8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

1/247

PRMunich Personal RePEc Archive

Macroeconomic Theory and Policy (2ndEdition)

David Andolfatto

Simon Fraser University

1. January 2008

Online athttp://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/6403/

MPRA Paper No. 6403, posted 19. December 2007 17:56 UTC

http://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/6403/http://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/6403/http://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

2/247

!"#$%%'%!(# )*&%$+ , -%.(#+

/01 &123240

56721 "014896334

:2;40 ?= @027?=>23A

/BBC

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

3/247

#D6E3?=>

!"#$%&' () *"& +',-- .,/&-%01 2',341% FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF (!"#$%&' 5) 64%$4% #73 8/$9,:/&7% FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF ;

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

4/247

#D6E3?= #403?03>

GF *"& +',-- .,/&-%01 2',341%F '6324068 (0H4;? 601 -=41IH3 "HH4I03J20KF !?6>I=?;?03 (>>I?>F '4;2068 7?=>I> $?68 L5-F )=?01> 601 #AH8?>F:HD448> 49 )D4IKD3F

/F 64%$4% #73 8/$9,:/&7%L )D? !6=M?3 94= L441> 601 .6N4=F L?0?=68&OI282N=2I; 20 6 :3632H (0H4;?J.?2>I=? !41?8F " '?4H86>>2H68 (03?=E=?36J3240 49 3D? PI>20?>> #AH8?F Q?896=?J$?1IH20K :36N282R63240 -482HAF

SF =71&'%#07%: #73 8>$&1%#%0,7-F 5?H2>240J!6M20K @01?= @0H?=36203AF&T 603? 7?=>I> ?T E4>3 4I3H4;?>F $6324068 601 (==6324068 &TE?H363240>F!I832E8? &OI282N=26 601 "02;68 :E2=23>F Q?896=?J(;E=4720K :36N282R63240-482HAF

UF =7&/$9,:/&7%F .6N4= !6=M?3 F " :2;E8? (01272>2N8?J.6N4= !41?849 &;E84A;?03 #D42H?F $?>?=763240 Q6K?>F !41?820K @0?;E84A;?03FL47?=0;?03 (0>I=60H? -482H2?>F

WF !,7-4/$%0,7 #73 C#D07EF " /J-?=241 &014V;?03 !41?8F (03?=06J324068 P4==4V20K 601 .?0120KF )D? $?68 $63? 49 (03?=?>3F )D? (03?=3?;JE4=68 PI1K?3 #40>3=6203F #40>I;?= 5?;601 601 5?>2=?1 54;?>32H :67J20KF )D? #I==?03 "HH4I03 601 3D? )=61? P6860H?F )=60>234=AX "032H2JE63?1X 601 -?=>2>3?03 -=41IH32723A :D4HM>F $?7?=>? #6I>6823AF

YF G0-1#9 2,901:F "HH4I0320K 601 5636F L47?=0;?03 :E?0120K 601 )6T6J3240 20 6 :3632H !41?8F .I;EJ:I; 7?=>I> 52>34=32406=A )6T63240F L47J?=0;?03 )=60>9?= -482H2?>F L47?=0;?03 5?!H23> 20 6 /J-?=241 !41?8F )D?(03?=3?;E4=68 L47?=0;?03 PI1K?3 #40>3=6203F )D? $2H6=1260 &OI276J8?0H? )D?4=?;F )=60>234=A L47?=0;?03 &TE?01?03I=? :D4HM> 601 )6TJ:;443D20K -482HAF )6T 7?=>I> P401J?> 20 L47?=0;?03-I=HD6>?>F

ZF !#$0%#9 #73 H7D&-%/&7%F 54;?>32H (07?>3;?03 5?;601 20 6 /J-?=241!41?8F " :;688 %E?0 &H404;A V23D :6720K 601 (07?>3;?03F (03?=E=?320K3D? #AH82H68 P?D6724= 49 3D? )=61? P6860H?F #84>?1 &H404;A "068A>2>601 3D? 5?3?=;2063240 49 3D? $?68 $63? 49 (03?=?>3F )D? (: #I=7? 601 3D?[?A0?>260 #=4>>F (03?=E=?320K -482HA (;E82H63240> P6>?1 40 #407?0324068Q2>14;F

CF I,7&: #73 H7!#%0,7F " :2;E8? %7?=86EE20K L?0?=63240> !41?8F )D?5?;601 94= $?68 !40?A P6860H?>F !40?36=A &OI282N=2I;F )D? Q?896=?J

&0D60H20K $48? 49 !40?36=A &THD60K?F !40?A '?I3=6823A 601 '40J'?I3=6823AF (0"63240X :?2K024=6K?X 601 Q6= F !40?36=A @0240F

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

5/247

\F 81,7,/01 +',J%" #73 .&D&9,$/&7%F .40KJ$I0 &721?0H?F " !683DIJ>260 !41?8 V23D

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

6/247

-=?96H?

)D?=? 2> 3416A 6 86=K? 12>H=?E60HA 20 3D? V6A ;6H=4?H404;2H 3D?4=A 2> E=6HJ32H?1 NA =?>?6=HD?=> 601 20 3D? V6A 23 2> 36IKD3 34 I01?=K=61I63?>F ( 6; 043?T6H38A >I=? VDA 3D2> 2> 3D? H6>?F -?=D6E> >4;? 20>3=IH34=>]3=620?1 20 481?=;?3D41>]9??8 3D63 ;41?=0 ;6H=4?H404;2H 3D?4=AX V23D 23> 20>2>3?0H? 40 ;2H=4J?H404;2H =2K4=X 4N>HI=?> 3D? 94=?>3 94= 3D? 3=??>F -?=D6E> >4;? 20>3=IH34=>]3=620?1 20 ;41?=0 ;?3D41>]9??8 3D63 3D? ;41?=0 6EE=46HD 2> >2;E8A 344 H4;JE82H63?1 ^;63D?;632H68_ 94= 3D? 67?=6K? I01?=K=61I63? 34 6N>4=NF QD63?7?=3D? =?6>40>X ( N?82?7? 3D63 3D?A 6=? 688 V=40KF

QD28? ;41?=0 ;?3D41> H60 201??1 N? H4;E82H63?1X 3D? N6>2H ?H404;2H 94=H?>?;N?11?1 V23D20 6 ^>6A_ 1A06;2HX >34HD6>32HX K?0?=68 ?OI282N=2I; ;41?8 H60 N??TE=?>>?1 20 6 7?=A >2;E8? 601 203I2327? ;600?=F !4=?47?=X 3D2> H60 N? 140?86=K?8A V23D 3D? 621 49 126K=6;> 49 3D? 94=;`

!

)D2> 2> 043 6 H4;E82H63?1 126K=6;F (0 ;63D?;632H68 3?=;>X 23 =?OI2=?> 043DJ20K ;4=? 3D60 D2KD>HD448 68?K?N=6 34 6068AR? 94=;688A ^29 3D? >2;E8? H68HI8I> 2>!=>3 E=4721?1]>4;?3D20K ( V4I81 =?H4;;?01 94= 203=41IH34=A 4= 203?=;?1263?8?7?8 H4I=>?>_F ? ^601 ( V4I81 6=KI? 3D? 94=;?=_X 3D2> >2;E8?126K=6; >I;;6=2R?> 3D? ?>>?03268 20K=?12?03> 49 60A ?H404;2H 3D?4=AF "01 A?3X23> E=?>?0H? 2> >3=60K?8A 6N>?03 20 3D? V6A ;6H=4?H404;2H> 2> H4;;408A 36IKD3F)D?=? 2> 04 =?6>40 94= VDA 3D2> >D4I81 N? 3D? H6>?F

)D? 126K=6; 6N47? =?E=?>?03> 21?6> 3D63 6=? 96;2826= 34 60A ?H404;2>3F )D?!=>3 2> 3D63 E?4E8? D67? $'&M&'&71&- 1?!0?1 47?= 12?=?03 H4;;41232?>a 6013D?A 3D?A 6=? K?0?=688A J09907E %, -4N-%0%4%& 6H=4>> H4;;41232?>F )D? >?H401

2> 3D63 E?4E8? 96H? 1,7-%'#07%-a 601 3D63 3D?>? H40>3=6203> 12H363? 3D? #N090%:%, -4N-%0%4%& 6H=4>> H4;;41232?>F (012721I68 N?D6724= 2> E=?>I;?1 34 =?"?H33D? 203?=6H3240 N?3V??0 E=?9?=?0H?> 601 H40>3=6203>F "KK=?K63? N?D6724= H40>32J3I3?> 6 H488?H3240 49 2012721I68 N?D6724=> 3D63 6=? 20 >4;? >?0>? H40>2>3?03 V23D?6HD 43D?=F )D63 2>X V? H40>3=IH3 .?7263D60 ^H47?=_ NA 61120K IE D2> 2012721I68E2?H?>F

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

7/247

)D2> >2;E8? V6A 49 4=K602R20K 3D4IKD3 2> 63 3D? >6;? 32;? 203I2327? 601=?;6=M6N8A "?T2N8?F (3 2> 203I2327? N?H6I>? 68;4>3 60A40? H60 =?863? 34 3D? 21?6

3D63 20H?0327?> 20"I?0H? N?D6724=F (3 2> "?T2N8? N?H6I>? bH4;;41232?>c H60 N?1?!0?1 20 60A 0I;N?= 49 V6A>a >4 3D63 3D? 126K=6; H60 N? N=4IKD3 34 N?6= 4068;4>3 60A ?H404;2H ED?04;?040F ? 3D2> 126K=6; 34 1?7?84E3D?4=2?> 49 86N4= >IEE8AX H40>I;E3240 601 >6720KX ;40?A 1?;601X 601 9?=32823AHD42H?F

)D?=? 2> 40? 43D?= K=?63 N?0?!3 6>>4H263?1 V23D 3D? 126K=6;F (0 E6=32HI86=XN?H6I>? 23 ;6M?> ?TE82H23 =?9?=?0H? 34 E?4E8?>d E=?9?=?0H?>X 23 H60 N? I>?1 34?768I63? 3D? J&9M#'& 1,7-&O4&71&- 49 K47?=0;?03 E482HAF &T6H38A D4V 40?2> 34 14 3D2> V23D4I3 =?9?=?0H? 34 2012721I68 E=?9?=?0H?> ?>H6E?> ;? ?032=?8AF!4=?47?=X NA N?20K ?TE82H23 6N4I3 2012721I68 E=?9?=?0H?>X 40? OI2HM8A 8?6=0>34 N? H6I324I> 20 3?=;> 49 =?86320K H407?0324068 ;?6>I=?> 49 ;6H=4?H404;2H6H32723A 34 60A >?0>2N8? 043240 49 >4H268 V?896=?F " D2KD?= L5- 4= 6 D2KD?=

HI==?03 6HH4I03 >I=E8I>X 94= ?T6;E8?X 14 043 0?H?>>6=28A 2;E8A 6 D2KD?= 8?7?8 49V?896=?a 601 .?7263D60 ;6A !01 23 4E32;68 34 6884V 94= >4;? E4>2327? 8?7?8 49I0?;E84A;?03F

( >D4I81 82M? 34 4?= 6 =?>E40>? 34 6 H=232H2>; 3D63 40? >4;?32;?> D?6=> 20=?863240 34 3D? ;41?=0 ;6H=4?H404;2H 6068A>2>F )D=4IKD4I3 3D? 3?T3X ( ;6M?82N?=68 ^NI3 043 ?TH8I>27?_ I>? 49 34 >4JH688?1 b=?E=?>?036327? 6K?03c 6>>I;E3240F)D2> ( 14 E=2;6=28A 94= E?16K4K2H68 EI=E4>?>F (0 96H3X 3D? ;41?=0 6EE=46HD 2004 V6A 1?E?01> 40 3D? =?E=?>?036327? 6K?03 94=;I863240 ^3D?=? 2> 043D20K 3D63E=?7?03> 40? 9=4; 203=41IH20K 6> ;IHD D?3?=4K?0?23A 6> 1?>2=?1_F QD28? >4;?H40H8I>240> 6=? 04 14IN3 >?0>2327? 34 3D? 6>>I;E3240X 3D?=? 6=? ;60A 43D?=>3D63 6=? 043 ^601 23 2> 3D?>? 8633?= H40H8I>240> 3D63 1?>?=7? ?;ED6>2>_F (0 60AH6>?X ( !01 23 2=402H 3D63 3D? H=232H2>; 49 3D2> 6N>3=6H3240 2> ;4>3 493?0 8?7?8?1 NA3D4>? VD4 E=?9?= 3D? 481?= ;?3D41484KAa VD2HDX NA 23> 7?=A 063I=?X 2> 3AE2H688AH6>3 20 3?=;> 49 6 =?E=?>?036327? 6K?03 ^?FKFX 20 3D? 94=; 49 6KK=?K63? N?D6724=68=?863240>D2E> 3D63 ;6M? 04 =?9?=?0H? 34 2012721I68 12?=?0H?>_F

)D?=? 2> >4;?3D20K ?8>? 3D63 ( >D4I81 E4203 4I3F ( ;6M? 72=3I688A 04 63J3?;E3 20 3D? 3?T3 34 1?>H=2N? VD63 D6> N?H4;? 6 D2KD8A 20"I?03268 N=60HD 49;41?=0 ;6H=4?H404;2H 3D?4=Aa 3D? >4JH688?1 '?VJ[?A0?>260 6EE=46HDF )D2> 2>=?K=?36N8? E=2;6=28A N?H6I>? >4 ;IHD 49 VD63 V? =?61 ?7?=A 16A 20 3D? 0?V>JE6E?= E?=362020K 34 ;40?36=A E482HA 6EE?6=> 34 N? H4IHD?1 20 3D2> 860KI6K?F'?7?=3D?8?>>X ( HD44>? 34 4;23 23 94= 3D? 94884V20K =?6>40>F 3X ( 6; 043 6 N2K960 49 3D? 6EE=46HD ^3D?=? 6=? N?33?= V6A>X 20 ;A 72?VX 34 207?>32K63? 3D? M?AOI?>3240> 20 ;40?36=A E482HA_F :32HMA E=2H?> 601 V6K?> ;6A N? 2;E4=3603 63>4;? 8?7?8X NI3 E=4N6N8A 14 043 96H34= 2034 3D? bN2Kc ?H404;2H OI?>3240>F "01( >3288 14 043 M04V VD63 60 b20"63240 >D4HMc 2> >IEE4>?1 34 =?E=?>?03 20 =?6823AF

:?H401X 3D?=? 6=? 68=?61A ;60A 3?T3N44M> 4I3 3D?=? 3D63 14 60 61?OI63? e4N 49?TE862020K 3D? 6EE=46HDX >4 3D63 3D?=? 2> 04 0??1 34 =?E?63 3D20K> D?=?F

%0 3D? 43D?= D601X ( 14 36M? 3D? 32;? 34 36M? >?=24I>8A >4;? M?A [?A0?J>260 20>2KD3> ^[?A0?> V6> 043 6 '?VJ[?A0?>260_F #403=6=A 34 VD63 >4;? ;6AN?82?7?X 3D? ;41?=0 6EE=46HD H60 N? I>?1 34 ;6M? E=?H2>? [?A0?>d 043240 49

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

8/247

H44=1263240 9628I=? 601 602;68 >E2=23>F (0 >D4=3X 3D? ;41?=0 6EE=46HD 14?> 043E=?H8I1? 3D? E4>>2N2823A 3D63 ;6H=4?H404;2H >36N282R63240 E482H2?> 6=? 20 >4;?

V6A 1?>2=6N8?F P?20K ?TE82H23 6N4I3 3D? H2=HI;>360H?> 20 VD2HD 3D2> ;6A N?3D? H6>?X D4V?7?=X ;6M?> H8?6= 3D? 6>>I;E3240> =?OI2=?1 34 K?0?=63? 3D? =?>I83^601 3D? =?68 V4=81 82;2363240> 3D63 6=? 82M?8A 34 2;E20K? 40 E482HA;6M?=> 201?>2K020K 3D?2= E482H2?>_F

"3 3D2> >36K?X ( V4I81 82M? 34 3D60M 688 ;A E6>3 >3I1?03> VD4 D61 34 >I9J9?= 3D=4IKD E=?82;206=A 7?=>240> 49 3D?>? 043?>F )D?2= >D6=E H4;;?03> D67?H403=2NI3?1 34 6 ;IHD 2;E=47?1 3?T3F ( V4I81 ?>E?H2688A 82M? 34 3D60M :I8360%=6RN6A?R 601 5606 5?84=;?X N43D 49 VD4; D67? >E?03 840K D4I=> 14HI;?0320K601 H4==?H320K 3D? 3AE4K=6ED2H68 ?==4=> 20 ?6=82?= 1=693>F )D4IKD39I8 H4;;?03>V?=? 68>4 =?H?27?1 9=4; P4N 5?84=;?X f60?3 *I6 f260KX 601 ;60A 43D?=> 3D636=? 344 0I;?=4I> 34 ;?03240 D?=?F )D60M A4I 688 7?=A ;IHDF

.#D03 P73,9M#%%,

Q4'7#N:R Q'0%0-" !,94/N0#

.&1&/N&'R 5KKA

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

9/247

#*"-)&$ G

)D? L=4>> 54;?>32H -=41IH3

GF (03=41IH3240

)D? L=4>> 54;?>32H -=41IH3 ^L5-_ 2> 60 ?H404;2H >3632>32H 3D63 40? D?6=>OI43?1 9=?OI?038A 20 3D? 0?V> 601 ?8>?VD?=?F PI3 VD63 ?T6H38A 2> 3D2> L5-3D20K >IEE4>?1 34 ;?6>I=?g "01 VDA >D4I81 60A40? H6=? 6N4I3 VD?3D?= 23 2>;?6>I=?1 63 688g

!4>3 E?4E8? D67? 63 8?6>3 6 76KI? 21?6 3D63 3D? L5- =?E=?>?03> >4;? ;?6J>I=? 49 h?H404;2H E?=94=;60H?Fd %0? 493?0 D?6=>X 94= ?T6;E8?X 3D63 6 H4I03=A

V23D 6 D2KD?= L5- 2> E?=94=;20K N?33?= 3D60 40? V23D 6 84V?= L5-a 4= 3D63 6=6E218A K=4V20K L5- 2> N?33?= 3D60 6 >36N8?X 4= 1?H82020K L5-F )D2> 21?6 49 3D?L5- 6> 6 ;?6>I=? 49 ?H404;2H E?=94=;60H? 2> D?81 >4 V21?8A 601 ^63 32;?>_6HH?E3?1 >4 I0H=232H688AX 3D63 40 3D?>? K=4I01> 6840?X 23 E=4N6N8A 1?>?=7?> H84>?=>H=I320AF

P?94=? V? H60 368M >?0>2N8A 6N4I3 L5- 601 VDA 23 ;2KD3 ;633?=X V? >D4I81D67? 6 H8?6= I01?=>360120K 49 D4V 3D? 3?=; 2> 1?!0?1 601 ;?6>I=?1F !4>3H4I03=2?> 20 3D? V4=81 D67? 6 K47?=0;?03 6K?0HA ^4= 6K?0H2?>_ =?>E40>2N8? 94=H488?H320K 601 6KK=?K6320K ;?6>I=?> 49 ?H404;2H 6H32723AF +4I H60 !01 6 82>3 493D?>? 6K?0H2?> 63 3D? 94884V20K V?N>23? ^3D? @023?1 '63240> :3632>32H> 5272>240_`

D33E`iiI0>363>FI0F4=KiI0>1i;?3D41>i203?=J063820M>i>1j063>363FD3;

(0 #60616X 4I= 06324068 >3632>32H68 6K?0HA 2> H688?1!"#"$%"$&% '#(#)#FG ";40K43D?= 3D20K>X :3632>32H> #60616 ;6203620> 6 >A>3?; 49 06324068 H71,/& #738>$&730%4'& P11,47%-^(&"_F )D? 94884V20K OI43?X 36M?0 9=4; 3D? :3632>32H>#60616 V?NE6K?X >I;> IE 3D?2= 4V0 ^>4;?VD63 0627?_ 72?V 49 3D? V4=81`

)D? (0H4;? 601 &TE?0123I=? "HH4I03> 6=? 3D? H?03=? 49 ;6H=4?H404;2H

6068A>2> 601 E482HAJ;6M20K 20 #60616F )D?A 6=? 6 ;?60> NA VD2HD #606J

1260> H60 72?V 601 6>>?>> 3D? E?=94=;60H? 49 3D? 06324068 ?H404;AF )D?

