mahdi farmanian - jf.isca.ac.ir
TRANSCRIPT
11
Ab
str
acts
An Examination and Critique of Theory of Compliance from Wahhabism
Perspective Mahdi Farmanian
Associate professor, department of theological religions, University of Religions and Denomina-
tions (author in charge),
Ebrahim Kazemi
Researcher at Dar al-A'alam Institute,
Abstract
In criticizing imitation of the four religions, Wahhabism considers any imitation
of the Muftis as illegal, and believes that the imitation is obeying the words of
non-God and the Prophet, while it supports the theory of compliance. Wahhabis
consider compliance as the pleasant Taqlid (imitation), imitation as adopting the
words without arguments, and compliance as adopting the words with arguments.
They have considered the issue of compliance within the different types of obli-
gation of Mokalafs (one charged with a duty) and have proposed three types of
obligations: "ijtihad, compliance and imitation". In their view, the compliance has
a very wide circle and includes the majority of the people. The Wahhabis by talk-
ing about the issue of compliance, have narrowed the circle of ijtihad and imita-
tion and have almost put away the imitation and they deal with that as an obliga-
tion. The current study, in addition to explaining the Wahhabism perspective on
ijtihad and imitation, defines the theory of their compliance, and examines and
criticizes the arguments of Wahhabism on this issue.
Keywords
Ijtihad, Taqlid, compliance, Wahhabism.
148
��� ��
� �
��
��
���
���
��)
����
�10
0(
���
��
1398
وهابیت باعنظریه اتّ بررس� و نقد
*�'�ی + ����!����� �7� %�**
���� -.G�� v��r� ?� ,��7� ,7� �� ��G� �� i �����^ �� &��3� ?� ,��7� -��'�� E ��,� &H
� ��. � ���� �T��.� e��� �,( ��^ e�> ? :,T� .�� -T>�� +T6� -T6�S� ?� FTG7�iT N �� �ی ���,��{ ,�: .�� &�G� =�I> �� i "��G !� ,��7� ,�� F�2� & ,G e�> r(� �� ,��7� -G �� i �, �.� :��"» �)G "��1� e�> Vr �2�F«�.�ی ��� .-��I� &�H N �� �� FT(�� �� iT
-�I��� &3�]� L��]� !I>� LT��]� =TI> -T� ,��»�� E�TA�/�,T��7� iT « }�T4� ��"��: ,�� .�� E&�H �S� -G��IG "�6�� i "���I' ی��G�� �� !��� �6��:� ������ ���' .
� 6�7� � ,8� �� ,��7� �A�/� "�6�� Ei �� -��I� }�{ G &�G� F�4.� �� ,��7� "?�@"��: ,�� �3' +�� &H ?� ���4D� wG ?� - ,T�� .� "',T6� +�T� � ?� ,T.G ��TI/ +T6� �
i �� -6�S� E,��7� �A�/� wG �� ��G� �H& -2�� &�G &< -��I� +6� }�{ �� ,7��� ����G �<�.
������� � ��G� Ei �� E,��7� E�A�/�.
��6�� j6�� :10/8/1398 c�6r% j6�� :18/1/1399
* v��r� &6�� "#���� ���: v��r� " �' ������ )e��I� ",�I6��(. [email protected]
** !��f���� -I��� �#�� $%. [email protected]
���������� 1 �.��/0
U�VP ���� 6C.� � T#�� W ) �0�0100(� 6 R�#�1398
Feqh A Quarterly Scientific-Research Journal
Vol. 26, No. 4, Winter, 2019
) �����۱۴۸-۱۶۴(
۶۸۴۸۰ jf.2019 ۱۰٫۲۲۰۸۱ Doi:
149
��$�
� $D
7 ,07
�3A
��K� I
�! P"8
�
�����
F;TI� !T1� � ���,� &]�� &�1�I� -1� ی��G �.4> ��1�/� �',�? �6��< -G -/�� G-1� ����G F�2� G �� ��( ���< .�/ ?�� +6��G�G Z,�� H ��� -G - �/ -TG ����� -�ی ��� �D , ���ی�7�� �A�/�Z -G "��: �32�� -.G�� v��r� ,��7� G ��G� ��
-TG �� &H "��T: }�T4� �� iT �� tT8G E,TA�*� ?� ,��7� ی/ &���� �T� ��TK� -T3�h��� -�I��� ��1�I� . -T�(���% -T.G�� v��r� ,��7� ,7� -G -���? +6� �� ��G� -B�'�
-6�S� -G i �� -G ���� �G�: ��G� &'�9G E��� "��: -/�� i ���]� L�2�T�"� ,T�����G 4� ��7� �A�/� ?� t8G �� i �� v2-G ,� ?� �T(�G ",T< &T�G �5��� ���K
�:w 6�",< -�<�� -���? +6� �� -: � "�G�� E ��.6 &H !� ی�.�» g�4� ی�.� -G i ��� w�: ?� ی ��%�� «��� .C6�K "�G�� !�: +6�� ��G� �K.� &'�9G +�G i ��
���� ,6� �� 2� +6,2��K� !�: �dH ����Tی �?. ���& ��G "�T<� -T: ���5�< +�� � "��: i �� -G !�A3� t�@ی���2� ,.� E1 ��� .&��T�� TG ��T( wT�: �التقلیـد و ی �
�" احLامه و انواعه<� � "��: i �� !�A3� -G ی��� . �% �� -u�H�� ,6HE -T6�S� �T���GGf �� i f iی -���� c�6r% �� ��G� -2�� F��8� ����G ��G� &'�9G &���
��� ,��7� �3� .
1 .)#*5� 7B�%�
�3� ����G Ei �� !�A3� �.� =A� ی��G+6��GT�G Z�T�� ی� �TD ,��7� �A�/� =� ���,�G� ��7� �A�/� !�A3� -G, �T�G� "',T6� ?� iT � ����- G- �.�ی ��� �T� =6?���T% .
��� ���� �7�2� G- �.�ی � �� �A�/�) E��S�� +G�1414� E 3 :y133( � �� }�4TK��� ,A�*� c�� �6A���Gی ��= T]@� -GT� �.6�T< ! T/TI@� -T: �6G P- �.�ی
c�� E,�: ",6� ����G ی� ���,�) E�2�9^1413� E1E y342(E � {< ) E� {<1417� E5 :y51( E��:�< ) E��:�T<1419� E2y E205( +G� +�T1��� ) E+�T1��� +TG1413� E10y E108( +�T1� 9T��
1 .�§�8 �2 01;�,2� 0�*2 ��� �1�.2� � : ���� ��.
150
��� ��
� �
��
��
���
���
��)
����
�10
0(
���
��
1398
6� ���� � G �� L6�.�"��: &�G �# ,�� ..� -G -/�� GL6� ی� -;��� �� ",< �T3' &��� :-G &�2�K� �9� �� }�4K� �� �A�/� �� �6A� \ �.�ی ��T�� ی��G ���< -2�� �� c
��� ���< =]@. »,��7� «-G �2 �� �T�� &��' �G ,� ���' V+�(�,��EP (�.�ی �T� +TG�1404� E5y E19( Z
) E��TS�� +G�1414� E3 :y366( FT1� E-T7� }�4TK� �� T:��T�� -TG &ی�� ,T��7� �� ,TA�*�,�6�': »2� �,��I� F1.2� �� ,��7�2�� + ی����- �.�7�«Z -G 6� �� �&H �# ' ": F1� -
���� -G ,��I� G &I�� ����: 1(1379� E1y E7��7�T:�T�� "�� ) E�T��, ی�7�G -E,< �? ی
-��I�2(.
