moral apologia

8/19/2019 Moral Apologia

1/29

!"#$% '("%")*$

+$,*- .$))/00

1/##2 34 5$%%6

+789:;4:;$?(#"@9"6">


2/29

5*%%*$L S"#%/2 /LE#$?/- ,$#*$F06 "@ 0J/*# "HFP $F- ^/F#2 S*-)H*?Q "#$ % & )/60K#/- *F

0J/ -*#/?0*"F "@ 2/0 $F"0J/#P HJ*?J J/ #/_/?0/-4` X4 S4 3/H*6 0J"K)J0 $ L"#$% $#)KL/F0

@"# M"-N6 /O*60/F?/ 0" E/ (/#6K$6*,/P HJ*%/ 1"JF !$?Q*/P $F"0J/# 7O@"#- )#/$0P $#)K/- _K60 0J/ "(("6*0/4

\"F6(/?*$%*606 "@0/F J$,/ $ J$#- 0*L/ @"%%"H*F) 6"L/ "@ 0J/ 0/?JF*?$%*0*/6 "@ 0J*6

"F)"*F) -*$%")K/4 IJ/ *L("#0$F?/ "@ 0J/ *66K/P 0J"K)JP -/L$F-6 0J$0 0J/ $#)KL/F0a6b

E/ )*,/F *F $F $??/66*E%/ @"#LP $F- 0J$0 *6 HJ$0 H/ H*%% $00/L(0 0" -" J/#/4 IJ/ E$6*?

*F)#/-*/F06 "@ 6/,/#$% ,/#6*"F6 "@ 0J/ $#)KL/F0 ?$F E/ H",/F 0")/0J/# $F- L$-/ ,/#2

?%/$# 0" 0J"6/ %$?Q*F) 6(/?*$%*R/- 0#$*F*F) *F (J*%"6"(J2 "# 0J/"%")24 S"L/0*L/6P 0J/

0/?JF*?$%*0*/6 $F- _$#)"F $?0K$%%2 -*60#$?0 @#"L 0J/ @"#?/ "@ 0J/ $#)KL/F04 S"P J/#/ H/

H*%% )*,/ $F ",/#,*/H 0J$0 %$26 "K0 0J/ 0/##$*F $F- (#",*-/6 #/$-/#6 H*0J $F *-/$ "@ 0J/

6"#0 "@ L"#$% $#)KL/F0 0J$0 H/ H*%% -/@/F- *F L"#/ -/0$*% *F %$0/# ?J$(0/#64 80 H*%% -#$H "F #/6"K#?/6 @#"L $ ,$#*/02 "@ L"#$% $#)KL/F06 $F- 0*/ K( 0J/ ,$#*"K6 60#$F-6 "@ 0J/

-*6?K66*"F $0 0J/ /F-P $0 HJ*?J ("*F0 0J/ E$6*? 6J$(/ $F- 0/O0K#/ "@ 0J/ $#)KL/F0 H*%%

J$,/ /L/#)/-4

./@"#/ -/,/%"(*F) 0J/ $#)KL/F0P $ H"#- *6 *F "#-/# $E"K0 0J/ #"%/ "@ $#)KL/F0 *F

@$*0JP "# $E"K0 0J/ #/%$0*"F6J*( E/0H//F (J*%"6"(J2 $F- #/%*)*"F4 U$*0J $F- #/$6"F $#/

6"L/0*L/6 0J"K)J0 0" E/ LK0K$%%2 "(("6/-P 6"L/0*L/6 E2 E/%*/,/#6 $F- KFE/%*/,/#6

$%*Q/P @"# -*@@/#/F0 #/$6"F64 ./%*/,/#6 HJ" 0$Q/ 0J*6 ,*/H 02(*?$%%2 6// 0J*6 $6 $ H$2 0"

6$@/)K$#- @$*0J4C 8@ @$*0J *6 E/2"F- 0J/ #/$%L "@ #$0*"F$% 0J"K)J0 "# 6?*/F0*@*? -*6?"K#6/P

*06 %/)*0*L$?2 -"/6FN0 -/(/F- "F L//0*F) 0J/ #*)"#6 "@ 0J/ *F0/%%/?04 IJ*6 ,*/HP ?$%%/-

@*-/*6LP @#"L 0J/ 3$0*F H"#- ,-'"(P HJ*?J L/$F6 [@$*0JP] J$6 E//F J/%- E2 $ FKLE/# "@

F"0/- XJ#*60*$F 0J*FQ/#6P $F- $%0J"K)J *0 *6 0J/ L*F"#*02 ("6*0*"FP *0 *6 $ ?"LL"F 60$F?/

$L"F) L$F2 E/%*/,/#6 0"-$2 HJ" J$,/ $-"(0/- 0J/ ("60L"-/#F L*F-6/0 0J$0 @*F-6

#$0*"F$% $#)KL/F06 0" E/ "@ -KE*"K6 ,$%K/4c

'L"F) KFE/%*/,/#6P 0J/ ,*/H 0J$0 @$*0J $F- #/$6"F $#/ $0 "--6 02(*?$%%2 #/@%/?06 $F

$%0")/0J/# -*@@/#/F0 (K#("6/P F$L/%2P 0" KF-/#6?"#/ 0J/ ?%$*L 0J$0 @$*0J *6 K00/#%2

*##$0*"F$%P $ ?%$*L 0J$0 J$6 #/?/*,/- @#/6J *L(/0K6 @#"L 0J/ #/?/F0 ("(K%$# E""Q6

0#KL(/0*F) $0J/*6L4 8F L$F2 $?$-/L*? $F- *F0/%%/?0K$% ?*#?%/6P 0J/ (#/,$*%*F) ,*/H *60J$0 E/%*/@ *F M"- *6 F/*0J/# 6?*/F0*@*?$%%2 ,*$E%/ F"# (J*%"6"(J*?$%%2 #/6(/?0$E%/P EK0

#$0J/#P _K,/F*%/ $F- F$d,/4 80N6 $ E/%*/@ H"#0J2 "@ 0J/ +%- /%0%- P 0J/ KF/F%*)J0/F/- $L"F)

K6P 0J/ *)F"#$F0 L$66 "@ L/F4 IJ/ L"#/ /-K?$0/-P H/N#/ 0"%-P _/00*6"F 6K?J ,/60*)/6 "@

6K(/#60*0*"F4 Y/%*)*"F L$2 E/ ?"L@"#0*F)P $ 6"K#?/ "@ ?"F6"%$0*"F $F- /ZK$F*L*02 *F

0#"KE%/- 0*L/6P "# $ J/%(@K% (62?J"%")*?$% ?#K0?J @"# 0J/ H/$Q4 .K0 HJ$0 *0 *6 1%* *6 0#K/

"# #$0*"F$%%2 -/@/F6*E%/4

'%"F) H*0J 0J/ L$_"#*02 "@ 0J/ XJ#*60*$F 0#$-*0*"FP H/ #/_/?0 0J/ ,*/H 0J$0 @$*0J $F-

#/$6"F $#/ $0 "--64 8F @$?0P H/ ,*/H (J*%"6"(J2 $6 $F $%%2P LK?J %*Q/ U#$F?*6 .$?"FP


3/29

HJ" 0J"K)J0 0J$0 $ %*00%/ (J*%"6"(J2 *F?%*F/- $ L$FN6 L*F- 0" "#$ ' & $0J/*6LP EK0

-/(0J *F (J*%"6"(J2 E#"K)J0 L/FN6 L*F-6 0" #/%*)*"F4A IJ*6 *6 F"0 0" /O$))/#$0/ HJ$0

(J*%"6"(J*?$% $#)KL/F06 ?$F $??"L(%*6J4 8F-//-P 0J/ %$60 ?"K(%/ "@ ?/F0K#*/6 "@ (J*%"6"(J2 J$,/ 0$K)J0 K6 0J$0 J$FQ/#*F) $@0/# $E6"%K0/ ?/#0$*F02 *6 K6K$%%2 @K0*%/4 .K0

HJ*%/ /@@"#06 0" ?"F?%K6*,/%2 (#",/ "# -*6(#",/ M"-N6 /O*60/F?/ 0" /,/#2"F/N6 6$0*6@$?0*"F

$#/ 6K#/ 0" @$*%P /F-/$,"#6 0" 6J"H #/%*)*"K6 E/%*/@6 0" E/ #$0*"F$%%2 (/#6K$6*,/ $#/ 60*%%

@$*# )$L/P $F- *F-//- ?#K?*$%4

8F 0J/ 6(*#*0 "@ U#$F?*6 .$?"FP X4 S4 3/H*6 E/%*/,/- 0J$0 $#)KL/F0 L",/6 0J/ E$00%/

0" 0J/*60*? )#"KF-64 ^/ 0J"K)J0 0J$0 0J/ ,/#2 $?0 "@ $#)K*F) $H$Q/F6 "K# #/$6"FP $F-

"F?/ *0N6 $H$Q/P 0J/#/N6 F" 0/%%*F) 0J/ #/6K%04B U"# #/$6"F 60*#6 0J/ J$E*0 "@ $00/F-*F) 0"

KF*,/#6$% *66K/6 $F- H*0J-#$H*F) "K# $00/F0*"F @#"L 0J/ 60#/$L "@ *LL/-*$0/ 6/F6/

/O(/#*/F?/6 0J$0 ?"F,*F?/ K6 0J$0 0J/#/N6 F"0J*F) L"#/ 0" %*@/ 0J$F HJ$0 L//06 0J/ /2/4IJ/6/ ?"F,*?0*"F6 $F*L$0/- 3/H*6 0" (#"-K?/ 0J/ ("(K%$#P EK0 _K60%2 @$L"K6 ,/#6*"F

"@ 0J/ L"#$% $#)KL/F0 0J$0 $((/$#6 *F 0J/ "(/F*F) ?J$(0/#6 "@ J*6 ?%$66*? E""Q 2"&"

3+&-(*-41-*#4 5/ H*%% 0$Q/ 0J*6 $#)KL/F0 $6 $ 60$#0*F) ("*F0 "@ "K# -*6?K66*"F4

8F0*L$0*"F6 "@ S"L/0J*F) !"#/

3/H*6 E/)$F J*6 L"#$% $#)KL/F0 @"# M"- E2 ("*F0*F) 0" 6"L/0J*F) K00/#%2

?"LL"F(%$?/9 0J/ H$2 H/ K6/ %$F)K$)/P /6(/?*$%%2 HJ/F H/ ZK$##/%4 +*6(K0$F06 "F E"0J

6*-/6 "@ $#)KL/F06 L$Q/ $((/$% 0" #K%/6 "# %$H6 "@ -/?/F0 JKL$F ?"F-K?0P 6J"H*F) 0J/*#

E/%*/@ *F $ 60$F-$#- "@ #*)J0 $F- H#"F)4

3/H*6 @$,"#/- 0J/ 0#$-*0*"F$% %$E/% [%$H "@ F$0K#/] @"# 0J*6 60$F-$#-P 0J"K)J 0J*6 L"#$%

%$H *6 6"L/0J*F) 0J$0 0#$F6?/F-6 0J/ F$0K#$% "#-/#4 5J/#/$6 H/ J$,/ F" ?J"*?/ EK0 0"

2*/%- 0" $ (J26*?$% %$H %*Q/ )#$,*02 HJ/#/ "K# E"-*/6 "# (J26*?$% F$0K#/ *6 ?"F?/#F/-P H/

-" J$,/ $ ?J"*?/ 0" "E/2 "# -*6#/)$#- 0J/ L"#$% %$H *F 0J/ #/$%L "@ "K# L*F- $F- H*%%4 .2

[%$H "@ F$0K#/] 3/H*6 0J"K)J0 H/ #/$%%2 L/$F $ %$H "@ +5641 F$0K#/P $F- J/ /O(%$*F/-

0J/ $(0F/66 "@ 0J*6 %$F)K$)/ E2 F"0*F) J"H H/ $?ZK*#/ QF"H%/-)/ "@ *04 ^/ 0J"K)J0 H/

QF"H *0 E2 F$0K#/ $F- -"FN0 F//- 0" E/ 0$K)J0 *04 5/ ?$F _K60 ("" 0J/ -*@@/#/F?/ E/0H//F

#*)J0 $F- H#"F) "F "K# "HFP "# $0 %/$60 H/ 6J"K%-4

3/H*6 H$6 #*)J0 0J$0 $0 %/$60 641# L"#$% @$?06 6//L "E,*"K6 *F-//-4 80N6 H#"F)P @"#

/O$L(%/P 0" 0"#0K#/ *FF"?/F0 ?J*%-#/F @"# @KFP $F- H/ (%$*F%2 #/?")F*R/ *04 '%0J"K)J

F"0 /,/#2 L"#$% 0#K0J 6J*F/6 H*0J 6K?J E#*)J0F/66P *0N6 H#"F) 0" 0J*FQ 0J$0 $%L"60 $%%

"@ /0J*?6 *6 ?"%"#/- )#$24 Y/@%/?0*"F 2*/%-6 %/)*0*L$0/%2 -*@@*?K%0 ZK/60*"F6 *F /0J*?6P 2/6P

EK0 $ )#/$0 L$F2 /0J*?$% 0#K0J6 #/L$*F "E,*"K64 1K60 $6 *0N6 ?%/$#%2 /F"K)J H#"F) 0" (K0

(#"@*06 E/@"#/ (/"(%/P 6" *6 *0 ?%/$#%2 /F"K)J #*)J0 0" $??"#- (/"(%/ E$6*? #/6(/?04


4/29

"#$ () & e,/F HJ/#/ (/"(%/ -*6$)#// "F /0J*?$% L$00/#6P 0J/2 "@0/F -*@@/# F"0 6" LK?J

$E"K0 0J/ /0J*?$% (#*F?*(%/6 *F,"%,/- $6 $E"K0 J"H E/60 0" $((%2 0J/L *F (#$?0*?$% 0/#L64

!$F2 H"K%-P @"# /O$L(%/P %$L/F0 *F60$F?/6 "@ %$E"# /O(%"*0$0*"F *F XJ*F$P EK0 HJ/#/$6

6"L/ L*)J0 0J*FQ 0J$0 L"#$%*02 0J/#/E2 -/L$F-6 0J$0 H/ F"0 ?"F0#*EK0/ 0" XJ*F$N6 L",/

0"H$#- ?$(*0$%*6LP "0J/#6 H"K%- 6$2 0J$0 ?"F0*FK*F) /?"F"L*? /F)$)/L/F0 H*0J $F-

/F?"K#$)/L/F0 "@ XJ*F$ *6 0J/ E/60 H$2 0" J/%( $%%/,*$0/ 6K?J $EK6/64 80N6 0J/ #/%$0*,/%2

#$#/ *F-*,*-K$% HJ" @//%6 6*L(%2 F" L"#$% ZK$%L6 $E"K0 /O(%"*0$0*"F "@ 0J/ (""#4

8F ?$6/ #/$-/#6 0J*FQ 0J$0 3/H*6P *F /LE#$?*F) "E_/?0*,/ /0J*?6P H$6 E/*F) 6/%@f#*)J0/"K6P

J/ H$6 ZK*?Q 0" $66K#/ 0J/L 0J$0 J/ -*-FN0 0J*FQ 0J$0 /*0J/# J/ "# $F2"F/ /%6/ $%H$26

@"%%"H6 0J/ L"#$% %$H4 I" 0J/ ?"F0#$#2P J/ "E6/#,/-P H/ $%% @$%% 6J"#0 "@ *0P -/6(*0/ "K#

#/?")F*0*"F "@ *0P $F- H/ @$%% 6J"#0 "@ *0 $%% 0"" "@0/F4

S" 0J*6 *6 0J/ @*#60 ($#0 "@ 3/H*6N6 $#)KL/F09 0J/#/ *6 $F "E_/?0*,/ L"#$% %$H 0J$0 *6

E*F-*F) "F "K# $?0*"F64 IJ*6 *6 0J/ /,*-/F?/ *F F//- "@ /O(%$F$0*"F4 IJ/ 6/?"F- ($#0

*F,"%,/6 $F *F@/#/F?/P 0J/ -#$H*F) "@ $ ?"F?%K6*"FP "F 0J/ E$6*6 "@ 0J*6 /,*-/F?/4 3/H*6

$#)K/- 0J$0 0J/ L"#$% %$H 0J$0 0/%%6 K6 J"H H/ "K)J0 0" E/J$,/ )*,/6 K6 ?"L(/%%*F)

