march/april issue of shades

84

Upload: shades-of-the-departed

Post on 06-Mar-2016

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Shades Of The Departed is a digital magazine for those with a fascination for old photographs.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: March/April Issue of Shades
Page 2: March/April Issue of Shades

ColumnsAppealing Subjects pg. 21 A Brief Illustrated Essay

Penelope Dreadful pg. 35A Dreadful Suffragette

Shades Centerfold pg. 39Miss March/April

The Healing Brush pg. 49The Tale of Two Tintypes

iAncestor pg. 63Picturing Technology

In2Genealogy pg. 71A Call To Arms

Captured Moments Returns Next Issue As A Gallery

FeaturesA Gallery Of Political Firsts pg. 5fM

Mini-Me pg. 11Maureen Taylor

A Gallery of Political Photographs pg. 15Carte-de-Visites to Buttons

Behind The Camera pg. 31C.M. Bell & Assassination

Woman’s Journal pg. 43Questions & Answers

In Every Issue

From My Keyboard pg. 2 Letter from the editor

The Exchange pg. 5Your comments

The Last Picture Show Back CoverThe graphic image on the back of a carte-de-visite or cabinet card

Download The MagazineOn The Cover

PhotographPresident JohnQuincy Adamsc o

n t e

n t s

Page 3: March/April Issue of Shades

from my keyboardfOOTNOTEMAVEN

Today, March 15, 2011,  is Shades Of The Departed’s third blog anniversary. Shades  @irst 

post was  called “No Place  For A  Lady,” about my favorite  female photographer,  Evelyn 

Cameron of Montana. Much has happened since that post. I’ve learned a great deal about 

my  favorite subject,  “women wearing glasses,”  and I’ve made  some wonderful  friends. 

But the true joy has been the addition of Shades Of The Departed The Magazine. Here’s 

to many more years of sharing the adventure with you the reader.

The Family Tree Magazine 2011 Best Genealogy Blogs have been announced and Shades 

would like to congratulate our contributors, Denise Levenick, The Family Curator, for her 

award in the Research Advice Category and to Denise Olson, Moultrie Creek Gazette, for 

her award in the Technology Category.

This  issue debuts  the @irst of the picturing  technology  columns in iAncestor by Denise 

Olson. A gallery of Captured Moments scrapbook pages designed by readers will be seen 

in  the  next  issue  of Shades  along with a  Brush With  History’s  @irst  article  on how  to 

create  custom  stamps  and  brushes  in  Photoshop,  Maureen  Taylor’s  Dressed  To  The 

Nines column, and Denise Levenick’s Ancestor ArtiFacts Question & Answer Column. See 

Pg. 79 for how to contribute.

On April 1, Shades will republish the Civil War Issue in honor of the 150th Anniversary. 

Several additions have been made to the original publication.

Oh, and there is a surprise in this issue. A new feature. Please, tell us if you liked it.

Politics & Old Photos

Page 4: March/April Issue of Shades

DENISE OLSON

Denise is the author of The Future of Memories Column. She also writes the blog Family Matters and experiments with her iPad

SHERI FENLEY

Sheri writes The Year Was . . . Column. She also authors the blog The Educated Genealogist.

CAROLINE POINTER

Caroline is the new In2Genealogy Columnist. She is also the author of the Family Stories blog.

PENELOPE DREADFUL

Penelope Dreadful is the alter ego of Denise Levenick. Denise authors the blog, The Family Curator and gives us something “Dreadful” every month.

VICKIE EVERHART

Vicki is the author of Creative Moments. She also authors the blog BeNotForgot.

JANINE SMITH

Janine is the new author of The Healing Brush Column. She also owns Landailyn Research & Restoration and is an award winning restorationist.

REBECCA FENNING

Rebecca authors the Saving Face column. She also writes the blog A Sense of Face.

CRAIG MANSON

Craig authors the Appealing Subjects column. He also writes the blog Geneablogie.

FOOTNOTEMAVEN

Maven edits Shades Of The Departed The Magazine. She also writes the blog footnoteMaven and Shades of the Departed.

contributors

Page 5: March/April Issue of Shades

T H E E X C H A N G E

WE LEAVE A MESSAGE WITH OUR READERS AT THE EXCHANGE

Sunny Morton’s Description of Shades For Family Tree Magazine:

Shades  of  the  Departed:  Gorgeous  antique  images  accompany regular posts  on  how  photographs  help  genealogical  researchers unpuzzle  the  past.  Written  by  footnoteMaven  (honored  in  the Everything  category),  the blog accompanies a  free  bimonthly e‐zine penned by multiple  contributors and edited by the Maven.

First and foremost to all the loyal readers of Shades who went the extra mile to nominate us for a second year and to vote Shades one of Family Tree Magazine’s Top 40 for 2011 in the Research Advice Category.

To the Expert Panel for honoring Shades as their selection in this Category.

To Family Tree Magazine for promoting the online world of Family History Blogging.

To the beautiful friends pictured to the left and to all those who have contributed to this magazine. This is your award. You are Shades. You and the professional work you do in every issue of this magazine are the reason for this award. Stand Up! Take A Bow! Nobody does it better! I can’t thank you enough! APPLAUSE! APPLAUSE! -fM

Thank You!

Page 6: March/April Issue of Shades

A Gallery of Political FirstsEvery family historian understands that if you don’t get the answer you were looking  for,  the fault may lie in the question you asked.

Such  is the case with the Galley of Political Firsts. Who was the Cirst President photographed? Would  that  be  sitting  president  or  former  president?  Who  was  the  Cirst  President photographed  with  his  cabinet?  Who  was  the  Cirst  President  photographed  in  the  White House? So many forms of the “Cirsts” questions. And the “Cirsts” are equally intriguing for First Ladies, women Senators, and women Representatives, as you will see.

THE MISSING DAGUERROTYPE

Portrait  photography  arrived  in  America 

just  in  time  to  record  the  likeness  of  the 

newly  inaugurated  ninth  president  of  the 

United States, William Henry Harrison.

March  4,  1841,  just  after  his  ill‐fated 

inaugural  address  (Harrison  developed 

pneumonia  and  died  31  days  later), 

Harrison  paused  to  have  a  formal 

photographic  portrait  taken  inside  the 

Capitol.  The  photographers  were  Justus  E. 

Moore,  a  prominent  Philadelphia  dentist, 

and his partner  “Captain” Ward.

Unbelievably,  the  present  location  of  the 

daguerreotype  portrait  of  President 

Harrison  is  unknown.  This  is  an extremely 

important historical  photograph, as it is the 

@irst photograph of a United States president 

taken while in of@ice.

Presidential Firsts

5 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 7: March/April Issue of Shades

Whi

te H

ouse

Mus

eum

- ht

tp://

whi

teho

usem

useu

m.o

rg/

This photograph of Polk and his cabinet

(minus Sec. of State James Buchanan) is

not only the first photo of a President and

his cabinet, but it is also the first interior

photograph of the White House. The

photograph was taken by John Plumbe in

the State Dining Room and shows new

wallpaper and chairs purchased by the

Polks. Reflected in the mirror is a crystal

chandelier and behind the group is an

ornate Italian mantle purchased by

President James Monroe.

The  earliest  known  photograph  of  a 

president  of  the  United  States  is  this 

daguerreotype  likeness  of  John  Quincy 

Adams  (President  1825‐1829).  This 

portrait of the former President was taken 

at  the  gallery  of  Bishop  and  Gray,  early 

August  1843,  Utica,  New  York.  President 

Adams was 76 years old.

In  his  diary  Adams  remarked,  “Four 

daguerreotype likenesses of my head were 

taken, two of them jointly with the head of 

Mr.  Bacon.  All  hideous.”  Adams  continued 

his diary entry the following day,  “At seven 

this  morning  Mr.  Bacon  came  and  I  went 

with him to the Shadow Shop, where three 

more  Daguerreotype  likeness  were  taken 

of  me,  no  better  than  those  of  yesterday. 

They are all too true to the original.”

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 6

Page 8: March/April Issue of Shades

Courtesy of The Library of Congress.

First Lady Firsts

Dolley  Madison,  three‐quarter  length  portrait, 

facing front, seated. Daguerreotype by Matthew B. 

Brady,  1848.

There  i s  some  dispute  as  to  who  was 

photographed @irst, Dolley Madison or Sarah Polk. 

Sarah  Polk  was  the  @irst  First  Lady  to  be 

photographed  on  the  White  House  grounds  and 

the @irst to be photographed with her husband.

President James Knox Polk and First 

Lady Sarah Childress Polk.

7 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 9: March/April Issue of Shades

Mrs. Harrison’s Photographs Scarce. There  is  a  large  public  demand  for photographs of the incoming @irst lady of  the  land,  and  the  ubiquitous photographer  seems  unable  to  meet demand. The  fact of the matter  is,  that pictures of Mrs. Benjamin Harrison are very  scarce  and  for  the  @irst  time  in many  decades  circumstances  have stolen a march on the camera @iend.

At half a dozen sources in Philadelphia, where pictures of prominent people all over  the  world  are  for  sale,  it  is  said that  there  are  but  few  of  Mrs. Harrison’s photographs taken in recent years  in  existence,  because  as  one dealer  expressed  it,  “she  was  never struck on herself to have many taken.”

Cour

tesy

of L

ibra

ry o

f Con

gres

s

Mrs.  Cleveland’s  pictures  are  being sold  indiscriminately,  for  in  the goodness  of  her  heart  she  once declared  that  al l  people  could reproduce  her  photograph  if  they wanted to.

“Mrs. Harrison’s Photographs Scare.” Photographic Times, Volume 18. Scoville Manufacturing Co. : 1888. pg. 585.

Note: This would probably account for why I have a photograph of Mrs. Cleveland in my collection.

Colle

ctio

n O

f The

foot

note

Mav

en

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 8

Page 10: March/April Issue of Shades

Courtesy of The Library of Congress.

Jeannette Rankin (Left)June 11, 1880 - May 18, 1973

Representative, 1917–1919, Republican from MontanaRepresentative, 1941–1943, Republican from Montana

The first woman elected to Congress, one of the few

suffragists elected to Congress, and the only Member

of Congress to vote against U.S. participation in World

War I and the only to vote against World War II. She

graduated from Montana State University in 1902 and

attended the New York School of Philanthropy. After a

brief period as a social worker in Spokane, Rankin

entered the University of Washington in Seattle where

she joined the woman suffrage movement, a campaign

that achieved its goal in Washington State in 1910.

Rankin became a professional lobbyist for the National

American Woman Suffrage Association (NAWSA).

Her efforts helped Montana women gain the vote in

1914.

Hattie Ophelia Wyatt Caraway (right)February 1, 1878 - December 21, 1950

Senator, 1931–1945, Democrat from Arkansas

The first woman elected to serve as a United States Senator.

Arkansas governor Harvey Parnell appointed Hattie Caraway to

the vacant seat of her deceased husband. She was sworn into

office on December 9, 1931. With the Arkansas Democratic

party's backing, she easily won a special election in January

1932 for the remaining months of the term, becoming the first

woman elected to the Senate. Hattie avoided the capital's social

and political life as well as the campaign for woman suffrage.

She recalled that "after equal suffrage I just added voting to

cooking and sewing and other household duties."

