looking to the future for children’s services · after the break-up of her marriage in the...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Looking to the future for children’s services · After the break-up of her marriage in the mid-1960s, for many years Bunty shared a home in Edinburgh with her widowed mother, to](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071116/5ffdee71abdf73065a24486e/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Feb 2006 • Issue 646
Looking to the future for children’s services
Feb o6 Master cover 19/1/06 7:37 am Page 1
![Page 2: Looking to the future for children’s services · After the break-up of her marriage in the mid-1960s, for many years Bunty shared a home in Edinburgh with her widowed mother, to](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071116/5ffdee71abdf73065a24486e/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Opportunities at the RCSLTDo you have finance, performance management, contracts, IT or health and safety skills or interests?
Would you like to make a contribution to the strategic direction of these areas in the running of the RCSLT?
The RCSLT is seeking applications for its Finance and Organisational Resources Board.
We need:
A Deputy Honorary TreasurerThe RCSLT is seeking nominations from members to stand for election as the Deputy Honorary Treasurer. This is for a four-year term
of office, starting in September 2006, with two years as the Deputy Honorary Treasurer on the Finance and Organisational
Resources Board and then two years as Honorary Treasurer and member of the RCSLT Council.
The Deputy Honorary Treasurer will:
❖ develop competency in the role of the Honorary Treasurer
❖ deputise if the Treasurer is absent
❖ as a member of the Finance and Organisational Resources Board, take on
special responsibilities for performance and contracts and deputise for the Honorary Treasurer
From September 2008 - September 2010 the Deputy Honorary Treasurer will become the Honorary Treasurer
and a full member of the RCSLT Council (trustee).
The Honorary Treasurer's role is to:
❖ chair the Finance and Organisational Resource Board meetings (four per year)
❖ report the Board's recommendations to Council
❖ liaise regularly with the Head of Performance and Contracts
❖ meet the external auditors independently at least once a year
❖ present the audited accounts at the annual general meeting
❖ attend four Council meetings a year
❖ as a trustee of RCSLT, contribute to its overall strategic direction
We are also seeking:
Two Finance and Organisational Resources Board membersThe Finance and Organisational Resources Board, chaired by the Honorary Treasurer, is a new board which has replaced
the Finance Committee.
The aims of the Board are to:
❖ implement the strategic objectives of the RCSLT within the functional areas of: finance, performance and
contracts, HR, IT and health and safety/buildings
❖ provide corporate leadership to implement the RCSLT strategy
❖ ensure the RCSLT complies with its governing documents, charity and company law and ensure probity
and effectively monitor the financial and business performance of the RCSLT as an organisation
There are vacancies for two members, one with specific responsibilities for ensuring that the RCSLT strategic objectives
for IT are taken forward and one for health and safety/buildings.
The term of office will be from commencement date to September 2007.
All these appointments are non-reimbursable, but travelling and accommodation expenses are met by the RCSLT.
For an application pack, please contact Bridget Ramsay: tel: 0207 378 3001 or email [email protected]
The deadline for receipt of nominations is 1 March 2006.
If you are interested in these appointments and would like more information, please call the current
Honorary Treasurer, Gill Stevenson. Tel: 01904725413 or email: [email protected]
IFC 25/1/06 8:59 am Page 1
![Page 3: Looking to the future for children’s services · After the break-up of her marriage in the mid-1960s, for many years Bunty shared a home in Edinburgh with her widowed mother, to](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071116/5ffdee71abdf73065a24486e/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Royal College of Speechand Language Therapists2 White Hart Yard, London SE1 1NX
Telephone: 020 7378 1200email: [email protected]: www.rcslt.org
President Sir George Cox
Senior LifeVice President Sir Sigmund Sternberg
Vice Presidents Simon Hughes MPBaroness JayBaroness Michie
Chair Sue Roulstone
Deputy Chair Rosalind Gray Rogers
Hon Treasurer Gill Stevenson
ProfessionalDirector Kamini Gadhok
Editor Steven Harulow
Deputy Editor Annie Faulkner
Publications Editor Sarah Gentleman
MarketingOfficer Sandra Burke
Publisher TG Scott(A division of McMillan-Scott plc)
Design Courts Design Ltd
Disclaimer:The bulletin is the monthly magazine of the Royal College of Speech and LanguageTherapists.The views expressed in the bulletinare not necessarily the views of the College.
Publication does not imply endorsement.Publication of advertisements in the bulletin isnot an endorsement of the advertiser or of theproducts and services advertised.
C O N T E N T S
COVER STORY:
Looking tothe future forchildren’sservicesSee page 8
February 2006 • Issue 646
Cover: Getty Images
4 Editorial and letters
6 News: SLTs join Amicus mass lobby; School Talk: coming to a town near you; Dementia dysphagia initiative wins equalities award; Council says no to separate speech and language therapy union and more
12 Anita Harron, Anne McMahon and
Éadaoin Ní Mhianáin discuss how they improved services to Irish-medium schools in Northern Ireland
14 Raman Kaur and Louise Highley recall how collaboration with SENCOs improved the communication needs of 200 schoolchildren
16 Sarah Illingworth describes a successful partial booking scheme
18 Professional issues: The CPD online diary: how it will help you
record your CPD
20 Any questions: Your chance to ask your colleagues and share your knowledge
21 Reviews: The latest books and products reviewed by SLTs
22 Opinion piece: Laura Seeley voices her opinion about the ‘dyslexia myth’
23 Specific Interest Groups: The latest meetings and events around the UK
Contents Feb 19/1/06 7:39 am Page 1
![Page 4: Looking to the future for children’s services · After the break-up of her marriage in the mid-1960s, for many years Bunty shared a home in Edinburgh with her widowed mother, to](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071116/5ffdee71abdf73065a24486e/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
www.rcslt.org February 2006 bulletin 5
editor ia l & let ters
L E T T E R S c o n t i n u e d
continued from previous page
In this context, I was impressed by Kamini
Gadhok’s active presence at the lobby and
by the respect in which she is clearly held.
This too can only be to the good of the
profession.
Jenny Sheridan
Battersea, London
Experience is also valuable After reading the letter regarding equal
banding for SLTAs (Bulletin, January 2006,
p4), I feel I must respond.
I have been an assistant for the past
decade and prior to this worked in adult
learning disability services. The experience I
have in this specialised area of work is vast,
and although I am very aware I am not a
qualified SLT, I feel that through my
experience I have many skills and
knowledge, which are far broader than that
of a newly-qualified therapist.
We do have similar levels of
responsibility in different areas and there
are many areas in which we can, and do,
work competently autonomously.
It is important that no one’s skills are
undervalued or underestimated, as
everyone works hard. There has been an
overlap in technicians’ and newly qualified
therapists’ pay for many years.
Agenda for Change is controversial, but
let it not divide the profession. We all have
different skills of equal value that
should be rewarded fairly. A professional
qualification is valuable, but so is
experience.
Rachel Roberts Creber
Communication Development Officer,
Learning Disability Directorate, Bro
Morgannwg NHS Trust
Who guards the guardians?I forget the precise quotation in Latin, but I
believe the translation is roughly, “who
guards the guardians?”
Having read of the antics of the Health
Professions Council’s former Director of
Finance in January’s Bulletin (p6) and
then of the 972 registration renewal
problems on another page (p8), I
wonder if there are plans to set up a body
to protect the professionals from the body
set up to protect the public from the
professionals (as Sir Humphrey from Yes,
Minister might have said)?
Presumably, any ideas I might have about
a link at all (allegedly) between ‘mailing’
and ‘other processing difficulties’ and
the ‘missing’ £133,326, could be put down
to an unfortunate tendency to read
Private Eye.
Clive Stagg
SLT
With the death on 24 October of Bunty Slater-Brown, Scotland lost
one of its best-known and loved therapists.
The elder daughter of a Fife farming family, Bunty was a bright
girl who, having done well at school and finding her first job in a
bank lacked challenge, decided to take a chance with the emerging
profession of speech therapy.
She trained in Edinburgh and opted to take the exams of both
the then existing societies, the Association of Teachers of Speech
and Drama and the British Society of Speech Therapists, qualifying
in 1944. (She recalled how one examiner, Joan Van Thal, made the
journey to Edinburgh as it was not considered safe for a young
woman to travel unaccompanied to London in wartime.)
Her first post was with the Midlothian Education Authority and
she later transferred to a similar role in Edinburgh, employed by
the city council where she spent the greater part of her working
life. Her abilities were always apparent and she progressed steadily
upwards through the hierarchy eventually becoming head of
service.
Following the reorganisation of speech therapy services in the
1970s, she moved to Dundee and a post with the Tayside Health
Board, which she held until her retirement.
She will be remembered with affection and gratitude, not only by
the countless young patients whose lives she enriched, but equally
by the generations of Edinburgh students who were privileged to
develop their clinical skills under her inspiring tuition and
sympathetic guidance.
After the break-up of her marriage in the mid-1960s, for many
years Bunty shared a home in Edinburgh with her widowed
mother, to whom she was devoted. Her only sibling, her much
loved younger sister Mary (also an SLT) sadly died in 2003.
Her retirement was, nevertheless, a happy one and afforded her
the opportunity to develop her many talents. She was an artist of
considerable merit and her other interests included poetry, drama
and music. Always an extrovert, she kept in touch with her large
circle of friends and former colleagues and was an active member
of our retirement network.
The adjective that most readily springs to mind when thinking of
Bunty is ‘colourful’, and that is how she will be remembered by
those of us who knew and loved her – the flaming red hair, the
dashing dress sense, the chunky jewellery, the vivid autumnal
shades that suited her so well and the rich, down-to-earth tones of
her voice. She will be greatly missed.
Mollie Donald
OBITUARY Margaret (Bunty) Slater-Brown 1923-2005
4-5 19/1/06 7:40 am Page 5
![Page 5: Looking to the future for children’s services · After the break-up of her marriage in the mid-1960s, for many years Bunty shared a home in Edinburgh with her widowed mother, to](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071116/5ffdee71abdf73065a24486e/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
bulletin February 2006 www.rcslt.org66
news
Speech and language therapists joined over
200 Amicus collegues at the Houses of
Parliament on 10 January to voice their
concerns over the potential break up of the
NHS, proposed by the government’s
Commissioning a Patient-led NHS.
Amicus members assembled on a cold,
gloomy morning to lobby their MPs and tell
them personally how the government’s
proposals will affect their services, and inform
them about what is happening to their
primary care clients as a result of current
spending cuts, subsequent vacancy freezes
and redundancies.
