=

OVN4=

SWrucWural Analysis of HisWorical ConsWrucWions – Jerzy Jasieńko (ed) © 2012 DPNH ProcławH PolandH ISSN 0860-2395H ISBN 978-83-7125-216-7

mbocloMANCb-BApba AmmolACe Tl bAoTenrAhb molTbCTflN lc MAplNov CriTroAi ebofTAdb perena CattariNI pergio iagomarsinoO ABpToACT =tithin= the= framework= of= merformance= Based= Assessment= EmBAFI= the= éaéer= focuses= on= the=imélementation= to= the= case= of= ancient= masonry= constructionsK= ActuallyI= the= comélexity= and= wide=variety=of=historical=masonry=buildings= Esuch=as=churchesI= éalacesI= towersI=columnsI= etcKF= require=the=adoétion=of=different=modelling=strategiesI= through=a=versatile=érocedureK=tithin=this=contextI=one=of=the=main=issues=is=the=definition=of=éerformance=levels=on=the=caéacity=curveI=érovided=by=the=nonlinear=éushover= analysisK= cirstlyI= éerformance= objectives= have= to= be= defined= also= considering= cultural=relevance= conceétsW= thusI= the=éreservation= of= the= cultural=heritage=asset= and= the= safety= of= the=éeoéle=using =it =should =be =considered =in =an =integrated =aééroachK =qo =this =aimI =in =the =éaéerI =a =multicriteria =aééroach=to=define=damage=levels=is=éroéosed=by=consideringW=aF=the=damage=at=the=scale=of=structural=element= Elocal damageFI= bF= the= mechanisms= in= architectonic= elements= EmacroelementFI= cF= the=global=behaviour=of=the=building=Ereéresented=by=its=pushover curveFK=qhenI=éroéer=criteria=are=established=to=correlate=damage=at=the=three=scales=and=define=éerformance=levels=on=the=caéacity=curveK= heywordsW peismic performance-based assessmentI Cultural heritageI jasonry buildings NK fNTolarCTflN =kumerous= countries= at= international= level= nowadays= share= the= need= of= éreservation= of= historical=constructionsK=eoweverI=the=great=variability=and=the=comélexity=of=masonry=historical=buildings=make=difficult=to=éroéose=wellJestablished=aééroachesI=as=the=ones=that=are=adoéted=in=codes=for=the=case=of=new=buildingsK==fn= the=éaéerI= the=attention= is= focused=on= the=use= of= the= disélacement= aééroach= for= the=merformance=Based =Assessment =EmBAFI =which =all =recent =research =efforts =and =some =codes =refer =toK =ft =seems =even =more=suitable= in=case=of= masonry=buildingsI= strongly= affected=by= the= nonlinear= behaviour= from= first=éhases=of=reséonseK=mBA=requiresI=on=the=one=handI=reliable=models=to=evaluate=the=seismic=reséonse=in=nonlinear= range=Ethrough=both=static=and=dynamic=methods=of=analysisF=andI= on=the=other=oneI=éroéer=verification=éroceduresK=tithin=the=context=of=nonlinear=static=analysesI=mBA=requires=the=definition=of=éerformance= levels= Elimit= statesF= on= the=caéacity= curve= obtained=by= the=éushover= analysisI= which= is=aimed= to= érovide= essential= information= on= the= actual= behaviour= in= terms= of= stiffness= Eequivalent=éeriodFI=strength=Etotal=base=shearF=and=ultimate=disélacement=caéacityK==cirst=of=allI=éerformance=objectives= have=to=be=linked= also=to=cultural=relevance=conceétsW=this= means=that= the=safety=éeoéle=and= the=éreservation=of= the=cultural=heritage=asset= should=be=considered= in= an=integrated= aééroachK= qhenI= a= suitable= and= versatile= érocedureI= able= to= envisage= the= wide= variety= of=heritage= constructionsI= has= to= be= introduced= to= define= éerformance= levels= on= caéacity= curveK= fn=éarticularI=in=the=éaéer=a=multi=criteria=érocedure=is=éroéosedI=aimed=to=take=into=account=the=reséonse=of= the= elements= that= add= uéI= at= the= different= scalesI= to= the= whole= reséonse= of= the= assetW= structural=elements= Elocal damageFI= architectonic= elements= EmacroelementsF= and= global= behaviour= Epushover curveFK=aifferent=aééroaches=are=usedI=based=on=heuristic=criteria=or=on=checks=of=the=éerformance=of=elements=and=macroelementsI=in=order=to=avoid=the=occurrence=of=local=“too=heavy”=damageK=================================================N=Assistant=mrofessorI=rniversity=of=denoaI=ftalyI=serenaKcattari]unigeKit=O=cull=mrofessorI=rniversity=of=denoaI=ftalyI=sergioKlagomarsino]unigeKit=

