~7Jf lILiJE ffl $I - f ~7JfmiJE JiWltWT

~ 36 ~ ~ 31l1f bull 1991 m~ 1990 ~ 2 ~ JIJ]

John Richard Schrock

~~lli~~fm~~~~~m~~~~~M$bullbull~~~~m~~~~ 9iiItm~~~~~JLflt~JiX 7 -1-Y~F1t~~Mh $Mc~iflt~~~~lt~ffJtmiHf~tt

~7~~m~~rr~illff~~m~~~~tl~oo~Mf~~~pound~~~~~~m~~~

~tl~~bullbullbullM~~~o~~M$~tt~~I~~~~~bullbullbull~~m~bullbullbull~

~Mm~~~repoundm~~~~ffi~~a~~~ft$~~o~M(bullbullwr$~eMraquoM ~~~m~~~f~M$W~a~m~~bullbull~~mh~~bull

I~Hlyen~l~$ampxt~B9 yeniJ

bull ~M~~m~ff bull~am~ff~m~~~~~ bull a-1-~R~M~~o~~~bullbull~aN~~MoAft~~~~m~

tyenJmtlL itfl~$B9ll-ttlif~o Aft~~Ji~tH[~f~$ ltHi~~~o Albert Schweizer lt t~~ffraquo Holt Rinehart fIl Winston NY 1965

bull ~~1Ii ~llu ffffUiiiI~YE fWfffU fmiP- 0 ~ Yxt MffrJ ~ ---~ ~ iit ~~

~lftl)J15imtl~~~ixo JltJr~ipoundtpound~~~~~)(( l5l~Jj~mlftlmp~ftlHjtiiljJE~~ )

~bullbullbullff~ff~~~~f~~~$If~f~ampbullbullbullfitto ~illAE~g~1000~ f~~ 285A~A 40A~tHtMf1Sl( OTA1988) Il5ftt 9601-9Xlt1$~$~0

~~N~j~M~lftl fU~

bull ~$A~~~~bullbullbull~~~~~tpoundmm~fi~k)Jm~~~~m~~~ Mtpound~~bullbull-~m~~~~~bullbullbullbullbullbullbull~om~bullbullY1-AtyenJbullbull ~bullbull~ amp~Wmmbullbullbullmbullbullf~JiXX~~$~re~~~YbullbullX~ff~

bull -~~~m~~~Attttamp~~~~A~bull n~w~~e~~~~s nAi9fH IBIlIanuel Kant ~ffiJtlifjregiJtJMbull0

bull m~~~~-~~i9~~mA~~ bullbull~~~~regbullbullbull ~~ fn1i ~ i9 IH~ ~~L i11p1( l=l ff i9 fi ~iW jJ at~tA~~ 0 ( ~ill Regan 1983 1f ) 0

P3

John Richard Schrock fBplusmn ~7JLtIBfJtl5Lf=pound1~~iIU~1f ~illJf(tiJ Wfm~)EtJfL pound~f~ftJHf

$pound~~ ~$Jfgttf~tlHIfmiddoti141t~ lH~jm~ J1l ( CSmlP ) 0

bull bullbull~~a~-~~bullbull~A~mfnM bullbull~~~~~m~~~~mz ~~WM~~am~~~~~~raquoZ8m~~mbullbull~iWamp~~~mbull~1i~~ ~o bullbullbullmbullbull~~~mB~m~~mm_m~ampbullbull~6~SE~B~ repoundm ~i-~J[poundm~FJJHiFa3reLQ tE8tlEi)t 1n~~sfHeEmm1t-~8tll=la3 ( Regan 1983

)

bull ~$fnbullbull~affiiW~aampAaamp~~~m~bullbullbullbull~0~amp~A~$Aa ~~m~ mSA~~Ma~-Ma~~~aMa~ttMMam~ff~~M

bull laquoi5UJtlA ~4Hll$W~fn~1f~ t1C~ftft1C$gtJ4l $f)H~Y ~~ttfi~m~a3~itl ~~J1l

bullbull fi~~~fn~sect$~~~~~~~niW~m-~bullbull~J1lbullbull ~~bullbull$~~~m~

~iRlitJtma~1JrilllElEmtt1iBin~t~8tltt~ Y~i-M~~yenf8U~~~ietz bull ~B ~~~~Sm~Ybullbull~~l=l~m~m~d~~m~oma~ft~~~W H~M~~~~bullbullfn~~-J[~~a$ffiW~~M~~o --~U~$fnW~ $~iW$gtJa3Att~~ ~OOAll~( HUlilane Society of the United States )IlHfia3wt =f 19851f

i$~-t ~ Jenifer nJJ

sect-~~~lli~a~~~~~W~abullbull$W~laquobullbull~~N~~~Y~~ -mtewffl Victorville $ 15 W~ Jenifer Graham i~iII)t(pound~IJ$l~lt~~8Uftn~~f=itshy

f+l~~l4twat iII~J~rPJi3lg Y1tOO1i~rt ~1Y A~~~~~~af5l~ffi~~8tl~m

~Y-~bullbull~~fteuro~~~gW 1~81f8~an~1fbullbullY~~=flliY-~m~ bull laquoffl-~~~reL~Wt )(tillI198tl~jJlmfiY~J~( Orlans 1988 1f ) l~~]ii)att NfY$itHH8ll~aftlfn~~]gl~)t~ttmfi1ftliJ~~aflj ffitfVifnltpoundtI~trltJ~M~

iiUflIME ~a~WJJ$i~t~~ illfiWt8U FJiz i1ii ~It IR ittJ ai~ in~i~j[ ~-ampl~$m iWft mffl WJqm~i1tfi-HJtyenjftJi ( $pound OTA 19881f)

bull -~~~m~~~Attttamp~~~~A~bull n~w~~e~~~~s nAi9fH IBIlIanuel Kant ~ffiJtlifjregiJtJMbull0

bull m~~~~-~~i9~~mA~~ bullbull~~~~regbullbullbull ~~ fn1i ~ i9 IH~ ~~L i11p1( l=l ff i9 fi ~iW jJ at~tA~~ 0 ( ~ill Regan 1983 1f ) 0

