miranda

19
FIRST DIVISION JOSE C. MIRANDA, ALBERTO P. DALMACIO, and ROMEO B. OCON, Petitioners, - versus - VIRGILIO M. TULIAO, Respondent. G.R. No. 158763 Present: PANGANIBAN, C.J. Chairperson, YNARES-SANTIAGO, AUSTRIA-MARTINEZ, CALLEJO, SR., and CHICO-NAZARIO, JJ. Promulgated: March 31, 2006 x- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -x D E C I S I O N CHICO-NAZARIO, J.: This is a petition for review on certiorari under Rule 45 of the Rules of Court, assailing the 18 December 2002 Decision [1] of the Court of Appeals in CA-G.R. SP No. 67770 and its 12 June 2003 Resolution denying petitioners Motion for Reconsideration.The dispositive portion of the assailed decision reads as follows: WHEREFORE, finding public respondent Judge Anastacio D. Anghad to have acted with grave abuse of discretion amounting to lack or excess of jurisdiction in issuing the assailed Orders, the instant petition for certiorari, mandamus and prohibition is hereby GRANTED and GIVEN DUE COURSE, and it is hereby ordered: 1. The assailed Joint Order dated August 17, 2001, Order dated September 21, 2001, Joint Order dated October 16, 2001 and Joint Order dated November 14, 2001 dismissing the two (2) Informations for Murder, all issued by public respondent JudgeAnastacio D. Anghad in

Upload: clyde-patrick-ygnacio-makabenta

Post on 18-Aug-2015

216 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

miranda case

TRANSCRIPT

FIRST DIVISION JOSEC. MIRANDA, ALBERTOP.DALMACIO, and ROMEO B. OCON,Petitioners, - versus - VIRGILIO M. TULIAO,Respondent.G.R. No. 15876 Present: PANGANIBAN, C.J.Chairperson,YNARES-SANTIAGO,AUSTRIA-MARTINE,CA!!E"O, SR., andC#ICO-NAARIO, JJ. Pro$%&'ated: Mar(h )*, +,,-.- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -. / E C I S I O N C#ICO-NAARIO, J.: This is a petition 0or re1ie2 on certiorari %nder R%&e 34 o0 the R%&es o0 Co%rt, assai&in'the *5 /e(e$6er +,,+ /e(ision7*8 o0 the Co%rt o0 Appea&s in CA-G.R. SP No. -999, and its *+"%ne +,,) Reso&%tion den:in' petitioners Motion 0or Re(onsideration.The dispositi1e portion o0the assai&ed de(ision reads as 0o&&o2s: ;#ERE%risdi(tion o1er his personthat an a((%sed $a: in1o=e the pro(esses o0 the (o%rt @Pete M. Pico vs. Alfonso V.Combing, "r., A.M. No. RT"-C*-9-3, No1e$6er -, *CC+A. Th%s, an a((%sed $%st0irst 6e p&a(ed in the (%stod: o0 the &a2 6e0ore the (o%rt $a: 1a&id&: a(t on hispetition 0or >%di(ia& re&ie0s.7)8 Pro(eedin' 0ro$ this pre$ise, the Co%rt o0 Appea&s r%&ed that petitionersMiranda, O(on and /a&$a(io (annot see= an: >%di(ia& re&ie0 sin(e the: 2ere not :et arrested orother2isedepri1edo0 their &i6ert:at theti$e the:0i&edtheir Ur'ent Motionto(o$p&etepre&i$inar: in1esti'ationB to rein1esti'ateB to re(a&& andFor E%ash 2arrants o0 arrest.738 Petitioners(o%nterthe0indin'o0theCo%rt o0 Appea&s6:ar'%in'that >%risdi(tiono1ertheperson o0 the a((%sed is reE%ired on&: in app&i(ations 0or 6ai&. %risdi(tion o1er their person is reE%ired 6e0ore the (o%rt (an a(t on their$otiontoE%ashthe2arrant 0ortheirarrest, s%(h>%risdi(tiono1ertheirperson2asa&read:a(E%ired 6: the (o%rt 6: their 0i&in' o0 the a6o1e Ur'ent Motion. In ar'%in' that >%risdi(tion o1er the person is reE%ired on&: in the ad>%di(ation o0 app&i(ations 0or6ai&, petitioners E%ote Retired Co%rt o0 Appea&s "%sti(e Os(ar #errera: E.