marilyn hamilton - sustainable cities & eco regions food for thought may 27

59
©Marilyn Hamilton PhD CGA Glocal Food for Thought Sustaining Cities & Eco-Regions:

Upload: renaissance2-social-innovation-catalyst

Post on 25-Dec-2014

777 views

Category:

Technology


1 download

DESCRIPTION

 

TRANSCRIPT

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Glocal Food for Thought

Sustaining Cities amp Eco-Regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Bee Hive Energy Resilient

Conformity Enforcers

Diversity Generators

Inner Judges

Resource Shifters

Intragroup Competitors

Sustain Hive amp Eco-Region

ORG PURPOSE = 40 LB HONEYYR

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

World Threats

Earth-Cosmos

Boundary

Human-Environment

Boundary

Civilization

Anthroposphere

Biosphere

Atmosphere

Hydrosphere

Lithosphere

Solar System

Universe

DepthDepth

Span

(TIME) Years BP

~ 10E+03

~ 10E+04

~ 10E+05

~ 10E+06

~ 10E+07

~ 10E+08

~ 10E+09

~10E+20 ~10E+10 ~10E+5 ~10E+03 ~10E+02 -meters- ~10E-01 ~10E-02 ~10E-05 ~10E-10 ~10E-20

(Big Bang)

Energy Entropy

Early Societies

TribesClans

Heterotrophic Ecosystems

Climatic Systems

Oceans Lakes Rivers

Rocks Minerals

Planetary Systems

Stars Galaxies

Quasars Pulsars

Complex Neocortex

Neocortex-Limbic Systems

Organic CompoundsCells

Inorganic Compounds

Atoms-Molecules-Gases

Sub-Atomic Particles

EnergySource

(LR-UR ExternalPhysical Perspective)copy Brian Eddy PhD Cand

Water

ClimateFood

Bio-Genes

Psycho-Cultural-Social

Energy

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Reframe Sustainable Eco-Region

BioregionEnvironment Context

Resilience in the Systemlt100000 to 1750 +-

Living off

renewable food

Capital Seed

Grain

bull Interest = Daily Food Stores

bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Basket

ltResilience in the Systemgt1750 ndash 19xx

Living off large

part of

Renewables

Capital Seed

Grain

bull Interest = Food Stores

bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Bag

No Resilience in the System1960 +-

Living off Seed

Grain

Capital Seed

Grainbull Withdrawals =

Daily Shopping Cart

No Recovery in the System2000

Consuming

Capital Seed

Grain

Capital Seed

Grain =bull Withdrawals=

Daily Shopping Carts

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and

integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in

cities around the world The conceptual approach includes

consideration of different types of capital

Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation

Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations

Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence

Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT

Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience

Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust

Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management

The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it

has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types

of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City

Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh

Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City

4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce

City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS

Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism

Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre

LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml

Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2

Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2

Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa

Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel

region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml

Municipality

APPLICANTS

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria

1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved

Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework

Environment

Subjective

Internal

Individual

Inter-subjective

Internal Collective

Objective

External

Individual

Inter-

Objective

External

Collective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Environment

3 Human

2 Social

5 Culture

6 Political

7 Financial

4 Technical

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Holistic

approach ndash

which types

of capital are

part of the

initiative

And how

they are

involved

2 Object-

ives for

the

initiative

(long and

short

term)

3 Results

measured with

relevant KPIacutes

linked to the

different types

of capital and

both long and

short term

objectives

4 Level of

innovation for the

initiative - describe

the uniqueness or

why this initiative

adds new

knowledge

regarding creating

more sustainable

cities

5 Summary

of strategic

learnings

from the

initiative to

share

globally and

to inspire

other cities

SCORING SHEET

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

15 Points for for holistic approach

with points for capitals

represented

15

25

35

45

55

2 5 Points for Objectives

Short Term = 2

Long Term = 3

3 5 Points for KPI

Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be

specifically defined

My point scoring

4 5 Points for Level of Innovation

Slight improvement

Moderate improvement

Major improvement

Extends prior capabilitycapacity

exponentially

Never before done truly new

5 5 Points for Summary of

Strategic Learnings

Clear

Succinct

Strategic

Compelling

Inspiring

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)

983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day

in Jangji River

983803 Water quality

- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002

rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009

- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004

rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009

983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River

- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia

- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom

- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)

- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)

983803 Urban afforestation

- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)

- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)

- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average

(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for

bicycles)

983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)

983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)

Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)

Level

983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of

Seoul)

983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment

highest in all of Seoul

983803 Resident survey

- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)

- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)

Environmental

awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards

983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city

983803 Selected as Green City 2008

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

The objectives of the city council for 2012 are

1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself

by over 10

2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use

of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)

3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor

sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)

4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with

photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)

5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel

operated vehicles to local public transportation

6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in

municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers

7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of

energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and

students

Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy

Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at

httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of

1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining

forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity

Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR

(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy

Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings

planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)

Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui

River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin

(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey

(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-

tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon

(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line

(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities

sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less

smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a

clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon

monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions

and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5

separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil

(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every

six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the

garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in

Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Bee Hive Energy Resilient

Conformity Enforcers

Diversity Generators

Inner Judges

Resource Shifters

Intragroup Competitors

Sustain Hive amp Eco-Region

ORG PURPOSE = 40 LB HONEYYR

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

World Threats

Earth-Cosmos

Boundary

Human-Environment

Boundary

Civilization

Anthroposphere

Biosphere

Atmosphere

Hydrosphere

Lithosphere

Solar System

Universe

DepthDepth

Span

(TIME) Years BP

~ 10E+03

~ 10E+04

~ 10E+05

~ 10E+06

~ 10E+07

~ 10E+08

~ 10E+09

~10E+20 ~10E+10 ~10E+5 ~10E+03 ~10E+02 -meters- ~10E-01 ~10E-02 ~10E-05 ~10E-10 ~10E-20

(Big Bang)

Energy Entropy

Early Societies

TribesClans

Heterotrophic Ecosystems

Climatic Systems

Oceans Lakes Rivers

Rocks Minerals

Planetary Systems

Stars Galaxies

Quasars Pulsars

Complex Neocortex

Neocortex-Limbic Systems

Organic CompoundsCells

Inorganic Compounds

Atoms-Molecules-Gases

Sub-Atomic Particles

EnergySource

(LR-UR ExternalPhysical Perspective)copy Brian Eddy PhD Cand

Water

ClimateFood

Bio-Genes

Psycho-Cultural-Social

Energy

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Reframe Sustainable Eco-Region

BioregionEnvironment Context

Resilience in the Systemlt100000 to 1750 +-

Living off

renewable food

Capital Seed

Grain

bull Interest = Daily Food Stores

bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Basket

ltResilience in the Systemgt1750 ndash 19xx

Living off large

part of

Renewables

Capital Seed

Grain

bull Interest = Food Stores

bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Bag

No Resilience in the System1960 +-

Living off Seed

Grain

Capital Seed

Grainbull Withdrawals =

Daily Shopping Cart

No Recovery in the System2000

Consuming

Capital Seed

Grain

Capital Seed

Grain =bull Withdrawals=

Daily Shopping Carts

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and

integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in

cities around the world The conceptual approach includes

consideration of different types of capital

Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation

Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations

Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence

Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT

Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience

Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust

Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management

The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it

has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types

of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City

Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh

Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City

4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce

City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS

Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism

Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre

LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml

Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2

Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2

Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa

Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel

region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml

Municipality

APPLICANTS

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria

1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved

Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework

Environment

Subjective

Internal

Individual

Inter-subjective

Internal Collective

Objective

External

Individual

Inter-

Objective

External

Collective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Environment

3 Human

2 Social

5 Culture

6 Political

7 Financial

4 Technical

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Holistic

approach ndash

which types

of capital are

part of the

initiative

And how

they are

involved

2 Object-

ives for

the

initiative

(long and

short

term)

3 Results

measured with

relevant KPIacutes

linked to the

different types

of capital and

both long and

short term

objectives

4 Level of

innovation for the

initiative - describe

the uniqueness or

why this initiative

adds new

knowledge

regarding creating

more sustainable

cities

5 Summary

of strategic

learnings

from the

initiative to

share

globally and

to inspire

other cities

SCORING SHEET

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

15 Points for for holistic approach

with points for capitals

represented

15

25

35

45

55

2 5 Points for Objectives

Short Term = 2

Long Term = 3

3 5 Points for KPI

Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be

specifically defined

My point scoring

4 5 Points for Level of Innovation

Slight improvement

Moderate improvement

Major improvement

Extends prior capabilitycapacity

exponentially

Never before done truly new

5 5 Points for Summary of

Strategic Learnings

Clear

Succinct

Strategic

Compelling

Inspiring

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)

983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day

in Jangji River

983803 Water quality

- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002

rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009

- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004

rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009

983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River

- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia

- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom

- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)

- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)

983803 Urban afforestation

- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)

- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)

- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average

(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for

bicycles)

983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)

983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)

Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)

Level

983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of

Seoul)

983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment

highest in all of Seoul

983803 Resident survey

- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)

- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)

