life on other planets? - university of richmond › ~ggilfoyl › cm › examples › ... ·...

26
Life on Other Planets? Four hundred years ago an advocate of the idea that planets orbited stars other than our Sun was burned at the stake. Giordano Bruno, a rebellious, independent Dominican monk (until he was kicked out of the order) further infuriated religious leaders by asserting in the late 16th century that beings like humans inhabited these other worlds. Let us now begin our study of extrasolar planets. Jerry Gilfoyle ExtraSolar Planets 1 / 20

Upload: others

Post on 25-Jun-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Life on Other Planets? - University of Richmond › ~ggilfoyl › cm › examples › ... · 2017-04-17 · Life on Other Planets? Four hundred years ago an advocate of the idea that

Life on Other Planets?

Four hundred years ago an advocate of the idea that planets orbited starsother than our Sun was burned at the stake. Giordano Bruno, a rebellious,independent Dominican monk (until he was kicked out of the order)further infuriated religious leaders by asserting in the late 16th centurythat beings like humans inhabited these other worlds. Let us now beginour study of extrasolar planets.

Jerry Gilfoyle ExtraSolar Planets 1 / 20

Page 2: Life on Other Planets? - University of Richmond › ~ggilfoyl › cm › examples › ... · 2017-04-17 · Life on Other Planets? Four hundred years ago an advocate of the idea that

How Do We Find Extra-solar planets?

1 Look here first.2 Look here second.

Jerry Gilfoyle ExtraSolar Planets 2 / 20

Page 3: Life on Other Planets? - University of Richmond › ~ggilfoyl › cm › examples › ... · 2017-04-17 · Life on Other Planets? Four hundred years ago an advocate of the idea that

How Do We Find Extra-solar planets?

1 Look here first.

2 Look here second.

Jerry Gilfoyle ExtraSolar Planets 2 / 20

Page 4: Life on Other Planets? - University of Richmond › ~ggilfoyl › cm › examples › ... · 2017-04-17 · Life on Other Planets? Four hundred years ago an advocate of the idea that

How Do We Find Extra-solar planets?

1 Look here first.2 Look here second.

Jerry Gilfoyle ExtraSolar Planets 2 / 20

Page 5: Life on Other Planets? - University of Richmond › ~ggilfoyl › cm › examples › ... · 2017-04-17 · Life on Other Planets? Four hundred years ago an advocate of the idea that

How Do We Find Extra-solar planets?

1 Look here first.2 Look here second.

Jerry Gilfoyle ExtraSolar Planets 2 / 20

Page 6: Life on Other Planets? - University of Richmond › ~ggilfoyl › cm › examples › ... · 2017-04-17 · Life on Other Planets? Four hundred years ago an advocate of the idea that

How Do We Find Extra-solar planets?

1 Look here first.2 Look here second.

Jerry Gilfoyle ExtraSolar Planets 2 / 20

Page 7: Life on Other Planets? - University of Richmond › ~ggilfoyl › cm › examples › ... · 2017-04-17 · Life on Other Planets? Four hundred years ago an advocate of the idea that

A Planet Around 51 Pegasus

Consider the data below which shows the oscillations in the speed of thestar 51 Pegasus implying the existence of an unseen, orbiting companion.What is the period of the oscillation? How is this period related to thedistance from 51 Pegasus to the unseen companion? What do theseresults imply about the maximum mass of the unseen companion? Assumethe mass of 51 Pegasus is ms = 2.2 × 1030 kg from its spectral type andthat it is a distance rpeg = 51ly from Earth.

Mayor and Queloz, Nat. 378 355

Jerry Gilfoyle ExtraSolar Planets 3 / 20

Page 8: Life on Other Planets? - University of Richmond › ~ggilfoyl › cm › examples › ... · 2017-04-17 · Life on Other Planets? Four hundred years ago an advocate of the idea that

‘Wobbling’ Stars

Consider a solar system consisting only of the Sun and Jupiter orbitingabout their center of mass. What is the size of the Sun’s ‘wobble’ as itorbits the center of mass? Compare the wobble with the radius of the Sun.If an alien species on a small planet (similar to Earth) orbiting 51 Pegasustried to observe the Sun’s wobble what would be the angular size of thewobble? The distance from 51 Pegasus to the is 51 ly.