Senators

9 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 11: March/April Issue of Shades
Page 12: March/April Issue of Shades

A  political  candidate’s  appearance  is  paramount 

these days due to  the power of mass media, but this 

pictorial  focus  dates  all  the  way  back  to  the  mid‐

nineteenth  century  when  the  tiny  tintype  reigned. 

Buttons  to  advertise  a  political  campaign  were  in 

use  since  Andrew  Jackson  ran  for  president,  but 

those  didn’t  feature  actual  photographs.  John  C. 

Fremont’s campaign in 1856 utilized a brass framed 

tintype  medallion,  but  it  is  not  as  well‐known  as 

Abraham Lincoln’s 1860 image (Right).  His  famous 

two‐sided  brass  framed  tintype    campaign 

medallion  set  the  stage  for  future  candidates 

utilizing small pinned buttons featuring portraits to advertise their political aspirations. 

Tintypes or ferreotypes were patented by Hamilton Lamphere Smith, a professor at Kenyon 

College in Ohio.  While commonly known as tintypes, these images were actually created on 

a  sheet  of  iron  coated  with  light  sensitive  chemicals.  After  developing,  the  image  was 

usually  coated  in  varnish.    They  could  be  inexpensively  produced  in  various  sizes.  The 

Lincoln tintype is only 2.5 cm in diameter.2 

This piece of political memorabilia image utilized a card portrait taken by Mathew Brady on 

February 27,  1860. Brady opened his  @irst  studio  in 1844 in New York City  and sought to 

photograph  the  well  known  and  famous  from  many  different  professions.  This  carte  de 

visite portrait also  appeared on the  cover  of Harper’s Weekly before being produced as  a 

tintype. 3

According to an article in the New York Evening Post, Richard C. McCormick, who was part 

of  a  committee  organizing  Lincoln’s  Cooper  Union  speech  reported  that  the  candidate 

Mini-MeMaureen Taylor explores Political Memorabilia and Lincoln’s Campaign

11 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 13: March/April Issue of Shades

arrived  for  this  portrait  in  a  wrinkled  new  suit.4  [You  can  read  Lincoln’s  speech  in  its 

entirety  in  the  New  York  Herald  (available  on  GenealogyBank.com)].5  In  the  campaign 

button, only Lincoln’s head and shoulders show.  

On  the  reverse  is  his  running mate  Hannibal 

Hamlin,  of Maine. Hamlin was an experienced 

politician.  Before  becoming  Lincoln’s  Vice‐

President,  Hamlin served  in  the Maine House 

of  Representatives,  the  U.S.  House  of 

Representatives,  as  a  U.S.  Senator  and  was 

Governor  of  Maine.6  These  double‐sided 

buttons with a candidate and his running mate 

are  called  jugates  and  are  sought  after  by 

collectors. 7

Tintypes  are  considered very durable,  but  they  are  susceptible to  scratches  and bending 

which allows the photographic image to @lake off or for rust to form.   A  few years ago I had 

an  opportunity  to  view  an  original  1860  Lincoln  medallion  and  see  how  a  photo 

conservator had painstakingly restored it to mint condition. If you have a damaged tintype, 

it may be able to be stabilized and restored. 8

In his re‐election campaign of 1864 Lincoln again used a tintype to promote his candidacy. 

The images used on pins,  and badges were taken by Anthony Berger or by Mathew Brady. 

These are available for  viewing on the  Library of Congress [LINK] website  in  their Prints 

and Photograph collection. 

These teeny photos made a powerful  political  statement. Future candidates took  note and 

the picture button remains popular today. 

Maureen Taylor is the author of Finding Your Civil War Ancestor in Your Family Album (Picture Perfect Press, 2011). 

1 Floyd Rinhart, Marion Rinhart and Robert W Wagner. The American Tintype ( Columbus, Ohio: Ohio State University Press, 1999) 9. 2 Mary Panzer, Mathew Brady and the Image of History (Washington: Smithsonian InsFtuFon Press for the NaFonal Portrait Gallery, 1997) 17.

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 12

Page 14: March/April Issue of Shades

3 Philip B. Kunhardt III, Peter W. Kunhardt, and Peter W. Kunhardt, Jr., Lincoln, Life-Size (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 2009) 34. 4 “The Presidential Campaign Another Republican Orator on the Stump” New York Herald February 28,1860 p. 25 “Hannibal Hamlin” Maine Memory www.mainememory.net/bin/Detail?ln=28921 accessed February 4, 20116 Sally C. Luscomb, The Collector’s Encyclopedia of Bu>ons 4th ediFon ( Atglen, Pennsylvania: Schiffer, 1999) 33‐34.  7 The full condiFon and treatment report appear in Maureen Taylor, Preserving Your Family Photographs 

(Westwood, MA: Picture Perfect Press, 2010). Available on Amazon.com. 

Finding the Civil War in Your Family Album

Maureen A. Taylor

Maureen Taylor, the Photo Detective, turns her attention to portraits and pictures taken in the Civil War era to help you find wartime stories in your family photo collection. These images, whether it's a man in uniform or a woman posing with her children, tell the story of your family's involvement in a critical period of history. If you're not sure if your photo dates from that timeframe, this book will help you determine when it was taken.

Purchase The Book Here [LINK]

13 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 15: March/April Issue of Shades
Page 16: March/April Issue of Shades

A Gallery of PoliticalPhotographs

A  carte‐de‐visite  used  by  Alexander Kennedy  to  run  for  County  Treasurer of Albany County, New York, for a three year term 1872 to 1875.

Kennedy  was  the  incumbent,  having been  elected  as  County  Treasurer  in 1869. He lost this election to Nathan D. Wendell.

The carte reads “For County Treasurer, Alexander  Kennedy,  1872,  Assiduity, 1875. M.B. Davidson, Security.”

A  bond  had  to  be  posted  for  the election.  Davidson may  have been his bond holder.

Bi-centennial History of Albany. History of the county of Albany, N.Y., from 1609 to 1886. New York : W.W. Munsell & Co., 1886.

Phot

o In

The

Col

lect

ion

Of f

ootn

oteM

aven

Carte-de-Visite

15 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 17: March/April Issue of Shades

1895 Cabinet Card ‐ THE FOURTH STATE SENATE OF MONTANA by Taylor, Helena, Montana.

26 individuals are pictured: 21 Senators, the Governor, Lieutenant Governor, Chaplain, Sergeant at Arms, and Secretary. 

The image of each Senator has his name and county labeled underneath. The others have name and title shown.

Elected in 1894 they served from 1895‐1897. There were 13 Republicans, 5 Democrats and 3 Populists.

Because the location of the State Capital was chosen in the same 1894 election (Helena over Anaconda), the State Capitol Building had not been constructed and the Legislature met in the Merchants Hotel, Helena.

There were 21 Senators, one from each county (there are now 56 counties) and each county was allowed one Senator regardless of its population (today, Senate Districts are 

Senators: 

Brown, Wetzel, Hoffman, Green, Eggleston, Smead, Steele, Power, Folsom, Leonard, Swift, Babcock, Cullen, Chandler, Hatch, Bronson, Ramsdell, Sligh, Cooper, Flowerree, Hurd.

Governor: John E. Rickards (R) 1893‐1897

Lt. Governor: Botkin (Senate President) 

Chaplain: CombsSgt. At Arms: StockpoleSecretary: Foster

Cabinet Cards

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 14

Page 18: March/April Issue of Shades

Many  states  compiled  photographic  albums  of  their  representatives  that  included autographs. I purchased a beautiful album of Vermont State Senators for the year 1884.

The oldest Senator is the Hon. Jon Curtis, of Bennington County. Hon. John Curtis, Dorset, republican, was born in Dorset, Dec. 24, 1819. He is a scientific and mechanical engineer. Was graduated from the University of Vermont in the class of 1847. He was postmaster in Dorset from 1876 to 1884, and has been superintendent of schools for about fifteen years. Religious preference, Methodist. P.O. address is North Dorset.

OFFICERS OF THE SENATE

Chauncey W. Brownell, Jr., Burlington, Secretary, republican, was born in Williston, Oct. 7, 1847. He is a lawyer, and located in Burlington in 1873. Is a graduate of the University of Vermont, class of 1870, and of the Law University of Albany in 1872. Was assistant secretary of the senate from 1874 to 1880, and succeeded to thee office ofsecretary in 1880, which

position he also held in 1882. He is the state's attorney elect for Chittenden county. Religious preference, Congregationalist.

Jesse Stearns, Middlebury, Reporter, republican, was born in Starksboro, Jan 21, 1859. He is a law student, and located in town in 1879. Was educated at Middlebury College, of which he is a graduate, class of 1883. Religious preference, Congregationalist.

Phot

o In

The

Col

lect

ion

Of f

ootn

oteM

aven

Jon Curtis, Bennington County

Chauncey W. Brownell, Jr.

Jesse Stearns

Albums

17 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 19: March/April Issue of Shades

Lafayette Soper, St. Johnsbury, Doorkeeper, republican, was born in Plattsburgh, N.Y., June 3, 1833. He is a weigh-master of the Fairbanks scale-works, and located in town in 1853. He received a common school education. He was orderly sergeant of Co. A, 11 regiment of Vt. Vols. He has been a justice of the peace. Religious preference, Congregationalist.

John E. Weeks, Salisbury, Assistant Doorkeeper, republican, was born in Salisbury, June 14, 1850. He is a farmer, and was educated at the common schools and at the Middlebury high school. He was a selectman in 1880, '82 nd '83, and has been a lister since 1883. Religious preference, Congregationalist.

Thomas C. Underwood

Thomas C. Underwood, Burlington, Page, republican, was born in Burlington, June 17, 1869. He is a student, and was a page in the senate of 1882. Religious preference, Episcopalian.

John E. WeeksLafayette Soper

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 18

Page 20: March/April Issue of Shades

J.B. Patton lost the 1908 election for County Treasurer Marion County, Ohio, to the Democrat William Wottring.

Owen D. Connolly served as the Assistant City Attorney for Troy, New York in 1904. It looks as if he may have lost the election. In 1910 he was the Assistant City Corporate Counsel and in 1920 he was in private practice.

Dr. R. H. Finefrock and Frank E. White were not researched.

Phot

o In

The

Col

lect

ion

Of f

ootn

oteM

aven

Campaign Cards

19 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 21: March/April Issue of Shades

Political Photographic Buttons

A  memorial  cabinet  card of  President William  McKinley,  First  lady  Ida McKinley  ,  and  their  home  in Canton, Ohio.

President McKinley, the 25th President of  the  United  States  was  the  @irst President of the 20th Century.

The card is crudely assembled and contains no information for the photographer.

Butto

ns In

The

Col

lect

ion

Of f

ootn

oteM

aven

Phot

o In

The

Col

lect

ion

Of f

ootn

oteM

aven

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 20

Page 22: March/April Issue of Shades

THERE  is  a  Cield  that  is  always  fresh.  New  political  stars  are  rising  on  the horizon  daily,  and  they  form  the  best  kind  of  business  material  for  the photographer—especially  if  he  specializes  and  goes  after  the  business  in  a systematic  and  businesslike  manner.~W.  Clement  Moore,Brief  Business Building Plans for Photographers  [Bulletin of Photography,  Vol.  11,  No.  268, pp. 461‐462, Sept 25, 1912]

Oh  if  only  it  were  that  simple‐‐the  relationships  between  politics  and  photography, 

politician and photographer.     And at  @irst,  it was. The earliest photographs of politicians 

were portraits, as the state of most photography at @irst consisted largely of portraiture.

