long-term fusion vision, strategy, and...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Rolefirefusionpower.org/NAS_PPPL_Fusion_Strategy_Zarnst... · 2018-04-12 · Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Role M.C. Zarnstorff PPPL](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022043005/5f89b388b9d45839513442ea/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Long-termFusionVision,Strategy,andRoleM.C.Zarnstorff
PPPL
PresentedtotheNASCommi7eeforaStrategicPlanforUSBurningPlasmaResearch
April11,2018
![Page 2: Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Rolefirefusionpower.org/NAS_PPPL_Fusion_Strategy_Zarnst... · 2018-04-12 · Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Role M.C. Zarnstorff PPPL](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022043005/5f89b388b9d45839513442ea/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
PerspecFveson:1. StatusofUSresearchsupporFngburningplasmascience
2. PPPLplansthatmightstrengthenoraccelerateUSresearchinburningplasmascience
3. StrategicelementssupporFngalong-termvisionforUSfusionenergyresearchandpromoteleadershipinthefield
BuildingonthetalkbyR.J.HawrylukinAus9n,TX
Outline
2
![Page 3: Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Rolefirefusionpower.org/NAS_PPPL_Fusion_Strategy_Zarnst... · 2018-04-12 · Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Role M.C. Zarnstorff PPPL](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022043005/5f89b388b9d45839513442ea/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
• StrongparFcipaFoninITERisthebestapproachtodevelopburningplasmaresearch,technology,andunderstanding- advancetofusionenergyresearch
• InnovaFonisrequiredtoimprovefusionenergyprospectsinUS- reducesize,cost,andincreaseefficiency,reliabilityofburningplasma- examples:liquidmetals,compacttokamaks(ST)andstellarators,HTS,advancedmaterials…- advancetowardscommercialfusionpower
• BothprovideopportuniFesforUSleadership
Summary
3
![Page 4: Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Rolefirefusionpower.org/NAS_PPPL_Fusion_Strategy_Zarnst... · 2018-04-12 · Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Role M.C. Zarnstorff PPPL](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022043005/5f89b388b9d45839513442ea/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
• ITERistheUSfacilityforburningplasmaresearch- ConstrucFoniswellalong- Benefitsfromworld-wideeffortandinvestment
• USparFcipaFoninscienceandtechnologydevelopment- TrainingofUSpersonnelinallaspects- SignificantUSleadership
• ThruITER:jointownershipofresults,IPrights,experFse
--ThescienceandtechnologyfromITERwillinformallmagne9c-confinementapproaches
USBurningPlasmaResearchisCenteredonITER
4
![Page 5: Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Rolefirefusionpower.org/NAS_PPPL_Fusion_Strategy_Zarnst... · 2018-04-12 · Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Role M.C. Zarnstorff PPPL](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022043005/5f89b388b9d45839513442ea/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
• ITERdesignislargelyfixed,candidateQ=10scenariosidenFfied- SteadystateQ=5scenarioissFllbeinginvesFgated
• PPPLleadingUSdiagnosFcdesignanddevelopmentCriFcalforITER’sresearchcapabilityAreaofUSleadership&responsibility,includingportdesign
• Developvalidatedapproachesforhigh-prioritytopics- DisrupFonsandrunawayelectronbeams- Edgeinstability(ELM)suppression- Power-exhaustwidth
StatusofUSBurningPlasmaResearchAcFviFes
5
![Page 6: Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Rolefirefusionpower.org/NAS_PPPL_Fusion_Strategy_Zarnst... · 2018-04-12 · Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Role M.C. Zarnstorff PPPL](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022043005/5f89b388b9d45839513442ea/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
• SciDAC-CenterforTokamakTransientSimulaFons(PPPLledcollab.)- 3DsimulaFonoftokamakdisrupFonswithconducFngwall- DisrupFondynamics,sha7eredpelletmiFgaFon,connecttoengr.