P3

John Richard Schrock fBplusmn ~7JLtIBfJtl5Lf=pound1~~iIU~1f ~illJf(tiJ Wfm~)EtJfL pound~f~ftJHf

$pound~~ ~$Jfgttf~tlHIfmiddoti141t~ lH~jm~ J1l ( CSmlP ) 0

bull bullbull~~a~-~~bullbull~A~mfnM bullbull~~~~~m~~~~mz ~~WM~~am~~~~~~raquoZ8m~~mbullbull~iWamp~~~mbull~1i~~ ~o bullbullbullmbullbull~~~mB~m~~mm_m~ampbullbull~6~SE~B~ repoundm ~i-~J[poundm~FJJHiFa3reLQ tE8tlEi)t 1n~~sfHeEmm1t-~8tll=la3 ( Regan 1983

)

bull ~$fnbullbull~affiiW~aampAaamp~~~m~bullbullbullbull~0~amp~A~$Aa ~~m~ mSA~~Ma~-Ma~~~aMa~ttMMam~ff~~M

bull laquoi5UJtlA ~4Hll$W~fn~1f~ t1C~ftft1C$gtJ4l $f)H~Y ~~ttfi~m~a3~itl ~~J1l

bullbull fi~~~fn~sect$~~~~~~~niW~m-~bullbull~J1lbullbull ~~bullbull$~~~m~

~iRlitJtma~1JrilllElEmtt1iBin~t~8tltt~ Y~i-M~~yenf8U~~~ietz bull ~B ~~~~Sm~Ybullbull~~l=l~m~m~d~~m~oma~ft~~~W H~M~~~~bullbullfn~~-J[~~a$ffiW~~M~~o --~U~$fnW~ $~iW$gtJa3Att~~ ~OOAll~( HUlilane Society of the United States )IlHfia3wt =f 19851f

i$~-t ~ Jenifer nJJ

sect-~~~lli~a~~~~~W~abullbull$W~laquobullbull~~N~~~Y~~ -mtewffl Victorville $ 15 W~ Jenifer Graham i~iII)t(pound~IJ$l~lt~~8Uftn~~f=itshy

f+l~~l4twat iII~J~rPJi3lg Y1tOO1i~rt ~1Y A~~~~~~af5l~ffi~~8tl~m

~Y-~bullbull~~fteuro~~~gW 1~81f8~an~1fbullbullY~~=flliY-~m~ bull laquoffl-~~~reL~Wt )(tillI198tl~jJlmfiY~J~( Orlans 1988 1f ) l~~]ii)att NfY$itHH8ll~aftlfn~~]gl~)t~ttmfi1ftliJ~~aflj ffitfVifnltpoundtI~trltJ~M~

iiUflIME ~a~WJJ$i~t~~ illfiWt8U FJiz i1ii ~It IR ittJ ai~ in~i~j[ ~-ampl~$m iWft mffl WJqm~i1tfi-HJtyenjftJi ( $pound OTA 19881f)

~bullbullA~~~d~~~~o ~bullbull~~~bullbull~ bullbullbullF~ ~~~M~ bullbull~~~~~bullbull~~M~amp~~~~~bullbullbull-a~~-~M~ft

1$ ~JlJt~HiH11$ fa ~~ 7f ~ fpoundJHJE ~Mk~~rRJ iii~ft r jlij11~ ftlffi fil l i9 -r~1$$~~0

~

1)~~-a~~bullbullbullbull ~~E~~fibull ~~m~mM~~~ampmmm~ ~~$lJ~ 9lfjjUDraize ~Hi( -fPitt9ampIi~JiJt )~1tt9amp~-i[~1tmfl ~tt( ~1E

~)~bullbull~~1tmft~~Wy~~mbullbullm~mfilibullbullbull~n~~~~ 1H~JtF]L

PA

2 ) nMyen=1Efr~~Mii--ai1~~filIj m~~~yen=~~~fpound 15f~ 28 zft3J

1$8t1mbullbullJ~~j~n~~33 (-reg~~yen=YflnitlUUpoundyen~fffifljfn~t1Iyen=~~~~t1o ) 3)~~ ~~Myen=bullbullyen=~g~bullbullbullt1I~ufto~~~yen=M~Myen=ft~~~m~

~ft1f~~ )~ISlI~~HampJtBlffgtl-EJW~1$~~poundti7fiT~~flfOMf~~Iii]IIi fpound KABT fa KATS

