mkultra research on human subjects
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
1/49
!"#$%%&'(
)*+!'
,*+
#$%%&!"
-
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
2/49
.
/
01234
)524
*64
34
342
344
34
24
346
3
$
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
3/49
.','"'7'0
5#5!'**''*.
#*('#--*8"
+7'*'1'
4
*'0
'
6666
629!"
4'
/'/5
6-:;&*'
*2*/.?@
78
8'
'.
2
4!=1.4'
A
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
4/49
582
4'
.
2'*/.B
44
'
4
5
'5665
'5
'5
4
'2
26
'64B
54'.2
452
'.-::C?
.25@
'/4
'/62
''4'!
'2
2'
C
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
5/49
24'.
5
'024
46
'*/.4
-:&%6-:D%64
42'
!44
4
2',4242
4
5'4
'
442
4'
24'
4
'-44
',44
5
42'
&
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
6/49
#445++//
2)*/.45
E6E4
E
4'
4
E
'
52
44
2
'.)4
E4
2E6*
2E
E
'*/.4
44'
242
5
'.
E5
'
2
4'44
F
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
7/49
*62
'424
4
2-::%6$%%&
4'
45
'
'
!
"#
*/.44
-:D%'*4
*/.G!=1.4'.-:DD
!"#$%#&'$(!
7/?
'@$-:D;&
)*+!,((
$-:;-'A#
44
2-:DF70
3+703+(1C&*#1CF(02
2*/.'C.
!$F-:DD*/.-.+$
)?-%$.-:CD34H--:%&
*/7
D
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
8/49
2*
/.'@
34)
III45I
5
5'#*
4
'&
4'+
'34
)
8'*
4
4G'.
24
'/
45
'1
4
82G'F
-:DD!"#$44*
2'=)
/
58
'42
*02,,
;
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
9/49
12'
203+
7H7*/.''''*/.-:D&
'/
44'D
=B#B4
=B
5'?/4
8
5
'@;
*4!=1.
6*/.5
*/.'34
2''*)
#.88
B(#.B
3.B
':.-:FA*/.B!=1.
5'?
'''''.82'@-%.
4*/.?8
*/.5''''/
*/.*.
HH+0'@--
:
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
10/49
.4*/.
4$%%$!)
*7+0
#5HB'
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
11/49
'''
224'/
2
2'@-C
.$*
4)
/2
''''
.*2
2
'.*
2
'/4
2'34
'
2
2
'-&
.-::&.$*'
#4'.
-::D*!.+
--
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
12/49
$
4'-F77
'-D)?.
'''2''
''.-'''
'@-;')?,
'''
'''@-:.4
'/5'
..$*4
4
2'8863+
-::C$#'.
.3*.3*(.
2-:C&-:CD4'$%0
44-::%'$-/-:::5
)&!*/0+
.$*?5
'@$$+44
5'.4+B5
)
!B
'2
442
-$
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
13/49
'''
''''.4
'''
'
""*-:C&
'?.@6'''
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
14/49
?4
255
''(',
2
'$C
!
4'
+
2'64B
542
4'
*1-::C
0.+*/4
5
4'6
E
2)
/4.
J+/5
-:C%-:C&-:C&
2'/
4
25''''/
'+
4J05
J+BJ+
-C
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
15/49
4J+
4J'''.5
/55'$&
64
+'04
?@
'*
4B'
.$%%$$#124)
I/G
I7'
!*,3
K''''!7,
'!77
*/.5400'$F
/-:::34#5$4,*/
.!2)
++//
4
'454
'.
4'/
-&
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
16/49
'$D
7'!B
4)
/4
2'
,
5
'.4
)
'3G
8'$;
/$%%&40'+.5
)?./'''
''''L."5)
+55'@.5
?@I
4'@$:
!)4
24'
4+B
85'4
2
2'.$%%&0'4
'
-F
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
17/49
#"
46
',4
GGGG'
G'A%
.$%%&34#54
)
1*7
7
*
''''5
56
'
I6
2
'II/I
'A-
.44
2
'*4J
-D
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
18/49
!.#.
