memorandum · 2014. 1. 2. · make-a-wish is the nation’s largest wish-granting organization....
TRANSCRIPT
MEMORANDUM
To: David Williams, President of Make-A-Wish
From: Sarah Marquart
Date: May 9, 2013
Subject: Make-A-Wish Formal Report for Your Review
The following is a formal report regarding our proposal for reducing the cost of a wish in order
to benefit more children and, as a result, reject fewer applications. In this report you will find
information regarding the feasibility of making this project a reality within the next year.
Most of the information compiled in this report was researched thoroughly by members of the
Make-A-Wish team through the company website, collaboration with Delta Airlines, pediatric
websites, and a professional SWOT analysis of our company. The report’s main focus is the
process of reducing the cost of a wish by acquiring more airline mile donations in order to help
more children through wishes or through financial assistance.
Make-A-Wish’s image can be improved with the implementation of this project. Eighteen
percent of children who apply to our organization are rejected. Often, this leads to bad press.
With just a few fiscal adjustments, this will not be an issue. In addition, our goal of helping
children will endure. We are sure that you have concerns about the fiscal implications of this
proposal. The main points of the report touch on what we imagine are many of your concerns:
Discussion of how donations will be managed
The process of acquiring airline mile donations
The feasibility of this plan based on up-to-date analysis of our funds
The timeline for the project
The staffing implications of our proposal
Many companies have shown interest in our proposal. In total, the plan would only cost our
company five hundred extra dollars per year when it is first implemented. This could be done
in the span of one year with minimal staff adjustments. Our final recommendations about the
project can be located on page thirteen.
We would like to thank you taking the time to read and consider our proposal to improve the
quality of life for all children with life-threatening medical conditions. We look forward to your
feedback on this ongoing project.
Page | 2
Make-a-Wish Sarah Marquart
May 14, 2013
Page | 3
Abstract
Make-A-Wish is the nation’s largest wish-granting organization. Since 1980, the Make-A-Wish
Foundation has given hope, strength, and joy to children with life-threatening medical
conditions. Beginning with one boy’s wish in 1980 to become a police officer, we have
continued to enrich the lives of children by working with families, doctors, donors, sponsors, and
entire communities. Today, we have evolved into an organization that grants a child’s wish in the
United States every forty minutes.
Make-A-Wish is very successful at our contribution to society; changing the lives of children
with life-threatening medical conditions changes communities. However, there is always room
for improvement. We would convince higher management to allow us to make our company
even better. When more and more children began to apply to the foundation as it grew in
popularity, that meant that more children were being rejected. This did not fit with our mission or
our goals. Therefore, we looked to change.
Change began with an idea: We would start off by reducing the cost of the wishes. Having less
money going toward each wish would allow more children to be helped and less being fully
denied. We also created a way to have more fulfilling wishes, just at lower costs. Travel costs
and lodging the families seem to be a huge part of the wish expense. There are many other ways
to fulfill our duties of making sure all costs are being taken care of.
These types of adjustments have great benefits toward the Make-A-Wish company. There are
more incentives toward our sponsors as well so we are not the only ones reaping the benefits.
Our financial analyst has created a cost and timeframe for all of these modifications. Another
huge part that we would like to add to our program is for the children who do not get their wish
fulfilled. They will get some sort of financial aid toward medical bills or to give the child some
sort of “wish.” This will enhance our mission statement of “enchrich[ing] the human experience”
by allowing us to help every child that comes to us. Their happiness is our goal and we plan to
continue and better our company for that reason.
Page | 4
Table of Contents
Abstract…………..…..3
List of Figures……..…5
List of Tables………...6
Executive Summary….7
Introduction Text……..8
Conclusion……….…12
Recommendations..…13
Works Cited………...14
Bibliography……..…15
Appendixes…………16
Page | 5
List of Figures
Figure 1. Expenses Before Miles Donated
Figure 2. Expenses After Miles Donated
Lodging 38%
Airfare 36%
Rental Car 16%
Miscellaneous 10%
Expenses Before Miles Donated
Lodging 54%
Airfare 29%
Rental Car 9%
Miscellaneous 8%
Expenses After Miles Donated
Page | 6
List of Tables
Table 1. Criteria for Receiving a Wish
Is the child
between the
ages of 2 ½ and
18 at the time of
referral?
