m klasing chen dissertation full defence
TRANSCRIPT
Cover Page
The handle http://hdl.handle.net/1887/138671 holds various files of this Leiden University dissertation. Author: Klasing Chen, M. Title: Memorable arts: The mnemonics of painting and calligraphy in Late Imperial China Issue Date: 2020-12-16
MemorableArts:
TheMnemonicsofPaintingandCalligraphyinLateImperialChina
Proefschrift
terverkrijgingvan
degraadvanDoctoraandeUniversiteitLeiden,
opgezagvanRectorMagnificusprof.mr.C.J.J.M.Stolker,
volgensbesluitvanhetCollegevoorPromoties
teverdedigenopdonderdag16december2020
klokke15.00uur
door
MonicaKlasingChen
geborenteSãoPaulo,Brazilië
in1988
ii
Promotor Prof.dr.H.G.D.G.DeWeerdtCo-promotor Dr.F.LinPromotiecommissie Prof.dr.K.Chemla(UniversitéParisDiderot)
Prof.dr.C.Clunas(UniversityofOxford)Prof.dr.A.GerritsenProf.dr.I.Smits
Coverandendpaperdesign:MonicaKlasingChenThisprojectwasfinancedbytheDutchResearchCouncil(NWO)witha“PhDintheHumanities”grant(projectnumber322-63-004).TheRomboutsFonds,theMingStudiesSocietyandtheGetty-HeidelbergDissertationWorkshopprovidedadditionaltravelfunds.
iii
Acknowledgments
I would like to express my sincere gratitude to all who helped me
duringmyPhDjourney.Iowemuchtotheextremelypatientstaffworkingatlibraries and collections in Japan, Taiwan, Europe and Canada, who put upwith my numerous questions and requests. I met many researchers atconferences and symposiawhose feedback greatly improvedmywork and Iam grateful for their honesty and encouragement.During these few years Ihad the opportunity to work with several scholars whose boundlessgenerosity has made me comprehend the true value of mentorship andcollaboration in academia. Iwant to thankMaghiel vanCrevel and Sarah E.Fraser, whose lessons I will cherish forever. The continuous support andinsightful comments from my supervisors Hilde De Weerdt and Lin Faninspiredmeandkeptmyresearchontherighttrack.Itwouldnothavebeenpossibletodevelopthisprojectwithouttheirguidanceandfriendship.
SherryFöhr,myfairygodmotherwitharedmarkerasawand,cheeredme on during the final stages of editing. Her straightforward yet positiveattitudemotivatedmeuntil theveryendand Icannotthankherenoughforthat. I alsowant to thankmy painting teacher, Li Zhongxin, whose unusualideas and creative enthusiasm have continuously inspired me for over adecade.Hiswisdomkeptmegroundedthroughoutmyproject. Iowespecialthankstomydear friendXiongHuei-lanandmyfamily,whoprovidedmoralsupportwhenitwasmostneededandneversaidnowhenaskedtoreadmydrafts.Finally,IcannotputintowordshowmuchItreasurethesupportofmylovelyhusbandDaniel,whoencouragesmenomatterwhatpeculiarprojectsIpursue.MonicaKlasingChenLeiden,October2020
iv
v
TableofContentsListofFigures.................................................................................................viIntroduction....................................................................................................1PARTI-RememberinginImperialChinaLocatingMemory.............................................................................................18PARTII-TheCalligrapher'sMemoryForgettingtoRemember..................................................................................62
FromAnonymitytoImperialStandard...........................................................101
LookingThroughaGrid..................................................................................134PARTIII-ThePainter'sMemoryThe“PaintingSection”ofMingDaily-UseEncyclopedias..............................176
TranslatingPracticalKnowledge....................................................................233
MemoryinHistoricalPerspective..................................................................276Conclusion...................................................................................................308Bibliography................................................................................................322
vi
ListofFigures
Fig.1.1 The“Goosesoaringdownfromanautumnalsky”moveinMingdynastychessmanual.
Fig.1.2 PalmmnemonicsintheFingerandPalmFormulaChartforRhymes(Qieyunzhizhangtu切韻指掌圖).
Fig.1.3 The“harmonichand”:ReproductionofChinesepalmmnemonicschartformusicalscaleinMémoiresurlamusiquedesChinois.
Fig.1.4 PalmmnemonicsformusicalscaleintheEssentialPrinciplesofthePitchPipes(Lülüjingyi律呂精義).
Fig.1.5 Palmwithearthlybranchesasreferenceformultiplicationanddivision.Equivalenceofunitsaccordingtodecimalplace.