Environmental

awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards

983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city

983803 Selected as Green City 2008

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

The objectives of the city council for 2012 are

1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself

by over 10

2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use

of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)

3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor

sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)

4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with

photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)

5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel

operated vehicles to local public transportation

6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in

municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers

7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of

energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and

students

Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy

Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at

httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of

1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining

forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity

Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR

(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy

Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings

planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)

Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui

River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin

(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey

(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-

tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon

(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line

(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities

sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less

smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a

clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon

monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions

and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5

separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil

(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every

six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the

garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in

Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Bee Hive Energy Resilient

Conformity Enforcers

Diversity Generators

Inner Judges

Resource Shifters

Intragroup Competitors

Sustain Hive amp Eco-Region

ORG PURPOSE = 40 LB HONEYYR

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

World Threats

Earth-Cosmos

Boundary

Human-Environment

Boundary

Civilization

Anthroposphere

Biosphere

Atmosphere

Hydrosphere

Lithosphere

Solar System

Universe

DepthDepth

Span

(TIME) Years BP

~ 10E+03

~ 10E+04

~ 10E+05

~ 10E+06

~ 10E+07

~ 10E+08

~ 10E+09

~10E+20 ~10E+10 ~10E+5 ~10E+03 ~10E+02 -meters- ~10E-01 ~10E-02 ~10E-05 ~10E-10 ~10E-20

(Big Bang)

Energy Entropy

Early Societies

TribesClans

Heterotrophic Ecosystems

Climatic Systems

Oceans Lakes Rivers

Rocks Minerals

Planetary Systems

Stars Galaxies

Quasars Pulsars

Complex Neocortex

Neocortex-Limbic Systems

Organic CompoundsCells

Inorganic Compounds

Atoms-Molecules-Gases

Sub-Atomic Particles

EnergySource

(LR-UR ExternalPhysical Perspective)copy Brian Eddy PhD Cand

Water

ClimateFood

Bio-Genes

Psycho-Cultural-Social

Energy

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Reframe Sustainable Eco-Region

BioregionEnvironment Context

Resilience in the Systemlt100000 to 1750 +-

Living off

renewable food

Capital Seed

Grain

bull Interest = Daily Food Stores

bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Basket

ltResilience in the Systemgt1750 ndash 19xx

Living off large

part of

Renewables

Capital Seed

Grain

bull Interest = Food Stores

bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Bag

No Resilience in the System1960 +-

Living off Seed

Grain

Capital Seed

Grainbull Withdrawals =

Daily Shopping Cart

No Recovery in the System2000

Consuming

Capital Seed

Grain

Capital Seed

Grain =bull Withdrawals=

Daily Shopping Carts

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and

integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in

cities around the world The conceptual approach includes

consideration of different types of capital

Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation

Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations

Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence

Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT

Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience

Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust

Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management

The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it

has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types

of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City

Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh

Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City

4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce

City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS

Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism

Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre

LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml

Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2

Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2

Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa

Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel

region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml

Municipality

APPLICANTS

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria

1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved

Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework

Environment

Subjective

Internal

Individual

Inter-subjective

Internal Collective

Objective

External

Individual

Inter-

Objective

External

Collective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Environment

3 Human

2 Social

5 Culture

6 Political

7 Financial

4 Technical

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Holistic

approach ndash

which types

of capital are

part of the

initiative

And how

they are

involved

2 Object-

ives for

the

initiative

(long and

short

term)

3 Results

measured with

relevant KPIacutes

linked to the

different types

of capital and

both long and

short term

objectives

4 Level of

innovation for the

initiative - describe

the uniqueness or

why this initiative

adds new

knowledge

regarding creating

more sustainable

cities

5 Summary

of strategic

learnings

from the

initiative to

share

globally and

to inspire

other cities

SCORING SHEET

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

15 Points for for holistic approach

with points for capitals

represented

15

25

35

45

55

2 5 Points for Objectives

Short Term = 2

Long Term = 3

3 5 Points for KPI

Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be

specifically defined

My point scoring

4 5 Points for Level of Innovation

Slight improvement

Moderate improvement

Major improvement

Extends prior capabilitycapacity

exponentially

Never before done truly new

5 5 Points for Summary of

Strategic Learnings

Clear

Succinct

Strategic

Compelling

Inspiring

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)

983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day

in Jangji River

983803 Water quality

- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002

rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009

- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004

rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009

983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River

- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia

- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom

- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)

- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)

983803 Urban afforestation

- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)

- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)

- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average

(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for

bicycles)

983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)

983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)

Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)

Level

983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of

Seoul)

983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment

highest in all of Seoul

983803 Resident survey

- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)

- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)

Environmental

awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards

983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city

983803 Selected as Green City 2008

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

The objectives of the city council for 2012 are

1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself

by over 10

2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use

of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)

3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor

sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)

4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with

photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)

5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel

operated vehicles to local public transportation

6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in

municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers

7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of

energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and

students

Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy

Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at

httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of

1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining

forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity

Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR

(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy

Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings

planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)

Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui

River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin

(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey

(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-

tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon

(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line

(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities

sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less

smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a

clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon

monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions

and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5

separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil

(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every

six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the

garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in

Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Bee Hive Energy Resilient

Conformity Enforcers

Diversity Generators

Inner Judges

Resource Shifters

Intragroup Competitors

Sustain Hive amp Eco-Region

ORG PURPOSE = 40 LB HONEYYR

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

World Threats

Earth-Cosmos

Boundary

Human-Environment

Boundary

Civilization

Anthroposphere

Biosphere

Atmosphere

Hydrosphere

Lithosphere

Solar System

Universe

DepthDepth

Span

(TIME) Years BP

~ 10E+03

~ 10E+04

~ 10E+05

~ 10E+06

~ 10E+07

~ 10E+08

~ 10E+09

~10E+20 ~10E+10 ~10E+5 ~10E+03 ~10E+02 -meters- ~10E-01 ~10E-02 ~10E-05 ~10E-10 ~10E-20

(Big Bang)

Energy Entropy

Early Societies

TribesClans

Heterotrophic Ecosystems

Climatic Systems

Oceans Lakes Rivers

Rocks Minerals

Planetary Systems

Stars Galaxies

Quasars Pulsars

Complex Neocortex

Neocortex-Limbic Systems

Organic CompoundsCells

Inorganic Compounds

Atoms-Molecules-Gases

Sub-Atomic Particles

EnergySource

(LR-UR ExternalPhysical Perspective)copy Brian Eddy PhD Cand

Water

ClimateFood

Bio-Genes

Psycho-Cultural-Social

Energy

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Reframe Sustainable Eco-Region

BioregionEnvironment Context

Resilience in the Systemlt100000 to 1750 +-

Living off

renewable food

Capital Seed

Grain

bull Interest = Daily Food Stores

bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Basket

ltResilience in the Systemgt1750 ndash 19xx

Living off large

part of

Renewables

Capital Seed

Grain

bull Interest = Food Stores

bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Bag

No Resilience in the System1960 +-

Living off Seed

Grain

Capital Seed

Grainbull Withdrawals =

Daily Shopping Cart

No Recovery in the System2000

Consuming

Capital Seed

Grain

Capital Seed

Grain =bull Withdrawals=

Daily Shopping Carts

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and

integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in

cities around the world The conceptual approach includes

consideration of different types of capital

Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation

Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations

Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence

Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT

Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience

Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust

Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management

The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it

has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types

of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City

Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh

Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City

4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce

City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS

Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism

Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre

LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml

Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2

Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2

Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa

Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel

region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml

Municipality

APPLICANTS

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria

1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved

Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework

Environment

Subjective

Internal

Individual

Inter-subjective

Internal Collective

Objective

External

Individual

Inter-

Objective

External

Collective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Environment

3 Human

2 Social

5 Culture

6 Political

7 Financial

4 Technical

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Holistic

approach ndash

which types

of capital are

part of the

initiative

And how

they are

involved

2 Object-

ives for

the

initiative

(long and

short

term)

3 Results

measured with

relevant KPIacutes

linked to the

different types

of capital and

both long and

short term

objectives

4 Level of

innovation for the

initiative - describe

the uniqueness or

why this initiative

adds new

knowledge

regarding creating

more sustainable

cities

5 Summary

of strategic

learnings

from the

initiative to

share

globally and

to inspire

other cities

SCORING SHEET

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

15 Points for for holistic approach

with points for capitals

represented

15

25

35

45

55

2 5 Points for Objectives

Short Term = 2

Long Term = 3

3 5 Points for KPI

Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be

specifically defined

My point scoring

4 5 Points for Level of Innovation

Slight improvement

Moderate improvement

Major improvement

Extends prior capabilitycapacity

exponentially

Never before done truly new

5 5 Points for Summary of

Strategic Learnings

Clear

Succinct

Strategic

Compelling

Inspiring

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)

983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day

in Jangji River

983803 Water quality

- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002

rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009

- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004

rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009

983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River

- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia

- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom

- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)

- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)

983803 Urban afforestation

- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)

- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)

- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average

(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for

bicycles)

983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)

983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)

Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)

Level

983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of

Seoul)

983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment

highest in all of Seoul

983803 Resident survey

- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)

- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)

Environmental

awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards

983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city

983803 Selected as Green City 2008

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

The objectives of the city council for 2012 are

1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself

by over 10

2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use

of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)

3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor

sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)

4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with

photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)

5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel

operated vehicles to local public transportation

6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in

municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers

7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of

energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and

students

Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy

Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at

httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of

1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining

forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity

Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR

(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy

Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings

planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)

Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui

River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin

(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey

(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-

tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon

(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line

(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities

sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less

smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a

clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon

monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions

and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5

separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil

(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every

six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the

garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in

Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

World Threats

Earth-Cosmos

Boundary

Human-Environment

Boundary

Civilization

Anthroposphere

Biosphere

Atmosphere

Hydrosphere

Lithosphere

Solar System

Universe

DepthDepth

Span

(TIME) Years BP

~ 10E+03

~ 10E+04

~ 10E+05

~ 10E+06

~ 10E+07

~ 10E+08

~ 10E+09

~10E+20 ~10E+10 ~10E+5 ~10E+03 ~10E+02 -meters- ~10E-01 ~10E-02 ~10E-05 ~10E-10 ~10E-20

(Big Bang)

Energy Entropy

Early Societies

TribesClans

Heterotrophic Ecosystems

Climatic Systems

Oceans Lakes Rivers

Rocks Minerals

Planetary Systems

Stars Galaxies

Quasars Pulsars

Complex Neocortex

Neocortex-Limbic Systems

Organic CompoundsCells

Inorganic Compounds

Atoms-Molecules-Gases

Sub-Atomic Particles

EnergySource

(LR-UR ExternalPhysical Perspective)copy Brian Eddy PhD Cand

Water

ClimateFood

Bio-Genes

Psycho-Cultural-Social

Energy

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Reframe Sustainable Eco-Region

BioregionEnvironment Context

Resilience in the Systemlt100000 to 1750 +-

Living off

renewable food

Capital Seed

Grain

bull Interest = Daily Food Stores

bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Basket

ltResilience in the Systemgt1750 ndash 19xx

Living off large

part of

Renewables

Capital Seed

Grain

bull Interest = Food Stores

bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Bag

No Resilience in the System1960 +-

Living off Seed

Grain

Capital Seed

Grainbull Withdrawals =

Daily Shopping Cart

No Recovery in the System2000

Consuming

Capital Seed

Grain

Capital Seed

Grain =bull Withdrawals=

Daily Shopping Carts

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and

integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in

cities around the world The conceptual approach includes

consideration of different types of capital

Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation

Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations

Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence

Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT

Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience

Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust

Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management

The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it

has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types

of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City

Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh

Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City

4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce

City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS

Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism

Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre

LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml

Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2

Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2

Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa

Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel

region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml

Municipality

APPLICANTS

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria

1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved

Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework

Environment

Subjective

Internal

Individual

Inter-subjective

Internal Collective

Objective

External

Individual

Inter-

Objective

External

Collective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Environment

3 Human

2 Social

5 Culture

6 Political

7 Financial

4 Technical

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Holistic

approach ndash

which types

of capital are

part of the

initiative

And how

they are

involved

2 Object-

ives for

the

initiative

(long and

short

term)

3 Results

measured with

relevant KPIacutes

linked to the

different types

of capital and

both long and

short term

objectives

4 Level of

innovation for the

initiative - describe

the uniqueness or

why this initiative

adds new

knowledge

regarding creating

more sustainable

cities

5 Summary

of strategic

learnings

from the

initiative to

share

globally and

to inspire

other cities

SCORING SHEET

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

15 Points for for holistic approach

with points for capitals

represented

15

25

35

45

55

2 5 Points for Objectives

Short Term = 2

Long Term = 3

3 5 Points for KPI

Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be

specifically defined

My point scoring

4 5 Points for Level of Innovation

Slight improvement

Moderate improvement

Major improvement

Extends prior capabilitycapacity

exponentially

Never before done truly new

5 5 Points for Summary of

Strategic Learnings

Clear

Succinct

Strategic

Compelling

Inspiring

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)

983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day

in Jangji River

983803 Water quality

- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002

rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009

- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004

rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009

983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River

- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia

- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom

- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)

- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)

983803 Urban afforestation

- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)

- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)

- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average

(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for

bicycles)

983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)

983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)

Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)

Level

983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of

Seoul)

983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment

highest in all of Seoul

983803 Resident survey

- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)

- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)

Environmental

awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards

983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city

983803 Selected as Green City 2008

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

The objectives of the city council for 2012 are

1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself

by over 10

2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use

of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)

3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor

sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)

4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with

photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)

5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel

operated vehicles to local public transportation

6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in

municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers

7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of

energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and

students

Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy

Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at

httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of

1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining

forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity

Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR

(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy

Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings

planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)

Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui

River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin

(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey

(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-

tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon

(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line

(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities

sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less

smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a

clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon

monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions

and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5

separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil

(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every

six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the

garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in

Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Reframe Sustainable Eco-Region

BioregionEnvironment Context

Resilience in the Systemlt100000 to 1750 +-

Living off

renewable food

Capital Seed

Grain

bull Interest = Daily Food Stores

bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Basket

ltResilience in the Systemgt1750 ndash 19xx

Living off large

part of

Renewables

Capital Seed

Grain

bull Interest = Food Stores

bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Bag

No Resilience in the System1960 +-

Living off Seed

Grain

Capital Seed

Grainbull Withdrawals =

Daily Shopping Cart

No Recovery in the System2000

Consuming

Capital Seed

Grain

Capital Seed

Grain =bull Withdrawals=

Daily Shopping Carts

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and

integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in

cities around the world The conceptual approach includes

consideration of different types of capital

Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation

Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations

Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence

Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT

Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience

Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust

Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management

The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it

has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types

of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City

Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh

Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City

4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce

City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS

Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism

Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre

LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml

Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2

Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2

Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa

Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel

region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml

Municipality

APPLICANTS

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria

1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved

Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework

Environment

Subjective

Internal

Individual

Inter-subjective

Internal Collective

Objective

External

Individual

Inter-

Objective

External

Collective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Environment

3 Human

2 Social

5 Culture

6 Political

7 Financial

4 Technical

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Holistic

approach ndash

which types

of capital are

part of the

initiative

And how

they are

involved

2 Object-

ives for

the

initiative

(long and

short

term)

3 Results

measured with

relevant KPIacutes

linked to the

different types

of capital and

both long and

short term

objectives

4 Level of

innovation for the

initiative - describe

the uniqueness or

why this initiative

adds new

knowledge

regarding creating

more sustainable

cities

5 Summary

of strategic

learnings

from the

initiative to

share

globally and

to inspire

other cities

SCORING SHEET

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

15 Points for for holistic approach

with points for capitals

represented

15

25

35

45

55

2 5 Points for Objectives

Short Term = 2

Long Term = 3

3 5 Points for KPI

Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be

specifically defined

My point scoring

4 5 Points for Level of Innovation

Slight improvement

Moderate improvement

Major improvement

Extends prior capabilitycapacity

exponentially

Never before done truly new

5 5 Points for Summary of

Strategic Learnings

Clear

Succinct

Strategic

Compelling

Inspiring

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)

983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day

in Jangji River

983803 Water quality

- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002

rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009

- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004

rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009

983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River

- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia

- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom

- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)

- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)

983803 Urban afforestation

- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)

- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)

- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average

(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for

bicycles)

983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)

983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)

Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)

Level

983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of

Seoul)

983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment

highest in all of Seoul

983803 Resident survey

- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)

- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)

Environmental

awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards

983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city

983803 Selected as Green City 2008

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

The objectives of the city council for 2012 are

1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself

by over 10

2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use

of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)

3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor

sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)

4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with

photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)

5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel

operated vehicles to local public transportation

6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in

municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers

7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of

energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and

students

Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy

Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at

httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of

1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining

forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity

Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR

(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy

Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings

planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)

Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui

River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin

(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey

(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-

tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon

(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line

(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities

sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less

smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a

clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon

monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions

and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5

separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil

(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every

six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the

garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in

Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Reframe Sustainable Eco-Region

BioregionEnvironment Context

Resilience in the Systemlt100000 to 1750 +-

Living off

renewable food

Capital Seed

Grain

bull Interest = Daily Food Stores

bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Basket

ltResilience in the Systemgt1750 ndash 19xx

Living off large

part of

Renewables

Capital Seed

Grain

bull Interest = Food Stores

bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Bag

No Resilience in the System1960 +-

Living off Seed

Grain

Capital Seed

Grainbull Withdrawals =

Daily Shopping Cart

No Recovery in the System2000

Consuming

Capital Seed

Grain

Capital Seed

Grain =bull Withdrawals=

Daily Shopping Carts

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and

integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in

cities around the world The conceptual approach includes

consideration of different types of capital

Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation

Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations

Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence

Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT

Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience

Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust

Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management

The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it

has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types

of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City

Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh

Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City

4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce

City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS

Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism

Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre

LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml

Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2

Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2

Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa

Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel

region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml

Municipality

APPLICANTS

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria

1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved

Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework

Environment

Subjective

Internal

Individual

Inter-subjective

Internal Collective

Objective

External

Individual

Inter-

Objective

External

Collective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Environment

3 Human

2 Social

5 Culture

6 Political

7 Financial

4 Technical

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Holistic

approach ndash

which types

of capital are

part of the

initiative

And how

they are

involved

2 Object-

ives for

the

initiative

(long and

short

term)

