msci - what if greece leaves the euro june 2015

11
  MSCI.COM | PAGE 1 OF 11 © 2015 MSCI Inc. All rights reserved. Please refer to the disclaimer at the end of  this document. WHAT IF GREECE LEAVES THE EURO? JUNE 2015 What If  Greece Leaves the Euro? Stress Testing the Greek Exit Scenario Using MSCI RiskManager Carlo Acerbi,  Zsolt Simon, Vivek Sridhar,  Thomas Verbraken June 2015 Introduction As the financial  press wonders about a potential  Greek exit from the euro, this paper examines a possible outcome for financial  markets by employing  a Greek Exit (Grexit) stress test using MSCI RiskManager.  1  This stress test scenario,  as well as its outcome on selected example portfolios  in the Illustration section, demonstrates  the potential  impact of  a Greek exit on the markets outside Greece by using the socalled RiskManager’s  “predictive stress test” tool. 2  The scenario design is based on the following guidelines:   A minimal set of  core factors was chosen to spread the shock across markets, illustrating cause and effect, not only correlation.   A propagation of  core factor shocks was based on a regression  performed in a similar turbulent period,  i.e., the European Sovereign Debt crisis, from December  2011 to May 2012.  The relative magnitude of  core factor shocks was studied via a principal  component analysis of  the chosen period,  with a few additional  shocks adjusted to account for changes in factor exposure to Greece since May 2012. This paper outlines our recommended  Greek Exit test scenario as well as the reasons behind the testing design.  The Greek Exit Scenario The implications for Greece of  a euro departure (referred to as “Grexit”)  illustrated by the hypothetical  stress test would be dramatic.  In this illustrative scenario,  Greece would adopt a new currency,  which immediately  experiences  a severe devaluation.  Here are the major potential  ramifications  of  such a scenario in this example:  All Greek public and private debtors would be under stress as they struggle to repay eurodenominated debt while their income streams are denominated  in the New Greek currency,  potentially leading to default for virtually all outstanding bonds.   Greek equities would not be spared either.  For a foreign investor,  the compound effect of  the currency devaluation and a drop in equity prices could lead to massive losses on Greek equity. 1  This is an illustrative scenario, not MSCI’s prediction of  how a Greek exit would play out. 2  Risk Manager has several tools for stress testing. The predictive stress test tool is meant to describe the propagation of  the shocks of  a limited number of  chosen risk factors across the rest of  the markets. 

Upload: dumitru-tudor

Post on 04-Nov-2015

8 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Greek crisis

TRANSCRIPT

  • MSCI.COM|PAGE1OF112015MSCIInc.Allrightsreserved.Pleaserefertothedisclaimerattheendofthisdocument.

    WHATIFGREECELEAVESTHEEURO?JUNE2015

    WhatIfGreeceLeavestheEuro?StressTestingtheGreekExitScenarioUsingMSCIRiskManager

    CarloAcerbi,ZsoltSimon,VivekSridhar,ThomasVerbraken

    June2015

    IntroductionAsthefinancialpresswondersaboutapotentialGreekexitfromtheeuro,thispaperexaminesapossibleoutcomeforfinancialmarketsbyemployingaGreekExit(Grexit)stresstestusingMSCIRiskManager.1Thisstresstestscenario,aswellasitsoutcomeonselectedexampleportfoliosintheIllustrationsection,demonstratesthepotentialimpactofaGreekexitonthemarketsoutsideGreecebyusingthesocalledRiskManagerspredictivestresstesttool.2Thescenariodesignisbasedonthefollowingguidelines:

    Aminimalsetofcorefactorswaschosentospreadtheshockacrossmarkets,illustratingcauseandeffect,notonlycorrelation.

    Apropagationofcorefactorshockswasbasedonaregressionperformedinasimilarturbulentperiod,i.e.,theEuropeanSovereignDebtcrisis,fromDecember2011toMay2012.

    Therelativemagnitudeofcorefactorshockswasstudiedviaaprincipalcomponentanalysisofthechosenperiod,withafewadditionalshocksadjustedtoaccountforchangesinfactorexposuretoGreecesinceMay2012.

    ThispaperoutlinesourrecommendedGreekExittestscenarioaswellasthereasonsbehindthetestingdesign.