258'A$
6'B
5
4'
"$"%"#
&
*?
4'@AA/?
'@AC,"+
*'4
4".4)
?3*5
'+
'
4
''''5
554'A&
*B7B-:CD'
"
48
++//'24
*'2
'AF
*
4'I*1I
-;
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
19/49
4
42'AD+
*?
'@A;
*
'.D/**
1?2
4'@A:!4*
'!'*,
4?
'@C%C-,
*',
4'C$,
.
*/-:;%'CA02
.*/-:::
5'CC
,
4'
/56*8
1M
4'B
*01'/
5'C&
,4
',B
-:
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
20/49
654
'CF
.4*
-:&%F%)
4*/..27
4.244
28
'15*
-:&%'CD
*?+!@
7*3'+#$F-:&A'C;.#!
*4
?'@C:,
!54
-:F%4
'&%/-:D;*
02,,1
'&-!?
'@&$
##
4'
701*
4'.6
44
/**1/**1('
$%
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
21/49
4'-::C
.D/**1
)?.D4
MB
#39#.*
'@&A)
!34'4
'#.
88B(
#.B
3.B
'@&C
-::C
4/**1*.
*.(4'&&
54
''4'
4-::;#
+H8.'4
4/**1*.'
.D/**1?
24'@
*..-
'05
4
5
$-
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
22/49
*.?
@*.'
48++//
25
62
'
*.52
6
'
2
'/5
4(
*.'/**1
54
22
.-*.'@&F
#
"2
44'
?5
4'@&D.'0
24
*4
'&;/
$$
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
23/49
'&:
./*'4
22
4'
'
'F%
*
4'
B
*'!'F-
04'
4
)'
H-:;D*'F$
4'
'?
24*'@FA
7B
7'?
'@FC0'?2
#*.
6'@F&
*'&6CB
'
$A
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
24/49
2
2?@
)'FF
/HB**E
??
@?
'@'''2
54
''''2'''
'FD
HB*B48
+
+//*'
38,0,?
2
.**-:&%'@F;.,
ND%$%CC2!-:;D'/-:;;*/.
4*ND&%%%%*/.
'F:
$'-::&
-:F%4
*77',5B
*?*?
@?'@D%,5-:&A+
!4?*'@D-
$C
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
25/49
B?
@B
'.
'D$
4'/6!=1.*/.
4'?/
5*/.'''4
2!=1.6
N-&%%%'@DA?4@?2
45@
4'DC
'54
?'''
'15
E
'@D&
1#*.$;''*'$FDC(
'"
?B
2'@DF#
4B?
884'@DD
24
)7'.
52*
'
$&
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
26/49
E4'D;
24522
4
'
#%
)?
G
44
'@D:44
44
*/.!=1.4-:&%6D%
11G-:;-43H(-$AAA';%4
4'3H-$AAA*
#1*#1(C&*#1CF
24'/-::-
*/.4
4'3H-$AAA?$'-%034'
/*
24700
'2G
'@;-
/
2
-:DC';$*#1CFCF'-%-('
*#14
'CF'-%-()?
$F
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
27/49
7.
'''@
52
7.'
#48
*E4
4'/-::A4'
42'I
+'I;A*
.*0135'.*013
-:&%*'#
4.*013?.3*.3
*(
2'@;C
-:&%*4
77'5*
?2
'@;&.*013
7+B-:&A2'
*
';F
.$*)$I
E
2'I;D*
.*013-::D
77'70
000(*/.
$D
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
28/49
004
34H-$AAA';;
4
5'56
65'5
'5
+
22
.22
'
54?2
'@;:.$%%A
0$"')#('+&
(5+*.&.104)
,G.*8
A%%,*'
'*IGG
'I:%
*B4
'.44
4'A%-:::*'..*013
'
.48II
'*4
$;
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
29/49
77
':-
.'**,
)
?5
(
''''
B5
B'?'''
B4
4':$
'*B
45
4)
24
'H4
''''4
II
'
5
':A
$:
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
30/49
.54)
2'.-::C(
4)
!
',4
5''
=4
+L5'*'3!5
!