2 .���� � ��*8I� �� �+�� ��=���
~ � -G &�G� �� ,�,7�.� =�> +G� -�1�� +G� �� ��� w�: =A� ��,> �6���� ):/��� G ,6G E���� ��( ����� =A� -G ��� w�: -G =�7�I� -. �A�/� ,�: F1�
-G ,��7� ,�: ��� �I��: � +TG�1416�1�T>1411� E2 :y137-138( Z) E-T���G -/ )+G� E=ی � /96
y248(Z �� �� ����K w�: U�� �6���� -: =2T� ��T< ?� ,T6G E���,T� �� ��� ,�: ��. � ,���G e�s� � ?� 6)G+ �G E?G � E�2y E52( .+G� F;> � 3� G =�> ,��7� +�G &,<
�� =2T� ?� F�/ ,��7� -.G�� -1;� ?� ,T6�' :T��7� T1�� -T1� 96T/ �� =2T� ?� FT�/ ,�� -G �I: �'� �� Z,���� v � � ?� ,T<G -�T<�� -T.G�� -T1;� ?� ,T��7� �TG ���K� E�2A/�� �� ,��7� � ?� F�2� -B -G =���% =2� � &�B ,6�#G �'� b��: � -TG E��� -1� ?� �� ��Tی ��� FT�/ �T� �T#� bی,T�1A� *: ?� �� ��� +6� -: =�6�'Z FT�/ �T'� +6��GT�G
+�1� ��TI� �� ,T��7� � ?� -T��' �T�:E �� !T*�� ,�TI%��ی T: FTT�2� �T'� �T�� F�/ �� )% Eی��� � ��12� �G �:�,���I�� .��AT6� �T6, ی � +�T�B �� ��T( "'
�� &�G ,�: :�/ -: �I:Z,�: ,��7� ��< R6 ?� ,6G E��� F -.G�� -1;� ?� ,��7� ��,T��,� ��T� RT6 �� �T58�� �� ��T( ,���G =2� ?� ,6G ی��� +��B -]�G E��� " �<�
)+G� E=�>1411� E2 :y138(. }�4� �f�s� ?� �]6 T�� +T6� ",<-TG �� ,T��7� �T�G� T6H -T: � �T]�� ��:��{
151
��$�
� $D
7 ,07
�3A
��K� I
�! P"8
�
�� �:,. -]�6� [�� �G-G &�G� ��{",T�� �]�� F: E,�T<G ,�T��% ,T6G ی,T@ -TB T�-���6r% �� ,��7� ,� 6% &�,G ,��,��3' ,6G w��/ �� b :L2�( ?��/ ��G� "',6� ?�
-G ,��7� "',6� �� �58���T� ��� �I�� �� �.�ی � -�7� ,A�*� R6 ی� ,T���� ?�*�T�: ,T��7� 9���& A�, .w( -TG,�& �6#�ی 1�TI� ۀT�� ی��TG �� ,T��7� �T�G� �T�^ ?�
-�I��,� 96/ &�,A�*� E�T�� ��� ,T8� �� ,T��7� Y�T6�� -T]�G1 FT�� -Tu�H ?� &T�G ��T�"��: "��� ���> E,�� ���.
&��T� �� ,T��7� VgT�4� V�]�� �3' ,6G �,�G� � ",T6� �T�G� V&T'�9G�1 ?� ��T<<+�� E�,� +6� ,��� ,18� +G ��� w��2�, � . � �T]�� ,T��7�",T�� �� ��T( -T]�G
,1@� ,�7� +G F �@ )+G� w��2�, �»w«�G E y E�107( C2TK L�T� E��T� EwT�: ,T�7� �e�� ��� -�I �;1ۀ�<�� -.G�� )&1� :y96( +6�+�� ,18� +G �-G w��2�, �T d� ��< �
�� ,�: 7� �� ���[T��� �T�� "��Tی ��7�T, �? ی )�� �TK( ��< -G �58�� ,��L�� E��� Ew�: 1ۀ;� C2K ���� �� -.G��.
+�� E&H �G " ��+G �� �T d� �� vT�4� +T6� ���T: 9T�� +�1��� &T�G� -T: ,T�:,��TI�� ,��7� Vg�4� V�]�� �,K�� .�� � -T: ��T� �T5�< ی��TG ,T��7� ,T6�' -TG ��T>
I�� !]@� �(�<v/� E� -G -: ی,A�*� ی��G -G 6 ������ F�2� g�D ��� �T> �-��I� -�I���� �: \ ���� ����7� V+�TI���TG ,Tی ���T1�TG + �T/ E, .+G vT/��T�� 96ی ��
�� "����7� i�T,ی �:�, :- >�� ��� �� ��< 1�� v�4� -G �6#�ی �> �� ,�����: F1� &�,G ���' a�% �� �� � � ��6? Z, =6��� ,��7� i�� :yT( ,��7� !� ,��7� .
�.� +6� -G !� ,��7� � L�]� -: ��T�: ,��7� ���.� ,A�*� v�r� ?� i�T� +T6� -T: ,��� !��@ �7�4� E,��7� .-��TI� �T� �� L�]� ��< 9�� y( ,��7� ��T, �? �� �ی �� ��
�: ,��7� -��1426��1�A�*�, )+G E+,ی /,�' :y688 695( .�G� & 96T/ �� ,T��7� i�� +6�-�I��� ,�� .+G �� ی �6#�ی/ �� +�1��6, � ��G.- )4 �7��, �? �;1ۀ '�6, � � &I�� ��
,��7� �� ��< �58�� !�� R6 -G E) E�1�1413� E10 :y1080(.
1. g�D -��I� +6� �� �6� ,8� ?� ���� -G Z��� ,��7� &��: �� � ��TK -T1� ی��G �� ,��7� "?/� ��G� �#6��� ���" �ی �., � �[��" ��A ��Gی �," &�� +6� �� �D ~>��� �� 6 ���.
152
��� ��
� �
��
��
���
���
��)
����
�10
0(
���
��
1398
-]�6� �G !�� ,�< �I�� ,��7� Vg�4� V�]�� ��G� ��� �4�7�< !�: -G ����� E . �� !� ,��7�-G ��� "��: &�G ����(� ����� ?� � � ��< V,��7� � �S� E,TA�*� ?� ��
-G i N �� �1� �1< ��8� � �.����� ���> i ��� ,��7� VL6 . i �T���S ی �7��, � g {-��I� �� �� L�]� V,��7� ی� ��� -�, ��� ��G iی ���! .�? �*�A,ی /,�'�7�� i�� +6�/ !��� ��6? Z��� -.�/A� &��� -.��1� ,���,� �� F�2� = � ,�����,T��: i N � . �4�7�T<
�� &�G +��u1� ���� &��(��� �9�� '���-�7� E�TA�*� ?� ,T, :�, �7��,ی :- ��> ���(���,TG ?� ,��7� i�� +6� -: ��� ,��7� �� �58�� &1� 6 +�.� &�T> ی� �T�� !�TAB
) E�4�7�<1415� E7 :y307(. ��I-�,�ی � ! ��,� 96/ &�1�I� ۀ�ی ���G �� ,��7� &�H -: ��� +6� ��G ,��
"��: &�G ,��7� ���@ �� �� �2 � FK� F�� -u�H ?� ,��7� Y�6�� E+6��G�G Z,�� &T�G ��T�"��: �� ��� ,8� E,�� ��< .,18� +G , ���� "��: &�G ��� � �� w��2� ���? � �
w�: ?� -: =��I� ,�7�"',6� G L2�� ���2� E��� �'� �� Z=�<G -�<�,��ی ��1 �� E=�<G -�<�� ���2� +6� ,�7� �#6� ���K ��G =������)w��2�, � +G�»L2�«�G E T� :y40( .
