Parameters for Rating MLAs (1/4)

Parameter Marks Past1 8

Present 2 52

Perception (through an opinion poll of 14,561 people)

40

Negative for new FIR cases after 2009 election 3

Minus 5

Negative for pending Charge Sheet 3 Minus 5

Total 100

2

RTI Data Source: 1 Election Commission of India’s Website; 2 Vidhan Bhavan and

City & Suburban Collector Offices; 3 Mumbai Police.

Parameters for Rating MLAs (3/4)

3

Past Parameter (Marks)

Education QualificationA minimum of 10th Pass - 1; if not – 0

1

Income Tax!) Possessing PAN Card - 12) Disclosing income in affidavit – 1

2

Criminal RecordIf the candidate has zero cases registered against her/him, then 5; else as below:1) Criminal Cases Registered containing the following charges: Murder, Rape, Molestation, Riot, Extortion - 02) Other criminal cases than the above mentioned – 3

5

Parameters for Rating MLAs (2/4) Present Parameter

(Marks)

Sessions AttendedBased on percentage of attendance. 1) 100% to 91%- 10; 2) 90% to 76% - 8; 3) 75% to 61% -6; 4) 60% to 51% - 4; and 5) below 50% - 0

10

Number of Questions AskedAgainst Group Percentage Rank. 16 being the top most percentile and so on to the lowest for 1

16

Importance of questions askedWeightage is given to issues raised through the questions depending on whether they belong to the State List, Central List or are in the domain of Municipal Authority. In the aggregate scale (out of 100) the following weightage is given: Constituency (including City) gets 5; State gets 15; and National gets 1

21

Total Local Area Development Funds Utilised during Dec'2009 to March'2012Calculation for the current financial year is done for the sanctioned fund of Rs. 3.75 crore approved till March 2012.1) 100% (or more) to 91%- 5; 2) 90% to 76% - 4; 3) 75% to 61% -3; 4) 60% to 51% - 2; and 5) below 50% - 0

5

4

Parameters for Rating MLAs (4/4)

6

Perception Parameter (Marks)

Perception of Public ServicesScore on Public Services

20

Awareness & AccessibilityScore on Awareness amongst people about their representative, their political party and ease of access to the representative

6

Corruption IndexScore on perceived personal corruption of the representative

10

Broad MeasuresScore on overall satisfaction and improvement in quality of life

4

7

Key Highlights of MLA RC 2012

8

  2011 2012Total Scores 1959.25 2034.84

Maximum Score 75.43 72.51Minimum Score 47.01 53.73Average Score 61.23 63.59

Spread 28.42 18.78

Reasons for movement in ranks between years 2011 and 2012

MLA Name Party Rank 2012 Main Reason Rank 2011 MoveYogesh Amrutlal Sagar BJP 1 Questions Asked, People's Perception 4 3

Mangesh Sangle MNS 2 New Crimininal Record (FIR) 1 -1Amin Amir Ali Patel INC 3 Attendance, People's Perception 10 7

Madhukar Balkrishna Chavan INC 4   7 3Jagannath Achanna Shetty INC 5 Questions Asked 2 -3Ramesh Singh Thakur INC 6 Questions Asked, Quality of Questions 12 6

Bala Dagdu Nandgaonkar MNS 7 Attendance 14 7Subhash Rajaram Desai SS 8 People's Perception 6 -2Kalidas Kolambkar INC 9 People's Perception 8 -1Vinod Ghosalkar SS 10 Attendance 15 5

Milind Bhupal Kamble NCP 11   9 -2Aslam Ramzan Ali Shaikh INC 12 Questions Asked, Quality of Questions 29 17

Rajhans Singh INC 13 People's Perception 25 12Nawab Malik NCP 14 Questions Asked 5 -9

Sardar Tara Singh BJP 15 New Crimininal Record (Chargesheet) 3 -12Mangal Prabhat Lodha BJP 16 Attendance 11 -5

Baldev  Basantsingh Khosa INC 17 Questions Asked, Quality of Questions 27 10Krishnakumar Shripad Hegde INC 18   20 2

Shishir Shinde MNS 19 Questions Asked 31 12Ravindra Dattaram Waikar SS 20   17 -3

Ramchandra Kadam MNS 21 Questions Asked 30 9Ashok Bhau Jadhav INC 22 Questions Asked 13 -9

