lithuania: the competition council imposes fine of more...

1
33 Lithuania: The Compeon Council imposes Fine of more than € 1 500 000 for An- compeve Pracce relang to Online Sale of Package Tours On 7 June 2012, the Compeon Council of the Republic of Lithuania (the CC) adopted a decision in which 30 tour operators/travel agents were fined more than € 1 500 000 for an an-compeve concerted pracce in the package tours sales market covering the enre territory of Lithuania. The CC found that the tour operators/travel agents concerned had coordinated their acons online by fixing a maximum discount level (up to 3% of the tour price) for package tours distributed via internet using the online tours searching and booking system E-TURAS managed by the undertaking UAB “Eturas”, thereby infringing Arcle 5 of the naonal Law on Compeon and Arcle 101 TFEU. E-TURAS system is a unique, fully automated, system for the search and booking of package tours online. The system is available to all market operators whishing to use it and is specifically designed for tour operators/travel agents selling package tours online. A tour operator/travel agent willing to sell tours via E-TURAS system had to conclude a contract with the owner of this system UAB “Eturas”. Since the system E-TURAS is available to all market operators wishing to use it and according to the contractual terms, a tour operator/travel agent who decided to use the system was aware of the fact that other tour operators/ travel agents (the competors) were using or could use the system too under the same condions. All tour operators/travel agents using the system were able to administrate their own informaon such as last minutes offers, daily offers, discounts, and were also able to amend their own data, send and receive informaon noces, etc. The invesgaon revealed that UAB “Eturas” sent to its clients an e-quesonnaire asking about the discount level they wanted to have implemented in the system. Thereaſter, UAB “Eturas” sent a system message informing on the limitaon of the discount level (maximum 3%). Moreover, UAB “Eturas” implemented this maximum discount level by using technical means in the system. Since then, the users of the system were not able to set a discount at their own discreon. It was found that the tour operators/travel agents actually applied the maximum 3% discount for internet sales. The operators/ travel agents tacitly acquiesced to such limitaon and did not distance themselves from such a common understanding. In its decision, the CC concluded that by joining the E-TURAS system used by a majority of tour operators/ travel agents (i.e. competors) and by failing to distance themselves from the implemented discount limitaon, the tour operators/travel agents concerned limited their ability to adopt pricing decisions independently and expressed their acceptance of the discount limitaon proposed by UAB “Eturas” to set a maximum discount level. The 30 tour operators/travel agents were found liable for the infringement of compeon rules. The invesgaon was triggered by informaon brought to the aenon of the CC by one of the agreements’ parcipant in return for immunity under the CC’s leniency programme. The said company was granted full immunity from fines. See press release (in Lithuanian) and Compeon Council decision (in Lithuanian)

Upload: others

Post on 19-Jul-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Lithuania: The Competition Council imposes Fine of more ...ec.europa.eu/competition/ecn/brief/03_2012/lt_online.pdf · E-TURAS system is a unique, fully automated, system for the

33

• Lithuania: The Competition Council imposes Fine of more than € 1 500 000 for Anti-competitive Practice relating to Online Sale of Package ToursOn 7 June 2012, the Competition Council of the Republic of Lithuania (the CC) adopted a decision in which 30 tour operators/travel agents were fined more than € 1 500 000 for an anti-competitive concerted practice in the package tours sales market covering the entire territory of Lithuania.

The CC found that the tour operators/travel agents concerned had coordinated their actions online by fixing a maximum discount level (up to 3% of the tour price) for package tours distributed via internet using the online tours searching and booking system E-TURAS managed by the undertaking UAB “Eturas”, thereby infringing Article 5 of the national Law on Competition and Article 101 TFEU.

E-TURAS system is a unique, fully automated, system for the search and booking of package tours online. The system is available to all market operators whishing to use it and is specifically designed for tour operators/travel agents selling package tours online. A tour operator/travel agent willing to sell tours via E-TURAS system had to conclude a contract with the owner of this system UAB “Eturas”. Since the system E-TURAS is available to all market operators wishing to use it and according to the contractual terms, a tour operator/travel agent who decided to use the system was aware of the fact that other tour operators/travel agents (the competitors) were using or could use the system too under the same conditions. All tour operators/travel agents using the system were able to administrate their own information such as last minutes offers, daily offers, discounts, and were also able to amend their own data, send and receive information notices, etc.

The investigation revealed that UAB “Eturas” sent to its clients an e-questionnaire asking about the discount level they wanted to have implemented in the system. Thereafter, UAB “Eturas” sent a system message informing on the limitation of the discount level (maximum 3%). Moreover, UAB “Eturas” implemented this maximum discount level by using technical means in the system. Since then, the users of the system were not able to set a discount at their own discretion. It was found that the tour operators/travel agents actually applied the maximum 3% discount for internet sales. The operators/travel agents tacitly acquiesced to such limitation and did not distance themselves from such a common understanding.

In its decision, the CC concluded that by joining the E-TURAS system used by a majority of tour operators/travel agents (i.e. competitors) and by failing to distance themselves from the implemented discount limitation, the tour operators/travel agents concerned limited their ability to adopt pricing decisions independently and expressed their acceptance of the discount limitation proposed by UAB “Eturas” to set a maximum discount level.

The 30 tour operators/travel agents were found liable for the infringement of competition rules.

The investigation was triggered by information brought to the attention of the CC by one of the agreements’ participant in return for immunity under the CC’s leniency programme. The said company was granted full immunity from fines.

See press release (in Lithuanian) and Competition Council decision (in Lithuanian)