module 1: why conservative care?jos140/materials/cc_worksheet.pdfthink back to a difficult decision...
TRANSCRIPT
Thisworksheetwillhelpyouactivielyengagewiththeinformationsoyoucanbetterretainandlearnnewskills.Downloadandprintthisworksheetandrecordyouranswersandreflectionsaboutconservativecareasyouwatchthevideosandworkthroughtheexercises.
Module1:Whyconservativecare?Q1:Onaveragehowlongdoyouthinkapersonwithstage5CKD(estimatedfunctionlessthan15)cansurvivewithoutdialysis?
A.Days
B.Weeks
C.Months
D.Years
Q2:Comparedtodialysis,howwouldCCimpactthefollowingfactors?Writedownwhetherthesefactorswouldincrease,decreaseornotchange? Increase Decrease NochangeTimeinthehospital:
Qualityoflife:
Physicalsymptoms:
Endoflifeathome:
Hospiceservices:
Q3:Writedown2prognosticfactorsthatwouldlimitsurvivalwithdialysisforWilliamandRita:William:1.
2.
Rita:1.
2.
Q4:Writethreepotentialsideeffectsofdialysisthatmaybeburdensomeforthesepatients:Q5:HowlongdoyouthinkapersonlikeWilliamcanliveondialysis?Wrapup:CheckyouranswersforQ1and2attheendofmodule1!Reflectionquestions:WhatsurprisedyoumostaboutConservativeCare?What’sonethingyouwilldodifferentlybasedonthismodule?
Module2:IdentifywhobenefitsQ1:Applythesurprisequestion(Wouldyoubesurprisedifthispatientdiedinthenextyear?)toWilliamandRita’scase.
Q2:Usingthe6-monthESRDintegratedprognosiscalculator(https://qxmd.com/calculate/calculator_135/6-month-mortality-on-hd),calculatethe6monthsurvivalforWilliamandRita:
William’sestimatedsurvivalondialysisat6months:
Rita’sestimatedsurvivalondialysisat6months:
Prognosisexercisetoputyourskillsintopractice:
Chooseapatientyouarescheduledtoseeinclinicwhomaybenefitfromconservativecare.
1. Calculatethispatient’smortalityriskusingthe6monthintegratedprognostictool.
2. Duringthevisit,assesshowtheirfunctionandpresenceofgeriatricsyndromesusingoneortwoofthequestionstaughtinthemodule.Hereareexamplequestions:
“Tellmewhatyourtypicaldayathomeislike.”
“Howhasyourabilitytodothethingsyouwanttodochangedinthepastyear?”
“Doyouhavedifficultyorrequireassistancewithanyofthefollowing?:bathing,dressing,toileting,transfers,grooming,eating”
“Whatdoyoufindmostchallengingaboutcaringforyourselfathome?”
“Haveyoufalleninthepastyear?”(Considertryingthe‘getandgo’testforanypatientwhohasexperiencedafall)
3. Writedownthepatient’sresponses.
4. Describeyourimpressionsfromdoingtheexercise.
5. Writedownonethingyouwilldotoassessfunctionandgeriatricsyndromesinyourpracticemovingforward?
Module3:LearnwhatmattersmostThinkbacktoadifficultdecisionyou’vehadtomakethathadimportantimplicationsforyourlife,career,relationshipsandforwhichtherewasnorightanswer.
Q1:Whatarethethingsthathelpedyoumakethedecision?
Q2:Whatkindsoftrade-offsdidyouweighwhenmakingthisdecision?
Q3:Whatfeelingsdidyouexperienceasyouworkedthroughmakingthisdecision?
Q4:Asaclinician,howwouldyourespondtoWilliam’sstatementbelow.Writedownexactwordsyouwoulduse:“Afterhearingthatmykidneysgotworse,Igotscared”
Yourresponse:
Q5:Thinkingaboutthepatientsyoucarefor,writedowntwoadditionalquestionsthatexplorewhat’spatientvaluesandprioritiesinadditiontotheonesyoulearnedinthismodule:
Question1:
Question2:
YourturntopracticeidentifyingtheREMAPskills:WatchthevideobetweenthenephrologyandWilliam.WritedownthespecificwordsthenephrologistusedforeachpartoftheREMAPframework:
Reframethebigpicture(writedownthereframestatement):
Expectandrespondtoemotion(writedowntoempathicstatementstorespondtopatient’semotion):
Mappatientvalues(writedownatleasttwomappingquestionsyouheard):
Alignwiththevalues(writedownastatementyouheardthatsummarizesthepatient’svalues):
Compareyouranswerswith‘checkyourworkandsummaryofREMAP’video.
