mapping climate change and security in north africa

Upload: german-marshall-fund-of-the-united-states

Post on 10-Apr-2018

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    1/48

    CLIMATE & ENERGY PAPER SERIES 2010

    MAPPING CLIMATE CHANGE AND

    SECURITY IN NORTH AFRICA

    JOSHUA BUSBY, KAIBA WHITE, AND TODD G. SMITH

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    2/48

    2010 Te German Marshall Fund o the United States. All rights reserved.

    No part o this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any orm or by any means without permission in writing

    rom the German Marshall Fund o the United States (GMF). Please direct inquiries to:

    Te German Marshall Fund o the United States

    1744 R Street, NW

    Washington, DC 20009

    1 202 683 2650

    F 1 202 265 1662

    E [email protected]

    Tis publication can be downloaded or ree at http://www.gmus.org/publications/index.cm. Limited print

    copies are also available. o request a copy, send an e-mail to [email protected].

    GMF Paper Series

    Te GMF Paper Series presents research on a variety o transatlantic topics by sta, ellows, and partners o the German

    Marshall Fund o the United States. Te views expressed here are those o the author and do not necessarily represent the

    views o GMF. Comments rom readers are welcome; reply to the mailing address above or by e-mail to [email protected].

    About GMFTe German Marshall Fund o the United States (GMF) is a non-partisan American public policy and grantmaking institu-

    tion dedicated to promoting better understanding and cooperation between North America and Europe on transatlantic

    and global issues. GMF does this by supporting individuals and institutions working in the transatlantic sphere, by conven-

    ing leaders and members o the policy and business communities, by contributing research and analysis on transatlan-

    tic topics, and by providing exchange opportunities to oster renewed commitment to the transatlantic relationship. In

    addition, GMF supports a number o initiatives to strengthen democracies. Founded in 1972 through a gi rom Germany

    as a permanent memorial to Marshall Plan assistance, GMF maintains a strong presence on both sides o the Atlantic. In ad-

    dition to its headquarters in Washington, DC, GMF has six ofces in Europe: Berlin, Paris, Brussels, Belgrade, Ankara, and

    Bucharest. GMF also has smaller representations in Bratislava, urin, and Stockholm.

    Transatlantic Climate Bridge Initiative

    Tis paper would not have been possible without unding rom the ransatlantic Climate Bridge, an initiative o the German

    Ministry or Foreign Aairs to connect and support those working to address the challenges o climate change, energy

    security, and economic growth at the local, the state, and the ederal level in the United States and Germany.

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    3/48

    Mapping Climate Change and Securityin North Africa

    Climate & Energy Policy Paper Series

    October 2010

    J W. B

    Uv Tx A

    K WUv Tx A

    T G. S

    Uv Tx A

    J W. B LBJ S P A Ck R S. S C I S Lw, Uv Tx A. K W GIS R S. S C I S Lw, Uv Tx A. T G. S P.D. S LBJ S P A Uv Tx A.

    T k G M F . T wk , , U. S. A R L U. S. A R O / W9NF-9--77. T j C C A P S (CCAPS),://../ T vw G M F U S.

    Exv S . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

    I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

    P C C-R S Cq . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3W A V A N A? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6

    Nv C V N A . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6

    C P I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3

    B . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 35

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    4/48

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    5/48

    Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa iii

    C z v x

    q

    . S v vk

    ,

    w x q -

    v. A

    N A, w,

    ,

    M,

    S M N, x

    S H A. NA E

    x, w

    x -

    w A v

    E.

    N A -

    v x -

    . I

    w w v

    , , ,

    w x k . T

    wk w

    , w w v

    v, A v-

    v , ,

    , , .

    T

    w

    v z

    w v ,

    , wk. UG I S (GIS), w

    v,

    x v

    A. W w v

    v w v

    N S k x ,

    w .

    T v v

    k. T M-

    k x

    - z,

    v w w -

    k

    v v. P

    v -

    z x, , , v

    v w w E

    v ,

    w k v

    - S, C, N,

    S. S k v-

    x M

    M, A, E.

    B v, w x

    w

    N A:

    , , ,

    .

    W ,

    - v , , v.

    W w ,

    v k k

    v

    x, .

    S w-v

    k k x

    w . I N A,

    wv, w S

    C A D, w w-

    v v

    v - z.

    Executive Summary

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    6/48

    The German Marshall Fund of the United Statesiv

    A , - A

    E w 5 (

    ) k

    v w

    k -

    w. Mv, ,

    w

    A E. C

    w x

    w v, w

    v - A E.

    T

    . Hwv,

    w

    w wk v

    , N, v

    , q

    . A

    k,

    v

    w E W.

    F, w , w

    -

    , w

    q

    v

    . C w v-

    C, E, E, N, S,

    S

    . A

    N S , v

    v.