    TheGreekExitScenarioTheimplicationsforGreeceofaeurodeparture(referredtoasGrexit)illustratedbythehypotheticalstresstestwouldbedramatic.Inthisillustrativescenario,Greecewouldadoptanewcurrency,whichimmediatelyexperiencesaseveredevaluation.Herearethemajorpotentialramificationsofsuchascenariointhisexample:

    AllGreekpublicandprivatedebtorswouldbeunderstressastheystruggletorepayeurodenominateddebtwhiletheirincomestreamsaredenominatedintheNewGreekcurrency,potentiallyleadingtodefaultforvirtuallyalloutstandingbonds.

    Greekequitieswouldnotbesparedeither.Foraforeigninvestor,thecompoundeffectofthecurrencydevaluationandadropinequitypricescouldleadtomassivelossesonGreekequity.

    1Thisisanillustrativescenario,notMSCIspredictionofhowaGreekexitwouldplayout.2RiskManagerhasseveraltoolsforstresstesting.Thepredictivestresstesttoolismeanttodescribethepropagationoftheshocksofalimitednumberofchosenriskfactorsacrosstherestofthemarkets.

  • MSCI.COM|PAGE2OF112015MSCIInc.Allrightsreserved.Pleaserefertothedisclaimerattheendofthisdocument.

    WHATIFGREECELEAVESTHEEURO?JUNE2015

    TheeffectontheEuropeanandglobaleconomywouldprobablybelimited,astheGreekeconomyissmallrelativetothetotaleurozone.Globalfinancialmarkets,however,wouldexperienceincreasedturbulence.StocksoffinancialinstitutionswithexposuretoGreekdebtlikelywouldsuffer,aswouldequitymarketsingeneralasaflighttoqualityensued.

    InEuropeanbondmarkets,yieldsofperipheralcountries(Italy,Spain,Portugal)wouldincreaseduetofearsofcontagion.TheyieldsofGermanBundsandothercorecountrieslikelywoulddrop,againduetoflighttoqualityeffects.Finally,theeurowoulddepreciateasfundswillflowoutofEurope.

    DesigningaGreekExit(Grexit)StressTestTwoDesignChoicesTheproposedMSCIRiskManagerstresstestconsistsoftwomajorparts:GreeceandWorldexGreece.TheeffectonGreeceismodeledwithacompositestresstest3thatconsistsof:

    AJumptoDefaultstresstestforallGreekbonds,bothsovereignandcorporate Ageneral80%shockonallGreekstocks

    FortheWorldexGreecescenario,weuseapredictivestresstest.Tospecifyapredictivestresstest,weneedtodefinethesetofcorefactorsandshockmagnitudes,togetherwiththeestimationwindowandthereturnhorizonusedfortheregression.IntheEuropeexGreecepredictivestresstest,wechosetoshockthefollowingcorefactors:

    Italian5Ygovernmentyield:+200bps Portugal5Ygovernmentyield:+200bps German5Ygovernmentyield4:46bps EurostoxxBanksindex:25%

    WeusedtheestimationwindowfromDecember1,2011toMay31,2012,andworkedwithweeklyreturns.Inthenextsectionwemotivatethesechoices.

    3SeetheRiskMetricsStressTestingGuideformoreinformationonthecompositestresstest.4Thisshockwouldproducenegativerates,asofJune30,2015.Dependingonhowtheinstrumentismodeled(negativeratesallowedornot),thismayleadtointerestratessetwithaminimumlevel.

  • MSCI.COM|PAGE3OF112015MSCIInc.Allrightsreserved.Pleaserefertothedisclaimerattheendofthisdocument.