Commissioning a Patient-led NHS,
published by the Department of Health on 27
July 2005, aims to give GPs a greater role in
designing and commissioning services for
their patients. The proposed changes include:
� For PCTs to withdraw from their provider
function and be solely responsible for
managing the commissioning of services
� To reduce the number of strategic health
authorities and line up those remaining to
match the geography of government regional
offices
� To reduce the number of PCTs from 302 to
100 or fewer by merger
The union says the proposals could mean that
SLTs, health visitors, community nurses and
other health professionals will no longer be
employed by the NHS and could instead be
employed by other organisations, including
private businesses, GPs and charities. The
results will be “the damaging fragmentation
of community services for patients”.
Amicus Head of Health, Gail Cartmail said,
“We are campaigning against plans in
Commissioning a Patient-led NHS, which we
know will fragment the delivery of services
currently provided by PCTs to the serious
detriment of clients/patients and staff.”
“At the same time, Amicus is leading local
and national campaigns against service and
staff cuts both in community and hospital
based services.”
RCSLT CEO Kamini Gadhok addressed
Amicus members at the event and outlined
the RCSLT’s position in relation to
Commissioning a Patient-led NHS.
“Speech and language therapists feel there
SLTs join Amicus mass lobby of ParliamentRCSLT expresses its concerns over Commissioning a patient-led NHS.Steven Harulow reports
The RCSLT’s position on Commissioning a Patient-led NHS
1 SLTs feel there is a need for healthcare reform and so, in principle, support changes that will result in improvements to patient care.
2 However, the RCSLT believes that fragmenting the provision of services will lead to a deterioration in those services for patients.In the new divisive world of commissioning and provision, who will be the holder of the care package who will ensure seamless care pathways for patients?
3 The RCSLT wants to know how government will ensure commissioners do the best job possible?Commissioning is highly complex, and commissioners need to be highly skilled and experienced. Feedback from our members is that some commissioners need further guidance and training to do this difficult job.
4 The RCSLT believes that service quality will suffer because practitioners are not being effectively engaged to ensure future healthcare provision is of high quality.There is a concern that SLTs, other professions and clinical leaders are not being empowered to take innovation forward. Decisions about the future of provider services are being decided with limited consultation at a local level and not necessarily by managers who know enough about the needs of the local population, the complexities of the range of community services, or what will be best to ensure continuity of care.
Waltham Forest SLT Ruth Robinson (second front fromright) joins the Amicus lobby of Parliament
006-007 19/1/06 7:41 am Page 1
![Page 6: Looking to the future for children’s services · After the break-up of her marriage in the mid-1960s, for many years Bunty shared a home in Edinburgh with her widowed mother, to](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071116/5ffdee71abdf73065a24486e/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
www.rcslt.org February 2006 bulletin 77
news
is a need for healthcare reform and so in
principle support changes that will result in
improvements to patient care,” Ms Gadhok
said.
“However, the RCSLT believes that
fragmenting the provision of services will
lead to a deterioration in those services for
patients. In the new divisive world of
commissioning and provision who will be the
holder of the care package who will ensure
seamless care pathways for patients?”
Ms Gadhok added that the RCSLT wants to
know how the government will ensure
commissioners do the best job possible?
“Commissioning is highly complex, and
commissioners need to be highly skilled and
experienced. Feedback from our members is
that some commissioners need further
guidance and training to do this difficult job,”
Ms Gadhok said.
“The RCSLT also believes that service
quality will suffer because practitioners are
not being effectively engaged to ensure future
healthcare provision is of high quality.
“There is concern that SLTs, other
professions and clinical leaders are not being
empowered to take innovation forward.
Decisions about the future of provider
services are being decided with limited
consultation at a local level and not
necessarily by managers who know about the
needs of the local population, the
complexities of the range of community
services, or what will be best to ensure
continuity of care.”
Effects of cuts on patient careRCSLT Workforce Planning Project Officer
Stef Ticehurst has gathered together evidence
showing the real effects NHS spending cuts
are having on client care:
� Lisa is a woman who had a stroke
resulting in dysphagia. She only required
physiotherapy input for mild waking
difficulties for one to two weeks, but, due to
the lack of a community speech and language
reablement service, had to stay in hospital for
a further five weeks. Another stroke patient
who required multidisciplinary input could
have used her rehabilitation bed.
� Because of a 0.4 whole time equivalent
(WTE) cut for an autistic spectrum disorder
post and a freeze on maternity leave cover, 46
families with children with severe autism
difficulties received letters in January saying
there would be no input into speech and
language therapy advice or input into their
education or care.
� As a result of a 0.5 WTE SLT post cut in a
school for children with specific language
impairment, 20 children at Key Stage 1 have
not received any speech and language therapy
advice/therapy into their communication
problems for over a year. This means they will
not be helped to increase their language skills
affecting their educational and social
development.
If you have more evidence of the effects of
cuts on client care, email: [email protected]
Meanwhile, a Commons Health Select
Committee has described Commissioning a
Patient-led NHS’ plans to save £250 million as
“clumsy and cavalier” and unlikely to improve
healthcare.
“The cycle of perpetual change is ill-judged
and not conducive to the successful provision
and improvement of health services,” the
committee’s report concludes. “Major
restructuring should only be undertaken if
there is an overwhelming argument in its
favour; in this case there is not.”
The report also criticises the 11-week
consultation period behind the proposals,
saying that, because the process started as
many people went on their summer holiday,
“patients, local people, NHS staff, other NHS
organisations, MPs, councillors and other key
stakeholders have been unable to contribute
meaningfully to the process.”
The report concludes, “The department
must more carefully consider the impact of its
proposals on its staff, which are its most
valuable asset. Major changes to the NHS
have large costs and should not be embarked
upon lightly.”
Do you have more evidence of the effects of cuts on
client care? email: [email protected]
RCSLT CEO Kamini Gadhok (centre left) and RCSLT Head of Policy andPartnership Nick Smith (centre right) with Amicus lobbyists
Kamini Gadhok (centre) brings home the RCSLT’sconcerns over Commissioning a patient-led NHS
006-007 25/1/06 9:02 am Page 2
![Page 7: Looking to the future for children’s services · After the break-up of her marriage in the mid-1960s, for many years Bunty shared a home in Edinburgh with her widowed mother, to](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071116/5ffdee71abdf73065a24486e/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
bulletin February 2006 www.rcslt.org88
news
Council says no toseparate speech andlanguage therapy union
The RCSLT has produced a new position paper to enable it to respond
to requests for the profession’s position regarding the role of SLTs
within the changing context and development of children’s services.
Supporting children with speech, language and communication needs
within integrated children’s services sets out a framework that has been
tested by author Marie Gascoigne with UK RCSLT members and
others from key groups, such as practitioners in independent practice,
the voluntary sector and higher education institutions.
Looking to the futurefor children’s services
Marie says, “We want people to
have an understanding that children’s
services in three to five year’s time will
be radically different to the services we
now know, and to have a position
paper that will allow the profession to
respond proactively rather than
reactively to the challenge that this creates.
"We need to think beyond the structures, systems and models we know
now and be creative. We also need to improve our sharing of practice
across the profession – the research for the paper has highlighted the
duplication of effort in services across the UK in developing working
models."
Supporting children includes a brief summary of theory underpinning
intervention for communication disability and analyses a number of key
policy initiatives over the past few years.
It sets out 15 recommendations that support four key areas: delivering
effective support; planning for maximum impact; systems for strategy and
developing the workforce.
The aim of the paper is to capture and disseminate key principles that
the RCSLT believes should underpin service commissioning and provision.
“In this way it will provide a framework that UK service planners and
managers can use to develop services that will best meet the needs of
children with speech, language and communication needs,” Marie adds.
The 28-page publication is included with this month’s Bulletin. It is also
available online at www.rcslt.org/resources or as a hard copy by contacting
the RCSLT switchboard, tel: 0207 378 1200.
New head of Policy for RCSLTThe RCSLT welcomes Nick Smith as its new Head of Policy and
Partnerships team.
Nick’s appointment is the third of four new heads of
department at the RCSLT as part of its major organisational
review. He joins Head of Performance and Contracts Brian
Gopsill and Head of Professional Development Sharon Woolf as
part of the new senior management team.
Nick (pictured) has a great deal of
experience in political influencing
and campaigning. Before joining the
RCSLT, he worked for the Labour
Party in Europe where he developed
excellent links with members of the
European and UK parliaments and
the British Government.
Nick has also been a campaigns
manager at the NSPCC and an
elected councillor responsible for
education in Camden, London. He is
a single dad, with two girls still in
primary school.
In his first two weeks with the RCSLT, Nick hit the ground
running. Firstly, he managed the RCSLT’s input into the
successful Amicus lobby at the House of Commons (see page 6)
and in week two visited Northern Ireland to work with RCSLT
CEO Kamini Gadhok, Workforce Planning Project Officer
Stephanie Ticehurst and Northern Ireland Policy Officer Alison
McCullough, to help develop a forthcoming conference on
communication needs.
‘Implementing Council’s strategic objectives and working
closely with RCSLT members on the new Policy and Partnerships
Board will be the first priority for the policy team in London and
across the UK,” Nick says.
“Together, we will develop policy to reflect the interests of
patients, RCSLT members and the organisation. Working in
partnership we will lobby and campaign to influence government
and others based on the views of the profession and the RCSLT
membership”.
At the October 2005 RCSLT Council meeting, RCSLT CEO Kamini
Gadhok reported that she had discussed the matter of a combined
professional body and trades union function with the CEO of the
Chartered Society of Physiotherapists (an organisation which successfully
combines both roles).
His advice was that the speech and language therapy profession in itself
is too small to present strong union representation, and that it would be
unlikely to be recognised as a negotiating body by government.
He also felt that there were insufficient economies of scale to make
trades union activities viable at an annual subscription rate members
would be able to afford.
The Council received the report and noted similar advice had been
received from Wales and agreed that no further work would be done on
the matter.
008-009 19/1/06 7:45 am Page 1
![Page 8: Looking to the future for children’s services · After the break-up of her marriage in the mid-1960s, for many years Bunty shared a home in Edinburgh with her widowed mother, to](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071116/5ffdee71abdf73065a24486e/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
www.rcslt.org February 2006 bulletin 99
news
SLT Ella Parker and dietician Gemma Bourke won a
£1,000 North London Knowledge and Skills
Framework Equalities Award of Excellence last
December for their joint initiative to improve the
lives of older hospital inpatients with dementia.
The pair, from the Whittington Hospital NHS
Trust, sought to challenge the inequalities that
many older individuals meet, especially those with
dementia whose difficulties are often
misunderstood and wrongly labelled.
They developed a weekly lunchtime interaction
and feeding group on the hospital’s care of older
people wards for individuals with swallowing or
feeding difficulties who are not meeting their
nutritional needs.
The initiative aims to meet each individual’s
diverse needs to help them to access an equal
service. As a result of the intervention patients are
better able to meet their nutritional needs in the
group and have opportunities for improved social
interaction.
