light ancient and modern concerns
TRANSCRIPT
7/28/2019 Light Ancient and Modern Concerns
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/light-ancient-and-modern-concerns 1/13
LIGHT ON ARCHITECTURE: Ancient and Modern
concerns
Monica A. Rivera
Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University
College of Architecture Studies
M.Arch 2
October 26, 2004
“ Architecture is the masterly, correct and magnificent play of
volumes brought together in light. Our eyes are made to see forms in
light; light and shade reveal these forms. It is of the very nature of
the plastic arts.” 1
Le Corbusier
Light, magic lamp under which things are given form to our eyes,
creates space and gives them quality. For all times, light has been a vital
matter in architecture, since its absence means blindness to forms. Its
careless use results in low quality of the spaces. Its excess produces
blindness, again.
Not only its functional quality has been the subject of broad studies for
architects and artists, but also its capacity to touch our souls has always
intrigued people. Light has the capacity of amaze us, independently from our
culture, time or geographic situation. The sun, fierce giver of light and life,
was praised by many ancient cultures as the supreme god that reigned over
the universe. For the Egyptians, light would be present when the god Ra was
looking at his people. It was the power of his sight that illuminated the
1Le Corbusier. Towards a New Architecture. Translated by Frederick Etchells, pp 29 (New York: Dover,
1986)
1
7/28/2019 Light Ancient and Modern Concerns
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/light-ancient-and-modern-concerns 2/13
7/28/2019 Light Ancient and Modern Concerns
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/light-ancient-and-modern-concerns 3/13
produce the corn weevil and other little creatures that are wont to spoil the
grain.” 2
Vitruvius also expresses his awareness about the changing
quality of light and heat during the year and its relation with the use of
the different rooms:
“Dining rooms for Spring and Autumn to the east; for when the
windows face that quarter, the sun, as he goes on his career from over
against them to the west, leaves such rooms at the proper
temperature at the time when it is customary to use them. Summer
dining rooms to the north, because that quarter is not, like the others,
burning with heat during the solstice, for the reason that it is
unexposed to the sun’s course, and hence it always keeps cool, andmakes the use of the rooms both healthy and agreeable. Similarly
with picture galleries, embroiderers’ work rooms, and painters’ studios,
in order that the fixed light may permit the colours used in their work
to last with qualities unchanged.” 3
The modern attitude toward light is quite different. Because of the
modern systems of lighting, heating and cooling, contemporary thought
dissociates light from heat, and sometimes even from the sun. The idea of comfort has changed, and modern standards are more precise in terms of
levels of light, temperatures and humidity, because modern technology
makes it possible to have the same conditions in a room all year round.
Advice in technical handbooks includes specific recommendations for each
use. Desirable conditions and an acceptable range of variation are given, but
the guidelines do not include recommendations about ways to achieve those
conditions. It is assumed that the conditioner systems will modify the
environment as needed.
Regarding the importance of light for the well functioning, health and
hygiene on a house, we find similarities with modern thought in the writings
2 Vitruvius, The Ten Books on Architecture. Translated by Morris Morgan, Book VI, Chapter VI, 2-4.
(New York: Dover, 1960).3 Ibid, pp180-181
3
7/28/2019 Light Ancient and Modern Concerns
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/light-ancient-and-modern-concerns 4/13
of Le Corbusier. We could say that he and Vitruvius, each one in accordance
with his time, share this functionalist concern about light and architecture.
In “The Manual of the Dwelling”, when Le Corbusier makes recommendations
about what to demand in a house, with respect to lighting he suggests
windows in every room, because a house only is habitable when it is full of
light and air.4 He argues against architecture that in name of “style” has
degenerated to a “respectful and servile salute to the past”, constraining
people to all its illnesses. He declares,
“A house is a machine for living in. Baths, sun, hot-water, cold-water,
warmth at will, conservation of food, hygiene, beauty in the sense of good
proportion.” 5
The impetuous words of Le Corbusier about the new spirit that
architecture should have were distorted by practice, giving a paper floor to
an architecture, which focused on the function (as a machine) and
technology, leaving the human and environmental considerations on the side.
He continues his criticism,
“Industry, overwhelming us like a flood which rolls on towards its
destined end, has furnished us with new tools adapted to this new epoch,
animated by the new spirit.