�: ?� ���2� � -: ��� ����K �� A�� ,��7� ��.6 v�4� +6� =�<G -�<�,� ��� w-G �� � �#6� &�? �� A�� ,��7� V��^ �� ��� 96/ �� �D ی����T� �� �� �TD
�I�� 96/ ,��7� E=�<G -�<�� ��� w�: ?� ���2� -: .+G !�: E&H �G " �� +�T1����� 9�� ,����,�< ���#G ���> �,� +6� V! � .+G +G� !�: �,�G� +�1��� �� ,T��7� Y�TG�� =�>
�� ,�6�� &�G ,�: .�� � ���.� =�� ,I6��-G F�2� G A�� -: ��� � �� ��� �'� ,6H�� ",��� ,��7� E,<G F�2� & ,G �T�� 96T/ �/@ &�? �� A�� ,��7� E+6��G�G Z��<
+6� ,��: ,��7� ,�����G ���? �� �� !��� !�1� -: �I�� -��' )+G E+�1���1413� E11 :y84( .�� &�G ی �6#�ی/ � � :- ی ��r� �� ,A�*� ,�: ��( v�r� !�� ?� ����ی )�� H
�1� E��� "��: ��6�� F�� J�,5� ,���� �T�� v�r� !�� V,�7� 9�� � ��6? Z,<G =�� g { +6��G�G 6ۀH» �r2� �F�� �� ��� 2�� ���� �: �&V� V� �: �&� �1���.�� �f �=� �� �« )F8�: 43( �1� ��T� ��� ,T����
F�� -: �5�< -G ,�7� �I�� =��-G 1<�� � �: -./��� E� �-G Z, +�1� i�T/� F�2� =2� &H -G �I�� 96/ �� �D ~>��� �� 9/)+G +�1���� E26 :y415( . +�� ?� �#6� ,�<
153
��$�
� $D
7 ,07
�3A
��K� I
�! P"8
�
+G �T�� -�TI��� 96T/ ���� � �� �� ,��7� � -: ��� +6� +�1��� :1. -T: ی,T�7� ی��TG ,<G -�<�,� �� !]@� �(�< V��,> ,<G ���@ �TG FT�2� T6 -T: ,T<G -�T<�,� =T]
�� +6� �� v/� � �G ,��7� E���K ��< .2. -d�@ -: ی,A�*� ی��G � ی��TG ی��ی �� V��,> -: ,�� �� �� -T: ,T<G -�<�,� �� ����S� +T6� �� E���TK ی,TA�*� ?� ,T����,TT�: ,T��7� �T#6� )&T1� :y457( .-�3' ���TTK � �T� -G �� �TD ����TT� ?� ",T< �1TT<
�� ��G�G Z,� �+< � G E+6 7� Y�6�� �,� � +6� &,< ���� 9�� ��G� "',6� �� ,��c .: �f � R6 �� �58�� �� ,��7� &�H�1� v�r� ,A�*� �T��d ,���� ,T��7� +�T1� ��
�� 96/ �� �D ����� �� �1<,�.
3 .�+�� ��RA �� "�C�� ���KA
»i N �V� «-TG �2 �� %V�T �.�ی %��T ی �� &��:��T� �2T� T6 ��T< V��� � �T�� &,T< ) E1376/���ی� E3 :y1189+G� Z EP��1404� E1 :y362 EvT�/�G� Z1408 :y48( یT�.� E+6��GT�G Z
� V��:�� �� �2 �� i N .:��&G �#6� �5�< ?� �5�< V�& :�� ���& �1& %�� ی �� �R6 -7� e�K� =�� }�4K �.�ی �! �� i N � ���� yT( یT�.� RT6 .� یT�.� V!�� ��% ��� &H�> ?� ی ��& %1� Ei N �9 y( ی�.� ��� E&H 9یT�B &1�
-: ��� ��G� -G � &��#6� ��� -���' �:6� -G �� i N �"��]� &�G �.� + ,�� . �T�G� �� i N �"��G !� ,��7� =�I> � -G �� &H ی�.�»r(� FT�2� TG "��1� e�> «&T�G "��T: �T��)�.��G E�1 T� :y101�TG E�T� � Z T� :y35+TG� Z E� 2�,T �1414� E2 :y143 E� {T< Z1412� E2 :y859 Z
+G� E=�>1411� E2 :y170 Eی��< Z1416 :y31( . �� ��G� ی1�� &���� Y�G�� �� i N � ��: =�I7� -��� � -G &���:
1 ."��: "�<� v�4� +6� -G ��@��K �(�G ی��� i N �� -: ,����� �A�/� ,��7� +�G . w�: ��G -6�S�& �� التقلید و احLامه>��ی � +6� V&�;> �(�G ?� �� e�> +6� ,�:) Eی��<
1416 :y33( .�� -6�S� +6� &�;> ?� ��: "�<� �� 2� +6,2��K� -G &��� . ��( "',6� �� 2�+6� �� �� 96T/ E�6� �TD �� 9T/ ,��7� -: ��� "��: &�G -��' �TG 9T�� �TA�/� �TI
�I�� v/� �I:�� .�� )�� � ی�T�� E�T�� v/� !?f !��� 1ۀ� �G -u�H ,6�'
154
��� ��
� �
��
��
���
���
��)
����
�10
0(
���
��
1398
-G ��� ,��7� �A�/� +�G ی��� -: ��� i N �� !�)�G E�� 2� � E�2 :y167( . �� ��� F;> ی ",�T��� �TA�/� ۀT/�� -G �� E,���� ��1�� -: ,��I� ��I: !��� +�G ,T@ T� ,��ی �
�� ,���,� \ ���� Y�> �2 E,��� ����� �� !]@� F6f� ,����� .�� � " �T' +6� ,6�'�1� "�� ,T6G +6��GT�G Z,T���,� =T� \ ���� ��,> ,��: ,��7� ��� !��� ,��1� ,�����
���� !� i N �� -: ,��: w���� �� ���� .,18� ,�� �� 9�� �� � ���@ -: ��I: ,I6��7� g�4�"��� � I� � -G �� ,�� -�3' ´ �� E,�� �T� ی��TG �TA�/� w�/ -: ��I: ,��
"��� � I� � -G �� �5�< -�3' ´ �� E,�� -T.�/ +�TG �� -T: ��� +6� � �S� -]�G E,��"�AG =�� ?� -]�G E,A�*� -� ,��I� F�/ -� -: ,��I� ��I: F�� ����� +6� -: ,���ی ��
�� ",��� i N �� <,�� .�� -���� � �� -� ����� +6� -: ,�� �� -� ,��: ,��7� ,����� ,T����� ��� i N �� &�H 3ۀ�h -]�G E,��: �A�/�)�G E�� � � :y15(.