Annie  Sitambalam Shekhar INC 23 Quality of Question 21 -2Pravin Darekar MNS 24   19 -5Gopal Shetty BJP 25 Quality of Question 22 -3Abu Asim Azmi SP 26 Attendance, Quality of Question 26 0Prakash Sawant SS 27 Attendance, Questions Asked 16 -11

Kripashankar Singh INC 28   23 -5Nitin Sardesai MNS 29 Questions Asked 18 -11

Sidikki Ziyauddin Abdul Rahim (Baba) INC 30 Attendance 28 -2Prakash Manchhubhai Maheta BJP 31 People's Perception 32 1

Chandrakant Handore INC 32 Questions Asked, Attendance 24 -8

10

MLA Name

Attendance

Questions Asked

Quality of Questions

Perceived Performer

Perceived Accessibility

Perceived Corruption

Criminal Record

Rank Movement

Score Movement

Scores (10)

Rank

Scores (16)

Rank

Scores (21)

Rank

Scores (20)

Rank

Scores (6) Rank

Scores (10)

Rank

Scores (5)

Rank 2012 2011 2012 2011

Yogesh Sagar 8 20 12.38 8 12.67 13 12.85 21 2.95 24 8.05 6 5 1 1 4 3 72.51 71.16 1.35

Mangesh Sangle 8 20 15.47 2 12.44 19 13.51 13 3.90 9 7.95 7 0 16 2 1 -1 72.15 75.43 -3.28Amin Patel 10 1 8.26 16 11.93 27 13.73 6 4.31 3 7.35 14 5 1 3 10 7 71.25 62.53 8.72Madhukar Chavan 10 1 7.22 18 12.23 22 13.67 9 4.28 5 7.47 12 5 1 4 7 3 71.01 67.82 3.19

Jagannath Shetty 10 1 6.19 20 12.01 26 14.09 2 4.01 7 6.96 28 5 1 5 2 -3 69.00 71.46 -2.46

Ramesh Thakur 8 20 7.73 17 12.65 15 13.89 3 3.16 20 7.70 8 5 1 6 12 6 68.59 62.17 6.43

Bala Nandgaonkar 10 1 16.00 1 12.71 12 14.38 1 3.76 11 6.38 30 -7 29 7 14 7 66.98 61.96 5.02

Subhash Desai 10 1 14.96 3 12.98 4 12.34 26 3.44 18 7.25 20 -5 20 8 6 -2 66.53 68.33 -1.80

Kalidas Kolambkar 10 1 3.60 25 12.84 9 13.02 20 3.77 10 7.55 10 5 1 9 8 -1 66.47 65.88 0.59

Vinod Ghosalkar 10 1 13.92 5 12.77 10 13.13 17 3.56 17 7.35 14 -5 20 10 15 5 66.37 61.39 4.99

Milind Kamble 10 1 2.58 26 12.95 5 13.49 15 3.05 21 8.13 3 5 1 11 9 -2 65.23 64.46 0.77

Aslam Shaikh 10 1 9.79 13 12.99 3 12.25 27 3.63 16 7.49 11 -2 17 12 29 17 64.62 54.71 9.91

Rajhans Singh 8 20 4.13 23 11.75 29 13.26 16 2.44 30 9.10 1 5 1 13 25 12 64.23 56.63 7.60

Nawab Malik 10 1 2.58 26 12.95 5 13.11 18 2.85 25 7.12 23 5 1 14 5 -9 64.07 69.27 -5.20

Sardar Tara Singh 10 1 12.90 7 12.47 17 13.65 11 3.98 8 6.19 31 -5 20 15 3 -12 63.91 71.22 -7.30

11

MLA Name

Attendance

Questions Asked

Quality of Questions

Perceived Performer

Perceived Accessibility

Perceived Corruption

Criminal Record

Rank Movement

Score Movement

Scores (10)

Rank

Scores (16)

Rank

Scores (21)

Rank

Scores (20)

Rank

Scores (6) Rank

Scores (10)

Rank

Scores (5)

