCaillard MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
OlivierCollange MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Paul MichelMertes MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FrancisSchneider MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Samira Fafi-KremerPharmD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MickaelOhana MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FerhatMeziani MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Nicolas MeyerMD PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the analysis andinterpretation of the data
Julie HelmsMD PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
FranccediloisCotton MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1881
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
12 Helms J Kremer S Merdji H et al Neurologic features in severe SARS-CoV-2infection N Engl J Med 20203822268ndash2270
13 Kandemirli SG Dogan L Sarikaya ZT et al Brain MRI findings in patients in theintensive care unit with COVID-19 infection Radiology Epub 2020 May 8
14 Ferguson ND Fan E Camporota L et al The Berlin definition of ARDS an expandedrationale justification and supplementary material Intensive Care Med 2012381573ndash1582
15 Starkey J Kobayashi N Numaguchi Y Moritani T Cytotoxic lesions of the corpuscallosum that show restricted diffusion mechanisms causes and manifestationsRadiographics 201737562ndash576
16 Beyrouti R Adams ME Benjamin L et al Characteristics of ischaemic stroke asso-ciated with COVID-19 J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry Epub 2020 Apr 30
17 Hess DC Eldahshan W Rutkowski E COVID-19-related stroke Transl Stroke Res202011322ndash325
18 Umapathi T Kor AC Venketasubramanian N et al Large artery ischaemic stroke insevere acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) J Neurol 20042511227ndash1231
19 Arabi YM Harthi A Hussein J et al Severe neurologic syndrome associated withMiddle East respiratory syndrome corona virus (MERS-CoV) Infection 201543495ndash501
20 Guo T Fan Y ChenM et al Cardiovascular implications of fatal outcomes of patientswith coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) JAMA Cardiol Epub 2020 Mar 27
21 Helms J Tacquard C Severac F et al High risk of thrombosis in patients in severeSARS-CoV-2 infection a multicenter prospective cohort study Intensive Care Med2020461089ndash1098
22 NagelMAMahalingamRCohrs RJ GildenD Virus vasculopathy and stroke an under-recognized cause and treatment target Infect Disord Drug Targets 201010105ndash111
23 Subramaniam S Scharrer I Procoagulant activity during viral infections Front Biosci(Landmark Ed) 2018231060ndash1081
24 Hung EC Chim SS Chan PK et al Detection of SARS coronavirus RNA in thecerebrospinal fluid of a patient with severe acute respiratory syndrome Clin Chem2003492108ndash2109
25 Lau KK Yu WC Chu CM Lau ST Sheng B Yuen KY Possible central nervoussystem infection by SARS coronavirus Emerg Infect Dis 200410342ndash344
26 Toledano M Davies NWS Infectious encephalitis mimics and chameleons PractNeurol 201919225ndash237
27 Kim JE Heo JH Kim HO et al Neurological complications during treatment ofMiddle East respiratory syndrome J Clin Neurol 201713227ndash233
28 Li Y Li H Fan R et al Coronavirus infections in the central nervous system andrespiratory tract show distinct features in hospitalized children Intervirology 201659163ndash169
29 Yeh EA Collins A Cohen ME Duffner PK Faden H Detection of coronavirus in thecentral nervous system of a child with acute disseminated encephalomyelitis Pedi-atrics 2004113(pt 1)e73ndashe76
30 Kivisakk P Imitola J Rasmussen S et al Localizing central nervous system immunesurveillance meningeal antigen-presenting cells activate T cells during experimentalautoimmune encephalomyelitis Ann Neurol 200965457ndash469
31 Absinta M Cortese IC Vuolo L et al Leptomeningeal gadolinium enhancementacross the spectrum of chronic neuroinflammatory diseases Neurology 2017881439ndash1444
32 Papatsiros VG Stylianaki I Papakonstantinou G Papaioannou N Christodoulo-poulos G Case report of transmissible gastroenteritis coronavirus infection associatedwith small intestine and brain lesions in piglets Viral Immunol 20193263ndash67
33 Stuckey SL Goh TD Heffernan T Rowan D Hyperintensity in the subarachnoidspace on FLAIR MRI AJR Am J Roentgenol 2007189913ndash921
34 Parpia AS Li Y Chen C Dhar B Crowcroft NS Encephalitis Ontario Canada 2002-2013 Emerg Infect Dis 201622426ndash432
e1882 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
DOI 101212WNL0000000000010112202095e1868-e1882 Published Online before print July 17 2020Neurology
Steacutephane Kremer Franccedilois Lersy Mathieu Anheim et al multicenter study
Neurologic and neuroimaging findings in patients with COVID-19 A retrospective
This information is current as of July 17 2020
ServicesUpdated Information amp
httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullincluding high resolution figures can be found at
References httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullref-list-1
This article cites 30 articles 6 of which you can access for free at
Citations httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullotherarticles
This article has been cited by 3 HighWire-hosted articles
Subspecialty Collections
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmriMRI
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmeningitisMeningitis
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionencephalitisEncephalitis e
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_cerebrovascular_disease_strokAll Cerebrovascular diseaseStrokefollowing collection(s) This article along with others on similar topics appears in the
Permissions amp Licensing
httpwwwneurologyorgaboutabout_the_journalpermissionsits entirety can be found online atInformation about reproducing this article in parts (figurestables) or in
Reprints
httpnneurologyorgsubscribersadvertiseInformation about ordering reprints can be found online
rights reserved Print ISSN 0028-3878 Online ISSN 1526-632X1951 it is now a weekly with 48 issues per year Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology All
reg is the official journal of the American Academy of Neurology Published continuously sinceNeurology
![Page 8: Neurologicandneuroimaging findingsinpatients with COVID-19 · enhancement (17%), and encephalitis (13%) were the most frequent neuroimaging findings. Confusion (53%) was the most](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060813/6091b284d4b0681e5152b42b/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Table 3 Characteristics of patients with COVID-19 with meningoencephalitis (continued)
Sex Age y Clinical symptoms
Days from COVID-19respiratory symptomonset to brain MRI Treatment up to this time point CSF analysis Imaging findings
M 78 Agitation 15 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
NR Focal LME
M 72 Impaired consciousnessbilateralpyramidal tract signs
20 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavirHydroxychloroquine
0 cellTotal protein 023 gLImmunoglobulin G 17 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Focal LME
M 61 Impaired consciousnessbilateralpyramidal tract signsconfusionagitation
14 Oxygen therapyAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
1 cellmm3
Total protein 023 gLImmunoglobulin G 17 mgL
Focal LME
M 66 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
22 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
NR Focal LME
F 53 Confusionimpairedconsciousness
29 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavir
0 cellTotal protein 029 gLImmunoglobulin G 21 mgL
Focal LME
F 64 Bilateral pyramidal tract signs 11 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibiotics
2 cellsmm3
Total protein 030 gLImmunoglobulin G 15 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Focal LME
F 77 Bilateral pyramidal syndromeconfusionagitation
30 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsLopinavir-ritonavirHydroxychloroquine
1 cellmm3
uarr Total protein 080 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 58 mgL
Diffuse LME
F 81 Confusionimpairedconsciousnessagitation
20 Admitted to ICUMechanical ventilationAntibioticsHydroxychloroquine
80 cellsmm3
uarr Total protein 062 gLuarr Immunoglobulin G 38 mgLOligoclonal bands identical in CSF and serum
Focal LME
Abbreviations ADEM = Acute disseminated encephalomyelitis CLOCC = cytotoxic lesion of the corpus callosum COVID-19 = coronavirus disease 2019 FLAIR = fluid-attenuated inversion recovery ICU = intensive care unitLME = leptomeningeal enhancement NR = not realized WM = white matter
Neurolo
gyorgN
Neurology
|Volum
e95N
umber
13|
Septem
ber292020
e1875
Copyright
copy2020
American
Academ
yof
Neurology
Unauthorized
reproductionof
thisarticle
isprohibited
requiring oxygen or presenting an ARDS This profile couldbe distinguished from the 2 others LME and encephalitisThe encephalitis profile affected younger patients and seemedto be particularly severe because it was associated with theneed for oxygen ARDS and death
Stroke patients less frequently had ARDS and this result is inagreement with the 6 patients with stroke previously reportedin that only 2 patients were admitted to ICUs16 One mayhypothesize that strokes in patients with COVID-19 could bedue to procoagulant events leading to thrombosis17 ratherthan to the systemic inflammatory process that accompaniesARDS which is also directed against the CNS However thisneeds to be assessed by further studies dedicated to stroke andthrombosis in patients with COVID-19
In our study 17 (27) patients had an acute ischemic strokeas was previously reported with SARS-CoV18 Middle Eastrespiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERS-CoV)19 andSARS-CoV-2111617 and among them 11 had large arteryinfarctions (including 6 proximal artery occlusions 2 cases ofinternal carotid artery dissection or occlusion) and 6 hadwatershed cerebral infarctions For 15 of 17 patients with anischemic stroke the respiratory symptoms related to COVID-19 had begun before this acute event while stroke precededrespiratory symptoms by 2 days for 2 patients
Several mechanisms are likely to be associated It is nowknown that SARS-CoV-2 could directly lead to myocardialinjury promoting cardiac arrhythmias associated with em-bolic events20 Six of our patients had arrhythmias which werepreviously unknown for 3 of them In the same way a severeacute myocardial injury may be associated with a decrease inbrain perfusion and therefore with watershed cerebralinfarctions As previously mentioned it is acknowledged thatviruses particularly SARS-CoV-221 are associated with anincrease of prothrombotic events such as ischemic stroke2223
Thereby viral infections may elevate procoagulant markersleading to thrombosis disseminated intravascular coagulationand hemorrhagic events23 As Beyrouti et al16 recently men-tioned all our patients tested showed elevated D-dimersmarkedly elevated (gt1000 μgL) for 10 of the 11 patientstested
Varicella zoster virus is also associated with direct vascularinvolvement and eventually arteritis promoting ischemicstroke events22 Furthermore the more severe critically illpatients hospitalized in ICUs have probably had hypoxemiaand hypotension leading to brain injuries18
Of the 36 abnormal MRIs 8 diagnoses of encephalitis weremade and LME was described especially on postcontrast T1-weighted and FLAIR in 11 patients either focal (single focus
Figure 1 Leptomeningeal enhancement
Axial T1 (A) before and (B) 5 minutes after contrast axial FLAIR (C) before and (D) immediately after contrast and (E and F) delayed (10 minutes) postcontrastaxial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) weighted MRIs Woman 77 years of age diffuse leptomeningeal linear FLAIR and T1 contrast enhancement(arrows) not visible on precontrast T1 and FLAIR (arrows) but seen better on delayed postcontrast FLAIR weighted MRIs (E and F)
e1876 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
vs multiple foci) or diffuse and preferentially located in theposterior supratentorial regions of the brain
Two main pathophysiologic hypotheses can be advanced toexplain the neuroimaging findings in the inflammatory profilegroup First SARS-CoV-2 may have a neuroinvasive potentialsimilar to other hCoVs because this family of viruses is relatedto each other genetically It is not clear if the virus can infiltratethe CNS with active replication and direct damage to braincells (viral encephalitis) as observed with other viruses suchas herpes simplex virus Likewise viral meningitis due to di-rect infiltration of the virus into the CSF may also be con-sidered because it was previously reported with SARS-CoV-1Indeed SARS-CoV-1 RNA was detected in the CSF of 2patients with seizures2425 A recent case report10 has de-scribed for the first time a case of seizures with the detection ofSARS-CoV-2 RNA in the CSF Similarly leptomeningealinflammation may be present adjacent to subpial corticallesions in the case of viral meningoencephalitis In the case ofviral encephalitis CSF analysis usually demonstrates lym-phocytic pleocytosis26 In addition the CSF protein level istypically elevated in viral encephalitis CSF viral RT-PCR isusually positive but can be negative if done too early This wasnot the case in our series and our results are in accordance
with recently published data that demonstrated an absence ofCSF pleocytosis and negative SARS-CoV-2 RT-PCR (5 of 5patients) but elevated protein level (4 of 5 patients) inpatients presenting cerebral MRI cortical abnormalities13
MRI pictures of viral encephalitis vary with causal pathogenNevertheless viral encephalitis usually involves cerebral GMwith diffusion restriction and can be associated with intrale-sional and diffuse leptomeningeal contrast enhancement Thiswas not the case in our series and did not argue for the directeffect of the virus It is all the more likely that the directdetection of SARS-CoV-2 RNA by RT-PCR was alwaysnegative in all our CSF samples
An alternative hypothesis appears more relevant the neuro-virulence of hCoVs especially MERS-CoV seems to bea consequence of immune-mediated processes1927ndash29 IndeedADEM and Bickerstaff brainstem encephalitis which weredescribed with MERS-CoV18ndash27 are 2 examples of autoim-mune demyelinating diseases resulting from a postinfectious orparainfectious process A recent case report9 has describeda case of acute hemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy (whichis the most severe form of ADEM) associated with COVID-19which strengthens the hypothesis of a predominant immuno-logic mechanism In our cohort we also described 2 cases of
Figure 2 Encephalitis
(A B D) Axial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) and(C) diffusion-weighted MRIs (A) Man 56 years of age lefthippocampus and amygdala FLAIR hyperintensity (B)Woman 71 years of age periventricular and subcorticalwhite matter FLAIR confluent hyperintensities (C) Man 55years of age corpus callosum splenium diffusion hyper-intensity (D) Man 64 years of age FLAIR middle cerebellarpeduncle hyperintensity
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1877
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
limbic encephalitis and 1 case of CLOCC Concerning thelatter no treatment had been started or stopped in previousweeks Thus 75 of encephalitis cases in our cohort (limbicencephalitis CLOCC radiologic ADEM radiologic acutehemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy) are possibly con-sidered immune-mediated diseases Therefore SARS-CoV-2ndashmediated disease is driven largely by immunologic processesand the same mechanisms could explain LME Indeed thearachnoid and pial membranes form the leptomeninges anda significant amount of antigen-presenting cells are present inthe subarachnoid space30 Thus initial immune activationoccurs in the subarachnoid space which is a site for antigenpresentation lymphocyte accumulation and proliferation andantibody production30 All lead to an important local in-flammatory infiltrate with a blood-CSF barrier disruptionwhich can also explain LME Thus LME can be linked toinflammatory or immunologic responses as previously de-scribed in animal models of autoimmune encephalomyelitis31
with some neurotropic viruses such as human T-cell leukemiavirus and HIV31 and in several immune-mediated neurologicdiseases31 Moreover a very similar intracranial pattern hasbeen described in an animal study in piglets affected by gas-troenteritis coronavirus32 Indeed histology demonstrateddiffuse pia matter gliosis with mild congestion of the meningeal
and parenchymal vessels with neuronal degeneration locatedmostly in posterior parietooccipital lobes24 PostcontrastFLAIR is the best sequence to highlight LME but a potentialpitfall is inhalation of increased levels of oxygen by patients whoare intubated which may increase subarachnoid space signalintensity noted on FLAIR images within the basal cisterns andsulcus along the cerebral convexities33 That is why we havechosen in this situation to acquire systematically precontrastand postcontrast FLAIR sequences to avoid misinterpretationof FLAIR hyperintensity within the subarachnoid spaces andnot to misdescribe a meningeal enhancement For our 11patients with LME no precontrast FLAIR signal abnormalitieswere visible in the subarachnoid spaces
Our study has several limitations mainly due to its multicenterand retrospective design First brain MRI protocols were dic-tated by clinical need and the patterns of working could bedifferent among the 11 centers even if neuroradiologists areused to work together Thus 36 of the MRIs were performedwithout administration of gadolinium-based contrast agentsnotably preventing the detection of LME therefore probablyunderestimating it Moreover LMEs are very subtle neuro-imaging findings which need the realization of delayed post-contrast FLAIR sequences which were not done in the vast
Figure 3 Radiologic acute disseminated encephalomyelitis
(A E I) Axial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) (B F J) axial diffusion (B F J) apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC) map and (D H L) postcontrast T1-weighted MRIs Man 60 years of age subcortical periventricular corpus callosum and posterior fossa white matter FLAIR hyperintensities without contrastenhancement (arrows) Some lesions appear hyperintense on diffusion-weightedMRIs with decreased ADC corresponding to cytotoxic edema (stars) Otherlesions present an ADC increase corresponding to vasogenic edema (cross)
e1878 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