(ept in app&i(ations 0or 6ai&, it is not ne(essar: 0or the (o%rt to 0irst a(E%ire>%risdi(tiono1er thepersono0thea((%sedtodis$issthe(aseor'rant otherre&ie0. The o%tri'ht dis$issa& o0 the (ase e1en 6e0ore the (o%rt a(E%ires>%risdi(tion o1er the person o0 the a((%sed is a%thoriDed %nder Se(tion -@aA, R%&e**+o0 the Re1isedR%&es o0 Cri$ina& Pro(ed%re andthe Re1isedR%&es onS%$$ar:Pro(ed%re @Se(. *+aA. In Allado vs. Diokno (232 SCRA 192), the(ase2as dis$issed on $otion o0 the a((%sed 0or &a(= o0 pro6a6&e (a%se 2itho%t thea((%sed ha1in' 6een arrested. In Paul Roberts vs. Court of Appeals (2! SCRA3"#), the Co%rt 2as ordered to ho&d the iss%an(e o0 a 2arrant o0 arrest in a6e:an(ependin' re1ie2 6: the Se(retar: o0 "%sti(e. And in $a%son vs. &'e%utiveSe%retar((3"1SCRA1"2455), theCo%rt orderedthe(asetrans0erred0ro$theSandi'an6a:an to the RTC 2hi(h e1ent%a&&: ordered the dis$issa& o0 the (ase 0or&a(= o0 pro6a6&e (a%se.7-8 In ar'%in', on the other hand, that >%risdi(tion o1er their person 2as a&read: a(E%ired 6: their0i&in' o0 the a6o1e Ur'ent Motion,petitioners in1o=e o%r prono%n(e$ent, thro%'h"%sti(e %risdi(tion o1er the person o0 the a((%sed.758 C%stod: o0 the &a2 is a((o$p&ished either 6: arrestor 1o&%ntar: s%rrender,7C8 2hi&e >%risdi(tion o1er the person o0 the a((%sed is a(E%ired %pon hisarrest or 1o&%ntar: appearan(e.7*,8 One (an 6e %nder the (%stod: o0 the &a2 6%t not :et s%6>e(t tothe>%risdi(tiono0the(o%rt o1erhisperson, s%(has2henapersonarrested6:1irt%eo0a2arrant 0i&es a $otion 6e0ore arrai'n$ent to E%ash the 2arrant. On the other hand, one (an 6es%6>e(t to the >%risdi(tion o0 the (o%rt o1er his person, and :et not 6e in the (%stod: o0 the &a2,s%(h as 2hen an a((%sed es(apes (%stod: a0ter his tria& has (o$$en(ed.7**8 Bein' in the (%stod:o0 the &a2 si'ni0ies restraint on the person, 2ho is there6: depri1ed o0 his o2n 2i&& and &i6ert:,6indin' hi$ to 6e(o$e o6edient to the 2i&& o0 the &a2.7*+8 C%stod: o0 the &a2 is &itera&&: (%stod:o1er the 6od: o0 the a((%sed. It in(&%des, 6%t is not &i$ited to, detention. The state$ent in Pico v. Judge Combong# Jr.#7*)8 (ited 6: the Co%rt o0 Appea&s sho%&d not ha1e6eenseparated0ro$theiss%einthat (ase, 2hi(histheapp&i(ation0orad$issionto6ai& o0so$eone not :et in the (%stod: o0 the &a2. The entire para'raph o0 o%r prono%n(e$entin Pico reads: A personapp&:in'0orad$issionto6ai& $%st 6einthe(%stod:o0the&a2orother2ise depri1ed o0 his &i6ert:. A person 2ho has not s%6$itted hi$se&0 to the>%risdi(tion o0 the (o%rt has no ri'ht to in1o=e the pro(esses o0 that(o%rt. Respondent "%d'esho%&dha1edi&i'ent&:as(ertainedthe2herea6o%tso0theapp&i(ant andthathe indeedhad >%risdi(tiono1er the6od:o0the a((%sed6e0ore (onsiderin' the app&i(ation 0or 6ai&.7*38 ;hi&e 2e stand 6: o%r a6o1e prono%n(e$ent in Pico inso0ar as it (on(erns 6ai&, 2e (&ari0: that,as a'enera& r%&e, one2hosee=s ana00ir$ati1ere&ie0 is dee$edtoha1es%6$ittedtothe>%risdi(tion o0 the (o%rt.7*48 As 2e he&d in the a0ore(ited (ase o0 Santiago, see=in' an a00ir$ati1ere&ie0 in (o%rt, 2hether in (i1i& or (ri$ina& pro(eedin's, (onstit%tes 1o&%ntar: appearan(e. Pico dea&s2ithanapp&i(ation0or6ai&, 2herethereisthespe(ia& reE%ire$ent o0theapp&i(ant 6ein' in the (%stod: o0 the &a2.In $eliciano v. Pasicolan,7*-8 2e he&d that 7t8he p%rposeo0 6ai& is tose(%reones re&easeandit 2o%&d6ein(on'r%o%s to'rant 6ai& toone2hois0ree. Th%s, 6ai& is the se(%rit: reE%ired and 'i1en 0or the re&ease o0 a person 2ho is in the (%stod:o0 &a2. The rationa&e 6ehind this spe(ia& r%&e on 6ai& is that it dis(o%ra'es and pre1ents resort tothe 0or$er perni(io%s pra(ti(e 2herein the a((%sed (o%&d >%st send another in his stead to post his6ai&,2itho%tre(o'niDin' the>%risdi(tiono0the (o%rt6:hispersona& appearan(ethereinand(o$p&ian(e 2ith the reE%ire$ents there0or.7*98 There is, ho2e1er, an e.