4-:;F'.!5
37
',5
08HGG'/
':C
1
4-:;F*
4-::%8
4':&,*B
424
44
'*
-::D.+$
54
2'
#"#
A%
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
31/49
.
44
'
**86-:D%
*
5
''''/
'*
5
'/4
8
5
':F
94
24'
!=1.-:D%4'
*2
'
*
54
'#6&2/$7899?
44
05':DH-C%-
-&%%%$%%%%%4'
#)?-:;F
!4
A-
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
32/49
FD4-:FD-:&;':;$*/
788:?
'@::,
?'@-%%
.-::C(45
5
2)
$*/788:;
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
33/49
7'"?
44'@-%A
"54',
74K
.?2@'-%C
77,?@
'-%&4'
*
4'
42'
4'?4
*G
'@-%F
?.3-:&%#
15*(4'''I
4I#5I
'I*'@-%D
.2
4'*/.
4
/6*)
/
/6*''''
AA
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
34/49
(''''
+4
''''*4
8
'-%;
.*0135
',
.*013'.*013@
4'@-%:.*013'.*013
4'?+
24
27H7*/.'@--%,
*/.7H7B5
'
4*B-::D4
*
'4B
4
4'/
44
'
18
82'.
'/$%%$(-+.4)
I+/H!/!(8'
AC
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
35/49
'.2
'I---(-+I/H!(
*
4'I--$
.$%%&*1*1(?)
.$+?*5*
1B6
62''''*
*-::D'--A,.*
-::&*
$'.'--C?
*
-::&.*0134
'@--&
,$%%-,.*$%%&*14'.
$%%-,.*?.*013111@
.*013B'--F
.*013
.*013'
9
5)
*'
8
4)$%%-,.**E,.*5
?@
4E,.*
E,.**B-::D
A&
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
36/49
0027H7E.*013B
E,.*
.*013E,.*-::%
4
'
#"HB-::D.$+
788=G
4'--D/
")
2
24'4
''''//
'''
'--;
-%&")?.5
N-%%%%A'
7'@--:
?@'-$%.-::D34#
4)
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
37/49
I!5"G5',
'-$-
*77*4
$%%%$%%$$%%A$%%C'-$$
$%%%2B$%%%
'
.7"
.!**81*1
.7.I.$+
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
38/49
$%%C!=B4
$$>
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
39/49
42
)*2
4'.4
'**14
22'-$F.54
4'-$D.
*
1'4
'.-::;(-+
4)
'IL
26652I
".'''
'7'=8L
!
)I/G'I-$;
54
4'
'!=1.
45
'344
'.24
'
2
4
A:
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
40/49
2'.24
44
4'
.
'
#$%
*24
4'
!5*
'
H5
2'.)4
''*
/**1*.'
5'
44
4'
34B
'
24
4
'.
'8'
*/.!=1.48
4'
++//4',
C%
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
41/49
'/
J'5
'
$%%C5*
'0)
066
24
'
5
6''''75
2'.
686'-$:
,'.
4
4'.6
24
4'-A%+
4
4'
46
'.4
$%%-50),,+&$'
"'.11,I
4'@-A-
C-
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
42/49
4'
2'.8
=C'&'
!)
-'62
'
$''
A''
C'5
('-A$
.54
42
'5
464
'-AA
24
4
4',
'
:6--
*',
4
5'
C$
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
43/49
-'=1'!04%*/$A6$C($%%-('?H
5?
@84'
/3
5''''6
52
*5'@
$'!4,&'$(!(
'+.$
.$:&*'--:DD('
A'.*0134.*013()$FDF-::&('
C'34'H'--:%'1'K'C-'AC#-:-:DF'
&'!A&'
F'&:'
D'*/C
;'!-F$'
:'52$'
$.$'
$'?$@DA-::C('
-%'.)!.$'01
K'A'-6C&:-:;$('
--''&:F-'
-$'#'5&2.)!.;$%%$
.-'
-A'.*01334"#1.*
0134--'
-C'.*013;$;'
-&'.*013;$:'
-F'!.+$F$#'1'$FAF:
-::D('
-D'22$*,222.+
*2521$A$-F'$!$&$%%$'
-;'!'