�� -T: ی��,7� �� -G �5�< �� -: ��� +6� ����� +6� 2ۀ�� wT�: ?� ,T6G ,T������ -: ��� ,� �,( e�> &1� +6� ,�: ی ��6,�� ��� %�:»���.V � �� T�2V� �e V9T� � �� �� � � �] �+TV� �=
�G �� �] V 2 � �� V-V � �� �+V� ���.V � ��� �f � �= �� V ��> ۗ ��� �r�� �� �� �: �& �� «)�����: 3( »��H �� � �: �" �rT���� �e� �� ��2� �= �A�� �� � �:�� �A��� ��� �-� � �� �=« )��@ :7( �I:�� +6��G�G Z-G �6���� -: ��� &�� H E���,� �� -2��
- ��� ,6G � &H ?� ی�,�: e9� .��� h�3ۀ � � �6+ ��K�� i N � ��TG �T5�< �'� ��< � &��� -:- ��� E�<�,� 9�� �� i N � �� e9�� �#6� , �� �ی�3ۀ � �7��h ,�: ��< ) E�� �
�G � :y15( . ���: �� ��( ���� +6� �� �� 2� �,/ ��G� ?��� ,�: +T6� �� �� ��G� �� a�?�� ���� �:, .�� � =�TI� L�T� ~GT� -T7� �� =T� ",T�7� �� =T� +� ,I6��E
,��I� �3�� ���7��� �� A�� &�H -: ��G� ��(�GE +TG ,T1@� ,T�7� !T]@� �� �� ,��I� F �@) E� �:f E&3���2012! :y115(.
�" ���ۀ ��#6. 2<� &�G� ?� -G " �� �ی6#/E��� ,��7� �A�/� &�� ی��� -: i "��]� �: a�?�� �A� �� ,��7� A�� ,��"� ,�� .eH ٰNO�,T � +G &1��� �T�� FT;> j�T<
G G ,�: �,�% ��� ,A�*� e�> F6f� -G ,6G L�]�- ��� gT���� T6 EFT�2� &H &�� H�� ,A�*� g���� �'� Zی L2�� 6 ��< � V,T��7� E,T< ,TA�*� �S��1� w�TI8� ��T<
)eH j�< E&1��T�1404 :y53( .eH +�T� +6� -G j�T< iT N �� �T d� �,TK�� �@��TK �T��
155
��$�
� $D
7 ,07
�3A
��K� I
�! P"8
�
�� +�� ���K �� A�� �� ,��7� Ee@ ��� ��� -�I��� 96/ EF�2� -G +���� .
+G � �� A�� �� ,��7� +�1��� ��� -�I��� 96/ ����: 1 .�,� �� !]@� �(�< ��,> -: ��� ,�7��� . 2 .-��I� ��� �ی ���& �*�A,ی :- ��,T� \ ���� �K�� 6 �A�/� .+G ~TD�� +�T1���
�G�/ �: &�G �� ,��7� Vی?��/ ~D�� ��� "� . ��,T> -T: ��T� ��T< ی��G ,��7� "��� ���ی ��Gی ی �D ی :- ���ی,A�*� ی��G v/� E���,� �� !]@� �(�<
��� 96/ E���,� \ ���� �K�� .^�� �>G �#6� ~D�� � E~D�� � +6� ?� �� �� -: ,-G +G �S� -G ,��7� ~D��� ?� +�1��� �1� �1< ,� � :e � : Z�� �D ����� ��^ �� &�,A�*�
! � : ��,T> T�� E,T���� �(�T< !]@� 2ۀ�� -G ,A�*� -� ,��I� ��� -������ی :- ,���,� \ ���� )+G E+�1���1426 :y684(.
G�H�G����G -B�' �<r' -u� -G ��G� ی" � ��16#/ �@��K �TA�/� +�G �� i N �"��,� ���> ,��7� "��]� +�� � �� &H ,�� E,�� "��� -: ���K3� G ,��E �T�� +< � ���:
�� !��� ?� �� �' &�H -:�� !T� -3�h -T: ,T��G � &T<��T�� iT N � . TG &T�H +�T�u1�� ,8� T��7� Y�T6�� &��:FT�� �� !��T� ?� ی��TIG E, "��� ���T> iT N �� Z,T�� +T6�?� TG ی �
���r� ,< "��� -: ��8�D�� ۀ./��� ����� ,< ,��7� ?� -: wT�: -G -: �1�7�I�",< "��� ��� E ���' ,���( ی����G g� � -u�HZ�A�/� -� ��� i �� E �TA�/� ��T6?
��-G �5�< �� -: ���� ���,7� -G ? ��@�� �1� ����-TG , -T�@�� ی� T��G �� ��T( -T: ,�G �� Z,��,G ,A�*�G i �� G -A/��� �� )]�- ��� ��< ��@� ,T�: iT �, ���ی �����
4� �?� �� ,��7� ?� �� ��( �: F1� F�2� gG, .
4 ."�C�� a��V' �+ �+�� N�Y�
1 .4. ���� 0� m�D ^*<
� ی v � ,��7� ?� ��^ =A� � &�� H��� ",< i �� -G ��G . �T6��TG �(�G�T�.� +ی ",< F;> � 3� ,��7� V�@�4K� ی�.� !��� +�G �� ,��7� ,�� ."��: &T�G &�H -T: ,T��
156
��� ��
� �
��
��
���
���
��)
����
�10
0(
���
��
1398
��� ",< ",��� �#6� ��< ?� -����:��: Vی ��ۀ ���! %�� +�G �� ,��7� �6��. �.�ی F�� -G ��� i�/� �� �.� +6� -G ,��7� ,A�*� =��FT�� ?� ,A�*� ��6? Z�I�� C�8K
-G =�� �� �1< � � J 4�� T�.� +6� -G ,��7� +6��G�G Z��� F{G &H �G ,��7� ی6+ �.�� =TI> +T6� ?� �T#6� V,TA�*� ی��TG ,TA�*� E��T� ی��TG ��T� e�> ��G ,���( !��@
��G ,���( .-G ,��7� �� ,T�7� -T: ی,TA�*� e�> -G i�/� -: �@�4K� یۀ �.�T2�� ?� TA�I�� "'H ,A�*�E ��� ,��7� ۀ���� L6�.� ?� � 3�� ���: .� -TG !��T� i�T/� �T�6A
� ��% !�:�9 /� -G i�/�-G ,A�*� -G ��� i�/� 6 i1 v � "��1� V+�<��»��*@ « »F�2� «�1� w�I8� ,��7� &H ۀT2�� eT �� �TI�� "T'H &T�H 7�, �? ��2ۀ� -B�' Z,��<��1 ��'�. �� ,��7� ��� �� �� ,A�*� -G ��� i�/� -B�'� ,�6�'E �T6���T�.� +T6ی
�TI��� G�+ ��ۀ ���! �) E�@�T��1418� E4 :y533 Eی,T�H Z1404� E4 :y221+G� Z EvT/@1427 E
�2 :y1248 E��/�/ Z1403 :y64 Eی��< Z1426 :y28( . -G �� ,��7� -: ��� ��I: "',6� �#6� e�> T6 i N �)T: �TI: ?� e�T> rT- �.�ی ��
"��: L6�.� E�I�� �*@ a2�> ,��)+G E+�1���1426 :y683( . L6�.� G gG4� L6�.� +6��� ",��� -����:��: Vی ��ۀ ���! ��� :- %�� +�G �� �6�� ��< . +T6� V&�;T> -T�1/ ?�
&�G� Ee�> ,�� .F;> &�H -G &�,A�*� ,�� !,� F�2� �.� e�1�� E&�2�> ��*@ ,��7� VL6�� -G ,��7� E,A�*� ?� ��� ��< Vی ��% ,��< �� �1< � � . ��( e�> +6� F�2� &�H
+6� �� "��: &�G -��' F�� ?� ,A�*� -: ,�� -G =�� �T1� �1< � � .+G ef,�T�� �� +�T1���F�� ?� �� ,A�*� e�> ��( ی��H -: ���[��" G�A�*� -: ��� "��: &,ی wI@ =��
��(�1� E��� "��: ��6�� ��( v�r� !�� ?� �� F�� &��� 9�� � V��( ��6? Z�I��� =�� 6H gۀ { +6��G�G ��� v�r� !�� ?� ,��7�» �r2� �F�� �� ��� 2�� ���� �: �&V� V� �: �&� �1���.�� �f �=� �� � « ��T�
�1� ��� F�� -: �5�< -G ,���� -G ,�: -./��� E��� ,��7� �I�� =�� +�1� FT�2� �I���ی /96 �D ~>��� �� 9/ ,��7�) E�1�1413� E11 :y84(.