6HH4I03> E=4721? N43D 6 E860020K 9=6;?V4=M 94= K47?=0;?03> 601 6 =?E4=3

H6=1 40 3D? =?>I83> 49 3D? E860> 3D63 K47?=0;?03> H6==A 4I3F "3 3D? H4=?49 3D? (0H4;? 601 &TE?0123I=? "HH4I03> ^(&"_ 2> 3D? H40H?E3 49 L=4>>

14;?>32H E=41IH3 ^L5-_ 601 23> H4;E40?03>F

G :??` D33E`iiVVVF>363H60FH6i

G

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

10/247

)D? >363?;?03 6N47? ;6M?> H8?6= 3D63 L5- 2> H40>21?=?1 6 H4=? H40H?E3F :48?3d> 36M? >4;? 32;? 34 207?>32K63? 23> ;?6>I=?;?03 601 E43?03268 I>?9I80?>>F

/F 5?!023240 49 L5-

*?=? 2> 6 >36016=1 1?!023240 49 L5-`

L5-` )D? 34368 768I? 49!068 K441> 601 >?=72H?> E=41IH?120 3D? 14;?>32H ?H404;A 47?= >4;? K27?0 E?=241 49 32;?F

1?!023240X V? K63D?= 3D63 3D? L5- =?E=?>?03> >4;? ;?6>I=? 493D? 8?7?8 49 E=41IH3240 20 60 ?H404;AF =?6>40X 3D? L5- 2> H4;;408A=?9?==?1 34 6> ,4%$4%F [??E 20 ;201 3D63 4I3EI3 H40>323I3?> 6 !,J49 K441>

601 >?=72H?>F )D63 2>X 23 =?E=?>?03> 3D? 768I? 49 VD63 2> E=41IH?1 47?= >4;?K27?0 203?=768 49 32;? ^?FKFX 6 ;403DX 6 OI6=3?=X 4= 6 A?6=_F D?83?= >?=72H?> E=41IH?1 47?= 3D? H4I=>? 49 6 A?6= 688 H403=2NI3? 34 60 ?H404;Ad>600I68 L5-F

.?3 I> 04V ?T6;20? 3D? 1?!023240 49 L5- ;4=? H6=?9I88AF '43? !=>3 49 6883D63 3D? L5- ;?6>I=?> 3D? h768I?d 49 4I3EI3F Q? V288 12>HI>> 3D? H40H?E3 49h768I?d 20 >4;? 1?3628 863?= 40a NI3 94= 04VX 6>>I;? 3D63 768I? 2> ;?6>I=?1 20I023> 49 h14886=>d ^9??8 9=?? 34 >IN>323I3? A4I= 9674=23? HI==?0HA_F QD?0 4I3EI3 2>;?6>I=?1 20 I023> 49 ;40?AX 23 2> =?9?==?1 34 6> 3D? 7,/07#9 +.2 ^63 HI==?03E=2H?>_F

%I3EI3 36M?> 3D? 94=; 49 E,,3- #73 -&'D01&-F QD63 2> 3D? 12?=?0H?N?3V??0 6 K441 601 6 >?=72H?g " K441 2> 60 4Ne?H3 3D63 H60 N? D?81 6> 207?034=Aa

VD28? 6 >?=72H? 2> 60 4Ne?H3 3D63 H60043 N? >34=?1F )D20M 49 3D? 12?=?0H?N?3V??0 60 4=60K? 601 6 D62=HI3F '43? 3D63 60A K441 2> 82M?8A 768I?1 408A34 3D? ?T3?03 3D63 23 A2?81> ^4= 2> ?TE?H3?1 34 A2?81_ 6 >?=72H? "4Va 6> VD?0 (H40>I;? 3D63 4=60K?X 94= ?T6;E8?F

'?T3X 043? 3D63 3D? 1?!023240 6N47? ;6M?> =?9?=?0H? 34 "7#9K441> 601 >?=J72H?>F " !068 K441 2> 34 N? 12>320KI2>D?1 9=4; 60 07%&'/&30#%& K441F "0203?=;?1263? K441 2> 60 4Ne?H3 3D63 2> E=41IH?1 601 I3282R?1 6> 6 20EI3 34V6=13D? E=41IH3240 49 >4;? 43D?= K441 4= >?=72H? *$"+$( "+, "$-, .,/$0) 01 &0(%$)2,/#"$0(F

"0 ?T6;E8? ;6A D?8E H86=29AF (;6K20? 3D63 86>3 A?6=X 60 ?H404;A E=41IH?1k/BB 49 7?K?36N8?>X kGWB 49 9?=3282R?=X kGBB 49 N=?61X 601 kWB 49 "4I=F (;6K20?9I=3D?= 3D63 688 49 3D? 9?=3282R?= V6> I>?1 20 3D? E=41IH3240 49 7?K?36N8?> 601

688 49 3D? "4I= V6> I>?1 20 3D? E=41IH3240 49 N=?61F %0? ;2KD3 N? 3?;E3?1 34H40H8I1? 3D63 3D? 600I68 L5- 94= 3D2> ?H404;A 2> kWBBX NI3 3D2> V4I81 N? V=40KF(0 96H3X 3D? L5- 2> ?OI68 34 k/BB l kGBB m kSBBa 3D63 2>X 3D? 34368 768I? 493D? !068 K441> E=41IH?1 ^N=?61 601 7?K?36N8?>_F )D? 768I? 49 3D? 203?=;?1263?K441> 2> ?TH8I1?1 9=4; 3D2> H68HI863240 N?H6I>? 3D?2= 768I? 2> 68=?61A ?;N?11?120 3D? 768I? 49 3D? !068 K441>F )D63 2>X VD?0 A4I E6A k/FBB 94= 6 NI018? 49

/

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

11/247

H6==43> 63 3D? >IE?=;6=M?3X kGFWB =?E=?>?03> 3D? 768I? 49 3D? 9?=3282R?= 3D63 V6>I>?1 34 K=4V 3D?>? H6==43>F

)D? ?T6;E8? 6N47? >IKK?>3> 60 683?=06327? ^NI3 ?OI2768?03_ 1?!023240 49L5-F 5?!0? D#94&S#33&3 6> 3D? 768I? 49 6 K441 4= >?=72H? 0?3 49 3D? H4>3 4960A 203?=;?1263? 20EI3> I>?1 34 E=41IH? 23F )D?0 40? H60 1?!0? 3D? L5- 6>3D? 34368 768I?1J611?1F (0 3D? H403?T3 49 3D? ?T6;E8? 6N47?X V? D67? kGWB 499?=3282R?= 601 kWB 49"4I= ^N43D 49 VD2HD I>? 04 203?=;?1263? 20EI3>_X 34K?3D?=V23D 3D? 768I? 611?1 20 3D? E=41IH3240 49 7?K?36N8?> ^kWB_ 601 N=?61 ^kWB_a 3D?>I; 49 VD2HD 2> kSBBF

!4720K 6840KX 4N>?=7? 3D63 3D? 1?!023240 6N47? ;6M?> =?9?=?0H? 34 3D? 3,S/&-%01 E=41IH3F )D? 14;?>32H E=41IH3 2> 34 N? 12>320KI2>D?1 9=4; 3D? 7#%0,7#9E=41IH3a 43D?=V2>? M04V0 6> 3D? +',-- T#%0,7#9 2',341% ^L'-_F )D? 129J9?=?0H? 2> 6> 94884V>F )D? L5- ;?6>I=?> 3D? 768I? 49 4I3EI3 E=41IH?1 V23D203D? N4=1?=> 49 6 14;?>32H ?H404;AX VD?3D?= 4= 043 3D2> E=41IH3240 36M?> E86H?

V23D 94=?2K0J4V0?1 96H34=> 49 E=41IH3240F )D? L'-X 40 3D? 43D?= D601X ;?6J>I=?> 3D? 768I? 49 4I3EI3 E=41IH?1 NA 3D? 96H34=> 49 E=41IH3240 4V0?1 NA 3D?hH232R?0>d 49 6 14;?>32H ?H404;AX VD?3D?= 4= 043 3D?>? 96H34=> 49 E=41IH3240 =?J>21? 40 14;?>32H >428 4= 043F 82M? #60616 601 3D? @023?1 :363?>X3D? 12?=?0H? N?3V??0 L5- 601 L'- 2> =?86327?8A >;688F 82M?)I=M?A 601 !?T2H4X 40 3D? 43D?= D601]V23D ;60A H232R?0> 82720K 601 V4=M20K6N=461]3D? 12>H=?E60HA N?3V??0 L5- 601 L'- H60 N? >2K02!H603F

21?= 3D? 3?=; E',-- 20 3D? 1?!023240 49 L5-F *?=?X 3D? K=4>>14;?>32H E=41IH3 2> 34 N? 12>320KI2>D?1 9=4; 3D? 7&% 14;?>32H E=41IH3 ^'5-_F)D? '5- 2> 1?!0?1 6> 3D? 345 (," 01 .$"#6 &0(%7-."$0(F !#$0%#9 1,7S-4/$%0,7>2;E8A =?9?=> 34 3D? 768I? 49 H6E2368 3D63 2> H40>I;?1 ^2F?FX 1?>3=4A?14= 1?E=?H263?1_ 20 3D? 6H3 49 E=41IH3240F

" H6>? H4I81 N? ;61? 3D63 3D? '5- 2> 6 N?33?= ;?6>I=? 49 6H3I68 E=41IH3240F3=IH3240 V4=M?=> 1?>3=4A k/BXBBB V4=3D 49 ?OI2E;?03 203D? E=4H?>> 49 NI28120K 6 kGBBXBBB D4I>?X ;4>3 E?4E8? V4I81 E=4N6N8A 6K=??3D63 kCBXBBB H40>323I3?> 6 N?33?= ;?6>I=? 49 3D? 768I? 611?1 34 3D? ?H404;AF&072=40;?03682>3> 6=? E6=32HI86=8A 9401 49 60 '5- ;?6>I=? ;412!?1 34 20H8I1?h?072=40;?0368 1?K=6163240d 601 h=?>4I=H? 1?E8?3240d 6> H4;E40?03> 49 H6E23681?E=?H263240F

8>&'10-& (L() #40>21?= 3D? ?T6;E8? 6N47?X 49 60 ?H404;A 3D63 E=41IH?> k/BB 207?K?36N8?>X kGWB 20 9?=3282R?=X kGBB 20 N=?61X 601 kWB 20 "4I= 47?= 3D? H4I=>?

49 40? A?6=F "> N?94=?X 6>>I;? 3D63 3D? ?032=? 6;4I03 49 9?=3282R?= 601 "4I=

2> H40>I;?1 20 3D? E=4H?>> 49 E=41IH20K 7?K?36N8?> 601 N=?61F PI3 2;6K20?

04V 3D63 3D? 9?=3282R?= 601 "4I= V?=? 043 E=41IH?1 3D2> A?6=a 3D63 2>X >IEE4>?3D63 3D?A V?=? E=41IH?1 86>3 A?6= 601 N=4IKD3 47?= 2034 3D2> A?6= 6> 207?034=A

^H6E2368_F 54?> 3D? 9?=3282R?= 601 "4I= 20 3D2> ?T6;E8? !3 3D? 1?!023240 49 60

203?=;?1263? K441g #4;EI3? 3D? L5- 601 '5- 94= 3D2> ?H404;AF

S

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

12/247

SF #40>I;E3240 7>F (07?>3;?03

#40>21?= 688 3D? ;288240> 49 K441> 601 >?=72H?> E=41IH?1 20 60 ?H404;A 47?=3D? H4I=>? 49 >4;? 32;? 203?=768F &H404;2>3> D67? 94I01 23 I>?9I8 34 12721?3D2> 76>3 601 D?3?=4K?0?4I> "4V 49 4I3EI3 2034 3V4 H63?K4=2?>` 1,7-4/$%0,7K441> ^601 >?=72H?>_a 601 07D&-%/&7% K441> ^601 >?=72H?>_F QD63 6=? 3D?12>320KI2>D20K HD6=6H3?=2>32H> 49 3D?>? 3V4 3AE?> 49 4I3EI3 601 VDA 2> 23 I>?9I834 ;6M? >IHD 6 12>320H3240g

#40>I;E3240 =?E=?>?03> 3D63 E6=3 49 3D? 4I3EI3 "4V 3D63 2> H40>I;?1 ^2F?FX1?>3=4A?1_ 94= 3D? EI=E4>? 49 6IK;?0320K 14''&7% ;63?=268 82720K >36016=1>FPA hHI==?03Xd ( ;?60 47?= 3D? H4I=>? 49 6 K27?0 32;?J203?=768X 82M? 40? ;403D 4=40? A?6=F (07?>3;?03 =?E=?>?03> 3D63 E6=3 49 3D? 4I3EI3 "4V 3D63 2> 1?>320?134 6IK;?03 3D? M4%4'& E=41IH3240 49 4I3EI3 ^601 I832;63?8AX 9I3I=? ;63?=26882720K >36016=1>_F (07?>3;?03 2> >4;?32;?> 68>4 =?9?==?1 34 6> 3D? E=41IH3240

49 7&J H6E2368 K441> 601 >?=72H?>F '43? 3D63 0?V H6E2368 K441> 6=? 34 N?12>320KI2>D?1 9=4; ,93 H6E2368 K441>]4=X 3D? -%,1U 49 ?T2>320K H6E2368]VD2HD2> E=?>I;6N8A ?;E84A?1 20 3D? E=41IH3240 49 HI==?03 4I3EI3 ^6840K V23D 43D?=96H34=> 49 E=41IH3240_F

!,7-4/$%0,7) )D63 N=60HD 49 3D? 4I3EI3 "4V 3D63 2> H40>I;?1 ^1?>3=4A?1_94= 3D? EI=E4>? 49 6IK;?0320K HI==?03 ;63?=268 82720K >36016=1>F

%0? >D4I81 M??E 20 ;201 3D63 3D? 12>320H3240 N?3V??0 H40>I;E3240 601207?>3;?03 2> 043 68V6A> >4 H8?6=JHI3a 601 20 E6=32HI86=X 3D? 12>320H3240 ;6A1?E?01 40 3D? 32;?J203?=768 I01?= H40>21?=63240F :IEE4>?X 94= ?T6;E8?X 3D63 (

D2=? 3D? M21 0?T3 144= 34 ;4V ;A 86V0 40? >I00A 693?=0440F )D? M21d> 86N4=^34K?3D?= V23D D2> 86V0;4V?= H6E2368_ 2> I>?1 34 E=41IH? h86V0J?0D60H?;?03>?=72H?>Fd ( E6A 3D? M21 kGB 601 8?3 D2; D67? 6 >2E 49 ;A N??= ^VD?0 D2> ;43D?=2>0d3 844M20K_F '4VX 3D2> kGB 20 86V0J?0D60H?;?03 >?=72H?>]14?> 23 H40>323I3?4I3EI3 20 3D? 94=; 49 H40>I;E3240 4= 207?>3;?03g

)D? 60>V?= 1?E?01> 40 3D? 32;?J203?=768 I01?= H40>21?=63240F (;6K20? 3D633D? N?0?!3 ( 1?=27? 9=4; 3D? 9=?>D8AJHI3 86V0 86>3> 94= 40? V??M ^3D? 86V0 0??1>34 N? ;4V?1 6K620 693?= 3D2> E?=241 49 32;?_F (9 3D? 32;?J203?=768 I01?= H40>21J?=63240 2> 40? 16AX 3D?0 40? H4I81 V?88 6=KI? 3D63 3D? 86V0J?0D60H?;?03 >?=72H?H40>323I3?1 6 94=; 49 207?>3;?03 3D63 K?0?=63?1 6 "4V 49 H40>I;E3240 94= >?7?=68E?=241> ^2F?FX 16A>_F %0 3D? 43D?= D601X 29 3D? 32;?J203?=768 I01?= H40>21?=632402> 40? V??M ^4= ;4=?_X 3D?0 40? ;2KD3 6=KI? 3D63 3D? 86V0J?0D60H?;?03 >?=J72H? >2;E8A H40>323I3?1 H40>I;E3240 ^6> 3D? 4I3EI3 1?E=?H263?> 9I88A 693?= 40?

