mmmmmmmemmeem research conduct inst of … · 2014. 9. 27. · jsu,rt, april 5-8. i :as ( organized...

AD-A142 264 CONDUCT 0F THE INTERNATIONAL MULTIGRI CONFERENCEU) I/

RESEARCH INST OF COLORADO FORT COLLNS S MCCORMICKFEB 84 AFOSR-TR-84-0450 AFOSR-ISSA-83-00027

UNCLASSIFIED F/G 12/1 NLmmmmmmmEmmEEm

mEEmmmEEmmEEEEmEEmmmEmmEEEEImhmmmmmmmmm*mmmmmf [

MICROCOPY RESOLUVCON "TEST CHART

N A IIO N A L B uJR IA U L -) S IA N T D > - I Q6 A

I&6

.2.

p " ,

-T

-CR-: AD-A142 264)CUMENTATION PAGE

to REPORT SECURITY CLASSIFCAI ION 1b. RESTRICTIVE MARKINGS

2a 5EC. .RITV CLASSIFiCATiON AUTHORITY 3. DISTRIBUTION/AVAILABILITY OF REPORT

:' "cve for p"'s ' c " ci " .. :on2b DEC. SSFICATION DOWNGRADING SCHEDULE unnied.

4 PERFCRAMING ORGANZATiON REPORT NuMBER(S) b MONITORING ORGANIZATION REPORT NUMIERIS)

AFOSR-TR- 8 4 -0 4 5 0

6& NAME OF PERFORM,NG ORGANIZATION 6o. OFFICE SYMBOL 74. NAME OF MONITORING ORGANIZATIONRese rch ! :S t IU, ( of ,[fapplicabiep~esarc ln~iut f 'f PPirG Iorcc Office c: ocienifc Rc~arch

: : !oradu

6c ADDRESS iCt>, Stote and ,IP Code) 7b. ADDRESS lCily, Slate and ZIP Code)Drake Creek;ide Two, Suite .00, 26.9 Redwing, Directorate of :,'azhea:.ica. - nfornationFo: Collins -O 80526 Sciences, Bolling AFB DC 2C332

Ea NAME OF FUNDING/SPONSORING 8b. OFFICE SYMBOL 9. PROCUREMENT INSTRUMENT IDENTIFICATION NUMBEROR€GA N IZAT ION (It aplicable)

.,OSR I 24 AFOSR-ISSA-83-00027

Bc ADDRESS 'City. State and ZIP Code) 10 SOURCE OF FUNDING NOS.

PROGRAM PROjECT TASK WORK UNIT

'in .rF DC 52332 ELEMENT NO, NO. NO. NO3cl-ing ,FEc DC2,23

i T iT E inct ua Curjty Ciauificatont

CONLUCT OF THE INTERNATIONAL MULTIGRID CONFERE CE 304 A3

12- PERSONAL AUTHOR(S)

1& T NPEE OF REPORT l3b TIME COVERED 14 DATE OF REPORT (Yr. Mo.. Dayf. 15 PAGE C

n3FROM 1/1/83 1o 3.D2a/3 FEB 8426 S.PF'.EMENTARIY NOTATION

17CCSAT' CODES 18 SU8,E C7 TERMS on~.etn mv.ewS neceaa andd-ntifs b, bi

F, EL L' -,PO, PSsJB 3R

19 AB AC Ccflfust',. r, ,IIl. n e I' . W ,I umber,Thf ]983 Tn*er:iza -,na! '.1ultigrid Conference was held at Colorado's Copper Mountain Ski

jsu,rt, April 5-8. i ( :as organized jointly by the Institute for Computational Studies a-:'rlerrid< 2 a'( niV(L;ity, U.S.A., and the Gastllschaft fur Mathematik und Datenverarbei-tung Bonn, R. 7, rnany, and was sponsored by the Air Force Office of Sponsored Researchand Narion nl AercnaulIc:: and "pace Administration Headquarters. The conference was

a, ended by 80 sci n ist.:;, divided by institution almost equally into private industry,

r,;"e- II ab-ratoroes, and academia. Fifteen attendeCs came from countries other than theW .. A. in addition to tI fruitful discussions, the most significant factor of the confer-

enc, " of cours;e th, Ire;ure:,. The lecturers include most of the leaders in the field

of mul ticrid research. The, program offered a nice integrated blend of theory, numerical

studies, basi rresearch, and applications. Some of the new areas of research that have

surfaced since the Koln-P'or:: conference include: the "algebraic multigrid approach; multi-- rrid treatment of Euler equations for inviscid fluid flow problems; ,,(CONTINUED)

L 0 DISTR BiUTION,AVAILAI8 IT € OF ABSTRACT 21 ABSTRACT SECUR.TY CLASSIFIb.TION

C NCLASSIFIED'UNLIMITED -I- SAME AS RPT ---OTIC s:;,-L - U IiL,,IF'IED-

2. d&ME OF RESPONSIBLE INDIVIDUAL 22b TELEPHONE NUMBER 22c OFFIC -$.MHOLlinc.lud" A ,e Code)

CPT John P. Thomas, Jr. ,(202) 767- 5026 M .