=

OVNR=

OK abcfNfTflN lc mbocloMANCb ibsbip clo CriTroAi ebofTAdb =merformance=Based=Assessment=EmBAF=usually=considers=a=set=of=oehabilitation lbjectivesI=related=to=the=fulfilment=of=séecific=merformance ievelsEmiF=in=the=occasion=of=given=barthquake=eazard=ievels=Edefined=by=the=annual=érobability=of=exceedance=or=the=return=éeriod=qoFK==crom= a= conceétual= éoint= of= viewI= in= case= of= ordinary buildingsI= éerformance= levels= are= usually=associated= to=consequences= like=costs=of= reéairI= safety=of=éeoéleI=usability= Ebuilding=fit= to=be=usedF=and= oéerational= requirementsK= fn= case= of= cultural heritage assetsI =mis =have =to =be =linked =also =to =cultural= relevance= conceétsW= thusI= the= conservation= of= the= cultural= heritage= asset= and= the= safety= of=éeoéle= should= be= considered= in= an= integrated= aééroachK= joreoverI= it= is= necessary= to= take= into=account=the=éresence=of=artistic=assets=as=wellK=qhusI= in=case=of=cultural=heritageI=within=the=context=of =mBA =it =seems =more =accurate =referring =to =pafety and Conservation lbjectives= than =simély =to =oehabilitation lbjectivesK= According= to= thisI= in= mbombqrAqb= érojectI= the= following= aséects=EtargetsF=have=been=considered=to=define=misW=

– rse and human lifeW= as= well= as= for= other= tyées= of= buildingI= the= éossibility= of= an= immediate=occuéancy=after=an=earthquake=and=the=éreservation=of=human=life=may=be=iméortant=for=a=cultural=heritage=asset;=

– Building conservationW= the= éreservation= from= building= damage= is= not= relatedI= as= for= ordinary=buildingsI= to= the= costs= of= reéair= or= rebuilding= but= to= the= éossibility= of= restorationI= due= to= the=intangible=value=of=a=cultural=heritage=asset;==

– Artistic assets conservationW=in=many=casesI=irreéarable=damage=to=artistic=assets=occurs=also=in=the=case= of= moderate= damage= to= structural= elements;= thus= it= is= necessary= to= define= séecific=éerformance=levelsK==

cor= each= one= of= the= above= aséectsI= different= éerformance= levels= may= be= associated= to= increasing=exéected=hazard=levels;=for=examéleI=in=case=of=Building conservation=targetsI=they=are=differentiated=in=ko aamageI aamage iimitationI pignificant but restorable damageI kear collapse=Efor=further=details=in=case=of=other=targets=see=cigure=NFKAmong=these=levelsI=some=are=considered=as=the=main=onesI=while=others= have= to=be=verified=only=on=séecific= cases= EsecondaryF;=once= the=main=and= the= secondary=are=verifiedI=the=remaining=ones=may=usually=be=considered=as=satisfiedK=As= knownI= mBA= generally= refers= to= the= use= of= nonlinear= static= analyses= and= the= evaluation= of= the=seismic= demand= by= the= Caéacity= péectrum= jethod= xNz= or= the= kO= jethod= xOzI= according= to= the=reduction= of= acceleration= and= disélacement= séectra= by= the= over= daméed= or= inelastic= aééroachI=reséectivelyK=As=knownI=in=this=caseI=the=seismic=reséonse=of=an=asset=is=described=in=terms=of=caéacity=curveW=thus=each=éerformance=level=has=to=be=correlated=to=a=séecific=éoint=of=such=curveI=as=shown=in=cigure=N=for=the=different=targets=and=éerformance=levelsK==

cigK N aefinition=of=éerformance=levels=on=the=caéacity=curve=

=PK pbfpMfC AppbppMbNT lc CriTroAi ebofTAdb =lnce= the=safety=and=conservation= requirements= have=been=defined=from=a=conceétual=éoint=of=viewI=éroéer= acceétance= criteria= have= to=be= established= in=order= to=verify= if= the= structure= is= able=or= not= to=satisfy =the =required =miK =fn =éarticularI =the =acceétance =criteria =require =the =definition =ofW =aF =éroéer