~~ampEJW~ft~~M~~~fO~o

4)m~~fflt1I~-~yen=~fpoundbullbull~d~t1I~frbullbullbullre~i~bullbullEJ ww-m~~~Yregff~M~-8~~~W~~fflAbullbullbull9lfbullbulloft~bullbullbullbullbull ~~~~~e~~~m~~~~~~8tEJWlf~_H~~fi~fP~~o ~~mfl$Y~~

~bullbullfl~mOO~bullbullbullbull1~~~~bullbullilibullbullbullbull~~~mftfpound~W~~Eom

~~l~~~W~ft~~~bullbullbulla~~ WM~yen=~t1IA~~bullbull~tt~~ ~~~~flOO~~~~f~~~ft~~~Q

5)ft~flQ~EJwn~~~~W~t1IoMOO~~~yen=~mfO~~ttft~bullbullbull~ $f - i1 lti Jlt 0

tlttm~

~ftfpound~~1ff1tEfJ m~-~~~lffi1mJLg~fr~~~Mi1~~~m Iill~HJ-~l1alii ~1ii]1Ii I ft~lfft~~sect)(o riiJ~ gu~Ji~pound~nlt1iJtt~tm~Hpmiddot~ mfi-~R~fifJL~

md1~flJ~Jiamp~7tijJ( ~

~~~JL~yen=tx~~33 ~9ififiyentJollli-flJ~Ji riiJtF~fl~~Jt1i~~~wrjftJoIffL -~

~~Mffli-tiflyenbullbull~y~gu~~~~mymflyen=~$bullbull~~t1o

n~~~~~~~~~~~~m~M~~~-W~~~o~~-~U~~~~

X6~~~Y~=~~33ft~iji flriiJ~~~i~fO1C)~~~ amp1I~f1ffJLJt~E~~~3~~lli

mlil~~iiJHllfflYWfgtlu~o ~~~~IR~a1 fi-~~~~f1ti~~lIfOFjft~~Il ~~-~~OO-~$Mabullbull~flmm~~ff~~bull ~~~~~~tJom~n~bullbull

tt1-R1 ftllnamp1tlli Jiij~iAJHHf1~~Il ~9fIi~M~~1tbullbull~lpoundtt~1I1trm~

Ii iff ~~j

bull ~t~i1t~~9 ti 6fa 1~~ 0

bull m~~m~~M~~~~~~~o

P5

bull _~~m~~~~~B~ff~~mff~ff~~ffl~ bullbullsect~R~~~o bull mbullbull~~~~~M~~~bullbullbull~m~Udo

~1amp~ bull ~~amp~Myen~mbullbullbullbullffl~~d~-~~-~o bull ~~~~~ff~ft~~~amp~~~bullbullm~~~~~~bull bull 1iUtJi5HJtl~ 0

bull ~ampM bullbullbullmm~M~m ~~bullbull~bullbull~amp~~o bull ~~ffl~~~m~amfflftn~nWm~M~Wmmmbullbull bull ~amp~bullbullbull~~m~~nwbullftnbullbullnmffftnbullbullm~~mffbullbullbullbullm j]~ ~ ~F~Biifif ~Jtifl~m 0

laquo ti -1- J lit Atttt~A~~B~~bullbullm~~~bullbull~o

~~~iit 3tEi5lBJL ~~~M~MHtf~fU~~fUmfi~fU f~fJt~-~~~iiR

~yen~~bull ~~~mW~~~-~4bullbullNK~T~-~4~~~~~W~~ff ~M~~~m~m~~j]~~bullbull~~~$~~mff~dm~bullbull~-~o ~~~~~iit~~~~~~~~~m~ffl bullbull~~m~

bull ~~~bullbullm~B~ffl-g~bullbull$ bullbullbull~o~amfi~-MMamp~~

~~bullbull~Nm~o-~~~ft~bullbullHifif~ifif~~~-~S~bullbull 150000000 ~M-armfJt~~ flIZm ~fij(tt~middot7Gt1ff f1ifJ ttf~amJW~JW~~~~ IZil

J1t~~iAAJam~m)ttt~Fm~~it1rbull~~J~~~ fMn~~~j~ ItfifflLfiJ~ ~~~m~~mtt~R~SZ~~~~~$~~bull M~bullbull~~MM~1 liiMJIi~1itW ~M~J~

Erwin Schroedinger ~ 1945 (ft~~1ii raquo~mB94Hi~mitT~~1itW~~j]

S~~fJ~-~~MtlM-~~~~ bullbull~~tf~~~M~~~~~amp~ ~M~~~ambullbull~~B~B~~tQ~~Mamp~B~~~~~~abullbull ffi

~~Ul~iqcent am7GUdiE~amp~~fIfjl~~mB9~bullbullm~riiJ11lIfIHJ ( Griffin1984 )

tt fffl ~afnm-W~~1J~ ~~ll ~ftft tiI ~~B~ a fr lilHUl ftl ~ in~$ ~poundFijt ~ Jij~~1t

I 1

89 frujJ J~ lt~~ilHRlI1~itEm 89 1~dlI fl-]r~ Jl~altJ tiltifi ~ ME ~ David0

Att tenborough 1pound ( li~_t 891 itraquo ffi~~f~ B9 lt ~~~ffiL~ -11amp a-t t1fl ffiftit 89~)( lI1ffiL P6

Mtt~ n Mtt~ n L--liij-tf---rn1-__-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-_-----1r liiitf n1