3 Results

measured with

relevant KPIacutes

linked to the

different types

of capital and

both long and

short term

objectives

4 Level of

innovation for the

initiative - describe

the uniqueness or

why this initiative

adds new

knowledge

regarding creating

more sustainable

cities

5 Summary

of strategic

learnings

from the

initiative to

share

globally and

to inspire

other cities

SCORING SHEET

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

15 Points for for holistic approach

with points for capitals

represented

15

25

35

45

55

2 5 Points for Objectives

Short Term = 2

Long Term = 3

3 5 Points for KPI

Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be

specifically defined

My point scoring

4 5 Points for Level of Innovation

Slight improvement

Moderate improvement

Major improvement

Extends prior capabilitycapacity

exponentially

Never before done truly new

5 5 Points for Summary of

Strategic Learnings

Clear

Succinct

Strategic

Compelling

Inspiring

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)

983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day

in Jangji River

983803 Water quality

- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002

rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009

- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004

rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009

983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River

- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia

- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom

- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)

- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)

983803 Urban afforestation

- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)

- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)

- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average

(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for

bicycles)

983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)

983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)

Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)

Level

983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of

Seoul)

983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment

highest in all of Seoul

983803 Resident survey

- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)

- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)

Environmental

awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards

983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city

983803 Selected as Green City 2008

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

The objectives of the city council for 2012 are

1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself

by over 10

2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use

of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)

3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor

sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)

4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with

photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)

5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel

operated vehicles to local public transportation

6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in

municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers

7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of

energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and

students

Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy

Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at

httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of

1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining

forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity

Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR

(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy

Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings

planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)

Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui

River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin

(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey

(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-

tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon

(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line

(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities

sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less

smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a

clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon

monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions

and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5

separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil

(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every

six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the

garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in

Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

Resilience in the Systemlt100000 to 1750 +-

Living off

renewable food

Capital Seed

Grain

bull Interest = Daily Food Stores

bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Basket

ltResilience in the Systemgt1750 ndash 19xx

Living off large

part of

Renewables

Capital Seed

Grain

bull Interest = Food Stores

bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Bag

No Resilience in the System1960 +-

Living off Seed

Grain

Capital Seed

Grainbull Withdrawals =

Daily Shopping Cart

No Recovery in the System2000

Consuming

Capital Seed

Grain

Capital Seed

Grain =bull Withdrawals=

Daily Shopping Carts

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and

integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in

cities around the world The conceptual approach includes

consideration of different types of capital

Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation

Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations

Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence

Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT

Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience

Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust

Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management

The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it

has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types

of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City

Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh

Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City

4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce

City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS

Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism

Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre

LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml

Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2

Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2

Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa

Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel

region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml

Municipality

APPLICANTS

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria

1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved

Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework

Environment

Subjective

Internal

Individual

Inter-subjective

Internal Collective

Objective

External

Individual

Inter-

Objective

External

Collective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Environment

3 Human

2 Social

5 Culture

6 Political

7 Financial

4 Technical

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Holistic

approach ndash

which types

of capital are

part of the

initiative

And how

they are

involved

2 Object-

ives for

the

initiative

(long and

short

term)

3 Results

measured with

relevant KPIacutes

linked to the

different types

of capital and

both long and

short term

objectives

4 Level of

innovation for the

initiative - describe

the uniqueness or

why this initiative

adds new

knowledge

regarding creating

more sustainable

cities

5 Summary

of strategic

learnings

from the

initiative to

share

globally and

to inspire

other cities

SCORING SHEET

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

15 Points for for holistic approach

with points for capitals

represented

15

25

35

45

55

2 5 Points for Objectives

Short Term = 2

Long Term = 3

3 5 Points for KPI

Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be

specifically defined

My point scoring

4 5 Points for Level of Innovation

Slight improvement

Moderate improvement

Major improvement

Extends prior capabilitycapacity

exponentially

Never before done truly new

5 5 Points for Summary of

Strategic Learnings

Clear

Succinct

Strategic

Compelling

Inspiring

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)

983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day

in Jangji River

983803 Water quality

- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002

rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009

- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004

rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009

983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River

- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia

- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom

- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)

- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)

983803 Urban afforestation

- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)

- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)

- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average

(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for

bicycles)

983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)

983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)

Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)

Level

983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of

Seoul)

983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment

highest in all of Seoul

983803 Resident survey

- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)

- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)

Environmental

awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards

983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city

983803 Selected as Green City 2008

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

The objectives of the city council for 2012 are

1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself

by over 10

2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use

of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)

3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor

sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)

4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with

photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)

5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel

operated vehicles to local public transportation

6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in

municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers

7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of

energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and

students

Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy

Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at

httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of

1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining

forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity

Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR

(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy

Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings

planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)

Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui

River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin

(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey

(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-

tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon

(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line

(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities

sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less

smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a

clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon

monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions

and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5

separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil

(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every

six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the

garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in

Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

ltResilience in the Systemgt1750 ndash 19xx

Living off large

part of

Renewables

Capital Seed

Grain

bull Interest = Food Stores

bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Bag

No Resilience in the System1960 +-

Living off Seed

Grain

Capital Seed

Grainbull Withdrawals =

Daily Shopping Cart

No Recovery in the System2000

Consuming

Capital Seed

Grain

Capital Seed

Grain =bull Withdrawals=

Daily Shopping Carts

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and

integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in

cities around the world The conceptual approach includes

consideration of different types of capital

Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation

Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations

Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence

Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT

Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience

Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust

Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management

The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it

has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types

of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City

Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh

Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City

4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce

City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS

Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism

Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre

LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml

Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2

Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2

Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa

Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel

region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml

Municipality

APPLICANTS

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria

1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved

Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework

Environment

Subjective

Internal

Individual

Inter-subjective

Internal Collective

Objective

External

Individual

Inter-

Objective

External

Collective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Environment

3 Human

2 Social

5 Culture

6 Political

7 Financial

4 Technical

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Holistic

approach ndash

which types

of capital are

part of the

initiative

And how

they are

involved

2 Object-

ives for

the

initiative

(long and

short

term)

3 Results

measured with

relevant KPIacutes

linked to the

different types

of capital and

both long and

short term

objectives

4 Level of

innovation for the

initiative - describe

the uniqueness or

why this initiative

adds new

knowledge

regarding creating

more sustainable

cities

5 Summary

of strategic

learnings

from the

initiative to

share

globally and

to inspire

other cities

SCORING SHEET

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

15 Points for for holistic approach

with points for capitals

represented

15

25

35

45

55

2 5 Points for Objectives

Short Term = 2

Long Term = 3

3 5 Points for KPI

Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be

specifically defined

My point scoring

4 5 Points for Level of Innovation

Slight improvement

Moderate improvement

Major improvement

Extends prior capabilitycapacity

exponentially

Never before done truly new

5 5 Points for Summary of

Strategic Learnings

Clear

Succinct

Strategic

Compelling

Inspiring

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)

983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day

in Jangji River

983803 Water quality

- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002

rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009

- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004

rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009

983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River

- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia

- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom

- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)

- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)

983803 Urban afforestation

- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)

- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)

- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average

(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for

bicycles)

983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)

983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)

Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)

Level

983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of

Seoul)

983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment

highest in all of Seoul

983803 Resident survey

- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)

- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)

Environmental

awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards

983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city

983803 Selected as Green City 2008

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

The objectives of the city council for 2012 are

1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself

by over 10

2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use

of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)

3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor

sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)

4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with

photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)

5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel

operated vehicles to local public transportation

6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in

municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers

7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of

energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and

students

Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy

Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at

httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of

1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining

forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity

Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR

(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy

Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings

planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)

Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui

River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin

(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey

(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-

tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon

(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line

(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities

sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less

smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a

clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon

monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions

and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5

separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil

(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every

six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the

garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in

Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

No Resilience in the System1960 +-

Living off Seed

Grain

Capital Seed

Grainbull Withdrawals =

Daily Shopping Cart

No Recovery in the System2000

Consuming

Capital Seed

Grain

Capital Seed

Grain =bull Withdrawals=

Daily Shopping Carts

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and

integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in

cities around the world The conceptual approach includes

consideration of different types of capital

Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation

Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations

Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence

Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT

Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience

Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust

Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management

The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it

has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types

of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City

Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh

Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City

4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce

City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS

Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism

Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre

LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml

Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2

Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2

Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa

Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel

region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml

Municipality

APPLICANTS

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria

1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved

Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework

Environment

Subjective

Internal

Individual

Inter-subjective

Internal Collective

Objective

External

Individual

Inter-

Objective

External

Collective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Environment

3 Human

2 Social

5 Culture

6 Political

7 Financial

4 Technical

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Holistic

approach ndash

which types

of capital are

part of the

initiative

And how

they are

involved

2 Object-

ives for

the

initiative

(long and

short

term)