#/$6"F 0" E/%*/,/ *F M"-4 T/#J$(6 3/H*6 ",/#60$0/- J*6 ?$6/ *F -#$H*F) 6K?J $ -/@*F*0*,/

?"F?%K6*"FP EK0 0J/ /,*-/F?/ *6 60*%% 6K))/60*,/P $F- *0 *6 ,/#2 LK?J $ %*,/ *66K/ H"#0J

(K#6K*F)WHJ/0J/# 0J/ L"#$% %$H )*,/6 K6 $0 %/$60 6"L/ 6*)F*@*?$F0 #/$6"F 0" E/%*/,/4

3/H*6 -#/H J*6 *F@/#/F?/ $@0/# F$##"H*F) -"HF 0J/ ("0/F0*$% $??"KF06 "@ 0J/ L"#$% %$H

0" F$0K#$%*6L $F- #/%*)*"F4 \$0K#$%*6L *6 0J/ ,*/H 0J$0 0J/ (J26*?$% H"#%- *6 $%% 0J/#/*6P $F- E/J*F- *0 *6 F" K%0*L$0/ ($00/#F "# (%$F "# (K#("6/4 IH/F0*/0Jf?/F0K#2 .#*0*6J

(J*%"6"(J/# $F- $0J/*60 ./#0#$F- YK66/%% "F?/ J$KF0*F)%2 /F?$(6K%$0/- 0J*6 (*?0K#/ "@

#/$%*02 H*0J J*6 @$L"K6 [6?$@@"%-*F) "@ -/6($*#] %*0$F24


5/29

(#/66*F) "F K6 0" E/J$,/ *F ?/#0$*F H$26P $6 _K60 6K?J $ ?%K/ 0" -//(/# #/$%*024 5/ QF"H

$E"K0 0J*6 %$H E2 /O(/#*/F?*F) *06 (K%% "F K6 @#"L 0J/ *F6*-/P HJ*?J )*,/6 K6 #/$6"F 0"

0J*FQ "@ *0 $6 $ J*F0 "@ 6"L/0J*F) L"#/P $F *F0*L$0*"F "@ 6"L/0J*F) E/2"F- 0J/ KF*,/#6/4

8F 0J/ "F%2 (%$?/ 0" %""Q @"# /,*-/F?/ "@ 6"L/0J*F) 0#$F6?/F-/F0P H/ @*F- *04:D

IJ/ 6"K#?/ "@ 0J*6 L"#$% "E%*)$0*"F *6FN0 %*Q/%2 0" E/ L/#/ L$00/#4 'F /,"%K0*"F$#2

$??"KF0 "@ ,""0-17( %, "# 8"0-",( -1P 6$2P L"#$% "E%*)$0*"F *6 ?/#0$*F%2 ("66*E%/P EK0 J"H

H"K%- F$0K#$%*6L /O(%$*F "E%*)$0*"F *06/%@g ^"H ?"%%/?0*"F6 "@ $0"L6 ?"K%- )/F/#$0/

$F- *66K/ )/FK*F/%2 E*F-*F) L"#$% ?"LL$F-6 *6 $%0")/0J/# L260/#*"K6P *@ F"0 $E6K#-4

X"F0/L("#$#2 F$0K#$%*60*? /0J*?*60 Y*?J$#- ."2- *-/F0*@*/6 )""-F/66 H*0J $ ?%K60/# "@

/L(*#*?$% (#"(/#0*/6P $L"F) 0J/L 0J/ 6$0*6@$?0*"F "@ LK0K$%%2 6K(("#0*,/ 6"?*$% JKL$F

F//-64:= XJ"*?/6 $#/ -//L/- L"#$% 0" 0J/ /O0/F0 0J$0 0J/2 6$0*6@2 6K?J F//-64 SK?J

$F $??"KF0 L*)J0 6//L 0" L$Q/ L"#$%*02 "E_/?0*,/P 2/0 *0N6 -*@@*?K%0 0" 6// J"H (K#/%2 /L(*#*?$% (#"(/#0*/6 ?"K%- #/$%%2 $??"KF0 @"# E*F-*F) "E%*)$0*"F "# *F0#*F6*? ,$%K/4 IJ/

$00/L(0 0" -/@*F/ L"#$%*02 *F 0/#L6 "@ 0J/ 6$0*6@$?0*"F "@ "K# -/6*#/6 0#*/6 0" #/(%$?/

0J/*6LN6 "E_/?0*,/ $??"KF0 "@ ,$%K/ $F- L/$F*F) H*0J 6KE_/?0*,/ 6$0*6@$?0*"FP EK0 0J/

/O?J$F)/ %/$,/6 K6 H"#6/ "@@4 80 #/L$*F6 $ %/$( "@ E%*F- @$*0J 0" $@@*#L 0J$0 $F20J*F) %*Q/

"E_/?0*,/ "E%*)$0*"F H"K%- /L/#)/ @#"L 6K?J /L(*#*?$% (#"(/#0*/64:` U"# 0J$0 L$00/#P

(/#6"F6 0J/L6/%,/6P /6(/?*$%%2 (/#6"F6 H*0J *F0#*F6*? ,$%K/ $F- -*)F*02P 6//L LK?J %/66

%*Q/%2 0" /L/#)/ @#"L ,$%K/%/66 *L(/#6"F$% 60K@@ 0J$F @#"L 0J/ *F0/F0*"F$% J$F- "@ $

(/#6"F$% X#/$0"#4

\"P *@ 0J/#/N6 6"L/0J*F) L"#/ J/#/P 3/H*6 6K))/606P *0N6 L"#/ %*Q/ $ L*F- 0J$F $

?"%%/?0*"F "@ $0"L6 "# 6/0 "@ /L(*#*?$% (#"(/#0*/64 IJ/ X$0J"%*? 0J*FQ/# 1"JF ^/F#2

\/HL$FP $ ?/F0K#2 E/@"#/ 3/H*6P J$- 6*L*%$#%2 $#)K/- 0J$0 "K# ?"F6?*/F?/P ($#0*?K%$#%2

"K# @//%*F)6 "@ )K*%0P %/$- K6 0" ?"F?%K-/ M"- /O*6064:C U//%*F)6 "@ ?"F6?*/F?/ $#/

"@0/F -*#/?0/- 0"H$#- @/%%"H JKL$F E/*F)6P EK0 6"L/0*L/6 "K# @//%*F)6 "@ )K*%0 "#

6J$L/P HJ*?J H/ 0$Q/ $6 /,*-/F?/ 0" 6K))/60 0J$0 H/ J$,/ "@@/F-/- 6"L/"F/P %$?Q

$F $((#"(#*$0/ JKL$F 0$#)/04 8@ 6K?J @//%*F)6 $#/ $((#"(#*$0/P 0J/2 LK60 0J/F J$,/ $

F"FJKL$F "F/4 7K# @//%*F)6 "@ #/6("F6*E*%*02P 6J$L/P $F- @/$# /L$F$0*F) @#"L "K#

?"F6?*/F?/ *L(%2 0J$0 [0J/#/ *6 7F/ 0" HJ"L H/ $#/ #/6("F6*E%/P E/@"#/ HJ"L H/ $#/

$6J$L/-P HJ"6/ ?%$*L6 K("F K6 H/ @/$#4]:c

8F $ 6*L*%$# ,/*FP 3/H*6N6 /66/F0*$% $#)KL/F0 ?$F E/ 6KLL$#*R/- %*Q/ 0J*69 IJ/#/ $#/

"E_/?0*,/ L"#$% @$?06P $L"F) 0J/L )K*%0 @"# H#"F)-"*F) $F- -K0*/6 H/ $#/ "E%*)/- 0"

"E/2 $F- $#/ #/6("F6*E%/ @"# F/)%/?0*F)P $F- 6K?J "E_/?0*,/ @$?06 $#/ E/00/# /O(%$*F/-

E2 $ #/%*)*"K6 KF-/#60$F-*F) "@ #/$%*02 0J$F E2 $ YK66/%%*$F H"#%-4 S" L"#$%*02 )*,/6 K6

6"L/ 6*)F*@*?$F0 (#/%*L*F$#2 #/$6"F 0" E/%*/,/ *F M"-4


6/29


7/29

/O*60/F?/4 7F/ "@ 0J/ L"60 *F0/#/60*F) -*6?K66*"F6 "@ 0J/6/ *66K/6 ?"L/6 @#"L ̂ /F#2

S*-)H*?QP 0J/ F*F/0//F0Jf?/F0K#2 $K0J"# "@ ;+" 2"*+%'( %,


8/29

$F- 6/%@f/,*-/F?/ "@ L"#$%*024 8F-//-P $#)K$E%2 6K?J ?%$#*02 "@ @"KF-$0*"F$% L"#$% 0#K0J6

*6 F/?/66$#2 @"# $F2 L"#$% $#)KL/F0 @"# M"- 0" H"#QP @"# 0J/ /,*-/F?/ "F HJ*?J 6K?J

$#)KL/F0 #/%*/6 J$6 0" E/ $0 %/$60 $6 ?%/$# $6 0J/ ?"F?%K6*"F4 .K0 HJ/#/$6 3/H*6 0J"K)J0

0J$0 60#"F)%2 /,*-/F0 L"#$% @$?06 "# 0#K0J6 ?#2 "K0 @"# $ )""- /O(%$F$0*"FP S*-)H*?Q

0J"K)J0 0J$0 6K?J 0#K0J6 /%*L*F$0/ 0J/ F//- @"# @K#0J/# /O(%$F$0*"F4

X#*0*?6 "@ G$F0N6 L"#$% $#)KL/F0 $0 0J*6 _KF?0K#/ L*)J0 ?$60*)$0/ *0 @"# 0J/ #/$6"F 0J$0

*0 $((/$#6 0" E/ 6K))/60*F) 0J$0 L"#$%*02 ($26P "# /,/F 0J$0 #/%*)*"K6 /0J*?6 *6 $%0")/0J/#

0"" L/#?/F$#2P (/#J$(6 /,/F /)"*60*?P 0" ZK$%*@2 $6 $ %/)*0*L$0/ L"#$% 0J/"#24

IJ*6 ?#*0*?*6LP 0J"K)JP *6 E$6/- "F $ 6J$%%"H KF-/#60$F-*F) "@ 0J/ $#)KL/F04 IJ/ ?%$*L

*6 F"0 0J$0 H/ 6J"K%- E/ L"#$% 0" /$#F $ #/H$#-j G$F0 ?/#0$*F%2 0J"K)J0 F" 6K?J 0J*F)4

^/ H$6 $-$L$F0 *F *F6*60*F) 0J$0 "K# L"#$% L"0*,$0*"F6 ?"K%- F"0 /,/F ("66*E%2 E/

L/#?/F$#2P "# 0J/2 H"K%-FN0 E/ -*60*F?0*,/%2 6%&40 $0 $%%4 Y$0J/#P 0J/ ?%$*L *6 0J$0P *F

$ (#$?0*?$% H$2P H/ J$,/ 0" E/%*/,/ 0J$0 L"#$%*02 L$Q/6 6/F6/P 0J$0 *0N6 -//(%2 #""0/-

"F 6"%*- @"KF-$0*"F6P $F- 0J$0 0J/ ?"F0/O0 H/ %*,/ *F *6 0J"#"K)J%2 L"#$% $@0/# $%%P *@ H/

$#/ )"*F) 0" #/L$*F $-/ZK$0/%2 ?"LL*00/- 0" L"#$%*024 IJ$0 H/ LK60 E/%*/,/ L"#$%*02

0" E/ #$0*"F$%P $F- 0J$0 L"#$%*02 ?"##/6("F-6 H*0J "K# K%0*L$0/ 6/%@f*F0/#/60P *6 @$#

@#"L 6$2*F) 0J$0 L"#$%*02 -/L$F-6 0J$0 H/ E/ L"0*,$0/- E2 1%*+-17 85* 6/%@f*F0/#/604

I" 0J/ ?"F0#$#2P *0N6 %*Q/%2 0J$0 6/%@f*F0/#/60/- L"0*,$0*"F #/ZK*#/6 0J/ &"1519-4*-%1

"@ (K#/ 6/%@f*F0/#/604 80N6 F"0 *F "K# 6/%@f*F0/#/60 0" E/ ?"F?/#F/- "F%2 $E"K0 "K# 6/%@f

*F0/#/60P ($#$-"O*?$%%2P _K60 $6 0J/ E/60 H$2 0" $00$*F J$((*F/66 *6 0" E/ ?"F?/#F/- $E"K0

6"L/0J*F) "0J/# 0J$F J$((*F/664

I" 6$2 0J$0 L"#$%*02 #/ZK*#/6 0J$0 H/ "??$6*"F$%%2 "# "@0/F LK60 E/J$,/ @"# 0J/ 6$Q/

"@ "0J/#6 *F $ 6(*#*0 "@ )/FK*F/ $%0#K*6L *6 F"0 0" 6$2 0J$0 L"#$%*02 /,/# -/L$F-6 0J$0

H/ LK60 E/J$,/ *F $ H$2 0J$0 )"/6 $)$*F60 "K# "HF K%0*L$0/ 6/%@f*F0/#/604 8F "0J/#

H"#-6P $ #/_/?0*"F "@ /)"*6L -"/6FN0 *L(%2 0J$0 $ J/$%0J2 ?"F?/#F @"# 6/%@f*F0/#/60 *6

?"F0#$#2 0" L"#$%*024 !"#$%*02 L$2 ?$%% "F K6 0" 6$?#*@*?/ "K# "HF 6J"#0f0/#L *F0/#/606P

L$2E/ /,/F "K# %*,/6P EK0 *F $ 0J/*60*? H"#%-P 0J*6 *6FN0 0J/ 6$L/ $6 6$?#*@*?*F) "K# "HF

K%0*L$0/ 6/%@f*F0/#/60P E/?$K6/ 0J/ 6"#06 "@ E/F/@*06 -/#*,/- @#"L $ YK66/%%*$F H"#%-

-"FN0 /OJ$K60 $%% 0J/ E/F/@*06 0J/#/ $#/4 5/ H*%% $#)K/ E/%"H 0J$0 0J/ -K$%*6L "@ (#$?0*?$%

#/$6"F -*6$((/$#6 *F $ 0J/*60*? H"#%- *F HJ*?J L"#$%*02 #/606 "F 0J/ -//(/60 @"KF-$0*"F6("66*E%/P HJ/#/$6 *0 #/L$*F6 $F KF#/6"%,/-P (/#J$(6 *F0#$?0$E%/P (#"E%/L @"# 0J/

F$0K#$%*604

IJ"6/ 7-- 7E%*)$0*"F6

X%"6/%2 #/%$0/- 0" S*-)H*?QN6 (#$?0*?$% #/$6"F -*%/LL$ *6 HJ$0N6 6"L/0*L/6 #/@/##/- 0" $6

0J/ "--F/66 "@ L"#$% "E%*)$0*"F64 X"F0/L("#$#2 /0J*?*60 Y*?J$#- "#$ (- & .#$F-0 ?%$*L6

0J$0 H/ ?$FF"0 -/@/F- 6J*#Q*F) "K# L"#$% -K02 E2 ?%$*L*F) 0J$0 -*6?J$#)*F) 0J$0 -K02

H"K%-FN0 6$0*6@2 "F/N6 [#/@%/?0*,/ (#/@/#/F?/64] !"#$% -K0*/6P $0 %/$60 0J"6/ F"0 F/)$0/-


9/29

E2 "0J/# ?"L(/%%*F) /F"K)J #/$6"F6P $#/ 0J"K)J0 0" ?"F@/# "E%*)$0*"F6 0J$0 H/ F//- 0"

