Gallagher, Chirieleison, Mehlman & Censer (2009)

Methods and resources Part I

Open-access desktop librariesAutomated knowledge mapping and graphing

May 6, 2009

Orlando, FL

Gallagher CA, Chirieleison J, Mehlman, K &

Censer, J

Gallagher, Chirieleison, Mehlman & Censer (2009)

Automated functions

Open-access

Support systematic reviews

Easily updated

Goals

Gallagher, Chirieleison, Mehlman & Censer (2009)

Relative risk compared to general adolescent population

0102030405060

Total

Males

Females

From Gallagher et al, 2007

Goal: Automate prevalence, RTC, diagnostic tool, etc.

Gallagher, Chirieleison, Mehlman & Censer (2009)

Relative risk compared to general adolescent population

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

From Gallagher et al, 2007

Goal: Automate prevalence, RTC, diagnostic tool, etc.

Gallagher, Chirieleison, Mehlman & Censer (2009)

Percent testing positive for Hepatitis C

1.8

2.52.3

1.1

2.0

0.3

3.7

0.0002 0.00020.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

4.0

Males Females Males Females Both Males Females Males Female

Bair, 2005(n=722)

Bair, 2005(n=280)

Feldman,2004

(n=622)

Feldman,2004

(n=89)

Murray,2003

(n=305)

Thomas,2005

(n=1,111)

Thomas,2005

(n=217)

Hepatitissurveillance

2004

Hepatitissurveillance

2004

Detention Detention Detention Detention Long-termsecure

Detention Detention Generaladolescent

Generaladolescent

From Gallagher et al, 2007

Goal: Automate prevalence, RTC, diagnostic tool, etc.

Gallagher, Chirieleison, Mehlman & Censer (2009)

1. Exhaustive search by specific condition

2. Storage and tagged coding in Zotero

3. Code:• Publication type• Study type• Population• Setting• Region• Country• State/Province/etc

4. Mapping and graphingExport

Export

5. Tie programming to website

Gallagher, Chirieleison, Mehlman & Censer (2009)

See handout

Physical health (Monica Rengifo-Pardo, MD)

Mental health (Gail Wasserman, PhD)

Substance abuse (Nena Messina, PhD)

Major group

Sub-group

Specific condition

Gallagher, Chirieleison, Mehlman & Censer (2009)

Type of study

Primary research areasPrevalence

Relative risks

Costs

Measurement

Interventions

Service provision

disparities

meeting standards

systems modeling

Gallagher, Chirieleison, Mehlman & Censer (2009)

1. Exhaustive search by specific condition

2. Storage and tagged coding in Zotero

3. Code:• Publication type• Study type• Population characteristics• Setting• Region• Country• State/Province/etc

4. Mapping and graphingExport

Export

5. Tie programming to website

Citation: Gallagher CA, Mehlman K, Chirieleison J, Censer J (2009). Automating knowledge production. The Lloyd Society

Gallagher, Chirieleison, Mehlman & Censer (2009)

Gallagher, Chirieleison, Mehlman & Censer (2009)

1. Exhaustive search by specific condition

2. Storage and tagged coding in Zotero

3. Code:• Publication type• Study type• Population• Setting• Region• Country• State/Province/etc

4. Mapping and graphingExport

Export

5. Tie programming to website

Citation: Gallagher CA, Mehlman K, Chirieleison J, Censer J (2009). Automating knowledge production. The Lloyd Society

Gallagher, Chirieleison, Mehlman & Censer (2009)

Gallagher, Chirieleison, Mehlman & Censer (2009)

1. Exhaustive search by specific condition

2. Storage and tagged coding in Zotero

3. Code:• Publication type• Study type• Population• Setting• Region• Country• State/Province/etc

4. Mapping and graphingExport

Export

5. Tie programming to website

Citation: Gallagher CA, Mehlman K, Chirieleison J, Censer J (2009). Automating knowledge production. The Lloyd Society

Gallagher, Chirieleison, Mehlman & Censer (2009)

Products

Available on-line, real-time at:

http://njh.thelloydsociety.org/509_mappingExamples.php

MapsCharts Full bibliographies (and working desktop libraries)

by type of study, condition, population, region and composition of sample

Gallagher, Chirieleison, Mehlman & Censer (2009)

Open access products:

• Real-time knowledge maps and graphs

• Downloadable, pre-configured desktop libraries (Zotero)

Gallagher, Chirieleison, Mehlman & Censer (2009)

Coding for systematic reviews

• Study quality

• Effect sizes