3 Results

measured with

relevant KPIacutes

linked to the

different types

of capital and

both long and

short term

objectives

4 Level of

innovation for the

initiative - describe

the uniqueness or

why this initiative

adds new

knowledge

regarding creating

more sustainable

cities

5 Summary

of strategic

learnings

from the

initiative to

share

globally and

to inspire

other cities

SCORING SHEET

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

15 Points for for holistic approach

with points for capitals

represented

15

25

35

45

55

2 5 Points for Objectives

Short Term = 2

Long Term = 3

3 5 Points for KPI

Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be

specifically defined

My point scoring

4 5 Points for Level of Innovation

Slight improvement

Moderate improvement

Major improvement

Extends prior capabilitycapacity

exponentially

Never before done truly new

5 5 Points for Summary of

Strategic Learnings

Clear

Succinct

Strategic

Compelling

Inspiring

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)

983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day

in Jangji River

983803 Water quality

- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002

rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009

- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004

rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009

983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River

- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia

- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom

- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)

- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)

983803 Urban afforestation

- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)

- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)

- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average

(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for

bicycles)

983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)

983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)

Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)

Level

983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of

Seoul)

983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment

highest in all of Seoul

983803 Resident survey

- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)

- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)

Environmental

awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards

983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city

983803 Selected as Green City 2008

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

The objectives of the city council for 2012 are

1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself

by over 10

2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use

of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)

3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor

sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)

4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with

photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)

5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel

operated vehicles to local public transportation

6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in

municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers

7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of

energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and

students

Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy

Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at

httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of

1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining

forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity

Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR

(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy

Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings

planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)

Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui

River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin

(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey

(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-

tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon

(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line

(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities

sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less

smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a

clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon

monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions

and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5

separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil

(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every

six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the

garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in

Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

No Recovery in the System2000

Consuming

Capital Seed

Grain

Capital Seed

Grain =bull Withdrawals=

Daily Shopping Carts

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and

integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in

cities around the world The conceptual approach includes

consideration of different types of capital

Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation

Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations

Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence

Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT

Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience

Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust

Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management

The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it

has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types

of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City

Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh

Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City

4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce

City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS

Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism

Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre

LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml

Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2

Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2

Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa

Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel

region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml

Municipality

APPLICANTS

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria

1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved

Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework

Environment

Subjective

Internal

Individual

Inter-subjective

Internal Collective

Objective

External

Individual

Inter-

Objective

External

Collective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Environment

3 Human

2 Social

5 Culture

6 Political

7 Financial

4 Technical

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Holistic

approach ndash

which types

of capital are

part of the

initiative

And how

they are

involved

2 Object-

ives for

the

initiative

(long and

short

term)

3 Results

measured with

relevant KPIacutes

linked to the

different types

of capital and

both long and

short term

objectives

4 Level of

innovation for the

initiative - describe

the uniqueness or

why this initiative

adds new

knowledge

regarding creating

more sustainable

cities

5 Summary

of strategic

learnings

from the

initiative to

share

globally and

to inspire

other cities

SCORING SHEET

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

15 Points for for holistic approach

with points for capitals

represented

15

25

35

45

55

2 5 Points for Objectives

Short Term = 2

Long Term = 3

3 5 Points for KPI

Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be

specifically defined

My point scoring

4 5 Points for Level of Innovation

Slight improvement

Moderate improvement

Major improvement

Extends prior capabilitycapacity

exponentially

Never before done truly new

5 5 Points for Summary of

Strategic Learnings

Clear

Succinct

Strategic

Compelling

Inspiring

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)

983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day

in Jangji River

983803 Water quality

- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002

rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009

- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004

rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009

983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River

- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia

- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom

- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)

- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)

983803 Urban afforestation

- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)

- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)

- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average

(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for

bicycles)

983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)

983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)

Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)

Level

983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of

Seoul)

983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment

highest in all of Seoul

983803 Resident survey

- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)

- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)

Environmental

awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards

983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city

983803 Selected as Green City 2008

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

The objectives of the city council for 2012 are

1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself

by over 10

2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use

of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)

3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor

sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)

4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with

photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)

5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel

operated vehicles to local public transportation

6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in

municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers

7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of

energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and

students

Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy

Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at

httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of

1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining

forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity

Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR

(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy

Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings

planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)

Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui

River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin

(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey

(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-

tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon

(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line

(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities

sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less

smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a

clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon

monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions

and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5

separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil

(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every

six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the

garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in

Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and

integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in

cities around the world The conceptual approach includes

consideration of different types of capital

Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation

Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations

Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence

Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT

Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience

Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust

Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management

The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it

has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types

of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City

Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh

Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City

4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce

City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS

Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism

Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre

LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml

Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2

Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2

Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa

Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel

region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml

Municipality

APPLICANTS

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria

1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved

Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework

Environment

Subjective

Internal

Individual

Inter-subjective

Internal Collective

Objective

External

Individual

Inter-

Objective

External

Collective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Environment

3 Human

2 Social

5 Culture

6 Political

7 Financial

4 Technical

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Holistic

approach ndash

which types

of capital are

part of the

initiative

And how

they are

involved

2 Object-

ives for

the

initiative

(long and

short

term)

3 Results

measured with

relevant KPIacutes

linked to the

different types

of capital and

both long and

short term

objectives

4 Level of

innovation for the

initiative - describe

the uniqueness or

why this initiative

adds new

knowledge

regarding creating

more sustainable

cities

5 Summary

of strategic

learnings

from the

initiative to

share

globally and

to inspire

other cities

SCORING SHEET

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

15 Points for for holistic approach

with points for capitals

represented

15

25

35

45

55

2 5 Points for Objectives

Short Term = 2

Long Term = 3

3 5 Points for KPI

Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be

specifically defined

My point scoring

4 5 Points for Level of Innovation

Slight improvement

Moderate improvement

Major improvement

Extends prior capabilitycapacity

exponentially

Never before done truly new

5 5 Points for Summary of

Strategic Learnings

Clear

Succinct

Strategic

Compelling

Inspiring

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)

983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day

in Jangji River

983803 Water quality

- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002

rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009

- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004

rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009

983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River

- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia

- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom

- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)

- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)

983803 Urban afforestation

- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)

- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)

- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average

(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for

bicycles)

983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)

983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)

Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)

Level

983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of

Seoul)

983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment

highest in all of Seoul

983803 Resident survey

- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)

- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)

Environmental

awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards

983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city

983803 Selected as Green City 2008

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

The objectives of the city council for 2012 are

1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself

by over 10

2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use

of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)

3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor

sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)

4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with

photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)

5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel

operated vehicles to local public transportation

6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in

municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers

7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of

energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and

students

Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy

Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at

httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of

1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining

forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity

Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR

(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy

Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings

planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)

Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui

River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin

(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey

(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-

tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon

(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line

(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities

sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less

smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a

clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon

monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions

and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5

separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil

(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every

six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the

garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in

Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and

integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in

cities around the world The conceptual approach includes

consideration of different types of capital

Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation

Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations

Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence

Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT

Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience

Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust

Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management

The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it

has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types

of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City

Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh

Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City

4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce

City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS

Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism

Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre

LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml

Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2

Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2

Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa

Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel

region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml

Municipality

APPLICANTS

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria

1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved

Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework

Environment

Subjective

Internal

Individual

Inter-subjective

Internal Collective

Objective

External

Individual

Inter-

Objective

External

Collective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Environment

3 Human

2 Social

5 Culture

6 Political

7 Financial

4 Technical

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Holistic

approach ndash

which types

of capital are

part of the

initiative

And how

they are

involved

2 Object-

ives for

the

initiative

(long and

short

term)

3 Results

measured with

relevant KPIacutes

linked to the

different types

of capital and

both long and

short term

objectives

4 Level of

innovation for the

initiative - describe

the uniqueness or

why this initiative

adds new

knowledge

regarding creating

more sustainable

cities

5 Summary

of strategic

learnings

from the

initiative to

share

globally and

to inspire

other cities

SCORING SHEET

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

15 Points for for holistic approach

with points for capitals

represented

15

25

35

45

55

2 5 Points for Objectives

Short Term = 2

Long Term = 3

3 5 Points for KPI

Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be

specifically defined

My point scoring

4 5 Points for Level of Innovation

Slight improvement

Moderate improvement

Major improvement

Extends prior capabilitycapacity

exponentially

Never before done truly new

5 5 Points for Summary of

Strategic Learnings

Clear

Succinct

Strategic

Compelling

Inspiring

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)

983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day

in Jangji River

983803 Water quality

- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002

rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009

- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004

rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009

983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River

- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia

- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom

- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)

- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)

983803 Urban afforestation

- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)

- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)

- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average

(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for

bicycles)

983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)

983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)

Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)

Level

983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of

Seoul)

983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment

highest in all of Seoul

983803 Resident survey

- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)

- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)

Environmental

awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards

983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city

983803 Selected as Green City 2008

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

The objectives of the city council for 2012 are

1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself

by over 10

2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use

of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)