• SciDAC-SCREAMonrunawayelectronmodeling(PPPLledcollab.)- Newresults:generaFon&sca7eringbyWhistlerwaves- AppearstoexplainpuzzlingexperimentalobservaFons- ITERimplicaFonsnotyetevaluated
• Deep-learningpre-disrupFontriggerformiFgaFon(Internalfunding)• Rail-gunlaunchedpelletmiFgaFon,forhotplasmaedge(Internalfunding,withU.Washington)
DisrupFon&RunawayElectronMiFgaFon
6
![Page 7: Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Rolefirefusionpower.org/NAS_PPPL_Fusion_Strategy_Zarnst... · 2018-04-12 · Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Role M.C. Zarnstorff PPPL](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022043005/5f89b388b9d45839513442ea/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
EdgeInstabilityControlWindowUnderstood
715
Locking threshold exceeded
Non-resonant 3D perturbations
Suppression threshold
met
IPEC Prediction of stability Space
Experimental Validation of Model
access to “hidden window”
Prediction of No Locking Window of ELM Suppression Validated in Experiment !
• BuildingonexperimentsatDIII-DandNSTX
• ControlofKSTARedge
stabilityusing3-rowsofperturbaFoncoilsatedge
• Varyamplitudeandtoroidalphaseofmiddlerowsofcoils
• QuanFtaFvevalidaFon
oftheoreFcalmodelforedgeinstabiliFescontrol
Suppressionthresholdmet
![Page 8: Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Rolefirefusionpower.org/NAS_PPPL_Fusion_Strategy_Zarnst... · 2018-04-12 · Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Role M.C. Zarnstorff PPPL](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022043005/5f89b388b9d45839513442ea/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
2MA NSTX-U
• IniFallyunderstoodthruheurisFcdrie-model(PPPL)
• PredicFonforITER:<1mmheatfluxwidth=>veryhighheatflux
• XGC1(PPPL)reproducesdata
variaFon,butpredictsturbulencebroadensITER.Isthiscorrect?
• NSTX-Uwilltestbroadening&miFgaFonbyfluxexpansion
DivertorHeat-Flux
8
Powerexhaustwidth(mm)
C-Mod
RangeofNSTX-UprojecFons
![Page 9: Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Rolefirefusionpower.org/NAS_PPPL_Fusion_Strategy_Zarnst... · 2018-04-12 · Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Role M.C. Zarnstorff PPPL](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022043005/5f89b388b9d45839513442ea/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
9
2.AcceleratePreparaFonsforBurningPlasmaScience:IntegratedModeling
IntegraFonFramework
Plasma-MaterialInteracFon
HeaFng&Fueling
Large-scaleInstabiliFes
EnergeFcParFcles
Tight/loosecouplingmethods
Mul$-scale$meadvance
Core model
Edge model
• HighfidelityintegratedmodelofburningplasmathruDOEExascaleProj.• IniFalfocus:core-edgeFghtintegraFon,buildingonSciDACmodels
SeetalkbyA.Bha7acharjee
tokamaks&
stellarators
PPPL(lead),ANL,LLNL,ORNL,Rutgers,U.Texas,UC-Boulder
![Page 10: Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Rolefirefusionpower.org/NAS_PPPL_Fusion_Strategy_Zarnst... · 2018-04-12 · Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Role M.C. Zarnstorff PPPL](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022043005/5f89b388b9d45839513442ea/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
• Reducedfidelity,faster,integratedmodelsunderdevelopment- ForpredicFvemodelingofproposedexperiments- ForrouFneanalysisofdata- Verifiedwithhigh-fidelitymodels- Validatedoncurrentexperiments,includingDIII-DandNSTX-U
• Especiallyimportantforhighpressure(β)andbootstrap-currentforlong-pulseexperiments,duetonon-linearevoluFonofequilibrium
• SimilareffortsstarFngforstellarators
PreparingProducFonWhole-DeviceModels
10
![Page 11: Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Rolefirefusionpower.org/NAS_PPPL_Fusion_Strategy_Zarnst... · 2018-04-12 · Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Role M.C. Zarnstorff PPPL](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022043005/5f89b388b9d45839513442ea/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Example:NSTX-Uisstudyingα-parFcleinstabiliFesapplicabletoITER
Conventional Beam-heated tokamaks
α-heatedconventional aspect
ratio tokamaks(ITER, DEMO)
α-heatedSphericalTokamaks
Beam-heatedNSTX-U
0
2
4
6
0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5
β fast/β total~ (EP-instability drive)/(EP-instability damping)
NSTX-U: Fast-ion dynamic range spanning ST and conventional A burning plasma regime
Vary beam pitch angle, pressure profile à Assess mode stability as a function of ion phase space
NSTX-U will: • assess confinement
of fast-ions in high-performance ST regimes
• extend predictive capabilities for energetic particle dynamics in burning plasma regime
![Page 12: Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Rolefirefusionpower.org/NAS_PPPL_Fusion_Strategy_Zarnst... · 2018-04-12 · Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Role M.C. Zarnstorff PPPL](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022043005/5f89b388b9d45839513442ea/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
• ITERisaphysicsandtechnologyexperimentWillprovideknowledge&experienceforfusionenergyresearch
• Asinthe2004NRCBurningPlasmaReport,ITERisnotaprototypeforacommercialpowerreactorintheUS- Needhigherperformanceforsizeandcost
• NextstepsbasedonITERarelargerandlikelymoreexpensive,e.g.EUDEMO
3.Long-termVisiontowardFusionEnergy
12
EU DEMOpulsed-ind.