majority of the centers Second we did not realize a follow-upMRI and some abnormalities could have appeared duringfollow-up Third outcomes were not available for all patients atthe time of writing Thus the mortality rate is probablyunderestimated in our cohort Fourth although patients withCOVID-19may develop a wide range of neurologic symptomswhich can be associated with ischemic stroke or encephalitis itis difficult to state without a controlled general neurologicpopulation that such events are more frequent in patients withCOVID-19 However it now seems well established thatthrombotic events are particularly frequent in patients withCOVID-1921 Moreover encephalitis which is a rare disorderin the general population34 was surprisingly frequent in ourpopulation
In this large multicentric national cohort most patients withCOVID-19 (56) with neurologic manifestations had brainMRI abnormalities such as ischemic stroke LME and enceph-alitis Because the detection of LME suggests the abnormality ofbrain MRI it would be interesting to realize systematicallypostcontrast FLAIR acquisition in patients with COVID-19
Concerning the cases of encephalitis and LME even if a directviral origin cannot be eliminated the pathophysiology of braindamage related to SARS-COV-2 seems rather to involve aninflammatory or autoimmune response The knowledge ofthe various clinicoradiologic manifestations of COVID-19could be helpful for the best care of the patients and ourunderstanding of the disease In addition to SARS cytokine
Figure 4 Multiple correspondence analysis
The ischemic stroke group (red) can be distinguished from the 3 others which largely overlapMost patients with ischemic stroke (numbers and dots in red onthe plot) are located on the same lower-right half of the graph indicating a commonality of symptoms Diag 1 (black) = normal brain MRI Diag 2 (red) =ischemic stroke Diag 3 (green) = encephalitis Diag 4 (blue) = leptomeningeal enhancement
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1879
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
storm syndrome and heart failure brain injuries may con-tribute to increased mortality This highlights the importanceof neurologic evaluation especially for patients hospitalized inICU with clinical deterioration or worsening of their symp-toms which can be associated with an acute neurologic event
AcknowledgmentThe authors thank Marie Cecile Henry Feugeas for her workin data acquisition for this study
Study fundingNo targeted funding reported
DisclosureThe authors report no disclosures relevant to the manuscriptGo to NeurologyorgN for full disclosures
Publication historyReceived by Neurology April 28 2020 Accepted in final formJune 9 2020
Appendix Authors
Name Location Contribution
StephaneKremer MDPhD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study acquisition of datainterpreted the data draftedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Franccedilois LersyMD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study acquisition of datainterpreted the data draftedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MathieuAnheim MDPhD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
Hamid MerdjiMD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MalekaSchenck MD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
HeleneOesterle MD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FedericoBolognini MD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Julien MessieMD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Antoine KhalilMD PhD
Bichat Hospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
AugustinGaudemer MD
Bichat Hospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Sophie CarreMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Manel AllegMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Claire LecocqMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
EmmanuelleSchmitt MD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ReneAnxionnatMD PhD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Franccedilois ZhuMD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Lavinia JagerMD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Patrick NesserMD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Yannick TallaMba MD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GhaziHmeydia MD
Saint-Anne hospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
JosephBenzakounMD
Saint-Anne hospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
CatherineOppenheimMD PhD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jean-ChristopheFerre MD PhD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Adel MaamarMD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
BeatriceCarsin-NicolMD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Pierre-OlivierComby MD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FredericRicolfi MDPhD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
PierreThouant MD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Claire BoutetMD PhD
University hospital ofSaint-Etienne France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
e1880 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
References1 Chen N Zhou M Dong X et al Epidemiological and clinical characteristics of 99
cases of 2019 novel coronavirus pneumonia in Wuhan China a descriptive studyLancet 2020395507ndash513
2 Huang C Wang Y Li X et al Clinical features of patients infected with 2019 novelcoronavirus in Wuhan China Lancet 2020395497ndash506
3 Glass WG Subbarao K Murphy B Murphy PM Mechanisms of host defense fol-lowing severe acute respiratory syndrome‐coronavirus (SARS‐CoV) pulmonary in-fection of mice J Immunol 20041734030ndash4039
4 Li K Wohlford‐Lenane C Perlman S et al Middle East respiratory syndromecoronavirus causes multiple organ damage and lethal disease in mice transgenic forhuman dipeptidyl peptidase 4 J Infect Dis 2016213712ndash722
5 Arbour N Day R Newcombe J Talbot PJ Neuroinvasion by human respiratorycoronaviruses J Virol 2000748913ndash8921
6 Desforges M Le Coupanec A Stodola JK Meessen-Pinard M Talbot PJ Humancoronaviruses viral and cellular factors involved in neuroinvasiveness and neuro-pathogenesis Virus Res 2014194145ndash158
7 Desforges M Le Coupanec A Dubeau P et al Human coronaviruses and otherrespiratory viruses underestimated opportunistic pathogens of the central nervoussystem Viruses 201912E14
8 Bohmwald K Galvez NMS Rıos M Kalergis AM Neurologic alterations due torespiratory virus infections Front Cell Neurosci 201812386
9 Poyiadji N Shahin G Noujaim D Stone M Patel S Griffith B COVID-19-associatedacute hemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy CT and MRI features Radiology2020201187
10 Moriguchi T Harii N Goto J et al A first case of meningitisencephalitis associatedwith SARS-coronavirus-2 Int J Infect Dis 20209455ndash58
11 Mao L Jin H Wang M et al Neurologic manifestations of hospitalized patients withcoronavirus disease 2019 in Wuhan China JAMA Neurol 2020771ndash9
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Xavier FabreMD
Hospital of RoanneFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GeraudForestier MD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Isaure deBeaurepaireMD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GregoireBornet MD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Hubert DesalMD PhD
University Hospital ofNantes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GregoireBoulouis MD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jerome BergeMD
University Hospital ofBordeaux France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ApollineKazemi MD
University Hospital ofLille France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
NadyaPyatigorskayaMD
Pitie-SalpetriereHospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
AugustinLecler MD
Foundation ARothschild Paris
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
SuzanaSaleme MD
University Hospital ofLimoges France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Myriam Edjlali-Goujon MD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
BasileKerleroux MD
University Hospital ofTours France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jean-MarcConstans MDPhD
University Hospital ofAmiens France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Pierre-EmmanuelZorn PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the acquisitionof data
MurielMatthieu PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the acquisitionof data
Seyyid BalogluMD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of datarevised the manuscriptfor intellectualcontent
Franccedilois-DanielArdellier MD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ThibaultWillaume MD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of datarevised the manuscriptfor intellectualcontent
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Jean-ChristopheBrisset PhD
French Observatoryof Multiple SclerosisLyon France
Interpretation of the datarevised the manuscript forintellectual content
SophieCaillard MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
OlivierCollange MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Paul MichelMertes MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FrancisSchneider MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Samira Fafi-KremerPharmD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MickaelOhana MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FerhatMeziani MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Nicolas MeyerMD PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the analysis andinterpretation of the data
Julie HelmsMD PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
FranccediloisCotton MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1881
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
12 Helms J Kremer S Merdji H et al Neurologic features in severe SARS-CoV-2infection N Engl J Med 20203822268ndash2270
13 Kandemirli SG Dogan L Sarikaya ZT et al Brain MRI findings in patients in theintensive care unit with COVID-19 infection Radiology Epub 2020 May 8
14 Ferguson ND Fan E Camporota L et al The Berlin definition of ARDS an expandedrationale justification and supplementary material Intensive Care Med 2012381573ndash1582
15 Starkey J Kobayashi N Numaguchi Y Moritani T Cytotoxic lesions of the corpuscallosum that show restricted diffusion mechanisms causes and manifestationsRadiographics 201737562ndash576
16 Beyrouti R Adams ME Benjamin L et al Characteristics of ischaemic stroke asso-ciated with COVID-19 J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry Epub 2020 Apr 30
17 Hess DC Eldahshan W Rutkowski E COVID-19-related stroke Transl Stroke Res202011322ndash325
18 Umapathi T Kor AC Venketasubramanian N et al Large artery ischaemic stroke insevere acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) J Neurol 20042511227ndash1231
19 Arabi YM Harthi A Hussein J et al Severe neurologic syndrome associated withMiddle East respiratory syndrome corona virus (MERS-CoV) Infection 201543495ndash501
20 Guo T Fan Y ChenM et al Cardiovascular implications of fatal outcomes of patientswith coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) JAMA Cardiol Epub 2020 Mar 27
21 Helms J Tacquard C Severac F et al High risk of thrombosis in patients in severeSARS-CoV-2 infection a multicenter prospective cohort study Intensive Care Med2020461089ndash1098
22 NagelMAMahalingamRCohrs RJ GildenD Virus vasculopathy and stroke an under-recognized cause and treatment target Infect Disord Drug Targets 201010105ndash111
23 Subramaniam S Scharrer I Procoagulant activity during viral infections Front Biosci(Landmark Ed) 2018231060ndash1081
24 Hung EC Chim SS Chan PK et al Detection of SARS coronavirus RNA in thecerebrospinal fluid of a patient with severe acute respiratory syndrome Clin Chem2003492108ndash2109
25 Lau KK Yu WC Chu CM Lau ST Sheng B Yuen KY Possible central nervoussystem infection by SARS coronavirus Emerg Infect Dis 200410342ndash344
26 Toledano M Davies NWS Infectious encephalitis mimics and chameleons PractNeurol 201919225ndash237
27 Kim JE Heo JH Kim HO et al Neurological complications during treatment ofMiddle East respiratory syndrome J Clin Neurol 201713227ndash233
28 Li Y Li H Fan R et al Coronavirus infections in the central nervous system andrespiratory tract show distinct features in hospitalized children Intervirology 201659163ndash169
29 Yeh EA Collins A Cohen ME Duffner PK Faden H Detection of coronavirus in thecentral nervous system of a child with acute disseminated encephalomyelitis Pedi-atrics 2004113(pt 1)e73ndashe76
30 Kivisakk P Imitola J Rasmussen S et al Localizing central nervous system immunesurveillance meningeal antigen-presenting cells activate T cells during experimentalautoimmune encephalomyelitis Ann Neurol 200965457ndash469
31 Absinta M Cortese IC Vuolo L et al Leptomeningeal gadolinium enhancementacross the spectrum of chronic neuroinflammatory diseases Neurology 2017881439ndash1444
32 Papatsiros VG Stylianaki I Papakonstantinou G Papaioannou N Christodoulo-poulos G Case report of transmissible gastroenteritis coronavirus infection associatedwith small intestine and brain lesions in piglets Viral Immunol 20193263ndash67
33 Stuckey SL Goh TD Heffernan T Rowan D Hyperintensity in the subarachnoidspace on FLAIR MRI AJR Am J Roentgenol 2007189913ndash921
34 Parpia AS Li Y Chen C Dhar B Crowcroft NS Encephalitis Ontario Canada 2002-2013 Emerg Infect Dis 201622426ndash432
e1882 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
DOI 101212WNL0000000000010112202095e1868-e1882 Published Online before print July 17 2020Neurology
Steacutephane Kremer Franccedilois Lersy Mathieu Anheim et al multicenter study
Neurologic and neuroimaging findings in patients with COVID-19 A retrospective
This information is current as of July 17 2020
ServicesUpdated Information amp
httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullincluding high resolution figures can be found at
References httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullref-list-1
This article cites 30 articles 6 of which you can access for free at
Citations httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullotherarticles
This article has been cited by 3 HighWire-hosted articles
Subspecialty Collections
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmriMRI
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmeningitisMeningitis
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionencephalitisEncephalitis e
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_cerebrovascular_disease_strokAll Cerebrovascular diseaseStrokefollowing collection(s) This article along with others on similar topics appears in the
Permissions amp Licensing
httpwwwneurologyorgaboutabout_the_journalpermissionsits entirety can be found online atInformation about reproducing this article in parts (figurestables) or in
Reprints
httpnneurologyorgsubscribersadvertiseInformation about ordering reprints can be found online
rights reserved Print ISSN 0028-3878 Online ISSN 1526-632X1951 it is now a weekly with 48 issues per year Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology All
reg is the official journal of the American Academy of Neurology Published continuously sinceNeurology
![Page 9: Neurologicandneuroimaging findingsinpatients with COVID-19 · enhancement (17%), and encephalitis (13%) were the most frequent neuroimaging findings. Confusion (53%) was the most](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060813/6091b284d4b0681e5152b42b/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
requiring oxygen or presenting an ARDS This profile couldbe distinguished from the 2 others LME and encephalitisThe encephalitis profile affected younger patients and seemedto be particularly severe because it was associated with theneed for oxygen ARDS and death
Stroke patients less frequently had ARDS and this result is inagreement with the 6 patients with stroke previously reportedin that only 2 patients were admitted to ICUs16 One mayhypothesize that strokes in patients with COVID-19 could bedue to procoagulant events leading to thrombosis17 ratherthan to the systemic inflammatory process that accompaniesARDS which is also directed against the CNS However thisneeds to be assessed by further studies dedicated to stroke andthrombosis in patients with COVID-19
In our study 17 (27) patients had an acute ischemic strokeas was previously reported with SARS-CoV18 Middle Eastrespiratory syndrome coronavirus (MERS-CoV)19 andSARS-CoV-2111617 and among them 11 had large arteryinfarctions (including 6 proximal artery occlusions 2 cases ofinternal carotid artery dissection or occlusion) and 6 hadwatershed cerebral infarctions For 15 of 17 patients with anischemic stroke the respiratory symptoms related to COVID-19 had begun before this acute event while stroke precededrespiratory symptoms by 2 days for 2 patients
Several mechanisms are likely to be associated It is nowknown that SARS-CoV-2 could directly lead to myocardialinjury promoting cardiac arrhythmias associated with em-bolic events20 Six of our patients had arrhythmias which werepreviously unknown for 3 of them In the same way a severeacute myocardial injury may be associated with a decrease inbrain perfusion and therefore with watershed cerebralinfarctions As previously mentioned it is acknowledged thatviruses particularly SARS-CoV-221 are associated with anincrease of prothrombotic events such as ischemic stroke2223
Thereby viral infections may elevate procoagulant markersleading to thrombosis disseminated intravascular coagulationand hemorrhagic events23 As Beyrouti et al16 recently men-tioned all our patients tested showed elevated D-dimersmarkedly elevated (gt1000 μgL) for 10 of the 11 patientstested
Varicella zoster virus is also associated with direct vascularinvolvement and eventually arteritis promoting ischemicstroke events22 Furthermore the more severe critically illpatients hospitalized in ICUs have probably had hypoxemiaand hypotension leading to brain injuries18
Of the 36 abnormal MRIs 8 diagnoses of encephalitis weremade and LME was described especially on postcontrast T1-weighted and FLAIR in 11 patients either focal (single focus
Figure 1 Leptomeningeal enhancement
Axial T1 (A) before and (B) 5 minutes after contrast axial FLAIR (C) before and (D) immediately after contrast and (E and F) delayed (10 minutes) postcontrastaxial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) weighted MRIs Woman 77 years of age diffuse leptomeningeal linear FLAIR and T1 contrast enhancement(arrows) not visible on precontrast T1 and FLAIR (arrows) but seen better on delayed postcontrast FLAIR weighted MRIs (E and F)