ReflectionquestionsaboutREMAP:
Q1:WhatsurprisedyouthemostaboutusingREMAPtoelicitpatientvaluesandpriorities?
Q2:WhatisonewaythatREMAPdiffersfromwhatyouusuallydowhenyoudiscusstreatmentdecisionswithpatientsandfamilies?
Q3:What’sonethingyouwilldodifferentlybasedonthismodule?
Module4:MakearecommendationToprepareformakingarecommendationforWilliamandRita,answerthefollowingquestions:
Q1:Whatwasmostimportant(valuesandpriorities)?
William:
Rita:
Q2:Whatthingsdideachonewanttoavoid?
William:
Rita:
Q3:WhattreatmentwouldyourecommendforWilliamandRita–conservativecareortrialofdialysis?
William:
Rita:
Recommendationexercise:It’syourturntopracticemakingarecommendation.Eachexerciseincludestherelevantmedicalandvaluesinformationtoformulatearecommendation.Afteryoucompletebothexerises,compareyouranswerswithanexpertresponse.Exercise1:Medicalhistory:RSisan78yearoldgentlemanwithadvancedsystolicheartfailure(ejectionfraction35%),peripheralvasculardisease,admittedtwiceforheartfailureinthelastyear.HehasdifficultywithADLsandrequiresassistancewithbathing.Heusesawalkertogetaroundandhashad2fallsinthelastyear.Serumalbumin2.8.Usingtouchcalcprognosticcalculator–youestimatethatifhewereondialysis,hehasa50%chanceofdyinginfirst6months.Withdialysis,patient’scurrentfunctionalstatuswouldlikelyworsenwithhighprobabilityofnursinghomeplacement.Aftersharingprognosiswithpatient,belowareresponsestoyour‘mappingvalues’questions:RSresponses:“WhenIthinkaboutthefutureandhowmyhealthhasbeen,it’sbeenhard.WhatIhopeforistogetmystrengthbackandbeabletotakecareofmyselfagain.Ihavealottogetbackto–spendingtimewithmygrandkids,enjoyinggoodhomecookedmealsaroundthetablewithmyfamily.ThisiswhatI’dbedoingallthisfor.Togetbackmylife.
“ThingsIworryabout–wellifthingsdon’tgomywayandmyconditionworsensandgettinghomeisn’tpossible.Iamnotthetypeofpersonwhowantstobeaburdenonmyfamily.Idon’twanttoendupinanursinghomeorinasituationthatIcouldn’tcareformyself.Thatwouldn’tbeliving.
“I’mhopefulthough–hopefulthatIcanbeattheseproblemsandclimboutontop.I’mwillingtobebackinthehospitalifitmeansgettingstrongerandregainingsomeofmylifeback.”
1. Whatwouldbeyourrecommendation?A. ConservativecarewithoutdialysisB. Timelimitedtrialofdialysis
2. Exactlywhatrecommendationwouldyousaytothepatient?Writedownyouexactwords.Example:BasedonX(goals),IwouldrecommendY(plan).
Exercise2:Medicalhistory:RSisan78yearoldgentlemanwithadvancedheartfailure(EF35%),peripheralvasculardisease,admittedtwiceforheartfailureinthelastyear.HehasdifficultywithADLsandrequiresassistancewithbathing.Heusesawalkertogetaroundandhashad2fallsinthelastyear.Serumalbumin2.8.Usingtouchcalcprognosticcalculator–youestimatethatifhewereondialysis,hehasa50%chanceofdyinginfirst6months.Withdialysis,patient’scurrentfunctionalstatuswouldlikelyworsenwithhighprobabilityofnursinghomeplacement.Aftersharingprognosiswithpatient,belowareresponsestoyour‘mappingvalues’questions:RSresponses:“Thesepastmonths,I’vebeeninandoutofthehospital.Ithasn’tmademeanybetter–infactI’mworseoffnowthanever.What’simportanttomeistospendthetimeIhaveleftwithmyfamily.I’velivedagoodlifeandraisedafamilyIamproudof.“I’mtiredofthepainandIwantthelittletimeIhavelefttobewithoutpain.Iwanttodieinmyownhomewithmywifesittingnexttome.“IworrymostaboutmyfamilyandhowtheywilldoonceI’mgone.I’vealwaysbeensomebodywhotookcareofthem.It’shardformetothinkaboutbeingdependentonthem.Iwanttoensurethattheywillbeok.“Iknowdoingmorethingsisn’tgoingtohelpmeandthatmaymeanmytimeisshortIwanttospendmylastdayswithdignity–notgoingbackandforthtoahospital.Iwanttobeoutpfpainandbreathingmylastbreathswithmywifebymyside.”