President St. Nick?

The  @irst  sitting  U.S.  President  during  the  age  of  photography was Martin  Van Buren,  a 

charter  founder  of  the  Democratic  Party,  who  if  he  lived  today  would  be  considered  a 

conservative Republican.  [His  is a name that has turned up in my  life a couple of times:  I 

attended Martin Van Buren  Junior High School  and  I  recently discovered a  @irst  cousin  in 

Texas whose @irst and middle names are Martin Van Buren]. 

Van Buren was probably was  the @irst President  to be photographed, although  it not clear 

that the photograph was taken during his term in of@ice.

APPEALING SUBJECTS

a brief illustrated essay OBSERVATIONS ABOUT POLITICS & PHOTOGRAPHY

CRAIG MANSON

21 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 23: March/April Issue of Shades

Martin Van Buren, 8th President of the United States

"His eyes — how they twinkled! His dimples: how merry,His cheeks were like roses, his nose like a cherry;His droll little mouth was drawn up like a bow . . ." 

­A Visit from St Nicholas,1823]

Collect a number of the photos of leading politicians taken by some of the best photographers, and you will Cind the attitude in most of the cases is straight, chest extended, lips Cirm and eyes cold, in many cases almost expressionless. Now mind you, I am not saying that this is the best attitude for a political photograph, but rather the usual one.~W. Clement Moore

Van Buren's photo‐portrait  is  interesting  precisely  because it belies Moore's  truths  about 

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 22

Page 24: March/April Issue of Shades

political photographs of the era.   Could the author of the preeminent children's Christmas 

poem  (coincidentally  also  named  Clement  Moore)  have  been  describing  his  fellow  New 

Yorker and then‐U.S. Senator when the poem was written in 1823? 

Compare Van Buren's portrait with that  of Andrew Johnson,  the 17th President.   Johnson 

seems to be the model  for Moore's (that being W. Clement Moore, the photography writer) 

take on political portraiture.

Andrew Johnson, 17th President of the United States. 

"[T]he attitude. . . is straight, chest extended, lips Cirm and eyes cold, . . . almost expressionless." ]

23 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 25: March/April Issue of Shades

Teddy Roosevelt Matures Political Photography

The  @irst  national  politician  to  make 

political  use  of photography  on  a  large‐

scale basis had to be Theodore Roosevelt. 

The  rough‐riding  president  made  good 

copy and a photo being worth a thousand 

words ,  certainly  made  excel lent 

photography.

Here's a "Clashlight photo" of Teddy at the University of Chicago campaigning for the Progressive ["Bull Moose"] party in 1912.

And an "action shot" in stereo  of TR during the 1912 campaign

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 24

Page 26: March/April Issue of Shades

In TR's era,   political photography started come of age, moving from portraiture to "candid" 

photography. ["candid" is placed in quotation marks, because there is nothing candid about 

any photograph of a politician, especially if the politician has anything to do with it].

Why Calvin Coolidge Had So Little to Say

No scholar is willing to say for sure, but it may be that the "photo‐op" was invented by the 

Coolidge administration.   And if Silent Cal  did not invent  the photo‐op he carried it to  the 

status of high art. In the following montage,  see Coolidge (1) speaking at all‐black Howard 

University  in  Washington,  (  2)  laying  a  cornerstone  at  a  Jewish  community  Center;  (3) 

signing a bill  for wounded veterans' bene@its on the White House lawn [yes,  that's General 

John "Black  Jack" Pershing next  to  the President and Grace Goodhue Coolidge behind her 

husband];  and  (4) most  improbably  of  all,   meeting  with members  of  the  Sioux  Indian 

Republican Club of the Rosebud reservation.

Fig. 1Fig. 2

Fig. 3 Fig. 4

Page 27: March/April Issue of Shades

Ever  after,  Presidents  have  used  such  stage‐managed  events  to  create  images  and 

impressions  that they control instead leaving matters to  the candid lens and random [and 

not so random] biases of the photojournalist's camera.  That sort of control over images has 

sparked a backlash from photographers and now the game is afoot!

Both  photographers  and  politicians  recognize  the  simple  truth  in  a  2005  article  by Germaine Greer:

"Painted portraiture  is understood to involve an element of idealisation; photography, on  the other hand,  is trusted as a record of the truth. The average  reader  of  newspapers  and  magazines  still  believes  that photographs  are  images  of  what  was  really  happening,  because  the photographer is of necessity an eyewitness."

   Photography Can Make Leaders ­ or Bring Them Down. Germaine Greer on Image, Power and Paranoia.  The Guardian, Saturday 25 June 2005 [LINK]

Greer's  ultimate  point  is  that  the  public,  amazingly  enough,  seldom  takes  note  of  the 

propagandistic  manipulation  of  photography  by  both  politicians  and  photojournalists.  

Greer  holds  photography  responsible,  at  least  in  part,  for  the  popularity  of both  John  F. 

Kennedy and Adolf Hitler.

But politics and photography are not  just about the pretty and the powerful.   Photography 

and politics are essentially about people, regular people.

["The camera is an instrument that teaches people how to see without a camera." 

~ Dorothea Lange]

The stereograph opposite depicts  a  crowd in New  York City awaiting election results  at  a 

time when the biggest name in wired communications was Western Union.  And they didn't 

project winners or losers!

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 26

Page 28: March/April Issue of Shades

[New York photo. caption:Watching the election returns‐‐great crowds before the Times Building and the Astor Hotel, New York, 1906].

This  1938  photograph  from  the  Farm  Security  Administration,  entitled  Political  Forum 

before  Dinner,  illustrates  everyday  Americans  exercising  their  inherent  right  to  political 

speech, during a time of great crisis in America.

27 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 29: March/April Issue of Shades

But the most poignant political photography is not just about people; in America, it's about 

the individual.

I Am An American PhotographTaken by the greatest political photographer of all time, Dorothea Lange

San Francisco, California, March 1942. A store, at 13th and Franklin streets, on December 8, the day after Pearl Harbor. The  store was closed following orders to persons of Japanese descent to evacuate from certain West Coast areas. The owner,  a  University  of  California  graduate,  was  housed  with  hundreds  of evacuees  in  War  Relocation  Authority  centers  for  the  duration  of  the war.~excerpted  from  the  of@icial  caption  by  the  Farm  Security Administration/Of@ice of War Information.

Photo credits: All courtesy Library of Congress

1. Martin Van Buren:Title: [Former President Martin Van Buren, half‐length portrait, facing right] 

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 28

Page 30: March/April Issue of Shades

• Date Created/Published: [photographed between 1840 and 1862, printed later] • Reproduction Number: LC‐USZ62‐13008 (b&w @ilm copy neg. of detail) LC‐BH82401‐5239 (b&w @ilm copy neg.) • Rights Advisory: No known restrictions on publication.• Call Number: PRES FILE ‐ Van Buren, Martin‐‐Photos • Repository: Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division Washington, D.C. 20540 USA • Accessible  at http://www.loc.gov/pictures/item/96522273/.

2. Andrew Johnson:

Date Created/Published: [between 1855 and 1865, printed later] 

• Reproduction Number: LC‐USZ62‐13017 (b&w @ilm copy neg. of detail) • Rights Advisory: No known restrictions on publication.• Call Number: PRES FILE ‐ Johnson, Andrew‐‐Photo‐‐Bust  • Repository: Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division Washington, D.C. 20540 USA• Accessible at http://www.loc.gov/pictures/item/96522530/

3. Theodore Roosevelt

  a. University of Chicago‐‐Date Created/Published: [ca. 1912] • Reproduction Number: LC‐USZ62‐32741 (b&w @ilm copy neg.) • Rights Advisory: No known restrictions on publication.• Call Number: PRES FILE ‐ Roosevelt, Theodore‐‐Miscellaneous Political and Social Activities [item] [P&P] • Repository: Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division Washington, D.C. 20540 USA

• Accessible at http://hdl.loc.gov/loc.pnp/pp.print 

b.  TR in auto‐‐Creator(s): Keystone View Company, • Date Created/Published: Meadville, Pa. : Keystone View Co., c1923 June 2, from a stereograph taken earlier. • Reproduction Number: LC‐DIG‐stereo‐1s02389 (digital @ile from original) • Rights Advisory: No known restrictions on publication.• Call Number: STEREO PRES FILE ‐ Roosevelt, Theodore‐‐Campaign of 1912 • Other Number: J261970 • Repository: Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division Washington, D.C. 20540 USA

• Accessible at: http://hdl.loc.gov/loc.pnp/pp.print 

4.  Calvin Coolidge

A. Howard University

Date Created/Published: [1924 June 6] 

• Medium: 1 photographic print. • Reproduction Number: LC‐USZ62‐111731 (b&w @ilm copy neg.) • Rights Advisory: No known restrictions on publication.• Call Number: LOT 12283, v. 3  • Notes: 

• National Photo Company Collection. • In album: v. 3, p. 14, no. 30989. 

• Accessible at: http://www.loc.gov/pictures/item/94509211/ 

B. Jewish Community Center

Date Created/Published: [1925 May 3] 

• Part of: National Photo Company Collection (Library of Congress) • Reproduction Number: LC‐DIG‐npcc‐13705 (digital @ile from original) • Rights Advisory: No known restrictions on publication.• Call Number: LC‐F8‐ 35839 [P&P] • Repository: Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division Washington, D.C. 20540 USA • Accessible at: http://www.loc.gov/pictures/item/npc2007013704/ 

C. Signing Veterans Bill

29 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 31: March/April Issue of Shades

• Date Created/Published: [1924] • Reproduction Number: LC‐USZ62‐111372 (b&w @ilm copy neg.) • Rights Advisory: No known restrictions on publication.• Call Number: LOT 12283, v. 2 • Repository: Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division Washington, D.C. 20540 USA • Notes: 

• National Photo Company Collection. • Item in album: v. 2, p. 2, no. 30959.  Accessible at:  http://www.loc.gov/pictures/item/94508212/ 

D. Meeting the Sioux Indian Republican Club

Date Created/Published: [1925] 

• Reproduction Number: LC‐USZ62‐35252 (b&w @ilm copy neg.) • Call Number: PRES FILE ‐ Coolidge, Calvin, 1872‐1933‐‐with Indians  • Notes: 

• No. 34605. • Accessible at: 

   http://www.loc.gov/pictures/item/95500767/ 

5.  New York Election Night

Date Created/Published: Chicago : H.C. White Co., 1907. 

• Reproduction Number: LC‐USZ62‐98435 (b&w @ilm copy neg.) • Rights Advisory: No known restrictions on publication.• Call Number: STEREO U.S. GEOG FILE ‐ New York‐‐New York City‐‐Street scenes • Accessible at:   http://www.loc.gov/pictures/item/89716041/ 

6.  Political Forum before Dinner, Ohio 1938

Date Created/Published: 1938 Aug. 