ppect

ralA

ccele

ration

MAMAGN LIMITATION

Artistic Asset Conservation

Building Conservation

RNSTORABLN MAMAGN LOSS PRNVNNTIONNNAR INTNGRITY

SIGNIFICANT BUT RNSTORABLN MAMAGN

CAPACITY CURVN

NNAR COLLAPSN

ppectral aisplacement

RNMUCNM MNMANM

PNRFORMANCN POINT

rse and euman iife

IMMNMIATN OCCUPANCY LIFN SAFNTY

Building Conservation mis

Artistic Asset Conservation mis

rse and euman iife mis

=

OVNS=

variables=Eand=the=correséonding=reference=limit=valuesFI=correlated=to=the=building=seismic=reséonseI=which=allow=us=to=check=the=éerformance=level;=bF=éroéer=vulnerability modelsI=able=to=evaluate=these=variables=for=a=given=seismic=actionK=A=suitable=variable=that=can=be=correlated=to=the=various=consequencesI=commonly=adoéted=in=literature=Ein=éarticularI=in=macroseismic=éostJearthquake=assessmentFI= is=the=damage levelK=fn=factI=although=the=damage=level=is=an=eméiric=and=qualitative=indicatorI=it=has=the=main=advantage=to=be=directly=related=to=the= reséonse= of= elements= Estructural= and= nonJstructuralF= and= artistic= assetsK= joreoverI= since= usually=losses= in= terms= of= casualties= and= injured= éeoéle= are= relatedI= by= éroéer= correlation= lawsI= to= damage=occurred=in=structural=elements=of=the=buildingI=this=variable=seems=éarticularly=convenient=for=all=the=considered=éerformance=targetsK=ft= is= evident= that=damage=assessment=of= the=whole=asset= results= from=that=occurred=at=different= lower=scalesI=those=of=each=single=structural=element=and=of=the=macroelements=Eéortion=of=the=assetI=usually=made=by=a=set=of=elementsI=for=which=it=is=éossible=to=recognize=an=almost=autonomous=behaviourI=as=for= a= masonry= wall= or= a= floorFKqhenI= as= discussed= in= detail= in= §4KNI= séecific= criteria= have= to= be=introduced=to=consider=all=different=scales=Esingle=structural=elementI= macroelementI=global=oneF=andI=finallyI=to=correlate=damage=and=éerformance=levels=on=the=caéacity=curveK=As=a=function=of=the=target=examinedI=the=main=scale=to=be=adoéted=as=reference=may=differK=rsually=it=is=that=of=the=whole=asset=in=case=of=Building Conservation and=rse and euman iife=targetsI=and=the=local=one=Esingle=elementF=in=case=of=Artistic AssetK=aamage=is=graduated=on=five=levels=Efrom=negligible=damage=to=the=comélete=collaéseFI=as=for=examéle=adoéted=in=the=bjpVU=scale=xPz;=obviously=in=the=mBA=the=last=one=is=not=interestingK=cigure=O=shows=the=adoéted=correséondence=between=éerformance=and=damage=levelsK=fn=case=of=cultural=heritageI=due=to=the=wide=architectural=and=moréhological=variety=of=assetsI=it=is=not=an= easy= task= to= outline= a= érocedure= that= is= versatile= enough= for= the= seismic= assessment= and= the=correlation= between= damage= and= éerformance= levelsK= fn= factI= it= has= to= be= able= to= take= into= accountW=iF=the= various= architectonic= asset= classes;= iiF= the= different= damage= classes= and= subJclasses= that= may=occur=EinJélane=or=outJofJélane=of=masonry=wallsI=rocking=of=blocksI=etcKF;= iiiF=the=different=modelling=strategies=to=be=adoétedK==

=

cigK O Correséondence=between=éerformance=and=damage=levels==As=regard=the=first=issueI=in=mbombqrAqb=éroject=a=classification=based=on=“mechanical”=criteria=has=been= éroéosed= x4zI= starting= from= the= identification= of= the= most= relevant= macroelements= in= historic=buildings=and=of=the=correséonding=damage=tyéesK=peven=architectonic=asset=classes=are=identifiedI=as=followsW= A= –= assets= subjected= to= érevailing= inJélane= damage= EeKgK= éalacesI= castlesIKKKF;= B= – =assets =subjected=to=érevailing=outJofJélane=damage=EeKgK=churchesI=mosquesI…F;=C –=slender=assets=that=can=be= reéresented= by= a= monoJdimensional= masonry= element= EeKgK= towersI= minaretsI…F;= a –=arched=structures= subject= to= inJélane= damage= EeKgK= triuméhal= archesI= aqueductsI= cloistersIKKKF;= b –=massive=structures= in= which= local= failure= of= masonry= érevails= EeKgK= fortressesI= city= wallsIKKF;= c –=blocky=structures= subjected= to=overturning=and=sliding= EeKgK= columnsI= archaeological= ruinsF;=d –=aggregated=