(eption to the r%&e that 0i&in' p&eadin's see=in' a00ir$ati1e re&ie0(onstit%tes voluntary appearance, and the (onseE%ent s%6$ission o0 ones person to the>%risdi(tiono0 the(o%rt. This isinthe(aseo0 p&eadin's 2hosepra:er ispre(ise&:0or thea1oidan(eo0 the>%risdi(tiono0 the(o%rt, 2hi(hon&:&eads toa special appearance. Thesep&eadin's are: @*A in civil cases, $otions to dis$iss on the 'ro%nd o0 &a(= o0 >%risdi(tion o1er theperson o0 the de0endant, 2hether or not other 'ro%nds 0or dis$issa& are in(&%dedB7*58 @+Ain criminal cases, $otions to E%ash a (o$p&aint on the 'ro%nd o0 &a(= o0 >%risdi(tion o1er theperson o0 the a((%sedB and @)A $otions to E%ash a 2arrant o0 arrest. The 0irst t2o are(onseE%en(es o0 the 0a(t that 0ai&%re to 0i&e the$ 2o%&d (onstit%te a 2ai1er o0 the de0ense o0 &a(=o0 >%risdi(tion o1er the person. The third is a (onseE%en(e o0 the 0a(t that it is the 1er: &e'a&it: o0the (o%rt pro(ess 0or(in' the s%6$ission o0 the person o0 the a((%sed that is the 1er: iss%e in a$otion to E%ash a 2arrant o0 arrest. To re(apit%&ate 2hat 2e ha1e dis(%ssed so 0ar, in (ri$ina& (ases, >%risdi(tion o1er the person o0the a((%sed is dee$ed 2ai1ed 6: the a((%sed 2hen he 0i&es an: p&eadin' see=in' an a00ir$ati1ere&ie0, e.(ept in (ases 2hen he in1o=es the spe(ia& >%risdi(tion o0 the (o%rt 6: i$p%'nin' s%(h>%risdi(tion o1er his person. There0ore, in narro2(ases in1o&1in' spe(ia& appearan(es, ana((%sed (an in1o=e the pro(esses o0 the (o%rt e1en tho%'h there is neither >%risdi(tion o1er theperson nor (%stod: o0 the &a2. #o2e1er, i0 a person in1o=in' the spe(ia& >%risdi(tion o0 the (o%rtapp&ies 0or 6ai&, he $%st 0irst s%6$it hi$se&0 to the (%stod: o0 the &a2. In (ases not in1o&1in' the so-(a&&ed spe(ia& appearan(e, the 'enera& r%&e app&ies, i.e., the a((%sedis dee$ed to ha1e s%6$itted hi$se&0 to the >%risdi(tion o0 the (o%rt %pon see=in' a00ir$ati1ere&ie0. Not2ithstandin' this, there is no reE%ire$ent 0or hi$ to 6e in the (%stod: o0 the &a2. The0o&&o2in' (ases 6est i&&%strate this point, 2here 2e 'ranted 1ario%s re&ie0s to a((%sed 2ho 2erenot in the (%stod: o0 the &a2, 6%t 2ere dee$ed to ha1e p&a(ed their persons %nder the >%risdi(tiono0the(o%rt. Notethat noneo0these(asesin1o&1etheapp&i(ation0or6ai&, nora$otiontoE%ash an in0or$ation d%e to &a(= o0 >%risdi(tion o1er the person, nor a $otion to E%ash a 2arranto0 arrest:*. In Allado v. %io&no,7*C8 on the pra:er o0 the a((%sed in a petition 0or (ertiorari on the'ro%nd o0 &a(= o0 pro6a6&e (a%se, 2e iss%ed a te$porar: restrainin' order en>oinin'PACC 0ro$ en0or(in' the 2arrant o0arrestandtherespondent>%d'etherein0ro$0%rther pro(eedin' 2ith the (ase and, instead, to e&e1ate the re(ords to %s. +. In 'oberts# Jr. v. Court of Appeals,7+,8 %pon the a((%seds Motion to S%spendPro(eedin's and to #o&d in A6e:an(e Iss%an(e o0 ;arrants o0 Arrest on the 'ro%ndthat the:0i&edaPetition0orRe1ie22iththe/epart$ent o0"%sti(e, 2edire(tedrespondent >%d'e therein to (ease and desist 0ro$ 0%rther pro(eedin' 2ith the (ri$ina&(ase and to de0er the iss%an(e o0 2arrants o0 arrests a'ainst the a((%sed. ). In (acson v.)