Jupiter’s mass 1.90 × 1027 kgSun’s mass 1.99 × 1030 kgSun-Jupiter distance 7.8 × 1011 mSun’s radius 6.96 × 108 m1 light-year 9.46 × 1015 m

More on wobbling stars here.

Jerry Gilfoyle ExtraSolar Planets 4 / 20

Page 9: Life on Other Planets? - University of Richmond › ~ggilfoyl › cm › examples › ... · 2017-04-17 · Life on Other Planets? Four hundred years ago an advocate of the idea that

The Doppler Effect

Jerry Gilfoyle ExtraSolar Planets 5 / 20

Page 10: Life on Other Planets? - University of Richmond › ~ggilfoyl › cm › examples › ... · 2017-04-17 · Life on Other Planets? Four hundred years ago an advocate of the idea that

The Doppler Effect

Jerry Gilfoyle ExtraSolar Planets 6 / 20

Page 11: Life on Other Planets? - University of Richmond › ~ggilfoyl › cm › examples › ... · 2017-04-17 · Life on Other Planets? Four hundred years ago an advocate of the idea that

Wobbling Stars

Jerry Gilfoyle ExtraSolar Planets 7 / 20

Page 12: Life on Other Planets? - University of Richmond › ~ggilfoyl › cm › examples › ... · 2017-04-17 · Life on Other Planets? Four hundred years ago an advocate of the idea that

Measuring Stellar Velocities

The velocities of distant starstowards or away from the Earthare measured using small blue-or red-shirts of the absorptionlines like those shown here inthe spectra of a variety of stars.Several methods are used tokeep the spectra precisely cal-ibrated for the long periodsneeded to record the observa-tions.

Jerry Gilfoyle ExtraSolar Planets 8 / 20

Page 13: Life on Other Planets? - University of Richmond › ~ggilfoyl › cm › examples › ... · 2017-04-17 · Life on Other Planets? Four hundred years ago an advocate of the idea that

51 Pegasus Location in the Sky

Jerry Gilfoyle ExtraSolar Planets 9 / 20

Page 14: Life on Other Planets? - University of Richmond › ~ggilfoyl › cm › examples › ... · 2017-04-17 · Life on Other Planets? Four hundred years ago an advocate of the idea that

51 Pegasus Location in the Sky

Jerry Gilfoyle ExtraSolar Planets 10 / 20

Page 15: Life on Other Planets? - University of Richmond › ~ggilfoyl › cm › examples › ... · 2017-04-17 · Life on Other Planets? Four hundred years ago an advocate of the idea that

Is 51 Peg’s Planet Eccentric?

ε =

√1 +

2El2

µα2= 1 − 2

rarp

+ 1

ε = 0

0 < ε < 1

ra pr

Red - Circular orbit

Blue - Elliptical orbit

v=0

Time

Velo

city

Jerry Gilfoyle ExtraSolar Planets 11 / 20

Page 16: Life on Other Planets? - University of Richmond › ~ggilfoyl › cm › examples › ... · 2017-04-17 · Life on Other Planets? Four hundred years ago an advocate of the idea that

Is 51 Peg’s Planet Eccentric?

ε =

√1 +

2El2

µα2= 1 − 2

rarp

+ 1

ε = 0

0 < ε < 1

ra pr

Red - Circular orbit

Blue - Elliptical orbit

v=0

Time

Velo

city

Jerry Gilfoyle ExtraSolar Planets 11 / 20

Page 17: Life on Other Planets? - University of Richmond › ~ggilfoyl › cm › examples › ... · 2017-04-17 · Life on Other Planets? Four hundred years ago an advocate of the idea that

51 Pegasus’ Planet Data

Mayor and Queloz, Nat. 378 355

Orbital period: 4.2293 ± 0.0011dVelocity resolution: 13 m/s

Jerry Gilfoyle ExtraSolar Planets 12 / 20

Page 18: Life on Other Planets? - University of Richmond › ~ggilfoyl › cm › examples › ... · 2017-04-17 · Life on Other Planets? Four hundred years ago an advocate of the idea that

Stellar Spectra

The spectral class is a method for classifying stars based on the pattern ofabsorption lines (which reveal the elements in the star’s photosphere) andtheir intensity (which reflects the abundance). These measurements canbe translated into the temperature and density of the star’s photosphere.