Rank 2012 2011 2012 2011

Mangal Prabhat Lodha 8 20 11.34 10 12.77 11 12.45 25 3.00 23 7.31 18 -2 17 16 11 -5 63.52 62.47 1.05Baldev Khosa 8 20 1.54 29 12.04 24 12.71 22 5.13 1 8.05 4 5 1 17 27 10 63.20 55.13 8.07Krishnakumar Hegde 10 1 4.13 23 12.92 7 10.90 32 2.05 32 7.38 13 5 1 18 20 2 62.59 59.03 3.56Shishir Shinde 8 20 10.83 11 12.66 14 13.66 10 4.15 6 7.63 9 -5 20 19 31 12 62.51 52.18 10.33Ravindra Waikar 10 1 14.45 4 12.87 8 11.62 30 2.81 27 7.04 24 -7 29 20 17 -3 62.35 60.58 1.77Ramchandra Kadam 10 1 11.86 9 12.46 18 12.63 24 3.69 12 7.34 17 -7 29 21 30 9 62.10 52.97 9.13Ashok Bhau Jadhav 10 1 5.66 21 11.78 28 13.73 6 4.31 3 7.35 14 -2 17 22 13 -9 61.50 62.07 -0.56Annie Shekhar 8 20 1.02 30 13.33 1 13.56 12 3.35 19 7.24 21 5 1 23 21 -2 61.39 58.76 2.64Pravin Darekar 8 20 13.41 6 12.51 16 12.71 22 5.13 1 8.05 4 -10 32 24 19 -5 60.54 59.33 1.21Gopal Shetty 10 1 9.28 14 12.09 23 13.75 4 3.64 13 7.01 25 -5 20 25 22 -3 60.52 58.73 1.79Abu Asim Azmi 10 1 6.70 19 13.23 2 13.75 4 3.64 13 7.01 25 -5 20 26 26 0 60.08 56.13 3.95Prakash Sawant 6 30 10.32 12 12.40 20 13.70 8 2.52 29 8.33 2 -5 20 27 16 -11 59.16 60.61 -1.45Kripashankar Singh 6 30 2.06 28 11.74 30 13.05 19 3.03 22 7.31 19 5 1 28 23 -5 58.93 58.09 0.84Nitin Sardesai 10 1 8.77 15 12.27 21 11.62 31 2.15 31 6.98 27 -5 20 29 18 -11 57.36 59.59 -2.23Ziyauddin Sidikki 10 1 0.51 31 10.45 32 12.02 28 2.83 26 5.86 32 5 1 30 28 -2 57.11 54.90 2.21Prakash Maheta 8 20 5.15 22 12.01 25 13.50 14 3.63 15 7.19 22 -5 20 31 32 1 55.33 47.01 8.32Chandrakant Handore 6 30 0.00 32 11.25 31 11.92 29 2.68 28 6.69 29 5 1 32 24 -8 53.73 57.27 -3.54

12

MLA Name Total Question MLA Name Total Question

Abu Asim Azmi 157 Mangesh Eknath Sangle 923Amin Amir Ali Patel 296 Milind Bhupal Kamble 38

Annie  Sitambalam Shekhar 24 Nawab Malik 38

Ashok Bhau Jadhav 136 Nitin Vijaykumar Sardesai 337

Aslam Ramzan Ali Shaikh 422 Prakash Manchhubhai Maheta 117

Ziyauddin Abdul Rahim Sidikki  22 Prakash (Bala) Vasant Sawant 424

Baldev  Basantsingh Khosa 27 Pravin Yashwanr Darekar 681

Bala Dagdu Nandgaonkar 1165 Rajhans Dhananjay Singh 77

Chandrakant Handore 8 Ramchandra Shivaji Kadam 515

Gopal Chinaiya Shetty 392 Ramesh Singh Thakur 270

Jagannath Achanna Shetty 137 Ravindra Dattaram Waikar 750

Kalidas Nilkanth Kolambkar 74 Sardar Tara Singh 645

Kripashankar Singh 35 Shishir Krishnarao Shinde 455

Krishnakumar Shripad Hegde 77 Subhash Rajaram Desai 868

Mangal Prabhat Lodha 486 Vinod Ramchandra Ghosalkar 716

Madhukar Balkrishna Chavan 191 Yogesh Sagar 546

Total 11049

13

Political Party Name

Total Score Average Rank Average Score

2011 2012 Inc. (%) 2011 2012 Inc.

(%) 2011 2012 Inc. (%)

BJP (5) 311 316 1.67 14 18 22.22 62.12 63.16 1.67

INC (14) 846 894 5.57 18 16 -10.84 60.46 63.83 5.57

MNS (6) 361 382 5.59 19 17 -9.73 60.24 63.61 5.59

NCP (2) 134 129 -3.31 7 13 78.57 66.87 64.65 -3.31

SP (1) 56 60 7.04 26 26 0.00 56.13 60.08 7.04

SS (4) 251 254 1.40 14 16 20.37 62.72 63.60 1.40