    WHATIFGREECELEAVESTHEEURO?JUNE2015

    RationaleBehindtheDesignChoicesEstimationWindowandReturnHorizonWhenmodelingaGreekexitstresstest,weenvisionedashockofamagnitudethattypicallycorrespondstolargerreturnhorizonswithleadlageffectsoftheorderofdays.Therefore,itwasnotadvisabletousedailyreturnsfortheregressionbutlongerreturnhorizonsinstead.Whenthereturnhorizonistoolarge,ontheotherhand,therearetoofewindependentobservationsintheestimationwindow.Hence,weeklyreturnsareanaturalcompromise.Fortheestimationperiod,wewentbacktoearly2012inthedepthsoftheEuropeanSovereigncrisis(sparkedbyGreecesfinancialproblems).TheGreek5YGovernmentyieldpeakedduringthisperiod,ascanbeseeninExhibit1.TheyieldreacheditshighestvalueattheendofMay2012,whichistheendofourestimationwindow.TheCDSmarketofGreeksovereigndebtfroze(CDSquotesstopped)inMarch2012whenGreecerestructureditsgovernmentdebtheldbyprivatecreditors.DuetothecomovementbetweenthegovernmentyieldandthesovereignCDSspreadandduetothelimitedliquidityoftheCDSduringthecrisisperiod,wedecidedtouseperipheralyieldsinsteadofperipheralCDSspreadsinthedefinitionofthestresstest.Forthestartoftheestimationwindow,welookedattheevolutionofcorrelationsthroughoutthecrisisperiod,asshowninExhibit2.Wewantedrelativelystablecorrelationsthroughouttheestimationwindow.TherewasashiftinmanycorrelationsaroundDecember2011,whichiswhywechosethatpointasthestartoftheestimationwindow.

  • MSCI.COM|PAGE4OF112015MSCIInc.Allrightsreserved.Pleaserefertothedisclaimerattheendofthisdocument.

    WHATIFGREECELEAVESTHEEURO?JUNE2015

    Exhibit1:Greece5YGovernmentYieldandtheCDSSpreadoftheGreekGovernment

    Source:Reuters,CMA,Markit.

    0

    5000

    10000

    15000

    20000

    25000

    30000

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    25

    30

    35

    CDSS

    pread(

    bps)

    Yield(

    %)

    GreeceGovernmentPostExchangeBenchmarkZeroCMAGreece(Senior,CR03)CDSMarkitHellenicRep(SNRFOR,CR)CDS

  • MSCI.COM|PAGE5OF112015MSCIInc.Allrightsreserved.Pleaserefertothedisclaimerattheendofthisdocument.

    WHATIFGREECELEAVESTHEEURO?JUNE2015

    Exhibit2:RollingCorrelationofItalian5YGovernmentYieldwithotherEuropeanYields

    Source:Correlationswerecalculatedbasedon5YgovernmentyielddatafromReuters.

    CoreFactorSelectionThedefaultofGreekgovernmentandcorporatedebtwouldcauseperipheralyieldstospikeduetofearofcontagion.TheconsequentflighttoqualitymaypotentiallyleadtotighteningGermanyieldsandaweakeningeuro.,ThestockpriceofbanksthatareexposedtoGreekdebtwouldalsobeunderpressure.Theaimofourtestwastomodelthoseeffectswithalimitednumberofcorefactors,whicharethenpropagatedtootherriskfactorswiththepredictivestresstest.WerepresentedtheyieldsofperipheralEUcountriesbytheItalian5YGovernmentyield,whichisingeneralcorrelatedwithotherperipheralcountriesyields(seeExhibit3).ThecorrelationwithSpain,theotherlargeperipheralEUeconomy,wasespeciallyhigh.Tocapturethechangeofthecorecountriesyields,weincludedtheGerman5Yyield.Finally,weshockedtheEurostoxxBanksIndextomodelthenegativereturnofthefinancialstocks.

    1

    0.5

    0

    0.5

    1 GermanGovernmentDebtBenchmarkZeroCouponSpanishGovernmentDebtBenchmarkZeroCouponFrenchGovernmentBenchmarkZero

    GreeceGovernmentPostExchangeBenchmarkZeroHungarianGovernmentDebtBenchmarkZeroCouponIrishGovernmentDebtBenchmarkZeroCouponItalianGovernmentBenchmarkZero

    PolishGovernmentDebtBenchmarkZeroCouponPortugueseGovernmentDebtBenchmarkZeroCoupon

  • MSCI.COM|PAGE6OF112015MSCIInc.Allrightsreserved.Pleaserefertothedisclaimerattheendofthisdocument.

