8.1.9A

Signed Statement of Common Ground with Historic England

River Humber Gas Pipeline Replacement Project

D O

C U

M E

N T

Application Reference: EN060004

Deadline 2 Submission – 12th October 2015

D O

C U

M E

N T

5.1

V

Hyder

nationaigrid

National Grid

River Humber Gas Pipeline Replacement Project

Statenient of Common Ground — [listoric England

c -

Ii 0I c•1 m D

?-

*:: i1 •

:Ii

.a-

r

--•

-.-

.:•‘

-

;iH

’

94 .4044 84 44 ‘84 ‘44’ 8444?442t44 448442: 24

44 4’

.2

.1 ‘4’ 6 844- ,,2 .14 ,‘4fl54& :244.4 -

14 4 ‘

4.

;iwa**-t— • ‘*14 er”rs’ itr

‘ 1’4*4

-

1414 14 *

24.1

‘2

4’

River Humnber Gas Pipeline Replacement Project —Statement of Common Ground Historic EnglandHyder Consulting (UK) Limlted-221 2059

‘I.

14-’

— 44

-.-r 4’

“ ‘: 1

44

4 44.,

42241

44

444

‘‘4

:—‘.‘

o• . -

ni1444 14 . ‘

.* :E4’.4

44’4

4 144—.-

1 —

14.

24%

CONTENTSN

Hjder

!vit,itni hitu ..•

I IfltrO(ftJCtIflFT . . I

1.1 Purpie of the E)ocumnt ,, 1

I ,2 Mntiers Addroised wilhln thl Document.I2 .SCht3IflO D1)ii(riptOfl . .,..

3 lvi tinrF, Of Aioit . .,.. 44 .1ttOr 1’1U( (c1l’(J ..... .8L ‘CJflØCI t tom Oit üf COflUliOfl CWouiid . . 0

:.

1,

-‘:

River Htanber Gas Pepekne Replacement ProecA —Statement ci Conimon Ground it stone EnglandHyder Consulting (UK) L,rtiiled-2212Yjg

River I-lumber Gas Pipeline Replacement Project —Sctement of Common Ground Historic EnglandIlyder Consulting (UK) Limited-2212950 Page ii

‘- •-

—“

•: i4144p%4•.. .

4 . -

k• ieij.ft>::.ti

rC •

I

r Øtr)1 -(t!-

1 .

-e *i4.,4 na .

Revision Stl.usApprevels

Originated by

Checked by

EnvwonrnentaConsultant(HyderConsulting)

TechnicalDirector(HyderConsulting)

Printed Name

Potya Georgieva

Nicky Hartley

Signed Name

/L ‘ ICi’ik

Date

10/03/2016

15/03/2015

Approved by

River H&rnher Gs Pipeline Repiacenent Project —Statement ef Common Ground Historic EnglandHydor Conultin9 (UK) Lluuted-22 1 2GtitJ

Revision History

flato Rev No. Summary of Changes Ref Section Purpose of issue

10103/20 0 FIrst Issue for Comment to Historic15 England

_______ __________

07104120 1 Second issue for \pprovaL to His torlo15 England

OistritfliUori

_rIthEmIcknspector of Ancient Monuments Historic Ençjlnncl)

Pugo IL

4. 4.

IDC

..

.

—ID

.

...

$.

-

t-

H.

-.

1r

P3t

...

+.

++

..+

C-‘

fl

++

.:

+

4.

+

.4I

+

+ H+

+

..

-...

Hr

—+

.-

-?

2.

-.

..+

+

-+

*-:.

2.!

+-

.+

1’4

o-

+-

——

+“

-3

’I

HH

-—

-+

.,

++

+.

C.

2—

++

.+

++

+.

4t

:--+

++

-t

+-

o--

++

++

—--

+.

..

I.—-

+3+

;.:

++

—H

+-

-

-

r

++

:

--.

rn-.

—.+

+.