3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor

sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)

4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with

photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)

5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel

operated vehicles to local public transportation

6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in

municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers

7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of

energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and

students

Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy

Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at

httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of

1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining

forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity

Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR

(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy

Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings

planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)

Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui

River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin

(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey

(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-

tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon

(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line

(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities

sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less

smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a

clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon

monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions

and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5

separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil

(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every

six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the

garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in

Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and

integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in

cities around the world The conceptual approach includes

consideration of different types of capital

Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation

Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations

Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence

Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT

Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience

Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust

Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management

The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it

has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types

of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City

Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh

Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City

4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce

City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS

Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism

Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre

LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml

Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2

Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2

Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa

Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel

region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml

Municipality

APPLICANTS

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria

1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved

Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework

Environment

Subjective

Internal

Individual

Inter-subjective

Internal Collective

Objective

External

Individual

Inter-

Objective

External

Collective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Environment

3 Human

2 Social

5 Culture

6 Political

7 Financial

4 Technical

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Holistic

approach ndash

which types

of capital are

part of the

initiative

And how

they are

involved

2 Object-

ives for

the

initiative

(long and

short

term)

3 Results

measured with

relevant KPIacutes

linked to the

different types

of capital and

both long and

short term

objectives

4 Level of

innovation for the

initiative - describe

the uniqueness or

why this initiative

adds new

knowledge

regarding creating

more sustainable

cities

5 Summary

of strategic

learnings

from the

initiative to

share

globally and

to inspire

other cities

SCORING SHEET

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

15 Points for for holistic approach

with points for capitals

represented

15

25

35

45

55

2 5 Points for Objectives

Short Term = 2

Long Term = 3

3 5 Points for KPI

Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be

specifically defined

My point scoring

4 5 Points for Level of Innovation

Slight improvement

Moderate improvement

Major improvement

Extends prior capabilitycapacity

exponentially

Never before done truly new

5 5 Points for Summary of

Strategic Learnings

Clear

Succinct

Strategic

Compelling

Inspiring

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)

983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day

in Jangji River

983803 Water quality

- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002

rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009

- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004

rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009

983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River

- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia

- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom

- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)

- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)

983803 Urban afforestation

- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)

- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)

- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average

(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for

bicycles)

983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)

983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)

Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)

Level

983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of

Seoul)

983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment

highest in all of Seoul

983803 Resident survey

- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)

- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)

Environmental

awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards

983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city

983803 Selected as Green City 2008

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

The objectives of the city council for 2012 are

1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself

by over 10

2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use

of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)

3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor

sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)

4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with

photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)

5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel

operated vehicles to local public transportation

6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in

municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers

7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of

energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and

students

Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy

Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at

httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of

1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining

forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity

Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR

(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy

Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings

planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)

Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui

River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin

(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey

(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-

tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon

(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line

(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities

sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less

smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a

clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon

monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions

and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5

separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil

(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every

six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the

garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in

Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and

integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in

cities around the world The conceptual approach includes

consideration of different types of capital

Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation

Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations

Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence

Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT

Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience

Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust

Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management

The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it

has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types

of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City

Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh

Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City

4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce

City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS

Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism

Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre

LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml

Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2

Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2

Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa

Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel

region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml

Municipality

APPLICANTS

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria

1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved

Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework

Environment

Subjective

Internal

Individual

Inter-subjective

Internal Collective

Objective

External

Individual

Inter-

Objective

External

Collective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Environment

3 Human

2 Social

5 Culture

6 Political

7 Financial

4 Technical

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Holistic

approach ndash

which types

of capital are

part of the

initiative

And how

they are

involved

2 Object-

ives for

the

initiative

(long and

short

term)

3 Results

measured with

relevant KPIacutes

linked to the

different types

of capital and

both long and

short term

objectives

4 Level of

innovation for the

initiative - describe

the uniqueness or

why this initiative

adds new

knowledge

regarding creating

more sustainable

cities

5 Summary

of strategic

learnings

from the

initiative to

share

globally and

to inspire

other cities

SCORING SHEET

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

15 Points for for holistic approach

with points for capitals

represented

15

25

35

45

55

2 5 Points for Objectives

Short Term = 2

Long Term = 3

3 5 Points for KPI

Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be

specifically defined

My point scoring

4 5 Points for Level of Innovation

Slight improvement

Moderate improvement

Major improvement

Extends prior capabilitycapacity

exponentially

Never before done truly new

5 5 Points for Summary of

Strategic Learnings

Clear

Succinct

Strategic

Compelling

Inspiring

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)

983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day

in Jangji River

983803 Water quality

- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002

rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009

- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004

rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009

983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River

- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia

- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom

- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)

- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)

983803 Urban afforestation

- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)

- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)

- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average

(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for

bicycles)

983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)

983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)

Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)

Level

983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of

Seoul)

983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment

highest in all of Seoul

983803 Resident survey

- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)

- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)

Environmental

awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards

983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city

983803 Selected as Green City 2008

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

The objectives of the city council for 2012 are

1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself

by over 10

2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use

of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)

3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor

sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)

4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with

photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)

5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel

operated vehicles to local public transportation

6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in

municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers

7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of

energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and

students

Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy

Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at

httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of

1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining

forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity

Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR

(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy

Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings

planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)

Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui

River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin

(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey

(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-

tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon

(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line

(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities

sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less

smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a

clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon

monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions

and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5

separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil

(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every

six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the

garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in

Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and

integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in

cities around the world The conceptual approach includes

consideration of different types of capital

Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation

Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations

Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence

Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT

Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience

Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust

Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management

The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it

has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types

of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City

Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh

Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City

4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce

City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS

Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism

Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre

LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml

Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2

Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2

Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa

Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel

region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml

Municipality

APPLICANTS

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria

1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved

Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework

Environment

Subjective

Internal

Individual

Inter-subjective

Internal Collective

Objective

External

Individual

Inter-

Objective

External

Collective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Environment

3 Human

2 Social

5 Culture

6 Political

7 Financial

4 Technical

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Holistic

approach ndash

which types

of capital are

part of the

initiative

And how

they are

involved

2 Object-

ives for

the

initiative

(long and

short

term)

3 Results

measured with

relevant KPIacutes

linked to the

different types

of capital and

both long and

short term

objectives

4 Level of

innovation for the

initiative - describe

the uniqueness or

why this initiative

adds new

knowledge

regarding creating

more sustainable

cities

5 Summary

of strategic

learnings

from the

initiative to

share

globally and

to inspire

other cities

SCORING SHEET

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

15 Points for for holistic approach

with points for capitals

represented

15

25

35

45

55

2 5 Points for Objectives

Short Term = 2

Long Term = 3

3 5 Points for KPI

Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be

specifically defined

My point scoring

4 5 Points for Level of Innovation

Slight improvement

Moderate improvement

Major improvement

Extends prior capabilitycapacity

exponentially

Never before done truly new

5 5 Points for Summary of

Strategic Learnings

Clear

Succinct

Strategic

Compelling

Inspiring

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)

983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day

in Jangji River

983803 Water quality

- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002

rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009

- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004

rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009

983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River

- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia

- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom

- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)

- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)

983803 Urban afforestation

- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)

- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)

- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average

(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for

bicycles)

983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)

983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)

Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)

Level

983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of

Seoul)

983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment

highest in all of Seoul

983803 Resident survey

- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)

- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)

Environmental

awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards

983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city

983803 Selected as Green City 2008

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

The objectives of the city council for 2012 are

1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself

by over 10

2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use

of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)

3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor

sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)

4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with

photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)

5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel

operated vehicles to local public transportation

6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in

municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers

7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of

energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and

students

Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy

Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at

httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of

1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining

forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity

Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR

(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy

Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings

planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)

Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui

River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin

(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey

(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-

tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon

(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line

(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities

sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less

smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a

clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon

monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions

and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5

separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil

(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every

six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the

garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in

Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City

Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh

Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City

4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce

City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS

Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism

Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre

LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml

Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2

Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2

Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa

Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel

region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml

Municipality

APPLICANTS

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria

1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved

Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework

Environment

Subjective

Internal

Individual

Inter-subjective

Internal Collective

Objective

External

Individual

Inter-

Objective

External

Collective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Environment

3 Human

2 Social

5 Culture

6 Political

7 Financial

4 Technical

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Holistic

approach ndash

which types

of capital are

part of the

initiative

And how

they are

involved

2 Object-

ives for

the

initiative

(long and

short

term)

3 Results

measured with

relevant KPIacutes

linked to the

different types

of capital and

both long and

short term

objectives

4 Level of

innovation for the

initiative - describe

the uniqueness or

why this initiative

adds new

knowledge

regarding creating

more sustainable

cities

5 Summary

of strategic

learnings

from the

initiative to

share

globally and

to inspire

other cities

SCORING SHEET

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

15 Points for for holistic approach

with points for capitals

represented

15

25

35

45

55

2 5 Points for Objectives

Short Term = 2

Long Term = 3

3 5 Points for KPI

Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be

specifically defined

My point scoring

4 5 Points for Level of Innovation

Slight improvement

Moderate improvement

Major improvement

Extends prior capabilitycapacity

exponentially

Never before done truly new

5 5 Points for Summary of

Strategic Learnings

Clear

Succinct

Strategic

Compelling

Inspiring

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)

