8/14/2019 Mooers' Law or Why Some Retrieval Systems Are Used and Others Are Not

1/2

X`e`ehxcjn`

Eaa`x~/ Lcw ax _b ^ae` X`}xg`ycl ^ ~}`e~ Cx`P~`m cjm A}b`x~ Cx` Ja}

^ 1 b GN 33~% c j m Gb ` ` j y gx a g l jgn/ j} gj vx`~`j} gj}nllnn})l cjm njogjn`xgjonlgwbgnb }b` cx` p~nm w}xplm ~n`jg lab` gj axm`xc} } b g b vagj}* _n cxn cll z;gw;gxn}bc} ~ae` x`}xg`yggl~ z g n g j ~ *cl}bapob }`nbjgncll xgg}bnx vnwx* j`y`x%}bnlnpb xnnngyn gj}nj0gynP]N* w b g l na}bnx~ ~}ne~* ~ae`}gen~ }nnb}ggnclly`x epnb bn}}nx*xnnngyn y`x lg}}l`np~}ajg`xp~`* _b g~ }bg~/1

Gpbaplm lgbn } a `rvlcgj }bg~ ~g}pc}gajh cmycj ngjo iax apx naj~gmnxgl}gajggvxgjngvl` axl c w ai bnbcygax BbgnbGh`lg`y` oay`xj~ }b` p~ aixngxg`ycl~ ~}`e~* _ ` b;gw ;ml b`cxm ai/ (Vcxkgj%~agl/~ L g g _ ( o a y ` x j g j o w g j g }a i }b`jgaxn vxnva~}nxap~ }g/;g}ggxn~a i }lgnnrva%

j`j}gcl oxaw}b g j ~ g r ai oay`xje`j}cn}gyg}gn~*Gj cjclao * w` egob} Ng}lG}b nia l lawgjo vxgjngvl ` (Eaanx~/ Lcw / /lax x`}xg`ycl ~ *;}`e~*

_` bcy` cll ~``j x`vax}~ m`~nxghgjox`}xg`ycl~ ~ } ` e wbgnb nc j v `x iaxej e n ` i igng`j}l * ~`cxnb eax` xggvgml *avnxc}na j lcxo`xnall`n}gaj~ cj m ~ a a j*Baw`y`x* c~ wn ipxjg~b apx np~}ae`x~eax` cjm bn}}nxx`}xg`ycl ~ ~}`e v`xiax%jgcjnn* ncj w ` b` c~~p x`m }bgl} }bn wgll

x`}xg`ycl~ ~}`e wgll }`jmgxag } } gbx p~`m wb`j`y`x g}g~ gggaxn/v g g g g %igll c j m } x a p b l n ~ a j g n i a xc n p ~}ajg`x }a bcy` gjiaxjgp}ga j }bcj } g wbge ja } }a bcy` g } ,G i bg~lc w g \ }xp`%%cjmGbxlg`yx }bc}

g}g~%}bg~g ~ gjm``m ;G vn~pggggg~}gncjg}`y`j ;G n jgn;glnajnlp~gaj* G j}b bpglm%gjo cjm vlcjjgjo ai/ a p x g g z } z z e g c zbc jmlg jo c jm xn}xgnygggv~ ~}`e~* \Y K

z bcy` }nggmnm} a h`lg`y` gevlgng}l *;gjm3 }a c r ~ p g j ` } b x a p o b a p } *} b g l } Ggggygggz g j i a x e c } g a j ` c ~ g l ; gy g gg lc b l nw g } >

clwc ~ ;g v a m }bgjo,cjm }bc}cll vnavlnz w ba bcm cn/nn\~ } a cgl gjiaxjggg}gaj\# \ %

}n}gg waplm wcj} }a LG\N }b n ~ n}n/jg }a

v`} }b` gj iaegc}gaj*33g~ g g a w gj'; ~pv%on~}gaj }bc} gje vnavl` e c j a3 wcj}gjiaegc}gaj* 4pgm}bgg} }b` w g l l cyagmp ~ g j o c ~ ~x`gggvx`ng~`l b n w x g x x n z}ogy`~}b`ggggj}axjgj}gnxg*G ~lgcll j ap * }x

Bcygjo gjiaxec}gaj g n vcgjipl ggjm3 6 dLg~}gie cb~nx}ga3g~*

}xajbl`~ae`* \Y` ;gll bcy` nrvn/xgnjnnm}bg~*Gi ap bcy` gggia}egg}gaxg* a g g G j g g \ }}gx~xx`cm g}*wbgnb g~ g g a }c lwc ~`cb *Wap ep~} }b`j }x }a pj}l`xb}cjmg}*/3/6

W4g}` vx`ycgl~* ] b g b G/xc}px`%%cjm g}~v%x`ycl` jn` g~ cll }nw najgg}gajvlcnn gje c j w n a e v c j g ` ~ * G 4 gb a x c } a xg ~ ~ c j mco`jng`~%g~ }bc} i ax ec j v`avl` g} g~eax` vcgjipl c}gm}xapbl`~axj`}a bcy`gjiaeg;g}gaj }bcj iax}b`jg ja } }a b w n

88 HpG_lj m }b` Ce`xgncj ^a`ga} iax Gjiaep}gaj # % a z n } a h e ! J a y z 779

Hpll`}gj ai }b` Ce`xgncj ang`}w iax Gjiaxec}gaj ng`jn`, v*88%8>, An}ah`x ! Jay`eh`x 3779