e1876 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
vs multiple foci) or diffuse and preferentially located in theposterior supratentorial regions of the brain
Two main pathophysiologic hypotheses can be advanced toexplain the neuroimaging findings in the inflammatory profilegroup First SARS-CoV-2 may have a neuroinvasive potentialsimilar to other hCoVs because this family of viruses is relatedto each other genetically It is not clear if the virus can infiltratethe CNS with active replication and direct damage to braincells (viral encephalitis) as observed with other viruses suchas herpes simplex virus Likewise viral meningitis due to di-rect infiltration of the virus into the CSF may also be con-sidered because it was previously reported with SARS-CoV-1Indeed SARS-CoV-1 RNA was detected in the CSF of 2patients with seizures2425 A recent case report10 has de-scribed for the first time a case of seizures with the detection ofSARS-CoV-2 RNA in the CSF Similarly leptomeningealinflammation may be present adjacent to subpial corticallesions in the case of viral meningoencephalitis In the case ofviral encephalitis CSF analysis usually demonstrates lym-phocytic pleocytosis26 In addition the CSF protein level istypically elevated in viral encephalitis CSF viral RT-PCR isusually positive but can be negative if done too early This wasnot the case in our series and our results are in accordance
with recently published data that demonstrated an absence ofCSF pleocytosis and negative SARS-CoV-2 RT-PCR (5 of 5patients) but elevated protein level (4 of 5 patients) inpatients presenting cerebral MRI cortical abnormalities13
MRI pictures of viral encephalitis vary with causal pathogenNevertheless viral encephalitis usually involves cerebral GMwith diffusion restriction and can be associated with intrale-sional and diffuse leptomeningeal contrast enhancement Thiswas not the case in our series and did not argue for the directeffect of the virus It is all the more likely that the directdetection of SARS-CoV-2 RNA by RT-PCR was alwaysnegative in all our CSF samples
An alternative hypothesis appears more relevant the neuro-virulence of hCoVs especially MERS-CoV seems to bea consequence of immune-mediated processes1927ndash29 IndeedADEM and Bickerstaff brainstem encephalitis which weredescribed with MERS-CoV18ndash27 are 2 examples of autoim-mune demyelinating diseases resulting from a postinfectious orparainfectious process A recent case report9 has describeda case of acute hemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy (whichis the most severe form of ADEM) associated with COVID-19which strengthens the hypothesis of a predominant immuno-logic mechanism In our cohort we also described 2 cases of
Figure 2 Encephalitis
(A B D) Axial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) and(C) diffusion-weighted MRIs (A) Man 56 years of age lefthippocampus and amygdala FLAIR hyperintensity (B)Woman 71 years of age periventricular and subcorticalwhite matter FLAIR confluent hyperintensities (C) Man 55years of age corpus callosum splenium diffusion hyper-intensity (D) Man 64 years of age FLAIR middle cerebellarpeduncle hyperintensity
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1877
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
limbic encephalitis and 1 case of CLOCC Concerning thelatter no treatment had been started or stopped in previousweeks Thus 75 of encephalitis cases in our cohort (limbicencephalitis CLOCC radiologic ADEM radiologic acutehemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy) are possibly con-sidered immune-mediated diseases Therefore SARS-CoV-2ndashmediated disease is driven largely by immunologic processesand the same mechanisms could explain LME Indeed thearachnoid and pial membranes form the leptomeninges anda significant amount of antigen-presenting cells are present inthe subarachnoid space30 Thus initial immune activationoccurs in the subarachnoid space which is a site for antigenpresentation lymphocyte accumulation and proliferation andantibody production30 All lead to an important local in-flammatory infiltrate with a blood-CSF barrier disruptionwhich can also explain LME Thus LME can be linked toinflammatory or immunologic responses as previously de-scribed in animal models of autoimmune encephalomyelitis31
with some neurotropic viruses such as human T-cell leukemiavirus and HIV31 and in several immune-mediated neurologicdiseases31 Moreover a very similar intracranial pattern hasbeen described in an animal study in piglets affected by gas-troenteritis coronavirus32 Indeed histology demonstrateddiffuse pia matter gliosis with mild congestion of the meningeal
and parenchymal vessels with neuronal degeneration locatedmostly in posterior parietooccipital lobes24 PostcontrastFLAIR is the best sequence to highlight LME but a potentialpitfall is inhalation of increased levels of oxygen by patients whoare intubated which may increase subarachnoid space signalintensity noted on FLAIR images within the basal cisterns andsulcus along the cerebral convexities33 That is why we havechosen in this situation to acquire systematically precontrastand postcontrast FLAIR sequences to avoid misinterpretationof FLAIR hyperintensity within the subarachnoid spaces andnot to misdescribe a meningeal enhancement For our 11patients with LME no precontrast FLAIR signal abnormalitieswere visible in the subarachnoid spaces
Our study has several limitations mainly due to its multicenterand retrospective design First brain MRI protocols were dic-tated by clinical need and the patterns of working could bedifferent among the 11 centers even if neuroradiologists areused to work together Thus 36 of the MRIs were performedwithout administration of gadolinium-based contrast agentsnotably preventing the detection of LME therefore probablyunderestimating it Moreover LMEs are very subtle neuro-imaging findings which need the realization of delayed post-contrast FLAIR sequences which were not done in the vast
Figure 3 Radiologic acute disseminated encephalomyelitis
(A E I) Axial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) (B F J) axial diffusion (B F J) apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC) map and (D H L) postcontrast T1-weighted MRIs Man 60 years of age subcortical periventricular corpus callosum and posterior fossa white matter FLAIR hyperintensities without contrastenhancement (arrows) Some lesions appear hyperintense on diffusion-weightedMRIs with decreased ADC corresponding to cytotoxic edema (stars) Otherlesions present an ADC increase corresponding to vasogenic edema (cross)
e1878 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
majority of the centers Second we did not realize a follow-upMRI and some abnormalities could have appeared duringfollow-up Third outcomes were not available for all patients atthe time of writing Thus the mortality rate is probablyunderestimated in our cohort Fourth although patients withCOVID-19may develop a wide range of neurologic symptomswhich can be associated with ischemic stroke or encephalitis itis difficult to state without a controlled general neurologicpopulation that such events are more frequent in patients withCOVID-19 However it now seems well established thatthrombotic events are particularly frequent in patients withCOVID-1921 Moreover encephalitis which is a rare disorderin the general population34 was surprisingly frequent in ourpopulation
In this large multicentric national cohort most patients withCOVID-19 (56) with neurologic manifestations had brainMRI abnormalities such as ischemic stroke LME and enceph-alitis Because the detection of LME suggests the abnormality ofbrain MRI it would be interesting to realize systematicallypostcontrast FLAIR acquisition in patients with COVID-19
Concerning the cases of encephalitis and LME even if a directviral origin cannot be eliminated the pathophysiology of braindamage related to SARS-COV-2 seems rather to involve aninflammatory or autoimmune response The knowledge ofthe various clinicoradiologic manifestations of COVID-19could be helpful for the best care of the patients and ourunderstanding of the disease In addition to SARS cytokine
Figure 4 Multiple correspondence analysis
The ischemic stroke group (red) can be distinguished from the 3 others which largely overlapMost patients with ischemic stroke (numbers and dots in red onthe plot) are located on the same lower-right half of the graph indicating a commonality of symptoms Diag 1 (black) = normal brain MRI Diag 2 (red) =ischemic stroke Diag 3 (green) = encephalitis Diag 4 (blue) = leptomeningeal enhancement
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1879
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
storm syndrome and heart failure brain injuries may con-tribute to increased mortality This highlights the importanceof neurologic evaluation especially for patients hospitalized inICU with clinical deterioration or worsening of their symp-toms which can be associated with an acute neurologic event
AcknowledgmentThe authors thank Marie Cecile Henry Feugeas for her workin data acquisition for this study
Study fundingNo targeted funding reported
DisclosureThe authors report no disclosures relevant to the manuscriptGo to NeurologyorgN for full disclosures
Publication historyReceived by Neurology April 28 2020 Accepted in final formJune 9 2020
Appendix Authors
Name Location Contribution
StephaneKremer MDPhD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study acquisition of datainterpreted the data draftedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Franccedilois LersyMD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study acquisition of datainterpreted the data draftedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MathieuAnheim MDPhD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
Hamid MerdjiMD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MalekaSchenck MD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
HeleneOesterle MD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FedericoBolognini MD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Julien MessieMD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Antoine KhalilMD PhD
Bichat Hospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
AugustinGaudemer MD
Bichat Hospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Sophie CarreMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Manel AllegMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Claire LecocqMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
EmmanuelleSchmitt MD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ReneAnxionnatMD PhD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Franccedilois ZhuMD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Lavinia JagerMD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Patrick NesserMD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Yannick TallaMba MD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GhaziHmeydia MD
Saint-Anne hospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
JosephBenzakounMD
Saint-Anne hospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
CatherineOppenheimMD PhD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jean-ChristopheFerre MD PhD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Adel MaamarMD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
BeatriceCarsin-NicolMD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Pierre-OlivierComby MD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FredericRicolfi MDPhD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
PierreThouant MD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Claire BoutetMD PhD
University hospital ofSaint-Etienne France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
e1880 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
References1 Chen N Zhou M Dong X et al Epidemiological and clinical characteristics of 99
cases of 2019 novel coronavirus pneumonia in Wuhan China a descriptive studyLancet 2020395507ndash513
2 Huang C Wang Y Li X et al Clinical features of patients infected with 2019 novelcoronavirus in Wuhan China Lancet 2020395497ndash506
3 Glass WG Subbarao K Murphy B Murphy PM Mechanisms of host defense fol-lowing severe acute respiratory syndrome‐coronavirus (SARS‐CoV) pulmonary in-fection of mice J Immunol 20041734030ndash4039
4 Li K Wohlford‐Lenane C Perlman S et al Middle East respiratory syndromecoronavirus causes multiple organ damage and lethal disease in mice transgenic forhuman dipeptidyl peptidase 4 J Infect Dis 2016213712ndash722
5 Arbour N Day R Newcombe J Talbot PJ Neuroinvasion by human respiratorycoronaviruses J Virol 2000748913ndash8921
6 Desforges M Le Coupanec A Stodola JK Meessen-Pinard M Talbot PJ Humancoronaviruses viral and cellular factors involved in neuroinvasiveness and neuro-pathogenesis Virus Res 2014194145ndash158
7 Desforges M Le Coupanec A Dubeau P et al Human coronaviruses and otherrespiratory viruses underestimated opportunistic pathogens of the central nervoussystem Viruses 201912E14
8 Bohmwald K Galvez NMS Rıos M Kalergis AM Neurologic alterations due torespiratory virus infections Front Cell Neurosci 201812386
9 Poyiadji N Shahin G Noujaim D Stone M Patel S Griffith B COVID-19-associatedacute hemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy CT and MRI features Radiology2020201187
10 Moriguchi T Harii N Goto J et al A first case of meningitisencephalitis associatedwith SARS-coronavirus-2 Int J Infect Dis 20209455ndash58
11 Mao L Jin H Wang M et al Neurologic manifestations of hospitalized patients withcoronavirus disease 2019 in Wuhan China JAMA Neurol 2020771ndash9
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Xavier FabreMD
Hospital of RoanneFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GeraudForestier MD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Isaure deBeaurepaireMD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GregoireBornet MD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Hubert DesalMD PhD
University Hospital ofNantes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GregoireBoulouis MD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jerome BergeMD
University Hospital ofBordeaux France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ApollineKazemi MD
University Hospital ofLille France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
NadyaPyatigorskayaMD
Pitie-SalpetriereHospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
AugustinLecler MD
Foundation ARothschild Paris
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
SuzanaSaleme MD
University Hospital ofLimoges France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Myriam Edjlali-Goujon MD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
BasileKerleroux MD
University Hospital ofTours France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jean-MarcConstans MDPhD
University Hospital ofAmiens France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Pierre-EmmanuelZorn PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the acquisitionof data
MurielMatthieu PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the acquisitionof data
Seyyid BalogluMD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of datarevised the manuscriptfor intellectualcontent
Franccedilois-DanielArdellier MD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ThibaultWillaume MD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of datarevised the manuscriptfor intellectualcontent
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Jean-ChristopheBrisset PhD
French Observatoryof Multiple SclerosisLyon France
Interpretation of the datarevised the manuscript forintellectual content
SophieCaillard MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
OlivierCollange MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Paul MichelMertes MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FrancisSchneider MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Samira Fafi-KremerPharmD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MickaelOhana MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FerhatMeziani MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Nicolas MeyerMD PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the analysis andinterpretation of the data
Julie HelmsMD PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
FranccediloisCotton MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1881
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
12 Helms J Kremer S Merdji H et al Neurologic features in severe SARS-CoV-2infection N Engl J Med 20203822268ndash2270
13 Kandemirli SG Dogan L Sarikaya ZT et al Brain MRI findings in patients in theintensive care unit with COVID-19 infection Radiology Epub 2020 May 8
14 Ferguson ND Fan E Camporota L et al The Berlin definition of ARDS an expandedrationale justification and supplementary material Intensive Care Med 2012381573ndash1582
15 Starkey J Kobayashi N Numaguchi Y Moritani T Cytotoxic lesions of the corpuscallosum that show restricted diffusion mechanisms causes and manifestationsRadiographics 201737562ndash576
16 Beyrouti R Adams ME Benjamin L et al Characteristics of ischaemic stroke asso-ciated with COVID-19 J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry Epub 2020 Apr 30
17 Hess DC Eldahshan W Rutkowski E COVID-19-related stroke Transl Stroke Res202011322ndash325
18 Umapathi T Kor AC Venketasubramanian N et al Large artery ischaemic stroke insevere acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) J Neurol 20042511227ndash1231
19 Arabi YM Harthi A Hussein J et al Severe neurologic syndrome associated withMiddle East respiratory syndrome corona virus (MERS-CoV) Infection 201543495ndash501
20 Guo T Fan Y ChenM et al Cardiovascular implications of fatal outcomes of patientswith coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) JAMA Cardiol Epub 2020 Mar 27
21 Helms J Tacquard C Severac F et al High risk of thrombosis in patients in severeSARS-CoV-2 infection a multicenter prospective cohort study Intensive Care Med2020461089ndash1098
22 NagelMAMahalingamRCohrs RJ GildenD Virus vasculopathy and stroke an under-recognized cause and treatment target Infect Disord Drug Targets 201010105ndash111
23 Subramaniam S Scharrer I Procoagulant activity during viral infections Front Biosci(Landmark Ed) 2018231060ndash1081