983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day

in Jangji River

983803 Water quality

- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002

rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009

- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004

rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009

983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River

- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia

- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom

- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)

- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)

983803 Urban afforestation

- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)

- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)

- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average

(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for

bicycles)

983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)

983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)

Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)

Level

983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of

Seoul)

983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment

highest in all of Seoul

983803 Resident survey

- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)

- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)

Environmental

awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards

983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city

983803 Selected as Green City 2008

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

The objectives of the city council for 2012 are

1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself

by over 10

2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use

of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)

3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor

sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)

4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with

photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)

5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel

operated vehicles to local public transportation

6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in

municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers

7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of

energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and

students

Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy

Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at

httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of

1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining

forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity

Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR

(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy

Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings

planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)

Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui

River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin

(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey

(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-

tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon

(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line

(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities

sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less

smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a

clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon

monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions

and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5

separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil

(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every

six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the

garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in

Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City

Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh

Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City

4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce

City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS

Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism

Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre

LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml

Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2

Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2

Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa

Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel

region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml

Municipality

APPLICANTS

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria

1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved

Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework

Environment

Subjective

Internal

Individual

Inter-subjective

Internal Collective

Objective

External

Individual

Inter-

Objective

External

Collective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Environment

3 Human

2 Social

5 Culture

6 Political

7 Financial

4 Technical

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Holistic

approach ndash

which types

of capital are

part of the

initiative

And how

they are

involved

2 Object-

ives for

the

initiative

(long and

short

term)

3 Results

measured with

relevant KPIacutes

linked to the

different types

of capital and

both long and

short term

objectives

4 Level of

innovation for the

initiative - describe

the uniqueness or

why this initiative

adds new

knowledge

regarding creating

more sustainable

cities

5 Summary

of strategic

learnings

from the

initiative to

share

globally and

to inspire

other cities

SCORING SHEET

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

15 Points for for holistic approach

with points for capitals

represented

15

25

35

45

55

2 5 Points for Objectives

Short Term = 2

Long Term = 3

3 5 Points for KPI

Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be

specifically defined

My point scoring

4 5 Points for Level of Innovation

Slight improvement

Moderate improvement

Major improvement

Extends prior capabilitycapacity

exponentially

Never before done truly new

5 5 Points for Summary of

Strategic Learnings

Clear

Succinct

Strategic

Compelling

Inspiring

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)

983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day

in Jangji River

983803 Water quality

- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002

rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009

- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004

rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009

983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River

- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia

- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom

- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)

- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)

983803 Urban afforestation

- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)

- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)

- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average

(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for

bicycles)

983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)

983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)

Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)

Level

983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of

Seoul)

983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment

highest in all of Seoul

983803 Resident survey

- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)

- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)

Environmental

awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards

983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city

983803 Selected as Green City 2008

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

The objectives of the city council for 2012 are

1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself

by over 10

2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use

of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)

3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor

sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)

4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with

photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)

5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel

operated vehicles to local public transportation

6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in

municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers

7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of

energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and

students

Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy

Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at

httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of

1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining

forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity

Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR

(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy

Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings

planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)

Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui

River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin

(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey

(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-

tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon

(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line

(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities

sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less

smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a

clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon

monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions

and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5

separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil

(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every

six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the

garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in

Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria

1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved

Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework

Environment

Subjective

Internal

Individual

Inter-subjective

Internal Collective

Objective

External

Individual

Inter-

Objective

External

Collective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Environment

3 Human

2 Social

5 Culture

6 Political

7 Financial

4 Technical

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Holistic

approach ndash

which types

of capital are

part of the

initiative

And how

they are

involved

2 Object-

ives for

the

initiative

(long and

short

term)

3 Results

measured with

relevant KPIacutes

linked to the

different types

of capital and

both long and

short term

objectives

4 Level of

innovation for the

initiative - describe

the uniqueness or

why this initiative

adds new

knowledge

regarding creating

more sustainable

cities

5 Summary

of strategic

learnings

from the

initiative to

share

globally and

to inspire

other cities

SCORING SHEET

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

15 Points for for holistic approach

with points for capitals

represented

15

25

35

45

55

2 5 Points for Objectives

Short Term = 2

Long Term = 3

3 5 Points for KPI

Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be

specifically defined

My point scoring

4 5 Points for Level of Innovation

Slight improvement

Moderate improvement

Major improvement

Extends prior capabilitycapacity

exponentially

Never before done truly new

5 5 Points for Summary of

Strategic Learnings

Clear

Succinct

Strategic

Compelling

Inspiring

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)

983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day

in Jangji River

983803 Water quality

- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002

rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009

- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004

rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009

983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River

- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia

- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom

- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)

- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)

983803 Urban afforestation

- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)

- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)

- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average

(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for

bicycles)

983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)

983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)

Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)

Level

983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of

Seoul)

983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment

highest in all of Seoul

983803 Resident survey

- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)

- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)

Environmental

awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards

983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city

983803 Selected as Green City 2008

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

The objectives of the city council for 2012 are

1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself

by over 10

2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use

of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)

3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor

sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)

4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with

photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)

5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel

operated vehicles to local public transportation

6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in

municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers

7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of

energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and

students

Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy

Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at

httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of

1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining

forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity

Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR

(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy

Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings

planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)

Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui

River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin

(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey

(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-

tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon

(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line

(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities

sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less

smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a

clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon

monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions

and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5

separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil

(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every

six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the

garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in

Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Environment

3 Human

2 Social

5 Culture

6 Political

7 Financial

4 Technical

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Holistic

approach ndash

which types

of capital are

part of the

initiative

And how

they are

involved

2 Object-

ives for

the

initiative

(long and

short

term)

3 Results

measured with

relevant KPIacutes

linked to the

different types

of capital and

both long and

short term

objectives

4 Level of

innovation for the

initiative - describe

the uniqueness or

why this initiative

adds new

knowledge

regarding creating

more sustainable

cities

5 Summary

of strategic

learnings

from the

initiative to

share

globally and

to inspire

other cities

SCORING SHEET

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

15 Points for for holistic approach

with points for capitals

represented

15

25

35

45

55

2 5 Points for Objectives

Short Term = 2

Long Term = 3

3 5 Points for KPI

Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be

specifically defined

My point scoring

4 5 Points for Level of Innovation

Slight improvement

Moderate improvement

Major improvement

Extends prior capabilitycapacity

exponentially

Never before done truly new

5 5 Points for Summary of

Strategic Learnings

Clear

Succinct

Strategic

Compelling

Inspiring

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)

983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day

in Jangji River

983803 Water quality

- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002

rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009

- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004

rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009

983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River

- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia

- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom

- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)

- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)

983803 Urban afforestation

- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)

- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)

- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average

(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for

bicycles)

983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)

983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)

Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)

Level

983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of

Seoul)

983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment

highest in all of Seoul

983803 Resident survey

- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)

- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)

Environmental

awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards

983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city

983803 Selected as Green City 2008

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

The objectives of the city council for 2012 are

1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself

by over 10

2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use

of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)

3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor

sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)

4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with

photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)

5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel

operated vehicles to local public transportation

6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in

municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers

7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of

energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and

students

Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy

Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at

httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of

1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining

forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity

Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR

(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy

Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings

planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)

Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui

River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin

(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey

(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-

tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon

(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line

(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities

sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less

smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a

clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon

monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions

and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5

separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil

(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every

six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the

garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in

Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Holistic

approach ndash

which types

of capital are

part of the

initiative

And how

they are

involved

2 Object-

ives for

the

initiative

(long and

short

term)

3 Results

measured with

relevant KPIacutes

linked to the

different types

of capital and

both long and

short term

objectives

4 Level of

innovation for the

initiative - describe

the uniqueness or

why this initiative

adds new

knowledge

regarding creating

more sustainable

cities

5 Summary

of strategic

learnings

from the

initiative to

share

globally and

to inspire

other cities

SCORING SHEET

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

15 Points for for holistic approach

with points for capitals

represented

15

25

35

45

55

2 5 Points for Objectives

Short Term = 2

Long Term = 3

3 5 Points for KPI

Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be

specifically defined

My point scoring

4 5 Points for Level of Innovation

Slight improvement

Moderate improvement

Major improvement

Extends prior capabilitycapacity

exponentially

Never before done truly new

5 5 Points for Summary of

Strategic Learnings

Clear

Succinct

Strategic

Compelling

Inspiring

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)

983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day

in Jangji River

983803 Water quality

- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002

rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009

- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004

rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009

983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River

- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia

- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom

- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)

- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)

983803 Urban afforestation

- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)

- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)

- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average

(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for

bicycles)

983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)

983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)

Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)

Level

983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of

Seoul)

983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment

highest in all of Seoul

983803 Resident survey

- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)

- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)