There have been a number of significant
outcomes of the lunchtime group, including
increased oral intake for patients compared to when
they eat alone; increased mood post-group;
improved holistic nutrition and swallowing
assessment; and identification of at-risk patients.
Commenting on their award, Ella and Gemma
said, “We are both delighted to have won this award
and gain recognition for our work. We plan to
extend the initiative so it will be rolled out to all
wards across the hospital and train more nursing
staff in this interactive feeding approach.”
Judith Jackson, speech and language therapy
service manager at the Whittington, said, “This
excellent venture has extended holistic patient care
and raised the awareness of swallowing and
nutrition issues throughout the hospital.”
Ella and Gemma intend to use the prize money
to continue to develop their initiative.
N E W S I N B R I E F
Complex needs onlineInterconnections, the independent
service focusing on children with
complex needs and their families, has
developed a free electronic bulletin
going to over 3,500 people in the UK and
Ireland, and overseas.The bulletin
includes news from other networks;
news of government initiatives;
information about forthcoming
conferences, meetings and events;
innovative work; summaries of research
findings; questions; and job vacancies.
Visit: www.icwhatsnew.com/bulletin
/bulletin.htm
The ICN needs youAre you undertaking any total/inclusive
communication projects in your local
area? Would you like to hear about the
total communication work other SLTs are
doing around Scotland? The RCSLT
Inclusive Communication Network is a
network of around 40 SLTs in Scotland, all
with an interest in total or inclusive
communication, that aims to facilitate
networking and share learning. If you are
interested in joining the network, email:
www.rcslt.org/news/icn
RCSLT membership growsFigures released in January show that
there are now 12,908 RCSLT members.
This includes 9,983 SLTs (99% of the SLTs
registered with the Health Professions
Council), 1,483 students and 314
associate members (speech and
language therapy support workers).
Paperless direct debit arrivesYou no longer have to complete a
mandate if you wish to pay your RCSLT
subscription by direct debit (DD). Just
contact RCSLT Membership Manager
Sharon Silvera, tel: 0207 378 3011 or
email: [email protected], if you
want to set up a DD, change your details
or cancel your DD. During the next
subscription year there will be a
surcharge for members wishing to pay by
cheque or credit card. If you are not
currently paying by DD please consider
this.
Dementia dysphagia initiative winsequalities award
Ella Parker (left) and Gemma Bourke with their award
SLTs in the mediaIt has been a busy few months for speech and
language therapy in the nation’s media.
RCSLT CEO Kamini Gadhok featured in a full-
page article in the London Evening Standard in
November on the problems caused by shortages of
SLTs.
The Herald newspaper in Edinburgh published a
letter from RCSLT Scotland Policy Officer Kim
Hartley on 23 November. The letter was in response
to earlier correspondence and recommended that
service providers contact their local speech and
language therapy service about establishing
“communication accessible” services.
Also in Scotland, Marion Rutherford spoke to
The Scotsman on Sunday on 11 December in
relation to a Portsmouth University study on the
use of gestures to clarify the meaning of words for
young children.
Michael Palin Centre manager Frances Cook
spoke about stammering and took concerned
parent’s calls as part of BBC Radio 4s Check Up
programme on 8 December.
Manchester SLT Nadine Arditti got up early to
appear on BBC Radio 5 Live’s breakfast programme
on 9 December. This was in response to a British
Medical Journal research report on dummies and a
reduction in sudden infant death syndrome. Nadine
spoke about the potential language development
problems indiscriminate dummy use can cause.
Later in the day, West London SLT Gila Falkus
featured on the BBC One O’clock News speaking on
the same subject. And on 10 December
Hammersmith SLT Annie Aloysius (nee Bagnall)
was a guest on Vanessa Feltz’s radio show on BBC
London.
If you’ve been in, or see speech and language
therapy in, the media spotlight, write and let
Bulletin know. Email: [email protected] or send the
evidence to Bulletin, 2 White Hart Yard, London
SE1 1NX.
Dav
id R
otch
elle
008-009 19/1/06 7:45 am Page 2
![Page 9: Looking to the future for children’s services · After the break-up of her marriage in the mid-1960s, for many years Bunty shared a home in Edinburgh with her widowed mother, to](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071116/5ffdee71abdf73065a24486e/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
bulletin February 2006 www.rcslt.org1100
news
N E W S I N B R I E F
Psychodrama and stammering Specialist SLT and psychodrama
psychotherapist Gail Smith will lead a
one-day workshop in Oxford on 11 March
to explore the clinical use of
psychodrama within adolescent and
adult stammering therapy. Participants
will explore how the psychological and
social impact of stammering can be
addressed using this method and the day
will provide an opportunity for
participants to explore work related or
personal issues around stammering. For
more information tel: 0775 321 8996 or
email: [email protected]
Opera evening for epilepsyThe National Centre for Young People
with Epilepsy (NCYPE) is inviting music
and opera lovers to join an evening of
opera and song at the Ashdown Park
Hotel on 18 February. Established artists
from Covent Garden, the English National
Opera and Glyndebourne will perform
the music for the evening.The evening
will include a champagne reception and
a four-course meal.The cost is £80 a
head. Contact Emma Johnston tel: 01342
831 245 or visit: www.ncype.org.uk
Guidelines on pandemic fluDepartment of Health guidance on major
infectious diseases can help allied health
professionals advise their patients on
potential pandemic flu epidemics, such
as ‘bird’ flu. Explaining Pandemic Flu gives
strategic guidance to assist local and
national planning in England, including
arrangements to support the UK
Influenza Pandemic Contingency Plan.
Visit: www.dh.gov.uk/PolicyAndGuidance
/EmergencyPlanning/fs/en
Call for better palliative careMore needs to be done to improve care
to patients who are dying, according to
an NHS Confederation report.The report
says 56% of people would prefer to die
at home, but only 20% do so, and up to
56% of people die in hospital although it
is an unsuitable environment for most
dying patients.The report calls for
improved choices for those wishing to
die in hospices or their own homes.Visit:
www.nhsconfed.org/docs/ooh_end_of_
life_care.pdf
Win a pack of ColorCards Three lucky Bulletin readers can
win a pack of Speechmark’s
ColorCards sequencing range in
this month’s prize draw.
Developed by language
professionals and teachers, these
language flashcards are designed
to support teaching and
therapeutic input in the clinic,
school and home.
Bulletin has two different
categories of ColorCards
sequencing sets to give away, one
set for adults and two
aimed at children.
To win your free
ColorCards, state
whether your
preference is for adult
or children’s cards and
send your name, RCSLT
membership number and
address to Sandra Burke, 2 White
Hart Yard, London SE1 1NX.
Entries close 14 February
2006. Only one entry per person.
Conference puts UK dysphagiaresearch on world mapOver 100 clinicians and researchers from a wide range of professional disciplines attended theinaugural meeting of the UK swallowing research group (UKSRG) in London on 2 December
The conference concentrated on four main themes:
the central control of swallowing and respiration;
clinical assessment; instrumental investigation; and
new and emerging treatments.
Dr Shaheen Hamdy, University of Manchester
lecturer and consultant gastroenterologist at the
Salford Royal Hospitals NHS Trust, presented his
work on the cortical control of swallowing. He
succinctly outlined the research to date, relating it to
the rehabilitation of patients with dysphagia
through consideration of cortical plasticity.
Consultant physician Michael Polkey, from
London’s Royal Brompton Hospital, described an
improved technique for the assessment of the
supraspinal pathways to the diaphragm - although
dysphagia was only mentioned in passing. Dr Lin
Perry, senior research fellow, St Bartholomew’s
Hospital, also gave a comprehensive overview of the
diagnostic reliability of dysphagia screening.
Cervical auscultation has been much debated in the
literature, and Dr Michael Drinnan, principal medical
physicist at the Freeman Hospital, Newcastle upon
Tyne, outlined clearly what is known about this
procedure, as well as presenting preliminary data on
the possible origin of the auscultation sounds.
Dysphagia nurse specialist Dr Steve Davies,
Gateshead Health NHS Trust, and Liz Boaden, head of
adult speech and language therapy services, Chorley
and South Ribble PCT, presented the dysphagia
competence framework, although this was slightly out
of place in the context of a research conference.
Keynote speaker Professor Angus Walls,
restorative dentistry, University of Newcastle upon
Tyne, discussed Living with your teeth. He reviewed
current knowledge of the relationships between oral
function and swallowing, and discussed and
reflected on optimal oral hygiene.
Annette Kelly, senior SLT at the National Hospital
for ENT and Dr Maxine Power, senior research
fellow at Salford Royal Hospitals NHS Trust,
presented their research. The former concentrated
on using fibreoptic endoscopic evaluation of
swallowing and video fluoroscopic swallow study to
score pharyngeal residue; the latter on reviewing the
literature on sensory stimulation as a treatment for
dysphagia.
Although time-limited, these important lectures
showed that SLTs are contributing significantly to
our understanding of the management of patients
with dysphagia.
The exciting development of the UKSRG
represents a significant step forward in stamping UK
dysphagia research onto the world map. The next
conference will be in 2007. For more information
visit: www.uksrg.org.uk
Sue McGowan
Clinical specialist SLT, National Hospital for
Neurology and Neurosurgery
email: [email protected]
010-011 19/1/06 7:46 am Page 1
![Page 10: Looking to the future for children’s services · After the break-up of her marriage in the mid-1960s, for many years Bunty shared a home in Edinburgh with her widowed mother, to](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071116/5ffdee71abdf73065a24486e/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
www.rcslt.org February 2006 bulletin 1111
news
School Talk: coming to a town near you
School Talk training timetable 2006
Date Region Venue Local Contact
7 February London (Southwark) The Newcomen Centre, Guy’s Hospital, St Thomas Street, Janet ChambersLondon SE1 9RT 0207 771 3431
13 February North West (Salford) Broadwalk Training Centre, 51 Belvedere Road, Fiona KornSalford M6 5EJ 0161 607 1683
22 March South West (Plymouth) TBC
30 March South East (Nr Woking) Meath School, Brox Road, Ottershaw, Janet DunnSurrey KT16 0LF 01932 872 302
2 May South East (Nr Woking) Meath School, Brox Road, Ottershaw, Janet DunnSurrey KT16 0LF 01932 872 302
19 May North East (Newcastle) Joseph Cowen Room, Claude Gibb Halls of Residence, Janet DunnNorthumbria University, University Precinct, Newcastle Upon Tyne NE1 8SU 01932 872 302
Early June London (Islington) TBC
16 June Yorkshire (Halifax) TBC Elizabeth Cameron01422 305 561
30 June South East (Meath) Meath School, Brox Road,Ottershaw, Janet DunnSurrey KT16 0LF 01932 872 302
The Communications Forum, with funding from
the Health Foundation, has produced a DVD and
training package called School Talk.
