minoan chronology workshop, sonderborg 10 11 2007
DESCRIPTION
Slides I gave at the workshop on Minoan chronology, organizer by Aarhus University at Sonderborg, Denmark, in November 2007TRANSCRIPT
A point in space, a moment in time: towards an integrated view of the Santorini eruption
Stuart Dunn
Centre for e-Research, King’s College London
Santorini Chronology Workshop, Aarhus, 10th November 2007
Objectives:
• Overview of tephra fallout
• Consistent representation of data
• Estimation of bulk volume of ejecta
• Towards ‘encoding archaeology’ - associating archaeological and natural sciences data spatially and temporally
Constructing a geodatabase of Theran tephraPlace name: Santorini archipelago (northern caldera basin)
Deposit type: sea-floor sediment ( 400m)
Grid reference: not given
Area: -
Thickness: 40m
Deposition method: composite
Archaeological context: -
Comments: -
Literature: Woods Hole Oceanographic Institute Research Vessel Chain Cruise # 61, ref. no. 67 – 34.
(26)
Place name: Hagia Varvara
Grid reference: 25.46 E; 35.29 N
Deposit type: pumice layer
Area: unknown
Thickness: 5 – 10 cm
Deposition method: waterborne or human agency
Archaeological context: LM IA or possibly IB cup included in pumice layer and
filled with p umice, immediately below a s urface layer
containing LM III pottery.
Comments: Very badly eroded by modern tourist pathways. Illegal
development in the area has further damaged the
stratigraphy. As far as the author is a ware, however, this is
the only inst ance where a vesse l is included in situ with the
volcanic material.
Literature: Blackman 2001: 138; Müller Celka 1996: 928 – 8; also Müller
Celka personal communication, 6/8/2001.
Constructing a geodatabase of Theran tephra
Constructing a geodatabase of Theran tephra
Constructing a geodatabase of Theran tephra: problems
• Accuracy and (versus) precision
• Georeferencing from heterogeneous formats
Constructing a geodatabase of Theran tephra: problems
• Accuracy and (versus) precision
• Georeferencing from heterogeneous formats and sources
• Assessing deposition process
• Harmonizing points, sections and stratigraphies
• Georeferencing places
-formal, based on lat/long or other mathematical expressions
-Informal, based on placenames, and/or where no formal mathematical identifier is present
24.87
34.87
Estimation of bulk volume of ejecta
• Geographical Information Systems (GIS)
• Triangulated Irregular Network (TIN)
‘Conceptually like bending a sheet of rubber to pass through the point, while minimizing the curvature of the surface’
- total raster cell value of 132,508,783.441, or…
• This is a maximum estimate - c. 90-100 km3 is nearer the mark
- 134.343 +/- 4 km3
Towards ‘encoding archaeology’
• Parallel between referencing points on the earth’s surface and referencing points in time
• Relative and absolute
• Development of reasoning models to manage space and time
M. Doerr et al 2004, fig 1.
The CIDOC-CRM
www.ahessc.ac.uk/briefing_paper
M. Doerr et al 2004, fig 2.
Towards ‘encoding archaeology: ‘meetings’
“The concept of “meetings is extraordinarily powerful: Chronology concerns and involves events … “Dating” an object actually means approximating the coherence volume of some event(s) in which the object was present.”
-Supporting Chronological Reasoning in Archaeology, Doerr et al 2004
Towards ‘encoding archaeology: ‘meetings’
• A. Deposition of a tephra deposit
• B. Production of a LMIA cup in Crete - predates A, but with smaller ‘coherence volume’.
• D. C14-datable fire destruction
“The concept of “meetings is extraordinarily powerful: Chronology concerns and involves events … “Dating” an object actually means approximating the coherence volume of some event(s) in which the object was present.”
- Doerr et al 2004
M. Doerr et al 2004, fig 2.
• C. Deposition of cup
A future project: Agent-based modelling
A future project: Agent-based modelling
After Giuseppe Trautteur and Raniero Virgilio
To Conclude…