    WHATIFGREECELEAVESTHEEURO?JUNE2015

    Exhibit3:CorrelationBetweenEuropeanYields

    Source:Correlationswerecalculatedbasedon5YgovernmentyielddatafromReutersbetween[date]and[date].MagnitudeofShocks:NoEuropeanCatastropheAccordingtoouranalysis,theseverityofcontagionthroughtheeurozoneperipheralcountrieswaslesspronouncedthanin2012whentheprevioussovereigndebtcrisisoccurred.Thereason:Portugal,Italy,SpainandIrelandmadeimportantstepsinthelastthreeyearstobuildmorestableeconomiesandtominimizetheimpactofafuturecrisis.Exhibit4showsthehistoryofthebetaofEuropeangovernmentyieldscomparedtotheGreekgovernmentyield.Notethatin2015theGreekbetashavebeenmuchlowerthantheywereinpreviousyears.ThedirectionoftheshocktotheGermanyieldandtotheEuropeanbankingstocksisderivedfromaprincipalcomponentanalysis(PCA)performedonthecorrelationmatrixofweeklyriskfactorreturnsovertheestimationperiod,asthefirstprincipalcomponentgavethemostplausibledirectionofashock.ThecorrelationbetweenaselectedsetofriskfactorsisshowninExhibit5,whereastheoutcomeoftheprincipalcomponentanalysisisshowninExhibit6.Thecorrelationduringtheestimationwindowwasasweenvisionedinourstresstest,i.e.,iftheItalianyieldincreases,thentheeurowoulddepreciate,equitywoulddrop(especiallythebankingsector),theGermangovernmentyieldwoulddecreaseandperipheralgovernmentyieldswouldincrease.5Thefirstprincipalcomponentshowedthesamedirectionofshocksonthecorefactors.Hence,wemodeledtheGrexitscenariobyusingtheabovementionedestimationwindowfromDecember1,2011toMay31,2012andappliedashockinthedirectionofthefirstprincipalcomponent.WesettheItalian5Ygovernmentyieldshockat+200bps,andshockedtheGerman5Ygovernmentyieldaccordingtothedirectionofthefirstprincipalcomponent.AstheItalianyieldincreasedby200bpsoverthelastthreemonthsoftheestimationperiod,wethinkthatthisshocksizeisreasonable.FortheEurostoxxBanksindex,wedidnottakethemagnitudeassuggestedbythePCA,butwescaledtheshockdown,basedonthecurrentlylowercorrelationwiththeItalian5Yyield.Thereason:backin2012,banksweremuchmoreexposedtoGreekgovernmentdebt,whiletodaygovernmentshavetakenovermuchofthisdebt.

    5Thiswastheresultofthespecificchoicewemadefortheriskfactorsandtestperiod.Differentchoicesmayyieldmateriallydifferentresults.

    GermanGovt5Y

    SpanishGovt5Y

    FrenchGovt5Y

    GreeceGovt5Y

    HungarianGovt5Y

    IrishGovt5Y

    ItalianGovt5Y

    PolishGovt5Y

    PortugueseGovt5Y

    GermanGovt5Y 1.00SpanishGovt5Y 0.03 1.00FrenchGovt5Y 0.24 0.47 1.00GreeceGovt5Y 0.24 0.35 0.12 1.00HungarianGovt5Y 0.25 0.24 0.31 0.20 1.00IrishGovt5Y 0.11 0.44 0.19 0.40 0.18 1.00ItalianGovt5Y 0.21 0.69 0.41 0.21 0.26 0.40 1.00PolishGovt5Y 0.13 0.45 0.30 0.24 0.45 0.32 0.54 1.00PortugueseGovt5Y 0.18 0.22 0.01 0.07 0.13 0.09 0.12 0.00 1.00

  • MSCI.COM|PAGE7OF112015MSCIInc.Allrightsreserved.Pleaserefertothedisclaimerattheendofthisdocument.

    WHATIFGREECELEAVESTHEEURO?JUNE2015

    Exhibit4:Rollingbetaof5YEuropeanGovernmentYieldstothe5YGreekGovernmentYield

    Source:betaswerecalculatedbasedon5YgovernmentyielddatafromReuters.Exhibit5:CorrelationBetweenSelectRiskFactors

    Exhibit6:PrincipalComponentAnalysis.