V??M_F

)DI>X 40? V6A 34 12>320KI2>D 34 N?3V??0 H40>I;E3240 601 207?>3;?03 2>34 !T 3D? 32;?J203?=768 I01?= H40>21?=63240 601 6>M VD?3D?= 0?V8AJE=41IH?14I3EI3 2> ?TE?H3?1 34 86>3 840K?= 3D60 3D2> 32;? 203?=768F (9 3D? 60>V?= 2> 04X3D?0 3D? 4I3EI3 H40>323I3?> H40>I;E3240F (9 3D? 60>V?= 2> A?>X 3D?0 3D? 4I3EI3

U

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

13/247

H40>323I3?> 6 94=; 49 207?>3;?03 3D63 6IK;?03> 3D? >34HM 49 ?T2>320K H6E2368^V23D H6E2368 K?0?=6320K 6 "4V 49 9I3I=? >?=72H?>_F

H7D&-%/&7%) )D63 N=60HD 49 3D? 4I3EI3 "4V 3D63 6IK;?03> 3D??T2>320K >34HM 49 H6E2368F

)D? ;4>3 H4;;40 32;?J203?=768> I>?1 20 ;6H=4?H404;2H 6068A>2> 6=? 40?OI6=3?= ^S ;403D>_ 601 40? A?6=F Q23D 3D?>? 32;?J203?=768>X 6 86=K? H86>> 49K441> 601 >?=72H?> H60 N? H8?6=8A H63?K4=2R?1 6> ?23D?= H40>I;E3240 4= 207?>3J;?03F )D? H40>3=IH3240 49 6 0?V D4I>?X 6 0?V E2?H? 49 ;6HD20?=AX 6 0?V H6=X 94=?T6;E8?X V4I81 >??; 34 H40>323I3? 0?V H6E2368 K441> ^61123240> 34 3D? ?T2>320K>34HM 49 H6E2368_F )D? >6;? H4I81 N? >621 49 ;60A ;?12H68 E=4H?1I=?> ^9=4;D?=026 4E?=63240> 34 N=?6>3 2;E8603>_ 601 ?1IH63240 >?=72H?> ^34 3D? ?T3?03 3D63>3I1?03> H60 N? ?TE?H3?1 34 D481 40 34 VD63 3D?A D67? 8?6=0?1 N?A401 3D? !068

?T6;_F (0 H403=6>3X 3D? E=41IH3240 49 E?=2>D6N8? 9441 E=41IH3>X 3=60>E4=363240>?=72H?>X D62=HI3>X >D?83?= >?=72H?>X ?3HFX V4I81 >??; 34 H40>323I3? H40>I;E3240F*4V?7?=X 3D?=? =?;620 43D?= 94=;> 49 4I3EI3 3D63 6=? 043 >4 ?6>28A H86>>2!?1a94= 3D?>? 4Ne?H3>X 6 eI1K?;?03 H688 ;I>3 N? ;61?F

(3 2> 2;E4=3603 34 M??E 20 ;201 3D63 3D? 3?=; h207?>3;?03d 6> 23 2> I>?1D?=? 12?=> 9=4; 3D? V6A 23 2> H4;;408A I>?1 20 ?7?=A16A 860KI6K?F (;6K20?X94= ?T6;E8?X 3D63 A4I 6=? HI==?038A 82720K 20 6 =?03?1 6E6=3;?03 NI3 1?H21? 34EI=HD6>? 6 D4;?F !4>3 E?4E8? V4I81 =?K6=1 3D2> EI=HD6>? 6> 60 h207?>3;?03d20 =?68 ?>363?F PI3 VD?3D?= 3D2> EI=HD6>? 2> H4I03?1 6> 207?>3;?03 20 3D? (&"1?E?01> 40 VD?3D?= 3D? D4;? A4I EI=HD6>?1 2> 60 481 D4;? 4= 6 0?V D4;?F"0 481 D4;? 2> H40>21?=?1 34 N? E6=3 49 3D? ?T2>320K ^=?>21?03268_ H6E2368 >34HMF)D? EI=HD6>? 49 60 481 D4;? >2;E8A =?E=?>?03> 6 HD60K? 49 4V0?=>D2E 20 3D??T2>320K >34HM 49 H6E2368 601 D?0H? 2> 043 H4I03?1 6> 207?>3;?03 94= 3D? ?H404;A

6> 6 VD48?F " 0?V D4;?X 40 3D? 43D?= D601X =?E=?>?03> 6 0?V 61123240 34 3D??T2>320K >34HM 49 =?>21?03268 H6E2368a 6 0?V D4;? 2> H4I03?1 6> 207?>3;?03 94=3D? ?H404;A 6> 6 VD48?F

8+, 9:; ),!($"$0( 01 $( )$,/% 1/0-"+, *#> .,0.6, &0--0(6> 7(),/%"#() "+, ",/-?

QDA 2> 3D? 12>320H3240 N?3V??0 H40>I;E3240 601 207?>3;?03 2;E4=3603g)D2> 12>320H3240 2> 2;E4=3603 N?H6I>? 3D? ;600?= 20 VD2HD 60 ?H404;A 12721?>

23> 4I3EI3 "4V 6H=4>> H40>I;E3240 601 207?>3;?03 I832;63?8A 1?3?=;20?> 3D?h840KJ=I0d 82720K >36016=1> 49 23> 20D6N23603>F #40>21?=X 94= ?T6;E8?X 60 ?H40J4;A H40>2>320K 49 96=;?=> E=41IH20K E?=2>D6N8? 9441 E=41IH3> A?6= 693?= A?6= 63>4;? K27?0 8?7?8F )D2> 8?7?8 49 E=41IH3240 1?3?=;20?> 82720K >36016=1> 04V 60142034 3D? 201?!023? 9I3I=?F :IEE4>? 04V 3D63 >4;? 49 3D?>? 96=;?=> N?H4;?H40>3=IH3240 V4=M?=> ?;E84A?1 20 3D? E=41IH3240 49 K=??0D4I>?> 601 2==2K63240

W

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

14/247

>A>3?;>F )D2> 127?=>240 49 86N4= 0?H?>>6=28A ?03628> 6 3?;E4=6=A 1?H820? 20 9441E=41IH3240 ^601 D?0H? HI==?03 82720K >36016=1>_ 6> 3D? 0?V H6E2368 3D63 2> H40J

>3=IH3?1 36M?> 32;? 34 N? E=41IH327?F PI3 20 3D? h840KJ=I0Xd 3D? 0?V H6E2368 D6>3D? ??H3 49 ?0D60H20K 6K=2HI83I=68 4I3EI3 601 D?0H? 9I3I=? 82720K >36016=1>N?A401 3D? 2023268 8?7?8F (0 3D2> V6AX 207?>3;?03 ?03628> 6 >6H=2!H? 49 HI==?03H40>I;E3240 20 ?THD60K? 94= D2KD?= 8?7?8> 49 9I3I=? H40>I;E3240F

%0 3D? #40H?E3 601 !?6>I=?;?03 49 #6E2368

)D? 3?=; 1#$0%#9 6EE?6=> 34 ;?60 12?=?03 3D20K> 34 12?=?03 E?4E8?F )460 ?H404;2>3X H6E2368 =?9?=> 34 6 34'#N9& 96H34= 49 E=41IH3240 601 07D&7%,':F(3 14?> 043X 20 E6=32HI86=X =?9?= 34 !060H268 6>>?3>X VD2HD >2;E8A =?E=?>?03 H862;>34 9I3I=? 4Ne?H3>F

)D? ;4>3 4N724I> 94=; 49 H6E2368 2> VD63 2> H688?1 $":-01#9 1#$0%#9F &TJ6;E8?> 49 EDA>2H68 H6E2368 20H8I1? 4Ne?H3> 82M? ;6HD20?=AX H4;EI3?=>X NI28120K>X8601X 6I34;4N28?>X D2KDV6A>X >?V6K? >A>3?;>X 601 207?034=2?> 49 K441>F &7?0EDA>2H68 4Ne?H3> >IHD 6> 3D?>? 6=? 12HI83 34 ;?6>I=?F I=20K 3D? >34HM 49 =?>21?03268 H6E2368X 2> 23 6EE=4E=263? 34 H4I03 3D? 0I;N?= 49D4I>?> 601 6E6=3;?03>X 4= 3D? >OI6=? 94436K? 49 82720K >E6H?g "01 2> 6 SBBB>OI6=? 9443 D4;? ;61? 49 N=2HM 3D? >6;? 3D20K 6> 6 SBBB >OI6=? 9443 D4;?;61? 4I3 49 =2H? E6E?=g 40? 611 34K?3D?= 6 D4I>? 6016 E=20320K E=?>> 34 6==27? 63 60 6KK=?K63? ;?6>I=? 49 EDA>2H68 H6E2368g

(0 E=20H2E8?X E?=D6E> 3D? 408A V6A 34 ;?6>I=? H6E2368 H40>2>3?038A 2> NA;6=M?3 768I?F (0 3D2> V6AX V? H4I81 >6A 3D63 6 N=2HM D4;? 768I?1 63 kUBBXBBB601 6 E=20320K E=?>> 768I?1 63 kGBBXBBB 34K?3D?= ;6M? IE kWBBXBBB V4=3D 49H6E2368F )D? hE=4N8?;d V23D 3D2> 6EE=46HD 2> 3D63 3D? 768I? 49 H6E2368 ;6A 76=A

?7?0 V23D4I3 60A HD60K? 20 23> EDA>2H68 OI60323AF %0 3D? 43D?= D601X E?=D6E>23 ;6M?> >?0>? 34 3D20M 49 ;4=? 768I6N8? H6E2368 6> H40>323I320K ;4=? h??H327?dH6E2368F/

(0 E=6H32H?X 23 6EE?6=> 3D63 3D? 6KK=?K63? >34HM 49 EDA>2H68 H6E2368 2> ;?6J>I=?1 I>20K 6 hE?=E?3I68 207?034=A ;?3D41Fd )D? V6A 3D2> 2> 140? 2> 34 36M?3D? 207?>3;?03 "4V ^;?6>I=?1 63 ;6=M?3 768I?_ 20 ?6HD 49 76=24I> 6>>?3 H86>>?>X6EE8A20K 6 H40>3603 1?E=?H263240 =63? ^3D63 76=2?> V23D 6>>?3 H86>>_ 601 3D?061120K 3D? =?>I83> 6H=4>> 207?>3;?03 A?6=> 601 6>>?3 H86>>?>F " ;6e4= E=4N8?;V23D 3D2> ;?3D41 2> 3D63 23 768I?> 3D? ?T2>320K H6E2368 >34HM 63 N,,U D#94&^D2>34=2H68 ;6=M?3 768I? 49 E6>3 207?>3;?03_ 20>3?61 49 HI==?03 ;6=M?3 768I?F-=?>I;6N8AX 3D2> 2> 140? N?H6I>? 23 2> 12HI83 34 6>H?=3620 3D? HI==?03 ;6=M?3768I? 49 688 94=;> 49 H6E2368F

@094=3I063?8AX 3D? ;?6>I=?;?03 49 H6E2368 E=4N8?; 2> 20 96H3 ;IHD V4=>?3D60 3D2>F )D? =?6>40 94= 3D2> 82?> 20 3D? 96H3 3D63 EDA>2H68 H6E2368 2> 043 3D?408A]4= ?7?0 ;4>3 2;E4=3603]94=; 49 H6E2368 20 60 ?H404;AF %0? H4I81 =?6>40

/ :??X 94= ?T6;E8?` P86HMX HD?= ^G\\W_X:@.60/$(= 3 ,(,/#6 :A7$6$B/$7-X )D? !() -=?>>X.40140X &0K8601 ^EEF SG]SU_F

Y

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

15/247

NA 60684KA 3D63 ?7?=A DI;60 N?20K 2> 6 M201 49 1I=6N8? ;6HD20?F (0 6 7?=A =?68>?0>?X ?6HD E?=>40 H60 N? 3D4IKD3 49 6> 60 4V0?=J4E?=634= 49 "4/#7 1#$0%#9

3D63 K?0?=63?> 6 ^E43?03268_ >3=?6; 49 86N4= >?=72H?> 47?= 32;?F

.2M? 6 ;6HD20? 4= 6 D4I>?X V? 0??1 34 N? ;6203620?1 601 ^63 32;?>_ =?JE62=?1F (0 3D? (&"X ;6203?060H? 601 =?E62= 2> H40>21?=?1 6 94=; 49 207?>3;?03F(0 H403=6>3X 688 E?=>4068 ?TE?0123I=?> 40 9441X H843D20KX >D?83?= 601 ;?12H68 >?=J72H?> 6=? 3=?63?1 6> H40>I;E3240F 54?> 3D2> ;6M? >?0>?g )D2> 2> 34 >6A 043D20K6N4I3 3D? 207?>3;?03> 3D63 E?4E8? ;6M? 34 2;E=47? 3D?2= >M288 ^6K620X ?1IH632402> 3=?63?1 6> 6 94=; 49 H40>I;E3240 20>3?61 49 207?>3;?03_X 4= 3D? 207?>3;?03>3D63 E6=?03> ;6M? 20 =62>20K 3D?2= HD281=?0F

QD63 2> 3D? 768I? 49 DI;60 H6E2368g (0 3D?4=AX 3D? ;6=M?3 768I? 49 6 E?=>40d>DI;60 H6E2368 2> 3D? E=?>?03 768I? 49 40?d> 829?32;? V6K? >3=?6; 0?3 49 3D?E=?>?03 768I? 49 60A 12=?H3 207?>3;?03> 20 DI;60 H6E2368 ^3D? >6;? E=20H2E8?D481> 94= 3D? 768I63240 49 60A 94=; 49 H6E2368_F (0 E=6H32H?X 12=?H3 H862;> 40

DI;60 H6E2368 6=? =6=?8A ?THD60K?1 20 ;6=M?3>X ;6M20K 3D? 768I? 49 DI;60H6E2368 ;4=? 12HI83 ^NI3 043 2;E4>>2N8?_ 34 ?>32;63?F

"043D?= 2;E4=3603 94=; 49 h20360K2N8?d H6E2368 ?T2>3> 20 3D? 94=; 49 ^12>?;JN412?1_ %&1"7,9,E:F )D? ;412!?= h12>?;N412?1d D?=? 2> I>?1 20 =?9?=?0H? 34hM04V8?1K?d 4= h3?HD0484K2H68 M04VJD4Vd 3D63 ?T2>3> >?E6=63?8A 9=4; VD63 ;6AN? ?;N412?1 20 ?23D?= EDA>2H68 4= DI;60 H6E2368F :4;? ?T6;E8?> 3D63 H4;? 34;201 D?=? ;6A 20H8I1? 3D20K> 82M? h4=K602R6324068 H6E2368d ^3D? V6A E=41IH32406H327232?> 601 12>3=2NI3240 0?3V4=M> 6=? 4=K602R?1X 4= 43D?= hN?>3JE=6H32H?d 3?HDJ02OI?>_X 4= ?7?0 3D? 203=41IH3240 49 0?V E=41IH3> ^?FKFX 3D? >I11?0 676286N2823A49 H4;EI3?=> 2> 043 3D? >6;? 3D20K 6> D6720K ;4=? 96H34=A >E6H?_F

"> A4I ;6A D67? KI?>>?1X 3D? 768I? 49 3D?>? h20360K2N8?d 4Ne?H3> 2> 493?012HI83 34 ;?6>I=?F '?7?=3D?8?>>X 3D2> 14?> 043 12;202>D 3D?2= E43?03268 2;JE4=360H?F H60 601 14 >E?01 >2K02!H603 =?>4I=H?> 34V6=1 h!KI=20K 3D20K>4I3Fd )D? ;4>3 4N724I> ?T6;E8? 2> $,5 ?TE?0123I=?F $,5 >E?0120K 2> H8?6=8A6 94=; 49 207?>3;?03X ?7?0 29 3D? 768I? 49 VD63 2> E=41IH?1 NA >IHD >E?0120K2> 12HI83 34 ;?6>I=?F PI3 94= >4;? >3=60K? =?6>40X $,5 >E?0120K ^601 43D?=94=;> 49 207?>3;?03 20 h20360K2N8?d H6E2368_ 2> 043 H4I03?1 6> 207?>3;?03 20 3D?(&"F (3 2>X D4V?7?=X H4I03?1 6> E6=3 49 3D? L5-F (;E82H238A 3D?0X $,5 >E?0120K2> H4I03?1 6> 94=; 49 H40>I;E3240F

)D? IE>D43 49 688 3D2> 2> 3D63 3D? (&" ?>>?032688A 2K04=?> DI;60 601 20360JK2N8? H6E2368X >4 3D63 H6=? ;I>3 N? ?T?=H2>?1 20 203?=E=?320K 3D? ;?6>I=?1 >34HM49 H6E2368 6> 3D? 3=I? >34HM 49 E=41IH327? H6E2368F .2M?V2>?X 40? ;I>3 N? H6=?9I820 203?=E=?320K ;?6>I=?1 207?>3;?03 6> =?"?H320K 3D? 3=I? 8?7?8 49 207?>3;?03 2060 ?H404;A ^?FKFX >??

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

16/247

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

17/247

UF *4V 3D? L5- 2> #68HI863?1

!"#"$%"$&% #/, # 60" 6$C, %#7%#=,%D B0"+ #/, B,%",(E0>,) *+,( 0(, )0,% (0" %,, +0* "+,> #/, -#),?