CA
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
44/49
-:'!'
$%'$#'.(+*'
*'.$-%A*'$F-::C('
$-'10$&'
$$'3+#)%&!*/0C;D-:::('
$A'C;C6C;&'
$C'.*0134.*013($*
!%$.$*/
.!..!.(C%A.D-::FK'$DF'&'
$&'0*.+*/.'('
+5-5.$
-%A*'--A6--C-::C('
$F'0#**/%)4@167!A$%%$.-C'
$D'7'!$4%*/.&-:::('
$;'$;:'
$:'+!'.5%2'!,',
58A770-C$%%&('
A%'+!'.5B,+$-$%%&'
A-'7$+'#'*'5'L5
$:$%%&'
A$'*#*'%!$;-::D('.
48
8'46*/.
+'/+
55.'1'+*/.
*.01.'A-::D)
/5''
.8
*
'''*
)(#.(
4(
'
AA'"'.!.'"#>2+'%
.$'.*/$-::$('
CC
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
45/49
AC'"'.!'&(4%#+'
*0KD)-D'$--::-('
A&'CC'
AF'+'%/>2,A$%%C('
AD'37'+'$?$@$'%).$+%$
)2$'.$,'#,$#
%#+-
'#5,2''#:;-::;('
&F'5:A6C'
&D'7,,5160-%$%%$(
&;'7-%'
&:'!-A;'
F%'7$6A'
F-'7F--CD'
C&
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
46/49
F$'C;A''FF:'*'-:;D('
FA'."$-$'
FC'.A;'
F&'.A;'
FF'C;A''FD;6F;CF;F'FD'.A:'
F;'0*.+*/%.'('
+-5.
$-%A*'&C-::C('
F:'.*013;C&'
D%'!##%##02$
#$&%$%%$('
D-'$&-'
D$'$;D6;;'DA',533'""#0*/''
+1$C-::CA$'
DC''
D&'#.#!%*/',
,"HA%-:;;DD'
DF',.'"(42CD:-:::('
DD'0)+%2'>
,>''
.,.!-::C&D'
D;'7-CD'
D:'!-F$'
;%'.*013F;:6F:%'
;-'34'H'-$AAA'$'-%.*/'
;$'.*013FDF'
;A'.2!52,6**'*-,.
K'&%/$!-::C'
;C'"$20,($+7-&
-::C-;.'
;&'!-FF6D'
;F'!$&D'
;D'.*013F;D'
CF
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
47/49
;;'FF#1F-F%D6%A
--A%'#*1(#02
.)&*A%-EC$*$;:*#1*)C&*#1CF.)/
G!!$D-::D
#(02
2'
#)-(4
2
#E$(
4
2EA(
EC(/1,(/1,
'
/#1%$9%%9%$
;:'!-;-'
:%'*0'3'"')#(
'+&++.&1,+
17$$$%%A'-;'
:-'046'+2'50
$--:::.-'
:$')%'''2'
!+).$,+,
6,$,-$C8?7888@
:A!A&'
:C'!52'
:&'+CF:6D%'
:F'!-F$'
:D'5:D'
:;':D'
::':D'
-%%':D'
-%-'0&D'
-%$',5A$'
-%A',5A$'
-%C',5A$'
CD
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
48/49
-%&',5A$'
-%F'!-DC'
-%D'!-D$'
-%;'!-D&6F'
-%:'.*0134$.$*/H$--::C4.34H
'-$;:-.$*/,-;-::C$
(C('
--%'.*013F;&'
---'!=.7''$.%
!0#+##+2,"HC$%%$'
--$'
--A'37'+'$?$@$'%)
.$+%$)2$'.$,
-
7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects
49/49
-$&'385'3.+.#,5'.
$%'+#*$./!
K'-C-E/C.-D$%%C'
-$F'.'.0&0'0'B$'*$
*+*'*1K'-%A:%:'-$D'!-;-'
-$;'='
-$:'-D'
-A%'!-&;6-F$'
-A-'!'!0%,,+&'
4,-:D$%%-('
-A$''-:D'
-AA'-:;'