ml pre launch pack design effectiveness
DESCRIPTION
We provide the most powerful suite of on-line tools and in home testing, for a successful Innovation and Shopper Research functions.TRANSCRIPT
PACT©
PACT©
Europe’s Fastest Growing Online Market Research Agency
• Established in 1999
• 150+ Research professionals
• 200+ Leading clients
• Projects in more than 50 countries worldwide
• Offices in Hamburg, Rotterdam, London, Madrid, Paris and New York
• European panel of 850.000 consumers and global access (GER: 130.000)
PACT©
PACT©
Your Pack Designs Fully Evaluative - a Solid Base for Growth
Pact© - Benefits
• Customised PACT© provides a packaging design solution tailored and customised around your needs
• Fully Evaluative Offering a well-rounded perspective with evaluative and diagnostic qualitative and quantitative feedback
• Latest Techniques Including a suite of state-of-the-art online techniques, visually appealing and motivating with normative database and in-house design expertise
• Delivers the base for Growth Provides a solid foundation for improving product performance at the place of purchase
• Proven Methodology Recognised and selected as best-in-class pack design method by multiple Fortune 500 companies
PACT©
Two critical challenges in the life of a product are:
1. Getting purchased in the store
2. Delivering a user experience that delivers re-purchase
The two defining moments in the life of a product are getting purchased and being used/experienced
PACT©
PACT©
PACT© Pack Design Test is modeled after the in-store purchase process
Search Consider
Shelf visibility,Stand-out &First impression
Decide Evaluate
Appeal,Benefits,
RTB’s,Brand
promise
Relevance/fit of benefits and
RTB’s
PACT© Study Research Objectives
Will the new pack design help to steal from the
competition?
What is the best place on the shelf?
Is the packaging design hierarchy
working well?
Does the pack design stand out on the shelf?
Is the new packaging design an improvement
over current?
Does the new design support the desired
positioning?
Is it likely to have a positive impact on the
business?
Should we go ahead and make the investment?
PACT©
PACT© offers a holistic perspective on the performance of your pack design
Search Consider Evaluate Decide
Is the pack noticed in a competitive crowd?
What benefits & values does the pack
communicate?
Is it relevant, compelling and consistent?
Is there an increased preference?
• Visual impact from
the shelf
• Shelf organization
• Ability to quickly
communicate key
points
• First Impression
• Design elements
hierarchy (focus
tracker)
• Perceived Brand
Values & Fit with
Brand Positioning
• Perceived Product
Benefits
• Overall Appeal
relative to key
competitors
• Likes & dislikes
design elements
(dot technique)
• Category Purchase
Drivers
• Preference from the
shelf
• Purchase Intent
PACT©
PACT© uses state-of-the-art visually stimulating survey modules
Search Evaluate Decide Consider
Stopping Power shelf test
Brand & ProductIdentification Test
Focus TrackerDesign Hierarchy Test
Category Purchase Drivers
Brand Values Product Benefits
Find-Time shelf test
First Impression(KPI)
Overall Pack Appeal(KPI)
Purchase Intent(KPI)
Dot Techniquedesign likes/dislikes
Preference from the shelf
OR
PACT©
KEY MEASURES:
% Picked up first
% Looked at in total
INPUT OUTPUT
T: Looked at in total
F: Picked up first
Most relevant for completely new
designs
Stopping Power Shelf Test
Does the new design really stand out in the fascia?Stopping Power is measured by placing the new packaging design in a simulated online shelf. Consumers are encouraged to browse and shop the shelf
Comparing the new
design in context on
shelf
PACT©
KEY MEASURES:
% Correct identification
Avg. time needed to find
INPUT OUTPUT
Most relevant for redesigns
The Find-Time test measures how easy and quickly it is for consumers to find your product on the shelf
Current pack New Pack Change Target
% correct identification
85% 87% +2 90%
Avg. time needed for correct
identification7.5sec 6.5sec -1sec 6sec
Consumers are asked to find your product and click on it. Upon exposure to the shelf the time needed to find the product, as well as the % who select the correct product is registered
Find-Time Shelf Test
PACT©
KEY MEASURES:% Correct brand recognition% Correct product type recognition% Correct (sub)-headline recall
INPUT OUTPUT
0.5s exposure timeCurrent
pack New packKey
competitor
% correct Brand Recall
52% 85% 74%
% correct Product recognition
85% 95% 93%
% correct headline recall
47% 63% 75%
Brand & Product Identification Test
(Tachistoscopic test with limited time exposure typically set at 0.1s, 0.2s and 0.5s)
The Brand & Product Identification Test uses a limited timed exposure to measure the ability of the pack design to quickly get the key points across
PACT©
KEY MEASURES:- First Impression - Overall Appeal- Purchase Intent
INPUT OUTPUT
Key Performance Indicators
First Impression, Overall Appeal and Purchase IntentThese are standard databased KPI’s, measured for the test product and key competitors
KPI’s
(top-2-box %)AN Other
SoupHeinz Soup
Campbell Soup
Musgrave New
Bench mark
Canned
First Impression 50 75 72 80 76
Overall Appeal 56 66 75 78 72
Purchase Intent 45 55 62 59 54
PACT©
PACT© 14
The Focus Tracker registers eye movement is registered to better understand the hierarchy and visibility of the different design elements
INPUT OUTPUT
KEY MEASURES:- Identification of high/low attention areas- Insight in the scanning order of consumers - Role and function of the various elements of
the packaging design
Focus Tracker Design Hierarchy Test
0 sec1
sec3
sec
4 sec
5 sec
2 sec
1
2
4
3
2
3
In a short training exercise respondents learn to track their eye movement using their mouse. This technique has been validated by the University of Groningen. White Paper is available.