    I ,

    w

    v k w wk v

    w

    . T w E

    k S, C, N. W

    v NGO

    v k , q

    v

    ,

    v v

    - . O

    N A

    M k M T v

    v v

    w . S

    -

    v

    z w

    .

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    7/48

    Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa 1

    C z v x

    q .

    S 7, v

    k w . S

    v vk -

    ,

    w x -

    q v.

    Ev

    w

    , UN S C, E C-

    , v v.

    A N

    A, w

    k M-

    , S M

    N, x S H

    A. N A

    E x, w

    x-

    w A v E.

    N A -

    v x -

    . I

    w w v

    , , ,

    T v , w . T UN S C 7. I U S, N I C N I A 8. TB v k w . Jv S, EUH Rv F P, w (H ; F 8; S 8; Bk 7; UN S- C 7).

    .

    C x k ,

    x v w-

    w.3 I v v-

    , w

    v z

    z. M v -

    (L, M, E),

    z -

    (S).

    A v q

    , w x (N) xv (A). O

    v x v ,

    S E. T

    wk w

    , w w v

    v, A v-

    v ,

    , , . F

    E U S, w

    , v -

    w E I

    v .

    C N A v

    v

    Lv . v w w 5 ,7 . T , w. I 5, 35 w . I k M, A, T, x (Lv . 8).

    3 M j N A v - w .6C ( 4F) -, 98-. T IPCC F A- v j .8C ( AB ) (IPCC 7). N A j v wk w v w Uv Tx Jk S G. S 43 .

    Introduction

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    8/48

    The German Marshall Fund of the United States2

    . L A x , w N

    w x . I

    ,

    E Sz C w S

    G A

    .

    T

    w

    v z

    w v ,

    , wk. UG I S (GIS), w

    v,

    x v

    A. W w v

    v w v

    N S k x

    -

    , w

    .

    T wk x

    k k v-

    v

    .4 A , w k v v

    v . W

    w k v x

    v

    , .

    I S w vw w

    v

    N A, k , ,

    , x w v. I S

    w - v-

    N A,

    4 F - , W ; A-M -; CENTRA T S C 9;N I C 9.

    w x ,

    , v v.

    T, k v

    v

    k

    . F v,

    w w N S

    x v S 3 x

    w

    v

    j q

    .

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    9/48

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    10/48

    The German Marshall Fund of the United States4

    S k w v

    k k, w -

    w v w-v . A

    v x

    w w. I

    w w, w -

    w ,

    v

    .3

    A x

    , S C A D

    (SCAD), v , k, , w-v N A

    Hx S .

    Lv .

    3 C 7.

    995-9

    j

    ( F ).

    W

    v - z.

    F w

    v v q

    x -

    z k . W v

    q ( w

    x z)

    v

    995-9 ( F ). T

    w k k ,

    k v

    v j .

    B, wk x

    FIGURE 1

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    11/48

    Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa 5

    w v,

    .4

    MigrationC w

    ,

    , w

    w .

    A -

    v -

    , -

    w- k

    . I w

    k v. S,

    4 T v v q q z, v -z ( ) ( 5). T SC A D w v Uv N Tx, I S CHx.

    -v, v

    -

    .5

    F E,

    N A, v

    -,

    .6 A

    , -S

    A v N

    A - E, w

    Fx, w

    E -

    v 5.7 Gv

    v w v

    v

    -S A,

    N A

    E (

    S D v ).

    I x, v v w

    , w

    v v

    , ,

    , x w v.8 T

    v v w

    , w w

    wk. W

    5 M ; M ; C . F GMF- , ://www..///-_vw?.=65

    6 N I C .

    7 S ://www.x../

    8 M 5; Wz Mv 9.

    FIGURE 2

    Sources: Authors calculations based on the Social Confict in Arica Database andUNEP/GRIO-Europe

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    12/48

    The German Marshall Fund of the United States6

    q ,

    q -v w w

    . M

    w

    .9

    O w

    k , w

    v.

    W v - -

    w k

    , v w v ,

    , vw

    w

    9 W Bk .

    S G 6.

    vv, k

    w - . T , v-

    v , Zw

    v S A.

    I E x, w

    w v

    w. N -

    E,

    z N

    A w E k w -

    G, N, S 7; R, J, S 8.

    FIGURE 3

    Source: Global Migrant Origin Database 2007

    FIGURE 4

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    13/48

    Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa 7

    v v.

    D

    , v

    w w

    . F, w, A-

    k -

    E. S, E

    A .

    T G M O D

    x v

    w v w.3 S

    k, k

    , v

    w

    v . F, -

    x w

    . D

    ,

    A

    E. T j 6

    A v v

    A . C Iv

    (4.6 ), Bk F (7. ), S

    A (6.4 ), Tz (5.6 )

    .

    T 4 N A, S,

    H 335.5

    7, w x

    w

    . F 3 4 w w

    w . T

    , 33 , A

    . F x, .6 M

    w , 487, w C Iv

    438, w Bk F. T

    H Rv E C E C 8; S 9.