24 Hung EC Chim SS Chan PK et al Detection of SARS coronavirus RNA in thecerebrospinal fluid of a patient with severe acute respiratory syndrome Clin Chem2003492108ndash2109
25 Lau KK Yu WC Chu CM Lau ST Sheng B Yuen KY Possible central nervoussystem infection by SARS coronavirus Emerg Infect Dis 200410342ndash344
26 Toledano M Davies NWS Infectious encephalitis mimics and chameleons PractNeurol 201919225ndash237
27 Kim JE Heo JH Kim HO et al Neurological complications during treatment ofMiddle East respiratory syndrome J Clin Neurol 201713227ndash233
28 Li Y Li H Fan R et al Coronavirus infections in the central nervous system andrespiratory tract show distinct features in hospitalized children Intervirology 201659163ndash169
29 Yeh EA Collins A Cohen ME Duffner PK Faden H Detection of coronavirus in thecentral nervous system of a child with acute disseminated encephalomyelitis Pedi-atrics 2004113(pt 1)e73ndashe76
30 Kivisakk P Imitola J Rasmussen S et al Localizing central nervous system immunesurveillance meningeal antigen-presenting cells activate T cells during experimentalautoimmune encephalomyelitis Ann Neurol 200965457ndash469
31 Absinta M Cortese IC Vuolo L et al Leptomeningeal gadolinium enhancementacross the spectrum of chronic neuroinflammatory diseases Neurology 2017881439ndash1444
32 Papatsiros VG Stylianaki I Papakonstantinou G Papaioannou N Christodoulo-poulos G Case report of transmissible gastroenteritis coronavirus infection associatedwith small intestine and brain lesions in piglets Viral Immunol 20193263ndash67
33 Stuckey SL Goh TD Heffernan T Rowan D Hyperintensity in the subarachnoidspace on FLAIR MRI AJR Am J Roentgenol 2007189913ndash921
34 Parpia AS Li Y Chen C Dhar B Crowcroft NS Encephalitis Ontario Canada 2002-2013 Emerg Infect Dis 201622426ndash432
e1882 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
DOI 101212WNL0000000000010112202095e1868-e1882 Published Online before print July 17 2020Neurology
Steacutephane Kremer Franccedilois Lersy Mathieu Anheim et al multicenter study
Neurologic and neuroimaging findings in patients with COVID-19 A retrospective
This information is current as of July 17 2020
ServicesUpdated Information amp
httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullincluding high resolution figures can be found at
References httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullref-list-1
This article cites 30 articles 6 of which you can access for free at
Citations httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullotherarticles
This article has been cited by 3 HighWire-hosted articles
Subspecialty Collections
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmriMRI
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmeningitisMeningitis
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionencephalitisEncephalitis e
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_cerebrovascular_disease_strokAll Cerebrovascular diseaseStrokefollowing collection(s) This article along with others on similar topics appears in the
Permissions amp Licensing
httpwwwneurologyorgaboutabout_the_journalpermissionsits entirety can be found online atInformation about reproducing this article in parts (figurestables) or in
Reprints
httpnneurologyorgsubscribersadvertiseInformation about ordering reprints can be found online
rights reserved Print ISSN 0028-3878 Online ISSN 1526-632X1951 it is now a weekly with 48 issues per year Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology All
reg is the official journal of the American Academy of Neurology Published continuously sinceNeurology
![Page 10: Neurologicandneuroimaging findingsinpatients with COVID-19 · enhancement (17%), and encephalitis (13%) were the most frequent neuroimaging findings. Confusion (53%) was the most](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060813/6091b284d4b0681e5152b42b/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
vs multiple foci) or diffuse and preferentially located in theposterior supratentorial regions of the brain
Two main pathophysiologic hypotheses can be advanced toexplain the neuroimaging findings in the inflammatory profilegroup First SARS-CoV-2 may have a neuroinvasive potentialsimilar to other hCoVs because this family of viruses is relatedto each other genetically It is not clear if the virus can infiltratethe CNS with active replication and direct damage to braincells (viral encephalitis) as observed with other viruses suchas herpes simplex virus Likewise viral meningitis due to di-rect infiltration of the virus into the CSF may also be con-sidered because it was previously reported with SARS-CoV-1Indeed SARS-CoV-1 RNA was detected in the CSF of 2patients with seizures2425 A recent case report10 has de-scribed for the first time a case of seizures with the detection ofSARS-CoV-2 RNA in the CSF Similarly leptomeningealinflammation may be present adjacent to subpial corticallesions in the case of viral meningoencephalitis In the case ofviral encephalitis CSF analysis usually demonstrates lym-phocytic pleocytosis26 In addition the CSF protein level istypically elevated in viral encephalitis CSF viral RT-PCR isusually positive but can be negative if done too early This wasnot the case in our series and our results are in accordance
with recently published data that demonstrated an absence ofCSF pleocytosis and negative SARS-CoV-2 RT-PCR (5 of 5patients) but elevated protein level (4 of 5 patients) inpatients presenting cerebral MRI cortical abnormalities13
MRI pictures of viral encephalitis vary with causal pathogenNevertheless viral encephalitis usually involves cerebral GMwith diffusion restriction and can be associated with intrale-sional and diffuse leptomeningeal contrast enhancement Thiswas not the case in our series and did not argue for the directeffect of the virus It is all the more likely that the directdetection of SARS-CoV-2 RNA by RT-PCR was alwaysnegative in all our CSF samples
An alternative hypothesis appears more relevant the neuro-virulence of hCoVs especially MERS-CoV seems to bea consequence of immune-mediated processes1927ndash29 IndeedADEM and Bickerstaff brainstem encephalitis which weredescribed with MERS-CoV18ndash27 are 2 examples of autoim-mune demyelinating diseases resulting from a postinfectious orparainfectious process A recent case report9 has describeda case of acute hemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy (whichis the most severe form of ADEM) associated with COVID-19which strengthens the hypothesis of a predominant immuno-logic mechanism In our cohort we also described 2 cases of
Figure 2 Encephalitis
(A B D) Axial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) and(C) diffusion-weighted MRIs (A) Man 56 years of age lefthippocampus and amygdala FLAIR hyperintensity (B)Woman 71 years of age periventricular and subcorticalwhite matter FLAIR confluent hyperintensities (C) Man 55years of age corpus callosum splenium diffusion hyper-intensity (D) Man 64 years of age FLAIR middle cerebellarpeduncle hyperintensity
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1877
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
limbic encephalitis and 1 case of CLOCC Concerning thelatter no treatment had been started or stopped in previousweeks Thus 75 of encephalitis cases in our cohort (limbicencephalitis CLOCC radiologic ADEM radiologic acutehemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy) are possibly con-sidered immune-mediated diseases Therefore SARS-CoV-2ndashmediated disease is driven largely by immunologic processesand the same mechanisms could explain LME Indeed thearachnoid and pial membranes form the leptomeninges anda significant amount of antigen-presenting cells are present inthe subarachnoid space30 Thus initial immune activationoccurs in the subarachnoid space which is a site for antigenpresentation lymphocyte accumulation and proliferation andantibody production30 All lead to an important local in-flammatory infiltrate with a blood-CSF barrier disruptionwhich can also explain LME Thus LME can be linked toinflammatory or immunologic responses as previously de-scribed in animal models of autoimmune encephalomyelitis31
with some neurotropic viruses such as human T-cell leukemiavirus and HIV31 and in several immune-mediated neurologicdiseases31 Moreover a very similar intracranial pattern hasbeen described in an animal study in piglets affected by gas-troenteritis coronavirus32 Indeed histology demonstrateddiffuse pia matter gliosis with mild congestion of the meningeal
and parenchymal vessels with neuronal degeneration locatedmostly in posterior parietooccipital lobes24 PostcontrastFLAIR is the best sequence to highlight LME but a potentialpitfall is inhalation of increased levels of oxygen by patients whoare intubated which may increase subarachnoid space signalintensity noted on FLAIR images within the basal cisterns andsulcus along the cerebral convexities33 That is why we havechosen in this situation to acquire systematically precontrastand postcontrast FLAIR sequences to avoid misinterpretationof FLAIR hyperintensity within the subarachnoid spaces andnot to misdescribe a meningeal enhancement For our 11patients with LME no precontrast FLAIR signal abnormalitieswere visible in the subarachnoid spaces
Our study has several limitations mainly due to its multicenterand retrospective design First brain MRI protocols were dic-tated by clinical need and the patterns of working could bedifferent among the 11 centers even if neuroradiologists areused to work together Thus 36 of the MRIs were performedwithout administration of gadolinium-based contrast agentsnotably preventing the detection of LME therefore probablyunderestimating it Moreover LMEs are very subtle neuro-imaging findings which need the realization of delayed post-contrast FLAIR sequences which were not done in the vast
Figure 3 Radiologic acute disseminated encephalomyelitis
(A E I) Axial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) (B F J) axial diffusion (B F J) apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC) map and (D H L) postcontrast T1-weighted MRIs Man 60 years of age subcortical periventricular corpus callosum and posterior fossa white matter FLAIR hyperintensities without contrastenhancement (arrows) Some lesions appear hyperintense on diffusion-weightedMRIs with decreased ADC corresponding to cytotoxic edema (stars) Otherlesions present an ADC increase corresponding to vasogenic edema (cross)
e1878 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
majority of the centers Second we did not realize a follow-upMRI and some abnormalities could have appeared duringfollow-up Third outcomes were not available for all patients atthe time of writing Thus the mortality rate is probablyunderestimated in our cohort Fourth although patients withCOVID-19may develop a wide range of neurologic symptomswhich can be associated with ischemic stroke or encephalitis itis difficult to state without a controlled general neurologicpopulation that such events are more frequent in patients withCOVID-19 However it now seems well established thatthrombotic events are particularly frequent in patients withCOVID-1921 Moreover encephalitis which is a rare disorderin the general population34 was surprisingly frequent in ourpopulation
In this large multicentric national cohort most patients withCOVID-19 (56) with neurologic manifestations had brainMRI abnormalities such as ischemic stroke LME and enceph-alitis Because the detection of LME suggests the abnormality ofbrain MRI it would be interesting to realize systematicallypostcontrast FLAIR acquisition in patients with COVID-19
Concerning the cases of encephalitis and LME even if a directviral origin cannot be eliminated the pathophysiology of braindamage related to SARS-COV-2 seems rather to involve aninflammatory or autoimmune response The knowledge ofthe various clinicoradiologic manifestations of COVID-19could be helpful for the best care of the patients and ourunderstanding of the disease In addition to SARS cytokine
Figure 4 Multiple correspondence analysis
The ischemic stroke group (red) can be distinguished from the 3 others which largely overlapMost patients with ischemic stroke (numbers and dots in red onthe plot) are located on the same lower-right half of the graph indicating a commonality of symptoms Diag 1 (black) = normal brain MRI Diag 2 (red) =ischemic stroke Diag 3 (green) = encephalitis Diag 4 (blue) = leptomeningeal enhancement
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1879
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
storm syndrome and heart failure brain injuries may con-tribute to increased mortality This highlights the importanceof neurologic evaluation especially for patients hospitalized inICU with clinical deterioration or worsening of their symp-toms which can be associated with an acute neurologic event
AcknowledgmentThe authors thank Marie Cecile Henry Feugeas for her workin data acquisition for this study
Study fundingNo targeted funding reported
DisclosureThe authors report no disclosures relevant to the manuscriptGo to NeurologyorgN for full disclosures
Publication historyReceived by Neurology April 28 2020 Accepted in final formJune 9 2020
Appendix Authors
Name Location Contribution
StephaneKremer MDPhD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study acquisition of datainterpreted the data draftedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Franccedilois LersyMD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study acquisition of datainterpreted the data draftedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MathieuAnheim MDPhD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
Hamid MerdjiMD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MalekaSchenck MD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
HeleneOesterle MD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FedericoBolognini MD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Julien MessieMD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Antoine KhalilMD PhD
Bichat Hospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
AugustinGaudemer MD
Bichat Hospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Sophie CarreMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Manel AllegMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Claire LecocqMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
EmmanuelleSchmitt MD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ReneAnxionnatMD PhD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Franccedilois ZhuMD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Lavinia JagerMD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Patrick NesserMD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Yannick TallaMba MD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GhaziHmeydia MD
Saint-Anne hospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
JosephBenzakounMD
Saint-Anne hospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
CatherineOppenheimMD PhD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jean-ChristopheFerre MD PhD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Adel MaamarMD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
BeatriceCarsin-NicolMD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Pierre-OlivierComby MD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FredericRicolfi MDPhD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
PierreThouant MD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Claire BoutetMD PhD
University hospital ofSaint-Etienne France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
e1880 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
References1 Chen N Zhou M Dong X et al Epidemiological and clinical characteristics of 99
cases of 2019 novel coronavirus pneumonia in Wuhan China a descriptive studyLancet 2020395507ndash513
2 Huang C Wang Y Li X et al Clinical features of patients infected with 2019 novelcoronavirus in Wuhan China Lancet 2020395497ndash506
3 Glass WG Subbarao K Murphy B Murphy PM Mechanisms of host defense fol-lowing severe acute respiratory syndrome‐coronavirus (SARS‐CoV) pulmonary in-fection of mice J Immunol 20041734030ndash4039
4 Li K Wohlford‐Lenane C Perlman S et al Middle East respiratory syndromecoronavirus causes multiple organ damage and lethal disease in mice transgenic forhuman dipeptidyl peptidase 4 J Infect Dis 2016213712ndash722
5 Arbour N Day R Newcombe J Talbot PJ Neuroinvasion by human respiratorycoronaviruses J Virol 2000748913ndash8921
6 Desforges M Le Coupanec A Stodola JK Meessen-Pinard M Talbot PJ Humancoronaviruses viral and cellular factors involved in neuroinvasiveness and neuro-pathogenesis Virus Res 2014194145ndash158
7 Desforges M Le Coupanec A Dubeau P et al Human coronaviruses and otherrespiratory viruses underestimated opportunistic pathogens of the central nervoussystem Viruses 201912E14
8 Bohmwald K Galvez NMS Rıos M Kalergis AM Neurologic alterations due torespiratory virus infections Front Cell Neurosci 201812386
9 Poyiadji N Shahin G Noujaim D Stone M Patel S Griffith B COVID-19-associatedacute hemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy CT and MRI features Radiology2020201187
10 Moriguchi T Harii N Goto J et al A first case of meningitisencephalitis associatedwith SARS-coronavirus-2 Int J Infect Dis 20209455ndash58
11 Mao L Jin H Wang M et al Neurologic manifestations of hospitalized patients withcoronavirus disease 2019 in Wuhan China JAMA Neurol 2020771ndash9
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Xavier FabreMD
Hospital of RoanneFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GeraudForestier MD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Isaure deBeaurepaireMD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GregoireBornet MD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Hubert DesalMD PhD
University Hospital ofNantes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GregoireBoulouis MD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jerome BergeMD
University Hospital ofBordeaux France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ApollineKazemi MD
University Hospital ofLille France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
NadyaPyatigorskayaMD
Pitie-SalpetriereHospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
AugustinLecler MD
Foundation ARothschild Paris
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
SuzanaSaleme MD
University Hospital ofLimoges France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Myriam Edjlali-Goujon MD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
