navigating crisis · seamless multi-channel service offering to their customers. their focus is on...
TRANSCRIPT
Navigating crisis
24 September 2020
Audit. Tax. Advisory.
PwC
Agenda
Time Activity Speaker
15:00 – 15:05Welcome
Introduction
Nicolai Wassermann
Helle Dreyer
15:05 – 15:30
How to manage temporary business disruption or
the "new normal" focusing on customer
experience, working from home, infrastructure
and connectivity
George Stylianides, Partner, PwC UK
15:30 – 15:55
Covid-19 Risk Management: An Operational Risk
lens on Covid-19 business continuity
management in Nordea
Johan Hjelm, Deputy head of Group Operational
Risk, Nordea
15:55 – 16:00 Closing remarks and key takeaways Helle Dreyer
2
PwC
Practicalities
3
Please use the chat function to ask questions01
The webinar will be recorded and uploaded to pwc.dk02
We will share the presentation after the webinar03
?
PwC
Delighting customers: what has changed
George StylianidesSeptember 2020
PwC
Near term challenges: impact of Covid
The numbers of customers needing additional support from their bank are increasing rapidly as a result of unemployment and COVID-19 related payment holidays coming to an end.
As a result, most firms are anticipating an increase in customer interactions to execute collection strategies, resolve issues arising including complaints, and customers becoming vulnerable.
Industry landscape
● Nearly one in four UK workers have been furloughed during the
pandemic, and one in seven UK workers are at risk of losing their jobs
once the Job Retention Scheme (JRS) ends this October
● With the Jobseeker claimant amount up by 126% to 2.8m since the
start of the lockdown, and 1.2 million credit card and loan repayment
holidays given already, the demands on Collections teams are set
to rise sharply
● 7 million households have lost all or most of their income during the
pandemic, creating a huge increase of customers being faced with
financial difficulty and vulnerability
● In addition, more customers find themselves in a wide range of
unavoidable circumstances, including bereavement and illness
● Based on trends following the Global Financial Crisis (GFC) and recent
COVID-related customer behaviours, complaints could exceed
average levels by 50% each month from October onward
● An anticipated rise in customer contact times, complaints and collections activity
coupled with exacerbated customer vulnerability puts increasing pressure on
front-line staff and the second-line of defence
● Banks need better methods for front-line teams to identify and manage the
experience for a wide range of vulnerabilities in adherence with FCA guidance
and ensure that these customers are treated fairly
● The end of payment holiday and the resulting financial impact on customers
will put pressure on Collections teams, therefore performance improvement and
capacity creation will be essential to manage cost to serve and quality of service
● Manual processes mean that there is a lack of real-time insights to empower
front-line teams with the guidance and nudges they need to remain compliant
and drive better customer outcomes
● Increasing capacity of contact centre employees by augmenting them with
technology solutions that provide them with real-time guidance and
prompts to effectively deal with spikes in complaint volumes
Business challenges
PwC
PwC
Customer interaction shifting to digital channels
PwC
Changes in customer behaviour, that
might otherwise have taken years, have
occurred in a matter of weeks as a result of
COVID-19.
We have seen a rapid acceleration in the
shift to digital channels, such as mobile
and contact centres, because of social
distancing and lockdowns. Even customers
who had previously resisted change have
adjusted their habits.
Banks that deliver the most complete and
effective digital experience, and support
their customers through this transition, will
be the biggest winners.
This new reality requires a fundamental
change in the role of the contact centre.
...accelerated by the impact of COVID-19
An evolution of Retail Banking distribution...
Changes in customer engagement channels during COVID-19 lockdown
(% of UK bank customers, April 2020)
Declining cost to serve
Increasing personalisation
● Initial branch reformatting
● Rise of self-service
● Digitisation of existing servicing
journeys
● Customers given choice on best
interaction
● Branch roles re-purposed
● Multiple contact points, including
via APIs
● Customers routed to best
interaction driven by AI
● Traditional branches
● No self-service
● Limited digital channels and
functionality
● Customer choice restricted
Branch at the heart of the customer
relationship, with call centre support
OmnichannelBranch first Digital first
Customers switch between channels
to access the right option available
The right channel for the right
interaction for a given customer
PwC
Improving the customer experience and outcomes requires a joined-up approach across people, process and technology that come together to transform performance and oversight of customer outcomes.