    3 S ://www..///___.

    A, M, T, wv v w,

    F. T .46 ,

    A. O

    , .46

    M E. .49 E-

    , 8, S, , E-

    . S A

    E ( v ) S

    (6,), w E I (59,)

    S A (,) ( F 5, x ).

    O 6 N A

    , .3 , 8 , - E (x

    F) ( F 4).

    F 6 (x ) w A

    9 E, w 3

    x 4.68

    4 . F-w

    .46

    A, M, T

    v F. T 39

    F 6.3

    4 v 6. S, -

    z F , v

    P 5 x

    . A

    w v M w,

    w F S S

    . A v

    M E M

    v M -

    k w. O

    v F v

    w A. A q C w 9 w

    Iq

    N E . M F

    x R

    E E. Nw -

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    14/48

    The German Marshall Fund of the United States8

    z , v A,M, T k v w

    v

    w F -

    k z

    A -9 .

    I x N A,

    kw w

    w k v -

    ( v ),

    v. T w v

    x 3 , z w -v.

    A Mx

    v

    995-5, v

    w

    . Ex ,

    -5

    Mx ( w

    v

    ), Mx

    U S

    w w .4

    6.7 8,

    .4

    A k k

    -

    N

    A E

    , w

    k . I

    w A

    -

    4 F, K, O .

    FIGURE 5

    Source: Global Migrant Origin Database 2007

    Source: Global Migrant Origin Database 2007

    FIGURE 6

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    15/48

    Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa 9

    Mx, A

    q .

    Hwv, Mx

    .5 Nw 9

    Mx

    w v

    .6 U 9 , w

    -

    w k

    , w

    w w.

    7

    I w ,

    j w w

    4.7 N A

    E 7 5.6 7.

    5 ( F 7).

    Lk A, A

    E w w

    j

    6.9 7 8.5

    9 5. T,

    E, N A( ) w 55

    w 7 48

    w 7 5. O , A

    M w 6

    w N A E

    5 ( Ax A).

    T N A w

    E -

    , v , w

    , 3,

    5 v ://.../__/CCMq.

    6 9 v ://.../v//

    7 T v w - w.

    34, 5. I A

    , -

    E w 485,

    .9 5 ( T ).8

    S, A

    j v

    8

    5. O N A -

    E, w

    vw E , w

    (A, E, S) 5. C-

    w, -

    N

    N, K, U 5 (v

    8 T Mx. T v , AFI , w z v w.

    FIGURE 7

    Source: Authors calculation based on data rom GlobalMigrant Origin Database 2010

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    16/48

    The German Marshall Fund of the United States10

    w

    ).

    O , ,

    N A

    Mx Mx

    . T

    w v , v

    w ,

    v. M ,

    v w

    . Mv,

    . M

    w k

    2020 2050

    Percent change

    in ag. yield

    (scenario A1FI)

    Emigration due

    to change in

    agricultural yield

    Percent change

    in ag. yield

    (scenario A1FI)

    Emigration due

    to change in

    agricultural yield

    2020 Total To Europe 2050 Total To Europe

    A .45 -36 -3 -.53 5 4

    C -.93 8 -.96 8 3

    Dj .3 - -.76

    E -.37 73 7 -.63 4 39

    E -.43 6 -.56 34

    E -.83 8 38 -.3 8 67

    L -.4 6 -.59 3 8

    M -.89 3 -.8 3 5

    M -.76 6 -.43 7 3

    M -. -.5 4 3

    N -.7 33 -.34 55 4

    S -.37 34 9 -3.3 55 4

    S -.9 9 -.9 38 7

    T .5 - - -.66 7 44 N A

    369 3 ,5 34

    A-w v -.84 ,573 485 -.4 9,66 ,9

    *

    TABLE 1

    Estimates of Future Migration Due to Crop Yields

    Source: Authors calculations based on crop-yield projections rom Rosenzweig and Iglesias 2009, population projections romUN Population Fund and elasticity rom Feng et al. 2010

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    17/48

    Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa 11

    w v .

    N, x -

    . C ,

    , k

    E

    w. O , -

    k E, K, U, N

    E. B

    w, N A

    k A M

    E, F, . M-

    v, q A

    E, w

    w w A w

    A w k

    .

    I ,

    w

    - E A,

    w x .

    T , v

    A w x, w

    v A E w

    w . A

    w k v w

    ,

    v -

    w-

    .

    T

    v -

    z v-

    w w . T

    k w w

    q w ,

    w - ,

    (w - - v)

    w A

    w.

    M w w

    v k v

    v . R v

    , ,

    ; k

    w . I

    v v,

    v E

    w

    v.

    W v

    v

    x ,

    kw

    . I , -

    , wv

    , w w

    v z .