BasileKerleroux MD
University Hospital ofTours France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jean-MarcConstans MDPhD
University Hospital ofAmiens France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Pierre-EmmanuelZorn PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the acquisitionof data
MurielMatthieu PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the acquisitionof data
Seyyid BalogluMD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of datarevised the manuscriptfor intellectualcontent
Franccedilois-DanielArdellier MD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ThibaultWillaume MD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of datarevised the manuscriptfor intellectualcontent
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Jean-ChristopheBrisset PhD
French Observatoryof Multiple SclerosisLyon France
Interpretation of the datarevised the manuscript forintellectual content
SophieCaillard MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
OlivierCollange MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Paul MichelMertes MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FrancisSchneider MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Samira Fafi-KremerPharmD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MickaelOhana MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FerhatMeziani MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Nicolas MeyerMD PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the analysis andinterpretation of the data
Julie HelmsMD PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
FranccediloisCotton MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1881
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
12 Helms J Kremer S Merdji H et al Neurologic features in severe SARS-CoV-2infection N Engl J Med 20203822268ndash2270
13 Kandemirli SG Dogan L Sarikaya ZT et al Brain MRI findings in patients in theintensive care unit with COVID-19 infection Radiology Epub 2020 May 8
14 Ferguson ND Fan E Camporota L et al The Berlin definition of ARDS an expandedrationale justification and supplementary material Intensive Care Med 2012381573ndash1582
15 Starkey J Kobayashi N Numaguchi Y Moritani T Cytotoxic lesions of the corpuscallosum that show restricted diffusion mechanisms causes and manifestationsRadiographics 201737562ndash576
16 Beyrouti R Adams ME Benjamin L et al Characteristics of ischaemic stroke asso-ciated with COVID-19 J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry Epub 2020 Apr 30
17 Hess DC Eldahshan W Rutkowski E COVID-19-related stroke Transl Stroke Res202011322ndash325
18 Umapathi T Kor AC Venketasubramanian N et al Large artery ischaemic stroke insevere acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) J Neurol 20042511227ndash1231
19 Arabi YM Harthi A Hussein J et al Severe neurologic syndrome associated withMiddle East respiratory syndrome corona virus (MERS-CoV) Infection 201543495ndash501
20 Guo T Fan Y ChenM et al Cardiovascular implications of fatal outcomes of patientswith coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) JAMA Cardiol Epub 2020 Mar 27
21 Helms J Tacquard C Severac F et al High risk of thrombosis in patients in severeSARS-CoV-2 infection a multicenter prospective cohort study Intensive Care Med2020461089ndash1098
22 NagelMAMahalingamRCohrs RJ GildenD Virus vasculopathy and stroke an under-recognized cause and treatment target Infect Disord Drug Targets 201010105ndash111
23 Subramaniam S Scharrer I Procoagulant activity during viral infections Front Biosci(Landmark Ed) 2018231060ndash1081
24 Hung EC Chim SS Chan PK et al Detection of SARS coronavirus RNA in thecerebrospinal fluid of a patient with severe acute respiratory syndrome Clin Chem2003492108ndash2109
25 Lau KK Yu WC Chu CM Lau ST Sheng B Yuen KY Possible central nervoussystem infection by SARS coronavirus Emerg Infect Dis 200410342ndash344
26 Toledano M Davies NWS Infectious encephalitis mimics and chameleons PractNeurol 201919225ndash237
27 Kim JE Heo JH Kim HO et al Neurological complications during treatment ofMiddle East respiratory syndrome J Clin Neurol 201713227ndash233
28 Li Y Li H Fan R et al Coronavirus infections in the central nervous system andrespiratory tract show distinct features in hospitalized children Intervirology 201659163ndash169
29 Yeh EA Collins A Cohen ME Duffner PK Faden H Detection of coronavirus in thecentral nervous system of a child with acute disseminated encephalomyelitis Pedi-atrics 2004113(pt 1)e73ndashe76
30 Kivisakk P Imitola J Rasmussen S et al Localizing central nervous system immunesurveillance meningeal antigen-presenting cells activate T cells during experimentalautoimmune encephalomyelitis Ann Neurol 200965457ndash469
31 Absinta M Cortese IC Vuolo L et al Leptomeningeal gadolinium enhancementacross the spectrum of chronic neuroinflammatory diseases Neurology 2017881439ndash1444
32 Papatsiros VG Stylianaki I Papakonstantinou G Papaioannou N Christodoulo-poulos G Case report of transmissible gastroenteritis coronavirus infection associatedwith small intestine and brain lesions in piglets Viral Immunol 20193263ndash67
33 Stuckey SL Goh TD Heffernan T Rowan D Hyperintensity in the subarachnoidspace on FLAIR MRI AJR Am J Roentgenol 2007189913ndash921
34 Parpia AS Li Y Chen C Dhar B Crowcroft NS Encephalitis Ontario Canada 2002-2013 Emerg Infect Dis 201622426ndash432
e1882 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
DOI 101212WNL0000000000010112202095e1868-e1882 Published Online before print July 17 2020Neurology
Steacutephane Kremer Franccedilois Lersy Mathieu Anheim et al multicenter study
Neurologic and neuroimaging findings in patients with COVID-19 A retrospective
This information is current as of July 17 2020
ServicesUpdated Information amp
httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullincluding high resolution figures can be found at
References httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullref-list-1
This article cites 30 articles 6 of which you can access for free at
Citations httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullotherarticles
This article has been cited by 3 HighWire-hosted articles
Subspecialty Collections
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmriMRI
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmeningitisMeningitis
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionencephalitisEncephalitis e
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_cerebrovascular_disease_strokAll Cerebrovascular diseaseStrokefollowing collection(s) This article along with others on similar topics appears in the
Permissions amp Licensing
httpwwwneurologyorgaboutabout_the_journalpermissionsits entirety can be found online atInformation about reproducing this article in parts (figurestables) or in
Reprints
httpnneurologyorgsubscribersadvertiseInformation about ordering reprints can be found online
rights reserved Print ISSN 0028-3878 Online ISSN 1526-632X1951 it is now a weekly with 48 issues per year Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology All
reg is the official journal of the American Academy of Neurology Published continuously sinceNeurology
![Page 11: Neurologicandneuroimaging findingsinpatients with COVID-19 · enhancement (17%), and encephalitis (13%) were the most frequent neuroimaging findings. Confusion (53%) was the most](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060813/6091b284d4b0681e5152b42b/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
limbic encephalitis and 1 case of CLOCC Concerning thelatter no treatment had been started or stopped in previousweeks Thus 75 of encephalitis cases in our cohort (limbicencephalitis CLOCC radiologic ADEM radiologic acutehemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy) are possibly con-sidered immune-mediated diseases Therefore SARS-CoV-2ndashmediated disease is driven largely by immunologic processesand the same mechanisms could explain LME Indeed thearachnoid and pial membranes form the leptomeninges anda significant amount of antigen-presenting cells are present inthe subarachnoid space30 Thus initial immune activationoccurs in the subarachnoid space which is a site for antigenpresentation lymphocyte accumulation and proliferation andantibody production30 All lead to an important local in-flammatory infiltrate with a blood-CSF barrier disruptionwhich can also explain LME Thus LME can be linked toinflammatory or immunologic responses as previously de-scribed in animal models of autoimmune encephalomyelitis31
with some neurotropic viruses such as human T-cell leukemiavirus and HIV31 and in several immune-mediated neurologicdiseases31 Moreover a very similar intracranial pattern hasbeen described in an animal study in piglets affected by gas-troenteritis coronavirus32 Indeed histology demonstrateddiffuse pia matter gliosis with mild congestion of the meningeal
and parenchymal vessels with neuronal degeneration locatedmostly in posterior parietooccipital lobes24 PostcontrastFLAIR is the best sequence to highlight LME but a potentialpitfall is inhalation of increased levels of oxygen by patients whoare intubated which may increase subarachnoid space signalintensity noted on FLAIR images within the basal cisterns andsulcus along the cerebral convexities33 That is why we havechosen in this situation to acquire systematically precontrastand postcontrast FLAIR sequences to avoid misinterpretationof FLAIR hyperintensity within the subarachnoid spaces andnot to misdescribe a meningeal enhancement For our 11patients with LME no precontrast FLAIR signal abnormalitieswere visible in the subarachnoid spaces
Our study has several limitations mainly due to its multicenterand retrospective design First brain MRI protocols were dic-tated by clinical need and the patterns of working could bedifferent among the 11 centers even if neuroradiologists areused to work together Thus 36 of the MRIs were performedwithout administration of gadolinium-based contrast agentsnotably preventing the detection of LME therefore probablyunderestimating it Moreover LMEs are very subtle neuro-imaging findings which need the realization of delayed post-contrast FLAIR sequences which were not done in the vast
Figure 3 Radiologic acute disseminated encephalomyelitis
(A E I) Axial fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) (B F J) axial diffusion (B F J) apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC) map and (D H L) postcontrast T1-weighted MRIs Man 60 years of age subcortical periventricular corpus callosum and posterior fossa white matter FLAIR hyperintensities without contrastenhancement (arrows) Some lesions appear hyperintense on diffusion-weightedMRIs with decreased ADC corresponding to cytotoxic edema (stars) Otherlesions present an ADC increase corresponding to vasogenic edema (cross)
e1878 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
majority of the centers Second we did not realize a follow-upMRI and some abnormalities could have appeared duringfollow-up Third outcomes were not available for all patients atthe time of writing Thus the mortality rate is probablyunderestimated in our cohort Fourth although patients withCOVID-19may develop a wide range of neurologic symptomswhich can be associated with ischemic stroke or encephalitis itis difficult to state without a controlled general neurologicpopulation that such events are more frequent in patients withCOVID-19 However it now seems well established thatthrombotic events are particularly frequent in patients withCOVID-1921 Moreover encephalitis which is a rare disorderin the general population34 was surprisingly frequent in ourpopulation
In this large multicentric national cohort most patients withCOVID-19 (56) with neurologic manifestations had brainMRI abnormalities such as ischemic stroke LME and enceph-alitis Because the detection of LME suggests the abnormality ofbrain MRI it would be interesting to realize systematicallypostcontrast FLAIR acquisition in patients with COVID-19
Concerning the cases of encephalitis and LME even if a directviral origin cannot be eliminated the pathophysiology of braindamage related to SARS-COV-2 seems rather to involve aninflammatory or autoimmune response The knowledge ofthe various clinicoradiologic manifestations of COVID-19could be helpful for the best care of the patients and ourunderstanding of the disease In addition to SARS cytokine
Figure 4 Multiple correspondence analysis
The ischemic stroke group (red) can be distinguished from the 3 others which largely overlapMost patients with ischemic stroke (numbers and dots in red onthe plot) are located on the same lower-right half of the graph indicating a commonality of symptoms Diag 1 (black) = normal brain MRI Diag 2 (red) =ischemic stroke Diag 3 (green) = encephalitis Diag 4 (blue) = leptomeningeal enhancement
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1879
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
storm syndrome and heart failure brain injuries may con-tribute to increased mortality This highlights the importanceof neurologic evaluation especially for patients hospitalized inICU with clinical deterioration or worsening of their symp-toms which can be associated with an acute neurologic event
AcknowledgmentThe authors thank Marie Cecile Henry Feugeas for her workin data acquisition for this study
Study fundingNo targeted funding reported
DisclosureThe authors report no disclosures relevant to the manuscriptGo to NeurologyorgN for full disclosures
Publication historyReceived by Neurology April 28 2020 Accepted in final formJune 9 2020
Appendix Authors
Name Location Contribution
StephaneKremer MDPhD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study acquisition of datainterpreted the data draftedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Franccedilois LersyMD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study acquisition of datainterpreted the data draftedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MathieuAnheim MDPhD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
Hamid MerdjiMD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MalekaSchenck MD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
HeleneOesterle MD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FedericoBolognini MD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Julien MessieMD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Antoine KhalilMD PhD
Bichat Hospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
AugustinGaudemer MD
Bichat Hospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Sophie CarreMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Manel AllegMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Claire LecocqMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
EmmanuelleSchmitt MD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ReneAnxionnatMD PhD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Franccedilois ZhuMD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Lavinia JagerMD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Patrick NesserMD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Yannick TallaMba MD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GhaziHmeydia MD
Saint-Anne hospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
JosephBenzakounMD
Saint-Anne hospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
CatherineOppenheimMD PhD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jean-ChristopheFerre MD PhD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Adel MaamarMD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
BeatriceCarsin-NicolMD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Pierre-OlivierComby MD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FredericRicolfi MDPhD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
PierreThouant MD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Claire BoutetMD PhD
University hospital ofSaint-Etienne France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
e1880 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
References1 Chen N Zhou M Dong X et al Epidemiological and clinical characteristics of 99
cases of 2019 novel coronavirus pneumonia in Wuhan China a descriptive studyLancet 2020395507ndash513
2 Huang C Wang Y Li X et al Clinical features of patients infected with 2019 novelcoronavirus in Wuhan China Lancet 2020395497ndash506
3 Glass WG Subbarao K Murphy B Murphy PM Mechanisms of host defense fol-lowing severe acute respiratory syndrome‐coronavirus (SARS‐CoV) pulmonary in-fection of mice J Immunol 20041734030ndash4039
4 Li K Wohlford‐Lenane C Perlman S et al Middle East respiratory syndromecoronavirus causes multiple organ damage and lethal disease in mice transgenic forhuman dipeptidyl peptidase 4 J Infect Dis 2016213712ndash722
5 Arbour N Day R Newcombe J Talbot PJ Neuroinvasion by human respiratorycoronaviruses J Virol 2000748913ndash8921
6 Desforges M Le Coupanec A Stodola JK Meessen-Pinard M Talbot PJ Humancoronaviruses viral and cellular factors involved in neuroinvasiveness and neuro-pathogenesis Virus Res 2014194145ndash158
7 Desforges M Le Coupanec A Dubeau P et al Human coronaviruses and otherrespiratory viruses underestimated opportunistic pathogens of the central nervoussystem Viruses 201912E14
8 Bohmwald K Galvez NMS Rıos M Kalergis AM Neurologic alterations due torespiratory virus infections Front Cell Neurosci 201812386
9 Poyiadji N Shahin G Noujaim D Stone M Patel S Griffith B COVID-19-associatedacute hemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy CT and MRI features Radiology2020201187
10 Moriguchi T Harii N Goto J et al A first case of meningitisencephalitis associatedwith SARS-coronavirus-2 Int J Infect Dis 20209455ndash58
11 Mao L Jin H Wang M et al Neurologic manifestations of hospitalized patients withcoronavirus disease 2019 in Wuhan China JAMA Neurol 2020771ndash9
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Xavier FabreMD
Hospital of RoanneFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GeraudForestier MD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Isaure deBeaurepaireMD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GregoireBornet MD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Hubert DesalMD PhD
University Hospital ofNantes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GregoireBoulouis MD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jerome BergeMD
University Hospital ofBordeaux France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ApollineKazemi MD