-G e�> � +6� +�G -: ����(� E��� ",�H ��/ �T�� ,��7� L6�.� Y�8� �� . e�T>��( L6�.� G e �E � �T�% Ve�T> ,T��1� �� ,A�*� e�> !�T:�9 iT1/� -G8TK e�T>
-G �*@ �� �1< � H�. -G +�1� e�> EF�2� L6�.� �� F(�� �� ,A�*� -G ��� i�/�
157
��$�
� $D
7 ,07
�3A
��K� I
�! P"8
�
V,��7� �1� !��� -�� +�G �� �6�� �� ,T��7� ?� -T: �T36�.� -TG -T/�� TG ! � " �T' �� Z,�"��: -G -�I��,� �*@ �� ,A�*� e�> E,�� +�1� V,T��7� LT6�.� �� �� ,A�*� e�> EF�2�
"��: FT(�� !��� ۀ�� +�G �� �6�� ,T�� ) E�T1�1426 :y683( .+T6� ۀT*��� �]T<H ���T(� L6�.� V�#��#B»,��7� «��� .�G� ,�> G �� ,��7� �»0T*@�G «)&T1�( "��: &T�G ,T�� .
> -: ,��I� +6� &�G �,K�� &�H�� Z�T�� FT�2� 0T*@�G ,A�*� e� �2T@ �T#6� -T:F�� ی1�� ,�> G �� ,��7� ���»0*@ V��^ +�« ) Eی��<1426 :y528( "��: L6�.� ,�� . ���T�e�s� &�H ��� F�2� �*@ ?� &��]� .&�� ,�> +6� ��*@ Y,��� ,TA�*� e�> V+�<�,�
�I��. � L6�.� ۀ*���FT�� E,T��7� ?� �T�G =�� FT�� Y�T1d �T�� ,TA�*� V&�� � =�� V&�� �
Z��� � ?� ,��7� ���@ E,A�*� +G� ��@ � �� ,T��7� E�T�G� 6ۀ�S� ��(�G 9�� -�1����: &�G i����� ". �?� �� ,��7� ?� EFT{G 6 g@ -G E�2f� �A/ -TG E=T]@ �TA/
��� "��: =�I7� i �����^ 6 i ��� .� ��% ?� ,��7�9 F�� i �T�� gT@ Ei1/��� "��1< v/� -TG T1�� ?� ��� ,��7� �� Z��< �N �h FT�2� vT/� &T�H Ve�T> &��TG
E�TTI�� �TT�� 96TT/ -TT]�G ) E-TT�1�� +TTG�1416E �20 :y17 Eی��TT< Z1431� E2 :y982( . ef,�TT��+G� �T�� �T�G� e�T> ��(�TG 9�� -��I� +6� �� -�1�� .+G� -TB�' TA/ �� 9T�� -T�1�� �
E��� -�3' +�� ,��7� L�.��� e�> ��G� ,��1� "��]� �>� ��*@ ?� �� ,A�*����� "��� =]@ =2� ?� ,��7� ?��/ -G �6A�.
2 .4. )�� )#*5� m�`"�C�� p�` �
�T�� "��T: ��( &H ی�2 �@�4K� ی�.� +�G i N �� -��I� �� ��G� .&T1� -T��' �@�4K� ی�.� E,< &�G -:i N �� �� �� y( ی! �.�ی ��.� -G &�����T: =�I7� .
-G G ��G� ی��'�: ",�H�G y( ی�.� � d� �,K��, ��T�� +6ی ��2ۀ �.�ی �! ��4G -: ������ CD� a�� . �T�G� یT1�� ef,�T�� ,T�B -TG �,T� +6� � d� ی��G
�� ����� ��< .,18� !�: -G �,�G� +G �� ���T�� w��2�, � -T: ��T<-��TI� �� iT N �ی ��"��: &�G ( -:&H�> �� ,� �, ��� &H -G =6�:�:��� "� .ی �6H» � ��� V ���.V � � 6 � V �8 �] �=
158
��� ��
� �
��
��
���
���
��)
����
�10
0(
���
��
1398
� �O� «)eH &��1� :31( E» � ��.�2 �"��.V � �� � �] �& �,�� �A�� �= «)����� :158( » � �6 �̂ �~V � � � � V �� ��� V �V� �s �1� 2� VF� �+ «)�I� :
115( �� �� &�G ��( ی�,� F�2� ,�: )+G� �G Ew��2�, � � :y7( . 6ۀH E�,� +6� �G ! � ,�<» �2V� �e V9� � �� �� ���.V � �� � � �] �G �� �+V� �= �] �f � �= V 2 � �� V-TV � �� �+TV� ���.V � ��� T��TV ��> ۗ ��� �rT�� T �� �� �: �& ��« )���T�� :3(
��� .-G �� -6H +6� �� 2� ��� "��: �:� F�2� &���� ) E�� 2�1427� E1 :y53(. " �� +6� �G� �6H -G E�6H6ۀH ,���Y 63 6#�ی ��� E���T�� 108 ELT��6 38 E"�T7G 53 eH &��T1�
18 9�� ��?��� ",< ef,���. �3' ,6G ��G� -2�� +�� ,7� ��:
�f � ۀ��I� � d� ی��G ��G� -: ��6H !1�i N �� "��: &�G !T� ی�.� �G E,��iT N �� ��� �2f���1� , �H &���A ( ی�.� �� ��-G y ���' �:.
���d ی�.�i N � �6H +6�Vg�4� E %�� ی ��� ��� <��6- ��� �K( ی�.� �G -: ی� ?�i N �� G -�<�� �2f� ��< -�3' �'� ���,� ��/ E,< +6� ?� ����i N �� e�T> +���6r% E
��G ,���( F�2� & ,G F6 �� E��� F�2� G "��1� 6#�ی� .
5 ."�C�� ���KA ��A
6 � ,< "��� -: ��8�D�� G-TG ,T��7� �A�/� �� ��G� ��] �T#6� ?� 96T1�� ی�T8�"��G v��r� "��T: F(�� +6� �� �����ی ��T� -T: ,T7G- ��� ���ی �,T� . &T�H "�TG��
� &��T� "��TG =2T� -T: �5�<�T� ���� �� \ ��T� -T3�h ,T�6�' c� �T�� �TA�/�"�AG ��� -: �I:�� � ,6G ���,� �� -2�� -G ی���@ -./��� &��� ���,�7��, �ی �? ��=
,�: .i �� F�� !�� " �' ���5�< -: ,� ,�7� -� ,A�*� -� ,��I� �6�E "�TAG -]�G ی�,���� �1�� ~G�� -G �21/� �(�< ,���� =�� ?�E ,���,� \ ���� &��� �� . " �T' +T6�
�� ����,� ,���� -���< -2�� ?� -: ��(�< GE �1�7�I� ����Th -G i�/� ��� w�: -G�: F1� 3�:�,� .�G� "',6� +6� -T1� +�TG ��- �',6^ "�T�� v2 ?ی �3���� -: �
� ^��" >,"% E���, �H�3�� v�A/ &�ی � -T: ���� �T% �� ���ی �TIG �T3�� یT��� -���� ,6H.
