media - documentary evaluation

30

Upload: annabeagley

Post on 23-Jun-2015

172 views

Category:

Education


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Media - Documentary Evaluation
Page 2: Media - Documentary Evaluation

In what ways does your media product use, develop or challenge forms and conventions of real media products?

Given the topic of documentary came across as a challenge, however once we began researching, planning, practicing and actually making the product we got more familiar with what a documentary is and how we could make a

successful one ourselves. We researched many existing documentaries involving certain issues and celebrities and we also did a lot of research on

Louis Theroux, Michael Moore and Nick Broomfield – existing and very famous documentary makers.

Page 3: Media - Documentary Evaluation

Inspiration Early on we decided to do an expository type of documentary, Michael

Moore is famous for his expository documentaries and after researching him we were set on using his style.

We wanted to expose but compare something and all we needed to do now is choose a certain topic to perform a documentary on so this lead

to many discussions and mind maps.

Page 4: Media - Documentary Evaluation

Planning

After writing down a number of possibilities using a mind map we narrowed it down to a few topics

including:

-Education- Fast food- Medical

- Antisocial behaviour

We decided on Education as our topic of interest because there is a variety of topics branching from that

such as: exams, behaviour, uniform, areas, bullying, racism, subjects, teaching and the quality or learning.

Page 5: Media - Documentary Evaluation

Developing After deciding an idea I created a Slide share to document our decisions and plan for the

documentary

Page 6: Media - Documentary Evaluation

LocationsR

eeds

Heathside

Private school located in Cobham, we filmed

interviews with students and teachers and also

looked at the outstanding facilities.

Public school located in Weybridge (we are

students here), we filmed the journey, teachers,

students and the facilities and compared them to

Reeds.

Page 7: Media - Documentary Evaluation

Filming

Firstly we filmed around Heathside getting all the footage we needed. Once we had done this we knew what to film for

Reeds meaning we could compare and use the same shots and techniques. The most important thing for us was the

interviews because they explain a lot and are very opinionated, it exposes student and teacher thoughts matching our expository documentary form. We used the Sony video

cameras supplied to us by the Media department at Heathside.

Page 8: Media - Documentary Evaluation

FilmingIn this section we filmed meg discussing the exam percentages

between Reeds and Heathside school, as she walks and announces the results the computers to the right hand side of the screen flash on to show the result percentages. It took us a while to plan and a number

of takes to get it right, but now it works it looks successful.

Page 9: Media - Documentary Evaluation

Interviews

One Shot – Mr Haining (sports and conditioning coach at reeds school) He explains what his job is and his

opinion of private school education.

Two Shot – Mrs Cooper (our current media teacher) used to

teach at a private school so discusses her personal view.

One Shot- Student at Heathside school giving his opinions of being

at a state school. We also interviewed students at Reeds.

Page 10: Media - Documentary Evaluation

Archive Footage

We were incredibly lucky to find archive footage quite late on during the project. Not only does it completely comprehend our documentary as a whole it also involves Barack Obama the president of the United States which is an extremely powerful opinion and makes our documentary much stronger. We

have put this footage as the opening section for our documentary as it immediately gains interest as people recognise this face.

Page 11: Media - Documentary Evaluation

EditingWe used the program iMovie to edit all of our

footage. Due to last years use of the program the whole group already knew the ins and outs of what

it does and how to use it to our advantage.

We put all of the footage on each time we did a bit of

filming and cut the unnecessary bits out, we

then put all of this in order and began adding things in such as: archive footage, voice over’s, music and

transitions.

Transitions. We used ‘Cross

Dissolve’ and ‘Cross Blur’ these two merge

clips together in a smooth way

to create fluidity in the documentar

y.

Voice Over’s. we wrote mini scripts that meg then recorded of herself

speaking, this went straight onto the clip.

Music. We decided

to add music that had no

lyrics because it

would most likely be

irrelevant to our topic so

we kept it simple but upbeat to

keep it interesting.

Page 12: Media - Documentary Evaluation

Shots and Camera Angles

The most used camera angles and shots we used were point of view, framing, two shot, one shot, long shot and wide angle.

Page 13: Media - Documentary Evaluation

How effective is the combination of your main product and ancillary texts?

I feel that both of the ancillary tasks combine extremely well with the main task. The poster is

simple yet eye catching and contains all relevant information to advertise the actual documentary

and the magazine spread is all about the documentary itself containing an image, bold and relevant title, interview and information about the

actual documentary.

Page 14: Media - Documentary Evaluation

Individual Ancillary Research

I thought I would research and plan what I was going to do before I began creating a double page magazine spread. This benefitted me and gave me

knowledge and understanding of what makes a successful magazine article.

Page 15: Media - Documentary Evaluation

Double Page Magazine SpreadI am really happy with my final outcome of the magazine double page spread, I have used typical conventions but made it different to most other existing magazine articles. I have

included all of the main things and the layout works well containing a bold title and channel 4 logo.

Page 16: Media - Documentary Evaluation

Group Ancillary Newspaper Advert/PosterWe weren’t sure whether to do a poster or a newspaper advert so

we therefore made a multi functional piece that can work both

ways. I searched for different images and came across this one

and decided to use it as the background. The group decided

the title and where to put the channel 4 logo. I knew we needed a quote somewhere and it would have looked out of place if I had but it at the top or bottom so I made it fit in the centre of the apple, this is going to draw

peoples attention to the quote which will then inspire them to

watch it. I think the title structure is clever and the photo and wording

is completely relevant to the documentary.