(/#@"#L /,/F *@ -"*F) 6" *6 F"0 6"L/0J*F) H/ H$F0 0" -"4 IJ*6P $)$*FP *6 ($#0 "@ HJ$0

3/H*6 H$6 )/00*F) $0 *F #/@/##*F) 0" L"#$%*02N6 $K0J"#*02 ",/# K64 !"#$%*02 -"/6FN0 0/%% K6

_K60 0" -" 0J"6/ 0J*F)6 H/ $%#/$-2 H$F0 0" -"4 S"L/0*L/6 *0 0/%%6 K6 0" -" HJ$0 H/ '%1>*

H$F0 0" -"P "# F"0 0" -" HJ$0 H/ '% H$F0 0" -"4 80N6 *F?"F,/F*/F0 *F 0J$0 H$2 @#"L 0*L/

0" 0*L/4

S*-)H*?Q -*6?K66/- J"H L"#$%*02 L*)J0 F"0 $%H$26 ?"F-K?/ 0" "K# J$((*F/66P $F- *6FN0

0J*6 _K60 HJ$0 H/ 6"L/0*L/6 @*F- 6" J$#- 0" 0$Q/ $E"K0 L"#$%*02g 5/ ?$F E/)*F 0" 0J*FQ

0J$0 *0 -/(#*,/6 K6 "@ @KF "# "@ 0J/ ?J$F?/ 0" -" HJ$0 H*%% )*,/ K6 )#/$0 J$((*F/66 $F-

/F_"2L/F04 5J/F/,/# $F2"F/ -"/6 6"L/0J*F) J/ )/FK*F/%2 0J*FQ6 *6 H#"F)P *6FN0 *0

%*Q/%2 0J$0 J/N6 ?J""6*F) 0" )*,/ (#*"#*02 0" 0J/ #K6J $F- 0J#*%% "@ 0J/ @"#E*--/F E2 (K00*F)

(%/$6K#/ E/@"#/ HJ$0 *6 #*)J0g

T%$0" 0J"K)J0 0J$0 F"E"-2 H"K%- /,/# QF"H*F)%2 ?J""6/ 0J/ E$-P 0J$0 *@ H/ L$Q/

$ ?J"*?/ 0" -" 6"L/0J*F)P *0 6J"H6 0J$0 H/ 0J*FQ 0J/ ?J"*?/ *6 )""-4 5#"F)-"*F) *6

"F%2 -"F/ "K0 "@ *)F"#$F?/P "F 0J*6 ,*/H4 .K0 0J/#/ $#/ "0J/# ("66*E%/ /O(%$F$0*"F6

0J$0 $??"KF0 @"# H#"F)-"*F)P *F?%K-*F) 2*/%-*F) 0" 0/L(0$0*"FP H/$QF/66 "@ H*%%P $F-

?"##K(0*"F "@ ?J$#$?0/#4 ')$*FP $6 3/H*6 6$*-P H/ $%% @$%% 6J"#0 @#"L 0*L/ 0" 0*L/4 8F "K#

(#/6/F0 ?*#?KL60$F?/6 H/ #/L$*F *L(/#@/?04 5/ $#/ $%% ZK*0/ @$L*%*$# H*0J 0J/ %K#/ "@

0/L(0$0*"FP $6 H/ $#/ H*0J "K# (/F?J$F0 @"# #$0*"F$%*R*F) "K# $?0*"F64 ' #$0*"F$%*R$0*"F

H/ J$,/ $%% E//F *F?%*F/- 0" K6/ *6 0" ZK/60*"F HJ/0J/# 0J/ $?0*"F H$6 #/$%%2 H#"F) $@0/#

$%%4 5J/F "K# ?J"*?/6 @$%% E/%"H 0J/ -*?0$0/6 "@ L"#$%*02 $F- H/ QF"H *0P "F/ #/6("F6/0" 0J/ #/6K%0*F) )K*%0 *6 0" $?QF"H%/-)/ "K# 6J"#0?"L*F)P EK0 $F"0J/# *6 0" %"H/# 0J/

60$F-$#-P "# /,/F 0" -/F2 $%0")/0J/# 0J/ /O*60/F?/ "@ 0J/ L"#$% 60$F-$#-4

IJ*6 *6 _K60 HJ/F *F0/%%/?0K$% -"KE06 $E"K0 0J/ @"KF-$0*"F6 "@ L"#$%*02 ?$F %""Q

,/#2 $00#$?0*,/4 !"#$%*02 H*/%-6 $K0J"#*02 $F- *F-K?/6 )K*%0P $F- H/ ?$F E/)*F 0"

#/6/F0 *04 5/ 60$#0 0" H"F-/# *@ L"#$%*02 *6 $%% *0N6 ?#$?Q/- K( 0" E/P *@ *0N6 $F20J*F)

L"#/ 0J$F $F *F0/#F$%*R$0*"F "@ ($#/F0$% 0/$?J*F)6P 6"?*$% L"#/6P "# L/#/ ?"F,/F0*"F

$F- ?"F-*0*"F*F)4 iF%/66 L"#$%*02 ?"F0*FK/6 0" E/ KF-/#60""- $6 #/60*F) "F 6"%*-

@"KF-$0*"F6P *06 $K0J"#*02 ?"L/6 *F0" ZK/60*"FP $F- KF-/#60$F-$E%2 6"4 5J2 0$Q/

6/#*"K6%2P @"# /O$L(%/P $F "E%*)$0*"F 0" @"#)" "F/N6 (#/@/#/F?/6 $F- 0" -" *F60/$- HJ$0"F/ L$2 F"0 H$F0 0" -"g +" "E%*)$0*"F6 #/$%%2 E*F- K6 /,/F *@ 0J/2 -"FN0 ?"##/6("F- H*0J

"K# #/@%/?0*,/ (#/@/#/F?/6g

8@ 0J/2 -" J"%- 0J*6 $K0J"#*02P 0J/F L"#$% "E%*)$0*"F6P /6(/?*$%%2 *F $ YK66/%%*$F H"#%-P

?$F 6//L 0" E/ #$0J/# "-- /F0*0*/64 S" 6$26 M/"#)/ !$,#"-/6 *F #/(%2 0" .#$F-0N6 ?%$*L

0J$0 -K02 ?$F /O?//- "K# #/@%/?0*,/ (#/@/#/F?/64 [IJ*6 "#$ (. & *6 _K60 0" E#*F) 0J/ ZK//#

/%/L/F0 E$?Q *FP] !$,#"-/6 H#*0/6P [80 *6 0" 6K(("6/ 0J$0 E/6*-/6 0J/ kQ*F- "@ (/#6"Fh 8

$L $F- L2 ($#0*?K%$# ($00/#F "@ k?$#/6h $F- *F0/#/606 0J/#/ *6 6"L/0J*F) /%6/P L2 -K02P


10/29

HJ*?J L$2 )" $)$*F60 0J/6/ $F- *F $F2 ?$6/ (#"(/#%2 ",/##*-/6 0J/L4]D= !"#$% @$?06P

"E%*)$0*"F6 *F ($#0*?K%$#P -*#/?0 K6 0" $?0*"F *F $ H$2 0J$0 F" L/#/%2 -/6?#*(0*,/ @$?0

?J$#$?0/#*R*F) 0J/ H"#%- ?$F -"4 !"#$%*02 ?"F@/#6 "E%*)$0*"F6 $F- ?"F60#$*F06 F"0 _K60"F "K# E/J$,*"#P EK0 /,/F "F "K# L"0*,$0*"F64 S$,*F) $ -#"HF*F) ?J*%- *F 0J/ J"(/ "@

/$#F*F) $ #/H$#-P 0J"K)J #/6K%0*F) *F $ )""- ?"F6/ZK/F?/P *6 60*%% )/F/#$%%2 0J"K)J0 "@ $6

%/66 0J$F /O/L(%$#2 E/J$,*"#4 !"#$%*02 $6?#*E/6 (#$*6/ $F- E%$L/P "@0/F *F-/(/F-/F0%2

"@ HJ/0J/# 0J/ L"#$% $)/F0N6 (/#6"F$% *F0/#/60 "# $-,$F0$)/ *6 6$0*6@*/-P $F- *0 (#",*-/6

*F0#*F6*? L"0*,/6 0" ,*#0K/ H*0J"K0 $%H$26 (#",*-*F) "E,*"K6 $-,$F0$)/6 0J$0 L"0*,$0/

0J/ #*)J0 E/J$,*"#4

e#*Q 14 5*/%/FE/#) 0#*/6 0" -*L*F*6J 0J/ ("H/# "@ !$,#"-/6N6 $#)KL/F0 E2 ?$60*F)

J*L $6 L/#/%2 6K))/60*F) 0J$0 $ KF*,/#6/ 0J$0N6 @KF-$L/F0$%%2 KF_K60 H"K%- E/ $F

$E6K#- H"#%-P )*,*F) K6 #/$6"F 0" E/%*/,/ *F $ -*,*F/ )K$#$F0// "@ (/#@/?0 _K60*?/4 IJ/F 5*/%/FE/#) #*-*?K%/6 6K?J $ ,*/H E2 ?*0*F) ./#0#$F- YK66/%%N6 $F$%")2 "@ @*F-*F) $

?#$0/ "@ "#$F)/6 HJ"6/ 0"( %$2/# *6 $%% E$-P $F- *F@/##*F) "F 0J*6 E$6*6 0J$0 0J/ "#$F)/6

KF-/#F/$0J LK60 E/ )""- 0" #/-#/66 0J/ E$%$F?/4 .K0 5*/%/FE/#) ?$FN0 6" /$6*%2 /,$-/

0J/ @"#?/ "@ !$,#"-/6N6 ("*F0 *F J*6 $#0*?%/P E/?$K6/ 0J/ /O*60/F?/ "@ E*F-*F) L"#$%

"E%*)$0*"F6 *6 J$#-/# 0" 6ZK$#/ H*0J $ F$0K#$%*60*? ?"F0/O0 0J$F $ 6K(/#F$0K#$%*60*?

"F/4 e%6/HJ/#/ *F J*6 E""QP 5*/%/FE/#) 0#*/6 0" 0K#F 0J/ 0$E%/6 ?"L(%/0/%2 "F 0J/

0J/*606P ?"F0#$60*F) 0J/L H*0J )#"HFfK(6 HJ" [#/?")F*R/ 0J$0 0J/ @$?0 0J$0 $ )*,/F

$?0*"F *6 L"#$%%2 "E%*)$0"#2 *6 *06/%@ $F ",/##*-*F) #/$6"F @"# (/#@"#L*F) 0J$0 $?0*"F4

' L"#$%%2 "E%*)$0"#2 $?0*"F *6 $F $?0*"F 0J$0 "F/ +4( 0" -" HJ/0J/# "F/ $41*( 0" -"

*0 "# F"04 Y/H$#-6 $F- (KF*6JL/F06 L$2 (#",*-/ 4''-*-%140 #/$6"F6 @"# -"*F) HJ$0

H/ L"#$%%2 "K)J0 0" -"P EK0 0J/2 -" F"0 ?"F60*0K0/ 0J/ %10# #/$6"F6 @"# -"*F) 6"4]D`

5*/%/FE/#) "E,*"K6%2 H$F06 0" $@@*#L 0J/ /O*60/F?/ "@ L"#$% #/$%*6L *F $ 60#"F) 6/F6/

J/#/P 6"KF-*F) LK?J %*Q/ 3/H*6P EK0 H*0J"K0 ?"L*F) 0" 0/#L6 H*0J _K60 J"H -//(%2

F$0K#$%*6L *6 $0 "--6 H*0J 6K?J #/$%*6L4 ^"H -" 6K?J "K)J06 /O*60 *F $ H"#%- HJ/#/ H/

$#/ ?$K6$%%2 -/0/#L*F/- 0" E/J$,/ _K60 $6 H/ -"g ^"H -" 6K?J E*F-*F) "E%*)$0*"F6 ?"L/

0" "E0$*Fg ^*6 F$0K#$%*60 $%%*/6 J$,/ "@0/F E//F 0J/ ,/#2 "F/6 L"60 ?"F0#*EK0*F) 0" 0J/

%"66 "@ ?"F@*-/F?/ *F 6K?J L"#$% #/$%*6LP #/F-/#*F) *0 L"#/ 0J$F $ %*00%/ -*6*F)/FK"K6 @"#

J*L 0" 0#/$0 0J/*6L $6 0J/ E*))/# ?K%(#*0 KF-/#L*F*F) 6K?J 0#$-*0*"F$% ?"F,*?0*"F64

\"H *@ 6K?J L"#$% @$?06 #/$%%2 /O*60P 0J/ )%$#*F) ZK/60*"F 0J$0 E/?Q"F6 0" E/ $F6H/#/- *6

J"H 0J/2 ?"K%- /,/# J$,/ $#*6/F *F $ F$0K#$%*60*? H"#%-4 !"#$% -K0*/6 *L("6/ "E%*)$0*"F6

0J$0 F//- 0" E/ "E/2/- /,/F *@ 0J/2 -"FN0 $%H$26 ?"##/6("F- H*0J "K# ?$#/6 $F- *F0/#/6064

IJ/2 _K60*@2 "# #/ZK*#/ (#$*6/ $F- E%$L/ @"# $?0*"F6 ?"LL*00/- "# "L*00/-P $F-

0J/2 #/ZK*#/ $ (K#*02 "@ L"0*,$0*"F4 '6 "#$ (/ & 3/H*6 (K0 *0P J"H ?"K%- E*06 "@ L$00/#

)/F/#$0/ 6K?J $K0J"#*0$0*,/ -/L$F-6g 80N6 F" H"F-/# 0J$0 0J/ *F@%K/F0*$% 0H/F0*/0Jf

?/F0K#2 $0J/*60 14 34 !$?Q*/ H#"0/P [!"#$% (#"(/#0*/6 ?"F60*0K0/ 6" "-- $ ?%K60/# "@

(#"(/#0*/6 $F- #/%$0*"F6 0J$0 0J/2 $#/ L"60 KF%*Q/%2 0" J$,/ $#*6/F *F 0J/ ?"K#6/ "@

/,/F06 H*0J"K0 $F $%%f("H/#@K% )"- 0" ?#/$0/ 0J/L4]DC !$?Q*/ J$- *F L*F- $ -*,*F/%2


11/29

"#-/#/- F$0K#$%*60*? /O(%$F$0*"F #$0J/# 0J$F 0#$F6?/F-/F0 T%$0"F*? L"#$% 0#K0J64 ^*6

*-/$ H$6 0J$0 L"#$% @$?06P $6 0#$-*0*"F$%%2 ?"F?/*,/-P ($#0*?K%$#%2 0J"6/ (/#0$*F*F) 0"