Technology
suitability
● Banks are undertaking technology suitability assessments to identify solutions required to achieve their target state including:
○ cloud technology contact centre solutions that are agile, can be easily customised to deal with change in customer behaviour and are integrated with key
authoritative data sources (e.g. CRM)
○ conversation analytic solutions that augment front-line staff and analyse customer intent and are able to classify conversations (e.g. complaints, vulnerable
customer) improving efficiency and customer outcomes
Staff
productivity
and
performance
● A number of banks have kicked off initiatives to improve ways of working by creating consistency in agent behaviour, reducing handoffs and risk of errors whilst
improving the customer experience
● As part of these programmes, their focus is on embedding clear and transparent KPIs to visualise and monitor performance at all levels, creating accountability
for performance and results
● Inflight programmes also focus on improving morale and problem solving within the front-line teams and establishing a culture of continuous improvement
● To deal with a potential lack of capacity, banks are assessing whether other staff (e.g. branch staff) can be re-skilled and re-deployed within key paint point areas
● They are implementing an operating model which allows them to improve capacity and operational efficiency by having access to third party skilled resources
for some areas that are non-standard or complex cases
● Banks are establishing clear guidelines of when front-line teams need support from relevant back-office teams (e.g. complaints, collections) to speed up
resolution time and customer experience
Augmenting
capacity
Strategy
review
● Banks have started assessing their channel strategy and delivery plans to ensure they are able to respond to this change in customer channel shift by having
the correct technology and capability in place and a delivery plan that is fit for purpose
● A key focus following the strategy review has been to commence work to redesign customer journeys to enable more self-service and reserving contact centre
agent support for high value customers / interactions (e.g. vulnerable customers)
What banks are doing in response to the challenges being faced
PwC
Contact centre transformation
Enabling channel
strategy
Given the current economic environment
and imperative to take out costs,
businesses need to update their channel
strategy to drive customer engagement
through digital self-serve channels as the
default and reserve human support for high
value interactions.
This channel strategy can be enabled
through a transformation of the contact
centre that encompasses:
● Creating a culture that focuses on agility and innovation
● Redesigning the operating model to streamline processes, rethink resourcing and talent management, and enable effective remote working
● Updating technology to adapt to changing customer habits quickly, create seamless customer journeys, and leverage valuable data sources for insights and real-time actions
Enabling a channel strategy through contact transformation across foundational areas...
Culture and ways of working
• Creating and promoting a culture that
embraces agility and innovation
• Breaking down silos with a clear
strategy and end-state to unite the
organisation
• Building a workforce of employees with
attitudes of next generation workers and
talent to deliver rapid change with fewer
dependencies
• Developing and investing in advanced
data analytics to empower employees
Technology
• A move to agile, scalable cloud native
customer contact platform solutions
• Enabling the right channel for the right
interaction for a given customer
• Seamlessly integrating new digital
channels, such as video
• Creating an ecosystem that integrates
key data sources to deliver a
personalised, high-quality customer
experience throughout the end-to-end
journey
Operating model & capabilities
• Updating or designing a target operating
model for the impact of COVID-19
• Enabling a hybrid office-remote working
model with the right balance of
permanent and contingent workers
• Creating small, agile multi-disciplined
contact centre teams that act as a
second line to digital, and are focussed
on high value and complex
conversations
• Recruiting and/or developing capabilities
aligned to digital enablement
...will result in cost efficiencies and improved experience for your customers
Cost reduction and productivity
• Cost takeout with a move away from monolithic platforms
that are expensive to maintain and operate
• Elimination of charges to access and gain additional value
from your data with implementation of open architecture
• Savings through contact centre location rationalisation and
a hybrid office-remote working model
• Increased opportunities to cross sell products by supporting
contact centre colleagues through agent prompts and next
best actions
• Reduction in staff costs through flexible resourcing models
that enable greater use of contingent workers
Improved customer experience
• Seamless, personalised customer experience across
multiple channels
• Improved customer outcomes through enablement of real
time insights into conversations
• Convenient, self-service options of engagement
• Customer needs met in the channel of preference
• Human support used to spend more time on the moments
that matter (e.g. supporting vulnerable customers)
PwC
Maximising value of technology – the human element
Given the context of the market, the performance bar for customer experience will be set significantly higher over the coming months. There is a way to address this challenge through a dedicated programme that sets out to improve ways of working, productivity and team morale.
