monitoring impacts and risk: case study of …...distribution, building baseline data sets 2. social...

24
Rohan Fisher

Upload: others

Post on 06-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Monitoring impacts and risk: case study of …...distribution, building baseline data sets 2. Social impact assessments, understanding the issues 3. Facilitating Knowledge exchange,

Rohan Fisher

Page 2: Monitoring impacts and risk: case study of …...distribution, building baseline data sets 2. Social impact assessments, understanding the issues 3. Facilitating Knowledge exchange,

Involves up to 30 million people worldwide contributing 15- 20% of global mineral and metal production.

Page 3: Monitoring impacts and risk: case study of …...distribution, building baseline data sets 2. Social impact assessments, understanding the issues 3. Facilitating Knowledge exchange,
Page 4: Monitoring impacts and risk: case study of …...distribution, building baseline data sets 2. Social impact assessments, understanding the issues 3. Facilitating Knowledge exchange,

Current Project

• DFAT GPFD funding

• 3 Years

• Building on pre-existing connections to SE Sulawesi and NTT

Page 5: Monitoring impacts and risk: case study of …...distribution, building baseline data sets 2. Social impact assessments, understanding the issues 3. Facilitating Knowledge exchange,
Page 6: Monitoring impacts and risk: case study of …...distribution, building baseline data sets 2. Social impact assessments, understanding the issues 3. Facilitating Knowledge exchange,
Page 7: Monitoring impacts and risk: case study of …...distribution, building baseline data sets 2. Social impact assessments, understanding the issues 3. Facilitating Knowledge exchange,

Gold mining in South East Sulawesi

Page 8: Monitoring impacts and risk: case study of …...distribution, building baseline data sets 2. Social impact assessments, understanding the issues 3. Facilitating Knowledge exchange,

Gold mining in South East Sulawesi

Page 9: Monitoring impacts and risk: case study of …...distribution, building baseline data sets 2. Social impact assessments, understanding the issues 3. Facilitating Knowledge exchange,

Overall Goal is towards

Reducing the harm and maximising the benefits from ASM

Small scale mining generates cash income potentially increasing food security building community resilience however impacts on human health can be severe and impacts on the environment can have long term consequences.

Page 10: Monitoring impacts and risk: case study of …...distribution, building baseline data sets 2. Social impact assessments, understanding the issues 3. Facilitating Knowledge exchange,

Activity Areas

1. Mapping and monitoring of extent and distribution, building baseline data sets

2. Social impact assessments, understanding the issues

3. Facilitating Knowledge exchange, finding ‘best practice’

Page 11: Monitoring impacts and risk: case study of …...distribution, building baseline data sets 2. Social impact assessments, understanding the issues 3. Facilitating Knowledge exchange,

Mapping and monitoring West Timor example.

We have a big problem!

Where?

Every where!

2012 training 4 Dept/every district

• Detailed field plans

• Simple open source data collection and visualisation tools

• Clear comprehensive training material

Page 12: Monitoring impacts and risk: case study of …...distribution, building baseline data sets 2. Social impact assessments, understanding the issues 3. Facilitating Knowledge exchange,

Field Survey West Timor

• Comprehensive survey of locations and erosion potential measurements.

• Building a picture of broader erosion and sedimentation impacts in a whole of catchment context, linking ASM back to other livelihood and rural development impacts.

Page 13: Monitoring impacts and risk: case study of …...distribution, building baseline data sets 2. Social impact assessments, understanding the issues 3. Facilitating Knowledge exchange,

Bombana gold mining district.

Restricted to two areas near the regional capital of Kasipute impacting two major catchments.