If we eliminate from our hearts and minds all dead concepts in regard
to the houses and look at the question from a critical and objective point of
view, we shall arrive at the “House-Machine”, the mass-production house,
healthy (and morally so too) and beautiful in the same way that the working
tools and instruments which accompany our existence are beautiful.” 6
Of course this process was encouraged by the times, and the necessity
of wide reconstruction of European cities after World War II, which allowed a
speedy spread of the “spirit”. In Latin-Americans countries, where
reconstruction was not necessary, his approach became symbols of progress
and modernization. More and more, artificial materials were replacing
4 Le Corbusier 5 Ibid, pp956 Ibid, pp227
4
7/28/2019 Light Ancient and Modern Concerns
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/light-ancient-and-modern-concerns 5/13
natural ones, among them light; whose increasingly artificial use significantly
reduced our experience of the outdoors. Corbusier writes,
“Water supply and lighting services are rapidly being evolved;
central heating has begun to take into consideration the structure of walls and
windows. Accepted things so far treated as almost unassailable no longer
hold their own: roofs which need no longer be pointed for purposes of
throwing off water, the enormous and handsome window-embrasures which
annoy us since they imprison the light and deprive us of it.” 7
Delirium for the technology gives us the
freedom of designing without the burdens such
as location and site restrictions that complicated
our free designs. The idea of having power over
nature allowed us to build without regard for it ,
forgetting that man primarily uses materials
from nature to build. The product: “all purpose”
buildings without souls, of great “international
style”, as similar as a clone, that cannot touch
the people who built them, or touch the people
for whom they were built.
Promulgated as the architecture of the
machine era and industrialization, it was
supposed to be the clear result of this spirit. Its form was meant to follow
function, with the expression of the new materials. Pure form and honest
materials would give beauty. On the way, the result was that any function
seemed to fit well to cubic volumes, and from the broad range of materials
available, only concrete, glass and steel were valid to express the new spirit.
“One building, for all nations and climates” 8
was the premise, and the mainfailure, together with the assumption that beauty had the same meaning for
all people and cultures. Even third world countries embraced these
architectural forms as symbols of progress. That these buildings were not
7 Ibid, pp232-2338 Le Corbusier, quoted on Leland M. Roth, Understanding Architecture, Hasper-Collins, Colorado, 1993
pp480, from Précisions sur un état présent de l’architecture et de l’urbanisme, pp64
5
7/28/2019 Light Ancient and Modern Concerns
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/light-ancient-and-modern-concerns 6/13
suitable for their climates, the costs of the “new” materials and construction
technology were extremely expensive on those countries, and the fact that
that architecture had no precedent on their countries, was not even
considered. In the following quote, Aalto states a fundamental issue about
tradition, new creation, and the correct balance between them to have
continuity,
“Human life consists, in equal degrees, of tradition and new creation.
Traditions cannot be wholly cast off and regarded as used objects, which have
to be replaced by something new. In human life continuity is a vital
necessity.” 9
“International Style” was built in the same way and with the same
ideas for different people, places, customs and necessities, resulting in
standardized machines for living or working. Machines as architecture don’t
fit us as the human beings. Because light and people behave and react
differently depending on where they are, architecture should be so too.
“When you make a building, you make a life. It comes out of life, and you
really make a life. It talks to you. When you have only the comprehension
of the function of a building, it would not become an environment of a life” 10
Great waste of energy and impact on the environment was also one of
consequences of a complete reliance on technology, and of the indifference
for the relationship between a building and its climatic and environmental
setting.
It’s important to note what the ancients said about this issue. For
example, Vitruvius addressed the relation between place and architecture in
the following way,
“If our designs for private houses are to be correct, we must at the
outset take note of the countries and climates in which they are built. One
style of house seems appropriate to build in Egypt, another in Spain, a
9 Alvar Aalto, “The Architect’s Conscience”, 1957 in Alvar Alto, pp6, (Switzerland, Les Editions
d’Architecture Artemis Zurich), 1970.10 Kahn, Louis, quoted on Leland M. Roth, Understanding Architecture, Hasper-Collins, Colorado, 1993,
pp10, from Conversations with Architects, New York, 1973.