The day-long training – disseminated by
children’s communication charity ICAN – aims to
facilitate inclusion of children with a
communication disability at Key Stage 2. It is a tool
to facilitate large-scale training of mainstream staff,
including teachers and teaching assistants, and SLTs
across whole areas.
It provides practical tips on how to change the
school environment and ensure children with a
communication disability can benefit fully from
their education.
The session costs only £25, and includes materials
and a light lunch.
The box below outlines the dates and venues for
2006. For more information, or to book your place,
contact ICAN: email: [email protected] or tel:
0845 225 4073.
Nuffield grant will support SLT studyTwo London-based SLTs and an SEN advisory officer have won a
£273,000, three-year, Nuffield education grant to conduct an
intervention study with secondary school children with specific
language impairment (SLI).
Dr Victoria Joffe, senior lecturer at City University’s Department of
Language and Communication Science, where the project will be
managed, is aided by Nita Madhani, SLT manager at Redbridge PCT,
and Melanie Foster, SEN advisory officer, Redbridge Children’s
Services Authority.
“It is very exciting,” said Dr Joffe, “the grant will enable a
randomised control study on speech and language therapy to take
place, and will provide speech and language therapy input into a
group – secondary school-aged children – that has been largely
ignored.”
The study aims to explore the prevalence, nature and types of SLI
and provide a description of language impairment in Year 7 secondary
school children.
The project, due to start in September in secondary schools in an
outer London borough, will investigate the effectiveness of two speech
and language therapy interventions – narrative/storytelling and
vocabulary enrichment – in improving language and
communication systems.
The study will investigate the effectiveness of each therapy and their
combination, and will examine which specific aspects of language are
improved. It will also identify specific areas of language and
communication, through the use of predictive outcome measures that
improve differentially as a result of the two interventions and their
combined effect.
According to Dr Joffe, teaching assistants will deliver the therapy
supervised by SLTs. Intensive training and support will be provided to
teachers and teaching assistants from participating schools.
“This type of service delivery is a realistic and recommended means
of intervention and sets the scene for significant changes in
professional practice and service delivery in the borough and allows
for capacity building in speech and language therapy and education,”
Dr Joffe added.
“Hopefully, this will be a service delivery model that a) we can test,
and b) be sustained by the NHS and local education authorities after
the project’s completion.”
For more details, contact Dr Victoria Joffe. Tel: 020 7040 4629,
email: [email protected]
Get
ty Im
ages
010-011 19/1/06 7:47 am Page 2
![Page 11: Looking to the future for children’s services · After the break-up of her marriage in the mid-1960s, for many years Bunty shared a home in Edinburgh with her widowed mother, to](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071116/5ffdee71abdf73065a24486e/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
bulletin February 2006 www.rcslt.org1122
feature IRISH MEDIUM EDUCATION
Irish-medium schools:partnership in practice
In recent years speech and language therapy
services in Northern Ireland (NI) have
addressed the increasing demand from
mainstream schools to support children with
speech, language and communication
difficulties in accessing the curriculum.
In 1999, the Western Health and Social
Services Board and the Western Education
and Library Board (WELB) piloted a new
initiative to meet this need. Due to the
success of the project, which combines a
model of training and in-class support for
education staff, the Department of Education
for Northern Ireland funded similar projects
in the remaining four education and library
boards.
Speech and language therapists are
seconded from health trusts to education and
library board facilities to:
� provide training and support for year one
teachers to increase their awareness of
language difficulties and their impact in
the classroom
� increase the awareness of classroom
assistants in supporting the teacher to
address children's language difficulties
� increase parents' awareness of the role
they can play in helping their children's
communication skills
� share knowledge of working practices
Primary schools are selected on the basis of
social need. The project team draws up a
service level agreement with each school
outlining the importance of collaboration
and the structure of the project (figure one).
This ensures the project's ethos is embedded
into daily classroom practice.
In-class supportEach school receives a fortnightly visit from
the advisory SLT, who models group activities
in the classroom. Demonstration provides a
model of how to modify language activities
for children with particular speech, language
or communication difficulties. The modelled
activities develop attention and listening
skills, comprehension, narrative skills,
vocabulary and phonological awareness.
The SLT ensures teachers can easily use the
language activities to develop speech and
language skills in any area of the curriculum.
TrainingTeachers and classroom assistants attend
training days and cluster groups that focus on
normal speech and language development;
identification of speech and language
difficulties; links between language and
literacy; the impact of speech and language
difficulties on ability to access the curriculum
and strategies; activities to support
development of communication skills and
specific areas of interest to participants, eg
fluency, word finding, autistic spectrum
disorder and selective mutism.
Strategies/resourcesSchools receive language resources to support
the implementation of the project.
EvaluationThe advisory SLTs evaluate the effectiveness
of the projects in terms of outcomes for:
Children - assessment of vocabulary,
narrative skills and phonological awareness
show more children falling within normal
limits post-project.
Teachers - questionnaires, scenarios and
action plans have provided feedback and
evidence of teachers' increased skills,
knowledge and confidence.
In September 2003, the projects extended
into Irish-medium schools in the South
Eastern Education and Library Boards
(SEELB) and WELB.
It was the first time that SLTs worked
directly with Irish-medium schools, a fast-
growing sector of the Northern Ireland
education system. In these 32 schools and
units, the curriculum is taught solely through
Irish. Children are immersed in Irish at
school, yet 98% of their parents are non-Irish
speakers (Comhairle na Gaelscolaíochta, the
Council for Irish-medium Education).
We were faced with two immediate
challenges:
� we are not fluent Irish speakers yet
needed to provide in-class support in
Irish
� we had no resources in Irish particularly
for phonological awareness, eg words that
rhyme in English do not rhyme in Irish
However, we were committed to providing
these schools with the same quality service
afforded to the other schools involved.
In order to do this we worked together
with Éadaoin Ní Mhianáin, the advisory
teacher for literacy in Irish-medium schools.
Our partnership proved to be essential both
on school visits and in developing resources.
Éadaoin jointly planned activities and
accompanied us on school visits. We were,
therefore, able to deliver language activities
totally in Irish and to collaborate with staff in
their chosen language. She advised on
SLTs Anita Harron, Anne McMahon and advisory teacher Éadaoin Ní Mhianáindiscuss how they improved speech and language therapy services to Irish-mediumschools in Northern Ireland
Figure one: Key elements of the projects
Strategies/resources
Evaluation Training
In-classSupport
RCSLT_feb_feature p12-13 19/1/06 7:49 am Page 2
![Page 12: Looking to the future for children’s services · After the break-up of her marriage in the mid-1960s, for many years Bunty shared a home in Edinburgh with her widowed mother, to](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071116/5ffdee71abdf73065a24486e/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
www.rcslt.org February 2006 bulletin 1133
curricular areas and the integration of
language and literacy activities.
Teachers' comments on the post-
programme questionnaires were extremely
positive and they expressed gratitude that
they were being provided with materials in
Irish: “I was very pleased that a lot of
resources were made available to me in the
Irish language. It is brilliant to now be getting
as much support for Irish-medium as for
others,” was one comment we received.
The teachers also explained that the
project's greatest strength is its practical
nature and that the in-class support had
inspired them to develop classroom practice
and school policies: “We have realised that we
want to add speech and language
development into our monthly plans, so we
are revising current plans and even language
policy.”
“I was impressed with the project and feel
that its benefits were, for once, aimed in a
practical way at the classroom.”
“This has been an invaluable speech
project from the point of view of second
language/immersion teaching. The children
are exposed to a more definite structured
language activity on a daily basis, which
undoubtedly helped their language
acquisition.”
As for the other project schools, we
evaluated outcomes for children on:
� receptive vocabulary - using the British
Picture Vocabulary Scale (BPVS)
� narrative - the bus story
� phonological awareness - Preschool and
Primary Inventory of Phonological
Awareness (PIPA)
We also wanted to find out if children in the
Irish-medium schools made comparable
progress to their peers in English-medium
schools. However, the assessments could only
be administered in English due to their
standardisation. This put the children in the
Irish-medium schools at a disadvantage as
their progress in Irish was not measured.
However, the results were encouraging (see
table one).
We discussed the lack of available Irish-
medium resources at regular planning
meetings with Éadaoin and the teachers, and
had to devise our own materials for our
school visits.
We were able to translate some of our own
materials into Irish but this was limited and
we could not do this for phonological
featureIRISH MEDIUM EDUCATION
awareness. However, we soon had a bank of
resources that we had piloted in the Irish-
medium schools.
We realised that other schools throughout
NI and the Republic of Ireland would benefit
from them. The question was: how could we
produce these in a more professional way and
distribute them more widely?
We had always found Black Sheep Press
materials very child-friendly and easy to use
and knew they had produced materials in
Welsh.
We contacted Alan Henson who was
interested in taking this further. We collated
all our Irish resources and developed them
into three sections – syllable segmentation,
rhyme and initial sounds.
We have a great sense of achievement now
that they are published and available for SLTs
and teachers throughout Ireland to buy,
enabling professionals to deliver an equitable
service to those learning in Irish.
The resource pack was formally launched
on 15 June 2005. Speaking at the launch, Séan
MacCorraidh, adviser on Irish-medium
education for Northern Ireland, declared the
resources are a strong foundation for the
implementation of a phonics methodology to
reading and spelling being developed in the
boards in partnership with Comhairle na
Gaelscolaíochta for use in Irish-medium
education both at primary and post-primary
levels.
RCSLT Northern Ireland Policy Officer
Alison McCullough also emphasised the
Anita Harron – advisory SLT, Foyle Health andSocial Services Trustemail: [email protected] McMahon – advisory SLT, Down LisburnHealth and Social Services Trustemail: [email protected]Éadaoin Ní Mhianáin – advisory teacher forliteracy in Irish-medium schools
References:Comhairle na Gaelscolaíochta (Council for Irish-mediumEducation).Visit: www.comhairle.org Deighilt Siollaí (IR 1); Rím (IR 2); Tús fhuaimeanna (IR 3). BlackSheep Press, August 2005.Visit: www.blacksheep-epress.com
benefits of partnership between SLTs and
education and the need for continued
collaboration.
Receptive vocabulary• Both sets of children made significant gains• Despite limited experience of English
vocabulary only 6% of children in Irish-medium schools were below average post-project compared to 23% on initial assessment
Narrative• Over a nine-month period the Irish-medium
children made gains of, on average, 15 months on information and sentence length
Phonological awareness• Both sets of children made significant
gains in the areas of syllable segmentation,rhyme awareness and phoneme isolation
• On syllable segmentation the Irish-medium children made greater improvement than their peers, possibly because of more exposure to novel words
Table one: Key findings/recommendations
Celebrating the launch of the Irish resource pack. Front row (l-r): Éadaoin Ní Mhianáin; AlisonMcCullough; Anita Harron; Anne McMahon. Back row (l-r): Sue Harpur (assistant advisory officer,WELB); Monica McNicholl (assistant programme manager, Foyle Trust); Séan MacCorraidh(adviser on Irish-medium education)
RCSLT_feb_feature p12-13 19/1/06 7:49 am Page 3
![Page 13: Looking to the future for children’s services · After the break-up of her marriage in the mid-1960s, for many years Bunty shared a home in Edinburgh with her widowed mother, to](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071116/5ffdee71abdf73065a24486e/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
bulletin February 2006 www.rcslt.org1144
feature COLLABORATION
Collaborative practice:successful intervention
We work in a busy inner city area of
Birmingham. In April 2003, we were
struggling to provide an effective and
efficient service to clients within a culturally
diverse and multilingual community.