    10.5

    0

    0.5

    1Jun1

    1

    Dec1

    1

    Jul1

    2

    Jan1

    3

    Aug1

    3

    Feb1

    4

    Sep1

    4

    Apr1

    5

    GermanGovt5Y SpanishGovt5Y FrenchGovt5YGreekGovt5Y HungarianGovt5Y IrishGovt5Y

    RiskFactor Vol CorrelationEuro 1.26 1.00 0.50 0.57 0.38 0.36 0.17 0.38 0.04EUROSTOXX50Index 2.59 0.50 1.00 0.86 0.63 0.32 0.26 0.55 0.07EUROSTOXXBanksIndex 5.59 0.57 0.86 1.00 0.60 0.42 0.18 0.67 0.06DEMGovt60M 0.10 0.38 0.63 0.60 1.00 0.03 0.24 0.21 0.18ESPGovt60M 0.34 0.36 0.32 0.42 0.03 1.00 0.35 0.69 0.22GRDGovt60M 1.85 0.17 0.26 0.18 0.24 0.35 1.00 0.21 0.07ITLGovt60M 0.35 0.38 0.55 0.67 0.21 0.69 0.21 1.00 0.12PTEGovt60M 1.79 0.04 0.07 0.06 0.18 0.22 0.07 0.12 1.00

    RiskFactor PC1 PC2 PC3 PC4 PC5 PC6 PC7 PC8Euro 0.36 0.07 0.13 0.03 0.90 0.02 0.18 0.07EUROSTOXX50Index 0.46 0.20 0.03 0.16 0.21 0.55 0.23 0.56EUROSTOXXBanksIndex 0.48 0.13 0.19 0.10 0.16 0.23 0.07 0.79DEMGovt60M 0.33 0.47 0.25 0.33 0.09 0.69 0.11 0.08ESPGovt60M 0.32 0.53 0.06 0.34 0.02 0.29 0.64 0.05GRDGovt60M 0.21 0.18 0.90 0.18 0.02 0.17 0.19 0.10ITLGovt60M 0.41 0.30 0.26 0.17 0.33 0.23 0.67 0.18PTEGovt60M 0.00 0.56 0.05 0.82 0.07 0.01 0.02 0.02

    PCvol 1.89 1.22 0.96 0.88 0.78 0.53 0.47 0.33PercExpl 45 19 11 10 8 4 3 1

  • MSCI.COM|PAGE8OF112015MSCIInc.Allrightsreserved.Pleaserefertothedisclaimerattheendofthisdocument.

    WHATIFGREECELEAVESTHEEURO?JUNE2015

    AsecondimportantobservationisthatthePortuguese5Yyieldwasnotshockedinthefirstprincipalcomponent,mostlikelyduetoidiosyncraticeventsaffectingPortugalduringtheestimationwindow.InordertoproperlycapturethepotentialcontagioneffectonPortugal,weaddPortugal5Ygovernmentyieldtooasacorefactorandshockitby200bps.Insummary,weproposedthefollowingshocksinourtest:

    Italian5Ygovernmentyield:+200bps Portugal5Ygovernmentyield:+200bps German5Ygovernmentyield:46bps EurostoxxBanksindex:25%

    Inthenextsectionweapplythestresstesttotwosampleportfolios.

    IllustrationToillustratethisproposedstresstest,weappliedourGreekexitscenariotoasampleportfolioreplicatingtheMSCIACWIIndex100%andtoasampleportfolioconsistingofgovernmentbondswithamaturityof10years.ThepredictedreturnaswellasthestandarderrorarebrokendownbycountryandareshowninExhibit7.Fortheequityindexbasedportfolio,weseeanegativereturnforallcountries,wherebytheseverityofthedropdependsontheproximitytoGreece,e.g.,Spain(aperipheralcountry)andAustria(whoselargestcompaniesarebanks)experiencerelativelylargedrops.AlsonotethattheGreekequitydrops80%inpriceand,sinceitisnotpartofthepredictivestresstest,thereisnostandarderrorforGreece.Whilethegovernmentbondsinperipheralcountrieswouldexperienceadropinvalueinthisillustration,corecountries,suchasGermanyandtheNetherlands,wouldgainvalue,aswellasothercountriesoutsidetheeurozone(e.g.,theU.S.,GreatBritain),whichgenerallybenefitfromflighttoqualityeffects.Greeceitselfwouldexperiencedefaultacrosstheboard.NotetheimplicationsforPortuguese,ItalianandCypriotdebt:

    ThepricedeclineinthePortuguesebondismuchlessthanthepricedeclineintheItalianbond,eventhoughboth5Ygovernmentyieldshavebeenshockedwith200bps.Thisismainlycausedbythedifferentbetaoftherespective10Ygovernmentyieldstothe5Yyield.ForItaly,thebetaofthe10Yyieldtothe5Yyieldis0.70,whereasforPortugalthisisonly0.33.Asaresult,thePortuguese10yearbondsuffersless.