• Part of: Farm Security Administration ‐ Of@ice of War Information Photograph Collection (Library of Congress) • Reproduction Number: LC‐USF3301‐006611‐M2 (b&w @ilm dup. neg.) • Rights Advisory: No known restrictions. For information, see U.S. Farm Security Administration/Of@ice of War 

Information Black & White Photographs(http://www.loc.gov/rr/print/res/071_fsab.html)• Call Number: LC‐USF33‐ 006611‐M2 [P&P] LOT 1032 • Other Number: F 9066 • Repository: Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division Washington, DC 20540 USA http://hdl.loc.gov/

loc.pnp/pp.print • Accessible at:    http://www.loc.gov/pictures/item/fsa1997018545/PP/ 

7.  I am an American

Creator: Dorothea Lange, photographer 

• Date Created/Published: 1942 Mar. • Reproduction Number: LC‐USZ62‐23602 (b&w @ilm copy neg.) • Rights Advisory: No known restrictions on publication.• Call Number: LOT 1801 • Repository: Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division Washington, D.C. 20540 USA • Notes: 

• No. A‐35. • Original negative is at the National Archives and Records Administration, NARA # 210‐G‐A35. • Published in: Dorothea Lange : American photographs / Therese Thau Heyman, Sandra S. Phillips, John 

Szarkowski. San Francisco : San Francisco Museum of Modern Art : Chronicle Books, c1994, plate 87. 

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 30

Page 32: March/April Issue of Shades

Behindthe CameraCharles Milton BELL, Indians and assassination politics in Washington, D.C. - fM

Charles Milton Bell, 1843 - 1893

Charles Milton Bell was the youngest member

of a family of photographers who operated a

studio in Washington, D. C., from around 1860

to 1874.

Charles established his own studio on

Pennsylvania Avenue in 1873 and it rapidly

became a fashionable place. Shortly after it

opened, Ferdinand Vandeveer Hayden became

a patron, sending Indian visitors who were in

Washington to the studio to have portraits

made. Ferdinand Hayden was well known

throughout America and Europe for his

explorations of the American West. Hayden put

Yellowstone on the map; documenting the

wonders of the region, and utilizing

photography in his reports as early as 1868. His

photographer was Bell. Most of the Indian

delegations to Washington, D.C. were

photographed by Bell.

Lucy Craig 1895

Phot

o In

The

Col

lect

ion

Of f

ootn

oteM

aven

31 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 33: March/April Issue of Shades

But  Bell’s most  interesting brush with political  photography  came on July  2,  1881 when 

President  Gar@ield was  shot  twice  by  Charles  Julius  Guiteau,  a  failed New  York  attorney 

whose  specialty  was  small  claims  and who  had always  been of  questionable  sanity.  The 

President  survived  for  eighty  days,  eventually  dying  of  sepsis.  The  only  photographer 

authorized by the defendant Guiteau and Washington authorities to visit the jail cell to take 

portraits  prior  to  the  trial  was  C.M.  Bell.  It  is  believed  that  Guiteau  entered  into  an 

agreement  with  Bell  for  the  sale  of  these  portraits  to  raise  funds  for  his  defense.  On 

February  8,  1882,  Guiteau wrote  to  a  prospective  buyer,  "Dear  Sir:  Photographs  are one 

dollar  apiece  or $9 per  dozen.  .  .The photograph is  very  @ine.  Send for what you wish by 

money order."

Bell chronicled everything associated with the trial. He took studies of the Baltimore and

Potomac Rail Road Depot where the shooting occurred, the courthouse, the gun, the assassin, the

victim, the doctors, defense attorneys, prosecutors, and various portraits of the jurors, including

the sole African American juror. Guiteau went to trial on November 14, 1881. The verdict was

rendered January 25, 1882, and he was hanged at the jail in Washington, D.C. five months

Cour

tesy

of t

he L

ibra

ry o

f Con

gres

s

Cour

tesy

of H

erita

ge A

mer

ican

a

President Garfield

Cour

tesy

of t

he L

ibra

ry o

f Con

gres

sCo

urte

sy o

f the

Lib

rary

of C

ongr

ess

Cour

tesy

of t

he L

ibra

ry o

f Con

gres

s

Guiteau

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 32

Page 34: March/April Issue of Shades

THE STUDIOS OF AMERICA. ‐ No. 9. — C. M. Bell's Gallery, Washington, D. C.

This palatial studio occupies the premises numbered 459, 461, 463, and 465 Pennsylvania Avenue,  the  most  celebrated  thoroughfare  of  the  national  capital.  On  either  side  of  the entrance, which is nearly on a level with the street, are large plate glass windows, adorned with a  tastefully  arranged collection of  cartes,  cabinets,  boudoir,  and panel  pictures.  This array  attracts  the  attention of passers by  on the broad Avenue, who,  after  looking  at  the specimen photographs, are very much inclined to pass into the reception room, where they will at once be captivated by the elegance of its appointments.

Encircling  the  center  of  this  large  room,  80  x 50 feet  in  size,  is  a  counter,  on which  are placed handsome  glass  show  cases  @illed with examples of both wet  and dry plate work. Within the enclosure are desks and chairs arranged for the convenience and comfort of the clerical  force  employed.  Hung  upon  the  walls,  and  supported  by  easels,  are  pictures  in crayon, charcoal, india ink, and oil, from the bust to full life‐size @igures.

Ascending  an  easy Might  of quarter winding stairs,  you  are brought  into  view  of a more elaborate display of art. The eye will rest on ornately painted ceilings and walls,  lighted by full  light  French  plate  glass  windows  and  a  central  dome skylight,  from which gracefully depends  a  large  chandelier.  The  @loor,  it will  next  be  noticed,  is  richly  carpeted.  In  each corner  of  the  room has  been  placed  a beautiful  life‐size  female  @igure  in bronze,  cast  by Theo. A. Mills. Beneath the chandelier is a bronze statue of a hunter and dog.  Interspersed among the easy chairs and articles of virtu are marble busts set on Aesthetically patterned pedestals. The walls are ornamented by more specimens of photographic  landscape work appropriately framed. Amid the perfect blending of colors, surrounded by the evidences of a re@inement of taste, a feeling of ease and contentment steals over you, and, sotto voce, you murmur, "'Tis good to be here."

Passing  in  due  time  to  the  back  of  the  room,  you  enter  one  of  the  two  well  arranged dressing  rooms,  separated  by  a  wide  companion  wav,  through  which  you  pass  to  the operators' reception room under the skylight. Here you are surrounded by a large array of backgrounds and accessories necessary  to  the works of art here made. The dimensions of this room are 30 x 40 feet.  Light enters  through ground glass  from a north exposure.  Still further back is a labyrinth of rooms devoted to the mechanical part of the business.

Connected with and forming part of this studio, is the spacious gallery formerly occupied by Mr. Whitehurst,  now  deceased,  under whose skylight  has been posed Henry Clay,  John C. Calhoun, Daniel Webster, and many other famous statesmen.

We are informed that the great success of Mr. Bell  is due to  his suavity of manner coupled with  high  artistic  ability,  and  to  the  gentlemanly  deportment  observed  by  his  corps  of assistants. The rule is, politeness to everybody.

A description of Bell’s Studio from the Photographic Times and American Photographer, 1883.

33 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 35: March/April Issue of Shades

Cour

tesy

of t

he L

ibra

ry o

f Con

gres

s

Washington, D.C. - photographing an Indian delegation,

in [C.M.] Bell's studio, for the government

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 34

Page 36: March/April Issue of Shades
Page 37: March/April Issue of Shades

Have  you  seen  this  woman?  Marjorie  Mullerschoen  is  wanted  in  connection  with 

Subversive Activity,  speci@ically Aiding and Abetting and Encouraging YOUNG girls, HAPPY 

Homemakers,  and DUTIFUL Dowagers  in pursuing the female independence of extending 

Woman’s Suffrage in our Great Nation.

What the diminutive Miss Mullerschoen lacks in height,  she makes up for in sheer Force of 

Personality,  as can be attested by  those who have  fallen under the  spell  of her  Even and 

Sane  Argument  and  her  Persuasive  Power  of  Speech.  Most  often  found mid‐day  in  the 

busiest boroughs of our  fair city Miss Mullerschoen has made  it  her business  to  befriend 

the Common Woman and to educate the uneducated in Woman’s Potential should the Right 

to  Vote  be  extended  to  our  “fairer  sex.”  She  is  not  intimidated  by  the  burly  butcher 

brandishing the  tools  of his  trade when she stops to speak  to his wife  as  she sweeps  the 

walk  in  front  of  his  shop.  No,  not  this  Jousting  Joan,  not  this  crusading  Queen.  Miss 

Mullerschoen has been observed to pull herself to her full height, tilt back her noble brow 

and look  the surly Brute  full  in  the  eyes. With only  a withering stare,  he quickly  backed 

down and retreated to the Shadows of his shop.

In  addition  to  her  admirable  qualities  of  Elocution  and  Education,  Miss  Mullerschoen 

displays a certain Elegance of person which is only seen in the rarest of young women. Her 

voice  is  never  shrill  or  harsh,  her  manner  never  base.  She  has  been observed  assisting 

PENELOPE DREADFUL

the dreadful suffragetteW A N T E D !

BY PENELOPE DREADFUL

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 36

Page 38: March/April Issue of Shades

young mothers with an unruly  brood,  and  soothing an old woman recently widowed and 

alone.

Some  Say  they  have  seen  Miss  Mullerschoen  brandishing  crude  signs  and  campaigning 

irreverently  before  the  political  of@icials  of our City,  but  if this  is  true,  surely  it  is  for  the 

Greater Good of Achieving a Most Noble and Honorable Goal. 

Some Say that her habitual lengthy overcoat conceals contraband goods, but only if placards 

of paper and pen have  become prohibited by  law.  Citizens would do well  to  recall  that  in 

this Great Nation, women AND men are guaranteed the Right to speak freely. 

Some  Say  that  Miss Mullerschoen oversteps  the  boundaries  of propriety  and  decency  by 

presenting  her  person  before  the  public  and  proclaiming  her  personal  preference  for 

political power. Would that we all had her courage. 

Miss  Mullerschoen  is  Inspirational  to  both  Men  and  Women;  those  with  power  and 

prominence do not deter her. Would that each of us  could be so  brave. Miss Mullerschoen 

gives voice  to  the voiceless, gives  dreams  to  those in desperation.  Even the most  junior of 

of@ice assistants can @ind hope for a better situation in Miss Mullerschoen’s courage.

Some  Say  Miss  Mullershoen  is  Subversive  and  Dangerous;  approach  this  woman  with 

caution. She has been known to steal a man’s heart.

Darling,

See you tonight after the Rally. Good Luck as Always.

Your devoted husband, Charles

14 February 1899

Copyright 2011, Denise Levenick

Photograph Courtesy of the footnoteMaven

37 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 39: March/April Issue of Shades

Imag

e co

urte

sy o

f Lib

rary

of C

ongr

ess

Page 40: March/April Issue of Shades

Miss March/April

Page 41: March/April Issue of Shades
Page 42: March/April Issue of Shades

Lookin' through Shades MagazineFound something tucked there in‐between

My blood runs coldMy memories have all been soldGreat Grandma is a centerfoldGreat Grandma is a centerfold

A part of me has just been rippedThe ages from my mind are strippedThat unnamed woman can't deny itfootnoteMaven had to buy it! 

