multi-family group therapy - iaed.org.il · multi-family group therapy: evaluation using the aesed...

14
Multi-Family Group Therapy: Evaluation Using the AESED Scale Marion Rom, MSW Social Worker Kile Brokop, BA Quality Analyst Jadine Cairns, RD, MSc Dietitian Pei-Yoong Lam, FRACP Pediatrician Provincial Specialized Eating Disorders Program for Children and Adolescents British Columbia Mental Health and Addiction Services

Upload: hoangnga

Post on 06-Aug-2018

225 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Multi-Family Group Therapy - iaed.org.il · Multi-Family Group Therapy: Evaluation Using the AESED Scale Marion Rom, MSW Social Worker Kile Brokop, BA Quality Analyst Jadine Cairns,

Multi-Family Group Therapy:

Evaluation Using the AESED Scale

Marion Rom, MSW

Social Worker

Kile Brokop, BA

Quality Analyst

Jadine Cairns, RD, MSc

Dietitian

Pei-Yoong Lam, FRACP

Pediatrician

Provincial Specialized Eating Disorders

Program for Children and Adolescents

British Columbia Mental Health and

Addiction Services

Page 2: Multi-Family Group Therapy - iaed.org.il · Multi-Family Group Therapy: Evaluation Using the AESED Scale Marion Rom, MSW Social Worker Kile Brokop, BA Quality Analyst Jadine Cairns,

2

Learning Objectives

Participants will:

• Review how parents of youth with an eating disorder accommodate the

eating disorder in their daily lives

• Gain an understanding of the components and purpose of Multi-Family Group therapy (MFGT) as a treatment modality

• Understand how parents cope with youth with an ED during MFGT at the Provincial Specialized Eating Disorders Program in Vancouver Canada

Page 3: Multi-Family Group Therapy - iaed.org.il · Multi-Family Group Therapy: Evaluation Using the AESED Scale Marion Rom, MSW Social Worker Kile Brokop, BA Quality Analyst Jadine Cairns,

Aim of the study

• To describe how parents are coping with youth with an ED at the beginning and end of MFGT using the AESED scale and satisfaction surveys

• Current outcomes-based literature on MFGT is limited

3

MFGT Research Team L-R:

Jadine Cairns, Kile Brokop, Marion Rom, Pei-Yoong Lam

Page 4: Multi-Family Group Therapy - iaed.org.il · Multi-Family Group Therapy: Evaluation Using the AESED Scale Marion Rom, MSW Social Worker Kile Brokop, BA Quality Analyst Jadine Cairns,

4

Background: Multi-Family Group Therapy (MFGT)

• Year-long therapeutic modality

• Team of therapists

• 6-7 families, all family members recruited for each session

• Initial intensive 4-day sessions followed by 4 to 6 one day follow-up sessions through the subsequent 12 months

• Experiential activities

• Mutual family support

Page 5: Multi-Family Group Therapy - iaed.org.il · Multi-Family Group Therapy: Evaluation Using the AESED Scale Marion Rom, MSW Social Worker Kile Brokop, BA Quality Analyst Jadine Cairns,

5

What is the AESED?

• The Accommodation and Enabling Scale for Eating Disorders (AESED) is a validated scale developed at King’s College, London, which explores five factors related to accommodation of the ED (Sepulveda 2009) in the family.

• The maximum score is 132 (Higher number = more accommodation)

Five Factors

Avoidance and

Modifying

Meal Ritual

Control of Family

Reassurance Seeking

Turning a Blind Eye

Page 6: Multi-Family Group Therapy - iaed.org.il · Multi-Family Group Therapy: Evaluation Using the AESED Scale Marion Rom, MSW Social Worker Kile Brokop, BA Quality Analyst Jadine Cairns,

MFGT in Vancouver (British Columbia, Canada)

• Provincial Specialized Eating Disorder Program at BC Children’s Hospital started MFGT in 2009

• In our 4th year, starting 7th group this spring

• Evaluation has been integrated into MFGT for continuous quality improvement and research purposes

6

MFGT Clinical Team. L-R: Pat Roles, Marion

Rom, Mandy Dhanda, Jadine Cairns, Tom Bauslaugh, Barbara Beach, Karen Dixon and Karina O’Brien