-l~~iR~itfiit ----Folfn

89JmmJEillaB1jJGJiJfTfWPaltJ~tlb4oJ 0 1pound Jane Goodall 89tIHrP jJG1Il9lJJJ~HlIl fl1fUIL[U~middot~bull

jJ~MManjJ~R~njJE1flfl~jJGaltJ~flS~~~jJbullbullflflm~~njJ fl=g A~ffi1rJaltJ~fIl 1IJ1i~ hftrf 7itL ~~ ~fa ffi1lamp Enlf3I~1f1lgilfamp ( Goodall 1987

yen) bullpoundonampP~waltJft~mlb~ampEm=gA~~flll118~altJffiC~1I1~~~

~lI1~~~~M~89M~~B~bullbullbullsect~~~A891m~J~~ Ebull ~A~~189~$~~~9lJJlb89~ft~-bullbull1pound-~~~~~ ~~ bullbullbullbull~mttw-~bullbullaltJA~$1poundm~~~Rn~mn+~wbullbullbull~~~~~ m poundftiJW~ 9E11pound sect~~1t~I-1plusmn~ftI~ E~~1lti~~891f$~t~~1pound-1~flf

~-yen-~

1if~A~lI1l1J1i~~891fffl~ 1t~89ftffl ~)L~ IJM~lHI~~1i1t~l ltf$~ ~~1I1

~~~g~QE~~~NOO~~nm~~mTsectS89~bull~fi~sectS~89~m~~mfl ffi1t 1poundtampy~mpound~ fll-)L~mflffi1t ~ sect Sltf$1tf~fflifa-tfimm~~~ 1Ji1tfta m~-~~1~~M~m-~flS~

Jii1fflt~f$~lt~ttgLdJtlA89njJ lt9llJ~89~W lt 9llJfiniij1~ftl ~~T mtt89~A~mW89m~~~I$ffiU89Q~~~~~fllt~~~~~n~

~A1flmffi~89W(~~R89~)m~lI1Xd~~n ~ftmpound~fIl~Aab1

~fl~~~~fim~rt~~mfl~fmMmll1~~~M~ampftm~E1IlM~~~89TM

1IlffiEm~bullbull1Il-~9llmW~~9~m~89~~~~Elt~~~~~~ ~89MlbJ~n~~f$89~E~~~~~W~~~E89plusmnA~BB bull

bull A~bullbullbull~~fflA89Mtt~Mfflb~ff1pound89MttMMRA~1pound~~~89lb naA-~~filbm~~ffi89~~~sectsectmm~mA~~~~1~fl

~~~A~~~m~altJv~bullbull~~nAf$~~~~mW~ZWff1pound89~~ ~~-~~a~5~~cpoundbullbull~895~~~amp~~~mftmfl~bullbull~bullbull

9i Griffin 19854 ) A=glbZrtij~~Jl~fl-~~~1ItBJjme~ ~~lf$~1~~M(fJ Jj~

pound~~jJ jpound~ Jacob Bronowski ffiJpound~

P7

fpound~1f1fpound~~BJ ~lfii1i~sectTftz 1$~1A~i)L~ftlffi~~89~~ RP ~if1~~nI

~bullbull~ttftbullbullbullbullbullbull89~m~bullbull~m+~M~~~A~~~Mbullbullbull ~-~A~~A~ff~~~~AM~~~~~~OOMOO~bullbull~~ bullbullA~

i1i~llimiddotA bullbull~~m~~Az~~fi~~~~~~~~~~ollm-~m~~ )L1K~~A~JampJftta i~~8t Walter Hunter 1910 ~btlaztm~~Em~ JJ~aJfj~

