marriage intentions among never married japanese … in predicting marriage intentions among...

1
The Center for Family and Demographic Research at Bowling Green State University has core funding from the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development (R24HD050959-01). Family Demographic and Research Center for Bowling Green State University Marriage Intentions Among Never Married Japanese Individuals Sayaka Kawamura Department of Sociology Bowling Green State University [email protected] • Average ages at first marriage in Japan have been steadily increasing, and they are among the oldest in the world (Raymo & Iwasawa, 2008) • In 2008, average ages at first marriage were ▪ 30 years for men ▪ 29 years for women (Statistics Bureau, Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications, 2009) • Proportion of those who have never married has also been increasing (Raymo & Iwasawa, 2008) • About 26% of men and 14% of women ages 35-39 were never married in 2000 (Raymo & Iwasawa, 2008) • Overwhelming majorities of Japanese young single men and women expect to marry someday (e.g., Kaneko et al., 2008; Raymo & Iwasawa, 2008) • What factors are associated with marriage intentions among never married Japanese men and women? Background Positive Factors Associated with Marriage Intentions • Marriage has a symbolic importance as a marker of adulthood (Lebra, 1984; Yamada & Shirakawa, 2008) • Marriage and childbearing are strongly connected in Japan, with nonmarital births accounting for roughly 2% of all births (e.g., Lebra, 1984; Tsuya & Mason, 1995;Tsuya & Bumpass, 2004) Negative Factors Associated with Marriage Intentions • Women’s educational attainment has greatly improved (e.g., Raymo & Iwasawa, 2005) • Traditional gender relationships remain strong (e.g., Tsuya & Bumpass, 2004) • The specialization framework is supported in Japan; women’s economic resources are negatively associated with the transition to marriage (e.g., Ono, 2003, Raymo & Iwasawa, 2005) Hypotheses • H1: Positive attitudes toward the importance of marriage in life are positively associated with marriage intentions • H2: The desire to have a child is positively related to marriage intentions • H3: Gender and economic resources interact: ▪ Women’s economic resources are negatively associated with marriage intentions ▪ Men’s economic resources are positively related to marriage intentions • The Japan 2000 National Survey on Family and Economic Conditions (Tsuya, Bumpass, & Rindfuss, 2008, N = 4,482) • Never married men and women ages 20-39 (n = 1,793) • Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) regression models were estimated • Interactions between gender and economic resources were tested Data and Methods • A strong belief in the importance of marriage was positively related to marriage intentions • The desire to have a child was positively and strongly associated with marriage intentions • Women were more likely than men to intend to marry • There was no significant interaction between gender and economic resources • Age was negatively associated with marriage intentions • Factors associated with marriage intentions did not differ greatly for singles in 20s and 30s (results not shown) • Among women, those with college degrees were more likely to intend to marry, compared to those who have completed high school (result not shown) Findings Limitations • Never married individuals in their 40s were not included because of small sample sizes • Cross-sectional data did not allow tests of the causal order between some key factors (e.g., desire to have children, belief in importance of marriage, and marriage intentions) Conclusion • Japanese singles still report relatively strong marriage intentions • Women have stronger marriage intentions than men, regardless of the persistence of gendered domestic responsibilities for Japanese married women • A strong desire for parenthood is a very powerful factor in predicting marriage intentions among Japanese singles Figure 3 Educational Attainment and Employment Status Figure 2 Importance of Marriage and Desire to Have a Child 1=strongly disagree to 5=strongly agree 1=definitely not to 5=definitely yes Figure 1 Marriage Intentions “Do you want to get married someday?” 1=definitely not to 5=definitely yes Table 1 OLS Regression Models Predicting Marriage Intentions Independent Variables b SE Gender (women=1) 0.129 *** 0.04 Age (in years) -0.013 ** 0.004 Importance of marriage for men 0.072 *** 0.02 Importance of marriage for women 0.104 *** 0.02 Desires to have a child 0.460 *** 0.02 Dating status (1=yes) 0.270 *** 0.04 Educational attainment Junior high school 0.117 0.08 Professional training -0.005 0.05 Junior college 0.037 0.05 College or more 0.107 * 0.04 Other -0.005 0.21 Employment status Full-time -0.097 0.66 Not working -0.136 * 0.07 Other -0.363 ** 0.14 Income < 1 million Japanese yen -0.078 0.05 1-1.99 million Japanese yen -0.132 ** 0.05 4-5.99 million Japanese yen or more 0.008 0.06 Co-residence with parents (1 = yes) 0.019 0.04 Urban residence in childhood (1 = yes) -0.033 0.04 Current geographic size Large metropolitan cities -0.031 0.04 Small cities/towns -0.049 0.05 Rural areas -0.023 0.05 Gender role attitudes 0.009 0.02 Success in work (1=yes) 0.097 0.05 Spending time with family (1=yes) 0.186 *** 0.04 Intercept 1.882 *** 0.17 Adjusted R-square Source: The Japan 2000 National Survey on Family and Economic Conditions p < .10, * p < .05, ** p < .01, *** p < .001. Full Model 0.4399 s

Upload: dinhnguyet

Post on 26-May-2018

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

The Center for Family and Demographic Research at Bowling Green State University has core funding from the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development (R24HD050959-01).