Performance Imperatives
● Productivity: Create capacity to manage expected increases in
demand and improve team morale through standardised ways of
working
● Customer satisfaction: Improve ‘operational grip’ to effectively
manage vulnerable customers segments
● Consistent customer outcomes: With enhanced insights on
customers (e.g. through conversation analytics solutions), process
consistency and execution quality is critical to apply those insights
Typical challenges
● High degrees of process variability, which leads to inconsistent
customer experience
● Managers promoted due to technical competence, not critical
leadership skills
● Lack of effective management operating system: goal setting,
problem solving, and effective capacity planning
Increased service
level adherence
Enhanced
leadership
capability
Reduced
operating costs
Optimised
processes
Better customer
satisfaction &
consistent
service
Better staff
engagement &
retention
Improved
performance and
productivity
Reduced variation
in performance
What banks are doing to improve performance and
productivity
● Coaching team leaders and empowering team members
● Visualising performance management to drive focussed
conversations
● Standardising ways of working before implementing large tech or
process change
Benefits that are being realised by banks
PwC
Technology that enables transformation
Legacy technology, non-integrated systems and a lack of a conversation and data analytics solution significantly impacts the ability of a bank to effectively deal with customers and reach the desired customer outcomes.
CRM + Cloud Contact Centre Solutions + Conversation and Data Analytics Solution
API
AGENT DESKTOP
(INTELLIGENT ROUTING LIVE CALL TRANSCRIPTS)
EXISTING SYSTEMS NEW / EXISTING SERVICES
(E.G. DATA ENRICHMENT)
CLOUD STORAGE ADVANCED ANALYTICS
PROACTIVE SERVICE SELF SERVICE CHAT BOT / AI HUMAN SUPPORT
Banks are undertaking initiatives such as technology suitability assessments to identify solutions that will help them provide a connected and
seamless multi-channel service offering to their customers. Their focus is on identifying relevant options and implementing the below solutions:
CRM solutions
● Customer centric architecture with CRM as core
backbone
● Multi-channel support with comprehensive agent
dashboard and guidance for quick case resolution
(inc. knowledge base)
EMAIL SMS SOCIAL
ONLINE
COMMUNITY DESKTOP & MOBILE
NATURAL
LANGUAGE CALL STEERING
IQT COMPANY WEBSITE SMS SOCIAL MESSAGING LIVE CHAT EMAIL PHONE SMS SOCIAL MESSAGING
Cloud contact centre solutions
● Seamless experience for customers across channels
(voice, chat, email, video etc.)
● Customer profile based intelligent routing to match
customer to most appropriate agent
● Single contact centre solution available across all
customer facing colleagues
Conversation and data analytics solution
● Machine learning analytics solution that is capable of
analysing conversations in real-time and provide
guidance, prompts and next best actions related to
complaints
● Deep analysis of complaints data, customer feedback
as well as agent performance
PwC
Looking forward Whilst banks have started undertaking initiatives to address the spike in customer contact, moving to the future state still requires considerable investment.
Increased service
level adherence
Enhanced
leadership
capability
Reduced
operating costs
Optimised
processes
Banks are trying to deal with an exceptionally challenging period of demand
peaks, whilst working remotely. This has identified some key areas of
improvements that need to be addressed.
The opportunity is to now invest in new technology, operations and
people to maximise efficiency and improve customer experience and
outcomes.
...Continued focus required across 3 clear areas:
Improving digital contact and self-service: creating effective digital journeys
for customers to interact with banks as a default channel, whilst establishing a
profile of contact centre agents that are skilled to handle high value / high
complex interactions with customers
Deployment of next gen contact centre technology: implementing a contact
centre solution that is fully integrated with key authoritative sources of data (e.g.
CRM) and augment call handlers with real-time conversation analytics
Performance and culture: increasing capacity and reducing risk by continuing or
developing programme of operational excellence and through strategic
resource redeployment and augmentation.
Customers – Deliver consistent high quality customer outcomes more
efficiently and in a joined up manner;
Colleagues – Enable more focus on higher skilled value add tasks through
improved ways of working, platform and tools;
The business – Unlock cost reductions, and build resilience and flexibility
into the operating model to cope with future volatility.