159
��$�
� $D
7 ,07
�3A
��K� I
�! P"8
�
1 .5. qJ� � mB#� ^�O ���U
��� ��� =�I� -u�H�6� � ��H�> ~G�� -G i�/� ��� �� �TD RT6 +T6� ��� �!��� �� �� "��1< -: ��< �;�<H ی��� �� T�� Z,<G -�<�� ��( �A7� ~G�� ?� ���:
��K �� �1]@ ,����G ~G�� -G i�/� G ��< �� -: ��� �>�,5� �� t8G F8� &�( 6 ��3]� �� &��#6� &H gG4�e�@ ��( �G �� &�H P��� e� +�T1� -TG Z,�:
T�1: TG �TI:�� �T�� ",T< v � i �� �A/��T� -T: �T1�� +6� �� �T�'-G � V��TK�� ,�: ��5� EF�2� �(�< �� Z,��G !]@� -G ,�����2@ -GT��� �6� � �6H -:
-G -T: ,���� ��/ -2�� &�� �� ��� ��� VF1*� [�.�� LT�]� &T�H �(�T< ��TK ,T����� �� T3� ��T� ��T< TG ~T>��� +6� �� ��G ,����� !]@� -G &,��� -G ��>
�<�� .� A�� ��'H -2�� +6� -G ��� -: ��� +6� ���� ��� ��� G ��< +6� -: �>��T�� vT/�� �(�T< +T6� -: ���� -2�� -G �21/� �(�< ��< +6� �� Z���,� V+��6
��G ,����� �.>� !]@� -G ��� &H . -TG �T.>� !T]@� �(�T< -: ��� F�2� &�,G +6�<=]8� -G��� ��T5��� Y�AG -: ��� +6ی � �� -G53� �(���V ��2ۀ ���� ?�� \ ��
���,� �� \ ���� �(�< +6� V&��� E���� =�� ?� .
2 .5. �%B N� c�V� ���� ��o
V�#6� v��Hi N �� � v��r� 6ۀ�S� ��{ v � -: ��� +6�F� �� ,��7� wG �� ��� ��< .-G�D F�� -.�/ -G ��G� -: ی� �����A�� ��IG E"��: ��� FT�� ��T6? Z��� T� ��
��� �A7� v�r� �AB ی���� ��( v��rT� +T6� ?� �]6 ?� ی ��% -G !9�� !��� -: ,T��i �� -��I� ��� � ��G� &,�H �� ی : G -:E -T.G�� v��rT� +T6� ,T< ,T���( v �
-G F�� -.G�� v��r� ?� �I: ,� �G ��: ��: ,�]� ,��7� ���Z &1� TG ��T 2� -T: ��{7���,18� ?� � �� w��2�, � +G �' ����/ � ?� ��3�� �� +� ,6=�TI� � �TG !,T7� Z
,T18� -B�' Z=�I�� � �r� ��� ,�7� 9�� -7� �� +� ��6? w��2�,T � +TG ی,T��7� ��T(�� �<�,� -�G�@ v�r� ?� C�8K � �3' !�T: -: =�I� ,�7� +� ���? +TG ,T1@�
160
��� ��
� �
��
��
���
���
��)
����
�10
0(
���
��
1398
Z,< � +� !�: L2�� F �@ +6��G�G ��G� i N �� -2�� �(�< V�6���� -: ��I: �G ��T���� ���T�^ E, "��T: vT/� E&�,TA�*� ?� -TG �T6������ h�T3ۀ �:"��� ���T> Z�TT��
���2@ ,��7� -:Z -G i1/� ��� ",< -���6r% 1�� +�G ) E����>1393 :y19( .-TG ,��7� &������ Z��� &3�]� L��]� -G &,��� �� �6��:� ��� E�� �TD wTG ?� TA�� �� ,��7� &�H
-�I��� ����� �<�' V&���( ,��1� ,�� )+G E+�1���1413� E26 :y415(.
3 .5. ��*8I� �8��V= ��%�
��� �6��/���� 1�� �A�/� ��8� �G ! �� ���T' ����Tی ��G ��,T> �TA�/� �,T7B,�: �,�% !��� �1�� -.�/E % ی��T��G ��T1� -7� +6� �66�% �,T��T� ,T�: . -T: �T�1�
��G� =: v � ",< &H v]��� &�� ��� &��� ",T< �TA�/� iT �� -��TI� -.T��� E��� . v�T�H -T�1/ ?�iT N �T6 % ?� �T]6��T,�ی ���: EiT N �� +�T<�r' �T�� �TA�/�E
-G ی��{ -3�h -: !��� ����G -: < &i N �� ,T������ �TA�/� -TG ی?T�� �#6� E��� ",< �<�� -G E��< �� ���� �',�? �� �� ��( -G �58�� e1�� ,���( ��/� ��( V��6�
��: ." �� 9�� +6� -G�D �G �TG N��� �TdH ET1�� �TA�/� "#6/ -G &�? ی� T�� �� 9T������ �{���� .��� -: ��� +6� &Hi N �� �� ,���� ��T< ,T<G )T3��� �GP ���ی
��G E,<G -�<�� F61� -: �� -B V=�� -i N �� ��� ,���( !*��.
�@8A ی�=
F�2� G ��^ e�> r(� ی�.� -G i ��E ,T��7� �T3� �G��G �� &�G� -: ��� ��;I� ?� �]6"��: }�4� -.G�� v��r� ?� ,�� . ,T���� �� iT �� �;���� &�1�I� ?� ی��IG ,�,7�.� &�H
6���� ��@ F�2� ,A�*� ?� ,6G ,����G �� a6�� ����,� ��T� wT�: -G &<��("��: -./���E ,��: ی ��% ��� w�: ?� .�GF�� -.�/ ��( �� ,��7� ��G� E���
,���,� �6H �6� � ~G�� ?� ���{� ��� -: ����� ی��G A��E -�TI��, ��TGی /96 ���"�AG i�{� -: !��� �#6� ,���� =�� ?� U,��� �E TKی � ,T��7� ?�T*�"��T]� �� ,T��
161
��$�
� $D
7 ,07
�3A
��K� I
�! P"8
�
-�I��� i �� �� " �' +6� -3�h ,�� �1�7�TI� ��T( ,6G !��� ,�,7�.� �T6H ´��T� -TG,� �G �6� � ."��1T< ��T� -TG ��T� i�T/� �� v�rT� �� ,A�*� -G i�/� &�H ,��
��^��: �7�� i ���" �,� .<� =A� -G ����G ��G� F1� +6� F�2� یT�.� ?� " �T' +6� " �����G ,��7 ���' ���,T� ���,T�B J�T� ��G� i �� G -.G�� v��r� "#� �� ,��7� -: . ��
�� i �� -6�S� ,7� v��H -G &��� <� �6�-: ��: "� TG -.�/ ��- ���� eT ��: �f � v T� G �6� � �6H -G ��I�� �� i�/��� C�8TK ���T�� !,T� U,�� "�AG �T6A�
��]@� � ,K -G �*�� ,T< ,T���( !�T�� �7�7@ G �6�-T: -Tu�H Z +�TG �� "? �T���T�A/ �T� ",�ی TG- �ی '� "� ��T� ���T' . -T.�/ �� ,T��7� ��T{ v T� -T]�6� ! �
F�� &���/ ",< ��� F�� -.�/ ��( ����' �� ����T�� "��T: �6�� . !�T� v�T�Hr'��:R� ی�� ?� &H ��{ �A�/� +�<� R� ,���( -.�/ ������G� .
