multi-scale study on the effects of harvesting on ... · category trait trait group morphology...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Multi-scale study on the effects of harvesting on ... · Category Trait Trait group Morphology Raunkiaer life Form 1) Rauk.cha 2) Rauk.geo 3) Rauk.hem 4) Rauk.mcpha 5) Rauk.mgpha](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050503/5f95870264f8a4161162f5b7/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Multi-scale study on the effects of harvesting on understory functional diversity in coniferous and mixed wood forests in the Clay Belt region of Quebec and Ontario
Liping Wei, Nicole Fenton, Yves Bergeron
11e colloque du CEF
![Page 2: Multi-scale study on the effects of harvesting on ... · Category Trait Trait group Morphology Raunkiaer life Form 1) Rauk.cha 2) Rauk.geo 3) Rauk.hem 4) Rauk.mcpha 5) Rauk.mgpha](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050503/5f95870264f8a4161162f5b7/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Partial harvest VRCareful logging
Local scale
Regional scale
National scale
Harvesting methods: Clear cut Careful logging Partial harvest
Silviculture treatments: Plowing Disk trenching Prescribed burning ….
Forest community Site Preparation
Modify micro-sites by changing: - Micro-climate- Plant competition- Soil condition (temperature, moisture, nutrient)
Multi-scale harvesting disturbance Introduction
![Page 3: Multi-scale study on the effects of harvesting on ... · Category Trait Trait group Morphology Raunkiaer life Form 1) Rauk.cha 2) Rauk.geo 3) Rauk.hem 4) Rauk.mcpha 5) Rauk.mgpha](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050503/5f95870264f8a4161162f5b7/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Local scale
Regional scale
National scale
Harvesting methods: Clear cut Careful logging Partial harvest
Silviculture treatments: Plowing Disk trenching Prescribed burning ….
Forest community
Multi-scale harvesting disturbance Introduction
principal aimSustainable timber production
![Page 4: Multi-scale study on the effects of harvesting on ... · Category Trait Trait group Morphology Raunkiaer life Form 1) Rauk.cha 2) Rauk.geo 3) Rauk.hem 4) Rauk.mcpha 5) Rauk.mgpha](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050503/5f95870264f8a4161162f5b7/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Local scale
Regional scale
National scale
Harvesting methods: Clear cut Careful logging Partial harvest
Silviculture treatments: Plowing Disk trenching Prescribed burning ….
Forest community
Multi-scale harvesting disturbance Introduction
Forest attributes
Dominant scale
Tree growthSoilUnderstory plants
![Page 5: Multi-scale study on the effects of harvesting on ... · Category Trait Trait group Morphology Raunkiaer life Form 1) Rauk.cha 2) Rauk.geo 3) Rauk.hem 4) Rauk.mcpha 5) Rauk.mgpha](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050503/5f95870264f8a4161162f5b7/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Environmental change 1
…Response trait 1
Community structure and diversity
Environmental change 2
Environmental change 3
Plant communities can be seen as the result of a hierarchy of abiotic and biotic filters that successively constrain which species and traits (from the regional pool) can persist at a site.
Lavorel and Garnier, 2002
5
Functional traits
Response trait 2
Response trait 3
Introduction
![Page 6: Multi-scale study on the effects of harvesting on ... · Category Trait Trait group Morphology Raunkiaer life Form 1) Rauk.cha 2) Rauk.geo 3) Rauk.hem 4) Rauk.mcpha 5) Rauk.mgpha](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050503/5f95870264f8a4161162f5b7/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Harvesting disturbance
Harvest scaleMethod scaleTreatment scale
Understory functional trait Q1: Best disturbance scale?Q2: Relationship between disturbance and trait at the best scale?
6
Forest attributes:
Forest typeTime since last fireTime since disturbance
Q3: the role of forest attributes in affecting trait-disturbance relationship?