FamilyDemographic

and

ResearchCen

ter

for

Bowling Green State University

Marriage Intentions Among Never Married Japanese IndividualsSayaka KawamuraDepartment of SociologyBowling Green State [email protected]

•AverageagesatfirstmarriageinJapanhavebeensteadilyincreasing,andtheyareamongtheoldestintheworld(Raymo&Iwasawa,2008)

•In2008,averageagesatfirstmarriagewere▪30yearsformen▪29yearsforwomen

(StatisticsBureau,MinistryofInternalAffairsandCommunications,2009)•Proportionofthosewhohavenevermarriedhasalsobeenincreasing(Raymo&Iwasawa,2008)

•About26%ofmenand14%ofwomenages35-39werenevermarriedin2000(Raymo&Iwasawa,2008)

•OverwhelmingmajoritiesofJapaneseyoungsinglemenandwomenexpecttomarrysomeday(e.g.,Kanekoetal.,2008;Raymo&Iwasawa,2008)

•WhatfactorsareassociatedwithmarriageintentionsamongnevermarriedJapanesemenandwomen?

Background

Positive Factors Associated with Marriage Intentions•Marriagehasasymbolicimportanceasamarkerofadulthood(Lebra,1984;Yamada&Shirakawa,2008)

•MarriageandchildbearingarestronglyconnectedinJapan,withnonmaritalbirthsaccountingforroughly2%ofallbirths(e.g.,Lebra,1984;Tsuya&Mason,1995;Tsuya&Bumpass,2004)

Negative Factors Associated with Marriage Intentions•Women’seducationalattainmenthasgreatlyimproved(e.g.,Raymo&Iwasawa,2005)

•Traditionalgenderrelationshipsremainstrong(e.g.,Tsuya&Bumpass,2004)

•ThespecializationframeworkissupportedinJapan;women’seconomicresourcesarenegativelyassociatedwiththetransitiontomarriage(e.g.,Ono,2003,Raymo&Iwasawa,2005)

Hypotheses

•H1:Positiveattitudestowardtheimportanceofmarriageinlifearepositivelyassociatedwithmarriageintentions

•H2:Thedesiretohaveachildispositivelyrelatedtomarriageintentions•H3:Genderandeconomicresourcesinteract:▪Women’seconomicresourcesarenegativelyassociatedwith marriageintentions▪Men’seconomicresourcesarepositivelyrelatedtomarriage intentions

•TheJapan2000NationalSurveyonFamilyandEconomicConditions(Tsuya,Bumpass,&Rindfuss,2008,N=4,482)

•Nevermarriedmenandwomenages20-39(n=1,793)•OrdinaryLeastSquares(OLS)regressionmodelswereestimated•Interactionsbetweengenderandeconomicresourcesweretested

Data and Methods

•Astrongbeliefintheimportanceofmarriagewaspositivelyrelatedtomarriageintentions

•Thedesiretohaveachildwaspositivelyandstronglyassociatedwithmarriageintentions

•Womenweremorelikelythanmentointendtomarry•Therewasnosignificantinteractionbetweengenderandeconomicresources

•Agewasnegativelyassociatedwithmarriageintentions•Factorsassociatedwithmarriageintentionsdidnotdiffergreatlyforsinglesin20sand30s(resultsnotshown)

•Amongwomen,thosewithcollegedegreesweremore likelytointendtomarry,comparedtothosewhohavecompletedhighschool(resultnotshown)

Findings

Limitations•Nevermarriedindividualsintheir40swerenotincludedbecauseofsmallsamplesizes

•Cross-sectionaldatadidnotallowtestsofthecausalorderbetweensomekeyfactors(e.g.,desiretohavechildren,beliefinimportanceofmarriage,andmarriageintentions)

Conclusion•Japanesesinglesstillreportrelativelystrongmarriageintentions

•Womenhavestrongermarriageintentionsthanmen,regardlessofthepersistenceofgendereddomesticresponsibilitiesforJapanesemarriedwomen

•AstrongdesireforparenthoodisaverypowerfulfactorinpredictingmarriageintentionsamongJapanesesingles

Figure 3EducationalAttainmentandEmploymentStatus

Figure 2ImportanceofMarriageandDesiretoHaveaChild

1=strongly disagreeto5=strongly agree 1=definitely notto5=definitely yes

Figure 1MarriageIntentions“Doyouwanttogetmarriedsomeday?”

1=definitely notto5=definitely yes

Table 1OLSRegressionModelsPredictingMarriageIntentionsTable 1: OLS Regression Models Predicting on Marriage Intentions

Independent Variables b SE

Gender (women=1) 0.129 *** 0.04

Age (in years) -0.013 ** 0.004

Importance of marriage for men 0.072 *** 0.02

Importance of marriage for women 0.104 *** 0.02

Desires to have a child 0.460 *** 0.02

Dating status (1=yes) 0.270 *** 0.04

Educational attainment

Junior high school 0.117 0.08

Professional training -0.005 0.05

Junior college 0.037 0.05

College or more 0.107 * 0.04

Other -0.005 0.21

Employment status

Full-time -0.097 0.66

Not working -0.136 * 0.07

Other -0.363 ** 0.14

Income

< 1 mill ion Japanese yen -0.078 0.05

1-1.99 mill ion Japanese yen -0.132 ** 0.05

4-5.99 mill ion Japanese yen or more 0.008 0.06

Co-residence with parents (1 = yes) 0.019 0.04

Urban residence in childhood (1 = yes) -0.033 0.04

Current geographic size

Large metropolitan cities -0.031 0.04

Small cities/towns -0.049 0.05

Rural areas -0.023 0.05

Gender role attitudes 0.009 0.02

Success in work (1=yes) 0.097 ✝ 0.05

Spending time with family (1=yes) 0.186 *** 0.04

Intercept 1.882 *** 0.17

Adjusted R-square

Source: The Japan 2000 National Survey on Family and Economic Conditions

✝p < .10, *p < .05, **p < .01, ***p < .001.

Full Model

0.4399

s