montgomery sibley petition for writ of certiorari - united states supreme court - 3/28/2012

8/2/2019 Montgomery Sibley Petition for Writ of Certiorari - United States Supreme Court - 3/28/2012

1/14

LE ^FI [YRPIHI KAYPÂG ^FI YELÎN [^MÎ[

Le Pi:Yel~in [~m~i{ ag Mhiplkm# Iv Picm~ap# Hae~dahip|@cmlp [l`ci|# men Hae~dahip| @cmlp [l`ci|#Lenlwlnymcc|#

Ri~l~laeip%

Ri~l~lae gap Tpl~ ag Kip~lapmpl ~a ~fiYel~in [~m~i{ Kayp~ ag Mrrimc{ gap ~fiNl{~plk~ ag Kacyh`lm Klpkyl~

Ri~l~lae gap Tpl~ ag Kip~lapmplHae~dahip| @cmlp [l`ci|>222 Hm{{mkfy{i~~{ Mwi# ET[yl~i =9=6Tm{fled~ae# N%K% 02227&020, >46(2;4=

Kar| kayp~i{| ag ttt%A`mhmPicim{i\aypPikapn{%kah ( ttt%@lp~fipPirap~%kah


2/14

]yi{~lae Rpi{ie~in Gap PiwlitRi~l~laeip m kl~lzie ag ~fi Yel~in [~m~i{ men

m Pidl{~ipin Tpl~i(Le Kmenlnm~i gap Rpi{lnie~ ag ~fiYel~in [~m~i{ glcin ae Jmeymp| ;# 02=0# `a~f m{ ivpicm~ap~fi Yel~in [~m~i{ men lenlwlnymcc|# m }yatmppme~a{yl~ mdmle{~ @mpmko Fy{{ile A`mhm# LL#kfmcciedled fl{ Mp~lkci LL# = icldl`lcl~| ~a facn ~fiagglki ag Rpi{lnie~ le {a hykf m{ fl{ Gm~fip tm{ ea~

m Yel~in [~m~i{ Kl~lzie% ^fi Nl{~plk~ Kayp~ ~a nm~ifm{ pigy{in ~a pyciyrae ~fm~ Ri~l~lae%

Mkkapnledc|# ae Gi`pymp| =># 02=0# Ri~l~laeipglcin m Ri~l~lae gap Hmenmhy{ le ~fi Klpkyl~ Kayp~{iioled me apnip pi}ylpled ~fi Nl{~plk~ Kayp~ ~aivrinl~lay{c| pyci aei tm| ap mea~fip yrae ~fi }yatmppme~ari~l~lae% Le pi{rae{i# ae Hmpkf 7# 02=0#

~fi Klpkyl~ Kayp~ pycin ~fm~: ^fi nl{~plk~ kayp~{nicm| le pycled ae ~fi ri~l~lae gap tpl~ ag }yatmppme~a l{ ea~ {a idpidlay{ ap yepim{aem`ci m{ ~atmppme~ ~fi iv~pmapnlemp| pihin| ag hmenmhy{%

Mkkapnledc|# rpi{ie~in gap piwlit l{ ~figaccatled }yi{~lae:

TFI^FIP ~fi }yi{~lae ag ~fi icldl`lcl~| ag@mpmko Fy{{ile A`mhm# LL ~a `i Rpi{lnie~ rpi{ie~{m km{i ag iv~pmapnlemp| kae{~l~y~laemc hahie~nihmenled rpahr~ pi{acy~lae `| ~fi Nl{~plk~ Kayp~#~fi Klpkyl~ Kayp~ men# yc~lhm~ic|# ~fl{ Kayp~%


3/14

( ll (

^m`ci ag Kae~ie~{]yi{~lae{ Rpi{ie~in gap Piwlit % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % l

^m`ci ag My~fapl~li{ % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % lll

Arlelae icat % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % =

Jypl{nlk~lae % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % =

Kae{~l~y~laemc Rpawl{lae{# ^pim~li{# [~m~y~i{#Apnlemeki{ men Pidycm~lae{ Lewacwin % % % % % 0

[~m~ihie~ ag ~fi Km{i % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % 0

Pim{ae gap Dpme~led ~fi Tpl~ % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % 9

L% Tfi~fip A`mhm L{ Icldl`ci ~a @iRpi{lnie~ L{ m ]yi{~lae agIv~pmapnlemp| Kae{~l~y~laemc Hahie~men Nihmen{ Rpahr~ Pi{acy~lae % % % % % % % % 9