Page 17: Media - Documentary Evaluation

Target Audience

We couldn’t pin point a certain age group because our

documentary is not only aimed at all age groups it will also be interesting to the ages of 13 –

80 years old. Students, Teachers, Parents and

Grandparents will all be able to watch, enjoy and relate to our documentary and it may help

many people make the decision of whether to spend loads of

money on a private education. The documentary covers both public and private schools and

looks inside at facilities and results

Page 18: Media - Documentary Evaluation

Media Students Feedback

We allowed our classmates to watch our documentary and asked them for feedback, we also returned the

favour. We filmed their views so we could keep them and refer back to it when necessary. They said they liked the topic as it hasn’t been done before in this style and they

thought it was relevant and interesting to recent and local society. They did however comment on the target

audience being aimed more at adults including teachers and parents but this didn’t matter too much to us.

Page 19: Media - Documentary Evaluation

What I Have Learnt From the Feedback

I think getting feedback was very important, it let us know what we were doing wrong and it boosted our confidence

when we got complimented. It taught us how to take constructive criticism and without regular feedback from

Mrs Cooper we would have been stuck.

Page 20: Media - Documentary Evaluation

How did you use media technologies in the construction and research, planning and evaluation

stages?We used a variety of technologies from equipment like tripods to search engines such as Google. Without using these technologies we would not have been able to create a documentary. We used the internet to do our

research and blogging and we used Microsoft office programmes for example: Microsoft Word to display the information and create the ancillary tasks. The more frequently I used these technologies the more I picked up on how to use them to my advantage. This will benefit me in the future and hopefully it means our group used technologies well to create a successful

documentary with two side tasks.

Page 21: Media - Documentary Evaluation

Computer Programs

Page 22: Media - Documentary Evaluation

Equipment

Page 23: Media - Documentary Evaluation

General Opinion on the Finished Documentary

The fact that we have only been given a tiny audience to get feedback off is to our disadvantage, but in general people have

commented on the clever topic choice and originality of the idea. Some of the filming is unsteady which has resulted from needing

footage to fill in the gaps and the relevant footage had to go in these gaps otherwise it wouldn’t flow. People have also said they like the way we ended it with ‘End of part 1’ because it makes them know

there is more to come. We covered a wide area of the documentary in a speedy 5 minute boundary however we did push it over by a few seconds, this doesn’t matter too much to us but people did pick up

on it. One of the interviews is a bit too long but it has so much relevant information it would be a shame to cut it out, it would also ruin the flow of the documentary so unless we went back to Reeds and re-interviewed Mr Haining this would not have been possible.

Page 24: Media - Documentary Evaluation

Personal OpinionAlthough my opinion could be biased I do think the documentary has worked out

really well. The footage is average but the editing made it all go together nicely and made it much more interesting. The part with the exam results flashing on the

computer screen looks good and the timing was very accurate. I also think the archive footage is a very strong part of the opening and the fact that Barack

Obama is in the documentary without any intention is even better. I think some of the filming could have been a lot steadier and in a few clips people tend to

stumble on their words but recover quickly, it wasn’t acted out and the answers we got built up a really good argument that would be concluded if the

documentary was longer. Another section I think works well is the car journey up the lane to Heathside school, it is fast and to the point and although it isn’t steady

it is still effective, especially with the music over the top.

Page 25: Media - Documentary Evaluation

What Went Well

Page 26: Media - Documentary Evaluation

Ways we Could Improve

Page 27: Media - Documentary Evaluation

Group Rolls Meg, Nick & Adam

We decided as a group to all take part in every activity but throughout the project our roles became more clear due to what

we were best at. I put a lot of ideas and research into the documentary and also did a lot of filming and editing for the final piece, Meg found herself interviewing and doing voice

over's while Nick edited footage as we went along and Adam did a lot of filming. We worked well as a group and all put in an

equal amount of effort at the end.

Page 28: Media - Documentary Evaluation

Time Keeping and Organisation

To begin with our organisation wasn’t too great but we got together as a group and made a plan for the term. Once we had all of our ideas and it was time to start filming we began to gain

organisation skills and stayed on task. We could have performed better if we had better organisation throughout the

whole project from start to finish but this was a mistake we have learnt from and would definitely make sure we had better time

keeping skills if we were given the chance to do this again.

Page 29: Media - Documentary Evaluation

Personal Input and Skill DevelopmentOverall throughout the second year of Media A-Level I have developed a number of skills, some being basic and others

being more complex.• I have learnt how to use a video camera and upload footage

onto the computer.• I have also got more and more familiar with the Apple Mac

computers and the iMovie program that we use to edit all of our footage

• I have learnt about conventions and camera shots/angles• Blogging has become easier and more skilful

• Working as a team has allowed me to develop teamwork and communication skills

• I know how to research, plan, film, edit and produce succesful media products

• Lastly I have developed an understanding of creating magazine articles and advertising schemes to collaborate with

the media product.

Page 30: Media - Documentary Evaluation

Blog

http://annadocumentary.blogspot.co.uk/

Keeping a blog was important for this project as it documented every step in an organised and public way meaning people can look and give me feedback. When I

get page views I know people have been looking and it would also be a great way of getting useful feedback from people across the country that don’t know me. Here is

the link to my blog…