My blood runs coldMy memories have all been soldGreat Grandma is a centerfoldGreat Grandma is a centerfold

It's okay, we understandNot all heirlooms are in our handWe know that when this issue's goneGreat Grandma’s centerfold lives on 

My blood runs coldMy memories have all been soldGreat Grandma is a centerfoldYes, Great Grandma is a centerfold

Great Grandma Is A Centerfold

Phot

o In

The

Col

lect

ion

Of f

ootn

oteM

aven

What began as an innocent remark by Diana Ritchie 

(Random  Relatives)  during  Miriam  Midkiff ’s 

(Ancestories) Scanfest;  became the  germ  of an  idea 

for  the  Shades  Old  Photo  Centerfold.  Yes,  Great 

Grandma will be  a centerfold in all  issues of Shades 

starting with March/April. Thank you, Diana, it was a 

great idea!

41 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 43: March/April Issue of Shades

Imag

e co

urte

sy o

f foo

tnot

eMav

en

Page 44: March/April Issue of Shades
Page 45: March/April Issue of Shades

What are the chief objections now urged against Woman Suffrage, and what are the best answers to them:

If women vote they must fight. (My personal favorite.)

Women are the mothers of men. Lucy Stone says: "Some woman perils her life for her country every time a soldier is born. Day and night she does picket duty by his cradle. For years she is his quartermaster, and gathers his rations. And then, when he becomes a man and a voter, shall he say to his mother, 'If you want to vote you must first kill somebody? It is a coward's argument."

Suffrage is not a right of anybody.

To say so is to deny the principles of the Declaration of Independence and the Bill of Rights. "Governments derive their just powers from the consent of the governed"—women are governed. "Taxation without representation is tyranny"—women are taxed. "Political power inheres in the people "—women are people. To deny these principles is to justify despotism. "The men who refuse the ballot to women can show no title to their own."

WOMAN’SJOURNAL

Woman's  Journal  was  a  women's  rights  periodical  published  from  1870‐1931.  It  was founded in 1870 in Boston, Massachusetts by Lucy Stone and her husband Henry Browne Blackwell  as a weekly newspaper.  This  new  paper incorporated Mary A.  Livermore's The Agitator, as well as a lesser known periodical called the Woman's Advocate.  It specialized in suffrage news.

Woman's Journal refused to carry advertisements for tobacco, liquor, or drugs.

The following is an excerpt of an article written by Henry B. Blackwell, the Journal’s editor for Our Day, A Record and Review of Current Reform, February, 1892.

As  interesting as the questions asked are the answers given. The article may be read in its entirety in Twice Told Tuesday, March 22, 2011 on Shades Of The Departed.

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 44

Page 46: March/April Issue of Shades

What eminent men have favored Woman Suffrage?

Among others, Abraham Lincoln, Chief Justice Chase, William Lloyd Garrison, Wendell Phillips, Samuel G. Howe, John G Whittier, Ralph Waldo Emerson, Charles Sumner, Henry Wilson, President Hayes, Governors Banks, Boutwell, Claflin, Washburn, Talbot, Ames and Long. Senators Geo. F. Hoar and Henry L. Dawes, John M Forbes, Robert Collyer, Bishops Haven, Bowman and Simpson, Rev. Joseph Cook, Bishop Phillips Brooks, Neal Dow, George William Curtis, the republicans of Massachusetts in successive platforms since 1870. The national republican platforms of 1872 and 1876. The Democrats of Massachusetts in their platform of 1882.

What eminent women have favored Woman Suffrage?

Among others, Margaret Fuller, Lydia Maria Child, Frances D. Gage, Lucretia Mott, Florence Nightingale, Elizabeth Barrett Browning, Harriet Beecher Stowe, Julia Ward Howe, Mary A. Livermore, Louisa M. Alcott, Elizabeth Stuart Phelps, Clara Barton, Frances E. Willard, Abby W. May, Lucy Stone, Mary F. Eastman, Frances Power Cobbe, Harriet Prescott Spofford, Mary Clemmer.

Only bad and ignorant women would vote.

Our ten years' experience of School Suffrage for women proves the contrary. The twenty-two thousand women who have voted are admitted to have been good and intelligent. The demand

Cour

tesy

of t

he L

ibra

ry o

f Con

gres

s

45 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 47: March/April Issue of Shades

for suffrage comes from the respected leaders and educated representatives of their sex. No woman can vote in Massachusetts unless she can read and write.

It is contrary to experience.

Not so. In England women have voted for twenty years in municipal elections. Hon. Jacob Bright has written to the Massachusetts Legislature that in England Woman Suffrage has proved "good for women, good for Parliament, and good for the country." It has worked so well there that it has just been extended to the women of Scotland. Are American women alone unfit to be trusted with political responsibilities?

There is no precedent in this country.

In Wyoming, women have voted for twenty-two years on all questions, on the same terms as men. Every successive governor—the judges of the Supreme Court, the Senators in Congress, the presiding elder of the M. E. Church, the newspapers of both parties, all agree that Woman Suffrage works well and gives satisfaction in Wyoming. The State constitution guaranteeing equal suffrage to women has been ratified by Congress, and the women of Wyoming will vote in the next Presidential election.

It would put our cities under Roman Catholic control.

There are, in all our large cities, even in New York, more Protestant women than Roman Catholic women; more American women than foreign women. There are in Boston 91,367 women over twenty years old who can read and write; 52,608 of these are Americans, 38,759 are of foreign birth. (See Carroll D. Wright's statistics for 1875.)

Women have not physical strength to enforce laws; therefore they should not help make them.

One-half our male voters have not physical strength to enforce laws, yet they help make them. Most lawyers, Edith Campbell Registering To Vote?

Cour

tesy

of t

he L

ibra

ry o

f Con

gres

s

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 46

Page 48: March/April Issue of Shades

judges, physicians, ministers, merchants, editors, authors, legislators and congressmen, and all men over forty-five years old are exempt from military service on the ground of physical incapacity. (See statistics of the late war.) Voting is the authoritative expression of an opinion. It requires intelligence, conscience and patriotism, not mere muscle. All the physical force of society is subject to call to enforce law, but cannot create law. Moral force, such as women possess, is as necessary as physical force to national well-being.

It will make domestic discord when women vote contrary to their husbands.

In cases where husbands and wives vote together it will be an additional source of sympathy and bond of union. In cases where they vote differently they will agree to differ, as they now do in religious matters. A man will not respect his wife the less because she has an opinion of her own and is free to express it.

The polls are not fit places for women.

Then they are not fit places for men. But if this were ever true, it is true no longer. The Australian ballot system has put an end to all disorder and removed every such ground of objection. Wherever women meet with men they are treated with respect. If the polls were as bad as represented they would not degrade women, but women would reform the polls.

What good will it do women to vote?

Just what it does for men. It will give women power to protect themselves in their persons, property, children, occupations, opportunities and social relations. It will enable them to get done what ought to be done, and to get undone what ought not to be done. As it has made certain classes of men, formerly treated as inferiors because disfranchised, more nearly equal with other men, so it will make all classes of women more nearly equal with men and with each other.

What good will it do men for women to vote?

Whatever enlarges the minds and hearts of women makes them more agreeable companions and better wives and mothers. The brains and conscience of an educated mother are the best inheritance of her children. Men will find it far pleasanter and more elevating to live with an equal than with an inferior in the home. There is no one so hard to manage as a fool.

What good will it do society for women to vote?

It will make government more fully representative. It will put an end to bribery in elections by doubling the number of voters and making it difficult to use money corruptly. Formerly when

47 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 49: March/April Issue of Shades

only a small class of men were allowed to vote, "every man had his price " and bribery was the rule. The wider the constituency the purer will be the political atmosphere. Candidates of better moral character will have to be nominated in order to secure the support of a majority of the women voters. Vice will be discouraged, poor and defenseless women will be better protected, and there will be a higher standard of public morals. Crimes against women will be more adequately punished, and children will be better cared for. Primary meetings will be made orderly, when women are expected to attend them. The manners and atmosphere of the smoking-car will be replaced by those of the lecture-room and the church-meeting. The caucus will be lifted to the level of the parlor. The presence of women will purify politics as it has already purified literature and refined society.

It will only double the vote—women will vote as their husbands do.

Then the family will cast two votes instead of one. But the quality of the voters changes the quality of politics. A political party of men and women will not be the same as a party of men alone. Women are more peaceable, refined, temperate, chaste, economical, humane and law-abiding than men. These qualities will influence the character of the government. The united votes of men and women will give the fullest, fairest, and most accurate expression of public opinion.

Source:

Blackwell, Henry B. “Questions To Specialists.” Our Day - A Record and Review of Current Reform. Vol. 50. Boston : Woman’s Temperance Publishing Association, 1892. pg. 141.

Cour

tesy

of t

he L

ibra

ry o

f Con

gres

s

Elizabeth Cady Stanton, seated, and Susan B. Anthony, standing, three-quarter length portrait. Two of the leaders in the suffrage movement.

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 48

Page 50: March/April Issue of Shades
Page 51: March/April Issue of Shades

I  love  tintypes.  Every  time  I’m  brought  one  to  restore,  I  hold  it,  oh  so  carefully,  oh  so 

reverently, and just gaze upon its awesomeness. An image on a piece of black painted metal 

(albeit,  not  tin)? The coolness  factor  is  way  up on this one!  Seriously,  you know  they  did 

something  right  with  this  photographic  process,  because  tintypes  generally  just  do  not 

fade! They’d be nearly perfect if it weren’t for that pesky little varnish problem!

What pesky little varnish problem? I’m glad you asked! Tintypes, also known as ferrotypes, 

used as their substrate what is known as japanned metal. A piece of metal was coated with 

a heavy black oil  varnish and set using heat. The process was very stable, which is why so 

many survive today, however, many times, as varnish will over time,  the surface darkened, 

discolored and cracked. But underneath the dark and the cracks, most are just as clear and 

sharp as  the  day  they’re  taken!  The  question  remains,  however,  how  to  get  beneath  the 

grunge and grime of old varnish to the treasure below? Paint remover? A  Sander? But you 

know I jest, right? 

First things @irst; scan that puppy onto your hard drive! A nice high resolution, 300 to 600 

ppi  is nice, and in color,  please;  if it’s not scanned in color, you’re cutting your restoration 

resources in half.  

[Note: This article was written for use in Adobe Photoshop CS4 or CS5, but can be modiCied in many image editing programs]

a tale of two tintypesTHE HEALING BRUSH

AN INEVITABLE FACT

BY JANINE SMITH

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 50

Page 52: March/April Issue of Shades

We  have  here  two  tintypes,  one  very  dark  and  the  other  darkened  and  discolored.  One 

looks worse than the other,  harder  to  @ix,  but looks can also be deceiving.   As with every 

photo, one restoration method does not @it all. Let’s take a quick look at a couple of ways to 

@ind the photos behind the discoloration. We’ll start with the darker of the two.

Always  try more  than one color  correction method on any  given photo.  You never  know 

what will  and won’t work,  or what may be just  slightly better than the last.  I must admit, 

however,  that my  @irst  inclination is always  to  start off with my trusty old  friend,  Curves. 