We had only two sessions a week to
manage a caseload of 10 local mainstream
schools, so we held a problem-solving
meeting with 10 special educational needs
coordinators (SENCOs), one from each
school.
We presented them with the following
problem: how could we best meet the
communication needs of 200 school-aged
children using two sessions a week of the
SLTs’ time?
Together we examined solutions. Our
purpose in doing this collaboratively was to
promote an interagency model of working
with schools that would ultimately encourage
joint ownership of communication goals.
The SEN Code of Practice (2001) supports
this: “It is good practice for education
professionals…to support and assist the work
of SLTs in educational settings. Collaborative
practice is essential for successful
intervention with children and young people
with speech and language difficulties.”
We first invited the SENCOs to state the
problems they had experienced with our
service. We identified the following issues:
� School staff were not always given
enough reassurance when they were
doing a good job
� SLTs were perceived as not wanting to
share their skills in working with
children with speech sound difficulties
� Activities given to children were
sometimes perceived as boring
� SENCOs were unhappy about SLTs
discharging children who were having
difficulties accessing the curriculum
� Speech and language therapy input
often did not meet national curriculum
standards for speaking and listening
After discussion, we agreed the following
mission statement: “Effective, efficient,
consistent and speedy access to intervention
for children with defined communication
needs in partnership with colleagues within
health and external to health.”
In order to achieve this, we decided to use
the sessions of speech and language therapy
time initially to train staff in the following
areas: comprehension, speech sounds, fluency
and expressive language.
During the next three terms we delivered
training to 10 SENCOs and 10 assistants (two
members of staff from each school). The
term ‘assistant’ has been used to represent a
range of roles in schools, such as learning
support assistant, integration assistant and
teaching assistant.
Each training package lasted three hours
and was hosted by one of the participating
schools. We followed a format that aimed to
encompass different adult learning styles
(adapted from Hanen, 1974).
At the end of each session, staff went away
with resources and practical ideas to use in
their schools – for example, a set of symbols
to support comprehension of the gingerbread
man story. Table one outlines our speech
sounds training package.
By September 2003, the training period
was over and we began to visit schools to
discuss the children on our caseload. We gave
all schools a timetable of our schedule before
visits so they could see how our time was
allocated.
Following on from the training, we sent
SENCOs a form to record each child’s main
communication need
(comprehension/expressive language/speech
difficulty or stammer). We also asked them to
state a preferred model of intervention.
The choices offered were: individual
programmes, group work and collaborative
working in the classroom with teaching staff.
Project evaluationIn September 2004, we evaluated whether
there had been any changes in attitude and
working practices. We met each SENCO and
Raman Kaur and Louise Highley discuss how collaboration with SENCOs helpedimprove the communication needs of 200 schoolchildren
Staff are clear about how scarce speech and language therapy resources are
Get
ty Im
ages
14-15 19/1/06 7:50 am Page 2
![Page 14: Looking to the future for children’s services · After the break-up of her marriage in the mid-1960s, for many years Bunty shared a home in Edinburgh with her widowed mother, to](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071116/5ffdee71abdf73065a24486e/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
www.rcslt.org February 2006 bulletin 1155
discussed individual cases. The following
differences were evident:
� Six of the 10 participating SENCOs had
achieved a better understanding of the
children’s communication skills and needs.
For example, one SENCO had previously
voiced concerns about a child’s /s/ blend
reduction. After training, she recognised that
his primary communication difficulty was
that of comprehension, and that he was
operating at 1 Information Carrying Word
level (Masidlover and Knowles, 1982).
� Six of the 10 SENCOs were now
highlighting children with comprehension
difficulties. Instead of wanting the SLT to
work on individual programmes with the
children, SENCOs were requesting other
intervention methods. This resulted in SLTs
working with teaching staff to enable them to
reduce language levels and complex topic
vocabulary (eg ‘transparent’ and ‘opaque’
became ‘dull’ and ‘clear’).
� New referrals from schools were becoming
more accurate, and supporting information
more relevant. This confirmed that SENCOs
had internalised knowledge from their
training. We reinforced this by discussing
new referrals with SENCOs with reference to
the information shared in the training
sessions.
� We found that teaching staff ’s expectations
of speech and language therapy had become
more realistic. SENCOs and SLTs were more
likely to agree on which children were ready
for discharge. Six of the SENCOs reported
more confidence in their ability to support
those children who continued to experience
communication problems and difficulties
accessing the curriculum.
� Referrals to speech and language therapy
halved in the six-month period after training.
This was due to five of the 10 SENCOs
setting up groups (eg speech/pre-
tutoring/vocabulary-building) before
referring children for speech and language
therapy. The assistants who had taken part in
our training ran these.
ConclusionsTen months after the completion of the
project, a review of the mission statement
suggested the following progress:
Speed of access: We are now seeing
children who are referred from participating
schools more promptly. This is because
children with communication problems are
featureCOLLABORATION
more likely to receive input before speech and
language therapy referral. Instead of being
referred at school entry, as previously, most of
the children are appropriately referred at a
later point, or are not referred at all.
Efficiency: We, as well as staff from
participating schools, are now clear about
how scarce speech and language therapy
resources are and are able to fulfil agreed
commitments. This has resulted in improved
joint ownership of speech and language input
for children, and improved working
relationships between participating schools
and SLTs, eg complaints from SENCOs have
decreased from three in the 12 months before
the project, to none in the year following the
project.
Consistency: Throughout the project, we
have used a consistent approach with all
school staff and parents. This has been
beneficial because it has promoted equality of
access to SLT resources across the schools.
Effectiveness: Six of the 10 participating
schools are now, with varying degrees of
confidence and independence, offering some
appropriate input to children with speech,
expressive and receptive language difficulties.
During school visits we have observed that
the practices being implemented in the
classroom are giving children more
opportunities to communicate and to access
the curriculum. For example, in two early
years’ settings, all staff wear photos on key
rings to support understanding of the daily
routine, and use objects of reference to enable
choice making.
Four parents from two of the participating
schools reported they have noticed increased
confidence in their children’s communication
and increased self-esteem.
Experience
• the SENCOs and assistants experienced what it is like to make a new sound and identified the difficulties associated with this
InformationWas given on:
• how speech sounds are made
• the development of speech sounds and processes
• the pre-requisite skills needed to make speech sounds
Practice
• SLTs demonstrated a step-by-step programme for children who are fronting/stopping etc.
Personalise
• School staff received a blank step-by-step programme that they completed and took away to apply to one child in their class with speech difficulties
Table one: speech sounds training programme
Next steps Following feedback meetings with SENCOs
and speech and language therapy staff, we
have now implemented the following action
plan:
� More training of SENCOs (eg Derbyshire
Language Scheme [Masidlover and Knowles,
1982]) to further develop their skills in
identifying and assessing children and in
improving the quality of their
communication groups.
� Inclusion of educational psychologists in
the termly planning meetings that have been
set up in the participating schools.
� Joint working between educational
psychologists and SLTs has created and
implemented an assessment system for use in
feeder nurseries. This should result in
children ‘at risk’ of continued language
difficulties being identified and flagged up as
of concern from the outset. SENCOs of
receiving schools would then be able to plan
for these children’s needs from school entry.
This tool was due to be evaluated in
September 2005.
Raman Kaur, Louise Highley
SLT team leaders, South Birmingham PCT
email: [email protected]
References:Department for Education and Skills. The SEN Code of Practice.DfES Publications, 2001.Masidlover M, Knowles W. The Derbyshire Language Scheme.Derbyshire County Council Educational Psychology Service,1982.Manolson, A. The Hanen Programme. Canada:The Hanen Centre
Publication, 1974.Acknowledgement:Special thanks to Kath Robinson, former principal SLT, SouthBirmingham PCT.
14-15 19/1/06 7:50 am Page 3
![Page 15: Looking to the future for children’s services · After the break-up of her marriage in the mid-1960s, for many years Bunty shared a home in Edinburgh with her widowed mother, to](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071116/5ffdee71abdf73065a24486e/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
bulletin February 2006 www.rcslt.org1166
feature CASELOAD MANAGEMENT
Partial booking at yourconvenience
Camden and Islington PCT has nine busy
health centres hosting a paediatric speech
and language therapy service. All new
referrals to the service are centrally
processed from one site, where the
principal SLT is based.
New children are offered a short 30-
minute appointment at their nearest health
centre within six weeks of receipt of their
referral. Two SLTs are available at the
appointment – one to engage with the
parent/carer, one with the child. The two
SLTs then discuss the case and prioritise
appropriately for detailed assessment.
This short appointment is followed by a
longer one lasting up to an hour, which
involves a detailed assessment. We make a
video of parent-child interaction where
appropriate, and give both oral and written
information and advice.
The SLT then writes a detailed report
that is sent to the parents first and then,
with their consent, distributed to the
referrer and key professionals such as the
health visitor and GP.
If families do not attend this initial
appointment we offer a second short
appointment. If this second appointment is
not attended and we are not contacted, we
discharge the child from the service and
send a discharge report to the referrer and
other key professionals where known.
We keep attendance records of these new
referral appointments. Over a five-month
period in 2003, the two busiest clinics
showed that only half the clients were
attending (table one).
This meant we were not only spending
about half our scheduled contact time
waiting for non-attenders, but we were also
completing note sheets and making up files
for children who would never enter the
service. We would then spend more time
sending second appointment letters, and
eventually writing and distributing
discharge reports.
At the beginning of 2004, we decided to
address ways of streamlining the new
referral systems to make them more
efficient and effective.
My research for this article led me to the
Department of Health (DH) website
(www.dh.gov.uk), where I found a range of
articles and directives on booking systems.
The government’s National Booked
Admissions Programme began in 1998 as
part of its strategy for modernising the NHS.
It aimed to make the NHS more accessible
and convenient. The NHS Choose and book
scheme, which offers patient choice in venue
and appointments, states that departments
should aim to reduce the non-attendance
rates, and in so doing reduce the time wasted
in chasing up appointments.
This system is mainly aimed at pressured
hospital departments, such as cardiology
where, for example, a patient needing a heart
operation can choose a hospital from up to
four, and decide when the operation is to be
carried out.