"E%*)$0*"FP /OJ*E*0 @/$0K#/6 6" 60#$F)/ 0J$0 0J/*# $((/$#$F?/ *F $ F$0K#$%*60*? H"#%-

6//L6 F"0J*F) %/66 0J$F L*#$?K%"K64 'F- KF@"#0KF$0/%2P L*#$?%/6 -" F"0 6*0 H/%% *F $

F$0K#$%*60*? H"#%-l U"# 0J*6 #/$6"FP $6 $F $0J/*60P !$?Q*/ J*L6/%@ @"KF- 0J/ F"0*"F "@

0J/*# /O*60/F?/ $%0")/0J/# -KE*"K64

7E,*"K6%2P $F2 6K?J #/_/?0*"F "@ L"#$% @$?06P "# KF-/#60$F-*F) "@ 0J/L $6 /%$E"#$0/

L*60$Q/6 "# )#$F- -/%K6*"F6P H"K%- #"E 0J/ L"#$% $#)KL/F0 @"# M"-N6 /O*60/F?/ "@ *06

(/#6K$6*,/ ("H/#4 80N6 $F $#)KL/F0 0J$0 ?$F "F%2 J"(/ 0" 6H$2 0J"6/ HJ" J$,/ @*#L

?"F,*?0*"F6 $E"K0 L"#$%*024 !$?Q*/ %$?Q/- "# %"60 6K?J ?"F,*?0*"FP EK0 L$F2 H"K%-

-*6$)#// H*0J J*LP 6K))/60*F) 0J$0 0J/2 ?$FN0 6J$Q/ 0J/*# ?"F,*?0*"F 0J$0 0J/ $K0J"#*02

"@ L"#$%*02 *6 KF-/F*$E%/4 IJ/2 L$2 #/?")F*R/ H*0J*F 0J/L6/%,/6 0J/ 0/L(0$0*"F0" ZK/60*"F 0J/ E*F-*F) ("H/# "@ L"#$%*02P /6(/?*$%%2 HJ/F 0J/ (%/$6K#/ (#"J*E*0/-

"# *F?"F,/F*/F?/ *L("6/- *6 )#/$04 IJ/2 H*%% /,/FP "F "??$6*"FP @$%% 6J"#0 $F- L$2

#$0*"F$%*R/ 0J/*# -"*F) 6" E2 $00/L(0*F) 0" %"H/# 0J/ L"#$% 60$F-$#-4 .K0 @/H $L"F) K6

-/?*-/ 0" 60"( #/6(/?0*F) 0J/ L"#$% %$H $%0")/0J/#4 e,/F 0J"6/ HJ" -/?*-/ 0" *)F"#/ *0

60*%% "@0/F E/%*/,/ *F *0P $0 %/$60 @"# $ HJ*%/4 '0 %/$60 (%6" L"#$% @$?06 6//L 0" *L("6/ $F

"E%*)$0*"F "F K6 0J$0 $((%*/6 *##/6(/?0*,/ "@ HJ/0J/# H/ H$F0 0" "E/2 *0 "# F"04 IJ/ L"#$%

$#)KL/F0 -"/6FN0 F/?/66$#*%2 F//- L$F2 6K?J $E6"%K0/P F"FF/)"0*$E%/ "E%*)$0*"F6P EK0 *0

F//-6 $0 %/$60 6"L/4 IJ"6/ HJ" 0J*FQ 0J$0 0J/ L"#$% $#)KL/F0 J$6 6K?J #/6"K#?/6 $0 *06

-*6("6$% H"K%- E/ L"#/ %*Q/%2 0" E/%*/,/ 0J$0 *0 #/0$*F6 )#/$0 ("0/F0*$%4

S"L/ L$2 $00/L(0 0" E%KF0 0J*6 @"#?/ E2 ("*F0*F) "K0 0J/ @$*%K#/6 "@ 0J"6/ HJ" J"%-

$ 60#"F) ,*/H "@ "E%*)$0*"F4 S*L"F .%$?QEK#FP @"# *F60$F?/P ?"F0/F-6 0J$0 [(/"(%/

HJ" 0$%Q LK?J "@ "E%*)$0*"F $((#"$?J (#$?0*?$% %*@/ H*0J $ ?/#0$*F Q*F- "@ $#L"K#2P

$F- "F/ 0J$0 L$2 L$Q/ 0J/L *F6/F6*0*,/P ?#K/%P *FJ"6(*0$E%/ 0" KF-/#60$F-*F) $F-

/O?K6/64 V ̂ *60"#2 6J"H6 (%/F02 "@ /O$L(%/6 HJ/#/ L"#$%*R*F) E#*F)6 F"0J*F) EK0

-*6$60/#4]Dc 5/ ?$F ?"F?/-/ LK?J "@ 0J*6 HJ*%/ *F6*60*F) 0J$0 *0 -/0#$?06 %*00%/ @#"L

0J/ F//- 0" $??"KF0 @"# 0J/ @"#?/ "@ )/FK*F/ "E%*)$0*"F64 e,/F *@ 0J/ %$F)K$)/ "@

L"#$% "E%*)$0*"F6 J$6 E//F $EK6/-P $F- /,/F *@P $6 *6 ?/#0$*F%2 0#K/P "E%*)$0*"F6 -"FN0

L$Q/ K( $%% "@ /0J*?6P 0J/2 #/L$*F $F *L("#0$F0 (*/?/ "@ 0J/ L"#$% (KRR%/ *F F//- "@

$-/ZK$0/ /O(%$F$0*"F4 !"#/",/#P 0J/ F"0*"F "@ )/FK*F/ "E%*)$0*"F (#",*-/6 0J/ E$6*6

@"# #/?")F*R*F) $F- ?"##/?0*F) 0J"6/ ,/#2 $EK6/6 0J$0 .%$?QEK#F *-/F0*@*/6l 70J/#H*6/P

.%$?QEK#FN6 ?"L(%$*F0 %"6/6 *06 /-)/ ?"L(%/0/%24

"#$ (% & Y/?$%% S*-)H*?QN6 ?"F,*?0*"F 0J$0 L"#$%*02 -"/6FN0 F//- )#"KF-*F) E/?$K6/ "@

*06 "E,*"K6F/664 ̂ *6 *-/$ H$6 0J$0 L"#$%*02P -/6(*0/ 0J/ (#$?0*?$% -K$%*6L (#"E%/L6 *0

)/F/#$0/6P *6 6" "E,*"K6%2 0#K/ 0J$0 F" #/%*)*"K6 "# 0J/"%")*?$% @"KF-$0*"F *6 ?$%%/- @"#4

!$?Q*/P "F 0J/ "0J/# J$F-P ?"F_/?0K#/- 0J$0 H*0J"K0 M"- *0N6 KF%*Q/%2 0J$0 L"#$%*02P

)*,/F *06 "-- @/$0K#/6P *6 0#K/4 5/ ?"F6*-/# E"0J 0J*FQ/#6 0" E/ #*)J0 *F "F/ H$2P $F-


12/29

H#"F) *F $F"0J/#4 5/ $)#// H*0J S*-)H*?Q $E"K0 0J/ "E,*"K6F/66 "@ L"#$% 0#K0JP EK0

-*6$)#// H*0J J*L 0J$0 0J*6 $%%"H6 L"#$%*02 0" -*6(/F6/ H*0J 0J/ F//- @"# @"KF-$0*"F64

5/ $)#// H*0J !$?Q*/ 0J$0 L"#$% "E%*)$0*"F6 6//L "-- *F ?/#0$*F #/6(/?06P /6(/?*$%%2

*F $ F$0K#$%*60*? H"#%-P EK0 H/ -*6$)#// H*0J 0J/ ?J"*?/ 0" )*,/ K( J*6 E/%*/@ *F L"#$%*02

$6 ?%$66*?$%%2 ?"F60#K/-4 8F60/$-P H/ 6K))/60 0J$0 $ @*#L (#*"# ?"F,*?0*"F "@ L"#$% 0#K0J

(#",*-/6 )""- #/$6"F 0" /F0/#0$*F $ 6K(/#F$0K#$% H"#%-,*/H4 ' (*?0K#/ "@ #/$%*02 *F HJ*?J

$%% %*@/ *6 F" L"#/ 0J$F $ (#"-K?0 "@ E%*F- F$0K#$%*60*? @"#?/6 $F- @"#0K*0"K6 ?"%%"?$0*"F6

"@ L"%/?K%/6 *6 @KF-$L/F0$%%2 %/66 $-/ZK$0/ 0" KF-/#H#*0/ L"#$%*02 0J$F $ (/#6"F$%

KF*,/#6/ ?#/$0/- $F- 6K60$*F/- E2 $ (/#@/?0%2 %",*F) M"-4 I#$-*0*"F$%%2 ?"F?/*,/- L"#$%

"E%*)$0*"F6P HJ*%/ #/6*-*F) ?"L@"#0$E%2 *F $ 0J/*60*? KF*,/#6/P $#/ *F?"F)#K"K6 *F $

(K#/%2 F$0K#$%*60*? H"#%-4

T%$0"F*6L $F- eO*60/F0*$%*6L 5/N,/ E//F 6K))/60*F) 0J$0 0J/ "E,*"K6 0#K0J "@ L"#$%*02 L*)J0 (#",*-/ /,*-/F?/ @"#

M"-N6 /O*60/F?/P $6 H/%% $6 #/$6"F 0" 0J*FQ 0J$0 0J*6 "E,*"K6 0#K0J -/(/F-6 K%0*L$0/%2

"F M"-4 '0 @*#60 )%$F?/P 6K?J $ ?%$*L L*)J0 6//L *L(%$K6*E%/P *@ F"0 *F?"F6*60/F04 8F

($#0*?K%$#P *0 L*)J0 6//L *F?"F6*60/F0 0" $#)K/ 0J$0 L"#$% 0#K0J *6 -/(/F-/F0 "F M"- *@

H/ ?$F QF"H *0 H*0J"K0 /,/F 0J*FQ*F) "@ M"-4 IJ*6 $%%/)/- *F?"F6*60/F?2 ?$F E/ -*6(/%%/-

*@ H/ #/?")F*R/P $6 FKL/#"K6 ?%$66*?$% 0J*FQ/#6 J$,/ ("*F0/- "K0P 0J$0 0J/ %&'"& %, 8"-17

*6 -*@@/#/F0 @#"L 0J/ %&'"& %, ?1%$-174 IJ$0 *6P 0J/ "#-/# *F HJ*?J H/ ?"L/ 0" QF"H

0J*F)6 L*)J0 E/ -*@@/#/F0 @#"L 0J/ "#-/# *F HJ*?J 0J*F)6 /O*60P "# J$,/ ?"L/ 0" /O*604

X/#0$*F L"#$% 0#K0J6 L*)J0 E/ $6 /,*-/F0 0" K6 $6 $F20J*F) ?$F E/P EK0 L$2 60*%% %/$,/KF$F6H/#/- 0J/ ZK/60*"F "@ HJ/#/ L"#$%*02 ?$L/ @#"L4 3*Q/H*6/P 0J/ @"KF-$0*"F6 "@

L"#$%*02 L*)J0 E/ $0 $ )#/$0/# -*60$F?/ @#"L K6 *F 0/#L6 "@ *LL/-*$0/ QF"H%/-)/ 0J$F

L"#$%*02 *06/%@4

IJ*6 *6 $ @KF-$L/F0$% -*60*F?0*"FP EK0 "F/ 0J$0 *6 "@0/F L*66/-P #/6K%0*F) *F F//-%/66

?"F@K6*"F4 Y/?/F0 E""Q6 -/@/F-*F) $0J/*6L J$,/ (/#(/0K$0/- 0J*6 ?"F@K6*"FP

KF@"#0KF$0/%2P EK0 F"0 6K#(#*6*F)%24 U"# *F60$F?/P Y*?J$#- +$HQ*F6 6//L6 0" *)F"#/ 0J*6

-*60*F?0*"F HJ/F J/ $6Q6P [*@ H/ J$,/ *F-/(/F-/F0 ?#*0/#*$ @"# ?J""6*F) $L"F) #/%*)*"K6

L"#$%*0*/6P HJ2 F"0 ?K0 "K0 0J/ L*--%/ L$F $F- )" 60#$*)J0 @"# 0J/ L"#$% ?J"*?/ H*0J"K0

0J/ #/%*)*"Fg]DA

"#$ (' & IJ/ *F0K*0*"F 0J$0 M"- $F- L"#$%*02 $#/ *F0*L$0/%2 #/%$0/- *6 $ -//( "F/ 0J$0

J$6 "@0/F E//F #/?")F*R/- E2 F"0/- 6("Q/6L/F "F E"0J 6*-/6 "@ 0J/ 0J/*6L>$0J/*6L

-*,*-/4 +"60"/,6Q2N6 @$L"K6 %*F/ 0J$0 *@ M"- -"/6FN0 /O*60P 0J/F /,/#20J*F) *6 (/#L*00/-P

*6 "F/ /?J" "@ 0J*6 0J/L/P $6 *6 0J/ M/#L$F (J*%"6"(J/# U#*/-#*?J \*/0R6?J/N6 ?"F@*-/F0

(#"?%$L$0*"F 0J$0 0J/ [-/$0J "@ M"-] 6J"K%- J$,/ @"# "F/ "@ *06 (#$?0*?$% "K0?"L/6 $

X"(/#F*?$F #/,"%K0*"F *F /0J*?64 '??"#-*F) 0" 0J*6 ,*/HP 6/%@*6JF/66 $F- (#*-/P (/#J$(6

/,/F #K0J%/66F/66 #*)J0%2 KF-/#60""-P 6J"K%- F"H /?%*(6/ 0#$-*0*"F$%%2 /O$%0/- L"#$%


13/29

,*#0K/6 %*Q/ JKL*%*02P $%0#K*6LP $F- ?"L($66*"F4 i(J"%-*F) 0#$-*0*"F$% L"#$%*02 $@0/#

0J/ -/$0J "@ M"- H$6FN0 \*/0R6?J/N6 ?"F?/#F4 80 H$6 #$0J/# J*6 $)/F-$ 0" /@@/?0 J*6

0#$F6,$%K$0*"F "@ ,$%K/6P *F $F /@@"#0 0" *F@K6/ )""-F/66 $)$*F H*0J 60#/F)0J $F-

J/#"*6L4

\*/0R6?J/ $F- !$?Q*/ H/#/ $0J/*606 HJ" 6$H 0J/ F"F/O*60/F?/ "@ M"- $6 L"#$%%2

#/%/,$F0P $F- U#/F?J /O*60/F0*$%*60 1/$F T$K% S$#0#/ H$6 $F"0J/#4 U"# 0J/6/ 0J*FQ/#6P

$0J/*6L -*-FN0 L/$F EK6*F/66 $6 K6K$% HJ/F *0 ?$L/ 0" /0J*?64 80 L/$F0 @KF-$L/F0$%

#/0J*FQ*F) "@ HJ$0 /0J*?6 *6 $%% $E"K0P E/?$K6/ 0J/2 #/?")F*R/- 0J/ %"F) J*60"#2 "@ $

(/#?/*,/- ?"FF/?0*"F E/0H//F M"- $F- L"#$%*024 IJ/2 0JK6 60$F- *F ?"F0#$60 0" 0J"6/

HJ" 0J*FQ 0J$0 /%*L*F$0*F) M"- @#"L 0J/ L"#$% /ZK$0*"F ?J$F)/6 %*00%/ "# 0J$0 *F?%K-*F)

M"- $--6 F"0J*F) "@ ?"F6/ZK/F?/4 IJ/ @"%%"H*F) ($66$)/ @#"L S$#0#/ *6 H"#0J ZK"0*F) $0

%/F)0J *F 0J*6 #/)$#-9I"H$#-6 :BB;P HJ/F 0J/ U#/F?J (#"@/66"#6 /F-/$,"#/- 0" @"#LK%$0/

$ 6/?K%$# L"#$%*02P 0J/2 6$*- 6"L/0J*F) %*Q/ 0J*69 M"- *6 $ K6/%/66

J2("0J/6*6P 6" H/ H*%% -" H*0J"K0 *04 ^"H/,/#P *@ H/ $#/ 0" J$,/ L"#$%*02P

$ 6"?*/02 $F- $ %$Hf$E*-*F) H"#%-P *0 *6 /66/F0*$% 0J$0 ?/#0$*F ,$%K/6

6J"K%- E/ 0$Q/F 6/#*"K6%2j 0J/2 LK60 J$,/ $F 4 /&-%&- /O*60/F?/ $6?#*E/-

0" 0J/L4 80 LK60 E/ ?"F6*-/#/- "E%*)$0"#2 4 /&-%&- 0" E/ J"F/60P F"0 0"