R0 (m) 9.0a (m) 2.5BT (T) 6.5IP (MA) 16.8fBoot 36%β 2.6%H98,y2 1.0Pthermal 2.2 GWNet Pelectic
500 MW
![Page 13: Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Rolefirefusionpower.org/NAS_PPPL_Fusion_Strategy_Zarnst... · 2018-04-12 · Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Role M.C. Zarnstorff PPPL](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022043005/5f89b388b9d45839513442ea/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
• Insomecountries,fusionwillbedevelopedbytheirgovernment• US:developmentofcommercialfusionwillbeledbyindustry- Roleofgovernmentistoenablebydevelopingunderlyingscience- Enableviapublic-privatepartnerships
• Interestbystart-upcompaniesveryimportantSignofsuccessindevelopingscienFficandtechnicalbasisforfusion- Assessmentthatgapsprobablycanbeclosed- Buildsonworld-wideexperiments(allkinds)andITER
• FocusonprioriFzingandresolvingrisks- Atminimumscale(cost)andonarapidFmescale
USRoutetoCommercialFusion
13
![Page 14: Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Rolefirefusionpower.org/NAS_PPPL_Fusion_Strategy_Zarnst... · 2018-04-12 · Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Role M.C. Zarnstorff PPPL](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022043005/5f89b388b9d45839513442ea/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
IndustryRequests• Safety• Long-termeconomicallycompeFFve• RapidconstrucFonandmoderatecapitalcostperunit• Licensingsimplicity• Reliability,availability,maintainability,inspectability(RAMI)• Steadystate,withload-following(quickshutdown/restart)• Publicacceptance- Noneedforwide-areaevacuaFon
Notthesameapproachassomeofourinterna9onalpartners
14
AeerEPRI,LIFEAdv.Commi7ee
![Page 15: Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Rolefirefusionpower.org/NAS_PPPL_Fusion_Strategy_Zarnst... · 2018-04-12 · Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Role M.C. Zarnstorff PPPL](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022043005/5f89b388b9d45839513442ea/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
• Robust,reliableoperaFon–eliminatedisrupFonsand“offnormalevents”- ThinfirstwallforT-breeding
• MoreefficientproducFonofenergyanduseofplant- Higherfusionpowerdensity=>higherβand/orB- LessrecirculaFngpower
• Smallerunitsizethan1GWe,especiallyduringdevelopment
• Robustpowerhandlingwithreducedmaintenance• Simplify,probablybyeliminaFonofsomesub-systems
• Needlong-livedmaterials,toreducemaintenance(esp.divertor)
ImplicaFons:InnovaFonisNeeded
15
![Page 16: Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Rolefirefusionpower.org/NAS_PPPL_Fusion_Strategy_Zarnst... · 2018-04-12 · Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Role M.C. Zarnstorff PPPL](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022043005/5f89b388b9d45839513442ea/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
• Liquid-metalboundaries(seeM.Jaworski)- Highpower-flux,eliminateerosion,allowslow-Zwallandhigherconfinement (NSTX-U,EAST?)