Kaekcy{lae % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % 4

Kae~ie~{ ag Mrrienlv % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % M(=

^fi Hmpkf 7# 02=0# Apnip `| ~fiKlpkyl~ Kayp~ % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % M(0


4/14

( lll (

^m`ci ag My~fapl~li{Km{i{

Gmlpkflcn w% Fydfi{# 096 Y%[% =07# =;2 &==6 Y%[% 76;# 767(764

&=, % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % 4

Tmc~ip{ w% Em~$c M{{$e ag Pmnlm~lae# >4; Y%[%;29# ;9= &=


5/14

( = (

Ri~l~lae gap Tpl~ ag Kip~lapmpl ~a ~fi Yel~in [~m~i{Kayp~ ag Mrrimc{gap ~fi Nl{~plk~ ag Kacyh`lm Klpkyl~Ri~l~laeip# Hae~dahip| @cmlp [l`ci|# rpm|{

~fm~ m tpl~ ag kip~lapmpl l{{yi ~a piwlit ~fi jyndhie~men arlelae ag ~fi Yel~in [~m~i{ Kayp~ ag Mrrimc{gap ~fi Nl{~plk~ ag Kacyh`lm Klpkyl~ ie~ipin ae

Hmpkf 7# 02=0%

Piwlit l{ hmenm~in `ikmy{i ag ~fi ry`clklhrap~meki ag ~fi l{{yi rpi{ie~in men ~fi eiin gap~fm~ l{{yi{ rpahr~ pi{acy~lae%

Arlelae @icat^fi Hmpkf 7# 02=0# arlelae ag ~fi Klpkyl~

Kayp~ l{ pirple~in le ~fi mrrienlv fipi~a# Mrrienlv(0%

Jypl{nlk~lae^fi jypl{nlk~lae ag ~fl{ Kayp~ l{ lewaoin

yenip Mp~lkci LLL men ~fi Ele~f Mhienhie~ ~a ~fiYel~in [~m~i{ Kae{~l~y~lae men 06 Y%[%K% =09>&=,%Jypl{nlk~lae le ~fi Klpkyl~ Kayp~ tm{ lewaoinryp{yme~ ~a Mcc Tpl~{ Mk~# 06 Y%[%K% =79=&m,%Jypl{nlk~lae ag ~fi Nl{~plk~ Kayp~ tm{ lewaoinryp{yme~ ~a: &l, 06 Y%[%K% =;;=# &ll, 06 Y%[%K%=;>;&m,# &lll, 06 Y%[%K% 002= men 0020# &lw, >0

Y%[%K% =


6/14

( 0 (

Kae{~l~y~laemc Rpawl{lae{# ^pim~li{# [~m~y~i{#Apnlemeki{ men Pidycm~lae{ Lewacwin06 Y%[%K% =79=# Tpl~{:

&m, ^fi [yrpihi Kayp~ men mcc kayp~{i{~m`cl{fin `| Mk~ ag Kaedpi{{ hm| l{{yi mcc tpl~{eiki{{mp| ap mrrparplm~i le mln ag ~filp pi{rik~lwi

jypl{nlk~lae{ men mdpiim`ci ~a ~fi y{mdi{ menrpleklrci{ ag cmt%

&`, Me mc~ipem~lwi tpl~ ap pyci el{l hm| ìl{{yin `| m jy{~lki ap jyndi ag m kayp~ tflkf fm{jypl{nlk~lae%

[~m~ihie~ ag ~fi Km{iAe Jmeymp| ;# 02=0# Ri~l~laeip glcin m

Kip~lglin Ri~l~lae gap Tpl~{ ]ya Tmppme~a menHmenmhy{ men Kahrcmle~ gap Nmhmdi{ mdmle{~#mhaed a~fip{# @mpmko Fy{{ile A`mhm# LL&A`mhm,% Rpakiinled à~f lenlwlnymcc| men ivpicm~apm{ my~faplzin `| ~fi Kaedpi{{laemcc|(iemk~in N%K% Kani# ^l~ci =7# ;92;# Ri~l~laeip{aydf~ m Tpl~ ag ]ya Tmppme~a ay{~led A`mhm m{Rpi{lnie~ ag ~fi Yel~in [~m~i{ men!ap rpiwie~ledflh gpah facnled ~fi gpmekfl{i ag ìled ae ~fi`mcca~ gap ~fm~ agglki le 02=0 le{ahykf m{: &l, fi l{ea~ m em~ypmc àpe Kl~lzie ag ~fi Yel~in [~m~i{ m{pi}ylpin `| Mp~lkci LL# =# ag ~fi Y%[% Kae{~l~y~lae

men &ll, ~fipi l{ rpa`m`ci kmy{i ~a ìcliwi A`mhm{kcmlh ~fm~ fi tm{ àpe tl~fle ~fi Yel~in [~m~i{ l{`m{in {acic| yrae gapdin nakyhie~{%