*ecutiveSecretary,7+*8 onthepra:ero0thea((%sedinapetition0or(ertiorari on the 'ro%nd o0 &a(= o0 >%risdi(tion on the part o0 the Sandi'an6a:an, 2edire(ted the Sandi'an6a:an to trans0er the (ri$ina& (ases to the Re'iona& Tria& Co%rte1en 6e0ore the iss%an(e o0 the 2arrants o0 arrest. ;e ho&d that the (ir(%$stan(es 0or(in' %s to reE%ire (%stod: o0 the &a2 in app&i(ations 0or6ai& are not present in $otions to E%ash the 2arrant o0 arrest. I0 2e a&&o2 the 'rantin' o0 6ai& topersons not in the (%stod: o0 the &a2, it is 0oreseea6&e that $an: persons 2ho (an a00ord the 6ai&2i&& re$ain at &ar'e, and (o%&d e&%de 6ein' he&d to ans2er 0or the (o$$ission o0 the o00ense i0e1erheispro1en'%i&t:. Ontheotherhand, i02ea&&o2the E%asha& o02arrantso0arrest topersons not in the (%stod: o0 the &a2, it 2o%&d 6e 1er: rare that a person not 'en%ine&: entit&ed to&i6ert: 2o%&d re$ain s(ot-0ree. This is 6e(a%se it is the sa$e >%d'e 2ho iss%ed the 2arrant o0arrest 2ho2i&& de(ide2hether or not he0o&&o2edtheConstit%tioninhisdeter$inationo0pro6a6&e (a%se, and he (an easi&: den: the $otion to E%ash i0 he rea&&: did 0ind pro6a6&e (a%sea0ter persona&&: e.a$inin' the re(ords o0 the (ase. Moreo1er, p%rs%ant to the pres%$ption o0 re'%&arit: o0 o00i(ia& 0%n(tions, the 2arrant (ontin%esin 0or(e and e00e(t %nti& it is E%ashed and there0ore (an sti&& 6e en0or(ed on an: da: and at an:ti$e o0 the da: and ni'ht.7++8 o: a hi'her pre0eren(ein the hierar(h: o0 ri'hts than propert: ri'hts,7+)8 de$andin' that d%e pro(ess in the depri1ationo0 &i6ert: $%st (o$e 6e0ore its ta=in' and not a0ter. 6#a*+$n7 a ,a--an& o' a--.*& 3a*.d on a*#3*.)#.n&21'$2.d0.&$&$on'o--./$.,,$&+&+.S.%-.&a-1 o' J#*&$%. and 3a*.d on do#3&*.n7.nd.-.d31&+.0o2$&$%a2 %2$(a&.%on*&$&.*7-a/. a3#*. o' d$*%-.&$on. ;e ne1erthe&ess 0ind 'ra1e a6%se o0 dis(retion in the assai&ed a(tions o0"%d'e An'had. "%d'e An'had see$ed a &itt&e too ea'er o0 dis$issin' the (ri$ina& (ases a'ainstthe petitioners. %st 6e(a%se the petitioners $i'ht,in the 0%t%re,appea& the assistantprose(%tors reso&%tion to the Se(retar: o0 "%sti(e. B%t e1en i0 the petition 0or re1ie2 2as 0i&ed6e0ore the iss%an(e o0 the 2arrants o0 arrest, the 0a(t re$ains that the penden(: o0 a petition 0orthe re1ie2 o0 the prose(%tors reso&%tion is not a 'ro%nd to E%ash the 2arrants o0 arrest. In +ebb v. de (eon,7+48 2e he&d that the petitioners therein (annot assai& as pre$at%re the0i&in' o0 the in0or$ation in (o%rt a'ainst the$ on the 'ro%nd that the: sti&& ha1e the ri'ht toappea& the ad1erse reso&%tion o0 the /O" Pane& to the Se(retar: o0 "%sti(e.Si$i&ar&:, the iss%an(eo0 2arrants o0 arrest a'ainst petitioners herein sho%&d not ha1e 6een E%ashed as pre$at%re on thesa$e 'ro%nd. The other 'ro%nd in1o=ed 6: "%d'e An'had 0or the E%asha& o0 the 2arrant o0 arrest is inorder i0 tr%e: 1io&ation o0 the Constit%tion. #en(e, "%d'e An'had as=ed and reso&1ed theE%estion: Inthesedo%6&e$%rder (ases, didthis Co%rt (o$p&:or adheretothea6o1e-E%oted(onstit%tiona& pros(ription, 2hi(his Se(. +, Arti(&e III Bi&& o0Ri'htsB to Se(. -@aA, R%&e **+, R%&es o0 Cri$ina& Pro(ed%re and to the a6o1e-(itedde(isiona& (asesH To this E%er: or iss%e, a0ter a deep per%sa& o0 thear'%$ents raised, this Co%rt, thro%'h 7its8 re'%&ar Presidin' "%d'e, 0inds $erit inthe (ontention o0 herein a((%sed-$o1ant, "ose Pe$pe Miranda.7+-8 "%d'e An'had is re0errin' to the 0o&&o2in' pro1ision o0 the Constit%tion as ha1in' 6een1io&ated 6: "%d'e T%$a&i%an: Se(. +. The ri'ht o0 the peop&e to 6e se(%re in their persons, ho%ses, papersand e00e(ts a'ainst %nreasona6&e sear(hes and seiD%res o0 2hate1er nat%re and 0oran: p%rpose sha&& 6e in1io&a6&e, and no sear(h 2arrant or 2arrant o0 arrest sha&&iss%e e.