• Sphericaltokamak(seeS.Gerhardt)- Morecompact,highβ,highermagneFcfielduFlizaFon,lowercapitalcost (NSTX-U&MAST-U)
• Higherefficiencycurrentdrive- Helicon-waveandinsidelaunchlower-hybridcurrent-drive(DIII-D&KSTAR)
• Compactstellarators/3D-Tokamaks(commi7ee’steleconference)- EliminatedisrupFons,eliminatecurrent-drive;highβ,highdensity,highgain (USled,but?)
InnovaFonOpportuniFes
16
![Page 17: Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Rolefirefusionpower.org/NAS_PPPL_Fusion_Strategy_Zarnst... · 2018-04-12 · Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Role M.C. Zarnstorff PPPL](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022043005/5f89b388b9d45839513442ea/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
• HTSmagnets(seeM.Greenwald,S.Prestemon)- HigherB,highercurrentdensity,enablescompactconfiguraFons- Mayallowsimplercoildesign
• Advancedmaterials- Longerlife,higherstrengthathightemperature- Reducemaintenance,increaseavailability,increasethermalconv.efficiency
• UsevalidatedsimulaFontoguideextrapolaFon(SeeA.Bha7acharjee)- Reducerisks
• Aimata“pilotplant”(seeJ.Menard)- AddressintegraFonrisksatmodestscale- ThenmaturetechnologyandoperaFngexperiencetogether- IfinnovaFonsachievehighQ,net-powerproducFoniseasierthanlife-FmetesFng
PPPLisexploringmanyofthesepoten9alinnova9onswiththecommunity.
InnovaFonOpportuniFesII
17
![Page 18: Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Rolefirefusionpower.org/NAS_PPPL_Fusion_Strategy_Zarnst... · 2018-04-12 · Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Role M.C. Zarnstorff PPPL](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022043005/5f89b388b9d45839513442ea/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
• DuringITERconstrucFonandburningplasmaoperaFon:- ExploreandmatureinnovaFons- A7emptmulF-innovaFonintegraFon,increasingTRL- ValidatemodelsforsimulaFon
• AssesscombinedresultsfromITERandinnovaFonsinmodeledprojecFons
• Goforwardwhenprojectedsystemsarecompelling,andaddresscommercialneeds- PilotPlantassmallascredible,toreducerisks,buildconfidence
StrategywithITER:InnovateinParallel
18
![Page 19: Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Rolefirefusionpower.org/NAS_PPPL_Fusion_Strategy_Zarnst... · 2018-04-12 · Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Role M.C. Zarnstorff PPPL](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022043005/5f89b388b9d45839513442ea/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
• USoutofITER:lossoftechnicalexperFse,experience,momentum- MissediteraFonwilldelayUSadvancetoburningplasmaresearch- RecoverbyexploringandmaturinginnovaFons;integraFng
• AssessresultsfrominnovaFonscombinedwithworld’sexperimentsinmodeledprojecFons,butwillnothavefullITERknowledge
• Goforwardwhenprojectedsystemsarecompelling,moFvatefunds- RecoverburningplasmaexperFseandexperience- MayuseinnovaFonstopartnerwithotherprogramspost-ITER- PilotPlantassmallascredible,toreducerisks,buildconfidence
StrategywithoutITER:Innovate
19
![Page 20: Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Rolefirefusionpower.org/NAS_PPPL_Fusion_Strategy_Zarnst... · 2018-04-12 · Long-term Fusion Vision, Strategy, and Role M.C. Zarnstorff PPPL](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022043005/5f89b388b9d45839513442ea/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
• StrongparFcipaFoninITERisthebestapproachtodevelopburningplasmaresearch,technology,andunderstanding- advancetofusionenergyresearch
• InnovaFonisrequiredtoimprovefusionenergyprospectsinUS- reducesize,cost,andincreaseefficiency,reliabilityofburningplasma- examples:liquidmetals,compacttokamaks(ST)andstellarators,HTS,advancedmaterials…- advancetowardscommercialfusionpower
• BothprovideopportuniFesforUSleadership
Summary
20