%*/P F"0 0" E/$0 "F/N6 H*@/P 0" E#*F) K( ?J*%-#/F $F- 6" @"#0Jj 6" H/ $#/

)"*F) 0" -" $ %*00%/ H"#Q "F 0J/ 6KE_/?0P HJ*?J H*%% /F$E%/ K6 0" 6J"H

0J$0 0J/6/ ,$%K/6 /O*60 $%% 0J/ 6$L/P *F6?#*E/- *F $F *F0/%%*)/F0 J/$,/F

$%0J"K)JP "@ ?"K#6/P 0J/#/ *6 F" M"-4 8F "0J/# H"#-6 V F"0J*F) H*%% E/?J$F)/- *@ M"- -"/6 F"0 /O*60j H/ 6J$%% -*6?",/# 0J/ 6$L/ F"#L6 "@

J"F/602P (#")#/66 $F- JKL$F*02P $F- H/ 6J$%% J$,/ -*6("6/- "@ M"-

$6 $F "K0f"@f-$0/ J2("0J/6*6 HJ*?J H*%% -*/ $H$2 ZK*/0%2 "@ *06/%@4 IJ/

/O*60/F0*$%*60P "F 0J/ ?"F0#$#2P @*F-6 *0 /O0#/L/%2 /LE$##$66*F) 0J$0 M"-

-"/6 F"0 /O*60P @"# 0J/#/ -*6$((/$#6 H*0J J*L $%% ("66*E*%*02 "@ @*F-*F)

,$%K/6 *F $F *F0/%%*)*E%/ J/$,/F4 IJ/#/ ?$F F" %"F)/# E/ $F2 )""- 4

/&-%&- P 6*F?/ 0J/#/ *6 F" *F@*F*0/ $F- (/#@/?0 ?"F6?*"K6F/66 0" 0J*FQ *04

80 *6 F"HJ/#/ H#*00/F 0J$0 [0J/ "#$ *) & )""-] /O*606P 0J$0 "F/ LK60 E/

J"F/60 "# LK60 F"0 %*/P 6*F?/ H/ $#/ F"H K("F 0J/ (%$F/ HJ/#/ 0J/#/ $#/

"F%2 L/F4DB

IJ*6 ($66$)/ *6 *F0/#/60*F) @"# 6/,/#$% #/$6"F6P F"0 %/$60 *F *06 ?"F0#$60 "@ /O*60/F0*$%*6L

$F- 6"L/0J*F) %*Q/ T%$0"F*6LP 0J/ F"0*"F 0J$0 L"#$% ,$%K/6 /O*60 *F $F *F0/%%*)/F0

J/$,/F /,/F 0J"K)J 0J/#/ *6 F" M"-4 ."0J "@ 0J/6/ $((#"$?J/6 $#/ ("0/F0*$% H$26 0J$0

$0J/*606 L*)J0 $,"*- 0J/ ?"F?%K6*"F "@ 0J/ L"#$% $#)KL/F04 5/N#/ *F?%*F/- 0" 0J*FQ

0J$0 T%$0"F*6L $F- /O*60/F0*$%*6L /$?J ?$(0K#/6P H*0J 6"L/ 6K??/66P ?#K?*$% $6(/?06 "@

L"#$%*02P EK0 0J$0 F/*0J/# *6 @K%%2 $-/ZK$0/ 0" $??"KF0 @"# $%% 0J$0 L"#$%*02 #/ZK*#/64


14/29

IJ/ T%$0"F*60 6$26 0J/#/ $#/ "E_/?0*,/ L"#$% ,$%K/6P /,/#2 E*0 $6 0#$F6?/F-/F0 $F-

E*F-*F) $6 3/H*6 E/%*/,/- *FP EK0 0J$0 0J/2 60$F- *F F" F//- "@ @"KF-$0*"F64 IJ/2

$#/P #$0J/#P E#K0/ @$?06P (/#J$(6 %*Q/ 0J/ 0#K0J6 "@ L$0J/L$0*?6P @*O/- @/$0K#/6 "@

#/$%*02P K%0*L$0/ @$?06 $E"K0 0J/ KF*,/#6/ "@ HJ*?J H/ E/?"L/ $H$#/4 IJ*6 ,*/H J$6

0J/ $-,$F0$)/ "@ L$Q*F) 6/F6/ "@ "K# $E*-*F) ?"F,*?0*"F *F 0J/ 0#K0J $F- "E,*"K6F/66

"@ L"#$%*02 $6 H/%% $6 *06 )#"KF- *F #/$%*024 80 /?J"/6 S*-)H*?QN6 ?%$*L 0J$0 L"#$%*02 *6

6/%@f/,*-/F0 $F- F//-6 F" @"KF-$0*"FP $F- *0 )"/6 6"L/ -*60$F?/ *F 6$0*6@2*F) G$F0N6

*F6*60/F?/ 0J$0 #/$%*02 6"L/J"H E/ ?"LL*00/- 0" L"#$%*024 80 $66/#06 0J$0 "E%*)$0*"F6 ?$F

E/ KF-/#60""- $6 #/$%*0*/6 0J$0 "E_/?0*,/%2 /O*60 $F- J$,/ E*F-*F) ("H/# ",/# K64

!$,#"-/6 $#)K/6P H/ 0J*FQ #*)J0%2P 0J$0 T%$0"N6 H"#-,*/HP 0J"K)J F"0 XJ#*60*$FP J$6 ,/#2

"@0/F E//F 0$Q/F 0" E/ ?"F)/F*$% 0" $ #/%*)*"K6 KF-/#60$F-*F) "@ 0J/ H"#%-4 ^/ ?"F0*FK/6

*F 0J*6 ,/*F9IJ/ *-/$ "@ 0J/ M""- 6//L6 0" (%$2 $ L/0$(J26*?$% #"%/ *F J*6 0J"K)J04

80 *6 6"L/J"H @KF-$L/F0$% 0" HJ$0 -( $6 H/%% $6 0" HJ$0 %57+* *% 8"P

LK?J L"#/ @KF-$L/F0$% 0J$F $#/ 0J/ $0"L64 ' T%$0"F*? L$FP 0J/#/@"#/P

HJ" 6/06 J*L6/%@ 0" %*,/ *F $??"#-$F?/ H*0J 0J/ M""- $%*)F6 J*L6/%@ H*0J

HJ$0 *6 -//(/60 $F- L"60 E$6*? *F /O*60/F?/4 7# 0" (K0 *0 $F"0J/# H$2P

H/ L*)J0 6$2 0J$0 HJ$0/,/# ,$%K/6 $ T%$0"F*? H"#%- *L("6/6 "F $ L$F

$#/ ,$%K/6 0" HJ*?J 0J/ T%$0"F*? H"#%- *06/%@ *6 ?"LL*00/-P 0J#"K)J $F-

0J#"K)J4D<

!$,#"-/6 )"/6 "F 0" $#)K/ 0J$0 0J*6 *6 1%* 0J/ ?$6/ H*0J $ YK66/%%*$F H"#%-P HJ/#/ ,$%K/6$F- "E%*)$0*"F6 ?$FF"0 E/ F/$#%2 6" -//(P J$,*F) $ )#*( "F%2 "F 6K#@$?/ (J/F"L/F$4

IJ*6 60$0K6 "@ L"#$% @$?06 *F $ F$0K#$%*60*? H"#%- J/*)J0/F6 0J/ 6//L*F) 60#$F)/F/66 "@

L"#$%*02 *F -/L$F-*F) 6" LK?J HJ*%/ %$?Q*F) 6K@@*?*/F0 )#"KF-*F)4

S" T%$0"F*6L -/@*F*0/%2 6//L6 0" J"%- $F $-,$F0$)/ ",/# (K#/ F$0K#$%*6L4 8F0/#/60*F)%2P

*0N6 $ ,*/H "@ 0J/ KF*,/#6/ 6J$(/- E2P $L"F) "0J/# 0J*F)6P L"#$% ?"F,*?0*"F64 IJ/

/O(%$F$0*"F )*,/F @"# 0J/ /O*60/F?/ "@ HJ$0 6//L 0" E/ 60$E%/ $F- /F-K#*F) L"#$% @$?06

*6 0J$0 0J/ KF*,/#6/ *06/%@ *6 $ L"#$% ?"F0/O04 IJ*6 *6 "#$ *( & $F *F0/%%*)*E%/ ,*/HP $F- *0N6

J$#- 0" #/@K0/4 80N6 F"0 @$# @#"L 0J/ ,*/H H/ "K#6/%,/6 J"%-P 0J"K)J "@ ?"K#6/ HJ$0 *0

%/$,/6 "K0 *6 0J/ L"60 *L("#0$F0 ($#0 "@ 0J/ (*?0K#/P *F "K# /60*L$0*"F4

'K)K60*F/P $F /$#%2 XJ#*60*$F T%$0"F*60P KF-/#60$F-$E%2 0J"K)J0 *0 L$-/ E/60 6/F6/ 0J$0

*@ 0J/ J*)J/60 60$F-$#- "@ )""-F/66 *6 0J/ "E_/?0 "@ 0J/ J*)J/60 @"#L "@ %",/P $6 *0 H$6 @"#

T%$0"P 0J/F 0J/ J*)J/60 #/$%*02 *6 %*Q/%2 0" E/ $ (/#6"F4 ./2"F- 0J/ *L(/#6"F$%*02 "@ 0J/

T%$0"F*? M""- *6 $F"0J/# (#"E%/LP $%#/$-2 $%%K-/- 0" E2 S$#0#/P $6 1"JF Y*60 "E6/#,/69

T%$0"N6 $??"KF0 "@ 0J/ [U"#L6] a*F?%K-*F) 0J/ M""-b $6 L"#$% /O/L(%$#6

%/$,/6 0J/L *F L/0$(J26*?$% %*LE"4 IJ/2 H"K%- /O*60 $6 /66/F0*$%%2

*F0/%%*)*E%/ *-/$6 /,/F *@ 0J/#/ H/#/ F" L*F-P JKL$F "# -*,*F/P


15/29

0" #/?")F*R/ 0J/L9 $6 "E_/?06 "@ 0J"K)J0P F"0 L/#/ ?"F60#K?06 "#

?"F?/(064 .K0P $6 'K)K60*F/ %/$#F/-P $F- $6 0J/ M#//Q \/"(%$0"F*606

J$- $66/#0/-P 0J/ F"0*"F "@ $F /0/#F$% "E_/?0 "@ 0J"K)J0 a$F- 0JK6

@"# T%$0" $ ?$K6/ "@ 0J"K)J0b H*0J"K0 $ ?/$6/%/66 0J*FQ*F) 6KE_/?0 *6

KF*F0/%%*)*E%/4 8F0/%%*)*E%/ U"#L6P F/,/# (#"("6/- $6 L/#/ ?"F?/(06P

?$FF"0 E/ (#"("6/- $6 T%$0" "#*)*F$%%2 (#"("6/- 0J/LP $6 @#//f@%"$0*F)

L/0$(J26*?$% *0/L64=;

IJ/ F//- @"# T%$0"F*? @"#L6 K%0*L$0/%2 0" E/ )#"KF-/- *F $ L*F- 0J$0 #/?")F*R/6 0J/L

*6 "F?/ $)$*F Q//F%2 @/%04 [U#// @%"$0*F) L/0$(J26*?$% *0/L6] -" F"0 J$,/ 0J/ "F0"%")*?$%

60#/F)0J $F- 60$E*%*02 0J$0 H/ 0J*FQ L"#$%*02 LK60 J$,/4 e,/F *@ H/ -*6?/#F 0J/6/ L"#$%

0#K0J6 E/@"#/ H/ *-/F0*@2 0J/*# -//(/# @"KF-$0*"F6P 0J*6 "F%2 #/L*F-6 K6 $)$*F 0J$0 0J/

"#-/# "@ QF"H*F) *6 -*60*F?0 @#"L 0J/ "#-/# "@ E/*F)4

U#//-"LP \$0K#$%*6LP $F- !"#$% Y/6("F6*E*%*02

'F"0J/# ZK/60*"F 0" #$*6/ @"# T%$0"F*606 *6 0J*69 ^"H ?$F 0J/2 $??"KF0 @"# 0J/ @#//-"L

H/ F//- 0" "E/2 0J/ L"#$% "E%*)$0*"F6 0J$0 0J/2 $@@*#L $6 ($#0 "@ 0J/ @K#F*0K#/ "@ 0J/

KF*,/#6/g 8@ H/ $#/ ?$K6$%%2 -/0/#L*F/- 0" E/J$,/ $6 H/ -"P 0J/F /,/#20J*F) 0J$0

J$((/F6P *F?%K-*F) /,/#2 JKL$F -/?*6*"FP *6 E"KF- 0" J$((/F _K60 $6 *0 -"/64 IJ/

KF*,/#6/ *06/%@ L*)J0 E/ $ L"#$% (%$?/P EK0 J"H ?$F JKL$F E/*F)6 E/ L"#$%%2 @#//

?#/$0K#/6P @#// /*0J/# 0" "E/2 "# -*6#/)$#- 0J/ L"#$% %$Hg IJ*6 *6 "@ ?"K#6/ $F "%- $F-

-*@@*?K%0 ZK/60*"FP EK0 *0N6 F"0 $0 $%% ?%/$# 0J$0 T%$0"F*606 J$,/ $F $-/ZK$0/ #/(%24 !"#$%@$?06 J$,/ F" (K#?J$6/ KF%/66 H/ J$,/ L"#$% @#//-"L4

"#$ ** & IJ*6 (#"E%/L *6 $?K0/ @"# F$0K#$%*606P "@ ?"K#6/P EK0 "K# ("*F0 J/#/ *6 0J$0

T%$0"F*606 HJ" -/F2 M"-N6 /O*60/F?/ $F- HJ" $@@*#L ?$K6$% -/0/#L*F*6L @"# JKL$F

E/*F)6 $#/ *F 0J/ 6$L/ E*F-4 SK(("6/ 2"K J$,/ $ ?J"*?/ 0" ?J/$0 "F $ 0/60 "# F"04

!"#$%*02 6$26 2"K 6J"K%-FN04 SK(("6/ 2"K /F- K( ?J/$0*F)4 7F $ -/0/#L*F*60*? (*?0K#/P

2"K# ?J"*?/ H$6 -/0/#L*F/-P 6K?J 0J$0P $0 0J/ L"L/F0 2"K L$-/ *0P 0J/ ?$K6$%

?"F-*0*"F6 $F- 0J/ (J26*?$% %$H6 $0 H"#Q *F 0J/ H"#%- -*?0$0/- 0J$0 2"K H"K%- -" /O$?0%2

$6 2"K -*-4 8F 0J"6/ ?*#?KL60$F?/6 2"K ?"K%-FN0 J$,/ -"F/ "0J/#H*6/4 I" 6$2 0J$0 2"K

"K)J0 F"0 0" J$,/ ?J/$0/-P 0J/FP *6 (#"E%/L$0*?P E/?$K6/ 2"K ?$FN0 E/ "E%*)$0/- 0" -"

HJ$0N6 *L("66*E%/ 0" -"P $F- *F 0J"6/ ?*#?KL60$F?/6P *0 H$6 *L("66*E%/ 0J$0 2"K ?"K%-

J$,/ -"F/ -*@@/#/F0%24 !"#$% @#//-"L *F $ -/0/#L*F/- H"#%- 6//L6 #K%/- "K04

!$#? +4 ̂ $K6/# 0$Q/6 "F 0J/ ?J$#)/ 0J$0 [E*"%")*?$% (/#6(/?0*,/6 m"@ L"#$%*02n $#/

*FJ/#/F0%2 /,*%P $6 0J/2 ?#/$0/ (#/-/0/#L*F/- "K0?"L/6P 0J/#/E2 /%*L*F$0*F) @#// H*%%4]

^/ #/(%*/6 0" 0J*6 ?J$#)/ $6 @"%%"H69

'6 (J*%"6"(J/#6 $F- (62?J"%")*606P 6K?J $6 +$F*/% +/FF/00P S0/,/F

T*FQ/#P $F- +$F*/% 5/)F/#P J$,/ $#)K/-P J"H/,/#P F"0J*F) $E"K0 $F


16/29

/,"%K0*"F$#2 "# E*"%")*?$% (/#6(/?0*,/ %/$-6 *F/O0#*?$E%2 0" 0J/ F"0*"F "@

$ -/0/#L*F/-P @*O/-P "# *LLK0$E%/ 6/0 "@ _K-)L/F06 "# E/%*/@64 .*"%")2

-"/6FN0 H"#Q 0J*6 H$24 7K# E*"%")2P $F- 0J/ E*"%")2 "@ $%% 6(/?*/6 "F

/$#0JP 6/06 K( $ #$F)/ "@ ("66*E%/ E/J$,*"#64 IJ/ #$F)/ H/ "E6/#,/

*F0/#$?06 H*0J 0J/ /F,*#"FL/F0P $F- /F,*#"FL/F06 ?J$F)/4=:

80N6 (#"E$E%2 0#K/ 0J$0 "K# E*"%")2 *6FN0 6K?J 0J$0 H/N#/ ?$K6$%%2 -/0/#L*F/- 0" E/J$,/

$6 H/ -" *F-/(/F-/F0 "@ "K# @%K?0K$0*F) ?"F0/O06P EK0 0J/ *L("#0$F0 ("*F0 *6 0J/ L"#/

)/F/#$% "F/ 0J$0P "F?/ H/ $-- E"0J F$0K#/ $F- FK#0K#/ *F0" 0J/ L*OP $ F$0K#$%*60*?