rSE and erMAN ifcE

BrfiafNd ClNSEosATflN

fMMbafATb lCCrmANCv

ifcb pAcbTv

NbAo CliiAmpb

pfdNfcfCANT BrT obpTloABib

aAMAdb

aAMAdb ifMfTATflN

Nl aAMAdblmboATflNAiN

O

P

4

aAMAdb ibsbi

mbocloMANCb ibsbip

dil

BA

i S

CA

iE –

te

liE

AS

SE

T

AoTfSTfC ASSETS

ilpp mobsbNTflN

obpTloABib aAMAdb

NbAo fNTbdofTv N

O

P

STo

rC

Tro

Ai E

iEM

ENT-

ilC

Ai

SC

AiE

aAMAdb ibsbi

=

OVNT=

buildings=in=the=historical=centresK=fn=additionI=three=main=classes=for=artistic=assets=have=been=definedW=m –=assets= which= are= structural= elements= of= the= building= EeKgK= carved= stone= columnsI…F;= n –=assets=which=are=strictly=connected=to=structural= elements=of= the=building= EeKgK= frescoesI= mosaicsI= stuccoesI=stone=éortalsI…F;= o –=assets= which=are= indeéendent= elementsI= with= their= own= seismic= reséonse= EeKgK=éinnaclesI= statuesI= balconyI…FK= aifferent= damage= classes= and= subclasses= have= been= identified= and=attributed=to=the=abovementioned=architectonic=and=artistic=classesK=As= regards= the= modelling= strategies= to= be= adoétedI= models= develoéed= in= literature= for= masonry=structures=may=be=classified=according=to=two=criteriaW=scale=of=constitutive=modelling=Eat=the=level=of=masonry= material= or= structural= elementF= and= tyée= of= descriétion= of= masonry= Eby= a= homogenized=equivalent= continuum=or= through=discrete=modellingFK= cour=different=kind=of=models=are=identified=by=the= combination= of= the=abovementioned= oétions;= each=architectonic= class= has= a= foremost= modelling=aééroachK=Among=these=strategiesI=the=equivalent=frame=model=and=the=macroJblock=oneI=ascribable=to=a= continuous= and= discrete= aééroach= faced= at= structural= element= scaleI= reséectivelyI= seem= to= be=éarticularly=efficient= in=the=engineering=éracticeI=because=of= their= relatively= low=coméutational=effort=also=in=the=case=of=comélex=structuresK==joreoverI=as=a=function=of=the=different=tyées=of=architectonic=assetsI=the=seismic=assessment=may=be=faced=starting=from=different= scales= and= in=different= wayK= peismic assessment refers= to=the=érocedure=aimed=to=coméare=the=structural=caéacity=Edescribed=by=the=caéacity=curveF=with=the=seismic=demand=Ein=terms=of=reduced=reséonse=séectrumF=in=order=to=define=the=éerformance=éoint=andI=thenI=check=for=the=fulfilment=of=éerformance=levelsK=fn=case=of=equivalent=frame=models=seismic=assessment=refers=to=nonlinear= static= érocedures= EeKgK= Caéacity= péectrum= jethodI= kO= jethodFI= whereas= in= case= of= the=macroJblock=modelling=to=the=equilibrium=limit=analysis=through=nonlinear=kinematic=aééroachK=aeéending= on= the= tyée= and= dimensions= of= the=buildingI= it= is= éossible= to= further= distinguish=amongW=aF=assets= made= by= a= single= element= or= macroelement;= bF= comélex= assets= made= by= a= set= of=macroelements;= cF= artistic= assetsK= cigure= P= summarizes= these= different= cases= and= the= correséonding=seismic=assessment=scaleK=fn= case= aF= seismic= assessment= is= usually= carried= out= on= the= caéacity= curve= reéresentative= of= the=reséonse=of=the=single=element=or=macroelementK==cor=comélex=assets=Ecase=bFI=it=is=necessary=to=distinguish=the=following=two=main=casesW=

–= buildings=characterized=by=a=box=behaviourW=in=this=case=the=seismic=assessment=requires=referring=to=a=global=Pa=model;=

–= buildings=made=by=a=set=of=macrolements=which=exhibit=an=almost=indeéendent=behaviourW=in=this=caseI= after= having= coméuted= a= éroéer= seismic= load= sharingI= the= seismic= behaviour= of= each=macroelement=is=analysed=indeéendentlyK==

fn =the =first =caseI =the =seismic =assessment =is =directly =éerformed =on =the =overall =caéacity =curve =reéresentative=of= the=whole= asset= reséonseK= fn= the=second=oneI= it= is= evaluated=on=the= caéacity= curve=reéresentative=of= each=macroelement= reséonse;= thenI= starting=from=evaluations= carried=out=on=all= the=relevant= macroelementsI= éroéer= combination= criteria= may=be= introduced= to= define= the= correséonding=éerformance=at=the=scale=of=the=whole=assetK=qhe=attribute=“relevant”=refers=to=the=significance=in=terms=of=correséonding=consequences=related=to=éerformance=targets=examinedK=cinallyI=for=artistic=assets=Ecase=cFI=according=to=the=three=classes=above=introduced=EmI=nI=oF=different=oétions=must=be=consideredK=fn=the=case=of=m=and=n classesI=the=artistic=asset=is=éart=of=the=building=or=is=attached=to=one=of= its= elementsI=so= the=éerformance= is= checked=considering=the=caéacity=curve=of= the=whole=architectonic=asset;= in=éarticularI=for=class=n EeKgK=frescoesI=mosaicsI…FI=it=is=necessary=to=take=into=account=the=interaction=effects=with=the=structural=elementK=lf=courseI=in=this= latter=caseI=damage=levels=have=to=be=defined=on=the=overall=caéacity=curve=by=monitoring=the=local=reséonse=of=the=single=structural=element=to=which=the=artistic=asset=is=connected=toK=Artistic=elements=of=class=o=are=analysed=by=the=same=models=used=for=architectonic=assets=made=by=one=elementK=fn=each=caseI=the=caéacity=curve=will=be=obtained=by=adoéting=the=modelling=aééroach=most=suitable=to=interéret=the=seismic=reséonse=of=the=asset=EeKgK=through=a=continuous=or=a=discrete=aééroachFK=qhusI= as= a= function= of= these= three= classes= above= introducedI= damage= levels= Eand= the= correséonding=éerformance= levelsF= have= to= be= definedI= reséectivelyW= at= macroelement= scaleI= in= case= aF;= at= global=Ein=case= of= box= behaviourF= or= macroelement= scaleI= in= case= bF;= at= local= scale= of= single= elementI= in=case=cFK==ft=is=worth=éointing=out=that=in=the=case=of=box=behaviourI=an=exhaustive=seismic=assessment=would= require= also= the=verification= on= the=éossible=occurrence= of= local= outJofJélane= mechanisms;= in=this= caseI= a= comélete= seismic= assessment= should= take= into=account= both= evaluations= Eon= the= overall=caéacity=curve=and=on=that=of=the=single=macroelement=that=may=exhibit=some=outJofJélane=reséonseFK==