DO FORM 1473.83 APR a01TION OF .A. 1., OBSOLETE. tUNCL Ae2l_-) _

SIUIJRITY CL*:,:. ... " TmS I

~'UNCLASSIFIEDu.,UTY CLASSICATION OF THIS PAGE

• ITEM #19, ABSTRACT, CONTINUED: 3-D problems; and the application of MG methods on vector

and parallel computers. ew results have also been achieved in the following areas:

software for standard el 1tic problems (finite element and finite differences); bifurca-

Stion problems; grid manipul ion processes; and comparisons with other techniques.

Questionnaires were sent to a participants after the conference, with about a thirdresponding. It is encouraging t note that there was virtually unanimou. ernhu:Ka. 'Iiutt~ie conference, facilities, organi tion, and environmern . There was especially pr:>" vresponse concerning the lecture con nt and format. It is significant that all t!:,,huresponded to question 9 concerning an her meeting indicated that. they would like oc-, h,.dI by 1984 or 1985. Attached to this repo are the completed questionnaires and a li ofthe speakers and attendees.

NTIS GRA&I

DTIC TABUnan"oaced

Just if~catin

Distribution/

Availability Codes -

Dist Special

0!1

no t

A.,

!.i co f r n e-ai i i s r a i a i n n n i o m w h r a ~e ;A l

fA

re po s c n e n n th le t r co t a d mt. IL ! IIIIic n' Ih ' l

:" *" .UNCLASSIFIED

' 1 9 8 4 .... 1 9 8 5 ., A t t a c h d t o ..r p a r t

th paer n1ttnes

A7OSR-TR- 84-0450

FINAL REPORT

for

NASA Contract No. NASW-3773

"Conduct of the International Multigrid Conference"

Dr. Stephen McCormick

Principal Investigator

Approved for public release Sdistribution unlimited.

Pesearch Institute of ColodoDrake Creekside Two <.,'re 200 2624 Redwinq Fort (ollins Colorado 805216 (303 226 6003

84 06 19 035"Now---

.N T C ............ [ . , ."

AIR F()TCS COFFE rF' 3CTENTTFT" RSEARe'9 (U7C)

Th i

Di2.

)LI~ J,;hie, Tochi,lcal Information Division

The 1983 International Multigrid Conference was held at Colorado's Cop-

per Mountain Ski Resort, April 5-8. It was organized jointly by the Insti-

tute for Computational Studies at Colorado State University, U.S.A., and the

Gasellschaft fur Mathematik und Datenverarbeitung Bonn, F.R. Germany, and was

sponsored by the Air Force Office of Sponsored Research and National Aero-

nautics and Space Administration Headquarters. The conference was attended

by 80 scientists, divided by institution almost equally into private industry,

research laboratories, and academia. Fifteen attendees came from countries

other than U.S.A.

In addition to the fruitful discussions, the most significant factor of

the conference was of course the lectures. The lecturers include most of

the leaders in the field of multigrid research. The program offered a nice

integrated blend of theory, numerical studies, basic research, and applica-

tions. Some of the new areas of research that have surfaced since the

Koln-Porz conference include:

the "algebraic" multigrid approach;

multigrid treatment of Euler equations for inviscid

fluid flow problems;

3D-Problems; and

the application of MG methods on vector and parallel

computers.

New results have also been achieved in the following areas:

software for standard elliptic problems (finite element

and finite differences);

bifurcation problems;

grid manipulation processes; and

comparisons with other techniques.

H ' " - ' , b 7.=

Questionnaires were sent to all participants after the conference, with

about a third responding. It is encouraging to note that there was virtu-

ally unanimous enthusiasm about the conference, facilities, organization,

and environment. There was especially positive response concerning the

lecture content and format. It is significant that all those who responded

to question 9 concerning another meeting indicated that they would like one

held by 1984 or 1985.

Attached to this report are the completed questionnaires and a list of

the speakers and attendees.

-2-

Dr. Ramesh Agarwal Dr. Anne Greenbaum Dr. T. PhillipsDePt. 22, Bldg. 110 Lawrence Livermore Lab ICASEP'kDonnell Douglas Research Labs Box 808, L-61 Mail Stop 132CP. 0. Box 516 Univ. of California NASA Langley Research CenterSt. Louis, MO 63166 Livemore, CA 94550 Hampton, VA 23665

Mr. Dov Bai Dr. Wolfgang HackbuschInst. for Comp. Studies Institut fur Informatik Dr. John RugeP. 0. Bo 1852 Chrlstlan-Albrechts Univ Kiel Inst. for Comp. StudiesP.O. Box 1852 Olshausenstr, 40-60 P.O. Box 1852Fort Collins, CO 80522 D-2300 Kiel 1 Fort Collins, CO 80522