Not that I always stick with it, but it is a starting point. 

Fig. 1 Curves - The Starting Point

51 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 53: March/April Issue of Shades

INTO THE LIGHT

In  this  case we’ll  go  with  a  Levels  adjustment,  visiting  each 

channel  individually,  moving  the  sliders  to where  the most 

information lies in the histogram.

The result isn’t all  that much better than Curves, but it is 

slightly  better.  It’s not nearly  good enough, but we will 

keep it as a base  for  the next step. Why would we do 

that? Because while  it  looks pretty bad,  what  it does 

do  is  bring  some depth  back  into  the  photograph; 

it’s just a better canvas to work on.Before

Fig. 2 Histogram

Fig. 3 Levels Adjustment

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 52

Page 54: March/April Issue of Shades

The next  step  is  why  the tintype needed  to  be  scanned  in color  in  the  @irst  place. We’re 

going to explore the color channels. You can either go into the channels themselves, or you 

can go into Black & White Adjustment layers, the Blue, Green and Red adjustments, for the 

same result.  Color   Channels   allow us  to see the level  of damage hidden in each channel. 

How  does  this  work? Well,  digital  images  are  made up  of pixels,  and  these  pixels  are  a 

combination of the color mode they reside in. For instance,  in CMYK color mode,  there are 

four channels, one made up of Cyan pixels, one of Magenta,  one of Yellow and one of Black 

pixels. In RGB mode, there are three channels, one each of Red, Green and Blue pixels. When 

a photo  is damaged over time,  some of the damage  is  due to  the  chemical makeup of the 

photographic process itself, such as silver nitrate, some due to atmospheric conditions, like 

smoke and light, and all sorts of combinations thereof. This sort of damage can reside more 

in one color channel  than the next. Damage along the lines of deep scratches will  reside in 

all  the  channels.  Blue  channels  are  typically  darker  and  in  many  cases  hold  the  most 

damage.

Fig. 4 Blue Channel

Fig. 5 Green Channel

Fig. 6 Red Channel

53 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 55: March/April Issue of Shades

The Green channels are typically better than the Blue,  containing  less damage, but usually 

more intonation than the Red, and can sometimes be your best choice.

The Red  channel  is  most  often  the best  bet,  albeit  not  always.  In  this  case  there was  a 

surprise; remember when I said varnish cracked? Well here it is!

You might tend to think that this was an unwelcome surprise,  but  it’s actually a wonderful 

discovery!  If you  look beyond  the craquelure,  you’ll  see  that a lot  of the worst  damage is 

gone. The tradeoff is that the depth of the detail is extremely faint, but that’s something you 

can work on  later.  But the best  thing is that  the cracking is huge! This makes  the work of 

taking those crack lines out much, much easier! Since there’s still a lot of lines to take out, I 

recommend a combination of the Clone Tool, the Patch Tool, the Healing Brush, the Content 

Aware…in  other  words,  use  a  combination of  the  close  work  tools  you  have  at  hand  in 

whatever image editor and version you have. Using one tool  in such a large area could all 

too easily lead to pixel repetition and smudging; not looks you want in your restoration.

Fig. 7 Tools

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 54

Page 56: March/April Issue of Shades

After you get the cracking taken care of, it’s just a matter of getting some of the detail back 

in.  DO this with dark  and  light  tones,  layers of  black  low  lights  and highlights  partnered 

with layer blend modes, painting in, or out, areas on Curves Adjustment masks and (or) the 

Dodge and Burn tools. Make a duplicate layer and blur it slightly to soften it up some.

Fig. 8 Detail

Bring  some  the  original  tonality  back  into  it; 

sample  a  bit  of  the  color  from  the  original  and 

make  a  new,  blank  layer  at  the  top of  your  layer 

stack;  @ill  with the  sampled  color  and  change the 

Layer Blend Mode to Soft Light. Bring some of the 

original  color back into the cheeks by painting the 

cheek color, again sampled from the original, on a 

blank  layer,  softening  with  a  light  Gaussian  Blur 

and the Same Layer Blend Mode.

Fig. 9 Tone

Fig. 8 Detail

55 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 57: March/April Issue of Shades

COLOR ME OFF

The  second  photo  looks  a  lot  easier  than  the  @irst, 

doesn’t  it? On this one we’ll  try  a little different  route 

and use a little used, mostly under‐appreciated tool  in 

Photoshop,  Variations.  True,  not  many  can  see  the 

value in Variations, but as a color correction tool, it can 

sometimes come in quite handy. 

When using Variations  as  a  color  correction tool,  you 

need  to  do  a  lot  of what  I  call  “eyeballing”,  checking 

one  thumbnail  against  the  other,  against  the  original, 

to  “eyeball” which looks best. There’s no multitude of 

sliders,  very  little  in  the way  of  tweaking  the  image 

inside of Variations, just your eyes. 

The  one  thing  you  must  always 

remember  to  do  when  using 

Variations  is  to  duplicate  your 

original  layer.  Variations  is  not  an 

a d j u s t m e n t  l a y e r,  b u t  i s 

destructive,  meaning  it  changes 

the  layer  itself.  Duplicate  your 

working  layer  and  this,  then, 

b e c om e s  y o u r  Va r i a t i o n s 

adjustment layer.

If you look at the Variations of the 

photo  left,  you  can  “eyeball”  that 

the  “More  Blue”  Variation  is  the 

best bet. If you go to the far right of 

the  panel,  you  can  see  that  the 

“Lighter” option is even better, still. 

This will be our base.

Fig. 2-1 Before

Fig. 2-2 Variations

Page 58: March/April Issue of Shades

Next, we’ll do a little lightening and tonal correction with Levels; once again moving the sliders within each color channel to where the information in the histogram starts…

Fig. 2-3 Variations Light

Fig. 2-4 Levels

…and lower the opacity of the levels layer down to around 60%.

57 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 59: March/April Issue of Shades

Now  we’re  going  to  introduce  a  little 

better color into the mix. In Photoshop 

CS5 and CS4,  you’ll  add a Photo Filter 

Adjustment layer; pre‐CS4 you’ll want 

to make  a duplicate layer,  or combine 

all your layer using keyboard shortcut 

Shift+Ctrl+Alt+E  (PC)  or  Shift+Cmd

+Opt+E  (Mac),  and use  the  combined 

layer as your adjustment layer, then go 

to  the  Image  menu,  Adjustments  > 

Photo  Filter.  The  color  you decide on 

will  be a matter of taste at  this  point. 

Different colors  will,  of  course,  give  a 

different feel to the photo.

I  went  with Warming  Filter  (81)  and 

moved the Density slider up to 35%.

Fig. 2-5 Levels 60%Fig. 2-6 Filters

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 58

Page 60: March/April Issue of Shades

I want to brighten the photo up a bit, 

now.  To  do  this,  we’re  going to  take 

all  the  color  out,  and  then  bring 

some back  in, with a Black  & White 

Adjustment.  Go  through  all  the 

presets  to  see which  looks  the  best 

and  lightens  up  the  overall  photo 

while  keeping  all  the  detail;  or 

darkens the detail if that’s what your 

photo calls for. The object is to make 

your  photo  look  better  with  this 

step.  If  it  does  nothing  to  enhance 

the photo,  or  detracts  in some  way, 

skip it.

I’ve used the High Contrast Red @ilter. 

Now  we’ll  bring back  most  of  the  color  of 

the  original  by  using  a  Luminosity  Layer 

Blend Mode on the adjustment layer.  

The biggest  bene@it  of  this  step  is  that  the 

background  is  brighter  and  that  the  blue 

cast  on  the  sleeve  has  lessened  slightly. 

Now  you  can  go  ahead  and do  the  regular 

restoration work. 

Fig. 2-7 Luminosity

Fig. 2-6 Black & White Adjustment

59 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 61: March/April Issue of Shades

Should you decide you don’t like the color of the @inished restoration, you can always throw 

another Black & White Adjustment over it and a Photo Filter over that in whatever tone you 

like. Lower  the opacity on either or both layers. My point here? Experiment!  Try different 

things and combinations until you like the result; something to remember in a case like this 

that has a distinct color in an area, such as in the cheeks, be sure to bring some of that color 

into the @inished restoration.

Fig. 2-8 Finished

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 60

Page 62: March/April Issue of Shades

Let’s  go  back  a minute  to  where  I  said that 

this last photo was actually the harder of the 

two.  There’s  no  visible  reason  that  that 

would  be  the  case.  The  answer  is  found 

zoomed  in  closer.  Not  only  is  the  varnish 

cracking larger in the  @irst photo, but there’s 

a lot less of it. 

Don’t you just love tintypes? Even under that 

pesky varnish,  the darkening and the cracks, 

there’s almost always a beautiful, clear photo 

just waiting to come out! 

Fig. 2-9 The More Difficult

Fig. 2-10 Comparison61 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 63: March/April Issue of Shades

Fig. 2-11 The BeautifulCompleted Project

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 62

Page 64: March/April Issue of Shades

iAncestorPicturing Technology

From Denise Olson

Introducing A New Shades Column

Page 65: March/April Issue of Shades

The iPad is a transformational device. It is a delightful book reader that does so much more. 

In  addition  to  my  genealogy  database  and  my  family  trees  at  Ancestry,  I  have  some 

awesome  tools  for note‐keeping,  reference,  collaboration  and even writing.  I’ll  be  talking 

about these in upcoming editions, but today’s topic is photos. 

I  am  constantly amazed with the  impact of  photos  on  the  iPad.  Even the most mundane 

snapshot gets  the royal treatment  thanks  to  the high‐resolution color  screen.  People who 

have never touched an iPad instinctively swipe from one photo to the next and when they’re 

shown how to zoom in on an adorable smile with a simple pinch, they are astounded. 

It’s  the  ultimate  brag  book 

and mine  is  full  of  photos, 

photo documentaries, home 

movies  and  family  history 

scrapbooks.  And,  photo 

junkie  that  I  am,  I  have 

several  apps  on my  iPad  to 

connect  me  to  Flickr  so  I 

can enjoy  not  only my own 

iANCESTOR

flipboard, flickr, & elizabeth cady stanton

TRANSFORMATIONAL DEVICE

BY DENISE BARRETT OLSON

Page 66: March/April Issue of Shades

c o l l e c t i o n  b u t  a  h u g e  a r c h i v e  o f  p h o t o s  f r om  a r o u nd  t h e  wo r l d . 

Let me introduce you to photo heaven.

Flickr is a photo‐sharing platform supporting a huge community of photo lovers. Amateurs, 

professionals  and  even  institutions  have  taken  to  the  site  and  their  contributions  have 

made Flickr an impressive resource for anyone interested in photos.

I  discovered Flickr while  looking  for  a 

place  to  upload  photos  so  family 

members  could  buy  prints  of  the  old 

family  pics  I  was  digitizing.  I  had 

neither  the  time  nor  ink  budget  to 

support  their print  requests and Flickr 

allowed them to choose the photos and 

sizes  they wanted,  then  order  and  pay 

for  them  without  my  involvement.  It 

didn’t  take  long  for  me  to  realize  that 

the $25/year premium package was also 

a cost‐effective way to archive my photos as a hedge against disaster.