University Hospital ofLille France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
NadyaPyatigorskayaMD
Pitie-SalpetriereHospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
AugustinLecler MD
Foundation ARothschild Paris
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
SuzanaSaleme MD
University Hospital ofLimoges France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Myriam Edjlali-Goujon MD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
BasileKerleroux MD
University Hospital ofTours France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jean-MarcConstans MDPhD
University Hospital ofAmiens France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Pierre-EmmanuelZorn PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the acquisitionof data
MurielMatthieu PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the acquisitionof data
Seyyid BalogluMD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of datarevised the manuscriptfor intellectualcontent
Franccedilois-DanielArdellier MD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ThibaultWillaume MD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of datarevised the manuscriptfor intellectualcontent
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Jean-ChristopheBrisset PhD
French Observatoryof Multiple SclerosisLyon France
Interpretation of the datarevised the manuscript forintellectual content
SophieCaillard MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
OlivierCollange MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Paul MichelMertes MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FrancisSchneider MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Samira Fafi-KremerPharmD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MickaelOhana MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FerhatMeziani MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Nicolas MeyerMD PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the analysis andinterpretation of the data
Julie HelmsMD PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
FranccediloisCotton MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1881
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
12 Helms J Kremer S Merdji H et al Neurologic features in severe SARS-CoV-2infection N Engl J Med 20203822268ndash2270
13 Kandemirli SG Dogan L Sarikaya ZT et al Brain MRI findings in patients in theintensive care unit with COVID-19 infection Radiology Epub 2020 May 8
14 Ferguson ND Fan E Camporota L et al The Berlin definition of ARDS an expandedrationale justification and supplementary material Intensive Care Med 2012381573ndash1582
15 Starkey J Kobayashi N Numaguchi Y Moritani T Cytotoxic lesions of the corpuscallosum that show restricted diffusion mechanisms causes and manifestationsRadiographics 201737562ndash576
16 Beyrouti R Adams ME Benjamin L et al Characteristics of ischaemic stroke asso-ciated with COVID-19 J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry Epub 2020 Apr 30
17 Hess DC Eldahshan W Rutkowski E COVID-19-related stroke Transl Stroke Res202011322ndash325
18 Umapathi T Kor AC Venketasubramanian N et al Large artery ischaemic stroke insevere acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) J Neurol 20042511227ndash1231
19 Arabi YM Harthi A Hussein J et al Severe neurologic syndrome associated withMiddle East respiratory syndrome corona virus (MERS-CoV) Infection 201543495ndash501
20 Guo T Fan Y ChenM et al Cardiovascular implications of fatal outcomes of patientswith coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) JAMA Cardiol Epub 2020 Mar 27
21 Helms J Tacquard C Severac F et al High risk of thrombosis in patients in severeSARS-CoV-2 infection a multicenter prospective cohort study Intensive Care Med2020461089ndash1098
22 NagelMAMahalingamRCohrs RJ GildenD Virus vasculopathy and stroke an under-recognized cause and treatment target Infect Disord Drug Targets 201010105ndash111
23 Subramaniam S Scharrer I Procoagulant activity during viral infections Front Biosci(Landmark Ed) 2018231060ndash1081
24 Hung EC Chim SS Chan PK et al Detection of SARS coronavirus RNA in thecerebrospinal fluid of a patient with severe acute respiratory syndrome Clin Chem2003492108ndash2109
25 Lau KK Yu WC Chu CM Lau ST Sheng B Yuen KY Possible central nervoussystem infection by SARS coronavirus Emerg Infect Dis 200410342ndash344
26 Toledano M Davies NWS Infectious encephalitis mimics and chameleons PractNeurol 201919225ndash237
27 Kim JE Heo JH Kim HO et al Neurological complications during treatment ofMiddle East respiratory syndrome J Clin Neurol 201713227ndash233
28 Li Y Li H Fan R et al Coronavirus infections in the central nervous system andrespiratory tract show distinct features in hospitalized children Intervirology 201659163ndash169
29 Yeh EA Collins A Cohen ME Duffner PK Faden H Detection of coronavirus in thecentral nervous system of a child with acute disseminated encephalomyelitis Pedi-atrics 2004113(pt 1)e73ndashe76
30 Kivisakk P Imitola J Rasmussen S et al Localizing central nervous system immunesurveillance meningeal antigen-presenting cells activate T cells during experimentalautoimmune encephalomyelitis Ann Neurol 200965457ndash469
31 Absinta M Cortese IC Vuolo L et al Leptomeningeal gadolinium enhancementacross the spectrum of chronic neuroinflammatory diseases Neurology 2017881439ndash1444
32 Papatsiros VG Stylianaki I Papakonstantinou G Papaioannou N Christodoulo-poulos G Case report of transmissible gastroenteritis coronavirus infection associatedwith small intestine and brain lesions in piglets Viral Immunol 20193263ndash67
33 Stuckey SL Goh TD Heffernan T Rowan D Hyperintensity in the subarachnoidspace on FLAIR MRI AJR Am J Roentgenol 2007189913ndash921
34 Parpia AS Li Y Chen C Dhar B Crowcroft NS Encephalitis Ontario Canada 2002-2013 Emerg Infect Dis 201622426ndash432
e1882 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
DOI 101212WNL0000000000010112202095e1868-e1882 Published Online before print July 17 2020Neurology
Steacutephane Kremer Franccedilois Lersy Mathieu Anheim et al multicenter study
Neurologic and neuroimaging findings in patients with COVID-19 A retrospective
This information is current as of July 17 2020
ServicesUpdated Information amp
httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullincluding high resolution figures can be found at
References httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullref-list-1
This article cites 30 articles 6 of which you can access for free at
Citations httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullotherarticles
This article has been cited by 3 HighWire-hosted articles
Subspecialty Collections
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmriMRI
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmeningitisMeningitis
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionencephalitisEncephalitis e
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_cerebrovascular_disease_strokAll Cerebrovascular diseaseStrokefollowing collection(s) This article along with others on similar topics appears in the
Permissions amp Licensing
httpwwwneurologyorgaboutabout_the_journalpermissionsits entirety can be found online atInformation about reproducing this article in parts (figurestables) or in
Reprints
httpnneurologyorgsubscribersadvertiseInformation about ordering reprints can be found online
rights reserved Print ISSN 0028-3878 Online ISSN 1526-632X1951 it is now a weekly with 48 issues per year Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology All
reg is the official journal of the American Academy of Neurology Published continuously sinceNeurology
![Page 12: Neurologicandneuroimaging findingsinpatients with COVID-19 · enhancement (17%), and encephalitis (13%) were the most frequent neuroimaging findings. Confusion (53%) was the most](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060813/6091b284d4b0681e5152b42b/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
majority of the centers Second we did not realize a follow-upMRI and some abnormalities could have appeared duringfollow-up Third outcomes were not available for all patients atthe time of writing Thus the mortality rate is probablyunderestimated in our cohort Fourth although patients withCOVID-19may develop a wide range of neurologic symptomswhich can be associated with ischemic stroke or encephalitis itis difficult to state without a controlled general neurologicpopulation that such events are more frequent in patients withCOVID-19 However it now seems well established thatthrombotic events are particularly frequent in patients withCOVID-1921 Moreover encephalitis which is a rare disorderin the general population34 was surprisingly frequent in ourpopulation
In this large multicentric national cohort most patients withCOVID-19 (56) with neurologic manifestations had brainMRI abnormalities such as ischemic stroke LME and enceph-alitis Because the detection of LME suggests the abnormality ofbrain MRI it would be interesting to realize systematicallypostcontrast FLAIR acquisition in patients with COVID-19
Concerning the cases of encephalitis and LME even if a directviral origin cannot be eliminated the pathophysiology of braindamage related to SARS-COV-2 seems rather to involve aninflammatory or autoimmune response The knowledge ofthe various clinicoradiologic manifestations of COVID-19could be helpful for the best care of the patients and ourunderstanding of the disease In addition to SARS cytokine
Figure 4 Multiple correspondence analysis
The ischemic stroke group (red) can be distinguished from the 3 others which largely overlapMost patients with ischemic stroke (numbers and dots in red onthe plot) are located on the same lower-right half of the graph indicating a commonality of symptoms Diag 1 (black) = normal brain MRI Diag 2 (red) =ischemic stroke Diag 3 (green) = encephalitis Diag 4 (blue) = leptomeningeal enhancement
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1879
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
storm syndrome and heart failure brain injuries may con-tribute to increased mortality This highlights the importanceof neurologic evaluation especially for patients hospitalized inICU with clinical deterioration or worsening of their symp-toms which can be associated with an acute neurologic event
AcknowledgmentThe authors thank Marie Cecile Henry Feugeas for her workin data acquisition for this study
Study fundingNo targeted funding reported
DisclosureThe authors report no disclosures relevant to the manuscriptGo to NeurologyorgN for full disclosures
Publication historyReceived by Neurology April 28 2020 Accepted in final formJune 9 2020
Appendix Authors
Name Location Contribution
StephaneKremer MDPhD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study acquisition of datainterpreted the data draftedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Franccedilois LersyMD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study acquisition of datainterpreted the data draftedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MathieuAnheim MDPhD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
Hamid MerdjiMD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MalekaSchenck MD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
HeleneOesterle MD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FedericoBolognini MD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Julien MessieMD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Antoine KhalilMD PhD
Bichat Hospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
AugustinGaudemer MD
Bichat Hospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Sophie CarreMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Manel AllegMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Claire LecocqMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
EmmanuelleSchmitt MD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ReneAnxionnatMD PhD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Franccedilois ZhuMD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Lavinia JagerMD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Patrick NesserMD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Yannick TallaMba MD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GhaziHmeydia MD
Saint-Anne hospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
JosephBenzakounMD
Saint-Anne hospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
CatherineOppenheimMD PhD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jean-ChristopheFerre MD PhD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Adel MaamarMD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
BeatriceCarsin-NicolMD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Pierre-OlivierComby MD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FredericRicolfi MDPhD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
PierreThouant MD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Claire BoutetMD PhD
University hospital ofSaint-Etienne France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
e1880 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
References1 Chen N Zhou M Dong X et al Epidemiological and clinical characteristics of 99
cases of 2019 novel coronavirus pneumonia in Wuhan China a descriptive studyLancet 2020395507ndash513
2 Huang C Wang Y Li X et al Clinical features of patients infected with 2019 novelcoronavirus in Wuhan China Lancet 2020395497ndash506
3 Glass WG Subbarao K Murphy B Murphy PM Mechanisms of host defense fol-lowing severe acute respiratory syndrome‐coronavirus (SARS‐CoV) pulmonary in-fection of mice J Immunol 20041734030ndash4039
4 Li K Wohlford‐Lenane C Perlman S et al Middle East respiratory syndromecoronavirus causes multiple organ damage and lethal disease in mice transgenic forhuman dipeptidyl peptidase 4 J Infect Dis 2016213712ndash722
5 Arbour N Day R Newcombe J Talbot PJ Neuroinvasion by human respiratorycoronaviruses J Virol 2000748913ndash8921
6 Desforges M Le Coupanec A Stodola JK Meessen-Pinard M Talbot PJ Humancoronaviruses viral and cellular factors involved in neuroinvasiveness and neuro-pathogenesis Virus Res 2014194145ndash158
7 Desforges M Le Coupanec A Dubeau P et al Human coronaviruses and otherrespiratory viruses underestimated opportunistic pathogens of the central nervoussystem Viruses 201912E14
8 Bohmwald K Galvez NMS Rıos M Kalergis AM Neurologic alterations due torespiratory virus infections Front Cell Neurosci 201812386
9 Poyiadji N Shahin G Noujaim D Stone M Patel S Griffith B COVID-19-associatedacute hemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy CT and MRI features Radiology2020201187
10 Moriguchi T Harii N Goto J et al A first case of meningitisencephalitis associatedwith SARS-coronavirus-2 Int J Infect Dis 20209455ndash58
11 Mao L Jin H Wang M et al Neurologic manifestations of hospitalized patients withcoronavirus disease 2019 in Wuhan China JAMA Neurol 2020771ndash9
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Xavier FabreMD
Hospital of RoanneFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GeraudForestier MD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Isaure deBeaurepaireMD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GregoireBornet MD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Hubert DesalMD PhD
University Hospital ofNantes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GregoireBoulouis MD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jerome BergeMD
University Hospital ofBordeaux France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ApollineKazemi MD
University Hospital ofLille France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
NadyaPyatigorskayaMD
Pitie-SalpetriereHospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
AugustinLecler MD
Foundation ARothschild Paris
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
SuzanaSaleme MD
University Hospital ofLimoges France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Myriam Edjlali-Goujon MD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
BasileKerleroux MD
University Hospital ofTours France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jean-MarcConstans MDPhD
University Hospital ofAmiens France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Pierre-EmmanuelZorn PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the acquisitionof data
MurielMatthieu PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the acquisitionof data
Seyyid BalogluMD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of datarevised the manuscriptfor intellectualcontent
Franccedilois-DanielArdellier MD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ThibaultWillaume MD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of datarevised the manuscriptfor intellectualcontent
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Jean-ChristopheBrisset PhD
French Observatoryof Multiple SclerosisLyon France
Interpretation of the datarevised the manuscript forintellectual content
SophieCaillard MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
OlivierCollange MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Paul MichelMertes MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FrancisSchneider MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Samira Fafi-KremerPharmD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MickaelOhana MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FerhatMeziani MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Nicolas MeyerMD PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the analysis andinterpretation of the data
Julie HelmsMD PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
FranccediloisCotton MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1881
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
12 Helms J Kremer S Merdji H et al Neurologic features in severe SARS-CoV-2infection N Engl J Med 20203822268ndash2270
13 Kandemirli SG Dogan L Sarikaya ZT et al Brain MRI findings in patients in theintensive care unit with COVID-19 infection Radiology Epub 2020 May 8
14 Ferguson ND Fan E Camporota L et al The Berlin definition of ARDS an expandedrationale justification and supplementary material Intensive Care Med 2012381573ndash1582
15 Starkey J Kobayashi N Numaguchi Y Moritani T Cytotoxic lesions of the corpuscallosum that show restricted diffusion mechanisms causes and manifestationsRadiographics 201737562ndash576