=

OVNU=

I =

cigK P qyées=of=assets=and=correséonding=seismic=assessment=scales==fn= the=following=éaragraéhI= a=multicriteria= aééroach=to=define=éroéer= damage= levels= on= the=caéacity=curve=is=éroéosed=andI=thenI= the=correlation=between=damage=and=éerformance=levels= is=treatedK=As=an=examéleI=the=issue=is=discussed=with=reference=to=the=case=of=class=A=of=architectonic=assetsI=those=with=a= érevailing= box= behaviourI= analysed= by= adoéting= the= equivalent= frame= modelling= aééroachK= As=knownI =according =to =this =aééroachI =each =wall =is =discretized =by =a =set =of =masonry =éanels =Epiers= and=spandrelsFI=in=which=the=nonlinear=reséonse=is=concentratedI=connected=by=rigid=areas=EnodesFK==QK abcfNfTflN lc mis lN Teb lsboAii CAmACfTv Crosb =qhe=definition=of=éerformance= levels=of= the=building=from=the=results=of=a=nonlinear= seismic=analysis=Eusually=a=éushover=analysisF=is=a=comélex=taskI=that=is=faced=in=a=different=way=in=literature=and=codes;=the=following=main=aééroaches=are=adoétedW=

– a= structural element approachI= that= assumes= the= attainment= of= a= certain= éerformance= level= at=global= scale= correséonds= to= the= steé= in= which= the= first= structural= element= reaches= the= same=éerformance=level=xRz;=

– an=heuristic approachI=that=defines=mis=on=the=basis=of=conventional=limits=directly=defined=on=the=caéacity=curveI= usually= in= terms= of=decay=éercentage=or= reaching=of= the=maximum=value=of= the=overall=base=shear=xSzK=

eoweverI= in= case= of= comélex= existing= masonry= buildingsI= éarticularly= those= belonging= to= the= cultural=heritageI= the=aéélication=of= these=aééroaches=may=lead= to=not= reliable=resultsK= fndeedI=while= in= case=of=a=boxJtyée=behaviour=with=quite=rigid=floors=it= is=reasonable=that=a=set=of=elements=and=walls=Edue=to=the=couéling=érovided=by=floorsF=reaches=almost=at=the=same=time=a=certain=damage=levelI=in=case=of=existing=buildings=this=condition=is=far=to=be=trueI=due=to=the=architectural=comélexity=and=the=éresence=of=flexible=

=

OVNV=

floorsK =fn =the =limit =case =of =coméletely =flexible =floorsI =it =is =reasonable =assuming =a =quite =indeéendent =behaviour=of=each=single=masonry=wallI=and=the=reaching=of=a=certain=éerformance=level=must=refer=to=that=at= the= macroelement= scaleK=eoweverI= this= is=a= limit= condition=and= in= generalI= even= in=case=of= wooden=floors=or=vaults=Ethat=are=tyéical=for=monumental=buildingsFI= floors=érovide=a=not=negligible=contribution=to=the=load=transfer=and=stiffnessK=As=a=consequenceI=the=reaching=of=a=certain=éerformance=level=at=scale=of=a=single=wall=may=not=coincide=with=that=of=the=whole=structureK=qhe=lack=of=homogeneity=of=damage=in=case= of= very= comélex= buildings= is= even= more= evident= at= the= scale= of= masonry= elements= Eéiers= and=séandrelsF;=thus=the=reaching=of=a=severe=éerformance=level=in=a=single=element=could=not=correséond=to=a=significant=strength=decay=on=the=overall=caéacity=curveW=thus=the=structural element approach=could=lead=to= a= too= cautionary= assessmentK= cinallyI= also= the= heuristic= aééroach= may= result= quite= conventional= if=adoéted=as=single=criterion=to=define=the=mis=on=the=caéacity=curveK=fn=éarticularI=it=does=not=assure=from=the=occurrence=of=heavy=damage=levels=EeKgK=near= to=collaéseF=at= local=scaleW=damages=that= could=be=not=coméatible=with=the=fulfilment=of=the=éerformance=level=which=is=checkedK=All=the=abovementioned=issues=stress=the=need=to=outline=a=érocedure=able=to=take=into=account=all=the=different=scales=thatconcur=to=define=the=overall=seismic=reséonse=and=to=combine=different=criteriaK=qo=this= aimI= in= the= following= the=mis= definition= is= éroéosed=based= on= two= main= steésW= firstlyI= in= §4KNI=damage= levels= are= defined= on= the= caéacity= curve= by= a= multicriteria= aééroach;= secondlyI= in= §4KOI=a=éroéer=correlation=between=damage=and=éerformance=levels=is=establishedK==QKNK aefinition of damage levels on the capacity curve by a multicriteria approach qhe=basic=idea=of=the=multicriteria=aééroach=is=that=the=assessment=of=a=certain=damage=level=at=global=scale=comes=out=from=a=set=of=checks=carried=out=at=different=scalesI=based=onW=

– heuristic approach Ederived=by=exéert=judgement=or=éarametric=analysesFW=related=to=the=fulfilment=of=conventional= limits=on= the=caéacity=curveI= either=of= the=whole=building=and=of= the=“relevant”=macroelements=they=coméose=the=asset;=

– systematic checks on elements and macroelementsW= aimed= to= avoid= the= occurrence= of= local=damage= levels= incoméatible= with= the= fulfilment= of= the= considered= damage= level= and= the=correséonding=éerformanceK=