1. Whatwouldbeyourrecommendation?A. ConservativecarewithoutdialysisB. Timelimitedtrialofdialysis
2. Exactlywhatrecommendationwouldyousaytothepatient?Writedownyouexactwords.Example:BasedonX(goals),IwouldrecommendY(plan).
Exercise1:Belowincludeshowanexpertwouldmakearecommendationforthisexercise.Thiscaseisanexampleofwhylearningthevaluesofthepatientiscriticaltomakingarecommendation.Survivalisuncertainyetwhatthattimelookslikeismorecertain.Dialysismayextendtimewithahighchanceoffunctionalsetbacksincludingdependency.RSresponses:Keyvaluessupportingrecommendationhighlightedinred“WhenIthinkaboutthefutureandhowmyhealthhasbeen,it’sbeenhard.WhatIhopeforistogetmystrengthbackandbeabletotakecareofmyselfagain.Ihavealottogetbackto–spendingtimewithmygrandkids,enjoyinggoodhomecookedmealsaroundthetablewithmyfamily.ThisiswhatI’dbedoingallthisfor.Togetbackmylife.
“ThingsIworryabout–wellifthingsdon’tgomywayandmyconditionworsensandgettinghomeisn’tpossible.Iamnotthetypeofpersonwhowantstobeaburdenonmyfamily.Idon’twanttoendupinanursinghomeorinasituationthatIcouldn’tcareformyself.Thatwouldn’tbeliving.
“I’mhopefulthough–hopefulthatIcanbeattheseproblemsandclimboutontop.I’mwillingtobebackinthehospitalifitmeansgettingstrongerandregainingsomeofmylifeback.”
1. Whatwouldbeyourrecommendation?Timelimitedtrialofdialysis,Althoughthereisasmallchanceofthispatientachievinghisgoalsofgettingstrongerandbackhome,heiswillingtoputupwithshorttermburdenstogetthere.
2. Exactlywhatrecommendationwouldyousaytothepatient?Givenyourgoalsaretogetstrongerandbacktoenjoyinggoodtimeswithyourfamily,Iwouldrecommendatrialofdialysisinhopeofachievingthesegoals.Ifnewsetbackscomeuporthesegoalsbecomelesslikely,wecandiscussstoppingdialysisandshiftingourfocusonyoursymptomsandcomfort.
Exercise2:Belowincludeshowanexpertwouldmakearecommendationforthisexercise.
Youmighthavenoticedthemedicalhistoryisthesameforbothexerciseswithsamesurvivalandfunctionalprognosis:dialysismayextendtimewithahighchanceoffunctionalsetbacksincludingdependency.Notehowvaluesinfluenceadifferentrecommendation.RSresponses:Keyvaluessupportingrecommendationhighlightedinred“Thesepastmonths,I’vebeeninandoutofthehospital.Ithasn’tmademeanybetter–infactI’mworseoffnowthanever.What’simportanttomeistospendthetimeIhaveleftwithmyfamily.I’velivedagoodlifeandraisedafamilyIamproudof.“I’mtiredofthepainandIwantthelittletimeIhavelefttobewithoutpain.Iwanttodieinmyownhomewithmywifesittingnexttome.“IworrymostaboutmyfamilyandhowtheywilldoonceI’mgone.I’vealwaysbeensomebodywhotookcareofthem.It’shardformetothinkaboutbeingdependentonthem.Iwanttoensurethattheywillbeok.“Iknowdoingmorethingsisn’tgoingtohelpmeandthatmaymeanmytimeisshort.Iwanttospendmylastdayswithdignity–notgoingbackandforthtoahospital.Iwanttobeoutpfpainandbreathingmylastbreathswithmywifebymyside.”
1. Whatwouldbeyourrecommendation?Conservativecarewithoutdialysis,Thevaluesexpressedstronglysupportaconservativepath–thepatientiswillingtotradepotentialsurvivalwithdialysisforafocusonsymptomsandendoflife.Conservativecarewillmorelikelyachievehisgoalsofpaincontrol,notsufferingandspendingendoflifeathome.
2. Exactlywhatrecommendationwouldyousaytothepatient?Givenyourgoalsaresymptommanagementandbeingathomeevenifthismeansshortertime,Iwouldrecommendconservativecarewithafocusonachievingthesegoals.Wewillnotpursuedialysisasthistreatmentwillnothelpyouwiththesegoals.
Congratulations,you’vecompletedtheConservativeCareCurriculum!!Reflectionquestion:Writedownonethingyoulearnedfromthiscurriculumthatyouwillcommittopracticeoverthenexttwoweeks?
Thankyouforyourparticipationinthiscurriculum.Pleasecompletethepost-curriculumsurveythatyouwillreceiveshortly!