162
��� ��
� �
��
��
���
���
��)
����
�10
0(
���
��
1398
���%+�8�
1. &H�>.
2. ,1@� E����@ -�1�� +G� )1416J( Eیمجموع الفتـاوg�78� E : E=�> +G ,18� +G +1@�2� , ��12� ~1*� E0�6,�R 6��2� L8512� 0� 42 ,A�L.
3. �T1� +TG &T1�� Ev/@ +G� )1427J(E مختصـر منتهـ� السـؤوال والامـل فـ� علمـ� الاصـول�1@ �6r�78� E :E�gوالجدل ¦1E ]G� / [ :!982����.
4. LT��6 E� 2�,TT � +TG� )1414J(E بیـان العلــم و فضـله CجــامgTT�78� E :�TT��92� e TT<¤� ,TGی� EE&�IG�� ¦1?�*2� +G� ��� Eی.
5. +G�,18� Ew��2�, � )�G � »L2�«(E مبحـث الاجتهـاد و الخـلافgT�78� E : +TG +1@�2�,T �[6� E+6� *2� +1@�2�, � +G ٰNO�, � E&@,I2� ,18� :/��.� +G ,18� !�¨� 0.�.
6. ,18� Ew��2�, � +G� )�G � »w«( Eمؤلفات محمد بـن عبـدالوهابE gT�78� : ,T6? 969.2�,T �E�� �2� [6� :,18� !�f� 0.�/ ��.� +G.
7. P�� +G ,1@� EP�� +G� )1404J( Eمعجـم مقـاییس اللغـة E6�E ¦1E =T>: �] !�T�f� vT�����f�.
8. E06?�/ =�> +G� ,18�)1411J(E إعلام الموقعین عن رب العالمینg�78� E :, � ,18� !�I2�� E=����G¦1 E� ��G :2� ���]�1�.2� v�0.
9. � +G ,18� E��S�� +G�]!� )1414J( Eلسان العرب E15�E ¦3 E� ��G: ��K ���.
10. ,.� Ev�/�G1408( ی�J(E القاموس الفقه� لغة و اصطلاحات E¦2g��� E :32����]�.
11. , � +G j�< eH,18� +G ٰNO� wT��2� ,T � +G )1404(E �T� J�T�2� ,T�@�� +T� C�TD��2 EwT��2� ,T � +G ,18� j��2� 076�{ �� w 2¤� �2 � ��:r� J��.2� F�� w��/¦1 E ���
6��.I2� 0�G�.2� 0]�112� E[6�2� E0 �{0
12. ,18� +G ��� Eی,�H )1404J(E الإحLـام ف� أصول الأحLامgT�78� E :,�T� E���1*2� ¦1 EG� �� :����G�.2� w�]2�.
13. �K� ,18� E�� 2�+6,2� )�G �»L2�«( E فتوی للشیخ البان�)��T 2f� ی �� i�1*�(E ~T1/v���� :C�� ,���G� ٰNO�� �G E/ �G E.
14. +6,2��K�,18� E�� 2� )1427J(E الله علیه و سلم �أصل صفة صلاة النبی صلE ¦1 E[6� :�]��.12� 0 �.
163
��$�
� $D
7 ,07
�3A
��K� I
�! P"8
�
15. +G �, � E?G ٰNO�, � +G 969.2 )�G �(E باز دروس للشیخ عبدالعزیز بن E]�G /[ :]�G �[.
16. C2TK +TG ,18� E+�1��� +G)1426J(E الاصـول مـن علـم الاصـولE ¦4 E[T6� : +TG� ��� .�2*�?ی
17. ��/�/,T18� +TG ��� E )1403(�.�2� E6gT�78� E�T3 :¦ E�T1�� ?� ���T1/1 E� �T�G E���0�1�.2� v�]2�
8TK 0TG�.2� }�0T: الصـحاح )1376J(E��T1@ +TG F�E ��1ی/��� .18�2� �T� E6E� ¦1E � ��G :����6�1�2 =�.2�+.
19. ��1(�} �,�� E ٰNO1379( ی�����(E هتحریر الوسیل¦ E1=> E :=�.2���� ��� 4� -I�s�.
20. E&3��� � �T:f )2012!( زمـن الصـحوة الحرکـات الاسـلامیة المعاصـرة فـ� السـعودیةE¦1 E� ��G: ����2� §8G¸2 0�G�.2� 0] �2
21. ���� +G =����G� E� {< )1412J(E الاعتصامg�78� E :E�2�A2� ,�� +G =��� ¦1 E[T6� :��� &3� +G� Tی��.�.
22. � {<E �T��� +G =����G� )1417J(E الموافقـات� E78gT� :�G� eH +TI@ +TG ��AT�� �,T� �E&1�� ¦1E ]�G /[ :+G� ��� &3�.
23. ,.� Eی��< K� +G� )1416J( Eامه و انواعهLالتقلید احE ¦1E [6� :+{�2����.
24. ,.� Eی��< �K� +G )1426J( Eالاصول و الفروعE ¦1 E[6�: ��� <� ?��:���.
25. 969.2�,TT � +TTG &1��TT� Eی��TT< )1431J(E ــاظرین �TT6E ¦1 E[شــرح مختصــر روضــة الن :-6��,�2����.
26. +��¤�,18� E�4�7��2� )1415J(E إیضـاح القـرآن بـالقرآنأضـواء البیـان فـ�¦ E1 �T�G E�: 32����]6?��2� ���2� 0� 4�2 �~.
27. ��� +G ,18� E��:�< )1419J( Eارشاد الفحول ال� تحقیق الحق من علم الأصولg�78� E :�<� j E06�� 9� ,1@¦1 E]�G /[ :�G�.2� w�]2����.
28. ,��,18� E�� � )�G �( E&بدعة التعصب المذهبی1� E T&���: -����f� 0 �]�.
29. C2K +G ,18� E+�1��.2� )1413J( Eیمجموع فتاو oو رسائل فضیلة الشیخ محمـد بـن صـال����v :� +G �K� E /1~ العثیمین +G ,A�[6� E&1��I2� =����G: +{�2� ��� T6��2� ���.
30. �2�9^E ,18� )1413J(E المستصف�gT�78� E :E��T�2�, � !�TI2�, � ,T18� ¦1E � �T�G :-�1�.2� v�]2����.
164
��� ��
� �
��
��
���
���
��)
����
�10
0(
���
��
1398
31. ,1@� +G ,18� E�@��� )1418J( Eشـرح الLب المنیـرکـوgT�78� E : -T69� E�T��@92� ,T18�E�1@ ¦2 E[6� :&]� .2� 0 �]�.
32. ,1@� E����> )6��� +G )1393J( Eشرح تنقیح الفصولE g�78� :E,.� � �2�, � -{ ¦1E -�6,�: ",8�� ��� �:�<.
33. +1@�2�, � E��16 �1�.� )�G �( E لام فـ� المسـائل الـثلاث الاجتهـاد و التقلیـد وLتحقیق ال
�678� E :E)1< �69� ,18� E&��1� ,18� +G ��� [�gالسنة و البدعة، العقیدة : =�.2����,;��32�.
