marilyn hamilton - sustainable cities & eco regions food for thought may 27
DESCRIPTION
TRANSCRIPT
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Glocal Food for Thought
Sustaining Cities amp Eco-Regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Bee Hive Energy Resilient
Conformity Enforcers
Diversity Generators
Inner Judges
Resource Shifters
Intragroup Competitors
Sustain Hive amp Eco-Region
ORG PURPOSE = 40 LB HONEYYR
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
World Threats
Earth-Cosmos
Boundary
Human-Environment
Boundary
Civilization
Anthroposphere
Biosphere
Atmosphere
Hydrosphere
Lithosphere
Solar System
Universe
DepthDepth
Span
(TIME) Years BP
~ 10E+03
~ 10E+04
~ 10E+05
~ 10E+06
~ 10E+07
~ 10E+08
~ 10E+09
~10E+20 ~10E+10 ~10E+5 ~10E+03 ~10E+02 -meters- ~10E-01 ~10E-02 ~10E-05 ~10E-10 ~10E-20
(Big Bang)
Energy Entropy
Early Societies
TribesClans
Heterotrophic Ecosystems
Climatic Systems
Oceans Lakes Rivers
Rocks Minerals
Planetary Systems
Stars Galaxies
Quasars Pulsars
Complex Neocortex
Neocortex-Limbic Systems
Organic CompoundsCells
Inorganic Compounds
Atoms-Molecules-Gases
Sub-Atomic Particles
EnergySource
(LR-UR ExternalPhysical Perspective)copy Brian Eddy PhD Cand
Water
ClimateFood
Bio-Genes
Psycho-Cultural-Social
Energy
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Reframe Sustainable Eco-Region
BioregionEnvironment Context
Resilience in the Systemlt100000 to 1750 +-
Living off
renewable food
Capital Seed
Grain
bull Interest = Daily Food Stores
bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Basket
ltResilience in the Systemgt1750 ndash 19xx
Living off large
part of
Renewables
Capital Seed
Grain
bull Interest = Food Stores
bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Bag
No Resilience in the System1960 +-
Living off Seed
Grain
Capital Seed
Grainbull Withdrawals =
Daily Shopping Cart
No Recovery in the System2000
Consuming
Capital Seed
Grain
Capital Seed
Grain =bull Withdrawals=
Daily Shopping Carts
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and
integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in
cities around the world The conceptual approach includes
consideration of different types of capital
Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation
Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations
Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence
Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT
Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience
Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust
Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management
The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it
has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types
of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City
Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh
Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City
4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce
City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS
Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism
Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre
LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml
Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2
Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2
Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa
Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel
region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml
Municipality
APPLICANTS
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria
1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved
Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework
Environment
Subjective
Internal
Individual
Inter-subjective
Internal Collective
Objective
External
Individual
Inter-
Objective
External
Collective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Environment
3 Human
2 Social
5 Culture
6 Political
7 Financial
4 Technical
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Holistic
approach ndash
which types
of capital are
part of the
initiative
And how
they are
involved
2 Object-
ives for
the
initiative
(long and
short
term)
3 Results
measured with
relevant KPIacutes
linked to the
different types
of capital and
both long and
short term
objectives
4 Level of
innovation for the
initiative - describe
the uniqueness or
why this initiative
adds new
knowledge
regarding creating
more sustainable
cities
5 Summary
of strategic
learnings
from the
initiative to
share
globally and
to inspire
other cities
SCORING SHEET
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
15 Points for for holistic approach
with points for capitals
represented
15
25
35
45
55
2 5 Points for Objectives
Short Term = 2
Long Term = 3
3 5 Points for KPI
Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be
specifically defined
My point scoring
4 5 Points for Level of Innovation
Slight improvement
Moderate improvement
Major improvement
Extends prior capabilitycapacity
exponentially
Never before done truly new
5 5 Points for Summary of
Strategic Learnings
Clear
Succinct
Strategic
Compelling
Inspiring
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)
983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day
in Jangji River
983803 Water quality
- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002
rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009
- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004
rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009
983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River
- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia
- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom
- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)
- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)
983803 Urban afforestation
- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)
- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)
- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average
(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for
bicycles)
983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)
983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)
Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)
Level
983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of
Seoul)
983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment
highest in all of Seoul
983803 Resident survey
- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)
- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)
Environmental
awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards
983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city
983803 Selected as Green City 2008
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
The objectives of the city council for 2012 are
1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself
by over 10
2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use
of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)
3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor
sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)
4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with
photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)
5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel
operated vehicles to local public transportation
6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in
municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers
7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of
energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and
students
Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy
Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at
httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of
1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining
forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity
Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR
(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy
Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings
planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)
Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui
River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin
(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey
(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-
tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon
(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line
(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities
sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less
smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a
clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon
monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions
and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5
separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil
(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every
six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the
garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in
Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Bee Hive Energy Resilient
Conformity Enforcers
Diversity Generators
Inner Judges
Resource Shifters
Intragroup Competitors
Sustain Hive amp Eco-Region
ORG PURPOSE = 40 LB HONEYYR
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
World Threats
Earth-Cosmos
Boundary
Human-Environment
Boundary
Civilization
Anthroposphere
Biosphere
Atmosphere
Hydrosphere
Lithosphere
Solar System
Universe
DepthDepth
Span
(TIME) Years BP
~ 10E+03
~ 10E+04
~ 10E+05
~ 10E+06
~ 10E+07
~ 10E+08
~ 10E+09
~10E+20 ~10E+10 ~10E+5 ~10E+03 ~10E+02 -meters- ~10E-01 ~10E-02 ~10E-05 ~10E-10 ~10E-20
(Big Bang)
Energy Entropy
Early Societies
TribesClans
Heterotrophic Ecosystems
Climatic Systems
Oceans Lakes Rivers
Rocks Minerals
Planetary Systems
Stars Galaxies
Quasars Pulsars
Complex Neocortex
Neocortex-Limbic Systems
Organic CompoundsCells
Inorganic Compounds
Atoms-Molecules-Gases
Sub-Atomic Particles
EnergySource
(LR-UR ExternalPhysical Perspective)copy Brian Eddy PhD Cand
Water
ClimateFood
Bio-Genes
Psycho-Cultural-Social
Energy
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Reframe Sustainable Eco-Region
BioregionEnvironment Context
Resilience in the Systemlt100000 to 1750 +-
Living off
renewable food
Capital Seed
Grain
bull Interest = Daily Food Stores
bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Basket
ltResilience in the Systemgt1750 ndash 19xx
Living off large
part of
Renewables
Capital Seed
Grain
bull Interest = Food Stores
bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Bag
No Resilience in the System1960 +-
Living off Seed
Grain
Capital Seed
Grainbull Withdrawals =
Daily Shopping Cart
No Recovery in the System2000
Consuming
Capital Seed
Grain
Capital Seed
Grain =bull Withdrawals=
Daily Shopping Carts
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and
integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in
cities around the world The conceptual approach includes
consideration of different types of capital
Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation
Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations
Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence
Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT
Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience
Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust
Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management
The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it
has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types
of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City
Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh
Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City
4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce
City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS
Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism
Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre
LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml
Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2
Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2
Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa
Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel
region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml
Municipality
APPLICANTS
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria
1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved
Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework
Environment
Subjective
Internal
Individual
Inter-subjective
Internal Collective
Objective
External
Individual
Inter-
Objective
External
Collective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Environment
3 Human
2 Social
5 Culture
6 Political
7 Financial
4 Technical
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Holistic
approach ndash
which types
of capital are
part of the
initiative
And how
they are
involved
2 Object-
ives for
the
initiative
(long and
short
term)
3 Results
measured with
relevant KPIacutes
linked to the
different types
of capital and
both long and
short term
objectives
4 Level of
innovation for the
initiative - describe
the uniqueness or
why this initiative
adds new
knowledge
regarding creating
more sustainable
cities
5 Summary
of strategic
learnings
from the
initiative to
share
globally and
to inspire
other cities
SCORING SHEET
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
15 Points for for holistic approach
with points for capitals
represented
15
25
35
45
55
2 5 Points for Objectives
Short Term = 2
Long Term = 3
3 5 Points for KPI
Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be
specifically defined
My point scoring
4 5 Points for Level of Innovation
Slight improvement
Moderate improvement
Major improvement
Extends prior capabilitycapacity
exponentially
Never before done truly new
5 5 Points for Summary of
Strategic Learnings
Clear
Succinct
Strategic
Compelling
Inspiring
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)
983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day
in Jangji River
983803 Water quality
- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002
rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009
- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004
rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009
983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River
- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia
- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom
- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)
- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)
983803 Urban afforestation
- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)
- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)
- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average
(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for
bicycles)
983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)
983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)
Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)
Level
983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of
Seoul)
983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment
highest in all of Seoul
983803 Resident survey
- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)
- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)
Environmental
awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards
983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city
983803 Selected as Green City 2008
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
The objectives of the city council for 2012 are
1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself
by over 10
2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use
of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)
3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor
sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)
4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with
photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)
5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel
operated vehicles to local public transportation
6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in
municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers
7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of
energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and
students
Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy
Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at
httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of
1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining
forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity
Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR
(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy
Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings
planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)
Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui
River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin
(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey
(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-
tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon
(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line
(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities
sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less
smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a
clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon
monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions
and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5
separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil
(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every
six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the
garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in
Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Bee Hive Energy Resilient
Conformity Enforcers
Diversity Generators
Inner Judges
Resource Shifters
Intragroup Competitors
Sustain Hive amp Eco-Region
ORG PURPOSE = 40 LB HONEYYR
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
World Threats
Earth-Cosmos
Boundary
Human-Environment
Boundary
Civilization
Anthroposphere
Biosphere
Atmosphere
Hydrosphere
Lithosphere
Solar System
Universe
DepthDepth
Span
(TIME) Years BP
~ 10E+03
~ 10E+04
~ 10E+05
~ 10E+06
~ 10E+07
~ 10E+08
~ 10E+09
~10E+20 ~10E+10 ~10E+5 ~10E+03 ~10E+02 -meters- ~10E-01 ~10E-02 ~10E-05 ~10E-10 ~10E-20
(Big Bang)
Energy Entropy
Early Societies
TribesClans
Heterotrophic Ecosystems
Climatic Systems
Oceans Lakes Rivers
Rocks Minerals
Planetary Systems
Stars Galaxies
Quasars Pulsars
Complex Neocortex
Neocortex-Limbic Systems
Organic CompoundsCells
Inorganic Compounds
Atoms-Molecules-Gases
Sub-Atomic Particles
EnergySource
(LR-UR ExternalPhysical Perspective)copy Brian Eddy PhD Cand
Water
ClimateFood
Bio-Genes
Psycho-Cultural-Social
Energy
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Reframe Sustainable Eco-Region
BioregionEnvironment Context
Resilience in the Systemlt100000 to 1750 +-
Living off
renewable food
Capital Seed
Grain
bull Interest = Daily Food Stores
bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Basket
ltResilience in the Systemgt1750 ndash 19xx
Living off large
part of
Renewables
Capital Seed
Grain
bull Interest = Food Stores
bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Bag
No Resilience in the System1960 +-
Living off Seed
Grain
Capital Seed
Grainbull Withdrawals =
Daily Shopping Cart
No Recovery in the System2000
Consuming
Capital Seed
Grain
Capital Seed
Grain =bull Withdrawals=
Daily Shopping Carts
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and
integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in
cities around the world The conceptual approach includes
consideration of different types of capital
Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation
Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations
Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence
Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT
Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience
Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust
Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management
The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it
has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types
of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City
Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh
Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City
4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce
City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS
Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism
Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre
LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml
Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2
Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2
Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa
Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel
region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml
Municipality
APPLICANTS
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria
1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved
Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework
Environment
Subjective
Internal
Individual
Inter-subjective
Internal Collective
Objective
External
Individual
Inter-
Objective
External
Collective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Environment
3 Human
2 Social
5 Culture
6 Political
7 Financial
4 Technical
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Holistic
approach ndash
which types
of capital are
part of the
initiative
And how
they are
involved
2 Object-
ives for
the
initiative
(long and
short
term)
3 Results
measured with
relevant KPIacutes
linked to the
different types
of capital and
both long and
short term
objectives
4 Level of
innovation for the
initiative - describe
the uniqueness or
why this initiative
adds new
knowledge
regarding creating
more sustainable
cities
5 Summary
of strategic
learnings
from the
initiative to
share
globally and
to inspire
other cities
SCORING SHEET
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
15 Points for for holistic approach
with points for capitals
represented
15
25
35
45
55
2 5 Points for Objectives
Short Term = 2
Long Term = 3
3 5 Points for KPI
Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be
specifically defined
My point scoring
4 5 Points for Level of Innovation
Slight improvement
Moderate improvement
Major improvement
Extends prior capabilitycapacity
exponentially
Never before done truly new
5 5 Points for Summary of
Strategic Learnings
Clear
Succinct
Strategic