Liverpool Cardiothoracic Centre NHS
Trust has trialled this system and has even set
up a call centre to support the Choose and
book system. It states: “Booking provides
certainty and choice for the patient and they
are now effectively able to plan their date
around other commitments.”
Islington PCT has also followed DH targets
to load Choose and book software to
outpatient services across the borough,
resulting in a financial reward for completing
this huge task.
In April 2005, one Islington GP practice
became the first in the borough to use the
national Choose and book system, allowing
patients to select their own outpatient
hospital appointment using a website or call
centre. Confidentiality is assured: a password
is issued to patients ensuring that only they
can change bookings.
The DH states, “The definition of a
partially booked appointment or admission
is: The patient is given the choice of when
to attend. For partial booking the patient is
advised of the total waiting time during the
consultation between themselves and the
healthcare provider/practitioner. The
patient is able to choose and confirm their
appointment or admission approximately
four to six weeks in advance of their
appointment or admission date.” (DH,
2004).
In designing a partial booking system for
our department, we looked at other
services using similar systems. For example,
the Islington physiotherapy department
sends a letter to clients when they reach the
top of the waiting list asking them to
contact the department within three weeks
if they still require an appointment. If no
contact is made the client is discharged. A
clerical officer supports the department’s
system.
We have monitored attendance rates at the
two clinics using this new system – the results
speak for themselves (see charts one and
two).
Charts one and two show that clinic one
had on average a response rate of 61%, which
is higher than the previous non-attendance
Sarah Illingworth describes a successful partial booking scheme that gives clientsthe autonomy to book their own appointments
Table one: Attendance rates for twobusy clinics in 2003
Scheduled Average % attended
Clinic one 86 50%
Clinic two 84 46%
16-17 19/1/06 7:51 am Page 2
![Page 16: Looking to the future for children’s services · After the break-up of her marriage in the mid-1960s, for many years Bunty shared a home in Edinburgh with her widowed mother, to](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071116/5ffdee71abdf73065a24486e/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
www.rcslt.org February 2006 bulletin 1177
rate of 46%. Clinic two had on average a
response rate of 54%, which is almost the
same as the previous non-attendance rate
of 50%.
It appears that the clinics are reaching the
same number of families through the partial
booking system, but have significantly
reduced the amount of paperwork required
following up non-attendance, and made their
contact time more efficient by 50%.
As attendance has consistently reached
almost 100% for those families who
contacted the service after receiving a referral
letter, therapists can now predict attendance
and offer a second more detailed assessment
appointment almost immediately. This new
system enables us to target families who do
not contact us more quickly, giving them an
opportunity to re-engage with the service.
PositivesAttendance for appointments has risen from
45% to 100% in the past year
� The therapists in each clinic are using their
time more efficiently and have reduced
paperwork for non-attenders
� Therapists’ time is used more effectively to
target children’s needs, making their work
more rewarding
� The system is currently manageable,
despite limited administrative support from
an SLT assistant one day a week
�Having departmentally-based
administrative support means we retain
control over appointments: families who call
featureCASELOAD MANAGEMENT
in receive a more personal approach
�We now have a Bengali co-worker who can
call families where English is not the home
language
� Families have informally reported they
prefer choosing their own appointment over
the telephone, and they like the flexibility of
choosing the appointment time and new
appointments
�When parents/carers call they can discuss
the appointment usually with an experienced
SLT, so they can also receive more
information via the telephone
� The system appeals to the clinic users who
attend appointments they have scheduled
themselves
� Referrers are able to chase up families who
do not contact more quickly and have re-
referred them where necessary
Challenges
� It took a significant amount of time to get
the system up and running at the base where
the referrals are sent out
� It continues to use a significant amount of
SLT time to run this initiative, and we are
currently requesting administrative support
�We initially feared we were losing families
who do not read English; however looking
through the records this does not seem to be
the case
�We now need to follow up families who
have not made contact with the help of the
referrers and ensure the service is as
accessible as possible
Due to the success of the partial booking
system, three other clinics now use this
method. I am currently designing a scheme
to follow up families who do not contact
using Sure Start SLTs. We have also begun to
gain some written feedback from clients from
structured questionnaires given in face-to-
face interviews.
We have a lot to learn from our colleagues
working in acute speech and language
therapy services, and other professions allied
to medicine. Even if government directives
appear to focus on acute services, there are
elements we can pull out and use to our
benefit.
Any change can feel stressful and requires
much time in planning and implementation,
but as our results have shown, the benefits
can only be positive.
Finally, we are keen to hear from other
departments using similar or other systems to
share working practice.
Sarah Illingworth – SLT, Islington PCTemail: [email protected]
References:Department of Health. Choose and Book. Patient’s choice ofhospital and booked appointment. Policy Framework for Choice
and Booking at the Point of Referral. DH, August 2004.
Charts one and two: clinic attendance rates after the new booking system
Our new partial booking system is as follows
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Perc
enta
ge
Clinic 1
April
May
June July
Augu
stSe
ptembe
rOc
tober
Nove
mber
Decem
ber
Month
% Responded % Attended
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Perc
enta
ge
Clinic 2
April
May
June July
Augu
stSe
ptembe
rOc
tober
Nove
mber
Decem
ber
Month
% Responded % Attended
receipt of referral
letter sent to clientasking them to
call in to arrange anappointment
appointment made overthe telephone with a
choice of time, anddetails sent via letter
referral sent back to referrer if nocontact made, with covering letter
16-17 19/1/06 7:51 am Page 3
![Page 17: Looking to the future for children’s services · After the break-up of her marriage in the mid-1960s, for many years Bunty shared a home in Edinburgh with her widowed mother, to](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071116/5ffdee71abdf73065a24486e/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
bulletin February 2006 www.rcslt.org18
profess ional i ssues
In April 2006, the RCSLT will introduce an
online diary system for all practising
therapists and support workers. The system is
a simple electronic way of recording all CPD
activities and reflections on learning on an
ongoing basis.
The diary will minimise paperwork and
align with the Heath Profession’s Council
(HPC) and the Knowledge and Skills
Framework (KSF) processes. It includes the
HPC’s categories for CPD activities, and can
cross reference CPD activities to the KSF
dimensions and levels for those working in
NHS settings.
In addition to the recording function, the
RCSLT will be able to send email alerts on
short courses relevant to members’ location
and clinical interest. The diary will also
provide a forum for discussion on CPD
matters.
Members will be able to access the diary
via the RCSLT website. Provision will be
made for those who do not have access to the
online system, in the form of paper-based
versions of renewal forms and CPD records.
The CPD online diary: how it willhelp you record your CPD
We expect that by 2008, only a minority of
practising members will not have Internet
access.
The diary will provide the mechanism for
recording compliance with the RCSLT
standards and allow the RCSLT to undertake
random audits of CPD records. This will
make the requirement for a log and a counter
signature on renewal forms redundant.
Ultimately, online membership renewal will
be introduced to improve efficiency and save
time.
Since we launched the pilot version in
November 2005, over 100 therapists and
support workers have logged on to the
system. We hope that by the time the pilot
finishes on 16 February, we will have received
feedback from all the users. This feedback
will help us determine what, if any,
modifications need to be made before the
final version is launched via the RCSLT
website in April 2006.
How does the online diary work?Once you have registered as a user, you will
receive a password via your email address.
You log on using your email address and
password and you can then start using the
diary. You are encouraged to change your
password to something familiar at the start.
There is a short online manual, giving you a
step-by-step guide to each page.
The main page is a view of a month on a
page (see figure one).
When you click on any day, a new page
comes up on the screen and you are asked to
enter the CPD activity, the time taken and
what kind of activity it is in relation to the
HPC’s categories, eg work-based learning,
professional activity, formal educational, self
directed learning (see figure two).
Further down the page you are asked to
make reflective comments on what you have
learned. You are also prompted to make a
link with the KSF dimensions (record which
dimension the activity relates to). A list of
CPD activities are cross-referenced to the
KSF dimensions – you just need to select the
relevant one and add it to your record.
You must remember to save the record, and
In December’s Bulletin (pp20-21) we outlined the new RCSLT continuing professionaldevelopment (CPD) scheme, due to begin in April 2006. A key part of the scheme will be anonline CPD diary, which will replace the old CPD log system. This month, we explain how theelectronic diary works and how it links with the CPD toolkit
Figure one: My Diary Figure two: List My Activities
18-19 19/1/06 7:53 am Page 22
![Page 18: Looking to the future for children’s services · After the break-up of her marriage in the mid-1960s, for many years Bunty shared a home in Edinburgh with her widowed mother, to](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071116/5ffdee71abdf73065a24486e/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
www.rcslt.org February 2006 bulletin 19
profess ional i ssues
you must complete it within 45 minutes of
writing, before your login period expires (the
system automatically logs you out after 45
minutes of inactivity, for your personal
security). Once saved, all the data entered
into the diary is held on a dedicated server,
which currently keeps over 150,000 secure
CPD records. There is therefore minimal risk
of records being lost.
You can view all your CPD activities under
List Your Activities. This shows you how each
activity is linked to the HPC and KSF, how
much time you have spent on each activity,
and what your reflections on learning were. If
you want a report on the amount of time you
have spent on CPD, click on the Hours Report
and obtain a breakdown of hours spent per
year (see figure three).
The RCSLT will undertake random audits on
a sample of diaries to assess compliance with
the new RCSLT standards (see table one). If
an audit reveals a shortfall in CPD activity,
we will contact the individual concerned and
make further enquiries as to their plans for
CPD. RCSLT staff will support members who
If the HPC selects you for audit, you will
have records showing you have maintained
up-to-date and continuous records of your
CPD. Your portfolio of evidence (PDPs, audit
forms, course certificates, supervision
records, peer review forms etc) will also form
part of the submission.
What if I don’t have access to theInternet?The RCSLT anticipates that, by 2008, the
majority of therapists and support workers
will have access to the Internet either at work
or home. However, there will also be paper
records available from the RCSLT on request.
These will allow you to record similar
information. You may still be audited by the
RCSLT if your name is selected in the
random audit. If selected, you will need to
submit your paper ‘diary’ and evidence from
your CPD portfolio to the RCSLT by
registered post.
Will I get forms in the postautomatically?CPD forms will not be sent to you with your
renewal letter this year. You will have to
download the forms from the website or
request copies to be sent to you by post.
Anna van der Gaag, consultant to the RCSLT
CPD Project and an HPC Council Member. She
was on the HPC’s CPD Professional Liaison
Group, 2003-2004.
Sharon Woolf, RCSLT Head of Professional
Development.
may be experiencing difficulties with
recording their CPD.
The new CPD scheme is mandatory for
RCSLT members. The online facility will
support members in recording the CPD they
have to undertake to maintain their HPC
registration and for their employers’
requirements. Wherever possible, the RCSLT
will support members in meeting their
requirements.