Research questions Introduction
![Page 7: Multi-scale study on the effects of harvesting on ... · Category Trait Trait group Morphology Raunkiaer life Form 1) Rauk.cha 2) Rauk.geo 3) Rauk.hem 4) Rauk.mcpha 5) Rauk.mgpha](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050503/5f95870264f8a4161162f5b7/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Clay Belt region
1) Data sets:DeGrandpré et al, 1993 Bescond et al., 2011Kpodo, 2014Lafleur et al., 2010Renard et al., 2016Higelin, unpublished
The percent cover of all vascu lar p lant spec ies present (including woody and herbaceous species with height < 2 m)
2) Vegetation Sampling105 sites986 plots (400 m2)4 subplots (1m2) per plot
Coniferous ecological region
Mixedwood ecological region
Method
7
Study area
![Page 8: Multi-scale study on the effects of harvesting on ... · Category Trait Trait group Morphology Raunkiaer life Form 1) Rauk.cha 2) Rauk.geo 3) Rauk.hem 4) Rauk.mcpha 5) Rauk.mgpha](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050503/5f95870264f8a4161162f5b7/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Three disturbance scales: Harvest scale : harvested vs unharvested Method scale : careful logging, partial harvest and clear cut Treatment scale : 10 silviculture treatments
Forest attributes:Forest typeTime since last fireTime since disturbance
15 traits represent:MorphologyRegeneration strategyResource utilization
Method
8
Data base
![Page 9: Multi-scale study on the effects of harvesting on ... · Category Trait Trait group Morphology Raunkiaer life Form 1) Rauk.cha 2) Rauk.geo 3) Rauk.hem 4) Rauk.mcpha 5) Rauk.mgpha](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050503/5f95870264f8a4161162f5b7/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Variable Levels DescriptionHarvest Unharv Pre-harvested or un-harvested forests Harv Harvested forestsMethod CPRS Cut with protection of regeneration and soils PAR Partial harvest CC Clear cutTreatment CPRSol CPRS without treatment
CPRSpl Plowing after CPRSCPRSdt Disk trenching after CPRSCPRSsa CPRS with small agglomerations of tree retentionCL Careful logging in OntarioPAR33.66 33% to 66% forests harvested PARms Partial cut with protection of small merchantable
stemsPARvr Partial Cut with conservation of canopy cover
(variable retention)CCol Clear cut without treatmentCCpb Prescribed burning after clear cut
Variable Description LevelsSTP Stand type bS MixedTSF Time since fire ≤100 yr >100 yrTSD Time since
disturbance≤15 yr
>15 yr
Harvesting disturbance Forest attributes
Method
9
Ecological variables – effect variables
![Page 10: Multi-scale study on the effects of harvesting on ... · Category Trait Trait group Morphology Raunkiaer life Form 1) Rauk.cha 2) Rauk.geo 3) Rauk.hem 4) Rauk.mcpha 5) Rauk.mgpha](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050503/5f95870264f8a4161162f5b7/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Category Trait Trait group Morphology
Raunkiaer life Form 1) Rauk.cha 2) Rauk.geo 3) Rauk.hem 4) Rauk.mcpha 5) Rauk.mgpha
Lateral extension 1) Clone.compact 2) Clone.phalanx 3) Clone.guerilla
Vegetative propagation 1) Rhizome 2) Non-rhizome
Maximum height (cm)Root depth (cm)Stem specific density (mg/mm3)Specific leaf area (mm2/mg)
Regeneration and dispersion
Mode of reproduction 1) Repro.veg 2) Repro.mse
Flowering phenology 1) Flower.sp 2) Flower.Su
Seed dispersal vector 1) Disper.ani 2) Disper.wow
Seed persistence 1) Seed.short 2) Seed.semi-permanent 3) Seed.permanent
Seed weight (mg)Resource utilization
Humidity preference 1) Humid 2) Xeric 3) Broad.humid
Light requirement 1) Shad.int 2) Shad.mid 3) Shad.tol
Habitat 1) MForest 2) PForest 3) NForest
Method
10
Functional trait groups
![Page 11: Multi-scale study on the effects of harvesting on ... · Category Trait Trait group Morphology Raunkiaer life Form 1) Rauk.cha 2) Rauk.geo 3) Rauk.hem 4) Rauk.mcpha 5) Rauk.mgpha](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050503/5f95870264f8a4161162f5b7/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