8/14/2019 Mooers' Law or Why Some Retrieval Systems Are Used and Others Are Not

2/2

ma }bg~*a p gjc lgcyn }a }lggxgk cbap}g} *]b ` gj}ajjc}gaj e c x`spgx` ap}aeck` m`ng~gaj~chap} g}ax a}b`x gjiax%e c } g a j * ]b` m ` n g ~ g a j ~ec x ` s p g x `cn}gaj g j }b` wc ai c }xapbl`~ajx` vxa%

ox;e ai waxk* ax}xgv~ ax vcgjipl gj}`x%yg`w~* G#jm`x~}cjmgjo}bn gj}axec}gaglec ~baw }bc} apx waxkw c~ wxgeo*"g x glgcx apx ba~~ w g g ~ p w j o * ax gpc\ b a w } b c} a p x waxk w c ~ jwml`~~*GGjygjo g}giajjc}gaj, ap ep~} bn n e %lp l ja } }a la~` g} *Gija}bgjo nlcn* gjiax%xj;g}gaj vgl`~ p vaj apxmn~k%pjxnc}l*G }g~c jpg~cjn` 36 bcy` g}najgn}a \4ap* G }g ~pjnajg}ax}cbln}a bpyn }a mp cj }bgjogghap} g} *Igjcll * gl ap ma }x }a p~`}b ` gjiaxec}gaj vxav`xl * ap ec h`cnnp~nm ai vp}}`xgjo gj~}ncmai waxk%gjo* ]b`j gj }b` `jm* }b` gjnasexc}gaj

ai }bn gjiaxec}gaj gj}a }b ` waxk apm aec a i} ` j ja } b` ja}gn`m ax cvv xnng%; x g m *_axk ~cy`mg~~nlmae wnavjgr`m*_ axk maj`%`y`j gj mpvlgnc}gaj%g~w m l vcgm cjm x`wcxm`m*

] b p ~ ja} bcygjo cjm ja } p~gjo gjiax%ec}gaj ncj ai}`j l cm }a l`~~ }xapblng}jm vcgj }bcj bcygjojjnl p~gjo g x *3 r 3

e` `rvlcgj }bg~ ipx}bnx*Gj gggcj waxkn j y g a j e ` ~* }b ` v ` j c G}` ~ l a x j n3 }b`gjo mglgo`j}gj }bn }gggmgjvcj m pb` aigjiaxec}gaj cx}4 egjax* gi }b` `rg~} c}c l l* Gj icn}*nggnblcnk a lmglgonjn }`jm~

ai}`j } a bn xn\yllxmn}l*] b ` ecj wb aman~ ja} "p~%wg}b gjiaxec}gaj g~~nnjc} b g~ bnjnb* vlcgjl c} waxk* o`}}gjo}b`da h maj`* *=vvxay;glvw ~ } g ' vxadnn}~wb`x` }bgjo~ cxn bcvi r jg jo*Aj` ep~}h` napxconnnp~ ax gevxpm`j}*a x ba}b,} a vagj} ap} }xae }b ` lg}nxc}pxn}bc} cnpxx`j} Gglbaxc}xxxvxad`n} wbgnb bgl~bcm cj `rv `j~gy` bg~}ax ;emi p l l bcnk%gjo ai }bn g}g4egonggg`xg}wc~ ip}gl` ixae}lgx w } ~ n } *C} ;G m`~k*cj ;cp}bax a i ;G}`nbjgngmx`vax}, h ja } }jglbgjo c vxgaxlg}`xc}px` ~`cxnb*cjm b aeg}}gjong};g%}ga j~ } a `cxlg`x waxk,nc j vxxvcxnbg~x`vax}~~ a epnb ic~}`x*wg}b }b` jmmg%} g a j mcmycj}co` }bgg}vx*ngvl`wgll }bgjk}b` gm`c~ vxn~nj}nmwnxn ggnwcjm w`x`bg~ a w j ; Pjlgk` c e``}gjo 3 c}}`jm`mgj @jolcjm, c} `jogj`nxgjo xggnn}g}gohg j}bg~ na}gj}xg} g~ ja} naj~gmxx`m spg}`vxnxvnx iaxc ggg`xjb`xa}/ }b` cpmgnjnn

vpcv` }b`ng}c}gaj cjmicn}~~bawgjo }b`lcnk ai naj}`j} ax j awl} g j c vgvnx*

_b`x` x`wcxm~* gj~}ncma i vpjg~b%e`j}* oa wg}b _ D l p~gjo gjlaxgjc}gaj*w ` nggj ` r v ` n } }bc}cj gj iaxec}ga j

x`xgxg`ycl~ n}`e wgll b p~`m a j l wg}bx`lpn}cjn`*A j }b` a}bnxbcjm* }bnxn cxn~g}pc}gaj~ w b`x}b` mglgo`j} igjmgggocjm p~n ai gjiaxjgc}gaj g~ ~}x`~b`mcjmxn\x,cxmnm* cjm wb`x` icglpx`}a xgjma x}a p~` gjlgejc}gaj g~wy` x`l vpjg~b`m*Gj wplg vlcna~*w` ncj `rv`n} x`}xg`yclp ~}njg~ } a bn cn}gy`l p~`mcjm w ` nc jnrvnn} vxn\~ggxn}xaggg }b` gjlaxec}gajp~`x~ }b`e~` ly`~ i a x bn}}nx~ ~}`x}g~*]bg~ }pjgn ap} }a b` }xpngj vxcn}gn`*

Hpll`}gj ai }b E ` c j ank} iax Gjiaxemge ^ n l * e h A c a h ` x l J a y ` e h j 3779 8>