...Delivering tangible benefits for:
From Current State To Future State
Strategy and
vision
Technology
and digital
enablement
Human
performance
Providing human support
to all customers for all
needs
Providing self-serve digital
journeys that are supported
by human support for
moments that matter
Limited integration of
systems and lack of real-
time data analytics
solutions
A de-centralised and less
mature operating model
Fully integrated customer
contact digital solutions
with real-time analytics in
place
A dynamic and agile
operating rhythm
supporting high performing
teams
Covid-19 Risk ManagementAn Operational Risk lens on Covid-19 business continuity management in Nordea
Johan Hjelm, Deputy Head of Group Operational Risk
24 September, 2020
Covid-19 crisis management
• Nordea has managed the COVID-19 crisis in an appropriate and
effective manner – no material Operational Risk incidents have
been observed
• Despite a large number of employees working remotely, countries
locked-down and the infection rate increasing …
…we have still been able to continue to serve our customers
within our defined Operational Risk limits
13
Covid-19 crisis management governance
• Already in January an enterprise wide Crisis Management
Team was formed, to address the crisis
• In March the Global Crisis Management Team (GCMT),
headed by the CRO, was convened
• Country focused CMTs were formed to manage country
specific situations
• These CMTs have been the hub for information sharing and
decision making throughout the crisis
14
Remote working
• A high percentage of our front office staff, as well as
central units, have worked from home from March/April
until today
• We have increased the capacity of our technical remote
working capabilities by up to 10 times, to address the
significantly higher demand
• All processes and systems, where there was a need for
remote working capabilities, have been evaluated based
on our risk appetite
• As a result we have been able to decided which
processes and systems could be fully or partially
performed remotely i.e. outside the normal office
environment
• A security awareness programme was created, and
continues to be maintained, to support staff with working
remotely, safely
15
Where are we today
• The Fraud and Information Security incident
numbers are still below the levels observed prior to
COVID-19
• IT production capacity, out of our off shore centres
in India, remains stable
• A significant percentage of our staff in all countries,
are still, primarily working from home
• However the pace of return to office varies from
country-to-country in our home markets
• We closely follow the health authorities
recommendations and implement these on a
country dimension
16
What is next
• The COVID crisis has highlighted that it is possible
to change the way we work, even in a non-COVID
environment
• Nordea, as many other organisations, are now re-
evaluating the balance between office based, and
non-office based work
PwC 17
Closing remarks and key takeaways
1
2
3
4
5
Customer interaction shifting rapidly to digital channels such as mobile and contact centres, because of social distancing and lockdowns.
Review of central operating model elements like people, process and technology with focus on transforming performance and oversight of customer outcomes.
When looking ahead the opportunity is to now invest in new technology, operations and people to maximise efficiency and improve customer experience and outcomes.
Nordea was able to continue to serve its customers within the defined Operational Risk limits despite a large number of employees working remotely due to countries locked-down.
Nordea are re-evaluating the balance between office based, and non-office based work.
www.pwc.dk
Thank you!
This publication has been prepared for general guidance on matters of interest only, and does not constitute professional advice. You should not act upon the information contained in this
publication without obtaining specific professional advice. No representation or warranty (express or implied) is given as to the accuracy or completeness of the information contained in this
publication, and, to the extent permitted by law, PricewaterhouseCoopers Statsautoriseret Revisionspartnerselskab, its members, employees and agents do not accept or assume any liability,
responsibility or duty of care for any consequences of you or anyone else acting, or refraining to act, in reliance on the information contained in this publication or for any decision based on it.
© 2020 PricewaterhouseCoopers Statsautoriseret Revisionspartnerselskab. All rights reserved. In this document, “PwC” refers to PricewaterhouseCoopers Statsautoriseret
Revisionspartnerselskab which is a member firm of PricewaterhouseCoopers International Limited, each member firm of which is a separate legal entity.
Together we succeed…
Helle Dreyer
Partner
M: +45 6155 5181E: [email protected]
Nicolai Wassermann
Senior Manager
M: +45 6155 8971E: [email protected]
If you have any questions related to the topic, you are more than welcome to reach out to us.