living religion in northern ireland:
DESCRIPTION
Living Religion in Northern Ireland:. Experiences of People of Faith Minorities in a Christian Majority Landscape. By Dr Gladys Ganiel. Part of the IRCHSS-funded research project To be completed over three years (2009-2011) Marks Centenary of 1910 Missionary Conference - PowerPoint PPT PresentationTRANSCRIPT
Trinity College Dublin
Living Religion in Northern Ireland:
Experiences of People of Faith Minorities in a Christian Majority Landscape.
By Dr Gladys Ganiel
Trinity College Dublin
•Part of the IRCHSS-funded research project•To be completed over three years (2009-2011)•Marks Centenary of 1910 Missionary Conference•Surveys, sociological case studies, theological reflection
Trinity College Dublin
Tonight’s TalkFocus on data related to ‘Faith Minorities’Data from 2009 SurveysData from 2010 Case Study
Trinity College Dublin
Purpose of Surveys
• To audit religious diversity on the island – Ethnic diversity within Christian
congregations/parishes; and ‘other’ religions– Perceptions of reconciliation (what is
reconciliation & who should be reconciled?)– Perceptions of ecumenism (what is ecumenism &
does it matter today?)– Perspectives of both faith leaders & laypeople
Trinity College Dublin
Surveys of Faith Leaders
Clergy, Pastors, Ministers, Faith Leaders
• More than 4,000 direct email or postal requests
• April-July 2009• Response rate 18%• Evangelicals over-
represented• Highest response rate
among Methodist & Church of Ireland
Trinity College Dublin
Surveys of Laypeople
On-line Exploratory Survey• More than 900 respondents• April-July 2009 on
www.ecumenics.ie • Atheists & evangelicals
over-represented• Provide useful points of
comparison for survey of faith leaders and provide directions for future research
Trinity College Dublin
‘Minority’ respondents• Only 14 of 710 respondents
on faith leaders survey• 9 from Republic, 5 from
Northern Ireland• Response rate 24%• Baha’i, Buddhist, Hare
Krishna, Hindu, Humanist, Jewish, Muslim
• Nothing substantial can be claimed from this data, due to small sample size
BUT …
Trinity College Dublin
Interesting Findings
• Leaders from Other Religions were most likely to say they had been provided with adequate training or resources for promoting reconciliation (89%)
• Other Religions (89%) reported the most positive conceptions
of ecumenism. • On ecumenism, Christians prioritized options including
‘Catholics and Protestants’
Trinity College Dublin
‘Lay’ Minority Respondents• 910 total respondents, 29 from Faith
Minorities (23 from Republic, 4 from NI, 2 did not indicate location)
• Includes Baha’i, Buddhist, Hindu, Jewish, Muslim, Sikh, Humanist, Jewish Orthodox, pagan, Soto Zen Buddhist, Tibetan Buddhist
• Again, nothing substantial can be claimed from this data, due to small sample size
BUT …
Trinity College Dublin
Interesting Findings• The laypeople who responded to our survey were more likely
to indicate that good civic relations and dialogue with Other Religions is part of ecumenism, than were the faith leaders who responded
• 25% of laypeople on the island as a whole reported accessing resources on reconciliation between people of different religions
• 28% of laypeople on the island as a whole had accessed general resources on reconciliation (25% in the Republic and 38% in Northern Ireland). The most likely to have done so were people from Other Religions (47%) and Other Christians (38%).
Trinity College Dublin
Faith Minorities Case Study 2010
• Context of seven other case studies– Fermanagh Churches Forum– Holy Cross Benedictine Monastery, Co. Down– Sli Eile (Jesuit youth organisation)– Abundant Life Assemblies of God church, Limerick– St Patrick’s United Church, Waterford– Jesus Centre, Dublin– Ballyboden Catholic lay parish council, Dublin
Trinity College Dublin
Faith Minorities Case Study (2010)
• Our purpose?To provide in-depth perspectives on what it is
like to live as a member of a faith minority community on this island
• Interviewees are not ‘representative’• Semi-structured interviews provide room for
depth and more nuanced understanding• Participants sourced through ISE contacts and
2009 surveys
Trinity College Dublin
Interviewee DemographicsAge Range Birthplace Religious background Current Religion Current residence Gender
40-60 Northern Ireland Church of Ireland Baha’i NI M
40-60 Turkey Muslim (Sunni) Muslim (Sunni) NI M
40-60 India Hindu Hindu NI M
18-25 Turkey Muslim Muslim NI F
40-60 India Sikh Sikh Ireland M
40-60 Ireland Jewish Jewish Ireland F
26-40 Northern Ireland Catholic Buddhist Ireland M
40-60 Ireland Catholic Buddhist Ireland F
65+ Ireland Church of Ireland Baha’i Ireland F
65+ Ireland Catholic Buddhist NI M (LGBT)
Trinity College Dublin
Irish or Northern Irish born interviewees
Dissatisfaction or disappointment with previous religion
But always several factors
Committing to a new faith
Trinity College Dublin
Experiences of Acceptance
• With family• With society around them
I can easily say this is one of the relaxed and good countries, where you can live your faith and don’t have any problem. … As long as you don’t go to very sensitive areas of the country where nationalism is very high.
- Afandee, Turkish Muslim in N. Ireland
Trinity College Dublin
• Present in all narratives• In social interactions • In public policies, politics, educational
system, etc.
Experiences of Rejection/Prejudice & Lack of Recognition
Trinity College Dublin
Meaning & Practice of ‘Everyday’ Religion
• Prayer, meditation, social work – religions give meaning to people’s everyday lives
• All say their religions are not about converting others
• Many emphasise that their religions are non-violent
Trinity College Dublin
Ecumenism
• All say ‘other religions’ should be included• This may be related to desire for recognition
or acknowledgement• But, one had not heard of ecumenism, two
were unsure, and another had checked its meaning in the dictionary
• Is ecumenism the same as inter faith dialogue?
Trinity College Dublin
Points to Ponder
Acceptance is hard to come byOrdinariness of everyday religious life
When little recognition, who should reach out?Relationship between inter-faith dialogue & ecumenism