made in india
DESCRIPTION
TRANSCRIPT
Made in India
Directed by Rebecca Haimowitz and Vaishali Sinha
Lisa and Brian Switzer, an infertile American couple, seek surrogacy help in India after they realize it is too expensive in America. This is a story of their journey and the bumps in the road along the way.
Summary
Cultural differences› Having a baby without a man› Standard of living› Money
Film’s Message
A different perspective on surrogacy› It’s not right or wrong› Birth parents aren’t being selfish› Beneficial for both sides› Last resort for both parties
Film’s Message
Understand the complexities of surrogacy› Why a family would do it› How it affects both parties› The business aspect
Film’s Message
Human rights› How much can you “scam” a
person for your business?› “Buying” a person› Husband-wife relationship› Women’s choices
Film’s Message
The notion of motherhood› Do you have to give birth to a child to be
their mother?› What rights should the surrogate have
after the baby is born?
Film’s Message
Many different perspectives› Doctors› The Switzers› Rudy Rupak- One founder of Planet
Hospital› American community› Surrogate mother› Surrogate family
Communication
Engaging› Kept the audience
entertained which made it easier for them to grasp the film’s message
› Some humor- kept it light
› Empathize with the characters
Communication
Feel a connection with both the Switzers and the surrogate mother.
Audience Response
Understand the decisions that were made and why.
Audience Response
Don’t judge before you know all the details in a situation.
Audience Response
Feel whatever emotions the people in the movie were feeling.
Audience Response
Have a new awareness of each of the cultures portrayed in the film.
Audience Response
Home video› More personal– easier to connect with Switzer family.
Sources
Personal accounts (interviews)› Surrogate› Surrogate family› Switzers› Doctors› Rudy Rupak› Hospital Executives
Sources
What is the role of the individual in the modern world?
Don’t judge others based on their culture.› Learn why people do the things they do
Why surrogacy was the best option› Cultural differences
Having a baby without a man Money Way of life Standard of living
› Become more worldly Have a better understanding of the cultures around
you.
Course Questions
What is the role of the individual in the modern world?
Economically› Buy things to fuel the economy
Pay for surrogate and surrogacy services› Realize the different impact money has
in different countries How much the surrogate is being paid in
India Cost of surrogacy in the United States
vs. India
Course Questions
What is the role of the individual in the modern world?
Realize the impact your decisions will have on the people around you.› Choosing surrogacy› Impact doctors will have by running
these programs› Offering more affordable surrogacy in
another country
Course Questions
What is the role of the individual in the modern world?
Know the legal and ethical implications of your choices.› Not everyone agrees surrogacy is
“politically correct” Buying a person Using them Other options Not being paid equally
Course Questions
How have human choices had a local and global impact?
Every choice you make has an impact on others in some way or another.› The Switzer’s choice to go through
surrogacy in India impacted those that heard their story as well as the surrogate and her family.
Course Questions
Is surrogacy a violation of human rights because you are “buying” a person?
Questions
Should people judge surrogacy differently based on if it is happening in the United States or in a poorer country?
Questions
As this becomes a more relevant topic in society what laws will be put in place?
Questions
What regulations will have to be made between companies such as Planet Hospital and the hospitals in foreign countries where these surrogates are actually giving birth?
Questions
If I was desperate to have a child and had seen the Switzer’s experience in India would I consider doing the same thing?
Questions