Compelling
Inspiring
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)
983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day
in Jangji River
983803 Water quality
- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002
rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009
- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004
rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009
983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River
- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia
- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom
- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)
- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)
983803 Urban afforestation
- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)
- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)
- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average
(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for
bicycles)
983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)
983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)
Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)
Level
983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of
Seoul)
983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment
highest in all of Seoul
983803 Resident survey
- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)
- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)
Environmental
awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards
983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city
983803 Selected as Green City 2008
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
The objectives of the city council for 2012 are
1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself
by over 10
2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use
of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)
3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor
sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)
4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with
photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)
5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel
operated vehicles to local public transportation
6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in
municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers
7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of
energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and
students
Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy
Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at
httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of
1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining
forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity
Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR
(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy
Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings
planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)
Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui
River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin
(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey
(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-
tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon
(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line
(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities
sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less
smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a
clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon
monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions
and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5
separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil
(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every
six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the
garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in
Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Bee Hive Energy Resilient
Conformity Enforcers
Diversity Generators
Inner Judges
Resource Shifters
Intragroup Competitors
Sustain Hive amp Eco-Region
ORG PURPOSE = 40 LB HONEYYR
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
World Threats
Earth-Cosmos
Boundary
Human-Environment
Boundary
Civilization
Anthroposphere
Biosphere
Atmosphere
Hydrosphere
Lithosphere
Solar System
Universe
DepthDepth
Span
(TIME) Years BP
~ 10E+03
~ 10E+04
~ 10E+05
~ 10E+06
~ 10E+07
~ 10E+08
~ 10E+09
~10E+20 ~10E+10 ~10E+5 ~10E+03 ~10E+02 -meters- ~10E-01 ~10E-02 ~10E-05 ~10E-10 ~10E-20
(Big Bang)
Energy Entropy
Early Societies
TribesClans
Heterotrophic Ecosystems
Climatic Systems
Oceans Lakes Rivers
Rocks Minerals
Planetary Systems
Stars Galaxies
Quasars Pulsars
Complex Neocortex
Neocortex-Limbic Systems
Organic CompoundsCells
Inorganic Compounds
Atoms-Molecules-Gases
Sub-Atomic Particles
EnergySource
(LR-UR ExternalPhysical Perspective)copy Brian Eddy PhD Cand
Water
ClimateFood
Bio-Genes
Psycho-Cultural-Social
Energy
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Reframe Sustainable Eco-Region
BioregionEnvironment Context
Resilience in the Systemlt100000 to 1750 +-
Living off
renewable food
Capital Seed
Grain
bull Interest = Daily Food Stores
bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Basket
ltResilience in the Systemgt1750 ndash 19xx
Living off large
part of
Renewables
Capital Seed
Grain
bull Interest = Food Stores
bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Bag
No Resilience in the System1960 +-
Living off Seed
Grain
Capital Seed
Grainbull Withdrawals =
Daily Shopping Cart
No Recovery in the System2000
Consuming
Capital Seed
Grain
Capital Seed
Grain =bull Withdrawals=
Daily Shopping Carts
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and
integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in
cities around the world The conceptual approach includes
consideration of different types of capital
Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation
Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations
Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence
Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT
Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience
Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust
Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management
The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it
has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types
of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City
Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh
Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City
4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce
City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS
Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism
Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre
LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml
Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2
Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2
Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa
Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel
region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml
Municipality
APPLICANTS
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria
1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved
Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework
Environment
Subjective
Internal
Individual
Inter-subjective
Internal Collective
Objective
External
Individual
Inter-
Objective
External
Collective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Environment
3 Human
2 Social
5 Culture
6 Political
7 Financial
4 Technical
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Holistic
approach ndash
which types
of capital are
part of the
initiative
And how
they are
involved
2 Object-
ives for
the
initiative
(long and
short
term)
3 Results
measured with
relevant KPIacutes
linked to the
different types
of capital and
both long and
short term
objectives
4 Level of
innovation for the
initiative - describe
the uniqueness or
why this initiative
adds new
knowledge
regarding creating
more sustainable
cities
5 Summary
of strategic
learnings
from the
initiative to
share
globally and
to inspire
other cities
SCORING SHEET
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
15 Points for for holistic approach
with points for capitals
represented
15
25
35
45
55
2 5 Points for Objectives
Short Term = 2
Long Term = 3
3 5 Points for KPI
Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be
specifically defined
My point scoring
4 5 Points for Level of Innovation
Slight improvement
Moderate improvement
Major improvement
Extends prior capabilitycapacity
exponentially
Never before done truly new
5 5 Points for Summary of
Strategic Learnings
Clear
Succinct
Strategic
Compelling
Inspiring
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)
983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day
in Jangji River
983803 Water quality
- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002
rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009
- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004
rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009
983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River
- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia
- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom
- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)
- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)
983803 Urban afforestation
- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)
- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)
- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average
(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for
bicycles)
983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)
983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)
Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)
Level
983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of
Seoul)
983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment
highest in all of Seoul
983803 Resident survey
- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)
- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)
Environmental
awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards
983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city
983803 Selected as Green City 2008
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
The objectives of the city council for 2012 are
1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself
by over 10
2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use
of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)
3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor
sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)
4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with
photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)
5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel
operated vehicles to local public transportation
6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in
municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers
7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of
energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and
students
Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy
Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at
httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of
1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining
forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity
Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR
(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy
Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings
planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)
Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui
River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin
(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey
(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-
tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon
(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line
(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities
sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less
smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a
clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon
monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions
and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5
separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil
(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every
six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the
garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in
Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
World Threats
Earth-Cosmos
Boundary
Human-Environment
Boundary
Civilization
Anthroposphere
Biosphere
Atmosphere
Hydrosphere
Lithosphere
Solar System
Universe
DepthDepth
Span
(TIME) Years BP
~ 10E+03
~ 10E+04
~ 10E+05
~ 10E+06
~ 10E+07
~ 10E+08
~ 10E+09
~10E+20 ~10E+10 ~10E+5 ~10E+03 ~10E+02 -meters- ~10E-01 ~10E-02 ~10E-05 ~10E-10 ~10E-20
(Big Bang)
Energy Entropy
Early Societies
TribesClans
Heterotrophic Ecosystems
Climatic Systems
Oceans Lakes Rivers
Rocks Minerals
Planetary Systems
Stars Galaxies
Quasars Pulsars
Complex Neocortex
Neocortex-Limbic Systems
Organic CompoundsCells
Inorganic Compounds
Atoms-Molecules-Gases
Sub-Atomic Particles
EnergySource
(LR-UR ExternalPhysical Perspective)copy Brian Eddy PhD Cand
Water
ClimateFood
Bio-Genes
Psycho-Cultural-Social
Energy
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Reframe Sustainable Eco-Region
BioregionEnvironment Context
Resilience in the Systemlt100000 to 1750 +-
Living off
renewable food
Capital Seed
Grain
bull Interest = Daily Food Stores
bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Basket
ltResilience in the Systemgt1750 ndash 19xx
Living off large
part of
Renewables
Capital Seed
Grain
bull Interest = Food Stores
bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Bag
No Resilience in the System1960 +-
Living off Seed
Grain
Capital Seed
Grainbull Withdrawals =
Daily Shopping Cart
No Recovery in the System2000
Consuming
Capital Seed
Grain
Capital Seed
Grain =bull Withdrawals=
Daily Shopping Carts
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and
integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in
cities around the world The conceptual approach includes
consideration of different types of capital
Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation
Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations
Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence
Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT
Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience
Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust
Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management
The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it
has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types
of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City
Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh
Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City
4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce
City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS
Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism
Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre
LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml
Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2
Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2
Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa
Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel
region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml
Municipality
APPLICANTS
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria
1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved
Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework
Environment
Subjective
Internal
Individual
Inter-subjective
Internal Collective
Objective
External
Individual
Inter-
Objective
External
Collective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Environment
3 Human
2 Social
5 Culture
6 Political
7 Financial
4 Technical
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Holistic
approach ndash
which types
of capital are
part of the
initiative
And how
they are
involved
2 Object-
ives for
the
initiative
(long and
short
term)
3 Results
measured with
relevant KPIacutes
linked to the
different types
of capital and
both long and
short term
objectives
4 Level of
innovation for the
initiative - describe
the uniqueness or
why this initiative
adds new
knowledge
regarding creating
more sustainable
cities
5 Summary
of strategic
learnings
from the
initiative to
share
globally and
to inspire
other cities
SCORING SHEET
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
15 Points for for holistic approach
with points for capitals
represented
15
25
35
45
55
2 5 Points for Objectives
Short Term = 2
Long Term = 3
3 5 Points for KPI
Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be
specifically defined
My point scoring
4 5 Points for Level of Innovation
Slight improvement
Moderate improvement
Major improvement
Extends prior capabilitycapacity
exponentially
Never before done truly new
5 5 Points for Summary of
Strategic Learnings
Clear
Succinct
Strategic
Compelling
Inspiring
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)
983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day
in Jangji River
983803 Water quality
- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002
rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009
- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004
rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009
983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River
- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia
- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom
- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)
- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)
983803 Urban afforestation
- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)
- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)
- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average
(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for
bicycles)
983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)
983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)
Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)
Level
983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of
Seoul)
983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment
highest in all of Seoul
983803 Resident survey
- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)
- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)
Environmental
awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards
983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city
983803 Selected as Green City 2008
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
The objectives of the city council for 2012 are
1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself
by over 10
2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use
of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)
3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor
sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)
4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with
photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)
5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel
operated vehicles to local public transportation
6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in
municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers
7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of
energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and
students
Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy
Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at
httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of
1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining
forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity
Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR
(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy
Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings
planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)
Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui
River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin
(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey
(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-
tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon
(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line
(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities
sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less
smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a
clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon
monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions
and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5
separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil
(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every
six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the
garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in
Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Reframe Sustainable Eco-Region
BioregionEnvironment Context
Resilience in the Systemlt100000 to 1750 +-
Living off
renewable food
Capital Seed
Grain
bull Interest = Daily Food Stores
bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Basket
ltResilience in the Systemgt1750 ndash 19xx
Living off large
part of
Renewables
Capital Seed
Grain
bull Interest = Food Stores
bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Bag
No Resilience in the System1960 +-
Living off Seed
Grain
Capital Seed
Grainbull Withdrawals =
Daily Shopping Cart
No Recovery in the System2000
Consuming
Capital Seed
Grain
Capital Seed
Grain =bull Withdrawals=
Daily Shopping Carts
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and
integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in
cities around the world The conceptual approach includes
consideration of different types of capital
Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation
Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations
Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence
Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT
Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience
Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust
Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management
The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it