Fig.2.1 ReproductionofGaoSong’sinstructionsoncharactercompositioninthelowerlayeroftheencyclopediaCompleteBookoftheCombined
TenThousandTreasuresoftheFiveCarts(Wuchehebingwanbao
quanshu五車合併萬寶全書)from1614;ReproductionofGaoSong’sseventy-twostrokesinthe1597encyclopediaPluckedBrocadefromthe
FiveCarts(Wuchebajin五車拔錦).Fig.2.2 FirstpageofGaoSong’scalligraphymanualreproducedintheMing
compilationCentralDraftingOffice’sSecretlyTransmittedCharacter
Treasury(Neigemichuanzifu內閣秘傳字府).Fig.2.3 IntroductiontoGaoSong’sseventy-twostrokesinthe1727
reproductionoftheOriginsofBrushMethods(Bifayuanliu筆法源流).Fig.2.4 Characteryue樂fromGaoSong’scalligraphymanualreproducedinthe
MingcompilationCentralDraftingOffice’sSecretlyTransmitted
CharacterTreasury(Neigemichuanzifu內閣秘傳字府).Fig.2.5 Charactergui龜fromGaoSong’scalligraphymanualreproducedinthe
MingcompilationCentralDraftingOffice’sSecretlyTransmitted
CharacterTreasury(Neigemichuanzifu內閣秘傳字府).Fig.2.6 GaoSong’s“buildingahouse”methodforcharactercomposition.Fig.3.1 ManuscriptoftheThousandCharacterEssayincursiveandregular
scriptfoundintheDunhuanglibrarycave.Fig.3.2 ManuscriptsoftheThousandCharacterEssayinsealandregularscript
foundintheDunhuanglibrarycave.Fig.3.3 Instructionsonhowtocomposethecharactersang顙intheYuan
editionoftheHundred-RhymeSong.Fig.3.4 IntroductorynotetotheHundred-RhymeSongintheYuaneditionof
theExtensiveRecordsfromtheForestofMatters(Shilinguangji事林廣記).
Fig.3.5 FirstpageofashortversionoftheHundred-RhymeSongfromthe1531CollectedMethodsforCursiveScript(Caoshujifa草書集法)byHuTingyu.
vii
Fig.3.6 FirstpageofthefirstofthreeversionsoftheHundred-RhymeSongwritteninthehandoftheWanliEmperor.
Fig.3.7 DetailfromrubbingoftheHundred-RhymeSonginthehandoftheMingimperialclansmanZhuJinghe.
Fig.4.1 Smallgraphofagridandexplanationonhowtocreateanine-by-ninesquaregridinthecompositionsectionofShengXiming’sStudyofCalligraphyModels(Fashukao法書考).
Fig.4.2 SmallgraphsoftheninepalacesandcompositionmodesinaMingeditionoftheEssentialFormulaoftheHanlinAcademy(Hanlinyaojue翰林要訣).
Fig.4.3 ModelforastampingtoolprovidedbyWangXihouinhisrenderingofChenYizeng’sinstructionsontheninepalaces.
Fig.4.4 DongQichangcommentsontheuseoftheninepalacesinhiscollectionofrubbings,theModelCalligraphyfromtheHalloftheFrolickingGoose
(Xihongtangfatie戲鴻堂法帖).Fig.4.5 JiangJi’sadaptedgridsfornarrowandflatcharacters.Fig.4.6 JiangHe’sgridforcharactersthathaveatriangulartop,suchashe合.Fig.4.7 JiangHe’snarrowgridforthecharactercomponent“water.”Fig.4.8 GridinQingpracticebookletforchildren.Fig.4.9 DetailfromZhuWei’seightbrokens(bapo八破)paintingdepictinga
practicesheetwithaprintedninepalacesgridinred.Table1 HeadingsofthepaintingsectiontextsandpossibleearliersourcesFig.5.1(a-c)
Instructionsonhowtopaintbirdsfromthepaintingsectionofthe1596editionoftheAssembledTreasuresfromtheTenThousandBooks.
Fig.5.2(a-n)
ThepaintingsectionofthePearlsfromtheSeaofLearning(Xuehaiqunyu學海群玉,publishedin1607.)
Fig.5.3 WengAng’sinstructionsonhowtomeasurethewidthandheightofthefacewiththefiveeyesandthreeplanes.
Fig.5.4 Cutsmadebyencyclopediaeditorstotherhymeonpaintingplumblossoms.
Fig.6.1 FiveMountains(wuyue五岳)andFourRivers(sidu四瀆)inthephysiognomymanualCompendiumfortheExpertPhysiognomist(Shenxiangquanbian神相全編).
Fig.6.2 WengAng’sgraphforplacingtheelementsoftheface.Fig.6.3 Threeillustrationsofhowcharactersareusedtodescribetheshapeof
facesfromthephysiognomymanualSelectedTruthsfromthePrinciple
ofPhysiognomy(Xianglihengzhen相理衡真).Fig.6.4 ExamplesfromthetypologyofeyesandeyebrowsfromWengAng’s
manual.Fig.6.5 DingGao’sgraphofthemaindivisionsofthefaceinfrontalview.Fig.6.6 DingGao’sgraphofthe“CircleofPrimordialChaos”(hunyuanjuan渾
viii
元圈).Fig.6.7 Graphofthedivisionoftheprimordialchaosintothetwobasic
elementsatthetopandthe“ThreeBrights”(sanguang三光)atthebottom.
Fig.6.8 Graphofthedivisionoftheprimordialchaosthroughshading.Fig.6.9 TwoexamplesfromGaoSong’sOriginsofBrushMethodsforbalancing
thespacebetweenhorizontalandverticalstrokesincharacters.Fig.6.10
PeriodicalfromtheRepublicanPeriodintroducingtheninepalacesmethodfordrawingfacestochildren.
Fig.7.1 AlbumofLandscapesbyDaiXi,LeafC.1848.Fig.7.2 TheTowerofEightOdesbyDaiYiheng.1871.Fig.7.3 SetoftwohangingscrollsofLandscapesafterAncientMastersbyDai
Yiheng,dated1866.Fig.7.4 ImprintandsideofDaiYiheng’s“Blametheempire”(qiaoguo譙國)
seal.