Flickr’s  organizational  tools makes  it  easy to  organize photos  into  sets  and then arrange 

those sets  into collections. Their group function is a great way for family photographers to 

share  their  photos. When there’s a  family  function planned,  build a Flickr group  for  that 

function and invite all the photographers in the family to join. They still upload their photos 

to  their  own Flickr  pro@ile,  but  one  extra  click  will  also  share  them  with  the  function’s 

group. Now the family has one central location to @ind all the photos of the event,  yet they 

still can see who took each one.

Groups are being used for a lot more than just family functions. You’ll @ind a group for just 

about any subject imaginable. From people, places and events to hobbies, animals and even 

colors, there’s a group for that at Flickr. 

65 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 67: March/April Issue of Shades

It’s also a very social platform. You can post your photos and include titles, descriptions and 

tags to describe each image. These entries make it easy  for others to  @ind your photos and 

even  add  their  own  comments.  While  you  can  join  Flickr  groups,  you  can  also  become 

friends with other Flickr  users.  These  “friendships” make it easy  to  keep up with friends 

and family through the photos they share. 

Some time back, the Library of Congress approached Flickr regarding an experiment to post 

some of  their  photo  collection on  the  site  and  see  if  they  could  learn more  about  those 

images  from  comments  and  tags  added  by  the  community.  Flickr  supported  them  by 

building  The Commons  ‐  an area  just  for museums  and archives.  The  result was amazing 

with a  huge  response  that  surprised everyone.  Today,  dozens of institutions  from around 

the world are presenting photos to the public through The Commons. You can @ind amazing 

collections like Matthew Brady’s Civil War photos from The National Archives, a collection 

of Ansel Adams’ photographs  also  from the Archives and Brisbane Bridges  from the State 

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 66

Page 68: March/April Issue of Shades

Library  of  Queensland.  The  Commons  continues  to  grow  as  other  institutions  take 

advantage of the opportunities it provides.

Which brings me back to my iPad.

There are any number of iPad apps that connect to Flickr, but my favorite is Flipboard. This 

app delivers news, Facebook updates, Flickr photos and more to my iPad, presenting it in a 

magazine  format that  is a  joy  to  browse. Not only does  it  provide  a beautiful platform to 

view this information, you are in complete control of the content delivered to you. And, you 

can change those sources any time you please.

As  you can see, my contents page is full of news  from Google Reader,  Flickr, Facebook and 

Twitter. I can even set up custom lists in Twitter to collect sources related to a speci@ic topic 

like local  news or  resources  for veterans which can  then become sections in my personal 

magazine.

TODAY

"To be alive in such an age! With every year a lightning page Turned in the world's great wonder book Whereon the leaning nations look. . . . When miracles are everywhere And every inch of common air Throbs a tremendous prophecy Of greater marvels yet to be. O thrilling age!"

~ Angela Morgan ~

67 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 69: March/April Issue of Shades

Here,  I’ve  opened  the  section  I  created  from  the 

Historic and Old Photos group at Flickr. By tapping the 

tiny  down arrow  to  the  right  of  the  title,  I  can  select 

another  group,  collection or  set  to  view.  I’m  going  to 

choose  Groups,  then  tap  Politician  Portraits  in  my 

group list to see what’s happening there. 

As  you browse pages  of content  in Flipboard,  you will 

see a collage of photos or article excerpts similar to the 

photo arrangement you see here. When a photo catches 

your interest, tap on it to open a page dedicated to that 

image. 

This photo of Elizabeth Cady  Stanton caught my  eye in this page of portraits  and I had to 

check  it  out.  The  image,  which has  been scanned  from  a book  or magazine,  opens as  an 

overlay above the Flipboard page. It includes any title and description included in the Flickr 

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 68

Page 70: March/April Issue of Shades

photo record.  Notice the name of the user who uploaded the photo, Political Graveyard,  is 

located above  the image with  a Reply  link on  the  right offering  the  opportunity  to  add a 

comment.  In the  top right  corner of the  overlay  are additional  social  functions  related to 

this  item.  Tap the Close button at  the top left  to  return  to  the Flipboard page to  continue 

browsing here or in other content sections. 

Combine the iPad, Flipboard and your choice of content from online news and photographic 

resources such as Flickr  and you have  a  delightful  reading experience that  you  can enjoy 

just about anywhere. One of the things that makes the iPad so special for me is the fact that 

I can do all this while enjoying the comfort of my favorite chair in the living room instead of 

glued to a computer screen in the den.  I can be connected to my favorite news,  photo and 

social networks and still a part of the family. Life is good! 

69 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 71: March/April Issue of Shades

What are you doing with your family memories? Are you looking for new and creative ways to share your family history research with others? The Future of Memories [LINK] is an idea book showing you how you can put the applications you already have to work with new and affordable services to share your family history. Electronic publishing isn’t confined to text and images. It covers a wide range of options from printed books to multimedia presentations with video and voice.

This primer introduces you to these new technologies and shows you how to take advantage of the opportunities they offer to produce quality histories at a reasonable price. It discusses the skills needed to create production-ready projects and suggests resources to help you get started.

Download a free sample of the book.

Denise Barrett Olson, blogger, writer, scrapbooker, and editor of The Moultrie Creek Gazette, recently released The Future of Memories: A digital publishing primer for the family historian. Anyone who has sung the "I'll publish the family history some day" blues should read this book; it makes some day feel a lot like today. - Denise Levenick, The Family Curator

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 70

Page 72: March/April Issue of Shades
Page 73: March/April Issue of Shades

Do you have a political issue that you are passionate about?   Many of us do,  and so did our 

ancestors.   I believe Henry Brooks Adams said it best when he wrote in a letter  to Charles 

Francis Adams, Jr. in 1858,

  “There are two things that seem to be at the bottom of our constitutions; one is   a continual tendency towards politics; the other is family pride; and it is   strange how these two feelings run through all of us.”

Family historians have “family pride” down pat.  Sometimes we have family pride when we 

start researching, and we want to  @ind more of it, or maybe, we want to @ind out the “why” 

behind  our  pride.    Sometimes,  because our  “present”  family  doesn’t  give  us much to  be 

proud  of,  we  begin  researching  to  @ind  family  pride  somewhere  in  our  familial  lines.  

However, whether you are trying to learn more about your ancestors by putting @lesh on the 

skeleton of your  family,  whether  you’d  like  to  know  if your  ancestors  voted and/or  how 

they voted, or whether you are trying to substitute for the loss of the 1890 census, politics, 

believe it or not,  can help.    There are records to be found and consulted both online and 

of@line to aid family history researchers in @inding out more about their ancestors’ political 

endeavors.

The key  to  @inding  them is  knowing where to  look, which may  seem  a little obvious,  but 

family  researchers  can get  stuck  in  looking  in  the same places  at  the same things  in  the 

same  exact  way.    Therefore,  the  following  guide  to  @inding  your  ancestors’  political 

IN2GENEALOGY

a call to armsIT WON’T BLOW YOUR SOCKS OFF

BY CAROLINE POINTER

Page 74: March/April Issue of Shades

proclivities  is  nothing  new.    It’s  not  “earth‐shattering”.    It’s  not  “blow‐your‐socks‐off” 

worthy.   Perhaps, though, it’s more of a call  to arms.   A call to stop everything and go look 

right now for how your ancestors’ voted,  for how and if they participated in civic activities, 

and for how they may have felt about particular issues of their day.

While not everything can be found online,  the internet is a good place to start.   Following 

are online resources for learning about the politics of your ancestor’s time.  Remember that 

your  ancestors  voted  in  their  communities  and  some  of  them  were  voted  for  by  their 

communities.    Most  of  the  time,  the  best  places  to  look  to  see  if  your  ancestor  was  a 

politician are in county histories and in newspapers.   To  @ind out about their voting habits, 

looking at voter’s registrations are best as well as biographical write‐ups.

Ancestry.com’s Card Catalog [LINK] – ($$) Searching the card catalog at this subscription 

based site by keywords such as “voter”, “voters”, or “voting” will bring up their collections 

that involve these keywords, including those outside the well‐known collection, “Census 

and Voter Registration”.  That’s right, the collection, “Stories, Memories, & Histories” comes 

up as well.  You can then pare down the listing by @iltering the results by nation in the 

sidebar.  Another way to search would be by location.  From the main “Search” menu, scroll 

down to the map of the U.S.A., and click on your focus state.  This will list collections for that 

particular state.

FamilySearch.org’s Card Catalog [LINK](Free) ‐ This site also boasts a healthy card 

catalog.  While there is an option to search by keyword, I was not able to bring up anything, 

and this may be because it’s still labeled as being in beta, and they aren’t done developing it.  

Therefore, the best way to look for political information is by location.  Using place names 

on the card catalog search page, enter in the state (and the county, if known) and the states 

that have voter information will have it listed on their collections.  If you are not able to visit 

the Family History Library, take care to note whether your selection is available at local 

Family History Centers.  If so, you can order the micro@ilm at your local Family History 

Center for a nominal fee to be viewed at your local center when it comes in from the Family 

History Library.

73 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 75: March/April Issue of Shades

USGenWeb.org [LINK] ‐ (Free) This volunteer‐operated site can be extremely helpful in 

@inding out local history as well as @inding transcriptions of voter registrations.  Select the 

state and then county that you are looking in and see what kind of information is offered.  

Because of its volunteer status, it can be hit or miss, but it’s well worth a look if you get a 

“hit”, and not much time will have been spent if it’s a “miss”.

State Archives (Free) ‐ Take a look at the collections that the state you are researching in 

has available.  For example, the Texas State Library and Archives Commission [LINK] has a 

collection entitled, Voters Registration, 1867 available.  1867 is an important year for those 

performing African‐American and Civil War research.  What’s available is going to vary 

from state‐to‐state, but you might be surprised at what you @ind when you look.

Google Books [LINK] ‐ (Free) If you’ve done any type of research online, then you’ll @ind 

searching on Google Books very easy, but the best part is that some of the books are 

available to view digitally.  Here, though, you’ll need to be a little more creative in your 

keyword search in order to @ind what you are seeking.  For example, a search with a 

keyword phrase such as “historical voting in southern Illinois” came back with some 

relevant books.  Also, search for county histories and biographies here.  Many times 

political events have been written about, and the political persuasion of your ancestor may 

be revealed in a biographical write‐up of them.  Many, many familial gems can be found in 

these county histories.  I have been very successful in @inding county histories and 

biographical write‐ups for my husband’s Ohio ancestors here.  They’ve helped to clear up 

some very big family mysteries by @illing in some much‐needed details.  Let me give you a 

word of caution, though.  Take the time to try to substantiate what you @ind in a 

biographical write‐up.  Think of it this way: if you were being interviewed for a biographical 

write‐up, would you tell them everything about yourself, warts and all?