Does the child
have a life
threatening
medical
condition?
Has the child’s
physician
determined that
the child is
medically
eligible?
Has the child
received a wish
from another
wish-granting
organization?
Eligible?
Yes Yes Yes No Yes
No No No Yes No
Page | 7
Executive Summary Make-A-Wish is the nation’s largest wish-granting organization. Since 1980, the Make-A-Wish
Foundation has given hope, strength and joy to children with life-threatening medical conditions.
Beginning with one boy’s wish in 1980 to become a police officer, we have continued to enrich
the lives of children by working with families, doctors, donors, sponsors, and entire
communities. Today, we have evolved into an organization that grants a child’s wish in the U.S.
every forty minutes.
This report examines the feasibility of lowering the average wish cost granted to a child through
the Make-A-Wish foundation from $7,500 to $7,000 or $6,900. This lower wish cost would
provide children whose application are rejected with a small amount of money to help pay for
their hospital bills or other expenses. The purpose of this report is to provide Make-A-Wish
affiliates with the information necessary for assessing the effectiveness of implementing this
plan.
Children within our budget who meet the criteria for a wish—those with life-threatening medical
illnesses between the ages of 2 and 18—are not the only ones who need our help. Each year
(inset number) of children are rejected from Make-A-Wish simply due to the fact that we do not
have enough donates to assist them.
Donations to these children would be monitored through traceable pre-paid VISA cards in order
to be certain that the funds are being spent properly.
Wish cost can be reduced if the cost of airfare, lodging, and rental cars are all virtually
eliminated. This can be done through partnership with large companies who rely on employee
travel year round. Companies will be encouraged to donate their frequent flyer miles on a large
scale as opposed to our current system. These miles could be used to purchase airline tickets, rent
cars, or secure lodging for families rather than the company paying with direct monetary
donations.
The effectiveness of implementing this proposal on a monetary basis is evidenced by the fact that
it would only cost our company $500 to send extra mailers to 10,000 of these large companies. It
is also evidenced by a poll of companies through our website that stated that over 87% would be
willing to be a part of this program. An incentive would even be offered to companies in the
form of discounts through other companies that partner with Make-A-Wish.
Based on these conclusions, recommendations for this project are (1) spend less than $400 to
send mailers out to these companies are supported in order to (2) cut down the cost of wishes so
that we can assist more children. In addition, this is recommended in order to improve our
company’s image; turning away children is not what we stand for.
Page | 8
Introduction Text
This report proposes lowering the average wish cost
granted to a child through the Make-A-Wish
foundation from $7,500 to $7,000 or $6,900 in order to
be able to assist more children and lower our rate of
application rejection. The funds subtracted from the
wish would be allocated to children whose applications
are rejected, but still meet our criteria. These funds
could be used to help pay medical expenses, or give
the child a mini-wish. What is Make-A-Wish?
Make-A-Wish’s mission statement is “We grant
wishes of children with life threatening medical
conditions to enrich the human experience with
hope, strength, and joy.” Make-A-Wish is a nonprofit
organization. We grant wishes of children between the
ages of 2-18 who have life threatening diseases. Our
charity organization all began in 1980 when the wish
of Chris Grecius was granted to become a police
officer. Ever since then we have over 25,000
volunteers along with reaching out to 250,000 children
each year. Our volunteers serve as granters, special
events assistants, and fundraisers. The Make-A-Wish
Foundation reflects the life-changing impact we make
on children, families, referral sources, donors, sponsors
and entire communities. These children are the past,
present and future of Make-A-Wish to share same
experience from the power of the wish.
Our Strengths as a Company
We have proudly granted over 10,000 wishes during
our 25 year history. In addition, our financial
statements are available for anyone to read on our
website (note sidebar). As a company, we offer
multiple ways to give back to our company including:
donate cash, donate goods or services, donate stock,
donate your time, etc. Our Foundation is supported
Financial Success 2012
(All percentages are percent of total
expense/revenue)
National Office
Functional Expenses:
Program Services 79%
Fundraising 12%
Management & General 9%
Sources of Revenue:
Individual Contributions: 59%
Corporate Alliances: 31%
Other Income and Revenue: 10%
Combined National and Office Chapters
Functional Expenses:
Program Services 75%
Fundraising 15%
Management & General 10%
Sources of Revenue:
Contributions 81%
Special Events 14%
Other Income & Revenue 5%
Page | 9
through local donations from individuals, corporations, small businesses, civic organizations,
churches, schools, social and service clubs, fund-raising events, memorial contributions,
foundations, and pay-roll deduction programs as well as our own special events.