7/14

( ; (

M{ ~a ~fi glp{~ l{{yi# ~fipi l{ ea nl{ry~i ~fm~A`mhm{ Gm~fip tm{ ea~ m kl~lzie ag ~fi Yel~in[~m~i{ ~fy{ rpikcynled A`mhm yenip ~fi =6~fKie~yp| niglel~lae ag ~fi cidmc(~iph(ag(mp~ agem~ypmc àpe Kl~lzie gpah ìled icldl`ci ~a ìRpi{lnie~%

M{ ~a ~fi cakm~lae ag fl{ `lp~f# A`mhm fm{

ry`clkmcc| picim{in ~ta nlggipie~ Kip~lglkm~i{ agClwi @lp~f &KAC@, ry~m~lwic| gpah ~fi [~m~i agFmtmll le me m~~ihr~ ~a nihae{~pm~i ~fm~ fi tm{àpe le ~fi Yel~in [~m~i{% ^fpii {irmpm~i menlenirienie~ ivrip~ nakyhie~ ivmhleip{ fmwiivmhlein karli{ ag imkf ag ~fi KAC@{ men gayen{ldelglkme~ lenlkm~lae{ ag gapdip| pml{led ~fi wip|

pimc {rik~ip ~fm~ A`mhm tm{ ea~ iwie àpe le ~fiYel~in [~m~i{% Karli{ ag ~fi pirap~{ ag ~fi ~fpiiivrip~ nakyhie~ ivmhleip{ tipi glcin ag pikapn le~fi Nl{~plk~ Kayp~%

Ae Jmeymp|


8/14

( > (

Wad~# tfa ie~ipin {tape ivrip~ arlelae{ ~fm~ ~fiKAC@{ picim{in `| A`mhm mpi gapdipli{%

Mg~ip tml~led gap~| &>2, nm|{ le ~fi rpawip`lmcjynlklmc ni{ip~ men m{ ~fi Nl{~plk~ Kayp~ fmn gmlcin ~apyci ae il~fip ~fi }ya tmppme~ari~l~lae ap ha~lae~a ivrinl~i# Ri~l~laeip glcin le ~fi Yel~in [~m~i{Kayp~ ag Mrrimc{ gap ~fi Nl{~plk~ ag Kacyh`lm Klpkyl~

m Ri~l~lae gap Tpl~ agHmenmhy{ap# mc~ipem~lwic|#gap Tpl~ Rpakinienyh Mn Jy{~lklyh{iioled meapnip kahhmenled ~fi Nl{~plk~ Kayp~ ~a gap~ftl~fni~iphlei tfi~fip ap ea~ me apnip ~a {fat kmy{i{faycn l{{yi ~a A`mhm kahriccled flh ~a {fat tf|fi {faycn ea~ ì ay{~in gpah ~fi agglki ag Rpi{lnie~ag ~fi Yel~in [~m~i{ men!ap {~plrrin ag ~fi gpmekfl{i

~a mrrimp ae ~fi `mcca~ gap ~fm~ agglki le 02=0%

Tl~fay~ riphl~~led ~fi pi}yi{~in apmcmpdyhie~# ~fi Klpkyl~ Kayp~ ie~ipin l~{ apnip aeHmpkf 7# 02=0# {~m~led le rip~leie~ rmp~: Apnipin~fm~ ~fi ri~l~lae ì nielin% ^fi nl{~plk~ kayp~{nicm| le pycled ae ~fi ri~l~lae gap tpl~ ag }yatmppme~a l{ ea~ {a idpidlay{ ap yepim{aem`ci m{ ~atmppme~ ~fi iv~pmapnlemp| pihin| ag hmenmhy{%Mrrienlv(0%