"> 3D? >40 49 (368260 2;;2K=603>X ( D67? D61 3D? E8?6>I=? 49 E6=32H2E6320K 203D? E=4H?>> 49 >6I>6K?J;6M20K 9=4; 3D? K=4I01 IE ^20H8I120K 3D? 2023268 >86IKDJ3?=_F P?82?7? ;?X 3D2> 2> 60 ?TE?=2?0H? A4I H60 1?!023?8A 64=1 34 ;2>> ^( D67?0?7?= 844M?1 63 ;A N=?6M96>3 >6I>6K? 20 OI23? 3D? >6;? V6A ?7?= >20H?_F "01VD28? ( D67? 0?7?= V4=M?1 63 6 >3632>32H68 6K?0HAX ( D67? 9=2?01> VD4 D67?F 3632>32H>d ;IHD 20 3D? >6;? V6A (72?V ;A N=?6M96>3 >6I>6K?F

)D? (&" =?E4=3 3V4 ;?6>I=?> 49 L5-X N43D 49 VD2HD >D4I81 611 IE 343D? >6;? 0I;N?= 20 3D?4=A ^NI3 20 E=6H32H? 12?= NA 6 =?86327?8A >;688 0I;N?=H688?1 6 h>3632>32H68 12>H=?E60HAd_F )D?>? 3V4 ;?6>I=?> 6=? N6>?1 40 3V4 12?=?036EE=46HD?>` 60 20H4;? 6EE=46HDX 601 60 ?TE?0123I=? 6EE=46HDF P?84VX ( 12>HI>>?6HD 6EE=46HD 20 3I=0F

)D? &TE?0123I=? "EE=46HD

)D? ?TE?0123I=? 6EE=46HD 34 H4;EI320K 3D? L5- =?82?> 40 3D? 94884V20K96H3` :"+$(= "+#" $% ./0)7&,) -7%" #6%0 B, .7/&+#%,)F "3 !=>3 N8I>DX 3D2>;2KD3 >??; 82M? 6 >3=60K? 3D20K 34 6>>?=3F QD63 29X 94= ?T6;E8?X 6 ;60I96H3I=?=E=41IH?> 60 6I34;4N28? 3D63 2> 043 1?827?=?1 34 6 1?68?=g (0 3D2> H6>?X 3D? 0?V8AE=41IH?1 6I34;4N28? 2> 3=?63?1 6> 6 EI=HD6>? 4907D&7%,': NA 3D? ;60I96H3I=?=F)D? 768I? 49 3D2> 207?034=A 207?>3;?03 2> N6>?1 40 3D? /#'U&% $'01&49 3D?6I34;4N28? ^2F?FX 3D? ;6=M?3 768I? 49 >2;286= 6I34;4N28?> 3D63 6=? >481 40 3D?;6=M?3_F

)DI>X 3D? &>$&730%4'& #$$',#1" H68HI863?> L5- 6> "+, "0"#6 %.,()$(=0( #66 )0-,%"$B>2./0)7&,) !(#6 =00)% #() %,/ ;600?= 2> >4;?32;?> =?9?==?1 34 6> 3D? +',-- .,/&-%01 8>$&730%4'&^L5&_F !63D?;632H688AX 3D2> 2> 140? 6> 94884V>F .?3 1?043? 3D? OI60323A 49K441 ^4= >?=72H?_ 3D63 2> >481 63 163? 63 ;6=M?3JE=2H? )D?0 3D? 768I?49 3D2> ?TE?0123I=? ^;?6>I=?1 20 14886=>_ 2> >2;E8A (9 3D?=? 6=? >IHDK441> 601 >?=72H?>X 3D?0 3D? L5& 2> K27?0 NA`

!!"

^G_

"K620X 043? 3D63 ?TE?0123I=?> 40 203?=;?1263? K441> 601 >?=72H?> 6=? 043 20JH8I1?1 20 3D2> H68HI863240 ^VDA 043g_FS

S )D? 04363240 ;?60> 3D63 2 > ,A7$

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

18/247

"H3I688AX 3D2> 2> 043 OI23? D4V 23d> 140?F )D? V6A 23 2> 140? 20 E=6H32H? 2> 34!=>3 H4;EI3? 34368 >E?0120K 40 688 ^0?V8A E=41IH?1_ !068 K441> 601 >?=72H?>X

VD?3D?= 4= 043 3D?A 6=? 14;?>32H688A E=41IH?1F %9 H4I=>?X 3D2> !KI=? V28820H8I1? ?TE?0123I=?> 40 2;E4=3>X VD2HD 6=? K441> 601 >?=72H?> 3D63 6=? 043E=41IH?1 14;?>32H688AF )4 6==27? 63 3D? L5& 3D?0X 40? ;I>3 >IN3=6H3 9=4; 3D2>!KI=? 3D? 34368 768I? 49 688 2;E4=3?1 K441> 601 >?=72H?>F

.6=K?8A 6> 3D? =?>I83 49 60 D2>34=2H68 6HH21?03X 3D? 06324068 20H4;? 601 E=41JIH3 6HH4I03> 4=K602R? 3D? ?TE?0123I=? H4;E40?03> 49 3D? L5- 2034 94I= N=461H63?K4=2?> 3D63 1?E?01 40 3D? >?H34= 20 VD2HD 3D? ?TE?0123I=? 2> I01?=36M?0F)D2> H86>>2!H63240 2> >4;?VD63 6=N23=6=A 20 3D63 3D?=? 2> 04 I02OI? V6A 20 VD2HD34 1?!0? h>?H34=Fd '?7?=3D?8?>>X 3D? V6A 3D2> 2> 140? 20 E=6H32H? 2> 34 1?!0? 94I=>?H34=> 6> 94884V>` nGo 3D? ",4-&",93 -&1%,'a n/o 3D? N4-07&-- -&1%,'a nSo 3D?E,D&'7/&7% -&1%,'a 601 nUo 3D? M,'&0E7 -&1%,'F :4;?32;?>X nGo 601 n/o 6=?H4;N20?1 34 94=; 3D? 3,/&-%01 $'0D#%& -&1%,'F )D? K47?=0;?03 >?H34= 20J

H8I1?> 688 8?7?8> 49 K47?=0;?03 ^2F?FX 9?1?=68X E=4720H268X >363?X 84H68X ?3HF_F )D?94=?2K0 >?H34= 20H8I1?> N43D 94=?2K0 E=2763? 601 K47?=0;?03 6K?0H2?>F

*6720K 1?!0?1 >?H34=> 20 3D2> V6AX 8?3 1?043? D4I>?D481 >E?0120Ka 8?3 1?043? NI>20?>> >E?0120Ka 8?31?043? K47?=0;?03 >E?0120Ka 601 8?3 1?043?94=?2K0 >?H34= >E?0120K ^40 14;?>32H688AJE=41IH?1 K441> 601 >?=72H?>_F "> 3D?>E?0120K 40 601 20H8I1?> 2;E4=3>X V? D67? 34 >IN3=6H3 43D? 768I? 493D?>? 2;E4=3>34 H68HI863? >E?0120K 40 14;?>32H688AJE=41IH?1 4I3EI3F @>20K3D?>? ?TE?0123I=? H63?K4=2?>X 3D? L5& ;6A ?OI2768?038A N? H68HI863?1 6>`

! ! ! ^/_

:20H? 3D2> 2> E=4N6N8A 043 A4I= !=>3 ;6H=4 H86>>X A4Id7? 82M?8A >??0 >4;?3D20K

>2;286= 34 ^/_ N?94=?F (3 14?>0d3 OI23? 844M =2KD3 3D4IKDX 14?> 23g )D2> 2> N?H6I>??7?=A ;6H=4?H404;2H> 3?T3N44M 20 ?T2>3?0H? ^3D63 ( 6; 6V6=? 49_ I>?> >82KD38A12?=?03 04363240a 601 20>3?61 V=23?> ^/_ 20 3D? 94884V20K V6A`

! ! ! ^S_

%N724I>8AX ^/_ 601 ^S_ 6=? ?OI2768?03 29 V? 1?!0? 601 )D?=?2> 043D20K V=40K 20 I>20K VD63?7?= 04363240 V? V2>DX 6> 840K 6> 3D? 0436324014?> 043 1?3=6H3 9=4; H8?6= 3D20M20KF

@094=3I063?8AX 3D? V21?8AJI>?1 04363240 20 ^S_ )0,%63 32;?> 6EE?6= 34 1?J3=6H3 9=4; H8?6= 3D20M20KF .?3 ;? ?TE8620F L?3 A4I= D601> 40 60A ;6H=4 3?T3HI==?038A 40 3D? ;6=M?3 601 "2E 34 3D? >?H3240 40 06324068 20H4;? 6HH4I0320KF'4V 844M 94= 3D? ?TE?0123I=? 21?0323A ^S_F (0 3D? 12>HI>>240 3D63 >I==4I01> 3D2>

21?0323AX A4I V288 2076=26N8A !01 >363?;?03> 6>>?=320K 3D63 1?043?> H40>I;EJ3240 ?TE?0123I=? 601 1?043?> 207?>3;?03 ?TE?0123I=?F )D?>? >363?;?03> 6=?;2>8?6120K ^6 E=41IH3 49 N61 04363240_ N?H6I>? 20 96H3 =?E=?>?03> D4I>?D481

3D2> 2> 043 3D? >6;? 6> >36320K ! )D? 8633?= 2> 60 ,A7#"$0(VD28? 3D? 94=;?= 2> 60 $),("$">F h>IEE8Ad 601 1?043?> h1?;601Xd 3D?0 23 2> 043 3=I? 3D63 *4V?7?=X 23 2> 3=I? 3D63 ! 63 6 ;6=M?3JH8?6=20K E=2H?F

GB

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

19/247

>?H34= >E?0120K 40 N43D H40>I;E3240 601 207?>3;?03 ^20 3D? 94=; 49 1I=6N8?>601 DI;60 H6E2368 207?>3;?03>_ 601 =?E=?>?03> 408A 40? H4;E40?03 49 20J

7?>3;?03 ^2F?FX ?6HD 49 601 68>4 20H8I1? ?TE?0123I=?> 40 207?>3;?03K441> 601 >?=72H?>_F

)6N8? GFG E=4721?> 3D? ?TE?0123I=? H4;E40?03> 49 L5- N6>?1 40 ^/_ 94=#60616F " 0I;N?= 49 4N>?=763240> 6=? 20 4=1?= D?=?F 3X 6> =?;6=M?1 ?6=82?=X043? 3D63 40? >D4I81 =?9=620 9=4; 203?=E=?320K 3D? >IN34368 6> H40>I;E3240F)D63 2>X 6 >2K02!H603 H4;E40?03 49 D4I>?D481 ?TE?0123I=?> 40 K441> 6=? 20 3D?94=; 49 1I=6N8? 601 >?;2J1I=6N8? K441>F > 3D63 6>2K02!H603 H4;E40?03 49 3D? EI=HD6>? 49 >?=72H?> 2> 68>4 20 3D? 94=; 49 207?>3J;?03 >?=72H?> ^N=4618A 1?!0?1_F :?H401X 6K620 6> =?;6=M?1 ?6=82?=X 043? 3D633D? (&" 408A 6EE?6=> 34 H4I03 NI>20?>> >?H34= >E?0120K 20 3D? 94=; 49 6112J3240> 34 EDA>2H68 H6E2368 ^601 043 60A 207?>3;?03> 20 20360K2N8? H6E2368_F )D2=1X043? 3D63 6 E4=3240 49 K47?=0;?03 EI=HD6>?> 2> 20 3D? 94=; 49 0?V H6E2368

K441>F (3 2> E=4N6N8A 3D? H6>?X D4V?7?=X 3D63 >4;? 49 3D? >E?0120K H63?K4=2R?16> hHI==?03d K441> 601 >?=72H?> ;2KD3 N? N?33?= 86N?88?1 6> 207?>3;?03F 40 ?TE4=3> K?0?=688A H40>2>3 49 N43D H40>I;E3240 601207?>3;?03 K441> 601 >?=72H?>F

)6N8? GFG L=4>> 54;?>32H -=41IH3` &TE?0123I=?JP6>?1#60616 /BBW ^;288240> 49 14886=>_

V,4-&",93 C&1%,'5I=6N8? 601 >?;2J1I=6N8? K441> GYUXCGW'40J1I=6N8? K441> GC\X/GS:?=72H?> UBZX\SU:IN34368"# A?(RF?5

Q4-07&-- C&1%,'$?>21?03268 >3=IH3I=?> C\XW\W'40J=?>21?03268 >3=IH3I=?> YSX\SC!6HD20?=A 601 ?OI2E;?03 \GXSWU(07?034=A 207?>3;?03 \XUY\:IN34368"# 5B@R;B?

+,D&'7/&7% C&1%,'#I==?03 K441> 601 >?=72H?> /Y/XSY\(07?>3;?03 SWXGWY:IN34368"# 5FARB5B

G,'&0E7 C&1%,'&TE4=3> 49 K441> UUSXUBG&TE4=3> 49 >?=72H?> YUXCWW

:IN34368"# B( #60616X #"':(! 36N8? SCBJBBGZF

GG

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

20/247

8>&'10-& (L5) #60 A4I 3D20M 49 60 ?T6;E8? 49 60 2012721I68 VD4 ;2KD3 N?840K34 ^2F?FX ;6M?> EI=HD6>?> 3D63 V4I81 N? =?"?H3?1 20_ ?6HD 49 3D? 94I= >?H34=>

1?>H=2N?1 20 )6N8? GFGg

)D? (0H4;? "EE=46HD

)D? 20H4;? 6EE=46HD 34 H4;EI320K 3D? L5- =?82?> 40 3D? 94884V20K 96H3`: .7/&+#%, 01 # =00) 0/ %,/ ;600?= 2> >4;?32;?> =?9?==?1 346> 3D? +',-- .,/&-%01 H71,/& ^L5(_F (0 E=20H2E8?X 3D2> H60 N? 140? 20 60A40? 49 6 0I;N?= 49 V6A>F

)D? ;4>3 4N724I> V6A 34 H68HI863? 6KK=?K63? 20H4;? V4I81 N? 34 1?!0? 602012721I68 ^4= D4I>?D481_ 6> 3D? N6>2H ?H404;2H I023F (0 K?0?=68X ?6HD 2012721I68

D6> ;I832E8? >4I=H?> 49 20H4;?X 20H8I120K 20H4;? 40 14;?>32H688AJ?;E84A?1 DIJ;60 H6E2368 ^V6K?>_X 20H4;? 40 14;?>32H688AJ?;E84A?1 H6E2368 ^12721?01>X=?3620?1 ?6=020K>X 203?=?>3 20H4;? 40 N401>_X 601 20H4;? 40 6>>?3> ?;E84A?1 203D? 94=?2K0 >?H34=X ^3D2> H4I81 20H8I1? V6K?> ?6=0?1 4I3>21? 49 3D? H4I03=A_F(0 3D? H4;EI363240 49 L5-X 3D2> 8633?= >4I=H? 49 20H4;? 2> 8?93 4I3 ^683D4IKDX23 2> 20H8I1?1 20 3D? ;?6>I=? 49 L'-_F )DI>X 29 3D?=? 6=? 14;?>32H =?>21?03>X40? H4I81 H4;EI3?`

!!"

"! # ^U_

'43? 3D63 36T?> 601 3=60>9?=> 34 601 9=4; 3D? K47?=0;?03 6=? 043 20H8I1?120 3D2> ;?6>I=?F QDA 2> 3D2>g .?3d> 3D20M 6N4I3 23F :IEE4>? 3D63 3D? K47?=0J

;?03 H488?H3> 36T?> 9=4; 2012721I68 '43? 3D63 3D2> 36T ;?6>I=? 20H8I1?>36T?> 9=4; 688 >4I=H?>X 20H8I120K >68?> 36T?>X E=4E?=3A 36T?>X 601 20H4;? 36T?>^20H8I120K H4=E4=63? 20H4;?X 63 8?6>3X 40 3D63 9=6H3240 49 3D? 14;?>32H NI>20?>>>?H34= 4V0?1 NA 14;?>32H =?>21?03>_F QD63 14?> 3D? K47?=0;?03 14 V23D 3D?>?36T?>g (3 I>?> 3D?; 34 E6A 3D? V6K?> 601 >686=2?> 49 K47?=0;?03 >?H34= ?;JE84A??>X VD2HD >D4V> IE 20 94= >4;? K47?=0;?03 V4=M?= (3 68>4 I>?> 3D?>?36T?> 34 ;6M? 3=60>9?=> 34 2012721I68> 20 3D? ?H404;AF '43? 3D63 3D?>? 3=60>9?=>14 043 H4I03 34V6=1 3D? L5- 6> 3D?A 14 043 H40>323I3? 60A E=41IH3240 49 0?VK441 4= >?=72H? ^3D?A >?=7? >2;E8A 34 =?12>3=2NI3? 4I3EI3 6H=4>> ;?;N?=> 49>4H2?3A_F '?7?=3D?8?>>X A4I >D4I81 M??E 3D? 94884V20K 20 ;201`

8+, 1#&" "+#" =0 "+#" =0

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

21/247

'63I=688AX 3D2> H4;;40J>?0>? V6A 49 =?E4=320K 20H4;? 2> 043 3D? V6A 3D?(&" 3AE2H688A 14?> 3D20K>F (0>3?61X 3D? (&" =?E4=3> 3D? N=?6M14V0 20 20H4;?

6HH4=120K 34 )6N8? GF/`

)6N8? GF/ L=4>> 54;?>32H -=41IH3` (0H4;?JP6>?1#60616 /BBW ^;288240> 49 14886=>_

Q6K?> 601 :686=2?> YZCX\/W#4=E4=63? -=4!3> N?94=? 36T_ G\SX\SYL47?=0;?03 PI>20?>> &03?=E=2>?> ^N?94=? 36T_ GSXSZB'?3 (03?=?>3 (0H4;? YGX/UB'?3 (0H4;? 96=;_ GXWWG'?3 (0H4;? ^I020H4=E4=63?1 96=;_ CUXYYY(07?034=A q68I63240 "1eI>3;?03 ]UU/

)6T?> 8?>> >IN>212?> 40 96H34=> 49 E=41IH3240 W\X\YGT.2 ^63 96H34= H4>3_ GXB\SX/BZ)6T?> 8?>> >IN>212?> 40 E=41IH3> \UXZWB#6E2368 #4>3 "884V60H? GCGXU/Z+',-- .,/&-%01 H71,/& (R;?FR;32H> #60616X #"':(! 36N8? SCBJBBBGF

"> A4I H60 >?? 9=4; )6N8? GF/X 23 2> >4;?VD63 H=AE32H ^043 34 ;?03240X 6;I>20K_F.?3d> 3=A 34 !KI=? 4I3 VD63d> K420K 40 D?=?F

3X ( 6; KI?>>20K 3D63 *#=,% #() %#6#/$,% =?9?=> 34 V6K? 20H4;? 0?3 4936T?>F )D? =?6>40 ( N?82?7? 3D2> 2> N?H6I>? 3D?=? 2> 68>4 6 H63?K4=A H688?1"#@,%6,%% %7B%$)$,% 0( 1#&"0/% 01 ./0)7&"$0(F -=?>I;6N8AX 96H34=> 49 E=41IH3240 D?=?=?9?=> 408A 34 DI;60 H6E2368X 6> ( 0432H? 3D63 3D? 20H4;? K?0?=63?1 NA 3D?