m~fpoundlvMfuvlM(em)~~a~~~ampWfi~~~~z~ Bmfpound1003~

XII1tli1-W~~Jm ilfpound~-=~ 1904 ~l~Tvt~~bull$jHifflmfl~5i vt~~

~~~~fpound~ampM~m~I~m~~fpound~~W~U~I~ n

Hunter ffHmBmm~~tiJII~T -~~it~m~ ~Ji9-r~~-1-)jiJ ~it~~~ ~~~~~~i~~a~nJfmbullbullbull~bullbullllibull~~1f1~~T~~ft~a Hunter ilI~i~itIJjf~~Ti~tfd4ampMJsect ~JiI T-~~tt 1i~i~ffl~trr~~tt1mT-1shy1

m~~~~~bullfpound~rr-~~~~~~~bullbullbullbull~~ nJfi1Q~M~

rli~~t~~m1A~m~bullbullOOm~mJfMfpound$~~~~mR~W~lli~~W ff~~j]

~EmfflbullbullA~~bullbull~~fpoundB8~~~~T~~bullbull~~bullbull-~~89U~tt fpound Hunter tyenJ~Jamp~ ~R~ 1Otl- 1~~1$~lll~mfNftfJjtf 1$Hllmftff~ llEfrJfpoundWi 1-~Jift-~bullfl~tt Hunter mR Rllm4lJfpound 5 fr~pg~~fC~J~~lCfZ

5r ffli ~BJ raj 1t~lf~i5i8jji~~Jamp~7C~~l-~ffijijbullbull Hunter 1yenJ~ijfpound

B~~W~Emm~Tfpoundm~~~m~$~bullbull M~~Jamp~Hrlffl~M~ftam~ iljf~~1l~JW-Jampbull 93j~ ~JliJ3H~ JIIHlt~~fpound~jf~0-lf- ~J~fampftdiEEmIll)m~lfm~ tt~-~fpound~9-r1i~~~TtyenJmillff~amp~~~-m~x~-~bullbull m~bullbullbull~~mIa~~~amp~~Jampma~J~~Em~~j]

middot~m~lg~~~$~ft~~(rtJ1m~mEm~)~fflmbullbullA~~~ ~HluJt1ijfj1fEmr~ IfAl1~~)J1tmfmfI] Hunter )f~tE 6 ~89)jfiltEj1ti~mffi

~~ NPilJlfJlijtftyenJmm ~tJ1t~l~$o ~-~A1~ff1IjJBUjUlf AOO~~1i~~u~ ~m~poundB5~ ~m~Il~

hti~ltm~j]~~raquo1977 -If Jffit1 C )MIT lliJffi lttltHfilJ UjJ~~iI1 -Jacob Bronowski o

ffirfJ~)(

~~m~$~ff~1$~bullbull~~~~~Ejl1-~mm~~i1-~mm1lbullbullm~ ~mm~~~~fi~~~~mjfrei~~Ej~Bffi~~HfflUamp~~~~bullbulld~ XttJiiilm

ilamp9il1tr9~iii f1tr9~iiiRraquo~I MlIfAIItr9G~ I I tllIfIttlmi

ilamp9il1tr9~Jii qraquo~ mfMiyenJG~ I

fRm ~1l1-WliIi( ffl ~ lilt4TfIIt~~ (j(j laquo~cent i1-ifiJ jsectfttf~ftF1E If)( 1 ~~FE ~sect-1-W~~ifiJmabull~ bullbullbull~UM~1-m~bullbulllaquolaquo~~~ _laquo bullbullu$ltm bullbullbull~~~(j(j~~)(

~mlyenJ1BfD

~~~-1-~~M~ftbullbull~XAreWlbull m~~XEM~~bullbull~m~~~~ ~$~~~~~bullbull~m~~ampTo~~~cent~~_~cent~~~~~~~~~~~~~

~M~~~$Z~T~~~o

~A~Wmlf~~bullbull~aE1-~~mfta~fi~bull~bull~_~~bull ~m-1-~~bullbull~(j(jM~~-1-~bullbull~ bullbullbullcentbullbullbullbullaft~~8M amp~~mfibullbullR-~~~O~~~ft~~A~~~bullbullaIi(e~~~c

~~mEW)(lfHbullbullmbullbull-M~bullbull~OOB~~M~~~~(j(jm_bullbull~ m~bullbull~~m~bullbullm~~mR~~tiT$~~~~~l~MM~~~$ Wft~~~~~_~~~M~~~aliWm~yenm~am~~lilfrt~

$Hliifo

A A

J[ i1I I

f ~ 1

JH ~

JiyenJ~i l1iyenJ~lt

iJHfP1 frR ~

iQ

~ fyenJt1J[

III

mll ~ JIj

JiXIMJIl

Jll1Ult~~ JlgtiIJT1tU~

ftj

bull m

W

Agtitr9n1i 5jJJl

e9

bullbull~H~Mm bullbullbull bullbullbullbull m~bullbullbull~~~ttam~Mbullbull~X ~~ti~bullbulloJj-fP1Ilutpound~1 ~1 sect ftiBltJit$fffiJjf~~ttamp~~ i~fllJ ~1ff~iR

~~ilj~c

2l1i~~(fJt~fljJ

-~$~~~reg1S ~~mE~bullbull~Mreg~~~~~1regM ~ ~lffc-ai~~1~I~fPbullbullbullh bull~~E~tt~~ bullbull~E~BltJbullbullo~ poundh1ti(pound~Mffll ~atJ1famp tl1iW ~regttilh iIiiampttBltJ~1(pound~tlnnt1ltr~jg i1 J fatfaJ BltJ JjlHiI 0 HnBltJ~1~~( ~t sect ~ )$ Sreg 1bull am1~BltJ1~iiJ 0te1amp1m~UL(pound-~c 4-Jeam I6~Ji Ifi]Bt~~iRffi ~~r sect MBltJ1 1tIlJ~~ 3J JLhnffftx 0

~lmdamHOO~Z ~I

3t1L IS regyenfJt3~~1tltjJLBltJtifF~1niF1iJl1Il~tffil BltJilltCJ~A~f1fi] BltJ amp11tlil -fP~Xm~cmlil4~~~-~MM~1mff~xOO ~~~~fifi~mR

s~bullbullwm~bullbulloW~ipound-fP~~Kam~~bullbullbullttitffi~bullbull~~1$~

~IMM~BltJMfti$~BltJ~M~amp~reg~h~$~m~~~~reg~1LHo

mbullbull~-Ham~~~(~K)~~mWam~ff~~~~1BltJ~fiJ~ BltJAo~-Hbullbull ~OOampmftt~~mHBltJftiiIii-~amp~fffbullbullOOM~

~~illffflbullbull~~~~regB~reg~fti bullbullM~~ampe~~m7~eW~fi~ ~fF~~Mm~~Wo~~(pound~~~~~~W31f~~Eff~~fflT~

J13~ fi9Mtlu m1h~BltJ~jfflTtlijL -J~~A~~~1tW~yenHifttifi1JItreg S7fctJ~ffmit-lf jffl~~=~~m~fctJ~~~~~~~~regW~ffi~ bull

bull ~fi~~~~W~~reg~m~bullbullU9~~~MOOro~~m7bullbullbull iI 1$tt~W$~bullbull~1l1$(pound71cf~E 1$8l~1lft Hf~-Wa(poundftft~~~~~~f~