(ept %pon pro6a6&e (a%se to 6e deter$ined persona&&: 6: the >%d'e a0tere.a$ination %nder oath or a00ir$ation o0 the (o$p&ainant and the 2itnesses he$a: prod%(e, and parti(%&ar&: des(ri6in' the p&a(e to 6e sear(hed and the personsor thin's to 6e seiDed.7+98 #o2e1er,a0tera(are0%& s(r%tin:o0there(ordso0the(ase, in(&%din'thes%pportin'e1iden(e to the reso&%tion o0 the prose(%tor in his deter$ination o0 pro6a6&e (a%se, 2e 0ind that"%d'e An'had 'ra1e&: a6%sed his dis(retion. A((ordin' to petitioners: Inthis(ase, then%&&it:o0theordero0"%d'e T%$a&i%an, 0orthearrest o0thepetitioners is apparent 0ro$ the 0a(e o0 the order itse&0, 2hi(h (&ear&: stated thatthe deter$ination o0 pro6a6&e (a%se 2as 6ased on the (erti0i(ation, %nder oath, o0the 0is(a& and not on a separate deter$ination persona&&: $ade 6: the "%d'e. Nopres%$ption o0 re'%&arit: (o%&d 6e dra2n 0ro$ the order sin(e it e.press&: and(&ear&: sho2ed that it 2as 6ased on&: on the 0is(a&s (erti0i(ation.7+58 Petitioners(&ai$is%ntr%e. "%d'e T%$a&i%ans "oint Order(ontainsnos%(hindi(ationthat here&ied solely on the prose(%tors (erti0i(ation. The "oint Order e1en indi(ated the (ontrar:: Uponre(eipt o0 the in0or$ationandreso&%tiono0 the prose(%tor, the Co%rtpro(eeded to deter$ine the e.isten(e o0 a pro6a6&e (a%se 6: persona&&: e1a&%atin'the re(ords . . ..7+C8 There(ordso0 the(asesho2that theprose(%tors (erti0i(ation2asa((o$panied6:s%pportin' do(%$ents, 0o&&o2in' the reE%ire$ent %nder (im# Sr. v. $eli*7),8 and People v. ,nting.7)*8 The s%pportin' do(%$ents are the 0o&&o2in': *.Reso&%tion dated +* "%ne +,,* o0 State Prose(%tor !eo S. Re:esB+.A00ida1it dated ++ Ma: +,,* o0 Modesto G%tierreDB).A00ida1it dated *C Ma: +,,* o0 Ro$eo B. O(onB3."oint Co%nter A00ida1it dated +) Ma: +,,* o0 Ma:or "ose C. Miranda andRe:na&do de &a Cr%DB4.A00ida1it dated *C Ma: +,,* o0 A&6erto /a&$a(ioB-./e(ision dated ++ Apri& *CCC o0 the Re'iona& Tria& Co%rt o0 Mani&a, Bran(h3* in Cri$ina& Case No. C9-*-,)44B9.S2orn state$ent dated +9 Apri& +,,* o0 Rode& Madera&B5.In0or$ation dated ++ "%ne +,,*BC.A00ida1it-(o$p&aint o0 ?ir'i&io T%&iaoB and*,.Medi(o-&e'a& Reports o0 the (ada1ers o0 E&eDer T%&iao and ?i(ente B%aDon. #en(e, pro(ed%ra&&:, 2e (an (on(&%de that there 2as no 1io&ation on the part o0"%d'e T%$a&i%an o0 Arti(&e III, Se(tion +, o0 the Constit%tion. "%d'e An'had, ho2e1er, 0o(%sedon the s%6stanti1e part o0 said se(tion, i.e., the e.isten(e o0 pro6a6&e (a%se. In 0ai&in' to 0indpro6a6&e (a%se, "%d'e An'had r%&ed that the (on0ession o0 SPO+ Madera& is in(redi6&e 0or the0o&&o2in' reasons: @*A it 2as 'i1en a0ter a&$ost t2o :ears in the (%stod: o0 the Nationa& B%rea%o0 In1esti'ationB @+A it 2as 'i1en 6: so$eone 2ho rendered hi$se&0 %ntr%st2orth: 0or 6ein' a0%'iti1e 0or 0i1e :earsB @)A it 2as 'i1en in e.(han'e 0or an o61io%s re2ard o0 dis(har'e 0ro$ thein0or$ationB and @3A it 2as 'i1en d%rin' the e&e(tion period a$idst a po&iti(a&&: (har'ed s(enario2here Santia'o Cit: 1oters 2ere pitted a'ainst ea(h other a&on' the &ines o0 the Miranda (a$p onone side and 0or$er Cit: Ma:or A$e&ita S. Na1arro, and a&&e'ed&: that o0 /ENRSe(retar: #eherson A&1areD on the other.7)+8 ;epainsta=in'&:2ent thro%'hthere(ordso0 the(aseand0o%ndnoreasontodist%r6the0indin's o0 pro6a6&e (a%se o0 "%d'eT%$a&i%an. It is i$portant to note that an e.ha%sti1e de6ate on the (redi6i&it: o0 a 2itness is not2ithin the pro1in(e o0 the deter$ination o0 pro6a6&e (a%se. As 2e he&d in +ebb7))8: A 0indin' o0 