    Terrorism

    P N A, A, v

    -

    . A G T ,

    3,676 k A w 995

    8, (,95 v) k A (44 v)

    k S. T, 4

    N A 55

    k (,88 v).9 M

    9 S ://www...//

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    18/48

    The German Marshall Fund of the United States12

    , , w wv v k

    W v. Hwv,

    wk S-

    M w k A Q

    I M (AQIM),

    A, z k M,

    N, M. W

    v -

    k. F

    N A, k w

    v

    q.

    U, x k

    w . I

    w , x w v,

    w k

    k v. T

    v,

    v w

    .3

    W

    v v

    v z

    w k W .

    Gv , , -

    wk, ,

    S-M

    z.3 A w

    v v v v

    A Q -

    .3 S v k

    v W ( U.S. 3 K Mkv 3; L K 8. T, k .

    3 RAND 7.

    3 K-B 9. F v w AQIM, F .

    ) w

    w

    v

    .33

    N, v N ,

    v T ,

    AQIM, , w N

    , k

    W.

    A v w k

    x w w -

    v v

    v . T

    x v v, v

    w

    v w

    w .

    I x , w w

    A v q, q-z

    , x -

    z. U - G

    T D 995 8,34 w N A

    k

    q k

    v .

    T v

    -

    w ( F 8).35

    I w

    33 CENTRA T S C 9, 35.34 T w - Sw S. A wk- w Uv Tx C Gk, M Ov, SjDk.

    35 A , v w. G T D,START, J , .

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    19/48

    Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa 13

    k. T O BL

    v, w v

    x

    . O

    q, w w

    q

    , -

    .

    Extreme Weather Events and

    Complex Emergencies

    C x

    v

    q x w

    v, ,

    , . W

    v x-

    , ,

    - w

    .

    D- q x

    , w, v,

    q z

    . R, w v

    . T U.S.

    w z wk 5

    H K. G w q

    7,

    w A 9.

    T - z v v v w

    v , w q

    q -

    . F x, v -

    , --v S

    99

    U S

    , O R

    H. T 99 , W

    w

    k C A (

    H M 998) H ( 4

    ).

    T Pk

    -

    ,

    U.S. w

    A. W

    w v

    , w k

    w- x

    . Ev W ,

    , z

    Pk wk

    , N w x w

    w w.

    A v

    w w-

    FIGURE 8

    Sources: Calculations by the authors based on data rom the Global Terrorism Data-base and UNEP/GRIO-Europe

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    20/48

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    21/48

    Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa 15

    Country Number of

    Disasters

    Number of

    Floods

    Number of

    Droughts

    Number of

    Storms

    Max.

    Killed

    Max. Total

    Affected

    Max.

    Homeless

    A 3 5 3 9 () 45,43 () 3, ()

    C 9 () 8, () 45, ()

    Dj 7 5 5 () 34, () ,5 ()

    E 5 3 (w) 3, () 3, ()

    E 4 .3 ()

    E 4 34 6 498 () .6 ()

    79,()

    L

    M 6 3 3 5 () () 4,586 ()

    M 4 5 () () , ()

    M 9 5 73 () 75, ()

    N 3 9 3 7 () 3.58 ()

    46,47 ()

    S 6 4 ,3 () 3.3 ()

    3, ()

    S 5 5 () () , ()

    T 4 4 6 () 7, () =, =, w= wv

    TABLE 2

    1995-2008 Climate-Related Disasters in North Africa

    Source: OFDA/CRED International Disaster Database

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    22/48

    The German Marshall Fund of the United States16

    A v - k v -

    ) -

    , ) w

    k , 3)

    v

    , 4)

    v . O

    v

    w

    v, w.

    T q k v.4

    W

    v v -

    q :

    Climate-RelatedHazardExposure.Ata

    , v x

    - z.

    PopulationDensity.Policymakersgenerally

    w v. A

    q,

    x - zw -

    k.

    HouseholdandCommunityResilience.The

    w

    w v

    v v

    z v

    - k ,

    , . C w

    k v q

    k

    v v. W

    , v w

    4 T v B ..

    Where Are the Vulnerable Areas in

    North Africa?2

    k v z z .

    GovernanceandPoliticalViolence.Weather

    q x

    v,

    q -v z v

    w

    v ,

    w,

    w x w

    v. A w w Pk

    J , w v v w

    v v. Ak k

    M w x

    . V

    v

    v , k

    S 99,

    j . P w

    v

    v v v

    z v .

    O v-

    k w -

    x - z j

    w , w v -

    ,

    v w v.

    E k x,

    ,

    , v v

    . I -

    k, v

    k. W

    vw x

    w -

    w . W

    w w

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    23/48

    Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa 17

    - w

    v .

    W k, w

    . W v

    q w v

    w

    v .

    T q v

    A, w. S, w

    A v , v ( F 9

    ).

    F k, w v

    k v. I

    FIGURE 9

    Composite Vulnerability Baskets and Indicators

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    24/48

    The German Marshall Fund of the United States18

    , k w

    q.