EDA>2H68 H6E2368 4V0?1 NA 3D? NI>20?>> 601 K47?=0;?03 >?H34=> 2> =?E4=3?1 4060 693?=J36T N6>2>F '43? 3D63 H4=E4=63? E=4!3> 20H8I1? ?6=020K> 3D63 6=? N43D=?3620?1 601 12>3=2NI3?1 6> 12721?01>X 601 2> 0?3 49 1?E=?H263240 H4>3> ^VD2HD 2>VDA 3D? H6E2368 H4>3 6884V60H? 2> 611?1 863?= 40_F

)D?=? 2> 60 2>>I? D?=? 6> 34 D4V 3D? 20H4;? 49 I020H4=E4=63?1 ^040J96=;_NI>20?>>?> 2> 3=?63?1F -=?>I;6N8AX 3D2> 2> eI>3 8I;E?1 20 V23D V6K?> 601 >686=2?>X683D4IKD E=4E?=8A >E?6M20KX 63 8?6>3 6 E6=3 49 3D2> >D4I81 6H3I688A N? =?H4=1?16> H6E2368 20H4;?F (3 2> =63D?= 6;I>20K 34 >?? 3D63 3D?=? 6=? >?E6=63? H63?K4=2?>94= 3D? 96=; >?H34= ^VDAg_F -=?>I;6N8AX 3D? 0?3 20H4;? 9=4; 96=;> =?E=?>?03>H6E2368 20H4;?F *4V?7?=X 3D? 0?3 20H4;? 49 I020H4=E4=63?1 96=;> 20H8I1?> N43DV6K? 20H4;? 601 H6E2368 20H4;? ^04 633?;E3 2> ;61? 34 >?E6=63? 4I3 3D?>?H4;E40?03>_F

)D? '5- =?E=?>?03> 3D? 0?3 ^49 1?E=?H263240_ 14;?>32H E=41IH3240F "31#&"0/&0%";?60> 3D63 3D? 20H4;?> V?=? H68HI863?1 0?3 49 h2012=?H3d 36T?> ^82M? >68?>36T?>_F )DI>X 34 H4;EI3? 3D? L5-X N43D H6E2368 H40>I;E3240 601 2012=?H3 36T?>;I>3 N? 611?1 34 3D? '5- !KI=?F

)D? (0H4;?J&TE?0123I=? (1?0323A

GS

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

22/247

:4 96=X V? D67? ?>36N82>D?1 3D63 601 ? 3V4 ?OI2768?0H? =?863240>X 23 94884V> 3D63 (0 43D?= V4=1>X 6KJ

K=?K63? ?TE?0123I=? 2> ?OI2768?03 34 6KK=?K63? 20H4;?X ?6HD 49 VD2HD 6=? ?OI27J68?03 34 3D? 768I? 49 6KK=?K63? E=41IH3240F "K620X 3D? V6A 34 I01?=>3601 VDA3D2> ;I>3 N? 3=I? 2> 6> 94884V>F 3X 60A 4I3EI3 3D63 2> E=41IH?1 ;I>3 68>4 N?EI=HD6>?1 ^61123240> 34 207?034=A 6=? 3=?63?1 EI=HD6>?> 49 0?V H6E2368 K441>X4= 207?>3;?03 >E?0120K_F *?0H? 3D? 768I? 49 E=41IH3240 ;I>3 ^NA 1?!023240_ N??OI68 34 3D? 768I? 49 >E?0120KF :?H401X >20H? >E?0120K NA 40? 2012721I68 H40J>323I3?> 20H4;? 94= >4;?40? ?8>?X 34368 >E?0120K ;I>3 ^NA 1?!023240_ N? ?OI6834 34368 20H4;?F

)D? 21?0323A 2> >4;?32;?> =?9?==?1 34 6> 3D?$(&0-,2,@.,()$"7/,$),("$">F .?3320K 1?043? 3D? L5(X ;4>3 203=41IH34=A ;6H=4?H404;2H 3?T3JN44M> ?TE=?>> 3D? 20H4;?J?TE?0123I=? 21?0323A 20 3D? 94884V20K V6A`

! ! ! ^W_

'43? 3D63 >20H? 3D? 20H4;?J?TE?0123I=? 21?0323A 2> 60 21?0323AX 23 #6*#>%D481> 3=I?F " 063I=68 20H82063240 2> 34 >IEE4>? 3D63 >20H? 3D? 21?0323A 2> 68V6A>3=I?X 40? H60 I>? 23 34 ;6M? "+,0/,"$ 4= ./,)$&"$363?;?03>F ??;> 34 >IKK?>3 3D63 60 ?TE60>2406=A !>H68 E482HA ^60 20H=?6>? 20#;I>3 0?H?>>6=28A =?>I83 20 60 20H=?6>? 20 L5- ^60 20H=?6>? 20#(0 96H3X"+,$(&0-,2,@.,()$"7/, $),("$"> $-.6$,% (0 %7&+ "+$(=F

8+, 9(&0-,2:@.,()$"7/, 9),("$"> )0,%!"#$-.6> "+#" #($(&/,#%, $( 6,#)% "0 #( $(&/,#%, $(

)4 I01?=>3601 VDA 3D2> 2> 3D? H6>?X VD63 40? ;I>3 =?H4K02R? 2> 3D63 6021?0323A 2> (0" # "+,0/> 6N4I3 3D? V6A 3D? V4=81 V4=M>F (0 E6=32HI86=X 3D?20H4;?J?TE?0123I=? 21?0323A 2> 043D20K ;4=? 3D60 6 ),%&/$."$0( 49 3D? V4=81a2F?FX 23 2> >2;E8A H63?K4=2R?> L5- 2034 34 23> ?TE?0123I=? H4;E40?03> 601 3D?0?TE8423> 3D? 96H3 3D63 34368 ?TE?0123I=? 2> B> &0(%"/7&"$0( ?OI2768?03 34 3436820H4;?F )4 ;6M? E=?12H3240> 4= 4?= 203?=E=?363240> 49 3D? 1636X 40? ;I>3(,&,%%#/$6>?;E84A >4;? 3AE? 49 3D?4=AF "> V? >D688 >?? 863?= 40X 60 20H=?6>? 20 -#> 4=-#> (0"8?61 34 60 20H=?6>? 20 X 1?E?0120K 40 H2=HI;>360H?>F PI3VD?3D?= 4= 043 2> E=?12H3?1 34 =2>? 4= 9688X 3D? 20H4;?J?TE?0123I=? 21?0323AV288 68V6A> D481 3=I?F

WF %3D?= !?6>I=?;?03 (>>I?>

Q?d7? 68=?61A 368M?1 6 N23 6N4I3 >4;? 49 3D? ;?6>I=?;?03 E=4N8?;> H40H?=0J20K 3D? H86>>2!H63240 49 4I3EI3 2034 23> H40>I;E3240 601 207?>3;?03 H4;E40?03>F)D63 12>HI>>240X D4V?7?=X V6> E=?12H63?1 40 3D? 6>>I;E3240 3D63 3D? H40H?E3

GU

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

23/247

49 h4I3EI3d V6> V?88J1?!0?1 601 H40>2>3?038A ;?6>I=?1F "> V? 12K 1??E?= 20343D? >6I>6K?J;6M20K ;6HD20?=AX D4V?7?=X V?!01 3D63 N43D 49 3D?>? 6>>I;E3240>

0??1 34 N? 72?V?1 V23D H6I3240F

3]3D63 3D? L5- 2>>IEE4>?1 34 =?E=?>?03 >4;? ;?6>I=? 49 3D? h768I?d 49 VD63 60 ?H404;A E=41IH?>20 3D? V6A 49 ^!068_ K441> 601 >?=72H?>a 4= h4I3EI3Xd 94= >D4=3F )D? ?6>2?>3 601;4>3 H40>2>3?03 V6A 49 6KK=?K6320K 3D? 768I? 49 12?=?03 K441> ^4= 96H34=> 49E=41IH3240_ 2> NA 61120K IE 3D?2= 768I?> 40 3D? N6>2> 49 ;6=M?3 E=2H?>]VD2HD6=? I>I688A 1?04;2063?1 20 I023> 49 3D? 06324068 HI==?0HAF %9 H4I=>?X >IHD 60?T?=H2>? !=>3 E=?>I;?> 3D? ?T2>3?0H? 49 ;6=M?3> 94= 12?=?03 94=;> 49 4I3EI3601 96H34=> 49 E=41IH3240a 601 >?H401X E=?>I;?> 3D63 E=2H?> 601 3D? OI6032J32?> ?THD60K?1 20 3D?>? ;6=M?3> 6=? >4;?D4V 4N>?=76N8? 34 06324068 >3632>32H686K?0H2?>F

%0? ;2KD3 >IEE4>? 3D63 20 3D? >4JH688?1 1?7?84E?1 V4=81X 3D63 3D?=? 6 >IJ

H2?03 0I;N?= 49 ;6=M?3> 34 E=2H? ;4>3 94=;> 49 K441> 601 >?=72H?>F PI3 ?7?0 203D2> N?>3JH6>? >H?06=24X >3632>32H260> 6=? H409=403?1 V23D 6 0I;N?= 49 H40H?E3I68601 E=6H32H68 E=4N8?;>F

)D? L47?=0;?03

#40>21?=X 94= ?T6;E8?X K47?=0;?03 hEI=HD6>?>d 49 4I3EI3F :4;? 49 3D2> 4I3JEI3 2> EI=HD6>?1 9=4; 3D? E=2763? >?H34= ^?FKFX ;28236=A EI=HD6>?> 9=4; E=2763?1?9?0>? H403=6H34=>_F PI3 6 86=K? H4;E40?03 49 K47?=0;?03 hEI=HD6>?>d 2> 20 3D?94=; 49 4I3EI3 3D63 23 E=41IH?> 23>?89 601 3D?0 3=60>9?=> 34 3D? E=2763? >?H34=63 R?=4 ^4= H84>? 34 R?=4_ E=2H?>a ?FKFX ;?12H68 >?=72H?>X 86V ?094=H?;?03 >?=72H?>X?1IH63240 >?=72H?>X ?3HF *4V 14?> 40? ;?6>I=? 3D? ;6=M?3 768I? 49 >?=72H?> >IHD

6> 3D?>? 3D63 6=? 043 >481 40 ;6=M?3>g:20H? ;6=M?3 E=2H?> 14 ?T2>3 94= E=2763? ;?12H68 H6=? 601 E=2763? ?1IH63240X

40? 6EE=46HD V4I81 207487? 3=A20K 34 0/$4%& 3D? 768I? 49 3D2> K47?=0;?03E=41IH3240 I>20K 3D? ;6=M?3 E=2H?> 4919,-& -4N-%0%4%&-676286N8? 20 3D? E=2763?>?H34=F )D2> ;?3D41 49 2;EI363240 ;6A 043 676286N8? 94= 6 86=K? H86>> 49 040J;6=M?3?1 K441> 601 >?=72H?>X D4V?7?= ^?FKFX VD63 2> 3D? ;6=M?3 768I? 49 3D?>?=72H?> E=4721?1 NA 3D? H4I=3 >A>3?;_g (0 E=6H32H?X 3D? V6A 3D2> 2> D6018?1 NA3D? (&" 2> >2;E8A 34 6>>I;? 3D63 3D? ;6=M?3 768I? 49 K47?=0;?03 E=41IH3240 2>?OI68 34 23> 96H34= H4>3F E621 kGWBXBBB E?= 600I; NA3D? K47?=0;?03X 3D?0 3D2> kGWBXBBB !KI=? 2> #--4/&3 34 N? 3D? ;6=M?3 768I?49 3D? eI12H268 >?=72H?> E=41IH?1 NA 3D? eI1K?d> 86N4= 20EI3F

)D2> ;?3D41 49 2;EI320K 3D? ;6=M?3 768I? 49 K47?=0;?03 E=41IH3240 ;6A

043 N? 6 N61 6EE=4T2;63240 63 ;4>3 32;?> 601 94= ;4>3 H4I03=2?>F '?7?=3D?8?>>X40? >D4I81 N? 6V6=? 49 3D? E43?03268 E239688> V23D 3D2> ;?3D41F )4 >?? VD63H60 K4 V=40KX H40>21?= 3D? 94884V20K >36=M ?T6;E8?F (;6K20? 60 ?H404;A 20VD2HD 86N4= 2> 3D? 408A 96H34= 49 E=41IH3240 601 6>>I;? 3D63 V4=M?=> 6=? ?23D?=?;E84A?1 20 3D? E=2763? 4= K47?=0;?03 >?H34=F )D? E=2763? >?H34= E=41IH?>

GW

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

24/247

601 >?88> ^63 ;6=M?3 E=2H?>_ 4I3EI3 63 3D? V6K? H4>3 VD2HD A2?81> E=4!3 $ F )D? K47?=0;?03 E=41IH?> 4I3EI3 63 3D? V6K? H4>3 601

>2;E8A hK27?>d 6V6AX !060H20K 23> V6K? N288 V23D 6 36T

@>20K H407?0324068 (&" ;?3D41>X 3D? 2;EI3?1 768I? 49 K47?=0;?03 E=41IHJ3240 2> H68HI863?1 6> $ #68HI86320K L5- NA 3D? ?TE?0123I=? 6EE=46HD20 3D2> ?H404;A V4I81 A2?81 $ ! #68HI86320K L5- NA 3D? 20H4;?6EE=46HD V4I81 A2?81 $ ! ! +4I >D4I81 N? 6N8? 34 H40720H?A4I=>?89 3D63 $

'4VX 2;6K20? 20 96H3 3D63 3D? ;6=M?3 768I? 49 2> R?=4a 3D63 2>X K47?=0;?03E=41IH3240 2> H40>21?=?1 34 N? 6 H4;E8?3? V6>3?F (0 3D2> H6>?X 3D? "/7,L5- 203D2> ?H404;A 2> K27?0 NA *4V?7?=X 3D?-,#%7/,)L5- H40320I?> 34 N? !(0 3D2> H6>?X K47?=0;?03 E=41IH3240 >D4I81 20 96H3 N? H4I03?1 6> 6%'#7-M&'49=?>4I=H?> ^9=4; E=2763? >?H34= ?;E84A??> 34 K47?=0;?03 >?H34= ?;E84A??>_a 23>D4I81 043 N? H4I03?1 6> 61120K 768I? 34 3D? ?H404;A 6> 6 VD48?F

'43? 3D63 3D2> 3AE? 49 E=4N8?; 2> 6N>?03 20 H4;EI320K 3D? L5- K?0?=63?1NA 3D? E=2763? >?H34=F :IEE4>?X 94= ?T6;E8?X 3D63 3D? NI>20?>> >?H34= ;6M?> 6h;2>36M?d 20 E=41IH20K 4I3EI3 3D63 04N41A 768I?>F (0 3D2> H6>?X 3D? ;6=M?3 768I?49 2> ?OI68 34 R?=4F )D? ?TE?0123I=?JN6>?1 L5- 0I;N?= 2> 04V K27?0 NA%601 3D? 20H4;?JN6>?1 L5- 0I;N?= 2> 04V K27?0 NA!!:20H?$ &3D? NI>20?>> >?H34= 04V ;6M?> 6 84>> ^0?K6327? E=4!3>_ ?OI68 34 $ &*?0H?X $ 601 $ V23D $ ;?6>I=20K 3D? 3=I?768I?J611?1 20 3D2> ?H404;AF

*4;? -=41IH3240

)2;?JI>? >3I12?> =?7?68 3D63 4I3 49 3D? 34368 6;4I03 49 32;? 676286N8? 342012721I68>X 408A 6 =?86327?8A >;688 9=6H3240 49 3D2> 2> 1?743?1 34V6=1 6H327232?>3D63 E=41IH? K441> 601 >?=72H?> 3D63 6=? >481 20 ;6=M?3> ^4= K27?0 6V6A NAK47?=0;?03>_F (0 43D?= V4=1>X 3D?=? 2> 82M?8A 6 >2K02!H603 6;4I03 49 32;? ^86N4=_1?743?1 34V6=1 6H327232?> 3D63 K?0?=63?",/& $',341%0,7X 1?!0?1 34 N? K441>601 >?=72H?> 3D63 6=? E=41IH?1 601 H40>I;?1 ^4= 207?>3?1_ V23D20 6 D4I>?D481^601 D?0H?X 043 ?THD60K?1 40 60A ;6=M?3_F (0 61123240 34 86N4=X D4I>?D481>68>4 K?0?=688A D67? 676286N8? 6 >34HM 49 H6E2368 3D63 2> 82M?V2>? ?;E84A?1 20 D4;?E=41IH3240 ^?FKFX 4V0?=J4HHIE2?1 D4I>20K 601 H40>I;?= 1I=6N8?>_F

)4 >?? VD63 >4=3 49 2>>I?> 6=2>? D?=?X H40>21?= 3D? 94884V20K ?T6;E8?>F (;6KJ20? 3D63 A4I 4V0 6 D4I>? 3D63 A4I =?03 4I3 63 kGWBB E?= ;403DF )D?0 3D2>kGWBB 2> H4I03?1 34V6=1 3D? L5-X >20H? 23 H40>323I3?> H6E2368 20H4;? 94= A4I^601 K?0?=63?> kGWBB E?= ;403D V4=3D 49 >D?83?= >?=72H?>X VD2HD 2> H40>I;?1

NA A4I= 3?0603>_F (;6K20? 04V 3D63 A4I 1?H21? 34 ;47? 2034 3D2> D4;?F )D?0A4I 04 840K?= =?E4=3 kGWBB 20 =?0368 20H4;? 40 A4I= 36T =?3I=0F *4V?7?=X 23>3288 =?;620> 3D? H6>? 3D63 3D? D4;? 2> K?0?=6320K kGWBB V4=3D 49 >D?83?= >?=72H?>3D63 6=? 04V H40>I;?1 NA A4I=>?89F #40>2>3?0HA 1?;601> 3D63 3D? (&" 2;EI3?3D? ;6=M?3 768I? 49 3D?>? >D?83?= >?=72H?> 6> 768I?1J611?1F (0 96H3X 3D2> 2> VD63