The values and benefits that a pack design communicates are measured in a competitive context through a card-sort technique
Total
KEY MEASURES:Fit of pack design with custom:- Brand Positioning/Value Statements- Product Benefit Statements
Picture sort question using ‘drag&drop’ of
product designs into best fitting response box
Brand Positioning & Product Benefits
INPUT OUTPUT
Perceived Brand Positioning
(top-2box %) Sony Philips Monster
Really understands my needs
55 54 56
Innovative 62 73 51
Easy to use 70 59 48
PACT©
The dot-technique (placement of green and red dots on specific design elements) with open-ended motivation provides understanding of likes and dislikes and clues for design optimization
KEY MEASURES:- Intensity of likes/dislikes of areas/designelements - Motivation/explanation of likes and dislikes
DOT Technique
INPUT OUTPUT
“The head of this shaver is unique and the picture on the package demonstrates this fact clearly.“Nice and clear image of the shaver”“The design is innovative; especially the head”
“This to much information on the front of the pack.”“I don’t like English texts on the front.”“Too much small prints”“Shows the clean and charge station of
the shaver which is a very practical feature”“A cleaning station is very important’.
“Brand of the shaver is very important.”“It’s clear that it is a Philips shaver.”
“Dark spots and circles are ntreally meaningful I think.”“Looks too spacey”“Very chaotic background”
“This claim is far too pretentious”“Typical Marketing claim.”
“It looks smart, quick and flexible.”“Suggests dynamic action”“Shows the flexibility of the shaving head”
“While here crucial information is placed about the shaver; really clear explanation.”“All functions of the shaver in just one view”
“Because this is simply the best razor I know.”
“The clean and charge station looks somewhat ‘out placed’alongside to the large image.”
“The head of this shaver is unique and the picture on the package demonstrates this fact clearly.“Nice and clear image of the shaver”“The design is innovative; especially the head”
“This to much information on the front of the pack.”“I don’t like English texts on the front.”“Too much small prints”“Shows the clean and charge station of
the shaver which is a very practical feature”“A cleaning station is very important’.
“Brand of the shaver is very important.”“It’s clear that it is a Philips shaver.”
“Dark spots and circles are ntreally meaningful I think.”“Looks too spacey”“Very chaotic background”
“This claim is far too pretentious”“Typical Marketing claim.”
“It looks smart, quick and flexible.”“Suggests dynamic action”“Shows the flexibility of the shaving head”
“While here crucial information is placed about the shaver; really clear explanation.”“All functions of the shaver in just one view”
“Because this is simply the best razor I know.”
“The clean and charge station looks somewhat ‘out placed’alongside to the large image.”
PACT©
Likes & dislikes of Current design
20%: “I like bottles that are ‘signed’”“I like the raised lettering, it’s rather distinctive” 40%:
“I can't think of anything I particularly dislike about the pack”
“I placed the red dot on the side because there really is nothing that I dislike about this whisky”
78%:
“Distinctive ship, you know the brand straight away”
“The first thing I noticed was the white sailing ship”
“The white Cutty Sark ship is distinctive and sets the brand apart from other bottles”
19%: “I hate the bottle color and -shape”“It’s not a big deal, but I don’t really like the bubble in the neck”“I dislike the narrow awkward neck of the bottle”
19%: “The writing is too difficult to read”“Not sure what the words say”
38%:
“I like the fact that the bottle gives a timeframe for how long the product has been produced. A product which has been on the market for more than 100 years shows tradition and tends to show quality over time”
“Traditional products always have an extra appeal because their long lives indicate quality”
59%: “It’s a very classy label”“It looks very nice, black contrasts against a green bottle”
20%: “It looks like a wine bottle”“It is repetitive. Either have the signature or have the name on the black part of the label or on the cap seal but you don't need all three. You are not selling ‘Perry Bros & Reid’”
PACT©
The in-store purchase decision will in part be driven by how consumers weigh the different product benefits in the category
KEY MEASURES:Relative importance of specific features andbenefits when shopping within the category
Category Driver Importance
INPUT OUTPUT
In the analysis phase the benefit importance and product performance scores are combined in a quadrant map that will help to prioritize on-pack and communication claims
PACT©
Winning in the store is in the end about being purchased. An ultimate preference test is included in the study using either a priced or un-priced simulated shelf
KEY MEASURES:% being preferred/purchased from the shelf(optional: % being considered for purchase)
Preference Test
INPUT OUTPUT
PACT©
Range-Build Evaluation Test
INPUT OUTPUT
The Range-Build EvaluationAsking consumers to drag and drop different SKU’s from the same brand onto a price perception line delivers a clear evaluation for how it is seen in context with competition
Cheap Expensive
PACT©
Survey comments
Why a green bottle?? Maybe it's tradition, but as much as it stands out, it also obscures my ability to observe the whiskey's color and quality. Having never bought Cutty Sark, I'm tempted to avoid it on the basis that there's this
green bottle
This was a fun and involving survey. It
was quick and easy. It was
interactive in nature
The bottle is important but only
when you have to taste a beverage
but after that the most
important is the taste.
Very interesting survey with reasonable amount of
time
No comments, the survey was fun and interesting. Keep up
the EXCELLENT job you are doing and God
bless.
I like the black stripe
of the bottom part of the
bottle, t gives a
premium touch
The bottle’s design doesn’t fit with the
image of the product they sell. Whisky is a
traditional beverage, a traditional bottle would fit better, not modern
designs.
Loved this survey it was to the point
and fun
Scotch whisky must have darker color… at least
for the customers, its a
preference
Cutty Sark need to increase its authenticity, tradition and
Scottish heritage.
PACT©
End Slide
New Product Development & Innovation
UK Contact :
Chris Kingsland
+ 44 (0) 20 3178 6277 Direct+ 44 (0) 7958 332 764 [email protected]