~1 ~ftft~(fJft~ni~ ~1f11~q4P iffl1lM1ltIgtiB9aW~11H tta~AiIii ani ~~f

PlO

m1ilfttJ ft1tfiVl~mtHtJ EIf~Jlfi~mI 0 Iil T N ~JM~i1iiiJilFFItl tf~jm(fJ ti~ i-RfJlfi (fJ~ tiU ~Hm~fIltf 14~rf5t$~1I( telti~(fJ~Mitf1IilJlJ1yenMti~lHR(fJffm )tJJt~tt5k t[HU11~ ~~~JplusmnEBl~rfflmi

fiffdilillJg ffiM~dplusmn~ffl T 1 )1~t~~1lI~(fJ~_1L 1 2 )A~~JI]~~~~~~tafi(fJampfflftliJf1L

3 )J1Jiit~Htt~~4tJ~tlfl(fJii$ 4 ) lilillft~Hs4tJ1J=Mr9ft~Hi 5 )~lltyen1~~~~1gfM~Htt 6 Hot Rf fli=1illlrifim 1Imi=~~ 0

~JUHyenJ A Jt~lli3t~$ ~regfHJ ipoundfi lIfE - fllHIflaquo 11Mnillt3t~~U (J91JrL fill f4l 7Jit fii1fff 4i

mreg~~~~A~~~~~~~mreg~~~ftm~~m~w~~bullbullbullWbullbull JJM~ gtfftiJtmmraquo sect BregMJ~Uf~Eifbull~tl~M 1I1m-regSlt ~littpound12i mmtiJ~~ ftm-~abullbull(J9~aftm~~B9fiipound~fi~ tW_ reg~3

ftJlUMI9~g

~D~-~A~~m~regmlit~I~m~~~~~~j~~m~

ff~bullbull~M~~~~~~~~ff~~a~~~m1J~~M~0A~B9bullbullbull gm bullbullfi~~ft~~regfi~tm~~B~reg~~~~~i1~~~~ttft~~m~~ m~~~~~ipoundfi~tpoundA~~~reg~ ~a~~w~~~u~

~~ipound~~~~fffmffM~~~~~~~ti~poundgm~-~~~reg~~~~~

~tiJ~fi3tK~~~~m~~li~~~~Fn

~mbullbull~(~~~~~)re-~m~~~(~~)afi~~ft ~~tt~m911~ 1filA~Ej 00 JtffiIfllregftUrli1 ~ftltpoundP1ltiirp BltJ1Uj~( 1ilt1if1lt~ftifti

)fibullbull~~~ttWM~~~~~~0A~~BMm~~~tii~~tiJ

~B9amp~~bullbull~~$ftAIfllM$~~~bullbull~~~0Abullbullbullbull~tpound~HHamp~rpB9 bullbull~mw~~MtiirpB9~~~bullbullbullbull~~m~ff~ftabull-~~~~~ bullbullbullbullamp~bullbullbullbullff~~~~~~~~bullbullbullbull~~fi~~~fi~~~~ft ~

~Mbullbull~~~regbullbull~~A~~~3tKi1 W~ipound8H~bullbull~~~B9 ~m ~iE~fmampilt~~Jsect0 Sigma Xi OO~Ii9iI~iJL yen-+liJf~~MilitEfB9-jH~~laquo ~~

B~Iftregbullbull~~bullbull~ftliJf~(1~9 )rp~~~bullbull~mru7~B9~~ PI1

at itf~1=iH1tUt~flfHfiyenJ ~)Effl7t~ lfJT~~ iyenJ -fP1J~ f(l~ul ffl~I1fffl WjiyenJ~1tif-o tEf11ttpound llUII6tJpoundJ OJ~7tMtI~~$Wif]~11 fBJ1ff~rtiyenJTtr xtFamp1=i$l2lit-fPitiHiiyenJti 192tlJH~0

fJ 131lt1=t5if1lt1ltflHtliyenJ 0 ~-1-~TrOJ it~tfj-tt Bt ttl ~fljltlttliyenJf ( ~n~1$fX1Xitffl tfj 1t~if

~iyenJ)bullbullfJ~ttbullbullWN~D~bullbulltpoundfJtpound~if_miyenJD

~regH~~ffl~I)~roreg~~~a~B9bullbull~~~~~~bullbullB9~

~~ 2 )ffl ~Jf~~1tL~~(pound-EB~~~r ~fill~B~fDHIJjB~~ft OO~nl~ll ~iU-fJH~HliJJ7JfmB9~tm fi5Sl~lamp~mitffltt~~iWf~(fJ1td~bull~HHIt~JftitW

~mBltJmJ7JB~~Hpound~~~~mftbullbull~M~ttftamp~Iftbullbull

~~ew~-~H~$~~bullbull SMBT$~~~t~~Ih~ g~h~ffi~-~M~~~~bullbullbullbullabullbullbullft~~T$~~~bull ffi~ $s~~IDffJ]tifi~I11im bull