pro6a6&e (a%se needs on&: to rest on e1iden(e sho2in' that $ore&i=e&: than not a (ri$e has 6een (o$$itted and 2as (o$$itted 6: thes%spe(ts. Pro6a6&e (a%se need not 6e 6ased on (&ear and (on1in(in' e1iden(e o0'%i&t, neither on e1iden(e esta6&ishin' '%i&t 6e:ond reasona6&e do%6t andde0inite&:, not one1iden(eesta6&ishin'a6so&%te(ertaint:o0'%i&t. As2e&& p%tin -rinegar v. .nited States, 2hi&e pro6a6&e (a%se de$ands $ore than 6ares%spi(ion, it reE%ires &ess than e1iden(e 2hi(h 2o%&d >%sti0: . . . (on1i(tion. A0indin' o0 pro6a6&e (a%se $ere&: 6inds o1er the s%spe(t to stand tria&. It is not aprono%n(e$ent o0 '%i&t. . . . Pro6a6&e (a%se $ere&: i$p&ies pro6a6i&it: o0 '%i&t and sho%&d 6e deter$inedin a s%$$ar: $anner. Pre&i$inar: in1esti'ation is not a part o0 tria& . . .. D$*($**$n7 a %-$($na2 %a*. on &+. 3a*$* o' ad.%$*$on o' &+$* Co#-& $n ano&+.- %a*. ,$&+d$''.-.n& a%%#*.d %on*&$&.* 7-a/. a3#*. o'd$*%-.&$on. "%d'e An'had had E%ashed the 2arrant o0 arrest on the 'ro%nd, a$on' other thin's, that there2as a petition 0or re1ie2o0 the assistant prose(%tors reso&%tion 6e0ore the Se(retar: o0"%sti(e. #o2e1er, a0ter the Se(retar: o0 "%sti(e a00ir$ed the prose(%tors reso&%tion,"%d'e An'had s%$$ari&: dis$issed the t2o (ri$ina& (ases a'ainst the petitioners on the 6asis o0the 0o&&o2in' e.p&anation: Rode& Madera& 2asoneo0thea((%sedinPeop&e1s. ;i&0redo !eano, eta&., RTC, Bran(h 3*, Mani&a, and 6ased 0ro$ his s2orn state$ents, he pinpointedto Mr. Miranda the $aster$ind and 2ith hi$ and the other po&i(e o00i(ers as thedire(t perpetrators, the O(to6er C, +,,* /e(ision o0 the S%pre$e Co%rt a6so&1in'the0i1e(opso0 $%rder, (ertain&:$a=es hiss2ornState$ents anarrationo00a&sehood and &ies and that 6e(a%se o0 the de(ision a(E%ittin' said o00i(ers 2ho2ere &i=e2ise 0a&se&: &in=ed 6: said Rode& Madera& in his Apri& +9, +,,*state$ents, it is no2 6e:ond do%6t that Rode& Madera& $ade %ntr%th0%&,0a6ri(atedandper>%redstate$entsandthere0orethesa$eis2itho%t pro6a6&e1a&%e. This Co%rt a'rees 2ith the de0enses 1ie2s. Indeed, o0 2hat %seis Madera&s state$ents 2hen the S%pre$e Co%rt re>e(ted the prose(%tionse1iden(e presented and add%(ed in Cri$ina& Case No. C9-*-,)44. Rode& Madera& is s%pposed to t%rn state 2itness in these t2o @+A (ases 6%t2ith the S%pre$e Co%rt de(ision ad1erted to, the pro6ati1e 1a&%e o0 hisstate$ents is pra(ti(a&&: ni&. . . . . This Co%rt 0inds $erit to the $ani0estation o0 the a((%sed Miranda datedO(to6er *5, +,,*, pra:in'0or thes%$$ar:dis$issa& o0 thet2o@+A $%rder(har'esin1ie2o0 the&atest de(isiono0theS%pre$eCo%rt in Peopleof tePilippines vs. +ilfredo (eao, et a&., G.R. No. *)55-, a(E%ittin'the a((%sedtherein and in e00e(t disre'ardin' a&& the e1iden(e presented 6: the prose(%tion inthat (ase.A((ordin'&:,thet2o@+A in0or$ations 70or8$%rder0i&eda'ainst "oseMiranda are ordered dis$issed.7)38 This is a (&ear (ase o0 a6%se o0 dis(retion. "%d'e An'had had no ri'ht to t2ist o%r de(ision andinterpret it to the dis(redit o0 SPO+Madera&,2ho 2as sti&& at &ar'e 2hen the e1iden(e o0 theprose(%tion inthe (eao (ase 2as presented. Ade(ision, e1en o0 this Co%rt, a(E%ittin' thea((%sed therein o0 a (ri$e (annot 6e the 6asis o0 the dis$issa& o0 (ri$ina& (ase a'ainst di00erenta((%sed 0or the sa$e (ri$e. The 6&%nder o0 "%d'e An'had is e1en $ore prono%n(ed 6: the 0a(tthat o%r de(ision in (eao 2as 6ased on reasona6&e do%6t.;e ne1er r%&ed in (eao that the (ri$edid not happenB 2e >%st 0o%nd that there 2as reasona6&e do%6t as to the '%i&t o0 the a((%sedtherein, sin(e the prose(%tion in that (ase re&ied on (ir(%$stantia& e1iden(e, 2hi(h interestin'&:is not e1en the sit%ation in the (ri$ina& (ases o0 the petitioners in the (ase at 6ar as there is herean e:e2itness: Rode& Madera&. The a((%sed in (eao 0%rther$ore had no $oti1e to =i&&respondent T%&iaos son, 2hereas petitioners hereinhad6eeni$p&i(atedinthetesti$on:o0respondent T%&iao6e0ore the Senate B&%e Ri66on Co$$ittee. It is prepostero%s to (on(&%de that 6e(a%se o0 o%r 0indin' o0 reasona6&e do%6t in (eao, itis no2 6e:ond do%6t that Rode&Madera& $ade %ntr%th0%&, 0a6ri(ated and per>%red state$ents andthere0ore the sa$e is 2itho%t pro6a6&e 1a&%e.7)48 On the (ontrar:, i0 2e are to per$it the %se o0o%r de(isionin (eao, ana(E%itta& onthe'ro%ndo0 reasona6&edo%6t a(t%a&&:pointstothepro6a6i&it: o0 the prose(%tions 1ersion o0 the 0a(ts therein. S%(h pro6a6i&it: o0 '%i&t (ertain&:$eets the (riteria o0 pro6a6&e (a%se. ;e (annot &et %nnoti(ed, too, "%d'e An'hads dis$issa& o0 the in0or$ations t2oda:s a'&.- 2e reso&1edto iss%e, %ponthe 0i&in' o0 a 6ond, a te$porar: restrainin' orderprohi6itin' hi$0ro$0%rther pro(eedin' 2iththe (ase. The 6ond2as 0i&ed the da:a0terthe in0or$ations 2ere dis$issed. ;hi&e the dis$issa& o0 the (ase 2as a6&e to 6eat the e00e(ti1it:date o0 the te$porar: restrainin' order, s%(h a6r%pt dis$issa& o0 the in0or$ations @da:s a0ter thisCo%rts reso&1e to iss%e a TRO a'ainst "%d'e An'hadA (reates 2i&d s%spi(ions a6o%t the $oti1eso0 "%d'e An'had. N#22$'$%a&$ono' a0-o%..d$n7n.%.**a-$21 %a--$.*,$&+ $& &+. -.$n*&a&.(.n& o' &+. o-d.-* *.& a*$d.31 &+. n#22$'$.d 0-o%..d$n7. In their se(ond assi'n$ent o0 error, petitioners (&ai$ that the Co%rt o0 Appea&s did not re(a&& orreinstate the 2arrants o0 arrest iss%ed 6: "%d'e T%$a&i%an, 6%t instead dire(ted "%d'e An'had toiss%e apparent&: ne2 2arrants o0 arrest.7)-8 A((ordin' to the petitioners, it 2as an error 0or theCo%rt o0 Appea&s to ha1e done so, 2itho%t a persona& deter$ination o0 pro6a6&e (a%se. ;e disa'ree. ;hether the Co%rt o0 Appea&s ordered the iss%an(e o0 ne2 2arrants o0 arrest or$ere&: ordered the reinstate$ent o0 the 2arrants o0 arrest iss%ed 6: "%d'e T%$a&i%an is $ere&: a$atter o0 s(r%p%&o%s se$anti(s, the s&i'ht ina((%ra(: 2hereo0 sho%&d not 6e a&&o2ed to a00e(t thedispositions on the $erits, espe(ia&&: in this (ase 2here the other dispositions o0 the Co%rt o0Appea&spoint totheotherdire(tion. %d'es therein on the 'ro%nd o0 'ra1e a6%se o0 dis(retion, in thesa$e 1ein, 2e (an a&so o1err%&e the de(ision o0 a >%d'e re1ersin' a 0indin' o0 pro6a6&e (a%se,a&so on the 'ro%nd o0 'ra1e a6%se o0 dis(retion. T+.-. $* no do#32. ".o0a-d1 $n &+. -.$n*&a&.(.n&o' a %-$($na2 %a*. d$*($**.d 3.'o-. a--a$7n(.n& Intheir thirdassi'n$ent o0 error, petitioners (&ai$that theCo%rt o0 Appea&s (o$$ittedare1ersi6&e error in orderin' the reinstate$ent o0 Cri$ina& Cases No. )--)4+) and No. )--)4+3,a&&e'in' that the order o0 dis$issa& iss%ed therein had 6e(o$e 0ina& and e.e(%tor:. A((ordin' topetitioners: It is a&so 2orth: to point o%t at this >%n(t%re that the "oint Order o0"%d'e An'had datedNo1e$6er *3, +,,*is NOTONE o0 thoseOrders2hi(h2ere assai&ed in the pri1ate respondent T%&iaos Petition 0or Certiorari, Manda$%sand Prohi6ition 0i&ed 6: the pri1ate respondent 6e0ore the Co%rt o0 Appea&s.As(are0%&&: en%$erated in the 0irst pa'e o0 the assai&ed /e(ision, on&: the 0o&&o2in'Orders iss%ed 6: "%d'eAn'had 2ere E%estioned 6: pri1ate respondent, to 