A good overview of the community structureCommunity-level approach
Functional Richness (FRic) Evenness (FEve) Divergence (FDiv)
- Functional diversity indices
- Generalized linear mixed models (GLMMs, Quasi-Poisson “family”) Model selection based on QAICc Fric (FEve, FDiv) ~ Null model Harvest Method Treatment Forest type Time since fire Time since disturbance Two random effects: “sites” and “plots”
Method
11
Data analysis
![Page 12: Multi-scale study on the effects of harvesting on ... · Category Trait Trait group Morphology Raunkiaer life Form 1) Rauk.cha 2) Rauk.geo 3) Rauk.hem 4) Rauk.mcpha 5) Rauk.mgpha](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050503/5f95870264f8a4161162f5b7/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Which traits predict species response to harvesting disturbance
- Basic RLQ analysis
Hausner et al., 2003
To identify and remove the potentially confounding effects of stand attributes
- Partial RLQ analysis
L
CA1
R
PCA3
Q
FCA2
Species Silvilculture treatments
Species
Plots
Plots
Traits
Co-Inertia
Co-In
ertia
Co-Inertia
RLQcovSTPRLQcovTSFRLQcovTSD
Method
12
Species-level approach
Data analysis
![Page 13: Multi-scale study on the effects of harvesting on ... · Category Trait Trait group Morphology Raunkiaer life Form 1) Rauk.cha 2) Rauk.geo 3) Rauk.hem 4) Rauk.mcpha 5) Rauk.mgpha](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050503/5f95870264f8a4161162f5b7/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Functional diversity indicesModels FRic FEve FDiv
Harvesting disturbance scales
Harvest -171.72 -202.02 -17.03
Method -211.98 -214.10 -79.47Treatment -484.69 -188.03 -183.43
Forest attributes
Forest type -5.51 -2.87 -34.17Time since disturbance -94.02 -55.33 -39.61
Time since fire -197.25 -12.99 -144.48
Differences in QAICc values between the different ecological models and the null model for functional diversity indices
The smaller the QAICc, the better the model with respect to the others.
13
Best disturbance scale Results and discussion
![Page 14: Multi-scale study on the effects of harvesting on ... · Category Trait Trait group Morphology Raunkiaer life Form 1) Rauk.cha 2) Rauk.geo 3) Rauk.hem 4) Rauk.mcpha 5) Rauk.mgpha](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050503/5f95870264f8a4161162f5b7/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Response variable Explanatory variable Estimate SE P FRic Unharv (Intercept) -1.26 0.04 < 2e-16 *** CCol 0.18 0.10 0.08 CCpb 0.45 0.18 0.01 * CPRSag 0.75 0.18 0.00 *** CPRSdt -0.65 0.22 0.00 ** CPRSol 0.11 0.07 0.13 CPRSpl -0.38 0.18 0.04 * CPRSsa 0.16 0.26 0.54 PAR33.66 -0.22 0.23 0.34 PARms 0.25 0.11 0.02 * PARvr 0.28 0.09 0.00 **FDiv Unharv (Intercept) -0.30 0.02 < 2e-16 *** CCol 0.11 0.07 0.09 CCpb 0.05 0.14 0.73 CPRSag 0.12 0.15 0.45 CPRSdt -0.41 0.12 0.00 *** CPRSol 0.00 0.05 0.91 CPRSpl -0.21 0.11 0.04 * CPRSsa 0.08 0.17 0.64 PAR33.66 -0.08 0.13 0.55 PARms 0.06 0.07 0.43 PARvr 0.05 0.06 0.39
Disturbance directly on trees and soil
Disturbance directly on trees
14
Effects of treatments on functional diversity Results and discussion
![Page 15: Multi-scale study on the effects of harvesting on ... · Category Trait Trait group Morphology Raunkiaer life Form 1) Rauk.cha 2) Rauk.geo 3) Rauk.hem 4) Rauk.mcpha 5) Rauk.mgpha](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050503/5f95870264f8a4161162f5b7/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Axis 1 Axis 2 Eigenvalues % Eigenvalues % Cum.%a) Treatment
Basic RLQ 0.37 61.19 0.12 19.62 80.81 RLQcovSTP 0.14 50.35 0.05 18.20 68.55 RLQcovTSF 0.39 64.03 0.12 19.93 83.96 RLQcovTSD 0.09 43.60 0.05 24.14 67.74
b) Method Basic RLQ 0.64 91.50 0.05 7.66 99.16 RLQcovSTP 0.06 67.25 0.03 27.60 94.85 RLQcovTSF 0.68 92.06 0.05 7.33 99.36 RLQcovTSD 0.19 90.12 0.01 8.73 98.85
“RLQcovSTP”, “RLQcovTSF” or “RLQcovTSD” Respectively means partial RLQ analysis using STP, TSF or TSD as co-variable.