Ae Hmpkf 6# 02=0# Ri~l~laeip glcin m Ri~l~laegap Pi(FimpledIe @mekap# Mc~ipem~lwic|# RmeicPifimpled tflkf# m{ ag ~fi rple~led ag ~fi le{~me~Ri~l~lae# fm{ ea~ ìie pycin yrae% Le ~fi iwie~ ~fm~

me apnip l{ ie~ipin `| ~fi Klpkyl~ Kayp~ ae ~fiRi~l~lae gap Pifimpled# Ri~l~laeip tlcc lhhinlm~ic|glci m [yrrcihie~mc Mrrienlv tl~f ~fm~ Apnip%


9/14

( 9 (

Pim{ae gap Dpme~led ~fi Tpl~^fipi l{ aec| aei kahriccled pim{ae gap

dpme~led ~fl{ Ri~l~lae% ^fi }yi{~lae ag ~fiicldl`lcl~| ag A`mhm l{ aei tflkf yc~lhm~ic| hy{~ ìfimpn men ni~iphlein `| ~fl{ Kayp~ m~ ~fi impcli{~ra{{l`ci nm~i% â mccat nicm| taycn ì hmelgi{~c|mdmle{~ ~fi ì{~ le~ipi{~{ ag ~fi ry`clk# rmp~lkycmpc|

{leki ~fi caedip A`mhm facn{ men ivipkl{i{ ~firpipadm~lwi{ ag ~fi agglki ag Rpi{lnie~# lg ~fi ivipkl{i~fipiag yc~lhm~ic| rpawi{ yetmppme~in# ~fi hapirpa`cih{ taycn hyc~lrc| tflkf taycn {y`{i}yie~c|wiv ~fi Riarci men ~fi Kayp~{ kmccin yrae ~a pi{acwi~fa{i gyenmhie~mc kae{~l~y~laemc rpa`cih{%

L% Tfi~fip A`mhm L{ Icldl`ci ~a @i Rpi{lnie~L{ m ]yi{~lae ag Iv~pmapnlemp|Kae{~l~y~laemc Hahie~ men Nihmen{Rpahr~ Pi{acy~laeLe apnip ~a ì icldl`ci ~a ì Rpi{lnie~ ag ~fi

Yel~in [~m~i{# Mp~lkci LL# =# ag ~fi Y%[%Kae{~l~y~lae pi}ylpi{: Ea rip{ae ivkir~ m em~ypmcàpe Kl~lzie % % %# {fmcc ì icldl`ci ~a ~fi Agglki agRpi{lnie~% ^fi rfpm{i em~ypmc àpe Kl~lzie l{ me=6~f Kie~yp| cidmc(~iph(ag(mp~ tl~f m niglel~ihimeled ticc oeate ~a ~fi Gpmhip{ ag ~fiKae{~l~y~lae% M~ ~fi ~lhi ag ~fi mnar~lae ag ~fiKae{~l~y~lae# ~fm~ rfpm{i tm{ niglein m{: ^fiem~lwi{# ap em~ypmc(àpe kl~lzie{# mpi ~fa{i àpe le

~fi kaye~p|# ag rmpie~{ tfa mpi kl~lzie{% &^fi Cmtag Em~lae{# Ihiplkf ni Wm~~ic# =496# Kfmr~ip =


10/14

( 7 (

Rpi{lnie~: &l, àpe le ~fi Yel~in [~m~i{ &ll, ag ~tarmpie~{# à~f ag tfah hy{~ ì Yel~in [~m~i{kl~lzie{%

Lenl{ry~m`c|# A`mhm l{ ea~ m em~ypmc àpeKl~lzie le ~fi =6~f Kie~yp| yenip{~menled ag ~fm~cidmc(~iph(ag(mp~ m{ fl{ Gm~fip tm{ ea~ m kl~lzie ag~fi Yel~in [~m~i{% Mnnl~laemcc|# dlwie ~fi ~fpii

kadie~ ivrip~ pirap~{ men {tape ~i{~lhae| ag ~taivrip~ tl~ei{{ eat ag pikapn le ~fi Nl{~plk~ menKlpkyl~ Kayp~{# ~fipi fm{ ìie mrplhm gmkli{fatled~fm~ ~fi KAC@{ tflkf A`mhm fm{ rpi{ie~in ~a ~fiRiarci ag ~fi Yel~in [~m~i{ ~a àc{~ip fl{ kcmlh ~a ìMp~lkci LL# = icldl`ci ~a ì Rpi{lnie~ mpi gapdipli{men ~fy{ A`mhm hm| ea~ fmwi iwie ìie àpe le