2it: *.A"oint Order dated A%'%st *9, +,,*B+.AOrder dated Septe$6er +*, +,,*B).A"oint Order dated O(to6er *-, +,,*B and3.A"oint Order dated O(to6er ++, +,,*. O61io%s&:, the"oint Orderdated No1e$6er *3, +,,* o0"%d'e An'had,2hi(h %&ti$ate&: dis$issed Cri$ina& Cases Nos. )--)4+) AN/ )--)4+3 is NOTin(&%ded in the &ist o0 the assai&ed OrderF"oint Orders. #en(e, the Co%rt o0Appea&s sho%&d not ha1e passed %pon the 1a&idit: or n%&&it: o0 the "oint Ordero0 No1e$6er *3, +,,*.7)58 Petitioners $%st ha1e 0or'otten that respondent T%&iaos Petition 0or Certiorari,Prohi6ition andManda$%s 2as 0i&ed not 2ith the Co%rt o0 Appea&s, 6%t 2ith this Co%rt. The Co%rt o0 Appea&sde(ided the (ase 6e(a%se 2e re0erred the sa$e to the$ in o%r *C No1e$6er+,,* Reso&%tion. S%(h petition 2as 0i&ed on +4 O(to6er +,,*, aro%nd three 2ee=s before the *3No1e$6er +,,* Order.Upon re(eipt o0 the *3 No1e$6er +,,* Order, ho2e1er,respondent T%&iao &ost no ti$e in 0i&in' 2ith this Co%rt a Motion to Cite P%6&i( Respondent inConte$pt,a&&e'in' that "%d'e An'had de&i6erate&: and 2i&&0%&&: (o$$itted (onte$pt o0 (o%rt2hen he iss%ed on *4 No1e$6er +,,* the Order dated *3 No1e$6er +,,* dis$issin'the in0or$ations 0or$%rder. On +*No1e$6er+,,*, 2ere0erredsaid$otiontotheCo%rt o0Appea&s, in 1ie2 o0 the pre1io%s re0erra& o0 respondent T%&iaos petition 0or certiorari, prohi6itionand mandamus. O%r re0erra& to the Co%rt o0 Appea&s o0 the Motion to Cite P%6&i( Repondent in Conte$pt p&a(esthe *3 No1e$6er +,,* Order 2ithin the iss%es o0 the (ase de(ided 6: the Co%rt o0 Appea&s. In(&ai$in'that "%d'e An'had (o$$itted(onte$pt o0 this Co%rt iniss%in'the *3No1e$6er+,,* Order, respondent T%&iao hadas(ri6edto"%d'e An'had ana(t $%(h$oreserio%sthan'ra1e a6%se o0 dis(retion. Respondent T%&iao (&ai$s that "%d'e An'had iss%ed the *3 No1e$6er +,,* Order on *4No1e$6er +,,*, antedatin' it so as to a1oid the e00e(ts o0 o%r *+ No1e$6er +,,* Reso&%tion. Insaid *+ No1e$6er +,,* Reso&%tion, 2e reso&1ed to iss%e a te$porar: restrainin' order en>oinin'"%d'e An'had 0ro$ 0%rther pro(eedin' 2ith the (ri$ina& (ases %pon therespondent T%&iaos 0i&in' o0 a 6ond in the a$o%nt o0 P+,,,,,.,,. Respondent T%&iao had 0i&ed the6ond on *4 No1e$6er +,,4. ;hi&e 2e (annot i$$ediate&: prono%n(e "%d'e An'had in (onte$pt, seein' as disobedience tola!ful orders of acourt and abuseof court processes are(ases o0 indire(t (onte$pt 2hi(hreE%ire the 'rantin' o0 opport%nit: to 6e heard on the part o0 respondent,7)C8 the pra:er to citepublic respondent in contempt and for oter reliefs "ust and equitable under te premises sho%&d6e (onstr%ed to in(&%de a pra:er 0or the n%&&i0i(ation o0 said *3 No1e$6er +,,* Order. In an: (ase, the reinstate$ent o0 a (ri$ina& (ase dis$issed 6e0ore arrai'n$ent does not(onstit%te do%6&e >eopard:. /o%6&e >eopard: (annot 6e in1o=ed 2here the a((%sed has not 6eenarrai'ned and it 2as %pon his e.press $otion that the (ase 2as dis$issed.73,8Astorespondent T%&iaos pra:er @in6oththeori'ina& petition0or certiorari as2e&& asinhis$otion to (ite 0or (onte$ptA to disE%a&i0: "%d'e An'had 0ro$ 0%rther pro(eedin' 2ith the (ase,2e ho&d that the n%$6er o0 instan(es o0 a6%se o0 dis(retion in this (ase are eno%'h to (on1in(e %so0 an apparent 6ias on the part o0 "%d'e An'had. ;e 0%rther reso&1e to 0o&&o2 the (ase o0 Peoplev. SP/0 (eao,73*8 6: trans0errin' the 1en%e o0 Cri$ina& Cases No. )--)4+) and No. )--)4+3 tothe Cit: o0 Mani&a, p%rs%ant to Arti(&e ?III, Se(tion 3, o0 the Constit%tion.;#ERE