References in Arabic / Persian
1. The Quran.
2. Ibn Timiyyah Harrani, Ahmad (1416 AH), Majmoo' al-Fatwa, research: Abd
al-Rahman ibn Muhammad ibn Qasim, Madinah, Majma 'al-Mulk Fahad le
Taba'ah al-Mushaf al-Sharif.
3. Ibn Hajib, Uthman ibn Umar (1427 AH), Mokhtasar Montahai al-Su'al va al-
Amal fi Ilmi al-Usul va al-Jadal, research: Nazir Hamad, first print, Dar al-
Hazm.
4. Ibn Abd al-Barr, Yusuf (1414 AH), Jame 'Bayan al-ilm va Fazleh, research:
Abd al-Ashbal al-Zuhairi, Saudi Arabia, first print, Dar Ibn al-Jawzi.
5. Ibn Abd al-Wahhab, Muhammad, Mabhath al-ijtihad va al-Khilaf, research:
Abdorahman ibn Mohammad al-Sadhan, Abdollah Ibn Abdolrahman al-
Jabrein, Riyadh: Jame'at al-Imam Mohammad ibn Saud.
6. Ibn Abd al-Wahhab, Muhammad, Mu'alifat Muhammad ibn Abd al-Wahhab,
research: Abdul Aziz Zayd al-Rumi, Riyadh: Imam ibn Muhammad Saud
University.
7. Ibn Faris, Ahmad Ibn Faris (1404 AH), Mojam Maqaees al-Loqat, 6 vols, first
print, Qom: Islamic School.
8. Ibn Qayyim Jawziyyah, Muhammad (1411 AH), A'alam al-Mawqa'in an Rab
al-Alamin, research: Muhammad Abdul Salam Ibrahim, first print, Beirut:
Dar al-Kotob al-ilmiyah.
9. Ibn Manzoor, Muhammad ibn Mokaram (1414 AH), Lisan al-Arab, 15 vols.,
third print, Beirut: Dar Sader.
10. Abu Jaib, Sa'adi (1408 AH), Al-Qamus al-Fiqhi Loqat va Istilahat, second
print, Damascus: Dar al-Fikr.
11. Al-Sheikh Ibn Abdullah Ibn Muhammad Ibn Abdul Al-Wahab, (1404 AH) le
Tawzih an Tawhid al-Khalaq fi Javab Ahl al-Iraq va Tazkaerat Ole al-Albab
fi Taraiqat al-Sheikh Muhammad Ibn Abd Al-Wahab, first print, Dar Tayebat,
Al-Riyadh, Al-Mamlekat Al-Arabiyah Al-Saudiat
12. Amadi, Ali Ibn Muhammad (1404 AH), Al-Hakam Fi Al-Usul Al-Ahkam,
Research: Sayyid Al-Jamili, first print, Beirut: Dar Al-Kitab Al-Arabi.
13. Al-Albani, Mohammad Nasser al-Din, A. Fatwa le al-Sheikh Al-Albani
(Majmau' Fatawa al-Albani), summary: Abu Sa'd Fathullah.
14. Al-Albani, Mohammad Nasser al-Din (1427 AH), Asl Sefat Salat al-Nabi
(peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him), first print, Riyadh: Maktab al-
Ma'arif.
15. Ibn baz, Abdul Aziz Ibn Abdullah, Dorus le Shaikh Abdul Aziz Ibn baz.
16. Ibn Uthaymeen, Muhammad ibn Saleh (1426 AH), Al-Osul Min ilm Al-Osul,
fourth print, Riyadh: Dar Ibn Al-Jawzi.
17. Jorjani, Ali Ibn Muhammad, (1403), Definitions, research: A group of
scholars, first print, Beirut, Dar Al-Kotob Al-Ilmiyah.
18. Johari, Ismail Ibn Hamad (1376 AH), Al-Sahah: Taj Al-Loqat va Sahah Al-
Arabiyah, 6 vols, first print, Beirut: Dar Al-ilm le al-Mala'een.
19. Khomeini, Seyyed Ruhollah Mousavi (1379 SH), Tahrir al-Waseela, first
print, Qom: Dar Al-ilm Institute
20. Satifan, Lacroix (2012) Zaman Al-Sahwa Al-Harakat Al-Islamiyat Al-
Mo'asereh Fi Al-Saudiyah, first print, Beirut: Al-Shabakat Al-Arabiyah va al-
nashr.
21. Shatibi, Ibrahim Ibn Musa (1412 AH), Al-I'etesam, research: Salim Ibn Eid
Al-Hilali, first print, Riyadh: Dar Ibn Affan-Saudi.
22. Shatibi, Ibrahim Ibn Musa (1417 AH), Al-Mawafiqat, research: Abu Ubaydah
Maroof Ibn Hassan Al Salman, first print, Dar Ibn Afan.
23. Shathari, Sa'd ibn Nasser (1416 AH), Al-Taqlid Ahkamah wa Anwa'ah, first
print, Riyadh: Dar al-Watan.
24. Shathari, Sa'ad ibn Nasser (1426 AH), Al-Osul wa Al-Furu, first print,
Riyadh: Dar konouz Ashbilia.
25. Shathari, Suleiman Ibn Abdul Aziz (1431 AH), Sharh Mokhtasar Rawzat al-
Nazerin, Riyadh, Dar al-Tadmeriah.
26. Al-Shanqiyati, Muhammad al-Amin (1415 AH), Azwa al-Bayan fi Izah al-
Qur'an be al-Qur'an, First print, Beirut: Dar al-Fikr le Taba'ah va al-Nashr va
al-Tawzi.
27. Shokani, Muhammad ibn Ali (1419 AH), Irshad al-Fohoul ila Tahqiq al-haq
min Ilm al-Usul, research: Sheikh Ahmad Ezzo Enayeh, first print, Dar al-
Kitab al-Arabi.
28. Abbasi, Mohammad Aid, Bada'a Al-Ta'asob Al-Madhabi, Oman - Jordan:
Maktab al-Islamiyah.
29. Al-Athimin, Muhammad ibn Saleh (1413 AH), Majmu' Fatawa va Rasa'el
Fazilah al-Sheikh Muhammad ibn Saleh al-Athimin, compiled by Fahd ibn
Nasser ibn Ibrahim al-Sulayman, Riyadh: Dar al-Watan - Dar al-Thoraya.
30. Al-Ghazali, Muhammad (1413 AH), Al-Mustafi, research: Muhammad Abdul
Salam Abdul Shafi, first print, Beirut: Dar al-Kotob al-Ilmiyah.
31. Fotuhi, Muhammad ibn Ahmad (1418 AH), Sharh al-Kawkab al-Munir,
research: Muhammad al-Zuhili, Naziah Hamad, second print, Riyadh:
Maktab al-Abikan.
32. Qarafi, Ahmad Ibn Idris (1393 AH), Sharh Tanqih al-Fosul, Research: Taha
Abdul Rauf Sa'ad, first print, Medina: Motahedeh Technical Company.
33. Mo'alemi Yamani, Abdul Rahman, Tahqiq al-kalam fi al-Masa'el al-Thalath
al-Ijtihad va al-Taqlid va al-Sunnah va al-Bid'at, al-Aqidat, Research: Ali Ibn
Muhammad Imran, Mohammad Azir Shams, Riyadh: Dar Al-Ilm Al-
Fawa'eid.