    ThereisanextremepredictedreturnwithlargestandarderrorforCypriotdebt.ThereasonisthatCypruswassufferingitsownfinancialcrisisin2012andweshouldnotextrapolatefromthatperiod.Instead,forportfolioscontainingCypriotassets,wemaywanttoaddanadditionalcorefactorforCyprusorstressthoseassetsinadifferentway.

    Thesetwoexamplesillustratethatoneshouldexercisecarewithstresstests,especiallywhenusingpredictivestresstesting.Itmaybenecessarytocustomizethestresstestforindividualusecases.

  • MSCI.COM|PAGE9OF112015MSCIInc.Allrightsreserved.Pleaserefertothedisclaimerattheendofthisdocument.

    WHATIFGREECELEAVESTHEEURO?JUNE2015

    Exhibit7:StressTestResultsforMSCIACWIandaSampleGovernmentBondPortfolio.

    ConclusionAstheGreekdebtcrisisdrivesapotentialexitfromtheeuro,weproposeaRiskManagerstresstesttomodeltheimpactofaGreekexitscenarioonfinancialassets.GiventhedifferentscenarioimplicationsonGreeceversustheWorldexGreece,wedesignedtwodifferentstresstests.OurtestsassumesthatinGreece,equitywouldsufferheavily,andvirtuallyallbondsdefault.TheimpactonEuropeandtheworldwouldbecausedbyfearofcontagionandasubsequentflighttoquality.Theseeffectsledtowideningperipheralyields,tighteningcorecountryyields,aweakeningeuroandadownwardpressureonequity,inparticularfinancialstocks.However,thetestresultsindicatedthattheimpactwouldnotbedevastatingfortheeurozone.

    MSCIAWCI(selectcountries) BondportfolioCountry deltaPV deltaPVSE Country deltaPV deltaPVSEAT 20.9% 1.4% AT 0.5% 0.7%AU 2.3% 1.1% BE 2.5% 0.8%BE 9.9% 1.0% CY 22.0% 17.9%CZ 9.2% 1.2% DE 4.9% 0.2%DE 10.2% 1.1% ES 7.4% 1.0%DK 7.7% 1.2% FI 3.8% 0.3%ES 14.0% 0.9% FR 0.3% 0.6%FI 11.2% 1.6% GB 5.3% 0.5%FR 10.7% 1.0% GR 20.4%GB 6.6% 1.0% IE 2.3% 0.8%GR 80.0% IT 11.5% 0.5%HU 18.4% 2.4% JP 7.2% 0.9%IE 7.9% 1.1% LT 3.6% 0.7%IT 18.6% 0.8% LU 2.9% 0.2%JP 0.5% 0.9% LV 1.3% 0.7%LU 7.6% 0.9% MT 0.1% 0.2%MT 3.5% 1.8% NL 4.8% 0.4%NL 6.8% 0.9% PT 5.7% 1.4%NO 7.8% 1.3% SI 4.5% 1.0%NZ 2.1% 1.0% SK 0.3% 0.7%PH 6.1% 1.6% US 7.7% 0.7%PL 11.0% 1.3%PT 11.4% 1.7%SE 11.9% 1.5%US 2.6% 1.0%TotalACWI 4.1% 0.9%

  • AMERICASAmericas 18885884567*Atlanta +14045513212Boston +16175320920Chicago +13126750545Monterrey +528112534020NewYork +12128043901SanFrancisco +14158368800SaoPaulo +551137061360Toronto +14166281007EUROPE,MIDDLEEAST&AFRICACapeTown +27216730100Frankfurt +496913385900Geneva +41228179777London +442076182222Milan +390258490415Paris 0800915917*ASIAPACIFICChinaNorth 108008521032*ChinaSouth 108001521032*HongKong +85228449333Mumbai +912267849160Seoul 0079885213392*Singapore 8008523749*Sydney +61290339333Taipei 00801127513*Thailand 0018001562077181*Tokyo +81352901555

    ABOUTMSCIFormorethan40years,MSCIsresearchbasedindexesandanalyticshavehelpedtheworldsleadinginvestorsbuildandmanagebetterportfolios.Clientsrelyonourofferingsfordeeperinsightsintothedriversofperformanceandriskintheirportfolios,broadassetclasscoverageandinnovativeresearch.Ourlineofproductsandservicesincludesindexes,analyticalmodels,data,realestatebenchmarksandESGresearch.MSCIserves98ofthetop100largestmoneymanagers,accordingtothemostrecentP&Iranking.Formoreinformation,visitusatwww.msci.com.