Environmental

awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards

983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city

983803 Selected as Green City 2008

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

The objectives of the city council for 2012 are

1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself

by over 10

2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use

of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)

3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor

sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)

4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with

photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)

5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel

operated vehicles to local public transportation

6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in

municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers

7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of

energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and

students

Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy

Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at

httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of

1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining

forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity

Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR

(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy

Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings

planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)

Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui

River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin

(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey

(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-

tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon

(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line

(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities

sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less

smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a

clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon

monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions

and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5

separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil

(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every

six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the

garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in

Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 Holistic

approach ndash

which types

of capital are

part of the

initiative

And how

they are

involved

2 Object-

ives for

the

initiative

(long and

short

term)

3 Results

measured with

relevant KPIacutes

linked to the

different types

of capital and

both long and

short term

objectives

4 Level of

innovation for the

initiative - describe

the uniqueness or

why this initiative

adds new

knowledge

regarding creating

more sustainable

cities

5 Summary

of strategic

learnings

from the

initiative to

share

globally and

to inspire

other cities

SCORING SHEET

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

15 Points for for holistic approach

with points for capitals

represented

15

25

35

45

55

2 5 Points for Objectives

Short Term = 2

Long Term = 3

3 5 Points for KPI

Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be

specifically defined

My point scoring

4 5 Points for Level of Innovation

Slight improvement

Moderate improvement

Major improvement

Extends prior capabilitycapacity

exponentially

Never before done truly new

5 5 Points for Summary of

Strategic Learnings

Clear

Succinct

Strategic

Compelling

Inspiring

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)

983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day

in Jangji River

983803 Water quality

- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002

rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009

- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004

rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009

983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River

- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia

- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom

- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)

- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)

983803 Urban afforestation

- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)

- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)

- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average

(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for

bicycles)

983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)

983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)

Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)

Level

983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of

Seoul)

983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment

highest in all of Seoul

983803 Resident survey

- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)

- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)

Environmental

awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards

983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city

983803 Selected as Green City 2008

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

The objectives of the city council for 2012 are

1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself

by over 10

2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use

of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)

3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor

sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)

4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with

photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)

5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel

operated vehicles to local public transportation

6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in

municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers

7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of

energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and

students

Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy

Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at

httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of

1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining

forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity

Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR

(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy

Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings

planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)

Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui

River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin

(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey

(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-

tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon

(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line

(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities

sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less

smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a

clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon

monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions

and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5

separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil

(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every

six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the

garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in

Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

15 Points for for holistic approach

with points for capitals

represented

15

25

35

45

55

2 5 Points for Objectives

Short Term = 2

Long Term = 3

3 5 Points for KPI

Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be

specifically defined

My point scoring

4 5 Points for Level of Innovation

Slight improvement

Moderate improvement

Major improvement

Extends prior capabilitycapacity

exponentially

Never before done truly new

5 5 Points for Summary of

Strategic Learnings

Clear

Succinct

Strategic

Compelling

Inspiring

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)

983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day

in Jangji River

983803 Water quality

- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002

rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009

- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004

rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009

983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River

- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia

- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom

- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)

- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)

983803 Urban afforestation

- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)

- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)

- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average

(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for

bicycles)

983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)

983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)

Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)

Level

983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of

Seoul)

983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment

highest in all of Seoul

983803 Resident survey

- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)

- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)

Environmental

awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards

983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city

983803 Selected as Green City 2008

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

The objectives of the city council for 2012 are

1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself

by over 10

2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use

of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)

3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor

sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)

4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with

photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)

5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel

operated vehicles to local public transportation

6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in

municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers

7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of

energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and

students

Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy

Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at

httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of

1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining

forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity

Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR

(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy

Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings

planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)

Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui

River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin

(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey

(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-

tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon

(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line

(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities

sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less

smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a

clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon

monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions

and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5

separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil

(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every

six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the

garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in

Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)

983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day

in Jangji River

983803 Water quality

- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002

rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009

- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004

rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009

983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River

- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia

- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom

- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)

- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)

983803 Urban afforestation

- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)

- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)

- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average

(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for

bicycles)

983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)

983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)

Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)

Level

983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of

Seoul)

983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment

highest in all of Seoul

983803 Resident survey

- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)

- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)

Environmental

awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards

983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city

983803 Selected as Green City 2008

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

The objectives of the city council for 2012 are

1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself

by over 10

2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use

of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)

3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor

sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)

4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with

photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)

5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel

operated vehicles to local public transportation

6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in

municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers

7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of

energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and

students

Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy

Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at

httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of

1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining

forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity

Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR

(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy

Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings

planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)

Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui

River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin

(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey

(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-

tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon

(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line

(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities

sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less

smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a

clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon

monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions

and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5

separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil

(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every

six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the

garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in

Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for

bicycles)

983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)

983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)

Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)

Level

983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of

Seoul)

983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment

highest in all of Seoul

983803 Resident survey

- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)

- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)

Environmental

awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards

983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city

983803 Selected as Green City 2008

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

The objectives of the city council for 2012 are

1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself

by over 10

2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use

of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)

3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor

sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)

4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with

photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)

5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel

operated vehicles to local public transportation

6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in

municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers

7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of

energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and

students

Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy

Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at

httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of

1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining

forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity

Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR

(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy

Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings

planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)

Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui

River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin

(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey

(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-

tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon

(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line

(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities

sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less

smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a

clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon

monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions

and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5

separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil

(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every

six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the

garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in

Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

The objectives of the city council for 2012 are

1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself

by over 10

2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use

of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)

3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor

sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)

4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with

photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)

5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel

operated vehicles to local public transportation

6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in

municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers

7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of

energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and

students

Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy

Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at

httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of

1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining

forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity

Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR

(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy

Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings

planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)

Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui

River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin

(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey

(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-

tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon

(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line

(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities

sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less

smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a

clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon

monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions

and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5

separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil

(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every

six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the

garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in

Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPI

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of

1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining

forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity

Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR

(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy

Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings

planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)

Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui

River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin

(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey

(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-

tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon

(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line

(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities

sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less

smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a

clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon

monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions

and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5

separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil

(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every

six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the

garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in

Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of

1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining

forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity

Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR

(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy

Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings

planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)

Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui

River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin

(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey

(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-

tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon

(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line

(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities

sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less

smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a

clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon

monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions

and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5

separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil

(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every

six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the

garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in

Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Identify one community that best embodies the

fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and

enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for

the investment made

Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of

community impact rather than high economic investment

Sustainable Community Award

2010

With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A community is a social group whose

members reside in a specific locality are

administered by some form of common

local governance or inherent political

structure interact economically and

socially and often have a common

cultural geographic and historical

heritage Communities are expected to

exceed populations of 100000

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Traditional View of Sustainable Development

Economy

SocialEnvironment

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Most definitions of sustainability encompass three

fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the

interconnectedness of social environmental and economic

considerations and equity in access to resources The

predominant definition of sustainable development comes

from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development

is development that meets the needs of the present without

compromising the ability of future generations to meet their

own needs

World Commission on Environment and Development Our

Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University

Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the

Brundtland Report)

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

3 Human amp Intellectual Captital

2 Social Capital

5 Culture amp Leisure

6 Political Capital

7 Financial Capital

4 Technical amp

Infrastructure Capital

4 Quadrant Map

Subjective Objective

Intersubjective Interobjective

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

A sustainable community demonstrates significant

progress towards four fundamental aspects

Society ndash Is the community developing strong and

harmonious relationships between people communities

regions and nations

Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in

balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of

ecosystems

Economy ndash Does the community create equitable

opportunities for all Are basic services met

Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied

sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations

and planning

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport

systems in existing urban areas including social housing

2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks

into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations

3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including

approaches such as integral coaching

4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership

5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local

regional national and global levels

6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity

through green growth

7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge

biology nanotech and genomics

8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including

green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches

9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and

education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing

10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart

grids to intelligent transport systems

RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

City

Community

4 Quadrant

8 Levels of Complexity

Map of

Capacities

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves

2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Great St ops Improves

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter

All

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Values

C

ho

ice

Well Not Better

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=216

000

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Interns Survey

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

Thought Leaders

Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter

n=12

-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise

Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford

copy Integral City Meshworks Inc

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into

how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of

the city

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Combo of 234

Petals =

6

How CityCommunity Measures Capacity

53

11

13

16

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

How CityCommunity Allocates Resources

76

9 gt3

12

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough

What is an

evolutionary

perspective on

Food Life

Resilience

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)

Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive

Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997

P

O

T

E

N

T

I

A

L

connections

+

+

3 Gen Z

Artists

2 Gen Y Young

Adults Heros

1 Gen X

Midlife

Nomads

4 Boomer

Elders

Prophets

3 Silents

Artists

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

Resilience in the System2010+

Live off renewable

interest = Food

Energy

Renewables

Capital = Gaia

bull Interest = Renewables

bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place

copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA

Master Rule

Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place