F. R. GERMANY

Or. Randy Bank Dr. Tony Jamieson Dr. Steve SchafferMathematics, C-012 Dept of Engineering Inst. for Comp. StudiesUniv of Calif, San Diego Princeton Univ P.O. Box 1852La Jolla, CA 92093 Princeton, NJ 98544 Fort Collins, CO 80522

Or.? David BarkaiControl Data Corp. Dr. Dennis Jespersen Dr. C. StreettInst. for Comp. Studies MS 202A-1 Inst. Computer Appl in SciP. . Box 1852 NASA Ames Research Center and Engr.Fort Collins, CO 80522 Moffett Field, CA 94035 NASA Langley Research CenterHampton, VA 23665Dr. Alda Behie Dr. Klaus StubenComputer Modeling Group Dr. Gary Johnson GMDIMAuUniv. of Calgary MS 5-9 Postfach 12407th Floor, Library Tower NASA Lewis Research Center Schlss BirlirwhoenCalgary, Alberta T2L 2A6 Cleveland, OH 44135 B-5205 St. Augustine 1CANADA F. R. GERMANY

Dr. Achi Brandt Dr. Kirk Jordan Dr. Frank ThamesInst. for Comp. Studies Exxon Research & Engineering MS 360P. 0. Box 1852 P.O. Box 45 NASA Langley Researxh CenterFort Collins, CO 80522 Linden, NJ 07036 Hampton, VA 23665

Or. David Caughey Dr. H. N. Lee Dr. Jim Thomas218 Upson Hall Dept. of Meteorology Inst. for Comp. StudiesCornell University 819 Wm. C. Browning Bldg. P. 0. Box 1852Ithaca, NY 14853 Salt Lake City, UT 84112 Fort Collins, CO 80522

Dr. Joel Dendy Dr. Doug McCarthy Dr. Ulrich TrottenbergMS 610 Computer Science Dept. GMD/IMALos Alamos Scientific Lab Purdue University Postfach 1240P. 0. Box 1663 West Lafayette, IN 47907 Schloss BirlinghovenLos Alamos, NM 87544 D-5205 St. Augustin I

F. R. GERMANYOr. 8. FaviniUniversita degli Studi de Roma Dr. Steve McCormick Dr. John VanRosendaleIstituto di Meccanica Applicata Inst. for Comp. Studies Inst. for Computer ApplAlle Macchine P.O. Box 1852 in Sci and EngrNASA Langley Research Center

Via Eudossiana, 18 Fort Collins, CO 80522 Hampton, VA 2366500184, ROMA, ITALYDr. P. A. Forsyth, Jr.

iuter Modeling Group Dr. Hans Mittelmann Dr. R. VerfurthUniversity of Calgary Wesler Hall 216 Ruhu-Universitat Bochum7th Floor, Library Tower Arizona State Univ. Institut for MathematikCalgary, Alberta T2L 2A6 Tempe, AZ 85282 Bochum 463 GERMANYCANADA

Dr. Piet Wesseling Dr. T. ZangDept. of Math & Informatics Inst. Computer Appl inTechnische Hogeschool Delft Sci & EngrJulianalaan 132, 2628 BL Delft NASA Langley Research CenterTHE NETHERLANDS Hampton, VA 23665

I 4

Lllttord N. Arnold uWeLer' Lppe 1i0 MIdlLeUTTeControl Data Corp. Inst. fur Physics Los Alamos National Lab40LOPS-4250 Fernwood GKSS - Research Center C3MSB265Arden Hills, MN 55112 D-2054 Geesthacht Los Alamos, MN 87545

GERMANY

Greg Astfalk Alain Forestier Oliver A. McBryaneCEA-IRDI Centre D-Etudes Courant Institute, NY Univ.Western Nuclearies De Saclay 251 Mercer Street

P.O. Box 900 DEMT/Serma New York, NY 10012Princeton, NJ 08540 91191-GIF sur Yvette Cedex

FRANCE

Ed ughran David Fox Major Ed Oliverst\ Math and Info Systems AFOSR/NM

Ps. for 1852 AFOSR/NM Bldg. 410 Boiling AFBFort Collins, CO 80522 Bolling AFB Washington, D.C. 20332

Washington, D.C. 20332

Chuen-Yen Chow Scott Fulton George W. PackageUniv of Colorado Dept. of Atmospheric Sci Cray Research, Inc.Campus Box 429 Colorado State Univ One Northgate SquareBoulder, CO 80309 Fort Collins, CO 80523 Greensburg, PA 15601

Juliana Chow Karl Gustafson

National Center for Univ of Colorado L. Padman Abhan IAtmospheric Res. Dept of Mathematics Chevron Oil Field Research Cc

P.O. Box 3000 Box 426 P.O. Box 446Boulder, CO 80307 Boulder, CO 80309 La Habra, CA 90631

Paul Ciesielski Seymour ParterDept. of Atmospheric Sci Dr. H. Holstein SyMour pteColorado State Univ Dept. of Computer Science Math Dept.Fort Collins, CO 80523 U.C.W. Aberystwyth Univ of Wisconsin-Madison