    *=tollfree

    [email protected]

  • MSCI.COM|PAGE11OF112015MSCIInc.Allrightsreserved.

    WHATIFGREECELEAVESTHEEURO?JUNE2015

    NOTICEANDDISCLAIMERThisdocumentandalloftheinformationcontainedinit,includingwithoutlimitationalltext,data,graphs,charts(collectively,theInformation)isthepropertyofMSCIInc.oritssubsidiaries(collectively,MSCI),orMSCIslicensors,directorindirectsuppliersoranythirdpartyinvolvedinmakingorcompilinganyInformation(collectively,withMSCI,theInformationProviders)andisprovidedforinformationalpurposesonly.TheInformationmaynotbemodified,reverseengineered,reproducedorredisseminatedinwholeorinpartwithoutpriorwrittenpermissionfromMSCI.TheInformationmaynotbeusedtocreatederivativeworksortoverifyorcorrectotherdataorinformation.Forexample(butwithoutlimitation),theInformationmaynotbeusedtocreateindexes,databases,riskmodels,analytics,software,orinconnectionwiththeissuing,offering,sponsoring,managingormarketingofanysecurities,portfolios,financialproductsorotherinvestmentvehiclesutilizingorbasedon,linkedto,trackingorotherwisederivedfromtheInformationoranyotherMSCIdata,information,productsorservices.TheuseroftheInformationassumestheentireriskofanyuseitmaymakeorpermittobemadeoftheInformation.NONEOFTHEINFORMATIONPROVIDERSMAKESANYEXPRESSORIMPLIEDWARRANTIESORREPRESENTATIONSWITHRESPECTTOTHEINFORMATION(ORTHERESULTSTOBEOBTAINEDBYTHEUSETHEREOF),ANDTOTHEMAXIMUMEXTENTPERMITTEDBYAPPLICABLELAW,EACHINFORMATIONPROVIDEREXPRESSLYDISCLAIMSALLIMPLIEDWARRANTIES(INCLUDING,WITHOUTLIMITATION,ANYIMPLIEDWARRANTIESOFORIGINALITY,ACCURACY,TIMELINESS,NONINFRINGEMENT,COMPLETENESS,MERCHANTABILITYANDFITNESSFORAPARTICULARPURPOSE)WITHRESPECTTOANYOFTHEINFORMATION.Withoutlimitinganyoftheforegoingandtothemaximumextentpermittedbyapplicablelaw,innoeventshallanyInformationProviderhaveanyliabilityregardinganyoftheInformationforanydirect,indirect,special,punitive,consequential(includinglostprofits)oranyotherdamagesevenifnotifiedofthepossibilityofsuchdamages.Theforegoingshallnotexcludeorlimitanyliabilitythatmaynotbyapplicablelawbeexcludedorlimited,includingwithoutlimitation(asapplicable),anyliabilityfordeathorpersonalinjurytotheextentthatsuchinjuryresultsfromthenegligenceorwillfuldefaultofitself,itsservants,agentsorsubcontractors.Informationcontaininganyhistoricalinformation,dataoranalysisshouldnotbetakenasanindicationorguaranteeofanyfutureperformance,analysis,forecastorprediction.Pastperformancedoesnotguaranteefutureresults.TheInformationshouldnotbereliedonandisnotasubstitutefortheskill,judgmentandexperienceoftheuser,itsmanagement,employees,advisorsand/orclientswhenmakinginvestmentandotherbusinessdecisions.AllInformationisimpersonalandnottailoredtotheneedsofanyperson,entityorgroupofpersons.NoneoftheInformationconstitutesanoffertosell(orasolicitationofanoffertobuy),anysecurity,financialproductorotherinvestmentvehicleoranytradingstrategy.Itisnotpossibletoinvestdirectlyinanindex.Exposuretoanassetclassortradingstrategyorothercategoryrepresentedbyanindexisonlyavailablethroughthirdpartyinvestableinstruments(ifany)basedonthatindex.MSCIdoesnotissue,sponsor,endorse,market,offer,revieworotherwiseexpressanyopinionregardinganyfund,ETF,derivativeorothersecurity,investment,financialproductortradingstrategythatisbasedon,linkedtoorseekstoprovideaninvestmentreturnrelatedtotheperformanceofanyMSCIindex(collectively,IndexLinkedInvestments).MSCImakesnoassurancethatanyIndexLinkedInvestmentswillaccuratelytrackindexperformanceorprovidepositiveinvestmentreturns.MSCIInc.isnotaninvestmentadviserorfiduciaryandMSCImakesnorepresentationregardingtheadvisabilityofinvestinginanyIndexLinkedInvestments.Indexreturnsdonotrepresenttheresultsofactualtradingofinvestibleassets/securities.MSCImaintainsandcalculatesindexes,butdoesnotmanageactualassets.IndexreturnsdonotreflectpaymentofanysaleschargesorfeesaninvestormaypaytopurchasethesecuritiesunderlyingtheindexorIndexLinkedInvestments.TheimpositionofthesefeesandchargeswouldcausetheperformanceofanIndexLinkedInvestmenttobedifferentthantheMSCIindexperformance.TheInformationmaycontainbacktesteddata.Backtestedperformanceisnotactualperformance,butishypothetical.Therearefrequentlymaterialdifferencesbetweenbacktestedperformanceresultsandactualresultssubsequentlyachievedbyanyinvestmentstrategy.ConstituentsofMSCIequityindexesarelistedcompanies,whichareincludedinorexcludedfromtheindexesaccordingtotheapplicationoftherelevantindexmethodologies.Accordingly,constituentsinMSCIequityindexesmayincludeMSCIInc.,clientsofMSCIorsupplierstoMSCI.InclusionofasecuritywithinanMSCIindexisnotarecommendationbyMSCItobuy,sell,orholdsuchsecurity,norisitconsideredtobeinvestmentadvice.DataandinformationproducedbyvariousaffiliatesofMSCIInc.,includingMSCIESGResearchInc.andBarraLLC,maybeusedincalculatingcertainMSCIindexes.Moreinformationcanbefoundintherelevantindexmethodologiesonwww.msci.com.MSCIreceivescompensationinconnectionwithlicensingitsindexestothirdparties.MSCIInc.srevenueincludesfeesbasedonassetsinIndexLinkedInvestments.InformationcanbefoundinMSCIInc.scompanyfilingsontheInvestorRelationssectionofwww.msci.com.MSCIESGResearchInc.isaRegisteredInvestmentAdviserundertheInvestmentAdvisersActof1940andasubsidiaryofMSCIInc.ExceptwithrespecttoanyapplicableproductsorservicesfromMSCIESGResearch,neitherMSCInoranyofitsproductsorservicesrecommends,endorses,approvesorotherwiseexpressesanyopinionregardinganyissuer,securities,financialproductsorinstrumentsortradingstrategiesandMSCIsproductsorservicesarenotintendedtoconstituteinvestmentadviceorarecommendationtomake(orrefrainfrommaking)anykindofinvestmentdecisionandmaynotbereliedonassuch.IssuersmentionedorincludedinanyMSCIESGResearchmaterialsmayincludeMSCIInc.,clientsofMSCIorsupplierstoMSCI,andmayalsopurchaseresearchorotherproductsorservicesfromMSCIESGResearch.MSCIESGResearchmaterials,includingmaterialsutilizedinanyMSCIESGIndexesorotherproducts,havenotbeensubmittedto,norreceivedapprovalfrom,theUnitedStatesSecuritiesandExchangeCommissionoranyotherregulatorybody.Anyuseoforaccesstoproducts,servicesorinformationofMSCIrequiresalicensefromMSCI.MSCI,Barra,RiskMetrics,IPD,FEA,InvestorForce,andotherMSCIbrandsandproductnamesarethetrademarks,servicemarks,orregisteredtrademarksofMSCIoritssubsidiariesintheUnitedStatesandotherjurisdictions.TheGlobalIndustryClassificationStandard(GICS)wasdevelopedbyandistheexclusivepropertyofMSCIandStandard&Poors.GlobalIndustryClassificationStandard(GICS)isaservicemarkofMSCIandStandard&Poors.