    W x-

    - z w

    ,

    / ,

    , v v. A , w

    w v

    ( x +

    ). W w

    x ,

    w w w

    v w

    k.

    A v -

    , x

    z v -

    v

    v w

    w . I N A

    . T

    , /, v-

    /v k w v

    v.

    W x - -

    x. M

    v A

    w w w k . F , w

    w x -

    z ( T 3 ). W

    v

    wk w

    j w A

    .

    Findings

    O z x w

    M M, A,

    T v w

    k E, w w

    E, S (

    F ).

    Variable (weight) Unit Source Years

    C q(.67)

    Ev , UNEP/GRID-E 975 - 7

    C w q(.67)

    Ev , UNEP/GRID-E 975 - 7

    F q (.67) Ev UNEP/GRID-E

    D v (.67) N v UNEP/GRID-E 98 -

    W (.67) P . q k

    x

    UNEP/GRID-E 997 - 8

    Lw v z(.67)

    C w v

    USGS EROS

    TABLE 3

    Climate-Related Hazard Exposure Data

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    25/48

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    26/48

    The German Marshall Fund of the United States20

    FIGURE 11

    Variable (weight) Indicator (weight) Source Years of Data Availability

    E (.5) L , ( 5 v) (.5)

    WDI - 7; T G,G-B, S

    S , () (.5)

    WDI 4 - 8; 998 A; 999 S; G-B

    H (.5) I ( , v)

    CIESIN 99-3

    L x () x (.5)

    WHO 6

    D N(.5)

    P 5w (.5)

    CIESIN 99-3

    P w - v k w (.5)

    WHO 6; C V S

    A H(.5)

    P x (PPP . $) (.5)

    WHO 6; S

    N w ( , ) (.5)

    WHO - 6; S

    TABLE 4

    Africa-Wide Household and Community Resilience Data

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    27/48

    Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa 21

    A v

    x w M T v-

    w v( w q) N C,

    w E S

    ( F ).

    F, w w k v

    v, w M-

    v

    v

    S H A, v

    v w

    v .

    F 3, N A v-

    , w -v

    v

    v v, x

    ,

    ( F 3). A w

    v,

    k v

    v ( T 5 ).

    FIGURE 12

    FIGURE 13

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    28/48

    The German Marshall Fund of the United States22

    Variable Indicator (weight) Source Year(s)

    Gv Rv-

    V A (.) W Gv I 8

    Gv RC

    Gv Ev (.) W Gv I 8

    O ExA

    Gz Ix (.) KOF Ix Gz 9

    Gv S P V (.) P IV Pj - 9

    N S Y (.) P IV Pj 855 - 9

    P V P Mv A-

    K Ev D S (KEDS) 995 - 8

    TABLE 5

    Governance and Political Violence Data

    W w -

    , S S , w

    v v M, T,

    M v w v v

    ( F 4).

    P k , w

    w E v

    , w k v-

    - S,

    C, N, S. S k

    v x M-

    M, A, E (

    F 5).

    W w k w

    x -

    z (

    x - z)

    , w v v w x

    - z v-

    w w ( F

    6). T N C

    w S. W E

    v , w

    M T v-

    z v w v

    v

    v

    w v.

    S q v-

    . W v

    v ? D w v -

    v

    w ? T j

    , w .

    W v,

    w Uv-

    Tx w

    .4 F x, w w k j

    w 98-

    4-6 , w w

    4 O K Ck N Vz Jk S G. T WR F (WRF) NC A R (NCAR) NO A A. T AB .

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    29/48

    Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa 23

    FIGURE 14

    E, w S, C,

    M w k x

    wv , A x w w (

    F 7).4

    W w k

    , w M-

    , T L

    w x

    , w A x .43

    S M, S,

    S w x , w

    E S x-

    w ( F 8).

    4 H wv w x 5 F.

    43 D v w v .

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    30/48

    The German Marshall Fund of the United States24

    FIGURE 15

    FIGURE 16

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    31/48

    Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa 25

    FIGURE 17

    FIGURE 18

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    32/48

    The German Marshall Fund of the United States26

    B w v v v, w w v

    x -

    z v

    v .

    Niger

    I , N x w

    8 N Rv,

    N. N 8 N

    w v

    , . P C

    M w . T

    w v

    v wk

    .44

    N w -

    . I F , z w

    , w

    w

    w.45 T v

    w w vv .

    N, N v

    (N k 35 53 A

    v x, 9 UNDP

    H Dv Ix, N k

    w).46

    N v

    v . N v

    8 k (w

    F ) A Ak N

    44 J ; T ; Nw C A.

    45 S .

    46 S ://..///

    w S D A . I , F

    Av j .

    T I

    3 4 5,

    , k N

    w.

    Hwv, N

    k .47 Ev N

    v w w

    , v , v F

    , w k - S

    w A Q I M (AQIM),

    F v

    ,7 v

    .48 W k

    kw w, w

    w v N -

    x .

    A AQIM,

    N S v

    T w

    v - -

    . T T, w v

    z v

    , 7

    9, v

    w. C

    9 , w w

    v .

    W T z k

    , v

    99 ,

    995, 998, 6.49

    TT v

    w AQIM. F x, T w

    47 Lw M .

    48 R , .

    49 Hkwz 5; AN 7; UPI 9.

    Narratives of Climate Vulnerability

    in North Africa3

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    33/48

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    34/48

    The German Marshall Fund of the United States28

    U Hw) A T B K D N G/

    Mv C, B (

    F 9). W w

    N Rv G,

    G.5 O

    T Az ( F 9

    N Rv B

    v).53

    T N , , Q v, -

    v -

    , , ,

    . T , -

    x. T v

    wk v ,

    , w v w

    x w

    v w, , k -

    .

    Sudan

    T D w S

    UN S G B

    K- w w, k

    k z

    w

    S v

    Jjw . W

    v

    - w S

    . D v

    v D

    v. W

    5 DLR .

    53 FEWSNET .

    v v w ? P,

    w v .

    Lk , S

    . T v v

    J . W

    v , x v

    v w

    v S. F

    v w

    98 99, v w

    v . I 9, v , v

    N-S

    3, .54 A v

    , A v

    w w j S

    w N. O , N

    M S K B N,

    ;

    ,

    w

    S v v w.55

    I x, v

    vw , k

    N, k

    x v w

    , w

    w S v

    . A S v

    , k v

    x ,

    J, x . I

    v w , S

    v . Mv, -

    S, - S

    54 G 9.

    55 Swz 9; I C G .

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    35/48

    Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa 29

    FIGURE 20

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    36/48

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    37/48

    Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa 31

    A -q , v

    v v

    z w -

    . I

    , k

    k v v

    , w D A C

    W .

    T w

    k -

    q k - v. A w v ,

    v v

    k z .

    B ,

    w

    . A

    ,

    . T x-

    v, v w

    q

    v

    . Ev

    , w

    .

    I v , w

    v v-v .

    T N A v-

    q ,

    , ,

    w

    . F ,

    v v

    v,

    v

    wk , ,

    . O

    N A

    , wk

    . A -

    , v A w-

    w v x

    w v

    . W -w

    w v

    w q ,

    v k

    k .

    A ,

    w

    , v w

    q

    . T w ,

    , w , -

    , , -

    .

    A v ,

    v

    w

    x - z.

    T w E k

    v, w v N

    A M

    x z

    v

    v

    v ( -

    ). B , S H, v M, x x

    v w

    , k v-

    w z w w

    ,

    j .

    Conclusion and Policy Implications

    4

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    38/48

    The German Marshall Fund of the United States32

    O , :

    C, N, S, S, -

    v w E. O

    , v

    k w. S, w

    , ,

    ,

    w .

    C k M T,

    x ,

    k q .T v .

    T w

    v

    .59

    T q S w

    x w v

    v w ,

    .

    O w

    w x v

    - v

    v-

    NGO v

    w E.

    Hwv, v

    , v NGO

    v - . Ev

    v ,

    -- x

    w .

    A ,

    - v

    v , w

    k .

    59 T v (K 9, , ).

    W v , w w :

    . F

    v

    v

    w E k

    S, C, N.

    Buildbasicgovernmentcapacityinthose

    v v

    v - .

    SupportNGOandlocalgovernment

    v w ,

    , -

    , w .

    . B v w N

    A v M

    v

    v

    Focusoninformation-sharingand

    z v w -

    z.

    Developbetterinformationresources

    v N A

    .

    W

    q , v

    k z

    . Pvv

    v -v

    w . A

    , v vv

    v w,

    v -

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    39/48

    Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa 33

    w . B v v v

    wk v ,

    ( -

    , w , v

    , v )

    w . H, v-

    v w

    .

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    40/48

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    41/48

    Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa 35

    AFP. . Thousands lee south Sudan loods,A 3 [ S 8, ]. Av

    ://www../w//

    /ALqM5jH73GDO5Q9xqW3K-

    B48Ew.

    A-M, I. . E. I

    Climate Change and National Security, D.

    M: Gw Uv P.

    AN. 7. Niger-Mali Tuareg Unrest, M 9

    [ S 9, ]. Av ://

    www..///NE_TUA..

    Bk, M. 7. Climate Change - the

    Gathering Storm, A 6 [ J 8, 7].

    Av ://www../_

    4/__w.?_=47794.

    B, C. 9. Southern Sudan loods

    displace thousands. C C C, J

    [ S 9, ]. Av

    ://www../.

    ?CID=599.

    B, Dw. 7. P Ak: TI Eqk I C. The

    Journal o Conlict Resolution 5 (5):75-743.

    B, Hv. . Climate not to blame or

    Arican civil wars. P N

    A S, S 7 [

    S 6, ]. Av ://www.

    .////8/3/57397#

    -.

    B, Hv, N P G, O

    M T. 8. I C

    C A C. W Bk.

    B, J. 7. C C N

    S: A A A. Nw Yk: C

    F R.

    Bibliography

    5

    . 8. W C A W?C C U.S. N S. Security

    Studies 7 (3):468-54.

    B, J. 9. F I? Pv,

    Wk S, C C I Conronting

    Poverty: Weak States and U.S. National Security,

    S. R, C. G C. P. W-

    , DC: Bk I P.

    B, J, T G. S, K W,

    Sw M. S. . Locating Climate Insecu-

    rity: Where are the Most Vulnerable Places in Arica?

    S C I S Lw,

    A [ S 6, ]. Av

    ://..//_

    //9/.?839563.

    C, K M., J G, J.R. MN,

    J P, P O, L F, R. J

    W, Ax T.J. L, J S,

    R Wz, Dk Mx. 7. The Age

    o Consequences. CSIS/CNAS, Nv [

    O , ]. Av ://www..

    ////75_q.

    .

    CENTRA T, S C.

    9. North Arica: The Impact o Climate Change

    to 2030: Geopolitical Implications. N I-

    C, D [ S 5,

    ]. Av ://www..v//

    PDF_GIF_/_/9_

    ___..

    CNA C. 7. National Security and the

    Threat o Climate Change [ J 8, 7]. Av-

    ://..//.

    C, P. 7. The bottom billion: why the

    poorest countries are ailing and what can be done

    about it. Ox; Nw Yk: Ox Uv

    P.

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    42/48

    The German Marshall Fund of the United States36

    C, S. . Developing AdequateHumanitarian Responses. GMF, J [ O

    , ]. Av ://www../

    /-/C_MAH_EV..

    D M E R. . Nw

    w T Q S

    , A 3 [ S 7, ]. Av-

    ://www../Nw+-

    +w+T++++Q+

    +S+-3643.

    W, Ax 7. Is Climate Change the

    Culprit or Darur?SSRC, J 5 [ J

    8, 7]. Av ://www../

    /7/6/5/------

    /.

    DLR. . Flooding along the river Niger in August

    2010, A 4 [ S 7, ]. Av-

    ://www.zk..//56.

    F, Sz, A B. K, M

    O. . Lk

    , MxUS -

    Proceedings o the National Academy oSciences 7 (3):457-46

    FEWSNET. . Signiicant increase in livestock

    losses due to heavy rains. USAID, S

    [ S 7, ]. Av

    ://www.w.//P/N_

    __9__..

    F, J-P. . Could Al-Qaeda Turn

    Arican in the Sahel?C Ew

    I P, J [ S 7,

    ]. Av www.w.

    //_q_..

    F, T. 8. T H

    P S C I H

    S C E I

    G W. D N I.

    G, J. 9. Violence Grips SouthSudan as Vote Nears. New York Times, D

    [ S 8, ]. Av

    ://www../9///w/

    /..

    G, N P, R N, I

    S. 7. Climate Change and Conlict: The

    Migration Link. I P A, M

    [ O , ]. Av ://

    www..///69/CWC_Wk_

    P_C_C..

    G T D, START, J

    , [ O , ]. Av

    ://www...//

    H, W. .An eective response to

    climate change underpins our security and pros-

    perity.F Cw O,

    S 7 [ O 8, ]. Av-

    ://www..v.k//w/-

    w/?vw=S=933444.

    Hx, C S., S M. G. 7.

    T T: C C CvC S-S A. Political Geography

    6 (6):695-75.

    Hx, C, I S. . A

    R: R V, H-M

    D, S C A. I Climate

    Change and Security Conerence. T,

    Nw.

    Hkwz, A. 5. The Tuareg in Mali and

    Niger: The Role o Desertiication in Violent Conlict

    ICE C S, A [ S 7,

    ]. Av ://www../

    //..

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    43/48

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    44/48

    The German Marshall Fund of the United States38

    Lv, M. . Climate-Security Linkages Lost inTranslation. Nw S B, S 3 [

    S 6, ]. Av ://w-

    ..//9/---

    -k-..

    Lv, M A., B A, M

    Bk, C C, B Fk, Bz Fk,

    P G, M J, R L,

    V M, K MM, Sv Mz,

    M Mz, T P, R P,

    C Tk, C V, W

    W, X X, G Y. 8.Assessment o Select Climate Change Impacts on U.S.

    National Security. C I E

    S I Nwk (CIESIN), C

    Uv, J [ J , 8]. Av

    ://www...//

    C_S_CIESIN_J_8_v_...

    Lv, M A., C Tk, C

    V, E D, M

    H. 5. Freshwater Availability Anoma-

    lies and Outbreak o Internal War: Results rom a

    Global Spatial Time Series Analysis. H S

    C C C [ A 6,

    6]. Av ://www.../

    //Lv__..

    Lw, Dv, A M. .

    Areva says Niger Imouraren startup delayed.

    R, F 6 [ S 7, ].

    Av ://..//v-

    Nw/AFJOE6PL56.

    M, P. . Climate Change, Agricultural

    Development, and Migration. G M

    F, J [ O 8, ]. Av www..//-/PM_

    V..

    M, S F. . Climate Change and Inter-national Migration. GMF, J [ O ,

    ]. Av www..//

    -/M_V3..

    M, N. 5. Ev R: A

    E S I. 3 E F,

    P, 3-7 M.

    N I C. 9. North Arica:

    The Impact o Climate Change to 2030 [

    S 6, ]. Av ://www.

    .v//PDF_GIF_/_/

    3__..

    . . E F C C

    C- M N A

    I. Population and Development Review 36

    ():48-4.

    N, P, Mj R. 8. N

    D Rk V Cv C.

    International Studies Quarterly 5 ():5985.

    N, R, N P G. 9.

    IPCC - x. P I S A, F 5-8,

    Nw Yk.

    Nw C A. . Niger: Getting

    ood in by truck, boat, camel, and cart, A 7

    [ S 9, ]. Av ://

    www.k./D/9775..

    R, C, L J, I S

    8. Climate Change, Migration and Conlict.

    W Bk S Dv G [

    S 4, ]. Av ://-

    .wk./EXTSOCIALDEVELOP-MENT/R/SDCCWkP_M-

    C..

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    45/48

    Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa 39

    RAND. 7. Ungoverned Territories: Under-standing and Reducing Terrorism Risks [

    O , 7]. Av ://www..

    ///7/RAND_MG56..

    R. . Five French Said Kidnapped

    in Niger, S 6 [ S 9,

    ]. Av ://www../

    //9/6/w//-

    k--.?x==x

    x=849743-I9EEI75NTqQ.

    . . Niger: France Urges Citizens

    to Leave Mining Region, S 7 [

    S 9, ]. Av ://www.

    .//9/8/w//8-

    N.?_==.

    S, I, K Sk G.

    6. R S Cv W. Inter-

    national Organization 6 ():335-366.

    Swz, A. 9. Scenarios or Sudan:

    Avoiding Political Violence Through 2011. U

    S I P, A [ S

    9, ]. Av www..///SR8_..

    S, Dv. .Military junta seizes power in

    Niger coup. Guardian, F 9 [ S

    9, ]. Av ://www..

    .k/w///9/--j-

    .

    S, Jv. 8. Climate Change and Interna-

    tional Security: Paper rom the High Representa-

    tive and the European Commission to the Euro-

    pean Council. E C, M 4

    [ J 8, 8]. Av ://www.

    ../D/_D//-

    D///99387..

    S, Sk P. 9. Climate Change,Migration and EU Security. C H,

    Nv [ S 6, ]. Av

    www...k/v//w-

    /-//67//66.

    T, O M, H H,

    Hv B. . D, P Ex-

    , Cv W. I International Studies Asso-

    ciation Annual Convention. Nw O, LA.

    T, W. . Road rom Juba and

    Nimule to Uganda on course. E Nw, A

    3 [ S 9, ]. Av

    ://www.w./85/-j--

    --.

    T, Mk. .Audio slideshow: Nigers

    double disaster. BBC, A 3 [ S

    9, ]. Av ://www...k/

    w/w-99798.

    UN S C. 7. Security Council Holds

    First-Ever Debate On Impact O Climate Change

    On Peace, Security, Hearing Over 50 Speakers. Nw

    Yk, U N. U N, A 7[ J 8, 7]. Av ://www.

    ./Nw/P//7/9...

    UPI. 9. Cease-ire truce reached with Niger

    rebels, M 6 [ S 7, ]. Av

    ://www../T_Nw/9/5/5/

    C----w-N-/

    UPI-9958443588/.

    V, Dv. 7. W R W? The

    National Interest, Nv/D [

    O , ]. Av www.-

    ./A.x?=6.

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    46/48

    The German Marshall Fund of the United States40

    Wz, M, K Mv. 9. ClimateMigration Will Aect the Worlds Security. C

    A P, D 8 [

    S 6, ]. Av ://www.

    .//9//__

    v..

    W, G W. . T M:

    M, T, A, L. I Climate

    Change and National Security, D. M:

    Gw Uv P.

    W Bk. .Managing the Social Dimensions

    o climate change in MENA: Climate change and

    human mobility [ S 6, ]. Av-

    ://www../_/O/

    WB-AFD_CCM_CN.

    .

    W F P. . Number O Hungry

    Quadruples in Southern Sudan Amidst Conlict and

    Drought, F [ S 9, ].

    Av ://www.w./w/w-

    /--q--

    ----.

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    47/48

  • 8/8/2019 Mapping Climate Change and Security in North Africa

    48/48

    OFF I C E S