Dyfed, SY 23 3BZ, U.K. Madison, WI 53706

Ken Cline W. R. Jines M. D. Ray

Harvey Mudd College Mobil Oil Company Mobil Oil Company

Clarement, CA 91711 13777 Midway Road 13777 Midway Road

Farmers Branch, TX 75234 Farmers Branch, TX 75234

Chris Curzon R. W. Jones Ted Reyhner

Harvey Mudd College Mobil Oil Corp. Boeing Company MS9W-61HlareyMud CAol1ege Exploration & Prod Res Div Box 3707Clarement, CA 91711 13777 Midway Road Seattle, WA 98124

Farmers Branch, TX 75234

Mark DeMario Dr. Michael J. Kascic, Jr. Mark ReimersDept. of Atmospheric Sci. Control Data Corp. Dept of MathematicsColorado State Univ 8100 34th Ave. So M/S HZN1OV Univ of British ColubiaFort Collins, CO 80523 Minneapolis, MN 55440 Vancouver, British Columbia

J. C. Diaz Art Lazanoff Patrick J. RoacheMobil Oil Corp. Inst. for Comp. Studies EcodynamicsExplor & Prod Res Div P.O. Box 1852 P.O. Box 817213777 Midway Road Fort Collins, CO 80522 Albuquerque, NM 87198Farmers Branch, TX 75234

M. S. El-Mandouh John V. MacGuire Stan Rudman-Mobil Oil Company McDonnell Douglas Grumman Aerospace Corp.1377 Midway Road Mail Stop 36-81 MSA 08-35Farmers Branch, TX 75234 3855 Lakewood Bfvd. Bethepage, MY 11714

Long Beach, CA 90846BeepgN 174

Mathon OilCompyRoy W. WesselMarathon Oil Company Control Data Corp.74OO S. Broadway 3545 Arthur CourtLittleton, CO 80121 Boulder, CO 80302

Wayne Schubert Matthew YedlinDept. of Atmospheric Sci. CONOCOColorado State University 1000 South PineFort Collins, CO 80523 Ponco City, OK 74601

Arthur S. Shieh David YoungEG&G Idaho, Inc. Boeing ComputerP.O. Box 1625 565 Andover Park W., MS 9C-01Idaho Falls, ID 83415 Tukwila, WA 98188

Greg Slaughter John ZelenkaHarvey Mudd College Control Data Corp.Claremont, CA 91711 8100-34th Ave. So M/SH QN1OV

Minneapolis, MN 55440

Roland A. SweetNational Bureau of StandardsDiv. 713, 325 BroadwayBoulder, CO 80303

William G. SzymczakNaval Surface Weapons CenterApplied Math Dr, CODE-R44White Oak, Silver Spring, MD

20910

Jerry TaylorDept. of Atmospheric SciColorado State UniversityFort Collins, CO 80523

G. W. ThomasScientific Software Corp.1801 California StreetDenver, CO 80112

William ThompsonNaval Environmental PredictionResearch Facility

Monterey, CA 93940

John Charles VossbergMcDonnell Douglas Long Beach3855 Lakewood BlvdMail Stop 36-81Long Beach, CA 90846

Alan J. Wallcrafta324

NSTL Station, MS 39529

INTERNATIONAL MULTIGRID CONFERENCE Y 983

APRIL 5-8, 1983

COPPER MOUNTAIN, COLORAOD

CONFERENCE QUESTIONNAIRE

Please return by May 30

To: Gloria Jean Thomas, Conference CoordinatorDepartment of Conferences and InstitutesRockwell HallColorado State UniversityFort Collins, Co 80523

1. What do you think about the environment and how it affected the conference?

Very important and very beneficial. I like conferences where I do not need

an automobile, where the participants are relatively isolated from the outside

world, and where some physical activity is possible.

2. From which lectures or types of lectures did you benefit most?

Brandt's survey lecture (not the paper), Stuben's paper on Algebraic Multigrid,

Thames' paper on mesh generation, and papers by Caughey, Jameson, and Jesperson.

3. Please comment on the planning of the schedule and program (timings, topics, etc.)

I like a tight order of the paper presentations, which corresponds to thepublished scedule.

There was a problem starting the sessions at 8:00am because the restaurant did

not opern until 7:30am and service was slow.

4. Please comment on the educational value of the conference. Did you learn any-

thing from attending the conference? If so, what specific areas were importantto you?

1. Algebraic Multigrid concepts. 2.Confirmation of my suspicions, dating back

to 1977, that MG will have trouble with high Reynolds number problems unless

upwind differencing is used on coarse grids. (MG makes the cell Reynolds number

problem worse.) 3.Awareness of the wide variety of cycling schemes used. (I still

think Cycle C is best.) 4.Difficulty of proper smoothing algorithm for complex prob'

5. How did the conference contribute to your own professional activities?

Definitely helped, notably in the areas of three-dimensional grid generation,

fluid dynamics, and electric field calculations.

w1

INTERNATIONAL MULTIGRID CONFERENCEAPRIL 5-8, 1983CONFERENCE QUESTIONNAIREPage 2

6. What are your activities (practitioner, basic researcher, observer, etc.)?Did you have beneficial contact with others involved in different activities?(e.g., As a basic researcher, did you benefit from contact with real applica-tions or the converse?)