6
7/28/2019 Light Ancient and Modern Concerns
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/light-ancient-and-modern-concerns 7/13
different kind in Pontus, one still different in Rome, and so on with lands and
countries of other characteristics” 11
The role of light in architecture is broad. It ranges from the mere
functional to the extraordinary poetic. Light has been used in architecture to
express subtleness as well as to strike with splendor, as a material on
architecture, as well as protagonist of it.
For the ancients,
the most poetic and
metaphysical powers of
light were reserved for
exceptional buildings,
such as temples or
tombs, and for very
important people or
gods.
Reconstruction of The
Colonnade of Amenhotep III
at the temple of Luxor
The setting of the building would be
carefully chosen with regard to the sun. In this
matter Vitruvius makes recommendations in the
case of temples as follows,
“…The temple and the statue placed in
the cella should face the western quarter of the
sky. This will enable those who approach the
altar with offerings or sacrifices to face the
direction of the sunrise in facing the statue in
the temple, and thus those who are
undertaking vows look toward the quarter from
11 Vitruvius, The Ten Books on Architecture. Translated by Morris Morgan, Book V. Chapter I. 1 (New
York: Dover, 1960).
7
7/28/2019 Light Ancient and Modern Concerns
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/light-ancient-and-modern-concerns 8/13
which the sun comes forth, and likewise the statues themselves appear to be
coming forth out of the east to look upon them as they pray and sacrifice.” 12
Gipsoteca Canoviana, Possagno, Carlo Scarpa, 1955-1957
The modern concep of man with respect
to himself has evolved. The power of nature
has been extended to our inner realities, so its
charms are not reserved for the gods or beings
that left, but are part of our delight here at the
mundane world. Evocative use of light can be
found in buildings with the most trivial uses.
There are no mental restrictions for that.
A clear and contrasting example of space
where light is used in a symbolic way, with
respect to the ancients is the museum.
Although religious architecture continues to be
the most inspiring architecture, new times
have witnessed the birth of a new kind temple,
one for ourselves, the museum, where man
can admire his own creations and where light
calls also for a redefinition.
Church of the Light, Osaka, Tadao Ando
At all times, architecture has one meaning when the rational spirit
prevails and another when the emotional spirit prevails. In the first case,
light is used only as an element to help a function (program element), itsaction and perception is limited, it doesn’t open the place to further
interpretations. In the second case, in contrast, light is used as an integral
element of the architecture. We would then say that light has become an
architectural form or element that interacts with other architectural parts,
12 Ibid, Book IV, Chapter V, 1.
8
7/28/2019 Light Ancient and Modern Concerns
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/light-ancient-and-modern-concerns 9/13
forming a whole, and creating different spatial moments that will activate not
only our eyes, but also our feelings and emotions.
The best example to illustrate this point is Le Corbusier. His works in
the first third of the twentieth century was focused on the pure forms,
“Architecture is the masterly, correct and magnificent play of masses
brought together in light. Our eyes are made to see forms in light; light and
shape reveal these forms; cubes, cones, spheres, cylinders or pyramids are
the great primary forms which light reveals to advantage; the image or these
is distinct and tangible within us and without ambiguity. It is for that reason
that these are beautiful forms, the most beautiful forms. Everybody is agreed
as to that, the child, the savage and the metaphysician. It is of the very
nature of the plastic arts.” 13
“The light plays on pure forms, and repays them with interest. Simple
masses develop immense surfaces which display themselves with
characteristic variety according as it is a question of cupolas, vaulting,
cylinders, rectangular prisms or pyramids.
Absence of verbosity, good arrangement, a single idea, daring and unity in
construction, the use of elementary shapes. A sane morality” 14
He is interested in the pure forms. It seems he is thinking more about
exterior forms, volumes under the light, “not for light striking on, breakingand in any case penetrating these volumes in order to exalt space.” 15 In
Towards a New Architecture, he addresses the interior light just in terms of
quantity and functionality. He emphasizes in the abundance of light that now
is possible to get in the spaces through the “wall of windows” that the new
technology of the concrete built:
“Reinforced concrete and steel allow of this audacity and lend
themselves in particular to a certain development of the façade by means of
which all the windows have an uninterrupted view: in this way, in the future,
inside courts and “wells” will no longer exist” 16
13 Le Corbusier.14 Ibid, pp.158-159.15 Bruno Zevi, “Light as Architectural Form”, World Architecture,1994, N.14, pp. 58.16 Le Corbusier.