16 Beyrouti R Adams ME Benjamin L et al Characteristics of ischaemic stroke asso-ciated with COVID-19 J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry Epub 2020 Apr 30
17 Hess DC Eldahshan W Rutkowski E COVID-19-related stroke Transl Stroke Res202011322ndash325
18 Umapathi T Kor AC Venketasubramanian N et al Large artery ischaemic stroke insevere acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) J Neurol 20042511227ndash1231
19 Arabi YM Harthi A Hussein J et al Severe neurologic syndrome associated withMiddle East respiratory syndrome corona virus (MERS-CoV) Infection 201543495ndash501
20 Guo T Fan Y ChenM et al Cardiovascular implications of fatal outcomes of patientswith coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) JAMA Cardiol Epub 2020 Mar 27
21 Helms J Tacquard C Severac F et al High risk of thrombosis in patients in severeSARS-CoV-2 infection a multicenter prospective cohort study Intensive Care Med2020461089ndash1098
22 NagelMAMahalingamRCohrs RJ GildenD Virus vasculopathy and stroke an under-recognized cause and treatment target Infect Disord Drug Targets 201010105ndash111
23 Subramaniam S Scharrer I Procoagulant activity during viral infections Front Biosci(Landmark Ed) 2018231060ndash1081
24 Hung EC Chim SS Chan PK et al Detection of SARS coronavirus RNA in thecerebrospinal fluid of a patient with severe acute respiratory syndrome Clin Chem2003492108ndash2109
25 Lau KK Yu WC Chu CM Lau ST Sheng B Yuen KY Possible central nervoussystem infection by SARS coronavirus Emerg Infect Dis 200410342ndash344
26 Toledano M Davies NWS Infectious encephalitis mimics and chameleons PractNeurol 201919225ndash237
27 Kim JE Heo JH Kim HO et al Neurological complications during treatment ofMiddle East respiratory syndrome J Clin Neurol 201713227ndash233
28 Li Y Li H Fan R et al Coronavirus infections in the central nervous system andrespiratory tract show distinct features in hospitalized children Intervirology 201659163ndash169
29 Yeh EA Collins A Cohen ME Duffner PK Faden H Detection of coronavirus in thecentral nervous system of a child with acute disseminated encephalomyelitis Pedi-atrics 2004113(pt 1)e73ndashe76
30 Kivisakk P Imitola J Rasmussen S et al Localizing central nervous system immunesurveillance meningeal antigen-presenting cells activate T cells during experimentalautoimmune encephalomyelitis Ann Neurol 200965457ndash469
31 Absinta M Cortese IC Vuolo L et al Leptomeningeal gadolinium enhancementacross the spectrum of chronic neuroinflammatory diseases Neurology 2017881439ndash1444
32 Papatsiros VG Stylianaki I Papakonstantinou G Papaioannou N Christodoulo-poulos G Case report of transmissible gastroenteritis coronavirus infection associatedwith small intestine and brain lesions in piglets Viral Immunol 20193263ndash67
33 Stuckey SL Goh TD Heffernan T Rowan D Hyperintensity in the subarachnoidspace on FLAIR MRI AJR Am J Roentgenol 2007189913ndash921
34 Parpia AS Li Y Chen C Dhar B Crowcroft NS Encephalitis Ontario Canada 2002-2013 Emerg Infect Dis 201622426ndash432
e1882 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
DOI 101212WNL0000000000010112202095e1868-e1882 Published Online before print July 17 2020Neurology
Steacutephane Kremer Franccedilois Lersy Mathieu Anheim et al multicenter study
Neurologic and neuroimaging findings in patients with COVID-19 A retrospective
This information is current as of July 17 2020
ServicesUpdated Information amp
httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullincluding high resolution figures can be found at
References httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullref-list-1
This article cites 30 articles 6 of which you can access for free at
Citations httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullotherarticles
This article has been cited by 3 HighWire-hosted articles
Subspecialty Collections
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmriMRI
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmeningitisMeningitis
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionencephalitisEncephalitis e
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_cerebrovascular_disease_strokAll Cerebrovascular diseaseStrokefollowing collection(s) This article along with others on similar topics appears in the
Permissions amp Licensing
httpwwwneurologyorgaboutabout_the_journalpermissionsits entirety can be found online atInformation about reproducing this article in parts (figurestables) or in
Reprints
httpnneurologyorgsubscribersadvertiseInformation about ordering reprints can be found online
rights reserved Print ISSN 0028-3878 Online ISSN 1526-632X1951 it is now a weekly with 48 issues per year Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology All
reg is the official journal of the American Academy of Neurology Published continuously sinceNeurology
![Page 13: Neurologicandneuroimaging findingsinpatients with COVID-19 · enhancement (17%), and encephalitis (13%) were the most frequent neuroimaging findings. Confusion (53%) was the most](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060813/6091b284d4b0681e5152b42b/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
storm syndrome and heart failure brain injuries may con-tribute to increased mortality This highlights the importanceof neurologic evaluation especially for patients hospitalized inICU with clinical deterioration or worsening of their symp-toms which can be associated with an acute neurologic event
AcknowledgmentThe authors thank Marie Cecile Henry Feugeas for her workin data acquisition for this study
Study fundingNo targeted funding reported
DisclosureThe authors report no disclosures relevant to the manuscriptGo to NeurologyorgN for full disclosures
Publication historyReceived by Neurology April 28 2020 Accepted in final formJune 9 2020
Appendix Authors
Name Location Contribution
StephaneKremer MDPhD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study acquisition of datainterpreted the data draftedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Franccedilois LersyMD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study acquisition of datainterpreted the data draftedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MathieuAnheim MDPhD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
Hamid MerdjiMD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MalekaSchenck MD
University Hospital ofStrasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
HeleneOesterle MD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FedericoBolognini MD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Julien MessieMD
Hospital of ColmarFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Antoine KhalilMD PhD
Bichat Hospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
AugustinGaudemer MD
Bichat Hospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Sophie CarreMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Manel AllegMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Claire LecocqMD
Hospital ofHaguenau France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
EmmanuelleSchmitt MD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ReneAnxionnatMD PhD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Franccedilois ZhuMD
University Hospital ofNancy France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Lavinia JagerMD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Patrick NesserMD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Yannick TallaMba MD
Hospital of ForbachFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GhaziHmeydia MD
Saint-Anne hospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
JosephBenzakounMD
Saint-Anne hospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
CatherineOppenheimMD PhD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jean-ChristopheFerre MD PhD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Adel MaamarMD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
BeatriceCarsin-NicolMD
University Hospital ofRennes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Pierre-OlivierComby MD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FredericRicolfi MDPhD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
PierreThouant MD
University hospitalsof Dijon France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Claire BoutetMD PhD
University hospital ofSaint-Etienne France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
e1880 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
References1 Chen N Zhou M Dong X et al Epidemiological and clinical characteristics of 99
cases of 2019 novel coronavirus pneumonia in Wuhan China a descriptive studyLancet 2020395507ndash513
2 Huang C Wang Y Li X et al Clinical features of patients infected with 2019 novelcoronavirus in Wuhan China Lancet 2020395497ndash506
3 Glass WG Subbarao K Murphy B Murphy PM Mechanisms of host defense fol-lowing severe acute respiratory syndrome‐coronavirus (SARS‐CoV) pulmonary in-fection of mice J Immunol 20041734030ndash4039
4 Li K Wohlford‐Lenane C Perlman S et al Middle East respiratory syndromecoronavirus causes multiple organ damage and lethal disease in mice transgenic forhuman dipeptidyl peptidase 4 J Infect Dis 2016213712ndash722
5 Arbour N Day R Newcombe J Talbot PJ Neuroinvasion by human respiratorycoronaviruses J Virol 2000748913ndash8921
6 Desforges M Le Coupanec A Stodola JK Meessen-Pinard M Talbot PJ Humancoronaviruses viral and cellular factors involved in neuroinvasiveness and neuro-pathogenesis Virus Res 2014194145ndash158
7 Desforges M Le Coupanec A Dubeau P et al Human coronaviruses and otherrespiratory viruses underestimated opportunistic pathogens of the central nervoussystem Viruses 201912E14
8 Bohmwald K Galvez NMS Rıos M Kalergis AM Neurologic alterations due torespiratory virus infections Front Cell Neurosci 201812386
9 Poyiadji N Shahin G Noujaim D Stone M Patel S Griffith B COVID-19-associatedacute hemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy CT and MRI features Radiology2020201187
10 Moriguchi T Harii N Goto J et al A first case of meningitisencephalitis associatedwith SARS-coronavirus-2 Int J Infect Dis 20209455ndash58
11 Mao L Jin H Wang M et al Neurologic manifestations of hospitalized patients withcoronavirus disease 2019 in Wuhan China JAMA Neurol 2020771ndash9
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Xavier FabreMD
Hospital of RoanneFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GeraudForestier MD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Isaure deBeaurepaireMD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GregoireBornet MD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Hubert DesalMD PhD
University Hospital ofNantes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GregoireBoulouis MD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jerome BergeMD
University Hospital ofBordeaux France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ApollineKazemi MD
University Hospital ofLille France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
NadyaPyatigorskayaMD
Pitie-SalpetriereHospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
AugustinLecler MD
Foundation ARothschild Paris
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
SuzanaSaleme MD
University Hospital ofLimoges France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Myriam Edjlali-Goujon MD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
BasileKerleroux MD
University Hospital ofTours France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jean-MarcConstans MDPhD
University Hospital ofAmiens France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Pierre-EmmanuelZorn PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the acquisitionof data
MurielMatthieu PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the acquisitionof data
Seyyid BalogluMD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of datarevised the manuscriptfor intellectualcontent
Franccedilois-DanielArdellier MD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ThibaultWillaume MD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of datarevised the manuscriptfor intellectualcontent
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Jean-ChristopheBrisset PhD
French Observatoryof Multiple SclerosisLyon France
Interpretation of the datarevised the manuscript forintellectual content
SophieCaillard MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
OlivierCollange MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Paul MichelMertes MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FrancisSchneider MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Samira Fafi-KremerPharmD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MickaelOhana MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FerhatMeziani MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Nicolas MeyerMD PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the analysis andinterpretation of the data
Julie HelmsMD PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
FranccediloisCotton MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1881
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
12 Helms J Kremer S Merdji H et al Neurologic features in severe SARS-CoV-2infection N Engl J Med 20203822268ndash2270
13 Kandemirli SG Dogan L Sarikaya ZT et al Brain MRI findings in patients in theintensive care unit with COVID-19 infection Radiology Epub 2020 May 8
14 Ferguson ND Fan E Camporota L et al The Berlin definition of ARDS an expandedrationale justification and supplementary material Intensive Care Med 2012381573ndash1582
15 Starkey J Kobayashi N Numaguchi Y Moritani T Cytotoxic lesions of the corpuscallosum that show restricted diffusion mechanisms causes and manifestationsRadiographics 201737562ndash576
16 Beyrouti R Adams ME Benjamin L et al Characteristics of ischaemic stroke asso-ciated with COVID-19 J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry Epub 2020 Apr 30
17 Hess DC Eldahshan W Rutkowski E COVID-19-related stroke Transl Stroke Res202011322ndash325
18 Umapathi T Kor AC Venketasubramanian N et al Large artery ischaemic stroke insevere acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) J Neurol 20042511227ndash1231
19 Arabi YM Harthi A Hussein J et al Severe neurologic syndrome associated withMiddle East respiratory syndrome corona virus (MERS-CoV) Infection 201543495ndash501
20 Guo T Fan Y ChenM et al Cardiovascular implications of fatal outcomes of patientswith coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) JAMA Cardiol Epub 2020 Mar 27
21 Helms J Tacquard C Severac F et al High risk of thrombosis in patients in severeSARS-CoV-2 infection a multicenter prospective cohort study Intensive Care Med2020461089ndash1098
22 NagelMAMahalingamRCohrs RJ GildenD Virus vasculopathy and stroke an under-recognized cause and treatment target Infect Disord Drug Targets 201010105ndash111
23 Subramaniam S Scharrer I Procoagulant activity during viral infections Front Biosci(Landmark Ed) 2018231060ndash1081
24 Hung EC Chim SS Chan PK et al Detection of SARS coronavirus RNA in thecerebrospinal fluid of a patient with severe acute respiratory syndrome Clin Chem2003492108ndash2109
25 Lau KK Yu WC Chu CM Lau ST Sheng B Yuen KY Possible central nervoussystem infection by SARS coronavirus Emerg Infect Dis 200410342ndash344
26 Toledano M Davies NWS Infectious encephalitis mimics and chameleons PractNeurol 201919225ndash237
27 Kim JE Heo JH Kim HO et al Neurological complications during treatment ofMiddle East respiratory syndrome J Clin Neurol 201713227ndash233
28 Li Y Li H Fan R et al Coronavirus infections in the central nervous system andrespiratory tract show distinct features in hospitalized children Intervirology 201659163ndash169
29 Yeh EA Collins A Cohen ME Duffner PK Faden H Detection of coronavirus in thecentral nervous system of a child with acute disseminated encephalomyelitis Pedi-atrics 2004113(pt 1)e73ndashe76
30 Kivisakk P Imitola J Rasmussen S et al Localizing central nervous system immunesurveillance meningeal antigen-presenting cells activate T cells during experimentalautoimmune encephalomyelitis Ann Neurol 200965457ndash469
31 Absinta M Cortese IC Vuolo L et al Leptomeningeal gadolinium enhancementacross the spectrum of chronic neuroinflammatory diseases Neurology 2017881439ndash1444
32 Papatsiros VG Stylianaki I Papakonstantinou G Papaioannou N Christodoulo-poulos G Case report of transmissible gastroenteritis coronavirus infection associatedwith small intestine and brain lesions in piglets Viral Immunol 20193263ndash67
33 Stuckey SL Goh TD Heffernan T Rowan D Hyperintensity in the subarachnoidspace on FLAIR MRI AJR Am J Roentgenol 2007189913ndash921
34 Parpia AS Li Y Chen C Dhar B Crowcroft NS Encephalitis Ontario Canada 2002-2013 Emerg Infect Dis 201622426ndash432
e1882 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
DOI 101212WNL0000000000010112202095e1868-e1882 Published Online before print July 17 2020Neurology
Steacutephane Kremer Franccedilois Lersy Mathieu Anheim et al multicenter study
Neurologic and neuroimaging findings in patients with COVID-19 A retrospective
This information is current as of July 17 2020
ServicesUpdated Information amp
httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullincluding high resolution figures can be found at
References httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullref-list-1
This article cites 30 articles 6 of which you can access for free at
Citations httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullotherarticles
This article has been cited by 3 HighWire-hosted articles
Subspecialty Collections
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmriMRI
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmeningitisMeningitis
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionencephalitisEncephalitis e
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_cerebrovascular_disease_strokAll Cerebrovascular diseaseStrokefollowing collection(s) This article along with others on similar topics appears in the
Permissions amp Licensing
httpwwwneurologyorgaboutabout_the_journalpermissionsits entirety can be found online atInformation about reproducing this article in parts (figurestables) or in
Reprints
httpnneurologyorgsubscribersadvertiseInformation about ordering reprints can be found online
rights reserved Print ISSN 0028-3878 Online ISSN 1526-632X1951 it is now a weekly with 48 issues per year Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology All
reg is the official journal of the American Academy of Neurology Published continuously sinceNeurology