-.-

++

++

-H

+••-

:-1’

a

Ii ltFOd[JctiOfl

1.1 Purpose of the 1)ocumenl.

1 .1.1 This document is a Statenlent of Cor mon Ground (SoCG) between NationalGrid and Historic England for a Development Consent Order (DCO) for theRiver Humbor Gas Pipeline Replacement Project.

1.1.2 This statement sets out the main areas of agreement and disagreementregarding the application documents between National Grid and HistoricEngland,

1 .2 IVinttet Addresf;o(i vvithin this Dociiirient

1.2.1 Dlscussiohs and responses to consultation, to date cover the following topicswhich form the basIs of this SoCG:

Archaaology (assessment methodology, baseline information, assessmentfindings arid conclusions, mitigation and enhancement measures)

rn Built Heritage (assessment methodology, baselIne Information,assessment findings and conclusions, mitigation and enhancementmeasures)

1 .2.2 The following DCC Application DOcuments are subject to review from HistoricEngland:

i Draft Chapter 6:Cultural heritage of the Environmental Statement (ES)(DCO Application Document Reference 6.6)

Appendices 6,1 to 6.5 of the Cultural Hat itago Chapter (DCC DocumehtReferences 8.6.1 6,6,2, 6.6.3, 6.6.4 and 6.6.5)

1 .2.3 National Grid has aimed to address all the points raised by Historic Englandwhere there has not been agreement. This statement sets out the outstandingissues and explains why there has been no resolution.

Rvar Humber Ga Pipeflne FepIncAnont Project Stteinent of Common rnound Histoc ngidnd

Hyder Consukirig (UK) Lnflred-221299

Scheme DescriptionNational Grid is proposing to construct a replacement gas pipeline under theHumber Estuary to ensure the long term security of the Feeder 9 GasTransmission Pipeline. The river bed cover over the existing No 09 Crossing iscurrently being eroded by the Humber Estuary. The Feeder 9 pIpeline carries ahigh level of importance within the National Transmission System (NTS) as astrategic pipeline conveying significant volumes of natural gas away from theEaslngton Importation Terminal south towards the Hatton Compressor Facility.

21 ,2 The Scheme would comprise a new high pressure gas pipeline installed Within abored tunnel that would run between the existing Goxhill Above GroundInstallation (AGI) on the south bank of the Humber Estuary within NorthLincoinshire to the Paull AOl on the north bank within East Riding of Yorkshire.

Figure 1 Location of the Scheme

2

2.11

River Humber Gas PIpeUw3 RepIccnient Project —Statement of Common Ground Historic EnglandIlyder ConsulLrnj (UK) Umted2212O5 Pajn 2

The total length of the pipeUne route would be up to 6 kilomotres (krn) from theGoxhlll AOl to the Paul! AG!. The length of the tunnel would be appoximatoly5,03km based on the provisional drive and reception pit locations with theEstuary crossing beIng 31cm. Approximately l2Orn of new pipeline would be laidonshore at Goxhill from the Goxhill AG! to the start of the tunnelled sebtion and

approximately 400m would he laid onshore at Paul! to connect the new pipelineinto Paul! AGI.The bored tunnel would have a minimum internal diameter of3.66m and a maximum internal diameter of 4m. The pipeline would be laid at adepth of a minimum of 7rn below the true bed of the Humber Estuary.

At the start of April 2015, English Heritage separated into two different bodies.A new charity retaining the name English Heritage looks after the NationalHeritage Collection - the stone circles, castles and abbeys, historic houses and

all the other sites that were previously in English Heritage’s direct care. Historic

England is now the competent authority for managing the historic environment

of England and in this case for advising on the care of the historic environmentin area of the Scheme, All the DCO documents prepared after let AprIl 2015 willtherefore refer to Historic England as a statutory consuitee.