(/#6(/?0*,/ *F/O"#$E%2 %/$-6 0" ?"L(%/0/ -/0/#L*F*6L4 ^$K6/#N6 /F%*60L/F0 "@ ^$#,$#-

(62?J"%")*60 T*FQ/# 0" J*6 ?$K6/ 6//L6 ?"KF0/#(#"-K?0*,/P *F?*-/F0$%%2P $6 T*FQ/# J$6

$?QF"H%/-)/-P $6 H/ $#/ $E"K0 0" 6//P 0J$0 $ F$0K#$%*60*? $??"KF0 "@ JKL$F @#//-"L *6FN0

$-/ZK$0/ 0" 6K60$*F 60#"F) $6?#*(0*"F6 "@ L"#$% #/6("F6*E*%*024

T*FQ/# -"/6P J"H/,/#P L$Q/ 6"L/ /@@"#0 0" -/@/F- L"#$% #/6("F6*E*%*02 "F F$0K#$%*60

0/#L64 8F ($#0*?K%$#P J/ /F-"#6/6 0J/ /@@"#0 "@ 0J"6/ [-/@/F6*,/ 6?*/F0*606] HJ"

6"L/0*L/6 0#2 0" -/@%/?0 0J/ ?J$#)/ "@ -/0/#L*F*6L E2 6$2*F) E/J$,*"# *6 F/,/# (/#@/?0%2

(#/-*?0$E%/P F"0 -/0/#L*F/- *F 0J/ [L$0J/L$0*?$% 6/F6/P] EK0 "F%2 $6 $ (#"E$E*%*024=D

IJ*6 *6 H"#6/ 0J$F ?"F@K6/-4 7K# @$*%K#/ 0" E/ (#*,2 0" 0J/ L2#*$- #/%/,$F0 @$?06 6J$(*F)

"K# $?0*"F6P #/F-/#*F) "K# (#/-*?0*"F6 "@ JKL$F E/J$,*"# L/#/%2 /(*60/L*?$%%2 (#"E$E%/

$0 E/60P -"/6FN0 -/0#$?0 @#"L J"H L$0/#*$%*6L *F (#*F?*(%/ H"K%- $%L"60 ?/#0$*F%2

*L(%2 $E6"%K0/ "F0"%")*?$% -/0/#L*F*6L "@ JKL$F ?"F-K?04 ̂ *6 ,$#*"K6 ?"F_/?0K#/6 "@

J"H $ (K#/%2 (J26*?$% 6260/L L*)J0 F"0 E/ -/0/#L*F*60*? 6//L H*%-%2 *L(%$K6*E%/9 "#$

*+ & [T/#J$(6 0J/ E#$*F $L(%*@*/6 #$F-"L /,/F06 $0 0J/ L"%/?K%$# "# ZK$F0KL %/,/%4

T/#J$(6 E#$*F6 $#/ F"F%*F/$# -2F$L*?$% 6260/L6 6KE_/?0 0" KF(#/-*?0$E%/ ?J$"64]==

T/#J$(6P $F- (/#J$(6 0J/ H"#%- H$6 ?#/$0/- @*,/ L*FK0/6 $)"4 !/#/ ("66*E*%*02 -"/6FN0

(%$K6*E*%*02 *L(%24 e,/F L"#/ 0" 0J/ ("*F0P T*FQ/# J*L6/%@ $?QF"H%/-)/6 0J$0 /,/F *@

6K?J #/L"0/ ("66*E*%*0*/6 "E0$*FP H/N#/ %/@0 H*0J F"0J*F) %*Q/ @#// H*%%P $F- F" ?"F?/(0 "@

#/6("F6*E*%*024

IJ/ T%$0"F*60 HJ" H*6J/6 0" $@@*#L -/0/#L*F*6L J$6 $ @/H ("0/F0*$% #/6("F6/6 J/#/4=`

SJ/ ?"K%- 6$2 0J$0P $%0J"K)J 0J/ H#"F)-"*F) -"/6FN0 L/#*0 0J/ 6"#0 "@ L$O*L$% E%$L/$66"?*$0/- H*0J #/0#*EK0*"FP $ L"-*?KL "@ ?/F6K#/ *6 60*%% $((#"(#*$0/ 0" /F?"K#$)/

E/00/# E/J$,*"# F/O0 0*L/4 +/0/##/F?/P #/J$E*%*0$0*"FP $F- ("6*0*,/ ?"F-*0*"F*F) L$Q/

(/#@/?0 6/F6/ /,/F *F $ -/0/#L*F/- H"#%-4 T/#J$(6 *0 L*)J0 /,/F E/ 6K))/60/- 0J$0 0J*6 *6

$ L",/ *F 0J/ #*)J0 -*#/?0*"F 0"H$#- $ E/00/# H"#%-P HJ/#/ H/ 60#*,/ L"#/ 0" KF-/#60$F-

"F/ $F"0J/#N6 @$*%K#/6 #$0J/# 0J$F _K60 $66*)F E%$L/ $F- /O$?0 #/,/F)/ $F- #/0#*EK0*"F4

8F #/6("F6/P H/ H"K%- 6K))/60 0J$0 0#2*F) 0" $00$*F J*)J/# %/,/%6 "@ KF-/#60$F-*F) "@

0J/ E/J$,*"#6 "@ "0J/#6 *6 *F-//- H"#0JHJ*%/P "@0/F F"E%/P EK0 0J/ T%$0"F*60P *F "(0*F)

@"# 0J*6 #/6"%K0*"FP J$6 6KE0%2 %"H/#/- 0J/ L"#$% 60$F-$#-4 \" %"F)/# $#/ L"#$% @$?06


17/29

E*F-*F) "F K6 0J/ H$2 3/H*6P "# T%$0"P 0J"K)J0 0J/2 H/#/P $F- L$F2 60*%% -" 0"-$24

!"#$%*02 J$6 *F60/$- E/?"L/ $ 6/0 "@ *-/$% )K*-/%*F/6 #$0J/# 0J$F -/L$F-6 @"# K6 0"

$E*-/ E24 IJ/#/ $#/ F" %"F)/#P @"# /O$L(%/P %80-74*-%1(P EK0 L/#/ (577"(*-%1(4 ')$*FP H/

?$FN0 E/ "E%*)$0/- 0" -" HJ$0 H/ $#/ /*0J/# F/?/66*0$0/- 0" -" "# (#/?%K-/- @#"L -"*F)P

HJ*?J *6 0J/ ?$6/ @"# $%% H/ -" *@ H/N#/ -/0/#L*F/-4 e,/F "K# -/?*6*"F /*0J/# 0" K6/ "# F"0

0" K6/ L"#$%*02 $6 "K# )K*-/%*F/ *6 *06/%@ -/0/#L*F/- $F- 6" F"0 @#//4

^/#/ 0J/ T%$0"F*60 L*)J0 H*6J 0" #/(%2 E2 6$2*F)P *F ?"F?/#0 H*0J L$F2 F$0K#$%*606P 0J$0

-/0/#L*F*6L $F- )/FK*F/ @#//-"L $#/ ?"F6*60/F0 $@0/# $%%4 5J/F H/P 0J#"K)J #/$6"FP

$((#/J/F- L"#$% 0#K0J $F- ?J""6/ 0" %*,/ $??"#-*F) 0" *0P H/ $#/ @#//4 U"%%"H*F) #/$6"F6

*F 0J*6 H$2 L$2 F"0 %*E/#$0/ K6 @#"L 0J/ ?$K6$% ?J$*FP EK0 -"/6 ?"F@/# "F K6 HJ$0/,/#

#/$% @#//-"L H/ $#/ ?$($E%/ "@4

3/H*6 @"KF- 0J*6 #/6("F6/ KF?"F,*F?*F)P $6 -"/6 0J/ ?"F0/L("#$#2 F$0K#$%*60*?

(J*%"6"(J/# 1"JF S/$#%/4=C SK(("6/ $)$*F 2"KN#/ ?"F6*-/#*F) ?J/$0*F) "F $ 0/60 "# 2"K#

0$O/64 o"K $((#/J/F-P 6K(("6/P 0J/ H#"F)F/66 "@ ?J/$0*F)4 o"K ("F-/# 0J/ ?J"*?/P

$F- L$Q/ K( 2"K# L*F- 0" -" 0J/ #*)J0 0J*F) $F- F"0 ?J/$04 5$6 2"K# ?J"*?/ L"#$%P

"F $ -/0/#L*F*60*? (*?0K#/g T/#J$(6 *0 H$6 L"#$% *F 0J/ 6/F6/ "@ ?"##/6("F-*F) 0" 0J/

L"#$% 0#K0J 0J$0 2"K 6J"K%-FN0 ?J/$0P EK0 *0 H$6FN0 $ L"#$%%2 6*)F*@*?$F0 -/?*6*"F *F $F2

-//( 6/F6/4 ^"H ?"K%- *0 E/g 80 H$6 $ -/?*6*"F 0J$0P *F 0J"6/ ?*#?KL60$F?/6P +4' 0" E/

L$-/4 o"K H/#/ -/0/#L*F/-P ?$K6$%%2P 0" -" /O$?0%2 $6 2"K -*-4 5*0J*F $ -/0/#L*F*60*?

@#$L/H"#QP /,/#20J*F) 0J$0 /,/#2"F/ -"/6 *6 E"KF- 0" J$((/F _K60 $6 *0 -"/64 I" ?$%%

$?0*"F6 H/ ?"F6*-/# *F $??"#- H*0J L"#$% 0#K0J @#// L"#$% ?J"*?/6 -"/6 F"0 L$Q/ 0J/L"#$ *, & 6"4 8@ 0J/ -/0/#L*F*606 $#/ #*)J0P H/ ?"K%-FN0 J$,/ -"F/ -*@@/#/F0%2P /,/#4 'F- *@

H/ -" E/J$,/ *F $??"#- H*0J L"#$%*02P *0 *6 E/?$K6/ "@ (J26*"%")*?$% ?$K6/6 *F "K# E#$*FP

F"0 E/?$K6/ "@ 0J/ (/#6K$6*,/ ("H/# "@ $E60#$?0 /F0*0*/64=c

5J$0 LK60 E/ @"#0J#*)J0%2 @$?/- J/#/ *6 0J$0 L"#$% "E%*)$0*"F6 #/ZK*#/ $ ?"F,*F?*F)

$??"KF0 "@ L"#$% @#//-"L $F- $6?#*(0*"F6 "@ L"#$% #/6("F6*E*%*024 IJ"6/ KF$E%/ 0"

$??"KF0 @"# )/FK*F/ L"#$% @#//-"L $F- HJ" H*6J 0" ?"F0*FK/ 6(/$Q*F) L/$F*F)@K%%2

"@ L"#$% #/6("F6*E*%*02 $#/ %*Q/%2 6*L(%2 0" ?J$F)/ 0J/ 0"(*?P K6*F) 0J/ 6$L/ H"#-6 0"

#/@/# 0" -*@@/#/F0 ?"F?/(064 I$Q/P @"# /O$L(%/P ?"F0/L("#$#2 (J*%"6"(J/# e%%*"0 S"E/#N6

$??"KF0 "@ L"#$% #/6("F6*E*%*029 [8@ $F $)/F0 *6 L"#$%%2 #/6("F6*E%/ @"# $F /,/F0 a$ E$FQ

#"EE/#2P 6$2bP 0J*6 L/$F6 a:b 0J$0 0J/ $)/F0 ?$K6/- 0J/ /,/F0j $F- aDb 0J$0 0J/ "??K##/F?/

"@ 0J/ /,/F0 #/@%/?06 "F 0J/ $)/F0N6 L"#$% ?J$#$?0/#4] 8F 0J*6 H$2P S"E/# 6$26P H/ ?$F

-*60*F)K*6J L"#$% #/6("F6*E*%*02 @#"L 0J/ L/#/ ?$K6$% #/6("F6*E*%*02 0J$0P @"# /O$L(%/P

H/ $((%2 0" 60"#L6 H*0J F" *L(%*?$0*"F "@ L"#$% (#$*6/ "# E%$L/4=A

+"/6 J*6 $??"KF0 "@ L"#$% #/6("F6*E*%*02 L$Q/ 6/F6/ "@ $6?#*E*F) )/FK*F/ (#$*6/ "#

E%$L/g 5/ -"FN0 0J*FQ 6"4 8@ -/0/#L*F*6L *6 0#K/P 0J/F F"0 "F%2 $#/ $%% "@ "K# $?0*"F6

*F,$#*$E%2 ?$K6/- E2 (#*"# ?"F-*0*"F6 $F- (J26*?$% %$H6P EK0 6" *6 "K# ?J$#$?0/#4 M/FK*F/


18/29

$6?#*(0*"F6 "@ 6%&40 &"(/%1(-8-0-*#P *@ 0*/- 0" "K# ?J$#$?0/#6P H"K%- #/ZK*#/ 0J$0 H/ $#/

#*)J0%2 #/)$#-/- $6 6K@@*?*/F0%2 #/6("F6*E%/ @"# "K# ?J$#$?0/#4 8@ "K# @#// ?J"*?/6 -" F"0

6J$(/ "K# ?J$#$?0/#P H/ $#/ F"0 #*)J0%2 #/6("F6*E%/ @"# 0J/ ?J"*?/6 0J$0 @%"H @#"L 0J$0

?J$#$?0/#4 ̂ /F?/P H/ @*F- S"E/#N6 %*F/ "@ 0J"K)J0 KF?"F,*F?*F)4

SK(("6/ '#*60"0%/ H$6 #*)J0 0J$0 "F/N6 ?J$#$?0/# *6 $ @KF?0*"F "@ HJ$0 "F/ ?"F6*60/F0%2

-"/64=B 8F 0J$0 ?$6/P "K# ?J$#$?0/#6 $#/ $ #/6K%0 "@ "K# ?J"*?/6P EK0 *@ "K# ?J"*?/6 $#/

$%% -/0/#L*F/-P 6" H"K%- E/ "K# ?J$#$?0/#4 !*)J0 6"L/ (/"(%/ /F- K( H*0J $ E$-

?J$#$?0/#P (/#@"#L*F) JK#0@K% $?0*"F6 0J$0 H/ $#/ *F?%*F/- 0" ?$%% *LL"#$%g SK#/4 .K0

H"K%- 6K?J (/#6"F6 E/ L"#$%%2 #/6("F6*E%/ @"# 6K?J $?0*"F6 $F- 0J/*# ?J$#$?0/#g \"0

"F $ -/0/#L*F*60*? (*?0K#/P @"# )/FK*F/ L"#$% (#$*6/ $F- E%$L/ -"FN0 @*0 *F0" $ (*?0K#/ "@

(/"(%/ HJ" $#/ *F,$#*$E%2 ?$K6/- 0" -" /,/#20J*F) 0J/2 -" $F- 0" E/?"L/ HJ$0/,/# 0J/2

E/?"L/4 5/ ?$F ?"F0*FK/ K6*F) 0J*6 %$F)K$)/ "@ (#$*6/ $F- E%$L/P $F- 0J/ %$F)K$)/ H*%%?"F0*FK/ 0" E/ 0$Q/F 0" L/$F HJ$0 *0 J$6 L/$F0 0#$-*0*"F$%%2P EK0 H/ H*%% E/ #/@/##*F)