![Page 14: Neurologicandneuroimaging findingsinpatients with COVID-19 · enhancement (17%), and encephalitis (13%) were the most frequent neuroimaging findings. Confusion (53%) was the most](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060813/6091b284d4b0681e5152b42b/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
References1 Chen N Zhou M Dong X et al Epidemiological and clinical characteristics of 99
cases of 2019 novel coronavirus pneumonia in Wuhan China a descriptive studyLancet 2020395507ndash513
2 Huang C Wang Y Li X et al Clinical features of patients infected with 2019 novelcoronavirus in Wuhan China Lancet 2020395497ndash506
3 Glass WG Subbarao K Murphy B Murphy PM Mechanisms of host defense fol-lowing severe acute respiratory syndrome‐coronavirus (SARS‐CoV) pulmonary in-fection of mice J Immunol 20041734030ndash4039
4 Li K Wohlford‐Lenane C Perlman S et al Middle East respiratory syndromecoronavirus causes multiple organ damage and lethal disease in mice transgenic forhuman dipeptidyl peptidase 4 J Infect Dis 2016213712ndash722
5 Arbour N Day R Newcombe J Talbot PJ Neuroinvasion by human respiratorycoronaviruses J Virol 2000748913ndash8921
6 Desforges M Le Coupanec A Stodola JK Meessen-Pinard M Talbot PJ Humancoronaviruses viral and cellular factors involved in neuroinvasiveness and neuro-pathogenesis Virus Res 2014194145ndash158
7 Desforges M Le Coupanec A Dubeau P et al Human coronaviruses and otherrespiratory viruses underestimated opportunistic pathogens of the central nervoussystem Viruses 201912E14
8 Bohmwald K Galvez NMS Rıos M Kalergis AM Neurologic alterations due torespiratory virus infections Front Cell Neurosci 201812386
9 Poyiadji N Shahin G Noujaim D Stone M Patel S Griffith B COVID-19-associatedacute hemorrhagic necrotizing encephalopathy CT and MRI features Radiology2020201187
10 Moriguchi T Harii N Goto J et al A first case of meningitisencephalitis associatedwith SARS-coronavirus-2 Int J Infect Dis 20209455ndash58
11 Mao L Jin H Wang M et al Neurologic manifestations of hospitalized patients withcoronavirus disease 2019 in Wuhan China JAMA Neurol 2020771ndash9
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Xavier FabreMD
Hospital of RoanneFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GeraudForestier MD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Isaure deBeaurepaireMD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GregoireBornet MD
Hospital of AntonyFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Hubert DesalMD PhD
University Hospital ofNantes France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
GregoireBoulouis MD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jerome BergeMD
University Hospital ofBordeaux France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ApollineKazemi MD
University Hospital ofLille France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
NadyaPyatigorskayaMD
Pitie-SalpetriereHospital ParisFrance
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
AugustinLecler MD
Foundation ARothschild Paris
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
SuzanaSaleme MD
University Hospital ofLimoges France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Myriam Edjlali-Goujon MD
Saint-Anne HospitalParis France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
BasileKerleroux MD
University Hospital ofTours France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Jean-MarcConstans MDPhD
University Hospital ofAmiens France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Pierre-EmmanuelZorn PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the acquisitionof data
MurielMatthieu PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the acquisitionof data
Seyyid BalogluMD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of datarevised the manuscriptfor intellectualcontent
Franccedilois-DanielArdellier MD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
ThibaultWillaume MD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of datarevised the manuscriptfor intellectualcontent
Appendix (continued)
Name Location Contribution
Jean-ChristopheBrisset PhD
French Observatoryof Multiple SclerosisLyon France
Interpretation of the datarevised the manuscript forintellectual content
SophieCaillard MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
OlivierCollange MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Paul MichelMertes MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FrancisSchneider MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Samira Fafi-KremerPharmD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
MickaelOhana MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
FerhatMeziani MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Acquisition of data revisedthe manuscript forintellectual content
Nicolas MeyerMD PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Major role in the analysis andinterpretation of the data
Julie HelmsMD PhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
FranccediloisCotton MDPhD
University Hospitalsof Strasbourg France
Designed and conceptualizedthe study interpreted thedata revised the manuscriptfor intellectual content
NeurologyorgN Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 e1881
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
12 Helms J Kremer S Merdji H et al Neurologic features in severe SARS-CoV-2infection N Engl J Med 20203822268ndash2270
13 Kandemirli SG Dogan L Sarikaya ZT et al Brain MRI findings in patients in theintensive care unit with COVID-19 infection Radiology Epub 2020 May 8
14 Ferguson ND Fan E Camporota L et al The Berlin definition of ARDS an expandedrationale justification and supplementary material Intensive Care Med 2012381573ndash1582
15 Starkey J Kobayashi N Numaguchi Y Moritani T Cytotoxic lesions of the corpuscallosum that show restricted diffusion mechanisms causes and manifestationsRadiographics 201737562ndash576
16 Beyrouti R Adams ME Benjamin L et al Characteristics of ischaemic stroke asso-ciated with COVID-19 J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry Epub 2020 Apr 30
17 Hess DC Eldahshan W Rutkowski E COVID-19-related stroke Transl Stroke Res202011322ndash325
18 Umapathi T Kor AC Venketasubramanian N et al Large artery ischaemic stroke insevere acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) J Neurol 20042511227ndash1231
19 Arabi YM Harthi A Hussein J et al Severe neurologic syndrome associated withMiddle East respiratory syndrome corona virus (MERS-CoV) Infection 201543495ndash501
20 Guo T Fan Y ChenM et al Cardiovascular implications of fatal outcomes of patientswith coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) JAMA Cardiol Epub 2020 Mar 27
21 Helms J Tacquard C Severac F et al High risk of thrombosis in patients in severeSARS-CoV-2 infection a multicenter prospective cohort study Intensive Care Med2020461089ndash1098
22 NagelMAMahalingamRCohrs RJ GildenD Virus vasculopathy and stroke an under-recognized cause and treatment target Infect Disord Drug Targets 201010105ndash111
23 Subramaniam S Scharrer I Procoagulant activity during viral infections Front Biosci(Landmark Ed) 2018231060ndash1081
24 Hung EC Chim SS Chan PK et al Detection of SARS coronavirus RNA in thecerebrospinal fluid of a patient with severe acute respiratory syndrome Clin Chem2003492108ndash2109
25 Lau KK Yu WC Chu CM Lau ST Sheng B Yuen KY Possible central nervoussystem infection by SARS coronavirus Emerg Infect Dis 200410342ndash344
26 Toledano M Davies NWS Infectious encephalitis mimics and chameleons PractNeurol 201919225ndash237
27 Kim JE Heo JH Kim HO et al Neurological complications during treatment ofMiddle East respiratory syndrome J Clin Neurol 201713227ndash233
28 Li Y Li H Fan R et al Coronavirus infections in the central nervous system andrespiratory tract show distinct features in hospitalized children Intervirology 201659163ndash169
29 Yeh EA Collins A Cohen ME Duffner PK Faden H Detection of coronavirus in thecentral nervous system of a child with acute disseminated encephalomyelitis Pedi-atrics 2004113(pt 1)e73ndashe76
30 Kivisakk P Imitola J Rasmussen S et al Localizing central nervous system immunesurveillance meningeal antigen-presenting cells activate T cells during experimentalautoimmune encephalomyelitis Ann Neurol 200965457ndash469
31 Absinta M Cortese IC Vuolo L et al Leptomeningeal gadolinium enhancementacross the spectrum of chronic neuroinflammatory diseases Neurology 2017881439ndash1444
32 Papatsiros VG Stylianaki I Papakonstantinou G Papaioannou N Christodoulo-poulos G Case report of transmissible gastroenteritis coronavirus infection associatedwith small intestine and brain lesions in piglets Viral Immunol 20193263ndash67
33 Stuckey SL Goh TD Heffernan T Rowan D Hyperintensity in the subarachnoidspace on FLAIR MRI AJR Am J Roentgenol 2007189913ndash921
34 Parpia AS Li Y Chen C Dhar B Crowcroft NS Encephalitis Ontario Canada 2002-2013 Emerg Infect Dis 201622426ndash432
e1882 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
DOI 101212WNL0000000000010112202095e1868-e1882 Published Online before print July 17 2020Neurology
Steacutephane Kremer Franccedilois Lersy Mathieu Anheim et al multicenter study
Neurologic and neuroimaging findings in patients with COVID-19 A retrospective
This information is current as of July 17 2020
ServicesUpdated Information amp
httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullincluding high resolution figures can be found at
References httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullref-list-1
This article cites 30 articles 6 of which you can access for free at
Citations httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullotherarticles
This article has been cited by 3 HighWire-hosted articles
Subspecialty Collections
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmriMRI
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmeningitisMeningitis
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionencephalitisEncephalitis e
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_cerebrovascular_disease_strokAll Cerebrovascular diseaseStrokefollowing collection(s) This article along with others on similar topics appears in the
Permissions amp Licensing
httpwwwneurologyorgaboutabout_the_journalpermissionsits entirety can be found online atInformation about reproducing this article in parts (figurestables) or in
Reprints
httpnneurologyorgsubscribersadvertiseInformation about ordering reprints can be found online
rights reserved Print ISSN 0028-3878 Online ISSN 1526-632X1951 it is now a weekly with 48 issues per year Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology All
reg is the official journal of the American Academy of Neurology Published continuously sinceNeurology
![Page 15: Neurologicandneuroimaging findingsinpatients with COVID-19 · enhancement (17%), and encephalitis (13%) were the most frequent neuroimaging findings. Confusion (53%) was the most](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060813/6091b284d4b0681e5152b42b/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
12 Helms J Kremer S Merdji H et al Neurologic features in severe SARS-CoV-2infection N Engl J Med 20203822268ndash2270
13 Kandemirli SG Dogan L Sarikaya ZT et al Brain MRI findings in patients in theintensive care unit with COVID-19 infection Radiology Epub 2020 May 8
14 Ferguson ND Fan E Camporota L et al The Berlin definition of ARDS an expandedrationale justification and supplementary material Intensive Care Med 2012381573ndash1582
15 Starkey J Kobayashi N Numaguchi Y Moritani T Cytotoxic lesions of the corpuscallosum that show restricted diffusion mechanisms causes and manifestationsRadiographics 201737562ndash576
16 Beyrouti R Adams ME Benjamin L et al Characteristics of ischaemic stroke asso-ciated with COVID-19 J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry Epub 2020 Apr 30
17 Hess DC Eldahshan W Rutkowski E COVID-19-related stroke Transl Stroke Res202011322ndash325
18 Umapathi T Kor AC Venketasubramanian N et al Large artery ischaemic stroke insevere acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) J Neurol 20042511227ndash1231
19 Arabi YM Harthi A Hussein J et al Severe neurologic syndrome associated withMiddle East respiratory syndrome corona virus (MERS-CoV) Infection 201543495ndash501
20 Guo T Fan Y ChenM et al Cardiovascular implications of fatal outcomes of patientswith coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) JAMA Cardiol Epub 2020 Mar 27
21 Helms J Tacquard C Severac F et al High risk of thrombosis in patients in severeSARS-CoV-2 infection a multicenter prospective cohort study Intensive Care Med2020461089ndash1098
22 NagelMAMahalingamRCohrs RJ GildenD Virus vasculopathy and stroke an under-recognized cause and treatment target Infect Disord Drug Targets 201010105ndash111
23 Subramaniam S Scharrer I Procoagulant activity during viral infections Front Biosci(Landmark Ed) 2018231060ndash1081
24 Hung EC Chim SS Chan PK et al Detection of SARS coronavirus RNA in thecerebrospinal fluid of a patient with severe acute respiratory syndrome Clin Chem2003492108ndash2109
25 Lau KK Yu WC Chu CM Lau ST Sheng B Yuen KY Possible central nervoussystem infection by SARS coronavirus Emerg Infect Dis 200410342ndash344
26 Toledano M Davies NWS Infectious encephalitis mimics and chameleons PractNeurol 201919225ndash237
27 Kim JE Heo JH Kim HO et al Neurological complications during treatment ofMiddle East respiratory syndrome J Clin Neurol 201713227ndash233
28 Li Y Li H Fan R et al Coronavirus infections in the central nervous system andrespiratory tract show distinct features in hospitalized children Intervirology 201659163ndash169
29 Yeh EA Collins A Cohen ME Duffner PK Faden H Detection of coronavirus in thecentral nervous system of a child with acute disseminated encephalomyelitis Pedi-atrics 2004113(pt 1)e73ndashe76
30 Kivisakk P Imitola J Rasmussen S et al Localizing central nervous system immunesurveillance meningeal antigen-presenting cells activate T cells during experimentalautoimmune encephalomyelitis Ann Neurol 200965457ndash469
31 Absinta M Cortese IC Vuolo L et al Leptomeningeal gadolinium enhancementacross the spectrum of chronic neuroinflammatory diseases Neurology 2017881439ndash1444
32 Papatsiros VG Stylianaki I Papakonstantinou G Papaioannou N Christodoulo-poulos G Case report of transmissible gastroenteritis coronavirus infection associatedwith small intestine and brain lesions in piglets Viral Immunol 20193263ndash67
33 Stuckey SL Goh TD Heffernan T Rowan D Hyperintensity in the subarachnoidspace on FLAIR MRI AJR Am J Roentgenol 2007189913ndash921
34 Parpia AS Li Y Chen C Dhar B Crowcroft NS Encephalitis Ontario Canada 2002-2013 Emerg Infect Dis 201622426ndash432
e1882 Neurology | Volume 95 Number 13 | September 29 2020 NeurologyorgN
Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
DOI 101212WNL0000000000010112202095e1868-e1882 Published Online before print July 17 2020Neurology
Steacutephane Kremer Franccedilois Lersy Mathieu Anheim et al multicenter study
Neurologic and neuroimaging findings in patients with COVID-19 A retrospective
This information is current as of July 17 2020
ServicesUpdated Information amp
httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullincluding high resolution figures can be found at
References httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullref-list-1
This article cites 30 articles 6 of which you can access for free at
Citations httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullotherarticles
This article has been cited by 3 HighWire-hosted articles
Subspecialty Collections
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmriMRI
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmeningitisMeningitis
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionencephalitisEncephalitis e
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_cerebrovascular_disease_strokAll Cerebrovascular diseaseStrokefollowing collection(s) This article along with others on similar topics appears in the
Permissions amp Licensing
httpwwwneurologyorgaboutabout_the_journalpermissionsits entirety can be found online atInformation about reproducing this article in parts (figurestables) or in
Reprints
httpnneurologyorgsubscribersadvertiseInformation about ordering reprints can be found online
rights reserved Print ISSN 0028-3878 Online ISSN 1526-632X1951 it is now a weekly with 48 issues per year Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology All
reg is the official journal of the American Academy of Neurology Published continuously sinceNeurology
![Page 16: Neurologicandneuroimaging findingsinpatients with COVID-19 · enhancement (17%), and encephalitis (13%) were the most frequent neuroimaging findings. Confusion (53%) was the most](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022060813/6091b284d4b0681e5152b42b/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
DOI 101212WNL0000000000010112202095e1868-e1882 Published Online before print July 17 2020Neurology
Steacutephane Kremer Franccedilois Lersy Mathieu Anheim et al multicenter study
Neurologic and neuroimaging findings in patients with COVID-19 A retrospective
This information is current as of July 17 2020
ServicesUpdated Information amp
httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullincluding high resolution figures can be found at
References httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullref-list-1
This article cites 30 articles 6 of which you can access for free at
Citations httpnneurologyorgcontent9513e1868fullotherarticles
This article has been cited by 3 HighWire-hosted articles
Subspecialty Collections
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmriMRI
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionmeningitisMeningitis
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionencephalitisEncephalitis e
httpnneurologyorgcgicollectionall_cerebrovascular_disease_strokAll Cerebrovascular diseaseStrokefollowing collection(s) This article along with others on similar topics appears in the
Permissions amp Licensing
httpwwwneurologyorgaboutabout_the_journalpermissionsits entirety can be found online atInformation about reproducing this article in parts (figurestables) or in
Reprints
httpnneurologyorgsubscribersadvertiseInformation about ordering reprints can be found online
rights reserved Print ISSN 0028-3878 Online ISSN 1526-632X1951 it is now a weekly with 48 issues per year Copyright copy 2020 American Academy of Neurology All
reg is the official journal of the American Academy of Neurology Published continuously sinceNeurology