Developer of algorithms and codes for solving 2D and 3D p lems of fluid

dynamics and electrostatics, especially in boundary-fittc ion-orthogonal

coordinates. Benefitted from contacts with both other "; ctitioners" and

with the intelligible theoretical people.

7. What were the conference's good and bad points?

Good: location, s, ieduling, quality of the best speakers, lodging

Bad: The written papers, abstacts, and conference schedule were poorly

organized. Even a conference with an informal.atmosphere needs a firm

schedule, sent at least one week ahead of the conference to the attendees,*

8. In your opinion, was the conference a success or failure?

Unqualified success; one of the best conferences I have attended in years.

9. Would you like to see another MG Conference (who, when and where)?

Yes; same community + any other contributors who know what they are doinai.

one or oneand 8 year intervals. I like Colorado, but the international flavor

and cooperation would be enhanced by moving it around. How about a conference

nominally every 14 years, with late-winter/spring meetings in Colorado alternating

with a late-summer/fall meeting in Europe (Germany, Holland, Britain) or Israel?

10. Additional comments:

* and a booklet of I- or 2-page abstracts bound together in the order of presentatioi

With more effort and organizational money, one can provide the actual papers in a

bound volume as the AIAA does, but this requires more lead time and cuts out the mos i

recent results. However, the booklet of abstracts is not difficult and helps

immensely in planning and taking notes, and should be absolutely required from the

authors. As an optiop, in addition to the bound abstracts, the authors can also

provide drafts of the full papers, as done at this conference, but these must be

STAPLED! The situation of having a lap full of 20 papers, unstapled, not in any **

Name Optional

Patrick J. Roache

"*order (either alphabetical on authors names, c'7 in order of presentation), and

contending with changes in the order of papers from the schedule, all the while

trying to take notes, detracted from the experience. I know other conferences

have the same problems, but it is unnecessary.

INTERNATIONAL MULTIGRID CONFERENCE

APRIL 5-8, 1983


CONFERENCE Q UES-TIONNAI RE

Please return by May_3O

to: Gloria Jean Thomas, Conference CoordinatorDepartment of Conferences and InstitutesRockwell HallColorado State UniversityFort Collins, Co 80523

I. What do you think about the environment and how it affected the conference?

S ru,': wnich ec tures or types of lectures did you bent t most?

3. Please comment on the planning of the schedule and projram (ti; iin~Ls, topcs, etc.

4. Please comment on the educational value of the conference. Did you leorn any-thing from attending the conference? If so, what specific areas were importantto you? -


" •7, _0/ -)t7i i

- ,- .



7. What were the conference's good and bad points? , , .

(G,. ,,)e&(dr_.A ', a ,4. ,,,.Y vd -.. - -,--Th ,,

8. In your opinion, was th onfernce a success or failure?


3k 9/Zki7z10. Additional comments: ooll4 r - ,4A7 -ecle*I .

Name Optional *.- eZ.8_ I.

L!

INTERNATION... MULTIGRID CONFERENCE M y 1983

APRIL 5-8, 1983 ,SlU,'



Please return by May_3_0


1. What do you think about the environment arid how it affected the conference?

Ai J?-1 1- 7 1i A/ FO,,7i4Z) /

AW;-,-77 0/ t L- F7 ~5K Cft& /Y j &


- 2Aj'4 t/.s5AY,-- "dc- -- t7m y .,J 4-7 &4 6&Ft E r'\;,,4c C E . ,e.SCK Vcll e-c/,',, ,- , v;Z~

3. Please comment on the planning of the schedule and program (timings, topics, etc.

-~, 6- 6 A/ I/\t&.EID

4. Please comment on the educational value of the conference. Did you learn any-thing from attending the conference? If so, what specific areas were importantto you?




37-H 4'4S /c, c7


G0r " /


- , uLJ(-5 S


yI W oJ, A-,kC 7-- '-CJ 4 ,,Mo-h'cK' 17----I- ,Lv -/7/T, .,c C IC t-

- /J /-2 YC' 4S AJs4A S) /~S 4 C6~)

10. Additional comments: . 7 1 T "1 ° J F<Di

Name Optional

S 4

? ECU' "r&1IY 16 1983


APRIL 5-8, 1983









'


A -%







Name (ptional

i. ,

= o,

INTERNATIONAL MULTIGRID CONFERENCE 5

APRIL 5-8, 1983 V








1C)C


,,e %'4 C k-A 1, ~5. How did the conference contribute to your own professional activities?