According= to= this= aééroachI= the= disélacement= on= the= overall= éushover= curve= correséonding= to= the=reaching=of=the=i-th=aamage=ievel=EaiiI=with=i===NKK4F=is=coméuted=asW=== ( ) 4IN;;min III == idddd daiijaiibaiiaii = =ENF==there= daiiIbI= daiiIj and= daiiId= are= the= disélacements= on= the= éushover= curve= correséonding= to= the=attainment=of=the=checks=éerformed=at=elementI=macroelement=and=global=scaleI=reséectivelyK=cigure=4=summarizes=the=multicriteria=aééroach=éroéosed=in=case=of=a=threeJstorey=masonry=buildingK==fn=order= to=exélain=these=checksI= it= is=necessary=to=introduce=a=variable=x=which=describes=the=state=of=the= element= Eéier= or= séandrelFI= of= the= macroelement= Emasonry= wallF= and= of= the= whole= buildingI= in=correséondence=with=the=current=disélacement=d=on=the=éushover=curveK=fn=the= case=of= the=structural=element= scaleI= differently= from=the=macroelement= and=global=onesI= five=damage= levels= are= considered= Ecigure= RFK= qhe= variable= x= can =beI =in =this =caseI =the =drift =db or= the=éercentage= of= strength= reduction= bbK= By= considering= the= whole= set= of= éiers= EmFI= it= is= necessary= to=evaluate=the=disélacement=daiiIbp in=which=it=is=attained=the=conditionW==

=NI

max Nj

mi j

xu +

æ ö=ç ÷ç ÷

è ø= EOF=

=where=uiHNIj=is=the=limit=threshold=of=the=variable=x=in=the=jJth=éierI=for=the=damage=level=iHNK=pimilarlyI=by=considering=the=whole=set=of=séandrels=EpFI=the=disélacement=daiiIbs is=the=one=on=the=éushover=curve=in=which=it=is=attained=the=conditionW=

=OI

max Nj

pi j

xu +

æ ö=ç ÷ç ÷

è ø= EPF=

=where=uiHOIj=is=the=limit=threshold=of=the=variable=x=in=the=jJth=séandrelI=for=the=damage=level=iHO=Eélease=note=that=for=the=evaluation=of=the=global=damage=level=ai4=no=check=is=required=in=séandrelsFK=

=

OVOM=

cinallyI=the=disélacement=on=the=éushover=curve=daiiIb=is=obtained=as=followsW=== ( )I I Imin Iaii b aii bp aii bsd d d= = E4F==ft=is=worth=noting=that=a=higher=damage=level=is=acceéted=in=séandrels=than=in=éiers;=this=is=due=to=the=different= role= of= these= elements= in= the= hierarchy=of= masonry= wallsK= fn= fact= éiers= reéresent= the= most=iméortant=elementsI=which=bear=both=static=loads=and=seismic=actionI=whereas=séandrels=are=secondary=elementsI=which=connect=éiers=by=transmitting=bending=momentsK==

=

cigK Q pummary=of=multicriteria=aééroach=éroéosed=to=define=ais=on=the=overall=caéacity=curve===fn= the= case= of= macroelementsI= the= variable= x= is= the= interJstorey= drift= dis or= a= éroéer= éercentage= of=maximum=base=shear=reduction=bj=Eevaluated=on=the=éushover==curve=of=the=macroelementFK=By=considering=the=whole=set=of=macroelements=EjFI=the=disélacement=daiiIj=is=the=one=on=the=éushover=curve=in=which=it=is=attained=the=conditionW==

=I

max Nj

ji j

xu

æ ö=ç ÷ç ÷

è ø= ERF=

=where=uiIj=is=the=limit=threshold=of=the=variable=x=in=the=jJth=macroelementI=for=the=damage=level=iK=At= the=global= scaleI= daiiId= is= evaluated= Eonly= for= f ==PI4F= by=considering= for= the=variable= x= a =éroéer =éercentage=of=reduction=of=the=maximum=overall=base=shear=bdK=salues=of=the=limit=thresholds=of=the=variables=x=are=éroéosed=in=qable=NI=as=a=function=of=the=damage=levels=and=scales=consideredK=As=regard=the=structural=elementsI=drift=and=strength=decay=limits=have=to=be=differentiated=as=a= function=of=the=different= failure=modes=that=may=occur=EeKgK=oockingI=aiagonal=CrackingI= Bed= goint= pliding= or= mixed= modes= as= wellF;= moreoverI= in= the= case= of= séandrelsI= as=highlighted=by=some=recent=exéerimental=caméaigns=and=for=examéle=discussed=in=xTzI=these=values=are=also=function=of=the=architrave=tyée=EeKgK=masonry=archI=stone=lintel=or=woodenLsteel=beamF=and=of= the=éresence=of=another=tensile=resistant=element=couéled=to=it=EeKgK=tieJrod=or=rKcK=ringJbeamFK=As=regard=the=masonry=éanels=constitutive=modelsI= a=bilinear= forceJdrift=relationshié=without=hardening=and= residual= caéacity= is= usually= éroéosed= in= various= codes= xSI= Uz;= howeverI= in= order= to= get= a= reliable=éushover=curve=on=which=define=ais=reéresentative=till=to=near=collaése=conditionI=more=accurate=models=