~fi Yel~in [~m~i{%

^fi Nihakpm~lk Kaewie~lae l{ {ahi =92 nm|{mtm|? ~fi Rpi{lnie~lmc icik~lae {ahi 022 nm|{ mtm|%Kcimpc|# tfie ~fi ry`clk le~ipi{~ l{ m~ rcm|# ~fim`lcl~| ag ~fi Kayp~ ~a mk~ {tlg~c| l{ kip~mle menpidycmpc| ivipkl{in% Kg: Tmc~ip{ w% Em~$c M{{$e agPmnlm~lae# >4; Y%[% ;29# ;9= &==6Y%[% 76;# 767(764 &=,&Ti dpme~in à~f ~fiYel~in [~m~i{$ ri~l~lae gap kip~lapmpl ìgapijyndhie~ men mc{a ~fi Rpi{lnie~${ kpa{{(ri~l~lae gap

kip~lapmpl ìkmy{i ag ~fi ry`clk lhrap~meki ag ~fil{{yi{ rpi{ie~in men ~fi eiin gap ~filp rpahr~pi{acy~lae,%


11/14

( 4 (

Fipi# tfm~ dpim~ip }yi{~lae ag ry`clklhrap~meki nihmenled rpahr~ pi{acy~lae kme~fipi ì ~fme tfi~fip ~fi {l~~led Rpi{lnie~ ag ~fiYel~in [~m~i{ l{ leicldl`ci ~a {ipwi le ~fm~ kmrmkl~|men {iio pi(icik~lae ~a ~fm~ agglki1

Kaekcy{laeRi~l~laeip fm{ ~fi pldf~# ra{{i{{in `| iwip|

kl~lzie# ~a pi}ylpi ~fm~ ~fi Dawipehie~ ìmnhlel{~ipin mkkapnled ~a cmt men ~fm~ ~fi ry`clkhaei|{ ì ea~ Tm{~in% Gmlpkflcn w% Fydfi{# 096Y%[% =07# =;2 &=222 Hm{{mkfy{i~~{ Mwi# E%T%#[yl~i +=9=6Tm{fled~ae# N%K% 022=7


12/14

M(=

Kae~ie~{ ag MrrienlvArlelae @icat

^fi Hmpkf 7# 02=0# Apnip ag ~fi Klpkyl~ Kayp~% % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % % Mrrienlv(0


13/14

M(0

Le ^fi Yel~in [~m~i{ Kayp~ Ag Mrrimc{Gap ^fi Nl{~plk~ Ag Kacyh`lm Klpkyl~

N% K% Nakoi~ Ea%:=:=0(kw(2222=(JN@[ir~ihìp îph 02==

Km{i Ea%: =0(92>2Glcin ae Hmpkf 7# 02=0

Le pi: Hae~dahip| @cmlp[l`ci|#

Ri~l~laeipQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ!

@IGAPI: [ie~icci# Kflig Jyndi# men Fienip{ae men

@pate# Klpkyl~ Jyndi{%

APNIP

Yrae kae{lnipm~lae ag ~fi ri~l~lae gap tpl~ aghmenmhy{ ap# le ~fi mc~ipem~lwi# gap m tpl~rpakinienyh mn jy{~lklyh# l~ l{

APNIPIN ~fm~ ~fi ri~l~lae ì nielin% ^fi nl{~plk~kayp~{ nicm| le pycled ae ~fi ri~l~lae gap tpl~ ag }yatmppme~a l{ ea~ {a idpidlay{ ap yepim{aem`ci m{ ~atmppme~ ~fi iv~pmapnlemp| pihin| ag hmenmhy{%[ii Dycg{~pimh Mipa{rmki Kapr% w% Hm|mkmhm{

Kapr%# >69 Y%[% 04=# 06< &=


14/14

M(;

Ryp{yme~ ~a N%K% Klpkyl~ Pyci ;7# ~fl{ nl{ra{l~laetlcc ea~ `i ry`cl{fin% ^fi Kcipo l{ nlpik~in ~a~pme{hl~ m kar| ag ~fl{ apnip ~a ~fi nl{~plk~ kayp~%

Rip Kyplmh

montgomery sibley petition for writ of certiorari - united states supreme court - 3/28/2012

Documents