-lTlft~ttlfi~~

~iiE ~tt~lt1m~~ampd~ilxrtxtlft~Iwttln i~~poundJAlJ13fmlfttl$ttltfiflJlJ T lft~jjJItll~tt iiilU1ipoundf7 1Jit~ttJ1t9lftH1Jlft ~ tI9 W hi T~1ltit19uL~Jftk lEfijl~jjJItI9iJijl~ilfllfL~iampiii IlilJlll~1ipoundf~o iJJAllEtI9fin 4~1il~iB~-ftX-1tiB~~Jt~t$f~l1-~~damplEtIinA9~lCJ lE~ itrt ~~ifiili raquoJII2tl(lfA1Ir~fnl-lfnl~f tili 1JlJttl(lf1t~ ~pound ilfllfLlUllilJlll EiBJlIUIllJl ~jllfifflfliBlYP bull m~ag~f44SltElfllfnlQ Jl~zEiB~~~ JfiLiiBJfiLBii9~LJlll1CKig4c 1~ ffiff~ittitLJlllmftampd~lJiB~~tIl~iLJllllE9~tl(lfill1f(agllt~1Jj~tm1i1yen~~~ JlEtI9~4SMIL

JIIIIfl5A9ffW1kM-a-~A91fl1igt ~TA9jyen~h ampJlUlf-iBm~llJilV1~~~iBff~~~~iBo RlfJl~~~f

~l PfwmniBf11J1l~ mjJ~ bull JlJtjjJI3C)lm~ MBiIlttf7A9lftjj8fiilfl5( W~WT~ 19881p 5 J1 26 EJ 133204-250 )iffiiJMiB1~~~lU1~~~fflitfi~~fnlll 13 f1tZ~t9lfflplusmnlllIiiJQ j~Rff ~~lf9lifiBUiiHriBt~tlfPfMHplusmnll1-1iiJII ~JltitltllEiBnjj(i1EtE~ ~~JUmlit 0

lltfn~~

~~bullbullyen~wRyenM~e~OOmR~~_~OO~nffffl~~~~reg~ St1Hiffle 0 ft1l1regi1I1MB~fiTfx ~ill2P- I Nflyen) tm~1t T18 fJtitb ~~T~fJ ~h JiJf

fi4~luampAyen1 lAitfJI~ftUulffi 1t~~ $fi1lpound~IyenJA~Ht1iffl sect~ftamp~jif$~(fJnt~ it0

$~~li~~f1yenJ pgiyen1E~lfilnt~~o tt ilii~1fU~ 50 if1~if1lfil~ itf3lJlJ 2010 ~$~Wshy

m~ ~JfHJii (fJ Wn-Ttl JtbtAf~lR$ ~~ if flHn $00 laquo ~(fJ~bullbullbull$B~~Wamtifi

-~mg~bullbull~~~B laquo~~~~m~~~ff~~(fJffM~S(fJbullbull$~~reg rll[tfifPt1itreg~1fil6 ( Schrock1983 bull )1ItJf~~fE~~4Ii--~iJt~fi Jtt7r ~

~~fIyenJ~~~~~mttftregfbullbull~~a1l1m~T~X~~fil(fJ~

Lysenko( llf4 )~-raquoi----1-1amp~~~rru~ rot~ro~RRM~~regmiliWWftR~~~~XS~~~ bullbull~mbullbull(fJplusmn

f1iFIli(fJ~~ Nikolai Vavilov ampnt~9[~T Morgan( fit )fflXSW~~$~Iyen)~I1l~$m

Vav Hov iAiRJU 1UJ-l7iFf~ fill 00 1( ffJ fIIrfiltJ $~fpound+frm~ 1tILli~~TtRfi ZJL ~ JIt Ifil at

P12

Trofilll Lysenko( ~~ )~ l9lmitijjTiil1tt~a-J~~mffJtt(fJ I11iIDf~wr llit ~tf~~gH~Q

fpoundfpound~ffJ~i~~~~~S~~bullbull~fi~~W-~-~~~ftmffim~~~ti~I~MfJ

fE~bullbullilttr1tjlftrr-to Eilrf~J1BMreg~fpoundW-ampm LrunarckianC ffL~R )i~jfff~RJtplusmn)t

JlJ -fiBfjj( 7 wr(r(HE1t 1938 ffampfft1JHrJyenIJT~~yenliJBUEfrt Xff 1950 1ffamptf~~

~ IIJtiftf~llJf ~ffl (r(J fft jtA 0

sectDn~~am~ff~A6~~~bullbull~~~~~Ntttt~~A~~

B9~mf4~aflSfamp~J15iJi-JttlL m1Z~JtlyenJ~~ famplfIi3l1HiJf~o Vavilov 7M=-1f$tag

Dn~~~ 1943 f9E-=f Saratov (~flHtt~)jJ]~Q ~~plusmn)ttflt 7 3000filfJt3~~~

flt30~~fff~llJf1LfJL~Q ($w 1989 7 J18 a (euroI~raquo 339415-420 $w ~~B9ft

gflt71m ZAMedvedevlf~It3E~ 1977tf1Q1 )