Control node

Non linear static analysis

global

inWerVWory_1

inWerVWory_2

inWerVWory_3

Pall 8 aiPaiO

aiN

ai4

pta

te=v

aria

bles

and=

Xa

iifo

ra

iP=a

nd=a

i4

smax

bM,3smax

bM,4smax

pta

te=v

aria

bles

and=

Xa

iifo

ra

i1=a

nd=a

i2

dis,2

dis,1

MAColbibMbNT pCAib : daiiIM

aiP

ai4

bd,3stotImax

bd,4stotImax

stotImax

dilBAi pCAib : daiiId

global

Pall 1

Pall 7

Pall 8

Pall 3

The worst condition among those evaluated at dif ferent scales isassumed as reference to def ine the ai W min Edai3IE I dai3IMI dai3Id F

aiPMN aiPMP aiPMU

aiP

bibMbNT pCAib : daiiIb

÷÷

ø

ö

çç

è

æ÷÷ø

öççè

æ=÷

÷ø

öççè

æ=

++

Nmax;NmaxminII ON jai

j

pjai

j

mii

ux

ux

0

0,2

0,4

0,6

0,8

1

0 0,1 0,2 0,3 0,4 0,5 0,6 0,7

sLs

u

ari ft [B]

aiP

ai4 aiR

bquivalent frame idealisation of tall U

Checks at level of each elementWkode

mier

ppandrel

dwallU

dwallU

s wal

lUfn

ters

tory

drif

t wal

lU

d

s tot

d

s

dai3Id

dai3IM dai3IE

=

OVON=

are=necessaryK= fn=éarticularI= it= is=éroéosed=to=assume=multiJlinear=constitutive=laws=like=those=shown=in=cigure= R;= in= case= of= éiersI= it= should= be= reéresentative= of= a= érevailing= shear= reséonse= EeKgK= aiagonal=CrackingFI=whereas=in=case=of=séandrels=of=a=tyéical=failure=in=éresence=of=a=wooden=architraveK===

Table N aefinition=of=variables=x=at=the=different=scales=and=limit=thresholds=Eall=limits=are=in=BF==

aii=ptructural element scale

Macroelement scale dlobal scale miers ppandrels

N – – disIN EMKMRIMKNRF= –

O oeaching=of=maximum=strength= –

jaximum=base=shear=EsjF=disIO EMKNRIMKPF=

–

P bseIP EMIOMF;==

dseIP EMKPIMKSF=bseIP EMIRMF;==dseIP EMKRINF=

bjIP EPMI4MF bdIP ENMIOMF

Q bseIQ EOMISMF;=dseIQ EMK4INKOF=

bseIQ EOMITMF;==dseIQ ENIOF=

bjIQ ERMITMF bdIQ EPMI4MF

R dseIR EMKSINKRF= dseIR ENKRIOKRF= – –

=

=

cigK R jultiJlinear=constitutive=laws=for=éier=EleftF=and=séandrels=ErightF=elements== =QKOK Correlation between damage levels and performance levels lnce=damage=levels=have=been=defined=on=basis=of=the=éroéosed=multicriteria=aééroachI=it=is=necessary=to=establish=“acceétability=thresholds”=in=order=to=define=the=disélacements=associated=to=the=fulfilment=of=the=various=éerformance=levelsK=qhe=definition=of=mis=on=the=caéacity=curve=may=be=done=directly=from=the=damage=levels=or=introducing=a=érobabilistic=aééroach=Eby=means=of=fragility=curvesFK=qhe =basic =assumétion =is =to =assume =as =“acceétability =criteria” =that =mis =are =coincident =with =the =correséonding= aisK= fn= éarticularI= this= criterion= seems= consistent= in= case= of= assets= constituted= by=a=single=element=or=macroelementK=aeséite=this=general=criterionI=at=global=scaleI=as=a= function=of= the=éerformance= target= examinedI= related= to= the= rse and euman iife= or =to =the =Building ConservationI=some=additional= refinements= may=be= introducedK= As= matter=of= factI= criteria= introduced= in=§4KNI= seem=consistent=in=terms=of=structural=éerformance=exéected=EBuilding Conservation=targetFI=but=could=be=not=always= suitable= in= terms= of= “life= safety”K= fn= factI= as= regard= the= rse and euman iife= éerformance=targetsI= the= occurrence= of= a= heavy= damage= in= a= quite= small= éortion= of= the= asset= could= éroduce= not=coméatible=consequences=for=the=i-th=mi=examinedK=aue=to=this=issueI=it=seems=reasonable=to=introduce=some=more=cautionary=checks=at=macroelement=scale=in=case=of=miP=associated=to=the=rse=and=euman=iife=target=EeKgK=by=adoéting=more=restrictive=values=for=bjIiFK=fn= order= to= establish= a= more= aware= correlationI= the= érobabilistic= distribution= of= ais= is= introducedK=aamage= levels= reéresent=discrete=damage=conditionsW= from=a=érobabilistic=éoint= of=view=it= is=usually=assumed= that= these= thresholds= correséond= to= the= conditional= érobability= of= RMB= of= being= in= or=exceeding=the=correséonding=damage=levelK=ft=means=that=in=correséondence=with=the=disélacement=daii=there=is=a=“small”=érobability=of=having=damage=levels=higher= than=iJthI=with=consequences=that=could=be=incoméatible=with=the=fulfilment=of=the=examined=miW=as=a=consequenceI=in=generalI=to=assume=mis=as= strictly= coincident= with= the= correséonding= damage= levels= could= be= not= always= on= the= safe= sideK=A=refinement= of= the= definition= of= mis= on= the= caéacity= curve= could= be= obtained= by= introducing=a=érobabilistic=aééroach= through=fragility=curves= and=by=checking= the=fulfilment=of= some=acceétance=criteria =Efor =examéleI =defined =in =terms =of =admissible= éercentage= of= collaésed= buildings= or= injured=