GY

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

25/247

;60A >3632>32H68 6K?0H2?> 14F

(0 E=6H32H?X D4V?7?=X >3632>32H68 6K?0H2?> 493?0 3=?63 3D? 768I63240 49 D4;?E=41IH3240 20H40>2>3?038AF #40>21?=X 94= ?T6;E8?X VD63 D6EE?0> 29 A4I 4V0601 4E?=63? 60 6I34;4N28?F +4I= EI=HD6>? 49 3D? 6I34;4N28? 2> =?H4=1?1 6>60 ?TE?0123I=? 40 6 H40>I;?= 1I=6N8?F )D2> 1I=6N8? K441 K?0?=63?> 6 "4V 493=60>E4=363240 >?=72H?>X 3D? 768I? 49 VD2HD >D4I81 N? =?H4=1?1 6> 768I?1J611?1F(0 96H3X 3D2> 2> 3AE2H688A 043 3D? H6>?F (0 H403=6>3X 29 6 36T2 H4;E60A EI=HD6>?> 3D?>6;? 6I34;4N28?X 23 2> 3=?63?1 6> 207?>3;?03 601 3D? =?7?0I? 3D? 36T2 H4;E60A?6=0> 9=4; 3D2> 6>>?3 2> =?H4=1?1 6> H6E2368 20H4;?F

:2;286=8AX H40>21?= 3V4 D4I>?D481>X 40? 49 VD2HD 2> h3=612324068Xd 601 3D?43D?= VD2HD 2> h;41?=0Fd PA 6 3=612324068 D4I>?D481X ( ;?60 40? 20 VD2HD 3D?963D?= K4?> 34 V4=M 601 >E?01> 6 H40>21?=6N8? 6;4I03 49 32;? 6=4I01 3D? D4;??0K6K?1 20 6H327232?> 82M? ;4V20K 3D? 86V0X H8?6020K 3D? KI33?=>X E620320K 3D?D4I>?X =?E62=20K D2> 6I34;4N28?X ?3HF "> V?88X 3D? ;43D?= >36A> 63 D4;?X =62>20K

3D? M21>X H44M20K ;?68>X H8?6020K 3D? D4I>?X ?3HF PA 6 ;41?=0 D4I>?D481X (;?60 40? 20 VD2HD N43D E6=?03> 6=? ?;E84A?1 601 H403=6H3 4I3 ?T3?0>27?8A 94=>?=72H?> 3D63 h>?89JE=41IH?1d NA 6 3=612324068 96;28A ^?FKFX 3D?A D2=? 6 0600A34 H44MX H8?60X 601 844M 693?= 3D? M21>a 3D?A D2=? H403=6H34=> 34 ??H3 D4;?=?04763240>X H6= =?E62=>X 601 ;6203620 3D? D4;?X ?3HF_F

(;6K20? 3D63 3D? 3V4 D4I>?D481> 1?>H=2N?1 6N47? 6=? ;4=? 4= 8?>> >2;286=20 6K? >3=IH3I=?X 0I;N?= 49 M21>X ?1IH63240 8?7?8 49 3D? E6=?03>X 601 43D?=633=2NI3?>F )D?0 3D? 3=I? 768I?1J611?1 K?0?=63?1 NA ?6HD D4I>?D481 2> 82M?8A34 N? >2;286=F PI3 3D? ;?6>I=?1 768I?J611?1 49 3D? ;41?=0 D4I>?D481 2> 82M?8A34 N? ;IHD D2KD?=X 6> ;60A 49 23> 32;?JI>? 6H327232?> 6=? 94=;688A ?THD60K?140 ;6=M?3> ^34K?3D?= V23D 3D? 96H3 3D63 3D? (&" 14?> 043 2;EI3? 6 768I? 34D4I>?D481 E=41IH3240 20 3D? 94=; 49 =62>20K M21>X D4;? ;6203?060H?X ?3HF_F

)D? >2;E8? ?T6;E8? 1?>H=2N?1 6N47? V6=0> I> 34 N? H6=?9I8 20 203?=E=?3J20K 32;?J>?=2?> ?721?0H? 49 3D? K=4V3D 20 L5- 6> =?"?H320K 60 20H=?6>?1 8?7?849 E=41IH3240F (0 E6=32HI86=X 34 3D? ?T3?03 3D63 hD4I>?D481 >3=IH3I=?d HD60K?>47?= 32;? ^9=4; 3=612324068 34 ;41?=0_X ;IHD 49 3D? K=4V3D 20 L5- ;6A >2;JE8A =?"?H3 6 ;?6>I=?;?03 ED?04;?040 ^=63D?= 3D60 =?"?H320K 3=I? K=4V3D 20E=41IH3240_F " >2;286= H67?63 2> 20 4=1?= VD?0 40? 2> ;6M20K H=4>>JH4I03=A H4;JE6=2>40> 49 L5-X ?>E?H2688A N?3V??0 1?7?84E?1 601 I01?=1?7?84E?1 H4I03=2?>F!IHD 49 3D? 4I3EI3 3D63 2> E=41IH?1 20 I01?=1?7?84E?1 H4I03=2?> 2> 82M?8A 3436M? 3D? 94=; 49 D4;? E=41IH3240 601 D?0H? 043 H4I03?1 34V6=1 4H268 L5-;?6>I=?>F

8>&'10-& (L;) "HH4=120K 34 3D2> V?N>23?` JJJLE9,N#90--4&-L,'EW *'#3&X&9#%&3W

G#1%-L#-$X D689 3D? V4=81 ^0?6=8A S N288240 E?4E8?_ ;606K? 34 827? 40 8?>> 3D60k/ 6 16AF QD28? 3D?>? I094=3I063? >4I8> 6=? I014IN3?18A E44= NA 60A ;?6>I=?X

?TE8620 VDA 3D? k/ 6 16A !KI=? 82M?8A 47?=>363?> 3D? 3=I? ?T3?03 49 3D?2= E47?=3AF

%0? ;2KD3 6=KI? 3D63 H40H?E3I688AX 3D? L5- >D4I81 ;?6>I=? 3D? ;6=M?3768I? 49 h;6=M?36N8?d 4I3EI3X ?7?0 29 23 2> 043 6H3I688A h;6=M?3?1Fd )D63 2>X 29

GZ

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

26/247

( 1?H21? 34 H8?60 3D? KI33?=> 49 ;A D4;? 40? 9688 ;4=020KX 3D? (&" >D4I81 ^20E=20H2E8?_ H4I03 3D2> H8?6020K >?=72H? 34V6=1 3D? L5-F QD28? ( 121 043 ;6=M?3

4I3 94= 3D2> >?=72H?X 23 2> H8?6=8A 6 >?=72H? 3D63 ( H4I81 D67? H403=6H3?1 4I3 94=F

)D2> 3D?0 =62>?> 3D? OI?>3240 49 VD?3D?= 3D?=? 6=? K441> 4= >?=72H?> 3D636=? h040J;6=M?36N8?Fd (0 96H3X 40? H4I81 6=KI? 3D63 3D?=? 6=?F "0 2;;?1263??T6;E8? 3D63 H4;?> 34 ;201 2> >8??EF %0? H60 E=41IH? 601 H40>I;? >8??E601 2012721I68> H8?6=8A 768I? >8??E ^6 ;202;I; 6;4I03 49 VD2HD 2> 0?H?>>6=A34 ;6203620 3D? D?683D 49 40?d> DI;60 H6E2368_F (3 2> 2;E4>>2N8?X D4V?7?=X 34H403=6H3 4I3 94= >8??E >?=72H?>a 2F?FX ( H60043 K?3 >4;?40? 34 >8??E 94= ;?F )D?>6;? ;2KD3 N? >621 49 8?6=020KF +4I H60043 K?3 >4;?40? 34 8?6=0 3D? H403?03> 493D2> 3?T3 94= A4IF !4>3 94=;> 49 8?2>I=? 6H327232?> 6EE?6= 34 N? 040J;6=M?36N8?6> V?88a ?FKFX D6720K >4;?40? 36M? 6 76H63240 40 ;A N?D689 eI>3 14?>0d3 >??;=2KD3F

%9 H4I=>?X 40? H4I81]20 E=20H2E8?X 63 8?6>3]633?;E3 34 2;EI3? 6 ;6=M?3 768I?

94= 040J;6=M?36N8? E=41IH3240 6> V?88F E?01> E=41IH20K 8?2>I=? H4I81 N? 768I?1 63 3D? 4EE4=3I023A H4>3 49 3D2> 32;?^2F?FX 3D? V6K? 3D63 2> 94=?K40? NA H40>I;20K 32;? 20 3D? 94=; 49 8?2>I=?_F ?X 3D? E=41IH3240iH40>I;E3240 49 8?2>I=? 2> 043 72?V?1 6> H40J3=2NI320K 34 L5- ^?7?0 H40H?E3I688A_F :20H? E?4E8? 4N724I>8A 14 768I? 8?2>I=?XD4V?7?=X 3D? L5- H60043 N? H40>21?=?1 3D? >48? 1?3?=;20603 49 VD63 1?3?=;20?>2012721I68 V?88JN?20KF

)D? @01?=K=4I01 &H404;A

)D? I01?=K=4I01 ?H404;A =?9?=> 34 ?H404;2H 6H32723A 3D63 2> N?A401 3D?>H4E? 49 K47?=0;?03 =?KI863240 601 ;?6>I=?;?03F @01?=K=4I01 6H32723A 3AE2J

H688A 36M?> E86H? 20 V?88J1?!0?1 ;6=M?3>X >4 3D63 23 2> =?86327?8A ?6>A 34 ;?6>I=?3D? ;6=M?3 E=2H?> K441> 601 >?=72H?> 3=60>6H3?1 20 3D?>? ;6=M?3>F (3 2> ;4=?12HI83]29 043 2;E4>>2N8?]D4V?7?=X 34 ;?6>I=? 3D? 748I;? 49 3=60>6H3240>X >20H?3D?A 6=? EI=E4>?8A D211?0F @01?=K=4I01 6H327232?> ;6A ?23D?= N? 8?K68 4= 288?K68F(9 3D?A 6=? 8?K68X 3D?A 6=? D211?0 E=2;6=28A 94= 3D? EI=E4>? 49 ?76120K 36T?>F3688?1 20 A4I= N6>?;?03X 6 1=AV688H403=6H34= ;6A 4?= A4I 3V4 E=2H?> 1?E?0120K 40 VD?3D?= A4I 6=? V28820K 34E6A NA H6>D 4= HD?OI? ^A4I V288 K?3 6 HD?6E?= E=2H? 29 A4I E6A V23D H6>D_F (93D?A 6=? 288?K68X 3D?A 6=? 4N724I>8A D211?0 34 67421 8?K68 =6;2!H63240>F (0 >4;?

eI=2>12H3240>X 94= ?T6;E8?X EI=HD6>20K 601 >?8820K >?T 601 H?=3620 94=;> 49 1=IK>2> 288?K68F

PA 3D?2= 7?=A 063I=?X I01?=K=4I01 ?H404;2?> 6=? 12HI83 34 ;?6>I=?X >4

3D63 60A ?>32;63? 49 3D?2= >2R? 2> 0?H?>>6=28A 2;E=?H2>?F '?7?=3D?8?>>X >4;? ?>J32;63?> 14 ?T2>3F "HH4=120K 34 40? :&0(0-$%" H#=#I$(,6=32H8?X 94= ?T6;E8?X3D? I01?=K=4I01 ?H404;A 20 (368A 2> ?>32;63?1 34 N? N?3V??0 rWJ/Zp 49 ^;?6J>I=?1_ L5-FU "HH4=120K 34 3D2> 6=32H8?X I01?=K=4I01 NI>20?>>?> 6=? V21?>E=?61

U VVVF?H404;2>3FH4;iH4I03=2?>i(368AiE=4!8?FH9;g9481?=m-=4!8?J&H404;2Hp/B:3=IH3I=?

GC

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

27/247

20 6K=2HI83I=?X H40>3=IH3240 601 >?=72H?>F

%0H? 6K620X 3D? E=?>?0H? 49 >IHD I0;?6>I=?1 4I3EI3 >D4I81 8?61 I> 34 72?V4H268 L5- 0I;N?=> V23D 6 962= 6;4I03 49 H6I3240 6> 3D?A 82M?8A I01?=>363? 3D?3=I? 768I? 49 E=41IH3240 NA 6 H40>21?=6N8? ;6=K20F %0 3D? 43D?= D601X VD28? 3D?8?7?8 49 L5- ;6A N? I01?=>363?1X 23> K=4V3D =63? ;6A 043 N?]63 8?6>3X 34 3D??T3?03 3D63 I01?=K=4I01 ^601 43D?= I0;?6>I=?1_ 6H32723A =?;620> 6 =?86327?8AH40>3603 E=4E4=3240 49 ;?6>I=?1 6H32723AF .2M?V2>?X H=4>>JH4I03=A H4;E6=2>40>49 L5- 6=? 82M?8A 34 N? ;4=? ;?6020K9I8 29 3D? >?3 49 ;?6>I=?1 6H327232?> 2> ;4=?4= 8?>> 3D? >6;?F Q? D67? 04 # ./$0/$=?6>40X D4V?7?=X 34 N?82?7? 3D63 ?23D?= 493D?>? H40123240> 6=? ;?3 20 =?6823AF

8>&'10-& (L@) (;6K20? 3D63 6 K47?=0;?03 >I11?08A ?06H3> 2034 8?K2>863240 60 4EJE=?>>27? 36T =?K2;? 40 23> H232R?0> ^?FKFX 6 GBBp 36T 40 688 20H4;?_F &TE8620 VDA

3D? ?H404;Ad> ;?6>I=?1 L5- 2> 82M?8A 34 9688 NA ;IHD ;4=? 3D60 3D? 3=I? 8?7?8

49 L5-F

YF '4;2068 7?=>I> $?68 L5-

L5- V6> 1?!0?1 6N47? 6> 3D? 768I? 49 4I3EI3 ^20H4;? 4= ?TE?0123I=?_F )D?1?!023240 121 043X D4V?7?=X >E?H29A 20 VD2HD I023> h768I?d 2> 34 N? ;?6>I=?1F (0?7?=A16A 829?X 3D? 768I? 49 K441> 601 >?=72H?> 2> I>I688A >363?1 20 3?=;> 49-#/C,"./$&,% ;?6>I=?1 20 I023> 49 3D? 06324068 HI==?0HA ^?FKFX #6061260 14886=>_F 49 N??= A4I 1=60M 63 86>3 02KD3d> >3I1?03 >4H268 H4>3A4I kSY ^601 E4>>2N8A 6 D60K47?=_F )D? SB D4I=> A4I V4=M?1 86>3 V??M H4>3A4I= ?;E84A?= kSBBa 601 >4 40F (9 V? 611 IE 20H4;?> 601 ?TE?0123I=?> 20 3D2>;600?=X V? 6==27? 63 6 L5- !KI=? ;?6>I=?1 20 I023> 49 ;40?Aa 3D2> ;?6>I=? 2>H688?1 3D?7,/07#9 +.2F

(9 ;6=M?3 E=2H?> ^20H8I120K 04;2068 ?THD60K? =63?>_ =?;620?1 H40>3603 47?=32;?X 3D?0 3D? 04;2068 L5- V4I81 ;6M? H4;E6=2>40> 49 L5- 6H=4>> 32;? 601H4I03=2?> 60 ?6>A 36>M ^>INe?H3 34 3D? H67?63> 4I3820?1 6N47?_F @094=3I063?8AX 6>96= 6> ;?6>I=?;?03 2>>I?> 6=? H40H?=0?1X ;6=M?3 E=2H?> 14 043 =?;620 H40>360347?= 32;?F :4 VDA 2> 3D2> 6 E=4N8?;g

)D? 768I? 49 ?23D?= 20H4;? 4= ?TE?0123I=? 2> ;?6>I=?1 6> 3D? E=41IH3 49E=2H?> ^;?6>I=?1 20 I023> 49 ;40?A_ 601 OI603232?>F (3 >??;> =?6>406N8? 34>IEE4>? 3D63 ;63?=268 82720K >36016=1> 6=? >4;?D4V =?863?1 34 OI603232?>a 601043 3D? 768I? 49 3D?>? OI603232?> ;?6>I=?1 20 ;40?A 3?=;>F (0 ;4>3 ?H404;2?>

^V23D >4;? 0436N8? ?TH?E3240>_X 3D? K?0?=68 8?7?8 49 E=2H?> 3?01> 34 K=4V 47?=32;?a >IHD 6 ED?04;?040 2> M04V0 6> 07!#%0,7F QD?0 20"63240 2> 6 9?63I=?49 3D? ?H404;2H ?072=40;?03X 3D? 04;2068 L5- V288 =2>? ?7?0 29 3D? OI603232?>49 E=41IH3240 =?;620 I0HD60K?1 47?= 32;?F 21?= 60 ?H404;A3D63 E=41IH?> 043D20K NI3 N=?61 601 3D63 A?6= 693?= A?6=X N=?61 E=41IH3240 2>?OI68 34 GBB 8467?>F :IEE4>? 3D63 3D? E=2H? 49 N=?61 3?0 A?6=> 6K4 V6> ?OI68

G\

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

28/247

34 kGFBB E?= 8469X >4 3D63 3D? 04;2068 L5- 3D?0 V6> ?OI68 34 kGBBF :IEE4>?9I=3D?= 3D63 3D? E=2H? 49 N=?61 D6> =2>?0 NA GBp E?= 600I; 47?= 3D? 86>3 3?0

A?6=>F )D? 04;2068 L5- 693?= 3?0 A?6=> 2> 3D?0 K27?0 NA ^GFGB_ "#^kGBB_ m k/YBF%N>?=7? 3D63 VD28? 3D? 04;2068 L5- 2> /FY 32;?> D2KD?= 3D60 23 V6> 3?0 A?6=>6K4X 3D? h=?68d L5- ^3D? >3I 3D63 E?4E8? E=?>I;6N8A H6=? 6N4I3_ D6> =?;620?1H40>3603 47?= 32;?F