Lysenko( ~~ )IyenJ H~ ~il1f71ijff~M~ mJtffli~tflflJlo pound6fB9 Lysenko

(~~ )iiJ8tt~mfHli~fUftIJiNt~- ffIiiJ~m Lysenko ~~11J~1t$AHt QfillyenJle~

~~JfIt~IyenJm-aa~ffD~~ftr~~TOO~~mag~pound~~JlJff9~

~~~~~IyenJ~~~~~7Q~~~~~fl~~a~~lyenJxWo

~ftm~~~ampOO~WbullbullbullmAU~~~flta~~B9ff~ffbullbullbull~

ili~~~tag$ft~ ~JlJyen~ Dick FeyntHan ffit([ii)plusmnftlJ~ ~M=iRflag$~~lpoundQ ftnt1Jt

~~mampIyenJMtf~ffilyenJ U-=f-~d~IyenJ~~bullbull-WlyenJ~~~ff0~

yentl f5I~ euroI ~~tmfamp~mIi ( ifIUJtfampAlfJii7poundJimag R Feynman If W Norton ampCo

1988f )

~sectH9lfiL~~~

ftmffHI ~ffJU sect aIyenJJl1~j~ f ft1l1 sect alfJmtt g2t~1I2t lfiltfl~ ftfl1fiftpoundJllffl0

dWlfilwftlfilbullbull ftm~~mR~ftm~1lyenJ-~1f~lyenJm~mbullbullbull~ bullbullbullbull~amp

~ll~-=f mftm sect aaglfiltflffM~ttft1f1~ sect alyenJ A-B-D lfilWlMHJi1 JllM sect aliltmfiTtpound~fX

iiJtmlyenJ~lfiluW~~~mJlJMRh~~lyenJ~m~o~~~mffU~~lyenJwWl~~rr~~ bull

bullbull sectalfil2t~B9Jt~bullbull~-mbullbull$ bullbull~B9~T~o

~liIJffifl-~JU~~~~~a~~~~IyenJ~R~m1~Bag~o~

mampu3IyenJft~pound~~RT~m~lyenJbullbull

~m~jjjiJ ~ JL ( MMWR 34l11t 54 jIJ 16m ) ~OOW(U~~fJIJ

~M~Wl~WT~OO~ft bullbull~ag-~~ fij 107iAJf1iBlIHHi 1976-1985

38451im Wimk 4 50

Jk~ 12323 1iWm 346liIf$IyenJ M-=fyen=tcM1)lH~ fiu IV Fi4mlt Mt ~ii 28 50 ittfElflHfk 238

~ttMreg)~~poundbullbullB9ttrr~w~~mlyenJ IMl pound Ifm 27 37 ~F A~F BBf~ 1 81

B~lIftlt 11 50 aB~ 1 50

A~lIftlt 1003 JIIlll$tlt 1 30

fJL~~~~-=f~~~bullbulllyenJiiJ~tt~~~~_

lyenJ lfillfl 3iJLlWdJJ f pound If~ 0 ttm 18 A lyenJ ffH1VJ JIiIi~~ 930 J5iJ~m 1 18

~~~~~~~~~~~R~Wbullbull~~ i1lpoundlfm 714

(r(J OOttlil4p1tjlyenJ llnJfif~~ttmsect aifilyenJ)J

~~sect~)J~amp~~~~lyenJ~)J~ft1ffi~fl~tt~~m~~~~~~To~~

bullbull~nbullbull~wa~-~~bullbull a9~ampW~~~~~bullbull~-~bullbull~bullbull ~bullbull~m~~~bullbull~~bull ~ffl~~~bullbullbullbull~~K~A~~bullbull~~~fi~~~ tA ~ rttAAff ~ lfii If11Ii ~~~bullbull~ Bl WB9 0

P13-14

1fHpound 1k~1~ ag IHI

bull m~Bmfpoundlf14-t~1~$l( sectffi~MilM1ftJ )altJ~~m~~~ ~1n~fCfl4E]~reg$W

~R~l~altJ~bullbull ~~ ~Xregbullbullm_ttmbullbullA~bull ~ bullbull$lltEj~plusmnamp~1HifllJE$W~jatl~~bullbullV- sectj]m~Jf$~jtijreg~Jt ~

i~fMl1fti t~jf~~~ 1pound~ltit~bull bull A~~~t~~~reg~~rt~~~tlm~~fMl~~reg~~~~~~~~~reg]

~ ~~m8~wug~~~~~bullbullabullbull~~~bullbull bull 0A~lMH4fHt F1fMlU( tf9ll (fgtt~raquo 1989 if 10 1J 30 S )~ kJfi~$m~~~

~~~~Q~ma~~m~mEreg~~~~~mmm

bull m~t~mB(sectffifl)~$ft~mAbullbull-~j]~yen~regma~~~4 E~$~~$~~~OO$~~-~~Y

bull oo~~~~laquo~~maTm~~~~~~~bullbullreg~ ~~ym~M~~~~~~bullbull~~AA~~~~j]~~yenj]B9Wbull oo~~~mbullbull~~~~~B~~fgtt~$Jftt~bull ~maltJbullbullbullbull~

bullbullY~Embullbullbullbulllf1~~altJ~~~affl~~~T~~~mbull ~~~~~ ~m~fpound~bullbull~~~o~A~~~greg~oo~~bullbull~A~~am ~reg~MOOreg~~~~~mH~o

M1f91ffuT bull ~fl~~~bullbullbullmregbullbull~~1fXo bull ~~bullbullbull~~bullbull~bullbulltl

bull JJil1 Lysenkoism( ~~ )j)( JJil1~~tsectmllll3~$~

bull pound~~D-~~~bullbullJfaltJ~~~~

bull m~ggM~~m~~Mftmbullbull~~bullbull