Weaknesses We Plan to Overcome
It is difficult to manage the huge team of volunteers. This requires proper delegation of duties
and very clear expectations. It is also difficult to grant each wish at our typical cost due to the
rising costs of airfare and lodging. Because we raise funds through donations, we rely on the
generosity of others. In hard economic times, this can be challenging.
Opportunities for Make-A-Wish
Our foundation has the opportunity to grow. With the help of more donations, our reach, offices,
and assistance would increase. Individuals continue to give including celebrities, companies who
offer their goods and services, etc. We have the opportunity to help their reputation and image.
Threats We Are Aware Of
Fraud is our biggest issue. Spam e-mails and letters often appear in inboxes and on door steps.
Unfortunately, we cannot control this. However, we fight it as well as we can by telling
recipients how to deal with fraud on our website. Another threat we face is parents who are
unhappy that their child has been rejected by our organization for some reason. We try to speak
with each parent individually in order to make sure they are satisfied with our answer.
Proposal for Lowering Wish Cost
Our company is well-received by the public. However children within our budget who meet the
criteria for a wish (note table)—those with life-threatening medical illnesses between the ages of
2 and 18—are not the only ones who need help. Each year 18% of children are rejected (see
sidebar on page 10) because we do not have the funds. In order to uphold the image of Make-A-
Wish as a company who makes dreams come true, we propose reducing the cost of a wish.
Table 1. Criteria for Receiving a Wish
Is the child
between the
ages of 2 ½ and
18 at the time
of referral?
Does the child
have a life
threatening
medical
condition?
Has the child’s
physician
determined
that the child is
medically
eligible?
Has the child
received a wish
from another
wish-granting
organization?
Eligible?
Yes Yes Yes No Yes
No No No Yes No
Page | 10
How Will Donations Be Managed?
If we reduce the cost of wishes, donations can be made to
children whose applications have been rejected. The donations
would be sent to the families in the form of a prepaid VISA
card. It is important to be sure that these cards are used
ethically and for either medical expenses or something that the
child desires. Therefore, we will make the family aware that the
purchases on the card are traceable. Through an online banking
system, our staff would be able to track purchases made to be
sure that the card is being spent correctly.
How Will Cost Be Reduced?
It is possible to reduce the cost of a wish in terms of airfare,
lodging, and rental cars. Reducing these costs is possible
through partnerships with large companies who rely on
employee travel year round. Companies will be encouraged to
donate large amounts of their frequent flyer miles. Though we
have a current system in place where miles can be donated, it is
done on a small scale. These donated miles could be used to
purchase airline tickets, rent cars, or secure lodging for families
rather than Make-A-Wish paying with direct monetary
donations.
Airline Mile Donations
Delta Airlines has created a way to directly donate any unused
or unwanted air mileage to Make-A-Wish. There is a 1,000
miles minimum to donate to the Make-A-Wish Foundation.
Donating these miles is not tax deductible though Delta
Airlines however. Once the transaction has been completed, it
cannot be reversed. These miles will be put to good use so
there is no threat against fraud. Frequent flyers can help make a
child’s wish come true by donating their unused flyer miles to
financially help the wish. A chart below will show the
advantages donated miles can make to financially helping the
wish come true.
How Many
Children are
Being Ignored?
Children Ignored
Because of Medical
Conditions
The definition of the
seriousness the disease is
not up to our national
organization to
determine. Some
organizations require a
doctor’s statement of
“terminal” rather than
just “life threatening.”
This is typically a non-
issue. If one location is
not willing to accept a
child another
organization may be.
However, the physician’s
word holds the power.
Children Ignored
Because of Funding
18% of children who
apply to the Make-A-
Wish foundation are not
able to be assisted
because our foundation
does not have the ability
to fund their wish to the
standard of the wishes of
other children we have
assisted.
Page | 11
Figure 1. Expenses Before Miles Donated
Figure 2. Expenses After Miles Donated
As shown in the above figures, there is valid proof that donating flyer miles can greatly increase
child’s financial aid towards their wish. The Delta Airlines have agreed to meet with us to come
up with a contract to have any unused flyer miles donated to Make-A-Wish. They will contact
the owners of the miles and inform them of their unused miles and unless they are used within
that next month, they will be donated.