2.1.5 National Grid and Historic England agree that Historic England has beenconsulted regularly by National Grid throughout the development of theScheme

2.1,3

2.1.4

Rvcr Humber One Pip&ne Replacement Project —Statement of Common Ground Hietoric Ençjtand

Hydor Corn,ultng UK) Limtted-2212059 Pagn 3

31,1

Mi tte rs of Ag ree rio n ITahe 3i outlines the rnatkrs of agreement between National Grid and HistoricEngland

Rier Humber Gas PIpeui R Iice,wn Prcject —StaWrnent of Coiurnor Orounc Htoifo EoOandfiyder Consulting UK) Lfrned22 12059Page 4

I• L

j

I

4

i

cfA

gre

emen

tA

ro:g

yar

.dB

uilt.agc

The

met

hodo

logy

sets

out

the

appr

oach

toth

eA

rcha

eolo

gyar

idB

uilt

Her

itag

eas

sess

men

t.en

dis.

pres

ente

dw

ithin

Sec

tion

6.3

ofth

eE

s.

His

tori

cE

ngla

ndhas

agre

edth

atm

arin

ear

chae

olog

yca

nbe

scop

ed

out

ofth

isass

ess

ment

due

toth

epr

opos

edco

nst

ruct

ion

thod

olog

y

ofbo

ring

atu

nnel

atle

ast

7mbe

low

the

true

bed

ofth

eR

iver

Hum

ber.

Alis

tof

the

desi

gnat

edass

ets

incl

uded

nth

eas

sess

men

tw

as

pres

ente

dto

His

tori

cE

ngla

nd(t

hrou

ghth

eE

tAS

eepi

ngR

epor

tand

the

Pre

lim

inar

yE

nvir

onm

enta

lIn

form

atio

nR

epor

t),

who

acce

pte

dit

nd

had

rio

furt

her

com

men

ton

any

othe

rde

sign

ated

asse

tsth

atSh

ould

be

cons

ider

ed.

Riv

erhurn

br

Gas

Plp

clin

cR

epla

cem

ent P

r*ct—

3te

ment

ofC

omm

onG

roun

dH

isto

ric

Eng

land

Hyd

erC

onsu

lting

(UK

)-U

mite

d-22

12S5

9

Mt:

rofA

gree’ct

CC

oeum

ent

.Naio

nari

dH

sto

rr.c

Erg

Refe

rence

Ass

essm

ent

Met

hed

oto

gy

Dra

ftC

hapt

er6

Cul

tura

lA

gree

dA

gree

d

Her

itag

e(D

CC

App

lkra

tiori

Docr

nen

tR

efer

ence

5.6)

I

His

tori

cE

ngla

ndco

nsid

ers

the

stud

yar

eafo

rthe

asse

ssrr

teri

tD

raft

Chap

terS

Cul

tura

lA

gree

dA

gree

d

appr

opri

ate.

Her

itag

e(D

CC

App

lica

tion

Doc

umen

tR

efer

ence

6.6)

His

tori

cE

ngla

ndag

rees

with

the

mel

nods

used

toob

tain

base

line

App

endi

x62

(DC

CA

gree

dA

gree

d

info

rmat

ion

arid

info

rmth

eas

sess

men

t.D

ccur

nent

Ref

eren

ce6.6

2)

AD

esic

Bas

edA

sses

smen

t(D

BA

)w

asun

dert

aken

toob

tain

App

endi

x6.

3ar

id6.

4(t

CO

info

rmat

ion

rela

ting

tohe

rita

geas

sets

.In

addi

tion

toth

eD

BA

aD

ocum

ent

Ref

eren

ce6.

6.3

•pro

gram

me

ofar

chae

olog

ical

inve

stig

acon

shas

been

unde

rtak

en.

Thi

san

d6.

6.4)

incl

uded

aeri

alph

otog

raph

anal

ysis

atth

eP

aull

side

cit t

he

Sch

eme

Apndix

6.5

(DC

C

and

geop

hysi

cal

surv

eys

atbo

thP

aull

and

Gax

hull.

The

appro

ach.

Dum

ent

Ref

eren

ce6.

6.5)

met

hodo

logy

and

resu

lts

ofea

chof

thes

ein

vest

igat

ions

ispr

esen

ted

wit

hin

the

rele

vant

ass

ess

ment

repo

rt.

Due

toth

epro

ject

tim

esca

les

and

unav

aiia

bili

tiof

and

for

Agr

eed

Agr

eed

arch

aeol

ogic

alfi

eldw

ork

itw

asno

tpo

ssib

leto

com

plet

eal

lphas

esof

the

arch

aeolo

gic

alas

sess

men

tpr

ior

toth

eco

mpl

etio

nof

the

ES

.

The

refo

rea

prog

ram

me

alar

chae

olog

ical

bia

ltr

ench

eval

uati

onis

Pag

eS

_‘V

,_—

_

Mat

ter

ofA

reom

ont

DD

Docu

mef

ltN

a:a

Gri

tst

orc

ac

Ref

era

ccpl

anne

dto

take

plac

eat

the

Gox

hill

and

PaLI

I!si

tes

anda

pala

eoen

viro

nmer

tal

asse

ssm

enta

tth

eP

aull

site

.B

oth

asse

ssm

ents

are

prog

ram

edfo

rea

rly

2Cr1

5an

dth

eir

resu

lts

wou

ldbe

si.b

rnit

ted

asan

upda

teto

this

ES.

Att

his

stag

e,H

isto

ric

Eng

land

has

rioob

ject

ions

toth

etr

ial

renc

hing

bein

gpr

ogre

ssed

duri

ngth

eco

nsid

erat

ion

ofth

eap

plic

atio

nas

the

;res

ults

wou

ldbe

avai

labl

epr

ior

tode

term

inat

ion.

Bas

elin

eIn

form

atio

n

Sec

tion

6.4

and

6.5

ofth

eE

Spr

esen

tth

eex

isti

ngan

dfu

ture

base

line

Dra

ftC

hapt

er6

Cul

tura

lA

gree

dA

gree

din

form

atio

n,re

spec

tive

ly,

that

has

been

cons

ider

edin

rela

tion

toth

e.H

erit

age

(DC

CA

ppli

cati

onA

rcha

eolo

gyan

dB

uilt

Her

itag

eA

sses

smen

tD

ocum

ent

Reference

6.6)

Alis

tof

the

desi

gnat

edass

ets

incl

uded

inth

isas

sess

men

tw

asD

raft

Cha

pter

6C

ultu

ral

Agr

eed

Agr

eed

pre

sente

dto

His

toric

Eng

land

.w

hoac

cept

edit

and

had

nofu

rther

Her

itag

e(D

CC

App

lica

tion

com

men

ton

any

othe

rde

sign

ated

asse

tsth

atsh

ould

beco

nsid

ered

.D

ocum

entR

efer

ence

6.6)

Pote

ntia

llyaf

fect

edre

cept

ors

have

been

assi

gned

ava

lue

inD

raft

Cha

pter

6C

ultu

ral

Agr

eed

Agr

eed

: acc

orda

nce

with

guid

ance

toas

sist

inde

term

inin

gth

ose

whic

hsh

ould

Her

itag

e(D

CC

App

lica

tion

beco

nsid

ered

with

inT

hede

tail

edas

sess

men

tH

isto

ric

Eng

!ard

Dom

ert

Ref

eren

ce5.

6)ag

rac-

sw

ithth

eev

alua

tion

ofva

’ue

ofre

cept

ors

pote

ntia

lly

affe

ctec

byth

eS

chem

e.

Ass

essm

ent

Fin

din

gs

arid

Concl

usi

ons

Sec

tion

6.8

ofC

hapt

er6

cith

eE

Spre

sents

the

pote

ntia

lre

sidu

alD

raft

Cha

pter

6C

uftu

ial

Agr

eed

Agr

eed

effe

cts

onea

chre

cept

orw

ithth

epr

ovis

ion

ofth

een

viro

nmen

tal

desi

gnH

erit

age

{DC

OA

ppli

cati

onan

dm

itiga

tion

mea

sure

s.D

ocum

ent

Ref

eren

ce66)

His

tori

cE

ngla

ndag

rees

with

the

asse

ssm

ent

ofre

sidu

alef

fect

son

arch

aeol

ogy

and

cult

ural

heri

tage

rece

ptor

s.—

Riv

erH

umbe

rG

asPi

pelin

eR

epla

cem

ent

Pro,

ect—

Sta

tem

ento

fC

omm

onG

roun

d1i

stO

ncE

ngla

ndH

yder

Con

sulti

ngCU

K)L.

imite

d-22

1295

9

Mit

igat

ion

and

Enh

ance

men

tM

easu

res

Mat

ter

ofA

rrie

’:

DC

CD

ct

Nat

cna.