HeritageQuest Online (Free, if you have a library card) ‐ This database is made available 

usually by a local library, and it can be accessed from home with your library card.  Its 

“Books” database can contain many people, family, and/or county histories.  It’s searchable 

by person, location, and title, and the books are available to view digitally.  Also while you 

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 74

Page 76: March/April Issue of Shades

Imag

e co

urte

sy o

f foo

tnot

eMav

en

Page 77: March/April Issue of Shades

are here exploring Heritage Quest Online, don’t forget to take a look at their PERSI 

database, where you can look for periodical articles on people, places, and titles.  Under 

“People”,  I searched for “voters” under keywords, and 26 results came back with one of 

them entitled, “George Paul Harrison and registered voters of his congressional district, 

1897”.  (If only I had an ancestor name George Paul Harrison.)  Don’t forget to look for 

county histories here as well.  However, these articles cannot be viewed digitally, but can be 

ordered for a nominal fee by clicking on the “Request Form” link. 

Local Library or Genealogical Library or WorldCat.org [LINK] – When looking in an 

online catalog of a library, you’ll need to use the same search strategies as when searching 

in Google Books in order to limit the hits.  If you are using an online catalog for a 

genealogical library, then using keywords such as “voters”, “voting”, and the county and 

state that you are focusing on should be enough to give you enough results for you to look 

at.  If looking at whether or not your ancestor was in politics, looking at county histories 

and newspapers would be your best bet by entering in the county and the state (e.g.,” 

Johnson County, Illinois”).

Google.com [LINK]– While Googling a topic such as “voter” can get tedious, try using the 

same search strategies as listed above for Google Books.  Also, if have a found a title in a 

state archives and you are not able to get to it to look at it, try Googling the name of the 

collection.  Someone may have transcribed it, digitally photographed it, or scanned it 

already.  For example, when I Googled, “Texas Voters Registration 1867”, someone had, 

indeed, scanned this list.  It’s available from Michael Hait Family Research Services [LINK] 

for nominal fees.  It’s broken‐up by county.  So, if you have a lot of research in a particular 

county in Texas in the post‐Civil War Era, procuring that county’s registration list for 1867 

could be extremely bene@icial.  As with everything else, you just won’t know until you look.

CyndisList.com [LINK] – This website is always chock full of links, and when it comes to 

the topic of voting, this is no exception.  Take some time to look it over.

GenealogyToday.com [LINK]– This site is lesser known and is smaller, but if it helps you 

@ind what you’re looking for, then it will become your new best friend.  It has a search 

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 76

Page 78: March/April Issue of Shades

feature for resources where you can enter in keywords, such as “voter”.  Now, the listings 

that come up are for other database sites, but it does inform you as to what site it is and if 

it’s subscription based or not.

Above were mainly online ideas that only required you get out of your house just a little bit, 

if at all.   Below are a few of@line resources  that can help you get out of the house  for your 

research:

The Genealogist’s Companion and Sourcebook by Emily Anne Croom.   She covers quite a bit 

in  @inding  and  using  administrative  records,  such  as  voters’  registrations  for  research.  

However,  the most  poignant example  of  @inding  these records  is  described on page  117, 

where Ms. Croom stumbles upon election returns for 1836 in a basement in Kentucky.  I kid 

you not.   This example,  alone,  should get  you out of the house  for your  research.   It’s not 

every day you @ind how your ancestor voted in a particular presidential election. 

The Public Record Research TIPS Book by Michael Sankey.   While this book would be more 

applicable  to  your  later  ancestors,  Mr.  Sankey  provides  a  listing of  states  and  their voter 

registration authorizations.   Some states’ voter registration information is unrestricted and 

some are harder to  get.   He provides  some workarounds for  these more restrictive states, 

though.

The  Family  Tree  Resource  Book  for  Genealogists by  Sharon  DeBartolo  Carmack  and Erin 

Nevius.    If  you’ve noticed,  I mention  this  resource  book  in  almost  every  article  I write.  

There’s a reason for this.   It’s extremely helpful for many research problems.  While it does 

not have direct information on records concerning voters and politics, in some cases,  it can 

point you in the right direction.

While @inding an abundance of these records easily would be nice, this probably will not be 

the case.  It’s not always easy, but you won’t know until you try.  In my own family research, 

I have a little bit of family lore that touches upon politics.  It’s been passed down that my 3rd 

Great‐Grandfather, Nelson Martin, was one of only 40 votes  in Johnson County,  Illinois  for 

Abraham Lincoln.  Johnson County is located in Southern Illinois, an area that is referred to 

77 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 79: March/April Issue of Shades

as the microcosm of the south because of the vast number of southerners that settled in the 

area,  including my 3rd Great‐Grandfather.   And back then, according to the  family  lore,  the 

vote was made vocally in front of the community.  The county ultimately went to Douglas by 

over 1500 votes.   While I’ve not been able to substantiate this bit of family lore, I have not 

given up @inding  the truth because  if  it  is  true,  the  incredible courage Nelson would have 

had  to  vote  against  the popular thought  in his  community  gives me great  pause,  and it’s 

something  I  keep  in  mind  every  time  I  vote  in  one  of  the  private  voting  booths  in  my 

community.   Moreover,  if I could substantiate it, what a wonderful glimpse of my 3rd Great‐

Grandfather  in  history  it  would  be,  especially  since he  lived  so  close  to  Cairo,  Illinois,  a 

known stop on the Underground Railroad.   On the other hand, maybe it’s not true, but one 

fact remains.  I’ll keep looking until I exhaust every possible resource.  

“Why pay money to have your family tree traced; 

go into politics and your opponents will do it for you.”

 ­ Author Unknown

Sources:

“There_are_two_things_that_seem_to_be…” Dictionary.com. Columbia World of Quotations. Columbia University Press, 1996. http://quotes.dictionary.com/There_are_two_things_that_seem_to_be (accessed: 5 Jan 2011).

George Paul Harrison and registered voters of his congressional district, 1897, HeritageQuest Online, PERSI, database (http://0‐persi.heritagequestonline.com.catalog.houstonlibrary.org/hqoweb/library/do/persi/results/articles : accessed 5 Jan 2011). 

Michael Hait Family Research Services, 1867 Texas Voters’ Registration Lists, website (http://haitfamilyresearch.com/1867Texas.aspx : 5 Jan 2011).

Croom, Emily Anne. The Genealogist’s Companion and Sourcebook. Cincinatti: Betterway Books, 2003.

Sankey, Michael. The Public Record Research TIPS Book: Insider Information for Effective Public Record Research.  Tempe: Facts on Demand Press, 2008.

Carmack, Sharon DeBartolo and Nevius, Erin. The Family Tree Resource Book for Genealogists. Cincinatti: Family Tree Books, 2004.

“Why pay money to have your family…” QuoteGarden.com. Unknown Source. (http://www.quotegarden.com/politics.html : accessed 24 Jan 2011).

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 78

Page 80: March/April Issue of Shades

ANCESTOR ARTIFACTS

Great-Aunt Agatha’s treasures got you down? Are you confused about how to undo past preservation mistakes and best save your family heirlooms for the next generation?

From photos stuck with hardened glue to funny-smelling movie film, from crocheted lace to crumbling newspapers, family historians are faced with a myriad of preservation problems. Caring for family treasures is a great responsibility, but it’s not hard when you are armed with Ancestor ArtiFacts.

Shades of the Departed is delighted to announce a new column dedicated to helping you find answers for tough questions. Denise Levenick is our resident expert, but if she doesn’t know the answer, she’ll find an expert who does!

Send your preservation, archiving, and restoration questions to [email protected]. Include your question, name, email, and the URL of your blog or web site if you have one.

See below for submitting photographs.

CAPTURED MOMENTS

Do you have a beautiful digital heritage scrapbooking layout or artwork you'd like to share. Submit it to Captured Moments at Shades. We would like to feature the very best digital artwork from readers' submissions.

You're the one who Captured The Moment. Show and Tell.

Submissions are to be emailed to [email protected] with the words Captured Moments in the subject line.

Please submit a brief paragraph telling us about your design, who is featured and why you were inspired. Include your name, email, and the URL of your blog or web site if you have one.

This is not a how-to, but we would like to know the software photo editing program and products you used. Credit the commercial backgrounds, elements, brushes, frames, layouts, etc. you used; or yourself if they were your own creation.

Also submit a high resolution image of your work.

See below for submitting photographs.

Contribute To Shades

79 Shades MAGAZINE | Political 2011

Page 81: March/April Issue of Shades

FEATURED ARTICLES

Shades is always on the lookout for feature articles. Do you have an idea as it relates to old photographs? If so, we would love to hear from you. We are looking for authors for feature themed articles. Send your idea to [email protected] with the words "Shades Feature Article" in the subject line.

Include your name, email, the url of your blog or website, and a short synopsis of your idea. Article length is flexible. Shades would also like a short bio of 50 words or less and a photograph of the author if your idea is selected. This will appear as “About the Author” at the end of each article. And don't forget, Shades is about old photographs. We encourage you to submit several for the article.

Upcoming Shades issues will feature old photographs as they relate to occupations (due by 1 April) and toys (due by 1 June).

See below for submitting photographs.

SUBMITTING PHOTOGRAPHS

When submitting photographs and digital artwork for publishing in Shades we ask that the image be 300 dpi and at least 8 inches wide for the scrapbooking layouts and digital art. Please send the image as a JPG or TIFF file.

Please send the files via a free file transfer site such as yousendit.com or 4shared.com. Both have a free membership, require registration, and have limitations on file sizes.

If you use yousendit.com, please register for the Lite account. Log in, choose Send File, browse your computer for the correct file, and attach. Yousendit will provide a secure link to your file. Cut and paste the link into your email, along with any other information that has been requested. (See categories above.)

We hope to see you in the pages of Shades The Magazine.

Shades MAGAZINE | www.shadesofthedeparted.com 80

Page 82: March/April Issue of Shades

Telephone Telegraph

TwitterA GATHERING of people assembled to promote sociability and community activity.

overhe

ard on

twitt

er

@FamilyStories I'm Elizabeth and I'm addicted to buying other people's heritage.

@FamilyStories Support group and quarantine. It's contagious. I'm pretty sure I caught it from @footnotemaven.

@littlebyteslife I'm Caroline & I'm addicted 2 buying other people's heritage. #SomeoneHas2 & yes, it's @footnoteMaven's fault. #oldphoto

@FamilyStories Admitting you have a problem is the @irst step. Buying archival boxes & sleeves is the 2nd.

Photograph indicates whoʼs speaking

@ indicates who theyʼre speaking to or talking about.

# indicates the subject.

And it must be done in 140 characters. Short & sweet! A lot like a telegram.

Page 83: March/April Issue of Shades

On Digital News Stands 1-15 MayOccupations & Photographs

May/June2011

Shades & Occupations

Next Issue

Page 84: March/April Issue of Shades

T H E L A S T P I C T U R E S H O W

The Back Of A Campaign Card -

The Progressive Party of 1912 (nicknamed the Bull Moose Party) was an American political

party created by a split in the Republican Party in the presidential

election of 1912. It was named after the era of reform which people were already calling the

Progressive Era. It was organized by Theodore Roosevelt after he lost the Republican nomination to William Howard Taft and pulled his

delegates out of the convention. Roosevelt lost in 1912 and while a few local candidates were elected, by 1914 the party virtually collapsed.

Mr. Porter did not win his bid for election as the Representative of the Pennsylvania State Legislature from the Progressive Party for the 12th District.

Clarence G. Porter, in the 1920 census a barber who owned his own shop.

Born 24 June 1874, died 14 April 1944 Springdale, Pennsylvania, of pneumonia.

Wife - Louie Porter.