highest
highest
Eigenvalues, percentage and cumulative percentage of variance explained by the first two axes of the basic RLQ and the partial RLQ at the treatment and method scales
15
RLQ analysis Results and discussion
![Page 16: Multi-scale study on the effects of harvesting on ... · Category Trait Trait group Morphology Raunkiaer life Form 1) Rauk.cha 2) Rauk.geo 3) Rauk.hem 4) Rauk.mcpha 5) Rauk.mgpha](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050503/5f95870264f8a4161162f5b7/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Treatments Functional trait groups
16
RLQ analysis
Axis 1: 53.05% of inertia
Axi
s 1:
16,
17%
of i
nert
ia
Results and discussion
![Page 17: Multi-scale study on the effects of harvesting on ... · Category Trait Trait group Morphology Raunkiaer life Form 1) Rauk.cha 2) Rauk.geo 3) Rauk.hem 4) Rauk.mcpha 5) Rauk.mgpha](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050503/5f95870264f8a4161162f5b7/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
PARvrCCol
CPRSolPARms
CPRSsaPAR33.66
CCpbCL
CPRSdtCPRSpl
unharvShad.midRauk.chaRauk.geo
Seed weightClone.guerilla
RhizomeSSD
NForestHumidDepthAniSeed.short
Rauk.mcphaRepro.vegClone.phalanxXericFlower.spPForestSee.permanent
Clone.compactRauk.mgpha
Shad.torSLA
Non-rhizomeHeightRepro.mse
Seed.semi-permanentRauk.hem
Broad.humidDisper.wow
MForestShad.intFlower.su
Axis 1
Treatments
Trait groups
Relationship between treatments and trait groups on the RLQ Axis 1
Treatment group 1 Treatment group 2
Treatment group 3
Treatment group 4
17
RLQ analysis Results and discussion
![Page 18: Multi-scale study on the effects of harvesting on ... · Category Trait Trait group Morphology Raunkiaer life Form 1) Rauk.cha 2) Rauk.geo 3) Rauk.hem 4) Rauk.mcpha 5) Rauk.mgpha](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050503/5f95870264f8a4161162f5b7/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
1. The details of silvicultural treatments were necessary for explaining patterns in functional diversity.
2. The relationship between silvicultural treatments and patterns of functional traits is: Ø Completely different response of unharvested to harvested despite
the age range in unharvested stands.
Ø Unharv and three treatments - CCpb, PAR33.66 and CPRSsa were found to be indicated by trait and by more than one trait group. The three treatments had totally the same indicator trait groups.
3. Forest attributes did not play dominant roles in determining functional diversity, only TSF slightly affected the trait-treatment relationship.
18
Conclusion
![Page 19: Multi-scale study on the effects of harvesting on ... · Category Trait Trait group Morphology Raunkiaer life Form 1) Rauk.cha 2) Rauk.geo 3) Rauk.hem 4) Rauk.mcpha 5) Rauk.mgpha](https://reader034.vdocuments.us/reader034/viewer/2022050503/5f95870264f8a4161162f5b7/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Mélanie DesrochersMorgane HigelinSophie GachetLaura Boisvert-marshJulie Arseneault
Acknowledgements
19