G-type

A-type

K-type

Jerry Gilfoyle ExtraSolar Planets 13 / 20

Page 19: Life on Other Planets? - University of Richmond › ~ggilfoyl › cm › examples › ... · 2017-04-17 · Life on Other Planets? Four hundred years ago an advocate of the idea that

The Main Sequence

The main sequence of theHertzsprung-Russell diagram isthe curve where the majority ofstars are located in this diagram.This line is so pronounced be-cause both the spectral typeand the luminosity depend on astar’s mass only to zeroth orderas long as it is fusing hydrogen.

Jerry Gilfoyle ExtraSolar Planets 14 / 20

Page 20: Life on Other Planets? - University of Richmond › ~ggilfoyl › cm › examples › ... · 2017-04-17 · Life on Other Planets? Four hundred years ago an advocate of the idea that

The Method of Trigonometric Parallaxes

To place a star on the Hertzsprung-Russell diagram the absolute luminosityhas to be determined. This step requires measuring the distance from theEarth to the star. Nearby stars appear to move with respect to moredistant background stars due to the motion of the Earth around the Sun.This apparent motion (it is not ”true” motion) is called Stellar Parallax.

Jerry Gilfoyle ExtraSolar Planets 15 / 20

Page 21: Life on Other Planets? - University of Richmond › ~ggilfoyl › cm › examples › ... · 2017-04-17 · Life on Other Planets? Four hundred years ago an advocate of the idea that

Getting the Mass of the Star

The luminosity of main sequence stars is proportional to their mass asshown in the plot below. Thus identifying the spectral type places the staron the main sequence and then measurments of its luminosity can bedirectly related to its mass.

Jerry Gilfoyle ExtraSolar Planets 16 / 20

Page 22: Life on Other Planets? - University of Richmond › ~ggilfoyl › cm › examples › ... · 2017-04-17 · Life on Other Planets? Four hundred years ago an advocate of the idea that

Orbital Plane Tilt

51 Pegasus

UnseenCompanion

Orbital Plane

Telescope

θ tilt

Jerry Gilfoyle ExtraSolar Planets 17 / 20

Page 23: Life on Other Planets? - University of Richmond › ~ggilfoyl › cm › examples › ... · 2017-04-17 · Life on Other Planets? Four hundred years ago an advocate of the idea that

A Planet Around 51 Pegasus

Consider the data below which shows the oscillations in the speed of thestar 51 Pegasus implying the existence of an unseen, orbiting companionnow called 51 Pegasus b. What is the period of the oscillation? How isthis period related to the distance from 51 Pegasus to 51 Peg b? What dothese results imply about the maximum mass of the unseen companion?Assume the mass of 51 Pegasus is ms = 2.2 × 1030 kg from its spectraltype and that it is a distance rpeg = 51ly from Earth.

Mayor and Queloz, Nat. 378 355

Jerry Gilfoyle ExtraSolar Planets 18 / 20

Page 24: Life on Other Planets? - University of Richmond › ~ggilfoyl › cm › examples › ... · 2017-04-17 · Life on Other Planets? Four hundred years ago an advocate of the idea that

Planet Comparison

JupiterMSun= 392,000MEarth

Me

rcu

ry

Ve

nu

s

Ea

rth

Ma

rs

0 1 2 3 4 50

100

200

300

400

Distance from the Sun (A.U.)

Ma

ss(M

/M⊕)

Jerry Gilfoyle ExtraSolar Planets 19 / 20

Page 25: Life on Other Planets? - University of Richmond › ~ggilfoyl › cm › examples › ... · 2017-04-17 · Life on Other Planets? Four hundred years ago an advocate of the idea that

Planet Comparison

JupiterMSun= 392,000MEarth

51 Pegasus b

Me

rcu

ry

Ve

nu

s

Ea

rth

Ma

rs

0 1 2 3 4 50

100

200

300

400

Distance from the Sun (A.U.)

Ma

ss(M

/M⊕)

HOT JUPITER!

Jerry Gilfoyle ExtraSolar Planets 20 / 20

Page 26: Life on Other Planets? - University of Richmond › ~ggilfoyl › cm › examples › ... · 2017-04-17 · Life on Other Planets? Four hundred years ago an advocate of the idea that

Planet Comparison

JupiterMSun= 392,000MEarth

51 Pegasus b

Me

rcu

ry

Ve

nu

s

Ea

rth

Ma

rs

0 1 2 3 4 50

100

200

300

400

Distance from the Sun (A.U.)

Ma

ss(M

/M⊕)

HOT JUPITER!

Jerry Gilfoyle ExtraSolar Planets 20 / 20