0" 6"L/0J*F) "0J/# 0J$F L"#$% #/6("F6*E*%*024 5J/F F$0K#$%*606 K6/ L"#$% %$F)K$)/P

0J/2 J$,/ 0" ?J$F)/ 0J/ 6KE_/?0 E2 6KE0%2 $E$F-"F*F) 0#$-*0*"F$% L"#$% ?$0/)"#*/6P HJ*%/

60*%% K6*F) H"#-6 0J$0 #/0$*F 0J/*# (K#?J$6/ @#"L $ E"##"H/- L"#$% ,"?$EK%$#2 H*0J $

(J*%"6"(J*?$% J*60"#2 0J$0 0J/ F$0K#$%*606 J$,/ #/F"KF?/-4

'F"0J/# /O$L(%/ "@ 0J/ H$2 F$0K#$%*606 ?J$F)/ 0J/ 0"(*? *6 Y*?J$#- +$HQ*F6N6 ?J$(0/#

"F 0J/ [#""06 "@ L"#$%*02] *F J*6 #/?/F0 E""Q ;+" @%' A"05(-%14 IJ/ 6KE0*0%/ "@ 0J/

?J$(0/# *6 [5J2 $#/ H/ )""-g] X"F6*-/#$0*"F6 "@ "#$ *- & HJ$0 L*)J0 %/$- K6 0" E/J$,/

/0J*?$%%2P J"H/,/#P -" F"0 (#",*-/ $F $??"KF0 "@ 0J/ @"KF-$0*"F6 "@ /0J*?6P F"# -" 0J/2 $F6H/# 0J/ ZK/60*"F "@ HJ/0J/# $F20J*F)P $F- HJ$0 *F ($#0*?K%$#P *6 )""- "# #*)J0 $F-

HJ24 IJ/ #/6K%0 *6 0J$0 LK?J "@ J*6 -*6?K66*"F 6Q$0/6 ",/# 6K(/#@*?*$% ZK/60*"F6 $F-

#/%*/6 "F $F/?-"0$% /,*-/F?/ "@ J"##*E%2 E$- #/%*)*"K6 0J*FQ/#6P F"F/ "@ HJ*?J -"/6

$F20J*F) 0" $-,$F?/ "K# KF-/#60$F-*F) "@ 0J/ #""06 "@ L"#$%*024 U"# 0J/ L"60 ($#0

+$HQ*F6 $,"*-6 $%0")/0J/# ZK/60*"F6 "@ HJ$0 L$Q/6 L"#$%*02 *&5"P $F- 6*L(%2 0#*/6

0" (#",*-/ *F60/$- $ F$0K#$%*60*? $F- /,"%K0*"F$#2 $??"KF0 "@ HJ2 H/ "??$6*"F$%%2

L$F*@/60 $%0#K*60*? E/J$,*"#64 ̂ $,*F) *-/F0*@*/- 6K?J /,"%K0*"F$#2 #/$6"F6WF$L/%2P

)/F/0*? Q*F6J*(P #/?*(#"?$0*"FP $ )""- #/(K0$0*"FP $F- 0J/ E/F/@*06 "@ ?"F6(*?K"K6

)/F/#"6*02W+$HQ*F6 $?06 $6 0J"K)J J/ J$6 (#",*-/- *F6*)J0 *F0" L"#$%*02 $F- *06

@"KF-$0*"F6 0J/L6/%,/64 ^/ H#*0/6P [5/ ?$F F" L"#/ J/%( "K#6/%,/6 @//%*F) (*02 HJ/F

H/ 6// $ H//(*F) KF@"#0KF$0/ aHJ" *6 KF#/%$0/- $F- KF$E%/ 0" #/?*(#"?$0/b 0J$F H/

?$F J/%( "K#6/%,/6 @//%*F) %K60 @"# $ L/LE/# "@ 0J/ "(("6*0/ 6/O aHJ" L$2 E/ *F@/#0*%/

"# "0J/#H*6/ KF$E%/ 0" #/(#"-K?/b4 ."0J $#/ L*6@*#*F)6P +$#H*F*$F L*60$Q/69 E%/66/-P

(#/?*"K6 L*60$Q/64]=


19/29

0" 0$Q/ 6K?J $F *F0K*0*"F $6 ,/#*-*?$%4`: +$HQ*F6P 0""P /L(%"26 L"#$% ,"?$EK%$#2 0J$0

#/0$*F6 *06 (K#?J$6/ E/?$K6/ "@ $ H"#%-,*/H 0J$0 J/ J$6 #/_/?0/- "K0 "@ J$F-4

'L/#*?$F (J*%"6"(J/# 5*%%*$L 1$L/6 ("*F0/- "K0 J"H 0J/ ?$0/)"#2 "@ &"7&"* $%6"

-"/6FN0 @*0 *F0" $ F$0K#$%*60*? (*?0K#/4 8F J*6 /66$2 [IJ/ +*%/LL$ "@ +/0/#L*F*6LP] J/

/O(#/66/- 0J/ @#//-"L J/ @/%0 0" K6/ L"#$% ?"F?/(0*"F6 $E"K0 HJ*?J J/ H$6 ?"F@*-/F0

0" 6J$(/ J*6 ,*/H "@ 0J/ H"#%-4 ^/ H#"0/ 0J$0P *@ ?"F?/(0*"F6 "@ 0J/ H"#%- ,*"%$0/ 0J*6

L"#$% -/L$F-P J/ [6J$%% @//% $6 @#// 0" 0J#"H *0 ",/#E"$#-P "# $0 %/$60 0" -"KE0 *0P $6 *@

*0 -*6$(("*F0/- L2 -/L$F- @"# KF*@"#L*02 "@ 6/ZK/F?/P @"# /O$L(%/4 V]`D U"# 1$L/6P

$6 @"# 3/H*6P $ ("0/F0*$% H*F-"H "@ *F6*)J0 *F0" #/$%*02 H$6 L"#$%*02P $F- $ @*O0K#/ "@

L"#$%*02 *6 #/)#/0 ",/# ?/#0$*F -/?*6*"F64 1$L/6 H#"0/ 0J$0

S"L/ #/)#/06 $#/ (#/002 "E60*F$0/ $F- J$#- 0" 60*@%/W#/)#/06 @"# $?06 "@

H$F0"F ?#K/%02 "# 0#/$?J/#2P @"# /O$L(%/P HJ/0J/# (/#@"#L/- E2 "0J/#6"# E2 "K#6/%,/64 ^$#-%2 $F2 "F/ ?$F #/L$*F "1*-&"0# "(0*L*60*? $@0/#

#/$-*F) 0J/ ?"F@/66*"F "@ 0J/ LK#-/#/# $0 .#"?Q0"F 0J/ "0J/# -$29 J"HP

0" )/0 #*- "@ 0J/ H*@/ HJ"6/ ?"F0*FK/- /O*60/F?/ E"#/- J*LP J/ *F,/*)%/-

J/# *F0" $ -/6/#0 6("0P 6J"0 J/# @"K# 0*L/6P $F- 0J/FP $6 6J/ %$2 "F 0J/

)#"KF- $F- 6$*- 0" J*LP [o"K -*-FN0 -" *0 "F (K#("6/P -*- 2"KP -/$#g]

#/(%*/-P [\"P 8 -*-FN0 -" *0 "F (K#("6/P] $6 J/ #$*6/- $ "#$ *. & #"?Q $F-

6L$6J/- J/# 6QK%%4 SK?J $F "??K##/F?/P H*0J 0J/ L*%- 6/F0/F?/ $F- 6/%@f

6$0*6@$?0*"F "@ 0J/ (#*6"F/#P *6 $ @*/%- @"# $ ?#"( "@ #/)#/06P HJ*?J "F/

F//- F"0 0$Q/ K( *F -/0$*%4 5/ @//% 0J$0P $%0J"K)J $ (/#@/?0 L/?J$F*?$%

@*0 0" 0J/ #/60 "@ 0J/ KF*,/#6/P *0 *6 $ E$- L"#$% @*0P $F- 0J$0 6"L/0J*F)

/%6/ H"K%- #/$%%2 J$,/ E//F E/00/# *F *06 (%$?/4

.K0 @"# 0J/ -/0/#L*F*60*? (J*%"6"(J2 0J/ LK#-/#P 0J/ 6/F0/F?/P $F- 0J/

(#*6"F/#N6 "(0*L*6L H/#/ $%% F/?/66$#2 @#"L /0/#F*02j $F- F"0J*F) /%6/

@"# $ L"L/F0 J$- $ )J"60 "@ $ ?J$F?/ "@ E/*F) (K0 *F0" 0J/*# (%$?/4`=

I#$-*0*"F$% ?"F?/(0*"F6 "@ L"#$% @#//-"LP L"#$% -K0*/6P L"#$% #/6("F6*E*%*02P )/FK*F/

#/)#/0P #/$% (#$*6/ $F- E%$L/ $#/ $%% -*@@*?K%0 0" L$Q/ 6/F6/ "@ *F $ F$0K#$%*60*? H"#%-4

IJ"6/ KF?"L@"#0$E%/ H*0J H$0/#*F) 6K?J ?"F?/(0*"F6 -"HF J$,/ #/$6"F 0" 0$Q/ 0J/*6L6/#*"K6%24

5J/#/$6 T%$0"F*606 @*#L%2 E/%*/,/ *F $F K%0*L$0/ M""-P $F /O*60/F0*$%*60 %*Q/ S$#0#/

-/F*/- 0J/ /O*60/F?/ "@ $F2 6K?J M""-4 [IJ/#/ ?$F F" %"F)/# E/ $F 4 /&-%&- M""-P 6*F?/

0J/#/ *6 F" *F@*F*0/ $F- (/#@/?0 ?"F6?*"K6F/66 0" 0J*FQ *04] 5J$0 0J*6 L/$F6P @"# S$#0#/P

*6 0J$0 H/ $#/ #$-*?$%%2 @#//P F"0 0" -*6?",/# L"#$%*02 "F "K# "HFP EK0 0" @"#)/ "K# "HF

,$%K/64 5/ -1B"1* L"#$%*02P F"0 '-(9%B"& *04 S" HJ/#/$6 T%$0"F*606P "# $0 %/$60 T%$0"F*606

HJ" E/%*/,/ *F -/0/#L*F*6LP /LE#$?/ "E_/?0*,/ L"#$% ,$%K/6 EK0 ?$FN0 $??"KF0 @"# 0J/

L/$F*F)@K% L"#$% @#//-"L 0J$0 6*)F*@*?$F0 $-J/#/F?/ 0" 6K?J ,$%K/6 #/ZK*#/6P S$#0#/


20/29

/F-"#6/6 0J/ 60#"F)/60 ("66*E%/ 6/F6/ "@ L"#$% @#//-"LP EK0 *F 0J/ (#"?/66 _/00*6"F6

"E_/?0*,/ L"#$% ,$%K/4

!"#$% @#//-"LP ?"F0#$#2 0" S$#0#/N6 ,*/HP *6FN0 0J/ @#//-"L 0" ?#/$0/ $F- *F,/F0 "K#"HF ,$%K/6P $6 *@ H/ ?"K%- ?J""6/ 0" L$Q/ _K60 $F20J*F) $0 $%% ,$%K$E%/ E2 J$((/F*F) 0"

,$%K/ *04 8@ 8 ,$%K/- ?J*%- 0"#0K#/ @"# @KFP 0J$0 H"K%-FN0 L$Q/ *0 $ ,$%K$E%/ $?0*,*02 *F $F2

L"#$%%2 6*)F*@*?$F0 6/F6/4 S$#0#/ 6*L(%2 6//L6 0" E/ H#"F)P $F- (#"@"KF-%2 6"P HJ/F J/

*F6*606 0J$0 H/ @*F- F" ,$%K/6 "# ?"LL$F-6 0" %/)*0*L*R/ "K# ?"F-K?04 S$#0#/ *6 $66KL*F)

0J$0P 6*F?/ "E_/?0*,/ L"#$% ,$%K/6 J$,/ M"- @"# 0J/*# E/60 /O(%$F$0*"FP KFE/%*/@ *F M"-

LK60 /F0$*% KFE/%*/@ *F "E_/?0*,/ L"#$% ,$%K/64 8@ 3/H*6P S*-)H*?QP $F- \/HL$F $#/

#*)J0P J"H/,/#P "K# E/%*/@ *F 60#"F) L"#$% ,$%K/6 "K)J0 0" E/ @*#L $F- #/6"%K0/ E/?$K6/

"@ 0J/ "E,*"K6F/66 "@ 6K?J 0#K0J6 *F $F- "@ 0J/L6/%,/64

IJ/#/N6 6"L/0J*F) ("H/#@K% $E"K0 S$#0#/N6 J/#"*? -/F*$% "@ -/0/#L*F*6L $F-

6"L/0J*F) #*)J0 $E"K0 @*#L E/%*/@ *F L"#$% @#//-"LP EK0 J*6 L$F/K,/# K%0*L$0/%2 6//L6

KF(#*F?*(%/-4 ̂ / -/F*/6 0J/ /O*60/F?/ "@ $F20J*F) "K06*-/ 0J/ (J26*?$% H"#%-P "F%2 0J/F

0" 0K#F J*6 E$?Q "F 0J/ %*Q/%2 6?/F$#*" 0" @"%%"H9 $ (K#/%2 L/?J$F*60*? (*?0K#/ "@ #/$%*02

0J$0 %/$,/6 F" #""L @"# )/FK*F/ @#// H*%%4 \"0 "F%2 -"/6 J/ F"0 /F-"#6/ -/0/#L*F*6LP

HJ*%/ )*,*F) %*00%/ $#)KL/F0 @"# -"*F) 6"P J/ /F-"#6/6 $F KF-/#60$F-*F) "@ @#//-"L 6"

#$-*?$% 0J$0 *0 ,*0*$0/6 0J/ "#$ */ & ("66*E*%*02 "@ $F2 "E_/?0*,/ ,$%K/ 6260/LP E2 ($*F0*F)

JKL$F E/*F)6 $6 F"0 L/#/ -*6?",/#/#6 "@ L"#$%*02P EK0 *06 *F,/F0"#64``

^$,*F) #/%*FZK*6J/- "E_/?0*,/ /0J*?6 *F J*6 /O*60/F0*$%*60 $((#"$?JP S$#0#/ 60*%% 0#*/-6$%,$)*F) $ 6/F6/ "@ *L("#0$F?/ @"# "K# -/?*6*"F6P ?%$*L*F) 0J$0 0J#"K)J "K# ?J"*?/6 H/