41,



7. What were the conference's good and bad oints?


C fCt



Namo/ Optional

~,I

INTERNATIONAL MULTIGRID CONFERENCE W3

APRIL 5-8, 1983 cmamS

COPPER MOUNTAIN, COLORAOD & NSTmJTES





2. From which lectures or types of lectures did ~ou benefit most? \




i S

INTERNATIONAL MULTIGRID CONFERENCEAPRIL 5-8, 1983

CONFERENCE QUESTIONNAIREPage 2






k Name Optional

. . . . . .. .,... .


APRIL 5-8, 1983









~~4Z _AJ 1AJL~ 0- b1





8. In your opinion, was the conference a Isucces7 or failure?



Name Optional


APRIL 5-8, 1983



Please return by May9 0





4. Please comment on the educational value of the conference. Did you learn any-thing from attending the conference? If so, what specific areas were importantto you? .

5. How did the conference contrite to ur own professional activities?

r .







Name Optional

INTERNATIONAL MULTIGRID CONFERENCE MAY

APRIL 5-8, 1983



Please return by Ma3O



14 k~ef.4 c r-tz+e g~ rCI~'xfe Aoh~jov" ) 4 AaLt iVM le (1't-

t..A~ ,f a.-.i ta LVAI c-fte ( t, jet4Y i S -f-"Pe-e leA


iX, I c#,,5 e, .- , "IL (w . Lr, i )


4. Please comment on the educational valwe of the conference. Did you learn any-thing from attending the conference? If so, what specific areas were importantto you?

411 QM ktfiA41&.


-rt ,A& ,- z



6-~4'-4k /0d It4L( j f LI'L Y 5 -4 OfL 'IV 0 S61 i~M VCV£ft,



Ski( c c eif



.r iih 5eiS w.4t dkfc~ll aE4 4o 4'

I&C bLd4 JZ.ye e~cj;I + . el #

Name Optional

1 P


APRIL 5-8, 1983







I(



5. How did the conference contribute to your own professional activities?A.

I cx



7. What were the conference' goo and points?

8. In your opinion, was the conference a sucs failure?



Name Optio l

K RECUI Lu

INTERNATIONAL MULTIGRID CONFERENCE AY 13 83

APRIL 5-8, 1983 cWfRENCS& WnTSITFL




'To:----6lort-Jean Thomas, Conference CoordinatorDepartment of Conferences and Institutes /Rockwell HallColorado State UniversityFort Collins, Co 80523





Z-L,


K v,

INTERNATIONAL MULTIGRID CONFERENCEAPRIL 5-8, 1983CONFERENCE QUESTIONNAIRE

Page 2

6. What are your activities (practitioner, bajtc.._.rsearcher, observer, etc.)?Did you have beneficial contact with others involved in different activities?(e.g., As a basic researcher, did you benefit from contact with real applica-tions or the converse?)





-Name 0 tional(-

RECEIV L)

INTERNATIONAL MULTIGRID CONFERENCE MAY 111983ONFERENUL-

APRIL 5-8, 1983 & INSTITIJTEc




T Gloria Jean Thomas, Conference CoordinatorDepartment of Conferences and InstitutesRockwell HallColorado State UniversityFort Collins, Co 80523


The meeting room was quite crowded, but otherwise suitable. It was

unfortunate that we were left in the dark as to food facilities on

the first evening and morning.


I benefit most from the lectures which deal mostly with computer

techniques, rather than with the underlying math theories.


Fine.

4. Please comment on the educational value of the conference. Did you learn any-

thing from attending the conference? If so, what specific areas were importantto you?

It was interesting to see that more people in the session were

interested in accuracy than in time and cost of computations.


I am better able to deal with my customers when I know what

their interes are.

k

INTERNATIONAL MULTIGRID CONFERENCEAPRIL 5-8, 1983CONFERENCE QUESTIONNAIREPage?2

6. What are your activities (practitioner, basic researcher, observer, etc.)?Did you have beneficial contact with others involved in different activities?

(e.g., As a basic researcher, did you benefit from contact with real applica-tions or the converse?)

I am a pre-sales analyst for a computer vendor, CRAY RESEARCH.

I had beneficial contact with several people.


GOOD: lectures, people, skiing.

BAD: food services, condos(instead of singles), incorrect spellingof names on lists.


Success.


Yes.


Please keep me on' your mailing list for all conferences that.

might possibly interest a computer analyst.

Thank you.

GEORGE W. PACKAGEName Optional

I

INTERNATIONAL MULTIGRID CONFERENCE REC rfivm

APRIL 5-8, 1983 MAY 09 1983

COPPER MOUNTAIN, COLORAOD "it iECES' & INSTITUTES




1. What do you think about the environment and how it affected the conference?, ,d .,t III /" f','t.,. ( , $Cf(') C .<' f ,////., r .f,

-j S-I "5/ Ok r4 d - e r .. v r t, 1,r 40(/a ,l T , 4


;,.<t-. p, : S/ rr oi. A//_ j<,/ : .f.//", -'.') ". < j


J r, t "< Sc /, .LAI ' A // ; C .


010- .


/s;' 4e?k'.,dh./ b X vL#!,~ Y', " "'r r,,f ;/t'f- r<,! /..,.