has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types
of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City
Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh
Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City
4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce
City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS
Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism
Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre
LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml
Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2
Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2
Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa
Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel
region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml
Municipality
APPLICANTS
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria
1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved
Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework
Environment
Subjective
Internal
Individual
Inter-subjective
Internal Collective
Objective
External
Individual
Inter-
Objective
External
Collective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Environment
3 Human
2 Social
5 Culture
6 Political
7 Financial
4 Technical
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Holistic
approach ndash
which types
of capital are
part of the
initiative
And how
they are
involved
2 Object-
ives for
the
initiative
(long and
short
term)
3 Results
measured with
relevant KPIacutes
linked to the
different types
of capital and
both long and
short term
objectives
4 Level of
innovation for the
initiative - describe
the uniqueness or
why this initiative
adds new
knowledge
regarding creating
more sustainable
cities
5 Summary
of strategic
learnings
from the
initiative to
share
globally and
to inspire
other cities
SCORING SHEET
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
15 Points for for holistic approach
with points for capitals
represented
15
25
35
45
55
2 5 Points for Objectives
Short Term = 2
Long Term = 3
3 5 Points for KPI
Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be
specifically defined
My point scoring
4 5 Points for Level of Innovation
Slight improvement
Moderate improvement
Major improvement
Extends prior capabilitycapacity
exponentially
Never before done truly new
5 5 Points for Summary of
Strategic Learnings
Clear
Succinct
Strategic
Compelling
Inspiring
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)
983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day
in Jangji River
983803 Water quality
- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002
rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009
- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004
rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009
983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River
- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia
- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom
- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)
- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)
983803 Urban afforestation
- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)
- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)
- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average
(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for
bicycles)
983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)
983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)
Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)
Level
983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of
Seoul)
983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment
highest in all of Seoul
983803 Resident survey
- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)
- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)
Environmental
awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards
983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city
983803 Selected as Green City 2008
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
The objectives of the city council for 2012 are
1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself
by over 10
2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use
of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)
3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor
sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)
4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with
photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)
5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel
operated vehicles to local public transportation
6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in
municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers
7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of
energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and
students
Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy
Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at
httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of
1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining
forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity
Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR
(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy
Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings
planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)
Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui
River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin
(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey
(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-
tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon
(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line
(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities
sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less
smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a
clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon
monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions
and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5
separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil
(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every
six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the
garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in
Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Reframe Sustainable Eco-Region
BioregionEnvironment Context
Resilience in the Systemlt100000 to 1750 +-
Living off
renewable food
Capital Seed
Grain
bull Interest = Daily Food Stores
bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Basket
ltResilience in the Systemgt1750 ndash 19xx
Living off large
part of
Renewables
Capital Seed
Grain
bull Interest = Food Stores
bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Bag
No Resilience in the System1960 +-
Living off Seed
Grain
Capital Seed
Grainbull Withdrawals =
Daily Shopping Cart
No Recovery in the System2000
Consuming
Capital Seed
Grain
Capital Seed
Grain =bull Withdrawals=
Daily Shopping Carts
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and
integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in
cities around the world The conceptual approach includes
consideration of different types of capital
Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation
Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations
Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence
Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT
Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience
Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust
Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management
The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it
has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types
of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City
Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh
Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City
4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce
City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS
Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism
Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre
LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml
Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2
Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2
Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa
Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel
region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml
Municipality
APPLICANTS
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria
1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved
Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework
Environment
Subjective
Internal
Individual
Inter-subjective
Internal Collective
Objective
External
Individual
Inter-
Objective
External
Collective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Environment
3 Human
2 Social
5 Culture
6 Political
7 Financial
4 Technical
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Holistic
approach ndash
which types
of capital are
part of the
initiative
And how
they are
involved
2 Object-
ives for
the
initiative
(long and
short
term)
3 Results
measured with
relevant KPIacutes
linked to the
different types
of capital and
both long and
short term
objectives
4 Level of
innovation for the
initiative - describe
the uniqueness or
why this initiative
adds new
knowledge
regarding creating
more sustainable
cities
5 Summary
of strategic
learnings
from the
initiative to
share
globally and
to inspire
other cities
SCORING SHEET
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
15 Points for for holistic approach
with points for capitals
represented
15
25
35
45
55
2 5 Points for Objectives
Short Term = 2
Long Term = 3
3 5 Points for KPI
Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be
specifically defined
My point scoring
4 5 Points for Level of Innovation
Slight improvement
Moderate improvement
Major improvement
Extends prior capabilitycapacity
exponentially
Never before done truly new
5 5 Points for Summary of
Strategic Learnings
Clear
Succinct
Strategic
Compelling
Inspiring
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)
983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day
in Jangji River
983803 Water quality
- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002
rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009
- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004
rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009
983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River
- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia
- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom
- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)
- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)
983803 Urban afforestation
- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)
- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)
- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average
(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for
bicycles)
983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)
983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)
Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)
Level
983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of
Seoul)
983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment
highest in all of Seoul
983803 Resident survey
- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)
- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)
Environmental
awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards
983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city
983803 Selected as Green City 2008
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
The objectives of the city council for 2012 are
1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself
by over 10
2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use
of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)
3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor
sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)
4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with
photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)
5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel
operated vehicles to local public transportation
6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in
municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers
7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of
energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and
students
Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy
Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at
httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of
1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining
forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity
Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR
(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy
Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings
planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)
Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui
River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin
(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey
(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-
tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon
(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line
(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities
sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less
smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a
clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon
monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions
and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5
separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil
(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every
six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the
garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in
Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
Resilience in the Systemlt100000 to 1750 +-
Living off
renewable food
Capital Seed
Grain
bull Interest = Daily Food Stores
bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Basket
ltResilience in the Systemgt1750 ndash 19xx
Living off large
part of
Renewables
Capital Seed
Grain
bull Interest = Food Stores
bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Bag
No Resilience in the System1960 +-
Living off Seed
Grain
Capital Seed
Grainbull Withdrawals =
Daily Shopping Cart
No Recovery in the System2000
Consuming
Capital Seed
Grain
Capital Seed
Grain =bull Withdrawals=
Daily Shopping Carts
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and
integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in
cities around the world The conceptual approach includes
consideration of different types of capital
Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation
Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations
Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence
Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT
Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience
Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust
Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management
The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it
has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types
of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City
Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh
Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City
4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce
City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS
Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism
Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre
LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml
Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2
Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2
Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa
Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel
region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml
Municipality
APPLICANTS
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria
1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved
Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework
Environment
Subjective
Internal
Individual
Inter-subjective
Internal Collective
Objective
External
Individual
Inter-
Objective
External
Collective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Environment
3 Human
2 Social
5 Culture
6 Political
7 Financial
4 Technical
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Holistic
approach ndash
which types
of capital are
part of the
initiative
And how
they are
involved
2 Object-
ives for
the
initiative
(long and
short
term)
3 Results
measured with
relevant KPIacutes
linked to the
different types
of capital and
both long and
short term
objectives
4 Level of
innovation for the
initiative - describe
the uniqueness or
why this initiative
adds new
knowledge
regarding creating
more sustainable
cities
5 Summary
of strategic
learnings
from the
initiative to
share
globally and
to inspire
other cities
SCORING SHEET
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
15 Points for for holistic approach
with points for capitals
represented
15
25
35
45
55
2 5 Points for Objectives
Short Term = 2
Long Term = 3
3 5 Points for KPI
Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be
specifically defined
My point scoring
4 5 Points for Level of Innovation
Slight improvement
Moderate improvement
Major improvement
Extends prior capabilitycapacity
exponentially
Never before done truly new
5 5 Points for Summary of
Strategic Learnings
Clear
Succinct
Strategic
Compelling
Inspiring
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)
983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day
in Jangji River
983803 Water quality
- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002
rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009
- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004
rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009
983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River
- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia
- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom
- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)
- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)
983803 Urban afforestation
- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)
- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)
- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average
(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for
bicycles)
983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)
983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)
Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)
Level
983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of
Seoul)
983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment
highest in all of Seoul
983803 Resident survey
- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)
- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)
Environmental
awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards
983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city
983803 Selected as Green City 2008
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
The objectives of the city council for 2012 are
1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself
by over 10
2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use
of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)
3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor
sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)
4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with
photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)
5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel
operated vehicles to local public transportation
6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in
municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers
7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of
energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and
students
Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy
Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at
httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of
1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining
forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity
Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR
(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy
Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings
planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)
Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui
River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin
(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey
(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-
tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon
(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line
(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities
sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less
smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a
clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon
monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions
and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5
separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil
(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every
six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the
garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in
Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
ltResilience in the Systemgt1750 ndash 19xx
Living off large
part of
Renewables
Capital Seed
Grain
bull Interest = Food Stores
bull Withdrawals = Daily Shopping Bag
No Resilience in the System1960 +-
Living off Seed
Grain
Capital Seed
Grainbull Withdrawals =
Daily Shopping Cart
No Recovery in the System2000
Consuming
Capital Seed
Grain
Capital Seed
Grain =bull Withdrawals=
Daily Shopping Carts
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and
integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in
cities around the world The conceptual approach includes
consideration of different types of capital
Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation
Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations
Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence
Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT
Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience
Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust
Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management
The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it
has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types
of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City
Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh
Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City
4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce
City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS
Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism
Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre
LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml
Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2
Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2
Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa
Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel
region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml
Municipality
APPLICANTS
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria
1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved
Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework
Environment
Subjective
Internal
Individual
Inter-subjective
Internal Collective
Objective
External
Individual
Inter-
Objective
External
Collective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Environment
3 Human
2 Social
5 Culture
6 Political
7 Financial
4 Technical
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Holistic
approach ndash
which types
of capital are
part of the
initiative
And how
they are
involved
2 Object-
ives for
the
initiative
(long and
short
term)
3 Results
measured with
relevant KPIacutes
linked to the
different types
of capital and
both long and
short term
objectives
4 Level of
innovation for the
initiative - describe
the uniqueness or
why this initiative
adds new
knowledge
regarding creating
more sustainable
cities
5 Summary
of strategic
learnings
from the
initiative to
share
globally and
to inspire
other cities
SCORING SHEET
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
15 Points for for holistic approach
with points for capitals
represented
15
25
35
45
55
2 5 Points for Objectives
Short Term = 2
Long Term = 3
3 5 Points for KPI
Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be
specifically defined
My point scoring
4 5 Points for Level of Innovation
Slight improvement
Moderate improvement
Major improvement
Extends prior capabilitycapacity
exponentially
Never before done truly new
5 5 Points for Summary of
Strategic Learnings
Clear
Succinct
Strategic
Compelling
Inspiring
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)
983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day
in Jangji River
983803 Water quality
- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002
rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009
- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004
rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009
983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River
- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia
- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom
- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)
- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)
983803 Urban afforestation
- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)
- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)
- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average
(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for
bicycles)
983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)
983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)
Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)
Level
983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of
Seoul)
983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment
highest in all of Seoul
983803 Resident survey
- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)
- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)
Environmental
awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards
983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city
983803 Selected as Green City 2008
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
The objectives of the city council for 2012 are
1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself
by over 10
2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use
of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)
3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor
sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)
4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with
photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)
5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel
operated vehicles to local public transportation
6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in
municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers
7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of
energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and
students
Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy
Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at
httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of
1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining
forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity
Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR
(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy
Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings
planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)
Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui
River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin
(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey
(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-
tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon
(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line
(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities
sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less
smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a
clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon
monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions
and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5
separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil
(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every
six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the
garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in
Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
No Resilience in the System1960 +-
Living off Seed
Grain
Capital Seed
Grainbull Withdrawals =
Daily Shopping Cart
No Recovery in the System2000
Consuming
Capital Seed
Grain
Capital Seed
Grain =bull Withdrawals=
Daily Shopping Carts
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and
integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in
cities around the world The conceptual approach includes
consideration of different types of capital
Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation
Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations
Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence
Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT
Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience
Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust
Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management
The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it
has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types
of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City
Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh
Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City
4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce
City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS
Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism
Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre
LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml
Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2
Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2
Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa
Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel
region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml
Municipality
APPLICANTS
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria
1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved
Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework
Environment
Subjective
Internal
Individual
Inter-subjective
Internal Collective
Objective
External
Individual
Inter-
Objective
External
Collective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Environment
3 Human
2 Social
5 Culture
6 Political
7 Financial
4 Technical
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Holistic
approach ndash
which types
of capital are
part of the
initiative
And how
they are
involved
2 Object-
ives for
the
initiative
(long and
short
term)
3 Results
measured with
relevant KPIacutes
linked to the
different types
of capital and
both long and
short term
objectives
4 Level of
innovation for the
initiative - describe
the uniqueness or
why this initiative
adds new
knowledge
regarding creating
more sustainable
cities
5 Summary
of strategic
learnings
from the
initiative to
share
globally and
to inspire
other cities
SCORING SHEET
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
15 Points for for holistic approach
with points for capitals
represented
15
25
35
45
55
2 5 Points for Objectives
Short Term = 2
Long Term = 3
3 5 Points for KPI
Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be
specifically defined
My point scoring
4 5 Points for Level of Innovation
Slight improvement
Moderate improvement
Major improvement
Extends prior capabilitycapacity
exponentially
Never before done truly new
5 5 Points for Summary of
Strategic Learnings
Clear
Succinct
Strategic
Compelling
Inspiring
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)
983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day
in Jangji River
983803 Water quality
- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002
rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009
- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004
rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009
983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River
- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia
- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom
- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)
- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)
983803 Urban afforestation
- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)
- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)
- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average
(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for
bicycles)
983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)
983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)
Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)
Level
983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of
Seoul)
983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment
highest in all of Seoul
983803 Resident survey
- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)
- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)
Environmental
awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards
983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city
983803 Selected as Green City 2008
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
The objectives of the city council for 2012 are
1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself
by over 10
2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use
of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)
3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor
sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)
4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with
photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)
5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel
operated vehicles to local public transportation
6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in
municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers
7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of
energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and
students
Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy
Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at
httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of
1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining
forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity
Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR
(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy
Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings
planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)
Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui
River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin
(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey
(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-
tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon
(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line
(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities
sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less
smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a
clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon
monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions
and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5
separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil
(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every
six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the
garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in
Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
No Recovery in the System2000
Consuming
Capital Seed
Grain
Capital Seed
Grain =bull Withdrawals=
Daily Shopping Carts
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and
integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in
cities around the world The conceptual approach includes
consideration of different types of capital
Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation
Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations
Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence
Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT
Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience
Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust
Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management
The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it
has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types
of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City
Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh
Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City
4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce
City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS
Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism
Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre
LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml
Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2
Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2
Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa
Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel
region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml
Municipality
APPLICANTS
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria
1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved
Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework
Environment
Subjective
Internal
Individual
Inter-subjective
Internal Collective
Objective
External
Individual
Inter-
Objective
External
Collective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Environment
3 Human
2 Social
5 Culture
6 Political
7 Financial
4 Technical
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Holistic
approach ndash
which types
of capital are
part of the
initiative
And how
they are
involved
2 Object-
ives for
the
initiative
(long and
short
term)
3 Results
measured with
relevant KPIacutes
linked to the
different types
of capital and
both long and
short term
objectives
4 Level of
innovation for the
initiative - describe
the uniqueness or
why this initiative
adds new
knowledge
regarding creating
more sustainable
cities
5 Summary
of strategic
learnings
from the
initiative to
share
globally and
to inspire
other cities
SCORING SHEET
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
15 Points for for holistic approach
with points for capitals
represented
15
25
35
45
55
2 5 Points for Objectives
Short Term = 2
Long Term = 3
3 5 Points for KPI
Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be
specifically defined
My point scoring
4 5 Points for Level of Innovation
Slight improvement
Moderate improvement
Major improvement
Extends prior capabilitycapacity
exponentially
Never before done truly new
5 5 Points for Summary of
Strategic Learnings
Clear
Succinct
Strategic
Compelling
Inspiring
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)
983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day
in Jangji River
983803 Water quality
- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002
rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009
- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004
rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009
983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River
- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia
- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom
- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)
- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)
983803 Urban afforestation
- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)
- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)
- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average
(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for
bicycles)
983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)
983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)
Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)
Level
983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of
Seoul)
983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment
highest in all of Seoul
983803 Resident survey
- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)
- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)
Environmental
awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards
983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city
983803 Selected as Green City 2008
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
The objectives of the city council for 2012 are
1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself
by over 10
2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use
of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)
3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor
sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)
4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with
photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)
5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel
operated vehicles to local public transportation
6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in
municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers
7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of
energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and
students
Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy
Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at
httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of
1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining
forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity
Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR
(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy
Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings
planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)
Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui
River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin
(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey
(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-
tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon
(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line
(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities
sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less
smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a
clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon
monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions
and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5
separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil
(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every
six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the
garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in
Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and
integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in
cities around the world The conceptual approach includes
consideration of different types of capital
Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation
Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations
Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence
Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT
Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience
Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust
Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management
The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it
has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types
of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City
Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh
Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City
4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce
City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS
Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism
Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre
LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml
Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2
Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2
Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa
Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel
region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml
Municipality
APPLICANTS
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria
1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved
Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework
Environment
Subjective
Internal
Individual
Inter-subjective
Internal Collective
Objective
External
Individual
Inter-
Objective
External
Collective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Environment
3 Human
2 Social
5 Culture
6 Political
7 Financial
4 Technical
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Holistic
approach ndash
which types
of capital are
part of the
initiative
And how
they are
involved
2 Object-
ives for
the
initiative
(long and
short
term)
3 Results
measured with
relevant KPIacutes
linked to the
different types
of capital and
both long and
short term
objectives
4 Level of
innovation for the
initiative - describe
the uniqueness or
why this initiative
adds new
knowledge
regarding creating
more sustainable
cities
5 Summary
of strategic
learnings
from the
initiative to
share
globally and
to inspire
other cities
SCORING SHEET
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
15 Points for for holistic approach
with points for capitals
represented
15
25
35
45
55
2 5 Points for Objectives
Short Term = 2
Long Term = 3
3 5 Points for KPI
Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be
specifically defined
My point scoring
4 5 Points for Level of Innovation
Slight improvement
Moderate improvement
Major improvement
Extends prior capabilitycapacity
exponentially
Never before done truly new
5 5 Points for Summary of
Strategic Learnings
Clear
Succinct
Strategic
Compelling
Inspiring
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)
983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day
in Jangji River
983803 Water quality
- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002
rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009
- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004
rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009
983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River
- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia
- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom
- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)
- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)
983803 Urban afforestation
- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)
- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)
- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average
(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for
bicycles)
983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)
983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)
Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)
Level
983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of
Seoul)
983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment
highest in all of Seoul
983803 Resident survey
- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)
- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)
Environmental
awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards
983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city
983803 Selected as Green City 2008
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
The objectives of the city council for 2012 are
1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself
by over 10
2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use
of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)
3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor
sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)
4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with
photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)
5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel
operated vehicles to local public transportation
6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in
municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers
7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of
energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and
students
Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy
Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at
httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of
1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining
forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity
Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR
(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy
Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings
planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)
Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui
River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin
(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey
(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-
tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon
(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line
(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities
sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less
smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a
clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon
monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions
and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5
separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil
(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every
six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the
garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in
Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and
integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in
cities around the world The conceptual approach includes
consideration of different types of capital
Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation
Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations
Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence
Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT
Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience
Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust
Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management
The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it
has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types
of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City
Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh
Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City
4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce
City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS
Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism
Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre
LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml
Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2
Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2
Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa
Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel
region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml
Municipality
APPLICANTS
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria
1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved
Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework
Environment
Subjective
Internal
Individual
Inter-subjective
Internal Collective
Objective
External
Individual
Inter-
Objective
External
Collective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Environment
3 Human
2 Social
5 Culture
6 Political
7 Financial
4 Technical
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Holistic
approach ndash
which types
of capital are
part of the
initiative
And how
they are
involved
2 Object-
ives for
the
initiative
(long and
short
term)
3 Results
measured with
relevant KPIacutes
linked to the
different types
of capital and
both long and
short term
objectives
4 Level of
innovation for the
initiative - describe
the uniqueness or
why this initiative
adds new
knowledge
regarding creating
more sustainable
cities
5 Summary
of strategic
learnings
from the
initiative to
share
globally and
to inspire
other cities
SCORING SHEET
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
15 Points for for holistic approach
with points for capitals
represented
15
25
35
45
55
2 5 Points for Objectives
Short Term = 2
Long Term = 3
3 5 Points for KPI
Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be
specifically defined
My point scoring
4 5 Points for Level of Innovation
Slight improvement
Moderate improvement
Major improvement
Extends prior capabilitycapacity
exponentially
Never before done truly new
5 5 Points for Summary of
Strategic Learnings
Clear
Succinct
Strategic
Compelling
Inspiring
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)
983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day
in Jangji River
983803 Water quality
- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002
rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009
- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004
rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009
983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River
- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia
- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom
- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)
- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)
983803 Urban afforestation
- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)
- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)
- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average
(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for
bicycles)
983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)
983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)
Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)
Level
983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of
Seoul)
983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment
highest in all of Seoul
983803 Resident survey
- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)
- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)
Environmental
awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards
983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city
983803 Selected as Green City 2008
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
The objectives of the city council for 2012 are
1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself
by over 10
2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use
of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)
3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor
sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)
4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with
photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)
5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel
operated vehicles to local public transportation
6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in
municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers
7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of
energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and
students
Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy
Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at
httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of
1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining
forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity
Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR
(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy
Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings
planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)
Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui
River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin
(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey
(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-
tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon
(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line
(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities
sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less
smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a
clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon
monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions
and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5
separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil
(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every
six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the
garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in
Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and
integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in
cities around the world The conceptual approach includes
consideration of different types of capital
Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation
Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations
Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence
Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT
Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience
Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust
Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management
The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it
has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types
of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City
Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh
Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City
4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce
City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS
Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism
Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre
LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml
Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2
Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2
Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa
Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel
region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml
Municipality
APPLICANTS
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria
1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved
Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework
Environment
Subjective
Internal
Individual
Inter-subjective
Internal Collective
Objective
External
Individual
Inter-
Objective
External
Collective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Environment
3 Human
2 Social
5 Culture
6 Political
7 Financial
4 Technical
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Holistic
approach ndash
which types
of capital are
part of the
initiative
And how
they are
involved
2 Object-
ives for
the
initiative
(long and
short
term)
3 Results
measured with
relevant KPIacutes
linked to the
different types
of capital and
both long and
short term
objectives
4 Level of
innovation for the
initiative - describe
the uniqueness or
why this initiative
adds new
knowledge
regarding creating
more sustainable
cities
5 Summary
of strategic
learnings
from the
initiative to
share
globally and
to inspire
other cities
SCORING SHEET
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
15 Points for for holistic approach
with points for capitals
represented
15
25
35
45
55
2 5 Points for Objectives
Short Term = 2
Long Term = 3
3 5 Points for KPI
Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be
specifically defined
My point scoring
4 5 Points for Level of Innovation
Slight improvement
Moderate improvement
Major improvement
Extends prior capabilitycapacity
exponentially
Never before done truly new
5 5 Points for Summary of
Strategic Learnings
Clear
Succinct
Strategic
Compelling
Inspiring
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)
983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day
in Jangji River
983803 Water quality
- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002
rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009
- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004
rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009
983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River
- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia
- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom
- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)
- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)
983803 Urban afforestation
- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)
- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)
- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average
(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for
bicycles)
983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)
983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)
Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)
Level
983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of
Seoul)
983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment
highest in all of Seoul
983803 Resident survey
- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)
- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)
Environmental
awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards
983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city
983803 Selected as Green City 2008
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
The objectives of the city council for 2012 are
1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself
by over 10
2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use
of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)
3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor
sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)
4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with
photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)
5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel
operated vehicles to local public transportation
6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in
municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers
7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of
energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and
students
Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy
Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at
httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of
1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining
forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity
Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR
(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy
Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings
planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)
Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui
River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin
(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey
(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-
tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon
(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line
(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities
sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less
smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a
clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon
monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions
and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5
separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil
(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every
six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the
garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in
Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and
integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in
cities around the world The conceptual approach includes
consideration of different types of capital
Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation
Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations
Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence
Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT
Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience
Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust
Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management
The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it
has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types
of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City
Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh
Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City
4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce
City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS
Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism
Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre
LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml
Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2
Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2
Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa
Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel
region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml
Municipality
APPLICANTS
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria
1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved
Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework
Environment
Subjective
Internal
Individual
Inter-subjective
Internal Collective
Objective
External
Individual
Inter-
Objective
External
Collective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Environment
3 Human
2 Social
5 Culture
6 Political
7 Financial
4 Technical
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Holistic
approach ndash
which types
of capital are
part of the
initiative
And how
they are
involved
2 Object-
ives for
the
initiative
(long and
short
term)
3 Results
measured with
relevant KPIacutes
linked to the
different types
of capital and
both long and
short term
objectives
4 Level of
innovation for the
initiative - describe
the uniqueness or
why this initiative
adds new
knowledge
regarding creating
more sustainable
cities
5 Summary
of strategic
learnings
from the
initiative to
share
globally and
to inspire
other cities
SCORING SHEET
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
15 Points for for holistic approach
with points for capitals
represented
15
25
35
45
55
2 5 Points for Objectives
Short Term = 2
Long Term = 3
3 5 Points for KPI
Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be
specifically defined
My point scoring
4 5 Points for Level of Innovation
Slight improvement
Moderate improvement
Major improvement
Extends prior capabilitycapacity
exponentially
Never before done truly new
5 5 Points for Summary of
Strategic Learnings
Clear
Succinct
Strategic
Compelling
Inspiring
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)
983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day
in Jangji River