How does the online diary link tothe toolkit?The RCSLT toolkit contains guidance and
forms for various work-based CPD activities.
When you use one of these forms, record the
activity in your online diary (type, time, date,
etc). You may or may not choose to write
reflective notes in the dairy – it depends
whether you have them on your form as well.
Store the form itself in your CPD portfolio
together with your personal development
plan (PDP), course certificates, book reviews,
KSF post outline, audit forms, CV, etc. You
can, of course, also store these electronically.
Figure three: The Hours Report
Become an online
diary local championWe need SLTs and support workers to join a
network of online diary enthusiasts.
As a local champion, you can help colleagues
who are new to using the diary.
Email: [email protected] to express your interest
Standard 1: Amount of CPD Undertake a minimum of 30 hours CPD per year (for full-time SLTs) (excluding mandatory training)
Standard 2: Type of CPD Undertake a mix of CPD activities (work- based, formal, self directed, professional activity)
Standard 3: Record of CPD activities Maintain an up-to-date record of CPD activities
Standard 4: Reflective account of Maintain an up-to-date record of the impact of CPD outcome of learning (impact on practice)
Table one: New RCSLT CPD Standards from April 2006
18-19 19/1/06 7:53 am Page 23
![Page 19: Looking to the future for children’s services · After the break-up of her marriage in the mid-1960s, for many years Bunty shared a home in Edinburgh with her widowed mother, to](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071116/5ffdee71abdf73065a24486e/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
bulletin February 2006 www.rcslt.org20
ask your co l leagues
Any Questions?Want some information? Why not ask your colleagues?
Prioritising adult servicesDo you have examples of effective prioritisation systems for
adult in- and outpatient caseloads or innovative models of
service delivery?
Lisa Ferrary
T E L : 01708 708343
E M A I L : [email protected]
Stroke care pathwayAdvice wanted on putting together a stroke care pathway on
a stroke unit.
Rebecca Hooper
T E L : 029 2071 5569
Viscometer and fluidsHave you used a viscometer to standardise fluid
consistencies or ensure consistent, correct thickening of
fluids at ward level?
Paula Rogers
T E L : 00 353 1 4162471
E M A I L : [email protected]
Long-term PEG Has anybody produced a leaflet for anxious relatives of
patients who are long-term PEG fed?
Jenny Boulter
T E L : 029 2031 3733
E M A I L : [email protected]
Priority rating scale Do you use a priority rating scale for clients with learning
disability in residential settings?
Gill Garvani
E M A I L : [email protected]
NQT pay scalesWe want to contact other NQTs who have been assimilated
onto Agenda for Change and are now on transitional pay
scales, as opposed to the minimum band 5 point. Has
preceptorship been affected by not being on the main scale?
How have you reacted to being at least one point behind
peers who started on AfC?
Shelagh Benford
Charlotte Mustoe
E M A I L : [email protected]
Caseload weighting toolHas anyone used the Nottingham caseload weighting tool?
Has it been adapted for SLTs? Or do you know of any other
caseload weighting tool?
Hilary Cowan
E M A I L : [email protected]
Paediatric assessmentsPaediatric speech and language assessments wanted,
including the CELF-P, CELF-3, STAP and RAPT?
Hannah Richards
E M A I L : [email protected]
ALD and accessible informationWhat are your local practices on using accessible
information when working in adult learning disability?
Helen Kirton
T E L : 01793 646980
E M A I L : [email protected]
Adult dysphasia care pathwaysIs anyone using care pathways for any adult client groups
other than stammering – specifically dysphasia?
Gayle McCormack
T E L : 01481 725 241 etx 4188
E M A I L : [email protected]
Prioritising referralsDoes anyone have a successful system for prioritisation of
adult neurological community referrals? What criteria do
you use?
Anne Baggs
T E L : 01625 661885
E M A I L : [email protected]
Email your brief query to [email protected]. RCSLT also holds a database of clinical advisers who may be able to help.Contact the information department, tel: 0207 378 3012. You can also use the RCSLT’s website forum to post your questionsor replies to other queries, visit: www.rcslt.org/forum
Question- Book reviews Feb 06 19/1/06 8:07 am Page 19
![Page 20: Looking to the future for children’s services · After the break-up of her marriage in the mid-1960s, for many years Bunty shared a home in Edinburgh with her widowed mother, to](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071116/5ffdee71abdf73065a24486e/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
www.rcslt.org February 2006 bulletin 2211
book reviews
Mental Health Aspects of Autism andAsperger SyndromeMOHAMMED GHAZIUDDINJessica Kingsley, 2005£13.95ISBN: 1-84310-727-9
B O O K O F T H E M O N T H
Book ReviewsAdult Cochlear ImplantRehabilitationKAREN PEDLEY, ELLEN GILES, ANTHONY
HOGAN (eds)
Whurr, 2005
£35
ISBN: 1-86156-321-3
This book contains much to help
SLTs learn about cochlear implants
(CI) and should be acquired by CI
teams for reference. Although the
title indicates that the target
caseload is adult, there is also
background information for a
paediatric population.
The editors document the ‘taken
for granted’ clearly and methodically, and
expand into new territory. There is an
excellent series of appendices, which support
the text and guide the clinician. The intention
is to make hearing rehabilitation with CI
recipients transparent, logical and coherent
with programmes that have a clear beginning,
a robust middle and a sensitive end. They
have introduced some innovative procedures
suited to the needs of adult CI recipients.
Using the materials in this book should
enable clinicians, whatever their level of
experience, to work out where each client
needs to start in their programme of
rehabilitation, and to set goals. This book
covers every step of the CI process in an
orderly fashion, from assessment through
‘switch-on’, to the traditional components of
aural rehabilitation and the less traditional
and vitally important area of psychosocial
support.
ALISON PEASGOOD
RCSLT Adviser, deafness and cochlear implants
In a Strange LandROBIN J REID
Athena Press, 2004
£10.99
ISBN: 1-84401-203-4
This book is a painstaking account of the
author’s experience of cancer from symptom
presentation, through diagnosis to
rehabilitation. No detail is omitted
as he tells his story interlaced with
his professional, medical and
social background against a
backdrop of his increasing faith.
Denial is initially
replaced by shock
and subsequent
acceptance of the cancer
diagnosis, followed by
increasing awareness of what
this will mean in terms of
treatment and future quality of
life.
The emotional cost of
encounters with individual
members of the multidisciplinary
team and other hospital employees makes
telling reading. Determined to be totally
honest, he spares no punches in telling it as it
was. Our profession, as well as Macmillan
Cancer Relief professionals and the National
Association of Laryngectomy Clubs emerge
This book provides a comprehensive
overview of pervasive developmental
disorders (PDD), which include autism and
Asperger syndrome. It then discusses
mental health issues related to this
population group in terms of possible
causes, incidence where known, symptoms,
current treatments and possible outcomes.
References support each chapter and there
are short case studies throughout.
The author stresses the need to tease out
the core features of PDD presenting in a
person and what behaviours are due to an
additional mental health issue. He also
supports the use of a multidisciplinary
approach both in assessment and
treatment.
The book is an overview and the author
highlights the areas where more research is
with credit; unfortunately the
same cannot be said for all.
Anyone coming into contact
with cancer patients: managers,
consultants, receptionists, would
benefit from reading this book,
though the author does not fit
the usual profile. While those
touched by this disease may draw comfort
from reading pre-selected passages, the
detailed account may be overly explicit for
others. Nonetheless, speech and language
therapy departments offering a specialist
service to laryngectomy patients might like to
have a copy available as a useful resource.
YVONNE EDELS
Macmillan consultant SLT - surgical voice
restoration,
Charing Cross
Hospital
needed. One area most involving SLTs is
supporting people with learning disabilities
who are at an increased risk of experiencing
mental health problems. A high proportion
of individuals with classic autism also have
learning disability, hence the importance of
this book.
The book is clearly laid out and easy to
read. It is a text one can dip into and
should be read by all professionals and
carers working with this population.
KATE EVANS
Specialist SLT, Adults with learning difficulties
with behaviours that challenge services
RCSLT adviser, ALD and challenging behaviour
R E A D A B I L I T Y:*****
VA L U E :
***** C O N T E N T S :
*****
R E A D A B I L I T Y:*****
VA L U E :
***** C O N T E N T S :
*****
R E A D A B I L I T Y:*****
VA L U E :
*****C O N T E N T S :
*****
Question- Book reviews Feb 06 19/1/06 10:00 am Page 20
![Page 21: Looking to the future for children’s services · After the break-up of her marriage in the mid-1960s, for many years Bunty shared a home in Edinburgh with her widowed mother, to](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071116/5ffdee71abdf73065a24486e/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
bulletin February 2006 www.rcslt.org22
Opinion p iece
I must begin by saying I am by no means
experienced in the area of dyslexia and bow
to superior knowledge in an instant. So, it is
with caution I write this discussion piece.
It started as a letter to the editor in the
hope that other therapists were disgruntled
or inspired by Channel 4’s ‘The dyslexia
myth’ programme, aired in September 2005.
I really wanted to know what other people
think, get some answers to questions the
programme didn’t answer and to try and
fully understand the proposed notions.
As the title suggests, recent research has
called the very concept of dyslexia into
question. The first problem I encountered
with the programme was that it seemed to
define dyslexia solely as a reading difficulty,
and did not include the other symptoms that
children with dyslexia frequently have, such
as spelling and writing difficulties.
It has always been my belief that dyslexia is
generally accepted as difficulties with reading
and writing skills. A child may not be able to
recognise letters and the sounds they
represent, be able to reproduce them in their
writing, or work out what sounds go where
in simple words that follow phonemic rules.
A collection of identifiable symptoms lead
to the diagnosis of dyslexia and, with luck, a
child will receive additional help to improve
their skills in this area. Currently,
phonological awareness skills are believed to
underpin such difficulties and that
remediating weaknesses here will help to
improve literacy development.
Another criteria used to mark out a child
with dyslexia, is that all other skills in the
child are developing within or above the
average range. It is solely the area of literacy
development that is peppered with some, or
Putting the ‘dyslexiamyth’ under thespotlight
all, of the associated problems.
The programme, however, suggested a
child with an average or high IQ with reading
difficulties has exactly the same type of
difficulties as a child with a low IQ and
reading difficulties. Therefore, IQ should not
be used to separate out these two sets of
children or to categorise reading difficulties.
However, by simultaneously widening (all
reading difficulties) and restricting (ignoring
writing and spelling etc) the definition,
various subtleties in presentation are lost and
what might be considered atypical learning is
instead grouped with slower learning
patterns.
If a child with a lower than average IQ has
reading difficulties compared to the age
average, but which are in line with their
overall skills, is this a reading difficulty? If a
child with a lower than average IQ has
reading skills significantly lower than their
ability, then is this the same reading
difficulty?