Page 14: Monitoring impacts and risk: case study of …...distribution, building baseline data sets 2. Social impact assessments, understanding the issues 3. Facilitating Knowledge exchange,

Mapping and monitoring training Open source GIS tools and free data for

• Simple data visualisaton

• Satellite based landscape mapping/monitoring

• Hydrological modelling

Page 15: Monitoring impacts and risk: case study of …...distribution, building baseline data sets 2. Social impact assessments, understanding the issues 3. Facilitating Knowledge exchange,

Field Survey Training

- Mine site location and descriptive attributes (GPS) - Participative GIS, mapping local community knowledge

Page 16: Monitoring impacts and risk: case study of …...distribution, building baseline data sets 2. Social impact assessments, understanding the issues 3. Facilitating Knowledge exchange,

Training material Production

• Removing Barriers to uptake – All free data and software – Using local data and issues – Hard copy and video screen shots

• Enabling sophisticated analysis – Remote sensing/Hydrological

modelling – Building enabling tools.

• Decentralising Capacity

– Significant power at district level – Facilitating local priorities – Incorporating local knowledge

Website: http://asm4d.wordpress.com/

Page 17: Monitoring impacts and risk: case study of …...distribution, building baseline data sets 2. Social impact assessments, understanding the issues 3. Facilitating Knowledge exchange,

Landscape mapping

• This landcover map produced as a result of project training shows the scale and extent of the mining (Red) and it’s proximity rice growing areas (Yellow) and an extensive aquaculture region (Dark Blue) Map produced by Iradaf Mandaya

Page 18: Monitoring impacts and risk: case study of …...distribution, building baseline data sets 2. Social impact assessments, understanding the issues 3. Facilitating Knowledge exchange,

Hydrological Modelling

• This map, produced as a result of project training shows, the modelled potential sediment flow from the gold mining region. It is clear from this and the previous map that run off from the mining areas goes straight through to rice growing and aqua culture regions. Map produced by Iradaf Mandaya

Page 19: Monitoring impacts and risk: case study of …...distribution, building baseline data sets 2. Social impact assessments, understanding the issues 3. Facilitating Knowledge exchange,

Field survey training

• Building capacity in sampling and monitoring methods.

• Facilitating testing of water and sediment mercury concentrations.

• Led By Dr Sara Beavis ANU . Fenner School

of Environment and Society in collaboration with BaliFokus

Water Quality Sampling - Bombana

Co-ordinated by Universitas Haluoleo

Page 20: Monitoring impacts and risk: case study of …...distribution, building baseline data sets 2. Social impact assessments, understanding the issues 3. Facilitating Knowledge exchange,

Social impact capacity building and research

• To complement the bio-Physical and environmental mapping of mining impacts in West Timor and Sulawesi

• Use of informed social analysis to facilitate more effective policy making and governance.

Page 21: Monitoring impacts and risk: case study of …...distribution, building baseline data sets 2. Social impact assessments, understanding the issues 3. Facilitating Knowledge exchange,

• Stake holder forums – Provincial level

• Gov/NGO/Uni/Company

• Very formal, not innovative

• Cross visits – Between provinces

– To Australia

• Community forums – Between communities

Knowledge exchange

Page 22: Monitoring impacts and risk: case study of …...distribution, building baseline data sets 2. Social impact assessments, understanding the issues 3. Facilitating Knowledge exchange,

Knowledge exchange

Cross visits – Australia – Senior symposium (April 2015)

• 15 Senior Indonesian's government, NGO and University representatives

• Excellent engagement with NTGDME

• Worst practice (Rum Jungle)

• and best practice (Prosecution and rehabilitation deposits)

– Workplace study tour (November 2015) • 6 Key staff engaged in ASM

• Learning, Sharing

Page 23: Monitoring impacts and risk: case study of …...distribution, building baseline data sets 2. Social impact assessments, understanding the issues 3. Facilitating Knowledge exchange,

• Community forums

– Learning about local solutions • Exploring the challenges and

opportunities

– The path to formalisation • What is informal and formal?

• Empowering mining communities

– Moving towards sustainability

Knowledge exchange

Page 24: Monitoring impacts and risk: case study of …...distribution, building baseline data sets 2. Social impact assessments, understanding the issues 3. Facilitating Knowledge exchange,

Key lessons

• Multi-stake holder engagement for all phases of implementation.

• Respecting and supporting local knowledge

• Decentralising expertise/authority

Website: http://asm4d.wordpress.com/