983803 Water quality
- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002
rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009
- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004
rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009
983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River
- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia
- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom
- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)
- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)
983803 Urban afforestation
- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)
- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)
- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average
(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for
bicycles)
983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)
983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)
Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)
Level
983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of
Seoul)
983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment
highest in all of Seoul
983803 Resident survey
- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)
- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)
Environmental
awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards
983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city
983803 Selected as Green City 2008
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
The objectives of the city council for 2012 are
1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself
by over 10
2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use
of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)
3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor
sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)
4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with
photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)
5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel
operated vehicles to local public transportation
6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in
municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers
7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of
energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and
students
Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy
Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at
httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of
1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining
forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity
Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR
(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy
Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings
planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)
Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui
River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin
(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey
(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-
tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon
(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line
(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities
sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less
smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a
clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon
monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions
and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5
separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil
(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every
six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the
garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in
Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Criteria The criteria focus on a holistic approach to Sustainability in cities and
integrate different types of resources or capital for a better future in
cities around the world The conceptual approach includes
consideration of different types of capital
Environmental Capital - Natural Resources Preservation
Social Capital - Well-being and Social Relations
Human and Intellectual Capital - Innovation and Social Intelligence
Technical and Infrastructure Capital - Transportation and ICT
Culture and Leisure Capital - Experience
Political Capital - Confidence and Public Trust
Financial Capital - Assets and Financial Management
The cities needs to demonstrate one or more special initiatives that it
has undertaken in the last two years in one or more of the various types
of capital above in order to reach a more sustainable future
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City
Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh
Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City
4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce
City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS
Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism
Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre
LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml
Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2
Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2
Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa
Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel
region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml
Municipality
APPLICANTS
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria
1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved
Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework
Environment
Subjective
Internal
Individual
Inter-subjective
Internal Collective
Objective
External
Individual
Inter-
Objective
External
Collective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Environment
3 Human
2 Social
5 Culture
6 Political
7 Financial
4 Technical
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Holistic
approach ndash
which types
of capital are
part of the
initiative
And how
they are
involved
2 Object-
ives for
the
initiative
(long and
short
term)
3 Results
measured with
relevant KPIacutes
linked to the
different types
of capital and
both long and
short term
objectives
4 Level of
innovation for the
initiative - describe
the uniqueness or
why this initiative
adds new
knowledge
regarding creating
more sustainable
cities
5 Summary
of strategic
learnings
from the
initiative to
share
globally and
to inspire
other cities
SCORING SHEET
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
15 Points for for holistic approach
with points for capitals
represented
15
25
35
45
55
2 5 Points for Objectives
Short Term = 2
Long Term = 3
3 5 Points for KPI
Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be
specifically defined
My point scoring
4 5 Points for Level of Innovation
Slight improvement
Moderate improvement
Major improvement
Extends prior capabilitycapacity
exponentially
Never before done truly new
5 5 Points for Summary of
Strategic Learnings
Clear
Succinct
Strategic
Compelling
Inspiring
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)
983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day
in Jangji River
983803 Water quality
- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002
rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009
- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004
rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009
983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River
- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia
- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom
- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)
- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)
983803 Urban afforestation
- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)
- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)
- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average
(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for
bicycles)
983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)
983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)
Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)
Level
983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of
Seoul)
983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment
highest in all of Seoul
983803 Resident survey
- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)
- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)
Environmental
awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards
983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city
983803 Selected as Green City 2008
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
The objectives of the city council for 2012 are
1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself
by over 10
2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use
of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)
3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor
sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)
4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with
photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)
5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel
operated vehicles to local public transportation
6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in
municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers
7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of
energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and
students
Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy
Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at
httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of
1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining
forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity
Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR
(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy
Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings
planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)
Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui
River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin
(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey
(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-
tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon
(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line
(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities
sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less
smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a
clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon
monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions
and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5
separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil
(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every
six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the
garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in
Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City
Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh
Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City
4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce
City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS
Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism
Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre
LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml
Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2
Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2
Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa
Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel
region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml
Municipality
APPLICANTS
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria
1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved
Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework
Environment
Subjective
Internal
Individual
Inter-subjective
Internal Collective
Objective
External
Individual
Inter-
Objective
External
Collective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Environment
3 Human
2 Social
5 Culture
6 Political
7 Financial
4 Technical
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Holistic
approach ndash
which types
of capital are
part of the
initiative
And how
they are
involved
2 Object-
ives for
the
initiative
(long and
short
term)
3 Results
measured with
relevant KPIacutes
linked to the
different types
of capital and
both long and
short term
objectives
4 Level of
innovation for the
initiative - describe
the uniqueness or
why this initiative
adds new
knowledge
regarding creating
more sustainable
cities
5 Summary
of strategic
learnings
from the
initiative to
share
globally and
to inspire
other cities
SCORING SHEET
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
15 Points for for holistic approach
with points for capitals
represented
15
25
35
45
55
2 5 Points for Objectives
Short Term = 2
Long Term = 3
3 5 Points for KPI
Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be
specifically defined
My point scoring
4 5 Points for Level of Innovation
Slight improvement
Moderate improvement
Major improvement
Extends prior capabilitycapacity
exponentially
Never before done truly new
5 5 Points for Summary of
Strategic Learnings
Clear
Succinct
Strategic
Compelling
Inspiring
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)
983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day
in Jangji River
983803 Water quality
- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002
rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009
- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004
rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009
983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River
- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia
- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom
- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)
- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)
983803 Urban afforestation
- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)
- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)
- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average
(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for
bicycles)
983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)
983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)
Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)
Level
983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of
Seoul)
983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment
highest in all of Seoul
983803 Resident survey
- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)
- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)
Environmental
awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards
983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city
983803 Selected as Green City 2008
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
The objectives of the city council for 2012 are
1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself
by over 10
2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use
of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)
3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor
sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)
4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with
photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)
5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel
operated vehicles to local public transportation
6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in
municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers
7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of
energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and
students
Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy
Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at
httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of
1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining
forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity
Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR
(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy
Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings
planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)
Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui
River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin
(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey
(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-
tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon
(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line
(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities
sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less
smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a
clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon
monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions
and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5
separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil
(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every
six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the
garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in
Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Chihuahua Curitiba Elblag Fort Collins Gdansk City
Hall Gdynia Gemeente Heerlen Helsingborg Hitesh
Bhatt Kielce City1 - Downtown Revitalize Kielce City
4 - Amphitheatre Kielce City5 ndash Geopark Kielce
City2 Alternative culture Kielce City3 KMGIS
Leszno1 (Urząd Miasta Leszna) Leszno2 tourism
Lidkoumlpings LODZ Sports amp Ent LODZ Revit Centre
LODZ Green Ring Madrid City Council Malmouml
Murcia Olsztyn Opole 1 waste treatment Opole 2
Strat plan Planeacioacuten Poznan City1 Poznan City2
Poznan City3 Poznan City4 Poznan City5 Song-pa
Gu Stargard Szczeciński Svetlogorsk Gomel
region Belarus Sydney Vadodara Vancouver Vaumlxjouml
Municipality
APPLICANTS
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria
1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved
Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework
Environment
Subjective
Internal
Individual
Inter-subjective
Internal Collective
Objective
External
Individual
Inter-
Objective
External
Collective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Environment
3 Human
2 Social
5 Culture
6 Political
7 Financial
4 Technical
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Holistic
approach ndash
which types
of capital are
part of the
initiative
And how
they are
involved
2 Object-
ives for
the
initiative
(long and
short
term)
3 Results
measured with
relevant KPIacutes
linked to the
different types
of capital and
both long and
short term
objectives
4 Level of
innovation for the
initiative - describe
the uniqueness or
why this initiative
adds new
knowledge
regarding creating
more sustainable
cities
5 Summary
of strategic
learnings
from the
initiative to
share
globally and
to inspire
other cities
SCORING SHEET
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
15 Points for for holistic approach
with points for capitals
represented
15
25
35
45
55
2 5 Points for Objectives
Short Term = 2
Long Term = 3
3 5 Points for KPI
Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be
specifically defined
My point scoring
4 5 Points for Level of Innovation
Slight improvement
Moderate improvement
Major improvement
Extends prior capabilitycapacity
exponentially
Never before done truly new
5 5 Points for Summary of
Strategic Learnings
Clear
Succinct
Strategic
Compelling
Inspiring
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)
983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day
in Jangji River
983803 Water quality
- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002
rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009
- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004
rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009
983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River
- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia
- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom
- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)
- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)
983803 Urban afforestation
- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)
- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)
- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average
(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for
bicycles)
983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)
983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)
Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)
Level
983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of
Seoul)
983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment
highest in all of Seoul
983803 Resident survey
- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)
- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)
Environmental
awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards
983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city
983803 Selected as Green City 2008
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
The objectives of the city council for 2012 are
1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself
by over 10
2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use
of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)
3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor
sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)
4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with
photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)
5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel
operated vehicles to local public transportation
6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in
municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers
7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of
energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and
students
Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy
Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at
httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of
1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining
forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity
Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR
(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy
Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings
planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)
Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui
River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin
(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey
(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-
tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon
(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line
(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities
sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less
smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a
clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon
monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions
and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5
separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil
(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every
six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the
garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in
Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Globe Awards ndash Sustainable City Overview ndash How I Applied Criteria
1 5 points for Holistic Approach ndash Types of Capitals Involved
Grouped according approximately to an Integral City Framework
Environment
Subjective
Internal
Individual
Inter-subjective
Internal Collective
Objective
External
Individual
Inter-
Objective
External
Collective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Environment
3 Human
2 Social
5 Culture
6 Political
7 Financial
4 Technical
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Holistic
approach ndash
which types
of capital are
part of the
initiative
And how
they are
involved
2 Object-
ives for
the
initiative
(long and
short
term)
3 Results
measured with
relevant KPIacutes
linked to the
different types
of capital and
both long and
short term
objectives
4 Level of
innovation for the
initiative - describe
the uniqueness or
why this initiative
adds new
knowledge
regarding creating
more sustainable
cities
5 Summary
of strategic
learnings
from the
initiative to
share
globally and
to inspire
other cities
SCORING SHEET
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
15 Points for for holistic approach
with points for capitals
represented
15
25
35
45
55
2 5 Points for Objectives
Short Term = 2
Long Term = 3
3 5 Points for KPI
Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be
specifically defined
My point scoring
4 5 Points for Level of Innovation
Slight improvement
Moderate improvement
Major improvement
Extends prior capabilitycapacity
exponentially
Never before done truly new
5 5 Points for Summary of
Strategic Learnings
Clear
Succinct
Strategic
Compelling
Inspiring
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)
983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day
in Jangji River
983803 Water quality
- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002
rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009
- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004
rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009
983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River
- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia
- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom
- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)
- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)
983803 Urban afforestation
- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)
- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)
- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average
(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for
bicycles)
983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)
983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)
Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)
Level
983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of
Seoul)
983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment
highest in all of Seoul
983803 Resident survey
- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)
- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)
Environmental
awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards
983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city
983803 Selected as Green City 2008
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
The objectives of the city council for 2012 are
1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself
by over 10
2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use
of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)
3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor
sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)
4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with
photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)
5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel
operated vehicles to local public transportation
6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in
municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers
7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of
energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and
students
Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy
Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at
httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of
1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining
forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity
Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR
(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy
Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings
planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)
Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui
River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin
(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey
(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-
tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon
(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line
(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities
sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less
smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a
clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon
monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions
and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5
separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil
(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every
six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the
garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in
Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Environment
3 Human
2 Social
5 Culture
6 Political
7 Financial
4 Technical
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Holistic
approach ndash
which types
of capital are
part of the
initiative
And how
they are
involved
2 Object-
ives for
the
initiative
(long and
short
term)
3 Results
measured with
relevant KPIacutes
linked to the
different types
of capital and
both long and
short term
objectives
4 Level of
innovation for the
initiative - describe
the uniqueness or
why this initiative
adds new
knowledge
regarding creating
more sustainable
cities
5 Summary
of strategic
learnings
from the
initiative to
share
globally and
to inspire
other cities
SCORING SHEET
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
15 Points for for holistic approach
with points for capitals
represented
15
25
35
45
55
2 5 Points for Objectives
Short Term = 2
Long Term = 3
3 5 Points for KPI
Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be
specifically defined
My point scoring
4 5 Points for Level of Innovation
Slight improvement
Moderate improvement
Major improvement
Extends prior capabilitycapacity
exponentially
Never before done truly new
5 5 Points for Summary of
Strategic Learnings
Clear
Succinct
Strategic
Compelling
Inspiring
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)
983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day
in Jangji River
983803 Water quality
- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002
rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009
- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004
rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009
983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River
- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia
- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom
- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)
- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)
983803 Urban afforestation
- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)
- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)
- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average
(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for
bicycles)
983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)
983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)
Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)
Level
983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of
Seoul)
983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment
highest in all of Seoul
983803 Resident survey
- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)
- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)
Environmental
awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards
983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city
983803 Selected as Green City 2008
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
The objectives of the city council for 2012 are
1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself
by over 10
2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use
of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)
3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor
sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)
4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with
photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)
5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel
operated vehicles to local public transportation
6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in
municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers
7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of
energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and
students
Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy
Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at
httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of
1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining
forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity
Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR
(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy
Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings
planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)
Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui
River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin
(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey
(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-
tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon
(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line
(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities
sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less
smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a
clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon
monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions
and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5
separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil
(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every
six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the
garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in
Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Holistic
approach ndash
which types
of capital are
part of the
initiative
And how
they are
involved
2 Object-
ives for
the
initiative
(long and
short
term)
3 Results
measured with
relevant KPIacutes
linked to the
different types
of capital and
both long and
short term
objectives
4 Level of
innovation for the
initiative - describe
the uniqueness or
why this initiative
adds new
knowledge
regarding creating
more sustainable
cities
5 Summary
of strategic
learnings
from the
initiative to
share
globally and
to inspire
other cities
SCORING SHEET
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
15 Points for for holistic approach
with points for capitals
represented
15
25
35
45
55
2 5 Points for Objectives
Short Term = 2
Long Term = 3
3 5 Points for KPI
Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be
specifically defined
My point scoring
4 5 Points for Level of Innovation
Slight improvement
Moderate improvement
Major improvement
Extends prior capabilitycapacity
exponentially
Never before done truly new
5 5 Points for Summary of
Strategic Learnings
Clear
Succinct
Strategic
Compelling
Inspiring
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)
983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day
in Jangji River
983803 Water quality
- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002
rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009
- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004
rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009
983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River
- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia
- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom
- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)
- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)
983803 Urban afforestation
- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)
- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)
- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average
(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for
bicycles)
983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)
983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)
Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)
Level
983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of
Seoul)
983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment
highest in all of Seoul
983803 Resident survey
- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)
- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)
Environmental
awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards
983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city
983803 Selected as Green City 2008
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
The objectives of the city council for 2012 are
1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself
by over 10
2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use
of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)
3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor
sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)
4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with
photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)
5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel
operated vehicles to local public transportation
6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in
municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers
7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of
energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and
students
Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy
Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at
httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of
1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining
forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity
Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR
(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy
Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings
planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)
Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui
River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin
(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey
(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-
tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon
(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line
(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities
sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less
smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a
clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon
monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions
and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5
separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil
(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every
six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the
garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in
Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 Holistic
approach ndash
which types
of capital are
part of the
initiative
And how
they are
involved
2 Object-
ives for
the
initiative
(long and
short
term)
3 Results
measured with
relevant KPIacutes
linked to the
different types
of capital and
both long and
short term
objectives
4 Level of
innovation for the
initiative - describe
the uniqueness or
why this initiative
adds new
knowledge
regarding creating
more sustainable
cities
5 Summary
of strategic
learnings
from the
initiative to
share
globally and
to inspire
other cities
SCORING SHEET
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
15 Points for for holistic approach
with points for capitals
represented
15
25
35
45
55
2 5 Points for Objectives
Short Term = 2
Long Term = 3
3 5 Points for KPI
Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be
specifically defined
My point scoring
4 5 Points for Level of Innovation
Slight improvement
Moderate improvement
Major improvement
Extends prior capabilitycapacity
exponentially
Never before done truly new
5 5 Points for Summary of
Strategic Learnings
Clear
Succinct
Strategic
Compelling
Inspiring
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)
983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day
in Jangji River
983803 Water quality
- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002
rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009
- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004
rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009
983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River
- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia
- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom
- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)
- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)
983803 Urban afforestation
- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)
- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)
- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average
(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for
bicycles)
983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)
983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)
Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)
Level
983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of
Seoul)
983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment
highest in all of Seoul
983803 Resident survey
- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)
- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)
Environmental
awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards
983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city
983803 Selected as Green City 2008
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
The objectives of the city council for 2012 are
1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself
by over 10
2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use
of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)
3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor
sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)
4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with
photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)
5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel
operated vehicles to local public transportation
6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in
municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers
7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of
energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and
students
Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy
Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at
httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of
1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining
forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity
Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR
(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy
Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings
planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)
Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui
River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin
(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey
(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-
tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon
(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line
(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities
sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less
smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a
clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon
monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions
and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5
separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil
(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every
six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the
garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in
Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
15 Points for for holistic approach
with points for capitals
represented
15
25
35
45
55
2 5 Points for Objectives
Short Term = 2
Long Term = 3
3 5 Points for KPI
Must relate to Criteria 1 above and be
specifically defined
My point scoring
4 5 Points for Level of Innovation
Slight improvement
Moderate improvement
Major improvement
Extends prior capabilitycapacity
exponentially
Never before done truly new
5 5 Points for Summary of
Strategic Learnings
Clear
Succinct
Strategic
Compelling
Inspiring
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)
983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day
in Jangji River
983803 Water quality
- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002
rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009
- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004
rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009
983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River
- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia
- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom
- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)
- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)
983803 Urban afforestation
- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)
- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)
- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average
(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for
bicycles)
983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)
983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)
Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)
Level
983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of
Seoul)
983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment
highest in all of Seoul
983803 Resident survey
- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)
- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)
Environmental
awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards
983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city
983803 Selected as Green City 2008
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
The objectives of the city council for 2012 are
1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself
by over 10
2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use
of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)
3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor
sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)
4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with
photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)
5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel
operated vehicles to local public transportation
6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in
municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers
7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of
energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and
students
Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy
Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at
httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of
1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining
forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity
Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR
(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy
Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings
planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)
Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui
River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin
(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey
(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-
tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon
(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line
(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities
sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less
smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a
clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon
monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions
and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5
separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil
(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every
six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the
garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in
Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Environment 983803 Waterway restoration 22km restored 81 of the total length (27km)
983803 River water circulation 20000 tons per day in Seongnae River 15000 tons per day
in Jangji River
983803 Water quality
- Seongnae River BOD=329 SS=1374 in 2002
rarr BOD=291 SS=1041 in 2009
- Tan River BOD=1031 SS=1433 in 2004
rarr BOD=716 SS=940 in 2009
983803 Increased diversity in the life forms in Seongnae River
- 36 types of birds 7 types of fish 126 types of insects 1 type of amphibia
- 17 types of invertebrate animals at river bottom
- Inhabitation of boreal digging frogs (level 2 extinction-risk animal)
- Inhabitation of corbiculas and marsh snails (found only in cleanest waters)
983803 Urban afforestation
- Green zone area 279259 in 2001 rarr 834721 in 2009 (200 increase)
- Number of trees 880013 in 2001 rarr 2485714 in 2009 (182 increase)
- Wall-planting wall space of 1025 planted per year on average
(2342 in 2003 rarr 6151 in 2009)
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for
bicycles)
983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)
983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)
Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)
Level
983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of
Seoul)
983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment
highest in all of Seoul
983803 Resident survey
- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)
- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)
Environmental
awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards
983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city
983803 Selected as Green City 2008
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
The objectives of the city council for 2012 are
1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself
by over 10
2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use
of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)
3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor
sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)
4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with
photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)
5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel
operated vehicles to local public transportation
6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in
municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers
7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of
energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and
students
Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy
Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at
httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of
1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining
forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity
Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR
(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy
Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings
planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)
Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui
River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin
(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey
(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-
tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon
(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line
(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities
sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less
smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a
clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon
monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions
and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5
separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil
(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every
six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the
garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in
Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Facility 983803 Bicycle road 110km constructed (265km of outer beltway for
bicycles)
983803 Urban water parks 15 established (2 in 2003 rarr 15 in 2009)
983803 Number of visitors to Seongnae River Water Park 330000 per year (up to 5000 per day)
Satisfaction 983803 Happiness (Seoul survey in 2008) 70 (highest in all of Seoul)
Level
983803 Satisfaction with natural environment (Seoul survey in 2008) 624 (highest in all of
Seoul)
983803 Satisfaction with living environment (Seoul survey in 2008) economicsocial environment
highest in all of Seoul
983803 Resident survey
- General satisfaction level increased each year in the past 4 years (831 in 2009)
- Perception of Songpa District environment-friendly city (325)
Environmental
awards 983803 2009 LivCom Awards
983803 2009 Award in the area of natural city
983803 Selected as Green City 2008
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
The objectives of the city council for 2012 are
1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself
by over 10
2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use
of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)
3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor
sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)
4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with
photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)
5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel
operated vehicles to local public transportation
6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in
municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers
7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of
energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and
students
Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy
Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at
httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of
1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining
forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity
Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR
(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy
Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings
planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)
Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui
River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin
(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey
(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-
tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon
(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line
(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities
sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less
smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a
clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon
monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions
and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5
separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil
(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every
six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the
garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in
Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
The objectives of the city council for 2012 are
1 The reduction of energy consumption of the Town Hall itself
by over 10
2 Homes and facilities built within the municipality with the use
of solar power for sanitary hot water (80 of new buildings)
3 Homes built in the municipality under bio-climatic andor
sustainable architecture criteria (25 of newly built homes)
4 Schools academic centers in the municipality with
photovoltaic equipment (25 of schools academic centers)
5 The incorporation of low energy consumption and ecologic fuel
operated vehicles to local public transportation
6 The introduction of efficiency and energy saving criteria in
municipal contracts for services municipal works and in tender offers
7 Increase the number of citizens aware of the importance of
energy saving above all among immigrants women the elderly and
students
Long term objectives for the 2020 are explained in the Sustainable Energy
Action Plan which is currently being revised The key kpi can be seen at
httpwwwenergiamurciaeupdfCAMBIO_CLIMATICOpdf
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of
1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining
forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity
Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR
(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy
Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings
planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)
Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui
River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin
(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey
(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-
tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon
(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line
(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities
sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less
smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a
clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon
monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions
and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5
separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil
(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every
six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the
garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in
Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPI
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of
1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining
forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity
Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR
(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy
Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings
planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)
Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui
River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin
(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey
(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-
tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon
(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line
(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities
sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less
smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a
clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon
monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions
and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5
separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil
(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every
six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the
garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in
Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
KPIImplantation of 2 new parks (+ 200000 m2 of green areas equipped) Identification of
1000 private areas with potential to become MNHPR (+ 14 million m2 of remaining
forests) Identification of 100 public areas with potential to become Urban Biodiversity
Conservancy Groves (+ 1 million m2 of remaining forests) Implementation of 3 MNHPR
(+ 37600 m2 of protected green areas) Implementation of 1 Biodiversity Conservancy
Grove (+ 10000 m2 of protected green areas) Native trees planting (+ 80000 seedlings
planted) Eradication of invading exotic plants (1000 exotic plants eradicated)
Conclusion of all the studies for the Barigui River basin revitalization (the Barigui
River Basin Revitalization Project) Relocation of families from the Barigui River basin
(750 out of the 1159 families are being relocated in 2010) Curitibas Avifauna survey
(400 species identified) Survey on butterflies (500 species) Conservancy of the red-
tailed Amazon (3 offsprings were captive breeded) Breeding of the red-browed Amazon
(3 offsprings were born in captivity) Implementation of the first step of the Green Line
(a complete avenue mass transportation corridor traffic lanes cycling facilities
sidewalks and linear park) Use of biofuel in the Green Line busses (25 less
smoke and 30 less carbon monoxide emissions) Tube-stations climatized by a
clean system (the system doesnt harm the ozone layer) Control of the carbon
monoxide emissions (in 2008 761 tonsrsquo reduction of carbon monoxide emissions
and in 2009 the reduction was of 22 tons per month) Implementation of 5
separation and recycling parks (500 Ecocitizens benefit) Collection of used cooking oil
(since March 2007 over 58000 litres were transformed) Collection of old tires (every
six months 500 tons of old tires transformed) Beginning of the implementation of the
garbage recycling and processing industry (85 of all the garbage collected in
Curitibas Metropolitan Region will be transformed)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Identify one community that best embodies the
fundamental aspects of a sustainable community and
enacts them in a way that represents the highest value for
the investment made
Commitment to sustainability is measured in terms of
community impact rather than high economic investment
Sustainable Community Award
2010
With World Bank amp Globe Forum gtgtFoundation
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A community is a social group whose
members reside in a specific locality are
administered by some form of common
local governance or inherent political
structure interact economically and
socially and often have a common
cultural geographic and historical
heritage Communities are expected to
exceed populations of 100000
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Traditional View of Sustainable Development
Economy
SocialEnvironment
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Most definitions of sustainability encompass three
fundamental elements consumption balanced with supply the
interconnectedness of social environmental and economic
considerations and equity in access to resources The
predominant definition of sustainable development comes
from the Brundtland Commission Sustainable development
is development that meets the needs of the present without
compromising the ability of future generations to meet their
own needs
World Commission on Environment and Development Our
Common Future (Oxford Great Britain Oxford University
Press 1987 page 8) (Frequently referred to as the
Brundtland Report)
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
3 Human amp Intellectual Captital
2 Social Capital
5 Culture amp Leisure
6 Political Capital
7 Financial Capital
4 Technical amp
Infrastructure Capital
4 Quadrant Map
Subjective Objective
Intersubjective Interobjective
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
A sustainable community demonstrates significant
progress towards four fundamental aspects
Society ndash Is the community developing strong and
harmonious relationships between people communities
regions and nations
Environment ndash Is the community consuming resources in
balance with renewal and the assimilative capacity of
ecosystems
Economy ndash Does the community create equitable
opportunities for all Are basic services met
Comprehensiveness ndash Has the community embodied
sustainability as a fundamental element in its operations
and planning
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
1 RETROFIT ndash designing building and retrofitting resilient habitats and transport
systems in existing urban areas including social housing
2 MESHORG - transitioning modern amp post-modern organizations and networks
into meshworks including topics such as holacracy and requisite organizations
3 DEEPCOACH- exploring the frontiers of 21st century coaching including
approaches such as integral coaching
4 TRANSLEAD - moving beyond integral leadership to transactivist leadership
5 INTEGOV - developing more integral systems of governance for at local
regional national and global levels
6 GREENGROWTH - rethinking economics and strategypolicy for prosperity
through green growth
7 BIORENEW - reforestation biofuels and other applications of cutting edge
biology nanotech and genomics
8 GREENFUND - developing new approaches to finance R2 projects including
green financing mechanisms and alternative currency approaches
9 DEEPCULTURE - what is going on in the worlds of entertainment and
education to shift our culture to a wiser way of being and doing
10 RENERG - pushing the envelope in renewable energy systems from smart
grids to intelligent transport systems
RENAISSANCE2 AGENDA 2010
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
City
Community
4 Quadrant
8 Levels of Complexity
Map of
Capacities
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
Abbotsford Comparison CapacityStopsImproves
2003
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Great St ops Improves
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
Random 250 Comparative WellNOTBetter
All
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Values
C
ho
ice
Well Not Better
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=216
000
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Interns Survey
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
Thought Leaders
Comparative Works WellNot WellBetter
n=12
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Beige Purple Red Blue Orange Green Yellow Turquoise
Works Well Does Not Work Well Work Better
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
Welcoming amp Inclusive Communities Abbotsford
copy Integral City Meshworks Inc
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Simple low cost low technology approach provides clear insight into
how resources taxes and grants can be best invested to release the potential of
the city
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Combo of 234
Petals =
6
How CityCommunity Measures Capacity
53
11
13
16
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
How CityCommunity Allocates Resources
76
9 gt3
12
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Food for ThoughtHow to think BIG enough
What is an
evolutionary
perspective on
Food Life
Resilience
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hives are Living Complex Adaptive System(s)
Indicators amp Awards must recognize amp rewardbull Holonsbull Social holonsbull Holarchiesbull Human Hive
Include individuals enlightened enterprisescities and eco-regions
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Human Hive Generational Cycle Panarchy Gunderson amp Holling 2002 The Fourth Turning Strauss and Howe 1997
P
O
T
E
N
T
I
A
L
connections
+
+
3 Gen Z
Artists
2 Gen Y Young
Adults Heros
1 Gen X
Midlife
Nomads
4 Boomer
Elders
Prophets
3 Silents
Artists
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place
Resilience in the System2010+
Live off renewable
interest = Food
Energy
Renewables
Capital = Gaia
bull Interest = Renewables
bull Withdrawals = sustain eco-regions as well as hive
copyMarilyn Hamilton PhD CGA
Master Rule
Take care of yourselfTake care of each otherTake care of this place