Gri

dH

isto

ric

ig’c

nd

Refe

rence

Miti

gatio

nan

den

hanc

emen

trn

asur

eti

are

dnt

ifie

dw

fthi

nSe

ctio

n&

7D

raft

Cha

pter

6C

uftu

ral

Agr

eed

Agr

eed

ofC

hapt

er6

ofth

eE

S.

Her

itag

e(D

CC

App

licat

ion

Miti

gatio

nm

easu

res

incl

ude:

Doc

umen

tR

efer

ence

6.7)

•P

repato

nof

aW

ritt

enS

chem

eof

Inve

stig

atio

n(W

SY)

for

all

arch

aeol

ogic

alm

itiga

tion

reiu

ired

.in

stal

lati

onof

tops

oil

stora

ge

bund

san

dei

ther

clos

ebo

ard

fenc

ing

orher

asfe

ncin

gto

crea

tepa

rtia

lsc

reen

ing

ofth

e-r

onst

ruct

ion

3cti

viti

esan

dto

redu

ceth

eim

pact

son

the

sett

ings

ofhe

rita

gere

cept

ors.

An

arch

aeolo

gic

alw

atch

ing

brie

fac

ross

the

area

sof

Gox

hill

and

Paul

!si

tes

whe

reso

lEst

nppi

ngw

ould

take

piac

e

•A

pefa

eoen

viro

nmen

tal

asse

ssm

ent

ofth

ere

cept

ion

pit a

nd

pipe

line

tren

chat

Paul

lin

orde

rto

furt

her

dete

rmin

eth

e

pote

ntia

lfor

pala

oenv

iron

men

ta!

rem

ains

tobe

pres

ent.

•E

nsur

eal

lwri

tten

reco

rds

ofth

ear

chae

olog

ical

inve

stig

atio

ns

are

com

plet

edan

dsu

bmit

ted

ina

tim

ely

man

ner

EH

agre

esth

atth

eap

proa

chto

furt

her

wor

kan

dar

chae

olog

ical

miti

gatio

nse

tou

tin

Cha

pter

6of

the

ES

isap

prop

riat

e.

Riv

erH

urnb

erG

asPi

pelin

eR

epla

cem

ent

Proj

ect—

Sta

tem

ento

f Com

mon

Gro

und

His

tori

cen

glan

d

Hyd

erC

onsu

ltin

g(U

K).

Lim

iLxi

22t2

959

Pag

e7

.

I:i.

4,t1

IViatters Not GoncludcdThere are no elements of the topics identified within Section 1 2i of this SQCGthat are not agreed,

Rive Huuber Gas Pipeline Replacernant Project Statement of Conio’on Ground Hi(orio EnglandIlyder Consnjt’ng (UK) Litnted2212959 Page 8

;

‘7.,.7-

‘.:7 ;

..:‘

L

5.1.1

Signod Stternent of Common GroundTh Statement of Common Ground on the topic of Culturaf Heritage has boonprepared by Hyder Consulting on behalf of NtIonaI Grid and agreed by HistoricEngland.

i’ihle 5—1 iu litLJ

Organ ition

Hii1orc Enyand

National Grid

Nanio and fitlo

Or Keith Emerlck

CALL LM4sO.’.€R

‘

River Humber Gas Plp&lne Replacement Project—Saternent of Common Ground Historlo Ençjtandityder Consulting (UK) Umitad-221 2959 Parje 9

-

j i)to