Do We Have the Funds?
Let’s take a look:
Combined National and International Revenues: $251,491,089
After subtracting our expenses: $173,591,443
This plan would raise the amount of funds allocated to public information a mere $500 in order
to send out 10,000 letters to companies, This $500 dollar increase is well within our means and
budget considering our end of the year net assets.
Lodging 38%
Airfare 36%
Rental Car 16%
Misc. 10%
Expenses Before Miles Donated
Lodging 54% Airfare
29%
Rental Car 9%
Misc. 8%
Expenses After Miles Donated
Page | 12
Conclusion
The effectiveness of implementing this proposal on a monetary basis is evidenced by the fact that
it would only cost our company $500 to send extra mailers to 10,000 of these large companies. It
is also evidenced by a poll of companies through our website that stated that over 87% would be
willing to be a part of this program. An incentive would even be offered to companies in the
form of discounts through other companies that partner with Make-A-Wish.
Companies
The companies that we would target include:
GA Braun
Tyson
Ford
GM
GE
Johnson and Johnson
Other companies that we would target are ones that we already have relationships with. These
participating companies have already showed interest in our program when polled. Ninety-eight
percent of companies that we already work with are willing to participate. As stated earlier, 87%
of new companies polled would be willing to try the program.
Timeline
If approved, the mailers will be sent out with our typical donation requests at the end of the year
in November. Companies will have until January to respond. Sending out these letters at the end
of the month would mean that companies are being targeted when they have the most unused
miles. By February, we should begin to receive the extra miles. We will begin the program on a
small scale at that point and branch out over the year.
Staffing Implications
Staff will be responsible for stuffing more envelopes which might require new hires or longer
hours. The new company relationships will be managed through the management department.
Finance will manage the new mileage figures and decide how they will be allocated. These
changes should not require new hires at first. However, as we proceed with the program, we will
make changes as necessary.
Page | 13
Recommendations
Based on these conclusions, recommendations for this project are (1) spend less than $400 to
send mailers out to these companies are supported in order to (2) cut down the cost of wishes so
that we can assist more children. In addition, this is recommended in order to improve our
company’s image; turning away children is not what we stand for.
Step By Step Breakdown
1. Discuss design for mailers with design team
2. Send design to printers and print mailers
3. Using a list of companies to target created by our PR department, mail out letters
4. Receive feedback from companies within two months
5. Create a running total of airline miles we accumulate
6. Use airline miles efficiently on any trips that take a child out-of-state
7. When an application that is received would typically be rejected, have the PR department
contact the family explaining that we can assist them in a smaller way.
8. If the family chooses financial assistance, send them a prepaid VISA card. Members of the
Finance department will be responsible for making sure funds are spent appropriately.
9. If the family chooses a mini-wish for the child, we will contact the local chapter of Make-A-
Wish and discuss how to make that child’s wish come true on a small scale.
Page | 14
Works Cited No Author. (April 13, 2011) About the Make-A-Wish and List of Wish Organizations. Ped-Onc
Resource Center. April 17, 2013. http://www.ped-onc.org/cfissues/maw.html
No Author. (n.d.) Donate Miles. Delta Airlines. April 17, 2013.
http://www.delta.com/buygftxfer/displayDonateMiles.action
No Author. (n.d.) Make-A-Wish. Make-A-Wish Foundation. April 17, 2013. http://wish.org/
Zachary Hanson. (n.d.) SWOT Analysis. Mogg Osborne PTY LTD. April 12, 2013.
http://www.moggosborne.com.au/files/docs/cpa%20project%20final%20design.pdf
Page | 15
Bibliography Ped-Onc Resource Center, http://www.ped-onc.org/cfissues/maw.html
o Social and community impact of Make-A-Wish
Delta Airlines, http://www.delta.com/buygftxfer/displayDonateMiles.action
o Airline miles information
Make-A-Wish Foundation, http://wish.org/
o Finance reports
o General Information about company
Field Period Knowledge
o Price of mailers
SWOT analysis,
http://www.moggosborne.com.au/files/docs/cpa%20project%20final%20design.p
df
o Information on successes, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats