management control systems for state bank of india

31
MANAGEMENT CONTROL SYSTEMS FOR State bank of India Submitted to: Mr.C. ANAND Submitted on: January 15, 2013 Submitted by: Sr. No. Name Enrollment No. 1 Shalini Shukla 11BSPHH0 2 Satya Anuragh 11BSPHH011144 3 S.Hemanth 11BSPHH0110 4 D.Uday Kumar 11BSPHH011089 5 G.Venkat Rao 11BSPHH 1 | Management Control Systems – State Bank of India

Upload: anuragh-venkataswamy

Post on 28-Dec-2015

129 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

DESCRIPTION

Management Control Systems for State Bank Of India

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Management Control Systems for State Bank Of India

MANAGEMENT CONTROL SYSTEMS

FOR

State bank of India

Submitted to: Mr.C. ANANDSubmitted on: January 15, 2013

Submitted by: Sr. No. Name Enrollment No.

1 Shalini Shukla 11BSPHH02 Satya Anuragh 11BSPHH0111443 S.Hemanth 11BSPHH01104 D.Uday Kumar 11BSPHH0110895 G.Venkat Rao 11BSPHH

6 Sai Krishna 11BSPHH

1 | M a n a g e m e n t C o n t r o l S y s t e m s – S t a t e B a n k o f I n d i a

Page 2: Management Control Systems for State Bank Of India

INDEX

SL.NO. CONTENTS PAGE NO.

1 INTRODUCTION 3

2 ORGANIZATION STRUCTURE 4

3 MANAGEMENT STYLE & CULTURE 6

4 PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM 9

5 MANAGEMENT CONTROL SYSTEMS 10

6MERITS OF CONTROL PROCESS ADOPTED BY SBI

17

7DEMRITS OFCONTROL PROCESSES ADOPTED BY SBI

18

8 RECOMMENDATIONS 19

9 CONCLUSION 20

10 REFERENCES 21

2 | M a n a g e m e n t C o n t r o l S y s t e m s – S t a t e B a n k o f I n d i a

Page 3: Management Control Systems for State Bank Of India

INTRODUCTION

STATE BANK OF INDIA

SBI, a bank with 60% government stake, was India’s largest commercial bank and 43rd largest

bank in the world with a market capitalization of $36.5 billion in 2011. It along with its five

associate banks and 22 subsidiaries, which constituted the State Bank Group, had more than

26700 employees, a pan India network of over 18000 branches and 25000 ATMS, and delivered

profit of $2.6 billion.

The origin of State Bank of India set its roots in year 1806 when Bank of Calcutta was

established. In 1921, the Bank of Calcutta and two other presidency banks (Bank of Madras and

Bank of Bombay) were amalgamated to form the Imperial Bank of India. In 1955, in controlling

interest the Imperial Bank of India was acquired by the Reserve Bank of India and State Bank of

India came into existence by an act of parliament, as a successor to the Imperial Bank of India.

Today, State Bank of India has spread its arms around the world and has a network of branches

spanning all time zones. SBI provides a range of banking products through its vast network of

branches in India and overseas, including products aimed at non-resident Indians. It also has

around 130 branches overseas. It is one of the largest financial institutions in the world. It has a

market share of about 20% among Indian commercial banks in deposits and loans.

The Bank is forging ahead with cutting edge technology and innovative new banking models, to

expand its Rural Banking base, looking at the vast untapped potential in the hinterland and

proposes to cover 100,000 villages in the next two years.

SBI is also focusing at the top end of the market, on whole sale banking capabilities to provide

India’s growing mid and large Corporate with a complete array of products and services. Bank is

consolidating its global treasury operations and entering into structured products and derivative

instruments.

3 | M a n a g e m e n t C o n t r o l S y s t e m s – S t a t e B a n k o f I n d i a

Page 4: Management Control Systems for State Bank Of India

Today, the Bank is the largest provider of infrastructure debt and the largest arranger of external

commercial borrowings in the country. It is the only Indian bank to feature in the Fortune 500

list.

ORGANIZATION STRUCTURE

ORGANIZATION CHART

4 | M a n a g e m e n t C o n t r o l S y s t e m s – S t a t e B a n k o f I n d i a

Page 5: Management Control Systems for State Bank Of India

There were four strategic business unit groups headed by Deputy Managing Directors. The

business units were:

National Banking Group

Rural and Agricultural Banking

5 | M a n a g e m e n t C o n t r o l S y s t e m s – S t a t e B a n k o f I n d i a

Page 6: Management Control Systems for State Bank Of India

Treasury and Markets

Mid-Corporate Group

The rural and agricultural banking group aimed into the enormous potential in rural India. The

creation of the mid corporate group was to cater to the second tier corporate borrowers and the

global capital markets.

There was a special committee group created, the Corporate Strategy and New Business

Group which was tasked with rolling out new businesses.

SBI was divided into 14 administrative circles each headed by a Chief General Manager.

Most circles consisted of two networks of branches, each headed by a General Manager. The

bank assigned each employee to a circle and then either promoted him within that circle or

posted him on assignments outside his circle on deputation. In order to provide executives a

diverse experience across functions, SBI promoted or transferred them every three to five years.

SBI employees were organized into three hierarchical levels – officers (35%), clerical (44%) and

subordinate staff (21%). The bank selected clerical and executive staff through countrywide

examinations. It often promoted the clerical staff to the executive cadre. The bank recruited

executives as probationary officers, and after successful completion of training promoted them

as assistant managers. There were 9 levels between an assistant manager and the chairman.

At the senior level, decision making was mostly collective. The Central Management

Committee, the bank’s apex committee, comprising of the Chairman, Managing Directors and

Deputy Managing Directors typically met twice a month to monitor progress and take major

business decisions. This committee reported to the Board of Directors.

MANAGEMENT STYLE & CULTUREOrganizational culture is a set of values, beliefs, and assumptions deemed appropriate in

thinking and acting inside an organization. Being shared by the organization’s elements, culture

6 | M a n a g e m e n t C o n t r o l S y s t e m s – S t a t e B a n k o f I n d i a

Page 7: Management Control Systems for State Bank Of India

helps solve and understand external and internal problems. Established notions, stable and long-

lasting beliefs on significant matters and understandings of the relationship between various

concepts all contribute to the culture at work, so the members accept their validity and are

influenced by the same regarding the people’s perspective, thoughts, feelings, and behavior

within the organization.

Most organizations have their respective stories to tell, passed on from generation to generation

of employees and customers. These organizations have stories as medium of organizational

values and set of goals among members. Also, stories can persuade external people into

throwing support to the organization. Hence, stories are taken to be indispensably integral to the

culture of an organization, and are an essential part of its success. Same is the case with SBI. It’s

a bank of more than 200 years old and it has been providing services to the nation and on that

value it proposes to move forward. This value is transmitted to its employees with help of

stories. So there is sense of commitment to the nation.

Another cultural behavior within the organization which outside people and employees may

learn from is rituals. Rituals are customary and recurrent practices that play a certain meaning in

any organization. They are functional for conveying the organization’s major values and

building relations among employees, outsiders, and managers. Staff meetings, reward and

evaluation processes, and annual dinner or lunch are some of the organizational rituals

conducted day-to-day. These things go well with SBI also. In addition to that study leave and

other benefits are provided to SBI employees, which go well with SBI vision statement of a

culture of mutual care and employee’s commitment to bank & a sense of belonging.

An employee’s interactions with role models reflect his personality traits like expectations,

experience, self-confidence and competitive streak. These dealings become the cornerstone of an

employee’s career in the organization. New employees with positive role models build

confidence with their performance; obtain experience, aware of expectation from them and

conscious of the organization’s culture. At SBI for the last 10 years one role model for the

employees was Mr. O.P Bhatt. That has shaped the culture of SBI and gave it a competitive

streak as both old & new employees saw him as role model.

7 | M a n a g e m e n t C o n t r o l S y s t e m s – S t a t e B a n k o f I n d i a

Page 8: Management Control Systems for State Bank Of India

SBI, with its 18000 plus branches across the country, envisions maintaining diversity as a way of

life as its culture’s core and its business’ foundation. The organization’s objectives are to attract

and keep a manpower that reflects India, to make policies and practices that use human potential

to the fullest, and to build hopes, realize dreams and develop equity in partners, neighborhood

and communities.

With the help of training at SBI, prospective employees are expected to become best bankers.

For them to learn efficiently and perform better, they are provided with feedback. In effect, the

culture is crystallized into these employees and thus, it shares a hand in maintaining

organizational culture. An organization’s culture, a few artifacts of which were just mentioned,

produces effects on corporate branding. In the course of prevalent globalization and international

franchising of companies, it is necessary for a systematic manner of managing the corporate

development in order to strive for long-term success. Organizational culture plays an important

role in making a company’s image and reputation, both an increasingly important factor for the

decision-making of purchasers.

Vision is the compass of the organization—a medium used to lead the company to its desired

and desirable direction. An organization wants a future that ensures a lasting business, and

through envisioning does the organization locate itself at a specific success position. Vision of

the company shapes its culture with the help of values. These two have been playing important

role in shaping culture in SBI. The values of customer excellence, profit orientation, risk-

taking & innovation, team playing and transparency in policies & systems have helped SBI

in diversifying into new businesses as well. Vision of becoming premier financial services

company and an institution with a culture of mutual care & commitment and of providing

continuous learning opportunity have shaped both business and culture of the organization.

Like most companies SBI has fair share of red tape which frustrate both employees and

customers. If you have a file which does not have a political or big corporate backing, it will take

months to move that file. This red tape is the reason of slow cross departmental work also. Other

than these work culture at SBI is formal and hierarchical in nature.

SBI recognizes and encourages innovation and risk taking. Innovation specifically financial

innovation is perhaps the prime reason for SBI’s dominant position in the marketplace. Such

8 | M a n a g e m e n t C o n t r o l S y s t e m s – S t a t e B a n k o f I n d i a

Page 9: Management Control Systems for State Bank Of India

financial innovation is risky in terms of substantial cost of research and development. However,

this innovation and risk taking has certainly benefited SBI. This has helped in gaining good

market share and business.

Outcome orientation scores relatively high in the organization culture behavior of SBI. The

outcome, vision, or big picture is regularly stressed in monthly department meetings. The big

picture within any organization is delivering a quality product at cost, on time, and

responsiveness to the customer’s needs. Often times, it is the details that dominate most of the

meetings and work time, yet the outcome does rate high. For example, a task force is already in

place developing the second and third generation of the product. This task force has before it

clearly defined goals that must be reached. These goals are the desired outcome and must be

fulfilled in order to have a successful outcome.

Overall, the organizational culture in SBI contributes to a healthy and pleasant job experience.

There definitely exists a shared meaning as each organization has a wide expanse of control,

talented cross-functional teams, and empowered employees. In closing, the IBM organizational

culture provides a supportive framework, is technologically innovative, and encourages

employee empowerment.

In 2010, SBI won the Asian Banker Achievement Award for the strongest bank in the Asia-

Pacific region

PERFOMANCE MANAGEMENT SYSTEM

9 | M a n a g e m e n t C o n t r o l S y s t e m s – S t a t e B a n k o f I n d i a

Page 10: Management Control Systems for State Bank Of India

Motivating people in a public sector organization is a huge challenge. The government dictated

salaries are not at par with the private sector. To overcome report writing, the individual reports

on employees were multiple choice formats. The number of committees to look into

performance management systems was formed. The structure at SBI was such that it empowered

people across organization, right from window assistants at the branches to credit committees at

the corporate office. The bank gave subordinate staff meaningful responsibility, for instance,

at the branches they were made responsible for guiding and assisting customers in simple tasks

such as dropping off checks, and forms and even in simple marketing efforts. There were

numerous employee recognition measures ranging from introducing a practice of sending simple

appreciation letters to conferring award for “Best Employee of the Month” to sending some

best performers on overseas trips with their families. There was online Employee Suggestion

Scheme. SBI actually implemented many of those suggestions. There was Chairman’s Club

Scheme, which selected 50 top performers from different fields. The winners and their spouses

were invited for dinner at Chairman’s residence. As a part of rights issue, SBI also introduced an

Employee Share Purchase Scheme to which everybody from the messenger to the Chairman

could subscribe.

MANAGEMENT CONTROL PROCESS

10 | M a n a g e m e n t C o n t r o l S y s t e m s – S t a t e B a n k o f I n d i a

Page 11: Management Control Systems for State Bank Of India

A management control systems (MCS) is a system which gathers and uses information to

evaluate the performance of different organizational resources like human, physical, financial

and also the organization as a whole considering the organizational strategies. Finally, MCS

influences the behavior of organizational resources to implement organizational strategies. MCS

might be formal or informal. The term ‘management control’ was given of its current

connotations by Robert N. Anthony. He defined Management Control is the process by which

managers influence other members of the organization to implement the organization’s

strategies. Management control systems are tools to aid management for steering an organization

toward its strategic objectives and competitive advantage. Management controls are only one of

the tools which managers use in implementing desired strategies. However strategies get

implemented through management controls, organizational structure, human resources

management and culture.

Following are the control systems put in place in SBI:

RISK MANAGEMENT STRUCTURE

An independent Risk Governance Structure is in place for Integrated Risk Management covering

Credit, Market, Operational and Group Risks. This framework visualizes empowerment of

Business Units at the operating level, with technology being the key driver, enabling

identification and management of risk at the place of origination.

The Risk Governance Structure in place in the Bank is as under:

The Risk Management Committee of the Board (RMCB) has the overall responsibility to

monitor and manage Enterprise Wide Risk.

The Credit Risk Management Committee (CRMC), Market Risk Management

Committee (MRMC), Operational Risk Management Committee (ORMC), Group Risk

Management Committee (GRMC) and Asset Liability Management Committee (ALCO)

support RMCB.

Chairman & Group Executive (Associates & Subsidiaries) are the members of RMCB

Chairman and Deputy Managing Directors are invited to attend all the meetings of the

Committee.

11 | M a n a g e m e n t C o n t r o l S y s t e m s – S t a t e B a n k o f I n d i a

Page 12: Management Control Systems for State Bank Of India

The Deputy Managing Director & Chief Credit and Risk Officer head CRMC, MRMC,

ORMC and GRMC. ALCO is headed by the Chairman & Chief Financial Officer.

Risk Management is perceived as an enabler for business growth and in strategic

business planning, by aligning business strategy to the underlying risks. This is achieved

by constantly re-assessing the inter-dependencies / interfaces amongst each silo of Risk

and business functions.

Bank is in the process of implementing Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) that will

integrate all the Risk Management functions of the Bank, explore inter-dependencies

amongst various risk types and act as a support system to strategic decision-making

process.

BASEL II IMPLEMENTATION

In accordance with RBI guidelines, the Bank has migrated to the Basel II framework, with the

Standardized Approach for Credit Risk and Basic Indicator approach for Operational Risk with

effect from March 31, 2008, having already implemented the Standardized Duration Method for

Market Risk

Simultaneously, the Bank is updating and fine-tuning its Systems and Procedures, Information

Technology (IT) capabilities, Risk Assessment and Risk Governance structure to meet the

requirements of the Advanced Approaches under Basel II.

Various initiatives such as new Credit Risk Assessment Models, independent validation of

Internal Ratings, loss data collection and computation of market risk Value at Risk and

improvement in Loan Data Quality would facilitate efficient use of Capital as well as smooth

transition to Advanced Approaches.

Risk Awareness exercises are being conducted across the Bank to enhance the degree of

awareness at the Operating levels, in alignment with better risk management practices, Basel II

requirements and over-arching aim of conservation and optimum use of capital.

Keeping in view the changes that the Bank’s portfolios may undergo in stressed situations, the

Bank has in place a policy, which provides a framework for conducting the Stress Tests at

12 | M a n a g e m e n t C o n t r o l S y s t e m s – S t a t e B a n k o f I n d i a

Page 13: Management Control Systems for State Bank Of India

periodic intervals and initiating remedial measures wherever warranted. The scope of the tests is

constantly reviewed to include more stringent and new scenarios.

CREDIT RISK MANAGEMENT

Credit Risk Management process encompasses identification, assessment, measurement,

monitoring and control of the Credit Exposures. Well-defined basic risk measures such as CRA

(Credit Risk Assessment) models, Industry Exposure norms, Counter-party Exposure limits,

Substantial Exposure limits, etc., have been put in place.

Credit Risk components such as Probability of Default, Loss Given Default and Exposure at

Default are being computed. Frequency of Stress Tests in respect of Credit Risk has been

increased from Annual to Half-yearly, to identify Credit Risk at an early stage and to initiate

appropriate measures to contain/ mitigate Credit Risk.

MARKET RISK MANAGEMENT

Market Risk Management is governed by the Board approved policies for investment, Private

Equity & Venture Capital, trading in Bonds, Equities, Foreign Exchange and Derivatives.

Exposure, Stop Loss, Modified Duration, Present Value and Value at Risk limits have been

prescribed. These limits, along with other Management Action Triggers, are tracked daily and

necessary action initiated, as required, to keep Market Risk within approved limits.

OPERATIONAL RISK MANAGEMENT

The Bank manages operational risks by having in place and maintaining a comprehensive

system of internal controls and policies. The main objectives of the Bank’s Operational Risk

Management are to continuously review systems and control mechanisms, create awareness of

operational risk throughout the Bank, assign risk ownership, alignment of risk management

activities with business strategy and ensuring compliance with regulatory requirements.

The Operational Risk Management policy of the Bank establishes a consistent framework for

systematic and pro-active identification, assessment, measurement, monitoring and mitigation of

13 | M a n a g e m e n t C o n t r o l S y s t e m s – S t a t e B a n k o f I n d i a

Page 14: Management Control Systems for State Bank Of India

operational risk. The Policy applies to all business and functional areas within the Bank, and is

supplemented by operational systems, procedures and guidelines which are periodically updated.

GROUP RISK MANAGEMENT

The State Bank Group is recognized as a major Financial Conglomerate and as a systemically

important financial intermediary, with significant presence in various financial markets.

Accordingly, it is imperative, both from the regulatory point of view as well as from the Group’s

own internal control and risk management point of view, to oversee the functioning of individual

entities in the Group and periodically assess the overall level of risk in the Group. This facilitates

optimal utilization of capital resources and adoption of a uniform set of risk practices across the

Group Entities.

The Group Risk Management Policy applies to all Associate Banks, Banking and Non-banking

Subsidiaries and Joint Ventures of the State Bank Group under the jurisdiction of specified

regulators and complying with the relevant Accounting Standards, where the SBI has investment

in equity shares of 30% and more with control over management. With a view to enabling the

Group Entities to assess their material risks and adequacy of the risk management processes and

capital, all Group members, including Non-banking Subsidiaries are encouraged to align their

policies and practices with the Group, follow Basel prescriptions and international best practices.

ASSET LIABILITY MANAGEMENT

The Asset Liability Management Committee (ALCO) of the Bank is entrusted with the

evolvement of appropriate systems and procedures in order to identify and analyze balance sheet

risks and setting of benchmark parameters for efficient management of these risks. ALM

Department, being the support group to ALCO, monitors the Bank’s market risk such as

liquidity risk, interest rate risk etc., by analyzing various ALM reports / returns. The ALM

department reviews the ALM Policy and complies with the Bank’s / RBI’s policy guidelines on

an ongoing basis. The Market Related Fund Transfer Pricing Mechanism has been implemented

for evaluating the business performance of the branches of the Bank.

14 | M a n a g e m e n t C o n t r o l S y s t e m s – S t a t e B a n k o f I n d i a

Page 15: Management Control Systems for State Bank Of India

INTERNAL CONTROL

The Bank has in-built internal control systems with well-defined responsibilities at each level.

The Bank carries out mainly two streams of audits - Inspection & Audit and Management

Audit covering different facets of Internal Audit requirement. Apart from these, Credit Audit is

conducted for units with large credit limits and Concurrent Audit is carried out at branches

having large deposits, advances and other risk exposures and selected BPR Outfits.

Expenditure Audit, involving scrutiny of accounts and correctness of expenditure incurred, is

conducted at Corporate Centre Establishments, Local Head Offices, Zonal Offices, On Locale

Regional Offices, Regional Business Offices, Lead Bank Offices, etc. To verify the level of

rectification of irregularities by branches, audit of compliance at select branches is also

undertaken. The Information System Audit (IS Audit) of the centralized IT establishments is

being conducted.

Risk Focused Internal Audit (RFIA)

The inspection system plays an important and critical role of introducing international best

practices in the internal audit function which is regarded as a critical component of Corporate

Governance. Inspection & Management Audit Department undertakes a critical review of the

entire working of audit units. Risk Focused Internal Audit, an adjunct to risk based supervision

as per RBI directives, is in vogue in the Bank’s audit system. Inspection & Audit of all branches

have been segregated into 3 groups on the basis of business profile and risk exposures. While

audit of Group I branches and credit oriented BPR entities (excepting SARC) is administered by

Central Audit Unit (CAU) at Inspection & Management Audit Department headed by a General

Manager (CAU), audit of branches in Group II & Group III category and other BPR entities are

conducted by ten Zonal Inspection Offices, located at various Centers, each of which is headed

by a General Manager (I&A). The audit of branches and BPR entities is conducted as per the

periodicity approved by Audit Committee of the Board (ACB) which is well within RBI norms.

Management Audit

With the introduction of Risk Focused Internal Audit, Management Audit has been reoriented to

focus on the effectiveness of risk management in the processes and the procedures followed in

the Bank. Management Audit universe comprises of Corporate Centre Establishments; Circles /

15 | M a n a g e m e n t C o n t r o l S y s t e m s – S t a t e B a n k o f I n d i a

Page 16: Management Control Systems for State Bank Of India

Apex Training Institutions, Associate Banks; Subsidiaries (Domestic / Foreign); Joint Ventures

(Domestic / Foreign), Regional Rural Banks sponsored by the Bank (RRBs). During the period

from 01.04.2010 to 31.03.2011, Management Audit of 45 domestic offices/establishments was

carried out.

Credit Audit

Credit Audit aims at achieving continuous improvement in the quality of Commercial Credit

portfolio of the Bank through critically examining individual large commercial loans with

exposures of 5 crores and above. Credit Audit System (CAS), which has been aligned with Risk

Focused Internal Audit, assesses whether the Bank’s laid down policies in the area of credit

appraisal, sanction of loans and credit administration are meticulously complied with. CAS also

provides feedback to the business unit by way of warning signals about the quality of advance

portfolio in the unit and suggests remedial measures. It also comments on the risk rating

awarded and whether it is in order. Credit Audit carries out a review of all individual advances

above the cut off limit within 6 months of sanction/enhancement/ renewal as off-site audit and a

post sanction audit once in 12 months as on-site.

Information System Audit:

Since April 2006, all the Branches are being subjected to Information Systems (IS) audit to

assess the IT related risks as part of audit of the branch. A “Handbook on Self Audit of

Information Systems” was introduced to facilitate branches for evaluating the efficiency level of

IT systems. IS Audit of centralized IT establishments has commenced in January 2007.

CONCURRENT AUDIT SYSTEM:

Concurrent Audit system is essentially a control process integral to the establishment of sound

internal accounting functions, effective controls and overseeing of operations. It works as a tool

for the Controllers of operations for scrutiny of day-to-day operations. Concurrent Audit System

is reviewed on an on-going basis as per the RBI directives so as to cover 30-40% of the Bank’s

Deposits and 60-70% of the Bank’s Advances and other risk exposures. Inspection & Audit

department prescribes the processes, guidelines and formats for the conduct of concurrent audit

at branches and BPR entities. As on 31.03.2011, the system covers 30.15 % of deposits and

75.21 % of advances and other risk exposures of the Bank.

16 | M a n a g e m e n t C o n t r o l S y s t e m s – S t a t e B a n k o f I n d i a

Page 17: Management Control Systems for State Bank Of India

VIGILANCE

The main objective of vigilance activity in the Bank is not to reduce but enhance the level of

managerial efficiency and effectiveness in the organization. Risk taking is integral part of the

banking business. Therefore, every loss does not necessarily become subject matter of vigilance

enquiry. Motivated or reckless decisions that cause damage to the Bank are essentially dealt as

vigilance ones. While vigilance aims at punishing the delinquent employees, it also protects the

legitimate and bonafide business decisions taken by them and any other action devoid of

malafides. The Vigilance Department in the Bank functions on these principles.

Based on the principle “Prevention is better than Cure”, the Vigilance Department is actively

involved in the preventive measures, which aim at taking steps, which are essential for avoiding

recurrence of similar nature of frauds in the Bank. At the same time, Vigilance department is

taking proactive measures to prevent the incidences of frauds arising in CBS environment.

Considering the size of the Organization, we have set up vigilance departments at each of the 14

Circles, headed by Deputy General Managers. At Corporate Centre, Vigilance set up is headed

by Chief Vigilance Officer of the rank of Chief General Manager. The department reports to the

Chairman directly and conducts its affairs independently. The guidelines of the Central

Vigilance Commission (CVC) are followed in letter and spirit in its functioning.

MERITS OF THE CONTROL PROCESSESS ADOPTED BY SBIThe following are the merits of the various management control systems adopted by SBI:

17 | M a n a g e m e n t C o n t r o l S y s t e m s – S t a t e B a n k o f I n d i a

Page 18: Management Control Systems for State Bank Of India

1. Improved Coordination and Control between Various Departments.

With various committees and audit bodies having clear cut roles and responsibilities to

play, it is easy to coordinate and control the functioning of various departments and

branch units.

2. Future-Oriented

Control systems adopted by SBI are like Market Risk Management and Asset Liability

management are entrusted with the job of analyzing the balance sheets and predicting the

future liabilities which helps in taking the corrective measures for the bank and thus

helping in reducing the risk associated with it and allows for adjustments to be made to

get back on course before the control period ends.

3. Clear Management Roles and Responsibilities

The organization structure at SBI is a bureaucratic setup, with clear cut roles and

responsibilities for each post defined, thus resulting in lack of confusion about decision

making and lack of confusion of the expected standard of performance from each

employee.

4. Reward and Recognition to employees

Thought the organization is mostly centralized in decision making and authority wise,

but still there are a number of small initiatives undertaken, such as “Best Employee of

the month” and “letters of appreciation”, which keeps employees motivated even in a

public sector job.

5. Risk Management

Being a commercial bank, SBI faces several threats from credit defaults, hence making

risk management a very important tool. Bank has taken several steps to ensure the

credibility of its clients, which is utmost necessity for SBI.

DEMERITS OF THE CONTROL PROCESSESS ADOPTED BY SBI

1. Delays in Decision Making Process.

18 | M a n a g e m e n t C o n t r o l S y s t e m s – S t a t e B a n k o f I n d i a

Page 19: Management Control Systems for State Bank Of India

Since the organizational set up of SBI is basically bureaucratic in nature, the decisions

making process can be very time consuming as the issues will be transferred from the

branch manager to the assistant general manager to deputy general manager to the chief

general manager.

2. No Involvement of employees in the Decision Making Process.

In case of SBI we see that the job of framing the policies and strategies for the bank rest

solely in the hands of top management, with no involvement of the employees hence

resulting in lower employee motivation and morale.

3. Lack of Room for Change and Innovation

Rigid framework and guidelines in the control systems of SBI leave no room for change

and innovation. Even the bureaucratic and centralized structure gives little incentive for

new ideas and thoughts.

4. Too many rules and regulations

As we can see, SBI has to comply with all the rules and regulations lay down by Reserve

Bank of India. This is a set of very comprehensive rules which leaves no scope if

creativity.

5. Centralized structure leading to bureaucracy

The power in hands of the branch managers of SBI is very remote. However they are the

people running the branches. Every small decision has to be sanctioned by the Central

Management Committee and hence this might lead to bureaucracy.

SUGGESTIONS & RECOMMENDATIONS1. Creation of Responsibility Centers

19 | M a n a g e m e n t C o n t r o l S y s t e m s – S t a t e B a n k o f I n d i a

Page 20: Management Control Systems for State Bank Of India

A responsibility centre is an organization unit that is headed by manager who is

responsible for its activities. Creation of responsibility centers will help in removing the

bureaucratic set up of the organization to some extent. This concept is based on

delegating of responsibility for specific assignments or projects with specific goals at

successive levels of organization. Performance of each member of the responsibility

centre will be measures against the achievement of the specified goal.

2. Divisional autonomy

Each divisional manger should be given liberty to take decisions which are in best

interest of his/her division. There should be no interference in the decision making

process by other divisions.

3. Employee Involvement in Decision Making Process

Following a bottom up approach will make the employees feel that they are a part of the

organization and they are valued as employees, which will motivate the employees to

make decisions and take actions which are in organizations best interest.

CONCLUSION

20 | M a n a g e m e n t C o n t r o l S y s t e m s – S t a t e B a n k o f I n d i a

Page 21: Management Control Systems for State Bank Of India

The management of any organization must develop a control system tailored to its organization's

goals and resources. Effective control systems provide factual information that's useful, reliable,

valid, and consistent. Controls are applied where failure cannot be tolerated or where costs

cannot exceed a certain amount. The critical points include all the areas of an organization's

operations that directly affect the success of its key operations. In case of Bank’s which function

on the concept of Risk and Returns, having efficient control systems in place are extremely

important. By efficient we mean systems which deliver the desired results and are easy to

understand and implement and also ensures viable patterns of employee behavior in order to

achieve organizational objectives.

SBI has efficient control mechanisms in place that is effective and function harmoniously within

the banking processes, does not create any bottleneck operations and provide factual information

that's useful, reliable, valid, and consistent.

REFERENCES21 | M a n a g e m e n t C o n t r o l S y s t e m s – S t a t e B a n k o f I n d i a

Page 22: Management Control Systems for State Bank Of India

www.wikipedia.org

www.statebankofindia.com

www.moneycontrol.com

www.scribd.com

State Bank of India : Transforming a State Owned Giant – Harved Business case

study

www.sbiglobal.in

SBI annual report

Management Control Systems (Text Book)

22 | M a n a g e m e n t C o n t r o l S y s t e m s – S t a t e B a n k o f I n d i a