Î

ÎÎ

ÎÎÎ Î Î

ÎÎ

ÎÎ Î Î

Î Î

0

0,2

0,4

0,6

0,8

1

0 0,5 1 1,5 2 2,5 3

0

0,2

0,4

0,6

0,8

1

0 0,5 1

aiP

ai4

aiPai4

aiR

db,5

db xBzdb xBz

sLs

u

sLs

u

aiR

db,4 db,5db,4db,3db,3

bb,3 su

bb,4 su bb,3 su

=

OVOO=

éeoéleFK= qhis= refinement= has= to= be= defined= for= each= séecific= examined= structure= and= cannot= be=quantified=in=general=termsW=in=factI=the=distribution=histogram=of=damage=levels=deéends=on=the=relative=éosition=of=each=damage=level=on=the=overall=caéacity=curve=Efunction=of=the=ductility=of=the=structureF=and=on=the=uncertainties=Eeéistemic=and=randomF=which=are=éresent=in=the=assessmentK=cigure=S=clarifies=this= issueW= the=érobability=of= having=ai= 4=and=R= deéends=by= the= relative= difference= on= the= caéacity=curve=of==daiP=and=daiQI=as=well=as=on=the=sloée=of=the=fragility=curvesK==

=

cigK S Correlation=between=mis=and=ais=through=a=érobabilistic=aééroach=based=on=fragility=curves=

=RK cfNAi obMAohp =tithin =the =éerformance =based =assessmentI =in =the =éaéer =a =érocedure =to =correlate =damage =and =éerformance= levels= based= on= a= multicriteria= aééroach= is= éroéosedK= fn= éarticularI= it= is= addressed= to=combine=all=the=different=scales=Esingle=structural=elementI=macroelement=and=globalF=that=may=concur=to=define=the=whole=reséonse=of=comélex=assetsI=such=as=the=case=of=masonry=historical=constructionsK=Although =the =limit =values =to =be =adoéted =as =reference =may =be =refined =on =the =basis =of =éarametric =numerical= analyses= and= the= suééort= of= exéerimental= caméaigns= Ein= éarticular= at= element= scaleFI= the=érocedure=seems=caéable=to=caéture=the=wide=variety=and=comélexity=of=these=structuresK===AChNltibadbMbNTp =qhe= results= have= been= achieved= in= the= éroject= mbombqrAqb= EwwwKéeréetuateKeuFI= funded= by= the=buroéean= Commission= in= the= peventh= cramework= mrogramme= EcmTLOMMTJOMNPFI= under= grant=agreement=n°=O44OOVK= obcbobNCbp xNz creeman=pKAKI= kicoletti= gKmK= C=qyrell= gKsK= ENVTRFK= “bvaluation=of= existing=building=for= seismic=

riskJ=A=case=study=of=muget=pound=kaval=phyéyard”I= BrementonI=tashingtonI= mrocK of the rKpK kational Conference on barthquake bngineersI=bbofI=NNPJNOOI=BerkeleyK=

xOz cajfar= mK= EOMMMFK= “A= non= linear= analysis= method= for= éerformanceJbased= seismic= design”I=barthquake ppectraI NSWPI=RTPJRVNK=

xPz drunthal= dK= ENVVUFK”buroéean= jacroseismic= pcale”I= Centre= buroééen= de= déodynamiqueet= de=péismologieI=iuxembourgK=solK=NRK=

x4z iagomarsino=pKI=Abbas=kKI=Calderini=CKI=Cattari=pKI=oossi=jKI=dinanniCorradini=oKI=jarghella=dKI=jattolin=cKI=miovanello=sK=EOMNNFK=“Classification=of=cultural=heritage=assets=and=seismic=damage=variables= for= the= identification= of= éerformance= levels”I= mrocK of ptructural repairs and jaintenance of eeritage Architecture conferenceI=SVTJTMU=I=tfq=mressI=fppk=NT4PJPRMVK=

xRz ApCbLpbf= 4NLMS= EOMMSFK= “peismic= oehabilitation= of= bxisting= Buildings”K= American= pociety= of=Civil=bngineersI=rpAK=

xSz burocode=U=–=mart=P=EOMMRFK=“aesign=of=structures=for=earthquake=resistanceK=mart=PW=Assessment=and=retrofitting=of=buildings”K=bks=NVVUJPI=CbkW=BrusselsI=OMMRK=

xTz Beyer= hK= EOMNOFK= “meak= and= residual= strengths= of= brick= masonry= séandrels”I= bngineering ptructuresI=4NI=RPPJR4TK=

xUz ftalian=Code=for=ptructural=aesign=EOMMUFK=aKjK=N4LNLOMMUI=lfficial=Bulletin=noK=OV=4LOLOMMUK=

ais defined on basis of multicriteriaapproach

aiN aiO ai3 ai4

cragilitycurves

0

0,5

1

50%=of probability ofbeing or=exceeding aiP

ML1

ML2

ML3

ML4

d

mrobabilitydistribution of ais

M

MIN

MIO

MI3

MI4

MIR

M N O 3 4 Raamagelevel

ff the=acceptance criterion isn’t=satisfied I=the=mi=limit threshold may moved back=with respect the=corresponding ai

Corresponding to ppp=aiP

s

d dai4dai3daiOdaiN

miP