)DI>X VD28? ;?6>I=20K 768I? 20 I023> 49 ;40?A 2> H407?02?03X 23 2> 68>4 E=4NJ8?;632H 6> 96= 6> ;?6>I=20K ;63?=268 82720K >36016=1>F PI3 29 V? H60 04 840K?==?8A 40 ;6=M?3 E=2H?> 1?04;2063?1 20 ;40?A 34 K27? I> 6 H4;;40 I023 49 ;?6J>I=?;?03X 3D?0 D4V 6=? V? 34 ;?6>I=? 3D? 768I? 49 60 ?H404;Ad> 4I3EI3g (9 60?H404;A >2;E8A E=41IH?1 40? 3AE? 49 K441 ^6> 20 4I= ?T6;E8? 6N47?_X 3D?0 3D?60>V?= 2> >2;E8?` !?6>I=? 768I? 20 I023> 49 3D? K441 E=41IH?1 ^?FKFX GBB 8467?>49 N=?61_F (0 =?6823AX D4V?7?=X ?H404;2?> 3AE2H688A E=41IH? 6 V21? 6>>4=3;?0349 K441> 601 >?=72H?>F (3 V4I81 ;6M? 82338? >?0>? 34 >2;E8A 611 IE 3D? 8?7?8 49

2012721I68 OI603232?> E=41IH?1a 94= ?T6;E8?X GBB 8467?> 49 N=?61X E8I> S 3=6H34=>X601 G/ D62=HI3> 14?> 043 611 IE 34 60A3D20K 3D63 V? H60 ;6M? >?0>? 49F

:4 V? =?3I=0 34 3D? OI?>3240 49 D4V 34 ;?6>I=? h768I?Fd "> 23 3I=0> 4I3X 3D?=?2> 04 I02OI? V6A 34 ;?6>I=? 768I?F *4V 40? HD44>?> 34 ;?6>I=? 3D20K> 1?E?01>40 3D? 3AE? 49 h=I8?=d 40? 6EE82?> 34 3D? ;?6>I=?;?03F 21?=3D? 12>360H? N?3V??0 '?V +4=M 601 -6=2>F *4V 14?> 40? ;?6>I=? 12>360H?g (03D? @023?1 :363?>X 840K 12>360H?> 6=? ;?6>I=?1 20 h;28?>Fd )D? 12>360H? N?3V??0'?V +4=M 601 -6=2> 2> SYSW ;28?>F (0 360H?> 6=? ;?6>I=?1 20hM284;?3?=>dF )D? 12>360H? N?3V??0 -6=2> 601 '?V +4=M 2> WCWG M284;?3?=>F)D60M9I88AX 3D?=? 2> 6 !T?1 h?THD60K? =63?d N?3V??0 M284;?3?=> 601 ;28?> ^G;28? 2> 6EE=4T2;63?8A GFY M284;?3?=>_X >4 3D63 N43D ;?6>I=?> E=4721? 3D? >6;?2094=;63240F fI>3 6> 2;E4=36038AX 3D?=? 2> 6 !T?1 ?THD60K? =63? N?3V??0 ;28?>#&/0%%32;? ^40? ;28? 3?0 A?6=> 6K4 2> 3D? >6;? 6> 40? ;28? 3416A_F

)D? ED?04;?040 49 20"63240 ^4= 1?"63240_ 12>34=3> 3D? 8?0K3D 49 4I= ;?6>I=J20K 20>3=I;?03 ^;40?A_ 47?= 32;?F $?3I=020K 34 4I= 12>360H? 60684KAX 2;6K20?3D63 3D? K47?=0;?03 1?H21?> 34 20H=?6>? 3D? 12>360H? 20 6 ;28? NA GBp E?= A?6=FQD28? 3D? 12>360H? N?3V??0 '?V +4=M 601 -6=2> 2> HI==?038A SYSW ;28?>X 693?=3?0 A?6=> 3D2> 12>360H? V288 D67? K=4V0 34 ^GFGB_"#^SYSW_ m \UWG ;28?>F #8?6=8AX3D? 20H=?6>? 20 12>360H? D?=? 2> eI>3 60 288I>240 ^3D? h=?68d 12>360H? D6> =?;620?1H40>3603 47?= 32;?_F :2;286=8AX VD?0 3D?=? 2> 60 20"63240X K=4V3D 20 3D? 04;J2068 L5- V288 K27? 3D? 288I>240 49 =2>20K 82720K >36016=1>X ?7?0 29 h=?68d 82720K>36016=1> =?;620 H40>3603 47?= 32;?F

)D?=? 6=? 6 0I;N?= 49 12?=?03 V6A> 20 VD2HD 34 1?68 V23D 3D? ;?6>I=?J;?03 2>>I?> 203=41IH?1 NA 20"63240F *?=?X ( 1?>H=2N? 40? 6EE=46HD 3D63 2> H4;J

;408A 614E3?1 NA >3632>32H68 6K?0H2?>F HI>>240 >I==4I0120K 3D??TE?0123I=?JN6>?1 L5- ;?6>I=?X V? D67? L5- K27?0 NA ^G_a VD2HD ( =?E=41IH?D?=? 94= H407?02?0H?`

!!"

/B

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

29/247

"> 3D2> ;?6>I=? =?82?> 40 HI==?03 ^2F?FX 163? _ E=2H?> ^VD?3D?= 6H3I68 4= 2;EI3?1_X23 2> >4;?32;?> =?9?==?1 34 6> 3D? +.2 /-4'&3 #% 14''&7% $'01&-a 4=

>2;E8AX 3D?7,/07#9 +.2F

'4VX HD44>? 40? A?6= 6=N23=6=28A ^?FKFX $ '(()_ 601 H688 3D2> 3D? B#%, >,#/F)D?0X 3D? ' +.2 ^$L5-_ 94= 60A A?6= 2> H68HI863?1 6HH4=120K 34 3D?94884V20K 94=;I86`

!!"

"$$%

)D2> ;?6>I=? 2> H688?1 3D? +.2 /-4'&3 #% N#-& :' $'01&-F (0 43D?=V4=1>X 3D? 768I? 49 3D? L5- 63 163? 2> 04V ;?6>I=?1 20 I023> 49 G\\Z 14886=>^20>3?61 49 HI==?03X 4= 163? 14886=>_F '43? 3D63 NA H40>3=IH3240X "$$% "$$%

0

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

1400

65 70 75 80 85 90 95 00 05

"#$% '%#()**+

,-./(% )01234-5#6 7$0 8%#6 9:;

)?1@@A

"-66-35$3BP> *L+ N534-5#6 9:;O0

"> 6 NAJE=41IH3 49 3D2> H68HI863240X 40? H60 H68HI863? 3D? 67?=6K? 8?7?8 49

E=2H?> ^3?HD02H688AX 3D?+.2 .&!

#%,'4= >2;E8AX 3D?$'01& 9&D&9_6HH4=120K34 3D? 94=;I86`

/G

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

30/247

0.0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

1.2

65 70 75 80 85 90 95 00 05

"#$% '%#()**+

,-./(% )0L

9:; :%B6#Q3( N)**+ R )O)?1@@A

'43? 3D63 3D? L5- 1?"634= 2> >2;E8A 60 201?T 0I;N?=a 2F?FX 23 D6> 04 ?H4J04;2H ;?6020K ^20 E6=32HI86=X 043? 3D63 "$$% $ ' NA H40>3=IH3240_F '?7?=J3D?8?>>X 3D? L5- 1?"634= 2> I>?9I8 94= ;6M20K H4;E6=2>40> 20 3D? E=2H? 8?7?86H=4>> 32;?F )D63 2>X ?7?0 29"$$% $ ' 601 "$$& $ ''& 2012721I688A D67? 04

;?6020KX V? H60 >3288 H4;E6=? 3D?>? 3V4 0I;N?=> 34 ;6M? 3D? >363?;?03 3D633D? h67?=6K?d 8?7?8 49 E=2H?> =4>? NA GBp N?3V??0 3D? A?6=> G\\Z 601 G\\CF

)D? ;?3D41484KA eI>3 1?>H=2N?1 6N47? 2> 043 9448JE=449F (0 E6=32HI86=X 3D?E=4H?1I=? 49 I>20K N6>? A?6= E=2H?> 34 H4;EI3? 6 ;?6>I=? 49 =?68 L5- 6>>I;?>3D63 3D? >3=IH3I=? 49 =?86327? E=2H?> =?;620> H40>3603 47?= 32;?F )4 3D? ?T3?033D63 3D2> 2> 043 3=I? ^23 ;4>3 H?=36208A 2> 043_X 3D?0 ;?6>I=?> 49 3D? E',J%"'#%&20 =?68 L5- H60 1?E?01 40 3D? 6=N23=6=A HD42H? 49 3D? N6>? A?6=F W D4I81 N? 043?1 3D63 ;6M20K H=4>>JH4I03=A H4;E6=2>40> 2> H4;E82H63?1 NA3D? 96H3 3D63 04;2068 ?THD60K? =63?> 3?01 34 "IH3I63? 47?= 32;? 6> V?88F (0E=20H2E8?X 40? H60 H4==?H3 94= 76=263240 20 3D? ?THD60K? =63?X NI3 D4V V?88 3D2>2> 6HH4;E82>D?1 20 E=6H32H? =?;620> 60 4E?0 OI?>3240F

$?68 E?= H6E236 L5-

(0 K?0?=68X 3D? =?68 L5- 49 60A ?H404;A ;6A =2>? ^4= 9688_ 4V20K 34` nGo 6

W :4;? >3632>32H68 6K?0H2?> D67? 203=41IH?1 76=24I> hHD620JV?2KD320Kd E=4H?1I=?> 34 ;232K63?3D2> E=4N8?;F

//

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

31/247

=2>? ^4= 9688_ 20 E4EI863240a 601i4= n/o 6 =2>? ^4= 9688_ 20 3D? 4I3EI3 E=41IH?1E?= E?=>40F )4 K?3 6 >?0>? 49 D4V ;63?=268 82720K >36016=1> 94= 3D? h67?=6K?d

E?=>40 20 60 ?H404;AX 23 ;6M?> >?0>? 34 12721? 60 ?H404;Ad> 34368 =?68 L5- NAE4EI863240 >2R?F )D? =?>I8320K 0I;N?= 2> H688?1 3D? ' $&' 1#$0%# +.2a 4=;4=? H4;;408AX 3D? ' $&' 1#$0%# 071,/&F

(3 H60043 N? >3=?>>?1 ?04IKD 3D63 ?T3=?;? H6I3240 >D4I81 N? ?T?=H2>?1 20203?=E=?320K =?68 E?= H6E236 L5- 6> 6 ;?6>I=? 49 ;63?=268 82720K >36016=1> 4=6> 6 ;?6>I=? 49 ?H404;2H V?896=?F 3X 40? >D4I81 M??E 20 ;201 688 49 3D?;?6>I=?;?03 2>>I?> 12>HI>>?1 63 8?0K3D 6N47?F :?H401X 6> 96= 6> ;63?=268 82720K>36016=1> 6=? H40H?=0?1X 3D?4=A >IKK?>3> 3D63 H40>I;E3240 2> 82M?8A 34 H40>323I3?6 N?33?= ;?6>I=? ^4= E?=D6E> ?7?0 V?683DX 34 3D? ?T3?03 3D63 H40>I;E3240 2>=?863?1 34 V?683D_F %0? V4I81 043 V603 34 eI1K? 3D? ;63?=268 82720K >36016=1>49 6 >3I1?03 V23D R?=4 20H4;?X 94= ?T6;E8?X >48?8A 40 3D? N6>2> 49 D2> 4= D?=20H4;?F K441 =?6>40 34 N?82?7? 3D63 ?H404;2H V?896=? 1?E?01>

043 408A 40 40?d> H40>I;E3240 "4VX NI3 68>4 40 43D?= 3D20K> ^?FKFX 8?2>I=? 32;?>E?03 V23D 40?d> 96;28A 601 9=2?01>_FY

Q23D 3D? 6EE=4E=263? H67?63> 20 E86H?X 8?3 I> ?T6;20? 3D? N?D6724= 49 =?68 E?=H6E236 L5- 94= #60616F 3D? ?748I3240 49 #60616d> E4EI863240601 3D? =?68 E?= H6E236 L5-F

Y 320K 12>HI>>240 40 3D? D2>34=A 49 V4=M 601 8?2>I=?X >??` *288X $4K?= PF ^G\\\_FJ$%"0/> 01 K0/C :"+$&X VVVFH4?FIK6F?1Iis=D288iV4=M?3D2HiD2>3FD3;

/S

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

32/247

16

20

24

28

32

36

65 70 75 80 85 90 95 00 05

I-66-35$3B;%($35$

,-./(% )0P

;3D/6#Q-35 3B )G) ? 1@@AG)

E3/(F%G EQ#Q-$Q-F$

/U

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

33/247

ZF L=4V3D 601 PI>20?>> #AH8?>

)D? E633?=0 49 ?H404;2H 1?7?84E;?03 12>E86A?1 20 3AE2H68 6;40K ;60A H4I03=2?>X ?>E?H2688A 94= 3D4>? 3D63 4HHIEA 3D? >4JH688?1h1?7?84E?1 V4=81Fd )D? ;4>3 >3=2M20K 9?63I=? 49 3D? 3=?01 =63?49 K=4V3D 20 =?68 E?= H6E236 20H4;?F (0 G\YGX 20H4;? E?= H6E236 V6> 6EE=4T2J;63?8A kGSXGBBF PA 3D? ?01 49 3D? >6;E8? 20 /BBWX 20H4;? E?= H6E236 D61 K=4V0NA 6 96H34= 49 /FZ ^34 kSWXYBB_F )D2> =?E=?>?03> 60 67?=6K? 600I68 K=4V3D 496EE=4T2;63?8A /F/pF

'4VX /F/p ;6A 043 >4I01 82M? 6 86=K? 0I;N?= 34 A4IF "01 A4I ;6A N?3?;E3?1 2034 3D20M20K 3D63 23 =?688A 14?> 043 ;633?= 7?=A ;IHD VD?3D?= 60

?H404;A K=4V> 63 GF/pX /F/pX 4= SF/pF (0 96H3X ?7?0 >??;20K8A >;688 12?=?0H?>20 840KJ=I0 K=4V3D =63?> >IHD 6> 3D?>? H60 3=60>863? 2034 DIK? 12?=?0H?> 20 3D?8?7?8 49 20H4;? 47?= 32;?F )D? =?6>40 94= 3D2> 82?> 20 3D? $,J&' ,M 1,/$,47307%&'&-%F

)4 6EE=?H263? 3D? E4V?= 49 H4;E4I01 203?=?>3X 2;6K20? 3D63 3D?=? 6=? 3D=???H404;2?> 601 3D63 6=? HI==?038A K?0?=6320K kGBXBBB 20 E?= H6E236 20JH4;?F &H404;A K=4V> 63 $ '*+X ?H404;A 63 $ **+X 601 ?H404;A 63 $ ,*+ E?= 600I;F QD63 V288 N? 3D? 8?7?8 49 E?= H6E236 20H4;? 63 3D??01 49 /B A?6=>g )D? 60>V?= 2> E=4721?1 20 )6N8? GFSF

)6N8? GFS` -4V?= 49 #4;E4I01 (03?=?>3

(023268 L5- L5- 693?= /B A?6=> #D60K?

&H404;A "$ '*# kGBXBBB kG/XY\U /Zp&H404;A "$ **# kGBXBBB kGWXUWS WWp&H404;A "$ ,*# kGBXBBB kGCXZZY CCp

" I>?9I8 94=;I86 34 M??E 20 ;201 2> 3D? >4JH688?1 X49& ,M A5F )D2> =I8?>363?> 3D63 29 60 ?H404;A K=4V> 63 6 =63? 49+E?= 600I;X 3D?0 3D? 0I;N?= 49A?6=> 23 36M?> 34 14IN8? 20H4;? 2> K27?0 NA `

$ )*

^Y_

)DI>X 60 ?H404;A 3D63 K=4V> 63 /p E?= 600I; V288 20H=?6>? 23> 82720K >36016=1>NA GBBp 20 SY A?6=>F "0 ?H404;A 3D63 K=4V> 63 Up E?= 600I; V288 14IN8? 23>82720K >36016=1> 20 408A GC A?6=>F

/W

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

34/247

;(> 1#&"0/ F$(&67)$(= =0L% 60(=2/7( =/0*"+ /#", B> , 1?E?01 20 86=K? E6=3 40 E6>3 K=4V3DX601 >20H? 4I= 9I3I=? 82720K >36016=1> ^601 3D4>? 49 4I= HD281=?0_ V288 1?E?01

40 HI==?03 601 9I3I=? K=4V3D =63?>X I01?=>360120K 3D? ED?04;?040 49 K=4V3D2> 49 E=2;6=A 2;E4=360H?F )D? N=60HD 49 ;6H=4?H404;2H> H40H?=0?1 V23D 3D?2>>I? 49 840KJ=I0 K=4V3D 2> H688?1 E',J%" %"&,':F " H84>?8A =?863?1 N=60HD49 ;6H=4?H404;2H>X VD2HD 2> H40H?=0?1 E=2;6=28A V23D ?TE862020K 3D? 8?7?8 601K=4V3D 49 20H4;?> 6H=4>> H4I03=2?>X 2> H688?1 3&D&9,$/&7% %"&,':F

)=6123240688AX ;6H=4?H404;2H> D6> H40H?=0?1 23>?89 ;4=? V23D 3D? 2>>I? 49h>D4=3 =I0d K=4V3DX 4= VD63 2> I>I688A 3?=;?1 3D? N4-07&-- 1:19&F )D? NI>20?>>HAH8? =?9?=> 34 3D? HAH82H68 "IH3I63240> 20 L5- 6=4I01 23> h3=?01Xd VD?=? 3=?01;6A 1?!0?1 ?23D?= 20 3?=;> 49 8?7?8> 4= K=4V3D =63?>F 34 =2>? 47?= 840K E?=241> 49 32;? ^63 8?6>3X 20#60616 601 >4;? 43D?= H4I03=2?>_X 3D? =63? 49 K=4V3D 47?= >D4=3 E?=241> 49 32;?H60 "IH3I63? >IN>36032688AF (0 96H3X 3D?=? 6EE?6= 34 N? ^=?86327?8A N=2?9_ E?=241>