,. 4,, l - .. A/r ,, s -. r# S'. o r~ ( I' ,. , r .- . <!.,,1,<

Afl(- (L4 IiO

0, Vv,/c,

..(k f.. ... .. ,.' -"S-/

- INTERNATIONAL MULTIGRID CONFERENCEAPRIL 5-8, 1983CONFERENCE QUESTIONNAIREPage 2


~- £".(j( fs.- ' 4& "\ I1L .C,, ) J o,,c/ oh- , o4/

kser o P - i1' , (-tr-. /

/ , 4 tiC,- "I vt7 " , ,, .r .r,. -;t / C , , -0-

7. What were the conference's good and bad points?7,y ,/> 'r#.'. 15 . < <t tsf <.l .,trC(

p, , 1 Ji-' /,) / c-' /% (! Z(v

8. In your opinion, was the conference a success or failure?7 ,t ,- ,.f - ', >' ((cr5< ,s A s ,- / /,, ,- ,--, vi . . ..



Name Optional

RECEIVEDINTERNATIONAL MULTIGRID CONFERENCE

MAY 1C 1983APRIL 5-8, 1983

COPPER MOUNTAIN, COLORAOD & INSTITUTES








5. How did the conference' cntribute o your own professional activities?

!-" '] ' : =-I I - , ... " .- ., -

------







Nap(e Op ona l

INTERNATIONAL MULTIGRID CONFERENCE MAY I;

APRIL 5-8, 1983 C oto L 19

COPPER MOUNTAIN, COLORAOD &IyraUi



To: Gloria Jean Thomas, Conference CoordinatorDepartment of Conferences and InstitutesRockwell HallColorado State UniversityFnrt Collins, Co 80523


2. From which lectures or types-of lectures did you benefit most?

-yk-,

3. Please comment-on the planning of the schedule and program (timings, topics, etc.)I

\ (/ , . 1 ( . . 2



AA V ,

...... . --- : i I" II I II il n

LIII



C"A

b ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t C&CA L'7{~(&(< Uk t .I-o -




(or K10. Additional comments:

Name Optional

.- ITT

- . I I 1 Ff l. . . : .. ..[.. . .. "


APRIL 5-8, 1983

COPPER MO"NTAIN, COLORAOD



.o- Gloria Jean Thomas, Conference CoordinatorDepartment of Conferences and Institute-Rockwell HallColorado State UniversityFort Collins, Co 80523


*e' ,, 6~A, 7-9/Ae~ yr , -o oLl<)' ,4" F -/ -C - ' -t C

,r" 0-U -, 7A 7-/A16

2. Fro m which lectures or types of lectures Jid you enetit most?

,0 T AEAJL A AA TH' A4l TIC/A _z x ' " ,9lEF od 7 6 F

. 9>a, comment on the p1 iann ru of th, -chedule and promam (t i;min c', topi cs etc.

A'7A1A1_ LvA_


f-/6 6 0 AJC & F " /-/ 6_ d/Lv AJ ,A4F- I/D~ E .< O A"7", -' 6

7-0 Te Y' (F _r 'A V! 1T-I1) . Z HA vc 6O 7TEA." A7

7-r~v ~ ~ ~ A 7 4''9 t /V 6


. ., -

- ---- --- --jJ

INTLRNATIONAL MULTIGRID CONFLRLNCLAPRIL 5-Q, 1983CONFERENCE OUESTIONNAIRL

6. What are your activities (practitioner, basic researcher, observer, etc.)?

Did you have beneficial contact with others involved in different activitil(.?(e.g., As a basic researcher, did you benefit from contact with real appl ira-tions or the converse?)

.PAA/I'D 6 CA0 7A . " ,r/ -/,L 0 T V l-FEe-S.

7. What were the conference' yood and bad points?

o ,7 W tCO- 1 - 7 - A j 7, 4/ e , , 1- AI A/ Y, /I eTeWAO S I-A/E 7~- A? /0AT- 7 O/ C~ Z-r~/ov )-r ),'~


. ould you like to set another MG Conference (who, when and where)?

,Qv 6_ 7- v E7 k:- Y/- /,/ 7. v c.4 C-'. /AI 7/1 6.


Nam O

N ame Option

INTERNATIONAL MULTIGRID CONFERENCE 'Rr

APRIL 5-8, 1983 *c3








4. Please comment on the educational value of the conference. Did you learn any-thing from attending the conference? If so, what specific areas were important





] - --[- . -- roo 'SMALL-


,--)\k CC -Z



Name Optional

RECEIVi.


APRIL 5-8, 1983

COPPER MOUNTAIN, COLORAOD & ltIIL,





2. From which lectures or types of lectures did you benefit most? Lec ---

4((-, c -' ,e .At,4

3. ?lease comment on the planning of the schedule and program (timings, topics, etc.)



( o





_-X CC , .



I .