Page 7: Multi-Family Group Therapy - iaed.org.il · Multi-Family Group Therapy: Evaluation Using the AESED Scale Marion Rom, MSW Social Worker Kile Brokop, BA Quality Analyst Jadine Cairns,

7

Methodology

• Parents were recruited from five MFGT groups from 2009-2012

• The AESED was administered at the launch (n=11) and at the final follow-up session (n=18) approximately one year later. Only data from complete AESEDS was included in the research data set

• Some parents declined to participate in research study

• Standard program evaluation measures on Likert-like scales assessing satisfaction with MFGT were also included

• Survey was administered after all MFGT sessions

Page 8: Multi-Family Group Therapy - iaed.org.il · Multi-Family Group Therapy: Evaluation Using the AESED Scale Marion Rom, MSW Social Worker Kile Brokop, BA Quality Analyst Jadine Cairns,

AESED Results

This indicates a reduction in parental accommodation of the ED in their daily lives post attendance at MFGT

8

Page 9: Multi-Family Group Therapy - iaed.org.il · Multi-Family Group Therapy: Evaluation Using the AESED Scale Marion Rom, MSW Social Worker Kile Brokop, BA Quality Analyst Jadine Cairns,

Measuring Parent Satisfaction with MFGT

• 93% of parents felt that MFGT contributed to increasing their confidence

• 95% of parents felt that MFGT helped in effectively dealing with the ED

• 80% of parents would strongly recommend MFGT to other families

Page 10: Multi-Family Group Therapy - iaed.org.il · Multi-Family Group Therapy: Evaluation Using the AESED Scale Marion Rom, MSW Social Worker Kile Brokop, BA Quality Analyst Jadine Cairns,

What parents said

Positive aspects of the group

• “we now eat together”

• “we took away the (weigh) scale”

• “I am more relaxed/accepting and prepared to deal with the challenges”

Opportunities for improvement

• “My own family members don’t participate as much as I like”

Page 11: Multi-Family Group Therapy - iaed.org.il · Multi-Family Group Therapy: Evaluation Using the AESED Scale Marion Rom, MSW Social Worker Kile Brokop, BA Quality Analyst Jadine Cairns,

Conclusions

• The AESED scores, in conjunction with parents’ strong self-reported satisfaction with MFGT, demonstrate the benefits of this modality.

• Although this current research cannot draw a correlation between MFGT intervention and better clinical outcomes, it provides a platform for future research in this area.

11

Page 12: Multi-Family Group Therapy - iaed.org.il · Multi-Family Group Therapy: Evaluation Using the AESED Scale Marion Rom, MSW Social Worker Kile Brokop, BA Quality Analyst Jadine Cairns,

12

Limitations

small sample size

cannot isolate the factor with greatest impact on satisfaction (i.e. degree of satisfaction might be influenced by unique circumstances of family member’s illness and family dynamics)

Difficult to generalize findings to other treatment centres using MFGT as there is no standardized protocol for how MFGT is conducted (therapy is based on general guiding principles)

Page 13: Multi-Family Group Therapy - iaed.org.il · Multi-Family Group Therapy: Evaluation Using the AESED Scale Marion Rom, MSW Social Worker Kile Brokop, BA Quality Analyst Jadine Cairns,

13

Next Steps

• Hope to implement some changes to MFGT content based on feedback from parents

• Next steps of evaluation: in order to further understand impact on parents and families and treatment outcomes post-MFGT, we hope to design a second study which will involve telephone based open ended interviews (minimum of 1 year post MFGT)

• Research Team is also hoping to design other research to investigate outcomes of families who have participated in MFGT

Page 14: Multi-Family Group Therapy - iaed.org.il · Multi-Family Group Therapy: Evaluation Using the AESED Scale Marion Rom, MSW Social Worker Kile Brokop, BA Quality Analyst Jadine Cairns,

References and Resources Consulted

• Asen E, Scholz M (2010). Multi Family Therapy: Concepts and Techniques

Routledge, New York.

• Dare C, Eisler I. (2000). A multi-family group day treatment programme for adolescent eating disorder. Eur Eat Disorders Rev. 8:4-18.

• Sepulveda AR, Kyriacou O, Treasure J. (2009). Developing and validation of the Accommodation and Enabling Scale for Eating Disorders (AESED) for caregivers in eating disorders. BMC Health Services Research. 9:171.

14