49 32;? VD?0 3D? =?68 L5- 6H3I688A 9688> ^2F?FX 3D? K=4V3D =63? 2> 0?K6327?_FQD?0 3D? =?68 L5- 9688> 94= 3V4 4= ;4=? H40>?HI327? OI6=3?=> ^>2T ;403D>_X 3D??H404;A 2> >621 34 N? 20 '&1&--0,7 ^2F?FX 3D? >D61?1 =?K240> 20 2;E4=3603 34 M??E 20 ;201 3D63 VD28? 23 2> 3?;E320K 34 12HD434;2R?6 E633?=0 49 ?H404;2H 1?7?84E;?03 82M? h3=?01d 601 hHAH8?dH4;E40?03>X 3D?=? 2> 20 96H3 04 # ./$0/$ =?6>40 34 N?82?7? 3D63 >IHD 6 1?H4;JE4>23240 ;6M?> 60A >?0>? 3D?4=?32H688A ^683D4IKDX 40? H4I81 H?=36208A E?=94=;>IHD 6 1?H4;E4>23240 >3632>32H688A_F P?H6I>? VD63 (d7? >621 D?=? 2> 2;E4=3603601 043 V21?8A 6EE=?H263?1X 8?3 ;? ?86N4=63?F

QD?0 72?V20K 6 126K=6; 82M? 34 1=6V6 >;443D 820? 3D=4IKD 3D? 1636 601 203?=E=?3 3D2> 6> h3=?01Fd )D? 12?=?0H?N?3V??0 3D? 6H3I68 1636 601 3D? 3=?01 820? 2> 3D?0 203?=E=?3?1 6> hHAH8?Fd @0J

94=3I063?8AX 3D?=? 2> 04 I02OI? 4= 4N724I> V6A 34 1?3=?01 32;?J>?=2?> 1636F (0 GFYX ( 12>E86A 3D? 3=?01 601 HAH8? H4;E40?03> 49 #6061260 L5- I>20K40? E6=32HI86= ;?3D41 ^6 HIN2H 3=?01_F

/Y

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

35/247

-.12

-.08

-.04

.00

.04

.08

9.4

9.6

9.8

10.0

10.2

10.4

10.6

65 70 75 80 85 90 95 00 05

:%7-#Q-35 B(34 1636F )D? ;2>J36M? 3D63 E?4E8? H4;;408A ;6M?X D4V?7?=X 2> 34 6>>I;? 6 >;443D 3=?01 820?]?>32;63?1 40 D2>34=2H68 1636]6H3I688A =?E=?>?03> 6 3=?01 3D63 H60 N? ?TE?H3?1 34E=?7628 2034 3D? 94=?>??6N8? 9I3I=?F )4 EI3 3D20K> 6043D?= V6AX E?4E8? H4;;408A

;6M? 3D? ;2>36M? 49 6>>I;20K 3D63 6 >;443D 3=?01 820? =?E=?>?03> >4;?3D20Kh=?68d 4= h9I016;?0368d 6N4I3 3D? V6A 60 ?H404;A 9I0H3240>F (0 96H3X 6 >;443D3=?01 820? ;6A N? 043D20K ;4=? 3D60 6 >3632>32H68 288I>240F

)4 ;6M? VD63 ( 6; >6A20K ;4=? H40H=?3?X H40>21?= 3D? 94884V20K 6=KI;?03F.?3 1?043? 3D? ^84K_ =?68 E?= H6E236 L5- 601 6>>I;? 3D63 A4I 601 ( M04VI01?=8A20K3#%# E&7&'#%07E $',1&--^5L-_ 94= 3D? ?H404;AF (;6K20? 9I=3D?=3D63 3D2> 5L- 2> K27?0 NA`

'"$ ! ! '" ^Z_

VD?=? '" 2> 6 =6014; 76=26N8?X =?E=?>?0320K 60 I094=?H6>36N8? h>D4HMd 34 3D??H404;Ad> L5-F Q? H60 6>>I;? 3D63'"36M?> 40? 49 3V4 768I?>X ?6HD 49 VD2HD2> 1?3?=;20?1 NA 3D? "2E 49 6 H420F %=X 34 N? >82KD38A ;4=? >4ED2>32H63?1X V?H60 6>>I;? 3D63 '" 2> 1?3?=;20?1 NA 6 1=6V 9=4; 6 '4=;68 12>3=2NI3240 V23D;?60 601 >36016=1 1?7263240 (9 V? >?3 $ & 3D?0 3D? ?TE?H3?1 768I? 49'" 6> 49 163? 2> K27?0 NA '"$ & (0 96H3X 3D? ?TE?H3?1 768I? 49' 94=60A $ ' * , 2> K27?0 NA ' $ &

)D? 5L- 20 ^Z_ 2> 60 ?T6;E8? 49 VD63 2> H688?1 6 '#73,/ J#9U J0%" 3'0M%F)D? h1=293d E6=6;?3?==?E=?>?03> 3D? ?TE?H3?1 =63? 49 K=4V3D 49 ^84K_ L5-F Q?

/Z

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

36/247

H60 >2;I863? 60 ?OI63240 82M? ^Z_ NA 6>>2K020K E6=6;?3?= 768I?> 601 K?0?=6320K3D? h>D4HM>dI>20K 6 =6014; 0I;N?= K?0?=634=F :IEE4>?X 94= ?T6;E8?X 3D63 V?

>?3"$(")" $ (-.^23> 768I? 94= 3D? #6061260 ?H404;A 20 G\YG_F .?3 $ &&&//^VD2HD K?0?=63?> 60 600I68 ?TE?H3?1 K=4V3D =63? 49 /F/pF "> V?88X HD44>? 6>36016=1 1?7263240 $ &&'/ E86A> 3V4 >2;I863?1 32;?J>?=2?> 94= ^6840K V23D 3D? 6H3I68 #6061260 1636_F

%0? 3D20K 3D63 >D4I81 >3=2M? A4I 9=4; 72?V20K D4V 3D? >2;JI863?1 >?=2?> =?>?;N8? 3D? 6H3I68 1636a 20 96H3X 23 V4I81 N? 7?=A D6=1 34 3?88^V23D4I3 M04V20K N?94=?D601_ VD2HD >?=2?> V6> K?0?=63?1 NA 4I= ;41?8 ^Z_ 601VD2HD V6> K?0?=63?1 NA 3D? ?H404;AF

9.4

9.6

9.8

10.0

10.2

10.4

10.6

10.8

65 70 75 80 85 90 95 00 05

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

37/247

K27?0 3D63 V? M04V 3D? 3=I? 5L-X V? H60 H4;EI3? 3D? 3D?4=?32H68 3=?01 601>D4V 3D63 14?> 043 H4==?>E401 34 6 >;443D 820?F

)D? 3D?4=?32H68 ^2F?FX 3=I?_ 3=?01 N?D6724= 12>E86A?1 NA 4I= ;41?8 ?H404;AH60 N? H68HI863?1 6> 94884V>F @>20K ^Z_X V? H60 1?1IH? 3D63`

'* $ ! '"! '*%

$ *! ! '"! '*

:2;286=8AX

'+ $ ! '*! '+%

$ ,! ! '"! '*! '+

#40320I20K 40 20 3D2> V6AX V? D67?`

'$ ! ! '"! '*! ! '

94= 60A 6=N23=6=A &

'4VX >IEE4>? V? 6=? 63 163? 601 V2>D 34 ?>32;63? 3D? 9I3I=? 8?7?8 49 L5-63 163? ! VD?=?2> >4;? 0I;N?= 86=K? ?04IKD 34 N? H40>21?=?1 3D? h840KJ=I0ad ?FKFX $ -& OI6=3?=> ^3?0 A?6=>_ 4 2034 3D? 9I3I=?F )D?0 V? H60 6>M 3D?OI?>3240` VD63 2> 3D? ?TE?H3?1 768I? 49' K27?0 VD63 V? M04V 63 163? g)D? 60>V?= 2> K27?0 NA`

'$ ! ^C_

)D2> h840KJ=I0d ^E?=241 6D?61_ 94=?H6>3 49 L5- H60 N? 3D4IKD3 49 3D? ;41?8d>h3=?01d 94= 3D? ^84K_ 8?7?8 49 L5-F (0 43D?= V4=1>X 3D? h840KJ=I0d 8?7?8 49 L5- 2>1?3?=;20?1 NA 3D?14''&7% 8?7?8 49 L5- E8I> 60 ?TE?H3?1 K=4V3D 3?=; F

'43? 3D63 >20H? HD60K?> 47?= 32;?X >4 14?> 3D? 3=?01 8?7?8 49 L5-F (0 96H3X>20H? 2> 6 =6014; 76=26N8?X 4I= ;41?8 12>E86A> VD63 2> M04V0 6> 6 -%,1"#-%01%'&73F '??18?>> 34 >6AX 6 >34HD6>32H ^=6014;_ 3=?01 820? 2> 043 K420K 34 844M60A3D20K 82M? 3D? >;443D 1?3?=;202>32H 3=?01 820? 1=6V0 20 X20 96H3X 04 =?6>40 34 N?82?7? 3D63 V288 ?7?= =?7?=3 N6HM 34 6 >;443D 3=?01 820??>32;63?1 V23D D2>34=2H68 1636F )D? ?>32;63?1 3=?01 820? 2> >2;E8A 6 !K;?03 493D? ?H404;?3=2H260d> 2;6K2063240 ^V? M04V 3D2>X NI3 D? 14?>0d3_F

QDA 2> 3D2> 2;E4=3603 34 I01?=>3601g (3 2> 2;E4=3603 94= 3D? 94884V20K=?6>40>F 3X 6> ;?03240?1 ?6=82?=X 3D?=? 2> 6 3?01?0HA 94= E?4E8? 34 N?82?7?3D63 6 >;443D8A 1=6V0 820? 3D=4IKD 3D? 1636 =?E=?>?03> >4;?3D20K h9I016;?0368d6N4I3 3D? V6A 60 ?H404;A 9I0H3240> 20 3D? 840KJ=I0F (0 43D?= V4=1>X 3D?=? 2>6 3?01?0HA 34 N?82?7? 3D63 60 ?H404;A V288 ?7?03I688A =?7?=3 N6HM 34 >4;?K27?0 3=?01 N?D6724=F "> 3D? ?T6;E8? 6N47? 1?;40>3=63?>X >IHD 6 N?82?9 2> 0430?H?>>6=28A H4==?H3 ^601 H60 ?6>28A N? 20H4==?H3X K27?0 D4V >2;286= 3D? >2;I863?1>?=2?> 20 ?;N8? 3D? 6H3I68 1636_F

:?H401X NA 6>>I;20K 3D63 3D? ?H404;A 14?> E4>>?>> 6 >;443D 3=?01X 40? 2>2;E82H238A 6>>I;20K 3D63 K=4V3D 601 NI>20?>> HAH8? ED?04;?06 6=? 201?E?01?03

/\

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

38/247

49 ?6HD 43D?=F )D63 2>X 40? 2> ?6>28A 8?1 34 3D? H40H8I>240 3D63 V? H60 I>?6 K=4V3D 3D?4=A 34 I01?=>3601 3=?01 N?D6724= 601 6 NI>20?>> HAH8? 3D?4=A 34

I01?=>3601 1?7263240> 9=4; 3=?01X V23D ?6HD 3D?4=A N?6=20K 04 =?863240 34 40?6043D?=F (0 96H3X 23 ;6A 7?=A V?88 N? 3D? H6>? 3D63 3D? >4JH688?1 hNI>20?>> HAH8?d2> 043D20K ;4=? 3D60 6 NAJE=41IH3 49 3D? E=4H?>> 49 ?H404;2H 1?7?84E;?03^6> >IKK?>3?1 NA 4I= ;41?8_F (0 43D?= V4=1>X V? ;6A N? V=40K 20 3D20M20K^6> E?4E8? H4;;408A 14_ 3D63 V? H60 I01?=>3601 3D? NI>20?>> HAH8? V23D4I3I01?=>360120K 3D? E=4H?>> 49 K=4V3D 23>?89F

M67&"7#"$0(% $( 345 -#> 6#/=,6> B, # B>2./0)7&" 01 # /#()0-=/0*"+ ./0&,%% F# %+$1"$(= "/,()GN $?,?O "+, PB7%$(,%% &>&6,L -#> B,$(,@"/$B6> 6$(C,) "0 "+, ./0&,%% 01 ,&0(0-$& ),2H 8?>>40 D?=? 2> 34 N? H6=?9I8 20 6>>I;20K 3D63 60 ?H404;A D6> 6>;443D 3=?01 601 3D63 L5- V288 ?7?03I688A =?3I=0 34 3D2> 3=?01F )4 1?;40>3=63?3D? E43?03268 E239688 49 3D2> H4;;408A D?81 72?VX H40>21?= 3D? =?68 E?= H6E236 L5- 94= f6E60 9=4;G\YB]/BBUF (;6K20? 3D63 60 ?H404;?J3=2H260 82720K 20 3D? A?6= G\ZS V603> 34 ?>32;63? 3D? h3=?01d 94= f6E60?>? L5-N6>?1 40 3D? D2>34=2H68 1636 G\YBJZSF )D? 16>D?1 820? ^6 >2;E8? 820?6= 3=?01_ 20 34 !3 3D? D2>34=2H68 1636 =?6>406N8A V?88F @094=3I063?8AX 3D?

94=?H6>3 49 L5- 96= 4 2034 3D? 9I3I=? V4I81 D67? N??0 4 6 361F

SB

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

39/247

4000

8000

12000

16000

20000

24000

28000

32000

36000

40000

60 65 70 75 80 85 90 95 00

8%#6 D%( 07/ 1/$,()??????7("$6 $" ,()%?

CF :HD448> 49 )D4IKD3

)D? =?6>40 94= VDA 6KK=?K63? ?H404;2H 6H32723A "IH3I63?> 3D? V6A 23 14?>X?7?0 20 =?86327?8A >36N8? 20>323I324068 ?072=40;?03>X =?;620> 86=K?8A 60 I0=?J>487?1 EIRR8?F (3 >D4I81 H4;? 6> 04 >I=E=2>? 3D?0 34 8?6=0 3D63 3D?=? 6=? ;60A12?=?03 DAE43D?>?> 3D63 4?= 12?=?03 203?=E=?363240> 49 4N>?=7?1 E633?=0>F"3 3D? ?01 49 3D? 16AX 3D? 820?> 49 1?N63? 6=? 1=6V0 6H=4>> 3D? 94884V20K 3V4OI?>3240>`

! K+#" #/, "+, ./$-#/> $%"&'$ "+#" #/, "+, 76"$-#", %07/&, 01 #==/,=#","7&"7#"$0(%Q

! K+#" $% "+, ()&%*!+$( B> *+$&+ #( ,&0(0-> /,%.0()% "0 #(> =$

8/12/2019 MPRA Paper 6403

40/247

:3=2H38A >E?6M20KX 6 -",1U =?9?=> 34 6 h>I=E=2>?d ?7?03 3D63 2> 1?3?=;20?1NA L41 4= 063I=? ^2F?FX 60 ?7?03 3D63 2> N?A401 3D? H403=48 49 60A ?H404;2H

6K?03 4= 6K?0H2?>_F " 3>I06;2 3D63 V2E?> 4I3 6 >2K02!H603 9=6H3240 49 6 =?K240d>>34HM 49 DI;60 601 EDA>2H68 H6E2368 H40>323I3?> 6 E4>>2N8? ?T6;E8?F )D? >I11?06EE?6=60H? 49 0?V 3?HD0484KA]82M? 3D? 203?=0?3];6A N? 6043D?=F

@094=3I063?8AX 3D? 203?=E=?363240 49 >D4HM ?7?03> 2> 043 ?032=?8A I06;N2KIJ4I>F 4;? =?82K24I> K=4IE> H403?01 3D63 3D? 5?H?;N?= /YX /BBU3>I06;2 3D63 62H3?1 >4I3D?6>3 ">26 V6> 20 96H3 N=4IKD3 94=3D NA L41 6> 6EI02>D;?03 94= 3D? =?K240d> >20> ^>?T 601 1=IK>_F "HH4=120K 34 3D2> 203?=E=?36J3240X 3D? 20D6N23603> ^601 34I=2>3>_ 20 >4I3D?6>3 ">26 N=4IKD3 3D? 3>I06;2 40NA 3D?2= 4V0 1?N6IHD?=4I> N?D6724=F )D2> 72?V =?OI2=?> 3D63 V? 36M? 6> &>S,E&7,4-^2F?FX I0?TE8620?1_ 3V4 3D20K>` nGo L41d> 86Va 601 n/o E=?9?=?0H?> 94=1?N6IHD?=4I> 6H327232?> ^3D63 724863? L41d> 86V_F '?7?=3D?8?>>X 40? ;2KD3 >32886=KI? 3D63 VD28? 3D? 3>I06;2 23>?89 >D4I81 D67? N??0 ?TE?H3?1X 3D? ?T6H3 163?

49 23> 6==2768 H4I81 043 D67? N??0 94=?H6>3?1F )DI>X 3D? 6H3I68 6==2768 49 3D?3>I06;2 2> >3288 I>?9I88A 203?=E=?3?1 6> 6 >D4HMF

)D? >6;? >4=3 49 6=KI;?03 H60 N? ;61? V23D =?>E?H3 34 6 3?HD0484KA >D4HMF)D63 2>X 8?3 I> 36M? 6> ?T4K?04I> 3V4 3D20K>` nGo 3D? 86V 49 063I=? K47?=020K 3D?E=4H?>> 49 12>H47?=Aa 601 n/o E=?9?=?0H?> 94= D2KD?= 82720K >36016=1>F )D?0 40?;2KD3 =?6>406N8A 6=KI? 3D63 3D? 21?6 N?D201 3D? 203?=0?3 V6> 20 96H3 3D? E=41IH349 DI;60 N?D6724= ^?FKFX $,5 6H32723A_F "> V23D 3D? 3>I06;2X D4V?7?=X 04 40?H60 =?6>406N8A N? ?TE?H3?1 34 94=?H6>3 3D? ?T6H3 6==2768 163? 49 60A 3?HD0484K2H6861760H?;?03F QD?0 M0