And what about a child of average ability
who has a reading age above their
chronological age, if asked to spell ‘flight’, can
easily say the letters to spell this word but, if
asked to write them down, writes ‘fhlgt’. This
child may make similar mistakes when
reading simple words, and struggles from
time to time ‘sounding out’ simple words.
This is not a reading difficulty according to
the programme, since this child performs at
an above average rate. So what is it then?
For me, it is impossible to separate reading
ability from all other aspects of literacy
development. Atypical skills are the key to
identifying recognisable patterns of
difficulties and this is the difference between
delay and disorder.
For children identified with reading
difficulties by the researchers a
comprehensive and intensive, programme
was devised and all the children were
reported as making significant progress in
their reading skills. However, writing and
spelling were ignored in the discussion.
Perhaps we are to assume these will improve
automatically?
In my opinion, all children benefit from
additional intensive one-to-one input in any
area of weakness. The fact that two sets of
children (one set with low IQ and the other
with average or above) improved in their
reading ability should not be used as a means
to redefine or disregard the term dyslexia.
It is right and proper to challenge our
beliefs and understandings about dyslexia,
but by ignoring all the other aspects that
feature in the profile of dyslexia, the
programme makers have failed to provide a
rounded argument to support their idea that
dyslexia doesn’t exist.
The consequences of such a programme
are potentially damaging to people who have
had to fight for their very obvious difficulties
to be recognised and to the resources which
have been allocated to help address their
problems in education, etc. The positive
outcome is to highlight the benefits of
teaching literacy skills properly and the
difference funding can make to all children in
schools, where resources can be deployed
effectively.
Laura Seeley voices her opinion about a recent TV programme on the ‘dyslexia myth’
Laura Seeleyemail: [email protected]: www.channel4.com/news/microsites/D/dyslexia_myth/dyslexia.html
Opinion 19/1/06 7:56 am Page 22
![Page 22: Looking to the future for children’s services · After the break-up of her marriage in the mid-1960s, for many years Bunty shared a home in Edinburgh with her widowed mother, to](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071116/5ffdee71abdf73065a24486e/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Speci f i c Interest Group not ices
National SIG Bilingualism (UKRI7)
23 February, 10.30am – 3.30pm (rescheduled
conference)
Working with and valuing diversity – A conference
exploring diversity, culture, religion and language
and exploring good practice. Key note speakers:
Ali Jan Haider, Head of Equality and Diversity,
Bradford City PCT and Mohammed Arshad,
Muslim Chaplain, Bradford Hospitals.
Midland Hotel, Bradford, West Yorkshire
Cost: assistants £30/SLT SIG Bilingualism
members £45/SLT non-members £55 (includes
two course buffet lunch)
Contact Christina Quinn, tel: 01274 877372,
email: [email protected]
Oxford Voice and Laryngectomy SIG (E31)
1 March 9.30am - 4pm
Transsexual voice therapy. Presentations on Pitch
surgery and pre and post SLT involvement; A
personal perspective of voice therapy and Policies
and guidelines.
Horton Lecture Theatre, Horton Hospital,
Banbury OX16 9AL
Cost: members free/non-members £15
Contact Penny Taylor or Elaine Coker, tel: 01604
545737, email:
The Yorkshire Region Aphasiology Group
(YRAG) (N37)
6 March, 2pm - 5pm
The Comprehensive Aphasia Test (CAT), Dr David
Howard, University of Newcastle.
The Psychology Department, University of York
Contact Tess Ackerman, tel: 0113 3921538, email:
Speech Disorders SIG - London (L27)
9 March, 3pm - 5pm
Second meeting, includes presentation on
PROMPT by SIG members.
The Nuffield Hearing and Speech Centre, Royal
National Throat Nose and Ear Hospital, Grays Inn
Road, London, WC1X 8DA
Cost: £10 annual subscription
Contact Shula Burrows, tel: 020 7915 1534, email:
SIG Disorders of Fluency – Affiliated to the
National SIG in Dysfluency (UKRI6)
10 March, 9.30am - 12.30pm
Listening Activities, Karen Lawrie. General
discussions on: Care pathways and discharge
criteria and Quantitative and qualitative measures.
PM: planning for the 2006 residential week.
Tadacaster Health Centre, North Yorkshire
Cost: Free
Contact Eileen Hope, tel: 01756 792233 ext 208,
email: [email protected]
Medico Legal SIG (UKRI13)
17 March, 10am - 4pm
Medico Legal issues related to SENDIST, Robert
Love, expert solicitor in education law from
Langley Wellington Solicitors.
The Palace Hotel, Buxton, Derbyshire
Cost: members £40/non members
£70/membership for the year £25
Contact Alison Hodson, tel: 07834 486488 or
email: [email protected]
SIG Working with Offenders (UKRI11)
17 March, 9.30am - 3.30pm
Study day and AGM. Consent - legal issues and
general aspects, two speakers, case studies and
workshop discussion.
Brooklands, Marston Green, Coleshill
Cost: members free/non-members £10 for the
day, or £12 for the day and membership
Contact Samantha Hill, tel: 07816 837016,
email: [email protected]
London Special Interest Group in ASD
22 March, 1pm - 4.30pm
Novel sociocognitive assessments as predictors of later
communication disorders and Promoting research in
SLT, Penny Roy, Shula Chiat and others.
Mary Sheridan Centre for Child Health,
5 Duggard Way, off Renfrew Road,
London SE11 4TH
Cost: members free/non-members £7.50/£15 to
join (optional)
Contact Penny Williams, tel: 020 7414 1431, email:
Trent Voice SIG (C10)
23 March, 9am - 4.30pm
New to voice study day - ideal for recently qualified
therapists or those new to voice work.
Patient and Friend’s Lounge, Tickhill Road
Hospital, Doncaster
Cost: members £20/non-members £30
Contact Kerry Healy/Anna White, tel: 01302
553178, email: [email protected]
SIG Aphasia Therapy (E24)
24 March, 10am - 4pm
Sentence processing, Jane Marshall.
RCSLT, 2 White Hart Yard, London SE1 1NX
Cost: members £30/non-members £40
(includes lunch)
Contact Debbie Stanton, tel: 01245 514190,
email: [email protected]
Managers SIG (C22)
30 March, 9.30am - 4pm
Speech and language therapy managers and the law
Room B702, Baker Building, University Central
England, Perry Barr, Birmingham
Cost: £20 includes membership. Cheques payable
to “Speech and Language Therapy Managers SIG”
Contact Helen Anderson, SLT Dept, Residence III,
North Staffs Maternity Hospital, Hilton Road,
Stoke-on-Trent, Staffs ST4 6SD, tel: 01782
552485/6, email: helenj.anderson@nsch-
tr.wmids.nhs.uk
SIG Cleft Palate and Craniofacial Anomalies
(National) (UKRI1)
5 April, 10am - 4pm
Study day and AGM. Reports on early intervention
with cleft palate and craniofacial children, Kathy
Chapman, Associate Professor of S&L Pathology,
University of Utah.
Management Development Centre, Aston
University, Birmingham
Cost: bookings prior to 24/2/06: Craniofacial
Society member £50/non-CFS member £60.
Booking after 24/2/06: CFS member £75/non-CFS
member £85
Contact Alison Jeremy, tel: 0121 333 9387 or
email: [email protected]
East Midlands Specific Language Impairment
SIG (C28)
6 April, 9.30am - 12.30pm (NB change of time)
Second SIG meeting: Diagnosing SLI;
Communicating about SLI; Outcome measurement.
Cecil Roberts Room, Nottingham Central Library,
Angel Row, Nottingham
Members £2/non-members £5
Contact Elaine Hirst, tel: 0115 942 8631, email:
Acquired Brain Injury in Children and
Adolescents SIG (E32)
27 April, 9.30am - 4.30pm
The journey from acute to community: Working with
children and adolescents following acquired brain
injury. A workshop for SLTs, SENCOs and
teachers, including guest speaker: Sue Walker on
ABI in schools.
Cost: £25 (inc lunch). Closing date for bookings,
15 March 2006
The Evelina Children’s Hospital, St Thomas’
Hospital, London
Contact Yamini Burgul, tel: 0207 188 3992, email:
To advertise your RCSLT-registered SIG
event for free send your notice by email
only in the following format:
Name of group and registration
number, Date and time of event,
Address of event, Title of event and
speakers, costs, contact details
Details may be edited
Send to: [email protected] by the
beginning of the month before
publication. For example, by Monday 1
February 2005 for the March Bulletin.
www.rcslt.org February 2006 bulletin 23
SIG 19/1/06 7:57 am Page 21
![Page 23: Looking to the future for children’s services · After the break-up of her marriage in the mid-1960s, for many years Bunty shared a home in Edinburgh with her widowed mother, to](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022071116/5ffdee71abdf73065a24486e/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
2006 Bulletin Supplement advertising schedule
To advertise in the Bulletin contact Katy Eggleton, tel: 0207 878 2344
Issue Date Booking and copy Expected to reach SLTs on:by midday on:
mid-Feb 2006 2 Feb 2006 15 Feb 2006
March 2006 14 Feb 2006 1 Mar 2006
mid-Mar 2006 2 Mar 2006 15 Mar 2006
April 2006 16 Mar 2006 1 Apr 2006
mid-Apr 2006 31 Mar 2006 15 Apr 2006
May 2006 19 Apr 2006 30 Apr 2006
mid-May 2006 3 May 2006 14 May 2006
June 2006 16 May 2006 1 Jun 2006
mid-Jun 2006 1 Jun 2006 15 Jun 2006
July 2006 15 Jun 2006 1 Jul 2006
mid-Jul 2006 3 Jul 2006 15 Jul 2006
August 2006 17 Jul 2006 1 Aug 2006
mid-Aug 2006 2 Aug 2006 15 Aug 2006
September 2006 14 Aug 2006 1 Sept 2006
mid-Sept 2006 4 Sept 2006 15 Sept 2006
October 2006 18 Sept 2006 1 Oct 2006
mid-Oct 2006 4 Oct 2006 15 Oct 2006
November 2006 18 Oct 2006 1 Nov 2006
mid-Nov 2006 3 Nov 2006 15 Nov 2006
December 2006 17 Nov 2006 1 Dec 2006
mid-Dec 2006 2 Dec 2006 15 Dec 2006
Please note New ad rates for 2006:Recruitment £23 per single column centimetre. Courses £21 per single column centimetreFull page discounted to £2,10010% Surcharge on all 3-column adverts. Agency Commission 10%We only accept digital copy. Bromides are not accepted
Column Sizes 1=42mm 2=90mm 3=136mm 4=188mm
To make a Supplement booking or for further information please call Sophie Duffin, tel: 020 7878 2312
Back page jan06 19/1/06 7:58 am Page 1