?#/$0/ $F- *F,/F0 F"0 "F%2 "K# (/#6"F EK0 "K# ,/#2 /0J*?6 "@ $?0*"F4 8F "K# ?J"*?/6P H/

?J""6/ F"0 _K60 @"# "K#6/%,/6 EK0 @"# "0J/#6 $6 H/%%4 5/ ?#/$0/ $ ?/#0$*F *L$)/ "@ L$F *F

"K# ?J""6*F)P $ ?/#0$*F *-/$%4 S" *F L$Q*F) ?J"*?/6 H/ ?J""6/ @"# $%% L/F4

S$#0#/ L$2 J$,/ E//F #*)J0 0" 6K))/60 0J$0 "K# ?J"*?/6 6J$(/ HJ" H/ $#/ $F- 0J$0 0J/2

#/@%/?0 HJ$0 H/ 0J*FQ $F *-/$% JKL$F "K)J0 0" E/P EK0 F"F/ "@ 0J$0 *L(%*/6 0J$0 "K#

?J"*?/6 -/0/#L*F/ ,$%K/4 ̂ / J$6 (#",*-/- 6*L(%2 F" "E_/?0*,/ E$6*6 @"# "K# ?J/#*6J/-

L"#$% ?"F,*?0*"F6P 6K?J $6 0J/ H#"F)F/66 "@ E/$0*F) "F/N6 H*@/ "# 0J/ #*)J0F/66 "@

#/6("F6*E%/ ?J*%- #/$#*F)4 'F- $F2 6/F6/ *F HJ*?J "K# ?J"*?/6P ?"F60#K/- $%"F)/O*60/F0*$%*60 %*F/6P *F,"%,/ $ ?J"*?/ @"# $%% "@ JKL$F*02P $6 S$#0#/ (K0 *0P #/L$*F6 L"#/

0J$F "E6?K#/4

IJ/ T%$0"F*606 0#2 ?$(0K#*F) 60#"F) L"#$% 0#K0J6P EK0 J$,/ %*00%/ 0" "@@/# "F 0J/ *66K/ "@

L"#$% @#//-"L4 eO*60/F0*$%*606 %*Q/ S$#0#/ 0#2 ?$(0K#*F) L"#$% @#//-"L E2 $66KL*F) *0

$6 $O*"L$0*?P EK0 0J/2 *F0/#(#/0 *0 6" #$-*?$%%2 0J$0 H/ J$,/ 0" -*6?$#- "K# ?"F,*?0*"F6

$E"K0 0#$-*0*"F$% L"#$%*024 .K0 E"0J L"#$% @#//-"LP #*)J0%2 KF-/#60""-P $F- 60$E%/

L"#$% 0#K0J6 $#/ ?#K?*$% 0" /0J*?6P $F- F" (*?0K#/ H*0J"K0 E"0J *6 ?"L(%/0/4 \/*0J/# 0J/

T%$0"F*606 F"# 0J/ /O*60/F0*$%*606 -*6?K66/-P *F "0J/# H"#-6P 6//L ?$($E%/ "@ 6K60$*F*F)


21/29


22/29

$F- *06 -/0/#L*F*60*? @#$L/H"#Q L/$F6 0J$0 ,*0$% L"#$% ?$0/)"#*/6P 0" 6K#,*,/P J$,/ 0"

E/ H$0/#/- -"HF $F- #/(%$?/-4 8@P %*Q/ e4 74 5*%6"F`C "# YK66/%%P H/ H/#/ ?"F,*F?/-

0J$0 $0J/*6L *6 0J/ 6"E/# 0#K0J "@ 0J/ L$00/#P 0J/F $ #/$6"F @"# 6/00%*F) @"# 6KE60*0K0/6 "@ *L("#0$F0 L"#$% ?$0/)"#*/6 H"K%- E/ 0J$0 *0N6 0J/ E/60 H/ ?$F -"4 IJ/ ("*F0 $0 *66K/ J/#/P

0J"K)JP *6 $+"*+"& $0J/*6L *6 0J/ 0#K0JP $F- H/N,/ $#)K/- 0J$0 (#*"# ?"F,*?0*"F6 $E"K0

L"#$%*02 ?"KF0 ("6*0*,/%2 *F @$,"# "@ 0J/*6L $F- $)$*F60 F$0K#$%*6L4

X"F0#$ ./#0#$F- YK66/%%P 0J/ /,*-/F?/ @"# M"-N6 /O*60/F?/ L*)J0 J$,/ E//F 6" ?%/$# $F-

KE*ZK*0"K6 0J$0 J/ 6*L(%2 ",/#%""Q/- *04 5J/#/$6 0J/ /O*60/F0*$%*606 $#/ #*)J0 0" 6//

0J/ *L("#0$F?/ "@ L"#$% @#//-"LP 0J/*# H"#%-,*/H ?$FN0 6K60$*F *0P F"0 0" L/F0*"F 0J/

$K0J"#*02 "@ L"#$% "E%*)$0*"F6j $F- HJ/#/$6 0J/ T%$0"F*606 $#/ #*)J0 0" 6// 0J/ $K0J"#*02

"@ L"#$% %$H6P 0J/2 /F?"KF0/# 6/,/#/ -*@@*?K%02 L$Q*F) 6/F6/ "@ 0J/ L"#$% @#//-"L H/

#/ZK*#/ 0" 6KEL*0 0" 6K?J %$H64 G$F0P 3/H*6P !$?Q*/P \/HL$FP S*-)H*?QP $F- S"#%/2 $%% #/?")F*R/- 0J/ H$2 $ !*F- E/J*F- 0J/ L"#$% %$H ?$F L$Q/ 6/F6/ "@ *06 -*?0$0/6 $F-

$K0J"#*02 $F- /F6K#/ "#$ *' & *06 #/6"F$F?/ H*0J #$0*"F$%*02WHJ/0J/# "# F"0 0J/2 H/#/

H*%%*F) 0" "(0 @"# 0J*6 6"%K0*"F4 T$2L/F0 "@ %*( 6/#,*?/ 0" 0J/ $K0J"#*02 $F- E/$K02 "@

L"#$%*02 H*0J"K0 @*F$%%2 ?"L*F) 0" 0/#L6 H*0J 0J/ 6J"#0?"L*F)6 "@ $ F$0K#$%*60*? $??"KF0

"@ L"#$%*02P %*Q/ H/ @*F- *F .#$F-0P 5*/%/FE/#)P $F- .%$?QEK#FP %$?Q6 (J*%"6"(J*?$%

?#/-*E*%*02WF" L$00/# J"H L$F2 0*L/6 0J/2 #/(/$0 0J/*# L$F0#$ *F $ %"K- $F- ?"F@*-/F0

,"*?/4 !"#/ #/$6"F$E%/ *F $ #/$% 6/F6/ *6 0J/ #/?")F*0*"F 0J$0 \*/0R6?J/P !$?Q*/P $F-

S$#0#/ J$- 0J$0 M"-N6 -/$0J J$6 E*) L"#$% *L(%*?$0*"F6P EK0 "K# ("*F0 *6 0J/ "(("6*0/

$F- ($#$%%/% "F/9 0J$0 M"-N6 /O*60/F?/ ("0/F0*$%%2 (#",*-/6 $F $??"KF0 "@ _K60 0J"6/

-*60*F?0*,/ @/$0K#/6 "@ L"#$%*02 0J$0 H/ $#/ "0J/#H*6/ 6" J$#-f(#/66/- 0" L$Q/ 6/F6/ "@9*06 #$0*"F$%*02P *06 F//- @"# @#//-"LP *06 *L("6*0*"F "@ $K0J"#*0$0*,/ -K0*/6P $F- 0J/ %*Q/4

' L"#$% $#)KL/F0 @"# M"-N6 /O*60/F?/ ?$F $,"*- 0J/ H/$QF/66/6 "@ 0J/ 0J*FQ/#6 H/N,/

?"F6*-/#/- HJ*%/ ?$(0K#*F) 0J/*# E/60 *F6*)J06 E2 6J"H*F) J"H (#"@"KF-%2 #/6"F$F0

0J/*6L *6 H*0J L"#$%*02 ?%$66*?$%%2 ?"F60#K/-4 .K0 H/N,/ "F%2 _K60 E/)KFP @"# 0" L$Q/ "K#

?$6/P H/ J$,/ ZK*0/ $ E*0 "@ H"#Q 0" -" *F #/L$*F*F) ?J$(0/#6P E/)*FF*F) H*0J 0J/ L"60

#/?K##*F) $F- L"60 @$L"K6 "E_/?0*"F "@ $%%P -/#*,/- @#"L 0J/ H#*0*F)6 "@ T%$0"4 "#$ +) &

\"0/69

a:4b X4 S4 3/H*6P 2"&" 3+&-(*-41-*# a\/H o"#Q9 !$?L*%%$FP :


23/29

a=4b .2 H$2 "@ $ 6J"#0 (#/,*/H "@ ?"L*F) $00#$?0*"F6P $%%"H K6 0" ("*F0 "K0 _K60 0J#//

?"F0/L("#$#2 (J*%"6"(J/#6 HJ" J$,/ "@@/#/- #/@"#LK%$0*"F6 "@ 0J/ "#$ *+) & L"#$%

$#)KL/F0 @"# M"-N6 /O*60/F?/9 3*F-$ q$)R/E6Q*P [+"/6 e0J*?6 \//- M"-g] F4-*+ 41'

E+-0%(%/+# ` a:


24/29

a:;4b M/"#)/ !$,#"-/6P [Y/%*)*"F $F- 0J/ sK//#F/66 "@ !"#$%*02P] *F


25/29

a:B4b 5/ #/@#$*F @#"L 6$2*F) 0J$0 /)"*6L H"K%- #/F-/# 0J/ L"#$% $#)KL/F0 $%0")/0J/#

*L("0/F0P 6*F?/ *@P $6 /0J*?$% /)"*6L L$*F0$*F6P H/ J$,/ $F "E_/?0*,/ L"#$% "E%*)$0*"F 0"

(K#6K/ 6/%@f*F0/#/60P 0J/F *0 *6 $F "E_/?0*,/ L"#$% "E%*)$0*"F $@0/# $%%P $F- 0J/ /O*60/F?/

"@ $F2 Q*F- "@ "E_/?0*,/ L"#$% "E%*)$0*"F *6 -*@@*?K%0P *@ F"0 *L("66*E%/P 0" #/?"F?*%/

H*0J F$0K#$%*6LP "# 6" H/ H*%% $#)K/4 .K0 "E_/?0*,/ /0J*?$% /)"*6L H"K%- ?/#0$*F%2 F"0

?"F-K?/P *F "0J/# #/6(/?06P 0" 0J/ 6"#0 "@ L"#$% $#)KL/F0 H/ H*%% @$,"#4

a:


26/29

0J"K)J 0J/#/N6 F" )/F/#$% -*@@/#/F?/ E/0H//F K6 E2 HJ*?J 0" _K60*@2 *04 S" /0J*?$% /)"*6L

*6 KF$??/(0$E%2 $#E*0#$#24

aD:4b ^/F#2 S*-)H*?QP ;+" 2"*+%'( %,


27/29


28/29


29/29

a``4b I" 0J/ /O0/F0 0J$0 S$#0#/ '%"( $#)K/ $)$*F60 -/0/#L*F*6LP J/ *L(%*?$0/6 J*L6/%@ *F

$ ?"F0#$-*?0*"F4 ^/ H#*0/6 0J$0 [0J/#/ *6 F" @*O/- JKL$F F$0K#/ E/?$K6/ 0J/#/ *6 F" M"-

0" ?"F?/*,/ *0P] 6" J/ 6//L6 0" 0J*FQ 0J$0 "F%2 M"- ?$F L$Q/ 6/F6/ "@ $ @*O/- F$0K#/ 0J$0

/O*606 E/@"#/ H/ $#/ 0J#K60 *F0" /O*60/F?/4 '0 0J/ 6$L/ 0*L/P J"H/,/#P J/ 0J*FQ6 0J$0P *@

H/ '-' J$,/ $ @*O/- F$0K#/P 0J$0 H"K%- )#"KF- 0J/ ?"F,*?0*"F 0J$0 -/0/#L*F*6L *6 0#K/4

7F J*6 ,*/HP *0 *6FN0 $F "(0*"F 0" /O(%$*F $H$2 "K# $?0*"F6 E2 #/@/#/F?/ 0" $ @*O/- $F-

)*,/F JKL$F F$0K#/P 6*F?/ 0J/#/ *6 F" -/0/#L*F*6L "F J*6 $F$%26*64 !"#$%*02 *6 ("66*E%/

E/?$K6/ -/0/#L*F*6L *6FN0 0#K/4 ^"H/,/#P *@ M"- /O*60/-P S$#0#/ ?%$*L6P 0J/#/ $%50'

E/ 0J*6 6"#0 "@ @*O/- F$0K#/ 0J$0 H"K%- #K%/ L"#$%*02 "K04 IJ*6 ?%$*L 60$F-6 *F "E,*"K6

0/F6*"F H*0J J*6 ?%$*L 0J$0 0J/ %"66 "@ M"- #/6K%0/- *F 0J/ %"66 "@ $F "E_/?0*,/ /0J*?6

(#/6?#*E*F) J"H H/ E/J$,/4 U"# *@ S$#0#/ H$6 #*)J0 0J$0 M"-N6 /O*60/F?/ $F- *F0/F0*"F$%

?#/$0*"F "@ K6 H"K%- J$,/ )*,/F K6 $ 60$E%/ F$0K#/ 0J$0 H"K%- "#$ *+- & J$,/ L$-/ K6

-/0/#L*F/- 0" E/J$,/ 0J/ H$2 H/ -"P 0J/F M"-N6 /O*60/F?/ H"K%- J$,/ L*%*0$0/- 474-1(* "E_/?0*,/ /0J*?64 ./*F) -/0/#L*F/- E2 0J*6 @*O/- F$0K#/P "F J*6 ,*/HP H/ H"K%- F"0 J$,/

E//F $E%/ 0" -" "0J/#H*6/4

a`C4b 5*%6"FP $ (#"L*F/F0 ?"F0/L("#$#2 0J*FQ/# HJ" J"%-6 0J/ F$0K#$%*60*? H"#%-,*/HP

6$26 JKL$F*02N6 E*) (#"E%/L *6 0J$0 6"L/ "@ *06 -//(/60 -/6*#/6 $#/ ?"L(%/0/%2 "K0 "@

62F? H*0J #/$%*024 ^/ (K06 *0 %*Q/ 0J*69 [IJ/ /66/F?/ "@ JKL$F*02N6 6(*#*0K$% -*%/LL$

*6 0J$0 H/ /,"%,/- 0" $??/(0 "F/ 0#K0J $F- -*6?",/#/- $F"0J/#4] 5J$0 J/ L/$F6 *6

0J$0 $6 JKL$F E/*F)6 /,"%,/- 0J/2 ?$L/ 0" E/%*/,/ *F M"-P *F %*@/ $@0/# -/$0JP $F-

"E_/?0*,/ L"#$%*024 .K0 /,/F0K$%%2P *F L"-/#F 0*L/6P 0J/2 ?$L/ 0" -*6?",/# 0J$0 M"-

-"/6 F"0 /O*60P 0J$0 L"#$%*02 *6 6"L/0J*F) H/ ?#/$0/- @"# "K# "HF (K#("6/6P 0J$0 0J/#/*6 F" L/$F*F) E/2"F- 0J*6 %*@/4 S// J*6 [IJ/ .*"%")*?$% .$6*6 "@ !"#$%*02P] J*041*-9

2%1*+0# a'(#*% :

moral apologia

Documents