9
7/28/2019 Light Ancient and Modern Concerns
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/light-ancient-and-modern-concerns 10/13
For architects: a wall all windows, a saloon full of light. What a contrast withthe windows in our houses making holes in the walls and forming and patch of
shade on either side.
His attitude with Ronchamp Chapel cannot be more contrasting. He
doesn’t emphasize rational values, but concentrates more on emotional ones.
Every window has been carefully considered, achieving a mystic and
exceptional atmosphere inside. Several devices have been used to achieve
it. For example on the south side, the massive walls, variable angles of the
perforations, and colored glass endow the light with own life. Henry
Plummer beautifully describes the work of Le Corbusier on Ronchamp,
“In the dim interior, natural light is used not to model the walls, but to
corrode and eclipse them. A tall and deliberately distracting fissure is
inserted in the angle between two main walls, just to the right of the altar,
prying open the volume, and giving prominence to light above ritual. The
upcurving roof is also detached from the walls by what Le Corbusier called “a
horizontal crack of light”, causing the roof to appear to levitate.
(…)Through great embrasures in the massive south wall, daylight
glances along steeply angled facets, perfuming the chambers with transparent
colour, from panes of glass painted by hand with childlike joy (…). Each
chamber is carved a slightly different shape, and aimed to a different part of
10
7/28/2019 Light Ancient and Modern Concerns
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/light-ancient-and-modern-concerns 11/13
sky, so no two are lit the same, and the sun awakens each in turn to animate
the wall with ebbing and flowing colour.” 17
In Ronchamp, light is not invisible, but has form, depth, and intensity.
Here light is an architectural form.
Light in architecture can be an inexhaustible topic, even more so if we
pretend to compare it through History. The points of comparison can be
innumerable, and the references too.
The power of light for expressing beauty seems to have had more
continuity. This fact can suggest that the human necessity for nourishment
of spirit, and light as an inspiring means of obtaining this nourishment has
not changed. Perhaps our inner sense is the same.
It is our outer self that looks to prevail over the world that we inhabit.
The false impression that man had mastered nature, leads him to the
dissociation from nature and its elements, among them, light. The effects of
17 Plummer Hernry, “Building with Light”, Escala, Anno 35, N.181, 1998, pp53-72
11
7/28/2019 Light Ancient and Modern Concerns
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/light-ancient-and-modern-concerns 12/13
this attitude have become evident, threatening to give us a stranger and
unpredictable world.
A new concern about architecture has reborn. New alternatives are
being explored looking for an architecture that is more energy-efficient, and
responsive to its environment, “gentle architecture” or “green architecture".
New tools let us now “catch” and “keep” the energy of our turbulent
star, but the principle is the same, make maximum use of natural conditions.
The idea that the sun can be the provider of light and heat, together as
energy, for our buildings seems to fit again on our minds.
Bibliography
• Vitruvius, The Ten Books on Architecture. Translated by Morris Hicky
Morgan (New York: Dover, 1960).
12
7/28/2019 Light Ancient and Modern Concerns
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/light-ancient-and-modern-concerns 13/13
• Alberti, Leon Battista. On the Art of Building in Ten Books. Translated
by Joseph Rykwert, Neil Leach, Robert Tavernor (Cambridge: MIT
Press, 1988).
• Lethaby, William Richard. Architecture, Mysticism and Myth (New
York, Dover Publications, 2004). [republication of the 2nd edition
1892]
• Le Corbusier. Towards a New Architecture. Translated by Frederick
Etchells (New York: Dover, 1986).
• Ander Gregg, Daylighting Performance and Design, (New Jersey,
Wiley, 2003), Second Edition.
• Guzowski, Mary. Daylighting for Sustainable Design, (McGraw-Hill,
2000)
• Leland M. Roth, Understanding Architecture, (Hasper-Collins, Colorado,
1993).
• Henry Plummer, “Building with Light”, Escala, Anno 35, N.181, 1998,
pp.53-72.
• Bruno Zevi, “Light as Architectural Form”, World Architecture, 1994,
N.14, pp. 56-59.
13