_ Name Opt onal


APRIL 5-8, 1983



Please return by May3







Lo"/

-M




G.vo d~ f'~~ f7-D~ CfS ~ , , 0 j ; efte 4 Sip 1-,le fr 4 7/,



ye-) A jear o~r +4wo 4~


Name Optional

INTERNATIONAL MULTIGRID CONFERENCE JuJV O/ 10

APRIL 5-8, 1983 CONi,_,,





1. -What do you think about the environment and how it affected the conference?

Ii "e Vey ~~e. v70, e-, c.,- rjo -

/

2. From which lectureK or types of lectures did you benefit most?


Ve;f



. I I I I

--~~~- ------I-l -i I ~ l- , i ,_ I ... ..



71 7Z lA 7 <J jy, -% //0


M . ', 1 ),, ,I , , -.-,> .// 3.7 / $7 i i. .

8. In ur opinionwas th conference a success or failure?


7;., 74 "Zo&A 27.... , o,..

10. Additional 'eomments:

Name Optfona4

I!S

C. 13

INTERNATIONAL MULTIGRID CONFERENCEDR. H. HOLSTEIN

DEPT. COMPUTER SCIENCEAPRIL 5-8, 1983 UNIV. COLLEGE OF WALES

ABERYSTWYTHGT, BRITAIN SY23 36ZCOPPER MOUNTAIN, COLORAOD

CONFERENCE .QUESTIONNAIRE

Please return by May 30 --- j





q ic& Ll,~l ~ d ~L44'L

4. Please comment on the educational value of the conference. Did you learn any-thing from attending the conference? If so, what specific areas were importantto you? 9 I

^I 7f -11- t )-'e At - C

A/4


,A. . , , ,,- -

Xxe, ,/.>. a

I .. 7 ,, 7,, ,. s,, . / , ,. .. -. f,, .. ., -

INTERNATIONAL MULTIGRID CONFERENCE R4~~APRIL 5-8, 1983 99CONFERENCE QUESTIONNAIRE C~Page 24

6. What are your activities (practitioner, basic researcher, observer, etc.)?Did you have beneficial contact with others involved in different activities?(e.g., As a basic researcher, did you benefit from contact with real appl ica-tions or the converse?)





Name Optional

INTERNATIONAL MULTIGRID CONFERENCE WeeW

APRIL 5-8, 1983 19~ 83COPPER MOUNTAIN, COLORAOD Ma IIwFEs


F Please return by May 30







;*;;*/(*~4 AA~L 0- C



7. What we re the conference's good and bad points?




Name Optional

NOW-


APRIL 5-8, 1983 N', !i

COPPER MOUNTAIN, COLORAOD & INST1T.

CONFERLNCE - QUESTIONNAIRE




Very FIeaoa' i I


qo qol e, .jetA +rckv- rl 0' of

3. Please comment on the planning of the schedule and program (timings, topics, etc.

4. Please connent on the educational value of the conference. Did you learn any-thing from attending the conference? If so, what specific areas were importantto you?

A.Y e-5 J, (4. ; ,-,.p -r,5sea b y ~ / ' e a / , b,' 1,'1y

-f .( ithe 'It f k aLp ro q cki -


el,) c t4 4, akY

T tC



a i+ei- 6 oj c t, ± c4r I

f1iit Ctq,(¢ t i-D i/L i'vB-3 people a) ho iay b e

tu4P- e .5 pof','o al 0y ; f-te ftzo- ) a 4'eii as o_T , eq J+. P70e,'.,a *i I, olc


Vb caqt rV:.j,; c4 b, r " c ll 4 1 PrCeitc7 -° fa () Ptoc eeWa', 5

; 6, I- q ;aj!r4,b ba'( pc~AI5~ Cvedt'i<-. c-L 'e-


Ha <4cc e .



_ kme Optional

-"- -- - -- ,1 '


APRIL 5-8, 1983


CONFERENCE OUEST iONNAI RE

Please return by May_3O

To: Gloria Jean Thomas, Cor~erence CoordinatorDepartment of Conferences and InstitutesRockwell HallColorado State UniversityFort Collins, Co 80523


' rOr: which lectures or types of lectures did you benefit most?




-ot-



,6 r At I n,,r c rf S'.ak~ .A, ~ a,~c r




I .,,.1 ,. , ,,.krL / -


Name Optional


APRIL 5-8, 1983






2. From which lectures or types of lectures diJ you benefit most?

3. Please comment in the planning of the schedule and program ,,t:l , to;ns, etc.


5. How did the conference contribut to your own pfofessional activities?

5. Hwr wn p G.AAA

o-'L64 ' m


6. What are your activities (practitioner, basic researcher, observer, frtc.)?Did you have beneficial contact with others involved in difter,nt activities?(e.g., As a basic researcher, did you benefit from contact with real applica-tions or the converse?)


ga &-,tA ,, 4&e 4e,, K. A 4 _



1--


Name Optional

DA

F LM

mmmmmmmemmeem research conduct inst of … · 2014. 9. 27. · jsu,rt, april 5-8. i :as ( organized...

Documents